Differential elliptic filter with a single op-amp
10340891 ยท 2019-07-02
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
A differential elliptic filter circuit includes: a differential amplifier, feedback and feedforward paths. An upper pair and a lower pair of inverting feedback paths couple a corresponding one the differential signal outputs of the amplifier to an inverting one of a pair of inputs of the amplifier, to provide two complex conjugate poles, and establish upper and lower virtual grounds at the amplifier inputs. Upper and lower inverting feedforward paths couple corresponding passive nodes of the upper and lower pairs of inverting feedback paths to respectively the lower and upper virtual grounds to provide two zeros of the circuit. The upper and lower non-inverting feedforward paths couple an upper and lower one of a pair of differential signal inputs of the circuit to respectively the upper and lower virtual grounds to enable positioning of the two zeros of the circuit on an imaginary axis of a pole-zero plot.
Claims
1. A differential elliptic filter circuit comprising: a pair of differential signal inputs; a differential amplifier including a pair of inputs and differential signal outputs; an upper pair and a lower pair of inverting feedback paths between a corresponding one the differential signal outputs and an inverting one of the pair of inputs of the differential amplifier, configured to provide two complex conjugate poles of the elliptic filter circuit, and to establish upper and lower virtual grounds at the inputs of the differential amplifier, wherein the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths each comprise a capacitor coupled in parallel with series coupled resistors between the corresponding one of the differential amplifier's outputs and the corresponding one of the virtual grounds, to provide complex conjugate poles of a low pass elliptic filter circuit, and the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths cross-coupled and configured to provide complex conjugate zeros of the low pass elliptic filter circuit; an upper inverting feedforward path of the inverting feedforward path coupling a passive node of the upper pair of inverting feedback paths to the lower one of the virtual grounds, and a lower inverting feedforward path of the inverting feedforward path coupling a passive node of the lower pair of inverting feedback paths to the upper one of the virtual grounds, and the upper and lower inverting feedforward paths configured to provide two zeros of the elliptic filter circuit; and an upper non-inverting feedforward path coupling an upper one of the pair of differential signal inputs to the upper one of the virtual grounds, and a lower non-inverting feedforward path coupling a lower one of the pair of differential signal inputs to the lower one of the virtual grounds, to enable positioning of the two zeros of the filter circuit on an imaginary axis of a pole-zero plot of the elliptic filter circuit.
2. The differential elliptic filter circuit of claim 1, further comprising: the upper and lower pairs of inverting feedback paths configured to provide complex conjugate poles of a low pass elliptic filter circuit; and the upper and a lower inverting feedforward paths each include a capacitor coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds, wherein the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths provide complex conjugate zeros of the low pass elliptic filter circuit.
3. The differential elliptic filter circuit of claim 1, further comprising: the upper and lower pairs of inverting feedback paths configured to provide complex conjugate poles of a high pass elliptic filter circuit; and the upper and a lower inverting feedforward paths each include a resistor coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds, wherein the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths provide complex conjugate zeros of the high pass elliptic filter circuit.
4. The differential elliptic filter circuit of claim 1, further comprising: the upper and lower pairs of inverting feedback paths configured to provide complex conjugate poles of a low pass elliptic filter circuit; and the upper and a lower non-inverting feedforward path including a capacitor coupled from a corresponding one of the pair of differential signal inputs to the corresponding one of the virtual grounds, wherein the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths provide complex conjugate zeros of the low pass elliptic filter circuit.
5. The differential elliptic filter circuit of claim 1, further comprising: the upper and lower pairs of inverting feedback paths configured to provide complex conjugate poles of a high pass elliptic filter circuit; and an upper and a lower non-inverting feedforward path including a resistor coupled from a corresponding one of the pair of differential signal inputs to the corresponding one of the virtual grounds, wherein the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths provide complex conjugate zeros of the high pass elliptic filter circuit.
