DEVICE AND METHOD FOR CHEMICAL LOOPING COMBUSTION, HAVING A PARTICLE SEPARATOR PROVIDED WITH AN INCLINED INTAKE DUCT
20210356120 · 2021-11-18
Inventors
- Airy TILLAND (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Benjamin AMBLARD (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Sina TEBIANIAN (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Ann CLOUPET (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Florent GUILLOU (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Stephane BERTHOLIN (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Mahdi YAZDANPANAH (Le Havre, FR)
Cpc classification
F23J15/022
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C10/10
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C10/24
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C9/003
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C10/005
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C99/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23J2217/60
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C2900/99008
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C2900/10001
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C2206/10
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Y02E20/34
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
F23C10/10
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F23C9/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Abstract
The present invention relates to a device and a method for chemical looping combustion, for which the end of the intake duct (4) opening out within the chamber of the separator (1) is inclined with respect to a horizontal plane (H).
Claims
1. A device for chemical looping combustion using a solid fuel which generates unburnt particles and employs oxygen carrier particles, such as metal oxides, and which comprises at least a combustion zone, a separator for particles contained in a gas mixture from the combustion zone, and a gas-solid separator, the particle separator comprising a chamber equipped with at least one intake duct connected to the combustion zone, at least one discharge duct situated in the lower part of the chamber, and at least one outlet duct situated in the upper part of the chamber and connected to the gas-solid separator, the chamber comprising a dense phase in the lower part and a dilute phase in the upper part, characterized in that the intake duct comprises an intake end which is inclined by an angle α with respect to a horizontal plane (H), the intake end opening out within the chamber.
2. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the angle α is between 10 and 70°, preferably between 30 and 50°.
3. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the intake duct comprises successively, in the intake direction, a vertical portion, an elbow, and the inclined intake end.
4. The combustion device as claimed in claim 3, wherein the vertical portion of the intake duct is at a distance D from the center of the chamber, D being strictly positive and less than 4 A, preferably less than 2 A and more preferably less than 1.5 A, where A is a dimension between the center of the chamber and a sidewall of the chamber.
5. The combustion device as claimed in claim 3, wherein the diameter C of the inclined intake end is between 0.5 and 4 L, preferably between 1 L and 3 L, more preferably between 1 L and 2 L, where L is the diameter of the vertical portion of the intake duct.
6. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the intake duct is entirely external to the chamber, the intake end opening out on a sidewall of the chamber.
7. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the intake duct is at least partly internal to the chamber, the intake duct passing through the lower wall of the chamber.
8. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the particle separator comprises between 1 and 20, preferably between 1 and 10 and more preferably between 1 and 4 intake ducts.
9. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the intake duct opens out in the chamber, in the upper part of the chamber comprising the dilute phase.
10. The combustion device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the inclination of the intake end of the intake duct is directed toward the longitudinal axis of the chamber.
11. A method for chemical looping combustion using a solid fuel generating unburnt particles, which employs oxygen carrier particles, such as metal oxides, and employs a device for chemical looping combustion as claimed in claim 1, wherein the following steps are carried out: a) a gaseous mixture from the combustion zone, comprising particles and combustion gases, is admitted to the chamber of the particle separator by means of at least one intake duct; b) the lightest particles, consisting predominantly of the unburnt particles, are extracted via an outlet in the upper part of the chamber, and the heaviest particles, consisting predominantly of the oxygen carrier particles, are discharged via the discharge duct in the lower part of the chamber; c) a gaseous stream comprising the light unburnt particles extracted via the outlet duct in the upper part of the chamber are sent to the gas-solid separator; d) a gas depleted in unburnt particles is discharged from the gas-solid separator via a duct; and e) the unburnt particles separated in the gas-solid separator are recycled to the combustion zone via a communication duct.
Description
BRIEF PRESENTATION OF THE FIGURES
[0032] Other features and advantages of the method and of the device according to the invention will become apparent upon reading the following description of nonlimiting exemplary embodiments with reference to the appended figures described below.
