Augmented tune/match circuits for high performance dual nuclear transmission line resonators
11243280 · 2022-02-08
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01R33/3685
PHYSICS
A61B5/055
HUMAN NECESSITIES
International classification
Abstract
A dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator is capable of operating on .sup.1X pairs, with X being .sup.31P, .sup.23Na, .sup.3He, or .sup.129Xe. The resonator avoids many of the problems inherent in conventional dual nuclear designs. No LC trap is used, and the coil has substantially the same spatial profile on both nuclei. In the resonator, an augmented MR tune/match circuit, includes a conventional capacitive L circuit, with the L circuit shunted at a match point by a notch filter tuned to a frequency of a companion nucleus. Also disclosed is a method for simultaneously resonating conductive loops of surface coils or conductive elements of volume coils simultaneously on both .sup.1H and X with hybrid transmission line termination elements bonded to the resonator loop or conductive elements in shunt with respect to one another.
Claims
1. A dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator, comprising active elements coupled to tune/match circuits configured to match resonance of the active elements to a T/R console on both .sup.1H and X of .sup.1H/X pairs simultaneously, wherein X is .sup.31P, .sup.23Na, .sup.13C, .sup.3He, or .sup.129Xe, wherein a hybrid notch filter tuned to notch or short circuit at a frequency of a companion nucleus is shunted across each of the tune/match circuits on a side opposite the coupling to the active elements.
2. The dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator of claim 1, wherein the active elements comprise conductive elements in a utility region of the dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator that are simultaneously resonated on both .sup.1H and X with high efficiency.
3. The dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator of claim 1, where the dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator has virtually identical spatial distributions on both .sup.1H and X frequencies.
4. The dual nuclear MR transmission line resonator of claim 1, wherein the active elements act as a T/R coil for both .sup.1H and X independently of each other.
5. A resonator, comprising: a coil coupled to tune/match circuits, wherein a hybrid notch filter tuned to notch or short circuit at a frequency of a companion nucleus is shunted across each of the tune/match circuits on a side opposite the coupling to the coil, where a B.sub.0 static field of a MR magnet is fine adjusted using a .sup.1H frequency of a .sup.1H/X pair simultaneously generated by the coil, thereby automatically adjusting B.sup.0 for both .sup.1H and of the .sup.1H/X pair for imaging or spectroscopy due to perfect spatial co-registration of the coil on both 1H and X.
6. A method, comprising: simultaneously resonating conductive loops of a surface coil or conductive elements of a volume coil on both .sup.1H and X with a plurality of hybrid transmission line termination elements, the conductive loops of the surface coil or the conductive elements of the volume coil coupled to tune/match circuits, wherein a hybrid notch filter tuned to notch or short circuit at a frequency of a companion nucleus is shunted across each of the tune/match circuits on a side opposite the coupling to the conductive loops or the conductive elements, said plurality of hybrid transmission line termination elements bonded to the conductive loops or conductive elements in shunt with respect to one another.
7. An augmented MR tune/match circuit, comprising: a capacitive L circuit comprising capacitors coupled in an L-configuration, with said capacitive L circuit shunted at a match plane of a T/R operating frequency by a hybrid notch filter tuned to notch or short circuit at a frequency of a companion nucleus, the hybrid notch filter shunted across the capacitive L circuit on a side configured to couple to T/R circuitry that provides the T/R operating frequency.
8. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 7, wherein the hybrid notch filter is constructed from a hybrid transmission line circuit or a helical resonator notching at the companion nucleus frequency.
9. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 8, wherein the augmented MR tune/match circuit acts as a normal tune/match port at the T/R operating frequency, while acting as a virtual short circuit termination at the frequency of the companion nucleus.
10. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 7, wherein a plurality of resonators are coupled to a plurality of the augmented MR tune/match circuits, the plurality of resonators configured in arrays for an accelerated imaging modality.
11. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 10 wherein the accelerated imaging modality is SMASH (SiMultaneous Acquisition of Spatial Harmonics) or SENSE (SENSitivity Encoding).
12. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 7, wherein one or a plurality of resonators is run off analog T/R circuitry, or is used in conjunction with at least one of multi-channel DDS controlled transmitters and multi-channel digital receivers.
13. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 12, wherein the analog T/R circuitry is quadrature hybrid circuitry.
14. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 7, wherein the capacitive L circuit is a balanced capacitive L circuit comprising a variable tuning capacitor connected in each of a pair of transmission lines connected to a resonator and a variable matching capacitor connected between the pair of transmission lines.
15. The augmented MR tune/match circuit of claim 7, wherein the capacitive L circuit comprises a pair of single-ended capacitive L circuits comprising a variable tuning capacitor connected in each of a pair of transmission lines connected to a resonator and variable matching capacitors connected to each of the pair of transmission lines and a ground plane.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) A more complete understanding of the present disclosure may be obtained by references to the accompanying drawings when considered in conjunction with the subsequent detailed description. The embodiments illustrated in the drawings are intended only to exemplify the disclosure and should not be construed as limiting the disclosure to the illustrated embodiments.
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16) In all of the above-identified Figures illustrating schematic diagrams (
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(17) As required, embodiments are disclosed herein; however, it is to be understood that the disclosed embodiments are merely examples and that the systems and methods described below can be embodied in various forms. Therefore, specific structural and functional details disclosed herein are not to be interpreted as limiting, but merely as a representative basis for teaching one skilled in the art to variously employ the present subject matter in virtually any appropriately detailed structure and function. Further, the terms and phrases used herein are not intended to be limiting, but rather, to provide an understandable description of the concepts.
(18) The terms “a” or “an”, as used herein, are defined as one or more than one. The term plurality, as used herein, is defined as two or more than two. The term another, as used herein, is defined as at least a second or more. The terms “including” and “having,” as used herein, are defined as comprising (i.e., open language). The term “coupled,” as used herein, is defined as “connected,” although not necessarily directly, and not necessarily mechanically.
(19) The device described in this disclosure is a dual nuclear MR resonator suitable for both imaging and spectroscopy. Specifically, it is designed to operate simultaneously on the MR resonance frequency of proton and one additional nucleus, designated generically as X. In practice, X may be .sup.13C, .sup.23Na, .sup.3He, .sup.129Xe, or .sup.31P. .sup.19F may be problematic because its frequency is very close to .sup.1H. .sup.3He may demand the use of helical resonator notch filters in lieu of transmission line hybrid filters, as will be discussed later.
(20) In the disclosed device, a plurality of hybrid transmission line notch filters and line terminators serves to effect a virtual short, or virtual ground in the center of a conductive loop in the case of a surface coil, or in the center of both members of a conjugate pair of conductive elements in a volume coil on both .sup.1H and X frequencies. The term conjugate pair refers to the amplitude and phase relationship between members of the pair. Each member carries equal RF current at each frequency, but with a phase difference of 180 degrees between the two members of the pair. The virtual ground is a point of high conductance or low resistance. When RF power is applied, large RF currents are generated, thereby generating the required RF magnetic field (B.sub.1 field) for MR experiments.
(21) In the disclosed device, the same plurality of hybrid transmission notch filters and termination elements also serves to isolate the RF energy at the .sup.1H frequency from the X tune/match port, while simultaneously isolating RF energy at the X nucleus frequency from the .sup.1H tune/match port.
(22) A key to the operation of the disclosed device is that hybrid transmission line termination elements and hybrid transmission line notch filters may be configured to serve as high efficiency, frequency dependent passive switches. No MEMS device, PIN diode, or other active element is required. The line insertion loss of the hybrid notch filters is very low, typically 0.05 dB or less. At the same time, isolation between the .sup.1H tune/match port and the X tune/match port is very high, typically exceeding −45 dB. Both the .sup.1H and X resonance tune and match virtually independent of each other, and unloaded Q (quality factor) is high on both.
