METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR IDENTIFYING PARTICLES, BASED ON MULTIFREQUENCY MEASUREMENTS OF RESONANCE PLATES
20220136953 · 2022-05-05
Inventors
- José Jaime RUZ MARTÍNEZ (Madrid, ES)
- Óscar MALVAR VIDAL (Madrid, ES)
- Eduardo GIL-SANTOS (Madrid, ES)
- Montserrat CALLEJA GÓMEZ (Madrid, ES)
- Francisco Javier Tamayo De Miguel (Madrid, ES)
Cpc classification
G01N2291/0427
PHYSICS
G01N29/348
PHYSICS
G01N29/022
PHYSICS
G01N2291/0256
PHYSICS
G01N2291/0426
PHYSICS
International classification
Abstract
The disclosure relates to a method for identifying adsorbates deposited on resonance plates. The method includes (i) calculating a candidate mass and candidate position of the adsorbate, disregarding the effect of stiffness, from the measurement of the frequencies of the plate and prior knowledge of the mass of the plate; (ii) using the calculated values as a starting point for calculating the final values of the mass and position of the adsorbate and the different stiffness coefficients from the measurement of the frequencies of the plate; (iii) comparing the values of the candidate mass of the adsorbate and of the calculated coefficients with a set of previously stored reference values corresponding to a catalogue of known adsorbates; and (iv) identifying the adsorbate deposited on the plate as the adsorbate belonging to the catalogue that is most similar to the obtained values.
Claims
1. A method for identifying an adsorbate of mass M.sub.a deposited on a plate of mass M.sub.p, wherein said plate comprises a set of vibration modes, and wherein, for said modes, the corresponding resonance frequency f.sub.0 thereof is displaced by a certain amount Δf upon depositing the adsorbate in an adsorption position (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) thereof; said method comprising the following steps: calculating a candidate mass and candidate position of the adsorbate from the measurement of the change in frequency of a plurality of vibration modes of the plate, with prior knowledge of the mass of the plate M.sub.p, the effect of the stiffness being disregarded, such that the change Δf is determined as follows:
U.sub.a=γ′.sub.xε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ′.sub.yε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ′.sub.xxyyε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)+γ.sub.′xyε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ.sub.′xxxyε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)+γ′.sub.yyxyε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0); comparing the values of the candidate mass of the adsorbate M′.sub.a and of the coefficients γ′ calculated in the preceding step with a set of reference values {M.sub.a.sup.D, (γ′).sup.D} which are calculated from the transformation to the reference system of the plate of previously stored values corresponding to a catalogue of known adsorbates deposited on the plate with a given orientation in a reference plane (x′, y′); and identifying the adsorbate deposited on the plate as the adsorbate belonging to the catalogue the values M′.sub.a and γ′ of which are the most similar to the values {M.sub.a.sup.D, (γ′).sup.D}.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the components γ′ measured in the reference system of the plate are related to the components γ measured in the reference system of the adsorbate belonging to the catalogue of adsorbates, which is rotated an angle θ about the z axis, by means of the expression:
γ′.sub.x=γ.sub.x cos.sup.4θ+γ.sub.y sin.sup.4θ+(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.2θ sin.sup.2θ−γ.sub.xxxy cos.sup.3θ sin θ−γ.sub.yyxy sin.sup.3θ cos θ
γ′.sub.y=γ.sub.y cos.sup.4θ+γ.sub.x sin.sup.4θ+(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.2θ sin.sup.2θ+γ.sub.xxxy cos.sup.3θ sin θ+γ.sub.yyxy sin.sup.3θ cos θ
γ′.sub.xy=(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.22θ+(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y)sin.sup.22θ−γ.sub.xxyy+(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos.sup.22θ sin.sup.22θ
γ′.sub.xxyy=1/2(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)sin.sup.22θ+γ.sub.xxyy+1/2(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos.sup.22θ sin.sup.22θ
γ′.sub.xxxy=(γ.sub.x−γ.sub.y+(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)cos 2θ)sin 2θ+1/2((γ.sub.xxxy+γ.sub.yyxy)cos 2θ+(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos 4θ)
γ′.sub.yyxy=(γ.sub.x−γ.sub.y−(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)cos 2θ)sin 2θ+1/2((γ.sub.xxxy+γ.sub.yyxy)cos 2θ−(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos 4θ).
