Speed of sound and/or density measurement using acoustic impedance
10088454 ยท 2018-10-02
Assignee
Inventors
- Douglas H. Loose (Southington, CT, US)
- Lambertus J Didden (Glastonbury, CT, US)
- Alan D. Kersey (South Glastonbury, CT)
Cpc classification
G01N2291/0251
PHYSICS
International classification
Abstract
Apparatus is provided featuring a signal processor or signal processing module configured at least to: receive signaling containing information about a radiation impedance of a piston vibrating a process medium, including a fluid or slurry; and determine a speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling received. The signal processor or signal processing module may determine a speed of sound measurement related to the process medium, based on at least partly on the density of the process medium, including where the density of the process medium is known, assumed or determined by the signal processor or signal processing module, or determine a density measurement related to the process medium, based on at least partly on the speed at which sound travels in the process medium, including where the speed of sound of the process medium is known, assumed or determined by the signal processor or signal processing module.
Claims
1. Apparatus comprising: a transducer apparatus or device that includes: a piston arranged in a rigid stationary wall, the piston arranged to be in contact with a process medium in a container or piping, and a motion-sensing transducer having a linear coil configured to respond to linear coil actuator signaling and vibrate harmonically the piston in contact with the process medium, and a linear actuator or processor configured to provide the linear coil actuator signaling to vibrate the piston, measure a velocity, acceleration or displacement of the piston, and provide signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston that includes information about the velocity, acceleration or displacement of the piston being measure and a force required to drive the piston being measured; and a signal processor or signal processing module configured at least to: receive the signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston; and determine corresponding signaling containing information about a speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston.
2. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a speed of sound measurement related to the process medium, based on at least partly on the density of the process medium, the density of the process medium being known, assumed or determined by the signal processor or signal processing module.
3. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a density measurement related to the process medium, based on at least partly on the speed at which sound travels in the process medium, the speed of sound of the process medium being known, assumed or determined by the signal processor or signal processing module.
4. Apparatus according to claim 3, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a speed of sound measurement in the process medium based at least partly on a time of flight measurement technique.
5. Apparatus according to claim 3, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a proper mix or mixture of the process medium based at least partly on a density measurement related to the process medium.
6. Apparatus according to claim 5, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine the proper mix or mixture of a wet concrete, based at least partly determining the density of a wet concrete.
7. Apparatus according to claim 6, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine the density of the wet concrete, based at least partly on knowing, assuming or determining the speed of sound in the wet concrete.
8. Apparatus according to claim 7, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine the speed of sound in the wet concrete based at least partly on a time of flight measurement technique.
9. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a speed of sound measurement, and is also configured to determine the volume percentage of air contained in the process medium based at least partly on the speed of sound measurement determined.
10. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the process medium is a slurry taking the form of a wet concrete, pulp slurry, or food processing slurry.
11. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine the sensed radiation impedance, based at least partly a ratio of the force exerted by a harmonically vibrating piston on the process medium to the velocity of the piston vibrating harmonically.
12. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the transducer apparatus or device is configured to act as an acoustic source.
13. Apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the transducer apparatus or device comprises a stationary rigid wall surrounding the piston so as to generate a pressure field in a hemisphere forward of the stationary rigid wall.
14. Apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the transducer apparatus or device comprises either an inline force-sensing transducer configured to measure the force required to drive the piston, or a measuring device configured to measure the electrical power driving the piston.
15. Apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the current going to and driving the linear coil is proportional to the force generated.
16. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured with at least one processor and at least one memory having computer program code, the at least one memory and computer program code configured, with the at least one processor, to cause the apparatus at least to receive the signaling and determine the speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling received.
17. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to provide the corresponding signal containing information about the speed of sound or density measurement related to the processing medium.
18. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the signaling contains information about a compressibility (1/) of the process medium and a speed at which sound travels within the process medium; and the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a density measurement of the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling received.
19. Apparatus according to claim 18, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to receive first signaling containing information about the compressibility (1/) of the process medium from the transducer apparatus or device configured to measure the compressibility (1/) of the process medium.
20. Apparatus according to claim 19, wherein the transducer apparatus or device is configured as a compressibility probe that comprises the piston that is used to provide a localized compressibility test of the process medium.
21. Apparatus according to claim 20, wherein the piston is pushed into the process medium in an oscillatory fashion, or pulsed at a certain repetition rate.