[0033]
[0034]
[0035]
[0036]
[0037]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0038]
[0039] Zone 2 represents the combustion zone of a chemical looping combustion (CLC) method; introduced into this zone are a solid feedstock via a duct 7, oxygen-carrying particles via a duct 8 from the oxidizing zone (not shown) of the CLC method, and a fluidizing gas supplied via a duct 12, such as, for example, steam or CO.sub.2, for promoting the fluidization of the oxide particles.
[0040] The solid feedstock (or fuel) treated in the combustion zone consists generally of a solid hydrocarbon source containing predominantly carbon and hydrogen. The feedstock is selected advantageously from coal, coke, petcoke, biomass, bituminous sands, and household waste.
[0041] This combustion zone 2 is able to operate in a fluidized bed in dense phase or in a circulating fluidized bed, or else according to an arrangement of beds consisting of a dense phase and a transport phase.
[0042] Advantageously, the velocity of the gas in the upper part of the combustion zone is between 1 and 10 m/s.
[0043] A flow of particles containing metal oxide particles, referred to as heavy particles, and light particles, comprising unburnt particles and possibly fly ash, all in a gaseous flow, is extracted from the combustion zone 2 and is subsequently introduced into a particle separator 1 via at least one intake duct 4.
[0044] The gaseous flow comes entirely or partly from the combustion zone 2 and is composed predominantly of CO, CO.sub.2, H.sub.2 and H.sub.2O, the balance possibly being from an external source containing, for example, recycled CO.sub.2 and/or steam, introduced via the pipe 11 in the lower part of the separator 1.
[0045] Preferably all of the gaseous combustion effluents are utilized for the separation of particles, and very preferably the total gas flow in the separator 1 may consist of at least 60% of the effluents from the combustion zone. Separation between the heavy particles and the light particles takes place in this particle separator 1, with the heavy particles depositing in the lower part of the particle separator, before being extracted from it via a discharge duct 5, and the light particles being carried to the upper part, before being extracted via an outlet duct 6, and then introduced into a gas-solid separator 3, for example a cyclone.
[0046] The purpose of this cyclone 3 is to separate the gas depleted in unburnt particles, which is subsequently extracted via a duct 10, and the unburnt particles, which are entrained with the metal oxide particles extracted via a duct 9 and recycled to the combustion zone 2.
[0047] The heavy particles extracted in the lower part of the particle separator 1 consist predominantly of metal oxides and may be sent to a second combustion zone, in which the oxygen carrier will be further reduced, or to an oxidizing zone, enabling the oxygen carrier to regain at least part of the oxidation state which it had at the entry to the combustion zone 2, and the lightest unburnt particles are recycled to the combustion zone, after separation from the gaseous effluent.
[0048] Therefore, as described in patent application FR 2 960 941 (WO 2011/151537), the intake and discharge/outlet parameters are selected so as to produce, in the chamber of the particle separator 1, a dense phase in the lower part of the chamber of the particle separator, and a dilute phase in the upper part of the chamber of the particle separator, and the intake duct 4 opens out preferably in the dilute phase.
[0049] The particles which settle in the lower part form a dense phase consisting of the heaviest particles, with a greater or lesser height in the separator depending on factors including the density of the particles, the feed rates and extraction rates; however, the level of said dense phase, forming the interface with the dilute phase, is preferably situated below the intake 4 opening out in the separator, to allow the introduction of the mixture of particles extracted from the combustion zone.
[0050] The present invention relates more particularly to the particle separator. According to the invention, the particle separator of the chemical looping combustion device comprises: [0051] a chamber, in which the particles are separated, the chamber comprising a dense phase in its lower part and a dilute phase in its upper part, with the particles being separated by elutriation, [0052] at least one intake duct, connected to said combustion zone, for transferring the flow from the combustion zone to the chamber of the particle separator, [0053] at least one discharge duct situated in the lower part of the chamber, for discharging the heavy particles, and [0054] at least one outlet duct situated in the upper part of the chamber, for discharging the light particles and the gas.
