METHOD FOR FORMING A LAYER OF SINGLE-PHASE OXIDE (FE, CR)2O3 WITH A RHOMBOHEDRAL STRUCTURE ON A STEEL OR SUPER ALLOY SUBSTRATE
20210010125 ยท 2021-01-14
Assignee
Inventors
- Olivier RACCURT (Grenoble Cedex 09, FR)
- Jean-Marie GENTZBITTEL (Grenoble Cedex 09, FR)
- Olivier SICARDY (Grenoble Cedex 09, FR)
- Francis BOURGUIGNON (Vitry-le-Francois, FR)
- Pierre-Jean MARCHAIS (Vitry-le-Francois, FR)
Cpc classification
F24S70/20
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Y02E10/40
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
F24S70/30
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
International classification
F24S70/20
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F24S20/20
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Abstract
The invention relates to a method for forming a layer of single-phase oxide (30) (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 with a rhombohedral structure on a steel or super alloy substrate (10), comprising the following successive steps: a) supplying a steel or super alloy substrate (10) covered with a surface layer, the steel comprising at least 2 wt.-% chromium; b) removing the surface layer in an atomsphere containing at least 0.2 atm dioxygen, creating a level of micro-deformation in the crystal lattice of the steel or super alloy that is greater than 1.0.10.sup.3, and a heating at a heating rate higher than 400 C./s, such as to form a layer of rhombohedral oxide (30) (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3, c) carrying out a thermal treatment, in the presence of air, at a water partial pressure of less than 10.000 ppm, and at a temperature varying between 400 C. and 1000 C., such as to grow the layer of rhombohedral oxide formed in step (b) to a thickness from 70 nm to 150 nm.
Claims
1-13. (canceled)
14. A method for forming a layer of single-phase oxide (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 with a rhombohedral structure on a steel or super alloy substrate, the method comprising: a) supplying a steel or super alloy substrate covered by a surface layer, the steel comprising at least 2% by weight of chromium; b) removing the surface to reach the substrate, using a subtraction step, under an atmosphere containing at least 0.2 atm of dioxygen, the subtraction step generating a level of microstrains in the steel or super alloy crystalline lattice larger than 1.010.sup.3 and local heating at a rate of more than 400 C./s, so as to form a single-phase rhombohedral oxide (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 layer; and c) performing a heat treatment under air at a partial water pressure of less than 10,000 ppm, and at a temperature varying from 400 C. to 1000 C., so as to make the single-phase rhombohedral oxide layer formed in the removing b) grow to a thickness from 70 nm to 150 nm.
15. The method according to claim 14, wherein the subtraction step in step b) is a mechanical subtraction done at a temperature from 10 C. to 400 C.
16. The method according to claim 14, wherein the subtraction step in step b) is a mechanical subtraction done at a temperature from 10 C. to 100 C.
17. The method according to claim 14, wherein a water content during step b) is less than 20,000 ppm.
18. The method according to claim 14, wherein a water content during step b) is less than 500 ppm.
19. The method according to claim 14, wherein a water content during step b) is less than 3 ppm.
20. The method according to claim 14, wherein the level of microstrains generated in the steel or super alloy crystalline lattice in step b) is more than 1.510.sup.3.
21. The method according to claim 14, wherein the level of microstrains generated in the steel or super alloy crystalline lattice in step b) is more than 310.sup.3.
22. The method according to claim 14, wherein the heating rate is between 400 C./s and 900 C./s.
23. The method according to claim 14, wherein the heat treatment is applied for a duration from 5 s to 2 h.
24. The method according to claim 14, wherein the heat treatment is applied for a duration from 1 minute to 60 minutes.
25. The method according to claim 14, wherein the partial water pressure during step c) is less than 600 ppm.
26. The method according to claim 14, wherein the partial water pressure during step c) is less than 500 ppm.
27. The method according to claim 14, wherein the thickness of the rhombohedral oxide layer obtained in step c) varies from 80 to 120 nm.
28. The method according to claim 14, wherein the percentage of chromium in the steel varies from 2 to 25% by weight.
29. The method according to claim 14, wherein the percentage of chromium in the steel varies from 5 to 16% by weight.
30. A method for fabrication of a solar absorber, the method comprising: forming a layer of single-phase oxide (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 with a rhombohedral structure on a steel or super alloy substrate, according to the method of claim 1; and applying an anti-reflection layer on the single-phase oxide layer.
