System and method for auto distilling liquids at strictly defined conditions regardless of composition
10363495 · 2019-07-30
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01N25/14
PHYSICS
B01D5/006
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01J5/0806
PHYSICS
G01J5/06
PHYSICS
International classification
B01D5/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01N25/14
PHYSICS
Abstract
A system and method for distillation of a liquid sample at atmospheric pressure for the improved prediction of the heating necessary before the initial boiling point (IBP) of the sample is detected regardless of sample composition to ensure the IBP is observed within certain time constraints. A plurality of infrared (IR) sensors provides real-time temperature control in addition to a conventional measurement of vapor temperature. One IR-sensor monitors the liquid sample temperature in the distillation flask to obtain a corrected IBP time independent of the sample properties. Another IR-sensor monitors the temperature of the rising vapor column as the vapor rises up the neck of the distillation flask. Alternatively, an IR matrix may monitor the temperature of the rising vapor column. The system and method expand the scope of samples analyzed with improved signal, reproducibility, and test accuracy and still remain within the prescribed limits of a selected standard.
Claims
1. A distillation assembly for distillation of liquid samples at atmospheric pressure, said distillation assembly comprising: a flask having a round bottom, a neck portion and a top opening; a stopper for covering the top opening of said flask; a heating element in thermal communication with said flask for heating said flask; a first thermal radiation detector in optical connection with said flask; a second thermal radiation detector in optical connection with said flask; a temperature detector traversing said stopper; a plurality of collimators having an aperture there through, said plurality of collimators housing said first and said second thermal radiation detectors; a condenser connected to said flask at one end of said condenser; a receiving vessel/collector in communication with said condenser, said receiving vessel/collector for receiving distillate; and a base plate for supporting said flask, said base plate having an aperture in the center thereof and positioned between said flask and said heating element.
2. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 1, wherein each collimator contains internal threading within said aperture.
3. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 2, wherein said first thermal radiation detector and said second thermal radiation detector are infrared sensors.
4. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 3, wherein said temperature detector measures temperature of a liquid sample within said flask without making contact with said sample.
5. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 4, wherein said temperature detector measures vapor temperature of said liquid sample within said flask by direct contact with said vapor of said liquid sample.
6. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 5, wherein said temperature detector is a thermometer.
7. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 6, wherein said second thermal radiation detector measures temperature of the vapor of said liquid sample without making contact with said liquid sample, and said vapor being measured is located in the area between said liquid sample and said temperature detector within the neck portion of said flask.
8. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 7, wherein said second thermal radiation detector is disposed below said temperature detector and above said first thermal radiation detector.
9. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 8, further comprising: a target zone on said flask, said target zone in optical communication with said first thermal radiation detector.
10. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 9, wherein said target zone is comprised of paint.
11. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 10, wherein said target zone has an emissivity of at least 0.95.
12. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 11, wherein said base plate is comprised of a metal coated glass-ceramic material.
13. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 12, further comprising an IR matrix configured to measure a temperature of vapor in the neck portion of the flask.
14. The distillation assembly, as recited in claim 13, wherein said IR matrix is comprised of an array of IR sensors.
15. A distillation assembly, comprising: a flask having a bottom, a neck portion and a top; a heating element configured to heat the flask; a first thermal radiation detector configured to measure a temperature of a liquid sample located in the bottom of the flask; a second thermal radiation detector configured to measure a temperature of vapor at a first location in the neck portion of the flask; a temperature detector configured to measure the temperature of vapor at a second location in the neck portion of the flask, wherein the second location is above the first location; a first collimator having an aperture therethrough and configured to house the first thermal radiation detector; a second collimator having an aperture therethrough and configured to house the second thermal radiation detector; a condenser connected to the flask; a receiving vessel coupled to the condenser and configured to receive distillate; and a base plate configured to support the flask.
