Coated member and method of manufacturing the same
11608303 · 2023-03-21
Assignee
Inventors
- Mineaki Matsumoto (Tokyo, JP)
- Takayuki Kurimura (Tokyo, JP)
- Kosuke Nishikawa (Tokyo, JP)
- Tadayuki Hanada (Aichi, JP)
Cpc classification
F05D2300/211
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F01D5/288
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F05D2300/6033
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
C04B41/52
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B41/522
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B2111/0025
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B41/522
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B2103/0021
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C23C28/04
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B41/52
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C23C4/02
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
F05D2300/502
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
C04B41/89
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B32B18/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
F01D5/282
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Y02T50/60
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
C04B35/80
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C23C28/042
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B2103/0021
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B35/80
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
F01D5/284
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
International classification
C04B41/89
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C04B41/00
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B32B18/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C04B41/52
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C23C4/02
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Abstract
Provided are a coated member in which damage of a coating film can be suppressed in a high temperature environment and the coating may be performed at low cost, and a method of manufacturing the same. A coated member includes a bond coat and a top coat sequentially laminated on a substrate made of a Si-based ceramic or a SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite, wherein the top coat includes a layer composed of a mixed phase of a (Y.sub.1-aLn.sub.1a).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.1 is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd) and Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-bLn.sub.1′.sub.b).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.1′ is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd), or a mixed phase of a (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.2 is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu) and Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-dLn.sub.2′.sub.d).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.2′ is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu).
Claims
1. A coated member comprising: a bond coat and a top coat sequentially laminated on a substrate made of a silicon (Si)-based ceramic or a SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite, wherein the bond coat is consist of at least one of silicide or mullite, the top coat includes a first layer composed of a mixed phase of a rare earth disilicate and a rare earth monosilicate, the rare earth disilicate being a (Y.sub.1-aLn.sub.1a).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.1 is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd, a is 0.1 or more and 0.5 or less when Ln.sub.1 is Nd, Sm, or Eu, and a is 0.2 or more and 0.5 or less when Ln.sub.1 is Gd), and the rare earth monosilicate being Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-bLn.sub.1′b).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.1′ is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd, and b is more than 0 and equal to or less than 0.5).
2. A coated member comprising: a bond coat and a top coat sequentially laminated on a substrate made of a Si-based ceramic or a SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite, wherein the bond coat is consist of at least one of silicide or mullite, the top coat includes a first layer composed of a mixed phase of a rare earth disilicate and a rare earth monosilicate, the rare earth disilicate being a (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.2 is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu, when Ln.sub.2 is Sc, c is 0.05 or more and 0.5 or less, and when Ln.sub.2 is Yb or Lu, c is 0.1 or more and 0.5 or less), and the rare earth monosilicate being Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-dLn.sub.2′d).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, Ln.sub.2′ is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu, and d is more than 0 and equal to or less than 0.5).
3. The coated member of claim 1, wherein the top coat has a second layer on the first layer, and the second layer is made of Re.sub.2SiO.sub.5 (here, Re is a rare earth element).
4. The coated member of claim 1, wherein a difference between a thermal expansion coefficient of the substrate on which the bond coat is laminated and a thermal expansion coefficient of the first layer is 3×10.sup.−6/K or less.
5. The coated member of claim 3, wherein a difference between a thermal expansion coefficient of the first layer and a thermal expansion coefficient of the second layer is 3×10.sup.−6/K or less.
6. The coated member of claim 2, wherein the top coat has a second layer on the first layer, and the second layer is made of Re.sub.2SiO.sub.5 (here, Re is a rare earth element).
7. The coated member of claim 2, wherein a difference between a thermal expansion coefficient of the substrate on which the bond coat is laminated and a thermal expansion coefficient of the first layer is 3×10.sup.−6/K or less.
