Mass spectrometry
11600483 · 2023-03-07
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
H01J49/4225
ELECTRICITY
International classification
H01J49/42
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
A method of carrying out mass spectrometry, comprising: using an electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap to contain a plurality of ions, each ion having a mass to charge ratio, the ions having a first plurality of mass to charge ratios, each ion following a path within the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap having a radius; and for each of a second plurality of the mass to charge ratios: modulating the radii of the ions in a mass to charge ratio-dependent fashion dependent upon the mass to charge ratio; fragmenting the ions thus modulated in a radius-dependent fashion; and determining a mass spectrum of the ions.
Claims
1. A method of carrying out mass spectrometry, comprising: using an electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap to contain a plurality of ions, each ion having a mass to charge ratio, the plurality of ions having a first plurality of mass to charge ratios and a second plurality of mass to charge ratios, wherein each ion of the first plurality of mass to charge ratios follows a path within the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap having a radius; and wherein each of the second plurality of mass to charge ratios are discretely spaced apart within a continuous range and for each of the second plurality of mass to charge ratios the method comprises: modulating radii of the ions in a mass to charge ratio-dependent fashion dependent upon the mass to charge ratio; fragmenting the ions thus modulated in a radius-dependent fashion within the ion trap; and determining a mass spectrum of the ions after each fragmentation.
2. The method of claim 1, in which the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap comprises one of: a linear ion trap (LIT), a quadrupolar ion trap, a three-dimensional ion trap, or an ion trap whose ions have consistent oscillation frequencies.
3. The method of claim 1, in which the modulation of the radii comprises modulating an electric field applied to the ions.
4. The method of claim 3, comprising applying excitation pulses, separated by a delay, with the delay providing the mass to charge ratio dependence.
5. The method of claim 3, comprising applying a modulated excitation pulse, which is modulated at a frequency.
6. The method of claim 5, in which the frequency is such so as to provide a resonance with an oscillation frequency of ions having the second plurality of mass to charge ratio.
7. The method of claim 5, in which the modulated excitation pulse comprises at least one of a Stored Waveform Inverse Fourier Transform (SWIFT) and a Stored Waveform Ion Radius Modulation (SWIM) pulse.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the modulation of the radii comprises preferentially changing the radii of the ions having the mass to charge ratio to a path with a different radius, or changing the radii of the ions not having the mass to charge ratio to a path with a different radius.
9. The method of claim 1, in which the step of fragmenting the ions comprises fragmenting ions which pass through a fragmentation zone.
10. The method of claim 9, in which the modulation of the radii modulates radii of ions into and/or out of the fragmentation zone.
11. The method of claim 1, in which the mass spectra are determined using at least one of the following group of instruments: a time of flight (TOF) mass spectrometer; a Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance (FT ICR); a Linear Ion Trap (LIT); and an Orbitrap mass spectrometer.
12. The method of claim 1, in which the mass spectra are determined using a triple quadrupole (QQQ) mass spectrometer.
13. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of modulating the radii of the ions in a mass to charge ratio-dependent fashion serves to place only ions with a particular mass to charge ratio within a fragmentation zone at a given time, and wherein the modulation of the path radii of the ions is varied with time to move ions with different mass to charge ratios into or out of the fragmentation zone.
14. The method of claim 1, wherein each of the second plurality of mass to charge ratios are separately modulated, fragmented, and determined.
15. A mass spectrometry instrument, comprising an electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap and a control circuit for the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap, the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap comprising electrodes comprising at least two axial trapping electrodes, a plurality of radial trapping electrodes and at least one excitation electrode, in which the control circuit is arranged so as to: apply voltages to each excitation electrode so as to contain, in use, a plurality of ions within a void defined by the electrodes, each ion following a path within the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap having a radius, the ions having a first plurality of mass to charge ratios; and a second plurality of mass to charge ratios, and wherein for each of a second plurality of the mass to charge ratios are discretely spaced apart within a continuous range and for each of the second plurality of mass to charge ratios the mass spectrometry instrument is configured to: modulate the radii of the ions dependent upon the mass to charge ratio; and wherein the instrument further comprises a fragmentation device arranged to fragment the ions of the second plurality of mass to charge ratios that were modulated in a radius-dependent fashion, wherein the ions are fragmented within the ion trap; and a mass determination device arranged to determine a mass spectrum of the ions after each fragmentation.
