Methods and apparatuses for producing a braided dual-sided compression packing seal and methods of using the same
09810324 · 2017-11-07
Assignee
Inventors
- Henri V. Azibert (Windham, NH, US)
- Paul Vincent Starbile (Woburn, MA, US)
- Philip Michael Mahoney, Jr. (Roslindale, MA, US)
Cpc classification
F16J15/22
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
D04C3/04
TEXTILES; PAPER
Y10T29/49826
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
D04C3/04
TEXTILES; PAPER
F16J15/22
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Abstract
The present application pertains to a braided dual-sided compression packing seal, methods for producing and using such a seal, and apparatuses suitable for producing such a seal. The braided dual-sided compression packing seal is made up of two or more different materials that are braided together in such a way that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has an asymmetrical configuration relative to a first axis that is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis and is substantially perpendicular to a side of the compression packing seal. Accordingly, when viewed in a cross-sectional plane, the compression packing seal may expose substantially only a first material along a first side of the seal, and substantially only a second material along a second side of the seal.
Claims
1. A braided dual-sided compression packing seal, wherein a longitudinal axis extends through the center of the compression packing seal along a length of the compression packing seal, the compression packing seal comprising at least a first material of a first material type and a second material of a second material type different than the first material type, wherein the first material is braided with the second material to form the compression packing seal, wherein the first material and the second material are disposed relative to each other such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has an asymmetrical configuration relative to a first axis that is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis and is substantially perpendicular to a side of the compression packing seal, and wherein, as a result of the braiding, the first material is disposed substantially completely along one side of the compression packing seal and the second material is disposed substantially completely along the other side of the compression packing seal, wherein the first material is braided with the second material using an interbraid pattern.
2. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the compression packing seal has a plurality of sides, and the compression packing seal presents an asymmetrical configuration when viewed in a plane that is perpendicular to the sides.
3. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the first material and the second material are further disposed relative to each other such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has a symmetrical configuration relative to a second axis perpendicular to the first axis.
4. The compression packing seal of claim 1, further comprising first and second exterior sides opposed to each other, wherein the first exterior side is substantially composed of the first type of material and the second exterior side is substantially composed of the second type of material, wherein the first type of material is different in material type than the second type of material.
5. The compression packing seal of claim 4, wherein the first material when braided with the second material forms substantially half of the compression packing seal to form the dual sided compression packing seal.
6. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the first material comprises carbon, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), a para-aramid synthetic fiber, polybenzimidazole fiber (PBI), or 95%+ carbon.
7. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the second material comprises acrylic, rayon, carbon, graphite, or fiberglass.
8. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the first material and the second material have different properties.
9. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the first material has a higher lubricity than the second material, a higher sealability than the second material, a higher extrusion resistance than the second material, or a higher thermal conductivity than the second material.
10. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the second material has a lower cost than the first material, a higher malleability than the first material, or a higher modulus than the first material.
11. The compression packing seal of claim 1, further comprising one or more warps extending through the packing material in the longitudinal direction for reinforcing the compression packing seal, wherein the warps are formed from at least one of carbon, metal wire, para-aramid synthetic fiber, polybenzimidazole fiber (PBI), acrylic, rayon, graphite, or fiberglass.
12. The compression packing seal of claim 1, further comprising a third material different than the first material and the second material.
13. The compression packing seal of claim 1, further comprising a fourth material different than the first material, the second material, and the third material.
14. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein: one or more of the first and second materials, when viewed in cross-section, are formed within the compression packing seal in a substantially triangular shape; and one or more of the first and second materials, when viewed in cross-section, are formed within the compression packing seal in a substantially square shape.
15. The compression packing seal of claim 1, wherein the compression packing seal, when viewed in cross section, is substantially rectangular with a ratio of a side of the compression packing seal to another side of the compression packing seal being substantially 4:3.
16. A method of packing a stuffing box substantially surrounding a shaft to form a sealing system, the method comprising: providing a compression packing seal according to claim 1; and placing the compression packing seal in the stuffing box.
17. The method of claim 16, wherein the compression packing seal is placed in the stuffing box so that the first material faces the shaft and the second material faces outwards against a radially interior wall of a the stuffing box.
18. The method of claim 17, wherein the first material is selected based on one of the following properties of the sealing system: a type of fluid being sealed against, a projected speed of the shaft while in use, a type of abrasive being sealed against in conjunction with the shaft or stuffing box, or a projected pressure on the packing material while in use.
