METHOD FOR OBTAINING STRONG FOCUSING OF ISOCHRONOUS ACCELERATOR BY VARYING MAGNETIC FIELD GRADIENT IN LARGE RADIAL RANGE
20240008166 ยท 2024-01-04
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
The present application provides a method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying the magnetic field gradient in a large radial range. The method is characterized by the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator providing not only a bending effect but also a focusing effect, equivalent to the effects of quadrupole, sextupole, and octupole magnets used in a synchrotron accelerator.
Claims
1. A method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range, wherein a main magnet of the isochronous accelerator provides a bending effect and a focusing effect, which is equivalent to effects of using of quadrupole, sextupole, and octupole magnets in a synchrotron accelerator; the method comprises: introducing a first-order, a second-order, and a third-order magnetic field gradients in the large radial range of the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator to achieve an enhanced focusing, compensation of chromaticity, handling of resonances similar to that provided by a quadrupole, a sextupole, and octupole lenses, and obtain a transverse focusing force required for an isochronous continuous wave acceleration from 1 GeV to 2 GeV.
2. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 1, wherein providing, by the main magnet of isochronous accelerators, the bending effect and the focusing effect comprises: 1) using a magnetic field with an angularly varying gradient as a main source of an axial focusing force, wherein, a magnetic field distribution is given by a formula of:
B(r,)=B.sub.0(r)[1+f cos N],N3(1) wherein B.sub.0 is a central magnetic field, is a relativistic factor, N is a number of sectors, f is a flutter of a magnetic field and is an angular position; and 2) varying the magnetic field gradient radially to simultaneously vary a peak region magnetic field B(r) in a radial direction to satisfy a polynomial form:
3. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 2, wherein, introducing the first-order magnetic field gradient in the large radial range of the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator to achieve the enhanced focusing similar to that provided by the quadrupole lens comprises: (1) solving for a radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and an axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z of the first-order magnetic field gradient; and (2) solving for a magnetic field adjustment coefficients a; in the equation (2) by solving a system of equations, where i ranges from 0 to 1.
4. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 3, wherein, solving for the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and the axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z of the first-order magnetic field gradient in the process (1) comprises: {circle around (1)} solving for a motion equation of a particle:
u+K(s)u=0(3) wherein u is a lateral displacement in an x or y direction; u is a second derivative of a lateral displacement, x is the radial direction, and y is an axial direction; {circle around (2)} obtaining a periodic function K.sub.x(s) of a focusing force:
5. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 4, wherein, solving for the transfer matrix within the one magnetic field period comprises: 1) varying a particle phase space motion state in a Focusing-Defocusing-Focusing (FDF) isochronous Fixed-Field Alternating Gradient (FFAG) accelerator as:
M=M.sub.0M.sub.FM.sub.0M.sub.DM.sub.0M.sub.F(7) M.sub.F represents a transfer matrix in two directions of the focusing field M.sub.F.sub.
6. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 5, wherein, obtaining, based on the Hill equation, the relationship equation between the transfer matrix M and the beam optical parameters , , and to solve for the , , and comprises: a. according to the Hill equation, obtaining a solution of the Hill equation by using a transfer matrix M as:
7. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 6, wherein, solving, based on the , , and , for the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and the axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z comprises: i. establishing an integral equation for calculating the radial oscillation frequency:
8. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 7, wherein, solving for the magnetic field adjustment coefficients a.sub.i in the equation (2) by solving the system of equations, where i ranges from 0 to 1, comprises: I. substituting an expression for
9. The method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by varying a magnetic field gradient in a large radial range according to claim 8, wherein, introducing the first-order magnetic field gradient in the large radial range of the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator to achieve the handling of resonances similar to that provided by the quadrupole lens comprises: 1) setting v.sub.x and v.sub.z as a radial and axial oscillation frequencies at an energy point before dangerous resonance occurs; 2) substituting v.sub.x and v.sub.z into equation (10.2) to obtain a.sub.0 and a.sub.1 in equation (2); wherein a.sub.0 is used to adjust a deflection effect of the magnetic field, and a.sub.1 is used to adjust the focusing effect of the magnetic field; and 3) adjusting the coefficients a.sub.0 and a.sub.1 to make values of v.sub.x and v.sub.z near a resonance region reach preset values, for obtaining a local oscillation frequency adjustment.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0056]