16. The instrument of claim 15, in which the electrostatic or electrodynamic ion trap comprises one of: a linear ion trap (LIT), a quadrupolar ion trap, a three-dimensional ion trap, or an ion trap whose ions have consistent oscillation frequencies.
17. The instrument of claim 15, in which the control circuit is arranged such that the modulation of the radii comprise modulating an electric field applied to the ions using each excitation electrode.
18. The instrument of claim 15, in which the control circuit is arranged such that the modulation of the radii comprises preferentially changing the radii of the ions having the particular mass to charge ratio to a path with a different radius, or preferentially changing the radii of the ions not having the particular mass to charge ratio to a path with a different radius.
19. The instrument of claim 15, in which the fragmentation device is arranged to fragment ions which pass through a fragmentation zone.
20. The instrument of claim 19, in which the control circuit is arranged to as to modulate the radii so as to shift ions into and out of the fragmentation zone.
21. The instrument of claim 15, in which the mass determination device comprises an instrument selected from the group comprising: a time of flight (TOF) mass spectrometer; a Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance (FT ICR) mass spectrometer; a Linear Ion Trap (LIT) mass spectrometer; an Orbitrap mass spectrometer; and a triple quadrupole (QQQ) mass spectrometer.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
(1) There now follows by way of example only, description of implementations of the disclosure, described with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(11) In a first implementation of the disclosure, we describe a mass spectrometry instrument which demonstrates the feasibility of 2D mass spectrometry in a linear ion trap (LIT), explored using SIMION ion trajectory calculations.
(12) All simulations were performed using SIMION 8.0 (Scientific Instrument Services, Ringoes, N.J., USA) on an ion optic bench with the following dimensions: x=16 mm, y=16 mm, z=83 mm. The linear ion trap (LIT) was built in a single potential array with a mirror symmetry around the y=0 plane and is similar to the one modelled by Schwartz et al. (J. C. Schwartz, M. W. Senko, J. E. P. Syka. A two-dimensional quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. 2002, 13, 659). The potential array contained 11 electrodes with a 10 grid unit/mm precision and was refined with a convergence limit of 10.sup.−5.
(13)
(14) Whilst not directly simulated here, the contents of the LIT can be transferred to a further mass spectrometer 10 to determine the mass spectrum after each excitation and fragmentation as explained below.
(15)
(16) After 50.0 μs, an excitation pulse generated externally using SWIFT was applied to the rods 3a-3d of the centre quadrupole 3 with a 700.00 V.sub.0p, amplitude and a 20-550 kHz frequency range as explained below. The length of each pulse was set at 380 μs.
(17) At the end of the excitation pulse, a fragmentation period modelled on the use of laser 7, using a top-hat fragmentation zone with a 0.05 mm radius about axis 8. The probability of fragmentation was calculated using the following equation:
P=1−e.sup.−t/T.sup.
in which P is the probability of fragmentation, t the time that the ion has spent within the fragmentation zone during the fragmentation period and T.sub.decay, was set at 500.0 μs. This model was chosen in order to mimic a laser-based fragmentation method. Both the radius of the fragmentation zone and the time decay were chosen arbitrarily in order to result in reasonable fragmentation efficiency. Only one fragmentation was allowed during each ion trajectory simulation. After the fragmentation period the ion trajectory calculation was set to end. The experimental script was repeated 128 times with 128 different excitation pulses.