8. The coated member of claim 4, wherein a difference between a thermal expansion coefficient of the first layer and a thermal expansion coefficient of the second layer is 3×10.sup.−6/K or less.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
First Embodiment
(8)
(9) The substrate 101 is a turbine member of an aircraft engine, or a gas turbine member for power generation such as a shroud, a combustion liner, or the like. The substrate 101 is made of a silicon (Si)-based ceramic or a SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite (CMC). The Si-based ceramic is a ceramic containing Si such as SiC, Si.sub.3N.sub.4, or the like. The SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite is a matrix composite in which SiC fiber is used as reinforcing fiber and SiC is used as a matrix.
(10) The bond coat 102 is formed on a surface of the substrate 101. The bond coat 102 is to secure good adhesion between the substrate 101 and the top coat 103. The bond coat 102 is made of silicide such as Si, MoSi.sub.2, LuSi.sub.2, or the like, mullite (3Al.sub.2O.sub.3-2SiO.sub.2), barium strontium aluminosilicate (BSAS, (Ba.sub.1-xSr.sub.x)O—Al.sub.2O.sub.3—SiO.sub.2), or the like. The bond coat 102 can be made of one of the above-mentioned materials or formed by laminating a plurality of materials. A thickness of the bond coat 102 is 20 μm or more and 200 μm or less.
(11) The bond coat 102 is formed by a spray method, a sintering method, or the like.
(12) The top coat 103 is formed on the bond coat 102. The top coat 103 according to the present embodiment is composed of a mixed phase of a rare earth disilicate and a rare earth monosilicate. A thickness of the top coat 103 is 20 μm or more and 400 μm or less.
(13)
(14) An ionic radius of Y.sup.3+ is 0.90 Å, and referring to
(15) In the case in which a rare earth element has an ionic radius larger than that of Y, there is a boundary between an a phase and a γ phase as illustrated in
(16) In order to allow an average ionic radius to be larger than that of Y, Y is substituted with a rare earth element having an ionic radius larger than that of Y. As a difference in ionic radius between a rare earth element and Y is increased, an effect of changing an average ionic radius of the rare earth elements is increased. Therefore, it is advantageous to select an element having an ionic radius larger than that of Gd in
(17) Table 1 illustrates a substitution amount of a substitution element (Gd, Eu, Sm, or Nd) in the (Y.sub.1-aLn.sub.1).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution and an average ionic radius of the rare earth elements.
(18) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Substitution Element a Nd Sm Eu Gd 0 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.1 0.908 0.906 0.905 0.9038 0.2 0.917 0.912 0.909 0.9076 0.3 0.925 0.917 0.914 0.9114 0.4 0.933 0.923 0.919 0.9152 0.5 0.942 0.929 0.924 0.919
(19) According to Table 1, the average ionic radius is to be 0.905 Å or more if a is 0.1 or more for Nd, Sm, or Eu, and 0.2 or more for Gd. That is, when a is equal to or higher than the above-mentioned range, the coated member can withstand an operation temperature up to 1300° C.
(20) Further, according to Table 1, the average ionic radius is to be 0.91 Å or more if a is 0.2 or more for Nd or Sm, and 0.3 or more for Eu or Gd. That is, when a is equal to or higher than the above-mentioned range, the coated member can withstand an operation temperature up to 1400° C.
(21) Meanwhile, if a is large, an amount of the substitution element is increased. Therefore, in consideration of raw material cost, cost for substitution is increased by using Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd, which are expensive elements. Therefore, there is an upper limit in the substitution amount of Nd, Sm, Eu, or Gd. In detail, it is preferable that an upper limit of a is 0.5.
(22) Referring to
(23) In the (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution in which Y is substituted with a separate rare earth element, an average ionic radius of rare earth elements (Y and Ln.sub.2) is changed depending on a substitution amount. In order to allow the average ionic radius to be smaller than that of Y, Y is substituted with a rare earth element having an ionic radius smaller than that of Y. Referring to
(24) Table 2 illustrates a substitution amount of a substitution element (Sc, Yb, or Lu) in the (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution and an average ionic radius of the rare earth elements.
