Radio-opaque writing instruments and methods of use

Abstract

A radio-opaque composition is formulated to enable a clinician to apply custom markings to a surface, such as a patient's skin or a surgical drape on the patient. More specifically, the radio-opaque composition may be used to write on the surface. The markings may be well-defined and contrast with the surface to which they are applied. Such a composition may include a liquid radio-opaque component that includes one or more radio-opaque materials that have been dissolved in a solvent, as well as a solid radio-opaque component with particles of one or more radio-opaque materials dispersed throughout a carrier, such as the solvent of the liquid radio-opaque component. Marking apparatuses that may be used to write with the radio-opaque composition are also disclosed, as are methods for using the radio-opaque composition.

Claims

1. A composition for use in marking a surface, comprising: a first radio-opaque component comprising a first radio-opaque material dissolved in a solvent; and a second radio-opaque component comprising a second radio-opaque material dispersed throughout a carrier.

2. The composition of claim 1, wherein the first radio-opaque material and the second radio-opaque material comprise different radio-opaque materials with different radio-opaque characteristics.

3. The composition of claim 1, wherein the carrier throughout which the second radio-opaque material is dispersed comprises the solvent within which the first radio-opaque material is dissolved.

4. The composition of claim 1, wherein the first radio-opaque component and the second radio-opaque component are non-toxic.

5. The composition of claim 1, wherein the first radio-opaque material comprises at least one of potassium iodide and iodine.

6. The composition of claim 5, wherein the second radio-opaque material comprises at least one of an element, an oxide of an element, and a salt of an element, with the element having an atomic number of at least 56.

7. The composition of claim 6, wherein the second radio-opaque material comprises at least one barium sulfate, bismuth oxide, and tungsten oxide.

8. The composition of claim 5, wherein the second radio-opaque material comprises at least one of an element, an oxide of an element, and a salt of an element, with the element having an atomic number of at least 56.

9. The composition of claim 8, wherein the second radio-opaque material comprises at least one of barium sulfate, bismuth oxide, and tungsten oxide.

10. The composition of claim 8, wherein the second radio-opaque material comprises at least one of tungsten, bismuth, and gold.

11. The composition of claim 1, further comprising: at least one polymer that: enables the composition to form a film; tailors a viscosity of the composition; and/or renders the composition at least temporarily indelible.

12. The composition of claim 1, further comprising: a pigment that imparts the composition with a desired color.

13. The composition of claim 1, comprising: a carrier comprising water and isopropyl alcohol, with the first radio-opaque component comprising potassium iodide and iodine in solution and with the second radio-opaque component comprising barium sulfate and bismuth oxide.

14. The composition of claim 13, wherein: the iodine comprises about 2% of the weight of the composition; the potassium iodide comprises about 5% of the weight of the composition; the barium sulfate comprises about 15% of the weight of the composition; and the bismuth oxide comprises about 5% of the weight of the solution.

15. The composition of claim 13, further comprising: Gentian violet.

16. A radio-opaque writing instrument, comprising: a container; a radio-opaque marking composition within the container, the radio-opaque marking composition consisting of non-toxic, biocompatible contents, including: a liquid radio-opaque component; and a solid radio-opaque component; and a dispenser that delivers the radio-opaque marking composition from the container onto a surface.

17. The radio-opaque writing instrument of claim 16, wherein the solid radio-opaque component is dispersed throughout the liquid radio-opaque component.

18. The radio-opaque writing instrument of claim 16, wherein the liquid radio-opaque component comprises a solution of a radio-opaque material.

19. A method for correlating radiographic images to a patient, comprising: placing a visible, radio-opaque marking material that includes a liquid radio-opaque component and a solid radio-opaque component on the patient's skin, at or adjacent to a location of the patient's body to be radiographically imaged; and radiographically imaging the location of the patient's body to obtain a radiographic image, a radio-opaque patient identifier appearing in the radiographic image.

20. The method of claim 19, wherein placing the visible, radio-opaque marking material that includes the liquid radio-opaque component and the solid radio-opaque component on the patient's skin comprises placing a marking material that includes the solid radio-opaque component dispersed in the liquid radio-opaque component on the patient's skin.

