Method for creating porous structures by particle expansion
10648064 ยท 2020-05-12
Assignee
- Millersville University of Pennsylvania (Millersville, PA, US)
- The United States Of America As Represented By The Secretary Of The Army (Washington, DC)
Inventors
- Mark Andrew Atwater (Sunbury, PA, US)
- Kris Allen Darling (Havre de Grace, MD, US)
- Mark Allen Tschopp, Jr. (Bel Air, MD, US)
Cpc classification
B22F2202/03
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F9/04
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F2202/03
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F2999/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F3/1121
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F2998/10
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F2998/10
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F3/1143
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F2999/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F3/24
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B22F9/04
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
Abstract
A process for producing a metal foam includes mechanically working a metallic powder such that oxide particles are finely dispersed within a metallic matrix and annealing the mechanically worked metallic powder in a vacuum the annealed metallic powder such that intraparticle porosity is formed by decomposition of the oxide particles at elevated temperature to reduce the oxide particles to metallic form and liberate the oxygen atoms in gaseous form, thereby creating porosity.
Claims
1. A process for producing a metal foam comprising: mechanically working a metallic powder such that oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen are finely dispersed within a metallic matrix; annealing the mechanically worked metallic powder in a vacuum; and forming the metal foam of the annealed metallic powder having intraparticle porosity formed by decomposition of the oxide particles at an elevated temperature to reduce the oxide particles to metallic form and liberate the oxygen atoms in gaseous form, thereby creating porosity.
2. The process of claim 1, wherein the metallic powder is a silver containing metallic powder.
3. The process of claim 1, wherein the mechanical working ball milling the metallic powder.
4. The process of claim 1, wherein the metallic powder is a copper containing metallic powder.
5. The process of claim 3, wherein the ball milling is cryogenic ball milling.
6. The process of claim 3, wherein the ball milling is room temperature ball milling.
7. The process of claim 1, wherein the annealing occurs at a temperature less than or equal to 800 C.
8. The process of claim 1, wherein the annealing occurs at a temperature less than or equal to 400 C.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(13) An improved process for producing a porous powder is provided. In addition, the porous powder can be used to produce metal foam. Stated differently, the process provides a plurality of particles within intraparticle porosity that can be used to produce metal foam. It is appreciated that a powder is a plurality of particles and the terms powder and particles are used interchangeably herein.
(14) The process includes mechanically working a metallic powder such that finely dispersed oxide particles are produced or are present within a metallic host matrix. For example, ball milling, extrusion and the like can be used to mechanically work the metallic powder.
(15) After the metallic powder with finely dispersed oxide particles have been produced, the oxide containing powder is annealed in a reducing atmosphere. For example, a metal powder can be ball milled and annealed in a reducing gas atmosphere containing hydrogen, ammonia, etc. In the alternative, a combination of metal powders can be balled mill to produce a mechanically alloyed powder, which is then annealed in a reducing gas atmosphere. Examples of metal powders include powders made from titanium, chromium, manganese, iron, cobalt, nickel, copper, zinc, aluminum, niobium, molybdenum, silver and alloys thereof. In some instances, copper metal powder, with or without a copper alloying element powder, can be ball milled. In addition, the ball milling may or may not be conducted at cryogenic temperatures.
(16) The ball milled powders contain oxygen. In some instances, the metal powder or combination of metal powders contain oxygen before being ball milled, however this is not required. Stated differently, the metal powder or combination of metal powders can have oxygen added thereto during the ball milling process. In addition, the oxygen can be present within and/or on the surface of the powder particles as adsorbed oxygen and/or as an oxide.
(17) The reducing atmosphere can contain hydrogen, however this is not required. For example, the reducing atmosphere can be a pure hydrogen atmosphere, an inert gas-hydrogen mixture, an ammonia containing gas mixture, a CO-containing atmosphere and the like. For example, an argon-hydrogen (ArH.sub.2) gas mixture can be used. In addition, the hydrogen reacts with the oxygen within and/or on the surface of the powder particles, e.g. oxygen in the form of oxide particles, during the annealing treatment to form steam (H.sub.2O(g)). As such, it is appreciated that the reducing atmosphere is an atmosphere that results in the reduction of oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen into vapor or gas molecules such that porosity is formed within the metallic matrix.
(18) Annealing of the ball milled powder can occur at a temperature less than or equal to 800 C. In some instances, annealing occurs at a temperature less than or equal to 700 C. In other instances, annealing occurs at a temperature less than or equal to 600 C. In the alternative, annealing can occur at temperatures greater than 800 C. for faster kinetics.