16. A method for automatic distillation of a liquid sample at atmospheric pressure using an automatic distillation assembly, said method comprising: selecting a group of products to be analyzed as said liquid sample; regulating condenser and receiver temperatures; introducing a predefined quantity of said liquid sample to said automatic distillation assembly, said distillation assembly comprising: a distillation flask having a round bottom portion and a neck portion extending therefrom and a stopper for sealing said neck portion of said distillation flask; a target zone on said round bottom portion of said distillation flask; a first infrared (IR) sensor having a beam focused on said target zone; a second IR sensor having a beam focused on the lower portion of said neck portion of said distillation flask; a plurality of collimators each having an aperture therethrough, said plurality of collimators housing the first and said second IR sensors; a condenser removably attached at one end to said neck portion of said distillation flask; a thermometer traversing said stopper, said thermometer having a tip extending below said condenser; a cooling source surrounding said condenser; a collecting flask removably attached to the opposite end of said condenser; a base plate for supporting said distillation flask; and a heating element in thermal connection to said base plate; initiating analysis with an initiating trigger; heating said liquid sample to a predefined minimum liquid temperature within a predetermined minimum time; heating said liquid sample to a predefined maximum liquid temperature within a predetermined maximum time; monitoring the temperature of said liquid sample with said first IR sensor; detecting presence of vapor from said liquid sample with said second IR sensor; detecting vapor temperature with said second IR sensor; adjusting heating temperature of said liquid sample based on temperature readings of said liquid sample and said vapor; monitoring temperature of said vapor with said second IR sensor; measuring vapor temperature of said liquid sample with said thermometer; measuring time lapse between when said vapor is detected by said second IR sensor and when said vapor temperature is detected by said thermometer upon contact of said vapor with said thermometer; and adjusting heating temperature of the liquid sample based on temperature readings of said liquid sample, said vapor and the difference between the temperature reading of said vapor when said vapor is detected by said second IR sensor and the temperature reading of said vapor upon contact of said vapor with said thermometer.
17. The method of claim 16, further comprising: determining the initial boiling point of said liquid sample.
18. The method of claim 17, further comprising: determining the 5% distillation point of said liquid sample.
19. The method of claim 18, wherein in said determining of said initial boiling point, the heating adjustment to said liquid sample is determined in accordance with the following equation:
(T.sub.chaufT.sub.liq)=A0+A1.sup.(A2.Math.Tliq)+A3.sup.(TliqTIRvap), wherein T.sub.chauf corresponds to the temperature of the heating element, Tliq corresponds to the temperature of the liquid sample measured by the first IR sensor, TIRvap corresponds to the temperature of the vapor measured by the second IR sensor and each of A0, A1, A2 and A3 corresponds to a different coefficient.
20. The method of claim 19, wherein before the initial boiling point occurs, the heating adjustment to said liquid sample is determined in accordance with the following equation:
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(8)
(9) Distillation flask 12 has a bulb or lower rounded portion 14 and a neck portion 16. Condenser 22 connects to neck portion 16 of distillation flask 12. Stopper 18 seals distillation flask 12 at the top of neck portion 16. Thermometer 20 traverses stopper 18 via an aperture (not shown) in stopper 18 until tip 21 of thermometer 20 is just below where neck portion 16 of distillation flask 12 connects to condenser 22. Cooling source 36 surrounds condenser 22. Collecting flask 24 collects condensate or distillate 40 produced from the distillation process.
(10) Cooling source 36 (e.g., continuous flow of water or solid-state cooling device) surrounds condenser 22 creating a temperature gradient in which accumulated vapor from distillation flask 12 condenses and rolls down condenser 22 until the condensate 40 drips into collecting flask 24. Collecting flask 24 may be in various configurations, including cylindrical, and may also be graduated to measure the quantity of distillate 40 collected. Sensor 25 determines when a predefined amount of distillate 40 has been collected, as shown in
(11) Still referring to
(12) Perhaps the most significant improvement of the present invention is the addition of the second IR noncontact sensor. Referring now to
(13) In an alternative embodiment, second IR sensor 34 is replaced by an IR matrix, i.e., several sensors, or an array of IR sensors (not shown). The matrix of sensors observes the column of signals, i.e., the line of temperatures, and the movement of the temperature gradient. Using an IR matrix, the process of vapor movement in the neck of the distillation flask is observed by measuring the temperatures of the neck, which, in turn, facilitates improvement of the regulation of temperature (e.g., preliminary heating of the liquid sample prior to IBP). Multiple measurements may be taken simultaneously of the vapor column as the vapor column rises from liquid sample 38 toward condenser 22.
(14) The current brass thermostat or collimator around the IR sensor used in existing devices contains a smooth aperture or optical canal therein which reflects interference radiation from extra-aperture dispositions and contributes to inaccurate IR readings. The inventors found that modifying the internal surface of the optical canal became necessary to reduce the reflection of the interference (i.e., noise) radiation. Possible modifications included adjusting the fine thread or using a specific covering, e.g., graphite paint or other comparable covering.
