PRO-BIOFILM COATING, METHOD FOR THE PRODUCTION THEREOF AND SUBSTRATE COATED WITH THE SAME
20220204904 · 2022-06-30
Assignee
Inventors
- Yolanda SÁENZ DOMÍNGUEZ (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Fernando ALBA ELÍAS (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- María LÓPEZ MARTÍNEZ (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Elisa SAINZ GARCÍA (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Carmen LOZANO FERNÁNDEZ (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Rodolfo MÚGICA VIDAL (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Beatriz ROJO BEZARES (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Ana GONZÁLEZ MARCOS (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Paula TOLEDANO REGALADO (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
- Ignacio MURO FRAGUAS (Logroño (la Rioja), ES)
Cpc classification
B05D1/62
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B05D2201/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
B05D1/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C12M1/12
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C23C16/455
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Abstract
The invention relates to a pro-biofilm coating applied by means of cold atmospheric plasma polymerization of a precursor on a substrate. The coating has a roughness such that it promotes the creation of more than 100% biofilm on the substrate, where the 100% of biofilm is the one as produced on the same substrate being devoid of said pro-biofilm coating. The invention also relates to a method of producing said pro-biofilm coating and a substrate coated with same.
Claims
1. A pro-biofilm coating applied on a substrate by means of cold atmospheric plasma polymerization of a precursor comprising carbon-oxygen groups, namely C—O, O—C═O, and C═O, which produce oxidative stress promoting creation of biofilm by bacteria, the coating having a roughness such that it promotes the creation of more than 100% biofilm on the substrate, where the 100% of biofilm is the one as produced on the same substrate being devoid of said pro-biofilm coating.
2. The pro-biofilm coating according to claim 1, characterized in that the precursor material constituting the coating is selected from the group consisting of (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (APTES) and a mixture of polyethylene glycol methyl ether methacrylate (PEGMA, MW: 500) and isopropanol (IPA).
3. The pro-biofilm coating according to claim 2, characterized in that the precursor material constituting the coating is APTES and the coating has a minimum average roughness (Ra) of more than 10 nm.
4. The pro-biofilm coating according to claim 2, characterized in that the precursor material constituting the coating is a mixture of PEGMA and IPA and the coating has a minimum average roughness (Ra) of more than 160 nm.
5. The pro-biofilm coating according to claim 1, characterized in that the substrate is selected from the group consisting of polystyrene and glass.
6. A method of producing a pro-biofilm coating as defined in claim 1, characterized in that it comprises applying a cold atmospheric plasma stream and coating precursor material on a substrate surface to be coated until obtaining a roughness such that it promotes the creation of more than 100% biofilm on the substrate, where the 100% of biofilm is the one as produced on the same substrate being devoid of said pro-biofilm coating.
7. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that it further comprises the step of performing, simultaneously with the application of the plasma stream, a relative movement between the substrate to be coated and the plasma stream so as to cover the entire surface of the substrate.
8. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that it further comprises the prior step of activating the surface of the substrate by means of plasma without precursor material.
9. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that the applied plasma is N.sub.2 plasma.
10. The method according to claim 9, characterized in that the plasma stream consists of 80 slm of N.sub.2.
11. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that the applied precursor material is selected from the group consisting of APTES and a mixture of PEGMA and IPA.
12. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that the precursor material is applied in liquid phase, transported by a stream of 1.5 slm of N.sub.2.
13. (canceled)
14. (canceled)
15. (canceled)
16. The method according to claim 11, characterized in that the precursor material is applied in liquid phase, transported by a stream of 1.5 slm of N.sub.2.
17. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that the substrate is selected from the group consisting of polystyrene and glass.
18. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that the application of the coating is performed homogeneously on the entire surface of the substrate.
19. A coated substrate with a pro-biofilm coating as defined in claim 1 applied on at least one surface thereof.
20. The coated substrate according to claim 19, wherein the precursor material constituting the coating is selected from the group consisting of (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (APTES) and a mixture of polyethylene glycol methyl ether methacrylate (PEGMA, MW: 500) and isopropanol (IPA).
