System and method for predetermining the onset of impending oscillatory instabilities in practical devices
11454394 · 2022-09-27
Assignee
Inventors
- Induja Pavithran (Chennai, IN)
- Vishnu Rajasekharan Unni (Chennai, IN)
- Raman Pillai Indusekharan Nair Sujith (Chennai, IN)
Cpc classification
F23N5/16
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05D2270/80
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
G01H1/00
PHYSICS
F05D2270/44
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05D2260/964
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23R2900/00013
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
International classification
Abstract
A system for early detection of onset of oscillatory instabilities in practical devices is described. The system consists of a measuring device (102), an instability detection unit (104) and a control unit (106). The measuring device (102) is configured to generate signals corresponding to the dynamics happening inside the practical device. The instability detection unit (104) along with an amplitude estimation unit (130) is configured to diagnose the stability of the practical device from the signals that are generated by the measuring device (102). Further, the control unit (106) is configured to control various operating parameters in the practical device based on the information obtained from the instability detection unit (104).
Claims
1. A system to determine impending oscillatory instabilities in a device, the system comprising: a measuring device (102) configured to generate at least one signal corresponding to dynamics in the device; an instability detection unit (104) provided in communication with the measuring device (102); and an amplitude estimation unit (130) provided in communication with the instability detection unit (104) and the measuring device (102), configured to estimate an amplitude of the impending oscillatory instabilities, wherein, the instability detection unit (104) is configured to diagnose the onset of the impending oscillatory instabilities in the device based on at least one of intermittent bursts in the signal generated by the measuring device (102) before the onset of oscillatory instabilities, or smooth variations in parameters as the device approaches the impending oscillatory instabilities, wherein the intermittent bursts are detected preceding a transition from a noisy or chaotic behavior to the oscillatory instabilities by detecting an increase in the amplitude of the impending oscillatory instabilities using the amplitude estimation unit (130).
2. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the system further includes a control unit (106) provided in communication with at least one of the measuring device (102), the instability detection unit (104) and the amplitude estimation unit (130), wherein the instability detection unit (104) is configured to generate control signal corresponding to onset of the impending oscillatory instabilities; and the control unit (106) is configured to control the oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts based on the control signal.
3. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the system is used to detect the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts in at least one of a combustor, an industrial furnace, a burner, aeroacoustic systems, aero-elastic systems, aeromechanical systems, air-compression systems and any other device subjected to oscillatory instabilities.
4. The system as claimed in claim 3, wherein a digital to analog convertor (120) is integrated with the system to convert at least one digital signal obtained as an output from the instability detection unit (104) to at least one analog signal that could be processed by a control unit (106).
5. The system as claimed in 1, wherein the measuring device (102) includes a plurality of sensors that are configured to generate the signal corresponding to the dynamics of the device.
6. The system as claimed in 5, wherein the sensor is selected from at least one of an acoustic sensor, a photodiode and a photomultiplier.
7. The system as claimed in 1, wherein an analog to digital converter (128) is integrated with the system to convert at least one analog signal generated by the measuring device (102) to at least one digital signal that could be processed by the instability detection unit (104) and the amplitude estimation unit (130).
8. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the system determines the proximity of the device to the oscillatory instabilities that proceeds through the intermittent bursts by performing at least one of 0-1 test, Burst count test and Hurst exponent test.
9. The system as claimed in claim 8, wherein the system configured to detect and control the impending oscillatory instabilities in the device by performing the 0-1 test comprises: the measuring device (102) provided in communication with the device and configured to generate at least one signal (measured signal) corresponding to the dynamics in the device; a signal conditioner (108) in communication with the measuring device (102) and configured to amplify the measured signal generated in the measuring device (102); an analog to digital convertor (128) connected to the signal conditioner; the amplitude estimation unit (130) in communication with the instability detection unit (104) and configured to estimate the amplitude of the impending oscillatory instability; the instability detection unit (104) provided in communication with the analog to digital convertor (128) and the amplitude estimation unit (130), wherein the instability detection unit (104) is configured to generate a value between 0 and 1 based both on the amplitude of instability estimated by the amplitude estimation unit (130) and the proximity of the device to the oscillatory instabilities proceeding through the intermittent bursts in the device; at least one digital to analog convertor (120) provided in communication with the instability detection unit (104); and the control unit (106) provided in communication with the digital to analog convertor, wherein the instability detection unit (104) is configured to generate a value close to 1 for noisy/chaotic signals and close to 0 for oscillatory dynamics and values in between 0 and 1 for the intermittent bursts.