31. A solar absorber obtained according to the method of claim 30, comprising a steel or super alloy substrate covered by a layer of single-phase rhombohedral oxide (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 with a thickness from 70 nm to 150 nm, and an anti-reflection layer, in sequence.
32. The solar absorber according to claim 31, wherein a thickness of the oxide layer is from 80 nm to 120 nm.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0050] This invention will be better understood after reading the following description and the appended drawings on which:
[0051]
[0052]
[0053]
[0054]
[0055]
[0056]
[0057]
[0058]
[0059] The different parts represented on the figures are not necessarily all at the same scale, to make the figures more easily understandable.
[0060] The different possibilities (variants and embodiments) must be understood as not being mutually exclusive and possibly being combined with each other.
DETAILED PRESENTATION OF PARTICULAR EMBODIMENTS
[0061] The method for forming a layer of single-phase oxide (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 with a rhombohedral structure on a steel substrate 10 comprises the following successive steps:
[0062] a) supply of a steel or super alloy substrate 10 covered by a surface layer 20, the steel comprising at least 2% by weight of chromium (
[0063] b) removal of the surface layer 20 to reach the steel or super alloy substrate 10, using a subtraction step, under an atmosphere containing at least 0.2 atm of dioxygen, the subtraction step generating a level of microstrains in the crystalline lattice of the steel more than 1.010.sup.3 and local heating at a rate of more than 400 C./s, so as to form a rhombohedral oxide layer 30 (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 (
[0064] c) performance of a heat treatment under air at a partial water pressure of less than 10,000 ppm, and at a temperature varying from 400 C. to 1000 C., so as to make the rhombohedral oxide layer 30 formed in step b) grow to a thickness of between 70 nm and 150 nm.
[0065] The substrate 10:
[0066] The substrate 10 supplied in step a) is a steel or super alloy substrate.
[0067] The steel substrate 10 comprises at least 2% by weight of chromium.
[0068] A man skilled in the art may for example choose a very slightly alloyed, slightly alloyed or strongly alloyed steel. Preferably, the steel or the super alloy comprises from 2% to 25% by weight of chromium, and preferably from 2% to 20% by weight of chromium, and even more preferably 5 to 16% by weight.
[0069] Steels can be steels conventionally used in the energy field for example such as steels according to European standard EN10216, American standard ASTM A213, the ASME construction code or others, containing more than 2% of chromium such as 10CrMo9-10 (T22) (1.7380), 11CrMo9-10 (T22) (1.7383), 20CrMoV13-5-5 (1.7779), 7CrWVMoNb9-6 (T23) (1.8201), 7CrMoVTiB10-10 (T24) (1.7378), X11CrMo5 (T5) (1.7362), X11CrMo9-1 (T9) (1.7386), X10CrMoVNb9-1 (T91) (1.4903), X10CrWMoVNb9-2 (T92) (1.4901), X11CrMoWVNb9-1-1 (E911) (1.4905), X12CrCoWMoVNb12-2-2 (1.4915), X20CrMoV11-1 (1.4922)
[0070] The steels used can also be CrNi stainless steels chosen from among standards EN10088, AISI, X7Cr13 (1.4003), X10Cr13 (1.4006), X12CrS13 (1.4005), X20Cr13 (1.4021), X30Cr13 (1.4028).
[0071] Advantageously, a nickel-based super alloy and/or a cobalt-based super alloy will be chosen. The super alloy may for example be an Inconel type super alloy marketed by the Special Metals Corporation or an ASTM-A-494 (625) super alloy.
[0072] The substrate 10 may have many geometric shapes. For example, it can be plane, concave or convex, tubular, etc. Any form in which the surface layer 20 can be removed by material subtraction can be chosen by the expert in the field.
[0073] The part may comprise a through hole or a blind hole, a shoulder, a throat, a groove, or it may have several elementary surfaces by the association of a sphere and a cylinder, a plane and/or a cone.
