System and process for electrochemical upgrading of bio-oils and biocrudes
10260156 ยท 2019-04-16
Assignee
Inventors
- Michael A. Lilga (Richland, WA)
- Asanga B. Padmaperuma (Richland, WA, US)
- Tedd E. Lister (Idaho Falls, ID, US)
- Eric J. Dufek (Ammon, ID, US)
- Lucia M. Petkovic (Idaho Falls, ID)
- Luis A. Diaz-Aldana (Idaho Falls, ID, US)
Cpc classification
C25B9/65
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Y02E60/36
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
C25B15/08
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
International classification
C25B15/08
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Abstract
A system and process are disclosed for electrochemically upgrading bio-oils and bio-crudes that enhance yields of selected reduction products for subsequent production of bio-based fuels.
Claims
1. A process for electrochemical hydrogenation of a complex bio-oil, the process comprising the steps of: introducing a feed comprising the complex bio-oil into an electrolysis cell having electrodes operatively coupled to a pair of ion-selective membranes arranged in a zero-gap arrangement to define a center compartment between an anode exchange membrane in contact with the feed comprising the complex bio-oil and a cathode exchange membrane in contact with water; and passing a current through the electrolysis cell to obtain protons from the water and short organic acids from the complex bio-oil by converting molecules in the feed to reduced products comprising reduced molecules containing a higher proportion of hydrogen than molecules in the feed while capturing the short organic acids in the center compartment, wherein the complex bio-oil comprises numerous different organic and inorganic compounds including esters, acids, aldehydes, alcohols, ketones, sugars, and phenol derivatives, wherein the electrochemical hydrogenation removes reactive species and upgrades the complex bio-oil so as to make the reduced products suitable for introduction into a transportation fuel processing system, and wherein the electrochemical hydrogenation is conducted without use of a supporting electrolyte or external hydrogen.
2. The process of claim 1, wherein introducing the feed includes flowing the feed continuously into the electrolysis cell.
3. The process of claim 1, wherein the current is varied.
4. The process of claim 1, further including passing the reduced products through a thermal hydrotreating reactor to further increase a proportion of hydrogen in the reduced product.
5. The process of claim 1, further including passing the reduced products to a thermal alcohol dehydration reactor to decrease an oxygen content in the reduced product.
6. The process of claim 1, further including passing the reduced products to a thermal alkylation reactor to increase an average molecular weight of the reduced product.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(11) The present invention includes an electrolysis system, electrolysis cell (electrolyzer), and process for upgrading (hydrotreating) bio-oils obtained from pyrolysis, and biocrudes obtained from hydrothermal liquefaction processing. In the following description, for purposes of brevity, bio-oils and biocrudes will be referred to as bio-oils or oils. In the following description, embodiments of the present invention are shown and described by way of illustration for carrying out the invention. It will be apparent that various modifications, alterations, and substitutions to the present invention may be made. The present invention is intended to cover all modifications, alternative constructions, and equivalents falling within the spirit and scope of the invention defined in the claims. Therefore the description should be seen as illustrative and not limiting.
(12)
(13) Electrolysis System 100 can be operated as a self-pressurized system to limit escape of H.sub.2 gas formed during reduction of protons and water within the cathode chamber, and to provide other advantages for conversion of bio-oils described herein. Pressures attainable in the system are limited only by the materials of construction. Typical operation pressures are from about 100 psi to about 500 psi. Higher pressures may also be used with compatible materials and suitable construction. Pressurized operation increases the concentration of dissolved H.sub.2 in the bio-oil. The increased H.sub.2 concentration shifts the equilibrium for H.sub.2 production and shifts the Nernst potential for the H.sub.2 evolution reaction to more negative potentials, thereby increasing the reduction potential attainable at the cathode.