Description

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

(1) In the drawings:

(2) FIG. 1 is a bar graph showing the calculated mass attenuation coefficients of various liquids, including water and various radio-opaque liquid compositions, for radiation at a representative intensity of 100 kVp;

(3) FIGS. 2 and 3 are charts showing the calculated mass attenuation coefficients of the liquids whose mass attenuation coefficients are represented by FIG. 1 at various energies;

(4) FIGS. 4 and 5 provide schematic representations of embodiments of marking apparatuses;

(5) FIG. 6 is a visible image of visible and radio-opaque markings made on an individual's skin with an embodiment of a marking composition according to this disclosure; and

(6) FIG. 7 is a radiographic image of the visible and radio-opaque markings made on the individual's skin with the embodiment of marking composition according to this disclosure.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

(7) This disclosure is directed to a marking composition and a marking apparatus useful in making clear and unambiguous markings on a patient in preparation for medical procedures, such as minimally invasive surgeries and other procedures. The markings may identify the patient, one or more treatment sites on the patient, the procedure(s) to be conducted at each treatment site (e.g., surgical approaches, etc.), one or more anatomic landmarks, or the like.

(8) A marking composition according to this disclosure may include one or more radio-opaque components. In addition, the marking composition may include a liquid carrier. Optionally (e.g., essentially, non-essentially, etc.), the marking composition may also include a pigment. As another option (e.g., an essential option, a non-essential option, etc.), the marking composition may include one or more of following: thickening agents, cosmetically/dermatologically acceptable vehicles, diluents, carriers, and/or binders.

(9) The liquid carrier of the marking composition may be aqueous or organic, and include one ingredient or a mixture of ingredients. In some embodiments, the liquid carrier may include water and isopropyl alcohol. The isopropyl alcohol may evaporate quickly and, thus, facilitate quick drying of the marking composition once it has been applied to a surface.

(10) The radio-opaque component(s) of the marking composition may also be referred to as “active ingredients.” The radio-opaque component(s) may be viewed under one or more imaging modalities (e.g., x-ray, CT, magnetic resonance (MR), ultrasound, etc.) that may be used in conjunction with a medical procedure, as well as one or more components that are visible to an individual without the aid of imaging (i.e., to the “naked eye”). In some embodiments, a radio-opaque component of the marking composition may also be visible to an individual without the aid of imaging. In various embodiments, the marking composition may include a combination of one or more liquid radio-opaque components and one or more solid radio-opaque components. More specifically, the solid radio-opaque component(s) may be carried by (e.g., homogeneously dispersible throughout, etc.) the liquid radio-opaque component(s) and any solvent for the liquid radio-opaque component(s). The combination of liquid and solid radio-opaque components may impart the marking composition with a viscosity suitable for easy flow.

(11) In a specific, but non-limiting, embodiment, the liquid radio-opaque component of a marking composition according to this disclosure may be aqueous or organic. The liquid radio-opaque component (e.g., a solvent of the liquid radio-opaque component, etc.) may comprise the carrier of the marking composition. A liquid radio-opaque component may include a radio-opaque material that has been dissolved in a solvent. Examples of aqueous liquid radio-opaque components include, but are not limited to, potassium iodide solution and iodine solution. The inclusion of iodine in the marking composition may impart the marking composition with antiseptic properties. In addition, the iodide and/or iodine may impart the marking composition with a visible color (i.e., orange-brown to violet), making the marking composition visible even without the addition of a pigment. Examples of organic radio-opaque substances that may be used as the liquid radio-opaque component or in the liquid radio-opaque component include, but are not limited to, iohexol and iopamidol.

