Method and device for determining the optimal turn direction of an aircraft
09536433 · 2017-01-03
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
Abstract
A method determines the optimal turn direction of an aircraft among two directions, right and left, following a lateral trajectory to join an arrival straight charted by an angle of arrival, based on a departure point and angle of departure defining a departure straight oriented along movement of the aircraft, the direction defined by a respectively positive or negative optimal turn sign, comprising: determining a conventional departure sign of the departure point; determining a center value of an angle of change of course equal to the difference between the angle of arrival and angle of departure referred back between 180 and +180, the center value exhibiting a logical sign corresponding to the center value sign of the angle of change of course; determining the sign of the optimal turn based on comparison between the departure sign and the logical sign, the sign of the optimal turn defining optimal turn direction.
Claims
1. A method for determining a lateral trajectory followed by an aircraft executed by a flight management system, the lateral trajectory being computed on a basis of a plurality of successively inserted sections of a flight plan and of aircraft parameters input by a pilot, a transition between two successive inserted sections requiring in certain cases that the aircraft turns according to a turn direction, said method comprising for at least one inserted section requiring said turn, a step of determining an optimal turn direction method of the aircraft defined with respect to its movement, from among two directions, right and left, the aircraft following the lateral trajectory so as to join an arrival straight oriented according to the desired direction of movement of the aircraft and charted by an angle of arrival, on a basis of a departure point and of an angle of departure defining a departure straight oriented in the direction of movement of the aircraft, the right or left direction of the optimal turn with respect to the movement of the aircraft being conventionally defined by a respectively positive or negative optimal turn sign, the said step of determining the optimal turn direction method comprising the steps: determining a conventional departure sign of the departure point with respect to the oriented arrival straight, the departure sign being positive or negative when the departure point is situated respectively on the left or on the right of the oriented arrival straight, determining a centered value of an angle of change of course equal to a difference between the angle of arrival and the angle of departure referred back between 180 and +180 , the said centered value exhibiting a logical sign corresponding to the sign of the centered value of the angle of change of course, determining the sign of the optimal turn on the basis of the comparison between the departure sign and the logical sign, the said sign of the optimal turn defining the optimal turn direction, and the method further comprising the steps of computing the lateral trajectory and proposing to the pilot to insert the computed trajectory in a flight plan.
2. The method according to claim 1, in which step of determining the sign of the optimal turn comprises the sub-step consisting in comparing the departure sign of the departure point and the logical sign, when the said signs are different, the optimal turn sign is equal to the logical sign, when the signs are equal, the sign of the optimal turn is determined by a sub-step on the basis of the logical sign.
3. The method according to claim 2, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn when the said signs are equal consists in assigning the opposite of the logical sign to the sign of the optimal turn.
4. The method according to claim 2, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn when the said signs are equal is performed as a function of the absolute value of the centered value of the angle of change of course and/or of the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight.
5. The method according to claim 4, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn when the said signs are equal comprises the sub-step consisting in: comparing the absolute value of the centered value of the angle of change of course with an angle equal to 180 minus a joining angle lying between 10 and 90 , when the said absolute value is less than the difference between 180 and the said joining angle, the optimal turn sign is equal to the logical sign, when the said absolute value is greater than or equal to the difference between 180 and the said joining angle, the sign of the optimal turn is equal to the opposite of the logical sign.
6. The method according to claim 5, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn, when the said signs are equal and when on output from the comparison step the said absolute value is greater than or equal to the difference between 180 and the said joining angle, comprises the sub-steps consisting in: determining a distance between the departure point and the arrival straight by orthogonal projection of the departure point onto the arrival straight, comparing the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight and a joining distance, when the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is less than the joining distance, the sign of the optimal turn is equal to the logical sign, when the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is greater than or equal to the joining distance, the sign of the optimal turn is equal to the opposite of the logical sign.
7. The method according to claim 5, in which the joining angle is equal to 45 .
8. The method according to claim 4, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn when the said signs are equal comprises the sub-steps consisting in: determining a distance between the departure point and the arrival straight by orthogonal projection of the departure point onto the arrival straight, comparing the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight and a joining distance, when the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is less than the joining distance, the sign of the optimal turn is equal to the logical sign, when the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is greater than or equal to the joining distance, the sign of the optimal turn is equal to the opposite of the logical sign.
