Cell stack device, module, and module housing device
11742510 · 2023-08-29
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
H01M8/04201
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/2475
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/243
ELECTRICITY
Y02E60/50
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
Y02E60/36
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
H01M8/2485
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/12
ELECTRICITY
International classification
H01M8/2485
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/04082
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
A cell stack device may include a cell stack comprising a plurality of cells, a manifold configured to supply a reaction gas to the plurality of cells, and a reaction gas supply pipe connected to the manifold. The manifold may include an insertion portion configured to connect the reaction gas supply pipe to the manifold and a first joining portion configured to join the insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe. A module may include the cell stack device contained in a housing container. A module housing device may include the module, an auxiliary device configured to operate the module, and an external casing configured to contain the module and the auxiliary device therein.
Claims
1. A cell stack device comprising: a cell stack comprising a plurality of cells, a manifold configured to supply a reaction gas to the plurality of cells, and a reaction gas supply pipe connected to the manifold, wherein the manifold comprises: an insertion portion configured for connection of the reaction gas supply pipe to the manifold, a gap between the insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe, and a first joining portion configured to join the insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe and seal one end of the gap on an outer side of the manifold; and in an arbitrarily defined cross-section along an insertion direction of the reaction gas supply pipe, a length of the gap in the insertion direction is longer than a thickness of the manifold.
2. The cell stack device according to claim 1, wherein a joint length, in the insertion direction, between the first joining portion and the reaction gas supply pipe, is shorter than double a thickness of the reaction gas supply pipe.
3. The cell stack device according to claim 2, wherein in the arbitrarily defined cross-section along the insertion direction of the reaction gas supply pipe, the joint length in the insertion direction is longer than the thickness of the manifold.
4. The cell stack device according to claim 1, wherein the reaction gas supply pipe is connected to a reaction gas supply source at one end of the reaction gas supply pipe, the other end of the reaction gas supply pipe is inserted into a first through hole as the insertion portion provided in the manifold and joined to the manifold via the first joining portion, and in the arbitrarily defined cross-section along the insertion direction of the reaction gas supply pipe, an angle θ1 is 30° or less, the angle θ1 being formed between a vertical line drawn from a first leading end portion of the first joining portion to the manifold, and a first straight line connecting the first leading end portion to a first point, the first point being located on a first contour line of the first joining portion and positioned at half a height from a first bottom portion to the first leading end portion of the first joining portion.
5. The cell stack device according to claim 1, wherein the first joining portion has a concave meniscus shape.
6. The cell stack device according to claim 1, wherein a first bent portion of the manifold extending away from the manifold along the reaction gas supply pipe is provided around an outer periphery of the insertion portion, and an end portion of the first bent portion and the reaction gas supply pipe are joined via the first joining portion.
7. A module comprising: the cell stack device according to claim 1 contained in a housing container.
8. A module housing device comprising: the module according to claim 7; an auxiliary device configured to operate the module; and an external casing configured to contain the module and the auxiliary device therein.
9. A cell stack device comprising: a cell stack comprising a plurality of cells, a manifold configured to supply a reaction gas to the plurality of cells; and a reaction gas supply pipe connected to the manifold, wherein the manifold comprises: an insertion portion configured for connection of the reaction gas supply pipe to the manifold, a gap between the insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe, and a first joining portion configured to seal one end of the gap as a result of joining the insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe; in an arbitrarily defined cross-section along an insertion direction of the reaction gas supply pipe, an average crystal area is 10000 μm2 or less with respect to crystals present in an analysis region that is defined by a portion of an outer cross-sectional perimeter of the first joining portion having a length of 500 μm, two parallel lines each having a length of 500 μm and having respective start points at both ends of the portion of the outer cross-sectional perimeter of the first joining portion, and a line joining two end points of the parallel lines opposite the respective start points.
10. The cell stack device according to claim 9, wherein the average crystal area is 4000 μm2 or less with respect to the crystals present in the analysis region.
11. The cell stack device according to claim 9, wherein a crystal area of all the crystals present in the analysis region is 40000 μm2 or less.
12. The cell stack device according to claim 9, wherein in the analysis region, an average crystal area of crystals positioned along the portion of the outer cross-sectional perimeter of the first joining portion is 2000 μm2 or less.