[0055] In the present description, a chamber comprising a dense phase in its lower part and a dilute phase in its upper part refers to a chamber suitable for comprising a dense phase in its lower part and a dilute phase in its upper part when the separator is not in operation. In operation, the chamber effectively comprises a dense phase in its lower part and a dilute phase in its upper part.
[0056] According to the invention, the intake duct comprises an intake end which is inclined (by an angle α) with respect to a horizontal plane. The intake end is the end of the intake duct that opens out into the chamber of the particle separator. The intake end is said to be inclined, since it is neither vertical nor horizontal. In other words, the angle α is between 1 and 89°. The inclination of the intake end allows the flow to be taken in according to a direction which comprises a lateral component (that is, a horizontal component). This inclination of the flow allows homogeneous distribution over the cross section of the chamber, thus enabling an improvement in the performance of the particle separator (improved separation and reduced cost).
[0057] According to one embodiment of the invention, the angle α may be between 10 and 70°, preferably between 30 and 50°. These angular ranges for inclination of the intake end permit optimized distribution, while avoiding excessively horizontal intake, which would carry a risk of entrainment of the flow toward the bottom, and preventing excessively vertical intake, which would carry the risk of intake in the form of a jet, similar to the effect in the prior art described in particular in patent application FR 2 960 941 (WO 2011/151537). Moreover, these angular ranges make it possible to limit the effects of erosion of the intake duct, which might exist if the angle α were too low.
[0058] The inclined intake end may preferably be directed toward the center of the chamber (or its longitudinal axis), to promote separation.
[0059] Moreover, the inclined intake end may be directed to the upper part of the chamber, to carry the particles to the upper part of the chamber.
[0060] In accordance with one implementation of the invention, the intake duct may comprise successively, in the intake direction, a vertical portion, an elbow and the inclined intake end. A design of this kind for the intake duct allows simple manufacture of the intake duct.
[0061] According to one preferred embodiment of the invention, the intake duct may be entirely external to the chamber. In this case, the intake end opens out on a sidewall of the chamber. Through this embodiment it is possible to limit the internals in the chamber, meaning that no element of the intake duct passes through a wall of the chamber. Furthermore, this embodiment makes it possible to do without specific internal elements: in particular, a conical element positioned above the intake duct, which is provided in certain solutions in the prior art (cf.
[0062] As a variant, the intake duct may be at least partly internal to the chamber. In this case, the intake duct passes through the lower wall of the chamber. For the embodiment in which the intake duct comprises a vertical portion, an elbow and the intake end, it may be the vertical portion which passes through the lower wall of the chamber. In this variant there is no need for the conical element breaking up the flows.
[0063] According to one aspect of the invention, the particle separator may comprise between 1 and 20, preferably between 1 and 10 and more preferably between 1 and 4 intake ducts.
[0064] The particle separator may advantageously comprise a plurality of intake ducts. This configuration promotes the homogeneity of the flows in the chamber.
[0065] When the particle separator comprises a plurality of intake ducts, the intake ducts may preferably be regularly spaced over the sidewall or walls of the chamber, or in the chamber, so as to optimize the homogeneity of the flows in the chamber.
[0066] The chamber may comprise an inlet of an external gas source allowing the fluidization of the dense zone.
[0067] Preferably, in order to separate the particles, the intake duct opens out in the upper part of the chamber, at a height corresponding to the dilute phase within the chamber.
[0068] According to one embodiment of the invention, the intake end may further comprise an inclination with an angle of E via a vertical plane.
[0069] The geometry of the separator may be parallelepipedal, cylindrical, or any other three-dimensional geometry.
[0070] Generally speaking, the material used for producing the chamber of the separator may be selected from high-temperature steels, as for example of the Hastelloy®, Incoloy®, Inconel® or Manaurite® type, or else ceramics.
