PROCESS AND SYSTEM FOR MEASURING THE OXIDATION STABILITY AND/OR THE THERMAL STABILITY OF A FUEL
20220187272 · 2022-06-16
Inventors
- Maira ALVES FORTUNATO (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Arij BEN AMARA (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Remy MINGANT (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Valerie SAUVANT-MOYNOT (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Laurie STARCK (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Sofiane BELAID (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
The present invention relates to a system for characterizing at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel sample. The system comprises at least a device (MSIE) for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement in the sample, and a device (MDM) for determining deposit mass forming in the fuel sample. The invention further relates to a method for characterizing at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of the fuel over time, from measurements performed by the system according to the invention.
Claims
1.-15. (canceled)
16. A system for determining at least one of oxidation stability and thermal stability of a fuel, comprising: a) a device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement in the fuel; and b) a device for determining a deposit mass forming in the fuel; and c) a processor for processing the measurement, the processor comprising a computer on which is implemented at least one joint analysis method for determining evolution over time of values of components of an equivalent electrical representation of the fuel determined from the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements and of values of a variation of the deposit mass in the fuel with the at least one joint analysis method enabling detection of a deposit mass of the fuel.
17. A system as claimed in claim 16, wherein the device for determining a mass of the deposit is a piezoelectric microbalance.
18. A system as claimed in claim 17, wherein the piezoelectric microbalance is a piezoelectric quartz microbalance.
19. A system as claimed in claim 16, wherein the device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement comprises at least one frequency response analyser.
20. A system as claimed in claim 16, wherein the device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement comprises at least one interdigitated electrode sensor.
21. A system as claimed in claim 16, comprising: means for automating the measurements carried out by the device for performing at least one of an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement and the device for determining the deposit mass.
22. A system as claimed in claim 16, comprising: means for transmitting the measurements.
23. A system as claimed in claim 16, wherein the means for processing the measurements performs a spectral analysis to determine values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of the sample, the components of the equivalent electrical representation comprising at least a first resistor in series with a capacitor in parallel with a second resistor.
24. A method for determining one of oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel over time from at least one sample of the fuel which are carried out for each of multiple time intervals comprising: i) performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements on the at least one sample and measurements of the mass variation of a deposit formed in the sample, by use of the system of claim 16; ii) from the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements, determining values of components of an equivalent electrical representation of the sample, comprising at least a resistor in series with a capacitor with the capacitor being in parallel with another resistor; and iii) from at least part of the values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of the sample and the measurements of variation of deposit mass for each of the time intervals with at least one of the oxidation stability and thermal stability of the sample of the fuel being performed for each time interval.
25. A method for determining at least one oxidation stability and thermal stability of a fuel as claimed in claim 24, wherein step iii) is carried out by comparing at least part of the values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of each sample for the time interval and the values of the measurements of variation of the mass of the deposit for each time interval with predetermined reference threshold values.
26. A method as claimed in claim 25, wherein step iii) is applied by at least a first reference threshold value for the capacitance of the capacitor of about 6.10-.sup.11 F and of a second reference threshold value for the capacitance of the capacitor of about 1.10-.sup.10 F, the first reference threshold value for the capacitance being an indicator of a start of oxidation of the fuel sample and the second reference threshold value of the capacitance being an indicator of a start of deposition in the sample.
27. A method as claimed in claim 25, wherein step iii) is applied by at least a first reference threshold value for the second resistor defined by R1-init/2 and of a second reference threshold value for the second resistor defined by R1-init/5, where R1-init is a value of the second resistor determined for the first time interval, the first reference threshold value for the second resistor being an indicator of starting of oxidation of the fuel sample and the second reference threshold value for the second resistor being an indicator of starting of deposition in the sample.
28. A method as claimed in claim 26, wherein step iii) is performed with use of at least a first reference threshold value for a first resistor defined by R0-init/2 and of a second reference threshold value for the first resistor defined by R0-init/5, where R0-init is a value of the first resistor determined for the first time interval with the first reference threshold value for the first resistor being an indicator of the starting of oxidation of the fuel sample and the second reference threshold value for the first resistor being an indicator of starting of deposition in the sample.