[0074] As represented on
[0075] The surface layer 20 covering the substrate 10 supplied in step a) does not require a particular surface condition and/or a particular preparation step. A standard state of cleanliness is sufficient, and similarly for oxidation, a standard state without pitting is sufficient
[0076] The surface of the surface layer 20 can be rough or smooth. The substrate 10 can be directly derived from an as-cast, hot or cold rolled, stretched, hot or cold forged material or it may have been subjected to a surface preparation step, for example it may have been chemically or mechanically polished. These preliminary forming or preparation methods are not exhaustive.
[0077] From a general point of view, the surface layer 20 may be in any state because this layer will be removed in step b).
[0078] Subtraction of the Thin Surface Layer from the Substrate 10:
[0079] The surface layer 20 covering the substrate 10 is removed during step b) (
[0080] Part of the substrate 10 can also be removed, in addition to the surface layer 20 (for example, by removing the surface layer and the external part of the substrate, represented by the dashed lines on
[0081] The subtraction step can remove pollutants, oxides and/or carbides that can cover the substrate 10.
[0082] The quantity of material to be removed to reach the native material of the substrate 10 will depend on the surface condition of the substrate 10. It will preferably be between 0.05 mm and 3 mm, and even more preferably between 0.1 mm and 1 mm.
[0083] The thickness of removed material is advantageously identical or substantially identical at all points on the substrate 10.
[0084] Subtraction of material may be mechanical and obtained by friction, shear, tearing, etc.
[0085] An man skilled in the art will choose a subtraction method capable of simultaneously:
[0086] i. removing the surface layer 20 from the surface until reaching the native material of the substrate 10,
[0087] ii. reaching a level of microstrains (Lorentz approximation) of more than 1.010.sup.3, preferably more than 1.510.sup.3 and even more preferably more than 3.010.sup.3; for example, the level of microstrains can be as high as 6.610.sup.3 or even higher values depending on the chosen subtraction method and/or the yield strength of the steel or the super alloy. The level of microstrains is sufficient to enable the creation of a lattice of dislocations sufficient for the fast diffusion of the chromium element towards the surface of the substrate 10;
[0088] iii. reaching a minimum temperature at the surface of the substrate 10, for example equal to 400 C. and preferably between 500 C. and 900 C., the temperature necessarily being reached instantaneously or at least substantially instantaneously by local heating at a heating rate greater than or equal to 400 C./s, and preferably between 400 C./s and 900 C./s.
[0089] Local heating means heating at the location at which the surface layer is removed, and substantially instantaneously with said removal.
[0090] Conditions i), ii), iii) can be combined to obtain the required single-phase oxide layer 30 (
[0091] Concerning point ii), depending on the composition of the substrate 10, the chromium element will be more or less present in the matrix and therefore the density of the necessary dislocations lattice will not be the same. The man skilled in the art will choose the dislocation level as a function of the percentage by mass of chromium in the substrate 10.
[0092] The microstrain level can be determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD).
[0093] The substrate 10 obtained after step b), is in biaxial tension. It has an axial stress 11=270 MPa, a circumferential stress 22=320 MPa and an average microstrain (Lorentz approximation) equal to: <>=3.110.sup.3. A widening of the peak is observed related to the formation of microstrains at the surface of the substrate 10. The microstrains were measured on depths varying from 2 to 17 m, perpendicular to the surface of the substrate 10.
[0094] Concerning point iii), the chosen subtraction method performed under air delivers a high strain power locally on the surface that is converted into heat and causes large temperature variations. These are both variations relative to time (very fast heating under the subtraction means and very fast cooling after passage of the tool) and gradients relative to the space (hot surface on cold substrate 10). This fast passage at high surface temperature enables nucleation of the oxide. The cooling temperature gradient shall be equal to or more than 100 C./s over the 900 C./400 C. range.
[0095] The method is applied under a dry atmosphere.
[0096] The temperature at the substrate/subtraction means interface could possibly be regulated by means of dry air at a low partial H.sub.2O pressure less than 20,000 ppm, preferably less than 500 ppm and even more preferably less than 3ppm. It has been observed that the use of a water-based cooling fluid will have a negative effect on formation of the oxide.
[0097] Preferably, the subtraction step is done at a temperature less than 400 C.
