Method and apparatus for sensing a fault in a power system
09667058 ยท 2017-05-30
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
G01R31/085
PHYSICS
G01R31/52
PHYSICS
G01R19/2513
PHYSICS
International classification
Abstract
A method in a power system which includes a protected unit, such as a transmission line, adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors. A first travelling wave differential current (ITWdiff) is determined based on a comparison between a determined first travelling wave current or a second travelling wave current in first and second positions and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively. The estimation is carried out using a propagation function which takes into account any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the protected unit. A second or normalized travelling wave differential current (ITWdiff) is determined by means of, based on the propagation function, adjusting at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics. The method may facilitate or enable mitigating or even eliminating any false differential current in elements of a travelling wave differential current vector which correspond to healthy conductors, caused by coupling effects between conductors.
Claims
1. A method in a power system including a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors, wherein on a condition that a fault occurs in the protected unit, at least one travelling wave is generated in the protected unit, wherein any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the protected unit can be modeled by means of a propagation function, the method comprising the steps of: determining a first travelling wave current in the first position and a second travelling wave current in the second position; and determining a first travelling wave differential current based on a comparison between the determined first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively, wherein the estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current is carried out by applying the propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively, wherein the first travelling wave differential current has a plurality of modes corresponding to respective ones of the plurality of conductors, the method further comprising the step of: determining a second travelling wave differential current by means of, based on the propagation function, adjusting at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics.
2. The method according to claim 1, further comprising step of: based on the first travelling wave differential current, identifying a mode of the first travelling wave differential current having a largest propagation delay, wherein the adjustment of at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics is based on the propagation function for the identified mode.
3. The method according to claim 2, wherein identifying a mode of the first travelling wave differential current mode having a largest propagation delay based on the first travelling wave differential current comprises the step of comparing eigenvalues associated with the modes of the first travelling wave differential current.
4. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the step of adjusting at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal arrival times at the first or second position and/or evolvement as a function of time.
5. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the step of: determining a third travelling wave differential current based on a combination of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current.
6. The method according to claim 5, wherein each of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current comprises a plurality of elements, and wherein the third travelling wave differential current is determined by means of element-by-element multiplication of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current.
7. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the steps of: on a condition that the first travelling wave current is estimated, determining a time when the first travelling wave current was determined; on a condition that the second travelling wave current is estimated, determining a time when the second travelling wave current was determined; determining a time-shift function based on the determined time and a propagation time period of a wave travelling from the first position to the second position, or vice versa, wherein the estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current is carried out by applying the time-shift function to the propagation function so as to obtain a time-shifted propagation function and applying the time-shifted propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively.
8. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the steps of: sensing at least one first current and at least one first voltage, respectively, in the first position; and sensing at least one second current and at least one second voltage, respectively, in the second position, wherein the first travelling wave current is determined based on the at least one first current and the at least one first voltage, and the second travelling wave current is determined based on the at least one second current and the at least one second voltage.
9. The method according to claim 8, wherein: sensing of the at least one second current and the at least one second voltage, respectively, is performed subsequent to sensing the at least one first current and the at least one first voltage, respectively, or vice versa; sensing of the at least one first current is performed simultaneously with sensing of the at least one first voltage; and/or sensing of the at least one second current is performed simultaneously with sensing of the at least one second voltage.
10. The method according to claim 8, further comprising the steps of: on a condition that the first travelling wave current is estimated, determining a time when the first travelling wave current was determined; on a condition that the second travelling wave current is estimated, determining a time when the second travelling wave current was determined; determining a time-shift function based on the determined time and a propagation time period of a wave travelling from the first position to the second position, or vice versa, wherein the estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current is carried out by applying the time-shift function to the propagation function so as to obtain a time-shifted propagation function and applying the time-shifted propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively, and wherein the time when the first travelling wave current was determined is based on a time when the at least one first current and the at least one first voltage, respectively, was sensed and the time when the second travelling wave current was determined is based on a time when the at least one second current and the at least one second voltage, respectively, was sensed.
11. The method according to claim 1, wherein the determination of the first travelling wave current and/or the second travelling wave current is based on an estimated surge admittance of the protected unit.
12. A processing module for use in a power system including a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors, wherein on a condition that a fault occurs in the protected unit at least one travelling wave is generated in the protected unit, wherein any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the protected unit can be modeled by means of a propagation function, the processing module being configured to: determine a first travelling wave current in the first position and a second travelling wave current in the second position; determine a first travelling wave differential current based on a comparison between the determined first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively; estimate the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current by applying the propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively, wherein the first travelling wave differential current has a plurality of modes corresponding to respective ones of the plurality of conductors; and determine a second travelling wave differential current by means of, based on the propagation function, adjustment of at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics.