[0071] In order to limit manufacturing costs, it is also possible to consider standard steels bearing applied layers of reinforced refractory cement (with thicknesses generally of between 2 and 50 cm, generally in the region of 20 cm) on the internal faces exposed to flow and to high temperatures, for the outer parts of the separator. Likewise possible is the use of refractory bricks.
[0072] Another configuration consists of walls comprising tubes in which a heat-transfer fluid circulates, as for example steam, and these tubes may also be produced with standard steels.
[0073] The metal oxide particles, such as, for example, oxides of Fe, Ti, Ni, Cu, Mn, Co and V, are used alone or as a mixture, and have an average size in general of more than 50 microns, preferably of between 100 and 500 microns.
[0074] The supported or unsupported, synthetic or mineral metal oxides generally have a density of more than 1200 kg/m.sup.3. For example, the nickel oxide particles supported on alumina (NiO/NiAl.sub.2O.sub.4) generally have a grain density of between 2500 and 3500 kg/m.sup.3, depending on the porosity of the support and on the nickel oxide content, and typically of approximately 3200 kg/m.sup.3.
[0075] Ilmenite, an ore combining titanium and iron, has a density of 4700 kg/m.sup.3.
[0076] The particle separator according to the present invention is used advantageously for separating the unburnt particles from metal oxide particles having a density of more than 1200 kg/m.sup.3, preferably more than 2500 kg/m.sup.3.
[0077] The oxygen transporter particles generally have a much greater size and density than those of the fly ash and of the unburnt particles having already been in contact with the oxygen-transporting particles in the combustion zone at high temperature. As an example, at the outlet from the combustion zone, it is considered that the size of the unburnt coal particles is less than 100 microns and that the majority of the particles have a size of less than 50 microns. The density of these particles is in general between 1000 and 1500 kg/m.sup.3.
[0078] Other particles, such as the fly ash, resulting from the combustion of the solid feedstock may also circulate with the remainder of the particles, and are characterized by a lower particle size and lower density than the oxygen carrier particles, and often also lower than the unburnt particles.
[0079]
[0080]
[0081]
[0082]
[0083]
[0084]
[0085] The parameters of these two figures are such as to define certain characteristic dimensions of the particle separator 1.
[0086] These two figures detail the characteristics of the feed or feeds of combustion fumes loaded with solid particles 17 which enter the particle separator 1 via the one or more intake ducts (to simplify the figures, only one intake duct 4 is shown). The figures also present the one or more outlets for gas loaded with solid fuel unburnts and ashes 13 from the particle separator 1 via the one or more outlet ducts 6. For this embodiment, the particle separator 1 is cylindrical and of diameter 2A. As a variant, the particle separator 1 may also have a rectangular cross section, or any similar form, and in that case A is the distance between the central/longitudinal axis of the chamber and a side wall of the chamber.
[0087] The number of intake ducts 4 and of outlet ducts 6 may be between 1 and 20, preferably between 1 and 10 and more preferably between 1 and 4. The ducts 4 and 6 have diameters labeled respectively as L and G. The superficial gas velocity in the ducts 4 and 6 is between 2 m/s and 30 m/s, preferably between 3 m/s and 25 m/s and more preferably between 4 m/s and 15 m/s.
[0088] In accordance with the operation illustrated in relation to
[0089] The suspension opens out in the particle separator 1 via the intake duct 4 into a dilute phase 16 composed essentially of gas (preferably at least 95% by volume), in which the superficial velocity may be controlled and represents from 30% to 300% of the mean terminal falling velocity of the oxygen-transporting particles. Precise adjustment of the superficial velocity in zone 1 allows control over the quantity of particles carried to the outlet duct 6. The flow of particles carried in the particle separator 1 to the outlet duct 6, relative to the cross section of the separator 1, may be less than 10 kg/s/m.sup.2, is typically between 0.02 and 5 kg/s/m.sup.2, and may contain at least half of the unburnt particles entering via the one or more intake ducts 4.
