METHOD FOR ESTIMATING A DOSE RATE ON THE BASIS OF A SPECTRAL IMAGE
20210165112 · 2021-06-03
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
A method for estimating a dose rate, on the basis of measurements taken by a gamma camera (2), the gamma camera defining an observation field (Ω), the estimated dose rate originates from irradiating sources (10.sub.a, 10.sub.b) located in the observation field, the irradiating sources emitting ionizing electromagnetic radiation; the observation field is discretized into a mesh; the gamma camera (2) comprises pixels (2.sub.j), each pixel being configured to detect the ionizing electromagnetic radiation, during an acquisition time, and to form an energy spectrum therefrom, each pixel being associated with at least one point of the mesh, such that together the pixels allow a position of the irradiating sources in the observation field to be obtained in one energy band or in a plurality of energy bands; the method comprising estimating a dose rate generated, at the gamma camera, by points of the mesh.
Claims
1. A method for estimating a dose rate, on the basis of measurements taken by a gamma camera, the gamma camera defining an observation field, wherein: the estimated dose rate originates from irradiating sources located in the observation field, the irradiating sources emitting ionizing electromagnetic radiation; the observation field is discretized into a mesh; the gamma camera comprises pixels, each pixel being configured to detect the ionizing electromagnetic radiation, during an acquisition time, and to form an energy spectrum therefrom, each pixel being associated with at least one point of the mesh, such that the pixels allow a position of the irradiating sources in the observation field to be obtained in one energy band or in a plurality of energy bands; the method comprising: a) acquiring spectra with the pixels; b) taking into account an emission spectrum, the emission spectrum being defined in one or more energy bands; c) selecting points of the mesh; d) on the basis of the spectra acquired by each pixel, estimating a spatial distribution of an activity, corresponding to the emission spectrum taken into account in b), for the selected points of the mesh; e) in each energy band of the emission spectrum, taking into account a pre-established conversion function relating a dose rate to a photon flux detected by the gamma camera; f) on the basis of the conversion function resulting from e), and of the spatial distribution of activity determined in d), estimating a dose rate generated, at the gamma camera, by the points selected in c).
2. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein: b) comprises taking into account an isotope, or a set of isotopes, potentially present in the observation field, the emission spectrum corresponding to the emission spectrum of the isotope or to the emission spectrum of the set of isotopes; d) comprises estimating a spatial distribution of an activity of the isotope or of the set of isotopes in the observation field.
3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein, in b), the emission spectrum taken into account comprises a single energy band.
4. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein d) comprise taking into account a spatial model associated with each pixel of the image, the spatial model defining a probability that a photon emitted by each point of the mesh is detected by the pixel with which the spatial model is associated.
5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein, in d), the spatial distribution of the activity corresponds to a distribution of the activity over an object surface.
6. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the conversion function is estimated by simulation.
7. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the conversion function is estimated by exposing at least one pixel of the gamma camera to a calibration irradiating source, such that the dose rate to which the pixel is exposed is known.
8. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein d) comprises, in each energy band of the emission spectrum, and for each pixel: estimating a photon flux detected by the pixel in the energy band, depending on a spatial distribution of the activity of the selected points of the mesh; on the basis of the spectrum detected by the pixel, determining, in the energy band, the photon flux detected by the pixel; wherein d) further comprises, in each energy band, and for each pixel, minimizing a discrepancy between the estimated photon flux and the measured photon flux.
9. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the gamma camera is associated with a rangefinder, for measuring a distance between the gamma camera and the observed scene, and wherein the method comprises, following f): g) measuring a distance between the gamma camera and at least one point of the observation field; h) using the distance measured in g) and the spatial distribution of activity estimated in d), estimating a dose rate generated, by the spatial distribution of the activity estimated in d), in a position different from the position occupied by the gamma camera.
10. The method as claimed in claim 9, wherein h) takes into account the dose rate estimated in f).
11. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the base rate estimated in f) is an equivalent dose rate.
12. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein c) comprises selecting all or some of the points of the mesh of the observation field.