[0057]
[0058]
[0059]
DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENTS
[0060] 1) Radial variation of magnetic field gradient for strong focusing principle: Compared with synchrotron accelerators, synchrotron accelerators use quadrupole (iron) lenses, sextupole (iron) lenses, and octupole (iron) lenses, in addition to using dipole magnets for orbit bending, to achieve strong focusing and chromaticity matching, thereby obtaining high energy. The reason why isochronous (cyclotron) accelerators cannot achieve high energy is that they only have dipole magnets for orbit bending and do not have quadrupole (iron) lenses, sextupole (iron) lenses, etc., making it difficult to achieve strong focusing and chromaticity matching. [0061] 2) Compared with synchrotrons, quadrupole (magnetic) lenses, sextupole (magnetic) lenses, etc., can only be used for the same orbit or for orbits with very small changes, because each lens is a hole that the orbit must pass through. If the orbit changes, such as in the spiral orbit of a cyclotron, it cannot pass through this hole. [0062] 3) Synchrotrons rely on the basic principle of synchronously variable RF frequency and magnet field strength, which determines that the accelerated beam is pulsed and cannot achieve continuous wave acceleration. Additionally, large magnets have a long time constant and a low repetition frequency for adjusting the magnetic field strength. Therefore, the average beam intensity of synchrotrons is generally lower. [0063] 4) In order to overcome the shortcomings of synchrotrons' inability to achieve continuous wave acceleration and to equivalently achieve the strong focusing and chromaticity matching functions of quadrupole (magnetic) lenses, sextupole (magnetic) lenses, and octupole (magnetic) lenses in synchrotrons, on the basis of radial alternating magnetic field gradient focusing, stronger axial focusing force can be obtained, as well as some transverse adjustment effects. This is achieved by innovatively proposing a method of varying the gradient of the magnetic field in the magnet pole peak region of the cyclotron in a large radial range, thereby generating local harmonic fields at specific radial positions on the magnet pole, and obtaining similar effects to multipole magnets such as quadrupole, sextupole, and octupole lenses, for enhancing focusing, compensating for chromaticity, and dealing with resonance, meeting the beam dynamics requirements for isochronous acceleration. Obtaining strong focusing through large-scale radial variation of the magnetic field gradient is a key technical measure for the isochronous accelerator to achieve higher energy and beam intensity. [0064] 2. The key technical challenge in implementing radial variation of magnetic field gradient for strong focusing in isochronous accelerators is that the radial span of the accelerator orbit is large, and the number of turns in the synchrotron is high, sometimes with multiple turns overlapping. Each multipole harmonic field that the orbit passes over at each local radius must meet the matching requirements for focusing and chromaticity at the corresponding energy as the spiral orbit rotates from small to large radii. As the orbit traverses each magnet, including different orders of gradients, a large number of matrices are involved. Each turn or equilibrium orbit is equivalent to a series of matrix multiplications, and each matrix corresponds to a point in the resonance diagram. With n turns or n equilibrium orbits, there are n points that are connected to form the resonance path, which then determines the n matrices. However, it is currently unknown what beam dynamics requirements these matrices must satisfy in order to realize the first, second, and third-order gradients of the magnetic field. No one has yet been able to theoretically define these matrices. [0065] 3. The processing flow of the present application to overcome the technical difficulties is as follows: firstly, the closed orbit radius r corresponding to the first-order magnetic field gradient is determined, which means that the energy corresponding to the first-order magnetic field gradient is calculated. In an isochronous accelerator, different energies correspond to different orbits. Secondly, after the energy is determined, i.e., the closed orbit radius is determined, the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient ai on this radius r is obtained to satisfy the polynomial formula (2). Thirdly, taking the introduction of the first-order magnetic field gradient as an example, the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and the axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z are solved. By solving the obtained v.sub.x and v.sub.y, the two magnetic field adjustment coefficients a.sub.0 and a.sub.1 of formula (2) are solved, where i in formula (2) corresponds to 0 and 1 for a.sub.0 and a.sub.1, respectively. a.sub.0 is the adjustment coefficient of the deflection magnetic field for 0-order magnetic field gradient, and a.sub.1 is the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient for the first-order magnetic field gradient. [0066] 4. The bottleneck problem and solution of the present application in overcoming the technical difficulties