(25) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Substitution Element c Sc Yb Lu 0 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.05 0.892 0.898 0.898 0.1 0.885 0.897 0.897 0.2 0.869 0.894 0.894 0.3 0.854 0.89 0.89 0.4 0.838 0.887 0.887 0.5 0.823 0.884 0.884
(26) According to Table 2, the average ionic radius is to be 0.897 Å or less if c is 0.05 or more for Sc, and 0.1 or more for Yb or Lu. That is, when c is equal to or higher than the above-mentioned range, the coated member can withstand an operation temperature of 1300° C.
(27) Further, according to Table 2, the average ionic radius is to be 0.885 Å or less if c is 0.1 or more for Sc, and 0.5 or more for Yb or Lu. That is, when c is equal to or higher than the above-mentioned range, the coated member can withstand an operation temperature of 1400° C. or more.
(28) Meanwhile, if c is large, an amount of the substitution element is increased. Therefore, in consideration of raw material cost, cost for substitution is increased by using Sc, Yb, and Lu, which are expensive elements. Therefore, there is an upper limit in the substitution amount of Sc, Yb, or Lu. In detail, it is preferable that an upper limit of c is 0.5.
(29) When the rare earth disilicate is (Y.sub.1-aLn.sub.1a).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7, the rare earth monosilicate according to the present embodiment is Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-bLn.sub.1′.sub.b).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, b>0). It is preferable that the substitution element Ln.sub.1′ of Y is the same as the substitution element of the rare earth disilicate. In detail, Ln.sub.1′ is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd.
(30) As the rare earth monosilicate, Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 (substitution amount b=0) can also be used, but in order to prevent concentrations of the rare earth element from being changed by interdiffusion with the rare earth disilicate, (Y.sub.1-aLn.sub.1a).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7, coexisting in the mixed phase, it is preferable that the substitution amount b is the same as the substitution amount a of the rare earth disilicate. Therefore, the upper limit of the substitution amount b is 0.5. It is preferable that when the substitution element is Nd, Sm, or Eu, a lower limit of the substitution amount b is 0.1, and when the substitution element is Gd, the lower limit of the substitution amount b is 0.2.
(31) When the rare earth disilicate is (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7, the rare earth monosilicate is Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a (Y.sub.1-dLn.sub.2′.sub.d).sub.2SiO.sub.5 solid solution (here, d>0). It is preferable that the substitution element Ln.sub.2′ of Y is the same as the substitution element of the rare earth disilicate. In detail, Ln.sub.2′ is any one of Yb, Lu, and Sc.
(32) As the rare earth monosilicate, Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 (substitution amount d=0) can also be used, but in order to prevent concentrations of the rare earth elements from being changed by interdiffusion with the rare earth disilicate, (Y.sub.1-cLn.sub.2c).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7, coexisting in the mixed phase, it is preferable that the substitution amount d is the same as the substitution amount c of the rare earth disilicate. Therefore, the upper limit of the substitution amount d is 0.5. It is preferable that when the substitution element is Sc, a lower limit of the substitution amount d is 0.05, and when the substitution element is Yb or Lu, the lower limit of the substitution amount d is 0.1.
(33) The top coat 103 is formed by a spray method. In the present embodiment, as spray particles, particles made of a mixture of rare earth disilicate powder and rare earth monosilicate powder are used.
(34) The spray particles are prepared by the following method. First, particles of the rare earth disilicate solid solution having the above mentioned composition are prepared. As raw material powders, SiO.sub.2 powder, Y.sub.2O.sub.3 powder, [Ln.sub.1].sub.2O.sub.3 powder (here, Ln.sub.1 is any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd), [Ln.sub.2].sub.2O.sub.3 powder (here, Ln.sub.2 is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu) are weighed and mixed with each other so as to have a predetermined composition. Alternatively, Y.sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 powder and Ln.sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 powder (here, Ln is any one of Sc, Yb, and Lu or any one of Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd) are weighed and mixed with each other so as to have a predetermined composition.
(35) Solid solution formation by heat-treatment can be promoted by using fine powders having a particle size of 1 μm or less as the raw material powders. Therefore, it is possible to decrease a heat-treatment time while removing unreacted particles.