21. The coated substrate according to claim 19, wherein the substrate is a cell culture dish.
22. Use of a cold atmospheric plasma polymerization of a precursor comprising carbon-oxygen groups, namely C—O, O—C═O, and C═O, which produce oxidative stress promoting creation of biofilm by bacteria, for producing pro-biofilm coating on a substrate for in vitro studies of microorganisms.
23. Use according to claim 22, wherein the substrate is a cell culture dish.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0014] The present invention will be better understood in reference to the following drawings which illustrate preferred embodiments of the present invention, provided by way of example, and should not be interpreted as being limiting of the invention in any way:
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0030] Plasma is the state a gas achieves when an amount of energy that ionizes its molecules and atoms is supplied to it. That is, the transition of matter from gaseous state to plasma state occurs by means of a dissociation of molecular bonds, accompanied by an increase or decrease in the electrons of the atoms, which gives rise to the formation of positively or negatively charged ions. Thermal plasma is distinguished from cold plasma depending on whether or not there is thermal equilibrium between plasma particles.
[0031] A non-equilibrium or cold plasma is that in which the temperature of the electrons (105-5000° C.) is much higher than that of the heaviest particles (neutral particles and ions), which are at temperatures close to ambient temperature (25-100° C.). The temperature of a cold plasma is thereby generally kept below 100° C., which allows it to be used in surface treatments on a wide range of materials without causing deterioration thereof due to excessive heating.
[0032] Cold plasma can be generated at atmospheric pressure in an open environment, i.e., it does not require using vacuum systems or chambers in which specific conditions are established.
[0033] These characteristics make cold atmospheric plasma technology highly versatile, relatively simple, and cost-effective. From the viewpoint of its industrial application, plasma has become an important tool for carrying out a number of surface treatments.
[0034] One of the main modifications to which the surface of a substrate treated with plasma can be subjected is “plasma polymerization”. This modification consists of the deposition of thin coatings using monomers in liquid state as precursors through their exposure to the plasma stream.
[0035] In a specific embodiment of the present invention, the plasma polymerization method using non-equilibrium or cold atmospheric plasma equipment (APPJ) was used for applying pro-biofilm coatings on Petri dishes under study. The selection of the different precursors to be deposited and operating parameters of the plasma (input variables) determine the specific characteristics of the coating obtained. This versatility is of vital importance when the physicochemical properties of the surface coatings are intended to be modified in a specific manner.
[0036] Another feature that makes this technology very attractive is that it works at room temperature and at atmospheric pressure, which largely facilitates its possible application to already existing production lines.
[0037] The APPJ equipment used (see
[0038] According to the preferred embodiment of the present invention, and still referring to
[0039] Next, the step of applying per se a stream (20) of cold atmospheric plasma (14) and precursor material (18) on the surface of the Petri dish (22) is performed.
[0040] Furthermore, the method also preferably comprises the step of performing, simultaneously with the application of the plasma stream, a relative movement between the substrate to be coated and the plasma stream so as to cover the entire surface of the substrate.
[0041] The plasma stream (20) projected onto the surface (which transforms, transports, and projects the precursor material onto the base of the Petri dish) has a diameter of about 10 mm. Therefore, for the homogeneous application of the coating (preferred embodiment) over the entire base of the Petri dish (22), this jet must move across the entire base (diameter of 30 mm). Given that the plasma (80 slm of N.sub.2) and precursor (1.5 slm of N.sub.2 which atomizes and transports the precursor material) streams are constant, for applying a homogeneous coating, this movement must be at a constant speed.
[0042] To that end, the Petri dish (22) rotates and moves (along one axis) simultaneously with the application of the plasma stream (20). Meanwhile, the plasma application equipment remains still. Evidently, according to alternative embodiments, the Petri dish may remain still while a plasma application nozzle moves. According to another additional alternative, both the Petri dish and the plasma application nozzle may move simultaneously with one another.
[0043] The linear (tangential) coating speed (Vt) is constant (10 mm/s). Every time one turn is coated (at a specific radius) the rotating speed (W) is modified (decreasing at the edge, increasing at the center) for the linear speed (Vt) to remain constant at all times. For every complete turn made by the Petri dish (22), it moves along the axis a specific forward movement distance (24). Keeping the linear speed (Vt) constant allows the applied coating to be homogeneous.