(18) SWIM Pulse Generation
(19) 128 Stored Waveform Ion Radius Modulation (SWIM) pulses were generated using python 2.7 programming language in the Spyder 2.3.8 development environment (Anaconda, Continuum Analytics, Austin, Tex., USA) and stored in a Comma Separated Values (csv) file format in order to be called by the SIMION workbench program.
(20)
in which M is the amplitude, f the frequency, n the index of the pulse, f.sub.max the maximum frequency of the pulse (here, 550 kHz) and f.sub.min the minimum frequency of the pulse (here, 20 kHz).
(21) In order to reduce the maximum voltage of the time-domain pulse, a quadratic phase function as proposed by Guan et al. (S. Guan, R. T. McIver, Jr. Optimal phase modulation in stored wave form inverse Fourier transform excitation for Fourier transform mass spectrometry. I. Basic algorithm. J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 92, 5841) was applied to the frequency-domain pulse:
(22)
in which φ is the phase, f the frequency, f.sub.max,range the maximum frequency of the total frequency range (here, 2117.151 kHz) and f.sub.min the minimum frequency (here, 20 kHz). The resulting function, combining eq. 2 and eq. 3:
PM.sub.(f,n)=M.sub.(f,n)×e.sup.iφ.sup.
was transformed into a time-domain pulse using the real part of its inverse fast Fourier transform.
(23) The resulting time-domain pulse was 1 s long with a 0.477 μs time increment. The significant part of the pulse was truncated to 380 μs and interpolated in order to achieve a 10 ns time increment before storage in a csv file.
(24) Particle Definition, Data Recording, and Data Processing
(25) Ion trajectory calculations were run without Coulombic repulsion. For each SWIM pulse, the trajectory of 100 ions of m/z 166, m/z 195, and m/z 322 were calculated. The m/z ratios of their fragments were m/z 122, m/z 181, and m/z 190 respectively. All m/z ratios were chosen arbitrarily. For each ion trajectory calculation, the index, m/z ratio and time-of-flight of the ion were recorded and stored in a text file at the moment of ion splat or the end of the simulation. The total ion current (TIC) was defined as the number of ions still present in the LIT at the end of the simulation.
(26) For the purposes of simulation, using python 2.7 programming language, the data recorded from the ion trajectory calculations was converted into a 2D mass spectrum, although in real world implementations a mass spectrometer (MS), typically a time of flight (TOF) MS would be used.
(27) For each m/z ratio, the Fourier transform of the ion count was calculated along the SWIM index n in magnitude mode. Since the sampling rate of n is 1, this results in a Nyquist frequency for the encoding frequency of 0.5. The frequency increment is 1/64, since the ion count was measured over 128 data points. A quadratic fit was used for frequency-to-mass conversion using the three precursor ion m/z ratios and encoding frequencies as reference points (E. B. Ledford, Jr., D. L. Rempel, M. L. Gross. Space charge effects in Fourier transform mass spectrometry. II. Mass calibration. Anal. Chem. 1984, 56, 2744).
(28) Simulation Results
(29) Frequencies of ion trajectories in a quadrupole are determined by the following equation:
(30)
(31) In which f.sub.r is the radial frequency, f.sub.drive the frequency of the RF voltage applied to the quadrupole electrodes, and β.sub.r the stability parameter used to solve the Mathieu equation in the radial dimension (0≤β.sub.r≤1). In the area of the stability diagram generally used in mass spectrometry, the β.sub.r stability parameter decreases when the m/z ratio increases (R. E. March. An introduction to quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometry. Journal of Mass Spectrometry 1997, 32, 351). Resonant RF voltages can be used in order to radially excite or destabilize ions of given m/z ratios in a quadrupole. Radial excitation increases with the RF amplitude and the length of the excitation voltage.
(32) This effect has been used for ion isolation in linear ion traps by Hilger et al. (R. T. Hilger, R. E. Santini, C. A. Luongo, B. M. Prentice, S. A. McLuckey. A method for isolating ions in quadrupole ion traps using an excitation waveform generated by frequency modulation and the quadrupole rods. However, many different electrodes shapes have been developed and tested for linear ion traps with similar results in terms of resonant frequencies. As long as resonant frequencies are stable over the size of the fragmentation zone, the quality of the radial modulation is unlikely to be affected.
