Load measuring method, load measuring device and load measuring arrangement
11585708 · 2023-02-21
Assignee
Inventors
- Christoph Schanz (Frickenhausen, DE)
- Philipp Cörlin (Stuttgart, DE)
- Tobias Ettenauer (Stuttgart, DE)
- Tobias Senkbeil (Heidenheim, DE)
- Dieter Zeisel (Forch, CH)
Cpc classification
G01L1/12
PHYSICS
G01L9/16
PHYSICS
International classification
G01L1/12
PHYSICS
G01L5/22
PHYSICS
G01L25/00
PHYSICS
Abstract
To improve the output signal quality of a load measurement by means of active magnetization, the invention provides a load measurement method for measuring a mechanical load on a test object (14), comprising: a) generating and applying a magnetic field to the test object (14); b) detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) by means of a first magnetic field detection device (20) to generate a first measurement signal (U1, UAB), c) detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) by means of a second magnetic field detection device (22) to generate a second measurement signal (U1, UAB), d) computationally determining a third measurement signal (UBT) from the first measurement signal (U1, UAB) and the second measurement signal (U2, UAT), and preferably comprising the steps of e) forming a difference from one (U2, UAT) of the first and the second measurement signals and the computationally determined third measurement signal (UBT) to produce an output signal, f) determining the mechanical load applied to the test object (14) based on the output signal. The invention also provides a corresponding load measurement device for carrying out the load measurement method.
Claims
1. A load measurement method for measuring a mechanical load on a test object (14), comprising: a) generating and applying a magnetic field to the test object (14), b) detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) by means of a first magnetic field detection device (20) to generate a first measurement signal (U1, UAB), c) detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) by means of a second magnetic field detection device (22) to generate a second measurement signal (U2, UAT), d) computational determination of a third measurement signal (UBT) from the first measurement signal (U1, UAB) and the second measurement signal (U2, UAT) and e) determination of an output signal from the third measurement signal and at least one of the first and second measurement signals (U1, U2) and f) determination of the mechanical load applied to the test object (14) based on the output signal.
2. The load measurement method according to claim 1, characterized in that 2.1. step e) comprises: forming the difference from one (U2, UAT) of the first and second measurement signals and the computationally determined third measurement signal (UBT) to produce the output signal and/or 2.2 step b) comprises: detection of the changed magnetic field by means of multiple series-connected magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) and tapping a sum or differential signal (UAB, U1) from these magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) and step c) comprises: detection of the changed magnetic field by means of one (A1) or a subset (26-1, A1, A2) of these magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) to tap a partial signal (U2, UAT) from the said one or said subset of the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2).
3. The load measurement method according to claim 2, characterized in that 4.1 step b) comprises detecting the changed magnetic field by means of at least two first magnetic field sensors (26-1, A1, A2) and at least two second magnetic field sensors (26-2, B1, B2) and that step b) comprises using such interconnection of the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2) that in each case the signals of a pair of a first (A1, A2) and a second (B1, B2) magnetic field sensor added in analog fashion and the signals of the pairs (A1, A2; B1, B2) subtracted in analog fashion are output as an analog differential signal (U1, UAB) and/or 4.2 further the sum signals of the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) are tapped and are evaluated in particular for determining a distance to the test object (14) and/or 4.3 an amplitude of the signal from the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) is determined as a third measurement signal in order to determine a difference of the amplitudes of the signals from the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) as a resulting output signal and/or 4.4 a coil (A1, A2, B1, B2) or a solid-state magnetic field sensor (27) is used as a magnetic field sensor (26-1, 26-2) and/or 4.4 the interconnection of the multiple magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) is varied in order to tap different sum or differential signals from the multiple magnetic field sensors.
4. The load measurement method according to claim 1, characterized in that step b) comprises detecting the changed magnetic field by means of at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) and tapping a differential signal from the at least one first (26-1) and the at least one second (26-2) magnetic field sensor to thus produce the first measurement signal and step c) comprises detecting the changed magnetic field by means of the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) to thus produce the second measurement signal and step d) comprises the computational determination of the measurement signal of the second magnetic field sensor (26-2) from the differential signal and the measurement signal of the first magnetic field sensor (26-1).