(14) Electrolysis System 100 reduces reactive oxygenated compounds such as the aldehydes, e.g., as depicted in chemical and electrochemical (EC) reactions [1]-[5], as follows:
EC cathode: 2H.sup.++2e.sup..fwdarw.2H.sub.ads[1]
EC anode: H.sub.2O.fwdarw.O.sub.2+2H.sup.+2e.sup.[2]
Surface reaction: 2H.sub.ads+aldehyde.fwdarw.alcohol[3]
Dehydration: alcohol.fwdarw.olefin+H.sub.2O[4]
Net reaction: aldehyde.fwdarw.olefin+O.sub.2[5]
(15) In net reaction [5], H.sub.2 does not appear in the balanced equation. As an example, aldehydes may be deoxygenated to produce O.sub.2 and an olefin product. Reactions [1]-[5] may employ an adsorbed hydrogen atom (Haas) generated at the cathode surface as a reactive species. However, reactive species may alternately involve other protonated or electrochemically reduced organics. Reactions [1]-[5] may employ an aldehyde, for example, but reactions can also reduce other oxygenates including, for example, ketones and phenolics. In reaction [4], alcohol intermediates can be dehydrated to olefins. Dehydration reactions may be conducted internal to the cell, or in a downstream reactor. The degree to which these ideal equations can be realized depends on reaction efficiencies at the selected electrodes. Self-pressurization with H.sub.2 can increase the ECH reaction versus H.sub.2 formation through equilibrium forces.
(16)
(17) In some embodiments, the cathode and anode are bonded to the membrane. In other embodiments, the electrodes are physically pressed against the membrane.
(18) In yet other embodiments, the electrodes are physically separated from the membrane. Electrodes described herein may be comprised of, or include, various selected materials and compositions including, but not limited to, for example, metals, carbons, various metals on carbon supports, various metal oxides on carbon supports or metal supports, various conductive composite materials, and combinations of these various materials as will be understood by those of ordinary skill in the electrochemical arts. No limitations are intended.
(19) In the figure, chemical reactions and the flow path of protons are shown at each electrode. The CEM binds negative functional groups, allowing protons to pass.
(20) In the present invention, electrolysis in the single membrane cell includes applying a potential to the electrodes that is sufficiently high to cause electrons to flow to, or from, molecules present in the electrolyzer. In operation, a sufficiently high potential during electrolysis may be attained by controlling either the applied potential or the applied current that flows through the electrolyzer. Ideally, electrons flow to molecules of the bio-oil in preference to water or acid.
(21) In other embodiments, potentials and currents delivered to the electrolyzer may be steady, ramped, or pulsed.
(22) In the exemplary embodiment, the cathode half-cell reaction provides reduction of bio-oil molecules and the anode half-cell reaction provides oxidation of water, but the invention is not limited thereto. For example, in other embodiments, the anode reaction may provide other oxidation reactions including, for example, oxidation of H.sub.2 such as that formed in excess at the cathode; oxidation of organics, for example, for wastewater treatment; oxidation that forms products such as ketones, or oxidation of chloride to chlorine gas. No limitations are intended.
(23)
(24) In the dual membrane configuration, electrical charge injected into the bio oil from the cathode is compensated for by movement of anions from the bio-oil [including, e.g., short organic acids such as acetic acid or chloride (Cl.sup.)] through the AEM into the concentrate stream between the two membranes. Protons generated at the anode, for example, during oxidation of water to O.sub.2, move through the CEM into the concentrate stream. The overall result of anion and proton movement results in collection of acids in the concentrate stream. Protons in the bio-oil may be consumed by generation of H.sub.2 and ECH of organics, which increases pH and decreases corrosivity of the bio-oil. Water and small organic molecules in the bio-oil can migrate in the direction of the flow of charge due to electro-osmotic drag. With proper selection of such characteristics as AEM pore size and/or other properties, the AEM can effectively separate short-chain organics, Cl.sup., and water from the bio-oil. Organic acids collected in the concentrate stream may be processed for selected commodity uses or sent to a reformer (not shown) should H.sub.2 be needed for downstream processing.
