Method for detecting damage of wind turbine blade and wind turbine
10167853 ยท 2019-01-01
Assignee
Inventors
- Kazunari Ide (Tokyo, JP)
- Katsuhiko Takita (Tokyo, JP)
- Takao Kuroiwa (Tokyo, JP)
- Mitsuya Baba (Tokyo, JP)
- Hiroshi Nishino (Tokyo, JP)
- Takuya Koyanagi (Tokyo, JP)
Cpc classification
F03D17/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05B2270/326
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05B2270/804
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
G01M11/085
PHYSICS
F05B2270/803
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Y02E10/72
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
Abstract
A method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade of a wind turbine rotor having at least one wind turbine blade comprises: a light incident step of allowing light to enter an optical fiber sensor being mounted on each of the wind turbine blade and having a diffraction grating part having a refractive index which is periodically varied in a longitudinal direction of the diffraction grating part; a light detection step of detecting reflected light from the diffraction grating part; an obtaining step of obtaining, from a temporal change of a wavelength of the reflected light received in the light receiving step, a wavelength variation index representing a variation amount of the wavelength; and a damage determination step of determining presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade on the basis of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step.
Claims
1. A method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade of a wind turbine rotor having at least one wind turbine blade, comprising: a light incident step of allowing light to enter an optical fiber sensor being attached to each wind turbine blade and including a diffraction grating having a refractive index which is repetitively varied in a longitudinal direction of the diffraction grating; a light detection step of detecting reflected light from the diffraction grating; an obtaining step of obtaining, from a periodic temporal change of a wavelength of the reflected light received in the light detection step due to rotation of the wind turbine rotor, a wavelength variation index representing a temporal variation component of the wavelength in the periodic temporal change; and a damage determination step of determining presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade on the basis of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step, wherein the wavelength variation index is a difference between a local maximum of the wavelength and a local minimum of the wavelength appearing in each rotation period of the wind turbine rotor.
2. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, wherein in the obtaining step, after a first extremal value that is one of the local maximum value or the local minimum value appears, determination of a second extremal value which is next to the first extremal value is suspended from a time point until an end of a time period t which satisfies a relation of 0.1 Tt0.5 T where T is the rotation period of the wind turbine rotor.
3. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, wherein in the obtaining step, a standard deviation of the wavelength within a time period of a prescribed length is calculated as the wavelength variation index.
4. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, wherein in the damage determination step, presence of the damage of the wind turbine blade is determined if a magnitude or change rate of the wavelength variation index falls outside a prescribed range.
5. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, further comprising: a time average calculation step of calculating an average of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step within a time period of not less than a rotation period of the wind turbine rotor, wherein in the damage determination step, presence of the damage of the wind turbine blade is determined on the basis of the average calculated in the time average calculation step.
6. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 5, further comprising: a data validity determination step of determining whether the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step is a valid data or an invalid data, wherein in the data validity determination step, the wavelength variation index is determined as an invalid data if a value of the wavelength represents an abnormality of the optical fiber sensor or if the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step is obtained from a difference between a local maximum of the wavelength and a local minimum greater than the local maximum, and wherein in the time average calculation step, the average is calculated by using only the wavelength variation index determined as a valid data in the data validity determination step.
7. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, wherein in the damage determination step, the damage of the wind turbine is determined by using, among the wavelength, only the wavelength obtained when a wind velocity falls within a prescribed range of wind velocity.
8. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 1, wherein the wind turbine rotor has a plurality of wind turbine blades, wherein the method further comprises a difference calculation step of calculating a difference between the wavelength variation index of a detection target wind turbine blade among the plurality of the wind turbine blades and a reference value which reflects the wavelength variation index of at least one comparison target wind turbine blade among the other wind turbine blades, and wherein in the damage determination step, a damage of the detection target wind turbine blade is determined on the basis of a temporal change in the difference calculated in the difference calculation step.