29. A method as claimed in claim 25, wherein step iii) is applied with at least one reference threshold value of mass variation of the deposit of about 15 μg/cm.sup.2 as an indicator of starting of deposition in the sample.
30. A method as claimed in claim 25, wherein, prior to step iii), the reference threshold values are predetermined by use of a reference fuel sample and of at least a reference method for determining at least one of the oxidation stability and thermal stability of a fuel.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0037] Other features and advantages of the invention are clear from reading the description hereafter of embodiments given by way of non-limitative example, with reference to the accompanying drawings wherein:
[0038]
[0039]
[0040]
[0041]
[0042]
[0043]
[0044]
[0045]
[0046]
[0047]
[0048]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0049] The present invention relates to a method and to a system for determining at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel, from a sample of the fuel to be studied.
[0050] According to the invention, the fuel of the sample to be studied can be any type of fuel, including ground and aviation fuels (jet fuel, diesel fuel, gasoline), ground and aviation biofuels included.
[0051] The system and the method according to the invention comprise the combination of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements in a fuel sample and of measurements of the mass of a deposit formed in this fuel sample. This combination of different measurements allows reliable determination of the evolution of the changes in the electrochemical state of a fuel sample subjected to at least one of oxidation and to temperature rise, and thus enables early detection (in advance) of the formation of a deposit in this sample. In other words, this combination of different measurements enables detection of starting of deposition in a fuel sample.
[0052] The system according to the invention comprises at least: [0053] a device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement in a fuel to be studied, from a sample of the fuel; and [0054] a device for determining a mass variation of a deposit forming in this fuel, from a sample of this fuel.
[0055] Advantageously, the system according to the invention is configured in such a way that the two types of measurement carried out by the device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement and by use of the device for determining a mass variation of a deposit are simultaneous or, in other words, synchronous. This guarantees coherent interpretation of the two types of measurement performed by the system according to the invention.
[0056] In general, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a technique of analysing the dynamic behavior of an electrochemical system, which applies an electrical perturbation to the system as a function of time and monitors its response over time. More specifically, if an electrochemical system is subjected to an electrical voltage, the current response of the system will reflect the polarization mechanisms involved in the material and the charge transfer phenomena of at least one of the material/electrode interfaces. Generally, electrochemical impedance and permittivity are complex quantities that describe the ability of the material to polarize under the influence of an electric field.
[0057] According to one implementation of the invention, the device for performing electrochemical impedance measurements that is used for implementing the method according to the invention comprises at least one of a frequency response analyser connected to at least two electrodes. According to one implementation of the invention, the frequency response analyser is a Solartron 1260 marketed by the Ametek SI company (USA). Advantageously, the Solartron 1260 frequency response analyser can be supplemented by the 1296 dielectric interface marketed by the Ametek SI company (USA), which improves up to 106 times the signal. Such a device allows measurement by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy very high impedances up to 1014Ω. The frequency range available with such an example of a frequency response analyser extends from 10 μHz to 30 MHz.
[0058] Advantageously, the frequency range explored by use of the frequency range analyser extends between about 5 Hz and 105 Hz. With fuels which are rather poor electrical conductive fluids (classified among the so-called “dielectric” materials), such a limited frequency range, which is sufficient for monitoring dipolar polarizations, ionic migrations and charge transfer phenomena (at low frequencies), can be advantageously used.
[0059] According to one implementation of the invention, the frequency response analyser can be controlled by a computer and of software installed on the computer. According to an implementation of the invention wherein the frequency response analyser is the Solartron 1260, the software can be the SMaRT software developed by the High Tech Detection Systems company (France).
[0060] According to one implementation of the invention, the electrodes of the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements correspond to an interdigitated electrode sensor. This type of sensor is particularly suitable for dielectrometry measurements on poorly conductive materials such as fuels. The interdigitated sensor has a set of positive and negative electrodes arranged in interlocking combs (in other words, the interdigitated sensor is made up of an alternation of positive and negative electrodes). The electrodes are deposited on an insulating substrate and extended by two electrical wires providing connection to a potentiostat. In the case of such an interdigitated electrode sensor, an electric field is created between a positive electrode and a negative electrode.
[0061] According to one implementation of the invention, the interdigitated sensor is of the IDEX Micron MS-25/60HT type marketed by the Netzsch company, wherein the electrodes are made of nickel, arranged 25 μm apart and deposited on a quartz substrate.
