Polycrystalline diamond percussion drill bits using low thrust and torque for application with small diameter drill bits
09551189 ยท 2017-01-24
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
E21B10/5673
FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
International classification
E21B10/46
FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
E21B17/10
FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
Abstract
A polycrystalline diamond drill bit for percussion drilling, in small holes in high silica ground. The bits are made having a bit body, and a series of insets locating in the bit body, and the bits are made using a double chisel design, or a modified double chisel design. The inserts are set into the bit body at very specific angles. The inserts have specific lengths to provide cut clearance for the bit body. The cutting angle the and radius on the tip of each insert in addition to the diameter of the inserts, provide a machine thrust pressure and machine torque pressure at low ranges when the PCD bits are used in percussion drilling.
Claims
1. A percussion drill bit, said drill bit formed having a body, the body capable of being secured with a drill shaft in preparation for a percussion drilling operation, the body having a center axis and a cutting face, the cutting face having a frontal flat face, and a beveled face extending outwardly radially therefrom, the body and the cutting face being integrally formed; said drill bit formed of a double chisel design or modified double chisel design configuration; said drill bit capable of operating at a machine torque pressure of less than 20 bar, and at a machine thrust pressure of less than 20 bar; said frontal face and said beveled face having a series of openings provided therein, and inserts being press fitted within said openings in preparation for usage of the drill bit in said drilling operation, each of said inserts having a tip comprising a polycrystalline diamond coating; select of said inserts providing a first set of inserts and others of said inserts forming a second set of inserts; said first set of inserts having a first approximately linear alignment and offset from the center axis of said bit body, and said second set of inserts having a second approximately linear alignment and also offset from the center axis of said bit body, said first and second sets of inserts forming wings of a double chisel, the first and second alignments being at an angle relative to each other; each insert provided in the cutting face of the drill bit positioned at a different radius from the center axis of said bit body than all of the other inserts provided upon said cutting face of the drill bit, each insert in the cutting face being non-tracking relative to all of the other inserts provided upon said cutting face of the drill bit; said drill bit body having a gauge diameter between about 1 inches to 3 inches; each insert being of conical shape; and each insert having a gripping portion of a diameter between about 0.300 inches to 0.520 inches, each insert having a grip length of between about 0.290 inches and 0.550 inches, and each tip of each insert having a length of between about 0.200 inches to 0.320 inches, and a conical surface of each tip formed at an angle from the insert grip portion of about 15 to 40 with the vertical of said inserts.
2. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein the drill bit operating range for machine torque pressure is between about 8 to 15 bar, and the machine thrust pressure setting for drill bit operation is set between 12 and 20 bar.
3. The percussion drill bit of claim 2 wherein the drill bit operation for optimal percussion drilling provides a machine torque pressure setting at 12 bar, and a machine thrust pressure setting at 15 bar.
4. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein the drill bit is formed of the double chisel design, and the bit body has a gauge diameter between about 1 to 2.
5. The percussion drill bit of claim 4 wherein the drill bit of double chisel design comprises four inserts provided upon the beveled face, and two inserts fitted within the frontal flat.
6. The percussion drill bit of claim 5 wherein the first and second sets of inserts each comprise at least three inserts.
7. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein said drill bit is formed of the modified double chisel design and said drill bit body has a gauge diameter about 2 to 3.
8. The percussion drill bit of claim 7 wherein the drill bit of modified double chisel design comprises between four to six PCD inserts mounted in the beveled face, and from two to four PCD inserts mounted within the frontal flat face.
9. The percussion drill bit of claim 8 wherein the first and second sets of inserts each comprise at least four inserts.
10. The percussion drill bit of claim 9 wherein said inserts having a tip radius between about 0.100 inch to 0.165 inch.
11. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein the polycrystalline diamond coating on each tip of each insert is 0.010-0.030 inch thick.
12. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein the radius from the center axis of the drill bit for each insert provided within the frontal flat face is as set forth in the following chart: TABLE-US-00005 Number of frontal flat face Radius of each insert Drill Bit Size Inserts from the center axis 1-1 1 1 2 3/16- 5/16 2 2 - 7/16 2 2 - 7/16 2 3 - 3.0 4 -- 13/16- 3 4 1.0.
13. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein each insert provided within the drill bit body having dimensions within the ranges as set forth as follows: TABLE-US-00006 Range Claimed for Inserts Range Dimensions Overall Length of Insert .500-.650 Diameter of Insert .3000-.4200 Tip Length .200-.260 Tip Angle 15.00-35.00 Tip Radius .100R-.145R Grip Length .290-.420.
14. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein each insert provided within the drill bit body having dimensions within the ranges as set forth as follows: TABLE-US-00007 Range Claimed for Inserts Range Dimensions Overall Length of Insert .600-.785 Diameter of Insert .3900-.4900 Tip Length .250-.350 Tip Angle 15.00-35.00 Tip Radius .120R-.155R Grip Length .300-.450.
15. The percussion drill bit of claim 1 wherein each insert provided within the drill bit body having dimensions within the ranges as set forth as follows: TABLE-US-00008 Range Claimed for Inserts Range Dimensions Overall Length of Insert .625-.785 Diameter of Insert .4800-.5200 Tip Length .260-.335 Tip Angle 25.00-40.00 Tip Radius .135R-.170R Grip Length .330-.500.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) In referring to the drawings,
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
(15) In referring to the drawings, and particularly
(16)
(17)
(18) More specifically, with respect to
(19) More particularly, the location of the inserts particularly upon the face of the drill bit body is rather important. It is desirable, and most effective in a drilling operation, to have each insert cutting rock around a perimeter off of the central axis of the bit body that is different from the radius of all of the other face inserts in operation. In that manner, each insert will be cutting rock independently, and not merely attempting to cut within the same groove formed by the previous insert in the rotation of the drill bit during a drilling operation. While it has been found not necessary, it may be that the inserts located upon the sloping portion of the bit body face may also be at differing radii, to attain the same effect during a drilling operation. Examples of the distance from the centerline or central axis for the drill bit body, and the radius of the insert from the centerline, may be seen from the following chart.
(20) TABLE-US-00004 No of face Drill Bit Size Inserts Distance from C/L 1 1 1 2 3/16- 5/16 2 2 - 7/16 2 2 - 7/16 2 3 3/8- 7/16- 3.0 4 -- 13/16- 3 1.0
(21) As can be noted in
(22)
(23)
(24) What can particularly be noted from the various apertures or openings that are provided within both the face of the bit body, and its sloping cutting face 8, and as also can be seen in
(25)
(26)
(27) The drill setting parameters for drilling with PCD inserts in small, 1-3 drill bits is shown. The drill parameters are extremely critical to prevent insert breakage and are mandatory when using PCD insert drill bits. These low settings are unique for drilling with PCD insert drill bits. No carbide bit can drill efficiently at these low settings in hard ground. Thrust and torque pressures are set to a minimum on the drill. Attained machine torque pressure at a range of 8-15 bar, and for the machine thrust pressure at a range of 10-20 bar is sufficient. Carbide bits require a range of 30-50 bar of machine thrust pressure, and 25-30 bar of machine torque pressure.
(28) A double chisel bit design is used with PCD inserts in bits sizes from 1-2 and a modified double chisel bit design is used in the 2-3 percussion drill bits sizes.
(29) At least, two air holes in size from 0.25 in diameter in the small 1-1 drill bits, and 3-4 holes from 0.312-0.437 in diameter in all of the bits above the 1 size are required.
(30) It is absolutely imperative to have the largest air holes possible in each bit, to flush the cuttings from the drilled hole and to keep the PCD diamond inserts cooled, to prevent deterioration of the PCD diamond due to heat. Small air/water holes tend to leave a large amount of cuttings in the hole, resulting in slower penetration rates, time lost cleaning the hole with a spoon, high bit body wear and overheating of the drill bit. Bits in sizes from 2-3 need to have a minimum of four air holes drilled into the bit body. Two on the sides of the bit and at least two in the face of the bit that is countersunk.