9. The method according to claim 8, in which the joining distance (Dist-r) is computed by the following formula: Dist-r=Rv*(1 +sin), in which Rv is a turning radius of the transition and is the centered value of the angle of change of course TCc.
10. The method according to claim 1, the method further comprising the steps of: determining the optimal turn direction of the said transition for each transition between a preceding section and a following section requiring a turn, the preceding section exhibiting the departure point and the angle of departure, the following section exhibiting the angle of arrival according to the desired direction of movement, and computing the lateral trajectory of the transition between the preceding section and the following section on the basis of the optimal turn direction computed at the previous step.
11. A method for determining a lateral trajectory of an aircraft executed by a flight management system, the lateral trajectory being computed on the basis of a plurality of successively inserted sections of a flight plan, a transition between two successive sections requiring in certain cases that the aircraft turn according to a turn direction, the method comprising the steps consisting in, for each transition between a preceding section and a following section requiring a turn: determining the optimal turn direction of the said transition by the method according to claim 1, the preceding section exhibiting the departure point and the angle of departure, the following section exhibiting the angle of arrival according to the desired direction of movement, computing the lateral trajectory of the transition between the preceding section and the following section on the basis of the optimal turn direction computed at the previous step, wherein the optimal turn direction is determined by the method according to claim 1 for the transitions of the flight plan not exhibiting a turn direction predefined in a navigation database.
12. The method according to claim 1, the method further comprising the steps consisting in, upon the insertion of a section for which it is necessary that the aircraft turn in order to join the said section from the preceding section: asking the pilot to choose the turn direction to be taken into account, when the pilot chooses the turn direction from among right and left, computing the lateral trajectory of the transition between the preceding section and the inserted section with the chosen turn direction, when the pilot chooses an automatic determination of the turn direction: determining the optimal turn direction according to claim 1, the preceding section exhibiting the departure point and the angle of departure, the inserted section exhibiting the angle of arrival according to the desired direction of movement, and computing the lateral trajectory of the transition between the preceding section and the following section on the basis of the optimal turn direction computed at the previous step.
13. The method according to claim 12, in which the pilot is interrogated regarding the turn direction to be taken into account when the said turn direction is not predefined in a navigation database.
14. The method according to claim 1, the aircraft having quit its initial flight plan comprising a plurality of successive sections, the said joining trajectory being computed between a current position of the aircraft and an arrival section chosen by the pilot from among the sections of the initial flight plan, the said trajectory being determined on the basis of said step of determining an optimal turn direction according to claim 1, and the current position corresponding to the departure point, the aircraft flying according to an angle of departure, the arrival section exhibiting the angle of arrival according to the desired direction of movement.
15. A computer program product, the said computer program comprising code instructions making it possible to perform the steps of the method according to claim 1.
16. A flight management system configured to compute a lateral trajectory followed by an aircraft computed on a basis of a plurality of successively inserted sections of a flight plan and of aircraft parameters inserted by a pilot, a transition between two successive inserted sections requiring in certain cases that the aircraft turns according to a turn direction, said flight management system comprising a device for determining the optimal turn direction of an aircraft being defined with respect to its movement, from among two directions, right and left, the aircraft following the lateral trajectory so as to join an arrival straight oriented according to the desired direction of movement of the aircraft and charted by an angle of arrival, on a basis of a departure point and of an angle of departure defining a departure straight oriented in the direction of movement of the aircraft, the right or left direction of the optimal turn with respect to the movement of the aircraft being conventionally defined by a respectively positive or negative optimal turn sign, the said device comprising: a module for determining a conventional departure sign of the departure point with respect to the oriented arrival straight, the departure sign being positive or negative when the departure point is situated respectively on the left or on the right of the oriented arrival straight, a module for determining a centered value of an angle of change of course equal to a difference between the angle of arrival and the angle of departure referred back between 180 and +180 , the said centered value exhibiting a logical sign corresponding to the sign of the centered value of the angle of change of course, and a module for determining a sign of the optimal turn on the basis of the comparison between the departure sign and the logical sign, the said sign of the optimal turn defining the optimal turn direction.
