High throw-count RF switch
11190183 · 2021-11-30
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
H03K17/693
ELECTRICITY
H03K2017/066
ELECTRICITY
H04B1/0458
ELECTRICITY
H03K17/62
ELECTRICITY
H03K17/76
ELECTRICITY
International classification
H03K17/62
ELECTRICITY
H03K17/693
ELECTRICITY
H04B1/48
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
A high throw-count multiple-pole FET-based RF switch architecture that provides good RF performance in terms of insertion loss, return loss, isolation, linearity, and power handling. A common port RFC is coupled along a common path to multiple ports RFn. Embodiments introduce additional common RF path branch isolation switches which are controlled by state dependent logic. The branch isolation switches help to isolate the unused branch ports RFn and the unused portion of the common path from the active portion of the common path, and thereby reduce the reactive load attributable to such branches that degrades RF performance of the ports RFn “closer” to the common port RFC. The branch isolation switches can also be used to reconfigure the switch architecture for a multiplex function as well as separate switch path banks for re-configurability of purpose, tuning, or varying switch throw counts and packaging options.
Claims
1. An RF switch including: (a) a plurality of ports each coupled to a common path through a series-shunt switching element; and (b) at least one series isolation switch each connected along the common path between a corresponding two sets of ports and configured to selectively connect or isolate the corresponding two sets of ports and configured to enable a first selected port to be coupled to a second selected port through the common path, with any series isolation switches between the first and second selected ports set to a conducting state and all other series isolation switches set to a blocking state.
2. The RF switch of claim 1, wherein the RF switch allows connection of any one port to any other port.
3. The RF switch of claim 1, wherein at least one port is a common port and at least one other port is a signal port.
4. The RF switch of claim 1, wherein at least one series isolation switch includes a series-shunt switch.
5. The RF switch of claim 1, wherein at least one series-shunt switching element is a high-isolation series-shunt switching element.
6. An RF switch including: (a) a plurality of ports each coupled to a common path through a series-shunt switching element; (b) a common port coupled to the common path; and (c) at least one series isolation switch each connected along the common path between a corresponding two sets of ports and configured to selectively connect or isolate the corresponding two sets of ports and configured to enable a selected port of a first set of ports to be coupled to the common port through the common path, with any isolation switches between the selected port and the common port set to a conducting state and all other isolation switches set to a blocking state.
7. The RF switch of claim 6, wherein the common port is unconnected and the RF switch is reconfigurable to operate as a matrix switch allowing connection of any one port to any other port.
8. The RF switch of claim 6, wherein at least one series isolation switch includes a series-shunt switch.
9. The RF switch of claim 6, wherein at least one series-shunt switching element is a high-isolation series-shunt switching element.
10. The RF switch of claim 6, further including a termination circuit operatively coupled to the common port.
11. An RF switch including: (a) at least one common path; (b) at least one common port coupled to the at least one common path; (c) at least three sections each containing at least one signal port coupled to at least one common path through a series-shunt switching element; and (d) at least two isolation switches each connected to at least one common path between two corresponding adjacent sections, each isolation switch including at least one series switch configured to selectively connect or isolate the two corresponding adjacent sections; wherein when a selected signal port is coupled to at least one common port through at least one common path, any isolation switches between the selected signal port and the at least one common port are configured in a conducting state.
12. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein when the selected signal port is coupled to at least one common port through at least one common path, any isolation switches between the selected signal port and the at least one common port are configured in a conducting state and all other isolation switches are configured in a blocking state.
13. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein at least one common port of the at least one common port is coupled between the ends of two of the common paths to define at least two groups of sections.
14. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein at least one isolation switch series switch has a first terminal and a second terminal each connected to corresponding adjacent sections, and further including a shunt switch coupled between the first terminal and circuit ground.
15. The RF switch of claim 14, wherein at least one isolation switch series switch has a first terminal and a second terminal each connected to corresponding adjacent sections, and further including a shunt switch coupled between the second terminal and circuit ground.
16. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein the at least one series switch comprises one or more series-connected FETs.
17. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein at least one series-shunt switching element comprises (1) a series FET coupled between a corresponding signal port and one of the at least one common path, and (2) a shunt FET coupled between such corresponding signal port and circuit ground.
18. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein each common port is unconnected and the RF switch is configured to operate as a matrix switch allowing connection of a selected signal port to any of a selected group of other signal ports.
19. The RF switch of claim 11, wherein at least one series-shunt switching element is a high-isolation series-shunt switching element.
20. The RF switch of claim 11, further including a termination circuit operatively coupled to the common port.
Description
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10) Like reference numbers and designations in the various drawings indicate like elements.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(11) The present invention encompasses a high throw-count multiple-pole FET-based RF switch architecture that provides good RF performance in terms of insertion loss, return loss, isolation, linearity, and power handling. In general, embodiments of the invention introduce additional common RF path branch isolation switches which are controlled by state dependent logic. The common RF path branch isolation switches can also be used to reconfigure the switch architecture for a multiplex function as well as separate switch path banks for re-configurability.
(12) Design Challenges
(13)
(14) In a practical integrated circuit (IC) layout, parasitic inductances and capacitances along the common path 102 do not allow for good return loss for all states/paths. Such inductances are shown as equivalent discrete inductors 108 in
(15) A design can be performance optimized for the “closest” ports to the common port RFC (e.g., RF1 and RF2), but the performance of other ports suffers. Similarly, if a design is performance optimized for the “farthest” ports from the common port RFC (e.g., RF11 and RF12), which experience the most intervening inductance, the performance of the closest ports suffers.
(16) Thus, for example,
(17) In one model of the switch 220 of
(18) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Insertion Loss Return Loss Isolation dB @ 6 GHz dB up to 6 GHz dB @ 6 GHz State dB @ 8 GHz dB up to 8 GHz dB @ 8 GHz 1 3* 3* 30 24* 1* 30 6 0.82 12 33 2.4* 5* 27.5 12 0.55 14.5 35 0.62 14.5 30
(19) Another design challenge has to do with IC packaging. Lower cost packaging—such as wire bonding in plastic enclosure packages—has cost advantages but has the challenge of inductive parasitics from wire bonds, which can limit bandwidth beyond some initial RF tuning advantages. A larger number of RF ports (for example, more than 6 ports) requires larger wire bond packages to accommodate additional package pins and maintain isolation. For a given die size, a larger package size requirement increases the length of the wire bonds.
(20) To overcome these design challenges, embodiments of the invention introduce additional common RF path switches controlled by state dependent logic, as described in the following sections. More particularly, instead of connecting all signal path branches through switches to the common path 102 leading to the common port RFC, embodiments of the invention extend the switch circuit bandwidth and other performance characteristics by creating switch bank groupings accessed through FET series branch isolation switches to reduce the reactive loading on the common path 102, and thus on the common port RFC. In doing so, the additional insertion loss of the added series branch isolation switches is balanced against the isolation required to accomplish improved bandwidth and other performance characteristics. Specifically, the ON resistance R.sub.ON of a switch (which results in RF loss) is a direct trade-off with the OFF capacitance C.sub.OFF of the switch (which creates RF isolation).
(21) Further, embodiments of the invention help reduce bond wire length by allowing a designer to split the common path 102 into two or more directions using series branch isolation switches. The series branch isolation switches are designed to be robust under high RF voltage conditions since in an OFF state (for isolation), a FET switch would experience a large applied voltage. Accordingly, appropriately designing, sizing, and stacking FET devices is required for the series branch isolation switch.