(12) Particles of the solid radio-opaque component may be dispersible or dispersed throughout a carrier, such as the solvent for the liquid radio-opaque component or a separate carrier of the marking composition. Particles of the solid radio-opaque component may have sizes that enable the solid radio-opaque composition to remain in suspension throughout the marking compositions. In various embodiments, the particles of the solid radio-opaque component may have sizes of about 2 microns to about 100 microns. The solid radio-opaque component may include one or more pure elements, oxides of elements, and/or salts of elements that are visible under x-ray and under CT imaging. Such an element or elemental species may have an atomic number sufficient to render the solid radio-opaque component radio-opaque under one or more types of imaging commonly used in medical settings (e.g., x-ray, CT, etc.) (e.g., an atomic number of 56 or greater, etc.). Non-limiting examples of such elements or elemental species include barium (Ba) species, bismuth (Bi) species and lanthanum (La) species. Specific examples of such inorganic salts include, but are not limited to, barium salts (e.g., barium sulfate (BaSO.sub.4), which is known to be safe and non-toxic to humans), bismuth salts (e.g., bismuth oxide (Bi.sub.2O.sub.3)), tungsten salts (e.g., tungsten oxide (WO.sub.3)), other salts of elemental species that have high atomic numbers, and combinations thereof. Specific embodiments of metals that may be used as a solid radio-opaque component of the marking composition include, without limitation, tungsten, bismuth, and gold.

(13) Each radio-opaque component of a marking composition according to this disclosure may be included in an amount equal to 0% of the weight of the marking composition to 100% of the weight of the marking composition. That is, the marking composition may include one radio-opaque component that makes up part or all of the marking composition or it may include a combination of radio-opaque components that together may make up part of the marking composition or an entirety of the marking composition. The marking composition may comprise or consist of (a) radio-opaque substance(s) that is (are) non-toxic and biocompatible.

(14) In a specific embodiment, a marking composition may include a carrier that comprises water and isopropyl alcohol, a liquid radio-opaque component that comprises potassium iodide and iodine, and a solid radio-opaque component that includes barium sulfate and bismuth oxide. Particles of the solid radio-opaque component may be dispersible or dispersed throughout the liquid radio-opaque component; thus, the liquid radio-opaque component may function as a carrier of the marking composition. Optionally, the marking composition may also include a pigment, such as Gentian violet. In some embodiments, the marking composition may consist essentially of the carrier, the liquid radio-opaque component, and the solid radio-opaque component (i.e., other ingredients, including the pigment, are not essential to enable the marking composition to be used in a manner that forms a uniform marking that can be seen in visible light as well as under one or more imaging modalities that are used in medical settings). In other embodiments, the pigment may be an essential component of the marking composition. In still other embodiments, the marking composition may consist of the carrier, the liquid radio-opaque component, and the solid radio-opaque component or of the carrier, the liquid radio-opaque component, the solid radio-opaque component, and the pigment.

(15) When one or more liquid radio-opaque components are combined with one or more solid radio-opaque components, the combination may provide for a flowable (e.g., low viscosity) marking composition with a desired level of radio-opacity. More specifically, the inclusion of one or more liquid radio-opaque components in the marking composition may minimize solids loading (i.e., the solids content, by weight) of the marking composition, reducing the overall viscosity of the marking composition while reducing the likelihood that the solid radio-opaque component(s) will settle and increasing the stability of the marking composition. A formulation of the marking composition may enable it to flow through an orifice of a marking apparatus (e.g., a pen, etc., with a configuration that enables it to dispense the marking composition in a manner that resembles writing with a conventional writing instrument) and to be readily and effectively applied to human tissue (e.g., skin, etc.) and, optionally, to other surfaces (e.g., the surfaces of surgical drapes, etc.). For instance, the marking composition may have the consistency of a smoothly flowing fluid that may be applied in a continuous film. Such a marking composition may have a viscosity in a range of about 100 centipoise (cP) (e.g., the viscosity of motor oil) to about 100,000 cP (or 1,000 poise (P)) (e.g., about the viscosity of toothpaste). Various examples of viscosities of a marking composition according to this disclosure include viscosities of about 70,000 cP or less, about 50,000 cP or less, about 30,000 cP or less, about 10,000 cP or less, about 5,000 cP or less, about 2,500 cP or less, about 1,000 cP or less, and about 500 cP or less.

