MRI RF pulse sequence for multidimensional outer volume suppression
10690739 ยท 2020-06-23
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01R33/5602
PHYSICS
International classification
G01R33/483
PHYSICS
Abstract
A magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques uses a T2-preparation outer volume suppression (OVS) pulse sequence to reduce the longitudinal magnetization outside a region of interest. A region is excited that includes the region of interest, radiofrequency (RF) signals are detected, and MRI images generated from the RF detected signals. The T2-preparation OVS pulse sequence includes, sequentially: a first tip-down excitation pulse, a first refocusing excitation pulse, a first tip-up excitation pulse that is selective spatially and/or spectrally, a second tip-down excitation pulse that is 180 out of phase with respect to the first tip-down excitation pulse, a second refocusing excitation pulse, and a second tip-up excitation pulse that is selective spatially and/or spectrally. Alternatively, the first tip-down excitation pulse is selective spatially and/or spectrally instead of the first tip-up excitation pulse, and the second tip-down excitation pulse is selective spatially and/or spectrally instead of the second tip-up excitation pulse.
Claims
1. A method for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) using a T2-preparation outer volume suppression (OVS) and fat suppression pulse sequence, the method comprising: with an MRI apparatus, applying a T2-preparation OVS pulse sequence to reduce the longitudinal magnetization outside a region of interest (ROI); and with the MRI apparatus, exciting a region that includes the region of interest, detecting from the region radiofrequency (RF) signals responsive to the excitation, and generating MRI images from the detected RF signals; wherein the T2-preparation OVS pulse sequence comprises, sequentially: a first half of the sequence comprising: a first tip-down 90, 90.sub.60180.sub.60 composite excitation pulse, a first 180 orthogonal hard refocusing excitation pulse, a first tip-up spatially and spectrally selective 90 spatial sinc excitation pulse, and a second half of the sequence comprising: a second tip-down 90, 90.sub.60180.sub.60 composite excitation pulse that is an amplitude-negated version of the first tip-down 90 composite excitation pulse, a second 180 orthogonal hard refocusing excitation pulse, and a second tip-up spatially and spectrally selective 90 spatial sinc excitation pulse that is an amplitude-negated version of the first tip-up selective 90 spatial sinc excitation pulse.
2. The method of claim 1 wherein the first tip-up pulse is a spectral-spatial pulse with sinc envelope and sinc subpulses, and the second tip-up pulse is a spectral-spatial pulse with sinc envelope and sinc subpulses.
3. A non-transitory, tangible, computer-readable storage medium containing a program of instructions that cause an MRI scanner to implement the method of claim 1.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(9)
(10) The first half of the sequence plays a 90 composite tip-down pulse 100, a 180 orthogonal hard refocusing pulse 102, and a selective 90 spatial sinc tip-up pulse 104 with appropriate timings for an echo time of .sub.1. The remaining transverse magnetization is spoiled. The second half negates in amplitude the tip-down and tip-up pulses, with echo time .sub.2. Specifically, the second half of the sequence begins with a tip-down pulse 106 that is an amplitude-negated version of the first tip-down pulse 100 to tip in the opposite direction. The refocusing pulse 108 is the same as 102 and the selective tip-up pulse 110 is independent of the first selective tip-up pulse 104. The remaining transverse magnetization is again spoiled. The combined effects of the two selective tip-up pulses 104 and 110 determine the nature of the OVS. The anti-symmetry of the overall sequence is important for B.sub.1 robustness for the passband. By tipping down in opposite directions for each half of the sequence, any imperfections from the first half of the sequence are compensated by the second half.
(11) There is a total T.sub.2 decay time of T.sub.prep=.sub.1+.sub.2. The value of T.sub.prep can be adjusted to incorporate T.sub.2-weighting for applications such as angiography. For general applications, T.sub.prep can be minimized.
(12) The tip-down pulses 100 and 106 are 90, 90.sub.60180.sub.60 composite pulses that are rotated such that the on-resonance magnetization is tipped onto the Y axis. By design, composite pulses are robust to B.sub.1 inhomogeneities. Additionally, the bandwidth is sufficient to be robust to off-resonance and excite fat at 1.5 T. In the passband of the pulse, the phase is approximately linear. This permits the pulse to be paired with a conventional tip-up pulse that has linear phase.