10. The system as claimed in claim 8, wherein the system configured to detect and control the impending oscillatory instabilities in the device that proceed through the intermittent bursts by performing the Burst count test comprises: a measuring device (202) provided in communication with the device and configured to generate at least one signal (measured signal) corresponding to the dynamics in the device; a threshold logic circuit (210) having a fixed threshold value for the signal; an amplitude estimation logic unit (232), provided in communication with the threshold logic unit (210) and configured to estimate the amplitude of the oscillations during instability, before instability is approached; an internal gating circuit (204) provided in communication with the threshold logic circuit (210) and configured to generate a gating signal; a comparator (212) provided in communication with the threshold logic circuit (210) and configured to compare measured signal with the fixed threshold value of the signal; a counter (216) provided in communication with the threshold logic circuit (210) and configured to count a number of peaks in the at least one signal above the fixed threshold value of the signal; and a controller (218) provided in communication with the counter (216) and configured to regulate the functioning of the device, wherein the gating signal controls a time duration of signal acquisition from the device.
11. The system as claimed in claim 10, wherein the system further includes a signal conditioner (208) provided in communication with the measuring device (202) and configured to amplify the measured signal.
12. The system as claimed in claim 10, wherein the controller (218) is configured to regulate the functioning of at least one of operating parameters of the device, such that the device is prevented from the oscillatory instabilities that happen through the intermittent bursts.
13. The system as claimed in claim 8, wherein the system configured to detect and control the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceeds through the intermittent bursts in the device by performing the Hurst exponent test comprises: the measuring device (302) provided in communication with the device and configured to generate at least one signal (measured signal) corresponding to the dynamics in the device; a signal conditioner (326) in communication with the measuring device (102); an analog to digital convertor (328) connected to the signal conditioner; the instability detection unit (304) attached to the analog to digital convertor (328); an amplitude estimation unit (306) in communication with the instability detection unit (304), configured to obtain information based on the stability of the device from the instability detection unit (304) and to estimate the amplitude of oscillations before the device exhibits instability; at least one digital to analog convertor (330) connected to the instability detection unit (304); and a second controller (332) attached with the digital to analog convertor; wherein the instability detection unit (304) is configured to generate a value close to 0 for oscillatory dynamics and values in between 0 and 1 for the intermittent bursts.
14. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the system determines an onset of the impending oscillatory instabilities by using a measure that can track the presence of the intermittent bursts in the signal.
15. The system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the system determines the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceeds through the intermittent bursts using at least one of variations in measures of fractality, variations in measures of multifractality, or variations in measures computed through recurrence quantification, for changes in the operating conditions of the device.
16. A method to determine impending oscillatory instabilities in a device, the method comprising: obtaining, by a measuring device (102), at least one signal (measured signal) corresponding to the dynamics in the device; and estimating, by an amplitude estimation unit (130), an amplitude of at least one of intermittent bursts in the at least one signal corresponding to the dynamics in the device; diagnosing, through an instability detection unit (104), the impending oscillatory instabilities of the device by utilizing at least one of intermittent bursts in the signal generated by the measuring device (102) and the estimated amplitude, before the onset of oscillatory instabilities or the smooth variations in parameters as the device approaches the impending oscillatory instabilities, wherein the intermittent bursts are detected preceding to a transition from a noisy or chaotic behavior to the oscillatory instabilities.
17. The method as claimed in claim 16, further includes generating using by a control unit (106), a control signal corresponding to the onset of the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts in the device; and controlling the oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts based on the control signal.
18. The method as claimed in claim 16, wherein the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts in the device is diagnosed by performing at least one of 0-1 test, Burst count test and Hurst exponent test.