[0098] The material subtraction step is done under an oxidising atmosphere (under air or under any other atmosphere containing at least 0.2 atm of dioxygen) to instantaneously create on the surface of the substrate 10 a thin layer of a rhombohedral oxide rich in Cr (Cr.sub.xFe.sub.1x).sub.2O.sub.3 (in which x is between 0 and 0.2; for example x=0.1) with nanometric thickness. This oxide is also denoted (Cr, Fe).sub.2O.sub.3.
[0099] The oxide formed is in compression. The volume of the oxide is larger than the substrate 10 from which it is formed. Since its lateral extension is restricted by the substrate 10, it is in compression. This point contributes to the protective nature of the layer by reducing diffusion coefficients within it.
[0100] The surface of the substrate 10 on which the material subtraction step was performed satisfying criteria i, ii) and iii), under a dry oxidising atmosphere, is in a residual tension stresses condition. Schematically, this corresponds to the formation of a hot skin formed during subtraction of material, contracting in contact with a substrate 10 that remained cold in depth.
[0101] On the contrary, surfaces subjected to a polishing step are subject to residual compression stresses and the required oxide cannot be formed in them. Similarly, a hot or cold rolling, grinding, electro polishing or electroerosion step, or a SMAT method cannot simultaneously obtain the required microstrain and heating levels. The oxide obtained with such methods will not be a mixed iron and chromium oxide and/or will not be a single-phase oxide and/or will not have the required final thickness. Therefore it will not have the required optical and/or thermal stability properties.
[0102] The material subtraction step may be chosen by a man skilled in the art, for example from among abrasive machining, drilling, milling, turning or any other means of obtaining the three simultaneous conditions i, ii), iii).
[0103] For example, depending on the application, the man skilled in the art can start from a plane substrate made of X10CrMoVNb9-1 type steel in any state. He can use an electric or pneumatic disc grinder and choose the nature of the preferably continuous disc, compatible with the substrate for example using a corundum or diamond base. The disc rotation speed, the contact pressure and the longitudinal and transverse movements to be applied will be chosen to be able to satisfy criteria i, ii), iii). The application may be such that continuity is achieved on the surface of the substrate. Furthermore, to satisfy oxidation conditions, implementation will take place under a controlled atmosphere satisfying the requirements defined above. The application of an arbitrary tool movement in an arbitrary atmosphere cannot result in a thin, continuous and conforming oxide
[0104] As a non-limitative example, the subtraction step respecting criteria i), ii) and iii), can be implemented on an X.sub.10CrMoVNb.sub.9-1 type steel substrate, particularly in the form of a piece of flat steel. The initial state of the steel substrate is not very important. In other words, the steel substrate can be as is following hot or cold transformations, or it may have been subjected to at least one preparation. The subtraction step then comprises the application of a contact pressure on the steel substrate by means of an electric or pneumatic disc grinder (for example a portable electric disc grinder). The man skilled in the art is capable of choosing the disc of the disc grinder. The chosen disc is preferably continuous (in other words it has no notches) and is compatible with the nature of the steel substrate. In particular, the disc can be diamond-based or preferably corundum-based.
[0105] The maximum peripheral speed of the disc can be determined as a function of the diameter, the nature and the rotation speed of said disc. For example, a maximum peripheral speed of 80 m.Math.s.sup.1 may be imposed on a 125 mm diameter AS 30 S INOX BF type disc.
[0106] During the subtraction step, the pressure and the contact angle of the disc relative to the surface of the steel substrate are adapted to be able to satisfy safety requirements and to be conforming with standard practice regarding general use of this equipment.
[0107] Finally, to satisfy oxidation conditions, implementation may be done under a controlled atmosphere satisfying the previously defined requirements (for example dry air with low H.sub.2O partial pressure less than 20,000 ppm, preferably less than 500 ppm and even more preferably less than 3 ppm).
[0108] Growth of the Oxide Layer 30 (Cr, Fe).sub.2O.sub.3:
[0109] During step c), a heat treatment is performed to force growth of the oxide layer 30 previously formed in step b). The heat treatment temperature is between 400 C. and 1000 C., and preferably between 400 C. and 850 C. The man skilled in the art will choose the temperature as a function of the composition of the substrate 10. The duration of the heat treatment depends on the geometry of the substrate 10 and the thickness of the oxide layer 30 formed during step b). The duration may for example be between 5 s and 2 h, and preferably between 1 minute and 60 minutes.