19. The method of claim 17, wherein the first material exhibits at least one of the following properties: a higher lubricity than the second material, a higher sealability than the second material, a higher extrusion resistance than the second material, or a higher thermal conductivity than the second material.
20. The method of claim 17, wherein the second material exhibits at least one of the following properties: a lower cost than the first material, a higher malleability than the first material, a higher modulus than the first material, or less polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) content than the first material.
21. The method of claim 16, wherein the stuffing box further comprises a lantern ring and the compression packing seal is a first compression packing seal provided between the lantern ring and a fluid to be sealed, and further comprising: providing a second compression packing seal according to claim 1 on the opposite side of the lantern ring from the first compression packing seal, wherein the first compression packing seal exhibits at least one of the following properties: higher lubricity than the second compression packing seal, higher thermal conductivity than the second compression packing seal, or higher sealability than the second compression packing seal; or the second compression packing seal exhibits at least one of the following properties: higher strength than the first compression packing seal, or greater abrasion resistance than the first compression packing seal.
22. The method of claim 16, wherein the stuffing box further comprises a lantern ring and the compression packing seal is a first compression packing seal provided between the lantern ring and a fluid to be sealed, and further comprising: providing a second compression packing seal according to claim 1 on the opposite side of the lantern ring from the first compression packing seal, wherein the first compression packing seal has substantially the same construction as the second compression packing seal and is provided in the stuffing box in a different configuration than the second compression packing seal.
23. The method of claim 16, wherein the compression packing seal is a first compression packing seal, further comprising: providing a second compression packing seal according to claim 1, wherein: the first compression packing seal is provided on at least one longitudinal end of the stuffing box, and the first compression packing seal exhibits at least one of the following properties: higher strength than the second compression packing seal, a greater sealing surface speed capability than the second compression packing seal, or greater sealability than the second compression packing seal.
24. The method of claim 16, wherein the compression packing seal is provided in multiple layers around the shaft, and a layer closest to a longitudinally exterior position in the stuffing box is provided in a different configuration than a layer in a longitudinally interior position in the stuffing box.
25. A method of producing a braided dual-sided compression packing seal, wherein a longitudinal axis extends through the center of the packing material along a length of the compression packing seal, the method comprising: providing a first material of a first material type and a second material of a second material type different than the first material type, braiding the first material with the second material to form the compression packing seal in such a manner that the first material and the second material are disposed relative to each other such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has an asymmetrical configuration relative to a first axis that is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis and is substantially perpendicular to a side of the compression packing seal, and wherein, as a result of the braiding, the first material is disposed substantially completely along one side of the compression packing seal and the second material is disposed substantially completely along the other side of the compression packing seal, wherein the first material is braided with the second material using an interbraid pattern.
26. The method of claim 25, wherein the first material and the second material are further braided with each other such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has a symmetrical configuration relative to a second axis perpendicular to the first axis.
27. The method of claim 25, wherein the compression packing seal comprises first and second exterior sides opposed to each other, and wherein the first material is braided to the second material such that the first exterior side is substantially composed of the first material and the second exterior side is substantially composed of the second material.
28. The method of claim 27, wherein the first material when braided with the second material forms substantially half of the compression packing seal.
29. A braided dual-sided compression packing seal, wherein a longitudinal axis extends through the center of the compression packing seal along a length of the compression packing seal, the compression packing seal comprising at least a first material made of carbon, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), a para-aramid synthetic fiber, or polybenzimidazole fiber (PBI), and a second material made of acrylic, rayon, carbon, graphite, or fiberglass, wherein the first material is different in material type than the second material, and wherein the first material is braided with the second material to form the compression packing seal, wherein the first material and the second material are disposed relative to each other such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal has an asymmetrical configuration relative to a first axis that is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis and is substantially perpendicular to a side of the compression packing seal, wherein, as a result of the braiding, the first material is disposed substantially completely along one side of the compression packing seal and the second material is disposed substantially completely along the other side of the compression packing seal, and wherein the first material is braided with the second material using an interbraid pattern.
30. The compression packing seal of claim 29, wherein the first material has a higher lubricity than the second material, a higher sealability than the second material, a higher extrusion resistance than the second material, or a higher thermal conductivity than the second material.