(23) A conceptual schematic of the resonator design according to the disclosure is shown in
(24) Technical Description And Operation
(25) The coil design disclosed herein is a type of transmission line resonator. Coils of this design exploit the fact that open circuit quarter wave lines give near short circuits (low resistance) on the opposite end, while short circuited quarter wave lines give near open circuits, or high resistances on the opposite end. All things being equal, the unloaded Q of a transmission line resonator increases with operating frequency. These devices typically perform well at VHF frequencies and above. In MR work, this usually means 30 MHz or above.
(26) The transmission line resonator approach may be improved by terminating a section of transmission line of some length less that λ/4 with a capacitor. The reactance of the capacitor is chosen to cancel the short circuit reactance (inductive) of the line segment at the desired operating frequency. Such a device is called a hybrid transmission line stub. In preferred embodiments, capacitors are used rather than inductors, given the inherent losses associated with the latter.
(27) At any given frequency, the impedance appearing across the terminals of a hybrid stub may be calculated by summing the capacitive reactance of the capacitor with the short circuit reactance of the line segment. While the reactance of the capacitor will decrease inversely proportional to the frequency, the reactance of the line segment will increase with frequency until the line is λ/4 at the operating frequency, corresponding to anti-resonance, or a very high resistance. By terminating a transmission line segment of proper length with a high Q capacitor, both virtual grounds and virtual open circuits may be impressed on any desired point. In preferred embodiments, transmission line segments are constructed from low loss line, and terminating capacitors are high Q capacitors. Variable capacitors are often used as they allow for fine adjustment of virtual ground and virtual open circuit locations.
(28) Though this design may be applied to most .sup.1H/X nuclear combinations, it will be useful for users to contemplate the behavior of the hybrid notch filters and hybrid termination stubs in the example of a .sup.1H/.sup.13C resonator design. The explanation to follow applies also to the following dual nuclear combinations: .sup.1H/.sup.23Na, .sup.1H/.sup.129Xe, .sup.1H/.sup.3He, and .sup.1H/.sup.31P.
(29) In the .sup.1H/.sup.13C example, the .sup.13C notch filter is formed by terminating a section of transmission line of electrical length λ/4 at ω.sup.1H (.sup.1H nuclear frequency) with capacitor C.sub.N13, such that a very low resistive impedance (short circuit) appears across the opposite end of the line section at frequency ω.sup.13C. At this frequency, the capacitive reactance of the capacitor is equal in magnitude but opposite in sign to the reactance of a short circuited length of transmission line of the same length, also at ω.sup.13C. The length of the .sup.13C notch filter line segment is about λ/16 at ω.sup.13C, and its associated short circuit reactance is readily canceled by C.sub.N13, a capacitor of modest value.
(30) At this point, it is illustrative to consider the behavior of the same hybrid notch filter at ω.sup.1H. At this frequency, the already small reactance of capacitor C.sub.N13 is ¼ of its previous value, so C.sub.N13 readily passes RF current at ω.sup.1H. In contrast, the impedance of the short circuit line segment at ω.sup.1H is very high and resistive, for inversion of a short circuited λ/4 line transforms a short circuit to an open circuit.
(31) In contrast, the .sup.1H notch filter is constructed from a section of line slightly less than λ/4, because it is desirable to set the short circuit with a termination capacitor, as done with the X notch filter. In practice, capacitors of less than 0.4 pF or so become problematic, so a slightly shorter line length is chosen such that the line reactance at ω.sup.1H may be conveniently canceled by a high Q VHF/UHF capacitor. At frequency ω.sup.13C, the small capacitor has a reactance in the range of 5,000 to 11,000 ohms or so, while the reactance of the short line segment is quite small, since the line segment is less than λ/16 at ω.sup.13C.
(32) Generally, X notch filters are constructed from line sections λ/4 in length at ω.sup.1H and terminated with some capacitor C.sub.NX whose value is chosen to cancel short circuit line reactance at ωX. In contrast, .sup.1H filters are constructed from a segment slightly shorter than λ/4 at ω.sup.1H for reasons discussed in the example above.