17. A method for determining a lateral trajectory followed by an aircraft executed by a flight management system, the lateral trajectory being computed on a basis of a plurality of successively inserted sections of a flight plan and of aircraft parameters input by a pilot, a transition between two successive inserted sections requiring in certain cases that the aircraft turns according to a turn direction, said method comprising for at least one inserted section requiring said turn, a step of determining an optimal turn direction method of the aircraft defined with respect to its movement, from among two directions, right and left, the aircraft following the lateral trajectory so as to join an arrival straight oriented according to the desired direction of movement of the aircraft and charted by an angle of arrival, on a basis of a departure point and of an angle of departure defining a departure straight oriented in the direction of movement of the aircraft, the right or left direction of the optimal turn with respect to the movement of the aircraft being defined by a respectively positive or negative optimal turn sign, the said step of determining the optimal turn direction method comprising the steps: determining a conventional departure sign of the departure point with respect to the oriented arrival straight with the flight management system, the departure sign being positive or negative when the departure point is situated respectively on the left or on the right of the oriented arrival straight, determining a centered value of an angle of change of course equal to a difference between the angle of arrival and the angle of departure referred back between 180 and +180 with the flight management system, the said centered value exhibiting a logical sign corresponding to the sign of the centered value of the angle of change of course, determining the sign of the optimal turn on the basis of the comparison between the departure sign and the logical sign with the flight management system, the said sign of the optimal turn defining the optimal turn direction, and the method further comprising the steps of computing the lateral trajectory with the flight management system and proposing to the pilot to insert the computed trajectory in a flight plan utilizing the flight management system.
18. The method according to claim 17, in which step of determining the sign of the optimal turn comprises the sub-step consisting in comparing the departure sign of the departure point and the logical sign, when the said signs are different, the optimal turn sign is equal to the logical sign, when the signs are equal, the sign of the optimal turn is determined by a sub-step on the basis of the logical sign.
19. The method according to claim 18, in which the sub-step of determining the sign of the optimal turn when the said signs are equal consists in assigning the opposite of the logical sign to the sign of the optimal turn.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) Other characteristics, aims and advantages of the present invention will become apparent on reading the detailed description which follows and with regard to the appended drawings given by way of nonlimiting examples and in which:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(19)
(20) The right or left direction of the optimal turn TDopt with respect to the movement of the aircraft is conventionally defined by a respectively positive + or negative optimal turn sign S.sub.TDopt. The method 10 according to the invention determines the sign of TDopt, and therefore TDopt itself by application of the convention:
S.sub.TDopt=+, TDopt=towards the right
S.sub.TDopt=, TDopt=towards the left.
(21) The method 10 according to the invention comprises the following steps.
(22) A step 150 consists in determining a conventional departure sign S.sub.Pd of the departure point Pd with respect to the oriented arrival straight Da. The departure sign is positive when the departure point Pd is situated on the left of the oriented arrival straight Da and negative when the departure point Pd is situated on the right of the arrival straight. This convention is illustrated in
(23) The space is indeed conventionally divided into two parts, a positive part situated on the left of the oriented straight Da, a negative part situated to its right. The sign of the point Pd makes it possible to characterize its position with respect to oriented straight Da.
(24) A step 200 consists in determining a centred value TCc of the angle of change of course equal to the difference between the angle of arrival Aa and the angle of departure Ad referred back between 180 and +180. TCc=value of (AaAd) lying between 180 and +180.
(25) The centred value TCc exhibits a logical sign SI corresponding to the sign of the centred value TCc of the angle of change of course.
(26) The logical sign SI corresponds to the LTD defined according to the prior art.
(27) A step 300 determines the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt on the basis of the comparison between the departure sign S.sub.Pd and the logical sign SI, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt defining the optimal turn direction TDopt, as explained hereinabove.
(28) The inventors have established that situations existed for which the choice of the LTD was not relevant, and that it was firstly appropriate to take account of the position of the departure point Pd with respect to the straight Da by way of its conventional sign S.sub.Pd.
(29) The inventors have thus established that as a function of the comparison between S.sub.Pd and the logical sign SI, either the sign of the optimal turn TDopt is equal to LTD, or it is equal to its opposite.
(30) Stated otherwise the method 10 according to the invention introduces a new parameter S.sub.Pd and a new step of comparison 300 between the logical sign SI equal to the LTD that would have been systematically chosen by an FMS according to the prior art computing the lateral trajectory, and this sign S.sub.Pd.
(31) An advantage of the method is that it introduces into the determination of the optimal turn direction TDopt a parameter dependent on the position, to the left or to the right, of the departure point with respect to the arrival straight Da, that is to say it takes account in a simple manner of the geometry of the flight plan of the aircraft.
(32) Taking this parameter into account makes it possible to choose a turn direction opposite to the LTD in certain situations for which this choice is more appropriate, as explained further on.
(33)
(34) According to this variant, step 300 of determining the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt comprises a sub-step 310 consisting in comparing the departure sign S.sub.Pd of the departure point Pd and the logical sign SI, and in defining the optimal turn turn sign S.sub.TDopt according to the following logic: when the signs are different, the optimal turn sign is equal to the logical sign SI:
S.sub.TDopt=SI=LTD when the signs are equal, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is determined by a sub-step 320 on the basis of the logical sign SI.
(35) The inventors have thus established that when the signs are different, the choice of LTD is a correct choice, and that the situations posing a problem correspond to the case for which the signs S.sub.Pd and SI are equal.
(36) The inventors have also fine-tuned two embodiments for carrying out the computation of the sign of TDopt on the basis of SI.
(37) According to a first embodiment illustrated in
(38) This entails a first choice of very simple logic.
(39)
(40) The logical sign SI is negative since the value of TCc is negative.
(41) A system according to the prior art computes a joining trajectory 80 comprising a leftward turn direction LTD.
(42) The sign of the point Pd is negative, and therefore the sign of Pd S.sub.Pd and the logical sign are both negative. The method 10 according to the invention determines a sign S.sub.TDopt of the optimal turn direction TDopt positive, i.e. a rightward optimal direction with a joining trajectory 81. It is noted in the figure that this trajectory 81 is shorter, and this may save fuel and above all allows a better slaving of the trajectory flown by the aeroplane to the flight plan defined by the pilot and/or the air traffic control.
(43) According to a second embodiment illustrated in
(44) The introduction of two criteria, one dependent on ITCcI and the other on Dist, these criteria being able to be used independently or cumulatively, makes it possible to refine the logic for determining TDopt.
(45)
(46) According to this variant, the sub-step 320 of determining the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt when the signs are equal comprises a sub-step 321 which compares the absolute value of the centred value of the angle of change of course ITCcI with an angle equal to 180 minus a joining angle AR lying between 10 and 90.
(47) A joining angle AR corresponds to the angle according to which an aircraft must join a straight line in space corresponding to its desired trajectory, such as the arrival straight Da and is illustrated in
(48) The joining angle corresponds to the angle of capture of the second leg L2 from the first leg L1. This angle can vary between 10 and 90 according to systems and according to operational needs. For aeroplanes flying commercial flights, AR is preferably equal to 45.
(49) When ITCcI is less than the difference between 180 and the joining angle, the optimal turn sign S.sub.TDopt is equal to the logical sign SI:
ITCcI<180AR, S.sub.TDopt=SI.
(50) When ITCcI is greater than or equal to the difference between 180 and the joining angle, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is equal to the opposite of the logical sign:
ITCcI180 AR, S.sub.TDopt=SI.
(51) This criterion makes it possible to take account of the ability of the aircraft to readily capture the arrival straight Da with the trajectory computed with a TDopt determined with the previous logic. Indeed when TCc is small, whatever its sign, there is little benefit (unless obliged by procedure) in computing a trajectory in the non-logical direction.
(52)
(53) According to this variant, the sub-step 320 of determining the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt when the signs are equal comprises a sub-step 322 consisting in determining 322 a distance Dist between the departure point Pd and the arrival straight Da by orthogonal projection of the departure point onto the arrival straight.
(54) Next a sub-step 323 compares the distance Dist between the departure point and the arrival straight with a predetermined joining distance Dist-r:
(55) When the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is less than the joining distance Dist-r, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is equal to the logical sign SI:
Dist<Dist-rS.sub.TDopt=SI.
(56) When the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight Dist is greater than or equal to the joining distance Dist-r, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is equal to the opposite of the logical sign SI:
DistDist-rS.sub.TDopt=SI.
(57) This condition will be better understood with the aid of
(58) If the point Pd is sufficiently far from the straight Da (DistDist-r) the aircraft can join the latter directly by carrying out the turn. The limit case is illustrated in
(59) If point Pd is too close to the straight Da, the aircraft will overshoot the straight Da while performing its turn, this situation being illustrated in
(60) The minimum distance of the point Pd from the straight Da making it possible to avoid overshoot corresponds to the distance Dist-r.