6. The differential elliptic filter circuit of claim 1, further comprising: the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths each comprise a resistor coupled in parallel with series coupled capacitors between the corresponding one of the differential amplifier's outputs and the corresponding one of the virtual grounds, to provide complex conjugate poles of a high pass elliptic filter circuit; and the inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths configured to provide complex conjugate zeros of the high pass elliptic filter circuit.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) These and other features and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent to those skilled in the art from the following detailed description in conjunction with the appended drawings in which:
(2)
(3)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENTS
(4)
(5)
(6) The upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1-2) each comprise a capacitor C.sub.1 coupled in parallel with series coupled resistors R.sub.2-R.sub.3 between the corresponding one of the differential amplifier's outputs 116A-B and the corresponding one of the inverting inputs 111A-B of the differential amplifier 114, to provide complex conjugate poles 142A-B of the low pass filter circuit 100; and to establish upper and lower virtual grounds at the inputs 111A-B of the differential amplifier. Specifically, the 1.sup.st of the upper pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1) couples the upper differential output of the circuit and amplifier 116A to the inverting input 111A of the amplifier via capacitor 112A (a.k.a. C.sub.1). The 2.sup.nd of the upper pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.2) couples the upper differential output of the circuit and amplifier 116A to the inverting input 111A of the amplifier via series coupled resistors 108A (a.k.a. R.sub.2) and 110A (a.k.a. R.sub.3). The upper pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2 establish the upper virtual ground at amplifier input 111A. The 1.sup.st of the lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1) couples the lower differential output of the circuit and amplifier 116B to the inverting input 111B of the amplifier via capacitor 112B (a.k.a. C.sub.1). The 2.sup.nd of the lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.2) couples the lower differential output of the circuit and amplifier 116B to the inverting input 111B of the amplifier via series coupled resistors 108B (a.k.a. R.sub.2) and 110B (a.k.a. R.sub.3). The upper pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2 establish the lower virtual ground at amplifier input 111B.
(7) The analog signal 120 at the output of this prior art differential low pass filter circuit 100 exhibits a limited decrease in the high frequency component of the input signal. Graph 130 shows the Prior Art differential low pass filter circuit's frequency response 132, with frequency on the horizontal axis and amplitude on the vertical axis. The circuit exhibits a broad transition region 134 between the lower frequencies which are passed, and the higher frequencies which are blocked. A low pass filter circuit with such a broad transition region is described as having a gradual roll-off.
(8) The pole plot 140 of the Prior Art differential low pass filter circuit is derived from the specific nodal equations for the circuit expressed within the general transfer function 129 for the circuit as shown in the following Eq. 1.
(9)
where r.sub.0 is called natural frequency, Q is quality factor, and the complex-domain frequency s is related to the real-domain frequency by the equation s=j where j={square root over (1)}. The three possible mathematical filter approximations implemented with such a filter transfer function are Bessel, Butterworth and Chebyshev. Bessel and Butterworth filter response exhibit a monotonically decreasing magnitude response. Chebyshev filter response exhibits ripples in the passband or stopband frequencies. The pole plot has a horizontal real axis and a vertical imaginary axis on the S plane. The pole plot 140 shows two complex conjugate poles 142A-B on the left side of the imaginary axis, in the 2.sup.nd and 3.sup.rd quadrants respectively. These poles are located on a circle 146 centered on the origin with a radius r.sub.0 corresponding to the natural frequency of the circuit. These complex conjugate poles are provided by the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2.
(10)
(11) The upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1-2) each comprise a resistor R.sub.1 coupled in parallel with series coupled capacitors C.sub.2-C.sub.3 between the corresponding one of the differential amplifier's outputs 166A-B and the corresponding one of the inverting inputs 161A-B of the differential amplifier 164, to provide complex conjugate poles 192A-B of the high pass filter circuit 150 and a pair of zeros 194A-B at the origin of the pole-zero plot 190; and to establish upper and lower virtual grounds at the inputs 161A-B of the differential amplifier. Specifically, the 1.sup.st of the upper pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1) couples the upper differential output of the circuit and amplifier 166A to the inverting input 161A of the amplifier via resistor 162A (a.k.a. R.sub.1). The 2.sup.nd of the upper pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.2) couples the upper differential output of the circuit and amplifier 116A to the inverting input 161A of the amplifier via series coupled capacitors 158A (a.k.a. C.sub.2) and 160A (a.k.a. C.sub.3). The upper pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2 establish the upper virtual ground at amplifier input 161A. The 1.sup.st of the lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.1) couples the lower differential output of the circuit and amplifier 166B to the inverting input 161B of the amplifier via resistor 116B (a.k.a. R.sub.1). The 2.sup.nd of the lower pair of inverting feedback paths (a.k.a. Fb.sub.2) couples the lower differential output of the circuit and amplifier 166B to the inverting input 161B of the amplifier via series coupled capacitors 158B (a.k.a. C.sub.2) and 160B (a.k.a. C.sub.3). The lower pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2 establish the lower virtual ground at amplifier input 161B.
