Systems and methods for reducing porosity in propellers
10875615 ยท 2020-12-29
Assignee
Inventors
- Alexander K. Monroe (St. Cloud, WI, US)
- Trevor George (Eldorado, WI, US)
- Philip R. Walker (Oshkosh, WI, US)
- Daniel J. Guse (Fond du Lac, WI, US)
- Justin D. Ericson (St. Cloud, WI, US)
- Jason Worful (Plymouth, MI, US)
Cpc classification
B63H20/26
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
B63B71/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B63H20/26
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
Abstract
A method of making a propeller includes forming the propeller to have blades coupled to an outer hub, the outer hub coupled to an inner hub via ribs, and the inner hub configured to be coupled to the marine vessel. The ribs each have first and second ends with a midpoint therebetween, an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, and a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween. The ribs are tapered such that the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end, and scalloped such that the width is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end. Each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub in radial alignment with one of the blades.
Claims
1. A method of making a propeller for a marine vessel, the method comprising: forming the propeller to have blades coupled to an outer hub; forming the propeller such that the outer hub is coupled to an inner hub via ribs, wherein the inner hub is configured to be coupled to the marine vessel, wherein the ribs each have a first end and a second end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the first end and the second end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, and wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween; forming each of the ribs to be tapered such that the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end; forming each of the ribs to be scalloped such that the width is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end, wherein the length between the first end and the second end varies from a smallest length to a greatest length that differ by a delta, and wherein each of the ribs is also scalloped such that the delta is greater than the width at the midpoint; and forming the propeller such that each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub to be radially aligned with one of the blades.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the propeller is configured such that the first end is farther than the second end from the marine vessel when the propeller is coupled thereto, wherein the thickness is greater at the second end than at the first end, and wherein the width is greater at the second end than at the first end.
3. The method according to claim 1, wherein each of the blades has a thickest region, and wherein each of the ribs is radially aligned with the thickest region of one of the blades.
4. The method according to claim 1, wherein each of the blades has a blade width divided into even thirds, and wherein each of the ribs is radially aligned with a center third of the even thirds of one of the blades.
5. The method according to claim 1, wherein the blades are three individual blades, and wherein the ribs are three individual ribs.
6. The method according to claim 1, further comprising forming each of the ribs to also be tapered between the inner end and the outer end such that the thickness is greater at the outer end than at the inner end.
7. The method according to claim 1, wherein the propeller is formed of aluminum.
8. The method according to claim 1, wherein each of the ribs has a center plane that is centrally defined between the leading surface and the trailing surface, and wherein the center plane is perpendicular to both the inner hub and the outer hub.
9. A propeller for a marine vessel, the propeller comprising: an inner hub configured to be coupled to the marine vessel; an outer hub and a plurality of ribs that couple the outer hub to the inner hub, wherein the ribs each have a first end and a second end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the first end and the second end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, wherein the width is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are scalloped, wherein the length between the first end and the second end varies from a smallest length to a greatest length that differ by a delta, and wherein each of the ribs is also scalloped such that the delta is greater than the width at the midpoint, and wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween, wherein the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are tapered; and a plurality of blades that are coupled to the outer hub; wherein each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub in radial alignment with one of the blades.
10. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein the propeller is configured such that the first end is farther than the second end from the marine vessel when the propeller is coupled thereto, wherein the thickness is greater at the second end than at the first end, and wherein the width is greater at the second end than at the first end.
11. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein each of the blades has a thickest region, and wherein each of the ribs is radially aligned with the thickest region of one of the blades.
12. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein each of the blades has a blade width divided into even thirds, and wherein each of the ribs is radially aligned with a center third of the even thirds of one of the blades.
13. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein the blades are three individual blades, and wherein the ribs are three individual ribs.
14. The propeller according to claim 9, further comprising forming each of the ribs to also be tapered between the inner end and the outer end such that the thickness is greater at the outer end than at the inner end.
15. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein the propeller is formed of aluminum.
16. The propeller according to claim 9, wherein each of the ribs has a center plane that is centrally defined between the leading surface and the trailing surface, and wherein the center plane is perpendicular to both the inner hub and the outer hub.
17. A method of making a propeller for a marine vessel, the method comprising: forming the propeller to have blades coupled to an outer hub; forming the propeller such that the outer hub is coupled to an inner hub via ribs, wherein the inner hub is configured to be coupled to the marine vessel, wherein the ribs each have a first end and a second end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the first end and the second end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, and wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween; forming each of the ribs to be tapered such that the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end; forming each of the ribs to be scalloped such that the width is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end; and forming the propeller such that each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub to be radially aligned with one of the blades; wherein the thickness decreases at a first rate between the second end and the midpoint, and the thickness decreases at a second rate between the midpoint and the first end, wherein the second rate is greater than the first rate.
18. A propeller for a marine vessel, the propeller comprising: an inner hub configured to be coupled to the marine vessel; an outer hub and a plurality of ribs that couple the outer hub to the inner hub, wherein the ribs each have a first end and a second end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the first end and the second end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, wherein the width is greater at the midpoint than at least one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are scalloped, and wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween, wherein the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are tapered; and a plurality of blades that are coupled to the outer hub; wherein each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub in radial alignment with one of the blades; and wherein the thickness decreases at a first rate between the second end and the midpoint, and the thickness decreases at a second rate between the midpoint and the first end, wherein the second rate is greater than the first rate.
19. A propeller for a marine vessel, the propeller comprising: an inner hub configured to be coupled to the marine vessel; an outer hub and a plurality of ribs that couple the outer hub to the inner hub, wherein the ribs each have a first end and a second end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the first end and the second end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, wherein the width is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are scalloped, and wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween, wherein the thickness is greater at the midpoint than at least at one of the first end and the second end such that the ribs are tapered; and a plurality of blades that are coupled to the outer hub; wherein each of the ribs is coupled to the outer hub in radial alignment with one of the blades; and wherein the propeller is configured such that the first end is farther than the second end from the marine vessel when the propeller is coupled thereto, wherein the thickness decreases at a first rate between the second end and the midpoint, wherein the thickness decreases at a second rate between the midpoint and the first end, wherein the second rate is greater than the first rate, and wherein each of the blades has a thickest region and each of the ribs is radially aligned with the thickest region of one of the blades.
20. A method of making a propeller for a marine vessel, the method comprising: forming the propeller to have blades coupled to an outer hub; forming the propeller such that the outer hub is coupled to an inner hub via ribs, wherein the inner hub is configured to be coupled to the marine vessel, wherein the ribs each have a forward end and an aft end that define a length therebetween, wherein a midpoint is further defined between the forward end and the aft end, wherein the ribs each have an inner end and an outer end that define a width therebetween, wherein the ribs each have a leading surface and a trailing surface that define a thickness therebetween; forming each of the ribs to be tapered such that the thickness decreases at a first rate between the forward end and the midpoint, and the thickness decreases at a second rate between the midpoint and the aft end, wherein the second rate is greater than the first rate; forming each of the ribs to be scalloped such that the width continuously increases from the aft end to the midpoint; and forming the propeller such that each of the blades has a blade width divided into even thirds, and such that each of the ribs is radially aligned with a center third of the even thirds of one of the blades.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) The drawings illustrate embodiments for carrying out the disclosure. The same numbers are used throughout the drawings to reference like features and like components. In the drawings:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
DETAILED DISCLOSURE
(12) This written description uses examples to disclose embodiments of the present disclosure and also to enable any person skilled in the art to practice or make and use the same. The patentable scope of the invention is defined by the claims and may include other examples that occur to those skilled in the art. Such other examples are intended to be within the scope of the claims if they have structural elements that do not differ from the literal language of the claims, or if they include equivalent structural elements with insubstantial differences from the literal language of the claims.
(13) In the present description, certain terms have been used for brevity, clarity, and understanding. No unnecessary limitations are to be implied therefrom beyond the requirement of the prior art because such terms are used for descriptive purposes only and are intended to be broadly construed. The different systems and methods described herein may be used alone or in combination with other systems and methods. Various equivalents, alternatives, and modifications are possible within the scope of the appended claims. Each limitation in the appended claims is intended to invoke interpretation under 35 USC 112(f), only if the terms means for or step for are explicitly recited in the respective limitation.
(14) The present disclosure generally relates to systems and methods for making a propeller for a marine vessel. An exemplary propeller for a marine vessel known in the art is shown in
(15) Each of the ribs 50 further extends between a first end 62 and a second end 64, which defines a length L therebetween. In the embodiment shown, the first end 62 is closer to the diffuser ring 90 than the second end 64. Similarly, each of the ribs 50 is defined as having a leading surface 72 and a trailing surface 74 to define a thickness T therebetween. As with the first end 62 and the second end 64, the leading surface 72 and trailing surface 74 may also be reversed, but are adopted as labels for clarity in the present disclosure.
(16) It should be recognized that while the diffuser ring 90 is generally described herein as being integrally formed with the propeller 10, this and other components disclosed herein may also be subsequently coupled through methods known in the art. Certain embodiments according to the present disclosure also lack a diffuser ring 90, but nonetheless refer to the diffuser ring 90 as a common landmark near the aft end of the propeller 10.
(17) Through experimentation and development, the present inventors have identified that systems and methods for making prior art propellers 2, which include a casting process known in the art, have an issue with porosity due to shrinkage. In particular, the designs of prior art propellers 2 frequently suffer from defects X caused by porosity due to shrinkage in the propeller materials during the casting process, as shown in the photograph of
(18) Compromises are made around casting temperature in order to contain and minimize the porosity. The porosity causes significant rework and repair, which causes significant variation in blade pitch, which in turn can cause vibration. The repair can also leave sub surface defects that can be sources for durability failures. Propellers that do not show symptoms of shrink are also likely to have sub surface defects that can cause durability issues. In addition, consideration for shell removal after casting can also complicate the design.
(19) The root cause for shrink porosity is that there is a section of the casting that is still molten while the feed line back to the pouring cup is solidifying (also referred to as freezing off). Once the puddle of molten steel solidifies, it shrinks and requires molten steel to feed the gap created. If the feed is shut off, it tears away from the solid steel around it and creates a significant amount of porosity.