13. A cell stack device comprising: a cell stack comprising a plurality of cells, a manifold configured to supply a reaction gas to the plurality of cells; and a reaction gas supply pipe connected to a reaction gas supply source at one end of the reaction gas supply pipe and connected to the manifold, wherein the manifold comprises: a main body portion comprising a space communicated with the plurality of cells and a second through hole, a flange portion protruding from the main body portion, the flange portion comprising a first through hole; the first hole is a first insertion portion and the second hole is a second insertion portion, each configured for connection of the reaction gas supply pipe to the manifold; the reaction gas supply pipe is inserted into the first through hole, and the reaction gas supply pipe and the manifold are joined by a first joining portion; and the other end of the reaction gas supply pipe is inserted into the second through hole, and the other end of the reaction gas supply pipe and the manifold are joined via a second joining portion.
14. The cell stack device according to claim 13, wherein a second gap is between the second insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe; the second joining portion is configured to seal one end of the second gap as a result of joining the second insertion portion and the reaction gas supply pipe; and a second joint length, in the insertion direction, between the second joining portion and the reaction gas supply pipe is longer than a thickness of the reaction gas supply pipe.
15. The cell stack device according to claim 13, wherein in the arbitrarily defined cross-section along the insertion direction of the reaction gas supply pipe, an angle θ2 is 30° or less, the angle θ2 being formed between a vertical line drawn from a second leading end portion of the second joining portion to the manifold, and a second straight line connecting the second leading end portion to a second point, the second point being located on a second contour line of the second joining portion and positioned at half a height from a second bottom portion to the second leading end portion of the second joining portion.
16. The cell stack device according to claim 13, wherein the first joining portion and the second joining portion have a concave meniscus shape.
17. The cell stack device according to claim 13, wherein a second bent portion extending away from the manifold along the reaction gas supply pipe is provided by the manifold and around an outer periphery of the second through hole in the manifold, and an end portion of the second bent portion and the reaction gas supply pipe are joined via the second joining portion.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(13) A cell stack device, a module, and a module housing device will be described using
(14) The cell stack device illustrated in
(15)
(16) A cell stack device 1 illustrated in
(17) Cell Stack Device
(18) The cell stack device 1 illustrated in
(19) At each of end portions of the cell stack 5, an electrically conductive end member 11 is disposed, which includes an electrically conductive unit 12 for collecting electricity generated by the power generation in the cell stack 5 (the fuel cells 3) and drawing the electricity to the outside.
(20) A reformer 6 is disposed above the cell stack 5, as a gas supply source for producing a fuel gas (hereinafter sometimes simply referred to as a “gas”), which is a reaction gas supplied to the fuel cells 3. A configuration can be adopted in which the cell stack device 1 includes the reformer 6.
(21) The reformer 6 illustrated in
(22) In
(23)
(24) One end of the fuel gas supply pipe 9 is connected to the reformer 6, and the other end thereof is inserted into an insertion portion 14 provided in the manifold 4 and joined with the manifold 4. The manifold 4 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9 can be manufactured from a heat resistant metal such as alumina-forming stainless steel or a chromia-forming stainless steel. The insertion portion 14 is a through hole provided in the manifold 4, and although it is provided in the upper face of the manifold 4 in the non-limiting example illustrated in
(25) As illustrated in
(26) As illustrated in
(27) As a result, the toughness of the first joining portion 17 between the fuel gas supply pipe 9 and the manifold 4 can be maintained at a high level, and cracks in the first joining portion 17 can be inhibited. Specifically, the long-term reliability of the cell stack device 1, a module 20, and a module housing device 40 can be improved.
(28) Note that “sealing one end of the gap” means that the one end of the gap 14a on the inner side of the manifold 4 may be sealed, or the one end of the gap 14a on the outer side of the manifold 4 may be sealed. In a case where the one end of the gap 14a on the inner side of the manifold 4 is sealed, the first joining portion 17 is provided in the interior of the manifold 4. Note that both the ends of the gap 14a may be sealed, and in this case, a surface of the first joining portion 17 exposed to a hydrogen-containing gas is referred to as a first surface S1, and a surface on the opposite side is referred to as a second surface S2.