13. A measuring device, comprising: a gamma camera comprising pixels, each pixel being configured to detect ionizing electromagnetic radiation, emitted by at least one irradiating source located in an observation field of the gamma camera, during an acquisition time, and to form an energy spectrum therefrom, each pixel being associated with at least one point of the mesh of the observation field, such that together the pixels allow a spatial distribution of each irradiating source in the observation field to be obtained in one energy band or in a plurality of energy bands; a processing unit, configured to: receive spectra acquired by a plurality of pixels of the gamma camera; implement at least b) to f) of a method as claimed in claim 1 on the basis of the acquired spectra.
Description
FIGURES
[0048]
[0049]
[0050]
[0051]
[0052]
[0053]
[0054]
[0055]
[0056]
[0057]
DESCRIPTION OF PARTICULAR EMBODIMENTS
[0058]
[0059] The gamma camera comprises pixels 2.sub.j, each pixel corresponding to an elementary spatial region of the observation field. Pixels are shown in
[0060] Generally, the pixels 2.sub.j are coplanar and distributed in a two-dimensional matrix array, preferably regularly. The matrix array may for example comprise 512×512 pixels, or even more. Each pixel 2.sub.j is an elementary radiation detector.
[0061] The gamma imager may be a Compton gamma camera, a pinhole-collimator gamma camera or coded-aperture gamma camera. It may also be a question, non-exhaustively, of a gamma camera the collimator of which comprises parallel channels, or convergent channels, or divergent channels. Thus, the term gamma camera corresponds to an imager having an observation field and configured to form an image allowing irradiating sources to be located in the irradiation field. Whatever the type of gamma imager, it allows a gamma image comprising pixels, each pixel corresponding to one elementary spatial region of the observation field, to be formed. The observation field Ω may be discretized at coordinates (x,y) into a mesh. Each pixel may thus be associated with one or more points of the mesh. When a Compton gamma camera is being used, the correspondence between pixels and points of the mesh varies depending on the detected interactions.
[0062] Preferably, each pixel 2.sub.j performs a spectrometric function, in the sense that it allows the radiation detected, during an acquisition time, to be separated spectrally into various spectral bands, or energy bands. When this type of pixel is used, it is possible to form various gamma images of a given observation field, each image corresponding to one energy band (denoted E.sub.i). The width dE.sub.i in each energy band E.sub.i is variable and depends on the performance of the pixels in terms of energy resolution. The width of each energy band may be about 1 keV, or a few keV, or a few tens of keV.
[0063] The acquisition time T of a spectrum, by each pixel, depends on the photon flux to which the pixel is exposed. It may be a few tens of ms, or a few seconds, and may last several minutes, or even several hours. The gamma spectrum acquired by each pixel may then comprise intensity peaks corresponding to emission intensities of known isotopes.
[0064] It is known that an emission spectrum S.sub.k is associated with each isotope k. Such an emission spectrum corresponds to a histogram of the emission rate as a function of energy. By emission rate, what is meant is an emitted number of photons corresponding to a unit activity of the isotope. Generally, the unit activity is 1 Bq. Thus, the emission spectrum corresponds to a number of photons emitted, in each energy band E.sub.i for the unit activity in question, in the present case 1 Bq.
[0065] A gamma image may be established by considering a combination of spectral bands, which correspond to the emission spectrum S.sub.k of an isotope. The combination may be a weighted sum. The image is then representative of a spatial distribution of the activity of the isotope in question.
[0066] In the example schematically shown in
[0067] With certain gamma imagers, in particular Compton gamma cameras or coded-aperture gamma cameras, the image acquired by the imager does not allow the irradiating sources in the observation field to be viewed directly. The acquired image undergoes processing, taking into account a response function of the camera, so as to allow a gamma image in which the intensity of each pixel corresponds to a flux of detected photons, originating from each point of the mesh, to be obtained in each energy band.
[0068] A processing unit 4 receives the spectra acquired by each pixel 2.sub.j of the gamma camera 2. The image-processing unit is notably configured to perform the operations described with reference to
[0069] The observation field Q is meshed, in such a way as to be discretized into points. Since the observation field is not known a priori, it may be likened to a virtual object surface P.sub.O on which each observation point has coordinates (x,y). An important element of the invention is that the points of the object frame of reference are considered to belong to the same object surface P.sub.O.