3. The method according to claim 2, wherein the resonant vibration modes comprise out-of-plane and/or in-plane vibration modes.
4. The method according to claim 1, wherein only resonant vibration modes experiencing a negative change in frequency with the deposition of the adsorbate are selected.
5. The method according to claim 4, wherein N>2 modes in total are measured, and M is the set of said modes with a negative change in frequency and wherein, for calculating the adsorption position in the first step, the following function is minimized:
6. The method according to claim 5, wherein for calculating the final adsorption position, the mass M′.sub.a and the different coefficients γ′, the following function is minimized:
7. The method according to claim 1, wherein the comparison of the values of the candidate mass of the adsorbate M.sub.a and of the coefficients γ′ with the set of previously stored reference values {M.sub.a.sup.D, (γ′).sup.D} is calculated by means of the similarity estimator I(θ):
8. The method according to claim 1, wherein the adsorbates are inorganic particles, viruses, bacteria, proteins and/or cells.
9. The method according to claim 1, wherein in the step corresponding to the calculation of the final values of mass M′.sub.a, of the position of the adsorbate and of the plurality of stiffness coefficients γ′, the effect of stiffness is taken into account by means of a perturbation method with respect to the initial identification.
10. A system for identifying an adsorbate of mass M.sub.a deposited on a plate of mass M.sub.p, wherein said plate comprises a plurality of vibration modes and wherein, for each of said modes, the corresponding resonance frequency f.sub.0 thereof is displaced by an amount Δf based on the non-dimensional displacement (û, {circumflex over (v)}, ŵ) of the plate in the corresponding vibration mode upon depositing the adsorbate in an adsorption position (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) thereof, wherein said system comprises: one or more plates; deposition means for depositing one or more adsorbates on the plates; measurement means for measuring the displacement of the resonance frequency when the adsorbate is deposited on one of the plates for a plurality of vibration modes thereof; said system being characterized in that comprises software and hardware means for recording and processing data, configured for reading the data generated by the measurement means and for storing a set of reference values {M.sub.a, γ}, corresponding to a catalogue of known adsorbates deposited on the plate with a given orientation in a reference plane (x′, y′), the software and hardware means being further configured for performing a method according to claim 1.
11. The system according to claim 10, wherein said system comprises a mass spectrometer.
12. The system according to claim 11, wherein the deposition means for depositing one or more adsorbates on the plates comprise one or more vacuum chambers and an ionization and/or electrospray system suitable for spraying adsorbates on the plates.
13. The system according to claim 10, wherein the measurement means for measuring the displacement of the resonance frequency comprise piezoelectric materials for performing frequency scanning and/or one or more phase-locked loops; and one or more lasers focused on the plates and configured for emitting a beam thereon.
14. The system according to claim 13, further comprising a photodetector suitable for receiving the laser beam reflected by the plates.
15. The system according to claim 14, comprising an amplifier connected to the photodetector and suitable for subsequently amplifying the signal for reading same.
Description
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0030]
[0031]
[0032]
[0033]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0034] As described in the section corresponding to the background of the invention, a plate having an arbitrary geometry can vibrate with very different modes and frequencies. When classifying these vibrations into different categories, a distinction is usually made between “out-of-plane” vibrations and “in-plane” vibrations. Out-of-plane vibrations are those vibrations for which the main displacement takes place perpendicular to the plane of the plate, and wherein displacements of another type are disregarded. Moreover, when the main displacements occur in the same plane as the plate, this is referred to as an in-plane vibration mode. The bending and torsional modes of cantilever type plates are examples of out-of-plane modes, whereas radial breathing modes of disc type plates are examples of in-plane vibration modes. Generally, and as shown in
[0037] Taking these effects into account and assuming that the size of the particle is much smaller than the size of the resonator, the change in relative frequency can be expressed as:
wherein T is the mean kinetic energy per oscillation cycle, U is the mean strain energy per oscillation cycle and the subscripts p and a correspond to the plate and adsorbate, respectively. The effect of the mass of particles on resonance frequencies of the plate corresponds to the kinetic energy part of Equation 1.