(25)
(26) Electrodes used in single and dual membrane cells described herein may be purchased commercially (e.g., Giner, Inc., Newton, Mass., USA), or may be constructed using methods known in the art. For example, for the dual membrane cell, an anode can be prepared as a sintered titanium (Ti) metal film with a platinum (Pt) coating formed by electroplating. The anode may then be hot pressed onto a CEM. A representative CEM may be a NAFION-117 sheet (Dupont, Wilmington, Del., USA). The cathode may be installed onto an AEM sheet by applying a catalyst mixture comprising 20% palladium (Pd) metal on a carbon support in a 5% NAFION ionomer solution (Dupont, Wilmington, Del., USA) diluted in methanol. The catalyst mixture and cathode metal may be attached to the AEM by hot pressing. A representative AEM may be a material such as EXCELLION (SnowPure, San Clemente, Calif., USA). Construction details and composition variations, including different metal catalysts, are known in the art and are not meant to be limiting.
(27) The present invention provides electrochemical hydrogenation processing of raw bio-oils for the first time. The electrochemical system includes a cell configuration with electrodes physically attached to a pair of membranes in an electrodialysis configuration. The system configuration eliminates need for addition of supporting electrolytes to the bio-oil, which minimizes the applied potential. In addition, the cell may be self-pressurized using H.sub.2 generated within the cell to enhance hydrogenation. Membranes in the electrochemical cell separate acids and water and reduce total acid number of bio oils. The configuration allows collection of acids for use as commodity chemicals or for reforming if downstream H.sub.2 is needed. Eliminating water from the bio-oil reduces transportation costs and improves the efficiency of downstream processes.
(28) The ECH process of the present invention also reduces acidity of the bio-oil through proton reduction and dialysis separation. For example, reduction in acidity can be expected to improve bio-oil stability and allow transportation of the treated bio-oil to centralized or other processing facilities. In addition, removal of small acids and other small molecules by dialysis prevents them from being sent to a downstream hydrotreater. Hydrogenation of small molecules in conventional processing wastes valuable H.sub.2 and generates light gases that need to be separated, collected, or flared.
(29) Results show the electrochemical process of the present invention also allows hydrotreating of bio-oils (with a reduction in phenolics and carbonyls in the bio-oil) to be conducted at lower temperatures (40 C. to about 80 C.) and at pressures less than about 300 psi (2.110.sup.3 kPa) than required for conventional thermal catalytic reduction approaches (i.e., 140 C. to 425 C. and pressures of between 1200 psi (8.310.sup.3 kPa) to 2000 psi (1.410.sup.4 kPa), and multiple stages of reduction to hydrotreat bio-oils without coke formation.
(30) Systems and processes of the present invention may change currently accepted flowsheets for upgrading bio-oil. For example, ECH reduction of phenolics and carbonyls in bio-oil at these moderate conditions has the potential to completely change currently accepted staged thermal catalytic approaches. For example, the extent of reduction of phenols was unexpected. A reduction in phenolics of about 50% was observed by product analyses. However, more extensive reduction can be expected with variations to the system such as using multiple electrolyzers in series and parallel, increasing contact time between the bio-oil and the electrode, and improving hydrodynamics within the electrolyzer to ensure good mixing and contact with the electrode. Phenols are difficult to reduce thermally in conventional processing.
(31) ECH of the present invention may also eliminate need for one or more hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) stages, may eliminate corresponding catalyst costs, and may therefore reduce overall capital expenditures. In cases where ECH-treated bio-oils require further thermal hydrotreating, the ECH-treated bio-oil and pressurized H.sub.2 exiting the electrochemical cells may be fed to an external reactor where thermal catalytic hydrotreating may be conducted. Thus, the present invention can employ electrochemically generated H.sub.2 in the process thereby minimizing need for H.sub.2 from external supplied sources including, e.g., H.sub.2 from natural gas reforming.
(32) ECH-treated bio-oils exiting the electrochemical cells may also be fed to other thermal reactors where other conversions may be carried out. For example, feeding ECH-treated bio-oils to an alkylation reactor may increase the average molecular weight of the reduced product, thereby increasing the fraction of the oil in the distillate range, for example by reacting alcohols with phenolics. As another example, feeding ECH-treated bio-oils to an alcohol dehydration reactor may deoxygenate the oil by removal of water to form olefins. Any or all of the external hydrotreating, alkylation, and dehydration reactors may be used in any order.