(33) In each SWIM file, ions are radially excitation over a range of frequencies (i.e. m/z ratios) with frequency-dependent RF amplitudes given by eq. 2 on the basis of the frequencies defined in eq. 5. For a given m/z ratio, the amplitude at their resonant frequency (i.e. the radius of the ion cloud after excitation) is modulated according to the index of the SWIM file n with the following encoding frequency:
(34)
(35) In which f.sub.e is the encoding frequency, f.sub.r is the resonant radial frequency of the ions' trajectory, f.sub.min is the minimum frequency of the frequency range (corresponding to the highest m/z ratio in the m/z range), and f.sub.max the maximum frequency in the frequency range (corresponding to the lowest m/z ratio in the m/z range).
(36) For laser-based or electron-based fragmentation methods which can be used with this implementation like IRMPD (S. A. Hofstadler, K. A. Sannes-Lowery, R. H. Griffey. Infrared Multiphoton Dissociation in an External Ion Reservoir. Anal. Chem. 1999, 71, 2067), UVPD (R. Cannon Joe, B. Cammarata Michael, A. Robotham Scott, C. Cotham Victoria, B. Shaw Jared, T. Fellers Ryan, P. Early Bryan, M. Thomas Paul, L. Kelleher Neil, S. Brodbelt Jennifer. Ultraviolet photodissociation for characterization of whole proteins on a chromatographic time scale. Anal Chem 2014, 86, 2185), or ETD (G. C. McAlister, D. Phanstiel, D. M. Good, W. T. Berggren, J. J. Coon. Implementation of Electron-Transfer Dissociation on a Hybrid Linear Ion Trap-Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer. Anal. Chem. (Washington, D.C., U. S.) 2007, 79, 3525), the zone of high fragmentation efficiency is at the centre of the quadrupole. When the radius of the ion cloud is large (high resonant excitation), the overlap between the ion cloud and the fragmentation zone is small, and little fragmentation can be expected. When the radius of the ion cloud is small (low resonant excitation), the overlap between the ion cloud and the fragmentation zone is high, and the fragmentation efficiency is expected to be high.
(37) Unlike FT-ICR MS, ion manipulation in the LIT does not require ion cloud coherence (M. B. Comisarow, A. G. Marshall. Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance spectroscopy. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1974, 25, 282). As a result, collisionally-activated dissociation can be used in 2D LIT MS without causing a loss of resolution. Fragmentation efficiency in CAD increases with ion kinetic energy: the overlap between ion cloud and the fragmentation zone is therefore high when the ions are excited at high radius, and low when ions are at low radius.
(38) Following these hypotheses, fragment ion abundances in SWIM are modulated at the same encoding frequency (defined in eq. 6) as the radii of their precursors, whether the fragmentation method is laser-based, electron-based, or CAD. This effect makes 2D MS in an LIT possible.
(39)
(40) In an in silico experiment, there is no limitation in voltage amplitudes, but in order to adapt the 2D MS experiment to a physical implementation, two competing factors are in play: the voltage amplitude of the pulse and the length of the pulse. On the one hand, the voltage amplitude of the pulse needs to be within the specifications of the RF amplifiers. On the other hand, compatibility of 2D MS on an LC timescale requires a limited pulse length (in the present experiment, the lowest frequency is 20 kHz, which corresponds to a pulse length of 400 μs). Furthermore, the choice of a phase modulation function that is independent of the SWIM index n leads to quicker generation of SWIM pulses before each experiment. In the present study, the phase modulation function proposed in eq. 3 was chosen.
