METAL SHEET BENT PORTION FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH SUPPRESSING METHOD AND AUTOMOTIVE PART
20240416405 ยท 2024-12-19
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
B21D53/88
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B21D5/01
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B23P9/04
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B21D22/26
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
Abstract
A metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method suppresses a growth of a fatigue crack generated in a bent portion formed by bending a metal sheet, and includes applying a plastic strain at least in a range from a bending start point to a bending end point on a bend inner side of the bent portion in a direction orthogonal to a valley line direction of the bent portion at an interval equal to or larger than a sheet thickness of the metal sheet in the valley line direction so as to generate a compressive residual stress.
Claims
1. A metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method of suppressing a growth of a fatigue crack generated in a bent portion formed by bending a metal sheet, comprising applying a plastic strain at least in a range from a bending start point to a bending end point on a bend inner side of the bent portion in a direction orthogonal to a valley line direction of the bent portion at an interval equal to or larger than a sheet thickness of the metal sheet in the valley line direction so as to generate a compressive residual stress.
2. The metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method according to claim 1, wherein the compressive residual stress is generated by forming an indentation band, which is a series of indentations, on the bend inner side of the bent portion by a needle peening treatment using an impact pin, and as the impact pin, an impact pin that has a radius of curvature of a tip thereof, in a cross section orthogonal to the valley line direction, equal to or less than a radius of curvature of the bent portion is used.
3. An automotive part comprising a bent portion formed by bending a metal sheet, wherein a growth of a fatigue crack is suppressed in the bent portion; and an indentation band which is a series of indentations formed by a needle peening treatment using an impact pin, the indentation band being formed at least in a range from a bending start point to a bending end point on a bend inner side of the bent portion in a direction orthogonal to a valley line direction of the bent portion at an interval equal to or larger than a sheet thickness of the metal sheet in the valley line direction.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
[0014]
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
Background of the Present Invention
[0020] As illustrated in
[0021] In view of this, as illustrated in
[0022] In examination of the cause of this, the inventors focused on stress distribution in the bent portion 3 as illustrated in
[0023] From this observation, it has been found that the reason why the growth of the fatigue crack generated on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 in the depth direction (sheet thickness direction) stops at a depth of about of the sheet thickness from the surface of the bend inner side is due to the compressive residual stress remaining inside the bent portion 3 even after the springback.
[0024] Therefore, based on the above finding that the growth of the crack in the sheet thickness direction stops due to the compressive residual stress remaining inside the bent portion, the inventors conceived that it is possible to prevent or suppress the growth of the crack in the valley line direction (lateral direction) of the crack 5 in the bent portion 3 by applying plastic strain at predetermined intervals in the valley line direction (lateral direction) to generate the compressive residual stress.
[0025] The present invention has been made through various examinations based on the above concept, and specifically has the following configuration.
First Embodiment
<Metal Sheet Bent Portion Fatigue Crack Growth Suppressing Method>
[0026] A metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method according to the first embodiment of the present invention is a method of suppressing the growth of a fatigue crack generated in a bent portion 3 formed by bending a metal sheet 1. Specifically, the method includes, as illustrated in
[0027] In addition, in the present first embodiment, as illustrated in
[0028] The reason why the metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method according to the present first embodiment suppresses the growth of a crack generated on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 in the valley line direction will be described based on the results of examination on a stress intensity factor at the tip of a crack generated on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 of the metal sheet 1 illustrated in
[0029]
[0030]
[0031] In the above Formula, t is a tensile stress; c is a bending stress; a is a length of a crack surface in a depth direction (sheet thickness direction); c is a length of the crack surface in a lateral direction (distance from a crack generation site to a crack tip in the lateral direction); b is a width of the metal sheet 1; t is a sheet thickness of the bent portion 3 (on the metal sheet 1); is an angle formed by a straight line L, being a line connecting the crack generation site and the crack tip, and the surface of the bent portion 3; and H(a, c, t, ), Q(a,c), and F(a, c, b, t, ) are functions given by individual variables (refer to the above known Literatures).
[0032] In
[0033] From the graph illustrated in
[0034] Here, based on the above examination result, a concept of suppressing the growth of the crack generated on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 in the valley line direction (lateral direction) will be described. Assuming that the growth of the crack in the depth direction stops at a position of about of the sheet thickness t, a length a of the crack surface in the depth direction is expressed as a t/4. Accordingly, when the crack surface ratio c/a=2, a relationship of 2ct is established. On assumption that the crack grows symmetrically in the lateral direction, 2c is a width of the crack surface in the lateral direction. Accordingly, it can be seen that the width (=2c) of the crack surface in the lateral direction when the crack surface ratio c/a=2 is substantially the same as the sheet thickness t of the metal sheet 1.
[0035] That is, when the purpose is to prevent or suppress fatigue fracture due to growth in the valley line direction (lateral direction) of a crack generated on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3, while the growth of the crack in the depth direction stops at the position of of the sheet thickness t and the width (=2c) of the crack surface in the lateral direction is equal to or less than the sheet thickness t in the process in which the crack further grows only in the lateral direction, it is considered that the stress intensity factor K(0) in the lateral direction is larger than the stress intensity factor K(90) in the depth direction and that the driving force of the crack propagation in the lateral direction is large. Therefore, stopping the crack propagation in the region is considered to be difficult.
[0036] However, in the region (region Q) where the crack grows to some extent and the width (=2c) of the crack surface in the lateral direction spreads to the sheet thickness t or more, the stress intensity factor K(0) is smaller than the stress intensity factor K(90) in the depth direction, and gradually decreases with an increase in the absolute value of the crack surface ratio c/a. Therefore, it is considered that the driving force of the crack propagation is also small in the region, and the crack propagation is to be stopped easily in this region.
[0037] Therefore, by allowing the growth of the crack in the region Q in which the stress intensity factor K(0) in the lateral direction is low, rather than stopping the growth of the crack in the region P in which the stress intensity factor K(0) in the lateral direction is high as compared with the depth direction, it is considered to be able to stop or suppress the crack with a compressive residual stress lower than that in the region P.
[0038]
[0039] In this manner, by forming the indentation band 9 at the interval d, which is the sheet thickness t or more, in the valley line direction of the bent portion 3 and applying the compressive residual stress, it is possible to suppress the growth of the crack in the valley line direction.
[0040] In the present first embodiment, the compressive residual stress of the bent portion 3 is generated by forming the indentation band 9, which is a series of the indentations 7, on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 by the needle peening treatment using the impact pin and applying plastic strain thereto as described above, in which a radius of curvature r of the tip 13 of the impact pin 11, in a cross section orthogonal to the valley line direction, is preferably equal to or less than the radius of curvature R of the bent portion 3.
[0041] This is because, in a case where the radius of curvature r of the tip 13 of the impact pin 11 is larger than the radius of curvature R of the bent portion 3, the bent portion 3 cannot be directly impacted by the tip 13 of the impact pin 11, making it difficult to appropriately generate the compressive residual stress in the bent portion 3.
[0042] Incidentally, there may be, in a part of the bend inner side of the bent portion 3, an occurrence of buckling deformation during bending, in which the radius of curvature can be locally extremely small. However, the radius of curvature R of the bent portion 3 may be defined as a macroscopic radius of curvature except for a case where the radius of curvature of the bent portion 3 is globally changed by buckling.
[0043] Furthermore, regarding the deformation of the bent portion 3 and the surroundings thereof in the metal sheet 1 due to the impact load of the impact pin and regarding the expansion of the bending angle of the bent portion 3 in a case where the radius of curvature of the impact pin 11 is larger than the radius of curvature of the bent portion 3, which are problems in the technique in Patent Literature 4 described above, the present first embodiment has a configuration in which the impact is performed by the impact pin 11 having the radius of curvature r smaller than the radius of curvature on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3, making it possible to suppress the deformation of the metal sheet 1 and the change in the bending angle of the bent portion 3 and possible to appropriately introduce the compressive residual stress to the bent portion 3.
[0044] In addition, the range in which the indentation band 9 is to be formed in the direction orthogonal to the valley line direction on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 may be set to all or a part of the range from the bending start point to the bending end point on the bend inner side. Here, the bending start point and the bending end point refer to bend R stops on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3.
[0045] At this time, when the crack generation position is obvious due to cracks and wrinkles in the width direction of the bent portion 3, stress conditions applied to the metal sheet, or the like, there is no need to perform treatment over the entire range of the bent portion 3 in the valley line direction on the bend inner side, and it is only required to generate compressive residual stress by forming the indentation band 9 only in the neighboring portion of the crack generation position and applying plastic strain.
[0046] The upper limit of the interval d of the indentation bands 9 in the valley line direction on the bend inner side of the bent portion 3 is not particularly defined, and may be determined based on the lifespan required for a part formed by bending a metal sheet, or the allowable crack length such as a length of crack allowable as a part and the lower limit of the crack length that can be found in periodic inspection.
[0047] Note that the present invention may include needle peening treatment performed simultaneously with a plurality of impact pins, and further improvement in productivity can be expected when combined with an automatic implementation method using a robot arm or the like. Furthermore, in the case of a part having a large number of bent portions, such as an automotive part, applying this treatment to the entire region of the bent portion would deteriorate productivity. Therefore, it is preferable, in this case, to limit application only to a location where the radius of curvature of the bent portion is small or a location where fatigue fracture on the bend inner side is likely to occur as a result of a fatigue test, stress analysis, or the like, performed in advance.
[0048] Furthermore, the present invention can be sufficiently applied with generation, in the bent portion, of the compressive residual stress capable of suppressing the growth of the crack in the valley line direction of the bent portion. Therefore, the method of generating the compressive residual stress is not limited to needle peening, and similar treatment may be performed by a method such as laser peening, shot peening, or cold spray. In the case of shot peening, masking is performed at a position other than a position where it is desired to introduce an indentation so as not to cause unnecessary plastic deformation, whereby similar effects can be obtained. These methods are methods in which plastic strain is applied to a material to generate compressive residual stress. Specifically, laser peening uses a shock wave during laser irradiation, while shot peening and cold spraying use projection of a projection material to give an impact to a bent portion, thereby applying plastic strain to the bent portion.
[0049] When the bending of the metal sheet is performed not as pure bending but with tensile and compression in the axial direction, there will be a shift in the position in the sheet thickness direction into which the compressive residual stress is introduced, but also in this case, the crack will stop at the position where the compressive residual stress is present. Therefore, when the position of the compressive residual stress does not greatly differ from the position of the sheet thickness t, implementation may be performed under the condition that the relationship between a depth a of the compressive residual stress and a length c of the crack surface in the lateral direction satisfies 2c>4a.
[0050] When the position in the depth direction where the compressive residual stress is introduced greatly deviates from the position of the sheet thickness due to springback, recalculation may be performed by the above method, and the interval d at which the needle peening treatment is to be performed may be determined based on the value of c/a at which K(0) decreases.
[0051] As described above, according to the present invention, the fatigue life of the part having the bent portion formed by bending a metal sheet can be effectively improved. Furthermore, according to the present invention, it is not necessary to perform the peening treatment on the entire surface on the bend inner side of the bent portion. This leads to improvement in productivity and the effect of improving the fatigue life due to the compressive residual stress and work hardening due to the local plastic strain applied on the bend inner side.
[0052] Still further, according to the present invention, even with no occurrence of cracks on the bend inner side of the bent portion, it is still possible to have an effect of reducing microscopic stress concentration because there is an effect of smoothing microscopic irregularities such as wrinkles. In addition, by using the impact pin having a tip with a small radius of curvature, it is possible to reduce the impact load required for deforming the metal sheet to form the indentation band. This makes it possible to perform stable implementation by suppressing the reaction force, leading to achievement of not only suppression of macroscopic deformation of the entire part being a possible concern when the method described in Patent Literature 4 is applied to a part having a bent portion of a metal sheet, but also application of the method to a production line using a robot arm or the like.
[0053] In addition, the present invention makes it possible to eliminate the possibility of insufficient performance of impact due to insufficient contact of the impact pin with the surface on the bend inner side of the bent portion. Furthermore, in application of the present invention to the manufacture of an automotive part, there is no need to use an additional press mold for performing bending work, unlike the method described in Patent Literature 1, application is possible to a burring portion as in the method described in Patent Literature 2, and furthermore, there is no need to use a scattering preventing container required for a shot peening treatment as in the method described in Patent Literature 3.
Second Embodiment
<Automotive Part>
[0054] As illustrated in
[0055] Also in the automotive part according to the present second embodiment, similarly to the metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method according to the first embodiment of the present invention described above, it is possible to suppress the growth of the crack in the valley line direction on the bend inner side of the bent portion by the compressive residual stress generated by the indentation band by the needle peening treatment at an interval equal to or larger than the sheet thickness of the metal sheet in the valley line direction, improving the fatigue life.
[0056] Although the plastic strain applied to the bent portion is obtained by the needle peening treatment in the automotive part according to the present second embodiment, the plastic strain to be applied to the bent portion in the automotive part according to the present invention is not limited to the plastic strain obtained by the needle peening treatment, and may be the plastic strain obtained by a treatment such as laser peening, shot peening, or cold spraying.
Example
[0057] An experiment performed for confirming operational effects of the present invention will be described below.
[0058] In the present Example, a fatigue test was performed on a fatigue test piece 21 illustrated in
[0059] A hot rolled steel sheet having a sheet thickness of 2.9 mm and a yield strength of 850 MPa class was cut out into 200 mm50 mm as a sample. The sample was bent using a press brake (bending machine) including a bending tool (punch) having a tip radius of curvature 3 mm to prepare a fatigue test piece 21. The fatigue test piece 21 includes: a bent portion 23 of a bend inner side bending radius R=2 mm and a sheet thickness t=2.8 mm; and piece portions 25a and 25b extending from both end sides of the bent portion 23, in which holes 27a and 27b each having a diameter 8.5 mm were provided in the piece portions 25a and 25b, respectively.
[0060] Next, as illustrated in
[0061] Subsequently, needle peening treatment was applied on the bent portion 23 of the fatigue test piece 21, and then the fatigue test piece 21 was subjected to a fatigue test under the boundary condition illustrated in
[0062] Thereafter, a penetrant inspection test of the bent portion 23 was performed every 10,000 load input cycles to measure the growth of a crack generated in the bent portion 23. The fatigue test piece in which the grown crack passed through two or more indentation bands 29 was determined to be unacceptable because of the crack growth, and the fatigue test was terminated. In addition, with the number of cycles of the cyclic load of 500,000 times set as a fatigue limit, the fatigue test piece 21 that reached the fatigue limit was determined to be acceptable, and the fatigue test was terminated.
[0063] In the present Example, the fatigue test was performed on the fatigue test piece 21 in which the interval d of the indentation bands 29 was varied, and the fatigue test pieces 21 having intervals d of 3 mm, 4 mm, and 5 mm, which are equal to or larger than the sheet thickness of the metal sheet 1 within the scope of the present invention, were defined as Invention Example 1, Invention Example 2, and Invention Example 3, respectively. For comparison, a test piece having the interval d=2 mm of indentation band 29, which is outside the scope of the present invention, was defined as Comparative Example 1. Table 1 indicates the interval d of the indentation bands 29 formed in the fatigue test piece 21 and the fatigue test results.
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Cycles at which Interval fatigue test Acceptable/ d (mm) terminated Unacceptable Comparative Example 1 2 200,000 Unacceptable Invention Example 1 3 500,000 or more Acceptable Invention Example 2 4 500,000 or more Acceptable Invention Example 3 5 500,000 or more Acceptable
[0064] In Comparative Example 1, the growth of the crack passed through two or more indentation bands 29 at 200,000 cycles, the test piece was determined to be unacceptable. In contrast, in all of Invention Examples 1 to 3, even at 500,000 cycles, the growth of the crack passing through the two or more indentation bands 29 was not observed before reaching the fatigue limit, and the corresponding test pieces were determined to be acceptable.
[0065] As described above, according to the present invention, it has been demonstrated to be able to suppress the growth of fatigue cracks on the bend inner side of the bent portion formed by bending a metal sheet, and able to improve the fatigue life.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0066] The present invention can provide a metal sheet bent portion fatigue crack growth suppressing method, which is capable of suppressing the growth of a fatigue crack of a bent portion, applicable to the bent portion after being bent without increasing the manufacturing cost of the bending of the metal sheet, without deteriorating the productivity and without changing the bending angle of the entire part or the bent portion, and provide an automotive part including a bent portion formed by bending the metal sheet, and capable of suppressing the growth of the fatigue crack in the bent portion.
REFERENCE SIGNS LIST
[0067] 1 METAL SHEET [0068] 3 BENT PORTION [0069] 3a BENDING START POINT [0070] 3b BENDING END POINT [0071] 5 CRACK [0072] 7 INDENTATION [0073] 9 INDENTATION BAND [0074] 11 IMPACT PIN [0075] 13 TIP [0076] 21 FATIGUE TEST PIECE [0077] 23 BENT PORTION [0078] 25a, 25b PIECE PORTION [0079] 27a, 27b HOLE [0080] 29 INDENTATION BAND