31. The compression packing seal of claim 29, wherein the second material has a lower cost than the first material, a higher malleability than the first material, or a higher modulus than the first material.
Description
DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
(21)
(22)
(23)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(24) Existing compression packing seals are ill-suited for handling the uneven distribution of stresses and other factors commonly associated with mechanical equipment. Conventional braiding techniques allow for different material types to be mixed, but typically only in symmetrical braiding patterns. Accordingly, conventional braiding techniques typically do not allow and are unsuitable for manufacturing a braided compression packing seal with a first material disposed substantially entirely on one side (e.g., substantially about a continuous 50% of the surface area of the seal) and a second material substantially entirely on a different side (e.g., substantially the continuous 50% of the surface area of the seal opposing the first side). As used herein in the current context, the term “substantially” is intended to infer that the material is disposed in a continuous manner over more than about half (50%) of the side of the braid, preferably over the vast majority of the side of the braid, and most preferably over the entire side of the braid.
(25) One possible solution is to separately braid two different compression packing seals, and then secure the two different compression packing seals together (e.g., with an adhesive). However, such a solution is problematic for a number of reasons. For example, this solution requires that two braided structures be created. Thus, the time required to braid the materials, and the wear-and-tear on the braiding machinery, is double what it would otherwise be if the braid consisted of a single material. Furthermore, because the different packing seals are merely secured together with adhesive, the resulting packing material is not as strong as a packing in which the constituent materials are braided together.
(26) Accordingly, it is desirable and advantageous to be able to produce a braided compression packing seal with asymmetrical properties in which the constituent materials are braided together using a single pass on a single braiding machine, without requiring the sue of an adhesive. An example of such a braided compression packing seal, produced using the techniques discussed in more detail herein, is shown in
(27) As shown in
(28) A longitudinal axis “L” extends through the center of the compression packing seal 130 along a length of the compression packing seal. A first axis “A.sub.1” is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis L and is substantially perpendicular to a side of the compression packing seal 130. The compression packing seal 130 of the present application may be composed of at least a first material 140 and a second material 150, which may be braided together in such a way that, when viewed in cross-section, the compression packing seal 130 has an asymmetrical configuration relative to the first axis A.sub.1. That is, the first material 140 is disposed substantially completely along one exterior side of the compression packing seal 130, while the second material 150 is disposed substantially completely along an opposing exterior side of the compression packing seal 130. On the other hand, one can define a second axis A.sub.2 perpendicular to the first axis such that, in cross-section, the compression packing seal 130 has a symmetrical configuration relative to the second axis A.sub.2.
(29) Stated differently, the compression packing seal 130 may have a plurality of sides, and the compression packing seal 130 presents an asymmetrical configuration when viewed in a plane that is perpendicular to the sides.
(30) When viewed in cross section, one or more of the first and second materials 140, 150 may be formed within the compression packing seal 130 in a substantially triangular shape. Further, one or more of the first and second materials 140, 150 may be formed within the compression packing seal 130 in a substantially square shape.
(31)
(32) However, one of ordinary skill in the art will understand that different shapes for the compression packing seal 130 may be realized by varying the materials, material thickness or density, and/or braiding pattern used.
(33) It should be noted that
(34) The first material 140 and the second material 150 can be readily and easily selected depending upon the desired properties of the braid and the environment in which the braid is exposed to. For example, one of ordinary skill in the art would readily select the first and second materials based upon any number of different desired properties. Some exemplary considerations for the first material 140 include, but are not limited to: the first material 140 may be selected to have a higher lubricity than the second material 140; the first material 140 may be selected to have a higher sealability than the second material 150; the first material 140 may be selected to have a different construction than the second material 150 (such as a continuous fiber construction versus a staple fiber construction); the first material 140 may be selected to have a higher extrusion resistance than the second material 150; and the first material 140 may be selected to have a higher thermal conductivity than the second material 150. The first material 140 may be composed of, for example, carbon, PTFE, a para-aramid synthetic fiber, polybenzimidazole fiber (PBI), or 95%+ carbon assay, or any other material suitable for its intended purpose.
(35) Similarly, the second material 150 may be selected to have a lower cost than the first material 140, a higher malleability than the first material 140, a higher modulus than the first material 140, or to comprise a lesser amount of PTFE than the first material 140. The second material 150 may be composed of, for example, acrylic, rayon, carbon, graphite, or fiberglass.