(13) The refocusing pulses 102 and 108 are 180 hard pulses. Off-resonance robustness of the sequence is constrained by the refocusing pulse so increasing bandwidth will improve performance. B.sub.1 robustness is added by refocusing orthogonally to satisfy CPMG conditions with this pulse.
(14) APEX can be adapted to various applications by customizing the two tip-up pulses 104 and 110 at the end of each half of the sequence. The sequence in
(15) A method of MRI using the pulse sequence of
(16) For applications such as coronary angiography, T.sub.2-preparation is beneficial for contrast enhancement. This requires a longer T.sub.prep and allows more time for sophisticated pulses. We use a 90 spectral-spatial sinc composed of spatial sinc subpulses with TBW 8 under a spectral sinc envelope with TBW 8. The pulse is spectrally designed with the assumption of cardiac imaging at 1.5 T. The passband for water is prioritized and as a tradeoff, the range of fat off-resonant frequencies is placed partially in the stopband and partially in the transition band.
(17) The spoiling gradients are on orthogonal axes to prevent stimulated echoes. Spoiling while the desired magnetization is longitudinal rather than transverse is crucial for minimizing flow-related phase effects. If suppressing flow signal is desirable, such as in black-blood imaging, spoilers can also be placed before and after each refocusing pulse.
(18) Numerical Bloch simulations were performed to evaluate the resulting M.sub.Z after the sequence. Bloch simulations with a spatial sinc tip-up were performed with T.sub.prep=6 ms and ignoring relaxation (T.sub.1=, T.sub.2=). Off-resonance was simulated over a frequency range of [128,128] Hz. B.sub.1 inhomogeneities were simulated over a range of [0.8,1.2] of the normalized B.sub.1 value. Bloch simulations with a spectral-spatial sinc tip-up intended for coronary angiography were performed with T.sub.prep=35 ms and with time constants simulating muscle at 1.5 T (T.sub.1=1008 ms, T.sub.2=44 ms). Off-resonance was simulated over frequency ranges of [64,64] Hz and [300,300] Hz to consider off-resonance of water and lipids at 1.5 T. B.sub.1 inhomogeneities were simulated over a range of [0.8,1.2] of the normalized B.sub.1 value.
(19)
(20) The most important factor for generating off-resonance robustness in this sequence is the alternating tip-down angles. If the two tip-down angles are the same polarity, the passband remains largely the same but the stopband is not tolerant of B.sub.0 inhomogeneity. For the sequence simulated in
(21)
(22) Phantom experiments were performed with a spectral-spatial sinc as the tip-up pulse to evaluate the spatial selectivity and fat saturation of the OVS sequence. The MRI imaging experiments were conducted on a 1.5 T GE Signa Excite scanner (GE Healthcare, Waukesha, Wis.) with a maximum gradient amplitude of 40 mT/m and slew rate of 150 mT/m/ms. All scans used the body coil for transmission. The phantom and in vivo cardiac studies used an 8-channel cardiac receive coil. The composite and refocusing pulse had durations of 900 s and 600 s respectively. The images were acquired with a single-slice gradient-echo sequence with field of view (FOV) 28 cm28 cm, 5 mm slice thickness, 256256 matrix size, TE=2 ms, TR=200 ms, flipangle=30, and T.sub.prep=35 ms.
(23) A spherical phantom with radius 14 cm was used to evaluate spatial selectivity. The spatially selective gradients were scaled to achieve a 14 cm passband. To demonstrate and evaluate the versatility and properties of the tip-up pulses, the spatial selectivities of each tip-up pulse were turned on and off.
(24) To evaluate the spatial suppression of the sequence, a quotient image was calculated by dividing the image with OVS by an image without OVS, Q=I.sub.OVS/I.sub.noOVS. Using the quotient image, passband-to-stopband ratio (PSR) was calculated by dividing mean signal of ROIs in the passband and stopband such that
PSR=Q.sub.passband/Q.sub.stopband.
(25) A water/oil phantom was used to evaluate fat saturation.
(26) Acquisitions of the phantom with no OVS sequence, the proposed sequence with T.sub.2-preparation and no OVS, and the proposed sequence with T.sub.2-preparation and OVS were performed. To evaluate the fat saturation, we compared the mean signal remaining after OVS with the signal acquired without preparation. We also evaluated spatial PSR by comparing the image with T.sub.2-preparation but no OVS with the image with T.sub.2-preparation and OVS.
