Method of Inspection of Wind Turbine Blades
20220099067 · 2022-03-31
Inventors
Cpc classification
F03D17/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05B2260/80
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05B2270/8041
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05B2270/804
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Y02E10/72
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
F03D17/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Abstract
A method for assessing and inspection of wind turbine blades 4, in particular moving wind turbine blades, comprising the steps of directing a data capture device such as a camera system 1 towards a wind turbine blade 4 that is to be assessed. The camera system 1 can be attached to an aerial craft such as a helicopter 3, and is provided with a laser 13 that is used to track the motion of the blade 4 that is to be assessed. The laser 13 may be adapted to track a single blade 4 or the camera system 1 may be provided with multiple lasers to track multiple blades of the same turbine at the same time. The method further comprises collecting data of the state or condition of the blade 4 using the camera system 1 during the time that the helicopter 3 navigates around the wind turbine 2. The image data of the blade that is captured is fed into a computer processor (not shown) which can be on-board the helicopter 3 or at a remote location. The computer processor is adapted to reconstruct the image data into a 2-D or 3-D virtual digital image of the wind turbine 2. The method further comprises using at least one algorithm to compare and contrast various parts of the digital image generated by the reconstruction, with corresponding parts of a predetermined image of a healthy wind turbine, to identify defects or damage to the actual wind turbine, and the extent of the defects and damage. Using machine learning and A.I., the method is able to ascertain if and when replacement of the wind turbine blade may be necessary. An apparatus for undertaking the method is also claimed.
Claims
1. A method for assessment of one or more wind turbine blades of a wind turbine, said method comprising: directing a data capture means towards a wind turbine blade that is to be assessed, said data capture means being disposed on a craft; tracking a wind turbine blade that is to be assessed using a guide means; collecting data of a state of said wind turbine blade using said data capture means during a time that said craft means navigates around said wind turbine; feeding said data collected by said data capture means to a computer processor; reconstructing an image derived from data captured by said data capture means into a digital image of said wind turbine blade using said computer processor, reconstructing an image derived from data captured by said data capture means into a digital image of said wind turbine blade using said computer processor, applying an algorithm to said digital image of said tracked wind turbine blade to compare parts of said digital image with corresponding parts of a predetermined image of a healthy wind turbine blade, to identify defects or damage to said tracked wind turbine blade.
2. The method as claimed in claim 1, further comprising using said identified defects or damage to determine if replacement, maintenance or repair of said wind turbine blade is necessary.
3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said data capture means comprises one or more devices selected from the set: an optical digital camera; an acoustic sensor; a thermal imaging camera; a plurality of sensors and/or transducers used together to capture data.
4. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the data capture means is operable automatically or manually to capture images of said wind turbine blade as said craft navigates around a wind turbine.
5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said craft is selected from the set: an aircraft; a helicopter; an unmanned aerial vehicle; a drone; a land vehicle; a marine craft or vehicle.
6. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said data capture means is mounted on said craft.
7. The method as claimed in claim 1, comprising tracking said wind turbine blade using a laser.
8. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein said guide means comprises a coherent light source.
9. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said craft means navigates around said wind turbine at least once.
10. The method of claim 6 comprising tracking a motion of a moving turbine blade using an electromagnetic wave.
11. The method as claimed in claim 6, comprising tracking the motion of a plurality of said moving wind turbine blades simultaneously.
12. The method as claimed in claimed in claim 6, comprising tracking a rotating wind turbine blade.
13. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said algorithm compares and contrasts individual regions of a said digital image of a said wind turbine blade with corresponding regions of a predetermined image of a healthy and/or undamaged wind turbine blade.
14. The method as claimed in claim 1: collecting a plurality of datasets each corresponding to a respective wind turbine blade; each said dataset comprising one or a plurality of digital images of said corresponding wind turbine blade; entering said plurality of datasets into an artificial intelligence engine.
15. The method as claimed in claim 14 wherein said artificial intelligence engine comprises said algorithm to compare and contrast parts of said digital image with corresponding parts of a predetermined image of a healthy wind turbine blade.
16. The method as claimed in claim 14, comprising: identifying one or more defects or regions of damage of said tracked wind turbine blade as an output of said artificial intelligence engine.
17. The method as claimed in claim 14, further comprising: obtaining a determination of whether a said wind turbine blade requires replacement and/or maintenance and/or servicing as an output of said artificial intelligence.
18. A data capture device for assessing and/or inspecting at least one wind turbine blade, said device comprising: a guide means; a first data capture means; a second data capture means; wherein in use, said guide means is operable to direct said first data capture means to a position on a said turbine blade of whose data is to be captured, wherein said second data capture means in use is adapted to capture data concerning substantially the whole of the said wind turbine blade and has a capture span that encompasses substantially a length of said turbine blade.
