Method for detecting acute Borna disease virus (BDV) infections, and diagnostic kit therefor, in particular in combination with methods for distinguishing acute from chronic and latent BDV infections, and diagnostic kits therefor
11835521 · 2023-12-05
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
One aspect of the present invention is directed to a method for detecting acute Borna Disease Virus (BDV) infections. According to the invention, the presence of heterodimers of p24 BDV phosphoprotein and p40 BDV nucleoprotein in a sample is determined by means of antibodies of both proteins using a sandwich ELISA. The invention also relates to a diagnostic kit for a sandwich ELISA for detecting mute BDV infections. Said kit uses a antibody of p24 BDV phosphoprotein and a second primary antibody of p40 BDV nucleoprotein, at least one reporter-molecule-labelled secondary antibody, means for immobilising a primary antibody on a surface, and instructions for carrying out the method according to the invention. The invention also relates to the combination of the method according to the invention and the new diagnostic kit with known methods for detecting circulating immune complexes (CIC) and antibodies. Acute BDV infections are thus distinguished from chronic and latent ones (humans and animals), allowing, for example, differential diagnosis and treatment monitoring for diseased individuals but also the identification of health risks depending on infection status in healthy carriers.
Claims
1. A method for detecting acute Borna disease virus (BDV) infections, comprising: the step of determining a presence of heterodimers composed of phosphorylated p24 BDV phosphoprotein and p40 BDV nucleoprotein in a sample using a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), wherein a first primary antibody is present in an immobilized state and is incubated with the sample, wherein a second primary antibody is added in a non-immobilized state after incubation of the sample with the first antibody, wherein either the first primary antibody is directed against a phosphorylated p24 BDV phosphoprotein and the second primary antibody is directed against a p40 BDV nucleoprotein and/or wherein the first primary antibody and the second primary antibody are monoclonal antibodies.
2. The method as claimed in claim 1 wherein the immobilized first primary antibody is present in an immobilized state on a surface via a first secondary antibody or is directly immobilized on the surface.
3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the non-immobilized primary second antibody is identified using a second secondary antibody comprising a reporter molecule.
4. The method as claimed in claim 1 wherein the first primary antibody and the second primary antibody originate from different species.
5. The method as claimed in claim 1 wherein the first primary antibody is present in an immobilized state directly on a surface or via a first secondary antibody on the surface, wherein the non-immobilized primary second antibody is identified using a second secondary antibody comprising a reporter molecule, wherein the first and second secondary antibodies are from different species or originate from the same species.
6. The method as claimed in claim 1 further comprising detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto.
7. The method as claimed in claim 1 further comprising detecting circulating free antibodies against p24 protein and/or the p40 protein.
8. A diagnostic kit for a sandwich ELISA for detecting acute BDV infections, comprising: a first primary antibody and a second primary antibody, a first of said first and second primary antibodies being directed against the phosphorylated p24 BDV phosphoprotein and a second of said first and second primary antibodies being directed against the p40 BDV nucleoprotein; at least one secondary antibody labeled with a reporter molecule; optionally means for immobilizing a primary antibody on a surface; and instructions for carrying out a method as claimed in claim 1.
9. The diagnostic kit for a sandwich ELISA for detecting acute BDV infections as claimed in claim 8 wherein the first primary antibody is present in an immobilized state directly on a surface or via a first secondary antibody on the surface, wherein the nonimmobilized primary second antibody is identified using a second secondary antibody comprising a reporter molecule, wherein the first and second secondary antibodies are from different species or originate from the same species.
10. The diagnostic kit as claimed in claim 8, further comprising means for detecting CIC composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto.
11. The diagnostic kit as claimed in claim 8, further comprising means for detecting circulating free antibodies against the p24 protein and/or p40 protein in the plasma/serum.
12. The method as claimed in claim 1 wherein p40 BDV nucleoprotein epitopes recognized by said second primary antibody do not overlap with a BDV phosphoprotein binding domain on the BDV nucleoprotein.