[0070] According to a first approach, which is simple to implement, the object surface P.sub.O is a planar surface. The angular observation field Ω of the gamma camera, which extends about the optical axis Δ, describes a segment of a sphere S (see
[0071] Each pixel of the gamma camera is characterized by a spatial response function and a spectral response function.
[0072] A spatial response function B.sub.j(x, y) is established for each pixel 2.sub.j. The spatial response function corresponds to a probability that a photon, emitted by a point (x, y) of the observation field, is detected by the pixel 2.sub.j. Thus, each pixel 2.sub.j has a spatial response function B.sub.j(x,y) established for all or some of the points (x, y) of the observation field Ω. The spatial model may be established analytically or by modelling. The spatial response function may be established for an isotope k, in which case it is denoted B.sub.j,k(x, y). It quantifies a probability that a photon, emitted by an isotope k, at a point (x, y) of the observation field, is detected by the pixel 2.sub.j.
[0073]
[0074] The spatial model may also be determined for a preset isotope. In this case, the spatial model takes into account the emission energies and their respective branching ratios. The spatial model then allows a probability of presence of the isotope to be established.
[0075]
[0076] Below, the response matrix is considered to be identical for each pixel, and it is denoted A.
[0077] Each row A(E.sub.p,.) of the matrix, such as shown in
[0078] The main steps of a method for estimating a dose rate produced by one or more irradiating sources located in the observation field of a gamma camera will now be described with reference to
[0079] Step 100: Acquiring a Spectral Image M.
[0080] In this step, a spectral image M is acquired, for an acquisition time that is sufficient to allow exploitable spectra to be obtained by the pixels 2.sub.j of the camera. The spectral image M is composed of spectra M.sub.j, each spectrum being acquired by one pixel 2.sub.j during an acquisition period. Each spectrum M.sub.j comprises photon flux M.sub.i,j, detected in energy bands E.sub.i The flux M.sub.i,j is the number of photons detected by the pixel 2.sub.j in an energy band E.sub.i per unit time.
[0081] Step 110: Selecting one or more energy bands, forming an emission spectrum S.sub.k. In this step, for various pixels 2.sub.j, one or more energy bands are selected. This selection may be made beforehand. This is notably the case when the isotope or isotopes liable to be present in the observation field is/are known beforehand. It is conventional to base the selection on a list containing about ten or a few tens of potentially present gamma-emitting isotopes, the respective emission spectra of which are known. In certain nuclear installations, the list may contain only a few isotopes, considered to be preponderant, or even a single isotope. Below, each isotope is represented by an integer k, comprised between 1 and K.Math.K is the number of potential isotopes. As indicated above, each isotope k is associated with an emission spectrum S.sub.k. The emission spectrum of an isotope comprises emission energies (the latter being discretized) and the branching ratio associated with each energy. The branching ratio corresponds to an emission probability.
[0082] According to one alternative, a plurality of isotopes may be selected, and an emission spectrum formed from a combination of the emission spectra of each isotope. The combination is for example a weighted sum. It is thus possible to form an emission spectrum comprising a predefined mixture of isotopes.
[0083] According to one possibility, the emission spectrum comprises only a single energy (for example 661.66 keV when .sup.137Cs is of interest), or a plurality of discrete energy bands (for example 1173 keV and 1332 keV when .sup.60Co is of interest).
[0084] Step 120: Determining the Flux Detected in Each Energy Band.
[0085] In this step, for each pixel 2.sub.j, the photon flux M.sub.i,j detected in each energy band E.sub.i selected in step 110 is determined. The flux M.sub.i,j corresponds to the number of photons detected in the energy band E.sub.i per unit time.