19. A data capture device for assessing and/or inspecting at least one wind turbine blade of a wind turbine, said device comprising: a data capture means configured for direction towards a wind turbine blade that is to be assessed; said data capture means being capable of being carried by a craft capable of navigating around said wind turbine; tracking means for tracking an individual wind turbine blade of said wind turbine; data collection means for collecting data captured by data capture means; means for reconstructing a digital image of a said tracked wind turbine blade; means for comparing regions of said reconstructed digital image with a digital image of an undamaged healthy wind turbine blade; means for identifying regions of damage or defect in said reconstructed digital image of said tracked wind turbine blade; and means for determining if maintenance, servicing and/or maintenance of said wind turbine blade is necessary.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0046] For a better understanding of the invention and to show how the same may be carried into effect, there will now be described by way of example only, specific embodiments, methods and processes according to the present invention with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
[0047]
[0048]
[0049]
[0050]
[0051]
[0052]
[0053]
[0054]
[0055]
[0056]
[0057]
[0058]
DETAILS DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENTS
[0059] There will now be described by way of example a specific mode contemplated by the inventors. In the following description numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding. It will be apparent however, to one skilled in the art, that the present invention may be practiced without limitation to these specific details. In other instances, well known methods and structures have not been described in detail so as not to unnecessarily obscure the description.
[0060] In this specification, the term “craft” includes any vehicle capable of navigating around a land or marine-based wind turbine and includes but is not limited to aircraft, land or marine surface vessels comprising helicopters, fixed wing aircraft, aerial drones, unmanned aircraft (UAV); marine surface vessels and land vehicles, either manned or unmanned.
[0061] The present invention is a method of inspection of wind turbine blades to assess their state and can be used for planning routine maintenance and/or preventing failure and/or for giving an early warning of likely failure. It offers a quick and more accurate measurement method that is repeatable and suitable for visual inspection, data collection, data analysis and database population for a large number of wind turbine blades. The method is not restricted to being used whilst the wind turbine blades are stationary, but can be used when such blades are in motion. The invention has generally a data collection phase, a data analysis or processing phase, and a data interpretation phase. The data analysis and interpretation can be automated using advanced algorithms that analyse the data gathered, onboard the craft or remotely, and compare it with historical data, and pre-defined quality benchmarks to assess and determine blade health.
[0062]
[0063] In terms of the specification of the optical camera, a colour camera with optics of a diameter of 15 cm and a focal length of approximately 50 cm can be used. This may be coupled with a high resolution sensor which would provide approximately 3000×3000 pixels over a 1° by 1° field of view. This should give a good resolvability for a 2 cm object at a distance of approximately 300 metres, when the laser is tracking the motion of the blade with no interruptions. With such a large optical diameter, the “depth of view” becomes vanishingly small (a couple of metres at a focus distance of 230 metres), however the system can be optimized to use a lower aperture size without compromising performance. This means the system must have extremely capable focus mechanism, and conventional methods of estimating the distance from the camera to the patch of turbine blade that is being captured can be adopted to achieve this. Alternatively, a long wave infrared camera can also be used.
[0064] In order for the data capture phase of the method to be optimum, the helicopter or craft carrying the data capture device 1 must maintain a distance of around 500 ft from all parts of the wind turbine at all times. This will require skill and training, but is something that experienced pilots will be able to achieve. During operation, the wind turbines are rotating at approximately 10 RPM, with the tip moving at 100 m/s. Thus, in order for the data capture process to be quick and efficient, then the system must be able to capture image data from between 50 to 100 wind turbines in 2.5 hours. This means that the goal is to circle each turbine once, with each circle lasting approximately 40 or 50 seconds, and in that time capturing approximately 400 images of each turbine (approximately 10 images per second). This reduces the cost of inspection and would enable the system to be suitable for installation in a wide variety of helicopters and craft, without compromising range or accuracy and performance of the data collection and defect identification. Similarly, the data capture phase of the method can be undertaken using a data capture devices other than an optical camera, and similar principles and considerations will apply.
[0065] In order to capture image data efficiently, the helicopter must circle the wind turbine once. However, if time/cost are not restrictive factors, the helicopter can circle the turbine more than once. Thus in
[0066] For each turbine, the helicopter is guided to approach and circle the turbine, and each image taken is subsequently textured onto a virtual turbine representing the external model (or internal model if also using a thermal imaging camera) of the turbine by processing software. The incident waves 15 (
[0067] Similarly, using a thermal imaging camera, an ultrasonic transducer, or other suitable sensor, which may form part of the data capture device that includes an optical camera, the internal geometry of the blade can also be inspected and any defects identified and ascertained.