(33) A conceptual schematic for notch filter action in augmented tune/match circuits is shown in
(34)
(35) Relevant conceptual admittance Smith chart trajectories are shown in
(36) In
(37) The overall operation of a complete, dual nuclear resonator according to the disclosure is now described with primary reference to
(38) As desired in preferred embodiments, a .sup.1H balanced tune/match circuit is formed by three capacitors 3, 4. The tune/match circuit is connected to a resonator loop (surface coil,
(39) At ωX, the .sup.1H tune/match circuit is transformed into a circuit equivalent to placing capacitors 4 in series, while eliminating C.sub.M 3 from the circuit. Thus, the tune/match circuit (formed by capacitors 3, 4) augmented by X notch filter (formed from transmission line segment 2 and capacitor C.sub.NX 1) efficiently reflects nearly all RF energy at frequency ωX back towards the active area of the resonator, thereby ensuring that .sup.1H tune/match port is well isolated from X port.
(40) Virtual grounds V.G., or shorts (high current points) are established in the arms 12 of surface coil on substrate 11 at frequency ω.sup.1H by action of .sup.1H termination element, which is composed of transmission line segment 15 and termination capacitor C.sub.1H 16, with length of line segment 15 slightly less that λ/4 at ω.sup.1H as measured from capacitor 16 to virtual ground point V.G. in the arms 12 of the surface coil.
(41) As with the .sup.1H tune/match circuit, the X tune/match circuit is fed by a high performance current balun 20, and formed by capacitors 8, 9, and shunted across capacitor C.sub.Mx 8 by .sup.1H notch filter formed by line segment 7 and capacitor 6. The X tune/match circuit is placed λ/4 at ω.sup.1H from x virtual ground point 12. This distance is less than λ/4 at ωX. As before, X tune/match circuit (formed by capacitors 8, 9) transforms complex load admittance of loaded X coil impedance to 50 ohms. Capacitors 9 transform the complex load admittance to a point on the unit conductance circle of the admittance Smith Chart at frequency ωX. At that point, the X match capacitor 8 is adjusted until load susceptance, X match capacitor susceptance, and .sup.1H hybrid notch filter susceptance all sum to zero at the X match plane. The line between X tune/match circuit (formed by capacitors 8, 9) and X current balun 20 is then matched by definition, as was the case with .sup.1H tune/match circuit.
(42) At ω.sup.1H, the X tune/match circuit (formed by capacitors 8, 9) is transformed into a circuit equivalent to placing capacitors 9 in series and eliminating capacitor 8. At ω.sup.1H, the transmission line segment 10, terminated on one end by capacitors 9 in series, establishes a very large resistive impedance across the coil loop 12. The x termination element, composed of capacitor 14 and line segment 13, with segment 13 being λ/4 long at ω.sup.1H, also establishes a large, resistive impedance at ω.sup.1H. Both of these resistors are in series, because termination element 13, 14 and the X augmented/tune match circuit (capacitors 8, 9 in conjunction with line segment 7 and capacitor 6) are effectively in series. This poises no problem for operation of the .sup.1H resonator, because .sup.1H resonance (virtual ground) is established by .sup.1H termination element 15, 16 which is connected in shunt with the X augmented tune/match circuit (capacitors 8, 9 in conjunction with line segment 7 and capacitor 6), and also with X termination element 13, 14. Simple circuit theory shows that a small resistive impedance, or near short, remains a near short when shunted by a large resistance, no matter how large. Thus, .sup.1H tune/match and .sup.1H termination elements act in concert to resonate the coil on .sup.1H and transform the loaded coil impedance to 50 ohms, as desired. Thus, .sup.1H circuitry acts as though no X circuitry were present.
