METHOD FOR IDENTIFYING NECKING LIMIT STRAIN OF METAL SHEET
20230152195 · 2023-05-18
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01N2203/0282
PHYSICS
International classification
Abstract
A method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet includes a step of measuring the distribution of strain in a tensile orthogonal direction in a tensile deformation process of a notch root for two or more types of sheet specimens having a notch geometry in a portion of a sheet edge; a step of obtaining a strain increment ratio of the notch root in the tensile deformation process and a strain gradient in the tensile orthogonal direction; a step of obtaining necking limit strain at which necking occurs in the notch root based on the strain increment ratio in the tensile deformation process; and a step of identifying the necking limit strain as a function of the strain gradient from the relation between the necking limit strain obtained for the two or more types of sheet specimens and the strain gradient at that time.
Claims
1. A method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet, the method identifying a relation between a necking limit strain, at which necking occurs at a sheet edge of a metal sheet by imparting tensile deformation, and a strain gradient, and the method comprising: a strain distribution measurement step of measuring, for two or more types of sheet specimens having a notch geometry for which a portion of a sheet edge is notched inward and having a different strain gradient in a tensile orthogonal direction that is orthogonal to a tensile direction when tensile deformation is imparted to a notch root of the notch geometry, distribution of strain of the notch root in the tensile orthogonal direction in a tensile deformation process; a strain increment ratio/strain gradient acquisition step of obtaining, for each of the sheet specimens, a strain increment ratio of the notch root in the tensile deformation process and a strain gradient in the tensile orthogonal direction, from the distribution of the strain in the tensile orthogonal direction measured at the strain distribution measurement step; a necking limit strain acquisition step of obtaining, for each of the sheet specimens, a necking limit strain that is a strain at a time of occurrence of necking in the notch root based on the strain increment ratio in the tensile deformation process obtained at the strain increment ratio/strain gradient acquisition step; and a necking limit strain identification step of identifying the necking limit strain as a function of the strain gradient from a relation between the necking limit strain obtained for each of the sheet specimens and the strain gradient at a time of the necking limit strain out of the strain gradients in the tensile deformation process obtained at the strain increment ratio/strain gradient acquisition step.
2. The method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet according to claim 1, wherein the strain distribution measurement step imparts tensile deformation to the notch root by applying a tensile load in a uniaxial direction to the sheet specimen.
3. The method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet according to claim 1, wherein the strain distribution measurement step measures the distribution of the strain in the tensile orthogonal direction by an image correlation method.
4. The method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet according to claim 2, wherein the strain distribution measurement step measures the distribution of the strain in the tensile orthogonal direction by an image correlation method.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
[0014]
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
[0025] A method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet according to an embodiment of the present invention is a method that identifies the necking limit strain at which necking occurs at a notch root 5a of a sheet specimen 1 of the metal sheet by imparting tensile deformation as illustrated in
[0026] Strain Distribution Measurement Step
[0027] The strain distribution measurement step S1 is a step of measuring, on each of two or more types of sheet specimens 1 having a notch geometry 5 for which a portion of a sheet edge 3 is notched inward as illustrated in
[0028] At the strain distribution measurement step S1, two or more types of sheet specimens 1 having the notch geometry 5 in which a portion of the sheet edge 3 is notched inward in a semicircular shape and in which a notch radius R of the notch geometry 5 and/or the distance from the notch root 5a to the sheet edge 3 on the opposite side (ligament length L) is different so that the strain gradient of the notch root 5a illustrated in
[0029] The notch radius R and the ligament length L of the notch geometry 5 are factors that affect the strain gradient produced at the notch root 5a by imparting tensile deformation. By changing the notch radius R and/or the ligament length L, the strain gradient when tensile deformation is imparted to the notch root 5a can be made different. Specifically, as the notch radius R is smaller or the ligament length L is shorter, the strain gradient is larger.
[0030] The suitable dimensions of the notch geometry 5 formed in the sheet specimen 1 are a notch radius R of greater than or equal to 0 mm but less than or equal to 500 mm and a ligament length L of greater than or equal to 1 mm but less than or equal to 500 mm (below the maximum width of the sheet specimen 1). If the notch geometry 5 exceeds the upper limits of these dimensions, a huge tensile testing machine is needed to impart tensile deformation to the notch root 5a in order to cause necking, which is not practical and therefore undesirable. It is further preferable that the notch radius R be greater than or equal to 1 mm but less than or equal to 450 mm and the ligament length L be greater than or equal to 1 mm but less than or equal to 450 mm.
[0031] Then, in the present embodiment, for each of the two or more types of sheet specimens 1 in which the notch geometry 5 is formed so that the strain gradient is different as in the foregoing, the tensile deformation is imparted to the notch root 5a by a tensile testing machine that applies a tensile load in a uniaxial direction in the plane of the sheet specimen 1.
[0032] The strains to be obtained at the strain distribution measurement step S1 are a maximum principal strain ε.sub.1 which is the strain in the tensile direction (y-direction in
[0033] The distribution of the maximum principal strain ε.sub.1 and the minimum principal strain ε.sub.2 in the tensile orthogonal direction only needs to be measured at predetermined time steps during tensile deformation for the range including the notch root 5a by, for example, an image correlation (DIC) method. When measuring the strain distribution by the image correlation method, the sheet specimen 1 for which lines or dots are printed on the surface at predetermined intervals or the sheet specimen 1 for which fine irregularities are formed on the surface at predetermined intervals only needs to be used. In the image correlation method, a camera is placed to capture images of the surface of the sheet specimen 1 including the notch geometry 5, the deformation of the notch geometry 5 during the process of imparting tensile deformation to the notch root 5a is captured, and image analysis is performed, thereby obtaining the respective distributions of the maximum principal strain ε.sub.1 and the minimum principal strain ε.sub.2.
[0034] However, the strain distribution measurement step S1 is not limited to measuring the strain distribution by the image correlation method and may also measure the strain distribution in the tensile orthogonal direction from the notch root 5a in predetermined time steps by attaching a strain gauge to the surface of the sheet specimen 1 along the tensile orthogonal direction.
[0035] At the strain distribution measurement step S1, as the strain rate when press forming is performed in an actual press machine is in the range of 0.01/sec to 1/sec, it is preferable that the strain rate of tensile deformation that is imparted to the notch root 5a be set to be in the range of 0.01/sec to 1/sec.
[0036] Strain Increment Ratio/Strain Gradient Acquisition Step
[0037] The strain increment ratio/strain gradient acquisition step S3 is a step of obtaining, for each of the two or more types of sheet specimens 1, the strain increment ratio of the notch root 5a and the strain gradient in the tensile orthogonal direction during the tensile deformation process from the strain distribution measured at the strain distribution measurement step S1.
[0038] The strain increment ratio r.sub.edge was defined by the following Expression (1) by referring to the “plastic strain ratio” (ratio of logarithmic strain in width direction ε.sub.2 to logarithmic strain in thickness direction ε.sub.3) specified in JIS 2254 (2008) and others, and by using the constant volume condition [logarithmic strain in thickness direction ε.sub.3=−(strain in longitudinal direction ε.sub.1+logarithmic strain in width direction ε.sub.2)].
[0039] In Expression (1), dε.sub.1 and dε.sub.2 indicate the unit time increments of the maximum principal strain ε.sub.1 (logarithmic strain in the longitudinal direction (tensile direction) of the sheet specimen 1) and the minimum principal strain ε.sub.2 (logarithmic strain in the width direction (tensile orthogonal direction) of the sheet specimen 1), respectively, at the strain concentration portion (notch root 5a) in the notch geometry 5 of the sheet edge 3.
[0040] Meanwhile, the strain gradient dε/dx is defined as the slope in the tensile orthogonal direction of the maximum principal strain ε.sub.1 at the notch root 5a and is obtained from the distribution of the strain in the tensile orthogonal direction measured at the strain distribution measurement step S1.
[0041] The strain gradient only needs to be obtained, for example, by dividing the difference between the strain at the notch root 5a and the strain at a predetermined distance (1 to 100 mm) in the tensile orthogonal direction from the notch root 5a by the relevant predetermined distance.
[0042] Necking Limit Strain Acquisition Step.
[0043] The necking limit strain acquisition step S5 is a step of obtaining, for each of the two or more types of sheet specimens 1, the strain at the time of occurrence of necking in the notch root 5a as the necking limit strain based on the strain increment ratio r.sub.edge obtained at the strain increment ratio/strain gradient acquisition step S3.
[0044] The reason for obtaining the necking limit strain based on the strain increment ratio r.sub.edge is as follows. When a tensile load in the in-plane uniaxial direction (y-direction in
[0045] Therefore, in the present invention, such a characteristic of the strain increment ratio is utilized to assume that the necking has occurred in the notch root 5a at the point where the strain increment ratio r.sub.edge deviates from the r-value in the tensile direction during the tensile deformation process, and the strain at the point of relevant deviation is obtained as the necking limit strain.
[0046] Then, in the present embodiment, as illustrated in
[0047] The present invention is not limited to the above-described method, and the method may use a certain index that identifies the deviation between the strain increment ratio r.sub.edge and the r-value. For example, when the ratio of the strain increment ratio r.sub.edge to the r-value is used as an index, the maximum principal strain at the time when the relevant index becomes a predetermined value or less, for example, below 1, only needs to be taken as the necking limit strain.
[0048] Necking Limit Strain Identification Step
[0049] The necking limit strain identification step S7 is a step of identifying the necking limit strain as a function of strain gradient from the relation between the necking limit strain obtained for the two or more types of sheet specimens 1 and the strain gradient at the time of the necking limit strain in the tensile deformation process.
[0050] As an example,
[0051] The sheet specimens 1 illustrated in
[0052] Then, as illustrated in
[0053] In the graph illustrated in
[0054] Then, for example, before performing actual press forming, a press forming simulation of a press forming product accompanied with stretch flanging is performed by a finite element method, and by applying the strain ε.sub.FEM and the strain gradient dε/dx.sub.FEM calculated by FEM analysis to the graph of the necking limit strain and the strain gradient in
[0055] Specifically, the strain ε.sub.FEM obtained by the FEM analysis is compared with the value f(dε/dx.sub.FEM) obtained by substituting the strain gradient dε/dx.sub.FEM at the position where the relevant strain was obtained into the evaluation function ƒ(X) of the necking limit strain [X]. Then, it can be judged that forming is feasible as necking does not occur if ε.sub.FEM<f(dε/dx.sub.FEM), and that forming is not feasible as the necking occurs if ε.sub.FEM>f(dε/dx.sub.FEM).
[0056] As in the foregoing, according to the method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet in the present embodiment, the necking limit strain that causes necking due to tensile deformation imparted to the sheet edge of the metal sheet can be identified easily and accurately, without the need of a plurality of dedicated tools and test devices.
[0057] In addition, according to the method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet in the present embodiment, based on the analysis result of the press forming simulation of the press forming product accompanied with stretch flanging, it is possible to predict the presence of occurrence of necking at a site subjected to stretch flanging and to deal with before leading to the fracture. It is also possible to prevent the fracture due to variations and the like in disturbances during the mass production stage of the relevant press forming product.
[0058] In the above description, the notch geometry 5 formed in the sheet specimen 1 has been semicircular as illustrated in
[0059] Furthermore, in the foregoing description, tensile deformation has been imparted to the notch root 5a by applying a tensile load in the in-plane uniaxial direction of the sheet specimen 1 using a uniaxial tensile testing machine, but the method of imparting the tensile deformation is not limited thereto. It may be a method in which the sheet edge on the side having the notch root 5a is supported by two or more points across the notch root 5a, the sheet edge on the opposite side of the notch root 5a is pressed, and a load that results in bending deformation in the plane of the sheet specimen 1 is applied, thereby imparting local tensile deformation to the notch root 5a.
[0060] In the present invention, the sheet specimen only needs to be a metal sheet, and specific examples thereof include a steel sheet, aluminum alloy sheet, magnesium alloy sheet, titanium alloy sheet, and the like. There are no restrictions on the material strength of the sheet specimen 1.
[0061] Moreover, the occurrence of necking when tensile deformation is imparted to the sheet edge of a sheet specimen, at the notch root 5a, is affected by the end face properties of the metal sheet due to differences in processing at the time of producing the sheet specimens such as piercing or shearing. Therefore, in the present invention, it is preferable to use a sheet specimen that has been fabricated so that the end face properties of the notch root 5a are the same by processing such as piercing or shearing in the same manner as blanks provided for press forming of actual press forming products.
[0062] Although the above description has been intended to identify the necking limit strain at which the necking occurs subjected to stretch flanging, the present invention may also target identifying the necking limit strain of the necking that occurs at the hole edge formed in a burring process.
EXAMPLE
[0063] Verifications for confirming the action and effect of the method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet according to the present invention were conducted, and the following describes that.
[0064] Identification of Necking Limit Strain
[0065] In the example, first, using sheet specimens 1 fabricated from two steel sheets having different tensile strengths (steel grade α: sheet thickness of 1.2 mm and tensile strength of 590 MPa class, steel grade sheet thick of 1.2 mm and tensile strength of 1180 MPa class) as a metal sheet, the necking limit strain was identified for each of the steel grade α and the steel grade β.
[0066] In the experiment, a plurality of sheet specimens 1 illustrated in
[0067] Next, from the measurement results of the distribution of the strain in the tensile orthogonal direction in the tensile deformation process, the strain gradient and the necking limit strain at the time of occurrence of necking in the notch root 5a were obtained. Table 1 indicates the results of the strain gradient and the necking limit strain obtained for each of the five types of sheet specimens 1 fabricated from the steel grade α. Table 2 indicates the results of the strain gradient and the necking limit strain obtained for each of the three types of sheet specimens 1 fabricated from the steel grade β. The strain gradients indicated in Table 1 and Table 2 were calculated by dividing the difference between the strain at the notch root 5a of the notch geometry 5 and the strain at a distance of 5 mm inward from the notch root 5a in the tensile orthogonal direction by the distance thereof.
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Sheet specimen [steel grade α] Strain Necking limit (FIG. 6) gradient strain Type A 0.0274 0.306 Type B 0.0369 0.438 Type C 0.0428 0.401 Type D 0.0642 0.480 Type E 0.0732 0.462
TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Sheet specimen [steel grade β] Strain Necking limit (FIG. 6) gradient strain Type B 0.0205 0.158 Type D 0.0163 0.113 Type E 0.0390 0.230
[0068] Subsequently, for each of the steel grade α and the steel grade β, from the relation between the necking limit strain and the strain gradient obtained for the sheet specimens 1, the necking limit strain [Y] was identified by the function of the strain gradient [X] at the notch root 5a in Y=f(X). In this case, from the linear approximation of the strain gradient and the necking limit strain, the evaluation function for the strain gradient [X] that imparts necking limit strain [Y] was defined as f(X)=aX+b, and the values of the parameters a and b were obtained.
[0069]
[0070] When the relation between the necking limit strain Y and the strain gradient X identified by the present invention is approximated by the evaluation function f(X)=aX+b, Y=2.933X+0.274 for the steel grade α and Y=4.752X+0.047 for the steel grade R, and it can be found that the strain gradient can be used to identify the necking limit strain in both steel grades.
[0071] In
[0072] Judgement of Press Forming Feasibility
[0073] Next, the necking limit strain on a stretch flanging portion of a press forming product 11 illustrated in
[0074] First, by the FEM analysis for which the metal sheet (steel grade a) is press-formed into the press forming product 11, the maximum principal strain and the strain gradient in the tensile orthogonal direction at the site P and the site Q that were subjected to stretch flanging were obtained. Then, the relevant obtained strain gradient X was substituted into the foregoing evaluation function f(X)=aX+b of the necking limit strain, and the necking limit strain Y=f(X) was calculated.
[0075]
[0076] The strain gradients were calculated by dividing the difference between the strain at the notch root 5a and the strain at a distance of 5 mm inward from the notch root 5a in the tensile orthogonal direction by the distance thereof. Table 3 collectively indicates the maximum principal strain ε.sub.FEM at the site P and the site Q, the strain gradient dε/dx.sub.FEM calculated using the difference between the strain at the notch root 5a and the strain at the position 5 mm inward in the tensile direction from the notch root 5a, the necking limit strain f(dε/dx.sub.FEM) calculated by giving the strain gradient dε/dx.sub.FEM, and the results for which the press forming feasibility was judged by the relevant obtained necking limit strain.
TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Evaluation site P Q Maximum principal strain 0.646 0.24 ε.sub.FEM Strain gradient dε/dx.sub.FEM 0.0795 0.0219 Necking limit strain 0.505 0.36 f(dε/dx.sub.FEM) Forming feasibility Not feasible Feasible judgement result
[0077] From the inventive examples illustrated in
[0078] As in the foregoing, it has been illustrated that the present invention can, on press forming products having a site subjected to stretch flanging, based on the necking limit strain identified using strain gradient, make a judgement of press forming feasibility.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0079] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a method for identifying a necking limit strain of a metal sheet that is capable of identifying necking limit strain at the time when necking occurred at the sheet edge of the metal sheet in press forming accompanied with stretch flanging easily and accurately, and capable of predicting the occurrence of fracture in advance during the mass production.
REFERENCE SIGNS LIST
[0080] 1 SHEET SPECIMEN [0081] 3 SHEET EDGE [0082] 5 NOTCH GEOMETRY [0083] 5a NOTCH ROOT [0084] 7 STRAIN CONCENTRATION PORTION [0085] 11 PRESS FORMING PRODUCT