(29) In addition, the “first joining portion” means a region surrounded, in the arbitrarily defined cross-section along the insertion direction of the fuel gas supply pipe 9, by the first surface S1, the second surface S2, a line connecting ends of the first surface S1 and the second surface S2 on the manifold 4 side and a line connecting ends of the first surface S1 and the second surface S2 on the fuel gas supply pipe 9 side.
(30) Further, the “meniscus shape” may be a concave meniscus shape as illustrated in
(31) Furthermore, the “thickness of the fuel gas supply pipe” D2 is a thickness of a part of the fuel gas supply pipe having the smallest thickness. However, the thickness of a part of the first joining portion 9 that is in contact with the first joining portion 17 is excluded.
(32) Here, the second surface S2 may be formed as a part in which a structure of a crystal close to the surface is a dendritic structure, or may be formed as a part that has a different material composition from each of the manifold 4 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9.
(33) Further, the joint length D1 may be shorter than double the thickness of the fuel gas supply pipe 9. In this way, the manifold 4 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9 is joined via the first joining portion 17 more strongly than necessary, and the freedom of movement of the first joining portion 17 is reduced; as a result, a concentration of the stress on the first joining portion 17 can be inhibited.
(34) In addition, in the arbitrarily defined cross-section along the insertion direction of the fuel gas supply pipe 9, the joint length D1 in the insertion direction may be longer than a thickness D3 of the manifold 4. As a result of this, even when the manifold 4 is vibrated in the insertion direction of the fuel gas supply pipe 9, cracks can be inhibited from occurring in the vicinity of a joint interface between the first joining portion 17 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9.
(35) Note that the “thickness of the manifold” D3 is a thickness of a part having the smallest thickness of the wall of the manifold 4 in which the insertion portion 14 is provided, but the thickness of a part of the manifold 4 that is in contact with the first joining portion 17 is excluded.
(36)
(37) In the non-limiting example illustrated in
(38) The non-limiting example illustrated in
(39) In addition, an annular member, which extends toward the reformer 6 side along the fuel gas supply pipe 9, may separately be provided around an outer periphery of the insertion portion 14. As another non-limiting example, the bent portion or the annular member may be provided around the peripheral edge of the insertion portion on the inner side of the manifold.
(40) In the non-limiting example illustrated in
(41)
(42) As illustrated in
(43) Further, as illustrated in
(44) A method will be described for identifying the crystal area of the crystals in a cross-section of the first joining portion 17. Firstly, the scanning electron microscope is used to obtain a channeling contrast image in a cross section of the first joining portion 17 that includes the second surface. Next, the crystals appearing in the obtained channeling contrast image are identified. Lastly, of the identified crystals, the crystal areas of the crystals surrounded by the above-described analysis region are identified using an image analysis method or the like.
(45) A non-limiting example of a method for manufacturing the above-described manifold 4 according to the present disclosure will be described next.
(46) The first joining portion 17 that joins the fuel gas supply pipe 9 and the manifold 4 can be provided by joining the manifold 4 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9 using a metallurgical joining method. The metallurgical joining methods are methods to perform joining through fusion welding, pressure welding, or soldering. Non-limiting examples of the fusion welding include laser welding, plasma arc welding, inert gas arc welding, MAG welding, gas welding, or the like. Further, non-limiting examples of the pressure welding include ultrasonic welding, friction welding, explosive welding, or the like.
(47) Adjustment of the joint length D1 between the first joining portion 17 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9, in the arbitrarily defined cross-section of the first joining portion 17 along the insertion direction of the fuel gas supply pipe 9, and adjustment of the crystal area of the crystals of the second surface of the first joining portion 17 can be realized by adjusting, as appropriate, various conditions of the joining method of the metallurgical joining methods. For example, in a case where the first joining portion 17 is provided by welding, the adjustments can be realized by adjusting an irradiation angle and an irradiation output of a heat source.
(48)
(49) Here, as illustrated in
(50) Further, in the course of further suppressing damage and the like to the first joining portion 17, a shape can be adopted in which the angle θ1 is 20° or less.
(51) Further, the first joining portion 17 can be a concave meniscus shape, or a linear shape. In this way, it is possible to inhibit the stress acting on the first joining portion 17 from concentrating on a single point, and the stress acting on the first joining portion 17 can be alleviated.