(41)
(42)
(43) The frequency of the modulation decreases with m/z ratio:
(44)
(45)
(46) The resolving power in the vertical precursor dimension of the 2D mass spectrum in
(47) In this implementation, unlike in 2D FT-ICR MS studies, calculating the Fourier transform of the data was only necessary in the vertical dimension, because the m/z ratios of ions was measured directly by the SIMION software. In a physical implementation, data processing will depend on the nature of the mass analyser 10. Orbitraps and FT-ICR mass spectrometers are both FT-based, which makes Fourier transforms necessary in both dimensions, but time-of-flights and quadrupoles both rely on computationally faster time-of-flight to m/z ratio conversion.
(48) In this implementation, the LIT has been used as an ion manipulation device. An LIT can be used as a mass analyser as well, or it can be coupled with other mass analysers by transferring ions to the mass analyser at the end of the fragmentation period. Optimizing the ion transfer depends on which mass analyser is used. In terms of cost, the LIT on its own or within a triple quadrupole is the most attractive option, but is slow in terms of acquisition time and has a low resolving power. Coupling the LIT with an Orbitrap or an FT-ICR mass spectrometer increases the resolving power dramatically, but also the cost of the instrument. These two mass analysers also have a slow duty cycle, which translates into long acquisition times. In order to achieve fast acquisition, TOF analysers have a considerable advantage because of their short duty cycles, and may enable to couple 2D MS with online liquid chromatography.
(49) This implementation shows the feasibility of two-dimensional mass spectrometry in a linear ion trap by, in this instance, applying SWIM pulses to modulate the radii of precursor ion clouds before applying a radius-dependent fragmentation method. The resulting fragment ion abundance is modulated with the same encoding frequency as the precursor ion abundance, or half the encoding frequency of the precursor ion abundance if the maximum excitation of the precursors leads to ion ejection. Calculating the Fourier transform of ion abundances and plotting them for each m/z ratio leads to 2D mass spectra that are similar to the ones described for 2D FT-ICR MS.
(50) 2D MS in a linear ion trap can therefore be applied to various radius-dependent fragmentation techniques: laser-based (IRMPD, UVPD), electron-based (ETD, PTD), or collision-based (CAD). The LIT can be used both as an ion manipulation device and as a mass analyser, but can be coupled with other mass analysers like an FT-ICR mass spectrometer, an Orbitrap, or a TOF in order to get various desired characteristics in the experimental setup, such as high resolution or fast acquisition times. In particular, coupling the LIT with a mass analyser with a fast duty cycle can lead to acquisition times shorter than 10 s, which makes 2D MS compatible with LC or GC timescales. Such an instrument would lead to LC-2D MS experiments in which the need for ion isolation analysis is eliminated. LC-2D MS would be a very useful technique for the analysis of complex samples, like in proteomics and in petroleomics, in which MS/MS eliminates many analytes.
(51) In a second implementation of the disclosure, shown in
(52) In this implementation, a set of four quadrupole electrodes 52 is provided along the length of the instrument to provide the fields to hold the ions captive. A further set of four excitation electrodes 60a, 60b, is provided as two pairs of electrodes, each pair 60a, 60b comprising two electrodes on opposite sides of the quadrupole electrodes 52.
(53) As such, rather than applying the SWIM excitation pulses to the quadrupole electrodes 52, they are instead applied to the excitation electrodes. Furthermore, rather than applying the excitation pulses to just one pair 60a, 60b of excitation electrodes, after the SWIM inverse Fourier transform step is taken, the real part of the time domain pulse can be applied to one pair 60a whereas the imaginary part is applied to the other pair 60b.
(54) This gives similar results to simply applying the pulse to one pair of electrodes, but with (at least approximately) half the amplitude applied to each pair of electrodes. As such, the peak amplitudes can be reduced.
(55) Furthermore, in this implementation, rather than having a SWIM frequency that increases linearly with the radial motion frequency, the SWIM frequency decreases with radial motion frequency. Ion abundances are modulated at f.sub.Nyquist−f instead off.
(56) The full-width at half-maximum is independent of frequency, which results in mass accuracy and mass resolution that decreases with m/z ratio regardless of the frequency profile. This can be seen in