22. Apparatus according to claim 21, wherein the piston has a motion or displacement that is in a range of about 100-300 microns.
23. Apparatus according to claim 20, wherein the first signaling contains information about a local compressibility of the process flow medium, based at least partly on the fact that, as the piston is pushed into the process medium in a repetitive mode, the process medium surrounding the compressibility probe does not effectively have time to respond; and the compressibility probe is configured to determine a dynamic response or a force to move the piston a given distance, based at least partly on the first signaling received.
24. Apparatus according to claim 23, wherein the compressibility probe is configured to measure: the force on the piston, and either the displacement or acceleration of the piston, where the acceleration of the piston is related back to the motion of the piston.
25. Apparatus according to claim 24, wherein the compressibility probe is configured to determine the local compressibility of the process medium, based at least partly on corresponding measurements providing a measure of a spring constant, or spring rate, of the system, which comprises the stiffness of a mechanical assembly supporting the piston and the stiffness of the process medium local to the piston, so that if the stiffness of the mechanical assembly is known, the local compressibility of the process medium can be inferred from the corresponding measurements made.
26. Apparatus according to claim 18, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to receive second signaling containing information about the speed at which sound travels within the process medium received from a SONAR-based array that measures the speed at which sound travels within the process medium, based at least partly on the speed at which compressional waves propagate through the process flow medium.
27. Apparatus according to claim 26, wherein the apparatus comprises the SONAR-based array.
28. Apparatus according to claim 27, wherein the SONAR-based array is configured to determine a volumetric flow rate of a process flow medium flowing in a process flow pipe.
29. Apparatus according to claim 28, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine a mass flow of the process flow medium in the process flow pipe, based at least partly on the combination of the volumetric flow measurement and a density measurement.
30. Apparatus according to claim 18, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to determine the density p of the process medium, based at least partly on the equation:
31. Apparatus according to claim 18, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured with at least one processor and at least one memory having computer program code, the at least one memory and computer program code configured, with the at least one processor, to cause the apparatus at least to receive the signaling and determine the density measurement of the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling received.
32. Apparatus according to claim 18, wherein the signal processor or signal processing module is configured to provide corresponding signal containing information about the density measurement of the process medium.
33. A method comprising: configuring a transducer apparatus or device having a piston and a motion-sensing transducer that includes a linear coil and a linear actuator by: arranging the piston in a rigid stationary wall, the piston arranged to be in contact with a process medium in a container or piping, and responding with the linear coil to linear coil actuator signaling and vibrating harmonically the piston in contact with the process medium, proving the linear actuator or processor signaling to vibrate the piston, measuring with the linear actuator or processor a velocity, acceleration or displacement of the piston, and providing with the linear actuator or processor signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston that includes information about the velocity, acceleration or displacement of the piston being measure and a force required to drive the piston being measured; and configuring a signal processor or signal processing module at least to: receive the signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston; and determine corresponding signaling containing information about a speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium, based at least partly on the signaling containing information about a sensed radiation impedance of the piston.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING
(1) The drawing includes
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF BEST MODE OF THE INVENTION
CCS-0084: FIGS. 1a-1d
(8)
(9) The signal processor or signal processing module 10a may also be configured to providing corresponding signaling containing information about the speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium.
(10) By way of example, a person skilled in the art would appreciate that radiation impedance may be understood to mean, or may be defined as, the ratio of the force a radiator exerts on a process flow medium to the velocity of the radiator.
FIG. 1 b: The Vibrating Piston
(11) By way of example, and according to some embodiments of the present invention,
u.sub.p(t)=u.sub.0e.sup.jt,(1)
where: u.sub.p=piston face velocity, u.sub.0=velocity amplitude, =angular frequency and t=time.
(12) Alternatively, the motion of the piston 20a could be described by either its acceleration or displacement with:
(13)
where: a.sub.0=the acceleration amplitude and A.sub.0=the displacement amplitude.
(14) The total force that acts on the face of a time-harmonic vibrating baffled piston in contact with an acoustic fluid or medium 24 is given by:
F=a.sup.2P.sub.avg=a.sup.2u.sub.0Z.sub.p(4)
where: a=piston radius, P.sub.avg=average pressure amplitude on the face of the piston, u.sub.0=piston velocity amplitude, and Z.sub.p=piston radiation impedance.
