Conversion of single-pass boiler to multi-pass operation
09618232 ยท 2017-04-11
Inventors
Cpc classification
F24H9/001
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F24H1/30
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F24H9/0026
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
International classification
F24H9/00
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
F24H1/30
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
Abstract
Modifications convert an existing single-pass boiler to operate with a multi-pass combustion gas flow through the flue passages of the heat exchanger of the boiler. A diverting target wall is arranged partway along the length of the original combustion chamber, and an upper draft diverter is arranged in a flue collector chamber above the flue passages, to divert some or all of the combustion gas into a multi-pass flow pattern through several flue passages of the heat exchanger in series. The modifications may further include changing the nozzle oil delivery rate and cone angle, the oil supply pressure, the draft conditions, and others. Heat extraction from the hot combustion gas to the boiler water is increased, exhaust gas temperature is decreased, and overall efficiency is increased, to result in a fuel and cost savings.
Claims
1. A system for converting an existing single-pass boiler to a multi-pass boiler in which flue gas flows in multiple passes through a heat exchanger of the boiler, comprising a diverting target wall installed in a combustion chamber of the boiler partway along a length of the combustion chamber below the heat exchanger, and an upper draft diverter installed in an upper flue collector chamber above the heat exchanger, wherein the heat exchanger includes plural flue passages that each respectively communicate entirely through the heat exchanger between the combustion chamber and the upper flue collector, and wherein the diverting target wall and the upper draft diverter are configured, positioned and installed to be effective to divert at least a portion of flue gas resulting from combustion in the combustion chamber to flow in a multi-pass flow pattern in series upwardly through one of the flue passages from the combustion chamber entirely through the heat exchanger to the upper flue collector chamber, then downwardly through another one of the flue passages from the upper flue collector chamber entirely through the heat exchanger to the combustion chamber, and then upwardly through a further one of the flue passages from the combustion chamber entirely through the heat exchanger to the upper flue collector chamber.
2. A boiler conversion system for a previously existing single-pass boiler that has a combustion chamber, a flue collector chamber, and a heat exchanger with at least three flue passages that each communicate entirely through said heat exchanger between said combustion chamber and said flue collector chamber so that respective portions of flue gas resulting from combustion of fuel in said combustion chamber would each flow respectively in a single pass through respective ones of said flue passages from said combustion chamber to said flue collector chamber in a previously existing single-pass configuration of said boiler, wherein said boiler conversion system is for converting said previously existing single-pass boiler to a multi-pass boiler in which at least some of said flue gas flows in multiple passes including a first pass, a second pass and a third pass through said heat exchanger, and wherein said boiler conversion system comprises diverting components including: a diverting target wall installed in said combustion chamber partway along a length of said combustion chamber so as to divert at least a majority of said flue gas to flow as a first flue gas flow from a first portion of said combustion chamber in front of said diverting target wall entirely through said heat exchanger to said flue collector chamber, in said first pass through said heat exchanger in at least one first flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger; and a draft diverter installed in said flue collector chamber partway along a length of said flue collector chamber so as to divert at least a majority of said first flue gas flow to flow as a second flue gas flow from a first portion of said flue collector chamber in front of said draft diverter entirely through said heat exchanger to a rear portion of said combustion chamber behind said diverting target wall, in said second pass through said heat exchanger in at least one second flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger; wherein said diverting components are configured and arranged such that at least a majority of said second flue gas flow then flows as a third flue gas flow from said rear portion of said combustion chamber entirely through said heat exchanger to a second portion of said flue collector chamber behind said draft diverter, in said third pass through said heat exchanger in at least one third flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger.
3. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said boiler further comprises a flue gas outlet communicating out of said second portion of said flue collector chamber.
4. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said first flue gas flow includes at least essentially all of said flue gas, said second flue gas flow includes at least essentially all of said first flue gas flow, and said third flue gas flow includes at least essentially all of said second flue gas flow.
5. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said boiler has a total of exactly three of said flue passages, said at least one first flue passage consists of exactly one first flue passage, said at least one second flue passage consists of exactly one second flue passage, and said at least one third flue passage consists of exactly one third flue passage.
6. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said boiler has a total of exactly six of said flue passages, said at least one first flue passage consists of exactly two first flue passages, said at least one second flue passage consists of exactly two second flue passages, and said at least one third flue passage consists of exactly two third flue passages.
7. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said diverting target wall has an opening therein configured and adapted to allow a minority portion of said flue gas to flow through said opening into said rear portion of said combustion chamber and there join said second flue gas flow.
8. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said draft diverter has an opening therein configured and adapted to allow a minority portion of said first flue gas flow to flow through said opening into said second portion of said flue collector chamber and there join said third flue gas flow.
9. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said diverting target wall and said draft diverter are imperforate and sealed to prevent any significant amount of said flue gas from flowing past said diverting target wall and said draft diverter respectively.
10. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said at least one first flue passage consists of exactly two first flue passages, and said at least one second flue passage consists of exactly one second flue passage.
11. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said combustion chamber and said flue collector chamber each extend horizontally, wherein said flue passages each extend vertically, and wherein said diverting target wall and said draft diverter are arranged and adapted so that said first flue gas flow will flow upwardly through said at least one first flue passage, said second flue gas flow will flow downwardly through said at least one second flue passage, and said third flue gas flow will flow upwardly through said at least one third flue passage.
12. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said diverting target wall is installed impermanently into said combustion chamber and said draft diverter is installed impermanently into said flue collector chamber by respectively being dimensioned and configured to fit and engage therein and being fitted and engaged therein.
13. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, further comprising at least one support member to be wedged or braced into said combustion chamber behind said diverting target wall so as to support said diverting target wall.
14. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said boiler, after said converting, has no refractory target wall and no refractory lining covering metal walls of said rear portion of said combustion chamber behind said diverting target wall.
15. The boiler conversion system according to claim 2, wherein said diverting target wall and said draft diverter are made of refractory ceramic fiber board or blanket.
16. The boiler conversion system according to claim 15, wherein said refractory ceramic fiber board or blanket is pre-cut to fit a sectional shape of said combustion chamber to fabricate said diverting target wall or to fit a sectional shape of said flue collector chamber to fabricate said draft diverter.
17. The boiler conversion system according to claim 15, wherein said refractory ceramic fiber board or blanket is not pre-cut to fit and is larger than a sectional shape of said combustion chamber or said flue collector chamber respectively, and said boiler conversion system further includes templates or instructions to cut said refractory ceramic fiber board or blanket to fit said sectional shape of said combustion chamber or said flue collector chamber.
18. A boiler conversion method for a previously existing single-pass boiler that has a combustion chamber, a flue collector chamber, and a heat exchanger with at least three flue passages that each communicate between said combustion chamber and said flue collector chamber so that respective portions of flue gas resulting from combustion of fuel in said combustion chamber would each flow respectively in a single pass through respective ones of said flue passages from said combustion chamber to said flue collector chamber in a previously existing single-pass configuration of said boiler, wherein said boiler conversion method is for converting said previously existing single-pass boiler to a multi-pass boiler in which at least some of said flue gas flows in multiple passes including a first pass, a second pass and a third pass through said heat exchanger, and wherein said boiler conversion method comprises installing diverting components including: installing a diverting target wall in said combustion chamber partway along a length of said combustion chamber so as to divert at least a majority of said flue gas to flow as a first flue gas flow from a first portion of said combustion chamber in front of said diverting target wall to said flue collector chamber in said first pass through said heat exchanger in at least one first flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger; and installing a draft diverter in said flue collector chamber partway along a length of said flue collector chamber so as to divert at least a majority of said first flue gas flow to flow as a second flue gas flow from a first portion of said flue collector chamber in front of said draft diverter to a rear portion of said combustion chamber behind said diverting target wall in said second pass through said heat exchanger in at least one second flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger; wherein said diverting components are configured and arranged such that at least a majority of said second flue gas flow then flows as a third flue gas flow from said rear portion of said combustion chamber to a second portion of said flue collector chamber behind said draft diverter in said third pass through said heat exchanger in at least one third flue passage among said flue passages of said heat exchanger.