13. The processing module according to claim 12, wherein the processing module is configured to receive the first travelling wave current and the second travelling wave current from a travelling wave current sensing module included in the power system configured to determine a first travelling wave current in the first position and a second travelling wave current in the second position, whereby the first travelling wave current and the second travelling wave current are determined by the processing module by receipt of first travelling wave current and the second travelling wave current from the travelling wave current sensing module.
14. The processing module according to claim 12, wherein the processing module is configured to determine a third travelling wave differential current based on a combination of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current.
15. The processing module according to claim 14, wherein each of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current comprises a plurality of elements, and wherein the processing module is configured to determine the third travelling wave differential current by means of element-by-element multiplication of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current.
16. A fault sensing system for a power system including a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors, wherein on a condition that a fault occurs in the protected unit at least one travelling wave is generated in the protected unit, wherein the fault sensing system is adapted to sense a fault in the protected unit, the fault sensing system comprising: the processing module according to claim 12, wherein a second travelling wave differential current as determined by the processing module has a plurality of elements, each element corresponding to a respective one of the plurality of conductors, and wherein the fault sensing system is configured to compare at least some of the elements of the second travelling wave differential current with respect to a fault sensing criterion, and on a condition that an element complies with the fault sensing criterion, determine that there is a fault in the conductor corresponding to that element.
17. The fault sensing system according to claim 16, wherein the processing module is configured to determine a third travelling wave differential current based on a combination of the first travelling wave differential current and the second travelling wave differential current, and wherein the third travelling wave differential current as determined by the processing module has a plurality of elements, each element corresponding to a respective one of the plurality of conductors, the fault sensing system being configured to assess at least some of the elements of the third travelling wave differential current with respect to a fault sensing criterion, and on a condition that an element complies with the fault sensing criterion, determine that there is a fault in the conductor corresponding to that element.
18. The fault sensing system according to claim 17, wherein the fault sensing system is configured to exclude any element of the third travelling wave differential current which has a negative value in the assessment of at least some of the elements of the third travelling wave differential current.
19. A power system comprising: a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors; and the processing module according to claim 12.
20. The power system according to claim 19, further comprising: a fault sensing system for a power system including a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors, wherein on a condition that a fault occurs in the protected unit at least one travelling wave is generated in the protected unit, wherein the fault sensing system is adapted to sense a fault in the protected unit, the fault sensing system comprising said processing module, wherein a second travelling wave differential current as determined by the processing module has a plurality of elements, each element corresponding to a respective one of the plurality of conductors, and wherein the fault sensing system is configured to compare at least some of the elements of the second travelling wave differential current with respect to a fault sensing criterion, and on a condition that an element complies with the fault sensing criterion, determine that there is a fault in the conductor corresponding to that element.
21. A non-transitory computer-readable storage medium on which there is stored a computer program product configured to, when executed in the processing module according to claim 12, perform a method in a power system including a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position, different from the first position, in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors, wherein on a condition that a fault occurs in the protected unit, at least one travelling wave is generated in the protected unit, wherein any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the protected unit can be modeled by means of a propagation function, the method comprising the steps of: determining a first travelling wave current in the first position and a second travelling wave current in the second position; and determining a first travelling wave differential current based on a comparison between the deter-mined first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively; respectively, wherein the estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current is carried out by applying the propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively, wherein the first travelling wave differential current has a plurality of modes corresponding to respective ones of the plurality of conductors; conductors, the method further comprising the step of: determining a second travelling wave differential current by means of, based on the propagation function, adjusting at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) Exemplifying embodiments of the invention will be described below with reference to the other accompanying drawings, in which:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10) In the accompanying drawings, the same reference numerals denote the same or similar elements throughout the views.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(11) The present invention will now be described hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which exemplifying embodiments of the present invention are illustrated. The present invention may, however, be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided by way of example so that this disclosure will convey the scope of the invention to those skilled in the art. Furthermore, like numbers refer to like or similar elements or components throughout. The steps of any method described herein do not have to be performed in the exact order as described, unless specifically stated.
(12)
(13)
(14) where ={square root over (YZ)} is a matrix, I+ and I are column vectors including the forward and backward traveling currents, respectively, and
Y.sub.c={square root over ((YZ).sup.1)}Y(3)
Z.sub.c=Y.sub.c.sup.1(4)
(15) Y.sub.c is the surge adittance matrix and Z.sub.c is the surge impedance matrix.