(36) A solid solution powder is obtained by performing heat-treatment on the mixed powders. As a method of preparing the solid solution powder, there is a method of performing heat-treatment at 1300° C. or more using an electric furnace, a method of performing plasma heat-treatment, a method of melting the raw material powders and grinding the obtained melt, or the like.
(37) The rare earth monosilicates represented by Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5, (Y.sub.1-bLn.sub.1′.sub.b).sub.2SiO.sub.5 (solid solution), and (Y.sub.1-eLn.sub.2′.sub.d).sub.2SiO.sub.5 (solid solution) are also prepared by the same method as described above.
(38) The rare earth disilicate powder and the rare earth monosilicate powder prepared by the above-mentioned method are weighed and granulated so as to have a predetermined composition ratio. The particles obtained as described above are classified, and particles having a size of 10 μm to 200 μm are used as the spray particles.
(39) Spray powders of Y.sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7, a (Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution, a (Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 solid solution were prepared. Further, a spray coating film was manufactured using these powders.
(40) The manufactured spray coating film was heat treated at 1300° C. for 100 hours and at 1400° C. for 100 hours, and a change in crystal phase was determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD). As illustrated in
(41) Meanwhile,
(42) Meanwhile,
(43) The mixing ratio of the rare earth disilicate powder and the rare earth monosilicate powder is determined in consideration of a thermal expansion coefficient of the top coat. In the coated member 100 according to the present embodiment corresponding to a laminate, when a difference in thermal expansion coefficient between the top coat 103 and a base of the top coat 103 is large, thermal stress is generated in the top coat 103. Cracks, or the like, can occur in the top coat 103 due to thermal stress generated in the top coat 103 by repeating operation and stop of equipment (aircraft engine or gas turbine).
(44) In order to alleviate thermal stress in the top coat 103, it is preferable that the difference between the thermal expansion coefficient of the top coat 103 and the thermal expansion coefficient of the substrate 101 including the bond coat 102, which is the base of the top coat 103, is 3×10.sup.−6/K or less (at room temperature to 1200° C.). In order to allow the difference in the thermal expansion coefficient to be in the above-mentioned range, the mixing ratio of the rare earth disilicate and the rare earth monosilicate is determined depending on the kind of substrate, the kind of rare earth disilicate, and the kind of rare earth monosilicate. At the time of preparing the spray powder, the raw material powders are weighed and mixed with each other so as to have the mixing ratio.
(45)
(46) The thermal expansion coefficient of the rare earth monosilicate is larger than that of the rare earth disilicate. Therefore, as illustrated in
(47) A top coat 103 having excellent steam resistance and thermal cycle durability can be obtained by mixing the rare earth disilicate having a thermal expansion coefficient relatively close to that of the substrate and the rare earth monosilicate having excellent steam resistance to form the solid solution as described above. A composition of the top coat 103 can be uniform by forming the top coat 103 using the spray particles made of the solid solution in advance. Since in the top coat 103, the rare earth disilicate does not remain in an un-reacted state, excellent steam resistance can be secured.
Second Embodiment
(48)
(49) The substrate 201 and the bond coat 202 are made of the same materials as those in the first embodiments. A first layer 204 of the top coat 203 is made of the same material as that of the top coat 103 according to the first embodiment, and has the same film thickness as that of the top coat 103 according to the first embodiment.
(50) The second layer 205 of the top coat 203 is made of a rare earth monosilicate represented by Re.sub.2SiO.sub.5. Re is one of rare earth elements or a plurality of rare earth elements can be selected. For example, the second layer 205 can be made of Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5, Yb.sub.2SiO.sub.5, Lu.sub.2SiO.sub.5, (Y, Yb).sub.2SiO.sub.5, (Y, Lu).sub.2SiO.sub.5, or the like. Considering raw material cost, it is preferable that the second layer 205 is made of Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 or a composite oxide, (Y, Re′).sub.2SiO.sub.5 (here, Re′ is another rare earth element except for Y) in which Y is partially substituted with another rare earth element. In view of preventing concentrations of rare earth elements from being changed by interdiffusion with the first layer 204, it is preferable that a substitution element Re′ is selected from Yb, Lu, Sc, Nd, Sm, Eu, and Gd. Particularly, it is preferable that the substitution element Re′ is the same material as the rare earth element contained in the first layer 204. Considering raw material cost, it is preferable that a substitution amount of Re′ is 0.5 or less.