[0044] A “pass” is defined as every time the plasma jet completely coats the base of the Petri dish. Different coatings have been obtained by applying from 2 up to 96 passes, as described hereinbelow.
[0045] Following the method described above, various pro-biofilm coatings were made using as precursor material either (3-aminopropyl)triethoxysilane (APTES) or a mixture in various proportions of polyethylene glycol methyl ether methacrylate (PEGMA, MW: 500) and isopropanol (IPA). Likewise, Petri dishes made of either polystyrene (PS) with a diameter of 30 mm (pre-treated with plasma and uncoated) or glass with a diameter of 90 mm were used. Table 1 below details the properties of the various samples of coatings made according to the method of the present invention:
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Sample Passes Substrate Precursor 0p 0 PS — 2p 2 PS APTES (100%) 4p 4 PS APTES (100%) 12p 12 PS APTES (100%) 24p 24 PS APTES (100%) 48p 48 PS APTES (100%) 72p 72 PS APTES (100%) 96p 96 PS APTES (100%) 0V 0 Glass — 48V 48 Glass APTES (100%) PG5 2 PS PEGMA (5%)/IPA (95%) PG10 2 PS PEGMA (10%)/IPA (90%) PG100 2 PS PEGMA (100%)
[0046] To quantify the percentage of biofilm produced (with respect to that produced by a control of uncoated Petri dish) which generates the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa on the studied samples, a technique with fluorescein diacetate (FDA) was used. According to the literature, said technique is used both to measure the microbial activity in the total biofilm (Adam and Duncan, 2001; Schnürer and Rosswall, 1982; Taylor et al., 2001), and to quantify the biofilm biomass (Honraet et al., 2005; Prieto et al., 2004). The biofilm was quantified after 24 hours of incubation at 37° C.
[0047] As can be seen in
[0048]
[0049] Taking this into account, “pro-biofilm limit” is defined as the roughness on the basis of which a biofilm greater than 100% is obtained (with respect to that generated in the control 0p).
[0050] In
[0051] Next, the preceding method was repeated using as a substrate a glass rather than a PS Petri dish. Glass dishes have a roughness very similar to PS dishes (uncoated PS; 0p Ra=4.87±1.13 nm and uncoated glass; 0V.fwdarw.Ra=4.67±0.98 nm).
[0052] A glass dish was coated with 48 passes.
[0053] Otherwise, the coating method was identical to that used with PS Petri dishes described above and APTES was used as liquid precursor material.
[0054] It was experimentally determined that the coating applied on the glass dish with 48 passes (48V) presented a roughness and % of biofilm with respect to the control (Ra=33.2±1.27 nm and 368±18%) very similar to the sample 24p with the coating applied on a PS plate with 24 passes (Ra=33.4±1.3 nm and 300±3.5%).
[0055] In this sense, it can be concluded that those APTES-based coatings having a very similar roughness generate a similar % of biofilm regardless the substrate on which they have been applied. The only difference in this case is that to obtain a coating on the glass with a roughness similar to that of PS, it was necessary to apply more passes (48 passes for glass and 24 passes for PS).
[0056] Based on the foregoing, it can be concluded that an APTES-based coating, with a specific roughness, generates a similar amount of biofilm, regardless the substrate (polystyrene, glass, or other) on which it is applied.
[0057] Next, the coating method described above was repeated using mixtures of PEGMA (MW500) and IPA at different concentrations instead of APTES.
[0058] In this case, the number of passes was set to 2 and the percentage by weight of PEGMA in a PEGMA and IPA dilution (5, 10, and 100% by weight) was varied.
[0059]
[0060] From these results, it can be concluded that it is not possible to define a common pro-biofilm limit for coatings based on different precursor materials. One of the possible reasons justifying the non-existence of a common pro-biofilm limit may be related to the fact that each precursor material produces a coating with a specific surface pattern. If it is taken into account that the surface morphology (roughness) has a significant relationship with the amount of biofilm generated, it is reasonable to think that different surface patterns will make microorganisms produce different amounts of biofilm.
[0061] In any case, regardless the precursor used (APTES or PEGMA), it is found that as roughness increases, the biofilm increases. Likewise, in any case there is a specific roughness on the basis of which the coating is pro-biofilm.