(31) Initial testing of 1 PCD insert percussion drill bits is ongoing and continues to date. During the early testing period, tests were conducted using thrust and torque settings for carbide bits. The initial tests were in very hard, 60,000 psi compressive strength, sandstone rock at the Mettiki coal mine near Oakland, Md. The early PCD bits tested drilled as much as 50, 6 holes, where the carbide bits could only drill about 7-6 holes.
(32) An attempt to make larger PCD insert percussion drill bits was done in sizes from 2-3. Testing at the Newmont, Leeville, mine in Nevada was started and conducted over a period of time. The 2 percussion PCD drill bits were able to drill this very hard ground two to four times faster than a carbide bit. The inserts never got dull after drilling 44,12 ft holes, 428 of hole, whereas, the carbide bits, could only drill from 2-712 ft holes before they either failed or drilled so slow that they needed to be changed out and replaced with a new bit.
(33) Penetration rates for the 2 carbide bits was from 2.59 minutes at 30 bar of machine thrust pressure and 30 bar of machine torque pressure on the first 12 hole drilled and 6.25 minutes per hole when the bit had dulled and the machine thrust pressure needed to be increased to 50 bar of machine thrust pressure and 30 bar of machine torque pressure to get the carbide bit to penetrate the ground.
(34) Penetration rates for the 2 PCD bit in most every hole drilled, ranged from 1.27 minutes with a very few holes taking 1.53 minutes to drill. The drill was set initially at 30 bar of machine thrust pressure and 30 bar of machine torque pressure. We encountered insert breakage and it took further testing before one arrived at the parameters that made it possible to drill with PCD inserts and not have the catastrophic insert failure we experienced at the initial thrust and torque settings.
(35) By setting the drill as low as possible on the thrust and torque, we found that the PCD bits, drilled faster and the requirement for torque were minimal. We had planned to lower the drill down to 12 bar of machine torque pressure and 12-15 bar of machine thrust pressure. Due to the bad maintenance on the drills, the adjustment valves would only allow us to reduce the machine torque pressure to 15 bar and 15 bar on the machine thrust pressure. At these settings, the PCD bits never experienced insert breakage, the results were outstanding. Lower torque settings were tried later and found to be even better for the PCD insert bit life and penetration rates. The penetration rate was from 50%-80% faster, than drilling with a carbide bit, using the low settings for torque and thrust.
(36) Parameters Identified for Drilling with PCD Insert Percussion Drill Bits Thrust:
(37) Settings from 10-15 bar with an extreme max upper limit of 20 bar. Anything above 20 bar, the thrust causes the inserts to penetrate the ground too deep and the torque on the drill shears off the tips of the inserts. Ideal settings 10-15 bar. One should use the lowest setting possible.
(38) Torque:
(39) Settings of 8-15 bar are recommended, with 15 being the extreme upper limit with a maximum machine thrust pressure of 15 bar. Always use the lowest settings possible.
(40) The very low thrust and torque drill settings are unique, for drilling with PCD insert drill bits, they are too low for a carbide bit to drill efficiently with, and were only discovered after trial and error to determine why the PCD inserts continually failed. The PCD bits were made a success by identifying the parameters of thrust and torque necessary to drill efficiently with PCD inserts. Carbide bits cannot drill the hard rock ground with the very low drill settings for the PCD bits. The drill settings are unique for PCD bits only. They have never been used or identified before.
(41) The design of the PCD insert 2 drill bits is a double chisel design. This 2 PCD insert design comprises four inserts on the outer gauge of the bit with two inserts in the center of the bit to make a double chisel action drill bit. From observations of the drilling, it was found that the design actually allowed the PCD drill bits to drill faster, clean the whole better and show minimal wear on the bit body in the highly abrasive ground that the testing was conducted in. Because of the length of the tip of the inserts, and the open sides of the double chisel design and the four large 0.312-0.375 diameters flushing holes, faster penetration and better cleaning of the hole was achieved. Carbide bits general have a round full face and shorter insert tips with nine inserts in the face of the bit, smaller air holes and less flushing area to rid the drilled hole of cuttings.