First Embodiment
(22)
(23) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Section Active Port BI Switch State A RF1-RF4 SW1 = OFF SW2 = OFF B RF5-RF8 SW1 = ON SW2 = OFF C RF9-RF12 SW1 = ON SW2 = ON
(24) Accordingly, the BI switches 302 are normally OFF (blocking), and only turned ON (conducting) when associated “far side” ports RFn are to be coupled to the common port RFC. The OFF state of each BI switch 302 helps to isolate the inactive branch ports RFn and the unused portion of the common path 102 from the active, in-use portion of the common path 102. Thus, the BI switches 302 are used to effectively disconnect (i.e., isolate) inactive branches and thereby reduce the reactive load attributable to such branches that would otherwise degrade the RF performance of the ports RFn “closer” to the common port RFC.
(25) Each BI switch 302 may be implemented as an independently switchable FET. Alternatively, each BI switch 302 may instead comprise a stack of serially-connected FETs sufficient to handle any incident voltage and concurrently operated to behave as a single single-pole, single-throw (SPST) switch. (See also the description below regarding respect to
(26) In the example as illustrated, 12 ports RFn are shown. However, more or fewer than ports may be included, depending on the needs of a particular application. The example also shows two BI switches 302 (SW1 and SW2), but more or fewer (but at least one) may be used. One point of note is that adding more BI switches 302 increases the insertion loss of “far side” ports RFn, so it is useful to balance the number of BI switches 302 against the increased performance they provide.
(27) TABLE 3 shows the insertion loss, return loss, and isolation figures for a model of the BI switch-based circuit shown in
(28) TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Insertion Loss Return Loss Isolation dB @ 6 GHz dB up to 6 GHz dB @ 6 GHz State dB @ 8 GHz dB up to 8 GHz dB @ 8 GHz 1 SW1 = OFF 0.50 22 35 SW2 = OFF 0.51 22 29 6 SW1 = ON 0.60 20 36 SW2 = OFF 0.85 14 31 12 SW1 = ON 0.70 14.6 35 SW2 = ON 0.80 14.6 31
(29) In some modes of operation, multiple signal ports RFn may be activated so as to operatively connect to the common port RFC; if so, the BI switches 302 corresponding to such signal ports RFn would be set to ON.
(30) In an alternative operational mode, the RF switch 300 shown in
(31) Moreover, by selectively activating the BI switches 302, multiple banks of matrix switches can be enabled for concurrent operation. For example, with SW1 in an OFF state and SW2 in an ON state, a connection can be made between RF1 and RF2 concurrently with a connection between RF5 and RF11 (i.e., bank 1 comprises RF1-RF4, while bank 2 comprises RF5-RF12). As another example, with both SW1 and SW2 in an OFF state, concurrent connections can be made between RF1 and RF3, RF6 and RF8, and RF10 and RF11, since each of such pairs are located in distinct banks of ports separated by the BI switches 302 (i.e., bank 1 comprises RF1-RF4, bank 2 comprises RF5-RF8, and bank 3 comprises RF9-RF12).
Second Embodiment
(32)
(33) The illustrated configuration may be useful for certain package sizes (e.g., a 4×4 pad or pin package) and/or an application requirement calling for short IC bond wires to the RFn ports. The main BI switches 402 may help to bridge such distances and reduce IL for each signal path. Note that some optimization of FET switch widths for the series FETs of each port RFn may be necessary as well to compensate for the added C.sub.OFF of the BI switches 404. There also may be a benefit to optimize the inductances between the various switches and the branches. The FET sizes may also be varied or tapered for optimization with respect to the added C.sub.OFF of the BI switches 404.
