Advanced Ion Exchange Membranes And Applications Thereof
20260121095 ยท 2026-04-30
Inventors
- Richard Kent Williams (Cupertino, CA, US)
- Yi Zheng (Canton, MA, US)
- Chris Scott Graham (Palo Alto, CA, US)
- Keng Hung Lin (Zhubei City, TW)
- Khushnood Ahmad Qazi (Los Alos, CA, US)
Cpc classification
H01M8/1011
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1034
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1051
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1025
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1048
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1065
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1039
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1032
ELECTRICITY
International classification
H01M8/1065
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1011
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1025
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1032
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1034
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1039
ELECTRICITY
H01M8/1048
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
Improved performance ion exchange membranes for use in PEM, AEM and DMFC fuel cells, buffered fuel cells, hydrolysis, other applications comprise a molecular matrix of homopolymers, di-monomer, heteropolymers, copolymers, or block-polymers of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon compounds combined with (i) skeletal support grid to improve durability, handling, reduce membrane swelling, and sequester dopants and nanoparticles from leakage; (ii) microporous membrane formed using a sacrificial filler process enhancing conductivity and limiting fuel crossover; (iii) hetero-ionomeric matrix of two-or-more membrane-bound acids e.g. sulphonic and phosphonic acid expanding usable range; (iv) permanent fillers enhancing conductivity and porosity including nanoparticles, metal-oxides, zeolites, silicates, GOs, CNTs, MOFs, POSS, and others; (v) ionic liquid doping to enhance membrane conductivity; (vi) membrane nanocoating preventing H.sub.2O.sub.2 diffusion; and/or (vii) catalytic nanocoating with metals, metal-oxides, and MOFs preventing atmospheric toxin catalyst poisoning. Combined with a heterogenous GDL, the IEM is integrated into iBFC power blade and energy bank applications.
Claims
1. An ion exchange membrane comprising an electrically conductive polymer matrix capable of conducting either cations or anions but not both; where the polymer contains a hydrophobic polymeric backbone providing structure and mechanical support to the membrane; where hydrophilic functional groups are attached either directly onto the backbone or indirectly at the terminus of a sidechain pendant molecule bonded or grafted onto the polymer mainchain; where the functional groups comprise a membrane bound acid or base readily ionized into an immobile anionic or cationic ionomer, by which mobile charged ions such as protons, hydronium, or hydroxide ions may attach and detach to facilitate hopping conduction through the polymeric matrix; where the membrane contains a skeletal matrix of inert pillars circumscribing and subdividing the conductive ionomeric membrane into panes; and where the skeletal matrix chemically bonds to the panes of conductive ionomeric polymers forming a unitary ion conduction membrane having both mechanical strength and electrical conductivity.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 where the membrane is an proton exchange membrane, the ionomers comprise immobile anions, and where the transported charge comprises hydrogen and hydronium ions.
3. The apparatus of claim 1 where the membrane contains a membrane acid of sulphonic or phosphonic acid.
4. The apparatus of claim 1 where the acid group is attached to the terminus of a sidechain pendant bonded to the mainchain.
5. The apparatus of claim 1 where the conductive membrane comprises a fluorocarbon homopolymer such as PFSA or heteropolymer such as PFSA-PTFE.
6. The apparatus of claim 1 where the conductive membrane comprises a functionalized hydrocarbon polymer such as a blend of arylene, ether, ketone, nitrile, sulfone,
7. The apparatus of claim 6 where the hydrocarbon polymer is functionalized by sulphonic, phosphonic, or phosphoric acids.
8. The apparatus of claim 1 where the membrane is coated with PTFE nanospheres.
9. The apparatus of claim 1 where the skeletal pillars comprise an inert hydrophobic material.
10. The apparatus of claim 9 where the skeletal pillar is bonded to the ionomeric polymer by an intervening linking compound such as a molecular glue or polyvinyl alcohol.
11. The apparatus of claim 9 where the skeletal pillar is co-molded with the ionomeric polymer, i.e. polymerized concurrently.
12. The apparatus of claim 9 where the skeletal pillar of claim 10 has a roughened surface from a chemical or radiation pretreatment before being molded with the ionomeric polymer.
13. The apparatus of claim 1 where the skeletal matrix is defined by a casting mold with a mold chaise inserted into the mold cavity to limit where the skeletal matrix is formed.
14. The apparatus of claim 13 where the mold compound filling the skeletal regions includes a combination of organic monomers, cross-linkers, and strengthening fillers such as carbon fiber.
15. The apparatus of claim 14 where the cross linkers invoke complete polymerization of the skeletal support
16. The apparatus of claim 15 where the remaining unoccupied space in the mold cavity after the mold chaise insert has been removed is filled with organic monomers and cross-linkers during which polymerization of the ionomeric polymer bonds to the fully polymerized skeleton.
17. The apparatus of claim 16 where the cross linkers cause only partially polymerize the skeletal support.
18. The apparatus of claim 17 where the remaining unoccupied space in the mold cavity after the mold chaise insert has been removed is filled with organic monomers and cross-linkers during which polymerization of the ionomeric polymer bonds and copolymerizes the partially polymerized skeleton.
19. The apparatus of claim 1 where an ion exchange membrane where the skeletal support matrix includes wide and narrow pillars, where the sheet of multiple ion exchange membranes has been singulated along the wider pillars.
20. An ion exchange membrane comprising an electrically conductive polymer matrix capable of conducting either cations or anions but not both; where the polymer contains a hydrophobic polymeric backbone providing structure and mechanical support to the membrane; where hydrophilic functional groups are attached either directly onto the backbone or indirectly at the terminus of a sidechain pendant molecule bonded or grafted onto the polymer mainchain; where the functional groups comprise a membrane bound acid or base readily ionized into an immobile anionic or cationic ionomer, by which mobile charged ions such as protons, hydronium, or hydroxide ions may attach and detach to facilitate hopping conduction through the polymeric matrix; where the membrane contains a sacrificial filler molecule such as sugar after molding.
21. The apparatus of claim 22 where the sacrificial filler is no longer present in the membrane.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0533]
[0534]
[0535]
[0536]
[0537]
[0538]
[0539]
[0540]
[0541]
[0542]
[0543]
[0544]
[0545]
[0546]
[0547]
[0548]
[0549]
[0550]
[0551]
[0552]
[0553]
[0554]
[0555]
[0556]
[0557]
[0558]
[0559]
[0560]
[0561]
[0562]
[0563]
[0564]
[0565]
[0566]
[0567]
[0568]
[0569]
[0570]
[0571]
[0572]
[0573]
[0574]
[0575]
[0576]
[0577]
[0578]
[0579]
[0580]
[0581]
[0582]
[0583]
[0584]
[0585]
[0586]
[0587]
[0588]
[0589]
[0590]
[0591]
[0592]
[0593]
[0594]
[0595]
[0596]
[0597]
[0598]
[0599]
[0600]
[0601]
[0602]
[0603]
[0604]
[0605]
[0606]
[0607]
[0608]
[0609]
[0610]
[0611]
[0612]
[0613]
[0614]
[0615]
[0616]
[0617]
[0618]
[0619]
[0620]
[0621]
[0622]
[0623]
[0624]
[0625]
[0626]
[0627]
[0628]
[0629]
[0630]
[0631]
[0632]
[0633]
[0634]
[0635]
[0636]
[0637]
[0638]
[0639]
[0640]
[0641]
[0642]
[0643]
[0644]
[0645]
[0646]
[0647]
[0648]
[0649]
[0650]
[0651]
[0652]
[0653]
[0654]
[0655]
[0656]
[0657]
[0658]
[0659]
[0660]
[0661]
[0662]
[0663]
[0664]
[0665]
[0666]
[0667]
[0668]
[0669]
[0670]
[0671]
[0672]
[0673]
[0674]
[0675]
[0676]
[0677]
[0678]
[0679]
[0680]
[0681]
[0682]
[0683]
[0684]
[0685]
[0686]
[0687]
[0688]
[0689]
[0690]
[0691]
[0692]
[0693]
[0694]
[0695]
[0696]
[0697]
[0698]
[0699]
[0700]
[0701]
[0702]
[0703]
[0704]
[0705]
[0706]
[0707]
[0708]
[0709]
[0710]
[0711]
[0712]
[0713]
[0714]
[0715]
[0716]
[0717]
[0718]
[0719]
[0720]
[0721]
[0722]
[0723]
[0724]
[0725]
[0726]
[0727]
[0728]
[0729]
[0730]
[0731]
[0732]
[0733]
[0734]
[0735]
[0736]
[0737]
[0738]
[0739]
[0740]
[0741]
[0742]
[0743]
[0744]
[0745]
[0746]
[0747]
[0748]
[0749]
[0750]
[0751]
[0752]
[0753]
[0754]
[0755]
[0756]
[0757]
[0758]
[0759]
[0760]
[0761]
[0762]
[0763]
[0764]
[0765]
[0766]
[0767]
[0768]
[0769]
[0770]
[0771]
[0772]
[0773]
[0774]
[0775]
[0776]
[0777]
[0778]
[0779]
[0780]
[0781]
[0782]
[0783]
[0784]
[0785]
[0786]
[0787]
[0788]
[0789]
[0790]
[0791]
[0792]
[0793]
[0794]
[0795]
[0796]
[0797]
[0798]
[0799]
[0800]
[0801]
[0802]
[0803]
[0804]
[0805]
[0806]
[0807]
[0808]
[0809]
[0810]
[0811]
[0812]
[0813]
[0814]
[0815]
[0816]
[0817]
[0818]
[0819]
[0820]
[0821]
[0822]
[0823]
[0824]
[0825]
[0826]
[0827]
[0828]
[0829]
[0830]
[0831]
[0832]
[0833]
[0834]
[0835]
[0836]
[0837]
[0838]
[0839]
[0840]
[0841]
[0842]
[0843]
[0844]
[0845]
[0846]
[0847]
[0848]
[0849]
[0850]
[0851]
[0852]
[0853]
[0854]
[0855]
[0856]
[0857]
[0858]
[0859]
[0860]
[0861]
[0862]
[0863]
[0864]
[0865]
[0866]
[0867]
[0868]
[0869]
[0870]
[0871]
[0872]
[0873]
[0874]
[0875]
[0876]
[0877]
[0878]
[0879]
[0880]
[0881]
[0882]
[0883]
[0884]
[0885]
[0886]
[0887]
[0888]
[0889]
[0890]
[0891]
[0892]
[0893]
[0894]
[0895]
[0896]
[0897]
[0898]
[0899]
[0900]
[0901]
[0902]
[0903]
[0904]
[0905]
[0906]
[0907]
[0908]
[0909]
[0910]
[0911]
[0912]
[0913]
[0914]
[0915]
[0916]
[0917]
[0918]
[0919]
[0920]
[0921]
[0922]
[0923]
[0924]
[0925]
[0926]
[0927]
[0928]
[0929]
[0930]
[0931]
[0932]
[0933]
[0934]
[0935]
[0936]
[0937]
[0938]
[0939]
[0940]
[0941]
[0942]
[0943]
[0944]
[0945]
[0946]
[0947]
[0948]
[0949]
[0950]
[0951]
[0952]
[0953]
[0954]
[0955]
[0956]
[0957]
[0958]
[0959]
[0960]
[0961]
[0962]
[0963]
[0964]
[0965]
[0966]
[0967]
[0968]
[0969]
[0970]
[0971]
[0972]
[0973]
[0974]
[0975]
[0976]
[0977]
[0978]
[0979]
[0980]
[0981]
[0982]
[0983]
[0984]
[0985]
[0986]
[0987]
[0988]
[0989]
[0990]
[0991]
[0992]
[0993]
[0994]
[0995]
[0996]
[0997]
[0998]
[0999]
[1000]
[1001]
[1002]
[1003]
[1004]
[1005]
[1006]
[1007]
[1008]
[1009]
[1010]
[1011]
[1012]
[1013]
[1014]
[1015]
[1016]
[1017]
[1018]
[1019]
[1020]
[1021]
[1022]
[1023]
[1024]
[1025]
[1026]
[1027]
[1028]
[1029]
[1030]
[1031]
[1032]
[1033]
[1034]
[1035]
[1036]
[1037]
[1038]
[1039]
[1040]
[1041]
[1042]
[1043]
[1044]
[1045]
[1046]
[1047]
[1048]
[1049]
[1050]
[1051]
[1052]
[1053]
[1054]
[1055]
[1056]
[1057]
[1058]
[1059]
[1060]
[1061]
[1062]
[1063]
[1064]
[1065]
[1066]
[1067]
[1068]
[1069]
[1070]
[1071]
[1072]
[1073]
[1074]
[1075]
[1076]
[1077]
[1078]
[1079]
[1080]
[1081]
[1082]
[1083]
[1084]
[1085]
[1086]
[1087]
[1088]
[1089]
[1090]
[1091]
[1092]
[1093]
[1094]
[1095]
[1096]
[1097]
[1098]
[1099]
[1100]
[1101]
[1102]
[1103]
[1104]
[1105]
[1106]
[1107]
[1108]
[1109]
[1110]
[1111]
[1112]
[1113]
[1114]
[1115]
[1116]
[1117]
[1118]
[1119]
[1120]
[1121]
[1122]
[1123]
[1124]
[1125]
[1126]
[1127]
[1128]
[1129]
[1130]
[1131]
[1132]
[1133]
[1134]
[1135]
[1136]
[1137]
[1138]
[1139]
[1140]
[1141]
[1142]
[1143]
[1144]
[1145]
[1146]
[1147]
[1148]
[1149]
[1150]
[1151]
[1152]
[1153]
[1154]
[1155]
[1156]
[1157]
[1158]
[1159]
[1160]
[1161]
[1162]
[1163]
[1164]
[1165]
[1166]
[1167]
[1168]
[1169]
[1170]
[1171]
[1172]
[1173]
[1174]
[1175]
[1176]
[1177]
[1178]
[1179]
[1180]
[1181]
[1182]
[1183]
[1184]
[1185]
[1186]
[1187]
[1188]
[1189]
DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION
[1190] A new class of ion exchange membrane membranes is described created to ameliorate or eliminate the various deficiencies present in present day conventional fuel cells. Specifically this patent discusses innovations in proton exchange membranes (PEMs), also known a cation ion exchange membrane (CEMs), or hydrogen ion exchange membranes (H.sup.+ IEMs). Topics discussed include [1191] IEM structural support for improved handling and operational reliability [1192] Proton exchange membrane (PEM) for hydrogen fuel cell operation [1193] Proton exchange membrane (PEM) for hydrogen from water hydrolysis [1194] Proton exchange membranes for alternative uses, including filtering and dialysis [1195] Hydrogen ion exchange membranes for alternative uses [1196] Applications of improved IEMs
[1197] Specifically this patent concentrates on the improved implementation of proton ion exchange membranes using hydrogen as a fuel source as reflected in its title Advanced Hydrogen Ion Exchange Membranes and Applications Thereof. The various embodiments of inventions described and disclosed herein can be implemented individually or in combination.
[1198] Although the focus of this discussion is on membranes transporting cations comprising ionized hydrogen, i.e. protons, its should be understood the principles, methods, fabrication techniques, and applications of such hydrogen based IEM fuel cells and electrolyzers are not strictly limited to such narrowly defined topics, but may be applied to other types of fuel cells and electrolysis such as those employing methanol, methane, glucose or where ion transport across the membrane involves negatively charged anions.
[1199] Alternative IEMs and related innovations involving anion exchange membranes (AEMs) for fuel cells and hydrolysis; ion exchange membranes for glucose based fuel cells and electrolysis (Glu-IEMs), and ion exchange membranes (IEMs) for electrolysis of carbon compounds are explicitly considered in this application, but numerous inventive elements such as endoskeletal support apply.
Basic IEM Terminology.
[1200] Herewith, the use of the terms cation, proton, and hydrogen ion as the H.sup.+ or the hydronium ion H.sub.3O.sup.+ will be used interchangeably unless explicitly being described in comparative terms. For clarification, in the lexicon of ion exchange membranes please refer to the Glossary of Terms section of this application. As defined herein, it will be understood that protons, i.e. ionized hydrogen, represent a specific subset of cations, which in turn together with anions are a subset of all ions. It should also be mentioned that the ionized state of matter is not a stable condition. In nature ions spontaneously revert to stable elements over time, the very reason an unused battery self discharges.
[1201] One advantage of a hydrogen fuel cell compared to other forms of energy is its fuel comprises stable elemental hydrogen atoms without toxic compounds. In operation, the hydrogen atoms are stripped of their electrons at the time of use resulting in hydrogen ions H.sup.+, i.e. protons are created just-in-time to be used. To accelerate the ionization process the fuel cell employs a catalyst. A catalyst is substance that increases the rate of a chemical reaction without itself undergoing any permanent chemical change. Common hydrogen catalysts include platinum and palladium. As numerous embodiments of this invention, the composition of the catalyst layer may include additives and permanent fillers added to enhance catalytic turnover rates (TORs), reduce interfacial contact resistance, and to prevent poisoning of the CL. Once the hydrogen is ionized the resulting protons traverse the ion exchange membrane from the anode to the cathode.
[1202] Positive charge transport within the IEM occurs by two mechanismscharge hopping and vehicular transport, with conduction involving two physical forms of propulsion namely drift conduction in response to electrostatic forces, and diffusion, a statistical mechanical mechanism involving the random vibration of atoms. All four combinations occur in a conducting ion exchange membrane but in varying degrees, specifically charge hopping driven by diffusion, charge hopping electrostatically driven by drift conduction, vehicular transport of ions driven by diffusion, and vehicular transport of ions electrostatically driven by drift conduction.
[1203] The relative contribution of these four conduction components depends on the manufacture and composition of an ion exchange membrane, the influence of ambient conditions such as temperature and relative humidity, and the current density flowing across the membrane. In various embodiments of this invention, these relative contributions are decided by IEM design and processing by controlling the ionomer concentration within the polymer and by controlling the crystallinity and porosity of the polymer's molecular matrix.
[1204] In the vernacular of ion exchange membranes, charge hopping aka Grotthuss conduction is the mechanism where protons repeatedly jump to negatively-charged immobile ionized molecules called ionomers, hopping from one ionomer to the next. Since the ionomers in a PEM are negatively ionized immobile anions, only positive charged cations can traverse the matrix. The driving force of protonic charge hopping comprises both diffusion, current conduction resulting from a concentration gradient; and from electric drift, the electrostatic force experienced by charge responding to an electric field.
[1205] Charge hopping can occur in any atomic matrix containing ionomers, i.e. immobile ionized groups. In a PEM membrane, these ionomers comprise membrane-bound acids that ionize into immobile anions. Because protons can hop between the adjacent anions, hopping conduction does not require pores and channels in the atomic matrix for conduction to occur. As such, hopping conduction is one-dimensional with protons flowing in a relatively straight line from the anode to the cathode. The magnitude of hopping current depends primarily on the ionomeric density within the matrix.
[1206] The term vehicular transport by contrast describes the movement of ions through channels within the polymer matrix and does not rely on ions attaching and detaching themselves onto immobile ionomers within the polymer. The role of the acid groups in vehicular transport is thereby to donate protons into the matrix through ionization, not to carry current. In this regard ionic liquids can also contribute to vehicular transport but without increasing the immobile ionomeric density. In vehicular transport, free protons spontaneously attach themselves to water molecules to form hydronium ions. As hydronium ions are significantly larger than free protons, they require contiguous pores in the polymer's matrix to form conductive channels through which they move.
[1207] As such vehicular conduction is tortuous, involving significantly longer path lengths than hopping conduction. The longer path length means both the electric field and concentration gradient providing vehicular propulsion are reduced thereby reducing their relative contribution compared to charge hopping. At high current densities, water created in the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) diffuses back into the matrix enhancing the role of vehicular transport by creating more hydronium charge carriers. In operation protons combine with water to form hydronium ions, some of which revert back into H.sup.+ and H.sub.2O, creating a equilibrium condition. By contrast the density of ionomers is fixed. At high current densities they become saturated and are unable to support greater currents.
[1208] In this complex manner charge hopping and vehicular transport both contribute to conduction in an ion exchange membrane. The relative contribution of diffusion and drift propulsion in each of these conduction mechanisms depends on the proton concentration gradient, membrane hydration, and the membrane's self generated electric field. In general terms, hopping conduction plays a dominant role at low currents while vehicular transport of hydronium dominates high current conduction.
[1209] In IEM lexicology, the term drift conduction describes current flow resulting from the electrostatic force exerted on a charge in an electric field. Drift conduction dominates charge flow in materials with an ample source of charge such as metal conductor or an ionomer carrying relatively low currents. The electric field present across the membrane is created autonomously by the accelerated ionization of hydrogen in the anode and the lack of protons persisting in the cathode together creating a perpetual charge imbalance so long that hydrogen continues to flow into the anode. While the electric field can also drive drift conduction of unbound protons in the matrix, their lifetime as free charge is limited by the presence of water interstitial to the polymer matrix.
[1210] In such cases, the hydrogen ions spontaneously bond to water forming charged hydronium ions. Like hydrogen ions, hydronium ions respond to electric fields exhibiting drift conduction. The major difference between charge hopping and vehicular transport is the conduction pathcharge hopping is a bulk property where conduction is able to flow directly through the polymer matrix. Because vehicular transport is limited to circuitous paths through the matrix, the net electric field is diminished significantly reducing the importance of drift conduction in vehicular transport.
[1211] The term diffusion describes the spatial reapportionment of molecules resulting from a concentration gradient. Rather than reacting to a force, diffusion is the statistical mechanical mechanism resulting from random motion whereby a concentrated bubble of ions has a greater chance of moving out of the congested region than it does heading back into the bubble. As such, both hydrogen ions and hydronium ions naturally diffuse from high concentration regions to lower concentration volumes. As long as hydrogen supply to the anode is maintained, the concentration gradient of protons ions will also persist, as such diffusion is present in charge hopping conduction. Maintaining a concentration gradient also drives diffusion based conduction via vehicular transport, especially at high currents.
[1212] Another key mechanism of fuel cell operation is the chemical reaction occurring in the cathode catalysts layer. In the cathode the incoming flux of protons and hydronium ions is countered by a preponderance of oxygen in the cathode. The oxygen combines with the protons by donating electrons, thereby reducing the cations back into uncharged hydrogen atoms. In steady state operation of a fuel cell, the rates of oxidation of hydrogen into cations in the anode and reduction of cations into hydrogen in the cathode necessarily balance in accordance with maintaining charge neutrality in the cell. Thermodynamics however dictates that the product of the coupled oxidation and reduction reactions, called a redox reaction, must have a lower energy than the fuel feeding the electrochemical cell. To satisfy this criteria, protons reduced to elemental hydrogen in the cathode necessarily combine with a reducing agent. Generally the reducing agent is either pure oxygen (100% O.sub.2) or room air which comprises 78% non-reactive nitrogen and 21% oxygen. Care must be taken to prevent carbon monoxide or H.sub.2O.sub.2 from reacting with the catalyst and poisoning the fuel cell.
PEM Fuel Cell Construction.
[1213] Given the emerging demand for clean and sustainable global energy applications, the need for reliable high-performance ion-exchange membranes for fuel cells is becoming increasingly evident, especially is the development of proton exchange membrane based fuel cells (PEMFCs). Unfortunately, present day PEM membranes suffer numerous deficiencies including excessive humidity dependence, low current density operation, low cell voltages, high membrane resistance and transient impedance, and an especially strong dependence of cell voltage on current. Other problems include repeated swelling and shrinkage of the membrane with water retention within the polymer leading to polymer wear out and shortened use life.