(42) The double chisel design of the PCD bit was a surprise because one was attempting to keep the cost per bit down by using a minimum number of very expensive PCD inserts. This design in carbide would not work in abrasive ground as there needs to be more carbide inserts on the gauge area to retard dulling. The features of the parameters required for drilling with PCD insert percussion drill bits was an innovation. Bits tried early in the development were the four wing bit and the three wing bit as in gauge sizes from 1-1. The three wing carbide bits tested, had only four inserts but were not fast in drilling, in 70% silica and 65,000 psi compressive strength sandstone rock. The four wing bits were similar as they did not perform as well as expected and were slower drilling.
(43) The PCD double chisel bit design defied all logic for performance and used the least number of inserts. This PCD bit design and the performances of the 2 double chisel design, was not expected, and now, the entire line of PCD drill bits from 1-2 shall use the same double chisel design, but the 2-3 PCD bits shall use a modified double chisel design. All bits use a 20-40 gauge angle on the body to attain gauge clearance of the bit body depending on the insert tip length used. The inserts in the center of the bit are arranged to achieve a double or modified double chisel cutting action and are in a non-tracking positions. They are nonsymmetrical in radius from the center of the bit. The PCD insert diameter for the 1-1 bits is a 0.3777 diameter insert that is 0.540-0.650 long with a single angle PCD tip for cutting. (See
(44) The cutting tip of the PCD inserts is the most critical dimension of the bit. The tip needs to be long enough to cut clearance for the bit body while maintaining structural integrity. The tip length on the 0.3777 diameter inserts needs to be from 0.230-0.260 in length. The tip on the 0.4442 diameter inserts needs to be 0.290-0.320 in length and the tip length on the 0.5002 diameter inserts needs to be from 0.300-0.325 in length. These dimensions have proven to be the most effective dimensions tested and are vital to maximizing penetration rates, bit life, and reducing wear and drag on the bit body. The radius on the nose of the tip should be 0.136R on the 0.3777 diameter, and 0.4442 diameter inserts. The radius on the nose of the 0.5002 diameter inserts as tested was a 1.50R. The 2 bits made with these inserts drilled about a minute slower than the bits made with the 0.136R radius nose. The larger cutting radius retarded penetration rates. Where one uses larger drills with more impact force on the bit, the 0.150R in the 2-3 gauge size bits works well. There needs to be a balance between the drill and the design of the PCD inserts used in the percussion drill bits.
(45)
(46) To provide even more specific ranges for the various dimensions for the conical PCD inserts, the following dimensions set forth the preferred dimensions for inserts having the diameters provided within the ranges specified, as follows:
(47) 1. A 0.3100-0.4000 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.230, a grip length of 0.370 and a cutting angle of 28 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.120R to 0.136R
(48) 2. A 0.3500-0.4000 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.230, a grip length of 0.420 and a cutting angle of 28 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.120R to 0.136R
(49) 3. A 0.4000-0.4500 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.285, a grip length of 0.315 and a cutting angle of 28 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.120R to 0.150R
(50) 4. A 0.4000-0.4500 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.310, a grip length of 0.365 and a cutting angle of 28 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.120R to 0.150R
(51) 5. A 0.4000-0.4500 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.310, a grip length of 0.500 and a cutting angle of 28 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.120R to 0.150R
(52) 6. A 0.4800-0.5200 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.320, a grip length of 0.365 and a cutting angle of 30 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.150R to 0.165R
(53) 7. A 0.4800-0.5200 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.320, a grip length of 0.405 and a cutting angle of 30 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.150R to 0.165R
(54) 8. A 0.4800-0.5200 dia. PCD conical insert that has a tip length of 0.320, a grip length of 0.470 and a cutting angle of 30 to 35 degrees with a tip radius of 0.150R to 0.165R
(55) A bit body with a sloped outer gauge area for placing the gauge cutting PCD diamond inserts. The slope angle on the bit body in a range of 25 to 35 degrees.