19. The boiler conversion method according to claim 18, further comprising removing a refractory material target wall and a refractory material lining from metal walls of said rear portion of said combustion chamber.
20. The boiler conversion method according to claim 18, further comprising making said diverting target wall and said draft diverter imperforate and sealed in said combustion chamber and said flue collector chamber respectively so that all of said flue gas flows successively in series through said at least one first flue passage, then through said at least one second flue passage, and then through said at least one third flue passage.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) In order that the invention may be clearly understood, it will now be explained in further detail in connection with example embodiments thereof, with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EXAMPLE EMBODIMENTS AND THE BEST MODE OF THE INVENTION
(6) The conventional single-pass cast iron sectional boiler shown schematically in
(7) Generally, the boiler 1 has been modified by the installation of a draft diverter system to achieve top efficiency from the basic boiler structure, by diverting the draft (and making additional modifications) to achieve a multi-pass gas flow through the heat exchanger 10 in the modified boiler 1, rather than the single-pass flow of hot flue gas through the heat exchanger 10 in the conventional boiler 1. As is apparent by comparing
(8) The most significant modification in the inventive system and method basically involves moving the combustion target wall from the rear wall of the boiler combustion chamber to a position within and partway along the length of the original combustion chamber at a location below one of the boiler sections, so as to divert all (or at least a portion) of the combustion gases upward, as well as installing an additional upper draft diverter 30 in the flue collector chamber or exhaust manifold chamber 12 so as to divert all (or at least a portion) of the flue gases downwardly through a next flue passage. More particularly, the details of this modification are as follows. Comparing
(9) While the RCF board is easy to cut with a typical saw or the like and is also easy to position and secure in the boiler spaces, the fabricator and installer should observe all health risk warnings regarding the handling or cutting of fiberglass, silica, other ceramic or other fibrous materials, as set forth by the material manufacturer in an applicable material safety data sheet or the like. For example, the fabricator and installer should wear gloves and a breathing respirator to avoid possible injury by the silica or fibrous materials.
(10) The above described arrangement of the diverting target wall 6 serves at least two functions. First, it diverts all (or at least a portion) of the hot combustion gases as a first diverted hot flue gas flow 20A upwardly through the first flue passage 11A as shown in
(11) Another aspect of the modifications of the boiler to achieve the multi-pass draft diversion, is the installation of the upper draft diverter 30 in the flue collector chamber 12 within the flue exhaust collector hood 13 as shown in
(12) On the other hand, in certain applications it may be necessary or desirable to purposely allow some bypassing of the multi-pass flue diversion, if the single flue passage 11A, 11B or 11C does not provide sufficient cross-sectional area to flow the entire combustion gas stream therethrough while maintaining the required overfire draft and breech draft values. In such a situation, a bypass hole is purposely formed in the diverting target wall 6 and in the upper draft diverter 30, or bypass leakage gaps are purposely left around the perimeter thereof, so that some of the combustion gases will still undergo a single-pass flow rather than a multi-pass flow through the heat exchanger 10. Furthermore, by allowing some bypass flow through the diverters as described above, it is possible to adjust the exhaust stack temperature as required to achieve the desired temperature value to avoid condensation while achieving the maximum efficiency possible. Namely, the more flue gas that is allowed to bypass the diverters and thus make a single pass through the heat exchanger, the higher the stack temperature will be. The lowest stack temperature is achieved by ensuring 100% flue gas diversion into the multi-pass flow configuration.