(16) Furthermore, a combination of various radio-opaque components with one another may increase the attenuation coefficient of the marking composition, providing for higher definition imaging contrast than is currently available with radio-opaque marking compositions. The use of two or more radio-opaque components in the marking composition may significantly widen the range of photon energies that are used in clinical imaging and that may be absorbed and, thus, attenuated by the marking composition. Thus, the marking composition may be useful with a variety of imaging conditions or modalities.

(17) To illustrate the effects of using a combination of liquid and solid radio-opaque components, the mass attenuation coefficient of a specific embodiment of marking composition was compared with the mass attenuation coefficients of other substances. In particular, mass attenuation coefficients were determined for: (A) water (to provide a baseline); (B) water with 2% iodine, by weight; (C) water with 2% iodine, by weight, and 5% potassium iodide, by weight; (D) water with 2% iodine, by weight, 5% potassium iodide, by weight, and 13% barium sulfate, by weight; and (E) water with 2% iodine, by weight, 5% potassium iodide, by weight, 13% barium sulfate, by weight, and 5% bismuth oxide, by weight. The mass attenuation coefficients that were calculated cover photon energies applicable to typical diagnostic x-ray and CT imaging (from 1 keV to 0.1 MeV), approach the lower limit of therapeutic radiation, and are taken from the photon interaction database at the National Institute of Standards and Technology and based on the calculations by Seltzer, as described in Radiation Research 136, 147 (1993). The chart of FIG. 1 shows the mass attenuation coefficient for each composition at a representative intensity of 100 kVp. As further radio-opaque components are added, the mass attenuation coefficient increases progressively. This phenomenon is consistent across all energy levels.

(18) By comparison, if barium sulfate is used alone to attain the equivalent level of attenuation achieved from formulation (D) above, which has a solids loading of 13%, a solids loading of 21.7% barium sulfate, by weight, would be required. Thus, with the inclusion of the liquid radio-opaque components (i.e., iodine solution and potassium iodide solution), the composition may provide the same level attenuation with significantly less (i.e., about 40%) less solids loading. Thus, the combination of liquid and solid radio-opaque elements may enable the formulation of marking compositions that have the same ability to attenuate radiation as existing radio-opaque materials, but with significantly less solids loading. With less solids loading, the marking composition is more stable, with a reduced propensity for solids settling, and able to flow better.

(19) As the charts of FIGS. 2 and 3 show, the mass attenuation coefficient of marking materials with combinations of radio-opaque components increase progressively across all energy levels applicable to typical diagnostic x-ray and CT imaging (i.e., from 1 keV to 0.1 MeV), indicating that the performance of the marking material is consistent and predictable, unlike currently available radio-opaque markers.

(20) In embodiments where the marking composition includes a pigment, the pigment may impart the marking composition with a specific visible color. As a specific, but non-limiting example, the pigment may comprise a dye, such as gentian violet (which is often used to provide pigment for visible medical marking compositions).

(21) In embodiments where the marking composition includes thickening agents, binders, and/or film-forming ingredients, one or more organic and/or inorganic polymers may be included to provide any of these functions. These ingredients may enable tailoring of the viscosity of the marking composition (e.g., they may impart the marking composition with gel-like characteristics, etc.). Such ingredients may be suitable for skin care and/or drug delivery. Examples of film-forming polymers include, but are not limited to, silicones, acrylates, cellulose compounds, polyvinyl alcohol, gelatin, xanthan gum, and polyethylene glycol. The inclusion of one or more film-forming polymers in the marking composition may impart the marking composition with temporary indelible characteristics (e.g., enable a marking to remain on a surface for a particular duration of time, prevent the marking from rubbing off of the surface, etc.).

(22) As illustrated by FIG. 4, an embodiment of a marking apparatus 10 that is capable of dispensing a marking composition 20 may include a reservoir 30 that holds the marking composition 20 and a re-homogenizer 35 (e.g., a steel ball, etc.) that is capable of homogenizing the marking composition 20 in the event that any of the ingredients of the marking composition 20 separate from the remainder of the marking composition 20. In some embodiments, the reservoir 30 of the marking apparatus 10 may be transparent to enable a clinician to visually determine whether the marking composition 20 is homogeneous and able to flow freely. After noting that the marking composition 20 is homogeneous and able to flow freely, the clinician may use the marking apparatus 10 to dispense the marking composition 20 through a dispenser 50 that communicates with the reservoir 30 to make markings on a surface.