(51) The second layer 205 is formed by a spray method similarly to the first layer 204. A thickness of the second layer 205 is 50 μm or more and 300 μm or less.
(52) In the case of applying the composite oxide containing a rare earth element selected from the plurality of rare earth elements to the second layer 205, particles solid-solubilized by heat-treatment after weighing and mixing raw material powders so as to have a predetermined substitution ratio can be used as the spray particles. In this way, uniformity of the composition in the second layer 205 is secured.
(53) In the present embodiment, it is preferable that a difference in thermal expansion coefficient between the first layer 204 and a base (the substrate 201 including the bond coat 202) is 3×10.sup.−6/K (at room temperature to 1200° C.). It is preferable that a difference in thermal expansion coefficient between the first layer 204 and the second layer 205 is 3×10.sup.−6/K (at room temperature to 1200° C.)
(54) As described in the first embodiment, the material of the substrate 201 (and the bond coat 202), the kinds of rare earth monosilicate and rare earth disilicate and a mixing ratio therebetween in the first layer 204, and the material of the second layer 205 are selected so that the respective layers can satisfy the differences in thermal expansion coefficient.
(55) Damage by steam erosion under a high temperature environment can be prevented by allowing the top coat 203 to be composed of two layers and forming a layer of the rare earth monosilicate having excellent steam resistance in an outermost layer as in the present embodiment.
(56) {Example}
(57) Tables 3 and 4 illustrate examples of coated members using a SiC fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composite (Tyrannohex, Ube Industries, Ltd., thermal expansion coefficient: 4×10.sup.−6/K (at room temperature to 1200° C.) as a substrate. Further, a difference in thermal expansion coefficient between a first layer and a base (a substrate including a bond coat) (at room temperature to 1200° C.), and a difference in thermal expansion coefficient between first and second layers (at room temperature to 1200° C.) are illustrated in Tables 3 and 4.
(58) TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Example 1 Example 2 Example 3 Example 4 Example 5 Top Coat Second Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 — Layer First 0.2(Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.5(Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.2(Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.5(Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.5(Y.sub.0.8Yb.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + Layer 0.8Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.5Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.8Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.5Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.5Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 (Molar Ratio) Bond Coat Si Si Si Si Si Difference in 1.3 2.5 1 2.2 — Thermal Expansion Coefficient between First and Second Layers (×10.sup.−6/K) Difference in 2 0.86 2 0.86 0.86 Thermal Expansion Coefficient between First and Base Layers (×10.sup.−6/K)
(59) TABLE-US-00004 TABLE 4 Comparative Comparative Example 6 Example 7 Example 8 Example 1 Example 2 Top Coat Second Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Gd.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 — Layer First 0.2(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.5(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + 0.2(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 + Y.sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.7 Y.sub.2SiO.sub.5 Layer 0.8(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.5(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2SiO.sub.5 0.8(Y.sub.0.8Gd.sub.0.2).sub.2SiO.sub.5 (Molar Ratio) Bond Coat Si Si Si Si Si Difference in 1.3 2.6 2.6 3.7 — Thermal Expansion Coefficient between First and Second Layers (×10.sup.−6/K) Difference in 2.2 0.9 2.2 0.3 3.4 Thermal Expansion Coefficient between First Layer and Base (×10.sup.−6/K)
(60) As illustrated in Tables 3 and 4, since in Examples 1 to 8, differences in thermal expansion coefficients between the respective layers were 3×10.sup.−6/K or less, thermal stress in the top coat was alleviated. Therefore, thermal cycle durability can be improved as compared in Comparative Examples 1 and 2 in which the difference in thermal expansion coefficient was more than 3×10.sup.−6/K.