(56) The low thrust settings on a drilling machine, in a range of 10 bar to 20 bar when using PCD insert percussion drill bits.
(57) The low torque settings on a drill machine, in a range of 8 bar to 15 bar when using PCD insert percussion drill bits.
(58) As noted in
(59) In addition,
(60) Further testing of PCD percussion drill bits indicates that they can operate effectively with a machine thrust pressure rate of 15 bar, as long as the machine torque pressure is reduced to 8 to 15 bar maximum. 12 bar maximum is preferred. These are very low ranges for percussion drill bits. Previous tests indicated that the machine thrust pressure could be as high as 20 bar, but this higher thrust did result in the inserts penetrating far deeper than required, resulting in insert failure, particularly where the machine torque pressure may have been set at 20 plus bar during testing. A maximum penetration rate of the PCD drill bits of 3.5 m/min was obtained when the machine thrust pressure was set at 16 bar and the machine torque pressure was set at 12 bar. Machine thrust pressure settings beyond 16 bar tended to slow down the penetration rate by a few seconds, caused the inserts to be driven deeper into the rock strata, in softer formations, and thereby increased the potential of insert breakage by a high torque. Breakage will definitely occur, it has been found, if the machine torque pressure is not reduced to 8 bar-15 bar maximum. These are levels that were never considered with prior art percussion drilling.
(61) As previously reviewed, the polycrystalline diamond inserts do need to have very specific dimensions, as set forth in the various tables previously reviewed, as for example, tip length, tip angle, and tip radius, to attain maximum performance and penetration rates, must be closely followed. Bit body angles for the outer gauge cutting PCD inserts needs to be set at specific angles, as detailed in these tables.
(62) On all chisel PCD bit designs, in sizes from 1 inch to 1 inch, the air holes need to be 0.250 inches in diameter, and there needs to be two side holes, and one hole in the face of the bit body, to make it work effectively. On all PCD bits and sizes from 1 inch to 2 inch gauge, there needs to be at least four air/water holes, as they need to be as large as possible to adequately flush the cuttings from the drilled hole. These holes need to be a combination of 0.250 inches, 0.312 inches, and 0.4375 inches in diameter. On PCD bits that range in size from 2 inch to 3 inch diameters, there needs to be five, six or seven air/water holes in the bit body, and these holes need to be in a range of sizes from 0.375 inches to 0.437 inches in diameter. On all PCD bits, it is suggested to always use the largest holes possible to facilitate cleaning of the hole of the drilled cuttings. This reduces abrasive wear on the bit body, and aids in faster penetration rates by not having to re-drill cuttings in the hole.
(63) PCD bits use a machine thrust pressure of up to 20 bar and a machine torque pressure of 12 bar max, the insert tips are longer and they show no wear in very hard and highly abrasive rock strata. PCD percussion drill bits drill 30%-50% faster than carbide bits, when tested side by side on the same drill. Carbide bits can not drill efficiently at the low thrust and torque settings used and required for the PCD drill bits in hard rock ground. After testing, and observing the PCD chisel and modified chisel bit designs as described herein, it has become evident that if percussion PCD bits are used and the parameters are set to the established settings, and the inserts and bit bodies have the established and recommended dimensions, and there is adequate air/water for flushing of the drilled hole, then using this unique system of low thrust and low torque for percussion drilling with PCD insert percussion drill bits is unique to the drilling world. If only parts of this system are used, separately, there will be some efficiency lost in the operation.
(64) All of the bits in the PCD line are designed with a double chisel or modified double chisel design to maximize penetration rates, increase bit life, and reduce cuttings left in the hole and to reduce bit body wear. The combination of the double chisel design, the tip length and smaller radius on the nose of the inserts, are what made these drill bits effective and drill 12 holes 2-4 times faster than carbide bits on every test conducted.
(65) Variations or modifications to the subject matter of this invention may occur to those skilled in the art upon review of the invention as described herein. Such variations, if within the spirit of this invention, are intended to be encompassed within the scope of any claims to patent protection issuing hereon. The description of the preferred embodiment, and its depiction in the drawings, are set forth for illustrative purposes only.