Rat-race balun and associated method for reducing the footprint of a rat-race balun
20240222839 · 2024-07-04
Inventors
Cpc classification
H01P5/10
ELECTRICITY
International classification
Abstract
A rat-race balun includes a transmission line loop and 4 input-output ports P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4 connected to the transmission line loop, the balun being designed to receive a first signal on the port P.sub.1, and to divide the first signal into a second signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.2 and a third signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.4, the second signal and the third signal being in phase opposition with one another, the balun wherein the balun is kidney-shaped and the ports P.sub.2, P.sub.4 each comprise at least a first section connected to the transmission line, the first section of the port P.sub.2 being parallel to the first section of the port P.sub.4.
Claims
1. A rat-race balun, comprising a transmission line loop and 4 input-output ports P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4 connected to said transmission line loop, said balun being designed to receive a first signal on the port P.sub.1, and to divide said first signal into a second signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.2 and a third signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.4, said second signal and said third signal being in phase opposition with one another, said balun wherein: the balun is kidney-shaped and the ports P.sub.2, P.sub.4 each comprise at least a first section connected to the transmission line, the first section of the port P.sub.2 being parallel to the first section of the port P.sub.4.
2. The rat-race balun according to claim 1, wherein the mutually parallel first section of the port P.sub.2 and first section of the port P.sub.4 face one another.
3. The rat-race balun according to claim 1, wherein the ports adjacent to one another from among the ports P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4 are connected by respective sections of the transmission line loop, and at least some of said sections are capacitor-loaded transmission line sections.
4. The rat-race balun according to claim 3, wherein: each of the respective transmission line sections between P.sub.1 and P.sub.2, between P.sub.2 and P.sub.3, between P.sub.3 and P.sub.4 is a line section of electrical length 2?.sub.1, of impedance Z.sub.1 and loaded by a capacitor of capacitance C and; where ?.sub.1<45? and the following equalities are satisfied:
5. The rat-race balun according to claim 3, wherein: the respective transmission line section between the adjacent ports P.sub.1 and P.sub.4 is of electrical length 6?.sub.1 comprising three consecutive line subsections each of electrical length 2?.sub.1, of impedance Z.sub.1 and loaded by a capacitor of capacitance C; where ?.sub.1<45? and the following equalities are satisfied:
6. The rat-race balun according to claim 3, wherein: the respective transmission line section between the adjacent ports P.sub.1 and P.sub.4 is of electrical length 2?.sub.2, of impedance Z.sub.3 and is a line section loaded by a capacitor of capacitance C2; where ?.sub.2<135 and the following equalities are satisfied:
7. The balun according to claim 1, comprising an impedance transformer loaded by a capacitor between the port P.sub.1 and the transmission line loop.
8. A method for reducing the footprint of a rat-race balun comprising a transmission line loop and 4 input-output ports P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4 connected to said transmission line loop, said balun being designed to receive a first signal on the port P.sub.1, and to divide said first signal into a second signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.2 and a third signal that is delivered to the port P.sub.4, said second signal and said third signal being in phase opposition with one another, comprising the following steps implemented by an electronic device for determining rat-race balun characteristics: determination of a kidney shape for the balun; connection of a first section of each of the ports P.sub.2, P.sub.4 to the transmission line, the first section of the port P.sub.2 being parallel to the first section of the port P.sub.4.
9. The method for reducing the footprint of a rat-race balun according to claim 8, according to which the mutually parallel first section of the port P.sub.2 and first section of the port P.sub.4 face one another.
10. The method for reducing the footprint of a rat-race balun according to claim 8, according to which the ports adjacent to one another from among the ports P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4 are connected by respective sections of the transmission line loop, and at least some of said sections are capacitor-loaded transmission line sections.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0031] The invention will be better understood and other features, details and advantages will become more clearly apparent on reading the non-limiting description that follows, and by virtue of the appended figures, which are provided by way of example.