are as follows: Firstly, the bottleneck problem is how to calculate the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x, axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z, and the Twiss parameters , , and based on the set magnetic field gradient (taking the first-order magnetic field gradient as an example). The parameters , , and are related to v.sub.x and v.sub.y, which are ultimately solved by an integral equation containing the parameter 3. Secondly, the present application uses two forms of transfer matrices M and sets the right sides of the two transfer matrices equal to each other, thus establishing a relationship between the matrix element m.sub.ij=f(a.sub.0, a.sub.1, s) and the cos , , , and . The parameters , , and are then solved by the relationship between the matrix element m_{ij} and , , and . Thirdly, the first form of the transfer matrix M is the transfer matrix of a particle through one magnetic field period, as shown in formula (7), where M.sub.0 is the matrix of the non-magnetic zone when a particle rotates through one magnetic field period, M.sub.F is the matrix of the forward magnetic pole when a particle rotates through one magnetic field period, and M.sub.D is the matrix of the reverse magnetic pole when a particle rotates through one magnetic field period. One magnetic field period is a circumferentially periodic magnetic focusing unit that includes a forward magnetic pole, a reverse magnetic pole, and their respective drift spaces. Moreover, the M.sub.F and M.sub.D matrix elements also include the relationship between the element and the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient a.sub.1 and the magnetic field deflection adjustment coefficient a.sub.0. Fourth, the transmission matrix M in the second form utilizes the matrix solution of the Hill equation, as shown in Equation (8), which includes the Twiss parameters alpha, beta, and gamma. Fifth, equating the right-hand side of the two forms of the transmission matrix M establishes the relationship between the matrices M.sub.F, M.sub.D, M.sub.0, and the parameters , , . As the matrices M.sub.F, M.sub.D, M.sub.0 are composed of 22 matrix elements, this also establishes the relationship between the matrix elements M.sub.11, M.sub.12, M.sub.21, M.sub.22, and the parameters , , . The parameters , , are then obtained by solving Equations (9.1), 9.2, 9.3, and (9.4). Sixth, the two magnetic field adjustment coefficients a.sub.0 and a.sub.1 in Equation (2) are solved. Since the matrix element mi contains the relationship between that element and a.sub.0 and a.sub.1, this relationship is substituted into the integral equations for v.sub.x and v.sub.z, and the equations are then solved simultaneously to obtain the deflection magnetic field adjustment coefficient a.sub.0 and the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient a.sub.1 in Equation (2).
[0067] Based on the above principles, a method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by adjusting the magnetic field gradient over a large radial range in the isochronous accelerator is provided.
[0068] The present application provides a method for obtaining strong focusing of an isochronous accelerator by adjusting the magnetic field gradient in a large radial range, as shown in
[0069] Supplementary Note 1:
[0070] The uniform magnetic gap, first-order variable magnetic gap, second-order variable magnetic gap, and third-order variable magnetic gap in
[0071] Furthermore, the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator not only provides deflection but also has a focusing effect. Specifically: [0072] 1) The magnetic field with angularly varying gradients is used as the main source of axial focusing force. The magnetic field distribution is given by the following equation:
B(r,)=B.sub.0(r)[1+f cos N],N3(1)
[0073] Where B.sub.0 is the central magnetic field, (r) is the relativistic factor, N is the number of magnetic pole sectors, f is the magnetic field modulation degree, and is the angular position.
[0074] Supplementary Note 2:
[0075] The first term on the right side of equation (1) is the central plane magnetic field of the accelerator, and the second term is the magnetic field gradient. The magnetic field gradient is affected by the distance between the magnets, with larger distances resulting in larger magnetic field gradients and vice versa. [0076] 2) By using the method of radial variation of magnetic field gradient, the peak magnetic field B(r) is simultaneously varied radially to satisfy a polynomial form:
[0077] where a.sub.i is the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient, r is the closed orbit radius, and i is the order of the magnetic field gradient, ranging from 0 to n. The focusing effect mentioned here refers to the change of the particle's orbit radius as it passes through the magnetic field peak region during the cyclotron motion, and the focusing effect other than the deflection caused by passing through different magnetic field gradient adjustment regions.
[0078] Supplementary Note 3: [0079] 1. In formula (2), r.sup.i and i are known parameters, while a.sub.i is an unknown parameter. r.sup.i is the radius of the closed orbit calculated when the closed orbit is solved. The closed orbit is shown in
[0082] However, the specific content still needs to be changed according to the individualized requirements for adjusting the magnetic field based on the second-order gradient, third-order gradient.
