METHODS FOR COUNTING THE NUMBER OF LIVING MICROORGANISMS CONTAINED IN A SPECIMEN SAMPLE AND APPARATUSES FOR IMPLEMENTING SUCH METHODS
20240182946 ยท 2024-06-06
Inventors
Cpc classification
C12M41/36
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C12M35/02
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C12M33/04
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
International classification
Abstract
According to an aspect, the present description is related to an apparatus for depositing on a substrate drops of a specimen sample including a liquid medium and living microorganisms. The apparatus includes a tray for supporting the substrate, a container, e.g. a syringe, configured to receive a volume of the specimen sample and a drop deposition motor configured to push the specimen sample out of the container to form drops of a predetermined volume that detach by gravity and fall on the substrate. The apparatus further includes guiding motors configured for changing a relative position of the tray and the container and a control unit configured to synchronize the drop deposition motor and the guiding motors in order to deposit drops on the substrate according to a pattern.
Claims
1. A method for counting the number of living microorganisms contained in a specimen sample comprising said living microorganisms in a liquid medium, wherein the method comprises: providing at least a first substrate; filling a container with a volume of said specimen sample; pushing the specimen sample out of the container to produce drops of a predetermined volume that detach by gravity and fall on said at least first substrate; moving the container relatively to the substrate synchronously with pushing the specimen out of the container to produce at least a first plurality of said drops on said at least first substrate; and after a predetermined incubation period, determining an initial concentration (C) of living microorganisms in the specimen sample from the colonies of living microorganisms developed on said at least first substrate.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein: the liquid medium comprises a nourishing medium adapted to develop colonies of living microorganisms from said living microorganisms comprised in the specimen sample; said at least first substrate is a non-wetting solid substrate so that the drops of said first plurality of drops produce a pattern of at least a first plurality of isolated drops on said at least first substrate; and said initial concentration C of living microorganisms in the specimen sample is determined from a ratio P.sub.0 between the number N.sub.0 of empty drops in which no colony was developed and the total number N of said first plurality of isolated drops on said at least first substrate.
3. The method according to claim 2, wherein a minimal edge-to edge distance (d) between two drops is about 1 mm.
4. The method according to claim 2, wherein said pattern is a regular two-dimensional pattern.
5. The method according to claim 2, further comprising dropping a plurality of drops at a same location of the pattern to increase the volume of said isolated drops of said first plurality of isolated drops produced on said at least first substrate.
6. The method according to claim 2, wherein said first plurality of isolated drops are produced on a first area of said at least first substrate and the method further comprises producing at least a second plurality of isolated drops on a second non-wetting solid substrate or on a different area of said at least first substrate, wherein the isolated drops of the first plurality of isolated drops and the isolated drops of the second plurality of isolated drops have different volumes.
7. The method according to claim 2, further comprising, after incubation, illuminating the substrate with a UV light.
8. The method according to claim 1, wherein: said at least first substrate comprises a nourishing medium adapted to develop colonies of living microorganisms from said living microorganisms; the determining of an initial concentration (C) of living microorganisms in the specimen sample comprises counting the number of colonies developed on said at least first substrate.
9. The method according to claim 1, wherein the container is filled with a first volume (V.sub.0) of the specimen sample and the volume (V.sub.d) of the plurality of drops dropped on the first substrate is smaller than said first volume; the method further comprising: after dropping the plurality of drops on the substrate, filling the container with a volume of liquid medium to produce a second specimen sample of said first volume (V.sub.0) with a smaller concentration (C.sub.1) of living microorganisms; dropping a plurality of drops of said second specimen sample on a second substrate or on a second area of said first substrate to determine the concentration of living microorganisms in said second specimen sample.
10. An apparatus for counting the number of living microorganisms contained in a specimen sample comprising said living microorganisms in a liquid medium, the apparatus comprising: a tray for supporting at least a first substrate; a container configured to receive a volume of said specimen sample; a drop deposition motor configured to push the specimen sample out of the container to form drops of a predetermined volume that detach by gravity and fall on said at least first substrate; at least one guiding motor configured for changing a relative position of the tray and the container; and a control unit configured to synchronize the drop deposition motor and the at least one guiding motor in order to deposit drops on said at least first substrate according to a pattern.
11. The apparatus according to claim 10, wherein the container is a syringe.
12. The apparatus according to claim 10, further comprising a drop detachment detector configured to detect the detachment of a drop from said container.