[0032]
[0033]
[0034]
[0035]
[0036]
[0037]
[0038]
[0039]
[0040] Identical references may be used in different figures to denote identical or comparable elements.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0041]
[0042] The processing module 1 comprises a power transistor (High Power Amplifier), called HPA 11. It operates in the L band (or any other frequency band, in a narrow band, for example with a width less than 20 MHZ, or even 15 MHZ), and at powers possibly reaching 1.5 kW peak.
[0043] As is known, power transistors have a low input impedance compared to the standard impedance of 50? and often consist of two chips (similar to two transistors), in a push-pull assembly here, this meaning having to divide (split) the input signal and to phase-shift them from one another by 180? before supplying them to the input of the transistor. The fact that the signals supplied to the input of the HPA 11 are in phase opposition makes it possible to reduce their interference due to amplification on two very close chips.
[0044] To this end, the processing module 1 comprises, upstream of the HPA 11, a balun 10 in one embodiment of the invention.
[0045] The input signal of the processing module 1, typically a train of RF pulses in the L band (in the example under consideration with a power In 47 dBm, and a load rate of 2%), is supplied to the input of the port P.sub.1 of the balun 10. The power of this input signal is P.
[0046] The two signals at the output of the ports P.sub.2 and P.sub.4, of the same power P/2 (to +/?0.2 dB % for example) and in phase opposition to one another, are supplied one to the input of one of the two chips of the HPA 11, and the other to the input of the other of the two chips of the HPA 11.
[0047] At the output of the HPA 11, the two amplified signals, in phase opposition, are supplied to the input of a balun 12, one on its port P.sub.2 and the other on the port P.sub.4. The balun 12 realigns the phases of these signals with respect to one another and outputs, on its port P.sub.1, the sum of these two phase-realigned signals.
[0048] The input impedance of the balun 10 is Z.sub.0, which is much greater than each of the input and output impedances Z.sub.E and Z.sub.S of the HPA 11. For example, Z.sub.0=50? and Z.sub.E, Z.sub.S less than 20 or even less than 10? (notably if LDMOS transistor), for example here 2.5?.
[0049] The balun 10, constructed here on a printed circuit board (PCB) with microstrips for example, comprises transmission line sections between each port P.sub.1, P.sub.2, P.sub.3, P.sub.4.
[0050] In a first embodiment, each transmission line section between two adjacent ports, in a conventional manner, has a physical length (in metres) \/4 outside the section between the adjacent ports P.sub.1 and P.sub.4 (that is to say the section that does not include the ports P.sub.2, P.sub.3) and that has a physical length 3?/4, A being the wavelength corresponding to the centre frequency of the input signal of the processing module 1. The electrical length corresponding to the physical length ?/4 is equal to 90?. As is known, the electrical length is a theoretical way of expressing wavelength without having to evoke the environment of the circuit: PCB (printed circuit board). In specific terms, this consists in considering that one wavelength ? corresponds to 360?. Theoretically, for a specific application, it is necessary to keep the same wavelength ratio. The propagation of EM waves depends on the medium, and therefore changes depending on the substrate ? (in m), but its associated length does not (always 360?).
[0051] The impedance of the unloaded transmission line of physical length ?/4 is Z.sub.c.
[0052] In a second embodiment, each quarter-wave line section under consideration in the first embodiment is replaced with its equivalent as a transmission line loaded by a capacitor.
[0053] In terms of physical dimensions, these equivalent sections differ, but in terms of behaviour (if studying S parameters for example) they are identical, as shown by a narrowband observation.
[0054] This modification is detailed in Compact Tunable 3 dB Hybrid and Rat-Race Couplers with Harmonics Suppression, Khair Al Shamaileh, Mohammad Almalkawi, Vijay Devabhaktuni, and Nihad Dib, INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY, VOL. 7, NO. 6, NOVEMBER 2012, and is illustrated in
[0055] This then gives the following equalities:
[0057] A 52% reduction in the size of the balun, corresponding notably to the choice of a value of ?.sub.1 less than 45?, was obtained in one exemplary embodiment.