(19) It is appreciated that the inventive ball milled powder can be formed into a component having a desired shape before the annealing treatment. For example, ball milled powder can be pressed into the desired shape and then annealed, which in turn can serve as a sintering treatment. In addition, the annealed component can have a porosity of at least 10%, 20%, 30% or 40%, preferably at least 50%, more preferably at least 60%, and still more preferably at least 65%. It is also appreciated that porosity is a measure of the void (i.e., empty) spaces in a material, and is a fraction of the volume of voids over the total volume, between 0 and 1, or as a percentage between 0 and 100%.
(20) In an effort to better explain the invention and yet not limit its scope in any way, one or more examples are discussed below.
(21) A copper-antimony (CuSb) alloy powder was formed by mechanically alloying Cu and Sb powders (Alfa Aesar, 99.9% and 99.5%, respectively) at the cryogenic temperature of 196 C. for 4 hours (h) using a modified SPEX 8000M Mixer/Mill. The elemental powders were combined to achieve 5 at % Sb in Cu. The as-milled powders contained no appreciable porosity and ball milling was used as a means to intimately mix the elements, and refine and distribute any preexisting oxides. Although oxygen exposure was controlled during milling and storage of powders, the manufacturer supplied precursors did contain appreciable oxygen content.
(22) The alloyed powder was annealed at 600 C. for a period of 1 h under 3% H.sub.2 (bal. Ar). In addition, the powders underwent pore formation and expansion during annealing. Furthermore, when annealing was conducted in the absence of H.sub.2, no expansion was observed.
(23) Microscopic examination of the loose powders was carried out using an FEI Nova Nano Lab 600 dual beam microscope using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and cross-sectional analysis of powder particles was performed using a focused ion beam (FIB). The grain size and grain orientations were measured using focused ion beam ion channeling contrast (FIBICC) imaging and electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), respectively. The FIB serial sectioning of the individual powder particles was used to visualize and quantify a representative three-dimensional (3D) pore structure in a volume 25.6 mm wide, 22.1 mm high, and 12.5 mm deep. The as-milled powders were also compacted in a die with a circular cross-section 3 mm in diameter for bulk measurements. Since as-milled powders were compacted, no initial porosity within the powders was lost and only porosity between particles was present before annealing. The compacts were weighed before and after annealing to measure the apparent density and changes in density were attributed to expansion within particles since little to no pore closure between particles was observed after compaction under the described conditions.
(24) The annealed CuSb particles were 60 m in size and irregularly shaped after foaming as illustrated in
(25) In addition to the above, and for the given temperature and hold time (600 C., 1 h), the pores were found to be highly interconnected, not only with each other, but with the free surface of their respective particles as well. Interestingly, the porosity did not create line-of-sight paths from surface-to-surface, even in small particles. Rather, the porosity formed tortuous passages from surface-to-surface, which was not entirely obvious without reconstructing the 3D pore structure.
(26) The as-milled grain size and hardness of the CuSb alloy powders were 9 nm and 3.5 GPa, respectively, as determined by X-ray diffraction analysis using Scherrer estimation and Vickers microindentation of individual particles. It is appreciated that a high-strength matrix is expected to suppress void expansion, but pure nanocrystalline (nc) materials are also notoriously sensitive to grain growth at elevated temperatures where they rapidly lose their strength (e.g., Cu begins grain growth at 75-100 C.). Herein, the Cu-5 at % Sb alloy powder had increased strength and thermal stability (a higher grain growth temperature) over pure nc-Cu. In addition to its influence on grain growth, Sb can influence the minimum foaming temperature. However, and despite some enhancement of strength and stability, Sb was found to be a poor stabilizing agent in nc-Cu at the expansion temperature of 600 C. and is potentially related to the large equilibrium solubility of Sb in Cu at elevated temperature (i.e. 5 at % Sb is fully soluble in Cu by 425 C.). In fact, the presence of Sb is actually thought to enhance solid state foaming since it dramatically lowers the solidus temperature to 660 C.
(27) Turning now to
(28) The FIB serial sectioning and subsequent image analysis steps were performed to quantitatively describe the nature of porosity in the particles. For example,
(29) A number of porosity statistics were ascertained from the 3D volume. First, the volume fraction porosity of the 3D foam was 37.1% with a 3.6% standard deviation in pore area fraction from slice-to-slice. Second, two-point correlation functions indicated that a representative length scale for correlation in the 2D slices is on the order of 1-3 m, as quantified by the convergence to the square of the area fraction, A.sub.f.sup.2, at larger distances. This length scale is in line with calculations of mean equivalent pore diameter (1.02 m for 5588 pores). Third, pores in the 2D slices were nonspherical, as evaluated from the mean eccentricity value of 0.70 (i.e. 0 is perfectly circular, 1 is a line). It is appreciated that this finding is in agreement with studies showing that pore coalescence and interconnectivity results in a more tortuous pore structure. Further supporting this finding, the 3D connectivity of the pore structure revealed that 92.1% of the porosity was interconnected (i.e. open porosity). Last, the mean planar surface area per unit volume from the 2D images was calculated to be 0.94 m.sup.2m.sup.3 or 9.410.sup.5 m.sup.2 m.sup.3, which is related to the true surface area per volume of 1.210.sup.6 m.sup.2 m.sup.3. In fact, this true surface per volume is equivalent to 0.235 m.sup.2 g.sup.1 which is comparable to the experimentally-measured value of 0.390 m.sup.2 g.sup.1 (i.e. using Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) analysis). As such, the analyzed volume was representative of the true, bulk condition.