13. The method of claim 6 wherein the CIC BDV antigens include all or a portion of p24 protein and/or p40 protein.
14. A method for determining a prevalence of BDV infection differentiating acute, chronic, and latent states in an epidemiological study of a population's mental and/or physical health comprising performing the method of claim 1 on a plurality of different samples drawn from the population; detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto in the samples; and detecting circulating free antibodies against p24 protein and/or the p40 protein in the samples, wherein presence of the heterodimers is indicative of an acute BDV infection, wherein absence of the heterodimers and presence of the CIC is indicative of a chronic BDV infection, and wherein absence of the heterodimers and the CIC and presence of the circulating free antibodies is indicative of a latent BDV infection.
15. A method for diagnosing BDV infection differentiating acute, chronic, and latent states in a patient with a psychiatric and/or neurological disorder comprising performing the method of claim 1 on a sample taken from the patient; detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto in the sample; and detecting circulating free antibodies against p24 protein and/or the p40 protein in the sample, wherein presence of the heterodimers is indicative of an acute BDV infection, wherein absence of the heterodimers and presence of the CIC is indicative of a chronic BDV infection, and wherein absence of the heterodimers and the CIC and presence of the circulating free antibodies is indicative of a latent BDV infection.
16. A method for monitoring the course of a BDV infection in a patient comprising periodically differentiating acute, chronic, and latent states by performing the method of claim 1 on samples obtained from the patient at different time periods; detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto in the samples; and detecting circulating free antibodies against p24 protein and/or the p40 protein in the samples, wherein presence of the heterodimers is indicative of an acute BDV infection, wherein absence of the heterodimers and presence of the CIC is indicative of a chronic BDV infection, and wherein absence of the heterodimers and the CIC and presence of the circulating free antibodies is indicative of a latent BDV infection.
17. A method for differential diagnosis of acute BDV infections from chronic and latent infections comprising performing the method of claim 1 on a sample of a patient and comparing results obtained to standards for chronic and latent infections, wherein the standards are obtained by detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) composed of BDV antigens and specific antibodies attached thereto in the sample; and detecting circulating free antibodies against p24 protein and/or the p40 protein in the sample wherein presence of the heterodimers is indicative of an acute BDV infection, wherein absence of the heterodimers and presence of the CIC is indicative of a chronic BDV infection, and wherein absence of the heterodimers and the CIC and presence of the circulating free antibodies is indicative of a latent BDV infection.
Description
DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9) The invention will be further elucidated with the aid of examples without being restricted thereto.
EXAMPLES
(10) Isolated blood samples from individuals showing a BDV infection are provided, the status of the infection being acute, chronic or latent or no infection being present.
(11) TABLE-US-00001 Table of medical personnel from Chongqing study Antigen Code Medical heterodimers CIC Antibody Infection Sample personnel (MP) Sex Age Diluted 1:10 Diluted 1:20 Diluted 1:100 status E3875 No details female 50 0.066 0.055 none E4064 Administration male 51 0.073 0.027 none E3728 Ophthalmology female 29 0.059 0.033 none E3667 Gastroenterology male 28 0.074 0.067 none E3977 Infection department female 48 0.076 0.2835 chronic E4173 Breast surgery female 47 0.0815 0.2625 chronic E4272 Surgical preparation female 49 0.0605 0.6325 chronic E3731 Ophthalmology female 52 0.044 0.607 0.183 chronic E3693 Heart surgery female 59 0.0755 0.587 0.237 chronic E3838 No details female 26 0.142 0.8975 acute E3727 Ophthalmology female 55 0.029 0.155 chronic E4265 Experimental research female 41 0.2455 0.173 0.044 acute E3630 Retired female 35 0.214 0.1305 0.097 acute E4113 Rehabilitation male 81 0.166 0.306 acute E4278 Surgical preparation male 29 0.236 0.715 acute E4123 Rehabilitation male 30 0.2195 0.366 acute E3968 Positive control MP male 57 1.9835 0.3675 0.3025 acute Student Negative control 0.0495 0.068 none Assessment of the assay results (standard for all BDV EIA assays) Cut-off = 0.100. Negative <= 0.1; borderline > 0.1-0.12; (+) weakly positive > 0.12-0.15; 1+ positive > 0.15-0.3 2+ positive > 0.3-0.6; 3+ positive > 0.6-1.0; 4+ positive > 1.0.
