Self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device
11527271 · 2022-12-13
Assignee
Inventors
- Oliver Schrape (Frankfurt, DE)
- Anselm Breitenreiter (Frankfurt, DE)
- Frank Vater (Frankfurt, DE)
- Milos Krstic (Frankfurt, DE)
Cpc classification
G11C7/1063
PHYSICS
G11C7/222
PHYSICS
H03K5/135
ELECTRICITY
International classification
G11C7/10
PHYSICS
H03K5/135
ELECTRICITY
H03K5/15
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
The invention is directed to a self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device, comprising three bistable-memory elements and a majority voter. The bistable-memory elements receive respective binary data signal, clock signal, and a feedback signal. Each of the bistable-memory elements is configured, in response to the clock signal assuming a first value, to provide a binary output signal with an output-signal value correlated to a data-signal value of the data signal, and in response to the clock signal assuming a second clock-signal value, to provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of a current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal. The majority voter receives the output signals each of the bistable-memory elements and is configured to provide the feedback signal with the feedback-signal value indicative of that output-signal value taken on by a majority of the currently received output signals.
Claims
1. A self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device, comprising an odd number of at least three bistable-memory elements and a majority voter, wherein the bistable-memory elements each receive a respective binary signal, a respective binary clock signal, and a respective binary feedback signal and wherein each of the bistable-memory elements is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming a first clock-signal value, provide a binary output signal with an output-signal value correlated to a data-signal value of the data signal, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming a second clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of a current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal; and wherein the majority voter receives the output signal of each of the bistable-memory elements and is configured to provide the feedback signal with the feedback-signal value indicative of that output-signal value taken on by a majority of the currently received output signals.
2. The device of claim 1, further comprising a feedback-SET-filter unit that receives, as a filter-input signal, the feedback signal and is configured to provide, as a filter-output signal, to at least one of the bistable-memory elements a filtered feedback signal, which corresponds to the received feedback signal from which at least a part of signal disturbances caused by single-event transients is removed.
3. The device of claim 1, further comprising a data-SET-filter unit that receives, as a filter-input signal, one data signal and is configured to provide, as a filter-output signal, to at least one of the bistable-memory elements a filtered data signal, which corresponds to the received data signal from which at least a part of signal disturbances caused by single-event transients is removed.
4. The device of claim 1, further comprising a clock-SET-filter unit that receives, as a filter-input signal, the clock signal and is configured to provide, as a filter-output signal, to at least one of the bistable-memory elements a filtered clock signal, which corresponds to the received clock signal from which at least a part of signal disturbances caused by single-event transients is removed.
5. The device of claim 2, wherein the feedback-SET-filter unit or a data-SET-filter unit or a clock-SET-filter unit comprise at least one delay unit which receives the filter-input signal and is configured to provide, as the filtered-output signal, the filter-input signal delayed by a predetermined time-span, or at least one guard gate that receives the filter-input signal and a delayed filter-input signal, which is the filter-input signal delayed by a predetermined time span, and is configured to provide, as the filter-output signal, a signal indicative of the filter-input signal only if the filter-input signal and the delayed filter-input signal are indicative of the same value.
6. The device according to claim 1, wherein each of the bistable-memory elements is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the binary output signal with the output-signal value indicative of that data-signal value assumed by the data signal during a last preceding transition of the clock-signal value from the second clock-signal value to the first clock-signal value.
7. The device according to claim 6, wherein each of the bistable-memory elements comprises a latch that receives the data signal and the clock signal and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the second clock-signal value, provide an intermediate-output signal with an intermediate-output-signal value indicative of the current data-signal value of the data signal, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the intermediate-output signal with the intermediate-output-signal value indicative of that data-signal value assumed by the data signal when the clock signal last assumed the second clock-signal value; and an open-latch that receives the intermediate-output signal, the feedback signal, and the clock signal and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of the current intermediate-output-signal value of the intermediate-output signal, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming the second clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value of the feed-back signal.
8. The device according to claim 1, wherein each of the bistable-memory elements is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming a first clock-signal value, provide a binary output signal with an output-signal value indicative of a current data-signal value of the data signal.
9. The device according to claim 8, wherein each of the bistable-memory elements comprises an open-latch that receives the data signal, the clock signal, and the feedback signal and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of the current data-signal value of the data signal, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming the second clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal.
10. The device according to claim 7, wherein each of the open-latches comprises a data-forwarding circuit that receives the clock signal and either, the data signal or, the intermediate-output signal, both hereinafter identically referred to as logic signal, and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of a current logic-signal value of the logic signal to the majority voter, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming the second clock-signal value, prevent the provision of the output signal by the data-forwarding circuit.