(13) As shown in
(14) Thus, due to the installation of the draft diverting components 6 and 30 according to the invention as shown in
(15) Furthermore, because a higher percentage of the energy value or energy content of the heating oil fuel is extracted, therefore a lower fuel oil input rate is required to satisfy the same heating demand. Furthermore, as mentioned above, if the original boiler was oversized for the required heat load, or if insulation upgrades or other improvements were made to the building serviced by the boiler, then it is further possible to derate the burner input. Such a derating or reduction of the fuel injection rate of the burner also goes hand-in-hand quite well with the inventive draft diversion to achieve a multi-pass gas flow. Namely, because all of the exhaust gas is forced to flow through a single flue passage (and then sequentially through each one of the flue passages individually), the flue is substantially restricted compared to the original total flue made up of the three flue passages in parallel with each other, which reduces the draft over the fire in the combustion chamber. Thus, with the draft diverting components 6 and 30 in place, it may not be possible to fire the boiler at the same fuel injection rate for which it was originally designed or rated. On the other hand, because of the increased heat transfer, it will not be necessary to fire the boiler at its original high firing rate, in order to achieve the same heat output.
(16) Derating the burner can be achieved simply by replacing the original fuel injection nozzle 9 with a replacement nozzle 9 having a smaller orifice and a decreased fuel delivery rating, for example switching from a nozzle 9 rated for 1.25 gph or 1.1 gph, to a replacement nozzle 9 rated to deliver 0.85 gph. A typical firing rate of 1.25 gph for a four section boiler will generally be reduced to a range of about 0.85 gph to about 1 gph according to the invention. Furthermore, through testing it has been found to be advantageous and preferable to change the oil injection cone pattern or angle, especially to a narrower cone angle. This is also achieved by selecting a suitable replacement nozzle 9, for example such a nozzle providing a narrower 45 cone angle rather than the typical 80 cone angle of the original nozzle 9. It has been found that such a narrower oil spray cone pattern also achieves a narrower and tighter combustion flame 19, which strikes against the closer diverting target wall 6 and curls back from the target wall 6 in a swirling manner like backwash from a waterfall falling into a pool below the waterfall. Such a flame pattern has been found to achieve very good complete combustion of all of the oil confined within the new smaller combustion chamber 5 that is bounded or limited by the diverting target wall 6. This helps to ensure that the combustion flame 19 is contained within the combustion chamber 5 and does not extend further upward into the colder heat exchanger 10, thereby helping to prevent or reduce sooting of the flue passage 11A. The diverting target wall 6 also becomes glowing red hot a short time after ignition of the combustion flame 19, and this further helps to maintain a very high heat environment in the smaller combustion chamber 5 which further aids in complete combustion of all of the injected oil.
(17) Furthermore, it has found to be advantageous in some installations, to increase the oil supply pressure, as supplied by the oil pump in the burner unit 8, compared to the original pressure setting of the burner unit 8 of the unmodified boiler 1. By increasing the oil pressure and reducing the nozzle size, the oil droplets in the spray cone are more thoroughly atomized in the form of finer oil droplets. While the increased oil pressure also increases the delivery rate of oil through the nozzle, this is counterbalanced by the smaller orifice size of the nozzle. These parameters are selected as necessary to achieve the desired oil injection rate, oil droplet atomization, oil spray cone angle, and flame pattern. The overall result achieves very thorough and complete combustion of the oil, and reduced oil consumption, which contributes to the energy savings and cost savings achieved by the overall inventive modifications, system and method.