The samples come from a large study which had been carried out in a university hospital in Chongqing, China, using the CIC assay and additionally the antibody assay and a real-time RT-PCR (Liu et al. 2015). The assays were carried out using the antibodies W1 and Kfu 2 that were used in DE 197 58 017 C2. In said assays, W1 is the primary antibody directed against the P40 BDV nucleoprotein and Kfu 2 is the primary antibody directed against phosphorylated P protein P24 phosphoprotein of BDV. The assay set-up for the CIC detection and for the antibody detection follow the respective schemas in
The assay set-up of the method according to the invention for antigen detection (heterodimers) follows the schema in
(12) Material of Method According to the Invention:
(13) AffiniPure goat anti-mouse IgG1, Fc fragment-specific antibodies (concentration 1.3 mg of antibody per ml), minimal cross-reaction with human, bovine and leporine serum proteins (code number 115-005-205, Jackson ImmunoResearch).
(14) Biotin-SP-conjugated AffiniPure goat anti-mouse IgG2a, Fc fragment-specific antibodies, minimal cross-reaction with human, bovine and leporine serum proteins (code number 115-065-206, Jackson ImmunoResearch).
(15) Alkaline phosphatase-conjugated streptavidin (code number 016-050-084, Jackson ImmunoResearch).
(16) Alkaline phosphatase substrate kit (code number 172-1063, Biorad) or individual substances for substrate buffer and substrate (Bode et al., 2001) as follows:
(17) Substrate buffer, diethanolamine buffer pH 9.8 (diethanolamine 1.007 M+MgCl.sub.2.6H.sub.2O 0.5 mM+NaN.sub.3 0.003 M);
(18) Substrate, p-nitrophenyl phosphate hexahydrate (pNPP.6 H.sub.2O) (0.003 M); 5 mg tablets (code number N9389 Sigma Aldrich); always prepare fresh in the assay, 1 mg of pNPP per ml of substrate buffer.
(19) Conjugate buffer (alkaline phosphatase) TBS-Tween pH 8.0 (TRIS 0.02 M+NaCl 0.14 M+KCl 0.003 M+0.05% Tween 20).
(20) Wash buffer, NaCl-Tween (0.9% NaCl+0.05% Tween 20+NaN3 0.003 M).
(21) Sample dilution buffer (also for steps 2, 4 and 5 in
(22) PBS-Tween pH 7.2 (KH.sub.2PO.sub.4 0.0015 M+Na.sub.2HPO.sub.4.12 H.sub.2O 0.008 M+NaCl 0.14 M+KCl 0.003 M+0.05% Tween 20+NaN.sub.3 0.003 M).
(23) Coating buffer, 0.01 M sodium phosphate/0.25 M NaCl pH 7.6 (NaH.sub.2PO.sub.4.2 H.sub.2O 0.02 M [stock A], Na.sub.2HPO.sub.4 0.02 M [stock B]; coating buffer contains 65 ml of stock A+435 ml of stock B+0.25 M NaCl in 1000 ml of double-distilled water).
(24) Stop solution, 3 M NaOH
(25) All chemical substances with degree of purity as specified by American Chemical Society (ACS grade), preferably by Sigma Aldrich.
(26) Nunc-Immuno 96-well microtiter plates for ELISA, MaxiSorp, F (flat bottom) (code number 442404, Nunc).
(27) BDV-Specific Key Reagents
(28) W1 (mouse subclass IgG2a) specifically directed against the nuclear BDV protein (N protein);
(29) Kfu2 (mouse subclass IgG1) specifically directed against the BDV phosphoprotein (P protein);
(30) W1 and Kfu2 are monoclonal mouse antibodies, first described by Ludwig et al., 1993.
(31) The inventors have hybridoma supernatants of these two antibodies, which were already produced and which are suitable for assay kit production on an industrial scale. The inventors also have hybridoma cells which allow unlimited production of further batches of the monoclonal antibodies W1 and Kfu2.