[0090] The particles which are not carried to the outlet duct or ducts (6′, 6″) settle in the dense phase 15 of the particle separator 1, and are collected in the lower part of the particle separator 1 and discharged via the discharge duct 5, forming a dense flow of particles 14, to another reaction zone, for additional combustion or for reoxidizing the oxygen-transporting particles. It is possible to form a fluidized dense phase 15 at the base of the particle separator 1. In this case, the dense phase 15 may be fluidized by provision of an external gas 11 in the particle separator 1. This gas passes through the particle separator and takes part in the physical process of separation of the particles by elutriation in the dilute phase 16, before exiting via the outlet duct 6. The distance between the top of the particle separator 1 and the top of the dense phase 15 is labeled N. According to one embodiment of the invention, N is between 2 A and 40 A, preferably between 2 A and 30 A and more preferably between 2 A and 20 A.
[0091] The intake ducts 4 are located at a distance D from the center of the particle separator. For example, the distance D may correspond to the distance between the axis of the vertical portion of the intake ducts 4 and the axis of the center of the particle separator. In accordance with one implementation of the invention, the distance D is strictly positive and may be between 0 and 4 A, preferably between 0 and 2 A and more preferably between 0 and 1.5 A.
[0092] The intake ducts 4 open out in the dilute part 16 of the chamber, by virtue of a window 18 with diameter C. According to one aspect of the invention, the diameter C is between 0.5 L and 4 L, preferably between 1 L and 3 L and more preferably between 1 L and 2 L, where L is the diameter of the vertical portion of the intake duct. The widening of the end of the intake duct 21 enables a lower gas velocity than in the intake duct 4. It is therefore possible to use a high velocity in the intake duct 4 (reduction in the head loss associated with acceleration of the particles) and to reduce the velocity at which gas is introduced into the separator 1, thereby making it possible to prevent gas jets, and improving distribution within the dilute phase 16.
[0093] The vertical part of the intake duct 4 is connected to the window of diameter C by virtue of an elbow with angle α in the plane (xz) and optionally of angle ε in the plane (xy). The angle α is between 1° and 89°, preferably between 10° and 70° and more preferably between 30° and 50°. The angle ε is between 0° and 360°.
[0094] In addition, the angle β defines the orientation in the plane (xy) of the intake duct 4 relative to the axis y. The angle β is between 0° and 360°.
[0095] The position of the bottom of the window 18 is set at a distance B from the dense zone 15 (limit of the dense zone 15 and the dilute zone 16). This distance B is between 0 and N-C, preferably between 0.1(N-C) and 0.9(N-C) and more preferably between 0.2(N-C) and 0.8(N-C). This design therefore makes it possible to prevent particles in the dense part from being carried by the gas, which arrives at a higher velocity.
[0096] In these figures, two types of outlet ducts 6 are identified, with the ducts 6′ sited on the upper wall of the particle separator 1, and the ducts 6″ sited on the sidewall of the particle separator 1. The ducts 6′ are sited at a distance F from the center of the particle separator 1. F may be between 0 and A.
[0097] In the plane (xy), γ defines the angle between the axis y and the position of the outlet duct 6′ sited at the upper wall of the separator 1. The angle γ may be between 0° and 360°.
[0098] The ducts 6″ are sited at a distance E from the upper wall of the particle separator 1. The distance E is between 0 and N.
[0099] In the plane (xy), δ defines the angle between the axis y and the position of the outlet duct 6′ sited on the side part of the separator 1. The angle δ is between 0° and 360°.
[0100] Part of the ducts 6′ and 6″ may penetrate into the dilute zone 16 of the particle separator 1. The length H′ of penetration of the ducts 6′ is between 0 and N, preferably between 0 and 0.5 N and more preferably between 0 and 0.2 N. The length H″ of penetration of the ducts 6″ is between 0 and A, preferably between 0 and 0.5 A and more preferably between 0 and 0.2 A.