(20) Traditionally, effort is taken to avoid putting thick ribs in contact with the blade as it creates a very large cross section, which takes even longer to solidify the root. As discussed above, the present disclosure adopts a different approach.
(21) The presently disclosed propeller 10 and methods for its creation include three primary features, which are discussed further below. In certain embodiments, each rib 50 has aggressive tapering 70 in the section where the blade 20 is expected to intersect the rib 50, whereby the precise intersection depends on pitch. The taper is therefore less aggressive where the blade 20 is not expected to intersect, forming a compound taper. This creates a tendency to solidify from bottom to top as desired. Scalloping 60 creates a secondary taper, which is quite aggressive for cross section reduction to keep the feed path open longer, specifically by solidifying from bottom to top as desired. Finally, placement of the rib 50 is aimed for the thermal center of each blade 20. In certain embodiments, the target is to be at or near the thickest region 24 of the blade 20. This again creates a tendency to solidify from thin to thick on the blade 20, thereby preventing porosity.
(22)
(23) Additionally, the present inventors have developed the model shown in
(24)
(25) As previously discussed with respect to the prior art propeller 2 shown in
(26) In certain embodiments, each blade 20 is evenly divided into thirds 26A-26C, whereby each rib 50 is formed to be in alignment with the center third 26B of one of the blades 20. In other embodiments, the ribs 50 are formed such that the blade alignment position 29 corresponds to a thickest region 24 or another position corresponding to the thermal center of a blade 20, which again has advantages for the reduction of shrinkage and porosity in the molding process.
(27)
(28) In certain embodiments, it can be said that this scalloping 60 appears as a continuous, concaved curve opening towards the aft end of the propeller 10. The radius of such a continuous curve may be uniform or non-uniform across the rib. These and other embodiments may further be described as incorporating scalloping 60 having a J-shape, a U-shape, a V-shape, or the like. In the embodiment shown in
(29) The present inventors have identified that by controlling the volume of material comprising the rib 50 through scalloping 60, tapering 70, and alignment with the blades 20, an improved solidification and cooling profile is provided during casting, thereby reducing porosity during the formation of the propeller 10. In particular, the systems and methods disclosed herein impact the time and direction of solidification to eliminate the creation of the isolated liquid pockets Z discussed above.
(30)
(31)
(32) In the embodiment shown, the tapering 70 between the second end 64 and the first end 62 primarily occurs at two different rates, a first rate section 76 between the second end 64 and the transition point 77, and a second rate section 78 between the transition point 77 and the first end 62. As shown, the second rate section 78 is greater, or more aggressive, than the first rate section 76. In addition to the tapering 70, the transitions of thickness T are shown to correspond with the differences in length L defined by the scalloping 60 previously discussed. For example, the length L1 between the first end 62 and the second end 64 shown as corresponding to the thickness T1 with respect to tapering 70 also corresponds to the length L1 with respect to scalloping 60. However, the transition points for scalloping 60 need not coincide with these for tapering 70. In the present embodiment, the transition point 77 is actually a transition segment, thereby defining lengths L2 and L3 between respective ends of the transition point 77 and the second end 64 of the rib 50. Likewise, the present embodiment depicts a rib 50 that is symmetrical across a central plane CP defined between the leading surface 72 and trailing surface 74.
(33) It should be recognized that in certain embodiments, the tapering 70 can be described as a continuous curve in the same manner describe with respect to scalloping 60 above. In other words, the rib 50 may have tapering 70 that is continuous, rather than linear, which may be applied over a portion or the entirety of the length L of the rib 50. By way of non-limiting example, the tapering 70 may resemble various V-shapes or U-shapes, which may be symmetrical or non-symmetrical about the center plane CP. In certain embodiments, the tapering 70 and/or scalloping 60 may also incorporate helical twisting (not shown) in addition, or as an alternative, to the tapering 70 and scalloping 60 previously described.
(34) An exemplary propeller 10 incorporating the design features previously discussed is shown in
(35) For comparison, the prior art propeller 2 from
(36)
(37)
(38) One of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that step 110 includes further sub-steps to produce a propeller mold in the customary manner. In an exemplary process, this would include creating a negative mold (such as of aluminum, but for a propeller 10 possessing the features disclosed herein), injecting wax into the mold to create a positive form of the propeller 10, then coating the wax with ceramic material. The wax is then melted out to create a ceramic shell having an internal negative cavity that again defines the propeller 10 to be cast.
(39) Once the propeller mold is created in step 110, molten material is poured into the mold in step 120 in the customary manner.
(40) The present inventors have identified a 2000 times reduction in porosity of certain propeller configurations produced according to the present disclosure over similar blade 20, rib 50 configurations known in the art.
(41) Moreover, the present inventors have identified that the systems and methods presently disclosed enable alignment of the ribs 50 with the blades 20 even with stainless steel propellers 10, which was previously known in the art to be problematic and is generally avoided. The present inventors have consequently found that by aligning the ribs 50 with the blades 20, the stress profiles of stainless steel propellers 10 are improved, whereby each of the blades 20 is better supported by the ribs 50 in use.