(34) In an alternative configuration, additional cross-connection switches 406 (SW5, SW6 are shown) may be added to facilitate use of the RF switch 400 in a switch matrix operational mode, as described above with respect to
(35) As in
(36) In some applications, it may be useful to fully isolate the common port RFC in order to allow an “all-OFF” state to provide high-isolation with respect to external circuitry. Accordingly, it may be useful to operatively couple a termination circuit 410 to the common port RFC. The termination circuit 410 may, for example, comprise a termination switch SW1 and a resistor R. Alternatively, an absorptive switch module of the type described below with respect to
Third Embodiment
(37)
(38) In the illustrated example, the common port RFC is positioned between the ends of the common path 102. The signal ports RFn (16 are shown by way of example) are coupled to the common path 102 so as to form multiple sub-groups (two are shown, G1, G2) of signal ports in a “butterfly” configuration (i.e., multiple banks Gn of signal ports arrayed around a centrally positioned common port RFC; thus, the concept is scalable). The common port RFC can be coupled to any of the ports RFn by activating appropriate ones of the intervening branch isolation switches SW1-SW4, similar to the operation of the architecture shown in
(39) The architecture shown in
(40) Series-Shunt Switching Element Options
(41) The high throw-count RF switch embodiments described above have simple series-shunt switching elements 103. However, in some applications requiring greater isolation, additional circuitry may be needed. For example,
(42) In operation, when series switch 602 is ON (conducting), shunt switch 604 is OFF, high-isolation switch 606 is ON, and termination switch 608 is OFF, thus coupling port RFn to the common port RFC through the inductor L. Conversely, when series switch 602 is OFF (blocking), shunt switch 604 is ON, high-isolation switch 606 is OFF, and termination switch 608 is ON, thus coupling port RFn to circuit ground through the termination resistor R.
(43) The embodiment shown in
(44) For example,
(45) In operation, when series switch 602 is ON (conducting), shunt switch 604 is OFF and high-isolation switch 606 is ON, thus coupling port RFn to the common port RFC through the inductor L. In this mode of operation, the parallel combination of the high-isolation switch 606 resistance R.sub.on and the termination resistor R behaves as two resistors in parallel: R.sub.on∥R. For RF applications, since insertion loss is critical, R.sub.on is set to be much less than the system characteristic impedance (generally 50 ohms for RF systems).
(46) Conversely, when series switch 602 is OFF (blocking), shunt switch 604 is ON and high-isolation switch 606 is OFF. In this mode of operation, the high-isolation switch 606 has the characteristics of a capacitor (with value C.sub.off) rather than a resistor (with value R.sub.on). Thus, the parallel combination of the switch capacitance C.sub.off and the termination resistor R behaves as a parallel RC circuit: C.sub.off∥R. The termination resistor R will absorb much of any signal present on the port RFn. In addition, the shunt switch 604 is partially repurposed to shunt any remaining RF signal present on the port RFn to circuit ground.
(47) There are at least four benefits to using an absorptive switch module architecture as described above compared to traditional circuit configurations: First, the termination switch 608 of
(48) Branch Isolation Switch Options
(49) The independently switchable branch isolation switches in the various embodiments of this description may be implemented in a variety of ways. As noted above, each branch isolation switch may be implemented as a FET, or as a stack of serially-connected FETs sufficient to handle any incident voltage and concurrently operated to behave as a single single-pole, single-throw (SPST) switch.
(50) As one example,
(51) An alternative to including a dedicated first shunt switch 704 for each BI switch 700 would be to use one or more of the series-shunt switching elements 103 (referring to
(52) In another variant embodiment, a second shunt switch 706 may be connected at node B to provide isolation on the other side of the series switch 702. Such a configuration may be useful, for example, in a switch matrix embodiment of the invention, allowing isolation of components coupled to the BI switch 700 on the side of node B.
(53) Methods
(54) Another aspect of the invention includes a method for switching between multiple RF signal ports, including: (a) providing a common port; (b) coupling at least two branches to the common port, each branch including at least one signal port; (c) coupling at least one branch isolation switch between the common port and a corresponding one of the at least two branches; (d) coupling a selected signal port to the common port; (e) setting any branch isolation switches between the selected signal port and the common port to a conducting state; and (f) setting all other branch isolation switches to a blocking state.
(55) Yet another aspect of the invention includes a method for switching between multiple RF signal ports, including: (a) providing at least one common path; (b) coupling a common port to the at least one common path; (c) coupling at least two branches each including at least one signal port to one of the common paths through a series-shunt switching element; (d) coupling at least one branch isolation switch to one of the common paths between the common port and a corresponding one of the at least two branches; (e) coupling a selected signal port to the common port; (f) setting any branch isolation switches between the selected signal port and the common port to a conducting state; and (g) setting all other branch isolation switches to a blocking state.