(15) The radiation impedance of the piston 20a is given by:
(16)
where: .sub.0=medium density, c.sub.0=medium sound velocity, k=wavenumber=/c.sub.0. J.sub.1=Bessel function of the first kind, and K.sub.1=Struve function.
(17) Note that Z.sub.p is a function of density, sound velocity frequency and piston radius only. At large values of 2ka (piston diameter large compared to the acoustic wavelength) equation (5) reduces to:
Z.sub.p=.sub.0c.sub.0(6)
Sound Velocity and/or Density Measurement
(18) In operation, and by way of example, the vibrating piston 20a may be installed such that it is in contact with the process medium or fluid 24 (or slurry in the case of wet concrete, pulp slurry or food processing slurry, for example) of interest. The piston 20a may be vibrated harmonically as give in equation (1). In
(19) Rearranging equation (4) to solve for the radiation impedance gives:
(20)
(21) For a known radius piston vibrating at a known frequency, inserting the measured force less any dynamic forces, F, and the velocity amplitude, u.sub.0, or alternatively a.sub.0 or A.sub.0 substituting equations (2) and (3), the radiation impedance may be determined. Once the radiation impedance is known, the quantity .sub.0c.sub.0 can be found from equation (5). If the density is known or assumed the sound velocity can be determined. Alternatively, if the sound velocity is known or assumed, the density can be determined. By way of example, and as a person skilled in the art would appreciate, the density or speed of sound of the process medium may be known or assumed, e.g., based at least partly on the process medium coming from, or form part of, known batch processing techniques having known or assumed characteristics, and/or from tables or charts containing information about known process medium. The scope of the invention is not intended to how the density or speed of sound of the process medium may be known or assumed. One possibility is to use the time of flight measurement (e.g., see patent application Ser. No. 13/583,062 to determine sound velocity then use the present method to determine density.
(22) In
(23) Transducer apparatus or device like element 20 are known in the art; and the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind of transducer apparatus or device, and is intended to include other types or kinds of transducer apparatus or devices both now known and later developed in the future.
(24) The scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind of container or piping or the process medium contained or flowing therein, and is intended to include other types or kinds of containers or pipings or process mediums contained or flowing therein, both now known and later developed in the future.
Calibration
(25) Since the dynamic forces of a vibrating piston, such as piston 20a, can be significant relative to the acoustic reaction force calibration may be required. By way of example, this could be done by simply vibrating the piston 20a in an environment which has low acoustic coupling to measure and then subtract the dynamic piston forces. For example, if the fluid or medium of interest was wet concrete or other water-based slurry, the piston 20a could be operated in air. The acoustic reaction force in air would be very low so the dynamic forces could be measured then subtracted from the total force measured when making the measurement in wet concrete or other water-based slurry.
(26) Calibration techniques are known in the art; and the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind of calibration technique, and is intended to include other types or kinds of calibration techniques both now known and later developed in the future.
Model
(27) By way of example, equation (4) was modeled, e.g., using MATLAB, and the following curve shows the change in the force to acceleration ratio for a 0.95 inch diameter piston vibrating in aerated water at 330 Hz. Note the relationship between air content and sound velocity was determined using a simplified Wood's equation:
(28)
where: P.sub.a=absolute pressure, and =air content or gas void fraction (GVF).
(29)
(30) Modeling software or program are known in the art; and the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind of modeling software or program, and is intended to include other types or kinds of modeling software or program both now known and later developed in the future.
Test Data
(31) By way of example, in a test procedure, the piston 20a driven by the combination of the voice coil 20d and the linear voice coil actuator 20e was installed in a vertical water column. An accelerometer was attached to the actuator/piston assembly and measured during the test. Also, the current provided by the linear coil actuator 20e to the voice coil 20d which is proportional to the total driving force was measured though an analog output from a voice coil amplifier (not shown). For this simple test, no calibration was completed therefore the force measured includes both the acoustic reaction force and dynamic forces.
(32) Varying amounts of air was bubbled through the vertical water column with the change in height measured to determine the percent air bubbles by volume:
(33)
Where: h=difference between aerated water column height and water only height and H=water only height
(34) The amount of air bubbles in the water will have a significant effect on the sound velocity of the water with only a minor change in density.
(35)
(36) Note that this simple test shows the same trend as the aforementioned model, that at a constant driving force as the air content increases the acceleration also increases.
CCS-0095: FIGS. 2a-2b
(37)
(38) The signal processor or signal processing module 50a may also be configured to providing corresponding signaling containing information about the speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium.