9. The method for detecting damage of a wind turbine blade according to claim 8, wherein the wind turbine rotor has at least three wind turbine blades, wherein the difference as to each of the wind turbine blades is calculated by repeating the difference calculation step by regarding the each of the wind turbine blades as the detection target wind turbine blade, and wherein in the damage determination step, which wind turbine blade has the damage is determined on the basis of the difference as to each of the wind turbine blades.
10. A wind turbine comprising: a wind turbine rotor having at least one wind turbine blade; an optical fiber sensor being attached to each wind turbine blade and including a diffraction grating having a refractive index which is repetitively varied in a longitudinal direction of the diffraction grating; a light source/signal processing unit connected to the optical fiber sensor and including: a light source for generating light which is input into the optical fiber sensor; and a light detector for detecting reflected light from the diffraction grating; and an index calculator for calculating, from a periodic temporal change of a wavelength of the reflected light detected by the light detector due to rotation of the wind turbine rotor, a difference between a local maximum of the wavelength and a local minimum of the wavelength appearing in each rotation period of the wind turbine rotor as a wavelength variation index representing a temporal variation component of the wavelength in the periodic temporal change, the wavelength variation index being used for determination of presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade.
11. The wind turbine according to claim 10, wherein the index calculator is configured to calculate, as the wavelength variation index, a standard deviation of the wavelength within a time period of a prescribed length.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(10) Embodiments of the present invention will now be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings. It is intended, however, that unless particularly specified, dimensions, materials, shapes, relative positions and the like of components described in the embodiments shall be interpreted as illustrative only and not limitative of the scope of the present invention.
(11) First, a configuration of a wind turbine having a wind turbine blade which is to be subjected to the detection of damage in an embodiment, will be described.
(12) In some embodiments, the wind turbine 1 may be a part of a wind turbine power generator. In this case, it may be that the nacelle 4 accommodates a generator (not shown) and a power transmitting mechanism (not shown) for transmitting rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5 to the generator. The wind turbine power generator is configured so that a rotation energy transmitted from the wind turbine rotor 5 via the power transmitting mechanism to the generator is converted into electric energy by the generator.
(13)
(14) As illustrated in
(15) The optical fiber sensor 12 has a diffraction grating part having a refractive index which is periodically varied in the longitudinal direction of the diffraction grating part.
(16) When a light having a broadband spectrum enters into the optical fiber sensor 12, interference occurs at reflection at the diffraction grating part having a periodically varied refractive index such that the intensity is increased only for a specific wavelength depending upon the grating interval (grating period). For this reason, the optical fiber sensor 12 reflects only a specific wavelength component and let the other wavelengths transmit.
(17) If a strain applied to the optical fiber sensor 12 or the surrounding temperature changes, the refractive index or the grating interval of the diffraction grating part changes, and corresponding to such a change, the wavelength of the reflected light changes. The wavelength o of the reflected light is approximately represented by the following formula (A):
.sub.o.sub.i=(.sub.z+.Math.T)/p(A)
wherein .sub.z represents a strain of the optical fiber, .sub.o represents a wavelength of reflected light, .sub.i represents an initial wavelength, represents a temperature coefficient, and T represents a difference between a temperature of the optical fiber and a reference temperature (i.e. change in temperature), and p represents a wavelength-strain conversion factor. The temperature coefficient is the sum of the thermal expansion coefficient and the thermo-optical coefficient n (i.e. =+n). represents a change of the grating period due to temperature change, and an represents the change of the refractive index due to temperature change.
(18) In this manner, the difference between the wavelength .sub.o of the reflected light in the optical fiber sensor 12 and the initial wavelength .sub.i can be influenced by the strain .sub.z of the optical fiber sensor 12 or the temperature T. Therefore, if the initial wavelength .sub.i is a prescribed value, ithe strain caused in the optical fiber sensor 12 or the temperature of the optical fiber can be determined by measuring the wavelength .sub.o of the reflected light.
(19) In an embodiment, the optical fiber sensor 12 is a FBG (Fiber Bragg Grating) sensor.