(27)
(28)
(29) In vivo head scans were used to demonstrate the performance of the sequence when no contrast manipulation is desired. The in vivo head scans used an 8-channel head coil. To minimize T.sub.prep, a 2 ms spatial sinc tip-up was used. Images were acquired with FOV=28 cm28 cm, 10 mm slice thickness, 256128 matrix size and T.sub.prep=6 ms. Total OVS duration was 11.1 ms and the sequence was played every TR. Proton-density-weighted images were acquired with spoiled gradient echo TE=2 ms, TR=1000 ms, flip angle=30. T.sub.1-weighted images were acquired with spoiled gradient echo TE=2 ms, TR=30 ms, flip angle=20. T2-weighted images were acquired with spin echo TE=50 ms, TR=1000 ms, flip angle=30. For a typical tissue with T.sub.2=50 ms, 89% of the original signal is expected to remain in the passband after OVS. The goal of these scans was to qualitatively demonstrate that the slight T.sub.2 weighting of the OVS sequence does not drastically alter the magnetization within the OVS FOV.
(30)
(31) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE I PSR RESULTS FOR HEAD SCANS IN FIG. 5 Brain Tissue PSR Fat PSR Contrast Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal PD 23.1 17.8 4.5 2.5 T.sub.1 21.9 16.2 4.1 2.2 T.sub.2 18.1 14.5 2.1 1.5
(32) In vivo cardiac scans were performed to demonstrate the versatility of the sequence and its application to coronary angiography. The spectral-spatial sinc tip-up designed for coronary angiography with pulse duration 7 ms was used. Acquisitions were gated by plethysmography for acquisition during diastole. Images were acquired with a 3D cones trajectory with alternating-TR (aTR) steady-state free precession (SSFP), TE=0.5 ms, TR.sub.1/TR.sub.2=4.484/1.196 ms, FOV=28 cm28 cm14 cm, flip angle=70, 1.2 mm isotropic resolution, 2D OVS ROI=14.5 cm11.4 cm, and T.sub.prep=35 ms. The cones were acquired in a phyllotaxis order to improve image quality and robustness to motion. The SSFP was catalyzed by a cosine ramp of 10 pulses for a catalyzation time of 56 ms. The OVS sequence was played once every R-R interval immediately before the SSFP catalyzation. The aTR timings were chosen to place an SSFP spectral null on fat for further fat suppression. 3D image-based navigators (iNAVs) were collected after the cones acquisition to construct a 3D translational motion model and the k-space acquisitions were adjusted with linear phase compensation for retrospective motion correction. T.sub.2-preparation is common in coronary MR angiography for increasing blood-myocardium contrast. Thus, to demonstrate the additional effects of OVS, we performed three scans: with no OVS or T.sub.2-preparation, with T.sub.2-preparation only, and with both OVS and T.sub.2-preparation. To evaluate the images, we calculated blood signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and blood-myocardium contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). SNR is calculated from an ROI in the left ventricle (LV) such that SNR=.sub.LV/.sub.LV. CNR compares the signal from an ROI in the left ventricle with the signal from an ROI in the myocardium (MYO) of the interventricular septum such that CNR=(.sub.LV.sub.MYO)/.sub.LV.
(33)
(34)
(35) From the phantom and in vivo results, we see that APEX can achieve sharp spatial profiles with strong suppression, corroborating Bloch simulation results. This sequence has sufficient bandwidth for robustness to typical off-resonance at 1.5 T. To further improve off-resonance performance, higher maximum RF amplitude is used to achieve higher bandwidths for both the composite 90 tip-down and 180 refocusing pulses.
(36) Almost all existing OVS techniques are robust to B.sub.1 inhomogeneities either from adiabatic pulses or repeated saturation. The simulations of APEX with both sinc and spectral-spatial sinc tip-ups demonstrate the robustness of this sequence to B.sub.1 inhomogeneity as well. However, sequences using adiabatic pulses likely have greater B.sub.1 inhomogeneity robustness, especially when B.sub.1 exceeds its nominal value. Additionally, sequences using adiabatic refocusing pulses can achieve greater bandwidth than hard pulses and have greater off-resonance robustness as a result.
(37) The two tip-up pulses presented are both based on sincs and the flip angles are thus linearly sensitive to small B.sub.1 inhomogeneities. In general, many potential tip-up pulses are linearly sensitive to B.sub.1 inhomogeneities. However, the tip-up pulses are nominally 90. For some small tip angle inhomogeneity , M.sub.z is proportional to sin(90+), which has a first-order derivative of zero, mitigating net sensitivity to B.sub.1 inhomogeneity. Furthermore, although transverse magnetization is proportional to cos(90+), which is sensitive to inhomogeneities, we are spoiling immediately. This creates an effective reset of the magnetizations in the passband such that any imperfections are not magnified.