(39) The objective of this part of the present invention is to provide a determination of the density of the process flow medium or fluid. The speed of sound, c, in a process flow medium or fluid is related to the bulk modulus, (1/compressibility) and density, , of the process flow medium or fluid via:
(40)
(41) Gas entrainment will significantly lower the sound speed in a process flow medium or fluid as the compressibility (1/) of the fluid increases dramatically with gas void fraction (GVF).
(42) The density of the process flow medium or fluid is thus given by;
(43)
(44) Consequently, a measurement of the speed of sound, combined with a determination of the process flow medium or fluid compressibility can be used to give a measure of the process flow medium or fluid density.
(45) Devices for the measurement of fluid compressibility are known in the art, and the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind thereof either now known or later developed in the future. By way of example,
FIG. 2b: An Exemplary Embodiment
(46) By way of example, and according to some embodiments of the present invention,
(47) This ported unit 34 may take the form or include a compressibility probe that utilizes a piston like element 20a (see
(48) Once the compressibility (1/) of the process flow medium or fluid and the speed (c) at which sound travels in the process flow medium or fluid are determined, the density () of the process flow medium or fluid may be provided by the following relationship:
(49)
(50) The SONARtrac array 32 may also be used to determine the volumetric flow rate of the medium or fluid flowing in the pipe 40. The combination of a volumetric flow measurement and a density measurement, as provided by this invention, may be further utilized to provide the mass flow of the medium or fluid flowing in the pipe 40.
(51) Ported units like element 34 and or compressibility probes are known in the art. The scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind of ported units and/or compressibility probes, and is intended to include other types or kinds of ported units and/or compressibility probes both now known and later developed in the future.
The Signal Processor or Signal Processing Module
(52) By way of example, and consistent with that described herein, the functionality of the signal processor or signal processing module 10a, 50a, and/or 20e may be implemented using hardware, software, firmware, or a combination thereof, although the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular embodiment thereof. In a typical software implementation, the signal processor would be one or more microprocessor-based architectures having a microprocessor, a random access memory (RAM), a read only memory (ROM), input/output devices and control, data and address buses connecting the same. A person skilled in the art would be able to program such a microprocessor-based implementation to perform the functionality set forth in the signal processor or signal processing module 10a, such as either determining a speed of sound or density measurement related to the process medium, or a density of the process flow medium, based at least partly on the signaling received, as well as other functionality described herein without undue experimentation. The scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular implementation using technology now known or later developed in the future. Moreover, the scope of the invention is intended to include the signal processor being a stand alone module, as shown, or in the combination with other circuitry for implementing another module.
(53) It is also understood that the apparatus 10 or 50 may include one or more other modules, components, circuits, or circuitry 10b or 50b for implementing other functionality associated with the apparatus that does not form part of the underlying invention, and thus is not described in detail herein. By way of example, the one or more other modules, components, circuits, or circuitry 10b or 50b may include random access memory, read only memory, input/output circuitry and data and address buses for use in relation to implementing the signal processing functionality of the signal processor 10a or 50a, or devices or components related to mixing or pouring concrete in a ready-mix concrete truck or adding chemical additives, etc.
The SONAR-Based Technology
(54) SONAR-based technology is known in the art, including that developed by the assignee of the present application. By way of example, the SONAR-based entrained air meter or arrays may take the form of SONAR-based meter, metering or array technology disclosed, e.g., in whole or in part, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,165,464; 7,134,320; 7,363,800; 7,367,240; and 7,343,820, all of which are incorporated by reference in their entirety.
