System and method for forecasting tax effects of financial transactions
09773276 · 2017-09-26
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G06Q40/00
PHYSICS
International classification
G06Q40/00
PHYSICS
G06Q20/10
PHYSICS
Abstract
A system and method for forecasting tax effects of financial transactions is provided. The system and method include a series of web pages. The web pages allow a user to 1) determine their federal and state tax rates, 2) describe the asset they wish to sell. Additional web pages then display the tax consequences of the sale of the asset along with the details of the calculations used to evaluate those consequences. Still more web pages can be used to describe an asset to buy. In this case, the displayed consequences are expanded to compare the benefit of holding the current asset against the benefit of acquiring the new asset.
Claims
1. A computer system for forecasting and comparing financial effects of holding a first asset versus selling the first asset and purchasing a second asset, comprising: a processor; and a non-transitory computer readable medium comprising code, executable by a processor, for implementing a method comprising the steps of generating, with the processor, a first sequence of one or more web pages, wherein the first sequence of the one or more web pages presents a user with an option using a link to compare the financial effects, in response to selection of the option using the link to compare the financial effects, generating a second sequence of one or more web pages, wherein the second sequence of one or more web pages contains a plurality of fields for the user to enter information describing the first asset, second asset, and user tax rates and wherein the second sequence of one or more web pages further includes a tax rate assistance option that generates a sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income, wherein the sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income comprises fields for user input of information describing the user's tax filing status, taxable income, state income tax rates, and state long term capital gains rates, in response to receiving information describing the first asset, calculating the financial effects of holding or selling the first asset using information describing the first asset, in response to receiving information describing the second asset, calculating the financial effects of selling the first asset and buying the second asset using information describing the first asset and second asset, and generating a third sequence of one or more web pages displaying the financial effects of holding or selling the first asset, wherein the financial effects include investment tips that comprise an amount of time that the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes.
2. The system of claim 1, wherein the plurality of fields are configured to receive at least one of the following: a combined federal and state ordinary income tax rate; a combined federal and state long-term capital gains tax rate; a first asset ticker symbol; a date of purchase of the first asset; a cost per share at purchase of the first asset; a first load or commission paid at purchase of the first asset; a number of shares to be sold of the first asset; a target or estimated price per-share that the first asset will bring when sold; and a second load or commission to be paid at the sale of the first asset.
3. The system of claim 1, wherein the financial effects include at least one of the following: a time the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes and an amount saved by utilizing long-term capital gains tax rates, an estimated capital gain or loss, an estimated net proceed from a sale of the first asset, and an estimated capital gains tax due resulting from the sale of the first asset.
4. The system of claim 1, wherein the plurality of fields are configured to receive at least one of the following: a combined federal and state ordinary income tax rate; a combined federal and state long-term capital gains tax rate; a first asset ticker symbol; a date of purchase of the first asset; a cost per share at purchase of the first asset; a first load or commission paid at purchase of the first asset; a number of shares to be sold of the first asset; a target or estimated price per-share that the first asset will bring when sold; a second load or commission to be paid at the sale of the first asset; an anticipated rate of return on the first asset; a second asset ticker symbol; an amount to invest of the second asset; a third load or commission to be paid at purchase for the second asset; a second anticipated rate of return on the second asset; and an expected number of years that either the first or the second asset will be held.
5. The system of claim 1, wherein the financial effects include at least one of the following: a time the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes and an amount saved by utilizing long-term capital gains tax rates, an estimated capital gain or loss, an estimated net proceed from a sale of the first asset, an estimated capital gains tax due resulting from the sale of the first asset, and a holding time period for holding the second asset so that the second asset will have a value that would be equal to the value for the first asset if the first asset is not sold.
6. The system of claim 1, wherein the plurality of fields are configured to receive a target or estimated price per-share that the first asset will bring when sold and the second sequence of one or more web pages includes a link to obtain the current price of the stock to be sold.
7. The system of claim 1, wherein one or more web pages in the third sequence show the calculations used to calculate the financial effects of selling the first asset.
8. The system of claim 1, wherein the investment tips further comprise an amount of money saved by delaying the sale of the first asset by the amount of time that the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes and thereby utilizing long-term capital gains tax rates.
9. The system of claim 1, wherein the method comprises displaying the first sequence of one or more web pages, second sequence of one or more web pages, and third sequence of one or more web pages.