13. The apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the drop detachment detector comprises a light emitting device and a photodetector, wherein the photodetector is configured to detect a variation of a light beam emitted by the light emitting device when a drop detaches.
14. The apparatus according to claim 10, further comprising: a camera configured to acquire images of the at least first substrate after a predetermined incubation period; and a processing unit configured to determine from said images, an initial concentration of living microorganisms in the specimen sample from the colonies of living microorganisms developed on the at least first substrate.
15. The method according to claim 2, wherein a minimal edge-to edge distance (d) between two drops is about 2 mm.
16. A method for counting the number of living microorganisms contained in a specimen sample comprising said living microorganisms in a liquid medium, wherein the method comprises: filling a container with a volume of said specimen sample; pushing the specimen sample out of the container to produce drops of a predetermined volume that detach by gravity and fall on at least a first substrate; moving the container relatively to the substrate synchronously with pushing the specimen out of the container to produce at least a first plurality of said drops on said at least first substrate; and after a predetermined incubation period, determining an initial concentration (C) of living microorganisms in the specimen sample from the colonies of living microorganisms developed on said at least first substrate.
17. The method according to claim 16, wherein: the liquid medium comprises a nourishing medium adapted to develop colonies of living microorganisms from said living microorganisms comprised in the specimen sample; said at least first substrate is a non-wetting solid substrate so that the drops of said first plurality of drops produce a pattern of at least a first plurality of isolated drops on said at least first substrate; and said initial concentration C of living microorganisms in the specimen sample is determined from a ratio P.sub.0 between the number N.sub.0 of empty drops in which no colony was developed and the total number N of said first plurality of isolated drops on said at least first substrate.
18. The method according to claim 17, wherein a minimal edge-to edge distance (d) between two drops is about 1 mm.
19. The method according to claim 17, further comprising: dropping a plurality of drops at a same location of the pattern to increase the volume of said isolated drops of said first plurality of isolated drops produced on said at least first substrate.
20. The method according to claim 17, wherein said first plurality of isolated drops are produced on a first area of said at least first substrate and the method further comprises producing at least a second plurality of isolated drops on a second non-wetting solid substrate or on a different area of said at least first substrate, wherein the isolated drops of the first and second plurality of isolated drops have different volumes.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0061] Other advantages and features of the invention will become apparent on reading the description, which is illustrated by the following figures:
[0062]
[0063]
[0064]
[0065]
[0066]
[0067]
[0068]
[0069]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0070] In the detailed description which follows, only some embodiments are described in detail in order to ensure clarity of the description, but these examples are not intended to limit the general scope of the principles that emerge from the present description.
[0071] The various embodiments and aspects described in the present description may be combined or simplified in multiple ways. In particular, the steps of the various methods may be repeated, reversed, or performed in parallel, unless otherwise specified.
[0072] When, in the present description, reference is made to calculating or processing steps for the implementation in particular of method steps, it is understood that each calculating or processing step may be implemented by software, hardware, firmware, microcode or any appropriate combination of these technologies. When software is used, each calculating or processing step may be implemented by computer program instructions or software code. These instructions may be stored in or transmitted to a storage medium that is readable by a computer (or computing unit) and/or be executed by a computer (or computing unit) in order to implement these calculating or processing steps.
[0073] In the figures, identical elements are indicated by the same references.
[0074]
[0075] In the method according to said first embodiment, the specimen sample comprises said living microorganisms in a liquid medium, wherein the liquid medium comprises a nourishing medium adapted to develop colonies of living microorganisms from said living microorganisms.
[0076] The method then comprises providing at least a first solid substrate 210, filling a container with a volume of said specimen sample, for example a syringe 230 as it will be described in greater details with reference to
[0077] The method further comprises moving the container relatively to said at least first substrate synchronously with pushing the specimen sample out of the container to produce at least a first plurality of said drops on said at least first substrate according to a pattern. In the method shown in
[0078] Although
[0079] The method according to said first embodiment then comprises, after a predetermined incubation period, determining an initial concentration of living microorganisms in the specimen sample from the colonies of living microorganisms developed on said at least first substrate. As shown in
[0080] Compared to methods of the prior art, in the methods for counting the number of living microorganisms according to the present description, by dropping drops of a predetermined volume of the specimen sample synchronously with the relative displacement of the container and the substrate, a perfect control of the deposition of the specimen sample on the substrate can be achieved. Further, in the exemplary method of
[0081] Further, the deposition of the specimen sample on the substate is contactless meaning that no contact is required between the container and the substrate and can be performed using standard containers as syringes.