(33) The following Examples provide a further understanding of the present invention.
Example 1
Electrochemical Hydrogenation
(34) 10 mL of bio-oil was added to the cathode chamber. 20 mL of purified water was added to the anode chamber. A direct current (DC) power supply delivered a constant current to the electrolyzer. The pressure increased gradually in the cathode chamber as H.sub.2 was generated (i.e., self-pressurized). The anode chamber containing water was maintained approximately 15 psi above the cathode pressure using both self-generated O.sub.2 and argon gas supplied from an external argon gas supply. A potential versus time curve during a 6 hour reaction at 0.95 amps (i.e., 0.95 A) shows a very flat profile indicating stable operation observed in all runs. TABLE 1 lists experimental conditions from several experiments performed to test electrochemical hydrogenation of bio-oil. Experimental conditions including the cathode catalyst, current density, time, and temperature were varied. Values for maximum pressure are those recorded at the end of the experiments given that pressure was allowed to increase over the course of the experiments from generated H.sub.2.
(35) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Max Current Time Temp Pressure Run # Run Date Electrode (A) (hours) ( C.) (psi) Run # 1 Oct. 15, 2014 - C Au 0.95 2 23.5 C. 192 Run # 2 Oct. 21, 2014 - C Au 0.95 2 48.4-40.8 155 Run # 3 Oct. 23, 2014 - C Au 0.95 2 78.3-57.7 126 Run # 4 Oct. 24, 2014 - C Au 0.475 4 43.2-40.1 119 Run # 4 Oct. 29, 2014 - C Au 0.2375 8 39.6-40.8 90 Run # 5 Nov. 18, 2014-C Pd 0.95 2 39.3-40.7 159 Run # 6 Nov. 19, 2014-C Pd 0.95 2 22.2-24.2 171 Run # 7 Nov. 20, 2014-C Pd 0.475 4 23.5-24.0 131 Run # 8 Nov. 21, 2014-C Pd 0.475 4 40.3-39.9 106 Run # 9 Dec. 10, 2014-C Pd 0.95 2 59.6-60.3 77 Run # 10 Dec. 17, 2014-C Pd 0.2375 8 60.8-59.0 125 Run # 11 Dec. 19, 2014-C Pd 0.95 2 60.6-60.0 162 Run # 12 Jan. 12, 2015-C Pd 0.95 6 39.6-40.9 213 Run # 13 Jan. 14, 2015-C Pd 0.95 6 39.6-41.0 322
Example 2
Separation
(36) Experiments were performed with a dual membrane cell (see
(37)
Example 3
Product Analysis
(38) Bio-oil samples electrochemically treated in the single-membrane cell (
(39) TABLE-US-00002 % Carbon, by .sup.13C NMR Total Ether + Carbonyl Carboxyl Phenolic Aromatic Alcohols Ether Aliphatic Alcohol sp.sup.2 sp.sup.3 sp.sup.2/ Run # (220-200) (185-170) (170-142) (142-95) (95-62) (62-45) (35-0) (95-45) (170-95) (95-0) sp.sup.3 FP-Feed 6.49 5.69 13.78 30.32 21.66 4.55 17.51 26.21 44.10 43.72 1.01 Run # 2 5.46 6.44 6.79 12.38 19.31 22.11 27.50 41.42 19.17 68.92 0.28 Run # 3 5.54 7.61 10.35 12.56 17.65 16.70 29.59 34.35 22.91 63.94 0.36 Run # 4 6.94 6.31 7.71 12.43 20.14 19.97 26.50 40.11 20.14 66.61 0.30 Run # 5 4.05 4.62 5.59 10.89 19.95 21.97 32.94 41.92 16.48 74.86 0.22 Run # 6 6.58 7.62 4.63 14.47 26.96 17.87 21.87 44.83 19.10 66.70 0.29 Run # 7 3.80 5.32 6.57 18.75 24.10 14.09 27.37 38.19 25.32 65.56 