Detection device for bioluminescent detection of biomarkers from a biological fluid sample using luminescent sensing proteins
20200393450 ยท 2020-12-17
Assignee
Inventors
- Keisuke Tenda (Tokyo, JP)
- Remco Arts (Best, NL)
- Daniel Citterio (Kawasaki, JP)
- Maarten Merkx (Best, NL)
- Kosuke Tomimuro (Yokohama, JP)
Cpc classification
G01N2333/15
PHYSICS
B01L2200/0631
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L2200/10
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L3/502753
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01N2333/185
PHYSICS
B01L2400/0457
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01N33/542
PHYSICS
International classification
G01N33/542
PHYSICS
Abstract
A fully integrated sample-in-signal-out microfluidic paper-based analytical devices are provided relying on bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) switches for target analyte recognition and colorimetric signal generation. Simultaneous colorimetric detection and quantification of multiple antibodies in a single drop of whole blood is shown. The devices make use of BRET-based antibody sensing proteins integrated into vertically assembled layers of functionalized porous layer(s) of material. The device enables sample volume independent, eliminates addition of reagents to the sample, and has on-device blood plasma separation. User operation is a single drop of a sample and the acquisition of a photograph after sample introduction, with no requirement for precise pipetting, liquid handling or analytical equipment except for a camera. Using different antibodies as targets, simultaneous detection in whole blood was achieved. This device is believed to be ideally suited for user-friendly point-of-care-testing in low-resource environments based on BRET-sensors.
Claims
1. A detection device for bioluminescent detection of analytical targets from a fluid sample using luminescent sensing proteins, comprising: (a) a first lamination layer with an opening for receiving the fluid sample; (b) a separation membrane for separating part of the fluid sample received through the opening of the first lamination layer; (c) a first porous layer impregnated with a luciferin receiving the separated fluid sample, wherein the luciferin dissolves into the fluid sample; (d) a second porous layer patterned with detection areas separated by hydrophobic barriers, wherein the detection areas are impregnated with one or more different luminescent sensing proteins for the detection of the analytical targets, wherein the second porous layer receiving the luciferin dissolved fluid sample, as passed through the first porous layer, which then interacts with the one or more different luminescent sensing proteins to generate a bioluminescent signal; and (e) a second lamination layer, which together with the first lamination layer encases and immobilizes the separation layer, the first porous layer and the second porous layer into a single vertically stacked assembly detection device.
2. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the first and second porous layer are one single layer.
3. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the first porous layer is made out of paper, cellulose fibers, glass fibers, threads, bamboo, cloth, or any combination thereof.
4. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the second porous layer is made out of paper, cellulose fibers, glass fibers, threads, bamboo, cloth, or any combination thereof.
5. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the fluid sample is a biological fluid sample or a non-biological fluid sample.
6. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the separation membrane is a blood cell filtration membrane.
7. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the single vertically stacked assembly detection device enables a pump-free transport mechanism of the fluid sample by means of capillary forces, gravity or a combination thereof.
8. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the analytical targets are biomarkers, antibodies, antigens, proteins, drugs or nucleic acids.
9. The detection device as set forth in claim 1, wherein the detection device comprises a reference scale or reference system for the bioluminescent emission signals.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029]
[0030]
[0031]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] Some of the drawbacks of classical heterogeneous immunoassays were successfully addressed by introducing a new type of bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET)-based immunoassay that integrates antibody binding and signal generation in a single protein switch referred to as LUMABS (
[0033] Antibody binding in LUMABS results in a readily detected change in emitted bioluminescence from green to blue. This ratiometric response offers significant advantages over intensity-based sensing approaches, which are inherently influenced by factors not related to target analyte concentration. These properties and the absence of background fluorescence and scattered excitation light allowed direct detection of antibodies in blood plasma with LUMABS using a mobile phone camera as detector. BRET-based switches are not limited to antibody detection as they can also be useful for therapeutic drug monitoring of low molecular weight compounds and nucleic acids.
[0034] BRET-based ratiometric sensing is particularly useful for colorimetric assays on paper platforms, since it eliminates important challenges for PADs associated with external light sources, environmental light conditions and intensity-based signaling. An additional benefit of paper-based BRET signal detection compared to solution phase assays is the suppressed absorption of the bioluminescent signal by blood components because of the short optical path length of thin paper layers. While the latter advantage has already been demonstrated by performing the final read-out on filter paper, current assay procedures still require complex and quantitative liquid handling steps such as cell separation, sample dilution, and substrate addition and mixing. These steps, while done in a laboratory setting, represent significant hurdles for the practical application of BRET-based diagnostics in user-friendly point-of-care-testing (POCT) by untrained users.
[0035] In the present invention, we have developed a fully integrated microfluidic paper-based analytical devices (PAD) for use with bioluminescent BRET sensors, which is provided herein with exemplary embodiments for LUMABS-based detection of (multiple) antibodies in spiked whole blood samples.
[0036] The 3D-PAD design of this invention has several important features: [0037] (i) short flow paths compared to lateral flow designs, which allows for rapid assays with low sample volumes, including viscous blood serum or plasma, [0038] (ii) on-device blood cell removal from whole blood samples, [0039] (iii) separate storage of luciferase-integrating BRET sensors and corresponding substrates (luciferin) in close proximity, and [0040] (iv) patterned signaling layer for simultaneous detection of multiple targets and the possibility to include positive and negative standards
[0041] Another challenge associated with PADs in general is the fact that quantitative results depend on the applied sample volume, since signal intensity relies on the absolute amount of target analyte in the detection area rather than the concentration. We show that the closed space created by full lamination of a paper-based analytical device contributes to limiting the sample volume that can be absorbed by the paper substrate, which is important because it allows for sample volume independent measurements. The 3D-PADs were therefore designed as closed compartments by complete device lamination for sample volume independent measurements.
Results and Tests
[0042] Before assembly of the integrated device, we first used simple spot tests with an HIV1-p17 antibody targeting LUMABS on wax-patterned paper to confirm that the antibody concentration-dependent response of LUMABS on the paper platform is comparable to the one observed in bulk solution. Having established that performance of LUMABS on paper is similar to that in solution, we next tested the performance in an integrated device. First, devices with the three signal detection areas modified with identical amounts of a single type of LUMABS (anti-HIV-LUMABS, anti-DEN-LUMABS or anti-HA-LUMABS, respectively) (
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Relevant analytical parameters for response curves shown in FIGS. 2A and FIG. 2B. Mean relative LUMABS type (amount).sup.[a] c.sub.50/nM hue.sub.0/degrees.sup.[b] st. dev./%.sup.[c] HIV (100 fmol) (FIG. 2a) 6.35 172.8 0.8 0.63 DEN (100 fmol) (FIG. 2a) 35.57 175.4 0.9 0.48 HA (250 fmol) (FIG. 2a) 8.48 171.5 0.6 0.47 HIV (100 fmol) (FIG. 2b) 5.65 172.1 2.1 0.86 HIV (500 fmol) (FIG. 2b) 55.66 171.1 0.3 0.58 HIV (1000 fmol) (FIG. 2b) 116.16 172.0 1.3 0.48 .sup.[a]Absolute amount of LUMABS deposited on a single signal detection area, .sup.[b]Standard deviations for measurements performed in triplicate, .sup.[c]Mean relative standard deviation of hue values obtained by triplicate measurements over the entire response curve.
[0043] Also, satisfactory batch-to-batch fabrication reproducibility was achieved for these manually assembled 3D-PADs, showing a relative standard deviation of the mean of the c50 values below 1% (c50=6.400.06 nM) for three batches of anti-HIV1 detecting devices fabricated on three different days. Next, the colorimetric response of devices having three signal detection areas modified with different amounts of anti-HIV-LUMABS (100, 500 and 1000 fmol) (
[0044] The availability of three detection areas can also be used to allow the multiplex detection of 3 different antibodies.