[0082]
[0083] Determining the initial concentration of living microorganisms in the specimen sample from the number of empty drops 224 is now described in more details.
[0084] As previously explained in reference to
[0085]
[0086] The method according to said first embodiment of the present description consists of counting the relative number P.sub.0 of unfilled drops after incubation and from this quantity, compute the actual concentration of microorganisms in the liquid. It is thus referred to as P.sub.0 method in the present description. The method is akin to transforming the analog method of spread counting known in the prior art into a digital method of counting zeros and ones.
[0087] The mathematical principle of this method is now described.
[0088] Consider N isolated drops of a liquid containing microorganisms at concentration C (number/mL) on a solid substrate. Each drop has a volume V. Defining
?=C?V (1)
as the mean number of organisms per drop, the probability that initially a drop contained n organisms is Poisson distributed:
where n!=1?2? . . . ?n. The probability that a drop contains no organism is therefore
P.sub.0=e.sup.??(3)
[0089] The P.sub.0 method therefore consists of counting the number of drops N.sub.0 that after incubation have stayed the same and determine:
[0090] Relation (3) is then used to estimate directly the mean number of organisms per drop:
?=?1n(P.sub.0) (5)
where ln ( ) is the natural logarithm function.
[0091] This leads in turn to the value of microorganisms' concentration in the original liquid:
[0092] As explained above, compared to methods of the prior art, the method according to the first embodiment does not necessitate prior preparation of a substrate.
[0093] Further, the total amount of liquid deposited on the surface is of order of 1 mL. After the incubation and counting period, the Petri dish can be easily washed for future use, circumventing waste management.
[0094] Drops may be deposited on nodes of a regular grid pattern, as shown in
[0095] Determining the drops that remain empty after incubation can be achieved by different measurements. One can directly observe the drops that are filled (i.e. non-empty drops) and develop a milky halo or spots inside (
[0096] As shown in the non-limitative example of
[0097] The error estimate for the P.sub.0 method is now described. Contrary to counting methods according to the prior art, the collisions between colonies and competition for resources has no importance because there are no microorganisms in the unfilled drops 224.
[0098] The statistical error can be estimated as follow.
[0099] We suppose that from a specimen sample comprising living microorganisms at concentration C, a plurality of N isolated drops of volume V.sub.d have been deposited. The value of the mean number of microorganisms per drop (equation 1 above) is ?.sub.0=CV.sub.d. The random variable X: a drop contains at least one microbe is a binary variable: X=0 with probability p=e.sup.??.sup.
[0100] From the number N.sub.0 of unfilled drops, we can determine an estimated value p.sub.e of p and its standard error ? p.sub.e:
From this estimation, we can determine an estimated value ?.sub.e of the mean number of microorganisms per drop: ?.sub.e=?ln (p.sub.e) and its error:
and therefore, the relative error R in estimation of the mean number of microorganisms per drop is:
[0101]
[0102]
[0103] In the example of
[0104] On the other hand, grids with different drop volumes and/or different spacings could be imprinted on the same or different substrates, allowing the extension of the dynamic range of measurements.
[0105] More particularly, providing pluralities of isolated drops of different volumes may be achieved using the method according to said first embodiment by dropping on a first area of the substrate a first plurality of drops of a first predetermined volume and on another area of the substrate, or on a different substrate, a second plurality of drops of a second predetermined volume, for example larger than the first volume. The second predetermined volume is for example obtained by dropping a plurality of drops at a same location of the pattern, thus increasing the volume of the drops produced on the substrate.
[0106]
[0107] As shown in the example of
[0108] The apparatus 500 further comprises at least one guiding motor configured for changing a relative position of the tray and the container. In the exemplary apparatus of
[0109] The apparatus 500 further comprises a control unit (not shown in
[0110] The container 530 is for example a syringe, for example as shown in
[0111] In operation, the substrate 510, e.g. a Petri dish, is positioned on the tray 560 and is moved sequentially in x and y directions relative to the container 530, e.g. a syringe, containing the specimen sample with the living microorganisms. Individual drops are formed by pushing down the specimen sample using the motor 535, configured for either driving a piston, or activating a pump or any similar method. When drops reach a critical volume V, depending on the needle size of the syringe, they detach by gravity and fall on the substrate 510. Synchronizing the speed of xy scan and the motor 535 results in a perfect spread. The substrate may be a neutral one, such as the plastic bottom of the Petri Dish for microbial growth in isolated drops as described in the first embodiment of the method according to the present description. The substrate may be a classic nourishing one such as an appropriate agarose gel, as it will be described in reference with
[0112] The apparatus 500 may further comprise a drop detachment detector 570 configured to count and/or to enhance accuracy of drop positioning on the substrate. The drop detachment detector 570 comprises for example an optical system, with a light emitting device, such as for example a light-emitting diode (LED) and a photodetector facing the light-emitting device. Due to the absorbance of the specimen sample, the photodetector may detect a variation in a light beam emitted by the light emitting device when a drop detaches and passes through the light beam. In some embodiments, the container may be continuously moving in the x direction and the drop detachment detector 570 detects the drop, thus enabling an accurate knowledge of the position of the drop on the substrate. In some other embodiments, the container may be moved only when a drop is detected, thus also enabling a control of the position of the drop on the substrate. Such drop detachment detector may also be an electrical detector, for example an accelerometer or force detector connected to the substrate to detect a change of mass.
[0113] The apparatus 500 may further comprise a camera (not shown in
[0114]
[0115] In the method according to the second embodiment, the substrate 610 comprises a nourishing medium 611 (such as agarose) adapted to develop colonies of living microorganisms from said living microorganisms. The substrate may be a Petri dish filled with such nourishing medium, as in methods according to the prior art.
[0116] As in the method according to the first embodiment, the method according to the second embodiment comprises filling a container with a volume of a specimen sample 620 comprising the living microorganisms in a liquid medium. The container is for example a syringe 230, as illustrated in
[0117] In the method according to the second embodiment, however, since the substrate already comprises a nourishing medium, the drops, when falling on the substrate, spread and fuse as in the counting method according to the prior art. The initial concentration of living microorganisms in the specimen sample is thus determined by counting the number of colonies 622 developed on the substrate after an incubation period, as in the CFU method according to the prior art.
[0118] However, and contrary to the manual method according to the prior art and illustrated in
[0119] Inventors have shown that the quality of spreading can be evaluated by a Coefficient of Variation method, as described in [Ref. 6]. According to this method, the area of the Petri dish is divided into M squares. The numbers n.sub.i of colonies in each square are counted and the average ? and variance V.sub.r of these numbers are computed. A perfect spread corresponds to a coefficient of variation C.sub.V=Vr /??1, while for a sub-optimal spreading, C.sub.V>1. While it is relatively easy to spend some time and to be careful when only few plates have to be made, it becomes difficult to keep the quality of spreading when hundred plates have to be made.
[0120]
[0121] Obviously, the apparatus shown in
[0122]
[0123] In a first step (
[0124] After the end of the deposition stage shown in
[0125] After the end of the step shown in
C.sub.1=(V.sub.2/V.sub.0)C.sub.0 (10)
[0126] Therefore, a dilution factor of (V2/V0) has been achieved. The device is now ready to deposit drops into a new Petri dish. Of course, the steps shown in
[0127] Although described by way of a number of detailed example embodiments, the methods and apparatuses according to the present description comprise various variants, modifications and improvements that will be obvious to those skilled in the art, it being understood that these various variants, modifications and improvements fall within the scope of the invention such as defined by the following claims.
REFERENCES
[0128] Ref. 1: R. J. Petri Eine kleine Modification des Koch'schen Plattenverfahrens. Centralblatt f?r Bakteriologie und Parasitenkunde, 1:279-80 (1887). [0129] Ref. 2: P. Thomas et al. Nonrecovery of varying proportions of viable bacteria during spread plating governed by the extent of spreader usage and proposal for an alternate spotting-spreading approach to maximize the CFU. J Appl Microbiol Volume: 113. ISSN: 1365-2672 Issue: 2 (2012). [0130] Ref. 3: J. E. Gilchrist et al. Spiral Plate Method for Bacterial Determination. J APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY, Vol. 25, No. 2, p. 244-252 (1973). [0131] Ref. 4: R. Hazan et al. A method for high throughput determination of viable bacteria cell counts in 96-well plates. BMC Microbiology 12:259 (2012). [0132] Ref. 5: I. Mihalcescu et al. Green autofluorescence, a double-edged monitoring tool for bacterial growth and activity in microplates. Physical Biology, 12 (2015). [0133] Ref. 6: B. Houchmandzadeh Theory of neutral clustering for growing populations, PHYSICAL REVIEW E 80, 051920 (2009).