(20) On the blade root part 3a of each of the wind turbine blades 3, four optical fiber sensors 12 (12A-12D) are mounted. As illustrated in
(21) Further, these four optical fiber sensors 12A, 12B, 12C and 12D are connected in series in this order by an optical fiber cable 16. The optical fiber cable 16 has connectors (13, 15) provided on the both end parts, and an optical fiber cable 14 for connecting the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D and the light source/signal processing unit 10 and the optical fiber cable 16 connecting the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D in series are connected via the connector 13 or the connector 15.
(22) In the embodiment shown in
(23) In the above description, an example where the optical fiber sensor 12 is mounted on the blade root part 3a of the wind turbine blade 3 is described. However, the place where the optical fiber sensor 12 is mounted in the wind turbine blade 3 is not limited to the blade root part 3a. For example, the optical fiber sensor 12 may be mounted on the tip part 3b (see
(24) The optical fiber sensors 12 may be mounted on each of the blade root part 3a and the tip part 3b of the wind turbine blade 3.
(25) In an embodiment, the light source/signal processing unit 10 including the light incident part 17 and the light detection part 18 is placed inside the hub 2.
(26) The light incident part 17 is configured to allow light enter into the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D. The light incident part 17 has, for example, a light source capable of emitting light having a broad range of spectrum.
(27) The light detection part 18 is configured to detect the reflected light from the diffraction grating part of each of the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D.
(28) The light of a broadband emitted from the light incident part 17 propagates in the optical fiber cables (14, 16) and enters into the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D. In each of the optical fiber sensor 12A-12D, only a light having a specific wavelength corresponding to the strain and the temperature of each of the diffraction grating part is reflected at the diffraction grating part. The reflected light having reflected at the diffraction grating part propagates in the optical fiber cables (16, 14) and then is detected by the light detection part 18.
(29) The optical fiber sensors 12A-12D are connected in series, and thus respective distances from the light incident part 17 to the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D, and respective distances from the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D to the light detection part 18, are different from one another. Thus, it is possible for the light detection part 18 to determine which optical fiber sensor 12 the detected light comes from on the basis of the elapsed time from emitting of the light by the light incident part 17 until detection of the reflected light from each of the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D by the light detection part 18A.
(30) The wind turbine 1 comprises a damage determination part 100 for determining a damage of the wind turbine blade 3. The damage determination part 100 is configured to obtain, from a temporal change of the wavelength of the reflected light detected by the light detection part 18, a wavelength variation index representing the variation amount of the wavelength, and to determine presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade on the basis of the wavelength variation index. That is, the damage determination part 100 is configured to detect a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 according to the method of the damage detection method as described below.
(31) The damage of the wind turbine blade 3 may be a crack caused in the wind turbine blade 3, for example. If damage such as a crack is caused and undergoes progression in the wind turbine blade 3, an accident such as breakage of the wind turbine blade 3 may occur. Then, by appropriately performing damage detection of the wind turbine blade 3, it is possible to determine an appropriate timing of maintenance of the wind turbine blade 3, for example, thereby to perform operation of the wind turbine 1 safely.
(32) Then, a method for detecting damage of the wind turbine blade 3 of the wind turbine 1 having the above described configuration, will be described.
(33)
(34) In some embodiments, a time average of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step (S6) is calculated (S10: time average calculation step), and in the determination step (S12), damage of the wind turbine blades 3 is determined on the basis of the average value calculated in the time average calculation step.
(35) In a method for detecting damage of the wind turbine blade 3 according to some embodiments, validity of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step (S6) is determined (S8: data validity determination step), and in the time average calculation step (S10), the average of the wavelength variation index is calculated using only the wavelength variation index determined as valid in the data validity determination step (S8).
(36) These steps S2 to S12 will be now described.
(37)
(38) As indicated in the graph of
(39) As the azimuth angle of the wind turbine blade 3 changes in accordance with the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5, the altitude of the wind turbine blade 3 also changes. Further, in general, the wind velocity becomes higher as the altitude becomes higher. Thus, during operation of the wind turbine 1, since wind load acting on the wind turbine blade 3 varies periodically depending upon the wind velocity in accordance with the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5, the strain in the wind turbine blade 3 also changes periodically, and the wavelength of the reflected light in the optical fiber sensor, which represents the strain in the wind turbine blade 3, also changes periodically. Accordingly, as described above, the local maximums .sub.Tn and the local minimums .sub.Bn appear repeatedly alternately in accordance with the rotation period of the wind turbine rotor 5. Further, the local maximums .sub.Tn and the local minimums .sub.Bn of the wavelength of the reflected wave in accordance with the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5 appear every time period of about T/2 where T is the rotation period of the wind turbine rotor 5.