[0068] In analysing the data that is gathered by the data capture phase, the image data has to be imported into a software system that undertakes the reconstruction of the virtual image. This can be done on a computing system aboard the helicopter, or remotely during the data capture phase (using a conventional data transfer link that transfers the data from the helicopter to a remote location for analysis). Alternatively it can be done after the data capture phase, whereby the data is fed into a computing system for analysis. There are many data processing software packages on the market that can undertake such an exercise. Such software includes modularization, aero-hydro-servo-elastic tools, and other aerodynamics multi-physics engineering software and generally software simulation tools. One such software package is ANSYS CFX, a high-performance computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software package that can be employed to create virtual images of turbines, from hundreds of files of image data. In order to demonstrate the accuracy of these software packages, in as far as calculating values for a blade that are comparable or equal to the manufacturer specified values (within an acceptable error margin), one method uses meshing, whereby an IGES file created by a CAD program such as SolidWorks can be imported into ANSYS MESHING CFD grid generation system to generate the computational grids required for the CFD analyses.
[0069] Meshing using boundary conditions (domain, physical or periodic) can help determine the torque and output power of a turbine blade, however periodic boundary conditions are used when the physical geometry of interest and the expected pattern of the flow have a periodically repeating nature (see Fluent Inc., 2006; Bazilevs, et al., 2011 incorporated herein by reference). Thus, for a healthy blade as the NREL 5MW blade mentioned above, typical boundary condition created in ANSYS software are fed an inflow speed where u=11.4 m/s and 0=12.1 RPM. These values help to replicate the rated power output of a blade. The result is compared against the power output of an identical blade from a reconstructed virtual image of that blade. This way, the known blade characteristics as specified by the manufacturer can be compared with the blade characteristics of the virtual blade that is formed from the image data captured by inspection of a real blade, to determine if certain external or internal structural changes of the blade affect the performance of the blade and if so, the extent of the effect. Thus, as an example, in one lab experiment of the method of the present invention, using ANSYS MESHING CFD grid generation system to simulate the behavior of a healthy blade, it was found that using the ‘sweep method’ and sampling 1,260,773 elements from one grid or mesh of the NREL 5MW blade, created 2,227,207 nodes, the process taking 480 seconds. Similarly, a sweep of 6,808,621 elements from another grid can achieve around 3,155,391 nodes in 600 seconds, whereas a sweep of 40,679,329 elements was able to achieve 10,683,442 in 5400 seconds, using an inflow speed=11.4 m/s and Ω=12.1 RPM rotational speed. Note that different nodes will be moving at different speeds. The grids analysed with this approach are structured in most parts of the domain, around the blade, and also along the far field and periodicity boundaries towards the blade. Because of the computing power required, it is important that the computing means be robust and powerful. Thus, if the sweeping method was undertaken using an Intel Core i7-2630 QM processor clocking at 2.9 GHz, with 8 GB RAM and 1 TB RADEON GRAPHIC 64 BIT hard drive for example, it would result in minimal run-times to create the CFD grids that are used to determine output power. Thus, a more powerful processor would be desirable, for faster and more elaborate meshing. Generally, it is time-consuming to generate fully structured meshes from the far field boundaries to the blade surface, however the more structured meshes are created, the higher the accuracy of the results obtained.
[0070]
[0071] The Output power can be calculated by following formula: P=τ×ω where P is power for one blade, τ is torque for one blade ω is angular velocity (rotor angular speed). The torque for a healthy blade within CFX is found from the following formula: torque_y( )@airfoil, and is equal to −1.66774e+006 (N m). Thus, the output power of this model is equal to 1.9512558e+006 (Nm/s) for one blade. Full output power for the wind turbine can be calculated by the following formula: ΔP=P×n where ΔP is the total output power for the whole wind turbine, P is power for one blade and n is the number of the blades. The wind turbine has 3 blades therefore the output power for this wind turbine is equal to 5.8 MW.
[0072]
[0073] There are differences between the pressure plot of a healthy blade, and the pressure plot of a damaged blade (
[0074] The computer processing apparatus used in this method can be provided with or can interface to design data or databases having details of manufacturer data for each type of blade. Thus, it will be important for details of the type of blade that has been inspected or that is due to be inspected, to be specified before the inspection or during data analysis, in the interest of like-for-like comparison, since the databases will contain details of different kinds of blades, with varying properties, and an error will occur if damage analysis comparison is undertaken on dissimilar blades.