10. The computer system of claim 9, wherein the investment tips are provided in a textual form.
11. A computer system for forecasting financial effects of a financial transaction, the system comprising: a processor; and a non-transitory computer readable medium coupled to the processor, the computer readable medium comprising code, executable by a processor, for implementing a method comprising the steps of generating a first sequence of one or more web pages, wherein the first sequence of one or more web pages presents a user with a first option of calculating tax on a sale of an asset and a second option of comparing two investment options on an after-tax basis, where a first investment option is continuing to hold the asset, and a second investment option is selling the asset and purchasing a different asset, wherein the first option and the second option are presented using links in the first sequence of one or more web pages, in response to selection of the first option, generating a second sequence of one or more web pages, the second sequence of one or more web pages containing fields for user input of information describing the user's tax rates and information describing the asset to be sold, wherein the second sequence of one or more web pages further presents the user with a tax rate assistance option and, in response to the user selecting the tax rate assistance option, generating a sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income, in response to receiving information describing the user's tax rates and information describing the asset to be sold, calculating the financial effects resulting from the sale of the asset to be sold, and generating a third sequence of one or more web pages displaying the financial effects of selling the asset to be sold, wherein the financial effects include a time the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes and an amount saved by utilizing long-term capital gains tax rates.
12. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the method comprises generating a fourth sequence of one or more web pages summarizing calculations used in the step of calculating financial effects.
13. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the method further comprises: in response to the user selecting the second option, generating a fifth sequence of one or more web pages, the fifth sequence of one more web pages containing fields for user input of information describing the user's federal and state tax rates, and information describing the asset to be sold, and information describing the different asset to be purchased.
14. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein calculating financial effects further comprises: calculating capital gain or loss resulting from the sale of the asset; calculating net proceeds resulting from the sale of the asset; and calculating estimated tax resulting from the sale of the asset.
15. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein information describing the user's tax rates includes a first rate at which the user pays state and federal income tax and a second rate at which the user pays state and federal capital gains tax.
16. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the information describing the asset to be sold includes at least one of the following: an asset ticker symbol; a date of purchase of the asset; a cost per share at purchase of the asset; a first load or commission paid at purchase of the asset; a number of shares to be sold of the asset; a target or estimated price per-share that the asset will bring when sold; a second load or commission to be paid at the sale of the asset; and an anticipated rate of return on the asset.
17. The computer system as recited in claim 13, wherein the information describing the different asset to be purchased includes at least one of the following: a different asset ticker symbol; an amount to invest of the different asset; a third load or commission to be paid at purchase of the different asset; a different anticipated rate of return on the different asset; and an expected number of years that the different asset will be held.
18. The computer system of claim 11, wherein the sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income further presents the user with a taxable income calculator option and, in response to the user selecting the taxable income calculator option, generating a sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's taxable income based on the user's prior tax forms.
19. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the information describing the asset to be sold includes at least an asset ticker symbol, and the second sequence of web pages presents the user with a symbol lookup option.
20. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the method comprises displaying the first sequence of one or more web pages, second sequence of one or more web pages, and third sequence of one or more web pages.
21. The computer system as recited in claim 13, wherein the link to the first option, when selected, causes the user's web browser to navigate to the second sequence of one or more webpages and the link to the second option, when selected, causes the user's web browser to navigate to the fifth sequence of one or more webpages.
22. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income, generated in response to the user selecting the tax rate assistance option, further comprises fields for user input of information describing the user's tax filing status.
23. The computer system as recited in claim 22, wherein the user's tax filing status is single, married filing jointly, or married filing separately.
24. The computer system as recited in claim 11, wherein the user's state of residence is obtained from an internal database and the user's state of residence is used in calculating the user's tax rate.
25. A method for forecasting and comparing financial effects of holding a first asset versus selling the first asset and purchasing a second asset, the method comprising: generating, with a server, a first sequence of one or more web pages, wherein the first sequence of the one or more web pages presents a user with an option using a link to compare the financial effects of holding or selling the first asset and purchasing the second asset; in response to receiving a user's selection of the option using the link to compare the financial effects, generating, with the server, a second sequence of one or more web pages, wherein the second sequence of one or more web pages includes a plurality of fields for the user to enter information describing the first asset, the second asset, and the user's tax rates and wherein the second sequence of one or more web pages further includes a tax rate assistance option that generates a sequence of one or more web pages to assist the user in determining the user's tax rate based on the user's taxable income; in response to receiving information describing the first asset, calculating, with the server, the financial effects of holding the first asset with the server; in response to receiving information describing the first asset and the second asset, calculating, with the server, the financial effects of selling the first asset and purchasing a second asset; and generating, with the server, a third sequence of one or more web pages displaying the financial effects, wherein the financial effects include a specified time the first asset must be held to avoid short-term capital gains taxes and an amount saved by utilizing long-term capital gains tax rates if the first asset is held for the specified time.
