System and method for converting optical diameters of aerosol particles to mobility and aerodynamic diameters
09891154 ยท 2018-02-13
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01N2015/0003
PHYSICS
International classification
Abstract
A system and a method of measuring a particle's size in a select aerosol using the optical diameter of the particle to perform a mobility and/or aerodynamic diameter conversion without any knowledge about the particle's shape and its optical properties in the aerosol being characterized. In one example embodiment of the invention, the method includes generating a set of calibration data and finding the optimal refractive index and shape that best fits the calibration data. In addition, the method includes creating a new calibration curve that provides a mobility-equivalent or aerodynamic-equivalent diameter.
Claims
1. A method for determining aerodynamic diameter aerosol size distribution of a mass of particles in an aerosol, comprising: providing a detector to receive electromagnetic radiation scattered from an interrogation volume; causing the mass of particles to flow through said interrogation volume and scatter electromagnetic radiation onto said detector to generate an electrical signal from said detector; generating a plurality of pulse height outputs from said electrical signal with a pulse height signal conditioner, each of said pulse height outputs corresponding to a particle passing through said interrogation volume and then correlating each pulse height output to an optical particle size or diameter; generating one or more sets of calibration data with a calibration system from the passing mass of particles, wherein the calibration system includes an aerodynamic diameter device adapted to generate at least one predefined aerodynamic diameter cut point for an optical particle diameter as part of generating the calibration data; determining a refractive index of the particles in the aerosol using the calibration data and a Mie light scattering model calculation that provides the best fit to the calibration data then creating calibration curves that provide aerodynamic-equivalent diameters for particles using the refractive index, wherein the refractive index of the mass of particles is unknown before conducting a measurement on the mass of particles in the aerosol; and converting optical diameters of said passing particles to aerodynamic diameters using the refractive index.
2. The method of claim 1 wherein the aerodynamic diameter device is an impactor or a set of impactors with different cut points.
3. The method of claim 1 wherein the aerodynamic diameter device is a cyclone or a set of cyclones with different cut points.
4. A method for determining size segregated aerosol mass concentration of a mass of particles in an aerosol, comprising: providing a detector to receive electromagnetic radiation scattered from an interrogation volume; causing the mass of particles to flow through said interrogation volume and scatter electromagnetic radiation onto said detector to generate an electrical signal from said detector; generating a plurality of pulse height outputs from said electrical signal with said pulse height signal conditioner, each of said pulse height outputs corresponding to a particle passing through said interrogation volume and then correlating each pulse height output to an optical particle size or diameter; generating one or more sets of calibration data with a calibration system from the passing mass of particles, wherein the calibration system includes an aerodynamic device which generates one or more known aerodynamic diameter cut points as part of generating the calibration data, then calculating a chi-square variable from the calibration data and determining if a minimum chi-square variable defined value has been reached; determining an optimal/effective refractive index of the aerosol of interest using the calibration data and a Mie light scattering model calculation that provides the best fit to the calibration data then creating calibration curves that provide aerodynamic-equivalent diameters using the optimal refractive index, wherein the refractive index of the mass of particles is unknown before conducting a measurement on the mass of particles in the aerosol; converting optical diameters of said passing particles to aerodynamic diameters using the optimal/effective refractive index; and calculating a size segregated mass concentration from said aerodynamic diameters.
5. The method of claim 4 wherein the aerodynamic device is an impactor or a set of impactors with different aerodynamic cut points.
6. The method of claim 4 wherein the aerodynamic device is a cyclone or a set of cyclones with different aerodynamic cut points.
7. The method of claim 1, wherein a new mobility-equivalent or aerodynamic-equivalent calibration curve is then created using the refractive index and a shape factor, and wherein the shape factor of the mass of particles is unknown before conducting a measurement on the mass of particles in the aerosol.
8. The method of claim 4, wherein a shape factor of the mass of particles is unknown before conducting a measurement on the mass of particles in the aerosol.
9. The method of claim 4, wherein if the minimum chi-square variable value is not reached, then adjusting the refractive index and then performing a Mie scattering calculation which generates new optical diameters, thereafter calculating another chi-square and comparing minimum chi-square variable values.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(10) Following are more detailed descriptions of various related concepts related to, and embodiments of, methods and apparatus according to the present disclosure. It should be appreciated that various aspects of the subject matter introduced above and discussed in greater detail below may be implemented in any of numerous ways, as the subject matter is not limited to any particular manner of implementation. Examples of specific implementations and applications are provided primarily for illustrative purposes.
(11) Referring to
(12) In this example embodiment, particle size measurement system 30 includes beam shaping optics 60 that may include a lens 62 such as a cylindrical lens. The shaping optics 60 may additionally or alternatively comprise reflective components such as mirrors, or fiber optic components (not depicted). A portion of the light scattered from particles over a solid angle 64 may be subtended by a light collection system or radiation collector 66 (e.g., a spherical mirror, aspheric condenser lenses, or other electromagnetic radiation collection devices available to the artisan) within the optics chamber 48. An unscattered portion 70 of the light beam 54 may be captured by a light trap 72. Inner surfaces 74 of the optics chamber 48 may be coated with a black or high absorptivity coating such as an anodized coating. Collected light 78 gathered by the radiation collector 66 may be transferred to a detector 80 such as a photodiode or a photomultiplier tube. The detector 80 may produce an electrical signal 82 proportional to the convolution of the incident electromagnetic radiation and the spectral sensitivity of the detector 80.
(13) In some embodiments, the aerosol flow stream 44 exits the optics chamber 48 through an outlet nozzle 84 and may be passed through a gravimetric filter 86, thereby producing a pre-filtered aerosol flow stream 88. The aerosol flow streams 44 may be drawn through the optics chamber 48 by a pumping system 90 that includes a protection filter 92, a flowmeter 94, a flow pulsation damping chamber 96 and a pump or blower 98 that is ducted to an exhaust 99. Numerous kinds of pumps or blowers may be utilized, including but not limited to a diaphragm pump, a rotary vane pump, a piston pump, a roots pump, a linear pump or a regenerative blower.
(14) In one embodiment, the CAPS 34 may condition the electrical signal 82 to define three different signal circuits: a dynamic mobility diameter signal circuit 100 for generating mobility diameter data/outputs 102 associated with the particles of the collected light 78 gathered by the radiation collector 66 and incident on the detector 80; a pulse height conditioner circuit 104 for detecting scattered light originating from individual particles as they pass through the interrogation volume 50 and generating pulse height outputs 106 in accordance therewith; and an aerodynamic diameter signal circuit 108 generating aerodynamic diameter data/outputs 110 that provide (direct or indirect) measurement of the size of the particles being measured as they pass through the interrogation volume 50. The outputs 102, 106 and 110 may be routed to a digital processor module 114 for calibration and subsequent conversion into a particle size distribution 113. The result can be output to a device 116, such as a display, a storage device, analog output or a computer.
(15) Functionally, beam shaping optics 60 may be utilized to configure the shape of the light beam 54 and interrogation volume 50 to possess certain characteristics, such as overall width and height, as well as intensity profile. The light trap 72 mitigates or prevents biasing of the electrical signal 82 that may be caused by the unscattered portion 70 of the light beam 54 gathered by the radiation collector 66 after multiple scattering within the optics chamber 48. When utilized, the high absorptivity coating on the inner surfaces 74 of the optics chamber 48 may further reduce the propagation of stray light. In operation, mobility diameter circuit 100 provides data akin to that produced by a differential mobility analyzer device while pulse height output 106 and aerodynamic diameter data/output 110 are akin to the outputs of OPC and APS devices, respectively.
(16) Particles can be collected on the gravimetric filter 86 and can be weighed to measure mass directly. This direct mass measurement can be used to create the calibration relationship between the electrical signal 82 and the mass of the collected particles (see discussion attendant
(17) The filtration device 46 of the sheath flow conditioning loop 45 removes particulate matters from the sheath flow stream 42 to provide a substantially clean flow of gas that shrouds or sheaths the aerosol flow 44. The cleansed sheath flow 42 helps contain particulates within the core of the aerosol flow 44 as it passes through the optics chamber 48, thereby mitigating against particulate contamination of the optics chamber 48 and appurtenances therein. The flow measuring device 47, when utilized, can provide an indication of the flow rate of the sheath flow stream 42 which can be subtracted from the total flow rate of the incoming flow stream 36 provided by the flowmeter 94 to determine the flow rate of the aerosol flow stream 44.
(18) The optical particle counter (OPC) is one of the most widely used aerosol instruments because of its low cost and ability to rapidly provide particle size distributions in real time. OPCs measure the size and number concentration of aerosol particles by means of light scattering by single particles. In addition to the particle size, the amount of light scattered by the particle also depends on the particle properties, namely refractive index and shape.
(19) Particle diameters measured by OPCs are usually referred to as optical diameters or PSL-equivalent diameters. Nevertheless, in most of the applications, optical diameters usually are not very useful, and they need to be converted to measures of diameter related to their physical behavior, such as electrical mobility and/or aerodynamic diameters. This conversion is necessary because mobility diameter is more commonly used for particles smaller than 1 m, while aerodynamic diameters are more commonly used in areas such as aerobiology, health effect studies, environmental monitoring, etc. The conversion can be done if aerosol particles are spherical in shape and their refractive indices are known since the light scattering and extinction by a spherical particle can be described and modeled by the Mie scattering theory. Unfortunately, except for certain laboratory generated aerosol particles, aerosols of interest are usually irregular in shape and/or their refractive indices are unknown. The following description provides more detail on the overall measurement system and on the operation of CAPS module 34 which eventually helps to generate more accurate and robust particle size measurement data by using calibration data generated along with Mie scattering modeling.