[0083] Furthermore, the present embodiment introduces a method for enhancing the focusing effect similar to the quadrupole lens by introducing the first-order gradient of the magnetic field in the large radial range of the main magnetic pole of the isochronous accelerator. The specific process is as follows: [0084] 1. Determine the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z of the first-order gradient of the magnetic field. [0085] 2. Solve the magnetic field adjustment coefficients a.sub.i in formula (2) by solving the system of equations, where i is 0 and 1.
[0086] Furthermore, the specific method for determining the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z in step 1 is as follows: [0087] {circle around (1)} According to the equation of motion of the particle,
u+K(s)u=0(3)
[0088] Where u is the lateral displacement in the x or y direction; u is the second derivative of the lateral displacement, x is the radial direction, and y is the axial direction; [0089] {circle around (2)} Obtaining the periodic function K.sub.x(s) of the focusing force;
[0090] K(s) is a periodic function of the focusing force, K.sub.x(s) is a periodic function of the radial focusing force, and K.sub.y(s) is a periodic function of the axial focusing force, depending on the magnetic field generated by the magnet elements arranged around the circumference of the isochronous accelerator. In the formula, is the particle deflection radius, B is the magnetic induction intensity, and B.sub.y is the axial component of the magnetic induction intensity. Equation (3) is the Hill equation. [0091] {circle around (3)} The transfer matrix within one magnetic field period is solved. One magnetic field period refers to a magnetic focusing unit and its corresponding drift space that is repeated periodically around the circumference. Choosing the energy corresponding to any loop as the starting point of the calculation, the closed orbit is obtained using the radial distribution of the magnetic field, and the transfer matrix M for the beam to propagate one magnetic field period along the equilibrium orbit is then obtained. [0092] {circle around (4)} Based on the Hill equation, the relationship equation between the transfer matrix M and the beam optical parameters , , and is obtained. Therefore, , , and are solved. [0093] {circle around (5)} Based on , , and , the radial oscillation frequency v.sub.x and the axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z are solved.
[0094] The process of solving the transfer matrix within one magnetic field period (step 3) is as follows: [0095] 1) The variation of the particle phase space motion state in the FDF isochronous FFAG accelerator can be described as follows:
[0096] where x represents the transverse displacement, x represents the particle scattering angle, M.sub.0 is the transfer matrix in free space, M.sub.F and M.sub.D represent the transfer matrices for focusing field and defocusing field, respectively.
[0097] Supplementary Note 4:
[0098] Formula (5) is the matrix that describes the motion of a particle from position x.sub.0 to x along the trajectory during one period of the magnetic field. It can be decomposed into three parts: the free space transport matrix M.sub.0 for regions with no magnetic field, the focusing field transport matrix M.sub.F for regions with positive magnetic poles, and the defocusing field transport matrix M.sub.D for regions with negative magnetic poles. The focusing field can be further divided into the radial focusing field, which is described by the transport matrices M.sub.F.sub.
[0099] The transfer matrix M.sub.F.sub.
[0100] is the bending radius, n is the magnetic field index, and s is the distance traveled by the particle.
where r is the particle's orbit radius, B is the magnetic induction intensity, n can be expressed using the coefficients in formula (2), (B/r) is the magnetic field gradient adjustment coefficient a_i in formula (2), r is the radius of the closed orbit in formula (2), and B is the average magnetic field in formula (2). In the matrix, M.sub.11 represents the magnification factor, and M.sub.21 represents the focusing-defocusing factor. [0101] 2) The relationship between the transfer matrix in one magnetic field period and the magnetic field configuration M.sub.0M.sub.F
M.sub.D is given by:
M=M.sub.0M.sub.FM.sub.0M.sub.DM.sub.0M.sub.F(7)
[0102] Here, M.sub.F represents the transfer matrix in the two directions of the focusing field, M.sub.F.sub.
[0104] Obtaining the equation relating the transfer matrix M and the beam optical parameters , , based on the Hill equation, the process {circle around (4)}. Then , , are solved and the specific process is as follows: [0105] a. According to the Hill equation, the solution of the Hill equation can be expressed using the transfer matrix M:
[0106] In formula (8), I is the unit matrix, , , are the Twiss parameters, and is the horizontal oscillation phase shift. [0107] b. Based on formulas (6.1), (6.2), (7), and (8), the relationship between cos , , , , and the matrix elements can be obtained to solve for , , and .