(18) A further advantageous effect and contribution to the increased efficiency relates to the flow direction of the hot flue gases relative to the flow direction of water 17 through the boiler. As described above in connection with
(19) Further modifications according to the invention relate to the venting of the boiler or heating appliance. As mentioned above, the multi-pass draft diversion necessarily imposes a greater constriction or restriction on the flue gas flow through the heat exchanger. As a result, this tends to reduce the draft through the modified boiler 1 compared to the original operating parameters of the unmodified boiler 1. Also, because the exhaust flue gas 21 exiting a modified boiler 1 is cooler than the exhaust flue gas 21 exiting the unmodified boiler 1, the buoyancy and natural draft created by the flue gas exhausting upwardly through a conventional chimney is also correspondingly reduced. This would further tend to reduce the natural draft through the modified boiler 1. Nonetheless, it has been found that derating the burner, i.e. reducing the oil injection rate, as discussed above may be adequate to maintain the required draft values over fire and at the breech. If not, a further recommended modification according to the invention is to install an insulated stainless steel chimney liner into the original natural draft chimney connected to the boiler, especially if it is an exterior uninsulated chimney. The insulated liner will achieve an increased natural draft, and will also maintain the exhaust gas temperature better throughout the height of the chimney, thereby further helping to avoid condensation of the oil combustion exhaust gases. Also, the stainless steel liner will be resistant to corrosion even if some minimal condensation of exhaust components occurs, for example at the top outlet of the chimney. Alternatively, another modification according to the invention involves providing a power venter, i.e. an electrically powered vent fan for direct venting of the boiler instead of natural draft venting via a chimney, or a draft induction fan to increase the draft provided by a chimney. One proposed arrangement according to the invention involves adding a powered draft inducer fan directly to the flue outlet collar of the flue outlet 14. Alternatively, the inventive modifications are especially suitable for use in connection with any conventional direct vent or power vented boiler arrangement. Such boiler arrangements have a forced draft that can be easily adjusted to achieve the required draft values. These considerations also apply for sealed combustion boiler and burner arrangements or any other boiler arrangement allowing a positive draft pressure value over the fire in the combustion chamber. When making the required adjustments, it must simply be considered or taken into account that there will be an additional constriction on the flue gases passing through the heat exchanger.
(20) Furthermore, while the inventive arrangements have been discussed in connection with oil-fired boilers, the same or similar modifications, features, characteristics, method steps and concepts also apply to gas-fired boilers, and especially those with power burners that positively create the required draft with a powered blower.
(21) With the teachings of the present application, a person of ordinary skill in the art is able to convert an existing old-fashioned relatively inefficient single-pass boiler to multi-pass operation with increased efficiency and decreased oil consumption. Thus, the owner of an older inefficient single-pass boiler is no longer faced with the dilemma of continuing to send money up the chimney in the form of wasted (uncaptured) heat value, or facing a high up-front capital expenditure to replace the old inefficient boiler with a new efficient multi-pass boiler. Instead, the homeowner can keep the old and serviceable yet inefficient single-pass boiler, and convert it to more-efficient multi-pass operation.
(22) As mentioned above, the front sectional view of
(23) While the inventive modifications have been described above in connection with a four-section cast iron sectional boiler as shown in
(24)
(25) However, as shown in
(26) It should further be understood, while not illustrated, that other smaller or larger boilers can also be outfitted with the flue gas diverting components and other modifications according to the invention, in a similar manner as in the boilers 1 and 2 discussed above. For example, a ten section boiler with nine flue passages can be outfitted with draft diverters to achieve a three-pass flue gas flow, respectively through three flue passages at a time, namely the flue gas flowing upwardly through three flue passages, followed by flowing downwardly through three flue passages, and then finally flowing upwardly through the last three flue passages. It is also not absolutely necessary that each pass through the heat exchanger must use the same number of flue passages. For example, in a six section boiler with a total of five flue passages, the draft diverters can be arranged to use the first two flue passages for upflow through the heat exchanger, followed by a single flue passage providing downflow through the heat exchanger, followed by an upflow through the last two flue passages. In such an arrangement, a bypass hole or gap is provided in the diverting target wall 6 and in the upper draft diverter 30 (as discussed above) to allow a bypass flow though these diverters, so that some of the flue gas does not follow the multi-pass circuit through the heat exchanger, but rather makes only a single pass through the heat exchanger. For example, about two thirds () of the combustion gas is diverted upwardly through the first two flue passages while about one third () of the combustion gas bypasses through the bypass hole in the diverting target wall 6. Then, one third () of the combustion gas is diverted downwardly through the third flue passage while one third bypasses through the bypass hole in the upper draft diverter 30. Finally, the downwardly diverted and the of the combustion gas diverted through the target wall 6 pass upwardly through the last two flue passages, and are then joined by the of combustion gas that was diverted through the upper draft diverter 30. Depending on the required firing rate, the required overfire draft, the number of flue passages, etc., various different positions and arrangements of draft diverting components are possible. For example, it is also possible to provide additional draft diverters in the heat exchange chamber 5 and/or in the flue collector chamber 12, in order to create a five-pass flow pattern through the heat exchanger 10, rather than the illustrated three-pass flow pattern. However, generally the three-pass flow pattern is preferred, because a higher number of passes through the heat exchanger may result in too great a constriction on the flue gas flow in most applications.