[0062] Next, a chemical and wettability characterization of the pro-biofilm coatings according to the embodiments of the present invention was performed.
[0063] The chemical characterization was performed by means of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis and the wettability characterization was performed by means of analysis of the water contact angle (WCA) measurement.
[0064] By means of XPS analysis, it is possible to identify and quantify the chemical composition of the first 3 to 5 nanometers of the coating (after which the biofilm grows).
[0065] In the case of the uncoated sample (0p), it is possible to identify the typical percentages present in PS (polystyrene) which are considerably different from those of the coated samples (for example, high percentage of carbon). This uncoated sample (0p) is the only one in which silicon is not detected as this element comes from APTES.
[0066] It may be concluded based on said
[0067] Moreover, by means of XPS analysis it is also possible to identify and quantify the bonds of each of the previously identified elements (C, O, Si, and N).
[0068] The deconvolution of carbon (C1s) is a common practice in surface chemical characterization. This deconvolution allows the partial spectra making up the total spectrum to be identified. Each partial spectrum corresponds to a specific bond to which the carbon is bound. The area of each partial spectrum (associated with a specific bond) allows its presence on the surface to be quantified with respect to the total bonds.
[0069]
[0070] Based on the analysis of the bonds and percentages shown in
[0071] Furthermore, the chemical structure of the surface of the coated samples (samples 2p and 72p, representative of all the APTES-coated samples) is very similar regardless the large difference in roughness existing between both of them (Ra of 2p=6.7 nm and Ra of 72p=55.1 nm).
[0072] Finally, based on the foregoing, the increase in biofilm production (greater roughness) is not determined by the chemical nature of the coatings, as there are no substantial differences between them which justify the increase in biofilm production.
[0073] Next, characterization was performed by means of WCA analysis, where WCA is the angle formed by the surface of a liquid upon contact with a solid. The contact angle value primarily depends on the relationship between the adhesive forces between the liquid and the solid and the cohesive forces of the liquid. The higher the adhesive forces, the lower the WCA.
[0074]
[0075] Therefore, in summary and with respect to coatings on PS using APTES, all the coatings have the same “chemistry” and “wettability”, and all the coatings have a different “morphology” and “% of biofilm”.
[0076] Therefore, the increase in the % of biofilm does not depend on the “chemistry” or “wettability” (adhesion) of the coating, but rather depends on of the modification of the “morphology” thereof (roughness).
[0077] Next, bacterial growth was studied (see
[0078] It can be observed in
[0079] The biofilm “over-production” mechanism
[0080] Next, the biofilm creation mechanisms according to the present invention will be described in detail.
[0081] In the first colonization phases of a surface by bacteria, the amine groups (NH.sub.2) present in the coating (coming from the plasma polymerization of APTES) promote adhesion therein, and subsequently, the carbon-oxygen groups (C—O, O—C═O, and C═O, also coming from the APTES and the surrounding atmosphere) produce oxidative stress promoting the creation of a larger amount of biofilm by the bacteria (in response to the mentioned stress).
[0082] Once the bacteria has been adhered to the surface of the coating, the increase in roughness (which is produced by increasing the passes) promotes the creation of biofilm (the greater the roughness, the more biofilm). The increase in coating roughness is promoted by the silicon oxide (SiO.sub.x, coming from the plasma polymerization of APTES) groups because every time a pass is applied, these groups build up in the coating in the form of spherical particles and clusters thereof having a larger size as the number of passes increases. The increase in roughness facilitates the creation of bacterial colonies, the adhesion thereof, and finally the generation of a larger amount of biofilm.
[0083]
[0084] Finally,
[0085] Finally, the speed of biofilm generation was determined by means of coatings according to the present invention.
[0086] Preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described in detail above. However, one skilled in the art might make modifications and variations therein without departing from the scope of protection defined by the following claims. For example, specific precursor materials and substrates have been described in the specific embodiments of the invention; however, one skilled in the art may apply the teachings disclosed herein to determine, by means of routine experiments, other combinations of precursor materials, substrates, and numbers of passes with plasma to provide pro-biofilm coatings having sufficient roughness so as to promote the creation of more than 100% biofilm, compared with the biofilm produced on the same substrate devoid of pro-biofilm coating, according to the present invention.