[0045] An important advantage of the ratiometric, hue-based readout approach used here is that the signal should be independent of the bioluminescence intensity. This is particularly important for bioluminescent sensors, as bioluminescence intensity typically decreases in time as a result of substrate turn-over and/or product inhibition. The results shown in the images of
[0046] Volume-independent analysis and long-term stability represent two important aspects of device performance for point-of-care applications. The results shown in
[0047] To evaluate the suitability of the 3D-PADs for antibody detection in biological samples, we next performed experiments with antibody-spiked porcine serum samples. The absolute bioluminescence emission intensities decreased when switching from aqueous buffer solutions to the blood serum matrix, which has been attributed to a lower activity of the NanoLuc enzyme in that matrix. For this reason, the amount of LUMABS deposited onto the signal detection areas was increased to 500 fmol for all three of the investigated sensor variants. Linear regression fits were applied to the linear segments of the experimental data. Response curves expanded for the low antibody concentration range were used to determine limits of detection using the 3 s method, yielding LODs of 2.8 nM, 7.1 nM and 19.3 nM for the detection of anti-HIV1, anti-HA and anti-DEN1, respectively. Having established the performance in blood serum, we finally tested the performance of the 3D-PADs using whole blood samples spiked with three different antibodies at variable concentrations. Here, red and white blood cells, as well as platelets are removed by the blood separation membrane integrated into the paper device. First, we established the minimally required volume of whole blood by applying different volumes of whole blood spiked with 50 nM of anti-HA (
[0048]
[0049] This invention is the first demonstration of a fully integrated paper-based analytical system relying on ratiometric bioluminescence detection in a single drop of whole blood in a highly user-friendly just add the sample manner. Because the response of the system is independent of the applied sample volume over a wide volume range, no complex reagent handling and no quantitative sample metering are required. Although a standard digital camera was used in this study for signal acquisition, other embodiments or applications of the 3D-PAD devices may use a smartphone camera, allowing integration of signal detection and application-based analysis without a dedicated measurement instrument. Embodiments and/or applications of these 3D-PADs are also not restricted to LUMABS-based detection of antibodies but may be combined with any BRET-based sensor protein, including recently developed sensors for small-molecule drugs (LUCIDs) and nucleic acids (BRET-beacons). As such, this invention represents an important advance in the field of POCT by enabling the transfer of paper-based analytical device technology into the market place.
Experimental Procedures
[0050] The following is an exemplary embodiment of experimental procedures.
Materials and Instruments
[0051] Ultrapure water (18.2 M cm) from a PURELAB flex water purification system was used throughout all experiments. LUMinescent AntiBody Sensing proteins (LUMABS) against HIV1-p17 antibody (anti-HIV-LUMABS), dengue virus type 1 antibody (anti-DEN-LUMABS) and hemagglutinin (anti-HA-LUMABS) were prepared following the previously reported procedure.sup.[1] and stored in freeze dried form at 80 degrees Celsius. NanoGlo Luciferase assay substrate (N1110, Furimazine, with enclosed Promega buffer) was purchased from Promega Corporation (Tokyo, Japan). anti-Dengue Virus Type I (Antibody, clone 15F3-1) (anti-DENT) was purchased from Merck Millipore (Tokyo, Japan). Hemagglutinin (HA) Tag Monoclonal Antibody (2-2.2.14) (anti-HA) was purchased from Thermo Fisher Scientific (Kanagawa, Japan). HIV1-p17 (clone 32/1.24.89) antibody (anti-HIV1) was purchased from Zeptometrix (New York, America). PBS10 (phosphate buffered saline, pH 7.4) was purchased from Nippon Gene (Tokyo, Japan). Porcine whole blood with 0.3 wt % citric acid and porcine serum were purchased from Tokyo Shibaura Zouki Co (Tokyo, Japan). All other reagents were purchased from Wako Pure Chemical Industries Ltd. (Osaka, Japan).
[0052] The filter paper used was a Whatman No. 1 filter paper (GE Healthcare, Tokyo, Japan). Hydrophobic wax patterns on A4 sized filter papers were designed in Adobe Illustrator CC software and printed with a ColorQube 8570 wax printer (Xerox, Norwalk, Conn., USA), followed by a heating process where printed wax was melted into the paper by placing it on a hot plate (Nissin 99 NHS-450ND) at 150 degrees Celsius for 180 s. Vivid plasma separation membranes grade GR (Pall Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) were cut into 7.9 mm circles by a hand craft punch (McGill, d=7.9 mm). To encase devices comprising multiple layers, hot lamination with a QHE325 laminator (Meiko Shokai, Tokyo, Japan) using 100 m thick (including top and bottom layer) hot lamination sheets (Jointex, Tokyo, Japan) was performed. Inlet holes on the top lamination sheet layer were cut by a Silhouette Cameo electronic knife blade cutting device (Silhouette, Lehi, Utah, USA). For capturing bioluminescence signals from multi-layer 3D-PADs, a DMC-FZ50 digital camera (Panasonic, Osaka, Japan) was used.
Paper Layer Modification
[0053] In general, to prevent the non-specific adsorption of target antibodies and LUMABS, all filter papers (wax-patterned or non-patterned) were first soaked for 15 min in 0.5 wt % bovine serum albumin (BSA) solution in PBS for blocking, subsequently immersed for 15 min into water to wash out excess amounts of BSA and allowed to completely dry for 30 min at 40 degrees Celsius, before any further modification. The filter paper was wax-patterned into spots of 4.0 mm diameter. LUMABS was applied as solution in PBS buffer containing 1 mg/mL of BSA.
Multi-Layer Device Assembly
[0054] Devices were assembled in sets of 8 pieces. Onto a wax-patterned and LUMABS impregnated paper sheet (
Optical Signal Acquisition
[0055] After passing of the respective incubation time, the bioluminescence emission signal was monitored in 3-minute intervals by taking a picture in a darkroom box made out of Styrofoam for eliminating ambient light interference. The settings of the digital camera were as follows: white balance fixed; exposure time 60 s; ISO 1600; f-value 2.8. Images were captured in camera RAW format, followed by conversion into JPEG format by the image processor of the Adobe Photoshop CC software (color temperature 3200 K, tint 150). Using the converted JPEG file, the hue value (on the 0-360 degrees scale) of the signal readout area(s) was measured with the image processing software ImageJ (National Institutes of Health).
Spot Tests and Microplate Assay
[0056] For initial paper spot tests, 1 L of 100 nM of anti-HIV-LUMABS (corresponding to an absolute amount of 100 fmol of sensor protein) was deposited into the test spots. After drying completely, 0.3 L furimazine (30 times diluted by Promega buffer), followed by 4 L of sample containing HIV1-p17 antibody at different concentrations (in PBS with 1 mg/mL BSA) were added to the test spots. For comparison purposes, the assay was also performed in a white 96-well microplate. 20 L of HIV1-p17 antibody sample solutions were supplemented with furimazine and LUMABS at a final concentration of 25 nM. In all cases (paper platform and microplate), photographs were taken in the darkroom box starting 15 min after deposition of all reagents.
Assays with Multi-Layer Devices in Aqueous Buffer Solutions or in Porcine Serum
[0057] If not mentioned otherwise, 20 L of the corresponding sample solution (in PBS buffer with 1 mg/mL BSA or in porcine serum) with a specified antibody concentration was applied to the sample inlet area of device. Photographs were taken in the darkroom box starting 15 min after sample application. For experiments evaluating the influence of applied sample amounts, sample volumes were varied between 20 L (minimum) and 60 L (maximum).
Selectivity and Cross-Reactivity Evaluation
[0058] The response of 3D-PADs with signal detection areas modified with different LUMABS (
Storage Stability Evaluation
[0059] Fully assembled 3D-PADs modified with anti-HIV-LUMABS were placed into capped vials filled with argon gas containing silica gel desiccant and stored in a freezer at 20 C. Bioluminescence signal evolvement in aqueous solutions was evaluated at room temperature after various storage periods. Concentrations of pre-deposited furimazine and anti-HIV-LUMABS were as mentioned above for multi-layer devices.