(23) Alternatively, in the embodiment of marking apparatus 10′ depicted by FIG. 5, the marking composition 20 may flow from the reservoir 30′ into a chamber 40′. The chamber 40′ may, in some embodiments, be transparent to enable a clinician to view the marking composition 20 therein. The marking composition 20 may flow from the reservoir 30′ to the chamber 40′ upon actuating the dispenser 50′ of the marking apparatus 10′ (e.g., by rotating the dispenser 50′, etc.). Such an arrangement may ensure that the reservoir 30′ containing the marking composition 20 is not exposed to ambient air and, thus, resists drying prior to being dispensed by the marking apparatus 10′.

(24) As another alternative, also depicted by FIG. 5, the chamber 40′ may be maintained under positive pressure and the marking apparatus 10′ may include a user-controlled feature 55′ (e.g., a valve, etc.) that controls the flow of the marking composition 20 from the chamber 40′ to the dispenser 50′ and, thus, the flow of the marking composition 20 out of the dispenser 50′ and onto a surface.

(25) In some embodiments, the dispenser 50, 50′ of a marking apparatus 10, 10′ may include an orifice of adjustable size. Such an orifice may enable a user (e.g., a clinician, etc.) to select a desired line width, or thickness, of markings made as the marking composition 20 passes out of the orifice of the dispenser 50, 50′.

(26) FIG. 6 is a visible image showing application of a marking composition according to this disclosure to an individual's skin with a marking apparatus according to this disclosure. The first marking (i.e., the marking on the left) is made with a marking composition that includes a pigment, while the second and third markings (i.e., the marking in the center and the marking at the right, respectively) are made with marking compositions that lack pigments. The markings have been defined by marking compositions with different solids loading of radio-opaque material. Each of the markings is clearly visible to the naked eye. FIG. 7 is an x-ray image of the same markings, illustrating that the markings are visible under imaging that is commonly used in medical settings.

(27) A basic embodiment of a method for preparing for surgical procedure, includes providing a marking apparatus 10, 10′, making one or more visible and radio-opaque markings on the patient or a covering over the patient with the marking apparatus 10, 10′, and subjecting the appropriate site to imaging (e.g., x-ray/fluoroscopy, etc.) for the purpose of comparing the indication to one or more internal structures associated with the procedure. In order to mark at or near the surgical site, the clinician can shake the marking apparatus 10, 10′ and observe that the marking composition 20 is able to flow freely, then dispense the marking composition 20 from the dispenser 50, 50′ of the marking apparatus 10, 10′. A marking composition according to this disclosure may enable the clinician to make customized, precise markings on the patient and/or on coverings over the patient. The marking may be customized for the patient, and may include information such as the patient's identity, the site where the procedure is to be performed, and information about the procedure to be performed (e.g., to assist in placing surgical instrument access points in the patient which are often necessary in minimally invasive surgical procedures, etc.).

(28) In use, after covering the operative site with the sterile surgical film, the clinician can subject the site to x-ray exposure and, by referring to the marking(s) formed by the radio-opaque composition to ensure that the proper procedure is being conducted at the proper site on the proper patient. In situations when a clinician finds that the first incision marking is not optimal, the marking composition may be removed and an appropriate mark may be made at another location.

(29) By identifying a patient with radio-opaque marking on the patient, images may be accurately matched with the appropriate patient.

(30) Although the foregoing disclosure sets forth many specifics, these should not be construed as limiting the scope of any of the claims, but merely as providing illustrations of some embodiments and variations of elements and/or features of the disclosed subject matter. Other embodiments of the disclosed subject matter may be devised which do not depart from the spirit or scope of any of the claims. Features from different embodiments may be employed in combination. Accordingly, the scope of each claim is limited only by its plain language and the legal equivalents thereto.