Modification of lithium titanate electrode particles to eliminate gas formation in cell operation
10601046 ยท 2020-03-24
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
H01M4/485
ELECTRICITY
Y02E60/10
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
H01M2220/20
ELECTRICITY
H01M10/0525
ELECTRICITY
International classification
H01M4/485
ELECTRICITY
C07F7/00
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
H01M10/0525
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
Lithium titanate, Li.sub.4Ti.sub.5O.sub.12, particles containing surface hydroxyl groups are susceptible to unwanted gas generation (such as hydrogen) in the presence of water contamination when the particles are used as active anode electrode material in lithium-ion cells operating with an anhydrous liquid electrolyte. In accordance with this disclosure, the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles are reacted with one of a group of selected agents containing organic alkoxy groups to form hydrophobic moieties on the surfaces of the particles which effectively block water molecules from the surfaces of lithium titanate particles in the anode of the cell.
Claims
1. A method of preparing lithium titanate (Li.sub.4Ti.sub.5O.sub.12) particles, characterized by the presence of hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles, for use as anode material particles in an electrochemical cell with an anhydrous electrolyte, the preparation of the lithium titanate particles being performed to replace the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles with hydrophobic groups for isolating the lithium titanate particles from water molecules produced as a contaminant in the operation of the electrochemical cell; the method comprising: reacting the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles with molecules of a compound selected from the group consisting of an alkanol, a sulfur-containing acid, a tetravalent silicon-containing compound, and a tetravalent titanium-containing compound, the selected compound containing hydroxyl groups or alkoxy groups or both alkyl groups and alkoxy groups, such that the reaction of the molecules of the selected compound with the hydroxyl groups on the lithium titanate particles produces water or an alcohol as a product removable from the lithium titanate particles, and molecular moieties of the remainder of the molecules of the selected compound are attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles in place of the hydroxyl groups, the attached molecular moieties containing alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups such that the remaining molecular moieties attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles serve as barriers to water contamination when the lithium titanate particles are subsequently placed and used in an electrochemical cell, and removing any residual selected compound and any residual water from the surface of the lithium titanate particles.
2. The method of claim 1 wherein the selected compound is an alkanol having one to four carbon atoms such that the molecules of alkanol react with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to form water as a by-product and to replace the hydroxyl groups with alkoxy groups to serve as barriers to water contamination.
3. The method of claim 2 wherein the alkanol is applied as a liquid to contact the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with alkoxy groups, and excess liquid alcohol and by-product water are then removed from the alkoxy-coated lithium titanate particles.
4. The method of claim 2 wherein the alkanol is applied as a vapor to contact the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with alkoxy groups, and the alcohol vapor and by-product water are then removed from the alkoxy-coated lithium titanate particles.
5. The method of claim 1 wherein the selected compound is a sulfur-containing acid selected from the group consisting of a sulfinic acid, a sulfenic acid, and a sulfonic acid, the sulfur-containing acid having a hydroxyl group, such that the sulfur-containing acid reacts with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to form water as a by-product and to replace the hydroxyl groups with a sulfur-containing moiety with at least one of alkyl groups, aromatic groups, and alkyl amino groups to serve as barriers to water contamination.
6. The method of claim 5 wherein the sulfur containing acid compound is dissolved in a non-aqueous solvent and the solution is applied to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with the sulfur-containing moiety, and any residual solution and any residual water are removed from the lithium titanate particles.
7. The method of claim 1 where the selected compound is a tetravalent silicon-containing compound with one to four alkoxy groups and the remainder alkane groups, such that an alkoxy group of the silicon-containing compound reacts with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to form an alcohol as a by-product and to replace the hydroxyl groups with a tetravalent silicon-containing moiety with alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups to serve as barriers to water contamination.
8. The method of claim 7 wherein the tetravalent silicon-containing compound is a silane selected from the group consisting of hexadecyltrimethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, dimethyl dimethoxysilane, and methoxytrimethylsilane.
9. The method of claim 7 wherein the silicon-containing compound is dissolved in a non-aqueous solvent and the solution is applied to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with the tetravalent silicon-containing moiety, and any residual solution and any residual water are removed from the lithium titanate particles.
10. The method of claim 1 where the selected compound is a tetravalent titanium-containing compound with one to four alkoxy groups and the remainder alkane groups, such that alkoxy groups of the titanium-containing compound react with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to form an alcohol as a by-product and to replace the hydroxyl groups with a tetravalent titanium-containing moiety with alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups to serve as barriers to water contamination.