(36) As illustrated in
(37) The first and second materials 140, 150 may be selected and deployed based on different applications of the compression packing seal 130. Advantageously, the properties of both the first and second materials 140, 150 may be leveraged in a single unitary compression packing seal 130 which can be braided in a single process on a single machine.
(38) In one example, the first material 140 may be placed against an interior wall of a stuffing box 20. The second material 150 may be placed against the rotating shaft 10. Thus, it may be desirable to select, for the second material 150, a strong material that is more expensive than the first material 140. Because the first material 140 may experience less wear-and-tear than the second material 150 in this configuration, it may be desirable to utilize a less expensive material for the first material 140 in order to decrease the overall cost of the compression packing seal 130.
(39) For instance, such a combination of materials may be used in a configuration similar to the one depicted in
(40) The second material 150 of the compression packing seal 130 may be provided on a side of the compression packing seal 130 that faces the shaft 10. The second material 150 in this case may be selected to have a higher lubricity and/or higher thermal conductivity than the first material 140.
(41) In another example depicted in
(42) Further examples are shown in
(43) One of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that the above properties, materials, and configurations are exemplary only, and that other types of materials, properties, and configurations may be selected based on the specific application.
(44) As will be shown in more detail below with respect to
(45)
(46) When braided using the material paths of
(47) The material paths may include a first material path 160 that is substantially triangular in shape, a second material path 170 and a third material path 180 that are substantially square in shape, and a fourth material path 190 that is substantially triangular in shape. The first material 140 and the second material 150 may be braided or interlocked along the material paths to form the compression packing seal 130.
(48)
(49) The material paths 160, 170, 180, 190 may be realized or embodied in a braiding apparatus 200 which braids the first material 140 and the second material 150 together. The braiding apparatus may move the first material 140 and the second material 150 with the assistance of a number of horn gears 210 that move carriers 220 around the material paths.
(50) Each of the horn gears 210 may include one or more slots 230 for receiving the carriers 220. The slots 230 may be sized and configured to receive corresponding mating portions of the carriers 220 such that the carriers 220 may be secured in the slots. The slots 230 are also sized and positioned so that, if a carrier is present in a first slot at the same time that a second slot is adjacent to the first slot (e.g., as in the example at the point 232 indicated in
(51) The horn gears 220 may be a series of gears of one or more sizes which are sized and configured to move the carriers 220 along the material paths without causing collisions between the carriers. More specifically, as the horn gears 210 rotate, the carriers 220 move to new positions along the material path. The carriers 220 move from one horn gear 210 to an adjacent horn gear 210 if the slots 230 of adjacent horn gears align at the appropriate time. That is, horn gears 210 and slots 230 are configured so that the carriers 220 are passed from one gear to another only at particular points, which forces a particular carrier 220 to follow only a specified path corresponding to the material path designated for the material carried by the carrier 220. Thus, a carrier 220 may be made to move along a path specific to the material carried by the particular carrier 220 in question.
(52) By selecting horn gears 210 of appropriate sizes, the material paths 160, 170, 180, 190 can be realized while avoiding collisions between carriers 220. For example, the horn gears 210 may be arranged into three rows 202, 204, 206. The horn gears 210 of the first row 202 may have a size, which is the same as the size of the horn gears 210 of the third row 206. Horn gears of the second row 204 may be of a different size than the horn gears of the first row 202 and the third row 206.
(53) For example, the horn gears 210 of the first row 202 of horn gears and the horn gears 210 of the third row 206 of horn gears may be substantially the same size and may further be larger than the horn gears 210 of the second row 204 of horn gears, as shown in
(54) Instead of defining the size of the horn gears 210 by the diameter or circumference of the horn gears 210, the size may also be defined by the number of slots 230 present in the horn gear. For example, if a first horn gear 210 has a size of “6” while a second horn gear 210 has a size of “4,” this may indicate that the first horn gear 210 has six slots for receiving the carriers 220 while the second horn gear 210 has four slots for receiving the carriers 220. Again, the ratio of the sizes of the horn gears 210 in this situation may be 6:4, 6:5, or 4:3.
(55) The slots 230 may be evenly dispersed around the perimeter of the horn gear 210. For example, if a horn gear 210 has six slots 230, the slots 230 may be separated from each other in 60 degree increments along the circumference of the horn gear 210.