(15) Two collimator prototypes were developed to reduce the amount of interference reflected from the internal wall of the collimator. The first prototype contained an infrared-absorbing plastic coating on the interior wall of the optical canal of the collimator. The second contained internal threading within the optical canal of the collimator.
(16) After testing the two collimator prototypes, the level of improvement in reducing the interference was found to be identical in both prototypes. The inventors observed a decrease of approximately 30% of IR-signal due to the elimination of interference influence. The increment of IR-temperature from the heated base plate became negligible.
(17) As the two versions provided the same level of improvement, the collimator with an internally threaded optical canal was selected. This collimator also reduced the number of components (i.e., infrared-absorbing plastic coating on the interior wall of the optical canal of the collimator no longer necessary) which translated to the elimination of potential problem sites.
(18)
(19) The ability of a surface to emit radiant energy (i.e., thermal radiation or heat energy) compared to that of a blackbody at the same temperature and with the same area is known as emissivity. Emissivity is the value given to materials based on the ratio of heat emitted compared to a blackbody, on a scale from zero (0) to one (1). Different materials display varying abilities to emit thermal energy. For example, a blackbody would have an emissivity value of 1 while a material that completely reflects heat would have an emissivity value of 0. Different materials would, thus, have emissivity values between 0 and 1. Therefore, the emissivity of the surface of a material is a measure of how effective the material emits energy as thermal radiation.
(20) The emissivity of glass used in existing devices is low (e.g., 0.85) in used IR-spectrum and may be unstable in the case of contamination of the surface, small changes in the bulb shape or surface contamination. The possibility for error in testing and analysis exists due to emissivity failure which may be observed with a temperature difference of up to 17 C. This is due to high reflection of interfering IR-exposure.
(21) To minimize error in testing from emissivity failure, and referring now to
(22) Less interference is tantamount to a more stable, accurate and reproducible IR signal. The present invention, thus, increases the emissivity of the glass distillation flask (e.g., through the use of paint on a target zone) to a number closer to 1.0 which reduces the amount of interfering radiation produced thereby. This yields a more stable IR signal with improved reproducibility. Though paint may be used for target zone 48, other similar material with emissivity increasing properties may be used and still remain within the contemplation of the present invention.
(23) The present invention also improves IR-sensor calibration to measure near-ambient temperature. The target measurement is the measurement of sample temperature in the flask just after filling and installation. This measurement can prevent error because of default in sampling temperature or can make automatic volume expansion compensation in the case of a sample temperature variation relative to a predetermined optimal value.
(24) Prior to the present invention, the current paradigm to minimize IR interference from the base plate was to use a base plate comprised of a low thermal conductivity material, e.g., ceramic material, such as synthetic compressed calcium silicate. However, the inventors found this material fragile due to its low density.
(25) Instead, the present invention uses a metal coating applied onto a reliable glass-ceramic base plate which, in turn, has the same desired effect, i.e., reduction in emissivity, albeit at a more pronounced level. For example, and with reference to
(26) As illustrated in
(27) The present invention, thus, provides for a base plate with a reduced level of emissivity, thus, reducing or minimizing the contribution of thermal interference as compared to the prior art. The effect of this reduction in emissivity manifests itself in less noise and interference and in improved IR-signal, accuracy and reproducibility of test results.
(28) Referring now to
(29) As a result of the improved distillation assembly, and as explained in further detail below, the present invention improves the preheating time and the predictability of the necessary heating before the IBP time of a liquid sample of unknown composition. The rate of vapor column movement may also be calculated, improving the 5% distillation time. Further, the drop of the vapor temperature is detected earlier permitting the optimal conditions for the final boiling point (FBP) detection to be chosen automatically.
(30) Turning now to the method and examples of distillation with improved control of IR-temperature of the present invention, current distillation apparatuses measure the vapor temperature using a thermometer or other comparable heat detector in direct contact with the vapor. In the '247 patent, a thermometer is positioned to be in direct contact with the vapor to measure the vapor temperature in the distillation flask.
(31) However, the inventors found that using this type of temperature sensor, while adequate, tends to delay the observation of the start of the boiling process. For example, and referring now to
(32) Temperature curve 56 using standard vapor thermometer 20 in direct contact with the sample vapor in the neck portion of the distillation flask shows a gradual increase in temperature for the first 420 sec. At 420 sec., a rapid increase in temperature is observed until approximately 460 sec. From 460 sec. and continuing on until 900 sec., the temperature is still observed to be increasing though the rate of increase in temperature has decreased.