11. The device according to claim 7, wherein each of the open-latches comprises a feedback-forwarding circuit that receives the feedback signal and the clock signal and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal assuming the second clock-signal value, provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal to the majority voter, and in response to the binary clock signal assuming the first clock-signal value, prevent the provision of the output signal by the feedback-forwarding circuit.
12. The device according to claim 10, wherein the data-forwarding circuit or the feedback-forwarding circuit comprise a tristate inverter or a combination of a transmission gate and a C-element.
13. The device according to claim 1, wherein the number of bistable-memory elements is three.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) Further embodiments will be described in the following with reference to the enclosed drawings. In the drawings:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(20)
(21) The self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device 100 comprises three bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 and a majority voter 180. Furthermore, the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 comprises a data-signal terminal 101 through which it receives a binary data signal 102 and a clock-signal terminal 103 through which it receives a binary clock signal 104.
(22) The binary data signal, the binary clock signal, and the binary feedback signal each holds one of two possible values at any moment in time. Hereinafter, those values are referred to as HIGH or “1” and LOW or “0”. Moreover, the first clock-signal value is either defined as HIGH or as LOW, wherein the second clock-signal value is defined as the opposite value.
(23) The three bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 in parallel receive the binary data signal 102, the binary clock signal 104, and a feedback signal 182. Furthermore, each of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 is configured to, in response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming a first clock signal value, provide a binary output signal 122, 142, and 162 with an output-signal value correlated to a data-signal value of the data signal 102. Moreover, each of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140 and 160 is configured to, in response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming a second clock-signal value, provide the output signal 122, 142, and 162 with the output-signal value indicator of the current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal 182.
(24) The majority voter 180 receives the output signal 122, 142 and 162 of each of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160. Moreover, the majority voter 180 is configured to provide the feedback signal 182 with the feedback-signal value indicative of that output-signal value taken on by a majority of the currently received output signals 122, 142 and 162.
(25) In the embodiment 100 of the modular-redundancy-memory device of
(26)
(27) Features of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100′ that are identical to those of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 are labeled using the same reference signs. For an explanation of those features, the reader is referred to the description of
(28) The self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device 100′ comprises three bistable-memory elements 120′, 140′, and 160′, which are implemented as D-latches receiving an additional RESET-signal, which will be explained in the following for the bistable-memory element 120′.
(29) The bistable-memory element 120′ receives the data signal 102 and the clock-signal 104 via the input terminal 101 and the clock-signal terminal 103, respectively. Furthermore, the bistable-memory element 120′ receives an asynchronous RESET-signal 102R via a RESET-terminal 101R. The bistable-memory element 120′ is configured to, if indicated by the RESET-signal 102R, provide the output signal 122 with the output-signal value equal to LOW independently of the data-signal value of the data signal 102 and the clock-signal value of the clock signal 104.
(30) In other embodiments of the modular-redundancy memory device of
(31) The separate data signals 102, 102′, and 102″ as well as the separate clock signals 104, 104′, and 104″ in most use-cases of the self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device resemble the same common data signal and clock signal, respectively. However, in principle those signals can also be of different origin.
(32) In another embodiment of the modular-redundancy-memory device, the feedback signal 182 is also provided externally for further processing. Such an embodiment will be described in the following with reference to
(33)
(34) Features of the modular-redundancy-memory device 200 that are identical to those of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 are labeled using the same reference signs. For an explanation of those features, the reader is referred to the description of
(35) In comparison to the modular-redundancy-memory device 100, the modular-redundancy-memory device 200 additionally comprises a feedback-signal terminal 284 through which the feedback signal 182 provided by the majority voter 180 is provided externally. By providing the feedback signal 182 externally and not the output signals of the individual bistable-memory devices 120, 140, and 160, always that output-signal value held by the majority of the bistable-memory devices 120, 140, and 160 is provided.
(36) In
(37) In other embodiments of the modular-redundancy-memory device, additionally or alternatively an inverted feedback signal is provided via the feedback-signal terminal 284.
(38) The number of redundant bistable-memory elements of the self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device 100 is three. As a result the self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device 100 is also often referred to as self-correcting triple-modular-redundancy (TMR) memory device. Nevertheless, other embodiments of the modular-redundancy-memory device also comprise an odd number of bistable-memory elements greater than three.