(52)
(53) The manifold 4 of a cell stack device 111 illustrated in
(54) Note that, since the joining (the first joining portion) of the first through hole 14d and the fuel gas supply pipe 9 can adopt the above-described configuration illustrated in
(55)
(56) Here, in the arbitrarily defined cross-section in the insertion direction of the fuel gas supply pipe 9, the angle θ2 is an angle formed between a vertical line drawn from the second leading end portion 18b of the second joining portion 18 toward the manifold 4, and a second straight line L2 joining a second point 18c and the second leading end portion 18b, the second point 18c being in a second contour line S4 of the second joining portion 18 and positioned at a height that is half of a height from a second bottom portion 18a to the second leading end portion 18b of the second joining portion 18.
(57) Further, in the course of further suppressing damage and the like to the second joining portion 18, a shape can be adopted in which the angle θ2 is 20° or less.
(58) As illustrated in
(59)
(60) In a non-limiting example illustrated in
(61) A non-limiting example of a method for manufacturing the above-described manifold 4 according to the present disclosure will be described. As illustrated in
(62) The first through hole 14d is formed by penetrating the flange portion 4b through a processing method, such as a punching process. Similarly, the second through hole 14e is formed by penetrating the main body portion 4a through a processing method, such as the punching process.
(63) The first joining portion 17 and the second joining portion 18 to which the fuel gas supply pipe 9 and the manifold 4 are joined can be provided by joining an outer surface of the manifold 4 and the fuel gas supply pipe 9 using a metallurgical joining method. The metallurgical joining methods are the methods to perform joining through the fusion welding, the pressure welding, or the soldering. Non-limiting examples of the fusion welding include the laser welding, the plasma arc welding, the inert gas arc welding, the MAG welding, the gas welding, or the like. Further, non-limiting examples of the pressure welding include the ultrasonic welding, the friction welding, the explosive welding, or the like.
(64) Further, in the manifold 4, in order to provide the first bent portion 14b and the second bent portion 14c formed integrally with the outer peripheries of a first through hole 14d and the second through hole 14e, respectively, the first bent portion 14b and the second bent portion 14c can be manufactured by a processing method such as the pressing process using dies having the shapes of the first bent portion 14b and the second bent portion 14c. Further, in a case where the first bent portion 14b and the second bent portion 14c are provided separately from the outer peripheries of the first through hole 14d and the second through hole 14e, respectively, members having the shapes of the first bent portion 14b and the second bent portion 14c may be prepared, and the respective members may be joined to the outer peripheries of the first through hole 14d and the second through hole 14e using the above-described metallurgical joining method.
(65) Cell
(66) A well-known general material may be used for the fuel electrode layer. For example, the fuel electrode layer can be formed of a porous electrically conductive ceramic, such as ZrO.sub.2 solid solution with a rare earth element oxide (referred to as a stabilized zirconia that also includes partially stabilized zirconia), and at least one of Ni and NiO.
(67) The solid electrolyte layer functions as an electrolyte that allows electron transfer between the electrodes, and has a gas blocking property that prevents leaks of the fuel gas and the oxygen-containing gas. The solid electrolyte layer is formed of ZrO.sub.2 solid solution containing 3 to 15 mol % of the rare earth element oxide. Note that the solid electrolyte layer may be formed from another material as long as that material exhibits the above-described properties.
(68) The material for an oxygen electrode layer is not particularly limited, and any well-known general material may be used. For example, the oxygen electrode layer can be formed of an electrically conductive ceramic made from a so-called ABO.sub.3 perovskite oxide. The oxygen electrode layer is gas permeable, and the open porosity thereof is in a range of 20% or more, and particularly in a range from 30 to 50%.
(69) The interconnector can be formed from an electrically conductive ceramic, but since the interconnector comes contact with the fuel gas (the hydrogen-containing gas) and the oxygen-containing gas (air or the like), a lanthanum chromite perovskite oxide (LaCrO.sub.3 based oxide) that is reduction resistant and oxidation resistant can be used. In order to prevent leaks of the fuel gas flowing through gas flow passages formed by the support body and the oxygen-containing gas flowing on the outer side of the fuel cells 3, the interconnector is dense and has a relative density of 93% or greater, and particularly 95% or greater.
(70) The support body is gas permeable to allow the fuel gas to permeate therethrough and arrive at the fuel electrode layer, and further, is electrically conductive to allow current collection via the interconnector. Thus, a material that satisfies these requirements, such as an electrically conductive ceramic or cermet can be used as the support body.