Further characterization of W1 and Kfu2 (Bode, 2008)
(32) TABLE-US-00002 Short description W1 Species Mouse Subclone TL9 IgG subclass IgG 2a Specificity N protein p40 of BDV (reference strain V) Dissociation constant (K.sub.D) 2.31 × 10.sup.−9 +− 0.26 × 10.sup.−9M (native N protein) Epitope type Conformational epitope (discontinuous) Hybridoma supernatant 1:500 usage dilution in BDV ELISAs (=ready-to-use) Recognition of recombinant (r) Yes (assay with earlier antigen ELISA) N protein Purified rN detection limit 1.5-3 nanograms per mL Kfu2 Species Mouse Subclone 57-4-33 IgG subclass IgG 1 Specificity P protein p24 of BDV (reference strain V) Dissociation constant (K.sub.D) 3.33 × 10.sup.−9 +− 0.34 × 10.sup.−9M (native P protein) Epitope type Conformational epitope (discontinuous) Hybridoma supernatant 1:500 usage dilution in BDV ELISAs (=ready-to-use) Recognition of recombinant (r) No (assay with earlier antigen ELISA) P protein, nonphosphorylated Recognition of rP, Yes (assay with earlier antigen ELISA) phosphorylated in vitro
First Description of the Epitope Sequences of W1 and Kfu2
(33) TABLE-US-00003 Epitope on N protein p40 of BDV SEQ ID No. W1 Epitope type Conformational epitope (discontinuous) Number of binding sites Five on 5mer peptides (N1-N5) in each case N1 3 Amino acid sequence 32_KFLQY_36 N2 4 Amino acid sequence 116_AKFYG_120 N3 5 Amino acid sequence 168_TMMAA_172 N4 6 Amino acid sequence 294_LAPRS_298 N5 7 Amino acid sequence 307_FYWSK_311
See also
(34) TABLE-US-00004 Epitope on P protein p24 of BDV SEQ ID No. Kfu2 Epitope type Conformational epitope (discontinuous) Number of binding sites Three (15mer, 12mer, 5mer peptides), P1-P3 P1, main domain, 8 Amino acid sequence phosphorylation site serine 22_RRERSGSPRPRKVPR-36 26/28 P2 9 Amino acid sequence 46_LLKDLRKNPSMI_57 P3 10 Amino acid sequence 142_DRSMK_146
See also
Protocol of Method According to the Invention:
(35) 100 μl each of a 1:1000 dilution of the goat anti-mouse IgG1 secondary antibody diluted with coating buffer are pipetted into the MaxiSorp F microtiter plates and incubated at 37° for one hour. Thereafter, three wash cycles are carried out with the wash buffer (120 ml total). Afterwards, the monoclonal antibody Kfu2 in a dilution of 1:500 (hybridoma supernatant) in PBS-Tween is incubated, at 100 μl per well, at 37° C. for one hour, followed by three wash cycles with the wash buffer. The samples (diluted 1:10 with PBS-Tween) are pipetted, at 100 μl each per well, into the microtiter plate and incubated at 37° C. for one hour, followed by three wash cycles with wash buffer. Thereafter, the monoclonal antibody W1 in a dilution of 1:500 as hybridoma supernatant diluted in PBS-Tween is added at 100 μl per well, incubated at 37° C. for one hour, followed by three wash cycles. Thereafter, the goat anti-mouse IgG2a secondary antibody labeled with biotin in a dilution of 1:1000 in PBS-Tween is added in an amount of 100 μl per well, incubated at 37° C. for one hour and subsequently washed with three wash cycles.
(36) Then, the alkaline phosphatase-labeled streptavidin, diluted 1:1000 in conjugate buffer TBS-Tween pH 8.0, is added in an amount of 100 μl per well and incubated at 37° C. for 30 min. This is followed by again three wash cycles with wash buffer.