0.39 Run # 8 4.06 4.84 6.65 11.51 23.20 19.32 30.42 42.52 18.16 72.94 0.25 Run # 9 5.62 4.94 7.87 13.27 21.86 16.24 30.21 38.10 21.14 68.31 0.31 Run # 10 2.95 6.40 4.56 8.82 26.36 18.39 32.52 44.75 13.38 77.27 0.17 Run # 11 2.36 4.86 4.00 7.20 23.42 24.70 33.46 48.12 11.20 81.58 0.14 Run # 12 4.35 7.37 4.65 8.75 30.94 15.43 28.50 46.37 13.40 74.87 0.18 Run # 13 2.84 5.67 3.02 6.99 18.27 26.97 36.24 45.24 10.01 81.48 0.12 Run # 14 2.63 4.78 3.22 7.40 19.28 26.22 36.46 45.50 10.62 81.96 0.13
(40) TABLE 3 lists results from other analyses. Data are shown graphically in
(41) TABLE-US-00003 H/C O/C KF (% UV at [CO].sup.# elemental elemental Run # water) 265 nm.sup.# CAN.sup.# TAN.sup.# PhAN.sup.# (mmol/g) C.sup.# H.sup.# N.sup.# O.sup.# ratio ratio FP-Feed 26.01 0.757 82.6 209.5 126.9 4.7 62.03 7.26 0.07 30.65 1.39 0.42 Run # 2 54.15 0.356 80.7 145.5 64.8 3.6 59.46 11.38 0.12 29.04 2.28 0.42 Run # 3 51.24 0.412 89.6 157.9 68.3 3.9 58.49 11.30 0.11 30.10 2.30 0.44 Run # 4 48.11 0.353 74.7 139.3 64.6 4.3 56.86 10.59 0.10 32.45 2.22 0.49 Run # 5 50.39 0.330 71.9 128.8 56.9 4.5 56.75 11.63 0.11 31.51 2.44 0.48 Run # 6 49.85 0.337 95.1 165.1 70.0 5.0 60.06 11.54 0.11 28.29 2.29 0.40 Run # 7 45.91 0.357 85.4 157.1 71.7 4.8 57.76 10.75 0.10 31.39 2.22 0.47 Run # 8 43.69 0.391 73.0 137.6 64.7 4.1 57.12 10.44 0.09 32.35 2.18 0.49 Run # 9 41.66 0.432 74.9 154.5 79.6 4.2 59.50 9.72 0.09 30.69 1.95 0.44 Run # 10 45.10 0.416 79.4 154.7 75.3 Run # 11 49.47 0.362 69.2 143.1 73.8 Run # 12 51.51 0.387 91.1 163.4 72.3 Run # 13 54.92 0.395 71.9 143.9 72.0 Run # 14 53.80 0.379 69.7 137.7 68.0 .sup.#corrected to dry weight
(42) Data indicate that phenolic groups in the bio-oil were electrochemically reduced. For example: a) the C/H ratio increases to a value of about 2. The increase is attributed to aromatic ring reduction; b) integration of .sup.13C NMR spectra shows that aromatic carbons decrease, aliphatic carbons increase, alcohol and ether carbons increase, and the aromatic-to-aliphatic ratio decreases substantially; c) acidity from phenol groups decreases as determined with the phenolic acid number (PhAN); d) UV-VIS spectra show that the absorbance at 265 nm (associated with phenol groups) decreases (see
Example 4
Alternate Anode Reaction
(43) EXAMPLE 4 demonstrates an alternate anode reaction in the electrochemical system other than water oxidation for treatment of bio-oil at near ambient pressure. In particular, gases produced in the cathode chamber including, for example, H.sub.2 and water vapor are fed to the anode chamber where H.sub.2 is oxidized to protons. The PEM electrolyzer of
(44) While exemplary embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that many changes and modifications may be made without departing from the invention in its true scope and broader aspects. The appended claims are therefore intended to cover all such changes and modifications as fall within the scope of the present invention.