19. The method as claimed in claim 18, wherein the process of diagnosing the impending oscillatory instabilities in the device by performing the 0-1 test comprises: generating at least one signal (measured signal) corresponding to the dynamics the device; amplifying the at least one signal generated in the measuring device (102); estimating the amplitude of oscillations during the oscillatory instability of the at least one signal; generating a value between 0 and 1 based on the estimated amplitude of oscillations during oscillatory instability and the proximity of the device to oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts in the device; and generating a value close to 1 for noisy/chaotic signals and close to 0 for oscillatory dynamics and values between 0 and 1 for the intermittent bursts.
20. The method as claimed in claim 16, wherein the impending oscillatory instabilities in the device that proceed through the intermittent bursts is diagnosed using a measure that can track the presence of the intermittent bursts in the signal.
21. The method as claimed in claim 16, wherein the process of diagnosing the impending oscillatory instabilities by using the intermittent burst produced during the oscillatory instabilities further includes: providing a threshold logic having a fixed threshold value for the signal; estimating the amplitude of the intermittent bursts during instability before instability is approached; providing a gating signal that is configured to control the time duration of signal acquisition from the device; comparing the measured signal with the fixed threshold value of the signal; counting the number of peaks in the at least one signal above the fixed threshold value of the signal; and controlling the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts in the device based on the number of peaks.
22. The method as claimed in claim 16, wherein the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceed through the intermittent bursts of the device is diagnosed using at least one of variations in measures of fractality, variations in measures of multifractality or variations in measures computed through recurrence quantification, for changes in the operating conditions of the device.
23. The method as claimed in claim 16, wherein the process of diagnosing the impending oscillatory instabilities that proceeds through the intermittent bursts in the device comprises performing a Hurst exponent test which generates a value close to 0 for oscillatory dynamics and values in between 0 and 1 for the intermittent bursts.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF FIGURES
(1) This invention is illustrated in the accompanying drawings, throughout which like reference letters indicate corresponding parts in the various figures. The embodiments herein will be better understood from the following description with reference to the drawings, in which:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION
(11) The embodiments herein and the various features and advantageous details thereof are explained more fully with reference to the non-limiting embodiments that are illustrated in the accompanying drawings and detailed in the following description. Descriptions of well-known components and processing techniques are omitted so as to not unnecessarily obscure the embodiments herein. The examples used herein are intended merely to facilitate an understanding of the ways in which the embodiments may be practiced and to further enable those of skill in the art to practice the embodiments. For example, although, certain embodiments herein are related to the system and method for early detection of instabilities in devices such as combustors in gas turbines, and industrial processing devices such as furnaces and burners for the ease of understanding the invention, it should be noted that the system according to the present invention may also be used for any other devices in which the transition to oscillatory instability from chaotic behavior happens though intermittent bursts. Further, although, certain embodiments herein are related to the system and method for detecting and preventing oscillatory instabilities in combustion systems, it should be noted that the system and method according to the present invention could also be used for preventing oscillatory instability in any noisy or chaotic systems; for example, structural instabilities that may arise due to aeroelastic flutter or flow induced vibration, aerodynamic and aeromechanical instabilities such as surge and, or instabilities arising in magnetohydrodynamics, or aeroacoustic instabilities in gas transport systems exhibiting pipe tone instabilities. Furthermore, although, certain embodiments herein are related to the systems and methods that utilizes faster and more robust techniques of burst counting and Hurst exponent methods for early detection of onset of instabilities, it should be noted that the system could utilize any other methods that could determine the transition to instability through intermittent burst in a smooth manner. Accordingly, the examples should not be construed as limiting the scope of the embodiments herein.