(16)
I.sub.TWx.sup.+=I.sub.x+Y.sub.CV.sub.x(5)
(17) Inserting the expressions for current and voltage in equations (1) and (2), respectively, into equation (5) yields:
I.sub.TWx.sup.+=2e.sup.xI.sup.+(6)
(18) Calculating I.sub.TWx at both ends of the transmission line, x=0 and x=1, gives:
(19)
(20) where
H=e.sup.{square root over (YZ)}l(9)
(21) is the propagation function matrix. If the detecting part of the protection scheme is assumed to be located at x=1, the phase domain column vector of traveling wave differential currents can be formulated as:
I.sub.TWdiff=HI.sub.TW0.sup.+I.sub.TWl.sup.+(10)
(22) Without losing any generality but merely in order to simplify the discussion, a protection scheme with only half-duplex communication can be assumed where the sending end is located at x=0 and the receiving end is located at x=1. However, the protection scheme can be mirrored such that faults can be detected at either end where both sides equally transmit and receive samples to the other station or side.
(23) During an internal fault, the phase-domain differential current seen by the protection scheme may be present in healthy phases due to the modal properties of the propagation function matrix. A worst case scenario may occur when the internal fault is located at the remote end in relation to the protection scheme, i.e. the fault is located close to the sending end of the protection scheme.
(24) Consider a multi-conductor transmission line of length l and having n conductors as illustrated in
(25) If a fault is assumed to occur at some distance l.sub.A from the sending end, the transmission line can be divided into two transmission line sections, denoted by indices A and B, respectively, in
H.sub.lA=e.sup.lA(11)
H.sub.lB=e.sup.lB(12)
(26) The propagation function matrix H of the entire transmission line length l equals the matrix multiplication of the two sections A and B:
H=H.sub.lAH.sub.lB=H.sub.lBH.sub.lA=e.sup.l.sup.
(27) Using equations (8) and (5) to relate the voltages and currents at each side of both transmission line sections gives:
I.sub.A+Y.sub.cV.sub.A=H.sub.lA(I.sub.0+Y.sub.cV.sub.0)(14)
I.sub.l+Y.sub.cV.sub.l=H.sub.lB(I.sub.B+Y.sub.cV.sub.B)(15)
(28) The voltage between section A and B must be equal since it is the same electrical node, i.e. V.sub.A=V.sub.B=V.sub.AB (not shown in
Y.sub.cV.sub.AB=H.sub.lA(I.sub.0+Y.sub.cV.sub.0)I.sub.A(16)
Y.sub.cV.sub.AB=H.sub.lB.sup.1(I.sub.l+Y.sub.cV.sub.l)I.sub.B(17)
(29) Setting the left-hand sides of equations (16) and (17) equal and identifying the traveling wave currents at both sides (x=0 and x=1) and rearranging yields:
(30)
(31) Note that I.sub.F is a column vector containing the phase domain fault currents in each respective conductor and is defined positive when the current is flowing out of the conductor according to
(32)
(33) Inserting equation (19) into the formula for calculating the differential current according to equation (10) yields the differential current as seen by the protection scheme during this internal fault:
(34)
(35) From the result in equation (20) the experienced differential current I.sub.TWdiff during an internal fault is related to the distance between the receiving transmission line end and the fault l.sub.B.
(36) Consider the case where l.sub.B=0, where the H.sub.lB matrix will be the identity matrix and consequently I.sub.TWdiff=I.sub.F, i.e. no off-diagonal matrix elements exist, and consequently no false differential current in healthy phases exists. In the opposite case where l.sub.B=1, the H.sub.lB matrix will be the full propagation function matrix of the transmission line, which typically includes off-diagonal elements. The amount of coupling that exist between the conductors is related to the eigenvalues of the YZ matrix and the length of the transmission line, as described further in the following.