[0062] Alternatively, a parallel plate capacitor, known as planar capacitor, can be used instead of an interdigitated electrode sensor. The operating principle of a parallel plate capacitor is comparable to that of an interdigitated electrode sensor except that, in this case, the distribution of the field lines is parallel.
[0063] According to the invention, a spectral analysis applied to the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements determines an equivalent electrical representation of the fuel sample with this equivalent electrical representation comprising at least a first resistor in series with a capacitor and the capacitor is in parallel with a second resistor. In general, the EIS spectra of all liquids can be modelled by an equivalent electrical circuit comprising resistors and capacitors. Complements may be found on a spectral analysis example in order to determine an electrical equivalent of a liquid in the document (De Souza et al., 2013).
[0064] According to one implementation of the invention, the spectral analysis can determine a diagram (called Nyquist diagram) as shown in
where f.sub.max is the bias frequency at the top of the semi-circle of the Nyquist diagram.
[0065] According to the invention, a mass variation of a deposit formed in the sample of the fuel to be studied is determined by use of at least one piezoelectric microbalance. A piezoelectric microbalance allows measurement of very low masses by measuring the change in resonance frequency of a piezoelectric crystal. More precisely, in a piezoelectric microbalance, a piezoelectric stimulation is applied via electrodes to a piezoelectric crystal, which then undergoes oscillation. The resonance frequency of the crystal is correlated to the mass thereof with any mass variation of the crystal (generated by a deposit on the crystal for example) causing a variation in the resonance frequency of this crystal. The mass variation can be determined from the frequency variation measurement, for example by use of a formula as follows, based on the Sauerbrey relation:
where n is the number of the oscillation harmonic of the crystal, f.sub.0 is the resonance frequency of the crystal (in Hz), μ.sub.q is the shear modulus of the crystal and ρ.sub.q is the density of the crystal, A is the piezoelectric surface of the crystal (area between electrodes, in cm.sup.2), and Δfs and Δm are the variations in frequency (in Hz) and in mass (in g) respectively.
[0066] Preferably, the piezoelectric microbalance used for implementing the method according to the invention is a quartz crystal microbalance (or QCM), also referred to as quartz microbalance. Indeed, quartz is characterized by an excellent quality factor.
[0067] According to one implementation of the invention, a quartz microbalance such as the eQCM 10M model marketed by the GAMRY Instruments company (USA) is used. According to an implementation of the invention, the piezoelectric microbalance is coupled with a potentiostat capable of working in an aqueous medium, such as the model marketed under reference 600 by the GAMRY Instruments company (USA). A potentiostat allows a potential or a current (which may be variable or not) to be applied to the electrode terminals, here the electrodes of the microbalance.
[0068] Advantageously, the electrodes of the device for determining the mass variation of a deposit formed in the sample of the fuel to be studied are also used for the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements. In other words, the electrodes of the system according to the invention are common to the device for determining the mass variation of a deposit formed in the sample of the fuel to be studied and to the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements.
[0069] According to one implementation of the invention, the system according to the invention can further comprise automation use of the measurements to be carried out by the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements and the device for determining a mass of a deposit formed in this fuel sample. In other words, the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and deposit mass measurement devices can be controlled by an automaton. This automaton allows preprograming the measurements to be performed and can notably allow them to be synchronized. The automaton, can for example, allow defining a sequencing of the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements to be carried out, simultaneously with the mass measurements of a deposit.
[0070] According to one implementation of the invention, the device can further comprise a transmitter for transmitting (by electrical wire, by optical fiber or by wireless transmission for example) the measurements carried out by at least one of the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements and by at least one of the device for determining a mass of a deposit formed in the fuel sample, and a processor for processing (of a computer using a microprocessor for example) the measurements carried out by the device for performing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements and by the device for determining mass of a deposit formed in this fuel sample.
[0071] According to one implementation of the invention, the measurement processor can comprise a computer on which at least one spectral analysis method for determining an equivalent electrical representation of the fuel sample being studied from the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements is implemented. Advantageously, a method for jointly analysing the evolution over time of the values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of the sample studied and of the mass variation values of a deposit in the sample is also implemented on this computer. The joint analysis can notably aim to determine if predefined thresholds above which a deposit forms in the sample have been reached. In this case, the measurement processor may also comprise a signaling device for signaling when a deposit is forming in the sample, such as an audible or visual alarm, or any type of alarm means.