(12) The embodiments herein achieve a system and method for determining the oscillatory instabilities in practical devices, before the instability occurs. Further, the embodiments herein achieve a system and method for predetermining the oscillatory instabilities in practical devices and controlling various parameters of the device in order to prevent the device from oscillatory instabilities. Further, the embodiments herein achieve a system and method for early detection of onset of oscillatory instabilities in devices where the transition to oscillatory instability from chaotic or noisy behavior happens though intermittent bursts, and controlling various parameters of the device in order to prevent the device from developing oscillatory instabilities. Referring now to the drawings, and more particularly to
(13)
(14) In another embodiment, the system 100 also includes a signal conditioner 108, an analog to digital convertor 128 and a digital to analog convertor 120. The signal conditioner 108 is configured to manipulate the signal (Φ(j)) generated by the measuring device 102, such that it meets the requirements of analog to digital convertor 128. In an embodiment, the signal conditioner 108 is configured to amplify the signal (Φ(j)) generated by measuring device 102. Further, if the signal (Φ(j)) obtained from the measuring device 102 is analog, the analog to digital convertor 128 coverts the analog signal to digital signal such that the signals (Φ(j)) could be processed in the instability detection unit 104 and in turn in the amplitude estimation unit 130. Further, the digital to analog convertor 120 converts the digital signal obtained as the output from instability detection unit 104 to an analog signal such that it could be processed by the control unit 106.
(15) It should be noted that the aforementioned configuration of system 100 is provided for the ease of understanding of the embodiments of the invention. However, certain embodiments may have a different configuration of the components of the system 100 and certain other embodiments may exclude certain components of the system 100. Therefore, such embodiments and any modification by addition or exclusion of certain components of system 100 and without otherwise deterring the intended function of the system 100 as is apparent from this description and drawings are also within the scope of this invention.
(16) In an embodiment, the instability detection unit 104 diagnoses whether the dynamics of the combustor is chaotic/noisy or non-chaotic/periodic, based on the signals Φ(j) generated by the measuring device 102 as a time series. A mathematical method described as 0-1 test in the literature can be used to identify the presence of chaos in a given time series. The instability detection unit 104 encapsulates a fundamentally new and heretofore unexplored application of the test as a tracker of oscillatory instabilities. The signal Φ(j) is measured such that the measured value at each instant provides essentially no information about future values when the combustor is in a stable operating condition. This is accomplished by configuring the instability detection unit 104 to sample the measured signal at a time interval corresponding to the first minimum of the average mutual information of the signal Φ(j). The average mutual information could be obtained as
(17)
(18) where,
(19) l represents the average mutual information.
(20) τ represents the location of average mutual information.
(21) Φ(j) represents the measured signal from combustor for j=(1, 2, . . . , N)
(22) P(S) represents probability of the event S.
(23) Typically, the location of the first minimum of the average mutual information (τ.sub.min) is T/4, where T is the natural acoustic period of oscillations in the combustor. In an embodiment, although, the value of τ.sub.min is prescribed, the instability detection unit 104 is robust for various values of the sampling interval as long as the consecutive values are poorly correlated. For example, comparable values of τ.sub.min may also be obtained by using a sampling interval corresponding to the first zero crossing of the autocorrelation of Φ(j).
(24) Further, from the measured signal Φ(j) for j=(1, 2, . . . , N) and j.sub.i+i−j.sub.i=τ.sub.min, translation variables p.sub.c and q.sub.c is obtained as,
(25)
where c is chosen randomly in the interval (π/5, 4π/5). The diffusive (or non-diffusive) behavior of p.sub.c and q.sub.c can be investigated by analyzing the mean square displacement M.sub.c(n). If the dynamics is regular then the mean square displacement is a bounded function in time, whereas if the dynamics is chaotic then the mean square displacement scales linearly with time. The mean square displacement M.sub.c(n) of the translation variables could be computed as
(26)
Note that this definition requires n<<N, where N represents the size of the measured signal. Further, the limit is assured by calculating M.sub.c(n) only for n≤n.sub.cut where n.sub.cut<<N. In practice, we find that n.sub.cut=N/10 yields good results, where n.sub.cut represents the value of the index up to which mean square displacement M.sub.c(n) is calculated. The test for chaos is based on the growth rate of M.sub.c(n) as a function of n. Hence, in order to formulate a modified mean square displacement D.sub.c(n) which exhibits the same asymptotic growth as M.sub.c(n) but with better convergence properties, the instability detection unit 104 is configured to remove the oscillatory term V.sub.osc(c, n) from the mean square displacement M.sub.c(n). The modified mean square displacement D.sub.c(n) could be obtained as
(27)
(28) Hence, by defining vectors ξ=(1, 2, . . . , n.sub.cut) and Δ=(D.sub.c(1), D.sub.c(2), . . . , D.sub.c(n.sub.cut)), the asymptotic growth rate K.sub.c of the modified mean square displacement D.sub.c with n could be obtained from the correlation of the vectors ξ and Δ. Normally, the value of K.sub.c essentially allows the user of the system 100 to distinguish between the chaotic and non-chaotic dynamics of the combustor. The asymptotic growth rate K.sub.c is a function of c for regular and chaotic dynamics. In the case of periodic dynamics, most values of c yield K.sub.c=0 as expected, but there are isolated values of c for which K.sub.c is large. Therefore, to ensure robustness of the measure to outliers and spurious resonances, the median value of K.sub.c (say K) is obtained for different random values of c.