(55) A. Introduction
(56) The known SONAR-based technology includes a gas volume fraction meter (known in the industry as a GVF-100 meter) that directly measures the low-frequency sonic speed (SOS) of the liquid or slurry flowing through a pipe. By way of example, the SONAR-based entrained air meter may take the form of SONAR-based meter and metering technology disclosed, e.g., in whole or in part, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,165,464; 7,134,320; 7,363,800; 7,367,240; and 7,343,820, all of which are incorporated by reference in their entirety. Using the Wood's equation, the volume percent of any gas bubbles or the gas void fraction (GVF) is determined from the measured SOS. The Wood's equation requires several other inputs in addition to the measured SOS of liquid/gas mixture. One of the additional inputs in particular, the static pressure of the liquid/gas mixture, can be very important for an accurate calculation of the GVF. To a first order, if the static pressure used for the GVF calculation differs from the actual static pressure of the liquid/gas mixture, then the calculated GVF may typically differ from the actual GVF by 1% as well. For example: Static Pressure used for GVF calculation=20 psia Calculated GVF=2% Actual Static Pressure=22 psia Static pressure error=22/201=0.1=10% Actual GVF=2%(1+0.1)=2.2% (10% error)
(57) In many cases, the static pressure of the liquid/gas mixture is available through existing process plant instrumentation. In this case, the measured static pressure can be input directly to the GVF calculation through, e.g., an analog 4-20 mA input in the SONAR-based gas volume fraction transmitter (e.g. GVF-100 meter). Alternatively, a correction to the calculated GVF can be made in the customer DCS for any variation from the fixed pressure that was used to originally calculate the GVF.
(58) In other cases, a static pressure transmitter can be added to the process plant specifically to measure the static pressure used for the GVF calculation. The measured pressure can either be input to the SONAR-based gas volume fraction transmitter (e.g., GVF-1200) or correction made in the DCS as described above.
(59) Occasionally, a the SONAR-based gas volume fraction meter (e.g., GVF-100) may be installed at a location in the process that does not already have a static pressure gauge installed and it is impractical to add one. This could be a location where there is no existing penetration of the pipe to sense the pressure and it would be difficult or expensive to add one. In the case, where a traditional pressure gauge is not available and it is desirable to have a static pressure measurement the following description of a non-intrusive (clamp on) static pressure measurement could be used.
(60) B. Description
(61) For example, according to some embodiments of the present invention, a non-intrusive static pressure measurement may be sensed using traditional strain gauges integrated into the sensor band of the SONAR-based gas volume fraction sensing technology (e.g. the known GVF-100 meter). As the static pressure inside the pipe changes, the static strain on the outside of the pipe also changes. Using a thin-wall assumption for simplicity (t/R<10, where t is the wall thickness and R is the radius) the tangential strain due to internal static pressure is:
(62)
where is the tangential strain (inch/inch), R is the radius (inch), E is the modulus of elasticity (lb/in2) and t is the wall thickness (inch). The radius, wall thickness and modulus is generally known, or at least constant and so if the tangential strain is measured the internal static pressure can be determined.
(63) By way of example, according to one embodiment of the present invention, four strain gauges could be arranged on the sensor band of the SONAR-based gas volume fraction sensing technology (e.g. the known GVF-100 meter) in a Wheatstone bridge configuration to maximize strain sensitivity and minimize temperature effects. In this case, the sensitivity assuming a strain gauge factor of 2, the sensitivity is approximately 13 V/, where V is volts. Assuming a 4-inch schedule 40 carbon steel pipe, a one psi change in pressure would cause a 4 V change in Wheatstone bridge output. This sensitivity would increase for larger diameter pipes which generally have a smaller t/R.
(64) The integrated pressure gauge could be calibrated in-situ for best accuracy, but it may be sufficient to normalize the pressure output to a certain know state then use the tangential strain formula above with know pipe parameters to calculate the pressure from the measured strain.
(65) The SONAR-based entrained air meter, metering or array technology are known in the art and may take the form of a SONAR-based meter disclosed, e.g., in whole or in part in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,165,464; 7,134,320; 7,363,800; 7,367,240; and 7,343,820, all of which are incorporated by reference in their entirety. The SONAR-based entrained air meter, metering or array technology is capable of providing a variety of information, including the pure phase density and pure phase liquid sound speed is known, such that the GVF can be determined by measuring the speed of sound and then applying the Woods Equation.
(66) Determining the GVF by measuring the speed of sound can provide fast an accurate data. Also the SOS measurement system can be very flexible and can easily be configured to work with different concrete containers and sample particular volumes.
(67) Consistent with that described above, the SONAR-based entrained air meter, metering or array technology are known in the art and may take the form of a SONAR-based meter disclosed, e.g., in whole or in part in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,165,464; 7,134,320; 7,363,800; 7,367,240; and 7,343,820.
Other Known Technology
(68) The acoustic transmitter, the acoustic receiver or receiver probe and/or transponders are devices that are known in the art, and the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to any particular type or kind either now known or later developed in the future.
THE SCOPE OF THE INVENTION
(69) While the invention has been described with reference to an exemplary embodiment, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, may modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation or material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiment(s) disclosed herein as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention.