Device comprising a capillary tube and a measurement module for estimating an activity of a radioactive liquid
12510678 · 2025-12-30
Assignee
- Ogheard; Florestan (Lyons, FR)
- COMMISSARIAT À L'ENERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ENERGIES ALTERNATIVES (Paris, FR)
Inventors
- Florestan Ogheard (Lyons, FR)
- Benoit Sabot (Gif-sur-Yvette, FR)
- Philippe GERVAIS (Orsay, FR)
- Matthieu Hamel (Gif-sur-Yvette, FR)
Cpc classification
G01T1/1645
PHYSICS
G01T1/167
PHYSICS
G01T1/2006
PHYSICS
International classification
G01T1/167
PHYSICS
Abstract
A device to measure the activity of a radioactive liquid, including a detection module, which extends around a measurement chamber that is intended to contain the liquid, and which is configured to detect ionizing radiation and to generate a detection signal; and a processing unit, which is connected to the detection module, and programmed to estimate an activity of the radioactive liquid based on the detection signal. The detection module comprises a solid-state scintillator detector, extending around the measurement chamber; and at least two photodetectors that are optically coupled to the scintillator detector. The device comprises a capillary tube, extending around a longitudinal axis, the capillary tube being arranged to be placed in a measurement position, and the capillary tube forming the measurement chamber.
Claims
1. A device configured to measure an activity of a radioactive liquid, the device comprising: a detector, which extends around a measurement chamber that is configured to contain the radioactive liquid, the detector being configured to detect ionizing radiation emitted from the measurement chamber and to generate a detection signal dependent on an amount of the detected ionizing radiation; and processing circuitry, connected to the detector, and programmed to estimate an activity of the radioactive liquid based on the detection signal, wherein: the detector comprises: a solid-state scintillator detector configured to produce scintillation photons when exposed to ionizing radiation, the solid-state scintillator detector extending around the measurement chamber; and at least two photodetectors that are optically coupled to the solid-state scintillator detector, each photodetector of the at least two photodetectors being configured to detect scintillation photons and to generate a detection signal dependent on an amount of scintillation photons detected; and the device further comprises a capillary tube, which extends around a longitudinal axis, and which defines an internal space configured to contain the radioactive liquid, the capillary tube being configured to be placed in a measurement position in which the solid-state scintillator detector extends around the internal space of the capillary tube, the capillary tube forming the measurement chamber.
2. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the solid-state scintillator detector extends around the capillary tube.
3. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the solid-state scintillator detector forms a wall of the capillary tube.
4. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein: the solid-state scintillator detector forms an aperture along the longitudinal axis; and the capillary tube extends through the aperture when the capillary tube is placed in the measurement position.
5. The device as claimed in claim 4, wherein the solid-state scintillator detector comprises a central segment, through which the aperture passes, the central segment being spherical, cylindrical, or polyhedral.
6. The device as claimed in claim 5, wherein each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, is optically coupled to the solid-state scintillator detector by a planar face; and the solid-state scintillator detector extends, from the aperture, to at least one planar face, so that the solid-state scintillator detector comprises the central segment, around the aperture, and at least one planar face.
7. The device as claimed in claim 6, wherein the solid-state scintillator detector comprises as many planar faces as there are photodetectors in the at least two photodetectors.
8. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, extends around a detection axis being secant to the longitudinal axis.
9. The device as claimed in claim 8, wherein respective detection axes of each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, are coplanar.
10. The device as claimed in claim 8, wherein respective detection axes of each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, are regularly spaced angularly with respect to one another about the longitudinal axis.
11. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, is optically coupled to the solid-state scintillator detector by a planar face.
12. The device as claimed in claim 11, further comprising a coupling segment formed by a material that is transparent to the scintillation photons, extending between the solid-state scintillator detector and at least one planar face.
13. The device as claimed in claim 1, further comprising a spectrometric detector, which lies facing the capillary tube, and which is connected to the processing circuitry, the processing circuitry being configured to detect a presence of impurities in the radioactive liquid, based on X-ray fluorescence peaks in a spectrum generated by the spectrometric detector.
14. The device as claimed in claim 1, further comprising a motorized translating unit including a motor and configured to move the capillary tube translationally along the longitudinal axis, so that the capillary tube may pass between the measurement position, facing the solid-state scintillator detector, and at least one sampling position, the at least one sampling position being offset, along the longitudinal axis, with respect to the measurement position.
15. The device as claimed in claim 14, further comprising a pumping unit configured to: admit, in the at least one sampling position, the radioactive liquid into the internal space of the capillary tube when the capillary tube is in contact with a solution contained in a reservoir, the radioactive liquid contained in the capillary tube forming a sample of the solution; and/or expel the radioactive liquid from the internal space of the capillary tube.
16. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein the capillary tube has an internal face bounding the internal space, the internal face being hydrophobic.
17. The device as claimed in claim 1, wherein; the detection signal resulting from each photodetector, of the at least two photodetectors, comprises pulses, each pulse resulting from an interaction of one particle, forming the ionizing radiation, in the solid-state scintillator detector; the processing circuitry is configured to detect pulses detected in a temporal coincidence by the at least two photodetectors; and the processing circuitry is further programmed to estimate an activity depending on a number of pulses detected in a temporal coincidence.
18. The device as claimed in claim 1, further comprising an observation camera arranged to view the capillary tube when the capillary tube is in an observation position, the observation position being offset from the measurement position, the processing circuitry being further programmed to estimate a volume of the radioactive liquid in the capillary tube depending on an image delivered by the observation camera.
19. A method for estimating an activity of the radioactive liquid using a device as claimed in claim 1, comprising: (a) introducing a liquid sample into the capillary tube; (b) placing the capillary tube in the measurement position; (c) acquiring detection signals with each photodetector; and (d) depending on the acquired detection signals, estimating the activity of the liquid sample present in the capillary tube, using the processing circuitry.
20. The method as claimed in claim 19, wherein: in step (a), the capillary tube occupies a sampling position, in contact with a reservoir containing the radioactive liquid; and between step (a) and step (b), the capillary tube is moved by a translating unit that includes a motor from the sampling position to the measurement position.
21. The method as claimed in claim 20, wherein in step (a), a pump is activated so as to suck some of the radioactive liquid present in the reservoir toward the capillary tube.
22. The method as claimed in claim 19, wherein step (d) further comprises: detecting, in the detection signals, double coincidence pulses generated in a temporal coincidence by two photodetectors of the at least two photodetectors; taking into account a detection efficiency relating to double coincidences; and determining the activity of the radioactive liquid based on a number of the double coincidences detected per unit time and the detection efficiency relating to the double coincidences.
23. The method as claimed in claim 22, wherein the at least two photodetectors comprise three photodetectors; and the detection efficiency relating to double coincidences is calculated based on a ratio between a number of pulses generated, in the detection signals, in a temporal coincidence by the three photodetectors and the number of double coincidences detected per unit time.
Description
FIGURES
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
DESCRIPTION OF PARTICULAR EMBODIMENTS
(15)
(16) Generally, the activity per unit volume or mass of a solution, intended to be injected into the body of a patient, is very high. In order to obtain an activity measurement with good accuracy, it is preferable to use a sample of small volume, so as to avoid saturation of the detector used. The inventors consider that a volume of less than 10 L, and preferably of 1 L or of a few L, is optimal. The volume may also be of the order of a few 100 nL or a few 10 nL or even of the order of 1 nL. The activity per unit volume is high enough for the total activity to be easily measurable. Moreover, the fact that the total activity of the sample is high enough makes it possible to carry out measurements spaced apart in time, and to check that the decrease in activity as a function of time is consistent with the half-life of the isotope.
(17) The radiopharmaceutical solution to be injected is contained, in liquid form, in a reservoir 20. One important element of the invention is use of a capillary tube 3, which is intended to collect the sample 2 of the pharmaceutical solution. In the example shown, the capillary tube 3 is a capillary tube made of quartz (fused silica), of 15 cm length, 900 m inside diameter and 1200 m outside diameter. The capillary tube 3 extends around a longitudinal axis . In this example, the longitudinal axis is parallel to a vertical axis Z. The horizontal plane P.sub.XY is defined by two orthogonal axes X and Y.
(18) The capillary tube 3 is translatable using a translation stage 4, which is preferably motorized. In the example shown, the translation stage is configured to move along a mast 5, parallel to the longitudinal axis . The translation stage allows a translation, along the longitudinal axis , of the capillary tube. The capillary tube may thus occupy various positions along the longitudinal axis, as described below.
(19) The device 1 comprises a measurement module 10, intended to quantify the activity of the sample 2 previously taken using the capillary tube 3. The translation stage 4 is thus configured to move the capillary tube between: A sampling position, in contact with the reservoir 20, so as to take a sample 2 of radiopharmaceutical solution: the sampling position is shown in
(20) The device is arranged so that when the capillary tube is in the sampling position, the capillary tube is engaged in the reservoir 20, so as make contact with the radiopharmaceutical solution. The reservoir 20 is removable and may not form part of the device. It may simply be a vial. The capillary tube 3 is connected, by a fluid connection, to a pumping unit 21. In this example, a first end 3.sub.1 of the capillary tube is dipped into the reservoir 20. The capillary tube has a second end 3.sub.2 opposite the first end 31. The second end 3.sub.2 is connected, by a steel tube 22, to the pumping unit 21. In this example, the pumping unit 21 is a syringe connected to a syringe driver. The steel tube 22 (inside diameter 2 mm) acts as a fluid connection between the capillary tube 3 and the pumping unit 21. Under the effect of actuation of the syringe driver, the pumping unit allows a negative or positive pressure to be applied to the capillary tube. This allows the radiopharmaceutical solution to be pumped or expelled through the first end 3.sub.1 of the capillary tube. A liquid sample 2 is thus taken. Admission of the liquid sample 2 into the capillary tube 3 has been represented in
(21) The device may comprise a tracking camera 23 configured to view admission of the liquid sample into the capillary tube 3. The tracking camera 23 is arranged to make it possible to view the position of the capillary tube 3 with respect to the solution present in the reservoir 20. When the first end 3.sub.1 has been dipped into the solution, the pumping unit 21 may be actuated. The device 1 may comprise a weighing machine 24 bearing the reservoir 20.
(22) After the sample 2 has been taken, the capillary tube 3 is translated by the translating stage 4, so as to move it away from the reservoir 20. The pumping unit 21 may be actuated so as to move the sample 2 inside the capillary tube 3.
(23) The capillary tube 3 is then moved, parallel to the longitudinal axis , to an observation position facing an observation camera 30. The observation camera makes it possible to form an image of the capillary tube 3, so as to estimate the volume of the sample 2. The way in which the volume of the sample is calculated is described below, with reference to
(24) Following acquisition of the image of the sample 2 by the observation camera 30, the capillary tube 3 is translated, by the translation stage 4, to a measurement position. In the measurement position, the sample 2 is placed in the measurement module 10. The device comprises a processing unit 40, which is connected to the measurement module 10, and programmed to estimate an activity of the sample 2 based on detection signals generated by the measurement module 10.
(25) Thus, contrary to the prior art, the capillary tube bounds an internal space, which contains the sample 2 the activity of which is measured. The capillary tube thus forms a measurement chamber.
(26) The measurement module 10 comprises instrumentation allowing an estimation of the activity of the sample. The implementation of the measurement module assumes that the radioactive isotope contained in the sample is known.
(27)
(28) In spite of their lower sensitivity compared with inorganic scintillators, an important advantage of organic scintillator materials is the ease with which they may be shaped, the latter being able to be carried out by molding.
(29) The scintillator detector 11 is optically coupled to a plurality of photodetectors 15. The latter may notably be photomultipliers, for example of the Hamamatsu H13175U-110 type. Preferably, the scintillator detector 11 comprises or is optically coupled to planar faces 12, each photodetector 15 being applied against one planar face 12, optionally using a coupling fluid. According to one possibility, at least one photodetector, or even each photodetector, is or comprises a photodiode. It may for example be a question of an SiPM photodetector (SiPM standing for Silicon PhotoMultiplier).
(30) One important aspect of the scintillator detector is that an aperture 13 extending about a central axis passes through it. During use of the scintillator detector in the device 1, the central axis coincides with the longitudinal axis . The aperture 13 is dimensioned to allow a translation of the capillary tube 3 through the scintillator detector 11. For example, when the outside diameter of the capillary tube 3 is 1.2 mm, the diameter of the aperture 13 may be equal to 1.4 mm. Generally, the diameter of the aperture is preferably between 1 mm and 1 cm.
(31) The scintillator detector may have a parallelepipedal shape, with four planar faces parallel to the central axis . Such a possibility is schematically shown in
(32) Preferably, the scintillator detector has rotational symmetry about the central axis . In the example shown in
(33) According to one possibility, the scintillator detector 11 may comprise a cylindrical central segment extending around the central axis . Such a possibility is shown in
(34) When the central segment 11 is a sphere or a cylinder, its radius may be between 15 mm and 25 mm when the scintillator material is an organic scintillator. The radius is for example equal to 18 mm. The optimum dimensions vary depending on the type of scintillator material used. It is considered that it is optimal for the central segment 11 to be spherical.
(35) In order to facilitate coupling with the photodetectors 15, the scintillator detector 11 comprises faces 12 that are planar, and preferably parallel to the central axis . In
(36) In the example of
(37)
(38) The measurement module 10 may comprise a spectrometric detector 17.