[0101] According to one embodiment example, an internal may be fitted in the particle separator 1 in the dilute phase 16 before the outlet 13. This internal allows separation to be improved.
[0102] The chemical looping combustion method according to the invention employs the chemical looping combustion device according to any of the embodiments described above or any of the combinations of said embodiments. For this method, the following steps are carried out: [0103] a) a gas mixture from said combustion zone, comprising unburnt particles, oxygen carrier particles and combustion gases, is admitted to the chamber of the particle separator by means of at least one intake duct, the intake duct comprising at least one intake end which is inclined with respect to a horizontal plane; [0104] b) the lightest particles, consisting predominantly of the unburnt particles, are extracted via an outlet in the upper part of the chamber of the particle separator, and the heaviest particles, consisting predominantly of the oxygen carrier particles, are discharged via the discharge duct in the lower part of the chamber; [0105] c) a gaseous stream comprising the lightest particles extracted via the outlet duct in the upper part of the chamber are sent to the gas-solid separator; [0106] d) a gas depleted in unburnt particles is discharged from the gas-solid separator via a duct; and [0107] e) the unburnt particles separated in the gas-solid separator are recycled to the combustion zone via a communication duct.
Comparative Example
[0108] The features and advantages of the device and of the method according to the invention will become more clearly apparent from a reading of the comparative examples hereinafter.
[0109] Three particle separation devices were studied via CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) simulations, these three devices being illustrated in the top part of
[0113] The CFD simulations were carried out using the FLUENT software. Firstly, only the gas phase in the intake duct(s) 4 and the dilute part 16 is simulated. In a second stage, light particles (ashes or unburnt particles) and heavy particles (oxygen carrier) are injected in the simulation with a DPM (Discrete Particle Method) approach, in which only the gas interacts with the particles through a drag force. In this approach, the particles have no effect on the gas velocity field. This assumption is used because the gas/particle flow is considered to be diluted with a volume percentage of particles of less than 1 vol %. The particles are injected at the inlet of the intake duct(s) 4 and are able to exit either via the outlet duct 6′ or via the bottom of the dilute phase 16, via an outlet duct 6″ (not shown). The percentage of particles exiting via the outlet duct 6′ at the top of the separator 1 is defined by a formula of the following type:
[0114] Table 1 presents the simulated conditions and also the dimensions used (in reference to the dimensions illustrated in
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Characteristics of the particle separator 1st device 2nd device 3rd device (prior art) (prior art) (invention) Length A (m) 2 Length N (m) 10 Number of intake ducts 1 1 2 Diameter L (m) 1.5 1.5 1.06 Length B (m) 1 Length D (m) 0 0 2.5 Angle α (°) — — 45 Diameter C (m) — — 1.06 Angle β (°) — — Duct 1: 90° Duct 2: 270° Angle ε (°) — — 90° Cone diameter (m) — 1.06 Number of ducts (6′) 1 Length F (m) 0 Diameter G (m) 1.4 Length H′ (m) 0 Gas density (kg/m.sup.3) 0.33 Gas viscosity (kg/m/s) 4.6 10.sup.−5 Mass flow of gas injected 4 4 Duct 1: 2 into (4) (kg/s) Duct 2: 2 Mass flow of gas (11) (kg/s) 1.1 Mass flow of heavy particles 60 injected (kg/s) Density of heavy 3300 particles (kg/m.sup.3) Mean diameter of heavy 200 particles (μm) Mass flow of light particles 0.6 injected (kg/s) Density of light particles 1000 (kg/m.sup.3) Mean diameter of heavy 50 particles (μm)
[0115] The bottom part of
[0116] Table 2 presents the percentages of light and heavy particles exiting via the upper outlet duct from the particle separator 1.
TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 comparison First device Second device Third device (prior art) (prior art) (invention) η(light particles) 100% 100% 100% η(heavy particles) 20% 5% 1%
[0117] Table 2 shows that the invention enables better separation between the light and heavy particles, with only 1% of the heavy particles exiting via the top of the device.