(56) Still another aspect of the invention includes a method for switching between multiple RF signal ports, including: (a) providing a common path; (b) coupling a common port to the common path; (c) coupling a plurality of sections each containing at least one signal port to the common path through a series-shunt switching element; (d) coupling at least one isolation switch to the common path between two adjacent sections; (e) coupling a selected signal port to the common port; (f) setting any branch isolation switches between the selected signal port and the common port to a conducting state; and (g) setting all other branch isolation switches to a blocking state.
(57) Another aspect of the invention includes a method for switching between multiple RF signal ports, including: (a) providing a common port; (b) coupling a plurality of sub-divisions to the common port through corresponding sub-division isolation switches, each sub-division containing: (1) a common path coupled at one end to a corresponding sub-division isolation switch; (2) a plurality of sections each containing at least one signal port coupled to such common path through a series-shunt switching element; and (3) at least one section isolation switch connected to the common path between two adjacent sections; (c) coupling a selected signal port to the common port; (d) setting the sub-division isolation switch for the sub-division containing such selected signal port and any section isolation switches between the selected signal port and the common port to a conducting state; and setting all other sub-division isolation switches and section isolation switches to a blocking state.
(58) Other aspects of the above methods may include one or more configurations in which (a) the common port is coupled between the ends of the at least one common path; (b) each branch isolation switch is a FET; each branch isolation switch comprises a stack of FETs; (c) each series-shunt switching element comprises (1) a series FET coupled between a corresponding signal port and an associated common path, and (2) a shunt FET coupled between such corresponding signal port and circuit ground; (d) the common port is disconnected and the RF switch is operated as a matrix switch allowing connection of a selected signal port to any of a selected group of other signal ports; (e) a cross-connection switch pair is coupled to each other and to the common paths of two of the plurality of sub-divisions at an end of such common paths opposite to the end coupled to a corresponding sub-division isolation switch; and/or (g) a common connection port is coupled between at least one cross-connection switch pair.
(59) Benefits and Uses
(60) Embodiments of the invention provide good RF performance at high frequencies with switch throw-counts of more than 8 (“8T”) while exceeding the RF performance of conventional switch circuits with throw-counts of 8 or less at the same or lower frequencies. For example, a conventional 8T or 12T FET-based switch has generally been limited to about a 3 GHz broadband response with acceptable loss parameters, whereas embodiments of the invention in 12T and 16T configurations have much higher operational bandwidths (in excess of 6 GHz) with roughly equivalent or better loss parameters. In addition, for smaller throw counts such as 4T or even 6T, an improvement in the ON resistance R.sub.ON of the FET technology often helps further increase the operational bandwidth (i.e., narrower width FET with lower ON resistance results in lower OFF capacitance C.sub.OFF, which extends the bandwidth).
(61) High throw-count multiple-pole FET-based RF switches in accordance with the present invention are useful in a wide variety of circuits for performing a range of functions, including (but not limited to) impedance matching circuits, power amplifiers (e.g., scalable periphery tunable matching power amplifiers, and Doherty amplifiers), tuning circuits, RF switches, etc. Such functions are particularly useful in such applications as filters banks in test equipment, radar systems (including phased array and automotive radar systems), and radio systems. Radio system usage includes (again, without limitation) cellular radio systems (including base stations, relay stations, and hand-held transceivers) that use technologies such as orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (“ODFM”) and variants thereof, high quadrature amplitude modulation (“QAM”), Code Division Multiple Access (“CDMA”), Wide Band Code Division Multiple Access (“W-CDMA”), Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access (“WIMAX”), Global System for Mobile Communications (“GSM”), Enhanced Data Rates for GSM Evolution (EDGE), Long Term Evolution (“LTE”), as well as other radio communication standards and protocols.