[1214] Together, these factors, further exacerbated by self-heating, humidity and ambient temperature dependence limit the conversion efficiency and electrical power density of even state-of-the art fuel cells. In particular, fuel cell voltage sag and/or voltage collapse with increasing current is especially problematic as it limits the fuel cell from directly driving a high current battery or the low-impedance input of a switching power supply needed for DC/DC voltage conversion. These problems arise for a variety of reasons including bad fuel cell design, poorly constructed membranes, inadequate process control of membrane fabrication, and lack of scalable manufacturing processes. Other factors include poor gas delivery as limited by fundamental construction deficiencies in gas diffusion layers and high interfacial contact resistances.
[1215] As described previously, a single proton-exchange membrane fuel cell generally comprises a five-layer membrane electrode assembly MEA5 sandwiched by bipolar plates BPP. The BPP is a rigid support structure in the PEMFC stack within which reactant and coolant flow occurs. The BPP is also responsible for current conduction and heat dissipation. The MEA5 comprises a gas diffusion layer (GDL) with a microporous layer (MPL) surrounding a three-layer membrane assembly or MEA3. The GDL is a layer of carbon paper or carbon cloth, which plays multiple important roles in gas distribution, mechanical support and electrical connection. Carbon layers are formed upon a substrate of carbon black and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) referred to as MPL, which assists in the timely removal of electrochemically produced water. As an embodiment of this invention, these carbon layers are heterogenous of varying concentration and porosity.
[1216] The MEA3 also known as a catalyst coated membrane or CCM comprises two catalyst layers (CLs) surrounding a proton-exchange membrane (PEM). The CL is the site where the hydrogen oxidation and oxygen reduction electrochemical reactions occur, through a series of coupled physiochemical processes. Platinum-loaded carbon, which is finely dispersed to interact with the ionomer, is the most frequently used catalyst owing to its excellent activity and durability in an electrochemical environment. Aside from platinum (Pt) other platinum group metals (PGMs) include palladium (Pd), osmium (Os), rhodium (Rh), ruthenium (Ru), and iridium (Ir). PGMs are desirable for their excellent electrical conductivity and catalytic activity and for their resistance to corrosion in acidic environments consistent with proton based charge transport. Unfortunately many noble metals are notoriously expensive. Alternative catalysts made in accordance with this invention are described in a subsequent section of this application.
[1217] One especially troublesome deficiency of ion exchange membranes is their loss in structural integrity, strength, durability and rigidity as the active ionomer is thinned. While attempts have been made to integrate reinforcement throughout the membrane's active film, any increase in ionomer strength is countered by a decrease in ion conduction and lower film conductivity, reducing power efficiency and increasing membrane resistivity thereby offsetting the linear reduction in resistance gained by thinning the membrane. Lower efficiency also further exacerbates membrane heating,
[1218] One approach is to integrate PTFE into a PFSA perfluorosulfonic acid membrane to form a heterogenous reinforced composite membrane or CRM. While simple to conceptualize, hydrophilic PFSA is mutually incompatible with the highly hydrophobic nature of PTFE. The intrinsic incompatibility of hydrophilic ionomers such as PFSA coated onto a hydrophobic PTFE substrate causes film stress. These stresses are aggravated by changes in both membrane hydration and temperature during normal operation. Specifically water logging and swelling causing severe volumetric changes in the PFSA are a function of both current and relative humidity.
[1219] Elevated temperatures and temperature gradients arising from the fuel cell's exothermic reactions likewise cause stress arising from the heterogenous films exhibiting differing temperature coefficients of expansion, i.e. differential CTEs. In normal use, power levels invariably fluctuate, in turn causing repeated expansion and shrinkage in the film under wet-to-dry-to wet transitions. As such, humidity cycling, temperature cycling, and power cycling all aggravate interfacial imperfections in the composite ionomer causing creep deformation, delamination, and cracking. In particular, the formation of cracks, tears, voids, and delamination dominantly occur between the PTFE and PFSA layers, leading to an irreversible deterioration of the fuel cell performance.
[1220] Rather than relying on CRM strengthening the ionomer itself, in an embodiment of this invention the ionomer is reinforced laterally by a matrix of semi-rigid pillars to form a skeleton interspersed throughout the membrane, thereby providing structural support to the IEM. Skeletal support is not mutually exclusive from the heterogenous reinforced composite membrane, but can reduce the mole fraction of inert PTFE in the film improving IEM conductivity or eliminate it totally.
IEM Structural Support.
[1221] The biggest problem of a fuel cell is sagging and deformation of the active ionomeric film during manufacturing and in operation. This problem originates from the intrinsic relationship between the electrical conductivity and membrane thickness. As shown in
[1222] Unfortunately, thinner films exhibit reduced mechanical strength and durability, causing them to sag and deform easily during handling and manufacturing. This increases the risk of damage during fabrication, manufacturing, and assembly of fuel cell or electrolysis modules. The term sag is defined as the deformation distance below the plane defined by the membrane's attachment points to its mechanical support. Ideally a membrane should be perfectly flat, coplanar with its edge support. Any deviation below the attachment plane is undesirable as it renders bonding between the gas diffusion layer and the membrane less uniform, potentially creating air gap pockets with no electrical contact, thereby increasing resistance.
[1223] The film sagging problem is further exacerbated in larger area membranes where mechanical edge support from the module assembly is farther removed from the center of the membrane and therefore less able to maintain film rigidity. As depicted in
[1224] For example, membrane 211 illustrates the characteristic sag of a narrow width 150-m thick film. Despite reducing the membrane's mass, thinning membrane 212 to a 40-m thickness decreases film rigidity thereby increasing the extent of the sag. Widening the distance across an IEM in order to achieve a larger area for greater current conduction further decreases mechanical support and further increases the magnitude of membrane sag as evidenced by 150-m thick membrane 213 and even more so for 40-m thick membrane 214. In other words every design and process change designed to enhance conductivity and reduce fuel cell resistance renders the ion exchange membrane less rigid and more subject to damage. The combined use of a thin large area membrane further exacerbates the film sagging problem, potentially rendering the membrane unmanufacturable.
[1225] Further complicating matters, most ionomeric membranes are made electrically active by conductive acid groups attached onto the main polymeric chain using an organic sidechain as an intermediary, i.e. as a pendant connecting the ionomer such as sulfonic acid to the backbone. While this approach provides additional control in trading off strength versus conductivity, it is inadequate to solve the mechanical rigidity issue during manufacturing.
[1226] Even worse, ion exchange membranes assembled into fuel cells can swell with water absorption during operation. The swelling occurs both laterally along the plane of the membrane and orthogonally to the membrane's surface impeding current and adversely affecting electrical conductivity. Swelling is a function of current, relative humidity, and temperature. Repeated cycles of swelling, e.g. from humidity cycling, also invokes various wear-out mechanisms shortening film integrity, reliability, and the use life of the membrane.
[1227] To resolve this problematic tradeoff between membrane conductivity and mechanical film strength, a new ion exchange membrane support structure is disclosed herein as an inventive embodiment comprising a skeletal support structure of electrically inactive pillars such as PTFE interspersed throughout the film at regular periodic intervals. When arranged in a waffle-like pattern, the skeleton is able to support thin membranes of arbitrary thickness unrelated to mechanical rigidity within the membrane's active polymer matrix. In one embodiment, this mechanical support or endoskeleton comprises semi-rigid pillars to which thin or fragile membrane can adhere. These pillars provide mechanical support to prevent film sag by holding the membranes tight, and in so doing reduce the range of atomic displacement with hydration.
[1228] This principle for mechanical support is illustrated in
[1229] Singulation may be performed by cutting the exoskeleton down its middle perpendicular to the film's surface using a laser, saw blade, or less ideally using a sharp edged mechanical punch. Laser singulation is preferred as it produces less mechanical stress on the film reducing the risk of tears, breaks, or damage to the membrane. The internal pillars 221, 222a, and 222b referred to herein as an endoskeleton, are as graphically represented narrower than that of the exoskeleton pillars 220a and 200b as they do not require cutting. After singulation, the endoskeletal grid remains a permanent artifact within the final IEM for use in a fuel cell, electrolysis unit, or filter application.
[1230] Referring to the graph curves 215, 216a, 216b, and 217a-217d illustrate the shape of the membrane for various support arrangements. Although the curves schematically represent in exaggerated form the shape of the membrane segments using various skeletal patterns, the abscissa of the graph also numerically represents vertical displacement or sag, with the peak displacement located laterally at the center between its two adjacent pillars. In membrane profile 215 exhibiting the greatest degree of sag, a membrane is supported only by exoskeletal pillars 220a and 200b. Adding a center endoskeletal pillar 221 bifurcates the film into two pieces 216a and 216b greatly reducing the sag. The benefit is made further evident by further subdividing the membrane into quartiles using endoskeletal pillars 222a, 221, and 222b positioned uniformly at 25%, 50% and 75% of the membranes width. The resulting reduction in film sag is represented by curves 217a, 217b, 217c, and 217d.
[1231] While the graph illustrates the addition of endoskeletal pillars in one dimension, the method can be applied in both axis, i.e. along the width and length of the membrane. Ideally, the spacing of the pillars long the x-axis and y-axis are substantially the same, forming a square frame to hold the active membrane. The square grid principle can be followed even when fabricating a rectangular shaped membrane simply by using integer number of squares to form the IEM. For example the width might comprise three endoskeletal pillars forming five segmented areas while lengthwise the distance may divided by 23 endoskeletal pillars forming 25 segments, five times the width. The net resulting shape is 525=125 squares with a net IEM aspect ratio of 5:1. Although the exoskeleton requires a minimal width to support singulation, there is no such restriction for the endoskeletal pillars which may be the same width as the exoskeleton or smaller, including the possibility of more than one endoskeletal width.
[1232] The benefit of the endoskeleton is not limited to manufacturing, it also aids in maintaining film integrity during operation. Specifically, ion exchange membranes physically deform during operation. The deformation can occur from local heating or retaining water, a mechanism referred to as membrane swelling. Humidity, temperature, and IEM current density all affect swelling. As depicted in
[1233] By adding endoskeletal pillars 235a and 235b to IEM membrane 230 as support, in-plane forces causing expansion are countered in kind by opposing forces 236x exerted from the skeletal pillars thereby preventing displacement. Although the fuel cell polymeric matrix may be under pressure, essentially there is no where for the atoms in the polymer to move to except orthogonally in response to force 236y. Even so because of the molecular bonds between the polymeric IEM 230 and the endoskeletal pillars 235a and 235b, there is limited opportunity for displacement because the film surface is tethered on both ends. The resulting magnitude in displacement in the y-direction 237 is very limited even though there is no direct opposing force in perpendicular axis.
[1234] Formation of the exoskeleton and endoskeleton and design considerations for fuel cell applications are further elaborated in a related application Advanced Fuel CellDesign, Apparatus, & Fabrication, referenced herein. In general the pillars of the membrane skeletal are formed by a polymeric compound such as a plastic such as a thermoplastic or polyolefin, PTFE, or glassy matrices reinforced by a filler such as carbon fibers, graphite, graphene, carbon nanotubes, and other mechanically strong insulating materials. In one implementation used to form the support pillars, finely powdered PTFE grains along with strengtheners are loaded into the mold and compressed to a high pressure between 10-to-100 MPa then heated to 360 C. to 380 C. to sinter the powder into a single polymerized mass. The addition of carbon fiber, graphene, carbon nanotubes, or polymeric shards provides added mechanical strength and support. In another embodiment the filler may include nanospun fibers of plastics or PTFE.
[1235] As described, the pillars are quasi-rigid, nonporous to gasses, not electrically conductive, and relatively inert chemically. One key design consideration is the active ionomer film filling the spaces between the pillars must adhere to the skeleton. The simplest way to ensure good attachment is to employ, at least in part, the same material in the pillars as those comprising the membrane. For example, forming the endoskeleton from PTFE with carbon filler and forming the membrane from PFSA coated PTFE means the membrane and the pillar are guaranteed to remain compatible because they both contain PTFE. Using a pure PFSA polymer as the membrane is more complex as the hydrophilic membrane must grafted onto hydrophobic PTFE skeleton using chemical reagents referred to herein as a pillar link to bridge the two. Another option is to use a low mole fraction of PTFE mixed with PFSA as a powder of nanospheres in the membrane starting materials for dispersion casting. Other options include choosing a polymer with a more reactive surface to facilitate enhanced bonding.
Membrane Matrix Frame.
[1236] Although the disclosed skeletal support structure strengthens the IEM membrane for operation and prevents mechanical damage to the film, by itself the endoskeleton and even the exoskeletal pillars do not facilitate convenient handling of the IEM during molding, post mold chemical treatments, catalyst formation, and attachment to the GDLs. In the referenced patent, one method to handle the thin film is to use temporary handles. A handle is a rigid block of material attached to one side of the membrane to facilitate handling needed to move the film from one processing step to the next without actually gripping the membrane. Although the use of handles including plastics, silicon wafers, metal, or polymers cand be used to transport the membrane among its processing steps, a handle suffers several limitations.
[1237] First the process of attaching a handle and then later detaching involves extra processing steps. Secondly, during chemical treatments portions of membrane attached to the handle are not exposed to the chemical reagents. This issue requires the assembly to be flipped over to treat both sides. Lastly, the attachment between the handle and the membrane can leave contaminant on the membranes surface. As such, it is better to coat both sides of the membrane with the catalyst layer before attaching any handle. But this requirement is paradoxical as there is no means to transport and coat the membrane without first attaching a handle.
[1238] To resolve this persistent and extremely problematic handling issue in IEM fabrication, one embodiment of this invention is a membrane matrix. The membrane matrix comprises multiple ion exchange membranes fabricated concurrently, together circumscribed by a membrane matrix frame. The membrane matrix frame provides mechanical support for the array of membranes during fabrication. As shown in
[1239] In one embodiment of this invention a marker or identifier 249 is included on one side of the frame to distinguish anode from cathode. The identifying mark may comprise an ink, fluorescent ink, indentation, etched, or stamped region identifiable using visible light, infrared, UV, or X-ray inspection. The marker which should be visible through a catalyst layer (CL) need not be visible through an attached GDL, since the MEA5 assembly process sequence can identify the anode from cathode and for example attach the CDL first meaning the last GDL to be attached identifies the anode side. With X-ray inspection, the GDL will not interfere with the inspection process.
[1240] Depicted in
[1241] During singulation only a portion 254x of the width of original exoskeleton 254w border survives the fabrication sequence as shown in
[1242] The overall process to form a MEA5 (i.e. CCM) with a matrix frame is depicted in the flow chart shown in
[1243] Alternatively in step 256b Form Surface Conduction IEM, the fabrication may involve sequential steps of forming a non-electrically active polymeric backbone such as PFTE powder co-activated by grafting electrically active ionomer sidechains and pendants such as PFSA onto the mechanical support framework. The actual membrane chemistry and process steps thereof varies by material and by the conducting ionic species, e.g. protons H.sup.+ in a cation exchange membrane also referred to as a proton exchange membrane (PEM), or by anions such as OH in an anion exchange membrane (AEM). More details of the membrane formation are discussed later in this application.
[1244] Subsequent to polymerization the process proceeds with the step Remove Sac Filler, Anneal, Cure, Dry 258 where the polymer is annealed, cured, and dried. In the event that the membrane includes a sacrificial filler, the filler is removed by a solvent prior to drying.
[1245] Alternatively, the membrane may be soaked in an ionic liquid in step 257a prior to curing. An ionic liquid comprises an organic salt that melts into a liquid state at room temperature releasing mobile cations and anions into a ionomeric polymer membrane. Because ionomeric membranes exhibit high specificity to only one polarity of ion transport, specifically hydrogen and hydronium cation transport in proton exchange membranes (PEM) or hydroxide anion transport in anion exchange membranes (AEMs), doping a IEM with an ionic liquid primarily enhances conduction in the dominant ionic species n the IEM. For example an IL introduced into phosphonic or sulphonic PEM membrane will enhance proton conductivity without increasing the number of ionized acid groups functioning as immobile anionic ionomers.
[1246] After polymer formation, membrane fabrication may proceed directly to catalyst layer formation shown by step 260. Alternatively in step 259a, the surface may be sprayed prior to CL formation with a nanocoating to enhance catalysis, reduce interfacial contact resistance, selectively suppress gas diffusion of fuels or toxins such as NO or H.sub.2O.sub.2, to suppress leakage of ionic liquids, or otherwise improve efficiency and/or enhance reliability. The coating may be sprayed subsequent to ionomer polymerization and prior to catalyst layer deposition, or subsequent to CL formation but prior to GDL attachments. The stochiometric contents of the nanocoating are discussed later in this application.
[1247] In step 260 Form Catalyst Layers the membrane is coated on both sides by a catalyst layer typically comprising carbon slurry mixed with a rare earth metal such as platinum (Pt), a metal oxide such as titanium dioxide (TiO.sub.2), or a combination thereof. Other additives may include MOFs, POSS, or nanoparticles including functionalized nanotubes, graphene oxides, and nanoclusters. The specific catalysts used in the CL depend on the type of ion exchange membrane, either PEM or AEM, and may vary from the anode to cathode side of the CCM. The catalyst layer may be deposited using chemical vapor deposition, by printing, ultrasonic spray painting, or sputtering. Because the catalyst comprises a mix of various elements and compounds of varying liquid solubility and vapor pressure, CVD or printing methods are subject to variability in mass production.
[1248] In contrast, sputtering uses a non-thermal non-chemical process involving a mass transfer mechanism is better suited to deposit films of precise and identical stoichiometry to its source target. Sputtering is also capable of performing an in-situ pre-deposition sputter etch process to activate the membrane's surface ions, ameliorate unwanted surface states, and remove surface contaminants, thereby improving the electrochemical interaction between the catalyst and the IEM.
[1249] An alternative embodiment of catalyst layer formation adapted to this invention is to print or extrude a thin catalyst layer decal as a laminate to mechanically attach to each side of the membrane. Such laminate processes are subject to interfacial states, contaminant adhering to the IEM surface, and to air pockets, aka bubbles, unavoidably forming between the soft membrane and the CL decal during the lamination process. Special cleaning steps and squeegee steps such as Dr Blade processes are required as part of the lamination process sequence.
[1250] More details of the catalyst layer formation are subsequently discussed later in this application. Regardless of what method is used, however, the catalyst material must be applied to both opposing sides of the membrane, meaning the membrane must be turned over to expose the anode and cathode CL formation sequentially. After the catalyst layer is deposited the resulting sandwich is referred to as a MEA3 meaning a three layer membrane electrode assembly or CCM, an acronym meaning a cathode coated membrane.
[1251] Subsequent to catalyst layer formation, the membrane may be optionally soaked in an ionic liquid 257b, coated with a nanolayer 259b, or both. The resulting structure represents a completed three layer membrane electrode assembly MEA3 261 ready for attachment to gas diffusion layers. Although the described processes can be varied in alternate sequences, to protect the catalyst layer from ambient toxins the nanocoating process step 285b necessarily must follow CL formation 260. The same protection is not likely required on the anode side as the hydrogen source is generally ultrapure with no gaseous contaminants.
[1252] Alternatively, to enhance interfacial charge transport, the nanocoating formation 259a must precede CL formation step 260. Similarly ionic liquid s may be introduced into the membrane prior to CL formation in step 257a or thereafter in step 257b. Regardless of the sequence, one advantage of performing nanocoating process step 259b after ionic liquid doping is to seal the I.sub.L within the membrane to prevent leakage. The unique process sequence made in accordance with this invention results in a completed MEA3 assembly 261.
[1253] As an embodiment of the membrane electrode assembly fabrication illustrated in
[1254] In an embodiment either the starting MPL or the carbon ink used to form the printed carbon layer may be embedded with GDL fillers. The GDL filler may comprise metallic or scavenger nanoparticles added principally to bond to, extract, and degrade nitric oxide (NO) and other airborne contaminants from being transported to the catalyst layer (CL) and thereby damaging or disabling the catalyst ions. In a hydrogen fuel cell the protective GDL filler nanoparticles are required primarily in the cathode GDL expose to air. In a direct methanol fuel cell however, contaminants may also be carried by an impure methanol source.
[1255] The lower case prefix h is the acronym hGDL identifies the gas diffusion layer is heterogonous, not uniform in composition or atomic density where the deposited carbon layers may comprise stepped or graded coatings generally increasing in porosity monotonically. In one set of embodiments, the deposited layers included shorter higher density fibers adjacent to the MPL and more porous materials comprising longer carbon fibers subsequently deposited atop the higher density layers. In one embodiment, the gradations in carbon density vary in discrete steps while in other implementations the variations are more gradual.
[1256] Subsequent to the hGDL formation in the step entitled Coat hGDL 263, the MPL layer may be treated with a thin coating to improving mechanical attachment and electrical continuity between the MPL and the CCM's catalyst layers by reducing interfacial states, enhancing conductivity, and reducing interfacial stresses. MEA5 fabrication comprises two options, either to (i) attach the GDL gas diffusion layers to the MEA3 in step 266 then to singulate the IEM into separate pieces in step 284a, or (ii) to first separate the film into distinct components, i.e. to Singulate IEMs from Matrix Frame in step 264a then attach the GDL to each membrane piece individually in step 265.
[1257] Specifically in the sequence comprising step 264 Singulate IEMs from Matrix Frame 264a followed by step 265 Attach GDL to Each IEM the assembly method comprises separating the multi-IEM matrix into precut pieces before attaching similarly sized GDL layer. Such arduous assembly method involve more handling and therefore risk film damage. The alternate flow involving step 2666 Attach GDLs to Matrix followed by step 264b Singulate IEMs from Matrix Frame is a batch process postponing the singulation of the membranes into discrete IEMs to the last possible step. Regardless of the flow used, the final outcome is a discrete 5-layer membrane electrode assembly (MEA5) 266 ready for assembly into a module, either as fuel cell, an electrolysis unit, or as ion specific filter.
[1258] Using dispersion casting in a pressurized mold, ionomers can be formed into a matrix of thin ion exchange membranes and skeletons supported by a stiff thick matrix frame surrounding the array. In this manner, two different designs are possible as shown in
[1259] In one method the matrix frame, exoskeleton, and endoskeleton and concurrently molded using dispersion casting as shown
[1260] In the example shown the mold defines at least one deep trench-like region 352a for the matrix frame, a second wider but shallower trench-like region 354a defining an exoskeleton and a third narrower shallow trench-like region 355a defining an endoskeleton. The various trenches are part of a three dimensional grid pattern that merge into another trench oriented perpendicular to the ones shown. The trenches are then filled to the top with a polymer mold compound such as a plastic or PTFE powder or a solution, then polymerized under heat and optionally light pressure, merging the monomers into a single piece of polymerized PTFE including regions 352b, 354b, and 356b which can be removed from the mold once it cools or partially cures.
[1261] In another embodiment, shown in
[1262] Subsequent processing of the skeleton fills in the intervening areas withing the skeletal grid with an ionomer or more accurately an ionomeric polymer. As shown in
[1263] The entire structure is held together by a thicker wider supporting membrane matrix frame connected to the outer exoskeleton 356a by tie bars 353. After singulation where the membrane matrix frame is cut into pieces by laser, saw, or stamp, a completed IEM 360 a fraction of the size of the matrix results.
[1264] Although the example shown illustrates a single 51 row of IEMs, the membrane matrix may include multiple rows such as a 52 grid by introducing additional horizontal exoskeletons similar to exoskeleton supports 307a and 307b into the patter. The shapes of the IEMs may be square or rectangular with aspect ratios typically of 5:1 or 7:1 and generally not exceeding 20:1. For example a 630 aspect ratio produces as active area of nearly 180 cm.sup.2 neglecting are lost to the endoskeleton. At a current density of 200 mA/cm.sup.2 this active area corresponds to a conduction current of 36 A and at of 500 mA/cm.sup.2 results in a current of 90 A.
[1265] As described previously the relationship between the matrix frame and the membrane may be symmetric or asymmetric. The asymmetric design for concurrently fabricating IEM1 through IEM5 membranes 301a-to-301e shown in
[1266]
[1267] In
[1268] The polymerized matrix is then removed from the mold chase, the mold chase is removed from the mold chamber and the completed frame and skeleton is flipped over withing the chamber comprising frame feature 390, exoskeleton features 401a and 401b, and endoskeleton features 402a, 402b and other regions not labelled as shown in
[1269] During the polymerization process shown in
[1270]
[1271] The handle can be any thick protective coating, or comprise a metal, silicon, or polymer slug designed to match the size of the matrix frame. Because of the possible slight height difference between the pillars 401, 402a and 402b compared to ionomer 410, the handle 411 may not uniformly contact catalyst layer 415, but instead include a small gap 412. In actual use, assembly pressure within a fuel cell state eliminates the gap, but preferably membrane synthesis conditions can be optimized to minimize or eliminate the gap.
[1272] In
[1273] Because handle 421 is thicker than matrix frame 390c, the frame will interfere with thermal conduction from heat chuck 420 into the deposition surface. The problem is remedied by inclusion of a thermally conductive handle 421 smaller the membrane matrix. Handle 421 may comprise metals such as copper or steel or may comprise silicon wafers.
[1274]
[1275] In
[1276] In the batch process as shown, multiple MEA5 assembly are made concurrently, followed by laser 441 singulation along defined cut line 440 shown in
[1277] The completed five-layer MEA5 following singulation is shown in
[1278] To further elucidate the structure of the membrane matrix during fabrication, a concurrent depiction of the top view of the matrix frame and a side view of the skeleton/membrane/frame can be illustrated at various steps in the process.
[1279] Other exoskeletal pillars 356b transecting the matrix array separate it into individual IEMs, in this example comprising vertically oriented pillars. Depending on the design and number of peripheral exoskeleton pillars 356a and 356c, and transecting exoskeletons 356b and more, together, collectively as exoskeleton 356, may form a membrane matrix having multiple rows and/or columns of IEMs. Contained within each exoskeleton-bound IEM is a grid of endoskeletons 354 defining square or rectangular areas 355z where the ionomer membrane is to be subsequently formed.
[1280] In
[1281]
[1282]
[1283] Once singulated, the individual IEMs can be removed from the sticky tape and assembled into the fuel cell assembly. In one embodiment, the singulated MEA5 are removed from the sticky tape using a pick and place machine and loaded into the fuel cell stack or stack with no human handling. In this case, the elimination of handling by factory automation reduces the risk of damage to the membrane and improves manufacturing yield and quality.
[1284] In contrast to the foregoing asymmetric frame method, a symmetric membrane matrix frame concurrently fabricating IEM1 through IEM5 membranes 301a-to-301e is shown in
[1285]
[1286] To form a symmetric frame vertically disposed around a matrix of IEM membranes, the molding process is more complex than in a symmetric design. As shown in
[1287] The bottom and top mold chases 462 and 464 respectively are solid and of the same dimension. The inner or intermediate mold chase 463 also has the same exterior dimensions but includes openings 452z and 453z of varying widths which later will correspond to exoskeleton 452 and endoskeleton 453. The stack of aligned mold chases includes a lateral gap 450z separating it from the sidewall of the mold chamber 460. This dimension of gap 450z is controlled by spacers or registration keys not shown inn the figure cross section.
[1288] In
[1289] In
[1290] In the step illustrated by
[1291] Flipping the assembly over for anode catalyst deposition 465a is shown in
[1292] The handle is then removed from the cathode and reattached to the anode side of the film. As shown in
[1293] In
[1294] Regardless of whether the matrix frame is symmetrically or asymmetrically positioned around the membrane itself, or eliminated altogether, the concurrent fabrication of multiple IEMs using a batch process is beneficial as it reduces process variability, improves electrical and chemical consistency, increases production throughput, and lowers manufacturing cost. Beneficial embodiments of the inventive IEM fabrication methods using the inventive membrane matrix frame are numerous, including: [1295] accurate control film thicknesses and dimensions via precision molds; [1296] rigid skeletal support of ultra thin ionomeric membranes during manufacturing and operation; [1297] rigid skeleton support including a peripheral exoskeleton and a thinner endoskeletal grid reduces film swelling from over hydration during operation; [1298] ability to control skeletal and frame strength and rigidity using carbon fiber or other reinforcing materials such as carbon nanotubes, graphene, or fibrous plastics; [1299] larger mechanical support frame for improved manufacturing by automated or robotic handlers; [1300] matrix frame is capable of concurrently fabricating any number of IEMs including a matrix of rows and/or columns of IEMs bounded by a wider exoskeleton; [1301] eliminates handling related film damage causing yield loss or latent reliability failures; [1302] eliminates human contamination of films during assemblyclean room compatible; [1303] able to support any ionomer including bulk conduction and surface conduction type; [1304] consistent polymerization of ionomer under conditions of controlled pressure and temperatures; [1305] capable of employing different materials on the anode and cathode of a CCM; [1306] capable of attaching GDLs to the CCM prior to singulation eliminating the need to handle discrete IEMs during catalyst coating and during MEA5 fabrication, i.e. attaching the GDLs; [1307] stress free laser singulation eliminates mechanical damage and tears in membranes; and [1308] batch process capable of supporting high volume production at lower costs.
[1309] The methods as described are compatible with any type of ionomeric membrane including fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon chemistries, homo-ionomer or hetero-ionomer membranes, with or without skeletal support or nanocoatings. The methods may be used in conjunction with microporous membranes fabricated using a sacrificial filler process, and/or combined with permanent fillers comprising bismuth compounds, graphene oxides, pristine and functionalized carbon nanotubes, silicates, zeolite, zirconium, tungsten, nanofibers, nanospheres, MOFs, and POSS.
Membrane Synthesis.
[1310] Although the process to fabricate the inert membrane matrix frame employs polymer chemistry relatively agnostic to the ionomer it supports, other embodiments involve the formation of the polymer itself. Ionomer chemistry depends on the conducting ion charge, either positively-charged ionized protons H.sup.+ or negatively-charged hydroxyl radicals OH. As such, in a fuel cell two different charge transport polarities are possible. Positive charge conducting IEMs are referred to as cation exchange membranes or more commonly known as proton exchange membranes with the acronym PEM. Negative charge conducting IEMs are referred to as anion exchange membranes or AEMs.
[1311] The chemistry of the membrane and the catalyst also vary with the chemical source of the charge whether gaseous hydrogen, sodium hydroxide, acids, or glucose. While not all fuel cells produce carbon free byproducts, most fuel cells effluents comprise water, i.e. H.sub.2O in liquid or vapor form. The presence of water in the fuel cell also affects the cell's operation either beneficially or to the detriment of its operating efficiency.
[1312] The electrochemistry of a fuel cell, using ionic transport through a membrane to create electricity is a generally reversible process in the cases of simple inorganic molecules such as hydrogen or hydroxide. This inverse process, making hydrogen from water or from alkaline water is referred to as electrolysis. The PEM and AEM membranes useful in fuel cells are generally also adaptable for use in electrolysis except that the membrane's area, chemistry, and catalysts may vary from their fuel cell counterpart.
[1313] Although glucose can be converted into electricity in a glucose fuel cell, the reverse process for electrolysis is not symmetric but instead converts glucose into hydrogen and various organic byproducts including commodity chemicals like sorbitol, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural, gluconic acid (GNA), and glucaric acid (GRA). GRA is considered a key intermediate for the production of biodegradable polymers and biodegradable detergents, as a metal complexation agent, and in pharmacology in chemotherapy and statin production.
[1314] The greatest commercial interest in ion exchange membrane is focused on hydrogen PEM fuel cells (H.sub.2 PEMFCs) and in PEM-based direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) where the lion's share of content in the application is focused. Specific examples of PEM membranes fabricated for various use cases are described here below.
Ionomeric PEM Fabrication.
[1315] In various embodiments of this invention, the fabrication of a PEM proton exchange membrane also referred to as a polyelectrolyte membrane involves a sequence of process steps that differ substantially from conventional membrane processing. The disclosed processes can be divided into two inventive methodsone synthesizing a surface conduction heterogenous ionomeric membrane, the other forming a homogenous bulk conduction ionomer whereby the primary difference is the way charge transport occurs. Either membrane formation method is compatible with the inert skeletal support structure described previously.
[1316] Specifically, the chemistry of forming a heterogenous PEM film is entirely dependent on the synthesis process required to form a resilient chemical bond between the hydrophobic backbone comprising an inert polymer such as PTFE and the hydrophilic ionomer involved in conduction. This process, can be achieved by co-polymerization, i.e. simultaneous formation of hydrophobic and hydrophilic elements bridged by an intervening sidechain pendant, or by grafting. In grafting a process for attaching sidechains to an inert long chain such as a PTFE backbone, the terminus of the sidechain comprises electrically active charge transfer molecules such as sulfonic acid, sulfonated pentablock terpolymers, and non-fluorinated ionomers such as sulfophenylated polyphenylene.
[1317] Unlike copolymerization which depends in the mutual compatibility of monomers and acid groups with cross-linking reagents and solvents during polymer formation, grafting depends on the chemistry of a molecular coating process performed subsequent to a membrane's structural synthesis. Simply put, in grafting a specific sequence of chemical reagents and/or radiation exposures are required to modify a hydrophobic backbone in order to graft a sidechain pendant and an associated hydrophilic ionomer onto its structure.
[1318] One exemplary process sequence is illustrated in
##STR00007##
where the symbol OAc represents the molecule acetoxy, chemically as OCOCH.sub.3 and structurally as OC(O)CH.sub.3 where the double bar symbol=means a double bond, not the equal sign in mathematical equation.
[1319] The properties of the resulting PVA polymer are affected by the degree of transesterification. PVA can be procured commercially in solution or made from PVA powder. For example, in small quantities PVA can be mixed by dissolving 4 g of PVA powder in 40 ml of deionized water and subsequentially mixed with a magnetic stirrer at 90 C. for 3 h until completely dissolved. In manufacturing, the solution can be purchased in volume and stirred at 90 C. immediately upon use.
[1320] The PVA treatment of the IEM matrix may be performed by immersing the fabricated membrane in the heated solution for between 3-to-24 hours. In one implementation made in accordance with this invention, the ion exchange membrane frame is occasionally removed from the PVA solution and rinsed in deionized water to remove any PVA particulates. As shown, the PVA treated PTFE film 502 comprises a coated hydrophobic backbone 502z to facilitate subsequent grafting to hydrophilic side groups of PFSA. The final PTFE thickness is then precisely controlled by a precision pressure mold, using a doctor blade process, or by the amount of material molded.
[1321] Thereafter in step 503 the membrane is spray coated with a PFSA solution comprising a solvent comprising a 1:1 weight percent ratio of deionized water and propanol mixed with a 0.5 weight percent of PTFE nanoparticles (NPs) to chemically neutralize the surface. The matrix frame is then held in a 60 C. oven for drying for approximately eight hours followed by a 150 C. anneal for thirty minutes resulting in PFSA-PVA-PTFE film 504 with polymerized microstructure 504z.
[1322]
[1323] The next step 511 Add Intercalated Sacrificial Layer involves introducing a filler into the mold or cast such as sugar, chitosan, or other water or solvent soluble molecules to control film microporosity. The sacrificial filler may be introduced by blending the filler in solid form into a mix of monomers used to create the thin membrane or by dissolving the filler and monomers with a solvent into solution for casting. According to Miriam-Webster, the term intercalated means to insert or position between or among existing elements or layers. In the context of a molecular lattice of a polymer or crystal, the intercalated sacrificial filler represents a molecule temporarily occupying space within the lattice to reduce the atomic density of the polymer thereby increasing microporosity. Although the size of micropores affect transmembrane water transport in both interfacial and bulk conducting films, porosity has a more profound effect in bulk materials.
[1324] In the case of forming an interfacial conduction IEM, the sacrificial filler is mixed with monomers of an inert electrically-insulating material co-molded with the sacrificial layer using cast molding in step 514 Form Inert Membrane during which polymerization of the constituent monomers occurs via cross linking optionally aided by heating and/or mild pressure. During casting or molding, the sacrificial molecules becoming embedded into molecular matrix of the polymer or glassy polymer.
[1325] After cooling, the polymer is treated to dissolve and remove the sacrificial filler from the matrix using a corresponding solvent as depicted in step 515 Remove Sacrificial Filler. The film may be subsequently washed or cleaned in water or other solvents, soaked in solvents, and/or heated in step 516 Treat/Cure Membrane in order to prepare the semi-insulating membrane for a subsequent coating step to enable electrical conductance.
[1326] In step 517 Coat Active Ionomer onto Membrane, the insulating polymeric substrate is coated with a conducting ionomer which bonds to surface of polymer strands either through surface tension or covalent bonding, thereby grafting hydrophilic functional groups such as sulfonic or phosphonic acid onto the polymer chains. The details of the graft or bond depend on the process used in preceding step 516.
[1327] Bonds for example may between the mainchain and a sidechain or pendant molecule may occur by various mechanisms including (i) attachment at a damage site created by a chemical reagent or by radiation treatment; (ii) attachment by a chemical substitution reaction where one or more atoms of the mainchain become replaced, e.g. substituting fluorine with carbon or oxygen to enable covalent bonding between the polymer backbone and sidechains; (iii) entanglement where one end of the sidechain becomes physically enveloped, i.e. tangled, with the 3D structure of the polymer's mainchain tethering the sidechain pendant and its acid terminus to the membrane's molecular matrix; or (iv) intertwining, where the molecular strands of two polymers, one inert and hydrophobic, the other hydrophilic and bonded to ionomeric termini, become so entwined they cannot be separated or untangled. Despite their repulsive forces, hydrogen bonding and Van der Waals forces occurring intermittently along the chains prevent the two incompatible chains from unwinding and dissociating.
[1328] In other cases, a cross linking agent such polydopamine or glutaraldehyde can secure the molecular structures to one another. In the special instance of inserting conductive ionones into the mainchain itself rather than by attaching a sidechain, the mainchain must be cleaved or severed to accommodate the insertion, a physical chemical process analogous to the way an endonuclease can sever deoxyribose in biochemistry.
[1329] Regardless of the molecular bonding mechanism in step 517 Coat Active Ionomer onto Membrane, the terminology does not simply mean to coat the exterior face of the membrane with an ionomeric coating but to encase the individual strands of the hydrophobic polymeric strands with a sheath of conducting sidechains and acids. The conductive encasement formed by the molecular coating process, analogous to myelin coating of nerves or insulation coating a wire, enables conduction along the length of the hydrophobic polymer strands, in essence forming surfaces for surface conduction within the polymeric or glassy matrix of the membrane.
[1330] Step 517 may also include introduction of a solute matrix of nanoparticles carried by a solvent. For example if the inert structural matrix formed in step 514 comprises PTFE and the monomers introduced in coating step 517 is a spray or solution of PTFE, PFSA and PVA, then in step 518 Treat/Cure Ionomer a thin layer of conductive channels of PFSA ionomeric conductors is formed along the spine of the PTFE mainchains. To strengthen the bonds, the PTFE membrane or skeleton is sprayed with PVA, washing the film with ethanol, then stimulating cross linking to the polytetrafluoroethylene surface using glutaraldehyde. Alternatively PVA may be cross linked to poly(acrylic acid-co-2-acrylamido-2-methyl propane sulfonic acid), chemically as (P(AA-AMPS)), to enhance stability.
[1331] In other variants, the polymer may comprise or fluorocarbons forming glassy matrices or may comprise low-fluorine or fluorine-free compounds. For example, other composite membranes made in accordance with this invention involve bonding using PVA with inorganic zirconium phosphate to form a highly-stable composite membrane of PTFE-ZrP-PVA. Thereafter, the film is ready for subsequent CCM processing in step 519 Catalyst Layer Processing. The resulting structure is an endoskeletal-supported composite reinforced membrane CRM which primarily conducts ions via ionomer pendants such as PFSA adhering to and attached along the PTFE chain.
[1332] The resulting ionomer is therefore a heterogenous film and IEM. Fabricating a bulk conducting film is also represented in the same flow chart commencing with formation of the skeletal support in step 510 to produce an endoskeleton of semirigid pillars including wider exoskeletal elements used for IEM singulation by laser or mechanical cutting, and optionally a thick wide frame for mechanical or robotic handling during fabrication. The next step entitled Add Intercalated Sacrificial Layer involves introducing a filler into the mold or cast such as sugar, chitosan, or other water or solvent soluble molecules to control film microporosity.
[1333] The sacrificial filler is then mixed with monomers of a hydrophilic electrically-conductive ionomeric material co-molded with the sacrificial filler using pressure or thermal cast molding in step 512 Form Ionomeric Membrane. In this process, also referred to as co-molding the sidechain and the mainchains are formed concurrently and covalently bound during the polymerization process. By integrating two hetero-monomer segments, i.e. a di-monomers, alternating between pristine hydrophobic mainchain segments and those containing sidechain pendants with hydrophilic ionomeric termini, the ionomer's equivalent weight (EW), i.e. the mole fraction of conductive ionomer groups, can be regulated.
[1334] For example, the ionomers Nafion, Aquivion, 3M, etc. comprise PFSA-PTFE di-polymer formed by a linear mainchain of hydrophobic TFE segments of (CF.sub.2CF.sub.2) alternated with a second monomer having a single oxygen substitution of fluorine, namely (CFOCF.sub.2) where the oxygen forms a second bond with a sidechain pendant with a hydrophilic ionomer terminus. The equivalent weight (EW) is defined as the number of grams of dry polymer per mole sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3) determined by the average distance between the side chains along the backbone, i.e. the occurrence frequency of the second monomer segment. Commercial equivalent weights range from 700 to 1200 for the PFSA class of fluorocarbon based membranes. The combination of a long inert mainchain with multiple sidechain pendants is sometimes referred to as a comb polymer because of its structural shape.
[1335] Partially fluorinated membranes include segments containing glass like compounds rather than PTFE. Examples include hydrolyzed perfluoro-(2,2-dimethyl-1,3-dioxole) (PDD) and poly(perfluoro-2-methylene-4-methyl-1,3-dioxolane) (PFMDD). Di-monomer based membranes also are common in hydrocarbon based polymers include polyethylene (PE), polyvinyl chloride (PVC), phenylsulfonyl-poly(benzoyl-phenylene) (PhSO)P(BzPh); poly phosphazene P(Pz); and poly siloxane P(Sx). Other forms of polymers contain multiple dissimilar segments on their mainchain. Examples include hybrid heteropolymers of hydrocarbons such as poly arylene ether sulfone (PAES, PAESf), poly arylene ether matrix (PAEM); poly(ether ketone) (PEK), poly(ether sulfone) (PES, PESf); poly(ketone sulfone) (PKS, PKSf); poly(arylene ketone ether sulfone) (PAKES, PAKESf); and poly(arylene ether sulfone) triazine bisphenol (PAES)(TzBPh).
[1336] A large class of copolymers employs linking molecules to complete a heterogenous mainchain or cross-linked chains. Examples include a large number of poly vinyl difluoride compounds (PVDF-co-X) where X may represent any number of monomeric segments including perfluorostyrene, polyphenylene quarter-Ph, polyamide sulfonimide, polyvinyl alcohol, PVP polystyrene, F.sub.6 propylene, and others. A key element to the assembly of copolymers is the inclusion of amphiphilic molecules to facilitate linking. An amphiphilic or amphiphatic molecule is one having both hydrophobic (nonpolar) and hydrophilic (polar) regions to facilitate bonding. One other class of copolymer comprises large subunits known as blocks assembled in a linear sequence, often with amphiphilic linkers contained within.
[1337] Returning to
[1338] Exemplary films made in accordance with this invention are shown in the samples shown in
PEM Measured Electrical Characteristics.
[1339] As shown in
[1340] Multiplying the conducted current density value times the measured cell voltage results in the power density curves shown in
[1341] Scaling the membrane's active area to mA.sub.FC=120 cm.sup.2 means a fabricated cell using the fabricated film will deliver 12 W at a current of 24 A and a cell voltage of V.sub.FC=0.5 V. The described CRM fabrication process demonstrated does not include any provisions for enhancing the porosity of the PTFE web-like framework reinforcing the film nor does it include the semi-rigid skeleton disclosed previously.
[1342] Use of the term polarization curves to describe the voltage-current characteristics of a fuel cell is a bit misleading as not all the electrical effects in a fuel cell relate to polarization related losses. Some effects, for example ohmic losses occurring in conductors such as the bipolar plates, are in fact not related to polarization while other loss mechanisms are. More broadly the losses can be categorized into four componentsa lossless polarization voltage V*, activation losses, ohmic losses, and concentration or transport losses.
[1343] The lossless component V* represents the zero current voltage differential between the ideal cell voltage V.sub.chem and the fuel cell's open-circuit terminal voltage V.sub.FC(I=0.sup.+)=V.sub.OC at the onset of conduction. This voltage differential is similar to a contact potential. Since this V* potential is overcome electrostatically, i.e. requiring no DC current, the voltage V.sub.chem is not meaningful in calculating efficiency of a fuel cell membrane or in power losses. Instead the open circuit voltage V.sub.OC neglecting the lossless component V* is a better reference when calculating efficiency. As such, the fuel cell efficiency can be calculated by .sub.FC=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC where the fuel cell voltage is a function of current, temperature, and relative humidity V.sub.FC=f (I.sub.FC, T, RH). Importantly, by maintaining temperature and relative humidity, a membrane's polarization curve allows extraction of numerous electrical properties of an ion exchange membrane including power output, conversion efficiency, heat generation, resistance and resistive losses, activation losses, and the onset of high current concentration losses.
[1344] Specifically the power generated by the fuel cell is given by the fuel cell's voltage V.sub.FC at a specified current whereby P.sub.FC=I.sub.FCV.sub.FC. The power output can be converted into power density by dividing its current I.sub.FC by the fuel cell's active area A.sub.FC in which power density in mW/cm.sup.2 is calculated as (P.sub.FC/A.sub.FC)=[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](V.sub.FC) where V.sub.FC is a function of current density. Similarly power input to a fuel is given by its open circuit voltage V.sub.OC multiplied by its current I.sub.FC or current density I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC, as given by either P.sub.in=I.sub.FCV.sub.OC or by (P.sub.in/A.sub.FC)=[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](V.sub.OC) where V.sub.OC=V.sub.eff=V.sub.chemV* and where V* is the voltage drop due polarization at I.sub.FC=O.sup.+.
[1345] As defined thermodynamically or electrodynamically, conversion efficiency .sub.FC of a fuel cell is defined as its by the power output V.sub.FC divided by its power input P.sub.in or simply .sub.FC=P.sub.FC/P.sub.in=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC where P.sub.FC and V.sub.FC are a function of I.sub.FC or I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC. The resulting equation if current in amperes (A) is replaced by current density in mA/cm.sup.2. In other words, the efficiency of a fuel cell at a specific current or current density is the ratio of its measured voltage to the open circuit voltage. For example, for Nafion polarization curve 520 operating at a current density of 50 mA/cm.sup.2 the fuel cell voltage is measured to be V.sub.FC=0.67V while the voltage at I.sub.FC=0.sup.+ is V.sub.OC=0.94V. Substituting the measured values into the expression, the corresponding empirical efficiency as defined by the ratio of the two is thereby .sub.FC=P.sub.FC/P.sub.in=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC=(0.67V)/(0.94V)=71% whereby activation losses are (100%.sub.FC)=(100%71%)=29% The activation voltage V.sub.a=V.sub.OCV.sub.FC=0.94V0.67V=0.27V.
[1346] In direct comparison, the polarization curves of fuel cells comprising membranes made in accordance with this invention include 100 m composite reinforced membrane (CRM) shown by curve 521 with V.sub.FC=0.72V, an activation voltage V.sub.a=V.sub.OCV.sub.FC=0.94V0.72V=0.22V and a corresponding loss of (1.sub.FC)=1(0.72V)/(0.94V)=(100%77%)=23%. Because the membrane is reinforced it can be scaled to higher performing thinner membranes. For example, curve 522 for a 50 m film exhibits a voltage at 50 mA/cm.sup.2 at V.sub.FC=0.80V, an activation voltage V.sub.a=V.sub.OCV.sub.FC=0.94V0.80V=0.14V and a corresponding loss (1.sub.FC)=1(0.80V)/(0.94V)=(100%85%)=15%. By comparison, curve 525 for a 20 m film exhibits a voltage of V.sub.FC=0.83V, an activation voltage V.sub.a=V.sub.OCV.sub.FC=0.94V0.83V=0.11V and a corresponding loss (1.sub.FC)=1(0.83V)/(0.94V)=100%88%=12%.
[1347] As demonstrated in the below table activation voltage of membranes made in accordance with this invention improved by 2.7 reducing from 270 mV and a 29% power loss to 110 mV with only a 12% power efficiency reduction. Because of the reduced activation loss, the membrane resistance R.sub.memb averaged across the ohmic region decreases from 2.5 cm.sup.2 down to 1.4 cm.sup.2.
TABLE-US-00008 Membrane V.sub.FC @ 50 mA/cm.sup.2 Activation V.sub.a 1 .sub.FC Ohmic R.sub.memb @ I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC = 175 mA/cm.sup.2 100 m Nafion 0.67 V 270 mV 29% R = (0.94 V-0.50 V)/(I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC) = 2.50 cm.sup.2 100 m CRM 0.72 V 220 mV 23% R = (0.94 V-0.53 V)/(I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC) = 2.30 cm.sup.2 50 m CRM 0.80 V 140 mV 15% R = (0.94 V-0.63 V)/(I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC) = 1.8 cm.sup.2 20 m CRM 0.83 V 110 mV 12% R = (0.94 V-0.69 V)/(I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC) = 1.4 cm.sup.2
[1348] As evidenced by a change in slope, above current densities of 50 mA/cm.sup.2, DC losses are primarily ohmic in nature including the chemical diffusion resistance involving cation conduction across the membrane and purely resistive losses for conducting electrons out of the fuel cell or fuel cell stack. At higher currents, e.g. over 175 mA/cm.sup.2 concentration losses begin to impede carrier transport including water logging, membrane swelling, and other transport effects.
[1349] The overall electrical behavior can be modelled as a lumped element model shown in
where the dynamic impedance 543 of magnitude Z(t) is given by
and where real components V.sub.effV.sub.chemV* and R.sub.memb=Re {Z.sub.memb}>>R.sub.ohmic. The ideal FC voltage 540, FC polarization voltage V*, and DC membrane resistance 102 are all functions of temperature T, relative humidity of the anode RH.sub.A, relative humidity of the cathode RH.sub.C, and current density I/A.
[1350] Even at zero current when resistive losses are diminutive, the fuel cell voltage V.sub.FC still remains less than the electrochemical potential V.sub.chem because of contact potential, i.e. the work function between dissimilar materials present in the cell's construction. As such, a fuel cell cannot deliver any power at the voltage V.sub.chem. More precisely, the maximum possible voltage of an unloaded fuel cell is given by V.sub.FC=V.sub.chemV* where V* the minimum polarization voltage is non-zero.
Bulk Conducting Ionomer PEM.
[1351] Another approach to forming a PEM membrane made in accordance with this invention is to employ a homogenous ionomer with added support in the active conducting areas. While pure ionomeric films suffer from swelling and risk mechanical damage during handling, in one embodiment of this invention the combination of the disclosed semi-rigid skeleton with a bulk conducting ionomer provides the complementary advantages of both mechanical support and high film conductivity not achievable by CRMs.
[1352] Note that for an ion-conduction mechanism in which water is the transport medium, even very thin hydrophobic barriers can drastically reduce ion conductivity. Accordingly, to overcome this problem, made in accordance with this invention the bulk conducting membrane includes narrow water channels called nanopores to enhance ion transport under low humidity conditions.
[1353] Accordingly, the disclosed bulk conducting membrane comprises a pure PFSA polymer with increased porosity. In one embodiment the enhanced porosity film is formed using a sacrificial filler interspersed within the PFSA matrix. To open pores within the ionomeric polymer, the filler must be present in the dispersion cast or mold at the time of PFSA formation. At the time of polymerization the filler occupies spaces where PFSA monomers would otherwise occupy. After the matrix is polymerized, the filler is removed using any solvent that does not dissolve PFSA. After the filler is dissolved and removed by the solvent, the resulting membrane is washed of any remaining reagents in deionized water and dried. In the spaces of the polymerized matrix the filler previously occupied, now a thermally stable nanopore remains increasing the ionomer's porosity and enhancing proton transport.
[1354] As depicted in the flow chart of
[1355] The PFSA is then dissolved in a solvent 556 and applied onto the crystalized substrate of the filler 557 giving time for the PFSA to soak into the filler crystal. Once thoroughly wetted, the ionomer is baked then polymerized and cured with heat and/or pressure 558. During molding and curing in either steps 551, 554, or 558 the polymer forms in and around the filler. The filler is then subsequently dissolved and removed by a solvent in step 559 followed by a final stabilizing bake 560.
[1356] For illustrative purposes
[1357] The mixtures were settled for at least 8 h to allow the PFSA solution precursor to fully infiltrate the pores of the sugar template. After curing, the PFSA was subjected to a water bath (at the temperature of 60 C.) in order to dissolve the sugar filler. The porous PFSA film was air dried at 60 C. for half an hour and then carefully detached from the glass substrates and thermally annealed at 150 C. for 30 min to complete the fabrication process.
[1358] The exemplary films fabricated through this process comprise a white porous film 570 shown in
[1359] The voltage-current relationship of fabricated porous PEM films 582a, 582b, and 582c is contrasted in
[1360] Although numerous models exist to theoretically predict PEM polarization curves, since we already have measured electrical characteristics, fuel cell parameters can be extracted using a simplified piecewise linear resistance model assuming a fixed zero open circuit polarization voltage of V*=V.sub.chemV.sub.OC where V.sub.OC is the open circuit voltage at the onset of conduction. According to the previously shown graph of
[1361] If we assume the intrinsic electrochemical fuel cell voltage is V.sub.chem=1.2 V, then V*=V.sub.chemV.sub.OC=1.2V0.94V=0.26V. Since this voltage drop occurs at nearly zero current, it dissipates no power and therefore can be ignored in power and efficiency calculations. Instead the value V.sub.OC=0.94V should be considered the ideal fuel cell voltage by which power loss is calculated regardless of what V.sub.chem is. Accordingly the terminal voltage of the fuel cell as a function of current can be estimated using an effective average resistance R.sub.eff by the equation
with a corresponding power P.sub.L delivered to a load given by
where the ideal fuel cell power at one-hundred percent efficiency is given by P.sub.100=I.sub.FCV.sub.OC when the current I.sub.FC=0, where R.sub.eff is the average resistance defined by R.sub.eff=(V.sub.OCV.sub.FC)/I.sub.L, and where the average power loss P.sub.loss dissipated within the fuel cell is P.sub.loss=I.sub.FC.sup.2 R.sub.eff.
[1362] A more accurate description of power loss is a piece wise linear model where the total energy lost is determined by a current dependent variable resistance R.sub.x where
and so on. As a discrete series summation P.sub.loss can be expressed as
for where I.sub.(x-1)<I.sub.FCI.sub.x and where R.sub.x is the small signal resistance R.sub.x=(V.sub.xV.sub.(x-1))/(I.sub.xI.sub.(x-1)). The power delivered to the load is given by
whereby P.sub.in=P.sub.L+P.sub.loss=I.sub.FCV.sub.OC or more specifically
The efficiency is then given by
[1363] To analyze the fuel cell performance, the electrical curves are converted in
[1364] The piecewise linear resistance occurring in the ohmic region of operation may also be considered as have a small signal differential resistance denoted by the lower case variable r.sub.ss where ss means small-signal or differential resistance. Differential resistance r.sub.ss may be considered as the partial derivative of voltage with respect to current for operation V/I within the ohmic operational region irrespective of the polarization voltage V*. Referring to the previous illustration
[1365] In
TABLE-US-00009 X I.sub.x/A V.sub.x X 1 I.sub.x1/A V.sub.x1 P.sub.in/A R.sub.FC P.sub.L/A P.sub.loss/A r.sub.ss Units: Membrane mA/cm.sup.2 V mA/cm.sup.2 V mW/cm.sup.2 cm.sup.2 mW/cm.sup.2 mW/cm.sup.2 % cm.sup.2 100 m A1 25 0.76 OC 0 0.95 24 7.6 19 5 80 7.6 Nafion A2 50 0.68 A1 25 0.76 48 5.4 34 14 72 3.2 PEM A3 115 0.60 A2 50 0.68 109 3.0 69 40 63 1.2 A4 180 0.50 A3 115 0.60 171 2.5 90 81 53 1.5 A5 200 0.45 A4 180 0.50 190 2.5 90 100 47 2.5 20 m B2 50 0.83 OC 0 0.95 48 2.4 42 6 87 2.4 PFSA-PTFE B3 115 0.79 B2 50 0.83 109 1.4 91 18 83 0.6 CRM PEM B4 180 0.67 B3 115 0.79 171 1.6 121 50 71 1.8 B5 200 0.60 B4 180 0.67 190 1.8 120 70 63 3.5 20 m C2 50 0.93 OC 0 0.95 48 0.4 47 1 98 0.4 Porous C3 115 0.90 C2 50 0.93 109 0.4 104 6 95 0.5 PEM C4 180 0.76 C3 115 0.90 171 1.1 137 34 80 2.2 C5 200 0.69 C4 180 0.76 190 1.3 138 52 73 3.5
[1366] From the above table the superior performance of the fabricated 20 m porous PEM over the 20 m PFSA-PVA-PTFE composite reinforced membrane CRM is confirmed. Both the porous PEM and the CRM significantly outperform conventional 100 m Nafion based membranes. All membranes employed a industry standard homogenous gas diffusion layer. A thorough comparison reveals several key beneficial innovations, namely [1367] The porous membrane exhibits almost no activation losses, i.e. no significant voltage droop in the first 50 mA/cm.sup.2. In contrast Nafion exhibited a 30% drop of 0.27V from 0.95V to 12 0.68V over the same current range. [1368] For a power input of 109 mW/cm.sup.2, nominal operation in the ohmic region, the porous PEM maintained a high cell voltage of 0.9V delivering 104 mW/cm.sup.2 output at a power conversion efficiency of 95% while the Nafion film delivered only 69 mW/cm.sup.2 at a poor efficiency of only 63%. The PFSA CRM membrane outperformed Nafion at an efficiency of 83% with a delivered power of 91 mW/cm.sup.2. [1369] At a higher power input 171 mW/cm.sup.2 in the higher end of the ohmic operating range, the porous membrane maintained an efficiency over 80% delivering 137 mW/cm.sup.2 while Nafion membrane falls to 53% power efficiency and only 90 mW/cm.sup.2 producing almost as a much heat as delivered power. The developed PFSA-PTFE CRM maintained a usable 71% efficiency and 121 mW/cm.sup.2 but not competitive to the porous PEM. [1370] At high input power densities of 190 mW/cm.sup.2 and over, all fuel cell exhibit efficiency loss due to carrier transport mechanisms and water logging. That said, the efficiency of the porous PEM maintained the best performance at 73% power efficiency, the CRM film delivered 63%, and the Nafion film fell to 47%. [1371] Beyond the activation operating region where resistance is not phenomenologically representative of fuel cell physics, the DC specific resistance the Nafion membrane over 109 mW/cm.sup.2 of input power ranged from 2.5-to-3.0 cm.sup.2 while the porous PEM exhibited specific resistances of 0.4-to-1.3 cm.sup.2, representing an 48% to 84% reduction. The CRM maintained a range of 1.4-to-1.8 cm.sup.2, a 40% improvement over conventional fuel cells. [1372] Small signal DC impedance r.sub.ss of the fabricated fuel cells ranged 0.6-to-3.5 cm.sup.2, slightly lower than Nafion in the ohmic range but more resistive at high power densities.
[1373]
[1374] Curves 600c, 600b, and 600a further illustrates the improvements in power efficiency q of the new membranes, where =(V.sub.OCV.sub.x)/(I.sub.x) at any point (I.sub.x, V.sub.x) and where V.sub.OC=0.94V. Clearly the porous PEM is capable of delivering significantly higher power outputs and efficiencies than present day fuel cells. The observed improvement in efficiency not only improves fuel cell performance and conserves fuel, it also reduces waste heat dissipated in the fuel cell stack.
[1375]
[1376]
[1377] In general the lossy inflection point roughly corresponds to the current at which peak power delivery occurs.
[1378] There is no one-to-one correspondence between current density I.sub.FC/A and power density P/A because the fuel cell voltage V.sub.FC is itself a function of current. Using the above table however power and voltage do correlate for each particular film. Specifically at I.sub.FC/A=180 mA/cm.sup.2, a 100 am Nafion PEM 585 exhibits a voltage of 0.5V and a power density at 90 mW/cm.sup.2. At the same current, a 20-m CRM PEM 586 exhibits a voltage of 0.67V and a power density at 121 mW/cm.sup.2 while the fabricated 20-m porous PEMs exhibit a voltage of approximately 0.76V with a corresponding power density at 137 mW/cm.sup.2. The performance of a fuel cell is also however, influenced by the performance of the gas diffusion layers that transport gas to the membrane.
Gas Diffusion Layer Fabrication.
[1379] The gas diffusion layer or GDL performs a number of roles in a PEM based fuel cell including providing (i) electric connection between the bipolar plate (BP) and catalyst layer (CL), (ii) pathways for reactant transport, heat and water removal, (iii) mechanical support for the membrane electrode assembly (MEA), and (iv) protection of the CL from erosion by gas flows or other factors. Physical processes in GDLs include diffusive transport, bypass flow induced by in-plane pressure differentials between neighboring channels, through-plane flow induced by mass sourcing and sinking to catalyst layers, heat transfer, two-phase flow, and electron conductance.
[1380]
[1381] The problem with any uniform material used to form a gas dis diffusion layer is an intrinsic tradeoff between atoms carrying current and the pores in between carrying gasses. Increasing the pore size improves gas flow but increases electrical resistance. Conversely smaller pores increase GDL surface contact area lowering contact resistance and improving the atomic volume of electrical conducting atoms in the GDL matrix, together reducing series resistance through the layer. Unfortunately, smaller pores limit gas transport through the matrix reducing the hydrogen fuel supply arriving at the PEM interface available to sustain necessary redox reactions. Smaller pores also adversely impact the cathode GDL's ability to remove generated water from the cell. Accordingly, a gas diffusion layer of unform porosity represents a significant compromise between gas and water transport versus electrical and thermal conduction. The resulting tradeoff results in IEMs with high electrical resistance, a propensity for water logging and membrane swelling, low cell voltages, and increased sensitivity of fuel cell performance to atmospheric humidity.
[1382] In an attempt to ameliorate this issue, commercial GDLs today generally comprise two layers as shown in
[1383] One immediate benefit of the bilayer GDL is the control of water agglomeration at the interface between the cathode catalyst layer 631 and the gas diffusion layer. Referring to
[1384] As shown in schematic on the left, in the absence of an microporous layer water transport from the CCM-GDL interface through GDL 621u to the gas channel cathode chamber 613 in cathode bipolar plate BPP 612 involves a convoluted interstitial path 617 referred to as tortuous water transport. Without controlling water diffusion, generated condensed water 610 also agglomerates 611a along the CCM impeding conduction and fuel cell operation. By introducing MPL 614, the water generation rate is controlled by MPL porosity greatly reducing water agglomeration 611x and reducing the propensity for membrane swelling and water logging.
[1385] It should be mentioned, that some publications refer to a macroporous substrate or MPS. This term is less common and somewhat confusing as it presumes a specific fabrication flow, specifically as the term macroporous substrate implies the GDL starting material contain larger pores than other layers within the gas diffusion layer. Care must be taken when examining publications to clarify the lexicology of the specific journal.
[1386] Practically speaking the starting substrate such as carbon paper may comprise larger pores than subsequent layers deposited on it or vice versa just so long that the smaller pore material contacts the CCM and the larger pore side contacts the bipolar plate. In essence the sequence by which the bilayer material is formed is irrelevant so long that it is assembled into MEA5 in the proper orientation. Within this application the term microporous layer (MPL) shall mean GDL layer having smaller pore sizes than other layers in the GDL, irrespective as to whether the MPL was used as a substrate in fabrication, or if it was deposited on another layer.
[1387] Although a bilayer GDL affords added control in balancing water and electric conduction, homogenous gas diffusion layers are far from optimum. In a creative embodiment of this invention, gas diffusion layers made in accordance with this invention comprise a deposited carbon layer that is neither homogenous in chemical composition and stoichiometry, nor uniform in porosity. The term hGDL is used herein to describe multilayer heterogenous gas diffusion layers' structures and to differentiate them from conventional bilayer GDLs having a single uniform deposited layer.
[1388] Fabrication of these next generation GDLs may involve a variety of materials including carbon paper, carbon fiber, carbon cloth, or carbon felt. Carbon is attractive because of its good thermal and electrical conductivity, its permeability to gasses, its low chemical reactivity and immunity to oxidative degradation, and lack of toxicity. Importantly carbon is hydrophobic helping drain condensed water and preventing undesirable edema-like water retention and membrane swelling. Alternative GDL materials may include metal based meshes and porous films but these materials suffer corrosion risks and are generally too hydrophilic for good water clearance.
[1389] Although carbon fiber paper offers superior electrical performance, carbon fiber cloth more easily stretches and deforms to better match the topography of the CCM catalyst layer and the bipolar plate sandwiching the GDL. The rigidity of carbon cloth can be modified and conductivity enhanced by applying additives such as carbon black powder or phenolic resin followed by a high temperature carbonization process. Alternative GDL materials include a polyacrylonitrile (PAN) derived carbon cloth, cellulose, or cotton fibers chemically coated to enhance their conductivity. One material well suited for realizing a porous structure with electrical conductivity is carbon in the form of graphite. Other candidates include carbon fibers, carbon nanotubes, graphene, and various composite materials.
[1390] Another concern is the behavior of a GDL under mechanical pressure. In fuel cell assembly the stack of membranes is compressed to ensure good contact between the conductive elements within the cell. Unfortunately, a sparse carbon matrix is compressible and will deform, allowing the GDL to encroach into the gas channels of the BPP and impeding gas flows. As shown in
[1391] Although GDLs can be formed by manually spraying or painting layers onto carbon paper, these methods are not reproducible, manufacturable, or scalable, as pore size depends on deposition rate, processing temperature, and stoichiometric solute concentration. Another challenge to reproducibility is the need to constantly stir carbon paints to maintain mixing and prevent fibers from precipitating out of solution.
[1392] As disclosed herein, one embodiment of this invention able to precisely control film thickness, stoichiometry and porosity of a multilayer carbon film involves the sequential deposition using a multi-head printer depicted schematically in
[1393] The term MPL is referred to as a micro-porous layer indicating the size of the pores in the paper are smaller than one micron, typically 0.5-to-1.0 m in diameter, smaller than the carbon deposited onto it. In 2D printing the print head must scan back and forth as the carbon MPL paper is fed through the printer in the same manner an inkjet printer works. Alternatively, the print head may comprise a continuous bar or a number of smaller print heads able to uniformly print the entire width of the paper in one pass eliminating the need for scanning the a single print head back and forth across the paper width.
[1394] In the case of linear motion of the carbon paper illustrated in
[1395] In one embodiment, the addition of GDL filler 622f during deposition results in permanent fillers 622x being formed with the printed GDL matrix. The function of the GDL filler is to sequester and degrade carbon monoxide (CO) to protect the CCM catalyst layer such as platinum from poisoning. Mechanistically carbon monoxide scavengers useful as GDL fillers made in accordance with this invention include elements able to oxidize CO into CO.sub.2. These include metal oxides of cerium oxide (CeO.sub.2), iron oxide (Fe.sub.2O.sub.3), manganese oxides such as MnO, calcium titanium oxides including CaTiO.sub.3 aka perovskite oxides, and copper based catalysts such as CuO. Aside from oxides of transition metals (TMs), other physical structures containing TMs may include functionalized carbon nanotubes, metal organic frameworks (MOFs), functionalized graphene substrates, TM nanoclusters, and functionalized polyhedral silsesquioxanes such as POSS and DDSQs. Other catalysts able to oxidize CO when embedded into the carbon matrix of the GDL include gold (Au) nanoparticles, bimetallic compounds such as platinum-tin (PtSn), zeolites, and catalysts of rhodium (Rh) and ruthenium (Ru) in various elemental, compound, and MOF configurations. For example, in ruthenium catalyzed reaction of carbon monoxide to form carbon dioxide, the reaction is given by CO+Ru+/(O.sub.2).fwdarw.CO.sub.2+Ru where the ruthenium is recovered fully with each turn. While the turnover frequency (TOF) for ruthenium (Ru) catalysts in the oxidation of CO to CO.sub.2 varies by temperature and pressure, in general a TOF of several hundred conversions per second is possible.
[1396] Like MOFs, zeolites can be used to complex catalytic transition metals such copper (Cu), iron (Fe), or cobalt (Co) into high temperature catalysts. Zeolites, aluminosilicates with a crystalline structure composed of SiO.sub.4 and AlO.sub.4 tetrahedra linked by shared oxygen atoms offer a variety of advantages to enhance TM performance and longevity in catalysis. Specifically, introducing a transition metal into zeolite allows the metal atom to function as the active reaction site while the inert zeolite framework provide chemical and thermal stability. Moreover, the porous structure of zeolites provides a large surface area, enhancing the adsorption of CO and facilitating the contact between reactants and catalytic sites. Examples of zeolite CO scavengers compatible with used in the inventive include copper zeolite (Cu-ZSM-5) and cobalt zeolite (Co-ZSM-5) where either copper or cobalt have been substituted into the zeolite atomic framework.
[1397] Using any of the scavengers described above, the GDL fillers behave like a microscopic scrubber similar to a catalytic converter in automotive vehicles but on a molecular scale. Although these scavengers may be introduced anywhere within the GDL or MPL substrate, they may also be contained in specific portions of the deposited film to reduce material costs. For example, the permanent filler 622x may be isolated or concentrated within the more coarse GDL3 layer 621f where exposure to incoming airflow is statistically greater than in less porous regions of the carbon matrix such as layer GDL1.
[1398] In another embodiment of this invention, the required mol fraction of filler molecules should scale with the density of the carbon layer containing it. For example, the required density of filler 626x in coarse layer GDL3 621f is lower than that needed in the denser less porous first layer GDL1 621d. By this argument, the filler concentration in MPL 620 should be even higher commensurate to its higher density, which is a disadvantage in having a higher material cost. One advantage of doping the MPL substrate with the scavenger catalyst filler is that the carbon paper can be prefabricated with the catalyst already embedded, thereby eliminated the need to complicate the deposition process by including GDL filler 622f as a solute into the carbon ink material 621c.
[1399] Other non-obvious considerations in the hGDL process involve equilibrating deposition rates to achieve a steady membrane speed during printing especially in continuous print roll-to-roll processes. Since the carbon paper necessarily advances at a steady pace, producing each deposited layer to a specific thickness must account for differences in the formulations of carbon solutions 625a, 625b, and 625c, each with different viscosities and carbon filler sizes. To maintain a constant deposition rate despite varying viscosities, the fluid pressure must be maintained separately for all three nozzles 625a, 625b, and 625c.
[1400] Another variable to be considered is the distance between the print head nozzle and the paper. As more layers are deposited not only does the GDL thickness increase but the gap between the print head and the paper decreases meaning the spot width from spray 626c is smaller than 626a. To maintain a uniform thickness the pressure and flow rate driving the printer head 625c must be greater than head 625b which must be higher than the pressure driving 626a in order to produce similar thickness assuming comparable viscosities. In this manner, carbon growth can be adjusted dynamically producing a pore size increasing from layer GD1 to GDL2 to GDL3. Although the multiple head implementation can produce step changes in porosity the method cannot produce a smooth continuous gradation in pore size.
[1401] In another embodiment, to produce a continuum in pore size made in accordance with this invention requires blending, i.e. mixing 627 different carbon sources and spray them through a common spray nozzle. This sequential blended carbon coating method is shown in
[1402] As depicted in schematic cross section of
[1403] Alternatively the pore size gradation can be more gradual as represented by graded GDL layer 621z shown in
[1404] While the exemplary cross section depicts the GDL attached onto the anode side of the CCM, i.e. where MPL 620 contacts cathode catalyst layer 631a, a second GDL of similar but not necessarily identical construction is attached on the anode side of the GDL contacting anode catalyst layer 631a. Although the same gas diffusion layer material may be used for both cathode and anode, the construction of the films as disclosed may also differ between the anode and cathode to better match the transported charge and electrochemistry of the redox half cell and whether the reaction at the interface involves oxidation or reduction chemistry.
[1405] The resulting gradient in gas concentrations from varying the film pore size improves gas transport by introducing diffusion assisted transport offsetting some of the impact of the micropore interface. A four zone graded GDL structure although not continuous to be vastly superior to the unform of uniform GDL atop the MPL demonstrated thus far. Five zone, six zone, or continuously graded pores are expected to further enhance fuel cell function and durability.
[1406] Pore size can varied by charging the growth conditions and by changing the length of carbon fibers used in the film growth. In one embodiment the micropore layer is composed of fibers 5-to-10 ms in size while the three GDL layers range from 6 mm up to 14 mm. During deposition, the average length can be adjusted by controlling the blend of mix of the carbon fibers in a continuous process. For example 6 mm fibers are transitioned to 10 mm fibers by decreasing the flow rate of the shorter fiber and gradually increasing the longer fiber content to replace shorter elements.
[1407] In one embodiment of this invention, the average porosity of the GDL on the cathode and anode side of the fuel cell need not be the same. For example, in a hydrogen fuel cell the anode involves ionized hydrogen (proton) transport while in the cathode the reducing agent is either pure gaseous oxygen or filtered air comprising a mix of 78% nitrogen and 21% oxygen not including water vapor which is present in both the FC's anode and cathode. Since the oxygen molecule O.sub.2 is larger than hydrogen molecule H.sub.2 and the proton H.sup.+, on one embodiment of this invention the GDL average porosity on the cathode carrying oxygen is fabricated with larger pores than the GDL used on the cathode.
[1408] Another important embodiment of the gas diffusion layer is to manage moisture in the cell during operation by draining away excess water, especially in the cathode. Water management includes process control of GDL porosity, tortuosity, and pore-size distribution (PSD). Made in accordance with the invention, moisture regulation is primarily controlled by hydrophobicity of the MPL layer and its interface to the catalyst layer, balancing the competing processes of membrane drying and water flooding.
[1409] The material properties may be adjusted by infiltrating using carbon nanotubes into the MPL, introducing NH.sub.4Cl ammonium chloride followed by recrystallization and pyrolysis, adding graphite powder or alternatively blending a small concentration of hydrophobic PTFE, e.g. 10% by weight into the carbon matrix. Alternatively graphene oxide may be employed when fabricating gas diffusion layers where the crystallinity of a carbon matrix is used to adjust its tensile strength and electrical conductivity based on the mix of CO and CO covalent bonds formed between the GO and the carbon fiber. Likewise permanent fillers designed to degrade atmospheric toxins such as CO into nonreactive CO.sub.2 may be included in the cathode GDL for a hydrogen fuel cell but are not required on the anode.
[1410] Note that the term gas diffusion layer is borrowed from the lexicography of hydrogen fuel cells where the reactants including the charge source such as ionized protons and the reducing agents such as oxygen are gaseous. In the case of glucose and hydroxide fuel cells however, charge conduction does not involve a gas but a suspension of cations or anions in solution.
[1411] In an exemplary fabrication sequence as described the GDL is formed on a carbon paper substrate then attached to the catalyst layer of the MEA3 core of the fuel cell. The assembly based process for attaching the GDL to the CCM is discussed later in a related application related application titled Advanced Fuel CellDesign, Apparatus, & Fabrication, referenced herein. The specific sequence, whether connecting the CCM to the anode side or cathode side GDL is not critical nor is the exemplary sequence intended to be limiting. Although the same GDL can be used for both anode and cathode sides of the CCM, in general the gases on the cathode side namely O.sub.2 and H.sub.2O are atomically larger than the H.sub.2 gas feeding than anode. As such, in one embodiment the pore sizes of the cathode size GDL are larger than that on the anode.
[1412] In one embodiment of this invention, the GDL attached to the cathode side of the CCM membrane in an MEAS assembly may include additives such as metal oxides, metal functionalized carbon nanotube, boron nitride nanoparticles, bismuth compounds, and polyhedral silsesquioxanes such as POSS and DDSQs, able to disrupt diffusion of atmospheric contaminants such as nitric oxide (NO) from reaching the CCM from ambient air supplies and poisoning the catalyst, the ionomeric groups, or both. In other words, scavengers preventing damage to the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) need not be limited to the catalyst layer itself but may be integrated into the gas diffusion layer, removing toxins before ever reaching the catalyst layer.
[1413] In another embodiment, a direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) comprises a heterogenous gas diffusion layer (hGDL) containing permanent GDL fillers embedded within the carbon matrix to remove contaminants present in the methanol before they can reach or damage the CCM. Methanol contaminants may include sulfur compounds, chlorides, and carbon monoxide (CO) all of which can adsorb on platinum, blocking active sites, and degrading catalyst activity in the anode ACL. Permanent fillers added into the anode GDL for DMFC include ruthenium or osmium additives and other transition metals used to break apart contaminants, cerium oxide (CeO.sub.2) acting as a store of oxygen able to oxidize CO.sub.2 and other compounds, and manganese Oxide (MnO.sub.2) useful in capturing sulfur compounds. These permanent GDL fillers help protect the anode's platinum catalyst in a DMFC by either reacting with the contaminants or by providing alternative pathways for oxidation
[1414] In another embodiment of this invention, the MPL side of the GDL can also be coated with an interfacial layer containing a stoichiometric blend of the atomic composition of the GDL and the catalyst layer. The benefit of coating the CCM facing side, i.e. the MPL of the GDL, with an interfacial deposition is to reduce to interfacial states between the GDL and the CCM and in so doing reducing the contact resistance and improving overall fuel cell efficiency. For example, this interfacial layer between the GDL and CCM may comprising a blend of inert PTFE nanoparticles, palladium metal, titanium dioxides, carbon, carbon fibers, graphene, and scavenger metals such as tungsten, nickel, and other transition metals less sensitive to corrosion.
[1415] In an alternative process the thickness of the catalyst layers formed on the ion exchange membrane can be thinned and a second catalyst layer formed on the underside of the GDL. This process, depicted in
[1416] The catalyst layer can be applied onto the MPL using a decal laminate, attached then annealed to minimize contact resistance. Fabrication of the CCM comprising IEM 635 and catalyst layers 631aa and 631cc can be made using a thinner catalyst layer. If these catalyst layers are sputtered onto IEM 635 all surface states can be eliminated. Beneficially in accordance with this invention, when attaching KECL 618 of the catalyst coated GDL to thin catalyst 631cc, the two materials are similar or identical thereby avoiding all contact resistance between the two elements. In this manner the total interfacial resistance between the hGDL, catalyst layer, and IEM are minimized.
[1417]
[1418] In an alternative embodiment the top of the GDL can be coated with a conductive complex such as copper-carbon (CuC) to improve the electrical contact with the bipolar plate. Referring again to the flow chart if
PEM+ Electrical Characteristics.
[1419] To isolate the impact of a graded hGDL heterogenous gas diffusion layer on PEM electrical performance, various structures were fabricated, combined with various membranes, and characterized.
[1420] As shown, all four improved membranes 581, 582c, 583c and 584 significantly outperformed Nafion film 580 exhibiting reduced polarization losses, lower resistance, and lower voltage droop. As measured a 20 m CRM composite reinforced membrane 584 using an innovative PFSA-PVA-PTFE film combined with the hGDL heterogenous gas diffusion layer outperformed the same membrane using a conventional bilayer GDL 581. Similarly the 20 m porous PEM combined with the hGDL heterogenous gas diffusion layer 583c outperformed the same membrane using a conventional bilayer GDL 582c. In other words, the graded hGDL made in accordance with this invention has been experimentally confirmed to outperform the same CCM using conventional GDLs.
[1421]
[1422] Curves 581 and 584 with data points B2-B5 and D2-D5 illustrate polarization curves for 20-m PFSA CRM membrane contrasting conventional GDLs and heterogeneous hGDL. Curves 582c and 583c with data points C2-C5 and E2-E5 illustrate polarization curves for 20-m porous PEM membrane contrasting conventional GDLs and heterogeneous hGDL. The hGDL data are summarized in the table below describing the measured voltage V.sub.x and V.sub.x-1 at two adjacent points, the power input P.sub.in, power output P.sub.L, and power loss P.sub.loss along with the efficiency .sub.FC, the DC resistance R.sub.FC and the differential resistance r.sub.ss.
TABLE-US-00010 X I.sub.x/A V.sub.x X 1 I.sub.x1/A V.sub.x1 P.sub.in/A R.sub.FC P.sub.L/A P.sub.loss/A r.sub.ss Units Membrane mA/cm.sup.2 V mA/cm.sup.2 V mW/cm.sup.2 cm.sup.2 mW/cm.sup.2 mW/cm.sup.2 % cm.sup.2 20 m D2 50 0.89 OC 0 0.95 48 1.2 45 3 94 1.2 PFSA-PTFE D3 115 0.84 D2 50 0.89 109 1.0 97 13 88 0.8 CRM + hGDL D4 180 0.72 D3 115 0.84 171 1.3 130 41 76 1.8 PEM+ D5 200 0.66 D4 180 0.72 190 1.5 132 58 69 3.0 20 m E2 50 0.94 OC 0 0.95 48 0.2 47 1 99 0.2 Porous E3 115 0.93 E2 50 0.94 109 0.2 107 2 98 0.2 hGDL E4 180 0.80 E3 115 0.93 171 0.8 144 27 84 2.0 PEM+ E5 200 0.74 E4 180 0.80 190 1.1 148 42 78 3.0
[1423] From the tabulated polarization curve data, a direct comparison between the heterogenous GDL and a conventional GDL can be made. For example hGDL point D3 has a voltage V.sub.FC=0.84V with a corresponding efficiency .sub.FC=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC=0.84V/0.94V=89%. By contrast point B3 for a 20-m PFSA CRM membrane described in a previous table, has a voltage V.sub.FC=0.79V with a corresponding efficiency .sub.FC=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC=0.79V/0.94V=84%, five points lower than the hGDL fuel cell.
[1424] Similarly hGDL point E3 has a voltage V.sub.FC=0.93V with a corresponding efficiency .sub.FC=18 V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC=0.93V/0.94V=99% while point C3, the polarization curve for a 20-m PEM CRM membrane at the same current density has a voltage V.sub.FC=0.90V with a corresponding efficiency .sub.FC=V.sub.FC/V.sub.OC=0.90V/0.94V=96%, three points lower than the hGDL fuel cell. The combination of the advanced membrane fabrication technologies together with heterogenous gas diffusion layer for convenience sake are referred to herein as PEM+ membrane.
[1425] In order to extract component resistances,
[1426] From the foregoing measurements, the fabricated 20-m CRM composite reinforced membrane comprising a PFSA-PVA-PTFE ionomer when combined with the graded hGDL heterogenous gas diffusion layer into a MEA5 showed an increase in power output and a reduction in membrane resistance compared to that of the same PEM membrane using a conventional bilayer GDL. Specifically, the conventional GDL MEA5 shown by curve 581p described in a previously reported table exhibited specific DC resistances R.sub.FC ranging from 2.4-to-1.4 cm.sup.2 while the PEM+ version of the same membrane shown by curve 584p exhibited DC R.sub.FC values of 1.5-to-1.0 cm.sup.2. Small signal resistances were non-monotonic, and similar to one another across the ohmic region of operation.
[1427] At every current density, the MEA5 based on the PEM+ membrane outperforms the conventional GDL. Small signal impedances of the CRM based PEM+ were slightly better than the conventional GDL device, in some cases being half the resistance but in other condition conditions being only comparable. The primary difference in these curves occurs at low currents corresponding to differences in activation energy. Small signal resistances in the ohmic region were more comparable.
[1428] Improvements demonstrated by curve 583p for the porous PEM+ membrane curves 585p are more substantial, varying from an extremely low 0.2 cm.sup.2 at low currents to only 1.1 cm.sup.2 at mA/cm.sup.2 current densities. In contrast the porous membrane with a conventional GDL shown by curve 582p exhibits 0.4 cm.sup.2 at lower currents, double the resistance of its PEM+ counterpart, and exhibited 1.3 cm.sup.2 at 200 mA/cm.sup.2 current densities, a 20% higher resistance than PEM+. Small signal impedance were also halved at low currents using the PEM+ MEA5 construction.
[1429] The reduced losses of the PEM+ MEA5 made in accordance with invention translates directly into an increase in delivered power for a specific input power, an increase in fuel cell power efficiency, and a reduction in waste heat generation.
[1430] Power efficiency , the ratio of power output over power input is shown for various MEA5 assemblies in
[1431] In
[1432] In real world applications, at 200 mA/cm.sup.2 a m=120 fuel cell delivers 24A. At this current, the power loss in 120 cm.sup.2 fuel cell depends on the technology employed. For example curve 602a for a 100 m Nafion membrane with a conventional bilayer GDL dissipates 12 W of power as heat, a PEM+ membrane and hGDL assembly shown by curves 602e dissipates only P.sub.loss=(42 mW/cm.sup.2)(120 cm.sup.2)=5 W in total representing a 60% overall reduction in heat generation. All intermediate implementations including those shown by the power dissipation curves 602b, 602d, and 602c are bounded by the two extremes.
[1433] Identical to the graph of
[1434]
MEA7 Assembly.
[1435] After singulation, individual five-layer MEA5s made in accordance with this invention are assembled into a fuel cell stack with intervening tripolar plates to form a seven layer MEA7 790as depicted in
[1436] In one exemplary hGDL, the total thicknesses Y.sub.GDLa and Y.sub.GDLc are each 350 m. The MEA5 assembly is sandwiched between two TPP tripolar plates 891. In one exemplary version the tripolar plates 891 are comprised of graphite or composite materials with a total thickness Y.sub.TPP of 450 m. The resulting thickness Y.sub.MEA7 of the exemplary seven-layer MEA7 assembly is 1.2 mm.
[1437] Implemented using the exemplary MEA7 design
[1438] In addition to reducing height of the fuel cell stack, the thin graphite tripolar plates offer reduced electrical resistance, improved thermal conduction, and unlike steel plates are corrosion resistant. As shown in
[1439] Alternatively the in situ temperature sensor may be used for active cooling in conjunction with dynamic temperature control circuit 879c as shown in
[1440] Power dissipation is a fuel cell depends on the heat generation in the membrane and in the ability of a bipolar or tripolar plate to remove the generated heat. Although many variables must be considered to correlate thermal impedance where =(P.sub.Q/T) to design and operating conditions of a fuel cell the general trend comprises a monotonic inverse, i.e. hyperbolic relationship 900 as depicted in
[1441] In contrast the table below includes reported values of airflow rate, heat generation, and measured peak temperature for higher conductivity materials. According to studies, thermal resistance ranges from 0.9-to-1.3 C./W for airflow rates over 1.4 m/s represented by points 901a and 901b and from 1.6-to-1.8 C./W at lower flow rates shown by points 902, 903a, and 903b. This thermal impedance does not include the benefit of the low stack height of a stack and thin bipolar plates.
[1442] Overlaying the two data sets in
[1443] The two most important design parameters to maximize convective cooling is surface area and airflow. If the surface area of a heat source is too small there is inadequate atoms involved in the heat exchange process whereby cooling will be limited and the resulting thermal resistance will be high. Conversely if the air is still atop a convective surface heat exchange will also be limited. Air removal of heat can occur in two ways, through self convection forming local loops of heat transfer and forced air convection where a fan or blower maintain a continuous supply of cool air to absorb generated heat. Both self convection and forced air cooling require adequate space above the heat dissipating surface for air to flow. If the gap between a heat source and enclosure is too tight air flow will be impeded an excessive heating will result.
TABLE-US-00011 Air Flow (m/s) P.sub.Q Heat (W) P.sub.Q/AF Temp T ( C.) Temp Rise T ( C.) Thermal ( C./W) 2.19 37.7 17 65 40 1.06 1.76 55.7 32 76 51 0.92 1.63 27.6 17 61 36 1.30 1.45 29.1 20 67 42 1.44 0.95 6.3 7 35 10 1.59 0.94 13.7 15 50 25 1.82 Data extracted from Thermal analysis of air-cooled PEM fuel cells, Intl J H.sub.2 Energy Dec 20212.
[1444] Applying the foregoing criteria to a n=8 m=120, i.e. 8s120p fuel cell design means for each cell in the stack P.sub.FC=P.sub.Qmax/n=48 W/8 6 W. Comparing this maximum P.sub.FC power to the power loss to power output curves of
[1445] Similarly curve 603d illustrates the slightly lower performance of a PEM+fuel cell comprising a CRM composite reinforced membrane with a hGDL heterogenous gas diffusion layer is able to deliver 130 mW/cm.sup.2 or 15.6 W per cell without exceeding the air-cooled 6 W thermal dissipation limit per cell, a 13% reduction in power capability compared to the porous PEM+film.
[1446] In dramatic contrast, Nafion PEM curve 603a confirm the 6 W/cell air cooled dissipation limit occurs at a power output of 75 mW/cm.sup.2 or only 9 W/cell, a 50% reduction in air-cooled power delivery capability compared to the porous PEM+ membrane and a 42% reduction in output power compared to a CRM PEM+ membrane.
TABLE-US-00012 Parameter P.sub.out/A P.sub.loss/A mA.sub.FC I.sub.FC P.sub.out P.sub.loss n V.sub.FCmin P.sub.out P.sub.loss Units mW/cm.sup.2 mW/cm.sup.2 cm.sup.2 A W/cell W/cell ns V W/stack W/stack Porous 150 50 120 24 18 6 6 0.58 108 36 PEM+ 8 0.44 144 48 10 0.35 144 48 CRM 130 50 120 24 15.6 6 6 0.58 94 36 PEM+ 8 0.44 125 48 10 0.35 125 48 Nafion 75 50 120 24 9 6 6 0.58 54 36 PEM 8 0.44 72 48 10 0.35 90 48
[1447] Assuming that the fuel cell stack must output a voltage at least 3.5V then for a n=8 stack, the condition can be met for fuel cell voltages V.sub.FC0.44V. According to the aforementioned thermal analysis, power loss is limited to 48 W for the fuel cell stack or 6 W per MEA7 cell. In this way a n=6 stack at the same power density thereby dissipates 36 W. A fuel cell stack where n=10, the power loss should be 60 W for liquid cooled cells. If air cooling is employed, the power remains limited to 48 W or 4.8 W per cell, not 6 W.
[1448] When direct thermal conduction into a temperature regulated backplane is included the thermal resistance is dramatically improved. For example a 120 cm.sup.2 fuel cell comprising a 12-layer stack with a 450-m thick graphite bipolar plate and a total per layer thickness of 1.2 mm has a net thickness of 14.5 mm. The corresponding thermal resistance of a single layer is 0.014 C./W. For a 12-layer stack the thermal impedance increases to .sub.FC=0.17 C./W, a value one-order-of-magnitude lower than air cooling. Assuming a T.sub.FC(max)=85 C. and a backplane temperature T.sub.bp=25 C., with a T.sub.FC=60 C. corresponding to P.sub.FC=T.sub.FC/.sub.FC=(60 C.)/(0.17 C./W)=352 W, a value triple the best case air cooling example.
IEM Membrane Fabrication.
[1449] The previous sections exemplify the formation and operation of homogeneous of PFSA and heterogenous composite reinforced membranes of a PFSA coated film of PTFE. Although these films are representative of ionomers useful in cation conducting fuel cells and electrolysis they are by no means intended to be limiting in beneficial features of the improved ion exchange membranes (IEMs) made in accordance with this invention.
[1450] In general, all ion exchange membranes suffer an intrinsic tradeoff between structural rigidity and electrical conductivity. The more conductive a film is, the weaker the mechanical support of the membrane becomes. Film conductivity may be improved by (i) thinning the membrane thickness, (ii) increasing the density of pendants to increase the molar concentration of ionomers in the matrix, (iii) increasing the hydrophilicity of the material to enhance water-carrier transport, and/or (iv) increasing the porosity of the membrane. In every case described, the mechanical strength of the film is compromised by replacing stronger hydrophobic backbone polymeric chains with weaker electrically active pendants.
[1451] The resulting weaker polymeric matrix adversely impacts the process of membrane fabrication and complicates the handling of films in the assembly of fuel cells or electrolysis units in order to avoid damaging the membrane. A thinner or weaker membrane also adversely impacts film durability, environmental resilience to temperature and humidity cycling, and operational longevity, i.e. membrane reliability. In particular, weaker film are more easily damaged during humidity cycling, power cycling, or a combination thereof.
[1452] In humidity cycling the IEM is subjected to operation during alternating cycles of low humidity, i.e. arid conditions, and high humidity. During humidity cycling water retention causes a mechanically unsupported film to swell like a sponge. During drying out periods, the film contracts causing stress on the hydrophobic backbone of the film. After numerous cycles, cracks appear in the molecular fabric of the film leading to membrane failure and leakages of gas and charges through the damage zones. Eventually the film fails altogether.
[1453] In power cycling, the IEM is operated in repeated cycles conducting high current density and low current density. At high power conditions, generated heat causes expansion of the center portions of a fuel cell stack aggravated by excess water produced in regions of high current density. Differential temperature coefficients of expansion among the various elements within a fuel cell, e.g. the CCM, GDL, bipolar and tripolar plates, and fuel cell stack end caps, result in film stresses on the membrane. Such cyclic operation can cause stress fractures in the polymer leading to immediate or latent failures. The combination of the humidity cycling and power cycling further exacerbates the problem by repeatedly subjecting the film to simultaneous high current densities at high humidity levels followed by cycles of cold arid conditions. The only means to overcome these intrinsic deficiencies of an ion exchange membrane is by improving the strength and durability of the film by reengineering its design.
[1454] Although the film and its mechanical elasticity properties are specific to the chemistry of the ion exchange membrane several key inventive features of an improved IEM made in accordance with this invention apply to all film compositions. These embodiments comprise the following: [1455] A structural endoskeleton made in accordance with this invention forming a grid-like network throughout the membrane laterally providing mechanical support to the more fragile or thinner electrically-active ionomer film, and limiting swelling and shrinkage of the membrane from humidity cycling or during operation thereby improving film stability, reliability and cycle life. [1456] A mechanism to control the microporosity of the IEM without fundamentally changing the chemistry of the resulting matrix. Made in accordance with this invention, the method may include temporarily introducing a soluble filler such as sugar during film polymerization and then removing the sacrificial filler with a solvent such as water after the film polymer is formed or cured. As such, sacrificial fillers comprising a large molecule present during membrane formation and subsequently removed increase film porosity by reducing the density and crystallinity of the membrane as made. Increased porosity enhances charge transport and ionomer conductivity. Conversely, permanent fillers are molecules introduced during casting or subsequent to molding that remain in place after fabrication. Unlike sacrificial fillers which are exclusively intended to increase film porosity by creating more channels within the matrix, permanent fillers can either increase or decrease membrane porosity. Specifically, permanent fillers that disrupt the periodicity, regularity, and crystallinity of a polymer during molding cause defective regions of amorphous material to be formed. These low-density amorphous defect regions exhibit higher permeability than their higher-density crystalline counterparts, and therefore enhance proton transport and conductance. Examples include the introduction of porous silica, alumina, silicates, graphene oxides, perfluoro-dimethyldioxole (PDD); or poly(perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane) (PFMMD) into the monomer blend prior to casting. Alternatively, post mold processing of a membrane by the selective application of coatings or molecular glues like PVA clog pores present after molding, reducing the channels into the membrane electrolyte. In so doing the permanent filler reduces film porosity, beneficially limiting oxygen back diffusion and fuel crossover, especially important to prevent methanol diffusion in a DMFC. [1457] Molecular glue comprising alcohols or solvents such as PVA where in heterogenous films the glue functions as an chemical intermediary between molecules incompatible for direct bonding. Made in accordance with this invention, examples include solvents able to bond hydrophobic and hydrophilic materials together either between dissimilar elements within a CMR composite reinforced membrane such as a PFSA-PTFE film or at the interface between the ionomer film and the IEM's endoskeleton. [1458] Nanocoating covering the ionomeric membrane forming an interfacial layer between the membrane and the catalyst layer. Made in accordance with this invention a nanocoating may reduce the influence of dangling bonds and interfacial charge states on film conduction, enhance catalytic activity, control CCM porosity and gas transport while minimizing oxygen back diffusion and fuel crossover. The coating can also mitigate the adverse impact of atmospheric contaminants such as carbon monoxide by gettering airborne gasses and particulates which otherwise may disable or poison CCM catalysts. The nanocoating may comprise chemical components present in the catalyst layer and in lower concentrations, chemical constituents of the ion exchange membrane. Alternatively the catalyst and nanocoating can be merged into a single heterogenous layer. [1459] Fillers & Dopants Aside from sacrificial and permanent fillers described above; fillers and dopants made in accordance with this invention comprise carbon fillers such as functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and graphene oxides (GO); oxide fillers such as silica and metal oxides; polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes fillers such as POSS and DDSQ; nanostructures comprising nanoparticles, nanoclusters, and nanofibers; fillers of metal oxide frameworks (MOFs) comprising ionomers, catalyst and scavenger metals and guests; along with solid acids and proton ionic liquids (PIL).
[1460] In the context of fuel cells, the last bulleted item Fillers and Dopants' describes processes that change the function of an ionomeric polymers. In chemistry, the term filler as defined by Wikipedia particles added to resin or binders (plastics, composites, concrete) that can improve specific properties, make the product cheaper, or a mixture of both. The two largest segments for filler material use is elastomers and plastics. Similarly, Wikipedia defines dopant as a small amount of a substance added to a material to alter its physical properties, such as electrical or optical properties. A variety of permanent fillers are described here below:
Carbon Fillers.
[1461] Examples of functionalized carbon include carbon nanotubes (CNTs) coated with sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H), carboxyl groups (COOH), hydroxy-phosphorus (POH), amino groups (NH.sub.2), silica (SiO.sub.2), and titania (TiO.sub.2). Examples of functionalized graphene oxides (GO) include polybenzimidazole grafted graphene oxide (ABPBI-GO), sulfonated polysulfone functionalized polymer graphene oxide (FPGO-sPSf, FPGO-sPSU), and perfluoropolyether grafted graphene oxide (PFPE-GO).
Oxide Fillers.
[1462] Oxide fillers comprise inorganic and metallic oxides and complexes thereof. Examples of silica and silicates include silica (SiO.sub.2), alumina-silica zeolite ((Al.sub.2O.sub.3).sub.x.Math.(SiO.sub.2).sub.y) and mordenite, sulfonated zeolite, nesosilicates ((SiO.sub.4).sup.4), silica mesostructured cellular foam (silica MCF), phosphorylated hollow mesoporous silica (HMS-PA), sulfonated hollow mesoporous silica (MCF-SA), or amino or sulfonated hollow mesoporous silica bonded onto a sulfonated polyether ether sulfone polymer (sPEES-MCF-NH.sub.2, sPEES-MCF-SA).
[1463] Examples of metal oxides and inorganic metal frameworks include bismuth molybdate (Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6), Al-grafted mesoporous silica (MCF-ionomer), poly(m-phenylene-bibenzimidazole) doped mesoporous silica cellular foam (mPBI-MCF), zirconium-dopamine composites and intercalant zirconium with OH, O and X termini. Other inorganic metal oxide include clusters of phosphotungstic acid treated silica (PWA-SiO.sub.2).
Oligomeric Silsesquioxanes Fillers.
[1464] Examples of functionalized polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS) include thiol coated POSS-SH, phosphoric POSS-S-PA, polyethylene glycol POSS-PEG, isobutyl POSS-iBu, vinyl POSS-Vi, chlorobutane POSS-8Cl, octakis(dimethylsilyloxy) Ot-POSS, octavinyl OV-POSS, octaphenyl OP-POSS, isobutyl-vinyl POSS-iBu-Vi, isobutyl-butylamine POSS-iBu-NH.sub.2, isobutyl-CI POSS-iBu-CI, isobutyl-hydroxide POSS-iBu-3OH, isobutyl-styryl POSS-iBu-styryl, isobutyl-polystyrene POSS-iBu-PS and for generic radicals R the styryl and polystyrene forms POSS-R-styryl and POSS-RPS.
[1465] Other functionalized versions include cyclopentyl-polystyrene POSS-Cp-PS, cyclohexyl-polystyrene POSS-Cy-PS, aminopropylisobutyl POSS-AmNH.sub.2, mercaptopropyl-isobutyl POSS-SH, and mono-(acryloisobutyl) POSS-A. Structural variants of oligomeric silsesquioxanes include double-decker topographies DDSQ functionalized in non-methylated and methylated forms NMe DDSQ and Me DDSQ, with optional functional groups including vinyl, methylpropyl, methyltrichlorosilane, dichloromethylvinylsilane, stereo vinyl, allyloxytrimethylsilane, propyl glycidyl ether, bromostyrene, and acetoxystyrene.
Nanostructure Fillers.
[1466] Examples of nanostructure fillers include nanoparticles, nanospheres, nanoclusters, and nanofibers. Nanostructures include sulfonated poly(methyl methacrylate) nanospheres (sPMMA NS) and porous nanospheres, poly methyl methacrylate sulfonated zinc nanoclusters (PMMA ZnS NCs). Nanosphere functionalized carbon nanotubes combine the structural stability of single and multi-walled CNTs with the catalytic and ionomeric activity of functionalized nanospheres. Example include platinum-amino and titanium-amino functionalized nanoparticle coated carbon nanotubes PtNH.sub.2 NP-CNT and TiNH.sub.2 NP-CNT as well as phosphorated titania carbon nanotubes PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 CNTs.
[1467] Made in accordance with this invention, nanofibers produced by electrospinning followed by crushing to control fiber length and porosity include poly sulfonated polystyrene nanofibers (sPS). Silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) may also be attached to a titanium-dopamine matrix using a sol-gel process. Other nanostructures include zirconium nanosphere Zr NS, also based on a polydopamine scaffold, and MoW nanoparticles derived from phosphotungstic acid. Alumina-silica zeolite ((Al.sub.2O.sub.3).sub.x.Math.(SiO.sub.2).sub.y) nanoparticles may be loaded with metal catalysts. Another class of nanostructure filler as described comprises platinum titanium dioxide nanoparticles (Pt-TiO.sub.2 NPs).
Metal Organic Frameworks (MOFs).
[1468] Examples of metal organic frameworks (MOFs) include convex, cluster, concave, rectangular array, trapezoidal, reflected trapezoidal, hexagonal drum, and octahedral drum geometries with functional sidechains and guest molecules. Other less periodic geometries include zinc-oxide hexaphosphate ester-based metal-organic frameworks and related chemistries. Metals may include elemental atomic titanium, platinum and palladium or metal complexes of zirconium(IV) chloride, zinc acetate, sulfonic ferrous or chromium terephthalate metal clusters. Made in accordance with the invention scavenger metals including lower-cost iron, cobalt and nickel provide catalyst protection from toxins such as NO may be substituted for catalyst metals on the MOF frame, attached to the organic ligands, or bound to a guest molecule.
[1469] Heterogenous metal organic bonds between catalyst and scavenger metal requires inventive organic ligands not used in conventional MOFs. They include dithiolene, ethanedithiol, pyridoxal-thiosemicarbazone, bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane, Schiff base, imidazophenanthroline carboxylate, ethylenediamine, salicylaldehyde, succinate, bidentate phosphine, and bipyridine. A organic alternative to MOF fillers includes triazole grafts onto the polymer's mainchain such as poly(oxy-diphenylether-bibenzimidazole) (OPBI-TG). A special category of metal frameworkzeolitic imidazolate frameworks aka ZIFs comprises tetrahedrally coordinated transition metal ions such as Zn, Co, or Cu bridged by imidazole or imidazolate type linkers (Im).
Solid Acid Fillers & PILs.
[1470] Examples of solid acids include the organic acids such as carboxylic acids (e.g. trimesic acid), oxalic acid, tartaric acid, citric acid, ascorbic acid, and maleic acid and the inorganic sulphamic acid. Being crystalline at room temperature, the acids do not leak nor rearrange the membrane matrix during power cycling. For example bismuth trimesic acid (BiTMA) can be incorporated into a membrane to enhance conductivity without compromising film durability.
[1471] Alternatively polymers can be doped with ionic liquids as a dopant. An ionic liquid is a salt in its liquid state at ambient conditions. General agreement defines an ionic liquid as a salt with a melting point below 100 C. at normal pressures. Unlike most liquids such as water, alcohols, and fossil fuels that are electrically neutral covalently bonded molecules even in their liquid state, ionic liquids are primary made of ions and therefore more chemically reactive and electrically conductive than their covalent counterparts. Ionic liquids (ILs), aka liquid electrolytes or ionic fluids, alter the conductivity of ionomeric membranes.
[1472] ILs come in two formscation ionic liquids and anion ionic liquids. Cation ionic liquids or CILs are derived from salts comprising methylimidazole, imidazolium, pyridine, and quaternary ammonia. Anion ion liquids or AILs are derived from tetrafluoroborate, hexafluorophosphate, bis-trifluoromethanesulfonimide, trifluoromethanesulfonate, dicyanamide, hydrogen sulphate, ethyl sulphate, and butyl-methylimidazolium tetrachloroferrate. A special form of ionic liquid is a protic ion liquid (PIL) comprising a mix of acid and base capable of reversible reaction involving proton (H.sup.+) exchange. In conjugate acid-base reactions, when an acid donates a proton it leaves behind a less positively charged conjugate base. As a coupled reaction, when the base receives the proton becomes a more positively charged conjugate acid. This acid-base reaction differs from simple redox reactions where ionization involves only the transfer of electrons.
[1473] PILs adaptable for use ionomeric polymers and fuel cells include alkyl imidazolium bis-(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ILs. Similarly, polymer ionic liquids aka poly-ILs comprise polymerizable functional groups such as vinyl or allyl groups with repeated monomeric units connected via a polymeric backbone. In operation ILs can enhance the efficiency of the oxidation reduction reaction (ORR) in the cathode of a PEM hydrogen fuel cell increasing conductance and reducing catalyst aging.
IEM Summary.
[1474] Made in accordance with this invention, an ion exchange membrane incorporating fillers and dopants including any of the above enumerated inventive features of carbon fillers, oxide fillers, POS fillers, nanostructure fillers, MOF fillers, and solid acid fillers and PIL dopants; or combinations thereof enable a myriad of potential performance improvements in ionomeric polymers. These innovations can be used separately or in combination. Because the chemical processes used to fabricate two different polymers are often times mutually incompatible or unable to form chemical bonds, the inventive combinations discussed herein are not obvious.
[1475] Aside from the described membrane chemistry, other processes and apparatus made in accordance with the invention to produce a fuel cell's seven-layer membrane electrode assembly (MEA7) include fabrication of an endoskeleton, control of IEM microporosity, and polymer bonding as described in the subsequent sections.
Endoskeleton.
[1476] By providing a endoskeletal grid surrounding panes of ionomer the ionomer cannot swelling laterally within the plane of the film. Furthermore, because the membrane remains compressed from iso-planar pressure of the endoskeleton, then vertical displacement from membrane swelling is also constrained. If the molecular matrix cannot swell, then there is simply no excess compartments in which water can agglomerate during operation. In this manner the endoskeleton provides mechanical regulation of water content within the film independent of the membrane's polymer chemistry. Various methods to reproducibly form endoskeletal support comprising a grid-like structure. The endoskeleton is further reinforced by a wider exoskeletal grid subdividing the matrix into separate discrete IEMs. The entire matrix is circumscribed by a thicker wider pillar, a matrix frame, to improve mechanical durability.
IEM Microporosity.
[1477] Given that that membrane structure is supported mechanically by the endoskeleton during operation, then ionomer charge hopping and IEM conductivity can be regulated by controlling microporosity of the membrane. Micropores comprise the natural crevasses present within a polymeric matrix where water and ions, either protons or hydroxyl ions may pass. In pure polymerization of a homogenous ion exchange membrane, only the unreacted monomers are loaded into a mold or casting unit whereby the film molecular density is determined by chemical bonding of specific length chains of the backbone and the sidechains. By contrast by introducing a sacrificial filler into the mold, the polymeric density is lowered by presence of the filler occupying intermediate locations within the matrix during polymerization.
[1478] Features of the intercalated sacrificial filler are exemplified in
[1479] In this schematic representation, atomic bonds to other atomic species such as fluorine in polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or polyfluorinated sulfonic acid (PFSA) or chlorine in polychlorotrifluoroethylene (PCTFE) are removed for the sake of clarity. Like panes in a stain glass window, the windows formed between the carbon backbones 800c function as pores in the membrane.
[1480] That said, this simplified rendering overstates the size of intra-matrix pores 801c. Instead in the center graphic (b) the carbon backbone 800e has been expanded to represent the real electrostatic surface of the carbon and its associated fluorine or chlorine adjuncts. The effective membrane pore size 801e in a charge constrained model of the matrix is significantly reduced. In order to increase the film porosity and pore size, an intercalating sacrificial filler like sucrose, glucose, fructose, or chitosan is included as a powder mixed with the carbon monomer prior to molding. During polymerization domains occupied by the filler leave large gaps 802 in the matrix where carbon bonding is absent. In this manner film porosity is increased improving membrane electrical conductivity.
[1481] In accordance with various embodiments of this invention, the filler must be removed by using a solvent or chemical solution that does not damage or disturb the polymer network. In general, solvent solutions comprising polar molecules dissolve solids comprised of polar molecules or salts. Conversely solvent solutions comprising non-polar molecules dissolve solids comprised of non-polar molecules. Since the polymeric backbone of the membrane comprises a non-polar molecular structure in order to include a sacrificial filler during polymerization and then subsequently remove it the filler should comprise polar molecules. By using polar sacrificial filler molecules within the non-polar membrane, the filler can be subsequently removed without damaging the polymer. For example, water can remove sugar as a filler without adversely affecting the polymeric membrane.
[1482] Alternatively, a sacrificial filler made in accordance with this invention may comprise an inorganic salt, an ester, or many other polar molecules in their solid form at room temperature. Polar molecular solids comprise geometries where one region has a net positive charge while the other portion has a negative charge, together forming an electrical dipole moment spanning an small intramolecular distance. When the electronegativity of two or more atoms in a molecule differ by more than 0.8, the more electronegative atom spatially redistributes the molecular electron cloud closer to its nucleus. This spatial redistribution creates a dipolar moment making the molecule appear charged even though the next charge state of the molecule is zero, i.e. it is not ionized. In extreme cases on imbalance the polar molecule is considered ionic. Examples of polar molecules useful as candidates for sacrificial fillers in ion exchange membranes include by example without limitation: [1483] Sugar, e.g. sucrose (C.sub.12H.sub.22O.sub.11), glucose (C.sub.6H.sub.12O.sub.6) or fructose (C.sub.6H.sub.12O.sub.6). [1484] Various inorganic salts such as sodium chloride (NaCl), potassium chloride (KCl), magnesium chloride (MgCl.sub.2), calcium chloride (CaCl.sub.2), and potassium iodide (KI). [1485] Molecular salts including ammonium chloride (NH.sub.4Cl), sodium carbonate (Na.sub.2CO.sub.3), potassium nitrate (KNO.sub.3), sodium sulfate (Na.sub.2SO.sub.4), copper(II) sulfate (CuSO.sub.4), and sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO.sub.3). [1486] Salts of organic acids including acetic acid (ethanoic acid) derived acetate salts such as sodium acetate (CH.sub.3COONa); citric acid derived citrate salts like sodium citrate (Na.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7) and potassium citrate (K.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7); lactic acid derived lactate salts such as sodium lactate (C.sub.3H.sub.5O.sub.3Na) and calcium lactate (C.sub.6H.sub.10CaO.sub.6); tartaric acid derived tartrate salts such as potassium sodium tartrate (KNaC.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6), aka Rochelle salt; malic acid derived malate salts, including sodium malate (C.sub.4H.sub.5NaO.sub.5) and magnesium malate (C.sub.4H.sub.4MgO.sub.5); oxalic acid derived oxalate salts like sodium oxalate (Na.sub.2C.sub.2O.sub.4) and calcium oxalate (CaC.sub.2O.sub.4); benzoic acid derived benzoate salts such as sodium benzoate (C.sub.7H.sub.5NaO.sub.2); succinic acid derived succinate salts including sodium succinate (C.sub.4H.sub.4Na.sub.2O.sub.4) and magnesium succinate (C.sub.4H.sub.4MgO.sub.4); fumaric acid derived fumarate salts like potassium fumarate (C.sub.4H.sub.2KO.sub.4); phthalic acid derived phthalate salts including diethyl phthalate (C.sub.12H.sub.14O.sub.4) and dibutyl phthalate (C.sub.16H.sub.22O.sub.4), ascorbic acid (vitamin C) derived ascorbate salts such as sodium ascorbate (C.sub.6H.sub.7NaO.sub.6) and calcium ascorbate (C.sub.12H.sub.14CaO.sub.12); and sorbic acid derived sorbate salts like potassium sorbate (C.sub.6H.sub.7KO.sub.2).
[1487] Aside from imbalances in atomic electronegatively, geometric shape plays an important role in determining if a molecule behaves as polar or non-polar in chemical reactions. In broad terms, pyramid-shaped and V-shaped molecules are generally considered to be polar whereas linear molecules are more non-polar in their behavior. The combination of electronegatively and geometry determine which solvents are best used to remove the sacrificial filler post-polymerization. While a list of every possible combination of filler and solvent is too expansive to include herein, it is generally known to those skilled in the art of chemistry which solvents dissolve various solutes.
[1488] Pragmatically, polar solvents are therefore best in dissolving polar molecules used as sold fillers during membrane formation. Mechanistically polar solvents exhibiting high dielectric constants can stabilize the positive and negative charges of solute molecules through dipole-dipole interactions and hydrogen bonding. Preferred polar-molecule solvents to dissolve polar fillers without damaging the membrane include the following: [1489] Deionized water (H.sub.2O). Often considered the universal solvent, water dissolves many polar substances due to its strong polarity and ability to form hydrogen bonds, but does not harm or degrade most polymers. [1490] Methanol (CH.sub.3OH). A polar solvent able to dissolve a wide range of polar compounds, methanol is soluble in water making it easy to rinse remaining solvent away after treatment. [1491] Ethanol (C.sub.2H.sub.5OH). Similar to methanol, ethanol is a common solvent able to dissolve many polar substances but with reduced toxic compared to methanol. Ethanol is soluble in water making it easy to rinse remaining solvent away after treatment. [1492] Acetic acid (CH.sub.3COOH). Due to the presence of a carbonyl group (CO) and a hydroxyl group (OH) within the molecule, acetic acid easily forms hydrogen bonds with other molecules, enabling it to dissolve a wide range of polar and non-polar compounds without damaging polymers [1493] Acetone (CH.sub.3COCH.sub.3, ace). A solvent with a medium polarity miscible with water, acetone is also good for dissolving many polar organic compounds. [1494] Ammonia (NH.sub.3). A polar solvent whose polarization arises from its trigonal pyramidal shape, with nitrogen (N) at the apex and three hydrogen (H) atoms at the corners of the base causing a region of partial negative charge near the nitrogen atom contrasting the more positive hydrogen atoms. Ammonia can dissolve many ionic compounds as well as other polar substances. [1495] Dimethyl sulfoxide (CH.sub.3).sub.2SO). Also known as DMSO, a solvent known for its ability to penetrate thin membranes including human skin. Care must taken in manufacturing to avoid inadvertent poisoning of machine operators by toxic substances transported by DMSO into the skin.
[1496] Other polar solvents include substances such as dimethylformamide or DMF (CH.sub.3).sub.2NC(O)H); N,N-dimethylacetamide or DMAc (CH.sub.3CON(CH.sub.3).sub.2); ethylene glycol (HOCH.sub.2CH.sub.2OH); propylene glycol (CH.sub.3CHOHCH.sub.2OH); tetrahydrofuran or THF (C.sub.4H.sub.8O), dioxane (C.sub.4H.sub.8O.sub.2); formamide (HCONH.sub.2); glycerol (C.sub.3H.sub.8O.sub.3); and pyridine (C.sub.5H.sub.5N). Another solvent, acetonitrile although versatile in dissolving a range of polar molecules is ill advised as is extremely dangerous causing severe health effects and/or death. Boric acid (H.sub.3BO.sub.3) dissolved in water may also act as a polar solvent even through it is not a polar solvent on its own. Alternatively bleach comprises a solution of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) in water. In a similar manner to boric acid, bleach itself is not a polar solvent on its own but inherits the ability to dissolve polar molecules from the polarized property of water. Care must be taken to completely wash all chlorine from a membrane before forming a catalyst layer as bleach is highly corrosive and oxidative substance and is therefore not recommended in CCM fabrication.
[1497] In another embodiment, temperature is used to eliminate the filler from a polymerized film. In such a case the filler may comprise a molecule with a melting point T.sub.m only slightly above the temperature of formation T.sub.f needed for monomer cross-linking but below the maximum allowable temperature T.sub.max to avoid damage to the polymeric matrix, or algebraically where T.sub.f<T.sub.m<T.sub.max. In this process, the solid filler is mixed with the membrane monomer, followed by polymerization at temperature T.sub.f. Thereafter the film is heated to the melting temperature of the filler Tm but below the maximum safe temperature T.sub.max of the polymeric matrix. During this step the filler melts into fluid and drains from the film. Alternatively the removal of the melted filler can be accelerated by using a heated solvent such as water or alcohol to help wash the dissolved filler from the membrane cavities.
[1498] Another method to use temperature as a control parameter for microporosity involves cold polymerization. In cold polymerization the temperature of the molding process is reduced with a corresponding increase in the mold pressure. The increased pressure enables polymerization of the ionomer at a lower temperature than at normal hot molding processes. By performing molding at a lower temperature the number of candidates for sacrificial fillers expands to include molecules with lower melting temperatures. Using cold polymerization, sacrificial fillers that might otherwise melt during hot molding can be employed. In such case a low melting temperature filler is mixed with the monomer and molded at high pressure with minimal heating. The polymerized film is then heater slightly at atmospheric pressure to melt the filler. During this step the filler melts into fluid and drains from the film. Alternatively the removal of the melted filler can be accelerated by using a warm but not hot solvent such as water or alcohol to help wash the dissolved filler from the membrane cavities.
[1499] As a completely different approach to controlling microporosity, the sacrificial filler may comprise an non-polar organic compound highly differentiated from the membrane polymer where the solvent used to remove the filler does not attack the membrane's polymeric matrix. Yet another approach employs using a powder comprising a low cost metal such as zinc or magnesium incorporated into the monomer powder. After polymerization the metallic sacrificial filler may be removed by a mild solution of hydrochloric acid.
[1500] Although the chemistry differs by the polymer used to form the membrane, the sacrificial filler used to form the micropores in the film, and the solvent used to remove the filler, the combination of chemicals used to form a microporous IEM in accordance with this invention requires the following criteria be met. [1501] The solvent used to remove the filler must not damage the polymeric backbone of the membrane [1502] The solvent used must not damage or degrade the electrically active charge group on the ionomer's pendant. [1503] The solvent should not leave corrosive residues in the membrane.
Polymer Bonding.
[1504] Another embodiment of this invention involves the use of molecular glue in fabricating the membrane. Molecular glue has two uses in the described processeseither to help adhere a hydrophilic ionomer to a hydrophobic backbone when fabricating a heterogenous composite reinforced membrane (CRM), to improve bonding between a homogenous hydrophilic ionomer and a hydrophobic endoskeleton, or to assist in cross linking of hybrid copolymers and block copolymers. In this manner the skeletal framework of a membrane may comprise entirely different plastics or composite materials than those used to form the thin ionomeric regions.
[1505] In the previous examples described herein, PVA treatment of PTFE was used to form a bridge between the hydrophobic PTFE and a hydrophilic ionomer such as PFSA. The same method can be applied to adhere a homogenous PFSA film to a PTFE pillar forming an endoskeleton. In this manner a molecular glue functions as if to cleave or clear certain areas of ionic charge causing localized hydrophobicity, replacing it with a bonding site for attaching sidechains, a process referred to as chemical grafting. In such an instance the sidechain functions as a buffer to physically separate the hydrophilic ionomer from the hydrophobic backbone. In reality, grafting PTFE to perform molecular gluing is a complex process and not simply an atomic substitution in the mainchain. This struggle to glue material onto a preformed film of PTFE is the consequence of its complete covalent bonds, a reason for it be criticized as an indestructible forever chemical dangerous to the environment.
[1506] In conclusion, very few solvents can degrade PTFE. According to the CP Lab Safety website it is because polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) is very non-reactive that renders it ideal for use with most chemicals. The only listed substances that degrade PTFE to any degree include chlorobenzene (mono); diethylamine; fluorine; gallic acid; gold monocyanide; lead sulfamate; mercuric cyanide; naphtha; as well as fuel oils, gasoline, and petroleum. Theoretically these agents could be used to treat PTFE to create graft points but care would be required not to degrade film stability.
[1507] An alternative mechanism to create graft points on a non-reactive hydrophobic backbone like PTFE can be achieved by treating the surface by a plasma or alternatively by sputter etching. Plasma etching is the process where a RF field is used to stimulate a gas to create a sea of chemically reactive ions which subsequently attack the target etch surface. Variables include the gas species used to create the plasma etchant ions, control of the chamber vacuum, pressure, and temperature, as well as the RF source power and oscillation frequency.
[1508]
[1509] Bonding force, expressed as force in the cgs system as dynes is a measure of the attractive force a molecule, in this case the mainchain, exerts on ions to form chemical bonds, i.e. its ability to perform chemical bonding. The higher the molecular binding force the more chemically active material is. As a unit of measure one dyne equals 10.sup.5 kg m/s.sup.2 or a hundred thousandth of a newton, i.e. 10.sup.5 N, which also sometimes is expressed as a hundredth of a milli-newton or 0.01 mN. When a film has complete covalent bonding with no dangling bonds the surface energy is low meaning it is difficult to form bonds. Untreated, PTFE typically has a surface energy less than 28 dynes or 0.28 mN. A plasma treatment for only 5 minutes increases the surface energy of PTFE to 105 dynes, far above the minimum surface reactivity of 60 dynes generally required for adhesive bonding.
[1510] Another way to characterize the reactivity of a film is in terms of surface tension or surface energy, measured in milli-newtons per centimeter or dynes per centimeter where 1 dyne/cm=0.01 mN/cm. Although they have identical units surface energy is the equivalent attractive force present between the molecules at the surface of a solid substance while surface tension is the force required to produce a displacement of molecules at a specified distance. The poor wettability of PTFE refers to the ability to bond to PTFE after dry etching either by plasma etching PE or a related method referred to as reactive ion etching (RIE). As purported, dry etching profoundly impacts surface energy and surface tension as well as affecting available molecular contact anglesthe angle relative to the surface where molecular grafts may occur.
[1511] Specifically pristine PTFE exhibits a surface energy of 16 dyne/cm while plasma and RIE treated surfaces are improved by one-to-two orders-of magnitude to 0.76 dynes/cm and 0.2 dynes/cm respectively. The weaker surface bonding energy results in increased surface tension for the etched materials, enhancing wetting from 46 dyne/cm for pristine PTFE to 68 dyne/cm for PE treated films and to 74 dyne/cm for RIE processed PTFE.
[1512] Exemplary plasma process conditions ranged from RF power from 125 W-to-175 W, exposure times from 450 s-to-750 s and total gas flow rates from 60-to-100 sccm. The term sccm is an acronym for standard cubic centimeter per minute. The reactant gasses employed comprised oxygen and argon with oxygen comprising between 50% to 80% of the mix. Other papers have reported etching of superhydrophobic surfaces such as PTFE and various plastics using other reactant gasses such as CHF.sub.3 and SH.sub.6.
[1513] Alternatively sputter etching, using a non-chemically reactive method of momentum transfer may be used to activate the PTFE surface for bonding. Mechanistically, plasma etching strips fluorine from the polymer exposing carbon atoms in the backbone to facilitate grafting. Unlike wet chemistry etching involving sodium ammonia or sodium naphthalene, plasma etching does not generate wet stream or liquid waste.
[1514] So plasma etching aside, if wet chemical etching is not effective in removing fluorine from a PTFE coated surface how then how can PTFE-PVA-PFSA composite reinforced membranes (CRMs) be fabricated? This somewhat unexpected mechanism shown in
[1515] After curing sown in the right most illustration labelled (c) the nanoparticles bond with themselves forming interstitial molecules 817b within the PTFE film covalently bonded via PVA 812 to a self organizing sidechain 823 connecting to an ionomer 815 such as PFSA. Once cured the interstitial nanoparticle molecule 817b provides mechanical locking of the entangled portion of the molecule within the PFSA structure without actually grafting itself onto the mainchain. This nanoparticle interlock facilitates mechanical and electrostatic attachment between the PVA-PTFE film below the PTFE surface and the PVA cross linkage to sidechains attached to its PFSA ionomeric terminus in the pendant. In this manner the ionomer adheres to the membrane mechanically and electrostatically without restricting the mainchain or necessarily forming new covalent bonds to the carbon backbone.
[1516] Process sequences may for example comprise starting with a PTFE membrane or skeleton spraying it with PVA, washing the film with ethanol, then stimulating cross linking to the polytetrafluoroethylene surface using glutaraldehyde. Alternatively PVA may be cross linked to poly(acrylic acid-co-2-acrylamido-2-methyl propane sulfonic acid), chemically as (P(AA-AMPS)), to enhance stability. Other composite membranes involve bonding using PVA with inorganic zirconium phosphate to form a highly stable composite membrane of PTFE-ZrP-PVA.
[1517] Still another category of nanoparticle surface modification involve polyoxyethylene (POE). In this process PVA and POE polymers are blended to form nanofibers using a process of electrospinning or electrospraying, fiber and film fabrication methods involving the simultaneous application of electric fields in the film or fiber formation process. In electrospraying employs a high voltage to disperse a liquid or for the fine aerosol through a small aperture liquid jet. Varicose waves on the surface of the jet lead form small and highly charged liquid droplets radially dispersed by Coulombic repulsive forces to form the fiber or film.
[1518] In a similar manner fiber production using electrospinning employ electric force to draw charged threads of polymer solutions or polymer melts into fiber several hundred nanometers in length. The fiber formation does not require chemical cross linking or high temperatures as the energy in imparted into bonding process electrostatically. In the example described, PTFE emulsion is blended with a carrier polymer solution such as polyethylene oxide (PEO) and poly(vinyl alcohol), i.e. PVA. Subsequent to electrospraying or electrospinning, sintering in nitrogen is performed, e.g. at 390 C. to fuse the PTFE into fibers or films while eliminating the carrier polymer. By controlling the blend, surface texture and surface energy of the film as formed can be adjusted from smooth to more porous membranes having rough surfaces supporting grafting and pendant attachment.
[1519] It should be mentioned that both polyoxyethylene (POE) and polyethylene oxide (PEO) refer to polymers of ethylene oxide. Somewhat confusingly however the terms are used in different contexts as distinguished by their molecular weight. In particular used in applications as thickening agents, the highly viscous polyethylene oxide (PEO) typically refers to the polymer with high molecular weight, while lower molecular weight polyoxyethylene (POE) is commonly used as a surfactant or emulsifier. Despite these differences, both PEO and POE consist of the same repeating unit, which is the ethylene oxide monomer (CH.sub.2CH.sub.2O).
[1520] In another fabrication method, a PTFE membrane is formed using polytetrafluoroethylene treated by a solution of chitosan (CS) crosslinked with poly(vinyl alcohol) using epichlorohydrin (ECH). Chitosan is a linear polysaccharide formed from shellfish and crustaceans composed of randomly distributed -linked D-glucosamine and N-acetyl-D-glucosamine. Chitosan is beneficial as a sacrificial filler in controlling film porosity in part because of its intrinsic fibrous structure. In film processing, the organochlorine compound epichlorohydrin, a toxic substance used in epoxy and miscible in polar organic solvents is employed to crosslink the PVA and chitosan followed by in situ chimeric SiO.sub.2 nanoparticle adhesion and water rinsing and/or soaking.
[1521] The modified PTFE membrane exhibits decreased carbon (C) and fluorine (F) content with a corresponding increase in hydrophilic groups. While developed for wastewater treatment, the enhanced hydrophilicity of the modified PTFE film makes the process a potential candidate for forming heterogenous composite reinforced membranes (CRMs) such as PTFE-PVA-PFSA as well as a means to glue homogenous PFSA ionomers onto a plastic or PTFE skeleton.
[1522] Made in accordance with this invention other embodiments comprise polymeric endoskeletal pillars strengthened by fibers such as carbon fibers, graphene, carbon nanotubes, polyamide and other long-chain aramid fibers, derived from an aromatic form of amides. Alternatively shards of harder polymer may be employed. In this context, aromatic refers to a conjugated ring of unsaturated bonds, empty orbitals exhibiting structural stability stronger than expected by the stabilization of conjugation alone.
[1523] Examples include hexagonal rings of six carbon atoms with an associated C-O groups connecting to N-H groups via amide linkages. By commercial taxonomy, at least 85% of the amide bonds must attach to two aromatic rings to be considered an aramid. Aramid physical properties include abrasion resilience, good resistance to organic solvents, electrically nonconductive, and featuring a very high melting point. Unencapsulated aramids are sensitive to acids, salts, electrostatic charge, and ultraviolet radiation.
[1524] Used as a strengthener, various forms of fibrous carbon or amides are generally embedded in thermoset like an epoxy resin, polydicyclopentadiene, polyimide, or other plastics. By mixing the different diameter particles-fibers into fiber layers in a 2D or 3D matrix, heterogeneity can improve the strength and resilience of endoskeletal support to thin membranes ush as ionomers. For example a PTFE-PVA-PVDF conjugate made in accordance with this invention for non energy uses can be repurposed to strengthen membrane endoskeletons despite representing a different application and field-of-art. As exemplified, creative elements of this invention is not the organic chemistry of forming the polymer backbone, but how to strengthen it, enable cross polymerization and bonding between dissimilar polymeric materials, control porosity, manage ionomeric functionalization to modulate conductivity while regulating hydration and swelling.
[1525] By introducing silicon hydroxyl groups onto the surface of polyacrylonitrile or PAN, a synthetic, semicrystalline organic polymer resin with the linear formula (CH.sub.2CHCN).sub.n, hydrophilic PAN-SiO.sub.2 fibers can be conjugated by molding or electrospinning with hydrophobic thermoplastic polyvinylidene difluoride PVDF formed by the polymerization of vinylidene difluoride to produce (C.sub.2H.sub.2F.sub.2).sub.n. The resulting PVDF-PAN-SiO.sub.2 fibrous plastic is stronger than numerous unstrengthened polymers.
[1526] In general the challenge to bond plastics of dissimilar polymers, especially category 1 plastics comprising polyethylene terephthalate (PET), category 2 comprising high-density polyethylene (HDPE), category 4 comprising low-density polyethylene (LDPE), and category 5 representing polypropylene (PP). Adhesives suitable for gluing polyethylene or polypropylene are generally labelled as such, but may fail if the surface morphology of the plastic is too dense or insufficiently porous to facilitate coating using nanofiber compounds.
[1527] Other more wettable plastics include category 3 for polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and category 9 for acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) which generally require either a solvent adhesive or epoxy compounds. Category 6 plastics comprising polystyrene (PS) is brittle and therefore not a suitable candidate for forming endoskeletal support for IEMs. Category 7 is the miscellaneous category including polycarbonate and acrylic requiring epoxy acrylic solvent adhesive, or cyanoacrylate. Other plastics may include acetal chemically known as polyoxymethylene or POM, a semi crystalline thermoplastic with high mechanical strength and rigidity.
[1528] In yet another embodiment of this invention, the PFSA ionomer can be attached to the rigid endoskeleton using a class of chemical bonding referred to as molecular glue. While traditional adhesives bond objects by physical adsorption effects which depend on a films surface energy, using a bis-diazirine reagent bonding is achieved through the formation of strong covalent bonds through promiscuous CH insertion, essentially clearing a region on a substrate surface the compound works by releasing N.sub.2 upon thermal or photo-chemical activation to afford reactive carbene species capable of undergoing efficient CH insertion with a wide range of polymer materials. Since the bis-diazirine reagent can react twice during bonding, it is able to form crosslinking delivering higher mechanical strength, improved flexibility without cracking, increased glass transition temperatures and more. Measured bonding strength between two pieces of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) exceed 2.3 MPa.
[1529] In summary, forming a heterogenous composite reinforced membranes (CRMs) such as PTFE-PVA-PFSA, grafting hydrophilic ionomers such as PFSA onto a PTFE mainchain, or bonding a homogenous film of PFSA to the polymeric skeletal structure made in accordance with this invention involve destruction of CF bonds to accommodate bonding or grafting hydrophilic pendants onto the matrix. Alternatively application of a layer of hydrophilic coating directly on the membrane surface using nanostructure locking may be employed. While the grafting process involves the application of expensive plasma etchers or hazardous chemicals, the surface coating method is simpler and lower in cost. Unfortunately in coated membranes, micropores may be blocked reducing water flux and film conductivity.
[1530] Highly soluble in water, non-toxic, biocompatible, hydrophilic, innocuous and non-carcinogenic, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) with its abundant hydroxyl groups is therefore beneficial as a hydrophilic additive, but requires cross-linked by another material such as glutaraldehyde to remain stable in an aqueous phase. As an alternative surface modification of PTFE, chitosan (CS) a sugar-like molecule prepared by the deacetylation of chitin can be used in conjunction with PVA to affix a PVA-CS hydrophilic layer onto the fibril surface of the PTFE.
[1531] In a similar fashion, to form a stable aqueous solution chitosan must be cross linked to PVA using a reagent such as epichlorohydrin (ECH). Another option for bonding super hydrophobic skeletons to hydrophilic ionomers such as PFSA may involve compatible fluoropolymers, i.e. fluoropolymers that are chemically similar to PFSA such as FEP (fluorinated ethylene propylene) or PVDF (polyvinylidene fluoride) through sintering or electrospraying.
[1532] In general, chemically coating a super hydrophobic surface (SHS) with a hydrophilic layer requires a polar solvent such as PVA able to coat the SHS using electrostatic force without the need for disrupting CF bonds. In order to form a bridge to hydrophilic molecules such as PFSA, sucrose, or chitosan, to form a stable aqueous solution however, a reagent such as glutaraldehyde or epichlorohydrin is required to facilitate cross linking between a polar molecule such as an PFSA ionomer or a sacrificial filler and the carrier solvent such as PVA, polyethylene oxide (PE) or (P(AA-AMPS)). Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
PEM Ionomer Summary.
[1544] For positive ion charge transport known as cation exchange membranes (CEM) or proton exchange membranes (PEM) a suitable material rejects electron transport and inhibits negative ion transport but supports positive ion conduction across the membrane.
[1545] Key feature of a proton exchange membrane is a non-reactive non-conductive chemical backbone, typically a hydrophobic non-polar polymer such as PTFE attached to a network of pendants with an ionomer terminus, easily ionized to result in a net negative charge state, and thereby only capable of conducting positive ionic charge, i.e. cations. The membrane is sandwiched by thin catalyst layers comprising noble metals such as Pt or Pd and optionally metallic oxides interspersed within a carbon matrix.
[1546] On the anode the catalyst is used to strip electrons from hydrogen to form free conduction electrons and hydrogen ions, i.e. protons, in a chemical process referred to as oxidation. On the cathode side of the membrane, another layer of catalyst atoms helps promote electrical bonding among the incoming hydrogen ions, the circuitous electrons, and a reducing agent, typically oxygen. The byproduct of the reducing process is water.
[1547] The following table below considers a list of potential candidates for realizing a proton exchange membrane with good mechanical rigidity and durability, superior ion conductivity, and good specificity against anion transport and electron conduction. The table is arranged by classes of atomic structure used to form the membrane including homogenous PFSA or PFSA-hydrocarbon blends with or without sacrificial fillers; heterogenous compound reinforced membranes (hCRMs); inorganic-organic compound reinforced membranes (io-CRMs); polymer-inorganic hybrid matrix; acid-base blends; anhydrous proton conductors; bio-polymers; ionic polymers; block copolymers; radiation-grafted membranes; as well as proton conducting gels & hydrogels. While some of the listed or proposed PEM ionomers are applicable for fuel cells and electrolysis, other membranes are useful in filtration, electrodialysis, drug delivery, water purification, desalinization, and as coatings for surfaces and tubing. The following table lists the major categories of PEM membranes arranged in this application.
[1548] As shown, each section describes a category of ion exchange membrane comprising a variety of membrane structures and a list of enhancements including numerous embodiments made in accordance with this invention, comprising for example and without limitation chemically inert endoskeletal support with reinforcing fillers such as carbon fibers and polymer shards; chemical bonding of the ionomeric membrane to reinforced pillars of the endoskeleton via polar-nonpolar linkers and molecular glues; sacrificial fillers controlling film porosity; embedded nanoparticles; metallic organic frameworks (MOFs) containing catalysts, gas scavengers, and guest ionomers; and numerous combinations thereof. Note terms with a lowercase prefix s refer to sulfonated forms of the atoms, bit other acids such as phosphonic acid may be employed in lieu of sulphonic acid.