[0058] The reduction ratio depends on the chosen value of ?.sub.1, and also on the PCB (notably its dielectric permittivity parameter ?.sub.r) under consideration. There is a reduction provided that ?.sub.1<45?: there is a reduction in the line length, which depends a great deal on the PCB that is used. Moreover, since Z.sub.1 is inversely proportional to tan(?.sub.1), tan(45?)=1 and the tan function is increasing over [0; 45? ] then the impedance of the equivalent lines is greater than that of the original line. In this case, there is a reduction in the width of the line, which depends a great deal on the PCB that is used, mainly on its thickness.
[0059] The capacitance value of the capacitor along with the impedance of the loaded line segments are deduced from the above equations linking them to the chosen electrical length ?.sub.1 less than 45?. Since the impedance is a function of the physical width of the microstrip, these are determined as a function of the impedance Z.sub.1 (Z.sub.1 here designating the characteristic impedance of the loaded lines, that is to say the impedance that a line would have at input if it were to be of infinite length: it does not depend on length).
[0060] It also follows that the value of the resonant frequency of the loaded transmission line may be adjusted as needed by modifying the value of C (for example by using varactor capacitors).
[0061] In Shamaileh et al., the change in impedance was an effect experienced by the authors.
[0062] It is proposed here to exploit this change in impedance: the smaller the length ?.sub.1 of the loaded sections, the higher their impedance. When using a balun 10 operating at low impedance, there is therefore more room for manoeuvre to reduce the length of the lines before reaching the limits of manufacturability associated with the line widths. It is therefore possible to obtain a component with very thin lines, of reduced length, operating at low impedances.
[0063] However, to meet one of the abovementioned specific features of the HPA, it is precisely necessary to have a balun 10 operating with low impedances at output P.sub.2, P.sub.4.
[0064] In a third embodiment of the balun 10, the second embodiment is modified in that the 3?/4 line section between the adjacent ports P.sub.1, P.sub.4 is replaced with its equivalent as a line loaded with a single capacitor this time, of capacitance C2, as shown in the block diagram of
[0065] This topology is more constrictive than the previous one explained in the second embodiment, because the impedance of the two segments replacing the 3?/4 line is then, unlike before, proportional to their electrical length.
[0066] This is due to the fact that
and that the tan( ) function is negative and increasing over this interval. The ? sign in equality 0_3 transforms the tan( ) function into an equivalent of the abs(tan) function over this interval. However, abs(tan(?.sub.2)?1 over
[0067] An additional reduction in the size of the balun 10 may be achieved if the value of ?.sub.1 is chosen to be less than 45? and if the value of 02 is chosen to be less than 135?, the impedance and electrical length values being determined using the following equalities 0_3 and 0_4.
[0068] This additional reduction is achieved notably if 3?.sub.1>?.sub.2 and if working with a substrate and impedances that do not bring about an excessively large difference in line width between the impedances Z1 and Z3 (that is to say if working with a substrate that, depending on the impedances Z1 and Z3 that are used, does not bring about an increase in the width of the lines that would cause an overall increase in the surface area covered by the balun, despite the decrease in the length of the lines); one example of a standard criterion is that the length should be at least greater than 3 times the width.
[0069] where Z.sub.P1P4 is the impedance of the equivalent transmission line section between the adjacent ports P.sub.1P.sub.4, of physical length 3?/4 and unloaded.
[0070] This means having to make compromises between the impedances of the various line segments of the balun: to reduce the size of the balun, it is necessary either to reduce the electrical length of its lines or to increase the impedance of its lines; however, in the case of the 3?/4 line loaded with a single capacitor, these two parameters are proportional, and a compromise is necessary. It is also necessary to take into account the impedance of the ?/4 lines; if it is excessively different from that of the 3?/4 line, the impedance discontinuity could reduce performance. The opposite is that, if they are too close, then this means that ?.sub.1 is close to 45? and therefore that the reduction of the ?/4 lines is less significant.