(71) Moreover, in each of the fuel cells 3 illustrated in
(72) During the manufacture of the fuel cells 3, in a case where the support body is manufactured by simultaneously sintering with the fuel electrode layer or the solid electrolyte layer, the support body can be made from an iron group metal, such as Ni, and a specific rare earth oxide, such as Y.sub.2O.sub.3. In addition, to ensure the fuel gas permeability, the support body has an open porosity of 20% or more, and particularly in a range from 25 to 50%. The support body also has an electrical conductivity of 300 S/cm or more, and particularly 440 S/cm or more.
(73) Here, in the fuel cell 3, a portion in which the fuel electrode layer and the oxygen electrode layer face each other via the solid electrolyte layer functions as a power generating element. That is, the oxygen-containing gas, such as air, flows outside the oxygen electrode layer and the fuel gas (the hydrogen-containing gas) flows in the gas flow passages inside the support body, and the gases are heated to a predetermined actuation temperature, generating power as a result. Then, current generated by this power generation is collected by the above-described electrically conductive member, via the interconnector disposed on the support body.
(74) Module
(75)
(76) Here,
(77) Furthermore, in the module 20 of the present non-limiting example, since the above-described cell stack device 1 is contained in the housing container 21, the module 20 with improved durability can be obtained.
(78) Module Housing Device
(79)
(80) In the module housing device 40 illustrated in
(81) Furthermore, an airflow hole 46 is formed in the dividing plate 43. The air flow hole 46 allows air in the auxiliary device housing chamber 45 to flow into the module housing chamber 44. An exhaust hole 47 is formed in a part of the outer plates 42 that configure the module housing chamber 44. Air inside the module housing chamber 44 is discharged through the exhaust hole 47.
(82) In the module housing device 40, as described above, by configuring the module 20 having improved durability to be contained in the module housing chamber 44, it is possible to obtain the module housing device 40 having improved durability.
(83) The present disclosure is not limited to the above-described non-limiting examples, and various modifications can be made without departing from the scope of the present disclosure. For example, in the above-described non-limiting examples, the explanation is made using so-called “vertical cells”. However, horizontal cells referred to commonly as “horizontal cells”, in which a plurality of power generating elements are formed on a support substrate, or so-called cylindrical cells may also be used.
(84) Furthermore, the fuel cells 3, the cell stack device 1, the module 20, and the module housing device 40 are described in the above-described non-limiting examples. However, the present disclosure can also be applied to electrolytic cells (SOEC) that generate hydrogen and oxygen (O.sub.2) as a result of electrolyzing water vapor (water) by applying water vapor and voltage to a cell, an electrolytic cell stack device and an electrolytic module that are provided with the electrolytic cells, and an electrolytic device that is a module housing device.
Example 1
(85) Manufacture of Samples
(86) According to the above-described methods for the above-described cell stack device, the manifold and the fuel gas supply pipe were welded using the laser welding method, and samples shown in Tables 1 to 4 were manufactured.
(87) The various members of the cell stack device were the same as those illustrated in
(88) Durability Test
(89) Hydrogen-containing gas was caused to flow through the gas flow passages of the fuel cells of the cell stack device, and further, air was caused to flow on the outer side of the fuel cells (on the outer face of the air electrode layer). Then, power was generated for 24 hours at 850° C. After that, the hydrogen-containing gas was stopped and the cell stack device was naturally cooled. The above procedure was repeatedly performed up to a predetermined number of repetitions, the test was stopped, and the presence or absence of cracks was verified. The results are shown in Tables 1 to 4.
(90) Note that further testing was not performed on stack devices in which cracks had occurred at the time of verification.
(91) The test results are shown in Tables 1 to 4. Note that, in Tables 1 to 4, the joint length between the first joining portion and the fuel gas supply pipe, an average crystal area value, a maximum crystal area value, a value of the average crystal area of the crystals positioned on the surface of the first joining portion, and a number of cycles of a thermal cycling test are listed.