(33) Still referring to
(34) When an additional temperature sensor, such as a noncontact IR sensor (i.e., second IR sensor 34), is used to monitor and measure the vapor temperature of the vapor in the area located between the liquid sample and the standard vapor thermometer in the neck portion of the distillation flask, the same gradual increase in temperature exhibited by temperature curve 56 is still observed from the beginning of the distillation process. However, now, as shown by temperature curve 60, the rapid increase in temperature is observed at 360 sec. (a full minute earlier) and continues until about 400 sec. From 400 sec. and continuing on until 900 sec., the temperature is still observed to be increasing, though the rate of increase in temperature has decreased.
(35) As the graph in
(36) From this earlier detection of the vapor temperature, determination of the rate of vapor movement, and estimation of the intensity of the evaporation energy of the sample, adjustments may be made to the initial heating (e.g., increase or decrease) of the liquid sample to speed up or slow down the distillation process (i.e., distillation rate) such as to ensure the IBP will be within the specified time limits of a selected distillation standard.
(37) Referring now to
(38) Beginning with block 202, the user first makes a selection of the group of product to be analyzed. In block 204, the distillation assembly, e.g., automatic analyzer, commences the regulation of the condenser and receiver temperatures. Now that the sample has been prepared and the parameters have been set, the distillation process may continue. The start of the testing or analysis begins by pushing a Start button or other similar initiating trigger on the distillation assembly, as depicted in block 206.
(39) The distillation process comprises several stages. Referring still to
(40) Block 210 illustrates stage 2 of the distillation process where the heating of the unknown liquid sample continues up to T.sub.liq.sub._.sub.max, the maximum acceptable temperature of the liquid sample, during Time.sub.Tmax.sub._.sub.ibp, the maximum acceptable time from the start of heating to IBP. Whether to adjust the heating of the sample at this time is dependent upon the temperature of the liquid sample as measured by the first IR sensor. The values of T.sub.liq.sub._.sub.min were chosen to permit observation of IBP within the range of restricted times, i.e., Time.sub.Tmin.sub._.sub.ibp and Time.sub.Tmax.sub._.sub.ibp.
(41) As heating of the liquid sample continues, the second IR sensor is continuously monitoring and measuring any vapor temperature present. The second IR sensor assists in the evaluation of the dynamic of temperature distributions (previously unknown) in the area between the liquid sample and the standard vapor thermometer in the neck of the flask after boiling has begun. If no vapor temperature can be measured by the second IR sensor, the heating of the liquid sample continues, as shown in the feedback loop from block 212 to block 210. If, however, the start of boiling is observed and the resulting rising of vapor can be detected by the observation of increasing vapor temperature measured by the second IR sensor (T.sub.IRvap), as shown in block 212, then the distillation process proceeds to stage 3.
(42) In stage 3, the heating power to the liquid sample may be adjusted (i.e., regulated), if necessary, on the basis of the temperature of the liquid sample in the distillation flask measured by the first IR sensor on the spherical portion of the distillation flask (T.sub.liq) and the temperature of the vapor measured by the second IR sensor at the lower part of the neck of the distillation flask (T.sub.IRvap), as shown in block 214. In other words, as the rate of column vapor movement rising up the neck may now be evaluated by the determination of T.sub.liq and T.sub.IRvap, these values allow for improvement in heat regulation. Timer Time.sub.vap.sub._.sub.step also starts counting, as shown in block 216, once the liquid sample begins boiling.
(43) The calculation of the required heating temperature taught by the prior art ('274 patent) assumes the liquid sample is petroleum-based or otherwise of petroleum origin. As such, prior art calculations based on only a single temperature measurement (i.e., the temperature of the liquid sample in the flask measured by a single, noncontact IR sensor) are not acceptable in cases where the liquid sample is of a different origin (e.g., bio-origin fuels, etc. . . . ). However, in stage 3 of the present invention, the measurement of the vapor temperature in the lower part of the neck of the distillation flask by the second noncontact IR sensor monitoring and evaluating the rate of vapor rising improves heating regulation during increased concentration of vapor rising in the neck area of the distillation flask.
(44) Thus, the dual temperature measurement of the present invention may evaluate the rate of vapor rising (i.e., the rate at which the column of vapor formed ascends the distillation flask) at known heating prior to the IBP, as the rate of vapor rising must correlate with the evaporation energy of the sample. This additional information, previously unavailable, broadens the scope (from the prior art) of the sample types that can be analyzed. Stage 3 would not be possible without the inclusion of the second IR sensor of the present invention. Nor would stage 3 be obtained using any other IR-imaging device.
(45) Still referring to
(46) In Stage 4, heating of the liquid sample is adjusted on the basis of the T.sub.liq, T.sub.vap and Time.sub.vap.sub._.sub.step values, as shown in block 220.
(47) A determination of whether the volume of distillate collected is greater than the control volume (Vol.sub.ctrl) is performed in block 222. If not, then the heating of the liquid sample is continually adjusted on the basis of the T.sub.liq, T.sub.vap and Time.sub.vap.sub._.sub.step values, as shown by the feedback loop from block 222 to block 220. If the volume does exceed the control volume (Vol.sub.ctrl), then the process proceeds to the final stage.
(48) Block 224 shows the final stage, stage 5, where the heating control can be switched to a PID control algorithm or similar convention beginning from volume Vol.sub.ctrl.
(49) According to the standards (e.g., ASTM D86), there are two standard limitations of time: (1) the time from the start of test (application of heating) to the observation of the first drop of distillate in the collecting flask (i.e., the IBP), and (2) the time from the IBP to the 5% distillation point (i.e., 5% of the initial volume of sample collected as distillate). The present invention improves both.
(50)
(51) Referring now to
(52) The detection of the rising vapor temperature (T.sub.IRvap), which occurs between stage 2 and stage 3 (See
(53) Once T.sub.IRvap is detected, heat adjustments, if any, may be made, as shown in stage 3 (See
(54) The necessary level of heating of the liquid sample is the difference between the temperature of the heating element (T.sub.chauf) and the liquid temperature (T.sub.liq) measured by the first IR sensor. The vapor temperature is measured by the second IR sensor T.sub.IRvap. A monotone two-factor dependence of heating from the liquid temperature T.sub.liq and the difference between the liquid and vapor temperatures (all measured by IR sensors) yield the following equation:
(T.sub.chaufT.sub.liq)=A0+A1.sup.(A2.Math.T.sup.
where A0, A1, A2 and A3 are empirical coefficients, and in the specific case of the heating element used, these coefficients had the following values: A0=250.2 A1=31.7 A2=6.67e-3 A3=0.47
(55) This equation corresponds to the energy transmitted (i.e., heat) to the liquid sample and calculates the correction or adjustment of heating approximately 10-30 seconds earlier than in the prior art. The adjustment in stage 3 of the temperature of the heating element T.sub.chauf may be made beginning from when vapor begins to rise from the liquid sample and can be repeated every 1-2 seconds until after 2-3 mL of distillate have been collected.
(56) Unlike the prior art, the vapor temperature is now measured by the second noncontact IR sensor and not by direct contact with the standard vapor thermometer. This second IR sensor further permits continuous measurements to be taken sooner in time and, thus, provides temperature readings to enable the operator (or automatic analyzer) to make adjustments, if necessary, to the heating temperature of the heating element to ensure the IBP and correct 5% distillation point of the liquid sample being analyzed are observed within selected standard limits.
(57) The detection of T.sub.vap rising occurs between stages 3 and 4 (See
(58) As illustrated by
(59) Referring now to
(60)
where A0, A1, A2 and A3 are empirical coefficients and A4 is a new empirical coefficient. This equation demonstrates the influence of the Time.sub.vap.sub._.sub.step parameter on the calculated heating. In the specific case of the heating element used, these coefficients had the following values:
A0=243.3
A1=32.87
A2=6.796e-3
A3=0.53229
A4=4.52314
(61) The present invention expands the scope of samples that can be analyzed with improved signal, reproducibility, and test accuracy and still remain within the prescribed limits of a selected standard. Such expanded sample types go beyond petroleum-based products and include liquid samples of non-petroleum origin (bio), IBP-high-slope products (contaminated), and high-boiling short-cuts (solvents).
(62) The various embodiments described herein may be used singularly or in conjunction with other similar devices. The present disclosure includes preferred or illustrative embodiments in which a system and method for auto distilling liquids at strictly defined conditions regardless of composition are described. Alternative embodiments of such a system and method can be used in carrying out the invention as claimed and such alternative embodiments are limited only by the claims themselves. Other aspects and advantages of the present invention may be obtained from a study of this disclosure and the drawings, along with the appended claims.