A preformulated pectin-based melt-to-make bulk gummy mix is disclosed that is storage stable and formulated, optionally with flavors and colors, in a bulk mix form that is convenient for the next step in manufacturing storage stable individual serving reduced sugar or sugar-free pectin-based gummies. Methods for making a storage stable bulk pectin-based gummy mix that is a precursor for making individual serving reduced sugar or sugar-free pectin-based gummies are disclosed, as well as methods for making individual serving reduced sugar or sugar-free pectin-based gummies from a storage stable bulk pectin-based gummy mix. Kits comprising a two-part pectin-based gummy mix and acidulant for initiating pectin gelling are also described for the convenient manufacture of individual serving reduced sugar or sugar-free pectin-based gummies.