5. The load measurement method according to claim 1, characterized in that 5.1 step a) comprises imposing an alternating magnetic field, in particular with frequencies from 1 kHz to 1000 kHz and step b) and c) comprise averaging the measurement signals over multiple wave trains, wherein an averaging over between 10 and 10000 wave trains takes place and/or 5.2 at least one sensor head (10) is used having the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) and/or 5.3 multiple sensor heads (10) which each include magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) are distributed around the test object (14) and are used for common measurement signal generation, 5.4 at least one sensor head (10) is used which includes planar coils (34) as magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and as a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) which are arranged in or on a printed circuit board element (36).
6. The load measurement method according to claim 1, characterized in that steps b) and c) comprise an averaged common mode for amplitude measurement.
7. The load measurement method according to claim 1, characterized in that at least one X arrangement (28) or V arrangement (32) of magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection devices (20, 22) and the magnetic field generating device (18) are used with a common ferromagnetic amplification core (30).
8. The load measurement method according to claim 7, characterized in that several X or V arrangements (28, 32) are used which are distributed around the test object (14).
9. A load measurement device (12) for measuring a mechanical load on a test object (14), comprising: a magnetic field generating device (18) for applying a magnetic field to the test object (14), a first magnetic field detection device (20) for detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) and for supplying a first measurement signal (U1, UAB), a second magnetic field detection device (22) for detecting a magnetic field changed by the test object (14) as a result of a mechanical load on the test object (14) and for supplying a second measurement signal (U2, UAT), and a computing device (40) for computationally determining a third measurement signal (UBT) from the first measurement signal (U1, UAB) and the second measurement signal (U2, UAT) and an evaluation device (25) configured to generate an output signal indicating a mechanical load from the third measurement signal (UBT) and at least one of the first (UAB) and the second measurement signal (UAT).
10. The load measurement device according to claim 9, characterized in that 10.1 the evaluation device (25) is configured to form a difference from one (UAT) of the first and the second measurement signals and the computationally determined third measurement signal (UBT) to produce an output signal based on which the mechanical load applied to the test object (14) can be determined and/or 10.2 the first magnetic field detection device (20) includes multiple magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) which are connected in series in order tap a common signal (UAB, U1) from the multiple magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) and the second magnetic field detection device (22) includes one (A1) or a subset (26-2, A1, A2) of these magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) belonging to the first magnetic field detection device (20) in order to tap a signal from only a portion of the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first magnetic field detection device (20).
11. The load measurement device according to claim 10, characterized in that 12.1 the first magnetic field detection device (20) comprises at least two first magnetic field sensors (26-1, A1, A2) and at least two second magnetic field sensors (26-2, B1, B2) and such interconnection of the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2, A1, A2, B1, B2) that in each case the signals (UAT, UBT) of a pair (A1, A2; B1, B2) of a first (26-1) and a second (26-2) magnetic field sensor added in an analog fashion and the signals of the pairs subtracted in an analog fashion are output as an analog differential signal (U1, UAB) and/or 12.2 there is further provided a sum signal tapping device for tapping sum signals of the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2), wherein the evaluation device (25) is configured in particular to determine a distance to the test object (14) by evaluating the sum signals and/or 12.3 the computing device (40) is configured to determine an amplitude of the signal of the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) as a third measurement signal and that the evaluation device (25) is configured to determine a difference of the amplitudes of the signals from the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) as a resulting output signal and/or that 12.4 coils (A1, A2, B1, B2) or solid-state magnetic field sensors (27) serve as magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2) and/or 12.5 a device for variably interconnecting the magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2, A1, A2, B1, B2) is provided, in particular for reversing or rectifying the polarity of one or a subset (26-1, A1, A2) of the magnetic field sensors relative to the remaining magnetic field sensors (26-2, B1, B2).
12. The load measurement device (12) according to claim 9, characterized in that the first magnetic field detection device (20) includes at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2) and is configured to tap a difference of amplitudes of signals of the first and the second magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2) from the at least one first (26-1) and the at least one second magnetic field sensor (26-2), this difference forming the first measurement signal (U1, UAB) and that the second magnetic field detection device (22) comprises the at least one first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and is configured to output an amplitude as a second measurement signal from the first magnetic sensor (26-1) and that the computing device (40) is configured to computationally determine the amplitude of the second magnetic field sensor (26-2) from the differential signal (UAB) and the measurement signal of the first magnetic field sensor (26-1) and output this amplitude as a third measurement signal.
13. The load measurement device (12) according to claim 9, characterized that the magnetic field generation device (18) is configured to impose an alternating magnetic field, in particular with frequencies from 1 kHz to 1000 kHz, on the test object and that the evaluation device (25) is configured to average the measurement signals over multiple wave trains, wherein averaging over between 10 and 10000 wave trains takes place.