(20) Referring now to
(21) Referring now to
(22) Referring now to
(23) Referring now to
(24) One application of a mobility-diameter-calibrated OPC of system 200 is that it can be combined with a Scanning Mobility Particle Sizer (SMPS) for wide range particle size distribution measurement (see
(25) Referring now to
(26) Referring more specifically to
(27) Referring again to
(28) Referring back to
(29) Referring now more specifically to
(30) Referring now more specifically to
(31) Referring now more specifically to
(32) Referring now more specifically to
(33) Referring now more specifically to
(34) In a related embodiment, a DMA and OPS particle sizing system includes a switch to allow for re-calibration by having the particle flow only to the DMA and then once its re-calibrated then the system switches back over to having the particle flow through both the DMA and the OPS.
(35) Referring now to
(36) In this example embodiment of the measurement method, a polydisperse aerosol was first measured by the SMPS and OPS simultaneously. To calibrate the OPS for mobility diameter, several DMA classified monodisperse aerosols were measured by the OPS. To improve data quality, the size channel boundaries of the OPS were adjusted so that all 16 channels were allocated over the narrow range from 0.3 to 1.0 m for high resolution measurement. Mie scattering calculations were then performed to find the optimal refractive index that minimized the difference between the mobility diameters of these monodisperse aerosols from the DMA and optical diameters from the OPS. The shape factor was also used to further improve the results. This calibration step is illustrated in
(37) Distributions of a laboratory generated methylene blue aerosol measured with SMPS and OPS were previously shown in
(38) A method was successfully developed to convert optical diameters to mobility diameters without the knowledge of aerosol shape and optical properties. Without the refractive index adjustment and shape factor correction, it was found that optical diameters could be quite different from the mobility diameters if the refractive indices of the aerosols were very different from the PSL aerosols (such as methlyne blue aerosol) and/or aerosols were nonspherical. The disclosed method is more robust than merging SMPS and OPS distributions by minimizing the count differences between the two measurement techniques, since the merged distributions by the latter method could be significantly biased by instrument counting efficiencies in the overlapping region.
(39) In one example embodiment, a measurement system for measuring aerosol size distribution includes an electromagnetic radiation source operatively coupled with beam shaping optics for generation of a beam of electromagnetic radiation; an inlet nozzle for passage of an aerosol flow stream therethrough, said aerosol flow stream containing particles and intersecting said beam of electromagnetic radiation to define an interrogation volume, said particles scattering said electromagnetic radiation from said interrogation volume; and a radiation collector for collection of a portion of said electromagnetic radiation scattered from the particles in said interrogation volume. A detector is also included for detection of said portion of said electromagnetic radiation collected by said radiation collector, along with a calibration system for generating one or more sets of calibration data from a particle of an aerosol of interest, said calibration system operatively coupled to said detector. The system also includes digital processing means for computing an aerodynamic diameter and/or mobility diameter from an optical diameter operatively coupled to said calibration system, said digital processing means configured to generate a Mie light scattering model to determine a refractive index of the particles of an aerosol of interest using the calibration data and then convert the optical diameters to aerodynamic diameters and/or mobility diameters using the resulting refractive index.
(40) In a related embodiment, the measurement system has a calibration system that is an electrical mobility device adapted to generate predefined electrical mobility size distributions or electrical mobility cut points. The electrical mobility device is selected from the group consisting of a differential mobility analyzer and electrostatic precipitator.
(41) In another related embodiment, the measurement system further includes a scanning mobility particle sizing device operatively coupled to the detector thereby providing a wide particle range sizing system adapted to measure a mass of particles having a lower limit defined as being between about 10 nm and about 500 nm and an upper limit defined as being between about 300 nm and about 10 m.
(42) In yet another related embodiment, the measurement system has a calibration system that is an aerodynamic diameter device adapted to generate aerodynamic diameter cut points. The aerodynamic diameter device is an impactor or a set of impactors with different aerodynamic cut points. In a related embodiment, the aerodynamic diameter device is a cyclone or a set of cyclones with different aerodynamic cut points.
(43) In another example embodiment, an instrument for measuring aerosol size distribution includes an electromagnetic radiation source operatively coupled with beam shaping optics for generation of a beam of electromagnetic radiation; an inlet nozzle for passage of an aerosol flow stream there through, said aerosol flow stream containing particles and intersecting said beam of electromagnetic radiation to define an interrogation volume, said particles scattering said electromagnetic radiation from said interrogation volume; and a radiation collector for collection of a portion of said electromagnetic radiation scattered from said interrogation volume. The instrument also includes a detector for detection of said portion of said electromagnetic radiation collected by said radiation collector; and digital processing means for computing a Mie light scattering model and adapted to incorporate optical properties of the particles in an aerosol of interest as part of the particle measurement, said digital processing means operatively coupled to said detector. In a related embodiment, digital processing means is also configured to convert optical diameters of the particles to aerodynamic diameters and/or electrical mobility diameters, said digital processing means operatively coupled to said detector.
(44) In another example embodiment, a method for determining electrical mobility aerosol size distribution includes providing a detector to receive electromagnetic radiation scattered from an interrogation volume and causing particles to flow through said interrogation volume and scatter electromagnetic radiation onto said detector to generate an electrical signal from said detector. The method also includes generating a plurality of pulse height outputs from said electrical signal with said pulse height signal conditioner, each of said pulse height outputs corresponding to a particle passing through said interrogation volume and corresponding to an optical particle size, and includes generating one or more sets of calibration data with a calibration system from the passing particles. The method further includes the step of determining a refractive index of the particle of an aerosol of interest using the calibration data and a Mie light scattering model, and converting optical diameters of said passing particles to electrical mobility diameters.
(45) In one related embodiment, the method includes providing as the calibration system an electrical mobility device which is capable of generating narrow electrical mobility size distributions or providing known electrical mobility cut points, wherein the electrical mobility device is selected from the group consisting a differential mobility analyzer and an electrostatic precipitator.
(46) In yet another example embodiment, a method for determining aerodynamic aerosol size distribution includes providing a detector to receive electromagnetic radiation scattered from an interrogation volume, and causing particles to flow through said interrogation volume and scatter electromagnetic radiation onto said detector to generate an electrical signal from said detector. The method also includes generating a plurality of pulse height outputs from said electrical signal with said pulse height signal conditioner, each of said pulse height outputs corresponding to a particle passing through said interrogation volume and corresponding to an optical particle size, and generating one or more sets of calibration data with a calibration system from the passing particles. The method further includes determining a refractive index of the particles of an aerosol of interest using the calibration data and a Mie light scattering model, and converting optical diameters of said passing particles to aerodynamic diameters. In a related embodiment, the calibration system is an aerodynamic diameter device adapted to generate at least one predefined aerodynamic diameter cut point, wherein the aerodynamic diameter device is an impactor or a set of impactors with different cut points. In another embodiment, the aerodynamic diameter device is a cyclone or a set of cyclones with different cut points.
(47) In yet another example embodiment, a method for determining size segregated aerosol mass concentration includes providing a detector to receive electromagnetic radiation scattered from an interrogation volume, and causing particles to flow through said interrogation volume and scatter electromagnetic radiation onto said detector to generate an electrical signal from said detector. The method also includes generating a plurality of pulse height outputs from said electrical signal with said pulse height signal conditioner, each of said pulse height outputs corresponding to a particle passing through said interrogation volume and corresponding to an optical particle size and generating one or more sets of calibration data with a calibration system. The method further includes determining the optimal/effective refractive index of the aerosol of interest using the calibration data and the Mie light scattering model, converting optical diameters to aerodynamic diameters, and calculating a size segregated mass concentration from said aerodynamic diameters.
(48) In a related embodiment, the calibration system of the method is an aerodynamic device which generates one or more known aerodynamic diameter cut points, wherein the aerodynamic device is an impactor or a set of impactors with different aerodynamic cut points. In another embodiment, the aerodynamic device is a cyclone or a set of cyclones with different aerodynamic cut points.
(49) The following patents that relate to OPC devices are herein incorporated by reference in their entirety and constitute part of the disclosure herein: U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,831,279; 5,561,515; 5,895,922; 6,639,671; 7,066,037; and 7,167,099 and 7,932,490. Having thus described several illustrative embodiments, it is to be appreciated that various alterations, modifications, and improvements will readily occur to those skilled in the art. Such alterations, modifications, and improvements are intended to be part of this disclosure, and are intended to be within the spirit and scope of this disclosure. While some examples presented herein involve specific combinations of functions or structural elements, it should be understood that those functions and elements may be combined in other ways according to the present invention to accomplish the same or different objectives. In particular, acts, elements, and features discussed in connection with one embodiment are not intended to be excluded from similar or other roles in other embodiments. Accordingly, the foregoing description and attached drawings are by way of example only, and are not intended to be limiting.