[0071] The values of capacitance C and impedance Z.sub.1 for each segment of length 2?.sub.1 connecting the adjacent points P.sub.1, P.sub.2 to one another, respectively connecting the adjacent points P.sub.2, P.sub.3 to one another, and connecting the adjacent points P.sub.3, P.sub.4 to one another, are for their part still determined by applying equations 0_1 and 0_2 above.
[0072] The shape of a rat-race balun that is usually used is circular or square and is therefore not ideal notably for use in a push-pull processing module 10 on a printed circuit, which has a full-length structure.
[0073] In a fourth embodiment, it is therefore proposed to produce the balun 10 by giving it a kidney shape (in the plane in which the printed circuit extends), as shown in
[0074] In one embodiment, with reference to
[0075] With reference to
[0076] In one embodiment, the kidney-shaped balun 10 is constructed using circular arcs between the 4 consecutive ports and the lengths of these arcs are set according to the lengths between ports defined by calculation according to one of the first, second and third embodiments. The combination of this kidney shape with the use of loaded lines as described in the second and third embodiments makes it possible to significantly reduce the size of the lines.
[0077] For example, if it is desired to implement the kidney shape in combination with the second embodiment with 6 capacitors, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, each of capacitance C: 12 circular arcs and their respective lengths are defined, with 2 concentric circular arcs (delimiting a transmission line) between each pair of consecutive ports: the structure is divided into 12 circular arcs; the angle of some of them is increased (those adjacent to the ports P.sub.2, P.sub.3 and P.sub.4), without changing their length, so as to obtain the desired shape.
[0078] In one embodiment, the sections 52, 54 of the ports P.sub.2 and P.sub.4 immediately connected to the body of the kidney-shaped balun 10 (extending in the plane of the printed circuit) are parallel to one another and extend (in embodiments where their length is non-zero) in one and the same direction, DE, from the body of the kidney-shaped balun 10. In one embodiment, these two parallel sections are identical.
[0079] In one embodiment, a section 51 of the port P.sub.1 (extending in the plane of the printed circuit) of the balun 10 is parallel to the sections of the ports P.sub.2 and P.sub.4 and extends in one direction from the balun 10 in an opposite direction, DO. In one embodiment, it is replaced with a resistor in parallel.
[0080] Thus, as described above and in a conventional manner, in this embodiment too, the input signal is supplied to the input of the kidney-shaped balun 10 at the port P.sub.1; the signal transmitted in the balun 10 undergoes power division and phase opposition and the signals at the output of the ports P.sub.2 and P.sub.4 have a power equal to half the power of the input signal and are in phase opposition. The port P.sub.3 of the balun 10 is isolated (grounded by a load) in the processing module shown in
[0081] At the output of the balun 10, the impedance is for example 12.5?, and then matching circuits (length different from ?/4) are arranged between the HPA 11 and the balun 10 in order to reduce the impedance to Z.sub.E if necessary (an impedance transformer, as is known, comprises transmission lines having increasing or decreasing diameters to modify the impedance).
[0082] A balun 10 corresponding to embodiment 2 and/or 3 is particularly suitable for narrowband uses.
[0083] The embodiments described above may be implemented independently or in combination: for example, in one embodiment of the invention, the kidney-shaped balun 10 is combined with one of the first, second and third balun embodiments. Each of the embodiments makes it possible to have a balun with a reduced footprint.
[0084] In one embodiment, in order for the balun to be able to maintain an input impedance of 50?, with reference to
[0085] The balun 10 according to the invention is therefore a signal distributor, with or without impedance transformation as the case may be, which is miniaturized and optimized with capacitor-loaded transmission lines. The invention advantageously replaces the historical solution combining a ?/4 impedance transformer associated with a ?/2 phase shifter. The invention is even more beneficial for substrates with low permittivity (FR-4 or RO4350b, low-cost substrates), where the footprint of the conventional solution is even more significant.
[0086] In terms of comparison with the solution, the footprint is greatly reduced: for a FR4 HP substrate with a dielectric permittivity constant of 4.34 and a height of 0.245 mm, a reduction of approximately 80% is observed, with reference to the table below, by combining embodiments 3 and 4 with a loaded transformer. This depends on the minimum width of a line and on the power accepted in the lines and in the capacitors.
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Historical solution Current solution Footprint ?.sub.r = 4.34, ?.sub.r = 4.34, h = 0.245 mm h = 0.245 mm S = 40 * 40 = 1600 mm.sup.2 S = 16.5 * 19.6 = 323 mm.sup.2 Reduction of almost 80% Means Microstrip lines Microstrip lines and 5 to 7 capacitors [0087] where ?.sub.r is the dielectric permittivity associated with the FR4 HP substrate, h is the thickness of the substrate, and S is the surface area of the component.
[0088]
[0089] With reference to
[0090] In one embodiment, in a step 101 of designing such a rat-race balun, for example corresponding to the second embodiment, a footprint reduction module comprising a memory storing software instructions and a processor determines, following the execution of the software instructions on the processor, the values of Z.sub.1, ?.sub.1 and C of the balun 10 satisfying equalities 0_1 and 0_2 such that ?.sub.1<45?.
[0091] For example, the substrate to be used is known, and the dimension of the lines as a function of impedance and dielectric length is therefore predictable. The operating impedance is known, and ?.sub.1 is chosen arbitrarily (complying with the condition ?.sub.1<45?), as a function of the obtained values of Z.sub.1 and C. It is checked that the associated lines are technically feasible, and meet the requirements. Based on this check, it is decided to retain this value of ?.sub.1 or to amend it accordingly. The search is refined for each value of ?.sub.1.
[0092] In another embodiment, the footprint reduction module furthermore determines the values of Z.sub.3, ?.sub.2 and C2 satisfying equalities 0_3 and 0_4 such that ?.sub.2<135?.
[0093] The balun is then manufactured taking these characteristics into account.
[0094] In a design step 102, with the electrical lengths of the line sections between ports of the balun being defined, the footprint reduction module determines, on the basis of these lengths and the actual impedances of the lines, the data defining a kidney shape for a rat-race balun and ports, so as to obtain a kidney-shaped balun as described above for example.
[0095] Steps 101, 102 may also be implemented independently of one another.
[0096] Such a method makes it possible to obtain a push-pull assembly comprising the rat-race balun constructed under these conditions, and occupying a reduced footprint.
[0097] The method may be implemented by executing software instructions on a processor as described. As an alternative, it may be implemented by dedicated hardware, typically a digital integrated circuit, either specific (ASIC) or based on programmable logic (for example FPGA/Field-Programmable Gate Array).
Justification for Obtaining Equalities 0_3 and 0_4:
[0098]
[0101] Matrix (1) below provides the parameters ABCD for the conventional transmission line of physical length 3?/4:
[0102] Next, to have an equivalent, it is necessary to have an equality between (1) and the matrix ABCD of a short-circuited shunt (2) multiplied on both sides by the matrix of a capacitor-loaded stub (3), represented by (4):
[0103] Equality (4) makes it possible to establish the following equations:
[0104] The correspondence between (1) and (5.a), (6) is used to determine:
[0105] Then substituting (6) into (5.b) gives rise to (7)
[0106] Finally, using (6) and (7), the value of the capacitance used in the equivalent loaded line is equal to
[0107] Since C>0, it follows that:
[0108] Using conditions (9.a) and (9.b), and taking into account that Z.sub.cl>0, the only possible values for ?.sub.cl are:
[0109] The aim is to reduce the length of the 3?/4 transmission line by replacing the three loaded ?/4 lines with a loaded 3?/4 line as shown in
[0110] To satisfy (11), it is necessary to take into account condition (10). Finally, the loaded 3?/4 line may have a size reduction for:
[0111] An ADS simulation was used to demonstrate that the miniaturized rat-race couplers have the same performance for three capacitor-loaded ?/4 lines and for one capacitor-loaded 3?/4 line.
[0112] Beyond the miniaturization aspects, these novel aspects provide greater flexibility with regard to the impedance value.