(56) Preferably, the horn gears 210 of the first and third rows 202, 206 of horn gears 210 each have 6 slots 230 for receiving the carriers 220, while the horn gears 210 of the second row 204 each have either 4 or 5 active slots that receive the carriers 220. In some embodiments, each horn gear 210 of the apparatus 200 has the same number of slots 230. For example, every gear 210 may be provided with six slots 230. However, although each gear is provided with six slots 230, the gears 210 of the second row 204 may only make use of four or five slots 230 during the braiding process. That is, the gears 210 may be sized and configured so that the carriers 220 are only carried by four or five of the six slots on the gears 210 of the second row 204. One or two of the slots 230 of the horn gears 210 of the second row 204 may not receive carriers during the braiding process. Thus, only four or five of the slots 230 on the gears 210 of the second row 204 may be “active” in that they receive carriers 220 during the braiding process. The relative sizes of the horn gears 210, as well as the speed of rotation of the horn gears 210, ensure that the one or two “passive” slots never align appropriately with adjacent horn gears during the braiding process so that a carrier 220 could be transferred into the passive slots.
(57) In addition to dividing the horn gears 210 into rows 202, 204, 206, the horn gears 210 may also be divided into columns. For example, the first, second, and third rows of horn gears may each comprise a first horn gear, a second horn gear, a third horn gear, and a fourth horn gear, respectively. Accordingly, the apparatus may have a first column 212 of horn gears 210, a second column 214, a third column 216, and a fourth column 218. Each column may include a first relatively large horn gear, and second relatively small horn gear, and a third horn gear of the same size as the first relatively large horn gear. The second horn gear of the column may be disposed between the first and third horn gears of the column.
(58) An exemplary direction of rotation is provided for each of the horn gears 210 in
(59) It should be noted that
(60) In the braiding process, the first material path 160 (see
(61) In other words (with reference to
(62) By placing materials in a different configuration, other structures for the compression packing seal 130 may be achieved. For example, by utilizing a first material 140 in the first and fourth material paths 160, 190 and a second material 150 in the second and third material paths 170, 180, it can be seen that a compression packing seal 100 may be produced having the first material 140 in the corners and the second material 150 in internal positions. This may be useful for providing, for example, a corner-reinforced compression packing seal 100 using a high-strength first material 140 and an inexpensive second material 150.
(63) An alternative braiding path layout is shown in
(64) The apparatus 200 is shown in more detail in
(65) As shown in
(66) The first, second, and third row of horn gears 210 may interconnect to form at least four material paths along one or more material tracks. The material paths may include a first material path that is substantially triangular in shape, a second material path and a third material path that are substantially square in shape, and a fourth material path that is substantially triangular in shape, as described above with reference to
(67) In some embodiments, instead of three rows the apparatus 200 may be considered to have four columns of horn gears. A first column of horn gears may move solely the first material, a second column and a third column may move the first and second materials, and a fourth column may move solely the second material.
(68) During operation, a spool containing the first material 140 or the second material 150 may be mounted to a receiving element 222 on the carriers 220. The first material 140 or the second material 150 may be fed from the spool into an appropriate receiving portion of the carrier 220. Thus, the carrier 220 may carry the spool of the material mounted on the receiving element 222 as the carrier moves around one of the material paths 160, 170, 180, 190. In this way, the materials may be braided along the x-y plane together as the carriers 220 pass by each other along the material paths. Furthermore, a passage 224 may be provided passing through the plate 208. The passage 224 may allow a warp 142 to be passed through the plate 208 in a direction perpendicular to the braiding direction (i.e., in the z-plane of
(69) Using the apparatus 200 and the material paths 160, 170, 180, 190 depicted in
(70) In view of the above, it will be seen that the invention efficiently attains the objects set forth above, among those made apparent from the preceding description. Since certain changes may be made in the above constructions without departing from the scope of the invention, it is intended that all matter contained in the above description or shown in the accompanying drawings be interpreted as illustrative and not in a limiting sense.
(71) Unless otherwise noted, terms used in the singular are understood to include the plural, and vice versa. The term “or” is understood to be inclusive and not exclusive unless otherwise noted.
(72) It is also to be understood that the following claims are to cover all generic and specific features of the invention described herein, and all statements of the scope of the invention which, as a matter of language, might be said to fall therebetween.