Antibody-Spiked Porcine Whole Blood Assays with Multi-Layer Devices
[0060] Porcine whole blood containing 0.3 wt % citric acid as an anticoagulant was spiked with various amounts of either a single antibody or a mixture of antibodies. Experiments were performed as in the case of working with aqueous buffers or serum, however with the applied sample volume generally being 30 L (20-60 L for experiments evaluating the sample volume dependency) and the incubation time before starting photograph acquisition being 21 min to account for the volume reduction by blood cell separation and lower sample flow speeds due to increased viscosity, respectively.
Curve Fitting Procedure
[0061] Curve fitting of the experimentally obtained data (antibody concentration vs. hue values) was done using equation 1 shown below, where c.sub.50 indicates the antibody concentration resulting in 50% of the maximal hue change and hue.sub.max and hue.sub.0 represent the maximal change in the measured hue value and the hue value in the absence of target antibody, respectively.
Other embodiments and teachings are provided in US Provisional Application 62/550,001 filed Aug. 25, 2017, which is herein incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Alternate Embodiment
[0062] The embodiment shown in
[0063] The LUMABS-based TADs developed in this embodiment offer user-friendly, quantitative and simultaneous POCT for multiple antibodies from a single drop of whole blood small enough to be collected from a finger prick. This TAD has four vertically arranged layers including lamination films for device fixation, a blood separation membrane for separating plasma from whole blood, and a sewn cotton thread layer in which LUMABS and furimazine (substrate for the luciferase) are pre-deposited in dry form, spatially separated in two intertwisted threads to prevent their premature mixing (
Device Fabrication
[0064] A schematic of the TAD fabrication is shown in
Sample Preparation
[0065] Antibodies against HIV1-p17 (HIV), hemagglutinin (HA), and dengue virus type I (DEN) were spiked at different concentrations into porcine whole blood, except for assaying multiple antibodies with different LUMABS, where measurements were performed in PBS (pH 7.4) containing 1 mg/mL of BSA.
Bioluminescence Detection
[0066] Bioluminescence emission was recorded by a digital camera (60 s exposure) in the dark. The presence of target antibodies is indicated by a change in the color of the emitted bioluminescence from green to blue, which is quantified by means of the HUE parameter extracted from the acquired RGB values (
Results
[0067] To evaluate the bioluminescence response on TADs, 8 L whole blood samples spiked with antibodies at concentrations of 1 to 500 nM for anti-HA and anti-HIV or 5 to 1000 nM for anti-DEN were applied onto the sampling area. Based on linear curve fits applied to the low sample concentration ranges of the response curves, detection limits of 10 nM, 6.1 nM and 50 nM, respectively, were obtained for the three antibodies in whole blood. The antibody concentration-dependent change of the bioluminescence emission color from green to blue confirms the mixing and reaction of the spatially separately pre-deposited LUMABS and furimazine in the intertwisted threads upon target antibody introduction from whole blood samples, as well as the reliable removal of red blood cells by the blood separation filter integrated into the TADs, which would otherwise absorb the emitted bioluminescence. Furthermore, the obtained homogeneous signals from the six signal detection areas show that mixing of LUMABS deposited on each of the six hydrophilic areas separated by hydrophobic barriers patterned by the permanent ink marker is prevented and that target antibodies from whole blood samples are equally distributed to each of the signal detection areas.
[0068] The batch-to-batch reproducibility of the manually assembled devices was evaluated using whole blood samples at concentrations of 1 to 500 nM for anti-HIV. The investigated three batches of devices were independently fabricated on different days and tested on different days. The absence of statistically significant variations of the hue values observed for three replicate measurements are an indication for the excellent manufacturing reproducibility of the devices. The HUE value-based colorimetric bioluminescence emission signals in whole blood samples at concentrations of 0, 25 and 500 nM of anti-HIV were found to be stable between 6-18 min after sample application, indicating that there is no need for exactly timed signal readout.
[0069] Finally, the performance of TADs for the simultaneous detection of three different antibodies (all at 500 nM in PBS) was evaluated to confirm the absence of cross-talk between signal detection areas targeting different analytes. For this purpose, two of six detection areas on one device are modified with identical LUMABS. This result indicates that no cross-talk is observed in the case of assaying multiple different antibodies (32) on single TADs.