(30) The CuSb alloy powders were consolidated to assess the level of porosity achievable by simple sintering. The as-milled powders, prior to annealing, were compacted at 0.5, 1, and 2 GPa, and the apparent densities after annealing were 2.83 g cm.sup.3 (31.3% dense), 4.06 g cm.sup.3 (45.4% dense), and 4.75 g cm.sup.3 (53.1% dense), respectively. During annealing, samples expanded from their compacted density to a lower final density. The results are summarized in Table 1 below. The average expansion (change in apparent density) was 30% for each sample. This indicates that the compaction pressure directly affects the final density, but does not significantly impact the expansion process. The density of 31.3% (68.7% porosity) for the 0.5 GPa compact is a remarkable result for a powder metallurgy process, especially since the pore structure is not dominated by necks between sintered particles. The amount of porosity achieved, using such a basic process, clearly shows that the current limits of solid state foaming may be reached or even exceeded using the current methodology in association with other solid state foaming processes.
(31) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Compaction Pressure % Dense % Dense (GPa) (compacted) (annealed) % Density Change 2.0 83.5 53.1 30.4 1.0 69.4 45.4 24.0 0.5 62.2 31.3 30.9
(32) For the high degree of foaming reported in the present study, an alternative (potentially more plausible) explanation for this phenomenon is proposed. The Cu powder used to create the alloy was produced by gas atomization, and the manufacturer's certificate of analysis reports an oxygen content of 5000 ppm. Hence, whether or not the expansion mechanism was related to the oxygen and/or oxide content of the powder was tested.
(33) Not being bound by theory, it was hypothesized that annealing under a hydrogen containing atmosphere would reduce Cu oxide particles/precipitates and/or react with free oxygen within the CuSb alloy particles to form water molecules. Then, voids would be created by the expansion of trapped steam.
(34) This oxide reduction and/or oxygen reaction with hydrogen expansion mechanism was preliminarily tested by annealing compacted samples under rough vacuum (better than 10.sup.2 Torr) and comparing the results to samples annealed in 3% H.sub.2 (bal. Ar). In addition, the testing showed samples annealed under vacuum actually exhibited a slight increase in density rather than expansion, i.e. a decrease in density. Also, these same samples were annealed again in a reducing atmosphere and exhibited similar expansion as samples annealed only under H.sub.2. This result confirmed the hypothesis that H.sub.2 plays a key role in the expansion process.
(35) The ability to achieve greater than 65% porosity, the ideal limit of gas entrapment, is an unexpected result, especially for a solid state foaming process. In addition, and since the expansion process is controlled by intraparticle interactions, there are considerable implications for reducing weight and/or improving the strength in bulk engineering structures produced via powder metallurgy.
(36) Completely unique to the inventive process disclosed herein is the ability to create foamed powder. This powder can be used in loose form (primary) or in concert with traditional PM methods (additive). In particular, the inventive additional process can add up to 35-40% porosity by intraparticle expansion to current solid state foaming methods such as creep expansion, loose-powder sintering, fugitive templates, composite metals foams, and any other method which utilizes a powder feedstock. Moreover, combining porous particles with solid particles can afford for components with a graded density and unique properties.
(37) Table 2 below provides a summary of pertinent characteristics for comparable techniques. The gas entrapment and loose-powder sintering data shown in the table were derived from D. C. Dunand, Adv. Eng. Mater. 2004, 6, 369. In addition, the Dunand data was for titanium and titanium alloys since these techniques are not commonly reported for Cu-base alloys. For this reason, the comparison was limited to aspects most transferable between the materials. In particular, intraparticle expansion was for loose powder only.
(38) As shown in Table 2, the expanding feedstock in compacted samples creates a bimodal pore size distribution since the small, micron-sized pores are accompanied by larger, interparticle pores. As indicated, intraparticle expansion and sintering is essentially a combination of gas entrapment and powder sintering and displays the additive benefit of an expandable feedstock. The additive porosity maximum was determined by the typical porosity of the process and it was assumed the remaining solid portion would be expanded to 40% porosity. In the compacted samples processed in this work, this was consistently achieved.