(39) The redundancy of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 as well as the self-correction of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 through the majority voter 180 protects the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 against loss of information due to single event upsets (SEUs) caused by a particle directly hitting of one of the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, or 160. However, loss of information can also be caused by single event transients (SETs), which are voltage pulses or glitches generated as a result of an ionization event. Loss of information due to SETs can be prevented by introducing a single-event-transient filter unit. In the following, different embodiments of the modular-redundancy-memory device comprising a single-event-transient filter unit will be described with reference to
(40)
(41) Again, features of the modular-redundancy-memory device 300 that are identical to those of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 are labelled using the same reference signs. For an explanation of those features the reader is referred to the description of
(42) In comparison to the modular-redundancy-memory device 100, the modular-redundancy-memory device 300 additional comprises the feedback-SET-filter unit 384. The feedback-SET-filter unit 384 receives the feedback signal 182 provided by the majority voter 180 and is configured to performed a filtering operation to filter alterations due to SETs from the feedback signal 182 and provided a filtered feedback signal 384.1, 384.2, and 384.3 to the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160, respectively.
(43) Different embodiment of single-event-transient filter units are already known in the prior art, such as, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 8,975,913 B2. In the following, different exemplary embodiments of the single-event-transient filter unit known from the prior art will be described with reference to
(44)
(45) The embodiment “(a)” of the single-event-transient filter unit receives an input signal labelled “D” and is configured to dispose of any alterations caused by SETs by shifting the input signal “D” in time to shift it outside a time window during which, for example, the feedback signal is being processed by the bistable-memory elements. To this end, the embodiment “(a)” of the single-event-transient filter unit is configured to split the input signal “D” into three output signals labelled “D0”, “D1”, and “D2”, wherein the output signal “D1” corresponds to the input signal “D” delayed by a time span “δ” and the output signal “D2” corresponds to the input signal “D” delayed by a time span 2-times “δ”.
(46) An alternative approach is implemented by the embodiment “(b)” of the single-event-transient filter unit, which comprises three guard gates labelled “GG”. The guard gates “GG” each receive the input signal “D” as a first input and the input signal “D” delayed by a time span “δ” as a second input. The guard gates are configured to only externally provide an output signal, labelled “D0”, “D1”, and “D2”, respectively, if the signal received at their two inputs is identical. As a result, alterations of the signal introduced by a SET shorter than a time span “δ” are filtered from the input signal “D”.
(47) In the embodiment “(c)”, the single-event-transient filter unit receives an input signal labeled “D” and is configured to provide three output signals labeled “D0”, “D1”, and “D2”. The output signal “D0” directly corresponds to the input signal “D”, while the output signal “D1” corresponds to a delayed version of the input signal “D” delayed by a time span “δ”. The output signal “D2” corresponds to an output provided by a guard gate which receives, as a first input, the input signal “D” and, as a second input, the input signal “D” delayed by the time span “δ”.
(48) The three embodiments shown in
(49) Besides introducing a single-event-transient filter unit for filtering the feedback signal 182, it is also possible to introduce a single-event-transient filter unit for filtering the data signal 102 before it is received by the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 as will be explained in the following with reference to
(50)
(51) Again, features of the modular-redundancy-memory device 400 that are identical to those of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 are labelled using the same reference signs. For an explanation of those features the reader is referred to the description of
(52) The modular-redundancy-memory device 400 additionally comprises the data-SET-filter unit 402. The data-SET-filter unit 402 receives the data signal 102 and is configured to provide filtered data signals 402.1, 402.2, and 402.3, which correspond to the received data signal 102 filtered for alterations from SETs. The filtered data signals 402.1, 402.2, and 402.3 are received by the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160, respectively.
(53) Alternatively or additionally it is possible to introduce a single-event-transient filter unit also for the clock signal 104 received by the bistable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160 to protect against SETs. Such an embodiment will be described in the following with reference to
(54)
(55) Again, features of the modular-redundancy-memory device 500 that are identical to those of the modular-redundancy-memory device 100 are labelled using the same reference signs. For an explanation of those features the reader is referred to the description of
(56) The embodiments 500 of the self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device additionally comprises the clock-SET-filter unit 504. The clock-SET-filter unit 504 receives the clock signal 104 and is configured to provide a filtered clock signal 504.1, 504.2 and 504.3, which correspond to the received clock signal 104 filtered for alterations from SETs. The filtered clock signals 504.1, 504.2, and 504.3 are received by the stable-memory elements 120, 140, and 160, respectively.
(57) In the embodiments of the self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device described above, bistable-memory elements can either be implemented as a latch or a flip-flop. In the following, a bistable-memory element implemented as an edged-triggered flip-flop and a bistable-memory element implemented as a level-triggered latch will be described with reference to
(58)
(59) The bistable-memory element 620 receives the data signal 102 via a data-signal terminal 620.10, the clock signal 104 via a clock-signal terminal 620.12, and the feedback signal 182 from the majority voter 180 via a feedback-signal terminal 620.14.