(40) That is, since usually, the wind load acting on the wind turbine blade 3 is the largest when the wind turbine blade 3 is at the uppermost part, the wavelength of the reflected light becomes a local maximum .sub.Tn at that time. Further, since usually, the wind load acting on the wind turbine blade 3 is the smallest when the wind turbine blade 3 is at the lowermost part, the wavelength of the reflected light becomes a local minimum .sub.Tn at that time.
(41) An azimuth angle is an angle between a prescribed reference direction and the axis line of the wind turbine blade 3 on the plan of rotation of the wind turbine blade 3. In this specification, the reference direction is the direction of the axis line of the wind turbine blade 3 when the wind turbine blade 3 is at the uppermost position. In this case, the azimuth angle when the wind turbine blade 3 is at the uppermost position of the wind turbine 1 is 0 degree, and the azimuth angle when the wind turbine blade 3 is lowermost position of the wind turbine 1 is 180 degrees. For reference,
(42) In an embodiment, in the obtaining step (S6), the difference between a local maximum and a local minimum which are next to each other in the temporal change of the reflected light is calculated as the wavelength variation index.
(43) In
(44) The difference A.sub.n between a local maximum and a local minimum as obtained in such a manner represents a magnitude of the variation of the wavelength of the reflected light within the time period between a time when the wavelength of the reflected light becomes a local maximum and a time when the wavelength of the reflected light becomes a local minimum. By determining presence or absence of damage of the wind turbine blade on the basis of the wavelength variation index A.sub.n representing the variation of the wavelength, it is possible to substantially eliminate influence due to temperature change on the measurement value (i.e. the measurement value of the strain) of the wavelength of the reflected wave by the optical fiber sensor. It is thereby possible to detect damage with a good accuracy even under an environment where temperature changes.
(45) In the temporal change of the reflected light, besides the local maximums .sub.Tn and the local minimums .sub.Bn according to the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5, another local peak (local maximum or local minimum) may appear due to temporal variation in the wind velocity, for example. Thus, in order to appropriately recognize the local maximums .sub.Tn and the local minimums .sub.Bn according to the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5 from the temporal change in the wavelength of the reflected light obtained by the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D, it is desirable to eliminate such a local peak.
(46) Thus, it may be that in the obtaining step (S6), determination of a second extremal value which is next to a first extremal value (e.g. .sub.T1) is suspended from a time point t.sub.0 when the first extremal value (.sub.T1) appears until an end of a time period t which satisfies a relation of 0.1 Tt0.5 T where T is a rotation period of the wind turbine rotor.
(47) By suspending determination of the second extremal value (a local minimum or local maximum) which is next to the first extremal value during a time period of a length of T/2, where a local maximum .sub.Tn and a local minimum .sub.Bn, according to the rotation of the wind turbine rotor 5 appear, from the time point t.sub.0 when the first extremal value (a local maximum or local minimum) appears until the end of a prescribed length of time period t which satisfies a relation of 0.1 Tt0.5 T, it is possible to more appropriately calculate the wavelength variation index, having eliminated a local peak (local maximum or local minimum) appearing within the period t.
(48) In an embodiment, in the obtaining step (S6), a standard deviation of the wavelength of the reflected light within a time period T.sub.SD of a prescribed length is calculated as the wavelength variation index. The standard deviation of the wavelength of the reflected light with the period T.sub.SD can be calculated by the following formula (D):
(49)
wherein in the above formula (D), .sub.o is the wavelength of the reflected light, N is the number of data of .sub.o within the time period T.sub.SD, m, represented by the following formula (E), is the average of .sub.o over the period T.sub.SD:
(50)
(51) The standard deviation of the wavelength of the reflected light in the optical fiber sensor 12 within the time period T.sub.SD of a prescribed length represents the magnitude of variation of the wavelength of the reflected light within the term T.sub.SD. Accordingly, damage of the wind turbine blade 3 can be detected by using the standard deviation of the wavelength of the reflected light in the optical fiber sensor 12 within the time period T.sub.SD as the wavelength variation index.