14. The load measurement device (12) according to claim 9, characterized in that 14.1 a common mode device for an averaged common mode of the magnetic field sensors for amplitude measurement is provided and/or 14.2 the magnetic field sensors (26, 26-1, 26-2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and the magnetic field generation device (18) form an X arrangement or a V arrangement (32), preferably with a common ferromagnetic amplification core and/or 14.3 at least one sensor head (10) is provided which includes magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) and/or 14.4 multiple sensor heads (10) which each include magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) are distributed around the test object (14) and are configured for common signal generation, 14.5 at least one sensor head (10) is provided which includes planar coils 34) as magnetic field sensors (26-1, 26-2; A1, A2, B1, B2) of the first and the second magnetic field detection device (20, 22) and as a generator coil (Lg) of the magnetic field generation device (18) which are arranged in or on the circuit board element (36).
15. A load measurement arrangement (16), comprising the load measurement device (12) according to claim 9 and a test object (14) the load of which is to be measured.
Description
(1) Embodiments of the invention will be described in more detail in the following with reference to the attached drawings wherein it is shown by
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14) The load measurement device 12 includes a magnetic field generating device 18 and multiple magnetic field detection devices 20, 22.
(15) The magnetic field generating device 18 includes a generator coil Lg and a driver circuit 24 (see
(16) The magnetic field detection devices 20, 22 have magnetic field sensors 26 in the form of detector coils A1, A2, B1, B2 or solid-state magnetic field sensors 27 and an evaluation device 25 (see
(17) The embodiment of the sensor head 10 shown in
(18)
(19) As
(20)
(21) The load measurement device 12 according to embodiments of the present invention implements a new signal processing concept for tapping and processing signals of the magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2.
(22) The signal processing concept here described can be applied to any sensor system that has multiple magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2, such as four detector coils (A1, A2, B1 and B2 form an X-version) or also only two detector coils (A1 and B1 form a V-version).
(23) In the illustrated embodiments, the magnetic field is generated via the flux concentrator 30 with the excitation coil or generator coil Lg.
(24) Also other structures and designs can be used for the described signal processing. For example, it is also possible to employ a variety of different magnetic field sensors 27 (Hall sensors, MR or GMR (giant magneto resistance) sensors or the most various magnetic flux concentrators 30 available on the market.
(25)
(26) As one can see from the interconnection of the coils on the left side of
(27) This results in the output signal UAB:
UAB=UAT−UBT=(U(A1)+U(A2))−(U(B1)+U(B2)),
where
UAT is the voltage of the pair A of first detector coils A1, A2,
UBT is the voltage of the pair B of second detector coils B1, B2,
U(A1) is the voltage of one first detector coil A1,
U(A2) is the voltage of the other first detector A2,
U(B1) is the voltage of one second detector coil B1, and
U(B2) is the voltage of the other second detector coil B2.
(28) The measurement signal is the amplitude of UAB. The phase of UAB is not measured. As a result, the sign information is lost.
(29)
(30) For signal processing using the analog principle it is recommended to use the differential signal A−B as a direct analog measured value—in the form of the amplitude of the above-described voltage UAB—in order to obtain an optimal S/N ratio. Typically achievable noise values are approx. 8 μV based on a signal height of several mV (0.1% . . . 0.5% based on the entire measuring range=FS). Another problem is that the signal UAB (corresponds to A−B) contains amplitude information and phase information at the same time. The phase information results in a non-linearity in the measurement signal which can cause the characteristic curve to bend very strongly in the event of large signal changes; a clear torque direction cannot be determined. By specifically introducing an asymmetry (e.g. by using coils with a different number of windings) the operating point can be shifted, but uncertainties remain regarding the nonlinear behavior at the minimum, the unknown or changing operating point (before a complete measuring range has been passed through during calibration), and possible disadvantages concerning temperature and distance sensitivity.
(31) Moreover, the well-known differential, single-channel approach shown in
(32) One method of avoiding these disadvantages is to sample the alternating magnetic field discretely and thus carry out a time-discrete measurement instead of a time-continuous measurement. If the amplitudes of A=(A1+A2) and B=(B1+B2) are measured directly, the S/N ratio (noise power of about 50 μV based on a useful signal of 10 . . . 20 mV) is slightly worse, but a clear determination of the torque direction and a separation of phase and amplitude are possible.