(60) The flip-flop is realized in the bistable-memory device 620 by a series arrangement of a latch 620.1 and an open-latch 620.3. The latch 620.1 receives both the data signal 102 and the clock signal 104 and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the second clock-signal value, provide an intermediate-output signal 620.2 with an intermediate-output-signal value indicative of the current data-signal value of the data signal 102, and in response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the first clock-signal value, provide the intermediate-output signal 620.2 with the intermediate-output-signal value indicative of that data-signal value assumed by the data signal 102 when the clock signal 104 last assumed the second clock-signal value.
(61) The open-latch 620.3 receives the intermediate-output signal 620.2, the clock signal 104, and the feedback signal 182 and is configured to in response to the binary clock signal (104, “CLK”) assuming the first clock-signal value (“CLK1”), provide the output signal (122, 142, 162, “O1”) with the output-signal value indicative of the current intermediate-output-signal value (“C IO1”) of the intermediate-output signal (620.2, “IO1”), and in response to the binary clock signal (104, “CLK”) assuming the second clock-signal value (“CLK2”), provide the output signal (122, 142, 162, “O1”) with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value (“C F”) of the feed-back signal (182, “F”).
(62) The feedback path of the open-latch 620.3 is closed by providing the output signal 122 via an output-signal terminal 620.16 to the majority voter (not shown in
(63)
(64) The latch 620.1 of the first bistable-element receives both the data signal “D1” and the clock signal “CLK”. In response to the binary clock signal “CLK” assuming the second clock-signal value LOW, the latch 620.1 is configured to provide an intermediate-output signal “IO1” with an intermediate-output-signal value “CD1” indicative of the current data-signal value of the data signal “D1”. In this particular example, the values “C D1” correspond to the values of “D1” when “CLK” is LOW.
(65) Further, in response to the binary clock signal “CLK” assuming the first clock-signal value HIGH, the latch 620.1 is configured provide the intermediate-output signal “IO1” with the intermediate-output-signal value “L D1” of that data-signal value assumed by the data signal “D1” when the clock signal “CLK” last assumed the second clock-signal “LOW”. In this particular example, the values “L D1” correspond to the values of “D1” when “CLK” transitions from LOW to HIGH. Assuming that the first transition from LOW to HIGH of “D1” is due to a SET and only affected “D1”, so that D2 and D3 are still indicative of the intended value of the input binary data signal, the value of “L D1”, that is directly associated to the glitch “G” in “D1”, is an erroneous intermediate output signal.
(66) The open-latch 620.3 of the first bistable-memory element receives the intermediate-output signal “IO1”, the clock signal “CLK”, and the feedback signal “F”. While the binary clock signal “CLK” assumes the first clock-signal value HIGH, the open-latch 620.3 is configured to provide the output signal “O1” with the output-signal value indicative of the current intermediate-output-signal value “C IO1” of the intermediate-output signal “IO1”. Thus, while the clock assumes a HIGH value, the output signal corresponds to the value that the input signal had during the last transition of “CLK” from LOW to HIGH. In the example shown in
(67) Therefore, while the binary clock signal “CLK” assumes the second clock-signal value, LOW in this particular example, the open-latch 620.3 is configured to, provide the output signal “O1” with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value “C F” of the feed-back signal “F”, thereby correcting the erroneous output of “O1”.
(68)
(69) The bistable-memory element 720 comprises an open-latch 620.3 that receives the data signal 102 via a data-signal terminal 620.10, the clock signal 104 via a clock-signal terminal 620.12, and the feedback signal 182 via a feedback-signal terminal 620.14. In response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the first clock-signal value, the open-latch 620.3 is configured to provide the output signal 122 with the output-signal value indicative of the current data-signal value of the data signal 102. In response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the second clock-signal value the open-latch is configured to provide the output signal 122 with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal 182.
(70)
(71) Each of the bistable-memory elements receives a clock signal “CLK” and a feedback signal “F”. Moreover, a first bistable-memory element receives a data signal “D1”, shown in
(72) While the clock signal “CLK” assumes a HIGH level, the output signal “O1” corresponds to the current value of “D1”, referred to as “C D1”. While the clock signal “CLK” assumes a LOW, the output signal “O1” corresponds to the current value of the feedback signal “F”, referred to as “CF”, that is provided by the majority voter. In the time diagram of
(73)
(74) In response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the first clock-signal value, the data-forwarding circuit 620.3.4 is configured to provide the output signal 122 with the output-signal value indicative of a current logic-signal value of the logic signal 802, i.e. either the data signal or the intermediate output signal, to the majority voter (not show in
(75) In the device 800, the open-latches 820.3 optionally also comprises a feedback-forwarding circuit 620.3.6 that receives the feedback signal 182 and the clock signal 104. In response to the binary clock signal 104 assuming the second clock-signal value, the feedback-forwarding circuit 620.3.6 is configured to provide the output signal 122 with the output-signal value indicative of the current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal 182 to the majority voter (not shown in
(76)
(77)
(78) In another exemplary circuit, the polarity of the MOS transistors is inverted and, additionally or alternatively the inverse of the clock signal is not provided to the pMOS transistor but to the nMOS transistor.