[0038] The kinetic energy T.sub.p of the plate can be expressed as:
T.sub.p=1/2A.sub.n.sup.2ω.sub.n.sup.2M.sub.p, (Eq. 2)
wherein M is the mass, ω.sub.n is the angular vibration frequency of the plate and A.sub.n is an arbitrary amplitude. Assuming that the particle is much smaller than the plate, the displacement along the particle can be considered constant; therefore, the kinetic energy of the adsorbate can be expressed as:
T.sub.a=1/2A.sub.n.sup.2ω.sub.n.sup.2M.sub.a(û(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+{circumflex over (v)}(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+ŵ(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2), (Eq. 3)
wherein û, {circumflex over (v)} and ŵ are the non-dimensional displacement of the corresponding vibration mode and (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) are the coordinates of the adsorption position on the plate. Using Equation 1, the effect of mass of the adsorbate on resonance frequency of the plate can ultimately be expressed as:
[0039] The strain of the plate when it is vibrating is transferred to the adsorbate that is deposited on its surface. The contact surface between the adsorbate and the plate plays a crucial role in strain transmission. Strain involves a spatial variation of the displacements and, therefore, a contact area which is, for example, very narrow at x, barely being able to transfer strain in said direction x, because the displacements are constant for all practical purposes in such a narrow space. This means that for a contact surface that is perpendicular to direction z, none of the components z of the strain will be transferred to the adsorbate. Given the state of in-plane strain of the plate in the adsorption position ε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0), ε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0) and ε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0), the final state of strain in the adsorbate will be proportional only to these three amounts. The proportionality constants will depend on the geometry of the adsorbate and also on the nature of the vibration mode. Since the thickness of the plate is considered small in comparison with its other dimensions, the mechanical state of the plate can be described with the plane stress approximation, and the mean strain energy of the plate can be expressed as:
wherein E and v are the Young's modulus and the Poisson's ratio of a perfectly isotropic material. If the material is elastically anisotropic, Equation 5 above must be transformed according to the stress-strain ratios of the anisotropic material. The stress energy in the adsorbate is quadratic with strain. As mentioned above, the strain of the adsorbate is proportional to the in-plane components of the strains of the plate at the point of adsorption, and therefore, a general expression of strain energy in the adsorbate is:
U.sub.a=γ.sub.xε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ.sub.yε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ.sub.xxyyε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)+γ.sub.xyε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+γ.sub.xxxyε.sub.xx(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)+γ.sub.yyxyε.sub.yy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0)ε.sub.xy(x.sub.0, y.sub.0), (Eq. 6)
wherein coefficients γ are constants that depend on the mechanical properties and the geometry of the adsorbate and on the geometry of the plate. A key feature of Equation 6 is that coefficients γ are completely independent of the adsorption position and the vibration mode and are, therefore, excellent candidates for a precise identification of the adsorbate; in other words, they form a stiffness “fingerprint” of the adsorbate, which can be experimentally determined. However, given that these coefficients depend on the geometry of the adsorbate, in a general case, they will change if the orientation of the adsorbate is different with respect to the coordinate system in which the mode and, therefore, the strains are defined. Therefore, in order to univocally form said fingerprint for the adsorbate, the real orientation must be resolved. This can be done if the mentioned print is defined in a fixed reference system for the adsorbate (for example, a reference system such as the one shown in
γ′.sub.x=γ.sub.x cos.sup.4θ+γ.sub.y sin.sup.4θ+(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.2θ sin.sup.2θ−γ.sub.xxxy cos.sup.3θ sin θ−γ.sub.yyxy sin.sup.3θ cos θ
γ′.sub.y=γ.sub.y cos.sup.4θ+γ.sub.x sin.sup.4θ+(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.2θ sin.sup.2θ+γ.sub.xxxy cos.sup.3θ sin θ+γ.sub.yyxy sin.sup.3θ cos θ
γ′.sub.xy=(γ.sub.xy+γ.sub.xxyy)cos.sup.22θ+(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y)sin.sup.22θ−γ.sub.xxyy+(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos.sup.22θ sin.sup.22θ
γ′.sub.xxyy=1/2(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)sin.sup.22θ+γ.sub.xxyy+1/2(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos.sup.22θ sin.sup.22θ