(37) Thereafter, the detection reaction takes place with p-nitrophenyl phosphate (1 mg/ml) p-NPP in substrate buffer pH 9.8. 100 μl each of the corresponding p-NPP solution are added, followed by an incubation at room temperature for 2.5 minutes. Note: continuous visual monitoring is necessary, the negative control must remain colorless, whereas the positive control changes color. The color reaction is stopped by addition of the stop solution (3 M NaOH) at 50 μl each per well. The absorbance is immediately determined at 405 nm using a suitable multichannel photometer. “Blank” measurement against unconverted substrate.
(38) CIC Determination as Per the Methods Described in DE 19758017 C2
(39) CIC determination in the samples was carried out as per the methods described in DE 19758017 C2 (see above schema in
(40) In the description of the materials, the code numbers are added below: AffiniPure goat anti-mouse IgG, Fc fragment-specific antibodies (code No. 115-005-071; Jackson ImmunoResearch).
(41) Alkaline phosphatase-conjugated AffiniPure goat anti-human IgG, Fc fragment-specific antibodies, minimal cross-reaction with bovine, equine and murine serum proteins (code No. 109-055-098; Jackson ImmunoResearch) for human samples.
(42) Alkaline phosphatase-conjugated AffiniPure goat anti-horse IgG, Fc fragment-specific antibodies (code No. 108-055-008; Jackson ImmunoResearch) for horse samples. Key reagents W1 and Kfu2, substrate kit or substrate buffer and substrate tablets, buffer and Nunc MaxiSorp F ELISA plates as described above for the new invention.
Antibody Determination in Plasma/Serum as Per the Methods Described in DE 19758017 C2
(43) The determination of the antibodies against the p24 protein and/or p40 protein in plasma/serum samples was in principle carried out as per the method described in DE 19758017 C2 (see above scheme in
(44) To carry out the BDV antibody EIA described in DE 19758017 C2, detection antigen from BDV-infected cells is required. The usage dilution of the detection antigens from infected cell cultures is, depending on the batch, between 1:100 and 1:300.
(45) A human oligodendroglial cell line (OLIGO/TL) persistently infected with BDV strain V (Briese et al., 1994) that allows the unlimited production of detection antigen was deposited at the German Collection of Microorganisms and Cell Cultures (DSMZ) in Braunschweig on 12 Dec. 1997 under No. DSM ACC2334.
(46) For the description of the remaining materials, see the CIC assay.
(47) Results:
(48)
(49)
(50) Samples E3727 and E3731 were negative in both antigen assays, even at the dilution of 1:2 in the case of the prior antigen assay. Both samples originate from the physician/nurse team in the eye care department of the hospital. However, the combination with the CIC assay shows that both were chronically infected with BDV (see the table). Team member E3731 had high CIC values and additionally antibodies, indicating an acute bout of virus that had recently taken place.
(51) In the case of samples E4265 and E3630, who were positive only with the new assay at 1:10 sample dilution, it should be emphasized that the prior assay, even at its sample dilution of 1:2 that is five times lower as standard, was not capable or not unambiguously capable of detecting BDV antigens. The assay according to the invention thus had at least a five-times higher sensitivity than the prior assay and was able to demonstrate that the medical coworkers (E4265 female, research; E3630 female, retired) went through an acute BDV infection at the sampling time point. If only the prior antigen assay had been available, the diagnosis “chronic infection” would have had to been made on the basis of the simultaneous detection of CIC, and the acute exposure would have been overlooked (see the table).
(52) Results of the combined use of the antigen assay according to the invention with the CIC assay and the antibody (Ab) assay as per DE 19758017 C2 are shown by
(53)
(54) The sample panel of medical personnel for which there was no mental disorders according to a structured interview, neither earlier nor currently, was chosen in order to show that the assay according to the invention, alone and in combination with CIC assay and antibody assay, is, independently of clinical symptoms, capable of differentiating between acute, chronic and latent infections and of excluding a BDV infection with analysis of a single blood sample. Chronic stress is common in everyday life in the medical sector, and so an increased activation risk does not appear unusual. In addition, there is an increased infection risk in the daily care of sick people.
(55) The volume of 100 μl for the prior antigen assay, with initial 1:2 dilution and subsequent dilution series, which volume is distinctly higher in comparison with the antigen assay according to the invention, was only available for selective parallel tests, as shown in
(56) The advantages of the new method according to the invention for antigen detection are also multifarious and practical without direct comparison.