(33) Particularly preferred embodiments of the method and device for measuring loads on test objects by means of active magnetization use time sampling of the difference of the amplitudes (A−B) and one of the two coil pairs A or B and from this the arithmetical determination of B (amplitude and phase) or for the second case A (amplitude and phase).
(34) Sampling preferably takes place at very high frequencies (several 100 kHz), so that several thousand wave trains of the alternating magnetic field (samples) can be evaluated.
(35) After averaging, between 100 and 1000 samples per second can be output as an output signal, so that the temporal resolution of the output signal is in the range of one to a few milliseconds.
(36) The “signal-to-noise” (S/N ratio) value thus achieved is between 8,000 and 12,500 (corresponding to a mechanical load of 60 and 150 MPa) depending on the safety factor used. This corresponds to a noise of approx. 2 μV or 0.013% FS . . . 0.008% FS related to a measuring range of 16 . . . 25 mV useful signal.
(37) In contrast to the purely analog measurement of UAT-UBT, both channels are preferably measured separately and thus amplitude and phase are determined separately.
(38) Advantageously, no wound coils are used, but planar coils 34 integrated in a printed circuit board 36 as they have been known for some time, in order to achieve a high reproducibility of the manufacturing processes at low costs (see
(39)
(40) In this embodiment, a first magnetic field detection device 20 which supplies a first measurement signal U1 on a first channel comprises the first magnetic field sensors 26-1, A1, A2 and the second magnetic field sensors 26-2, B1 and B2, wherein the magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2, A1, A2, B1, B2 are connected in pairs in series (A1+A2) and (B1+B2) and in series in the opposite direction to each other as described above using prior art, if present in pairs. Thus, the first magnetic field detection device 20 corresponds to the analog structure and the analog channel of the single-channel known circuit from
(41) In addition, a second magnetic field detection device 22 is provided for supplying a second measurement signal U2, UAT, which comprises only the at least one first magnetic field sensor 26-1 (e.g. only the one first magnetic field sensor 26-1 in the V arrangement or only the pair of first magnetic field sensors A1+A2 in the X arrangement) and supplies the measurement signal only of the at least one first magnetic field sensor 26-1. Thus UAT is supplied as a measurement signal U2.
(42) In addition, a computing device 40 is provided which calculates the measurement signal of the at least one second magnetic field sensor 26-2 from these measurement signals UAB and UAT.
(43)
(44)
(45)
(46) Sampling preferably takes place with frequencies in the range from 1 kHz to several 100 kHz, and further preferably a common mode (e.g. implemented as software in a microprocessor) for improved amplitude measurement and an averaging over several wave trains (10 to 1000 wave trains) takes place.
(47) A further advantage of the signal processing described is the freedom of choice of ferromagnetic materials for the flux concentrator 30, which can be used in this process in the respective combinations of coil—ferromagnetic material. In addition to iron cores milled from the raw material, current sensor heads 10 also use cores that are printed in 3D or transformer plates that have to be assembled at high cost. There is now the prospect of not only commercial ferrite cores but also the core itself being completely omitted and the rear cover being covered with a metallic foil.
(48) In other embodiments not further shown here, the outputs of the individual magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2, A1, A2, B1, B2 can be individually tapped and can be tapped and evaluated individually or in different combinations as differential signal or sum signal. In this way, different measurement signals can be tapped and further measurement signals can be calculated therefrom. The first and second magnetic field measuring devices 20, 22 can thus be constructed from different magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2, A1, A2, B1, B2.
(49) The four detector coils (A1, A2, B1, B2) can be differently interconnected depending on the intended use in order to obtain a usable measurement signal via an amplifier 42.
(50) The interconnection of the coils or more generally of the magnetic field sensors 26-1, 26-2 can take place on hardware form—e.g. via an appropriately designed PCB element 36—or in the form of switching electronics—e.g. controlled by software.
(51) For this purpose, the outputs of the detector coils A1, A2, B1, B2 can be individually connected to sensor electronics, which interconnects the outputs or evaluates them individually depending on the intended use. In particular, subsets of the detector coils can be tapped in a rectified manner in order to generate a sum signal, or tapped with mutually different polarity in order to tap a differential signal.
(52) One advantage of such a preferred design of the signal processing described here resides in a mutual connection of the pairs of coils, so connection (A1−B1) −(A2−B2) allows local defects (for example cracks in the shaft) to be detected (this is not possible today with the A3 integral sensor designed as X).