(12) The analog signal 170 at the output of this prior art differential high pass filter circuit 150 exhibits a limited decrease in the low frequency component of the input signal. Graph 180 shows the Prior Art differential high pass filter circuit's frequency response 182, with frequency on the horizontal axis and amplitude on the vertical axis. The circuit exhibits a broad transition region 184 between the lower frequencies which are blocked, and the higher frequencies which are passed. A high pass filter circuit with such a broad transition region is described as having a gradual roll-up.
(13) The pole plot 190 of the Prior Art differential high pass filter circuit is derived from the specific nodal equations for the circuit expressed within the general transfer function 179 for the circuit as shown in the following Eq. 2.
(14)
where r.sub.0 is the natural frequency, Q is the quality factor, and the complex-domain frequency s is related to the real-domain frequency by the equation s=j where j={square root over (1)}. The three possible mathematical filter approximations implemented with such a filter transfer function are Bessel, Butterworth and Chebyshev. Bessel and Butterworth filter response exhibits a monotonically decreasing magnitude response. Chebyshev filter response exhibits ripples in the passband or stopband frequencies. The pole plot has a horizontal real axis and a vertical imaginary axis on the S plane. The pole plot 190 shows two complex conjugate poles 192A-B on the left side of the imaginary axis, in the 2.sup.nd and 3.sup.rd quadrants respectively. These poles are located on a circle 196 centered on the origin with a radius r.sub.0 corresponding to the natural frequency of the circuit. These complex conjugate poles as well as the pair of zeros 194A-B centered at the origin are provided by the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2.
(15)
(16)
(17) The upper and a lower inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 each include a capacitor C.sub.4 coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes 105A-B to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds at the inputs 111A-B of the differential amplifier 114. These inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 provide the complex conjugate zeros of the low pass elliptic filter circuit. Specifically, the upper inverting feedforward path is provided by a capacitor 202A (a.k.a. C.sub.4) coupled between the upper passive node 105A and the lower virtual ground at the inverting input 111B of the differential amplifier. The lower inverting feedforward path is provided by capacitor 202B (a.k.a. C.sub.4) coupled between the lower passive node 105B and the upper virtual ground at the inverting input 111A of the differential amplifier.
(18) The upper and a lower non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.2 each include a capacitor C.sub.3 coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes 105A-B to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds at the inputs 111A-B of the differential amplifier 114. These non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.2 allow the positioning of the complex conjugate zeros 244A-B on an imaginary axis of the pole-zero plot 240 of the differential elliptic low pass filter circuit. Specifically, the upper non-inverting feedforward path is provided by a capacitor 200A (a.k.a. C.sub.3) coupled between the upper input 102A of the filter circuit and the upper virtual ground at the non-inverting input 111A of the differential amplifier. The lower non-inverting feedforward path is provided by capacitor 200B (a.k.a. C.sub.3) coupled between the lower input 102B of the filter circuit and the lower virtual ground at the non-inverting input 111B of the differential amplifier.
(19) The analog signal 220 at the output of the differential elliptic low pass filter circuit 200 exhibits a substantial decrease in the high frequency component of the input signal when compared to the prior art low pass filter shown in
(20) The pole-zero plot 240 of the differential elliptic low pass filter circuit is derived from the specific nodal equations for the circuit expressed within the general transfer function 229 for the circuit as shown in the following Eq. 3.
(21)
where r.sub.0 is called natural frequency, Q is quality factor, and the complex-domain frequency s is related to the real-domain frequency by the equation s=j where j={square root over (1)}. The mathematical filter approximation implemented with such a filter transfer function is identified as Elliptic. The pole-zero plot has a horizontal real axis and a vertical imaginary axis on the S plane. The pole-zero plot 240 shows two complex conjugate poles 142A-B on the left side of the imaginary axis, in the 2.sup.nd and 3.sup.rd quadrants respectively. These poles are located on a circle 146 centered on the origin with a radius r.sub.0 corresponding to the natural frequency of the circuit. These complex conjugate poles are provided by the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2. The pole-zero plot 240 also shows two complex conjugate zeros 244A-B positioned on the imaginary axis at a radius greater than r.sub.0. These complex conjugate zeros are provided by the combined inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 and Ff.sub.2.