(37) From equation (9), the phase domain propagation function H of a transmission line with n conductors is related to the per-unit-length shunt admittance Y and series impedance Z matrices and the transmission line length l. The shunt admittance Y and series impedance Z matrices are both square (dimension nn) and also symmetrical, i.e. Y=Y.sup.T and Z=Z.sup.T, where T denotes matrix transpose. At every frequency, the matrix product YZ in the exponent in equation (9) can be transformed using eigenvalue decomposition. The eigenvalue equation describes the relation of the matrix A, eigenvalue .sub.k and eigenvector v.sub.k,
Av.sub.k=.sub.kv.sub.k(21)
(38) The eigenvector v.sub.k is a column vector that corresponds to the eigenvalue .sub.k. If the matrix A is of dimension nn, there will be a total of n eigenvalue/eigenvector pairs. Combining all n eigenvalues and their respective eigenvectors into matrices yields:
Av=v(22)
(39) where v is a square matrix in which the eigenvectors are the columns and is a diagonal matrix that contains each eigenvalue .sub.k in element kk. There is no defined order in which the eigenvalues should be sorted and that they can switch positions if required. However, the positions of the eigenvectors should then also be switched such that eigenvalueeigenvector relationship can be maintained. The eigenvalues can for example be sorted in increasing or decreasing order of magnitude. Inserting A=YZ and replacing the general notation of eigenvector matrix v with T.sub.i in equation (22):
YZT.sub.i=T.sub.i(23)
T.sub.i.sup.1YZT.sub.i=(24)
(40) Similarly, writing the corresponding equation of the matrix multiplication ZY that can be diagonalized into the same eigenvalues, , by applying a different eigenvector matrix T.sub.v:
ZYT.sub.v=T.sub.v(25)
T.sub.v.sup.1ZYT.sub.v=(26)
(41) Since Z and Y are both symmetrical matrices, i.e. Y=Y.sup.T and Z=Z.sup.T:
T.sub.v.sup.1Z.sup.TY.sup.TT.sub.v=(27)
(42) Transposing both sides of equation (27) yields:
(T.sub.v.sup.1Z.sup.TY.sup.TT.sub.v).sup.T=.sup.T(28)
(43) Since (AB).sup.T=B.sup.TA.sup.T and the transpose of a diagonal matrix is the matrix itself, (.sup.T=),
T.sub.v.sup.TYZT.sub.v.sup.T=(29)
(44) where T.sub.v.sup.T is the transposed inverse of T.sub.v. Comparing the result in equation (29) with equation (24), the relation between transformation matrices T.sub.i and T.sub.v can be identified as:
(45)
(46) The result in equation (30) shows that the rows in the inverse current transformation matrix T.sub.i.sup.1 are actually the corresponding columns of T.sub.v, i.e. eigenvectors of the matrix product ZY. Note that the sets of eigenvectors in T.sub.i and T.sub.v in principle could be determined separately. However, since an eigenvector can be multiplied by a scalar 0 and still fulfill the eigenvalue equation (21), the different eigenvectors in T.sub.i and T.sub.v must be scaled such that the relations in equation (30) are fulfilled. One way to achieve this is if the eigenvectors in T.sub.i and T.sub.v are scaled to unity. Another way is to determine one of the eigenvector matrices, then its inverse, and finally using the relations in equation (30) to produce the other set of eigenvectors if required. This also ensures the eigenvectors appear with correct scaling in relation to each other. Herein, only the transformation matrix T.sub.i and its inverse T.sub.i.sup.1 are used. The eigenvectors in T.sub.i may for example be obtained using PSCAD/EMTDC, and are not normalized. Since the inverse T.sub.i.sup.1 is calculated from the transformation matrix, scaling of eigenvectors is automatically compensated in the calculation of inverse since the product of both matrices equal the identity matrix.
(47) A significance of the transformation matrices T.sub.i and T.sub.v are that they relate the modal and phase domains for currents and voltages respectively:
I.sub.phase=T.sub.iI.sub.mode(31)
V.sub.phase=T.sub.VV.sub.mode(32)
(48) In some symmetrical cases (e.g. a flat two-conductor system or an ideally transposed three-phase transmission line), the per-unit length admittance Y and impedance matrices Z will consist of a repeated single entry in the diagonal and another single value in all non-diagonal elements. The matrix product YZ will then also be symmetric and therefore YZ=(YZ).sup.T=Z.sup.TY.sup.T=ZY. This further implies that T.sub.i=T.sub.v and that the inverse T.sub.i.sup.1=T.sub.i.sup.T=T.sub.v.sup.1=T.sub.v.sup.T. However, in the general case, transmission lines are not perfectly balanced and consequently T.sub.iT.sub.v since in general, YZZY. The phase domain propagation function can also be expressed as the transform applied to the diagonal modal domain propagation function:
H=T.sub.iH.sup.mT.sub.i.sup.1(33)
(49) In order to obtain the modal domain propagation function, the transformation matrices can be rearranged in the opposite order:
H.sup.m=T.sub.i.sup.1HT.sub.i(34)
(50) The modal domain propagation function can be obtained from the eigenvalues from solving the eigenvalue equation in (23):
H.sup.m=e.sup.{square root over ()}l(35)
(51) Since is a diagonal matrix where each .sub.k represents each uncoupled mode k, the modal domain propagation function matrix is also a diagonal matrix where each diagonal element corresponds to a mode. The propagation function in each mode k is:
H.sup.mk=e.sup.{square root over (.sup..sup.
(52) Each modal domain propagation function can be relatively accurately approximated as a combination of a minimum phase shift function and a time delay as shown in equation (37) below:
H.sup.mk(s)H.sup.mk(s).Math.e.sup.s.sup.