[0072]
[0073] According to another aspect, the invention relates to a method for characterizing the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel. The method according to the invention is implemented from at least one sample of the fuel to be studied and it comprises at least three steps that are each applied for a time interval of time intervals. These time intervals can for example evenly or unevenly split a period during which at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of the fuel sample is to be monitored.
[0074] The method according to the invention comprises at least the following steps for a given time interval: [0075] i) performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement on the fuel sample and a measurement of the mass variation of a deposit formed in this sample, by a system for determining at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel sample according to any one of the variants described above; [0076] ii) from the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements, determining values of the components of an equivalent electrical representation of the fuel sample, as described above, comprising at least a first resistor in series with a capacitor which the capacitor being in parallel with a second resistor; and [0077] iii) from at least part of the values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of the fuel sample and the measurements of the mass variation of the deposit for the time interval considered determining at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of the fuel sample for this time interval.
[0078] According to the invention, steps i) to iii) are repeated for each time interval splitting the time period during which at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of the fuel sample being studied is to be monitored.
[0079] In general, as evidenced in the application examples below, the electrochemical impedance measurement provides a qualitative approach to changes that occur within a fluid, while the deposit mass variation measurement permits quantification of a deposit and thus monitoring the fouling kinetics of real equipment. In particular, the combination of the analysis of the electrochemical impedance measurements and of the mass variation measurements allows early detection of a start of aging of a fuel sample, which would not be reliably possible with only one of the two measurement types taken individually. In particular, the impedance measurement considered alone could lead to interpretation errors whereas, when combined with the deposit mass variation measurement, the interpretation becomes more reliable, as shown in the application examples hereafter.
[0080] According to one implementation of the invention, step iii) can be applied comparing at least one of at least part of the values of the components of the equivalent electrical representation of the sample and the values of the mass variation measurements of the deposit in the sample with predetermined reference threshold values.
[0081] According to one implementation of the invention, the reference threshold values are predetermined by at least one of a reference fuel sample and of at least one of at least one reference method for characterizing the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of a fuel sample. In other words, the reference threshold values are calibrated to a fuel sample, preferably of the same type as that to be monitored, and one or more methods allowing to determinate at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability are applied for each time interval, in addition to steps i) to iii) described above. Among various reference methods, it is possible to select, for example, the induction period measurement method (the ASTM D525 or ASTM D7545 standard methods, or to at least one of the EN 15751 standard) and the ASTM D2274 standard method for monitoring the formation of liquid insolubles.
[0082] According to one implementation of the invention, these predetermined threshold values can then be used for early detection, for example by using any variant of the system according to the invention, of the formation of a deposit in another sample of a fuel identical or similar to that on which the threshold values have been predetermined.
[0083] According to one implementation of the invention, if the value of capacitance C1 increases, for example from a value C1-init of the order of 4.10-11 F, and if: [0084] at a given time interval, the value of capacitance C1 reaches a reference threshold value of about 6.10-11 F, it can be concluded that oxidation of the fuel has started or, in other words, that fouling has started in the fuel sample being considered, or [0085] at a given time interval, if the value of capacitance C1 reaches a reference threshold value of about 1.10-.sup.10 F, it can be concluded that fouling in the fuel sample is at an advanced stage.
[0086] According to one implementation of the invention, if the value of resistance R1 (respectively R0) decreases as a function of time from a value R1-init (respectively R0-init), and if: [0087] at a given time interval, the value of resistance R1 (respectively R0) is less than a reference threshold value that is half the value of R1-init (respectively R0-init), it can be concluded that aging of the fuel has started, or [0088] at a given time interval, if the value of resistance R1 (respectively R0) is less than a reference threshold value that is a fifth of R1-init (respectively R0-init), then the formation of a deposit in the sample considered is effective, or even at an advanced stage.
[0089] According to one implementation of the invention wherein the value of resistance R0 is significantly less than the value of resistance R1 (what is meant by significantly less is that R0 is less than at least 0.01*R1), the evolution over time of the values of resistance R0 is not taken into account to characterize at least one of the oxidation stability and the thermal stability of the fuel studied.
[0090] According to one implementation of the invention, if the value of the mass variation DM is greater than 15 μg/cm2 (ratio of the mass to the surface area of the measuring electrode), that fouling is established.
[0091] More preferably, a cross-interpretation of the values taken over time by resistances R0, R1 and mass variation DM is performed in order to determine a reliable state of progress of a deposit in the sample being considered, for example from the aforementioned predetermined reference threshold values. The interest of such a cross-interpretation is shown in the application examples hereafter, in particular in Example 2 for which a reliable conclusion has been drawn by means of such a cross-interpretation.
EXAMPLES
[0092] The advantages of the method and of the system according to the invention are presented hereafter in three comparative application examples.
[0093] In these three examples, a fuel is subjected to an artificial aging process via temperature rise and oxidation. In Example 1, the fuel is a BO type diesel fuel. In Example 2, the fuel is a HVO 9263 type biodiesel fuel. In Example 3, the fuel is an aviation fuel.
[0094] The experimental protocol used for the three fuel types is described hereafter. A sample of a volume of 500 ml of a fuel to be tested is placed in a three-neck flask, itself placed in 130° C. (for Example 3) or 150° C. (for Examples 1 and 2) thermostatically-controlled oil bath. Air is then injected at a constant flow rate (10 L/h) into the liquid via a bubbler, to control the oxidation conditions.
[0095] The method according to the invention is implemented by a system as described above, notably comprising a device for performing an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurement (referred to as EIS measurement hereafter) and a frequency response analyser and of an interdigitated electrode sensor, and a device for determining a mass of a deposit, in form of a quartz microbalance (for performing a measurement referred to as EQCM hereafter). The electrodes of these two devices are immersed in the fuel sample to be studied. EIS and EQCM measurements are carried out continuously over time and analysed in real time. Moreover, liquid samples are collected over time for performing a measurement of induction period type, referred to as IP measurement hereafter, according to the prior art. The IP measurements are carried out by use of the Rancimat device for the diesel type fuels (Examples 1 and 2) and of the PetroOxy device (ASTM D7545) for the jet type fuels (Example 3), used according to the EN 15751 standard.
Example 1
[0096] For this example, the fuel is a BO type diesel fuel. The operating conditions of this example are presented in Table 1.
[0097] The results of this example are presented in
[0098] By combining the analyses of
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Conditions & protocol Volume 500 ml Temperature 150° C. Air flow 10 L/h Sampling V = 15 ml 0, 3.5, 6, 17.5, 18 and 40 h Nitrogen-blanketed flasks Low-temperature conditioning (<5° C.)
Example 2
[0103] For this example, the fuel is a HVO type (9263) biodiesel fuel. The operating conditions of this example are presented in Table 2.
[0104] The results of this example are presented in
[0105] By combining the analyses of
TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Conditions & protocol Volume 500 ml Temperature 150° C. Air flow 10 L/h Sampling V = 15 ml 2/day Nitrogen blanketing Low-temperature conditioning < 5° C.
Example 3
[0110] For this example, the fuel is an aviation fuel. The operating conditions of this example are presented in Table 3.
[0111] The results of this example are presented in
[0112] By combining the analyses of
TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Conditions & protocol Volume 500 ml Temperature 130° C. Air flow 10 L/h Sampling V = 15 ml 2/day Nitrogen blanketing Low-temperature conditioning < 5° C.
[0117] Thus, it clearly appears that the method and the device according to the invention have significant advantages over the IP measurement of the prior art: [0118] the electrochemical impedance measurement provides a qualitative approach to the various changes that occur within the fluid, leading to conclusions similar to that of an IP measurement according to the prior art. The IP measurement can therefore be advantageously replaced by a EIS measurement, more accurate, faster, less expensive and more descriptive; and [0119] the EQCM measurement allows direct quantification of the deposit obtained, and therefore to monitor the fouling kinetics and the fouling rate that would have been observed with a real equipment.
[0120] The two types of measurement, EIS and EQCM, are thus complementary; they notably provide qualitative and quantitative information relative to the various mechanisms involved in the aging phase of a fuel.