[0110] The heat treatment is done under a dry air atmosphere or an atmosphere containing a partial H.sub.2O pressure of less than 10,000 ppm, for example between 1 ppm and 10,000 ppm, and preferably less than 600 ppm, for example between 1 ppm and 600 ppm, even more preferably less than 500 ppm, for example between 1 ppm and 500 ppm.
[0111] At the end of step c), the thickness of the mixed iron and chromium oxide layer 30 of the (Fe,Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 type of rhombohedral type is from 70 nm to 150 nm, and preferably from 80 nm to 120 nm, for example of the order of 100 nm.
[0112] It has been observed that the thickness of single-phase oxide formed at the end of step c), tended towards a maximum of the order of 150 nm independently of the heat treatment duration and temperature. On the contrary, the thicknesses of non-single-phase oxide layers can be up to more than 400 nm.
[0113] Mechanical stresses in the material can be relaxed in step c).
[0114] The substrate 10 obtained by the previously described method will be covered by a stable oxide layer 30. There are no layers intercalated between the steel substrate 10 and the oxide layer 30. The oxide layer 30 has intrinsic optical selectivity properties, in other words high solar absorbance and low emittance.
[0115] The substrate 10 obtained by the previously described method can for example be used to make a solar absorber that has improved selectivity properties compared with solar absorbers obtained by techniques known in prior art.
[0116] In particular and for comparison purposes, the inventors have determined the properties of an absorber obtained using a method known in prior art and an absorber obtained using the method according to this invention.
[0117] In both cases, the surface of a substrate made of T91 (X10CrMoVNb9-1) type steel was oxidised.
[0118] In this regard,
[0119]
[0120] The reflectance curves obtained for the known sample and for the inventive sample can be used to calculate values of the solar absorbance () and emittance () at 100 C., 300 C. and 450 C. for each of the two samples. The method used for these calculations is presented in the Appendix section of this invention.
[0121] Thus, table 1 contains the absorbance and emittance properties for the known sample, and table 2 contains the properties for the inventive sample.
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 (100 C.) (300 C.) (450 C.) 73.17 6.47 9.50 11.91
TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 (100 C.) (300 C.) (450 C.) 77.70 2.30 3.42 6.89
[0122] Comparing the values in the two tables, it can be seen that for the same type of sample, in this case T91 (X10CrMoVNb9-1), the method according to the invention can obtain a tube with a higher level of solar absorbance equal to 77.70% instead of 73.17% while having a lower emittance level of 6.89% at 450 C. compared with 11.91%.
[0123] The selectivity of the absorber can be improved by adding one or several anti-reflection layers 40 deposited a posteriori on the oxide layer 30 (
[0124] The solar absorber fabricated using the method according to the invention is oriented particularly for medium or even high temperatures (thermodynamic concentrating solar power station).
[0125] The substrate 10 can also be used to make the sensitive part of a flux sensor, or a temperature sensor under irradiation.
[0126] The substrate 10 can also be used for temperature applications under air (lower than the working temperature of the substrate 10), or for applications requiring increased protection against hot oxidation.
[0127] For example, the working temperature of a T91 (X10CrMoVNb9-1) steel is about 650 C.
[0128] Illustrative and Non-Limitative Examples of One Embodiment:
[0129] The method was used on a steel substrate 10 containing about 9.5% of Cr (T91 (X10CrMoVNb9-1)). In particular, the substrate 10 was oxidised at 650 C. for an hour under dry air so as to form the protective layer 30 on the surface of the substrate 10. The layer 30 thus formed is a 90 nm thick layer of (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3 . An SiO.sub.2 anti-reflection layer was also deposited on a part of the substrate 10 (called part I) leaving another part of the sample (called part II) without an anti-reflection layer.