26. The method of claim 25, wherein the plurality of fields are configured to receive at least one of the following: a combined federal and state ordinary income tax rate; a combined federal and state long-term capital gains tax rate; a first asset ticker symbol; a date of purchase of the first asset; a cost per share at purchase of the first asset; a first load or commission paid at purchase of the first asset; a number of shares to be sold of the first asset; a target or estimated price per-share that the first asset will bring when sold; and a second load or commission to be paid at the sale of the first asset.
27. The method of claim 25, wherein the financial effects include at least one of the following: an estimated capital gain or loss, an estimated net proceed from a sale of the first asset, and an estimated capital gains tax due resulting from the sale of the first asset.
28. The method of claim 25, wherein the plurality of fields are configured to receive at least one of the following: a combined federal and state ordinary income tax rate; a combined federal and state long-term capital gains tax rate; a first asset ticker symbol; a date of purchase of the first asset; a cost per share at purchase of the first asset; a first load or commission paid at purchase of the first asset; a number of shares to be sold of the first asset; a target or estimated price per-share that the first asset will bring when sold; a second load or commission to be paid at the sale of the first asset; an anticipated rate of return on the first asset; a second asset ticker symbol; an amount to invest of the second asset; a third load or commission to be paid at purchase for the second asset; a second anticipated rate of return on the second asset; and an expected number of years that either the first or the second asset will be held.
29. The method of claim 25, wherein the financial effects further include a holding time period for holding the second asset so that the second asset will have a value that would be equal to the value for the first asset if the first asset were not sold.
30. The method of claim 25, wherein the third sequence of one or more web pages displaying the financial effects of holding or selling the first asset includes links to view underlying calculation details.
31. The method of claim 25, further comprising displaying the first sequence of one or more web pages, second sequence of one or more web pages, and third sequence of one or more web pages.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) For a more complete understanding of the present invention and for further features and advantages, reference is now made to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
(15) The preferred embodiments of the present invention and their advantages are best understood by referring to
(16) Environment
(17) In
(18)
(19) For the purposes of this description, it may be assumed that one or more computer systems 102 are configured as web servers. Other computer systems 102 may be assumed to be web clients. Computers 102 that act as web clients include a web browser program 214. Web browser programs 214 request web pages from web server programs 212 using the hypertext transport protocol (HTTP). Web server programs 214 receive these requests and, where appropriate return corresponding web pages.
(20) System and Method for Forecasting Tax Effects of Financial Transactions
(21) An embodiment of the present invention provides a system and method for forecasting tax effects of financial transactions. The tax determination method is embedded in a series of web pages provided by one or more of web server programs 212. Users access these web pages to forecast the tax consequences associated with performing securities transactions.
(22)
(23) Selecting either of the two options within web page 300 brings the user to web page 400 (see
(24) Selecting of the first option (i.e., choosing to determine the tax consequences of selling a security) web page 300 causes web page 400 to followed by web page 500 (see
(25) Web page 500 includes a “Get Results” button. This button is activated by the user when they have finished entering the required information and wish to see the results of tax consequences of their proposed sale.
(26) Activation of the “Get Results” button invokes web page 600 (see
(27) The editable, interactive summary of the proposed transaction Web page 600 includes fields for the remaining values previously entered by the user using web page 500. These values are also editable, providing the user with the option of experimenting with different values.
(28) The tax consequences of the proposed transactions include fields displaying: 1) the capital gain or loss resulting from the sale, 2) the net proceeds resulting from the sale, and 3) the estimated tax resulting from the sale.
(29) The tax consequences also describe the holding period ramifications of the proposed transaction. This description displays (where appropriate) both the long-term and short-term capital gain tax consequences of the proposed transactions. When possible, web page 600 may offer helpful tips or guidance regarding short and long term capital gains taxes (e.g., “if you hold this security for an additional fourteen days, you will receive a long-term rate.”).
(30) Web page 600 includes a “Recalculate” button. Activation of this button sends the user to a subsequent invocation of web page 600. Each subsequent invocation is updated to reflect any changes made to the editable and calculated values within web page 600. In this way, web page 600 provides a tool that allows the user to visualize the effects of a proposed transaction. The use can then make changes and experiment with the same, similar or different transactions.
(31) In some cases, users may want to delve into the details of the calculations performed by web page 600. To this end, web page 600 includes a “View Calculations” button. Activation of this button sends the user to Web page 700.
(32) Web page 700 (see
(33) To this point, this description has focused (although not exclusively) on the case where the user selects the first option within web page 300 (i.e., choosing to determine the tax consequences of selling a security). As mentioned, web page 300 also includes a second option where the user chooses to sell an asset and purchase a replacement asset.