(52) The length of the time period T.sub.SD of a prescribed length for calculating the standard deviation is not particularly limited.
(53) In the data validity determination step (S8), whether the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step (S6) is a valid data or an invalid data, is determined
(54) By calculating the average of the wavelength variation index in the time average calculation step (S10), which will be described later, using only the wavelength variation index determined as a valid data suitable as the wavelength variation index in this data validity determination step, it is possible to detect damage of the wind turbine blade 3 more appropriately.
(55) In the data validity determination step (S8), it may be that a wavelength variation index calculated by using a wavelength value of reflected light indicating abnormality of the optical fiber sensor (i.e. a wavelength variation index calculated abnormally), is determined as an invalid data.
(56) It may be that a wavelength variation index determined as not being an invalid data is determined as a valid data.
(57) By calculating the average in the a time average calculation step (S10) by using only the wavelength variation index determined as the valid data calculated normally, it is possible to detect damage of the wind turbine blade 3 more appropriately.
(58) An example of the wavelength variation index calculated by using a wavelength value of the reflected light indicating abnormality of the optical fiber sensor includes, for example, a wavelength variation index calculated when the data of wavelength of the reflected light detected by the light detection part 18 is not updated for at least a prescribed length of time due to e.g. failure of the optical fiber cable 14 (i.e. in the case of wavelength fixation). Another example may be a wavelength variation index calculated e.g. when the wavelength value of the reflected light detected by the light detection part 18 falls outside the wavelength range which is intrinsically measurable by the light detection part 18.
(59) In the time average calculation step (S10), an average of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step (S6) within a time period T.sub.AVE of not less than a rotation period T of the wind turbine rotor, is calculate.
(60) In order to evaluate a damage of the wind turbine blade 3, it is usually necessary to monitor the wind turbine blade 3 over a long period of time of e.g. weeks or months. By calculating the average of the wavelength variation index within the time period T.sub.AVE of a length depending on the purpose, it is possible to appropriately detect a damage of the wind turbine blade 3.
(61) The time period T.sub.AVE for calculating the average of the wavelength variation index is not particularly limited, and it may be 10 minutes, for example.
(62) In the time average calculation step (S10), the average may be calculated by using only the wavelength variation index determined as a valid data in the data validity determination step (S8).
(63) In the damage determination step (S12), presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 is determined on the basis of the wavelength variation index calculated in the obtaining step (S8). By determining presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 on the basis of the wavelength variation index representing the variation of the wavelength, it is possible to substantially eliminate an influence due to temperature change on the measurement value (i.e. the measurement value of the strain) of the wavelength of the reflected light by the optical fiber sensors 12A-12D. Accordingly, it is possible to detect a damage with a good accuracy even under an environment where temperature changes.
(64) In the damage determination step (S12), it may be that presence of a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 is determined if a magnitude or change rate of the wavelength variation index falls outside a prescribed range.
(65) In the damage determination step (S12), it may be that a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 is determined by using, among the wavelength, only the wavelength obtained when a wind velocity falls within a prescribed range of wind velocity.
(66) By determining a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 using only the wavelength of the reflected light detected when the wind velocity falls within a prescribed range of wind velocity and the wavelength variation index based on such a wavelength, it is possible to reduce the influence of the variation according to the wind velocity of the wavelength of the reflected light and the wavelength variation index and thereby to detect a damage of the wind turbine blade more appropriately.
(67) In an embodiment, the prescribed range of wind velocity is a range of from 10 to 13 m/s.