[0086] Step 130: Modelling the Detected Flux
[0087] In this step, a photon flux {circumflex over (M)}.sub.i,j that would be detected by each pixel 2.sub.j if each isotope k on the object surface P.sub.O had an apparent activity O.sub.k(x, y) is modelled. The apparent activity O.sub.k(x,y) corresponds to an activity of the isotope when each point of the observation field is considered to belong to the object surface P.sub.O. It will be recalled that the activity of an isotope corresponds to a number of disintegrations per second. Depending on the apparent activity O.sub.k(x, y), the flux {circumflex over (M)}.sub.i,j detected by each pixel 2.sub.j, in an energy band E.sub.i, is such that:
[0088] where: [0089] x is an elementwise product (Hadamard product); [0090] A.sub.i(E) is a vector of (1,I) size, corresponding to a column of the matrix A for energy channel i; [0091] S.sub.k(E) is the emission spectrum of the isotope k, discretized into I energy bands; it takes the form of a vector of (1,I) size; [0092] B.sub.j,k(x, y) is a spatial response function associated with the pixel 2.sub.j of an isotope k; it is a matrix of (X, Y) size, where X and Y are the dimensions of the observation surface P.sub.O discretized into coordinates (x, y), [0093] O.sub.k(x,y) is a spatial distribution of the apparent surface activity. It is a matrix of (X, Y) size;
[0094] {circumflex over (M)}.sub.i,j is a scalar quantity. It will be noted that expression (1) comprises a sum over each isotope k in question.
[0095] The contribution {circumflex over (m)}.sub.k,i,j of the isotope k in the energy band E.sub.i within pixel 2.sub.j is such that
[0096] Step 140: Determining the Apparent Activity
[0097] In step 140, in each energy band E.sub.1, and for each pixel 2.sub.j, the flux M.sub.i,j detected in step 120 is compared with the flux {circumflex over (M)}.sub.i,j modelled in step 130. It is a question of finding, for each isotope k in question, the matrix O.sub.k(x, y) that minimizes an error, for example a squared error, between M.sub.i,j and {circumflex over (M)}.sub.i,j.
[0098] Thus,
[0099] According to one preferred embodiment, the minimization may be of Poisson type, such that:
[0100] Such a minimization may be achieved using an MLEM algorithm (MLEM standing for Maximum Likelihood Expectation Maximization), such algorithms being known to those skilled in the art.
[0101] At the end of step 140, as many images O.sub.k(x, y) as there are isotopes in question will have been obtained.
[0102] When an isotope, .sup.60Co for example, has various emission lines, in various energy bands, the images O.sub.k(x, y) correspond to a spatial distribution of the activity of the isotope, which takes into account the emission spectrum S.sub.k of the isotope.
[0103] Step 150: Estimating the Dose Rate
[0104] In step 150, the dose rate is estimated for at least one isotope k, or even for each isotope k for which a significant apparent activity O.sub.k (x, y) has been detected at at least one point (x,y) of the mesh.
[0105] The dose rate generated by the isotope k on the pixels of the gamma camera is such that:
[0106] This may also be written:
[0107] The scalar D.sub.i is the value, in the energy band E.sub.i, of a conversion function D that converts the photon flux in the dose rate. The conversion function D is established in each energy band E.sub.i in a calibrating step 90 described below.
[0108] .sub.k is the dose rate, conventionally expressed in Gy/h, or the equivalent dose rate, conventionally expressed in Sv/h, corresponding to the emission spectrum taken into account. The various dose rates
.sub.k, corresponding to various isotopes k or to various emission spectra S.sub.k, respectively, may be estimated and each of these dose rates summed.
[0109] Step 150 allows an estimation of the dose rate produced by all or some of the isotopes k within the observation field to be obtained. This functionality allows a distribution of the various isotopes in the observation field to be evaluated.
[0110] Steps 110 to 150 may be carried out for the entire observation field, or for certain points of the observation field. It may for example be a question of points selected by an operator, on the basis of the spectrum image acquired in step 100. It may for example be a question of a particular region of the observation field, comprising a particular irradiating source.
[0111] The method may also comprise the following steps.
[0112] Step 160: Estimating the Dose Rate Depending on Distance
[0113] The gamma camera may be associated with a rangefinder 3, so as to estimate a distance between the gamma camera and various points of the observation field. The rangefinder may be optical or acoustic or electromagnetic. The distance d.sub.O corresponds to the distance between the camera and the object surface P.sub.O.
[0114] It is then possible to estimate, simply, a dose rate at various distances. To this end, the estimation of the apparent activity O.sub.k(x,y), i.e. the activity on the object surface P.sub.O, is used as starting point. If x′ and y′ represent the coordinates of a measurement point parallel to the object surface P.sub.O and located at a distance d from the object surface, the dose rate, at this point, generated by an isotope k, may be estimated using the expression:
[0115] where c.sub.k is a factor that allows the distance to be taken into account, this factor being described below.