γ′.sub.xxxy=(γ.sub.x−γ.sub.y+(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)cos 2θ)sin 2θ1/2((γ.sub.xxxy+γ.sub.yyxy)cos 2θ+(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos 4θ)
γ′.sub.yyxy=(γ.sub.x−γ.sub.y−(γ.sub.x+γ.sub.y−γ.sub.xy−γ.sub.xxyy)cos 2θ)sin 2θ1/2((γ.sub.xxxy+γ.sub.yyxy)cos 2θ−(γ.sub.xxxy−γ.sub.yyxy)cos 4θ), (Eq. 7)
wherein θ is the angle between the two coordinate systems (see
[0040] The present invention further allows the adsorption position, the mass, and the various stiffness coefficients of the adsorbate to be calculated from the relative changes in frequency of several vibration modes by means of numerical calculation. Nevertheless, the extraction of all the useful information about the changes in relative frequency of several vibration modes of a plate is not a task free of complex issues a priori, due to the large number of parameters involved in the problem. One problem with general optimization with a large amount of variables may involve, in any case, a high computational cost. However, there are some peculiarities that can be used in different preferred embodiments of the invention to simplify said optimization. It is important to note that the change in relative frequency presents a linear dependence on all the parameters of the problem, except the position coordinates (x.sub.0, y.sub.0). This means that the position must be calculated with precision to avoid large uncertainties in the rest of the parameters. For the type of adsorbates typically of interest, the effect of mass is generally much greater than the effect of stiffness; therefore, a first good estimation of the adsorption position can be performed, disregarding the effect of stiffness. This greatly simplifies the optimization problem. Once this estimation has been performed, the stiffness parameters can subsequently be included as a small perturbation of the initial problem. The optimization problem is thereby transformed into smaller and simpler subproblems which can be solved sequentially. For this purpose, it is possible to define two vectors which will be used during the process:
wherein d.sub.n.sup.2=û.sub.n(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+{circumflex over (v)}.sub.n(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2+ŵ.sub.n(x.sub.0, y.sub.0).sup.2 is the square of the total displacement. Φ.sub.n, in turn, is a vector containing all the information about the n-th vibration mode and Δ is the vector containing the unknowns being sought and is completely independent of the vibration mode and the adsorption position.
[0041] For an example in which N modes in total are being measured and given that stiffness causes positive changes in frequency and mass causes negative changes in frequency, a good option for ensuring a precise estimation is to choose only those modes which experience a negative change in frequency. Where M is the set of said modes with a negative change in frequency, for calculating the adsorption position, the following function is minimized:
wherein δf.sub.m is the displacement of the relative frequency of the experimentally measured m-th mode. Values (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) ∈ Ω minimizing function F.sub.0(x, y) are the first estimation of the adsorption position. It must be noted that the minimum number of modes necessary for this first estimation is three, and at least one must have a considerable variation along the x coordinate and another along the y coordinate in order to correctly solve (x.sub.0, y.sub.0). The second step is to include the stiffness terms corresponding to strains x, y and xy. The other three terms (xxyy, xxxy, yyxy) are generally much smaller than these three and can be disregarded in this step. Next, the minimum around the previous calculated position (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) is sought. The new function that must be minimized is:
[0042] The new values of position (x.sub.0, y.sub.0) and the first calculation of Δ.sup.i for i=2, 3, 4 are obtained from the minimization of Equation 11. In the next step, the rest of the stiffness terms can be included by simply increasing the sums in Equation 11, from i=1 to i=5, 6 and 7. It is important to mention that the entire method for obtaining all the components of Δ can be divided into sequential steps. For example, after the first estimation of the position, it is possible to use the modes in which, in that position, the main component of strain is component x. In that case, it is necessary to include only these vibration modes in Equation 11 and only terms Δ.sup.l and Δ.sup.2. After this step, it is possible to include component y of stiffness, component xy and so on and so forth, always ensuring that the minimum value found for the function F.sub.1 is lower than it is in the preceding step. The mass can be calculated using the mode having the greatest negative change in frequency. With q being said mode, the mass can be calculated as follows:
[0043] A further application of the technique of the present invention in a preferred embodiment thereof is being able to identify particles with very high precision. When there is a set of objects, the distinguishing capacity of a given method grows together with the number of properties that the method can measure based on the elements of the set. The mass and all the different terms of stiffness make this technique a highly powerful tool for this task. For each particle of the set, there is defined a database with the values of M.sub.a, γ.sub.x, γ.sub.y, γ.sub.xy, γ.sub.xxyy, γ.sub.xxxy and γ.sub.yyxy which will be necessary for being able to make a comparison between particles. However, the amounts experimentally obtained for making said comparison are M.sub.a, γ.sub.x′, γ.sub.xy′, γ.sub.xxyy′, γ.sub.xxxy′ and γ.sub.yyxy′. To make the comparison, Equations 6 is used with the values of the database, and the following function is formed:
wherein superscript D refers to the values of the database. Equation 13 has been weighted, giving more importance to those components having a higher value at the point of adsorption, in order to improve the success of the identification. Nevertheless, in other embodiments of the invention, other similarity estimators can likewise be used for the identification of the particles. The minimization of Equation 13 (or of the chosen similarity estimator, in each case) allows the angle of orientation for each particle of the set to be calculated, with the particle giving the minimum value of said equation being most likely the right particle.
[0044] As a non-limiting example of a preferred embodiment of the invention, the process of identifying four particles with the same mass, the same Young's modulus, the same volume but a different shape, using out-of-plane vibrations of a cantilever type square plate is illustrated next. In said example, finite element simulations of a plate with said shape and the adsorption of four particles with different shapes, that is, a disc, a square, a cube, and a bar with three different orientations (see
[0045] For this type of vibration modes, the only relevant displacement is ŵ(x.sub.0, y.sub.0) and the strains in the adsorption position are proportional to the curvatures of the plate:
wherein h is the thickness of the plate. For all the proposed particles, coefficients γ.sub.xxxy and γ.sub.yyxy are zero and will therefore have only four stiffness parameters. For greater convenience, parameters γ are defined such that the change in relative frequency due to stiffness, when the orientation is zero, is defined by the expression:
wherein
and ∧.sub.n is a numaer dependent on the mode coming from integration into Equation 5. Prior to the test simulations, the four stiffness coefficients Kγ.sub.x, Kγ.sub.y, Kγ.sub.xy and Kγ.sub.xxyy have been calculated by means of finite element simulations (FEM) for the four particles in order to complete the database represented in Table 1 below:
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Parameters of the database obtained by FEM for the four particles used for the identification test. Particle M.sub.α/2M.sub.c(ppm) Kγ.sub.x(ppm) Kγ.sub.y(ppm) Kγ.sub.xy(ppm) Kγ.sub.xxyy(ppm) Disc 10.7342 2.6144 2.6144 4.4922 0.7367 Square 10.7342 2.6509 2.6509 4.3671 0.7182 Cube 10.7342 0.6339 0.6339 1.5262 0.0778 Bar 10.7342 3.0169 0.5112 2.0858 0.1317
[0046] The identification test therefore consists of calculating the change in relative frequency of the twelve vibration modes due to the adsorption of each of the particles by means of finite element simulations. The obtained values are used for calculating all the parameters by applying the inverse problem. Then, by using the database shown in Table 1, the identification algorithm described above is applied in order to identify the corresponding particle. This method is applied for the six different particle configurations and by varying the adsorption position on the entire surface of the plate.
[0047] The identification success by applying the method of the invention is represented in
[0048] In conclusion, the present invention proposes a novel technique for the identification and classification of particles with extremely high precision based on the changes in relative frequency experienced by the vibrations of plates when these particles are adsorbed on their surface. Due to the special features that these resonant structures have, it is possible to distinguish particles with the same mass and Young's modulus, but with a different shape, which is not possible with the methods known in this field. The invention therefore constitutes an important breakthrough for the field of nanomechanical spectrometry, which can have relevant applications such as the identification and classification of viruses, bacteria, or particulate matter, considerably improving the distinguishing capacity of methods in the state of the art.