(53) Every mode k in a transmission line (of length l) has its own respective propagation delay .sub.k, which implies that each mode also has its own individual propagation speed v.sub.k. If all modes are launched down the transmission line from location x=0, they will appear at point x along the transmission line in a predetermined order, i.e. the mode with highest propagation speed will appear first, the second highest after that, and so on.
(54)
(55) In the time domain, the different modal propagation delays in combination with the characteristics of the minimum phase shift functions, (H.sup.mk) are the origins of false differential current in healthy phases, or conductors. Hypothetically, if these two properties would be common for all modes, the phase domain propagation function matrix could be expressed as the identity matrix multiplied with a common modal propagation function as illustrated in equation (38) below. Since the identity matrix by definition contains no off-diagonal elements, no false differential currents would appear in healthy conductors.
(56)
(57) Equation (38) should only be considered as an illustrative example, since the modes are usually not equal. The example could however illustrate a scenario when a fault occurs at l.sub.B=0 since this would imply that H(s)=1 and =0.
(58) Usually there are two different types of modes. Firstly the ground mode which is active when ground current flows in the system. Secondly, the remaining modes are known as metallic modes. The ground mode normally possesses a longer travel time, lower characteristic admittance and a larger resistance than the metallic modes.
(59) The result in equation (20) showed that the experienced differential current I.sub.TWdiff depend on the length l.sub.B from the receiving end at which the fault occurs. Since each mode in general has its own propagation speed, the difference between modes will obviously increase with line length, i.e. l.sub.B=1 will be the worst case for the differential protection scheme with regard to coupling between conductors and correctly identifying the faulted pole.
(60) Assuming l.sub.B=1 and inserting equations (33) and (35) into equation (20) results in equation (39) below which relates the experienced phase domain differential currents (ITWdiff) with respect to the phase currents in the fault location (I.sub.F):
(61)
(62) Using equation (37) in equation (39) yields:
(63)
(64) In order to better illustrate the impact of each mode in the phase domain, the diagonal modal propagation function matrix can be rewritten as a series of sparse matrices, each sparse matrix including only a single element:
(65)
(66) The matrix multiplication in each mode can be further simplified. For the k-th mode, the product of the 3 matrix multiplications can be written as a multiplication of the k-th column in T.sub.i by the k-th row in T.sub.i.sup.1. If the transformation matrix and its inverse are denoted T.sub.i=A and T.sub.i.sup.1=B respectively:
(67)
(68) Note that the matrix multiplication of the column and row vector will result in an nn matrix which in the general case will contain complex elements. In equation (42) the experienced phase domain differential current I.sub.TWdiff during a fault I.sub.F can be analyzed. Each mode appears at the receiving transmission line-end at the time determined by its respective propagation delay .sub.k. In addition to the delay, the minimum phase shift function in each mode (H.sup.mk) will also apply low-pass' filters of different characteristics to each mode. The minimum phase shift functions H.sup.mk in most conditions will approach the input as time increases and the entire expression within the parenthesis in equation (42) will therefore approach the identity matrix with time. The worst crosstalk between conductors will therefore occur when the fault first arrives in the receiving end. It cannot be determined which conductors that are involved in a fault until all modes have arrived, i.e. the ground mode must be allowed to arrive.
(69) As described in the foregoing, false differential current in healthy conductors may appear due to the different properties of each modal propagation function. A gist of embodiments of the present invention is to identify the slowest mode (usually the ground mode) and apply delays and low pass functions to all other modes, such that every element in the output vector will have equal time delay and attenuation/distortion during the fault in a worst case scenario. This may for example be implemented as applying a normalization matrix to the differential current I.sub.TWdiff so as to filter out modal domain differences in the propagation function for faults located close to the sending end. In order to determine the normalization matrix, the mode that has the largest propagation delay is identified. Otherwise, some modes would have a positive time delay which would require the differential currents to be predicted when the protection scheme would be implemented in the time domain. The propagation delays for a given transmission line with n conductors (and n modes) of length l are sorted where the slowest mode will be denoted as s.sub.1, followed by a mode denoted by s.sub.2, and so on.