(68)
(69) Specifically, the graph shows a temporal change of the wavelength variation index in a case where the steps S2 to S12 as shown in
(70) In the graph of
(71) In
(72) As indicated by
(73) From this result, by preliminarily setting a threshold value so that presence of damage in the wind turbine blade 3 is determined if the standard deviation of the wavelength variation index falls below 0.1, for example, it can be determined that a damage is caused in the 2nd blade in the eighteenth unit time.
(74)
(75) In this damage detection method, the wavelength variation index is obtained in the above-described obtaining step (S6), and via the data validity determination step (S8), the average of the wavelength variation index is calculated in the time average calculation step (S10). Then the difference in the wavelength variation index between the wind turbine blades in the difference calculation step (S14), and in the determination step (S16), a damage of the wind turbine blade 3 is determined on the basis of the difference calculated in the difference calculation step (S14).
(76) In an embodiment, in the difference calculation step (S14), a difference between the wavelength variation index (or the time average thereof) of one detection target wind turbine blade among the three wind turbine blades and a reference value which reflects the wavelength variation index (or the time average thereof) of one comparison target wind turbine blade among the other wind turbine blades, is calculated.
(77) As the above reference value, the wavelength variation index (or the time average thereof) of one comparison target wind turbine blade among the other wind turbine blades 3 can be used. Or as the above reference value, an average of the wavelength variation index (or the time average thereof) of two or more comparison target wind turbine blades among the other wind turbine blades 3, or an average of the wavelength variation indices (or the time averages thereof) of two or more comparison target wind turbine blades among the other wind turbine blades 3 and one detection target wind turbine blade.
(78) For example, in the difference calculation step (S14), in the wind turbine 1 having three wind turbine blades 3 comprising a 1st blade, a 2nd blade and a 3rd blade, a wavelength variation index I.sub.1 of the 1st blade as the detection target wind turbine blade is calculated, and a wavelength variation index I.sub.2 of the 2nd blade as the comparison target wind turbine blade is calculated. Then, the difference between these wavelength variation indices i.e. I.sub.1-I.sub.2 is calculated. In the same manner, the difference I.sub.2-I.sub.3 between the wavelength variation indices of the 2nd blade as the detection target wind turbine blade and the 3rd blade as the comparison target wind turbine blade is calculated, and the difference I.sub.3-I.sub.1 between the wavelength variation indices of the 3rd blade as the detection target wind turbine blade and the 1st blade as the comparison target wind turbine blade is calculated. In the damage determination step (S16), presence or absence of a damage of the wind turbine blades 3 is determined on the basis of the differences in wavelength variation index, i.e. I.sub.1-I.sub.2, I.sub.1-I.sub.2, and I.sub.1-I.sub.2, calculated in the difference calculation step (S14) as described above, and which wind turbine blade 3 has a damage is also determined on the basis of such differences in wavelength variation index, i.e. I.sub.1-I.sub.2, I.sub.1-I.sub.2.
(79) Shown in each of
(80) In the graph of
(81) In contrast, in the graph of
(82) Further, by preliminarily setting a threshold for the difference of the wavelength variation index (or the average thereof), it is possible to detect a damage from the temporal change of the difference and to specify the wind turbine blade 3 in which a damage is caused. For example, in the example as shown in
(83) Embodiments of the present invention were described in detail above, but the present invention is not limited thereto, and various amendments and modifications may be implemented within a scope that does not depart from the present invention.
(84) In this specification, an expression of relative or absolute arrangement such as in a direction, along a direction, parallel, orthogonal, centered, concentric and coaxial shall not be construed as indicating only the arrangement in a strict literal sense, but also includes a state where the arrangement is relatively displaced by a tolerance, or by an angle or a distance whereby it is possible to achieve the same function.
(85) For instance, an expression of an equal state such as same equal and uniform shall not be construed as indicating only the state in which the feature is strictly equal, but also includes a state in which there is a tolerance or a difference that can still achieve the same function.
(86) For instance, an expression of a shape such as a rectangular shape or a cylindrical shape shall not be construed as only the geometrically strict shape, but also includes a shape with unevenness or chamfered corners within the range in which the same effect can be achieved.
(87) On the other hand, an expression such as comprise, include, have, contain and constitute are not intended to be exclusive of other components.