(39) The spectrometry circuit is connected to the processing unit 40. More precisely, the processing unit implements a spectral-analysis algorithm, allowing certain singularities to be identified. It may be a question of radioactive impurities. It may be a question of peaks resulting from the X-ray fluorescence of certain materials, in particular metals, for example Fe, In or Pd. Metals resulting from the process used to produce the radioactive isotope form impurities in the radiopharmaceutical solution. The excitation inducing the X-ray fluorescence may be due to X-rays or gamma-rays emitted directly or indirectly by the isotopes. For example, when the isotope is a .sup.+ emitter, the fluorescence may be induced by irradiation of the sample with photons resulting from annihilation of the .sup.+ particle.
(40) The spectrometric detector may use a detection material such as CeBr.sub.3 or NaI(TI) or CsI or CdTe. This type of material allows a spectrum of acceptable quality to be formed using a spectrometric detector that is compact enough to be integrated into the detection module 10. The spectrometric detector may be of GeHP type, provided that adequate cooling means, for example a cryogenic tank or thermoelectric cooling, is provided.
(41) The detection module 10 extends, along the longitudinal axis , between a lower face 10.sub.inf and an upper face 10.sub.sup. On account of the presence of the photodetectors 15, which may be sensitive to visible light, the detection module 10 is sealed through use of a shutter 18, on the lower face 10.sub.inf facing the container 20, and of an opaque bellows 19, which extends around the capillary tube, from the upper face 10.sub.sup.
(42) The inventors have established a digital model in order to simulate the detection performance of a scintillator detector such as described with reference to
(43) Such a digital model is intended to estimate the energy absorbed by the scintillator detector when the latter is subjected to exposure to radiation produced by a predetermined isotope.
(44)
(45) In
(46) In
(47) The curves d) of
(48) When the device 1 is implemented, the processing unit 40 is connected to each photodetector 15 and collects a detection signal generated by each thereof. More precisely, each photodetector is connected to a coincidence detection circuit 16, which is intended to determine the pulses detected in temporal coincidence by two photodetectors (double coincidences) and by the three photodetectors (triple coincidences). As described in the publication Broda R. et al Radionuclide metrology using liquid scintillation counting, Metrologia 44 (2007), when a sample of unknown activity considered to be a pure emitter is used, it may be shown that a detection efficiency , called the absolute detection efficiency, may be determined based on a ratio of the number of triple coincidences to the number of double coincidences.
(49) More precisely, if N.sub.T corresponds to the number of triple coincidences and N.sub.D corresponds to the number of double coincidences, the ratio
(50)
designated RCTD (ratio of triple to double coincidences), is such that:
(51)
where: S(E) is the absorption spectrum of the isotope in question, which corresponds to curve d) of
(52)
(53) is the energy loss per unit path length of an incident (.sup.+ or .sup.) particle in the scintillator detector; E.sub.max is the maximum energy of the emission spectrum of the incident particle; kB is a semi-empirical parameter, usually designated Birks' coefficient, expressed in cm.Math.MeV.sup.1. This parameter describes the non-linearity of the scintillator. It is usually between 0.007 and 0.015 cm.Math.MeV.sup.1.
(54) The parameters S(E),
(55)
and kB are input data. RCTD is a measured datum, resulting from the coincidence detection circuit 16. The product .sub.0 (product of multiplication of the quantum efficiency of the photomultipliers by the luminous efficiency of the scintillator material) may be determined so as to obtain the absolute detection efficiency . The calculated efficiency is the one that allows equality (1) to be satisfied.
(56) The calculated efficiency is used to determine a double-coincidence detection efficiency .sub.D, according to the expression:
(57)
(58) The activity Act of the isotope is then determined, from N.sub.D, with:
(59)
N.sub.D corresponds to a so-called logical sum of the double coincidences detected per unit time. For example, if there are three photodetectors 15.sub.1, 15.sub.2 and 15.sub.3, N.sub.D is such that:
(60)
where N.sub.1,2, N.sub.1,3 and N.sub.2,3 are the number of double coincidences detected, per unit time, by photodetectors 15.sub.1 and 15.sub.2, 15.sub.1 and 15.sub.3, 15.sub.2 and 15.sub.3, respectively. N.sub.1,2,3 corresponds to the number of triple coincidences detected per unit time: N.sub.1,2,3=N.sub.T (6). The processing unit 40 receives the quantities N.sub.1,2, N.sub.1,3 and N.sub.2,3 and N.sub.T from the coincidence circuit 16. It may then determine by implementing expression (1). This makes it possible to obtain .sub.D, by implementing (3), based on , and then the activity Act via expression (4).