(62) Fabrication Technologies and Options
(63) The term “MOSFET” technically refers to metal-oxide-semiconductors; another synonym for MOSFET is “MISFET”, for metal-insulator-semiconductor FET. However, “MOSFET” has become a common label for most types of insulated-gate FETs (“IGFETs”). Despite that, it is well known that the term “metal” in the names MOSFET and MISFET is now often a misnomer because the previously metal gate material is now often a layer of polysilicon (polycrystalline silicon). Similarly, the “oxide” in the name MOSFET can be a misnomer, as different dielectric materials are used with the aim of obtaining strong channels with smaller applied voltages. Accordingly, the term “MOSFET” as used herein is not to be read as literally limited to metal-oxide-semiconductors, but instead includes IGFETs in general.
(64) While the embodiments of the invention described above have used FET switches, the circuit architectures may be implemented with other transistor switch technologies, including the various types of bipolar junction transistors (BJTs). In addition, other switch technologies may be used, including PIN diodes and microelectromechanical system (MEMS) switches.
(65) As should be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art, various embodiments of the invention can be implemented to meet a wide variety of specifications. Unless otherwise noted above, selection of suitable component values is a matter of design choice and various embodiments of the invention may be implemented in any suitable IC technology (including but not limited to MOSFET and IGFET structures, as well as BJT-based and MEMS-based switches), or in hybrid or discrete circuit forms. Integrated circuit embodiments may be fabricated using any suitable substrates and processes, including but not limited to standard bulk silicon, silicon-on-insulator (SOI), silicon-on-sapphire (SOS), GaAs pHEMT, MESFET, and BJT technologies. However, the inventive concepts described above are particularly useful with an SOI-based fabrication process (including SOS), and with fabrication processes having similar characteristics. Fabrication in CMOS on SOI or SOS enables low power consumption, the ability to withstand high power signals during operation due to FET stacking, good linearity, and high frequency operation (in excess of about 2 GHz, and particularly above about 5 GHz). Monolithic IC implementation is particularly useful since parasitic capacitances generally can be kept low by careful design.
(66) It may be particularly useful to package integrated circuit embodiments of the invention using well-known “flip chip” (also known as “controlled collapse chip connection”) processes, which allows for better physical separation between each of the signal ports RFn and the common port RFC. Such separation results in less mutual interaction (e.g., parasitic capacitances, inductive coupling) when connection such ports to external circuitry. Flip chip packaging is a method for interconnecting semiconductor devices, such as IC chips and microelectromechanical systems (MEMS), to external circuitry with solder bumps that have been deposited onto the chip (IC die) pads. The solder bumps are deposited on the chip pads on the top side of an IC wafer during the final wafer processing step. In order to mount the chip to external circuitry (e.g., a circuit board or another chip or wafer), it is flipped over so that its top side faces down, its pads are aligned with matching pads on the external circuit, and deposited solder is reflowed to complete the interconnect.
(67) Voltage levels may be adjusted or voltage and/or logic signal polarities reversed depending on a particular specification and/or implementing technology (e.g., NMOS, PMOS, or CMOS, and enhancement mode or depletion mode transistor devices). Component voltage, current, and power handling capabilities may be adapted as needed, for example, by adjusting device sizes, serially “stacking” components (particularly FETs) to withstand greater voltages, and/or using multiple components in parallel to handle greater currents. Additional circuit components may be added to enhance the capabilities of the disclosed circuits and/or to provide additional functional without significantly altering the functionality of the disclosed circuits.
(68) A number of embodiments of the invention have been described. It is to be understood that various modifications may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. For example, some of the steps described above may be order independent, and thus can be performed in an order different from that described. Further, some of the steps described above may be optional. Various activities described with respect to the methods identified above can be executed in repetitive, serial, or parallel fashion. It is to be understood that the foregoing description is intended to illustrate and not to limit the scope of the invention, which is defined by the scope of the following claims, and that other embodiments are within the scope of the claims.