[0108] The process {circle around (5)} is to solve the radial oscillation frequencies v.sub.x and v.sub.z based on the , , and values. The specific process is as follows: [0109] i. Establishing an integral equation for calculating the radial oscillation frequency.
[0111] Furthermore, the process (2): Solve the magnetic field adjustment coefficients a.sub.i,i=0,1 of formula (2) by solving the system of equations, as follows: [0112] I. Substituting the expression for
from equation (9.2) into equation (10.1). [0113] II. Obtaining the integral equation (10.2) containing unknowns a.sub.0 and a.sub.1:
[0114] where M.sub.12 (a.sub.0, a.sub.1, s) expressed in terms of matrix elements, with i=1 and j=2, and N is the number of magnetic periods in 360 around the circumference, s.sub.0 is the starting point of a magnetic period and S.sub.0+L is the ending point.
[0115] Supplementary Explanation 5:
[0116] The use of i=1 and j=2 in m.sub.ij is to correspond to formula (9.2) where
Formula (10.2) is substituted with formula (9.2). [0117] III. Recalculating formula (9.1), (9.2), (9.3), and (9.4) using formula (6.1), formula (6.3), formula (7), and formula (8), then substituting formula (9.2) into formula (10.1). The function (s) is used to solve for the axial oscillation frequency v.sub.z in formula (10.1). [0118] IV. Using the solved values of v.sub.x and v.sub.z to solve for a.sub.0 and a.sub.1 in formula (10.2) by simultaneous equations.
[0119] Furthermore, by introducing the first-order magnetic field gradient within the maximum radial range of the main magnet of the isochronous accelerator, a similar treatment of resonance as a quadrupole lens is achieved, which specifically includes: [0120] 1) Setting v.sub.x and v.sub.z as the radial and axial oscillation frequencies at the energy point where dangerous resonance occurs. [0121] 2) Substituting v.sub.x and v.sub.z into formula (10.2) to obtain formula (2) for a.sub.0 and a.sub.1. a.sub.0 is used to adjust the deflection effect of the magnetic field, while a.sub.1 is used to adjust the focusing effect of the magnetic field. [0122] 3) Adjusting the coefficients a.sub.0 and a.sub.i to make the v.sub.x and v.sub.z near the resonance region reach the set values, thereby obtaining local oscillation frequency adjustment.
[0123] Supplementary Explanation 6:
[0124] As shown in
Example 1
[0125] As an example, a 10 MeV high-current cyclotron central region test device is designed for an experimental verification work. The main magnet of the device is a 4-pole magnet with a pole radius of 45 cm, a total weight of 13 tons, and a machining accuracy better than 0.1 mm. The first-order gradient of the magnetic field was adjusted from a radius of 22 cm to a radius of 44.5 cm. Magnetic field measurements showed that the expected strong focusing force was obtained, with v.sub.z close to 0.6. The highest target beam intensity in the accelerator reached 432.6 A. Due to the limitation of high-frequency machine power, the extracted external target beam current was 230.85 A. The 10 MeV high-current cyclotron central region test device demonstrated that even small and compact isochronous cyclotrons can achieve stronger axial focusing by adjusting the magnetic field gradient over a large radial range. The device achieved a proton beam current of over 400 A, demonstrating the technical capability of obtaining mA-level current from an accelerator physics perspective. The test device is also the first prototype of a PET small cyclotron accelerator developed independently in China, verifying the overall technical capability of domestically developed PET cyclotron accelerators. Subsequently, based on the experimental setup, optimization design was carried out. Taking into account the target of optimizing PET isotope production yield and the overall consideration of technical performance optimization, the magnetic pole radius was increased to 50 cm, and the extracted proton beam energy was increased to 14 MeV, with a total weight of nearly 15 tons. The magnetic field first-order gradient was adjusted from a radius of 22 cm to 49 cm, and v.sub.z was maintained at a level of 0.6.
[0126] The large range variation of the first-order magnetic field gradient can improve the beam intensity of the 10 MeV 20 MeV compact cyclotron, the second-order magnetic field gradient can break through the energy limit of the compact cyclotron and successfully develop a 100 MeV high-current cyclotron, and the third-order magnetic field gradient can be used to innovate and design a 2 GeV high-energy high-current isochronous FFAG accelerator.
[0127] It should be emphasized that the specific examples mentioned above are merely explanatory of the present application and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. Those skilled in the art, after reading this specification, can make modifications to the above examples without creative contribution, but all modifications within the scope of the claims of the present application are protected by patent law.