(38) Additional robustness for the selectivity of the sequence can be gained by repeating the tip-up pulse in both halves. The configuration for cardiac imaging already implements this by spectrally suppressing fat twice.
(39) As a tradeoff for using adiabatic pulses or repeated RF pulses to achieve B.sub.0 and B.sub.1 robustness, existing sequences have high SAR.
(40) Additionally, many existing sequences are time consuming, especially those that achieve OVS by saturating multiple 1D slabs, with some durations over 200 ms. Sequences with spatially selective tip-up and tip-down pulses are in general shorter. The sequence in the configuration shown in
(41) Phantom results corroborate the performance of the sequence in the Bloch simulations. We see a lower PSR in
(42) The head scan results demonstrate expected contrast when T.sub.prep is minimized. This suggests that APEX can be used in Mill applications even where T.sub.2-weighting may not be desired. To further minimize T.sub.2-weighting, additional techniques can be used to reduce the tip-up pulse duration such as time-optimal VERSE.
(43) The head scans with proton-density-weighted, T.sub.1-weighted, and T.sub.2-weighted contrasts have vertical PSRs of 23.1, 21.9, and 18.1 and horizontal PSRs of 17.8, 16.2, and 14.5 respectively. This is similar to results from reference which had PSR=16.6 from its phantom results. The fat has relatively lower PSR, likely due to its shorter T.sub.1.
(44) From the coronary angiography results, we see that when comparing the images with no T.sub.2-preparation or OVS to the image with only T.sub.2-preparation, the SNR has decreased and the CNR has increased. This is expected because it has been demonstrated in previous work that T.sub.2-preparation increases CNR and by the nature of T.sub.2-preparation, the signal decreases. When comparing the images with T.sub.2-preparation and no OVS to the images with T.sub.2-preparation and OVS, we see that the chest muscle has already become partially suppressed from the T.sub.2-preparation and the OVS further reduces the signal. The myocardium PSR=3.2 echo the results from reference, which had a mean PSR=3.18. Suppression of the arms from T.sub.2-preparation and OVS to reduce aliased signal when reconstructing likely accounts for the sharper coronary images.
(45) We see in
(46) In these fully sampled images, the recovered chest fat signal does not impact image quality but aliasing could become an issue when attempting to reduce the FOV. The severity of the aliasing artifact can be reduced by selecting a trajectory that oversamples the center of k-space, such as cones, 3D radial, and PROPELLER trajectories. Oversampling will reduce low frequency aliasing and as we can see from
(47) In contrast to the cardiac results, the brain images with OVS in
(48) Another advantage of this sequence is its uniform, high TBW passband. Alternative OVS sequences use 2D-spiral pulses which result in sensitivity to B.sub.0 and B.sub.1 inhomogeneities that distort the 2D passband profile in the form of ripple and phase shifts. 2D-spiral pulses also cannot achieve a high TBW in the allotted excitation time. These apodization effects can negatively impact intensity-based motion correction algorithms. A more uniform passband also leads to lower passband variance and thus higher SNR.
(49) All the experiments were performed at 1.5 T and translation of sequence performance to 3 T remains to be investigated. The Bloch simulation results of
(50) Finally, each tip-up pulse provides up to 2D selectivity. We have taken advantage of this through the spatial-spectral pulses for cardiac imaging. There is also a possibility for selectivity spectrally and in three spatial dimensions for 4D OVS. Initial Bloch simulation results demonstrate that this is achievable.
(51) The first tip-up pulse and second tip-up pulse can be frequency modulated such that the OVS passband is shifted spatially.
(52)
(53) The apparatus may be configured to perform the techniques of the present invention by means of a non-transitory, tangible, computer-readable storage medium containing a program of instructions that cause an Mill scanner to implement the methods described herein.
(54) We have presented a new framework for implementing multidimensional OVS with robustness to B.sub.0 and B.sub.1 inhomogeneities. Furthermore, the OVS sequence can be made relatively short and has relatively low SAR. APEX is designed to be simple to implement and have minimal impact on overall scan time. We have demonstrated the sequence in several in vivo examples and the flexibility of the sequence suggests it is suitable for other applications as well.