(79) Since the binary value at the output node of the tristate inverter 1020a.3.4.2 while the clock signal assumes a HIGH value is the inverse of the data signal, an inverting stage 902 is included to provide, as output signal, a value corresponding to the data signal.
(80) Additionally, the open latch 1020a.3 comprises a feedback-forwarding circuit 1020a.3.6 that also comprises a tristate inverter 1020a.3.6.2. whose output node 1020a.3.6.1. is connected to the output node 1020.a.3.4.1 of the tristate inverter 1020.a.3.4.2. The operation is similar to that discussed with reference to the tristate inverter 1020.a.3.4.2. However, the connection of the clock signal and the inverse clock signal obtained by providing the clock signal 104 to an inverting stage 1020a.3.6.4 is such that the output is provided at an opposite clock phase as in the case of the data-forwarding circuit 1020a.3.4. In this example, the binary value at the output node 1020a.3.4.1 is the inverse of the feedback signal whenever the clock signal is LOW (and thus the inverse clock signal is HIGH). Therefore, during a HIGH clock phase the output signal 122 corresponds to the (inverse of the inverse of the) binary data signal and during a LOW clock phase the output signal corresponds to the (inverse of the inverse of the) feedback signal 182.
(81) In
(82) Additionally, or alternatively, the feedback-forwarding circuit may also comprise a combination of a C-element and a transmission gate, as it is shown in
(83) The bistable-memory elements shown in
(84)
(85) The bistable-memory element 1120a comprises a rising-edge TSPC flip-flop 1120a.2 with three gated inverters, which receives the data signal 102 via the data-signal terminal 620.10 and the clock signal 104 via the clock-signal terminal 620.12, wherein an output terminal of the flip-flop 1120a.2 is connected to the output terminal 620.16.
(86) Furthermore, the bistable-memory element 1120a comprises a TSPC transmission gate 1120.4, which receives the feedback signal 182 via the feedback-signal terminal 620.14 and the clock signal 104 and is configured to provide at its output terminal the feedback signal 182, when the value of the clock signal 104 is LOW. Moreover, the output terminal of the transmission gate 1120.4 is also connected to the output terminal 620.16.
(87) Other variations to the disclosed embodiments can be understood and effected by those skilled in the art in practicing the claimed invention, from a study of the drawings, the disclosure, and the appended claims.
(88) In other embodiments, the bistable-memory element also comprises other implementations of the TSCP flop-flop. An example of such an embodiment will be explained with reference to
(89)
(90) All elements of the bistable-memory element 1120a that are also comprised within the bistable-memory element 1120b are labelled in
(91) Similar to the bistable-memory element 1120a, the bistable-memory element 1120b comprises a rising-edge TSCP flip-flop 1120b.2 with three gated inverters. However, in addition to the three gated inverter, the gated inverter closest to the output of the flip-flip comprises an additional feedback loop to stabilize internal nodes.
(92) In summary, the invention is directed to a self-correcting modular-redundancy-memory device, comprising three bistable-memory elements and a majority voter. The bistable-memory elements receive respective binary data signal, clock signal, and a feedback signal. Each of the bistable-memory elements is configured, in response to the clock signal assuming a first value, to provide a binary output signal with an output-signal value correlated to a data-signal value of the data signal, and in response to the clock signal assuming a second clock-signal value, to provide the output signal with the output-signal value indicative of a current feedback-signal value of the feedback signal. The majority voter receives the output signals each of the bistable-memory elements and is configured to provide the feedback signal with the feedback-signal value indicative of that output-signal value taken on by a majority of the currently received output signals.
(93) In the claims, the word “comprising” does not exclude other elements or steps, and the indefinite article “a” or “an” does not exclude a plurality.
(94) A single unit, stage or device may fulfil the functions of several items recited in the claims. The mere fact that certain measures are recited in mutually different dependent claims does not indicate that a combination of these measures cannot be used to advantage.
(95) Any reference signs in the claims should not be construed as limiting the scope.