(61) The aforementioned condition makes it possible to eliminate overshoot situations, such that Dist<Dist-r, when they must not be accepted. The turn according to the desired track is accepted only if the aircraft is able to join the arrival straight or second leg L2 directly, without overshooting.
(62) A minimum distance Dist-r can also be chosen by providing a margin.
(63) Conventionally, the minimum distance Dist-r is computed as a function of the turning radius Rv of the transition according to the formula:
Dist-r=Rv*(1+sin),
With =TCc.
(64) According to a third variant illustrated in
(65) When the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is less than the joining distance Dist-r, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is equal to the logical sign SI.
(66) When the distance between the departure point and the arrival straight is greater than or equal to the joining distance Dist-r, the sign of the optimal turn S.sub.TDopt is equal to the opposite of the logical sign SI.
(67) Cumulatively taking into account the position of the departure point Pd/first leg L1 (sign of Pd), the distance of Pd from the straight Da/leg L2 and the value of the angle of change of course TCc for the determination of the optimal turn direction TDopt makes it possible to finely identify situations for which the LTD according to the prior art does not correspond to the correct choice, and therefore to determine an optimal turn direction suited in any circumstances to the aircraft's flight conditions.
(68)
(69) The system according to the prior art does not take into account the geographical position of the desired arrival point Pa, i.e. the arrival waypoint WPa corresponding to the leg 2. As described in
(70) The trajectory 81 obtained on the basis of the turn direction determined by the method according to the invention joins further upstream the arrival straight Da, and therefore makes it possible to comply with the arrival point Pa.
(71) According to another aspect, the invention relates to a method for determining a lateral trajectory of an aircraft using the above-described method for determining the turn direction according to the invention. The trajectory can be computed in various situations and according to diverse variants of operational implementations, explained hereinbelow by way of example.
(72) A first variant relates to a method for determining a lateral trajectory of an aircraft, computed on the basis of a plurality of successively inserted sections of a flight plan, a transition between two successive sections requiring in certain cases that the aircraft turn according to a turn direction, the method comprising the steps consisting in, for each transition between a preceding section and a following section requiring a turn: determining the optimal turn direction TDopt of the said transition by the method described hereinabove, the preceding section exhibiting the departure point Pd and the angle of departure Ad, the following section exhibiting the angle of arrival Aa according to the desired direction of movement, computing the lateral trajectory of the transition between the preceding section and the following section on the basis of the optimal turn direction TDopt computed at the previous step.
(73) According to one embodiment of this first variant, the optimal turn direction TDopt is determined by the method hereinabove for the transitions of the flight plan not exhibiting a turn direction predefined in a navigation database.
(74) A second variant illustrated in
(75) Note that the pilot may not wish to choose the turn direction, this amounting to engaging the automatic mode by default, the pilot being able at any moment to decide to force the choice to a value or to let the system choose.
(76) According to one embodiment of this second variant, the pilot is interrogated regarding the turn direction to be taken into account when the turn direction is not predefined in the navigation database.
(77) A third variant relates to a method for determining a lateral joining trajectory of an aircraft that has quitted its initial flight plan comprising a plurality of successive sections, the joining trajectory being computed between a current position of the aircraft and an arrival section chosen by the pilot from among the sections of the initial flight plan, the trajectory being determined on the basis of an optimal turn direction TDopt computed by the method hereinabove, the current position corresponding to the departure point Pd, the aircraft flying according to an angle of departure Ad, the arrival section exhibiting the angle of arrival according to the desired direction of movement.
(78) According to another aspect, the invention relates to a device 160 for determining the optimal turn direction TDopt of an aircraft defined with respect to its movement, from among two directions, right and left.
(79) The aircraft follows a lateral trajectory to join an arrival straight Da oriented according to the desired direction of movement of the aircraft and charted by an angle of arrival Aa, on the basis of a departure point Pd and of an angle of departure Ad defining a departure straight Dd oriented in the direction of movement of the aircraft.
(80) The right or left direction of the optimal turn TDopt with respect to the movement of the aircraft is conventionally defined by a respectively positive or negative optimal turn sign S.sub.TDopt.
(81) The device, illustrated in
(82) According to one embodiment, the module 160 is integrated into a flight management system FMS, typically in its TRAJ module 105.
(83) The invention thus also relates to a flight management system of an aircraft of FMS type comprising the device 160 according to the invention.
(84) According to a last aspect, the invention relates to a computer program product comprising code instructions making it possible to perform the steps of the method according to the invention.