(61) Preferably, the efficiency is determined, on each measurement, by a ratio of the number of triple coincidences to the number of double coincidences. The double-coincidence detection efficiency .sub.D may thus be determined, according to (3), on each measurement. The need for laboratory calibration is avoided, this being a notable advantage of the invention.
(62) The activity Act of the sample 2 may be estimated at various successive measurement times t, so as to obtain values Act(t). The variation in Act(t) as a function of time may be compared with a theoretical variation, established based on the half-life of the isotope in question. A deviation between the measured variation and the theoretical variation may be indicative of the presence of contamination in the sample 2.
(63) The activity Act(t) of the sample 2, measured at measurement time t, is preferably normalized by the volume of the sample. This makes it possible to estimate the activity per unit volume or mass of the radiopharmaceutical solution present in the container 20.
(64) The volume of the sample may be estimated using an image acquired by the observation camera 30, while the sample 2 occupies the observation position. On account of the geometry of the capillary tube, without any particular processing, the sample extends between two menisci, as shown in
(65)
where: L is the total length of the sample; r is the inside radius of the capillary tube; H.sub.1 is a height of the first meniscus; H.sub.2 is a height of the second meniscus.
(66) The quantities L, r, H.sub.1 and H.sub.2 are estimated from the image. The observation camera will have been calibrated beforehand, for example through acquisition of an image of a test pattern or a graduated ruler.
(67) According to one possibility, the inner wall of the capillary tube is hydrophobic, or has been subjected to a hydrophobic treatment. Such a treatment allows the presence of menisci on either side of the sample to be reduced or even eliminated.
(68) After the activity of the sample has been determined, the capillary tube is translated toward the sampling position and the sample may be expelled into the reservoir 20 by applying a positive pressure to the capillary tube.
(69) According to one possibility, the capillary tube 3 may be made directly from an inorganic scintillator material that has mechanical characteristics and a surface finish similar to those of glass or quartz.
(70) The same surface treatment as used for glass may be applied to make it hydrophobic and avoid surface contamination.
(71) Such a capillary tube makes it possible not only to sample a liquid, but also to take an image with a view to measurement of volume and to detect the radiation emitted by the liquid.
(72) Any non-hygroscopic inorganic scintillator may be used, such as YAG(Ce) (cerium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet), YAP(Ce) (cerium-doped yttrium aluminum perovskite), GaGG(Ce) (cerium-doped gadolinium aluminum gallium garnet), etc.
(73) Just as in the embodiments described above, the capillary tube may be inserted into the scintillator detector 11.
(74) The scintillator detector 11, into which the capillary tube 3 is inserted, is preferably of the same composition as the capillary tube.
(75)
(76) In a step 100, the capillary tube is moved into the sampling position and a sample 2 is taken under the effect of the pumping unit.
(77) In a step 110, the capillary tube is placed in the observation position and an image of the sample is acquired by the observation camera, this allowing the volume (or mass) of the sample to be estimated.
(78) In a step 120, the capillary tube is placed in the measurement position, in the measurement module 10. The activity of the sample is estimated based on the detection signals resulting from each photodetector, and on the number of double coincidences detected. Step 120 may be implemented before step 110.
(79) The inventors have used a device such as described above, the scintillator detector being like that described with reference to
(80) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Activity Activity per unit Trial per unit volume - reference Deviation reference Isotope volume (Bq/mL) method (Bq/mL) (%) 1 .sup.18F 7.93 10.sup.7 8.23 10.sup.7 3.7% 2 .sup.18F 7.52 10.sup.7 7.52 10.sup.7 0.01% 3 .sup.11C 9.54 10.sup.6 9.47 10.sup.6 0.61%
(81) In table 1, the third and fourth columns correspond to the activity per unit volume determined by implementing the invention and the reference method, respectively. In trial 1, a capillary tube without hydrophobic treatment was used. In trial 2, the capillary tube received a hydrophobic treatment, this possibly explaining the smaller deviation between implementation of the invention and the reference method.
(82) The device according to the invention makes it possible to estimate the activity of a radioactive liquid without requiring complex calibration, involving a reference laboratory. Specifically, the measurement is performed on a sample of small volume, taken from a radiopharmaceutical solution. Activity is estimated on the basis of measurements of double coincidences, as described above, the detection efficiency being able to be calculated through a ratio of triple coincidences to double coincidences.
(83) The device according to the invention is easily automatable, this making it possible to limit the intervention by operators in proximity to the radioactive liquid. Specifically, translation of the capillary tube, control of the pumping unit and control of the measurement module may be automated. This helps to decrease the dose absorbed by the intervening personnel.