(34) Selection of this second option brings the user to web page 800. Web page 800 (see
(35) Unlike web page 500, web page 800 prompts the user to enter a target return rate. After entering the required data, the user activates a “Continue” button included in web page 800.
(36) Activation of the “Continue” button invokes web page 900. Web page 900 (see
(37) Web page 900 includes a “Get Results” button. The user activates this button when they have finished entering the required information and wish to see the tax consequences of their alternatives.
(38) Activation of the “Get Results” button invokes web page 1000. Web page 1000 (see
(39) To provide the editable, interactive summary of the proposed transaction, web page 1000 includes fields showing the assumptions entered by the user. These values are editable, providing the user with the option of trying assumptions.
(40) The editable, interactive summary of the proposed transaction Web page 1000 includes fields for the remaining values previously entered by the user using web pages 800 and 900.
(41) The tax consequences of the proposed transactions include fields displaying: 1) the capital gain or loss resulting from the sale, 2) the net proceeds resulting from the sale, and 3) the estimated tax resulting from the sale.
(42) The tax consequences also describe the holding period ramifications of the proposed transaction. This description displays (where appropriate) both the long-term and short-term capital gain tax consequences of the proposed transactions. When possible, web page 1000 may offer helpful tips or guidance regarding short and long term capital gains taxes (e.g., “if you hold this security for an additional fourteen days, you will receive a long-term rate . . . ”).
(43) The investment comparison portion of web page 1000 compares the user's current holding (i.e., the asset that they propose to sell) with their new investment (i.e., the asset that they propose to buy). This section shows the effects of retaining the current holding at the rate of return that the user has estimated with the new investment at its projected rate or return. For most implementations, this section will present this comparison graphically, charting the relative worth of these two investments over the period that the user has estimated that they would be held.
(44) In most cases, it is useful to present this type of time-based comparison in several textual forms. For typical implementations, this section of web page 1000 includes a calculation showing the user the number of years that they would have to retain the new asset (at a the user's estimated rate of return) given before the new asset matches the asset being sold. This section of web page will typically also tell the user the minimum rate of return required before the new investment will match the asset being sold within a given time period (e.g., twenty years).
(45) Web page 1000 includes a “Recalculate” button. Activation of this button sends the user to a subsequent invocation of web page 1000. Each subsequent invocation is updated to reflect any changes made to the editable and calculated values within web page 1000. In this way, web page 1000 provides a tool that allows the user to visualize the effects of a proposed transaction. The use can then make changes and experiment with the same, similar or different transactions.
(46) In some cases, users may want to delve into the details of the calculations performed by web page 1000. To this end, web page 1000 includes a “View Calculations” button. Activation of this button sends the user to Web page 1100.
(47) Web page 1100 (see
(48) As mentioned previously, web page 400 includes a link to a tax rate assistant. Activation of this link brings the user to a tax rate assistant (see
(49) The tax rate assistant then looks up the user's state of residence from an internal database. The tax rate assistant uses the state of residency along with the user's filing status and current taxable income, to calculate the user's state income and long term capital gains taxes. These figures are displayed to the user. When the user activates a calculate button the user's combined (i.e. state and federal) tax rate and combined long term capital gains tax rate are also displayed.
(50) In some cases, the user may not know their taxable income for the current year. For this reason, the tax rate assistant includes a taxable income calculator popup. As shown in
(51) As previously mentioned the tax rate assistant retrieves the user's state of residency from an internal database. In some cases, the database value may be incorrect (e.g., where the user has moved). In other cases, the user may wish to compare the tax consequences of living in different states.
(52) For this reason, the tax rate assistant includes a state individual tax rates popup. As shown in
(53) For most implementations, web pages 300 through 1100 share a set of common features. These are intended to provide the user with a uniform navigation experience. The common features typically include text and other explanatory features. Each web page also typically includes a synopsis showing the user how far they have progressed in the tax determination method (i.e. where they are and which web pages follow their current location).
(54)
(55) The roadmap also shows path taken by the user when the select the second option on web page 300 (i.e., to sell an asset and purchase a new asset). In this case, the user accesses web page 400 to define their tax status. Once tax status has been defined, the user accesses web page 800 to describe the asset that they propose to sell. Web page 800 is followed by web page 900 where the user describes the asset that they are considering for purchase. The tax consequences of the sale of the old asset and the investment consequences of the entire transaction (both sale and purchase) are displayed on web page 1000. The user may modify the proposed sale and return to web page 1000. Alternatively, the user may access web page 1100 to view the calculations underlying the information displayed in web page 100.
(56) Although particular embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be obvious to those skilled in the art that changes and modifications may be made without departing from the present invention in its broader aspects, and therefore, the appended claims are to encompass within their scope all such changes and modifications that fall within the true scope of the present invention.