(27) The inventive modifications disclosed herein have been experimentally provided and tested in at least four different boilers using different brands of burners (including Carlin, Beckett, and Riello brand burners). Example test data of the combustion and efficiency parameters of two of the test units, before and after installing the inventive modifications, are as follows.
(28) TEST UNIT #1: Memco SS Four-Section Boiler
(29) Before installing inventive modifications:
(30) Single-pass flue gas flow path through three heat exchanger flue passages in parallel
(31) 0.8580 nozzle at 100 psi oil pressure
(32) Unit has powered draft induction
(33) Draft at breech 0.04 w.c.
(34) Draft over fire 0.02 w.c.
(35) Zero smoke on Bacharach scale
(36) 12% CO.sub.2
(37) Gross temperature at breech 469 F.
(38) Net temperature at breech 400 F.
(39) AFUE 83% efficiency
(40) After installing inventive modifications:
(41) Three-pass flue gas flow path through three heat exchanger flue passages in series
(42) 0.8545 nozzle at 150 psi oil pressure
(43) Unit has powered draft induction
(44) Draft at breech 0.04 w.c.
(45) Draft over fire 0.02 w.c.
(46) Zero smoke on Bacharach scale
(47) 12.5% CO.sub.2
(48) Gross temperature at breech 335 F.
(49) Net temperature at breech 260 F.
(50) AFUE 87% efficiency.
(51) TEST UNIT #2: Peerless JOWT Four-Section Boiler
(52) Before installing inventive modifications:
(53) Single-pass flue gas flow path through three heat exchanger flue passages in parallel
(54) 0.8580 nozzle at 140 psi oil pressure
(55) Unit has natural draft with chimney
(56) Draft at breech 0.03 w.c.
(57) Draft over fire 0.01 w.c.
(58) Zero smoke on Bacharach scale
(59) 12% CO.sub.2
(60) Gross temperature at breech 455 F.
(61) Net temperature at breech 390 F.
(62) AFUE 83% efficiency
(63) After installing inventive modifications:
(64) Three-pass flue gas flow path through three heat exchanger flue passages in series
(65) 0.8545 (or 60) nozzle at 150 psi oil pressure
(66) Unit has natural draft with chimney
(67) Draft at breech 0.01 w.c.
(68) Draft over fire +0.02 w.c.
(69) Trace smoke on Bacharach scale
(70) 12% CO.sub.2
(71) Gross temperature at breech 340 F.
(72) Net temperature at breech 270 F.
(73) AFUE 86% (to 87%) efficiency
(74) Note: Loss of negative draft over fire and trace of smoke in exhaust are not acceptable and must still be corrected through further adjustments and/or by providing powered draft induction and/or a pressure fired burner and/or an insulated stainless steel chimney liner to keep the chimney warmer and smoother-flowing and thus to improve the natural draft.
(75) Other test results have generally shown that typical existing four-section single-pass boilers are operating with a gross breech temperature of about 450 F. or higher, with 11 to 12% CO.sub.2 in the exhaust gas, achieving an AFUE efficiency of 83 to 85%. After installing the inventive modifications and making the associated adjustments, these boilers are found to operate with a gross breech temperature of 322 to 355 F., with about 12 to 12.5% CO.sub.2 in the exhaust gas, achieving an AFUE efficiency of at least 86%. The lower temperature exhaust gas and the associated higher efficiency means fuel savings and thus cost savings for the owner or operator of the boiler.
(76) Although the invention has been described with reference to specific example embodiments, it will be appreciated that it is intended to cover all modifications and equivalents within the scope of the appended claims. It should also be understood that the present disclosure includes all possible combinations of any individual features recited in any of the appended claims. The abstract of the disclosure does not define or limit the claimed invention, but rather merely abstracts certain features disclosed in the application.