[0130] The single-phase nature of the oxide layer is verified by X-ray diffraction. The equipment used is a Bruker diffractometer (model: D8 Advance) equipped with a Cu source and a LynxEye type linear detector. The power supply voltage and current of the X-ray type are 40 kV and 40 mA respectively. The beam width is 12 mm, and its divergence is 0.45. Under these conditions, the only phase detected in the oxide is rhombohedral (Fe,Cr).sub.2O.sub.3, confirming the single-phase nature of the oxide layer.
[0131] A substrate 10 and its protective oxide layer 30 obtained by the method according to the invention was tested under working conditions (500 C. in air), and in particular was subjected to an exposure of 3000 hours at 500 C. under air. In this regard,
[0132] On each of these three diffractograms, the arrows indicate representative peaks of the oxide layer (Fe, Cr).sub.2O.sub.3. No significant variation of these peaks is detected, thus confirming an excellent stability of the oxide layer. Therefore these results confirm that the substrate 10 is protected from oxidation.
[0133] The inventors have also measured the variation of optical properties, particularly the solar absorbance and emittance at 450 C., during 3000 hours of ageing at 500 C. under air.
[0134] The results obtained are assembled on
[0135] The stability of the optical properties and the oxide layer measured by X-ray diffraction shows the excellent resistance to oxidation under air at 500 C. of the samples relative to the samples in documents [5] and [6] mentioned at the end of the description.
Appendix
[0136] Absorbance means a coefficient of absorption of an electromagnetic wave by a body. In this case, the solar absorbance corresponds to the absorption coefficient of the solar spectrum by the material, and particularly the oxide layer 30. It is calculated from the measured reflectance spectrum of a spectrophotometer and the solar spectrum.
[0137] Emittance means the percentage of radiation flux emitted in all directions by a material, particularly the oxide layer 30, at a given temperature T relative to the radiation flux in all directions from the black body at this same temperature (it is understood that a black body has an emittance of 100%).
[0138] Reflectance or total reflectance means the proportion of light flux reflected by a surface as a function of an incident flux on said surface. Reflectance is total when it is measured in all directions using an integration sphere. The reflectance spectrum gives the reflectance as a function of the wavelength.
[0139] The measurement of the total reflectance spectrum can be used to calculate the solar absorbance and the emittance .sub.T at a temperature T. In this description, it is assumed that Kirchhoff's law is applicable since the material is opaque (The man skilled in the art can consult documents [1] and [2] mentioned at the end of the description), such that (; ,)=(; ,) (1).
[0140] If the total measurement (on the entire space) and for an opaque material without any non-linear effect (that is generally accepted for solar absorbers), the total emittance and the total reflectance are related by the relation .sub.T()=1.sub.T() (2).
[0141] Thus, the solar absorptance and the emittance at temperature T are defined by the following relations:
wherein:
[0142] : total solar absorptance
[0143] (T): emittance at temperature T
[0144] .sub.T(): total reflectance at wavelength
[0145] B.sub.T(): Irradiance of the black body at temperature T and at wavelength
[0146] S(): Solar irradiance at wavelength
[0147] : wavelength
[0148] The measurement procedure is described in the paper by J. Braillon et al. [3] mentioned at the end of the description.
[0149] A solar absorber is said to be selective if it has strong solar absorbance and low emittance at the working temperature. The ideal curve for such a material is given in the paper by C. Kennedy [1] mentioned at the end of the description, and reproduced in
REFERENCES
[0150] [1] C. Kennedy, Review of mid- to high-temperature solar selective absorber materials, Tech. Rep. NREL/TP-520-31267, NREL, National Renewable Energy Laboratory 1617 Cole Boulevard Golden, Colo. 80401-3393, 2002; [0151] [2] J. Palmer, Handbook of Optics, second ed., Part II, ch. 25, The Measurement of Transmission, Absorption, Emission and Reflection. M. Bass, 1994; [0152] [3] J. Braillon et al., Development of optical tool for the characterization of selective solar absorber tubes, AIP Conference Proceedings 1734, 130004 (2016); [0153] [4] FR2976349; [0154] [5] O. Raccurt et al., Study of the stability of a selective solar absorber coating under air and high temperature conditions, Energy Procedia, Vol. 69, 2015, p 1551-1557; [0155] [6] Raccurt, O. et al., In air durability study of solar selective coating for parabolic trough technology, (2017), AIP Conference Proceedings 1850(1), 130010.