(70)
(71) Note that the mode with the longest propagation delay usually is the ground mode. Using the propagation function of mode s.sub.i together with the inverse of the modal domain propagation function matrix, the modal domain normalization matrix for a transmission line of length l can be determined as:
N.sub.l.sup.m=H.sup.ms1(s)(H.sup.m).sup.1(44)
(72) In the frequency domain the inverse of the propagation function matrix could be used. This could however translate into the time domain as a transfer function with positive time delays and highly unstable high-pass filters where the gain increases with frequency, and would probably not be practical. Since the modal propagation function matrix is diagonal, the inverse is simply the inverse of each diagonal element. Using the approximation in equation (37) and applying it to equation (44) yields:
(73)
(74) The diagonal element of the mode which was identified as the slowest mode, s.sub.1, will cancel out and thus be 1 (no filter or delay). Further expansion of equation (45) yields:
(75)
(76) The result in equation (46) may be interpreted as each element including a phase shift (delay in time-domain) and a quotient of two low-pass minimum phase shift functions. Since .sub.s1 can be chosen as the maximum delay of all modes, the subtraction in the exponential will always be positive or zero (i.e. .sub.s1.sub.k0). This may ensure that the delay always has the correct sign. Using the same transformation matrix as for the propagation function to relate modal and phase domain:
N.sub.l=T.sub.iN.sub.l.sup.mT.sub.i.sup.1(47)
N.sub.l.sup.m=T.sub.i.sup.1N.sub.lT.sub.i(48)
(77) The normalization matrix can be applied to the differential current which the protection scheme experiences during a fault close to the sending end or station from equation (39) and determine the normalized differential current .sub.TWdiff:
(78)
(79) Inserting equations (40) and (46) into equation (49) yields:
(80)
(81) Performing the cancellations in equation (50) yields:
(82)
(83) Equation (51) indicates that in the normalized differential current .sub.TWdiff a differential current will only be present in the faulted phases. The output will appear as filtered by the minimum phase shift function of the slowest mode s.sub.1, H.sup.ms1(s) and be delayed by the propagation delay of this mode, .sub.s1. No additional delays have been introduced since the faulted phase cannot be identified until all modes have arrived at the receiving end. The delay and filter has been applied to the modes ks.sub.1 such that all modes have equal properties during this fault.
(84) If only the time delay is considered, equation (46) can be interpreted as giving the slowest mode a head start by means of delaying the other modes. This is illustrated by the example illustrated in
(85) It has been shown that for faults at l.sub.B=0, the vector of differential current I.sub.TWdiff will contain no false differential current in healthy conductors. During faults at the other end of the line, i.e. at l.sub.B=1, application of the normalization matrix to I.sub.TWdiff may mitigate or even eliminate any false differential current in healthy phases. Elements of the resulting vector of differential currents, .sub.TWdiff, will only be non zero for elements which correspond to a non-healthy, faulty, phase. Since it is difficult or even perhaps impossible to know where on the transmission line that a fault will occur, a combination of I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff is according to an example contemplated to be used as input to a decision logic or the like which determines or assesses whether there is a fault in the transmission line or not. Each of I.sub.TWdiff and I.sub.TWdiff may in a sense be considered to represent a boundary of the transmission line, such that false differential current always is eliminated in healthy conductors. The combination of I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff may for example include making an element-by-element multiplication of I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff. During faults at either l.sub.B=0 or l.sub.B=1, an element in at least one of I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff corresponding to a healthy conductor may contain a zero current, which consequently would make the product of the corresponding elements in I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff zero as well. Formally defining the result of the element-by-element product of the two vectors as a third column vector M.sub.TWdiff:
M.sub.TWdiff=diag(I.sub.TWdiff).Math..sub.TWdiff=diag(.sub.TWdiff).Math.I.sub.TWdiff(52)
(86) The result of diag(A) is a square diagonal matrix which contains the elements of column vector A in the diagonal elements. During a fault at an arbitrary location along the transmission line, i.e. 0<l.sub.B<1, neither of the respective, corresponding elements in I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff corresponding to a healthy conductor can be assumed to be zero. Applying the differential current as experienced by the protection in the receiving transmission line end from equation (40) for a fault occurring at an arbitrary distance 0<l.sub.B<1 from the receiving transmission line end:
(87)
(88) Using the result in equation (53) and applying the normalization matrix (which is determined for the entire transmission line length l):
(89)
(90) The two equations (53) and (54) result in two different vectors of differential current during a fault at location l.sub.B before and after the normalization matrix has been applied. As mentioned before, the normalization matrix will when applied introduce filtering and delays in the modes ks.sub.1 such that all modes have equal properties during faults located at l.sub.B=1. Therefore, during faults at a location of the transmission line 0<l.sub.B<1, the differential current in modes ks.sub.1 may be exposed to less delay and filtering than what is assumed in the determination of the normalization matrix, which may result in that .sub.TWdiff may appear as too much filtered and/or delayed. Each mode will arrive at the receiving transmission line end in opposite order as compared with the differential current in equation (53), i.e. the mode s.sub.1 will arrive at the receiving end first, followed by s.sub.2 and so on. Attenuation/distortion will be more evident in the modes which otherwise allow relatively high frequency components to travel down the transmission line.