11. The method of claim 10 wherein the tetravalent titanium-containing compound is a compound represented by one of Ti(OX).sub.4, Ti(OX).sub.3Y, Ti(OX).sub.2YR.sub.1, Ti(OX)YR.sub.1R.sub.2, where X and Y are alkyl groups and R.sub.1 is an alkyl group and R.sub.2 is an alkyl group containing 1-6 carbon atoms.
12. The method of claim 10 wherein the tetravalent titanium-containing compound is dissolved in a non-aqueous solvent and the solution is applied to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with the tetravalent titanium-containing moiety, and any residual solution and any residual water are removed from the lithium titanate particles.
13. A method of preparing lithium titanate (Li.sub.4Ti.sub.5O.sub.12) particles, characterized by the presence of hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles, for use as anode material particles in an electrochemical cell with an anhydrous electrolyte, the preparation of the lithium titanate particles being performed to replace the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles with hydrophobic groups for isolating the lithium titanate from water molecules produced as a contaminant in the operation of the electrochemical cell; the method comprising: reacting the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles with an aliphatic alkanol having one to four carbon atoms, the reaction of the aliphatic alkanol with the hydroxyl groups on the lithium titanate particles producing water as a product removable from the particles, and alkoxy groups attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles in place of the hydroxyl groups, the attached alkoxy groups attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles being selected to serve as barriers to water reaction with the lithium titanate particles when they are subsequently placed as an anodic electrode and used in an electrochemical cell employing an anhydrous electrolyte and in which the lithium titanate particles are to be used to repeatedly intercalate and de-intercalate lithium ions in the charging and discharging of the cell, and removing any residual aliphatic alkanol and any residual water from the surface of the lithium titanate particles.
14. The method of claim 13 wherein the aliphatic alkanol is applied as a liquid to contact the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with alkoxy groups, and excess liquid alcohol and by-product water are then removed from the alkoxy-coated lithium titanate particles.
15. The method of claim 13 wherein the aliphatic alkanol is applied as a vapor to contact the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with alkoxy groups, and the alcohol vapor and by-product water are then removed from the alkoxy-coated lithium titanate particles.
16. A method of preparing lithium titanate (Li.sub.4Ti.sub.5O.sub.12) particles, characterized by the presence of hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles, for use as anode material particles in an electrochemical cell with an anhydrous electrolyte, the preparation of the lithium titanate particles being performed to replace the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles with hydrophobic groups for isolating the lithium titanate from water molecules produced as a contaminant in the operation of the electrochemical cell; the method comprising: reacting the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles with molecules of a compound selected from the group consisting of a tetravalent silicon-containing compound and a tetravalent titanium-containing compound, the selected compound containing alkoxy groups or both alkoxy groups and alkyl groups, such that the reaction of the selected compound with the hydroxyl groups on the lithium titanate particles produces an alcohol as a product removable from the particles, and molecular moieties of the remainder of the molecules of the selected compound are attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles in place of the hydroxyl groups, the remaining molecular moieties containing alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups such that the remaining molecular moieties attached to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles can serve as barriers to water contamination when the lithium titanate particles are subsequently placed and used in an electrochemical cell, and removing any residual selected compound and any residual alcohol from the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles.
17. The method of claim 16 wherein the tetravalent silicon-containing compound is a silane selected from the group consisting of hexadecyltrimethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, dimethyldimethoxysilane, and methoxytrimethylsilane.
18. The method of claim 16 wherein the silicon-containing compound is dissolved in a non-aqueous solvent and the solution is applied to the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to replace the hydroxyl groups with a tetravalent silicon-containing moiety with alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups, and any residual solution and any residual water are removed from the lithium titanate particles.
19. The method of claim 16 where the selected compound is a tetravalent titanium-containing compound with one to four alkoxy groups and the remainder alkane groups, such that alkoxy groups of the titanium-containing compound react with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the lithium titanate particles to form an alcohol as a by-product and to replace the hydroxyl groups with a tetravalent titanium-containing moiety with alkoxy groups or a combination of alkoxy groups and alkyl groups to serve as barriers to water contamination.
20. The method of claim 16 wherein the tetravalent titanium-containing compound is a compound represented by one of Ti(OX).sub.4, Ti(OX).sub.3Y, Ti(OX).sub.2YR.sub.1, Ti(OX)YR.sub.1R.sub.2, where X and Y are alkyl groups and R.sub.1 is an alkyl group and R.sub.2 is an alkyl group containing 1-6 carbon atoms.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
(5) An active lithium-ion cell material is an element or compound which accepts or intercalates lithium ions, or releases or gives up lithium ions in the discharging and re-charging cycling of the cell. A few examples of suitable electrode materials for the anode electrode (negative electrode) of a lithium ion cell are graphite, silicon, alloys of silicon with lithium or tin, silicon oxides (SiO.sub.x), and lithium titanate. During cell-discharge, electrons are released from the anode material into the electrical power-requiring external circuit and lithium ions are released (de-intercalated) into an anhydrous electrolyte. Lithium titanate is a preferred anode material and it is the coating of particles of lithium titanate which is the focus of the coating practices of this invention.
(6) Examples of positive electrode materials (cathode) include lithium manganese oxide, lithium nickel oxide, lithium cobalt oxide and other lithium-metal-oxides. Other materials are known and commercially available. One or more of these materials may be used in an electrode layer. In accordance with practices of this invention the respective electrode materials are typically initially in the form of submicron to micron-size particles, in the range of tens of nanometers to tens of microns.
(7)
(8) In
(9) Deposited on both major faces of the negative electrode current collector 12 are thin, porous layers of negative electrode material 14. In accordance with this disclosure, the negative electrode material is typically resin-bonded particles of lithium titanate which may include interspersed carbon particles providing enhanced electron conductivity. As illustrated in
(10) A positive electrode is shown, comprising a positive current collector foil 16 and, on each major face, a coextensive, overlying, porous deposit of resin-bonded, particulate, positive electrode material 18. Positive current collector foil 16 also has a connector tab 16 for electrical connection with other electrodes in a grouping of lithium-ion cells or with other electrodes in other cells that may be packaged together in the assembly of a lithium-ion battery. The positive current collector foil 16 and its opposing coatings of porous positive electrode material 18 are typically formed in a size and shape that are complementary to the dimensions of an associated negative electrode. In the illustration of
(11) A thin porous separator layer 20 is interposed between a major outer face of the negative electrode material layer 14 (as illustrated in
(12) In many battery constructions, the separator material is a porous layer of a polyolefin, such as polyethylene (PE) or polypropylene (PP). Often the thermoplastic material comprises inter-bonded, randomly oriented fibers of PE or PP. The fiber surfaces of the separator may be coated with particles of alumina, or other insulator material, to enhance the electrical resistance of the separator, while retaining the porosity of the separator layer for infiltration with liquid electrolyte and transport of lithium ions between the cell electrodes. The separator layer 20 is used to prevent direct electrical contact between the facing negative and positive electrode material layers 14, 18, and is shaped and sized to serve this function. In the assembly of the cell, the facing major faces of the electrode material layers 14, 18 are pressed against the major area faces of the separator membrane 20. A liquid electrolyte is typically injected into the pores of the separator and electrode material layers.
(13) The electrolyte for the lithium-ion cell is often a lithium salt dissolved in one or more organic liquid solvents. Examples of suitable salts include lithium hexafluorophosphate (LiPF.sub.6), lithium tetrafluoroborate (LiBF.sub.4), lithium perchlorate (LiClO.sub.4), lithium hexafluoroarsenate (LiAsF.sub.6), and lithium trifluoroethanesulfonimide. Some examples of solvents that may be used to dissolve the electrolyte salt include ethylene carbonate, dimethyl carbonate, methylethyl carbonate, propylene carbonate. There are other lithium salts that may be used and other solvents. But a combination of lithium salt and solvent is selected for providing suitable mobility and transport of lithium ions in the operation of the cell. The electrolyte is carefully dispersed into and between closely spaced layers of the electrode elements and separator layers. The electrolyte is not illustrated in the drawing figure because it is difficult to illustrate between tightly compacted electrode layers.
(14) In accordance with practices of this invention, lithium titanate particles are prepared by a surface modification process for use as an anode material in a lithium-ion cell and other lithium cells.
(15) Preparation of Lithium Titanate Particles as Non-Gassing Electrode Material.
(16) As summarized above in this specification, lithium titanate particles, intended for use as anode materials in lithium cells, are contacted with a selected material which is used to react with hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles to form pendant water-repelling oxy-alkane groups or other suitable hydrophobic organic groups.
(17) Treatment of the LTO Particles with an Alkanol.
(18) In a first example, ethanol is used as providing hydrophobic ethoxy groups (OC.sub.2H.sub.5) for replacing hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of lithium titanate particles. The chemical reaction of ethanol with representative hydroxyl groups on the surface of a single LTO particle is illustrated in
(19) In the left side of
(20) Hydroxyl groups (depicted as OH) are depicted as chemically bonded to the surface titanium sites. It is believed that a water molecule reacting at a titanium atom site provides a hydroxyl group on the titanium atom and a hydrogen atom on an adjacent oxygen atom in the surface crystal structure of the LTO particle.
(21) Four water molecules (H.sub.2O) are also schematically depicted as being simply physically adsorbed to the surface of the LTO particle.
(22) In this portion of
(23) In a first example, a volume of LTO particles are simply mixed in a pure liquid alcohol such as, for example, methanol, ethanol, a propanol, or a butanol. In accordance with normal material handling practices the particles will have been exposed to normal ambient atmospheric conditions with water-containing air. The liquid alcohol wets the surfaces of the LTO particles, displacing adsorbed water and reacting with hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the particles. This reaction by for example, ethanol, may be conducted at temperatures ranging from 0 C. to 200 C. at predetermined compatible pressures in the range of one to three bar. For example, liquid ethanol could be used to wet and react with the surfaces of the LTO particles at a temperature of 50 C. and at a pressure of one bar. The particles are filtered or otherwise suitably removed from the liquid alcohol and the LTO particles are then placed, for example, in a vacuum oven, to remove all liquid alcohol and water from the surfaces of the particles. The particles may be heated in the oven to a suitable determined temperature, for example up to about 200 C. at pressures up to three bar.
(24) In a similar related process, LTO particles may be placed and distributed in and along an enclosed tube or channel. A mixture of aliphatic alcohol vapor, which may be diluted with a dry inert gas, is flowed over the particles at a selected temperature up to for example about 200 C. at pressures up to three bar. At the completion of the reaction of the LTO particles with the alcohol, a flow of heated inert gas at a reduced pressure may be used to remove residual alcohol.
(25) The dried alcohol-treated LTO particles are ready for processing as an active electrode material for forming an anode in a lithium-ion or other lithium anode using cell or battery. The LTO particles with their coating of pendant alkoxy groups may, for example, be mixed with a suitable minor portion of carbon black particles or other suitable conductive particles, and further mixed with a solution or dispersion of a suitable polymeric binder such as polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) in an anhydrous solvent such as N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP). The mixture of particulate anode material constituents may then be applied as a suitably thick layer over, for example, a copper current collector foil. The binder is suitably treated and the NMP solvent removed to complete the formation of the porous electrode material. The anode structure may be utilized with a complementary cathode structure, interposed separator, and infiltrated anhydrous electrolyte solution to assemble a cell or a desired number of interconnected cells in a battery structure.
(26) Treatment of LTO Particles with Sulfur Containing Compounds.
(27) LTO particles with surface OH groups may be treated with solutions of compounds of sulfenic acid (RSOH), sulfinic acid (RSOOH), or sulfonic acid (RS(O).sub.2OH or RSO.sub.3H). The OH groups of these acids react with the hydrogen ions (H+) of the OH groups on the surfaces of the LTO particles to form pendant hydrophobic groups on the LTO particles and water as a by-product.
(28) Suitable compounds of sulfenic acid, for example, include methyl sulfenic acid (CH.sub.3SOH), propyl sulfenic acid (C.sub.3H.sub.8SOH) and the like.
(29) Suitable compounds of sulfinic acid include phenyl sulfenic acid (C.sub.6H.sub.5SOOH), hydroxymethyl sulfinic acid (HOCH.sub.2SOOH), and the like.
(30) Suitable compounds of sulfonic acid include toluene sulfonic acid (C.sub.7H.sub.7SO.sub.3H), taurine (C.sub.2H.sub.4NH.sub.2SO.sub.3H), and the like.
(31) A solution of the sulfur-containing acid compound is dissolved in a non-aqueous solvent such as benzene, toluene, or furan and the solution used to react with hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of a volume of LTO particles. At the completion of the surfaces reactions, the LTO particles are filtered or removed from the solution of sulfur-containing acid. The LTO particles are rinsed with fresh solvent and filtered. The LTO particles are then placed, for example, in a vacuum oven, to remove residual solvent from the surfaces of the particles. The particles may be heated in the oven to a suitable determined temperature, for example up to about 200 C. at pressures up to three bar.
(32) The surfaces of the LTO particles are now coated with pendant hydrophobic groups comprising the selected sulfur acid moiety and the attached organic alkyl, aromatic, and or amino-alkyl groups. The treated LTO particles may be processed, as described above, into porous, resin-bonded particulate active anode material layers.
(33) Treatment of LTO Particles with Silane Coupling Agents.
(34) It is preferred to use silane coupling agents characterized by the formula Y.sub.4aSi(OX).sub.a, where a has a value of 1-3, where X and Y may be alkyl groups selected such that one alkoxy group (OX) reacts with a hydroxyl group on the surface of a LTO particle and the remaining OX and Y groups serve to block water molecules from access to the surface of the particle. Examples of such compounds are hexadecyltrimethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, dimethyldimethoxysilane, and methoxytrimethylsioxane.
(35) On the left side of
(36) In
(37) The reaction of such silane coupling agents with a volume of LTO particles may be conducted as follows.
(38) A solution of a selected silane coupling agent is formed in a non-aqueous solvent such as benzene, toluene, or furan and the solution used to react with hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of a volume of LTO particles. The reaction of the silane coupling agent with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the LTO particles may require modest heating over a predetermined period of time. The by-product alcohol may be separated and recovered from the solution of the coupling agent. At the completion of the reaction the surface-coated LTO particles are filtered or removed from the solution of the silane coupling agent. The LTO particles are rinsed with fresh solvent and filtered. The LTO particles are then placed, for example, in a vacuum oven, to remove residual solvent from the surfaces of the particles. The particles may be heated in the oven to a suitable determined temperature, for example up to about 200 C. at pressures up to three bar to promote removal of the solvent.
(39) The surfaces of the LTO particles are now coated with pendant hydrophobic groups comprising the selected silicon-based silane moiety and the attached organic alkyl and alkoxy groups. The silane coupling agent treated LTO particles may be processed, as described above, into porous, resin-bonded particulate active anode material layers.
(40) Treatment of LTO Particles with Titanate Coupling Agents.
(41) A first example of suitable titanate coupling agents are represented by the formula, Ti(OX).sub.4, where X represents an alkyl group containing 1-6 carbon atoms. Tetrabutyl titanate, (C.sub.4H.sub.9O).sub.4Ti, is an example of such a coupling agent. This alkyl titanate has four alkoxy groups, any one of which may react with a hydroxyl group on the surface of an LTO particle to couple a hydrophobic titanate moiety, OTi(OC.sub.4H.sub.9).sub.3, to the surface of the particle and to simultaneously release a molecule of butyl alcohol. The use of tetrabutyl titanate to react with LTO particles with pendant hydroxyl groups is illustrated schematically in
(42) As depicted in
(43) Thus, when LTO particles with pendant OH groups are contacted with a suitable solution of this tetra-alkyl titanate, pendant tributyl titanate groups are attached to titanium sites on the surface of each particle, providing hydrophobic alkyl titanate groups that block water molecules from access to the LTO particles when they are employed as active anode material in a lithium cell.
(44) Other suitable titanate coupling agents include one to three alkoxy groups attached to a tetravalent titanium atom and other alkyl groups, without an oxygen atom, attached to the titanium atom. Examples include Ti(OX).sub.3Y, Ti(OX).sub.2YR.sub.1, Ti(OX)YR.sub.1R.sub.2, where X and Y are alkyl groups and R.sub.1 is an alkyl group and R.sub.2 is an alkyl group.
(45) The reaction of such titanate coupling agents with a volume of LTO particles may be conducted as follows.
(46) A solution of a selected titanate coupling agent is formed in a non-aqueous solvent such as benzene, toluene, or furan and the solution used to react with hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of a volume of LTO particles. The reaction of the titanate coupling agent with the hydroxyl groups on the surfaces of the LTO particles may require modest heating over a predetermined period of time. The by-product alcohol may be separated and recovered from the solution of the coupling agent. At the completion of the reaction, the surface-coated LTO particles are filtered or removed from the solution of the titanate coupling agent. The LTO particles are rinsed with fresh solvent and filtered. The LTO particles are then placed, for example, in a vacuum oven, to remove residual solvent from the surfaces of the particles. The particles may be heated in the oven to a suitable determined temperature, for example up to about 200 C. at pressures up to three bar to promote removal of the solvent.
(47) The surfaces of the LTO particles are now coated with pendant hydrophobic groups comprising the selected titanium-based titanate moiety and the attached organic alkyl and alkoxy groups. The titanate coupling agent treated LTO particles may be processed, as described above, into porous, resin-bonded particulate active anode material layers for lithium cells.
(48) Thus, at least four different types of reactants and/or coupling agents are disclosed and utilized for reaction with hydroxyl group-containing surfaces of lithium titanate particles intended for use as active anode particles in a lithium-ion cell or similar lithium cell. Each surface reactant is selected to react with the surface hydroxyl groups and to replace them with hydrophobic organic alkyl groups, or the equivalent, that block access of water molecules to the surfaces of the LTO particles when they are receiving (intercalation) and releasing (de-intercalation) lithium ions in the anhydrous environment of a lithium electrochemical cell. By blocking access of water to the particulate LTO anode material, gas generation is reduced or eliminated in the operation of the cell.
(49) Examples of practices of the LTO surfaces coating methods are described for purposes of illustration. Such illustrations are not intended to limit the scope of the claimed invention.