(22)
(23) The upper and a lower inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 each include a resistor R.sub.4 coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes 155A-B to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds at the inputs 161A-B of the differential amplifier 114. These inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 provide the complex conjugate zeros of the high pass elliptic filter circuit. Specifically, the upper inverting feedforward path is provided by a resistor 252A (a.k.a. R.sub.4) coupled between the upper passive node 155A and the lower virtual ground at the inverting input 161B of the differential amplifier. The lower inverting feedforward path is provided by resistor 252B (a.k.a. R.sub.4) coupled between the lower passive node 155B and the upper virtual ground at the inverting input 116A of the differential amplifier.
(24) The upper and a lower non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.2 each include a resistor R.sub.3 coupling a corresponding one of the passive nodes 155A-B to a corresponding one of the virtual grounds at the inputs 161A-B of the differential amplifier 114. These non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.2 allow the positioning of the complex conjugate zeros 294A-B on an imaginary axis of the pole-zero plot 290 of the differential elliptic high pass filter circuit. Specifically, the upper non-inverting feedforward path is provided by a resistor 250A (a.k.a. R.sub.3) coupled between the upper input 152A of the filter circuit and the upper virtual ground at the non-inverting input 161A of the differential amplifier. The lower non-inverting feedforward path is provided by resistor 250B (a.k.a. R.sub.3) coupled between the lower input 152B of the filter circuit and the lower virtual ground at the non-inverting input 161B of the differential amplifier.
(25) The analog signal 270 at the output of the differential elliptic high pass filter circuit 250 exhibits a substantial decrease in the low frequency component of the input signal when compared to the prior art high pass filter shown in
(26) The pole-zero plot 290 of the differential elliptic high pass filter circuit is derived from the specific nodal equations for the circuit expressed within the general transfer function 279 for elliptic circuits as set forth above in Eq. 3. The mathematical filter approximation implemented with such a filter transfer function is identified as Elliptic. The pole-zero plot has a horizontal real axis and a vertical imaginary axis on the S plane. The pole-zero plot 290 shows two complex conjugate poles 192A-B on the left side of the imaginary axis, in the 2.sup.nd and 3.sup.rd quadrants respectively. These poles are located on a circle 196 centered on the origin with a radius r.sub.0 corresponding to the natural frequency of the circuit. These complex conjugate poles are provided by the upper and lower pair of inverting feedback paths Fb.sub.1-2. The pole-zero plot 290 also shows two complex conjugate zeros 294A-B positioned on the imaginary axis at a radius less than r.sub.0. These complex conjugate zeros are provided by the combined inverting and non-inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 and Ff.sub.2.
(27) In another embodiment of the invention biquadratic high and low pass filters are disclosed. In a 1.sup.st biquadratic low pass filter embodiment of the invention the inverting feedforward paths Ff.sub.1 of the elliptic low pass filter shown in
(28) Derivations:
(29) Elliptic filter approximation requires a transfer function as set forth above in Equation 3. The above transfer function has a numerator that depends on variable s. The zeros of this transfer function are located at s=+j.sub.0 and s=j.sub.0, meaning that they are purely imaginary and located on the imaginary axis j. The prior-art filters in
(30) Elliptic Lowpass Filter:
(31) The embodiment of the differential elliptic low pass filter circuit shown in
(32)
To derive the transfer function of this filter, which represents the ratio between the output voltage V.sub.o(s) and the input voltage V.sub.in(s) in the frequency domain as shown in Equation 4, we need to solve the nodal equations describing the Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) at the passive node 105A/105B and virtual ground 111A/111B as shown in the following Equation 5:
(33)
where we have defined conductance values G.sub.1=1/R.sub.1, G.sub.2=1/R.sub.2, and G.sub.3=1/R.sub.3 to simplify the notation and V.sub.1 represents the voltage across capacitor 106 shown in
(34) Solving this set of equations to obtain the ratio between the output voltage V.sub.o(s) and the input voltage V.sub.in(s) leads to the transfer function show in the following Equation 6:
(35)
This transfer function shown in Equation 6 includes s.sup.2, s, and constant terms in the numerator. To implement an elliptic filter, the first-order term s needs to be forced to zero.