(43) At ωX, the augmented .sup.1H tune/match circuit (capacitors 3, 4 in conjunction with augmented transmission line segment 2 and capacitor C.sub.NX 1) is transformed into the equivalent of a capacitive termination, with capacitors 4 in series, and capacitor 3 removed. At ωX, the augmented .sup.1H circuit and its offset line 5 set up a large capacitive reactance (several thousand ohms, for example) at coil arms 12. In a similar manner, .sup.1H termination element 15, 16 sets up an even larger capacitive reactance. The end result is a capacitive reactance of around 7,000 ohms (nominal) or more, as both .sup.1H augmented tune/match circuit (capacitors 3, 4 in conjunction with augmented transmission line segment 2 and capacitor C.sub.NX 1) and .sup.1H termination element 15, 16 are effectively in series at ωX. However, both are in shunt with the X augmented tune/match circuit and the X termination element. A large capacitive reactance is essentially “swamped” by a very small resistive impedance, or near short. Thus, X tune/match and X termination elements act in concert to resonate the coil at ωX and transform the loaded coil impedance to 50 ohms at ωX, as desired. Thus, .sup.1H circuitry is transparent to X circuitry.
(44) With particular reference to the volume coil shown in
(45) Preferred embodiments of the resonator and its sub-assemblies and ancillary hardware are now described.
(46) Hybrid notch filters and hybrid termination elements can be constructed from low loss coaxial cable and high q capacitors, usually variable. In the preferred embodiment, hybrid notch filters and hybrid termination elements are constructed from low loss stripline or microstripline transmission line, with the line constructed on low loss substrate such as Rogers Duroid or Rexolite 1422. Conductive track such line should be at least 5 skin depths deep at the X nucleus (lowest) frequency. In the preferred embodiment, well known variants of stripline or microstripline such as meander line and fin line may be used in certain situations. Meander line saves space, while the use of fin line may help reduce dielectric loss at high frequencies, such as 200 MHz or higher. In the preferred embodiment, tune/match circuits, whether balanced capacitive L circuits, or pairs of single ended L circuits, can be feed from high performance current baluns, either ferrite bead (“W2DU balun”) or sleeve baluns. The Baluns should have a common mode current resistance of 5,000 to 6,000 ohms or more. Current balance should be within 1% or better, with phase difference of balun output currents within 1 degree of 180 degrees. In the preferred embodiment, shielded, balanced lines constructed from matched lengths of coaxial cable interconnect balun and augmented tune/match circuits. Cables should be integral multiples of ½ wave at the operating frequency of tune/match circuit.
(47) In the special case of .sup.1H/.sup.3He resonators, the hybrid notch filters, and possible the termination elements should be constructed from high Q helical resonators. Since the frequency spacing is small for this particular nuclear pair, it is desirable for the slope of notch filter curve (dV/dω) to be high, which is the case for high Q helical resonators, for Z helix is usually in the range of 800 to 1500 ohms. This allows the filter to return from notch to base in a span of about 9 or 10 MHz. In preferred embodiments, helical resonators will be wound on a low loss substrate, such as air or Rexolite 1422, and enveloped in a highly conductive shield can. Helical resonators may be bonded to tune/match circuits just as hybrid notch filters are so bonded.
(48) In preferred embodiments, either surface coils or volume coils may be fabricated. A plurality of surface coils may serve as a parallel transmit/receive array for accelerated imaging methods such as SMASH (SiMultaneous Acquisition of Spatial Harmonics) or SENSE (SENSitivity Encoding). Surface coils may be flat or conformal in shape.
(49) In preferred embodiments, volume coils are driven with 4 point drive (quadrature), while the other elements are passive, and will couple to other elements by induction. In yet another preferred environment, all elements are phased by DDS transmitter chips, with each conjugate pair of elements driven off a current balun.
(50) In preferred embodiments, arrays of surface coils are controlled and driven off multi-channel DDS transmitters, with each channel assigned a current balun.