(91)
(92) For the differential currents in I.sub.TWdiff, when mode s.sub.1 arrives, any false differential current will start to decrease towards zero with a rate determined by the time constant associated with H.sup.ms1.sub.lB(s). In order to simplify description of principles of embodiments of the present invention, it may be assumed that the fault current in the location of the fault (I.sub.F) can be described by a step function, for which the magnitude does not change such that the time delays can be neglected once each mode have arrived. It may further be assumed that the transfer function approaches 1.0 for lower frequencies and that all modes ks.sub.1 have relatively high time constants such they have reached their final values when mode s.sub.1 arrives at the receiving transmission line end. The differential current for t.sub.s1B can then be expressed as:
(93)
(94) In equation (55) the sum of all column/row products equals the identity matrix, which implies that the sum of all modes except for mode s.sub.1 is the identity matrix subtracted by the matrix associated with mode s.sub.1:
(95)
(96) Expansion of the multiplication in equation (56) yields:
(97)
(98) Since the modes will appear in reversed order in the normalized differential current .sub.TWdiff, the first mode s.sub.1 will appear at t=.sub.s1B, i.e. at the same time as for the original differential current. Before t=.sub.s1B, all elements in .sub.TWdiff will be zero. In the time interval between the arrival of slowest mode (t=.sub.s1B) and the second (next) slowest mode (t=.sub.s2B+.sub.s1.sub.s2), .sub.TWdiff can be expressed as:
(99)
(100) Expansion of equation (58) yields:
(101)
(102) Comparing the left-hand side matrix in equation (57) with the matrix in equation (59), it can be noted that all off-diagonal elements are equal but have different signs in the two equations. This implies that any false differential current will appear in .sub.TWdiff as well during faults at 0<l.sub.B<1, but that it however will appear with opposite sign as compared to a false differential current appearing in I.sub.TWdiff. The false differential current appearing in I.sub.TWdiff will start to decrease towards zero with the same or substantially the same time constant as the false differential current appearing in .sub.TWdiff starts to appear. During this time, all false differential currents will have opposite polarities in I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff, respectively. A product of two quantities with opposite polarities will be negative, while a product of two quantities of the same polarityeither positive or negativewill be positive. This allows for a false differential current in M.sub.TWdiff to be eliminated by discarding all negative products therein. Limiting the elements in M.sub.TWdiff to only those with positive values or those being zero, and calculating the square root of each element yields:
C.sub.TWdiff=max(0,M.sub.TWdiff)(60)
(103) The term within the square root in equation (60) is limited to positive values, ande hence evaluation of the square root does not yield an imaginary result.
(104) Hence, for faults that may occur either at or substantially at l.sub.B=0 or l.sub.B=1, an element-bye-element product of vectors I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff may eliminate any false differential current, since in case of a false differential current appearing in an element in one of the respective vectors the corresponding element in the other one of the respective vectors will be zero or substantially zero. However, for a fault that may occur at an arbitrary point or location along the transmission line, such as for example substantially in the middle of the transmission line, false differential currents for corresponding elements may appear in both of the vectors I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff. However, as described above, for faults that may occur at such locations along the transmission line, modal components may arrive in opposite order in I.sub.TWdiff as compared to .sub.TWdiff. The first modal component to appear in .sub.TWdiff will in general be the slowest mode, s.sub.1. Due to properties of the columns in the transformation matrix T.sub.i and the rows of its inverse T.sub.i.sup.1, any false differential currents will initially appear with opposite signs in the two vectors I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff. A product of two elements with opposite signs will be negative, which means that if all negative values are discarded after the element-by-element multiplication of I.sub.TWdiff and .sub.TWdiff, or limiting the elements in the resulting vector to those having values greater than or equal to zero, any false differential current may be eliminated for faults that may occur at an arbitrary location along the transmission line, 0l.sub.B1.
(105) Referring now to
(106) In
(107) The power system 100 comprises a processing module 120 configured to determine a first travelling wave current in the first position 103 and a second travelling wave current in the second position 104. For example, the processing module 120 may be configured to receive the first travelling wave current and the second travelling wave current from a travelling wave current sensing module 121 included in the power system 100, which travelling wave current sensing module 121 is configured to determine a first travelling wave current in the first position 103 and a second travelling wave current in the second position 104.
(108) Although
(109) The processing module 120 is configured to determine a first travelling wave differential current based on a comparison between the determined first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively. The processing module 120 is configured to estimate the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current by applying the propagation function to the second travelling wave current or to the first travelling wave current, respectively. The first travelling wave differential current has a plurality of modes corresponding to respective ones of the plurality of conductors of the transmission line 102.