(29) The obtained value of K would lie close to 1 for noisy/chaotic signals and close to 0 for regular dynamics. Further, if the combustor flow field is inherently turbulent, the transition to instability would be associated with a decrease in the value of K from 1 to a lower value depending on the turbulent intensity; i.e., higher the intensity of turbulence at instability, higher the departure of K from 0 at instability. Hence, a threshold value of K may be defined upon crossing of which a suitable control unit 106 may be configured to control various parameters of the combustor and maintain the combustor under stable operating conditions.
(30)
(31) After computing τ.sub.min, the sampling rate (F.sub.s) at which the signal Φ(j) is acquired could be then revised as F.sub.s=10/τ.sub.min. By fixing the sampling rate (F.sub.s) the system could be optimized for precursor detection. It should be noted that the aforementioned procedure for obtaining τ.sub.min and F.sub.s is provided for the ease of understanding of an embodiment of the invention. Further, although the aforementioned values of τ.sub.min and F.sub.s are prescribed, it should be noted that the detection techniques utilized in the system 100 as disclosed in this description are robust for changes in these quantities within a reasonable range.
(32) The system 200 includes at least one sensor. The sensor is configured to acquire signal from the device (combustor (C)) to which the system 200 is incorporated. The acquired signal then reaches the instability detection unit 204 where the proximity of the operating condition to instability is determined. Further, the instability detection unit 204 is configured to generate appropriate signals corresponding to the instability and transfers the signals to the control unit 218.
(33) The controller 218 is configured to control various operating parameters in the combustor (C) based on the information obtained from the instability detection unit 204. In an embodiment, a suitable threshold is set for the number obtained by the instability detection unit 204, such that when the threshold is crossed, the control unit 218 suitably ensures that the combustor (C) remains in stable operating conditions, by controlling various parameters in the combustor (C), thereby increasing the stability margin of the combustor (C).
(34) The instability detection unit 204 diagnoses the onset of instabilities in the device (combustor (C)) to which the system 200 is incorporated and provides a signal to the amplitude estimation unit 230 to estimate the amplitude of the oscillations during instability, by examining the bursts generated within the device prior to instability. Bursts refer to a sudden spike in the amplitude of the measured signal which decays after a short duration. The occurrence of such bursts in the measured signal leads to an intermittent switching behavior of the signal between low and high amplitudes. This is often the case in high Reynolds number flow devices where the transition to oscillatory instability from chaotic behavior happens through intermittent bursts. Such bursts are also common in systems with high levels of noise where the transition to instability happens through a region characterized by intermittent bursts.
(35) In one embodiment, the onset of impending instabilities is determined by counting the number of peaks (N) in the signal Φ(j) above a user-defined threshold (ξ) for a time duration (t). The threshold (ξ) would correspond to the acceptable levels of amplitude of the device (combustor (C)). In an embodiment, the value of time duration (t) is defined as 400 τ.sub.MIN and all the peaks (N.sub.tot) that are generated within the time duration (t) are counted. In an embodiment, the time duration (t) would correspond to 100 oscillatory cycles in the device (combustor (C)) at full blown instability. For example, in a device such as combustor (C) with instability happening at 250 Hz, the sampling would be at 10 kHz for time duration of 400 ms. The probability of the operating condition becoming unstable can be defined as
p=N/n.sub.tot
The value of p is a measure of the proximity of the operating condition to instability. In an embodiment, the value of p smoothly increases towards 1 for an increase of the parameters towards instability. Further, the combustor (C) could be prevented from instability by activating the control unit 218 when the measured value of p exceeds a set threshold probability as required. In an embodiment, a suitable threshold is set for the probability of the combustor (C) to attain instability, such that when the threshold value is obtained, the control unit 218 suitably ensures that the combustor (C) remains in stable operating conditions, by controlling various control parameters in the combustor (C), thereby increasing the stability margin of the combustor (C).
(36) In an embodiment, the system 200 provided with a unit for early detection of onset of instabilities in the combustor (C), by counting the bursts generated within the combustor (C) includes a signal conditioner 208, threshold logic 210, a comparator 212, a gating signal 214, a counter 216, and a control unit 218 as shown in
(37) It should be noted that the aforementioned configuration of system 200 is provided for the ease of understanding of the embodiments of the invention. However, certain embodiments may have a different configuration of the components of the system 200 and certain other embodiments may exclude certain components of the system 200. Therefore, such embodiments and any modification by addition or exclusion of certain components of system 200 and without otherwise deterring the intended function of the system 200 as is apparent from this description and drawings are also within the scope of this invention. The amplitude estimation unit 230, uses the signals generated by the instability detection unit to in turn estimate the amplitude of the oscillations during instability before instability is approached using amplitude estimation logic 232.
(38) In yet another embodiment, the onset of impending instabilities is determined by means of computing the Hurst exponent. For determining the Hurst exponent, the signal Φ(j) of length L is divided into a number (n) of non-overlapping segments (x.sub.i(j), i=1, 2, . . . , n) of equal span (w). Further, the mean of the signal is subtracted from these segments to obtain a cumulative deviate series as,
(39)
(40) Furthermore, in order to account for local trends in the segments, a local polynomial fit (
(41)
(42) The Hurst exponent H.sup.2 is then obtained as the slope of the linear regime in a log-log plot of S.sub.w.sup.2 for various span sizes.
(43)
(44) It should be noted that the aforementioned configuration of system 300 is provided for the ease of understanding of the embodiments of the invention. However, certain embodiments may have a different configuration of the components of the system 300 and certain other embodiments may exclude certain components of the system 300. Therefore, such embodiments and any modification by addition or exclusion of certain components of system 300 and without otherwise deterring the intended function of the system 100 as is apparent from this description and drawings are also within the scope of this invention.
(45) A method for early detection of onset of oscillatory instabilities in practical devices and controlling various parameters of the device in order to prevent the device from oscillatory instabilities is explained herein below.
(46)
(47)
(48) The foregoing description of the specific embodiments will so fully reveal the general nature of the embodiments herein that others can, by applying the current knowledge, readily modify and/or adapt for various applications such specific embodiments without departing from the generic concept, and, therefore, such adaptations and modifications should and are intended to be comprehended within the meaning and range of equivalents of the disclosed embodiments. For example, although, certain embodiments herein are related to the system and method that utilizes the 0-1 test, burst counter and Hurst exponent methods for early detection of onset of instabilities as they are fast and robust, it should be noted that the system could utilize any other methods that could determine the transition to instability through intermittent bursts. For instance, from the variations in the generalized Hurst exponent data (H.sup.q), the Holder spectrum could be constructed. Further, a multifractal spectrum width (W) could be calculated by means of the constructed Holder spectrum. The multifractal spectrum width (W) also has a decreasing trend as the device approaches instability and thereby can be used as an indicator to identify the onset of instability. Another possible indicator to identify the onset of instability could be obtained from what are known as recurrence plots. By a recurrence quantification analysis, quantities such as laminarity, determinism, trapping time and so on could be obtained. These quantities show trends indicative of the transition. Changes in the values of the largest Lyapunov exponent are another useful indicator. Furthermore, although certain embodiments of the invention discloses the system and method for determining impending instabilities in combustor, it should be noted that the system and method as disclosed in the present invention could be used for any other device that is subject to oscillatory instabilities. For example, the generality of the method may be seen in