Exemplary Example 1
(51) Summary:
(52) In this non-limiting example, a dual nuclear transmission line resonator design according to the disclosure which may be applied to both surface coils and volume coils is presented. The active elements of the resonator are resonant on both .sup.1H and X. No wave trap is used in the active elements, which are essentially “clean” transmission line elements. Efficiency is very high on both .sup.1H and X, and port-to-port isolation is excellent. In this example, a small .sup.1H/.sup.13C surface coil is described.
(53) Methods:
(54) A single loop transmission line resonator was constructed from copper clad Rexolite 1422. The loop was designed for 4.7T. This loop is essentially a “swelling” in a balanced transmission line, with an inner diameter of 2 cm. Termination elements were fabricated from equal lengths of HF-290 coaxial line, with ends terminated by variable piston capacitors. The piston capacitors were meshed to give resonance in the middle of the loop on both .sup.1H and .sup.13C. Balanced capacitive L tune/match circuits were used to match the loop to 50 ohms on both nuclei. Each L was augmented with a complementary nucleus hybrid resonator set to within about 20 KHz of target frequency and connected to a high performance ferrite bead current balun. Scattering parameters (S.sub.11 and S.sub.21) measurements were performed on a vector network analyzer (VNA), and 90 degree flips were measured on a Varian 4.7T console. Loop resonance and hybrid resonator adjustments were made using a grid dip meter augmented with a digital frequency counter.
(55)
(56) Results:
(57) Good Q was demonstrated on both .sup.1H and .sup.13C, with −55 dB and −49 dB, respectively, on VNA S.sub.11 measurements. S.sub.21 measurements showed −63 dB isolation for .sup.13C.fwdarw..sup.1H, and −45 dB .sup.1H.fwdarw..sup.13C. The low insertion loss of the tune/match augmentation resonators was verified by measuring virtually equal .sup.1H 90 degree flip angle powers with the .sup.13C augmentation resonator in circuit and out of circuit. This is shown in
(58) Conclusion:
(59) Careful design and placement of hybrid termination elements and hybrid augmentation resonators leads to the realization of a dual nuclear coil with high efficiency on both .sup.1H and X. This design sidesteps many of the problems inherent in other dual nuclear designs.
REFERENCES
(60) 1) Erickson M G, et al. TEM Transmission Line Coil . . . MRM 2007 October 58(4) 800-7. 2) Electronic Applications of the Smith Chart P H Smith, 2nd Edition 1995. 3) Vaughan J T, et al. High frequency volume coils . . . MRM 1994 32 Feb. 6, 2018
Exemplary Example 2
(61) Method:
(62) The dual nuclear transmission line resonator of Exemplary Example 1 was also used for Exemplary Example 2.
(63) Results:
(64) Unloaded Q was measured for both .sup.1H and .sup.13C by measuring the derivative of the S.sub.11 curve on either side of resonance. Q was 245 for .sup.1H and 196 for .sup.13C. Next, the coil was loaded with a .sup.13C urea phantom. After shimming on .sup.1H, the .sup.13C spectrum in
(65) Conclusion:
(66) An experimental dual nuclear transmission line resonator was successfully constructed and tested. The design side steps many of the problems inherent in conventional dual nuclear designs. No LC trap is used, and the coil has essentially the same spatial profile on both nuclei. This resonator could be used in real time, simultaneous .sup.1H/X T/R operation. The resonator is not difficult to fabricate, and lends itself to volume coils and array designs.
(67) All references cited herein are expressly incorporated by reference in their entirety. It will be appreciated by persons skilled in the art that the present disclosure is not limited to what has been particularly shown and described herein above. In addition, unless mention was made above to the contrary, it should be noted that all of the accompanying drawings are not to scale. There are many different features to the present disclosure and it is contemplated that these features may be used together or separately. Thus, the disclosure should not be limited to any particular combination of features or to a particular application of the disclosure. Further, it should be understood that variations and modifications within the spirit and scope of the disclosure might occur to those skilled in the art to which the disclosure pertains. Accordingly, all expedient modifications readily attainable by one versed in the art from the disclosure set forth herein that are within the scope and spirit of the present disclosure are to be included as further embodiments of the present disclosure.