(110) The processing module 120 is configured to determine a second travelling wave differential current by means of, based on the propagation function, adjustment of at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics.
(111) Referring now to
(112) The protected unit 102 is adapted to convey power from a first position 103 in the protected unit 102 or transmission line 102 to a second position 104, different from the first position 103, in the transmission line 102, or vice versa, via the plurality of conductors. According to the example depicted in
(113) According to the embodiment illustrated in
(114) According to the embodiment illustrated in
(115) The first processing unit 109 is adapted to determine a first travelling wave current in the first position 103 based on the at least one first current and the at least one first voltage sensed in the first position 103 by the current sensing unit 105 and the voltage sensing unit 107, respectively. The second processing unit 110 is adapted to determine a second travelling wave current in the second position 104 based on the at least one second current and the at least one second voltage sensed in the second position 104 by the current sensing unit 106 and the voltage sensing unit 108, respectively. One or both of the first and second processing units 109, 110 may be adapted to model any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the transmission line 102 by means of the propagation function.
(116) According to the embodiment illustrated in
(117) According to the embodiment illustrated in
(118) According to the embodiment illustrated in
(119) The connections between the different entities in the power system 100 as indicated in
(120) In accordance with the embodiment depicted in
(121) With further reference to
(122) With further reference to
(123) The power system 100 may comprise a decision logic module 117 to which for example the second travelling wave differential current, as determined by the fifth processing unit 113, and possibly a third travelling wave differential current, as determined by the sixth processing unit 114, are input.
(124) The decision logic module 117 may be configured to assess or compare at least some of the elements of the second travelling wave differential current with respect to a fault sensing criterion, and on a condition that an element complies with the fault sensing criterion, determine that there is a fault in the conductor corresponding to that element.
(125) On a condition that there is determined that there is a fault in a conductor included in the transmission line 102, protective action may be taken. The transmission line 102, or at least the conductor or conductors in which a fault has been determined to occur, may be isolated from at least a portion of the rest of the power system 100, e.g. by means of some circuit breaker arrangement (not shown in
(126) The decision logic module 117 may be configured to assess or compare at least some of the elements of the third travelling wave differential current with respect to a fault sensing criterion. On a condition that an element complies with the fault sensing criterion, the decision logic module 117 determine and/or declare that there is a fault in the conductor corresponding to that element. The fault sensing criterion may for example include whether an element complies with a predefined fault sensing metric. In alternative or in addition, the fault sensing criterion may for example be based on detection techniques such as time-inverse overcurrent characteristic or differential-restrain or current restraining characteristic, as known in the art.
(127) The decision logic module 117 may together with the processing module 120 depicted in
(128) Referring now to
(129) The computer-readable means 122, 123, or computer readable storage mediums, shown in
(130) The processing module 120 and/or any one of the first to sixth processing units 109-114 may include or be constituted for example by any suitable CPU, microcontroller, DSP, ASIC, FPGA, etc., or any combination thereof. The processing module 120 and/or any one of the first to sixth processing units 109-114 may optionally be capable of executing software instructions stored in a computer program product e.g. in the form of a memory. The memory may for example be any combination of RAM and ROM. The memory may comprise persistent storage, which for example can be a magnetic memory, an optical memory, a solid state memory or a remotely mounted memory, or any combination thereof.
(131) In conclusion, a method in a power system is disclosed, according to an embodiment of the present invention. The power system includes a protected unit adapted to convey power from a first position in the protected unit to a second position in the protected unit, or vice versa, via a plurality of conductors. A first travelling wave differential current is determined based on a comparison between a determined first travelling wave current or a second travelling wave current in first and second positions and an estimation of the first travelling wave current or the second travelling wave current, respectively. The estimation is carried out using a propagation function which takes into account any distortion, attenuation and/or delay of the waveform of a wave due to propagation of the wave in the protected unit. A second travelling wave differential current is determined by means of, based on the propagation function, adjusting at least one of magnitude and phase of the first travelling wave differential current such that all modes attain equal or increasingly equal modal characteristics. The method may facilitate or enable mitigating or even eliminating any false differential current in elements of a travelling wave differential current vector which correspond to healthy conductors, caused by coupling effects between conductors.
(132) While the present invention has been illustrated and described in detail in the appended drawings and the foregoing description, such illustration and description are to be considered illustrative or exemplifying and not restrictive; the present invention is not limited to the disclosed embodiments. Other variations to the disclosed embodiments can be understood and effected by those skilled in the art in practicing the claimed invention, from a study of the drawings, the disclosure, and the appended claims. The mere fact that certain measures are recited in mutually different dependent claims does not indicate that a combination of these measures cannot be used to advantage.