(36) Therefore, the following equality shown in the following Equation 7 needs to be satisfied:
C.sub.4G.sub.1C.sub.3G.sub.2C.sub.3G.sub.1C.sub.3G.sub.3=0Equation 7
Equation 7 includes a positive term C.sub.4G.sub.1 which can cancel out the sum of the negative terms. This key characteristic, meaning the presence of a term with opposite sign, is established by the cross-coupled capacitors 202A-B (a.k.a. C.sub.4). Further analysis shows that the above equation can be satisfied by two different values of C.sub.4, with each value leading to a different set of component values realizing the desired transfer function.
(37) Once the above condition is satisfied; the circuit transfer function reduces to the same form as of one of an elliptic filter as shown in the following Equation 8:
(38)
(39) The relationship between the above transfer function and the standard transfer function can be established using the following Equations 9-11:
(40)
(41) The design methodology starts with a desired numerical transfer function and ends with obtaining the component values. One can note that the desired numerical transfer function includes four parameters: K, .sub.0, r.sub.0, and Q. This indicates four conditions or equations to be satisfied. In addition, one needs to satisfy Equation 7. So, there are a total of five conditions to satisfy which are represented by five equations. On the other hand, the circuit includes seven components: R.sub.1, R.sub.2, R.sub.3, C.sub.1, C.sub.2, C.sub.3, C.sub.4. This implies, seven variables and 5 equations. Therefore, once can arbitrarily select two of the components and calculate the remaining five components. As mentioned before, doing so leads to two set of acceptable values for the five components.
(42) Elliptic High Pass Filter:
(43) The embodiment of the differential elliptic high pass filter circuit shown in
(44)
where V.sub.1 represents the voltage across resistor 156 (a.k.a. 2R.sub.2). Solving this set of equations, we obtain the transfer function shown in the following Equation 13:
(45)
(46) To realize an elliptic filter, we need to force the first-order term in the numerator to zero as shown in the following Equation 14:
G.sub.4C.sub.1G.sub.3C.sub.2G.sub.3C.sub.1G.sub.3C.sub.3=0Equation 14
Once again, this condition can be satisfied if the first positive term cancels out the sum of the subsequent negative terms. This key mathematical property is established by the cross-couple resistor R.sub.4. Once this condition is satisfied; the above transfer function takes up the form of an elliptic filter as shown in the following Equation 15:
(47)
(48) Design methodology involves starting from the target numerical transfer function with 4 variables and considering the requirement in Equation 14 which results in five equations and seven variables. Selecting two component values lets us calculate the remaining five component values. Solving the equations leads to two sets of valid values for the five remaining components.
(49) Biquadratic Filters:
(50) A biquadratic filter has the general form shown in the following Equation 16:
(51)
(52) The main difference between a general biquadratic filter and an elliptic filter is that the former includes complex conjugate zeros with non-zero real part while the latter only includes purely imaginary complex conjugate zeros. As a result, the magnitude response of an elliptic filter drops to zero at the notch frequency. On the other hand, the biquadratic filter has a non-zero magnitude response at the notch frequency. However, the amount of attenuation may be sufficient in certain applications to adopt a biquadratic filter rather than an elliptic filter for reasons such as better noise performance or smaller chip area.
(53) Biquadratic Low Pass Filter:
(54) A specific embodiment of interest for the biquadratic low pass filter is when C.sub.4=0 and the transfer function takes the form shown in the following Equation 17:
(55)
The above transfer function includes a quadratic numerator with complex conjugate zeros providing finite attenuation at the notch frequency.
(56) In the second embodiment of the biquadratic low pass filter when C.sub.3=0, the transfer function takes the form shown in the following Equation 18:
(57)
The above transfer function includes simply a real zero.
(58) Biquadratic High Pass Filter:
(59) In a first embodiment of the biquadratic high pass filter, one specific case of interest is when g.sub.4=0 or equivalently R.sub.4 is not used. The resulting transfer function is shown in the following Equation 19:
(60)
The above transfer function includes a quadratic numerator with complex conjugate zeros providing finite attenuation at the notch frequency.
(61) In the second embodiment of the high pass biquadratic filter when g.sub.3=0, or equivalently R.sub.3 is not used, the resulting transfer function is shown in Equation 20:
(62)
The above transfer function includes simply a real zero.
(63) The foregoing description of a preferred embodiment of the invention has been presented for purposes of illustration and description. It is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise forms disclosed. Obviously many modifications and variations will be apparent to practitioners skilled in this art. It is intended that the scope of the invention be defined by the following claims and their equivalents.