(92) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Average Presence/Absence of Average Maximum crystal cracks after thermal Joint crystal crystal area value cycling test Sample length area value area value at surface 400 420 No. (mm) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) cycles cycles 1 0.8 9120 30035 1928 Present — 2 0.9 8921 30101 1978 Present — 3 1.0 9003 28781 1911 Absent Absent 4 1.4 8992 34252 1942 Absent Absent 5 1.7 9187 30994 1997 Absent Absent 6 1.8 9091 28222 1978 Absent Present 7 2.2 8934 29716 1954 Absent Present
Durability Test Result 1
(93) For sample No. 1 with the joint length of 0.8 mm and Sample No. 2 with the joint length of 0.9 mm, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 400 cycles. However, for Samples No. 3 to 7 with the joint lengths of 1.0 mm or greater, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 400 cycles.
(94) For Samples No. 6 and 7 with the joint lengths of 1.8 mm or greater, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 420 cycles. However, for Samples No. 3 to 5 with the joint lengths of 1.0 mm to 1.7 mm, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 420 cycles.
(95) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Average Presence/Absence of Average Maximum crystal cracks after thermal Joint crystal crystal area value cycling test Sample length area value area value at surface 440 460 No. (mm) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) cycles cycles 1 1.4 13119 30118 1979 Present — 2 1.4 11021 30381 1965 Present — 3 1.4 10000 31003 1999 Absent Present 4 1.4 8110 32411 1921 Absent Present 5 1.4 6208 29931 1896 Absent Present 6 1.4 4000 28251 1991 Absent Absent 7 1.4 3107 30004 1936 Absent Absent
Durability Test Result 2
(96) For Sample No. 1 with the average crystal area value of 13119 μm.sup.2 and Sample No. 2 with the average crystal area value of 11021 μm.sup.2, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 440 cycles. However, for Samples No. 3 to 7 with the average crystal area values of 10000 μm.sup.2 or less, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 440 cycles.
(97) For Samples 3 to 5 with the average crystal area values greater than 4000 μm.sup.2, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 460 cycles. However, for Samples No. 6 and 7 with the average crystal area values of 4000 μm.sup.2 or less, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 460 cycles.
(98) TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Average Maximum Average Presence/Absence Joint crystal crystal area crystal area of cracks after Sample length area value value value at thermal cycling No. (mm) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) surface (μm.sup.2) test 480 cycles 1 1.4 8109 51126 1988 Present 2 1.4 8071 43004 1945 Present 3 1.4 8114 40000 1989 Absent 4 1.4 8111 32222 1998 Absent 5 1.4 8067 28251 1911 Absent
Durability Test Result 3
(99) For Sample No. 1 with the maximum crystal area value of 51126 μm.sup.2 and Sample No. 2 with the maximum crystal area value of 43004 μm.sup.2, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 480 cycles. However, for Samples No. 3 to 5 with the maximum crystal area values of 40000 μm.sup.2 or less, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 480 cycles.
(100) TABLE-US-00004 TABLE 4 Average Maximum Average Presence/Absence Joint crystal crystal area crystal area of cracks after Sample length area value value value at thermal cycling No. (mm) (μm.sup.2) (μm.sup.2) surface (μm.sup.2) test 500 cycles 1 1.4 8121 32877 2572 Present 2 1.4 8111 33526 2128 Present 3 1.4 8004 34847 2000 Absent 4 1.4 7974 33442 1765 Absent 5 1.4 8022 35242 1439 Absent
Durability Test Result 4
(101) For Sample No. 1 with the average crystal area value at surface of 2572 μm.sup.2 and Sample No. 2 with the average crystal area value at surface of 2128 μm.sup.2, cracks occurred in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 500 cycles. However, for Samples No. 3 to 5 with the average crystal area values at surface of 2000 μm.sup.2 or less, cracks did not occur in the first joining portions in the thermal cycling test of 500 cycles.
REFERENCE SIGNS LIST
(102) 1 Cell stack device 3 Fuel cell 4 Manifold 5 Cell stack 6 Reaction gas supply source (reformer) 9 Reaction gas (fuel gas) supply pipe 14 Insertion portion 14a Gap 14b First bent portion 14c Second bent portion 14d First through hole 14e Second through hole 17 First joining portion 18 Second joining portion D1 Joint length D2 Thickness of fuel gas supply pipe D3 Thickness of manifold D4 Gap length 20 Module (fuel cell module) 40 Module housing device (fuel cell device) S1 First surface S2 Second surface S3 First contour line S4 Second contour line L1 First straight line L2 Second straight line