[0116] In the system of the coordinates x′ and y′, any point located on the optical axis of the camera has the coordinates (0, 0).
[0117] The factor that allows the distance to be taken into account is obtained via a measurement of the distance d.sub.O between the gamma camera and the object surface P.sub.O. The following is then obtained:
[0118] With .sub.k(0, 0, d.sub.o)=
.sub.k,
.sub.k being the dose rate resulting from step 150: see either of expressions (6) and (6′).
[0119] It will be understood that the obtainment of an apparent activity O.sub.k(x,y), as a result of step 140, allows a dose rate to be estimated for various points of the observation field at various distances with respect to the object plane. This however assumes knowledge of a distance d.sub.O between the gamma camera and the object surface, so as to be able to compute the factor c.sub.k that allows the distance to be taken into account.
[0120] In the embodiment described above, the object surface is considered to be a planar surface. Considering the irradiating sources to be distributed over such a surface makes it possible to avoid the need for a three-dimensional reconstruction of each irradiating source. It is therefore a simplifying assumption, avoiding the need for complex computing means. According to one variant, a measurement of a distance between the camera and a plurality of points of the observation field is available. This measurement may be obtained by a range finding sensor, a LIDAR sensor for example, performing a scan along the observation field. In this case, the object surface is then a non-planar surface. It is defined depending on the distance between the camera and the various points, of the mesh, for which a distance to the camera was determined.
[0121] The method described above assumes a prior calibration, so as to determine the conversion coefficient D.sub.i in a plurality of energy bands. This is the subject of step 90.
[0122] Step 90: Determining the Dose Rate-Photon Flux Conversion Function
[0123] The dose rate, at the energy E, is obtained using a conversion function that is obtained empirically:
[0124] The conversion function D(E) allows a conversion to be performed between a dose rate and a photon flux detected, at the energy E, by a pixel of the gamma camera.
[0125] The parameters β, α and E.sub.0 may be determined by simulation. [0126] β=3.5×10.sup.−11 (Sv/h)/(keV/s); [0127] α=0.45; [0128] E.sub.0=400 keV.
[0129] Since the parameters β, α and E.sub.0 are known, expression (9) allows a conversion function to be obtained for various energies.
[0130] The parameters of the conversion function D(E) may also be determined experimentally. This step is carried out by exposing the gamma camera to a calibration source, which generates a known emission spectrum. The irradiating source may for example be monoenergetic, though this condition is not absolutely necessary. The dose rate D.sub.i generated, at the camera, by the source, in an energy band E.sub.i, is well characterized.
[0131] It is possible to show that the dose rate to which each pixel of the gamma camera is exposed is:
[0132] where T is the acquisition time and S(E) is the spectrum acquired by a pixel during the acquisition time. θ is the set of parameters of the conversion function i.e. β, α and E.sub.0.
[0133] During the calibration, a number Q of acquisitions of spectra S.sub.q(E) are carried out using one or more pixels of the gamma camera. During each acquisition, the camera is exposed to a dose rate .sub.q which is known because the calibration source is known and the distance between the calibration source and the gamma camera is also known. Thus, for each acquisition, it is possible to write:
[0134] where T.sub.q is the acquisition time of each spectrum and D.sub.θ,q(E) is the conversion function given by expression (9) during each acquisition.
[0135] The parameters θ of the conversion function may be estimated by minimizing the discrepancy between D.sub.q and each integral
the latter being parameterized by the set of parameters θ. Thus, an error is minimized, between the dose rate to which the camera is actually exposed, and the estimation of this dose rate using the conversion function according to expression (9).
[0136] Thus
[0137] {circumflex over (θ)} is the estimation of the optimal parameters of the conversion function.
[0138] In expressions (6) and (6′), the coefficient D.sub.i is such that:
D.sub.i=D.sub.{circumflex over (θ)}(E.sub.i) (13)
[0139] {circumflex over (θ)} corresponds to the parameters of the conversion function, which are estimated either by modelling or by experimental calibration.
[0140]
[0141] Trials have been carried out using a gamma camera comprising CdZnTe pixels and using two point .sup.57Co sources.
[0142] On the basis of the measurement shown in
[0143] The invention is applicable to various nuclear installations, or, more generally, to operations of seeking for and characterizing radioactive sources.