[0075] For blades installed in a wind farm that is to be analysed for damage, each blade's individual data must be collected and also manipulated to calculate the torque and output power as described in the above meshing process. The aim is to use suitable sensors to collate sufficient data to develop a CAD model of a moving blade with sufficient detail of the leading edge damage.
[0076] The results of the cad simulation using the same setup (Boundary condition, Flow domain, mesh size) for a blade with various damaged size are plotted in
[0077] Thus, in a preferred embodiment, a method for assessing and inspection of wind turbine blades 4, in particular moving wind turbine blades, comprises the steps of directing a data capture device such as a camera system 1 towards a wind turbine blade 4 that is to be assessed; the camera system 1 is attached to an aerial craft such as a helicopter 3, and is provided with a guide means such as a laser 13 that is used to track the motion of the blade 4 that is to be assessed, and feed the camera system the position of the area that is to be photographed. The laser 13 may be adapted to track a single blade 4 or the camera system 1 may be provided with multiple lasers to track multiple blades at the same time. The method further comprises collecting data of the state or condition of the blade 4 using the camera system 1 during the time that the helicopter 3 navigates around the wind turbine 2. The image data of the blade that is captured is fed into a computer processor (not shown) which can be on-board the helicopter or at a remote location. The computer processor is adapted to reconstruct the image data into a 2-D or 3-D digital or virtual image of the wind turbine. The method further comprises using at least one algorithm to compare and contrast various parts of the digital image generated by the reconstruction, with corresponding parts of a predetermined image of a healthy wind turbine, to identify defects or damage to the actual wind turbine, and the extent of the defects and damage. Using machine learning, the method can ascertain if repair or replacement of the wind turbine blade is necessary, by reference to metrics such as a drop in power output.
[0078] The method provides an intelligent and sensitive system that can distinguish between an undamaged surface and a damaged surface. Position sensors may be used to keep track of each and every turbine, so that during reconstruction and creation of the virtual blade, image data integrity from each blade is assured.
[0079] In the method, software is used to transform collected data into the required CAD model, that is subsequently transformed into a virtual image that can be assessed to provide a damage assessment report stating the extent of the damage, and the potential performance improvement by repairing or replacing the damage.
[0080] A computer or hand-held mobile phone application can be used to undertake some of the iterations. Wi-Fi or a mobile telephone network, may be employed to transmit data from the data capture device to the computer processor. Alternatively, data stored onto the storage memory of the data capture device can be manually transferred to the computing processing device, to begin the reconstruction of the virtual image.
[0081] Other sensors that can be used to capture data include an infrared camera, an acoustic transmitter, an acoustic receiver, a radiation source, a radiation detector, an ultrasonic device, a radiographic device, a thermographic device, and other suitable electromagnetic devices.
[0082] In addition, data from the computer processor unit could be collated into historical data on each blade, to create a profile that maps the normal power output for a given wind speed against reduced operation for the same wind speed. A threshold can be manually or automatically set, to ascertain a position, when power output is significantly low, and the blade is in need of repair or replacement. An Artificial intelligence engine can be employed to calculate the extent by which various parts of a blade have worn, based on data fed into it, and at what point bade replacement can achieve efficiency.
[0083] The technology may be adapted to undertake data capture of several turbine blades at the same time. For this to be possible, the device can be fitted with several sensors coupled to several lasers to simultaneously track and capture image data of a plurality of turbines.
[0084] The benefits of the device are significant. It would prevent the loss of revenue by allowing the turbine to continue generating throughout the inspection, maximising efficiency and revenue for the wind farm operator
[0085] Since workers are not endangered whilst working at height, and the wind farm has less down time due to shorter inspections periods, there would be an increase of production time.
[0086] Data signatures of each turbine can be developed into a database. A healthy blade will have a particular type of signature, whereas a blade with a defect will also have a signature corresponding to the level of defect. As more measurements are taken, and more blades inspected, a continuum of signatures will be developed, and a large dataset created. An A.I. engine and machine learning can be employed to predict, considering historical data of other turbines in the area, what the lifecycle of a new turbine will look like, and to map how much defect is acceptable, before the turbine must be replaced. Similarly, an acoustic signature, or thermal imaging signatures taken from blades, before and after the defect, can also be used as a blade inspection method, and to monitor the performance (and power output) of each wind turbine over time.
[0087] Having described and illustrated the principles of the invention with reference to preferred embodiments, it will be apparent to a skilled man in the art that the invention can be modified in arrangement and detail without departing from such principles. Accordingly, in view of the many possible embodiments to which the principles may be put, it should be noted that the detailed embodiments are illustrative only and should not be taken as limiting the scope of the invention.