(39) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Intraparticle Intraparticle Loose-Powder Expansion and Method Property Expansion Gas Entrapment Sintering Sintering Typical porosity 40% 25-40% 20-50% 50-70% Pore Size 1-10 m 10's-100's m 10's-100's m Bimodal Grain size 1-5 m >50 m >50 m 1-5 m Process time 1 h 1-20+ h 0.5-24 h 1 h Process T (% of 64.3% 60.7-78.3% 66%+ 64.3% melting) Additive porosity N/A 55-64% 52-70% 50-70% maximum
(40) To determine whether simple annealing would be sufficient to generate a complex, sintered part, the CuSb alloy powder was inserted into a pawn-shaped mold and annealed. The resulting part is shown in
(41) Processes for producing metal foam, metal components from metal foam powder, etc., as disclosed herein are shown generally at reference numeral 10 in
(42) In one process, the metallic powder with oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen is annealed in a reducing atmosphere at step 130 and the metallic powder with intraparticle porosity is provided at step 132. In another process, the metallic powder with oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen is added to a sacrificial template at step 140 and then sintered in a reducing atmosphere at step 142. It is appreciated that sintering in the reducing atmosphere can result in the oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen undergoing a chemical reduction such that steam is produced and intraparticle porosity provided. The template is removed at step 144 and a porous metal component made from metal foam is provided at step 146.
(43) In yet another process, the metallic powder with oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen from step 120 is sintered in a reducing atmosphere at step 150 such that a foamed metal component having a desired shape is provided at step 152.
(44) In still yet another process, the metallic powder with oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen from step 120 is sintered using a traditional process at step 160 to provide a traditional powder metallurgy (PM) component at step 162 as is known to those skilled in the art. Then, the PM component is annealed in a reducing atmosphere at step 164 such that intraparticle porosity is formed as discussed above and a porous metal component is provided at step 166. It is appreciated that additional steps or processes can be included within the scope disclosed herein so long as a metallic powder with oxide particles and/or dissolved oxygen is annealed or sintered in a reducing atmosphere such that metal powder and/or a porous metal component with intraparticle porosity is provided.
(45) In summary, a process for creating metal foams with porosities in excess of 65% via an intraparticle expansion solid state foaming process combined with powder sintering is provided. The relatively simple technique involves only two steps: milling the powder and then annealing the milled powder in a reducing atmosphere. The working hypothesis is that oxides and/or adsorbed oxygen within the particles are reduced/reacted during annealing to create creates steam, which in turn expands into voids. The porosity is very fine, averaging 1 m in diameter, and is characterized by a non-spherical morphology. After 1 h at 600 C., the pores show extensive coalescence and percolation (>90% open porosity). The microstructure of a CuSb alloy features a fine grain size replete with twins, and an ultra-fine to nanoscale grain size at many of the free surfaces.
(46) As provided in the parent application of the present application, hydrogen is useful to form porosity in oxide-distributed metallic particles. The exemplary system was copper with copper oxide particles being heated under a hydrogen-containing atmosphere to aid in the reduction of the oxides and the commensurate formation of porosity. Three examples are given in compacted silver (Ag) powder: 1) silver oxide (Ag.sub.2O), 2) copper oxide (CuO), and 3) both oxides together (Ag.sub.2O+CuO). These three conditions are used to elucidate effects of reduction potential. Under an argon-hydrogen mixture, all three materials were observed to increase in height (measured directly by dilatometry and proportional to porosity) during heating. The dilatometry measurements are provided in
(47) The same materials were processed identically under a pure argon atmosphere. In this case, no hydrogen is available to drive the reduction of the oxides. Instead, the instability of the oxides at elevated temperature is sufficient to cause decomposition and formation of pores by the gaseous products. It is understood that reduction of any substance is characterized by the gain of an electron and no oxygen or hydrogen is required. In this instance, thermal energy and a non-oxidizing environment is sufficient for the oxides to reduce to metallic form and to liberate the oxygen atoms in gaseous form, thereby creating porosity. The non-oxidizing environment may be an inert atmosphere. Furthermore, by evacuating the reaction chamber such that a reduced pressure of non-oxidizing gas is present, the vapor pressure of the materials being heated rises, and this facilitates the reduction of oxides. For the similar reason, having vacuum in the reaction chamber also facilitates the reduction of oxides.
(48) A vacuum or substantially a vacuum is a space in which there is no matter or in which the pressure is so low that any particles in the space do not affect any processes being carried on there. It is a condition well below normal atmospheric pressure. One of skill would understand a true absolute vacuum is not required to meet the definition
(49) Dilatometry results for each material are presented below.
(50) As shown in
(51) As will be clear to those of skill in the art, the embodiments of the present invention illustrated and discussed herein may be altered in various ways without departing from the scope or teaching of the present invention. Also, elements and aspects of one embodiment may be combined with elements and aspects of another embodiment. It is the following claims, including all equivalents, which define the scope of the invention.