(57) Firstly, what is possible is a broad applicability for a very wide variety of different sample materials, i.e., for any type of body fluid or tissue fluid. BDV activity is measured independently of the host species. Furthermore, the determination of the phosphorylated heterodimers composed of p24 and p40 allows the verification of acute BDV infections, since the primary antibody Kfu2 only binds the active phosphorylated form of the BDV P protein. For the monoclonal antibody Kfu2 used here, this is globally a unique feature.
(58) In contrast to the assay described in DE 19758017 C2, what is presently determined is the heterodimer. In contrast, the prior method is based on two capture antibodies, i.e., immobilized primary antibodies against both p24 and p40, being used in order to also determine monomeric forms thereof. Accordingly, however, it was not possible to differentiate the present phosphorylated heterodimers therewith. In one embodiment, the method according to the invention uses, in addition, secondary antibodies which allow a high level of reproducibility. In the embodiment with the binding pair biotinstreptavidin coupled to an enzyme such as alkaline phosphatase, a signal enhancement and thus improved detectability is achieved compared to the prior visualization of the signal solely via enzyme-labeled anti-antibodies. Furthermore, significantly less patient sample (10 μl for one-time determination, 20 μl for dilution series from 1:10) is required, and the sensitivity of the method is higher according to the five-times higher initial dilution of the sample of 1:10. This became especially apparent by it being possible to identify an acute BDV infection in more individuals than with the prior antigen assay.
(59) The present invention provides a completely new assay method for acute BDV infections that has a higher sensitivity than the prior antigen assay and is independent of limited resources, as represented by rabbit antibodies for example. By combination with CIC assay and antibody assay, the new method is capable of reliably distinguishing between acute, chronic and latent infections (humans and animals) and of thereby raising BDV diagnostics to a hitherto unreached level of informative value with a high standard of quality.
(60) The method according to the invention is therefore suitable especially for diagnosis, but also for course monitoring of a BDV infection, especially also for determination of the therapy plan. Furthermore, the method according to the invention can be part of a treatment method.
(61) The previously unpublished amino acid sequences of the binding sites which form the respective conformational epitopes are named for the first time here. They are essential molecular constituents of the properties of the monoclonal antibodies W1 and Kfu2.
(62) The present invention provides a completely new assay method for acute BDV infections that is independent of limited resources and can be used in humans and animals in an overarching manner as regards species. By combination of the new diagnostic kit with the use of known methods or kits for detecting circulating immunocomplexes (CIC) and antibodies in the plasma or serum, the new method is capable of reliably distinguishing between acute, chronic and latent infections (humans and animals) and of reaching a hitherto unreached level of informative value in BDV diagnostics.
CITED LITERATURE (IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER)
(63) Berg M, et al., J Gen Virol. 1998; 79 (Pt 12):2957-2963. Bode L. Human Bornavirus infection towards a valid diagnostic system. APMIS Suppl 124, 2008; 116: 21-39. Bode L, et al. The Lancet 1997; 349: 178-179. Bode L, et al. Mol Psychiatry 1996; 1: 200-212. Bode L, Ludwig H. Borna disease virus infection, a human mental-health risk. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2003; 16(3):534-545. Review. Bode L, et al. Mol Psychiatry 2001; 6: 481-491. Briese T, et al. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1994; 91(10):4362-4366. Cubitt B, et al. J Virol. 1994; 68(3):1382-1396. Dietrich D E, Bode L. Human Borna disease virus infection and its therapy in affective disorders. APMIS Suppl 124, 2008; 116: 61-65. Dietrich D E, et al. Bipolar Disorder 2000; 2: 65-70. Ferszt R, et al. Pharmacopsychiatry 1999; 32 (4):142-147 Liu X, et al. Virol J. 2015; 12: 39. Ludwig H, et al. Arch Virol 1993; Suppl 7:111-133. Rudolph M, et al. Structure 2003; 11: 1219-1226. Schwemmle M, et al. J Biol Chem. 1997; 272(35):21818-21823