(53) This possibility of an alternating (e.g. mutual) connection still has a further advantage, because within the scope of safety-relevant applications (e.g. SIL classification according to the IEC 61508 series of standards “functional safety of safety-related electrical/electronic/programmable electronic systems”), various methods for controlling or eliminating faults can be supported. This enables monitoring during operation for the detection of random faults as well as the safe control of detected faults and the transition to a safely defined state. For this purpose, two signal paths can be used, in which evaluation takes place in the first channel (A1−B1) and in the second channel (A2−B2). If, for example, these two originally identical values differ by more than twice their specification, the two pieces of information can be set off against each other and, if necessary, checked for plausibility.
(54) If the coils (A1+B1)−(A2+B2) are connected, it is advantageously possible to find out whether stress gradients or transverse forces occur—but this constellation is used, for example, in applications in which varying axle loads and different traction ratios are to be determined, but not exclusively.
(55) If the coils A1, A2, B1, B2 are sampled directly and set off against each other in a second process step, additional information on the temporal signal invariance can be obtained.
(56) In the range of large diameters >100 mm of the test object 14 (e.g. a shaft), the methodology can be advantageously used to arrange several individual sensors around a rotating shaft (as described and shown in DE 10 2017 107 111.3) and then to set off their measurements—in this case, the signal to be analyzed is based on the multiple wiring n[(A1+A2)−(B1+B2)], which then permits averaged data processing in a second step. For example, n=the number of measurement points assumes values between four and sixteen.
(57) All the interconnections and constellations described can generally be operated either in an “X” mode (X arrangement 28,
(58) Finally, the phase between A or B relative to the generator as well as the sampled signal (A−B) relative to the generator can be derived from the alternating fields at Lg and at Ai, Bi (with i=1 or the relative phase relationship between signal A and B) and can be usefully further calculated.
(59) In this context, the reverse-connected (see coil orientation at the beginning of the windings) and the synchronized constellation of all the variants described are also considered to be covered by the invention.
(60) A preferred configuration of the method for measuring a force or voltage applied to a test object 14 comprises the following steps:
(61) generating a magnetic field;
(62) applying the generated magnetic field to the test object 14;
(63) applying a force to the test object 14;
(64) detecting the magnetic field changed by the test object 14 as a result of the applied force with a first magnetic field detection device 20 and providing a first measurement signal U1, UAB with the first magnetic field detection device 20 (“A−B”);
(65) detecting the magnetic field changed by the test object 14 as a result of the applied force with a second magnetic field detection device 22 and providing a second measurement signal U2, UAT with the second magnetic field detection device 22 (“A” or “B”);
(66) computational determination of the third measurement signal UBT (“B” or “A”) from the first measurement signal (“A−B”) and the second measurement signal (“A” or “B”);
(67) determining the resulting signal “output signal A*−B*” as the difference between the second measurement signal and the third, computationally determined measurement signal=amplitude (A)−amplitude (B);
(68) determining the force or tension applied to the test object based on the resulting signal.
(69) Preferably, the sum signals of coils A1+A2+B1+B2 can be tapped and evaluated, so that a measurement of a distance to the test object 14 can be realized in an advantageous manner. Thus, in addition to the force or tension, the distance of the sensor head 10 to the test object 14 can also be measured.
(70) Furthermore, an averaged common mode is preferred in order to achieve a simplified amplitude measurement.
(71) Preferably an additional or alternative measuring signal of a wiring (A1+B1) −(A2+B2) can be tapped.
(72) As mentioned above, two or four solid-state magnetic field sensors 27 can be used instead of the detector coils A1, A2, B1, B2. Especially when such magnetic field sensors 27 are used, the concept shown here also works with direct current and/or a non-changing magnetic field.
LIST OF REFERENCE SIGNS
(73) 10 sensor head 12 load measurement device 14 test object 16 load measurement arrangement 18 magnetic field generating device 20 first magnetic field detection device 22 second magnetic field detection device 24 driver circuit 25 evaluation device 26 magnetic field sensor 26-1 first magnetic field sensor 26-2 second magnetic field sensor 27 solid-state magnetic field sensor 28 X arrangement 30 magnetic flux concentrator 32 V arrangement 34 planar coil 36 printed circuit board element 40 computing device 42 amplifier 44 A/D converter 112 load measurement device (prior art) A1 first detector coil A2 first detector coil B1 second detector coil B2 second detector coil Lg generator coil S1 magnetic field generation S2 edge attenuation S3 magnetic field detection S4 vibration damping, amplification S5 A/D conversion, signal processing