Composition and a Method of Using the Composition to Increase Wheat Yield

Abstract

The present invention comprises a novel combination and composition for controlling weeds in wheat. The combination comprises a post-emergence phenoxy herbicide such as Quizalofop-p-ethyl (QPE). The novel composition further includes a broadleaf herbicide. When applied to wheat comprising QPE tolerance, surprisingly, the novel composition appears to provide synergy that results in increased wheat yield over and above the yield expected from wheat intolerant of QPE, untreated wheat, or wheat treated with either QPE or a broadleaf herbicide. Despite the fact that QPE is typically used to kill members of the grass family, the present invention successfully employs the novel combination to increase wheat yield.

Claims

1. A method for controlling harmful plants in QPE-tolerant wheat, said method comprising applying a composition comprising a broadleaf herbicide and QPE at levels adequate to produce a synergistic effect on wheat yield resulting in yields above that expected from applying either a broadleaf herbicide without QPE or applying QPE without a broadleaf herbicide.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein said wheat yield is about 45% higher than QPE-tolerant wheat treated with only a broadleaf herbicide.

3. The method of claim 1 wherein said wheat yield is about 15% higher than QPE-tolerant wheat treated with only QPE.

4. The method of claim 1 wherein said composition comprises between about 8 and about 12 ounces per acre QPE at 0.88 lbs a.i./gallon where a.i. indicates active ingredient.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein the broadleaf herbicide comprises between about 0.3 and about 1.0 lb. ai/acre of one or more of 2,4-D Ester and MCPA Ester.

6. The method of claim 1 wherein the broadleaf herbicide comprises between about 15 fl oz./acre and 32 fl a/acre of one or more of Bromoxynil+MCPA, Clopyralid+MCPA, and Pyrasulfotole+BroxM.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein the broadleaf herbicide comprises between about 0.1 and about 5 oz/acre of one or more of Dicamba, Flucarbazone, Starane Ultra, Mesosulfuron, Propoxycarbazone, Prosulfuron, Pyroxsulam, Thifensulfuron, Tribenuron, Sulfosulfuron, and Pyroxasulfone.

8. The method of claim 1 wherein the broadleaf herbicide comprises between 0.1 said composition comprises between about 0.3 and about 1.0 lb ai/acre broadleaf herbicide.

9. The method of claim 1 wherein said composition is applied at one of 8, 10, and 12 ounces per acre.

10. A composition for controlling harmful plants in and increasing the yield of QPE-tolerant wheat above an expected yield resulting from any of: application of a broadleaf herbicide alone, application of QPE alone, and serial or separate applications of a broadleaf herbicide and QPE, said composition comprising a broadleaf herbicide and QPE combined.

11. The composition of claim 7 wherein application of said composition produces a synergistic effect on yield.

12. A method of controlling weeds in wheat plants covered by U.S. Pat. No. 9,578,880 said method comprising applying a composition comprising a broadleaf herbicide and QPE, wherein the application rate of said QPE ranges between about 8 and about 12 ounces per acre QPE at 0.88 lbs a.i./gallon where a.i. indicates active ingredient.

13. The method of claim 12 wherein said method produces a synergistic effect thereby increasing yield of said wheat plants above a yield of wheat plants to which a broadleaf herbicide is applied without QPE and above a yield of wheat plants to which QPE is applied without a broadleaf herbicide.

Description

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017] FIG. 1 is a diagram of a molecular structure of Quizalofop-p-ethyl (QPE)

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0018] The present invention employs a previously unknown synergistic relationship to attain markedly higher yields of wheat. Specifically, the invention demonstrates that the application of QPE and a broadleaf controller to QPE-tolerant wheat does not result in a simple additive increase in the yield of wheat. Further, the application of QPE to QPE tolerant wheat in combination with a broadleaf controller does not negatively affect the effectiveness of the broadleaf controller, nor is the effectiveness of QPE grass control decreased. Instead, wheat treated in the manner disclosed herein exhibits an increased yield over QPE-tolerant wheat treated with QPE alone, or treated with a broadleaf controller alone. The present invention demonstrates a previously unknown synergistic effect on yield offering producers a means to increase yield while managing weeds.

[0019] Yield of QPE-tolerant wheat in bushels per acre was measured under the following conditions: where no QPE was applied, where QPE was applied alone, where one or more broadleaf herbicides were applied, and where a combination of a QPE source and a broadleaf herbicide were applied together. For each test condition, the level of both grass control and broadleaf control was recorded. Finally, the application rate of each active substance was recorded. One QPE source is Aggressor which comprises Quizalofop-P-ethyl 10.3%. The results may be reviewed as presented below in Table 1.

TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Grass Broadleaf Weed Yield Treatment A Treatment B Rate/Acre Control Control Bu/acre Aggressor 8 94% 0% 71.2 Aggressor 10 95% 0% 74.8 Aggressor 12 96% 0% 75.4 2,4-D Ester .31 lb ai/acre 0% 85% 56.4 2,4-D Ester .62 lb ai/acre 0% 95% 57.3 MCPA Ester .50 lb ai/acre 0% 90% 58.3 MCPA Ester 1.00 lb ai/acre 0% 95% 60.2 2,4-D Amine .50 lb ai/acre 0% 75% 55.7 2,4-D Amine 1.00 lb ai/acre 0% 90% 56.8 MCPA Amine .50 lb ai/acre 0% 78% 52.4 MCPA Amine 1.00 lb ai/acre 0% 93% 56.9 Bromoxynil + MCPA 16 fl oz/acre 0% 95% 58.3 Bromoxynil + MCPA 24 fl oz/acre 0% 98% 60.1 Clopyralid + MCPA 16 fl oz/acre 0% 90% 59.3 Clopyralid + MCPA 32 fl oz/acre 0% 96% 60.2 Dicamba 3 fl oz/acre 0% 90% 56.7 Dicamba 4 fl oz/acre 0% 93% 57.9 Dicamba 5 fl oz/acre 0% 96% 58.4 Everest Flucarbazone 2 oz/acre 65% 55% 67.3 Starane Ultra .105 lb ae/acre 0% 85% 60.1 Starane Ultra .210 lb ae/acre 0% 93% 58.3 Outrider Sulfosulfuron .66 oz/acre 55% 60% Osprey Mesosulfuron 4.75/acre 35% 50% 60.4 Olympus Propoxycarbazone .90 oz/acre 45% 65% 63.2 Peak Prosulfuron .60 oz/acre 0% 85% 59.2 Zidua Pyroxsulam 2 oz/acre 70% 30% 60.3 Harmony Thifensulfuron .30 oz/acre 0% 93% 59.1 Ally Tribenuron .30 oz/acre 0% 93% 58.4 Aggressor+ 2,4-D Ester .31 lb ai/acre 95% 85% 88.7 Aggressor+ 2,4-D Ester .62 lb ai/acre 93% 95% 86.4 Aggressor+ MCPA Ester .50 lb ai/acre 95% 90% 85.3 Aggressor+ MCPA Ester 1.00 lb ai/acre 95% 95% 86.2 Aggressor+ Bromoxynil + MCPA 16 fl oz/acre 98% 95% 88.3 Aggressor+ Bromoxynil + MCPA 24 fl oz/acre 98% 98% 89.2 Aggressor+ Clopyralid + MCPA 16 fl oz/acre 96% 90% 86.4 Aggressor+ Clopyralid + MCPA 32 fl oz/acre 98% 96% 87.3 Aggressor+ Dicamba 3 fl oz/acre 96% 90% 87.4 Aggressor+ Dicamba 4 fl oz/acre 95% 93% 86.5 Aggressor+ Dicamba 5 fl oz/acre 93% 96% 83.1 Aggressor+ Flucarbazone 2 oz/acre 95% 55% 78.5 Aggressor+ Starane Ultra .105 lb ae/acre 96% 85% 89.1 Aggressor+ Starane Ultra .210 lb ae/acre 98% 93% 88.4 Aggressor+ Mesosulfuron 4.75 oz/acre 95% 65% 79.5 Aggressor+ Propoxycarbazone .90 oz/acre 95% 83% 81.2 Aggressor+ Prosulfuron .60 oz/acre 98% 85% 82.6 Aggressor+ Pyroxsulam 2 oz/acre 95% 80% 85.7 Aggressor+ Thifensulfuron .30 oz/acre 96% 93% 86.4 Aggressor+ Tribenuron .10 oz/acre 98% 98% 87.4 Aggressor+ Sulfosulfuron .66 oz/acre 50% 60% 71.4 Aggressor+ Pyroxasulfone 1 & 2 oz/acre 77% 98% 89.2 Aggressor+ Pyrasulfotole + BroxM 15 oz/acre 95% 98% 89.6

[0020] Unexpectedly, a synergistic effect on yield was detected for certain combinations where the QPE source and a broadleaf herbicide were both applied. Broadleaf herbicides that are contemplated by the present invention include, but are not limited to the list provided in the Background section of this document. Specifically, 1) where the QPE source (0.88 lbs a.i./gallon) (where a.i. indicates active ingredient) was applied at the rate of 8, 10, or 12 ounces per acre, without a broadleaf herbicide, yields were between 75.4 to 71.2 bu/acre and, generally, grass was controlled over 90%. And, 2) where the broadleaf herbicides were applied, either alone or in combination, at two different rates, but without QPE, broadleaf weeds were controlled and the yields were between 52.4 and 67.3. For the vast majority of trials where the QPE source was applied, grass was controlled.

[0021] When the broadleaf herbicides were applied, in combination with QPE, at two different rates, grass control was generally in the 90+% with a few exceptions. Further, the broadleaf herbicide/grass herbicide (QPE) combination resulted in yields exhibiting the synergistic effect of the combination. Namely, yield of wheat subjected to QPE treatment without broadleaf herbicide was 71.2 to 75.4 bu/acre. Yield of wheat subjected to broadleaf herbicide treatments without QPE ranged 52.4 to 67.3 bu/acre. But yields of the wheat treated with a combination of broadleaf herbicide and QPE ranged 71.4 to 89.6 and averaged 85.4 bu/acre. For most of the samples where the combination was applied, the combination also provided high levels of both grass and broadleaf control. It may have been expected that combining QPE and broadleaf herbicide might result in a yield better than one of the treatments, however, the combined treatment of broadleaf herbicide and QPE resulted in an increased reported yield that indicates more than a simple additive effect. Namely, 20 of the 23 trials where QPE and broadleaf herbicide was combined reported yields over 80 bu/acre with a high reported at 89.6 as compared to a control where only broadleaf treatment was applied and none of the 25 trials showed yields over 67.3 bushels/acre, and a control where only QPE was applied to three samples and their yields ranged 71.2 to 75.4 bushels/acre.

[0022] Finally, formulations and compositions comprising the present invention may be made as known by those of ordinary skill in the art and may comprise, but are not limited to, one or more of: wettable powder, dust, dispersion concentrate, emulsifiable concentrate, and water dispersible granules comprising or consisting of QPE, or QPE and a broadleaf herbicide.