TABLE-US-00013 PEM Structure Category PEM Enhancements 1 PFSA bulk membranes PFSA endoskeleton, pillar link homopolymer sacrificial filler nanoparticle coating 2 PFSA-PTFE PFSA CRM endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE-co-PTFE heteropolymer sacrificial filler PFSA-PVA-PTFE & composites nanoparticle coating 3 perfluorodimethyldioxole (PDD) amorphous endoskeleton, pillar link perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane- homopolymer sacrificial filler sulfonic acid (PFMMD-SA) glassy matrices nanoparticle coating 4 sulfonated polyethylene (sPE) polyethylene endoskeleton, pillar link bromated polyethylene (BrPE) (PE) polymers sacrificial filler 5 sulfonated polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) polyvinyl alcohol endoskeleton, pillar link +cellulose acetate (PVA-g-CA) (PVA) polymers sacrificial filler +sulfosuccinic acid (PVA-SSA) & copolymers crosslinked copolymer +SSA grafted PVA (PVA-co-SSA) phosphorylated polyvinyl alcohol (PPVA) +phosphorus acid (PO.sub.3H.sub.2-PVA) +phosphoric acid (PO.sub.4H.sub.2-PVA) +phosphotungstic acid (PWA-PVA) +trimethoxysilylpropanethiol (TSMP PVA) +chitosan Na-alginate PVA 6 polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF-SA) polyvinyl endoskeleton, pillar link +polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVDF-PVP-SA) difluoride sacrificial filler +azobisiso butyronitrile (PVDF-AIBN-SPA) (PVDF) polymers crosslinked copolymers +perfluoro-hexene (PVDF-AIBN-SPA-PFH) & copolymers polyvinyl alcohol (PVDF-co-sPVA) polystyrene (PVDF-PVP-PSSA) polycarbonate (PVDF-co-sPC) methyl-methacrylate (PVDF-co-PMMA) perfluorosulfonic acid (PVDF-co-PFSA) 7 polypropylene CRM (PFSA-co-PP) polypropylene endoskeleton, pillar link polypropylene CRM (PFSA-PTFE-co-PP) (PP) copolymers sacrificial filler 8 sulfonated polyvinyl chloride (sPVC) polyvinyl endoskeleton, pillar link polyvinyl butylimidazolium grafted chloride (PVC) sacrificial filler polyvinyl chloride PVC-g-P(VBIm) polymers 9 sulfonated polyimide (sPI): ODADS polyimide (PI) endoskeleton, pillar link sulfonated polyimide (sPI): pBABTS polymers sacrificial filler 10 sulfonated polystyrene (sPS) polystyrene (PS) endoskeleton, pillar link styrenesulfonate (sSA) polymers & sacrificial filler cross-linked styrenesulfonate (sSA-X) copolymers 11 sulfonated poly fluorenyl ether fluorenyl ether endoskeleton, pillar link ketone nitrile (sPFEKN) ketone nitrile sacrificial filler polymers 12 polyphenylene disulfonic acid (PPDSA) polyphenylene endoskeleton, pillar link polybiphenylene disulfonic acid (PBPDSA) (PP) polymers & sacrificial filler linear/sidechain/kinked sulfonated copolymers crosslinked copolymer polyphenylene (sPP) branched copolymer +p-benzoyl/p-phenoxybenzoyl post-sulfonated phenylated (SDAPP) via Diels Alder condensate pre-sulfonated phenylated PPs polybiphenylene-co-phenylene disulfonic acid (BXPY) sulfonated polyphenylene - biphenyl (SPP-BP)/quaterphenol (SPP-QP) sulfonated polyphenylene - triphenol (SPPT), meta-biphenyl (SPPBm), ortho biphenyl (SPPBo), naphthyl (SPPN) sterically hindered pyridine moieties sulfo-phenylated polyphenylene (X + Y)N branched sulfo-phenylated polyphenylene (sPPB-x % DB) hydroxylated sulfonated phenylated polyphenylene (sPPP-OH) diiodo-biphenyldisulfonic acid (DiIPS) dibromo-biphenyldisulfonic acid (DiBrDS) sulfonimide branched poly (phenylenebenzophenone) (SI-PPBP) 13 sulfonated polyarylene ether (SPAE) polyarylene endoskeleton, pillar link sulfonated perfluoropolyether (sPFPE) ether (PAE) sacrificial filler sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone polymers graphene oxide (GO) (SPAES) filler, graft, crystallites phosphotungstic acid crystallites (PWA) 14 sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone poly ether endoskeleton, pillar link (sPEEK or PEEK-sPEEK) ketones (PEK, sacrificial filler sulfonated poly ether ketone (sPEK) PEEK, PE.sub.xK.sub.y) sulfonated poly ether ketone-ketone (sPEKK) polymers sulfonated poly ether-ether-ether ketone (sPEEEK) sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone-ketone (sPEEKK) sulfonated poly ether ketone-ketone-ketone (sPEKKK) sulfonated poly ether ketone ether ketone- ketone (sPEKEKK) sulfonated (poly ether ketone) - poly ether ketone (sPEK-PEK or 2PEK) 15 sulfo poly ether-ether sulfone (sPEES, SPEESf) polymers and endoskeleton, pillar link sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone-co- copolymers of sacrificial filler poly(ether imide) (sPEES-co-PEI, sPEESf- poly ether bismuth trimesic acid co-PEI) sulfones (BiTMA) sulfonated poly (phenylene ether-ether- poly ketone bismuth molybdate sulfone)-poly (acrylamido-methyl- ether sulfones (Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6) propanesulfonic acid) (SP-PMPS) poly arylene fluorinated polyethersulfone (FPES, ketone ether FPESf, FPESU) sulfone di-poly(arylene ketone ether sulfone) (2PAKESf, 2PAKES, 2PAKESU) poly(arylene ketone ether ketone sulfone) (PAKEKS, PAKEKSf, PAKEKSU) sulfonated poly ether sulfone - bismuth trimesic acid heteropolymer (SPES- BiTMA, SPESU-BiTMA) sulfonated poly ether sulfone - bismuth molybdate heteropolymer (SPES- Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6, SPESU-Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6) sulfonated quaterphenol polysulfone (S.sub.4Ph-PSU, S.sub.4Ph-PSf) bis-hydroxyphenyl ether sulfone (BHPESf, BHPES, BHPESU) 16 membrane agnostic dopants, incl: hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE CRM with carbon sacrificial filler PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM filler carbon nanotubes sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone SO.sub.3H/COOH (SPAES, SPAESf) POH/NH.sub.2 sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (sPEEK) SiO.sub.2/TiO.sub.2 sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone graphene oxide (sPEES, sPEESf) PFPE-GO polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) ABPBI-GO phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) Hoffman GO chitosan (CS) Scholz-Boehn GO Ruess GO Lerf-Klinowski GO 17 membrane agnostic dopants, incl: hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE CRM with silica filler sacrificial filler PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM HMS-PA phosphoric sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone acid, hollow mesopore (SPAES, SPAESf) silica sulfonated polyether ether ketone (sPEEK) Al-graft mesopore silica sulfonated polyether ether sulfone silica-MCF (SPEES, SPEESf) mesostructured polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) cellular foam phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) chitosan (CS) 18 perfluoro-methyl-dioxolane-co-PFSA hybrid glassy endoskeleton, pillar link PFMMD-co-PFSA copolymer sacrificial filler PFMDD-co-PFSA (PFMMD-co-X) PFMD-co-PFSA PFMMD-co-PFMD-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-PFMD-co-PFSA +chlorotrifluoroethylene PFMMD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA +pentafluorostyrene PFMMD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA 19 poly(dioxo-dihydro-pyrrole-carbonyl) hybrid glassy endoskeleton, pillar link sulfanoyl fluoride-co-styrene (PDDP-CSFS) copolymer sacrificial filler PDDP-CSFS-co-SPmax (sulfo (phenyl (PDD-co-X) sulfonyl)-biphenyl high copolymer 20 sulfonated phenyl-alkane (sPhC.sub.nH.sub.2n+2) hybrid phenyl endoskeleton, pillar link phenyl-aldehyde (sPhCHO) copolymer sacrificial filler (phenyl-co-X) 21 styrene-co-X hybrid styrene endoskeleton, pillar link sulfo poly (trifluorostyrene) linear PTFS copolymers and sacrificial filler cross-link poly (trifluorostyrene) PTFS-X grafts cross linker perfluoroalkoxy alkanes polystyrene (styrene-co/g-X) sulfonic acid PFA-g-PSSA polystyrene co polystyrene-sulfonate copolymer PS-co-sPSS styrene-urethane poly thermoplastic urethane - polystyrene sulfonic acid - divinyl benzene PTPf-PSS-DVB flexible poly thermoplastic urethane ester - rigid poly thermoplastic urethane linear copolymer 22 sulfonated polysulfone P(Sf-sSf) hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link (sulfone) sacrificial filler 23 polyamide sulfonimide P(Am-co-sAm) hybrid endoskeleton, pillar link copolymer sacrificial filler (polyamide) 24 poly sulfonated phosphazene P(Pz-co-sPz) hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link (phosphazene) sacrificial filler 25 poly sulfonated siloxane P(SiX-co-sSiX) hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link (siloxane) sacrificial filler 26 covalent triazine polymers CTP/sCTP hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link sulfonated phenylated CTF-Ph (triazine) sacrificial filler tris(4-formylphenyl)amine sCTP-TPA Pd NP catalyst triazine trifluoride CTP-TF sulfonated triazine framework s6TPh sulfonated triazine framework s3T6Ph fluorinated triazine framework 6T6PhF.sub.4 sulfo bi-pyrroles triazine 6T12Ph6bPy sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone) triazine bisphenol linear copolymer P(SPAESf)-co-TBPh 27 sulfobutyl-vinylimidazolium-methyl hybrid methyl endoskeleton, pillar link methacrylate copolymer F.sub.3 methane methacrylate sacrificial filler sulfonate (sBVIm-TfO-co-MMA) copolymers PMMA nanoclusters polyester grafted poly(methyl P(MMA-co-X) Pd PMMA nanoclusters methacrylate) (PE-g-PMMA) Pd-MMA-MAA bridging maleic anhydride MAH - poly(methyl sulfonated PMMA methacrylate) linear copolymer nanoclusters P(MMA-co-MAH) PMMA porous maleic anhydride derivative Mi - poly nanospheres (methyl methacrylate) linear copolymer ZnS PMMA nanocluster P(MMA-co-MAH-co-Mi) polyvinylidene fluoride grafted poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA-g-PVDC) 28 carboxy methyl cellulose polyvinyl hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link alcohol acrylamide (CMC-PVA-AA) (carboxy methyl sacrificial filler cellulose) carboxylated carbon nanotube (CCNT) sulfonated activated carbon (SAC) 29 multi-acid sidechains (MASC) modifying: hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE CRM (multi acid sacrificial filler PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) sidechain MASC) PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone (SPAESf, SPAES) sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (sPEEK) sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (sPEESf, sPEES) polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) chitosan (CS) 30 arylene ether IEM variants hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link sP12F97B (arylene-ether) sacrificial filler sP6F9CB 31 POSS/DSSQ doped hybrid membranes POSS doped endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE CRM hybrid polymers sacrificial filler PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) polyhedral POSS variants PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM oligomeric POSS-SH, POSS-A-PA, sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone silsesquioxane POSS-PEG, POSS-iBu, (SPAESf, SPAES) (POSS) POSS-Vi, POSS-BuCl, sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone double decker Ot-POSS, OV-POSS, (sPEEK) silsesquioxane Ph-POSS, POSS-SH, sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (DDSQ) POSS-A, POSS-iBu-Vi, (sPEESf, sPEES) POSS-iBuNH.sub.2, polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) POSS-iBuCl, phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) POSS-iBu3OH, chitosan (CS) POSS-iBu-styrl POSS-iBu-PS, POSS-R-styrl, POS-R-PS, POSS-Cp-PS, POSS-Cy-PS, POSS-Am-NH.sub.2 POSS-cage & prisms: hexagonal & octagonal pendants, bead, chain, barbells, planar, dendritic, non-planar double decker silsesquioxane: cubic DDSQ, Me/non-Me DDQ 32 nanoparticle doped/coated hybrid IEMs hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link extend polytetrafluoroethylene ePTFE nano fillers and sacrificial filler PFSA-PTFE CRM dopants of polyimide (PI) coating PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) nanolayers nanocomposites PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM nanofibers zirconium composite sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone nanospheres electrospun nanofibers (SPAESf, SPAES) nanotubes nanoparticle coat CNTs sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone +polybenzimidazole PBI (sPEEK) +pyridine PyPBI sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone NH.sub.2 CNT (sPEESf, sPEES) PtNH.sub.2 NP CNT polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) TiNH.sub.2 NP CNT phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) phosphorated titania chitosan (CS) PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 CNT 4-sulfophthalic acid-poly vinyl alcohol sGA linker: sulfonated (SPA-PVA) glutaraldehyde novel nano-doped IEM polymers polyethylene oxide PEO poly(dopamine) (pDA) sulfonated polystyrene poly(sulfonated dopamine) (pSDA) nanofibers (sPS) poly(dopamine-sulfonated dopamine) Ag nanoparticles (p(DA-SDA) polytetrafluoroethylene - titanium (IV) butoxide sol-gel matrix 33 PFSA-PTFE CRM hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM with fillers sacrificial filler sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone (zirconium) intercalant zirconia iZr (SPAESf, SPAES) intercalant Zr sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (sPEEK) +OH terminus ( type Zr) sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone +O terminus ( type Zr) (sPEESf, sPEES) +X terminus ( type Zr) polyvinyl X = F.sup., Cl.sup., Br.sup., alcohol (sPVA) OH.sup., HSO.sub.4.sup. phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) zirconium nanosphere chitosan (CS) ZrNS or ZrO.sub.2 4-sulfophthalic acid-poly vinyl alcohol (SPA-PVA) 34 grafted IEMs hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link poly(vinylbenzyl chloride)-poly(4,4- with metal sacrificial filler diphenylether-5,5-bibenzimidazole)- organic metal oxide frame MOF triazole graft copolymer matrix frameworks +guest (PVBC-co-OPBI-co-OPBI-TG) (MOF) fillers +stack/cubic other MOF-doped IEMs +trapezoid PFSA-PTFE CRM +double trapezoid PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) +hexagonal drum PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM +octagonal drum sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone +rectangular array (SPAESf, SPAES) metal complexes sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (sPEEK) +Zr.sub.6O.sub.4(OH).sub.4 sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone Cr terephthalate cluster (sPEESf, sPEES) sulfonic ferrous cluster polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) M-L-M configurations sulfo phenylene- M-dithiolene, M-DPPE, bibenzimidazole (sPBI) M-EDT, M-PLTSC, sulfo chitosan (sCS) M-ambidentate, 4-sulfophthalic acid-poly vinyl alcohol M-BIPY, M-Schiff base (SPA-PVA) M-salicylaldehyde metal scavenger MOFs +metal scavenger via metal to hetero-metal ligand (M-L-hM) +ligand scavenger +guest scavenger +interleaved/stacked scavengers +scavenger guests Fe scavenger MOFs Co scavenger MOFs Ni scavenger MOFs zinc-oxide ester hexaphosphate MOF (Zn.sub.6O.sub.24(C.sub.6H.sub.18O.sub.24P.sub.6)) 35 PWA-doped polysulfone copolymer hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link poly(4-vinylpyridine) (PSf-co-P4VP) with fillers and sacrificial filler +ferro-cyanide- coordinated poly(4- dopants molybdenum tungsten vinylpyridine) (CP4VP) ionomers (tungsten) nanoparticles (MoW NPs) PWA-doped poly vinyl alcohol with phosphotungstic acid quaternized polyethyleneimine silica clusters (SiO.sub.2-PWA) copolymer (PVA-co-QPEI) +chlorophenyl)methyl-dihydro benzodioxin-methyloxidanylidene- benzothiazine-carboxamide (R.sub.4N.sup.+) ionomers other PWA-doped IEMs PFSA-PTFE CRM PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone (SPAESf, SPAES) sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (sPEEK) sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (sPEESf, sPEES) polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) sulfo phenylene-bibenzimidazole (sPBI) sulfo chitosan (sCS) 36 zeolite doped IEMs hybrid polymer endoskeleton, pillar link PFSA-PTFE CRM with fillers sacrificial filler PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) (zeolite) phenylated zeolite PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM sulfonated mordenite sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone sulfonated zeolite (SPAESf, SPAES) frameworks sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone zeolite nanoparticles (sPEEK) sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (sPEESf, sPEES) polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) sulfo phenylene-bibenzimidazole (sPBI) sulfo chitosan (sCS) 37 polysulfone IEMs acid-base endoskeleton, pillar link sulfonated polysulfone (sPSf, sPSU) polymers and sacrificial filler bromated polysulfone (BrPSf, BrPSU) fillers functionalized para-linked bromated polysulfone (polysulfone) graphene oxide (BrPSf).sub.x or (BrPSU).sub.x sulfonated polysulfone polysulfone filler doped IEMs (FPGO-sPSf, FPGO-sPSU) PFSA-PTFE CRM platinum titanium PTFE with perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) titanium dioxide PFSA-PVA-PTFE CRM nanoparticle sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone (PtTiO.sub.2 NPs) (SPAESf, SPAES) polyoctahedral sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone silsesquioxanes (POSS) (sPEEK) sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (sPEESf, sPEES) polyvinyl alcohol (sPVA) sulfo phenylene-bibenzimidazole (sPBI) sulfo chitosan (sCS) 38 PBI/OPBI anhydrous IEMs anhydrous endoskeleton, pillar link poly phenylene-bibenzimidazole (p-PBI, polymers and sacrificial filler m-PBI) copolymers pristine electrospun poly oxydiphenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) PBI/OPBI nanofibers (OPBI) crushed electrospun +hexyl-vinylimidazolium dihydrogen PBI/OPBI nanofibers phosphate proton ion liquid hexachlorocyclo- (PHVIm-H.sub.2PO.sub.4) PIL triphosphazene (HCCP) poly dihydroxy phenylene (2OH-PBI) imidazolechlorocyclo- hexafluoroisopropylidene- triphosphazene (ImCCP) polybenzimidazole (F.sub.6-PBI) PBI-ZIF phenylene sulfur dioxide polybenzimidazole benzimidazole - zeolitic (SO.sub.2-PBI) imidazolate framework poly(arylene ether benzimidazole) (PAEBI) poly(2,5-benzimidazole) (ABPBI) cross linked PBI chains oxydiphenylene benzimidazole - poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) copolymer (OBPI-co-PVBC) +quaternary ammonia linked (DABCO, quinuclidine, quinuclidinol) +phosphoric acid (PA) doped oxydiphenylene benzimidazole - polyaniline copolymer (OPBI-PANI) +quaternary ammonia linked 39 chitosan (CS) biopolymer IEMs biopolymers & endoskeleton, pillar link chitosan poly(D-glucosamine) copolymers sacrificial filler chitosan poly(N-acetyl-D-glucosamine) chitosan P[HVIm] H.sub.2PO.sub.4 PIL sulfonated chitosan (sCS) cellulose functionalized CNT cross linked sulfonated chitosan (XL-sCS) alginic acid chitosan sulfonate (sCS) phosphorylated chitosan (pCS) functionalized CS bio-copolymer IEMs CS-co-polyacrylonitrile f(CS-co-PAN) CS-co-polystyrene f(CS-co-PS) CS-co-polyvinyl alcohol f(CS-co-PVA) CS-perfluorinated sulfonic acid (CS-PFSA) vinylpyridine CS graft (CS-g-PVP) +carbon nanotube (CS-g-PVP-CNT) styrenesulfonic acid CS graft (CS-g-SSA) +carbon nanotube (CS-g-PVP-SSA) POSS crosslinked chitosan (POSS XL CS)
1. PFSA Homopolymer IEMs.
[1549] As detailed previously homogeneous films of perfluorosulfonic acid having the acronym PFSA comprise the combination of a structural fluorocarbon backbone with sidechains bridging mainchain carbon atoms to sulfonic acid ionomers through intervening sidechains. Together the combination of the electrically active PFSA ionomer and its associated sidechain form a pendant, so named because it hangs off of the mainchain. As depicted previously in
[1550] In homogeneous PFSA membranes the mechanical strength of the film is determined purely by its backbone while the sidechain length affects the film density and water transport. Without the sidechain the hydrophilic sulfonic acid would be unable to bond to the hydrophobic backbone. Pure PFSA films are however notoriously fragile and subject to swelling during operation. As one embodiment made in accordance with this invention, a homogenous membrane of PFSA is mechanically strengthened by am endoskeletal framework of stronger more-rigid polymers to which the PFSA attaches. The resulting structure reduces excess moisture retention and swelling of the film while improving handling. In another embodiment of the invention, the PFSA microporosity is controlled by inclusion of a sacrificial filler introduced during the dispersion casting and polymerization process.
[1551] Strictly defined, the backbone of pure PFSA can be categorized as the hydrophobic polymer polytetrafluoroethylene or PTFE which connects to the hydrophilic sulfonic acid ionomers through varying length sidechains, together able to function as a cation specific conduction medium. Pragmatically however, the term PTFE is generally used in reference to a non-conductive homopolymer, not to a blend of PFSA and PTFE. Instead PFSA-PTFE blends are heterogenous, and herein are referred to as a composite reinforced membrane or CRM.
[1552] The below table and similar tables to follow throughout the application describes the general structural category of the film, the mechanical structural support of the film, solvents and reagents used for mixing or delivering monomers and solutes, solvents and reagents used for promoting cross linking (denoted in the table by the abbreviation X-L), and various skeletal support options made in accordance with this invention.
[1553] The following table lists various attributes of a bulk PFSA homopolymer:
TABLE-US-00014 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 1. perfluorinated PFSA polymer: PTFE, FEP, solv: PVA, PFOA, sac filler, CNTs, sulfonic acid homopolymer PE, PP. HFC, polyethylene oxides, POSS, bulk PFSA pillars: reinforced X-L: P(AA-AMPS) NPs, MOFs, PIL fillers (C-fiber/NT)
[1554] Nascent perfluorinated sulfonic acid, referred to as bulk PFSA is an ionomeric polymer comprising a hydrophobic mainchain with a perfluorinated sidechain pendant and a sulfonic acid ionomer as the sidechain terminus. Despite comprising a mainly tetrafluoroethylene (TFE) backbone blended with modified segment substituting the mainchain fluorine for an oxygen linked sidechain, pristine PFSA is considered a homopolymer. The copolymer of PFSA and PTFE, containing longer segments of poly tetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) mixed with PFSA sidechains is referred to as a hybrid composite reinforced membrane or CRM is discussed separately in section 2. The adjective bulk refers to the conduction mechanism, mainly that the conductive channels for ion transport in pure PFSA are bulk properties, not limited by surface conduction along the polymer's inner surfaces.
[1555] As previously articulated, one of the innovative features of the described cationic IEM or PEM is the integration of a chemically inert endoskeleton into the ionomeric membrane, providing both mechanical support and suppressing film swelling and contraction. Bonding between the PFSA and an inert endoskeleton depends on the compatibility of hydrophilic and hydrophobic components or upon bridging between the two. In fact, because of the inert nature of PTFE it remains challenging to bond it to anything. The best way to form PTFE bonded to PFSA is by co-molding them concurrently. Because the backbone of PFSA is tetrafluoroethylene, identical is composition but shorter in length than PTFE, the two spines are compatible and interchangeable.
[1556] Aside from polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), endoskeleton candidates able to bond to pure PFSA ionomeric films include fluorinated ethylene propylene (FEP), polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF). Otherwise bonding to PTFE requires a cross linking adhesive such as PVA or a fluoropolymer-based glue. Endoskeletal candidates include polymers with low-energy surfaces such as polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP).
[1557] Solvents used in the preparation of PFSA polymers involve poly vinyl alcohol (PVA); carcinogenic perfluorooctanoic (PFOA); hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) compounds comprising hydrogen, fluorine, and carbon; polyethylene (PE); and P(AA-AMPS), a copolymer of poly acrylic acid (AA) and 2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propane sulfonic acid (AMPS).
[1558] In various embodiments made in accordance with this invention, various fillers and dopants added to bulk PFSA films may include sacrificial fillers and permanent fillers. Sacrificial fillers may a comprise sugar on dissolvable solid whose solvent does not damage the polymer matrix during filler removal. Permanent fillers include (a) carbon fillers, (b) oxide fillers, (c) POSS fillers, (c) nanostructure fillers, (d) MOFs, and (e) solid acid fillers, ionic liquids, and PIL dopants. Among these, carbon fillers include functionalized nanotubes (CNTs), functionalized graphene oxide (GO), and functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs).
[1559] Oxide fillers include silica, zeolites, mordenite, nesosilicates, silica mesostructured cellular foam (Si-MCF), and hollow mesoporous silica (HMS). Metal oxides include molybdate, Al-grafted mesoporous silica (MCF-ionomer), zirconium-dopamine composites, intercalant zirconium. and phosphotungstic treated silica. Polyhedral and double decker oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS, DDSQ) include countless chemical and structural variants. Nanostructure fillers include metallic and ionic nanoparticles, nanospheres, nanoclusters, and nanofibers. MOFs include catalytic, ionomeric, and scavenger metals in various geometries. Solid acids, ionic liquids and PILs comprise additives used to control conductivity through film pH.
2. PFSA-PTFE Heteropolymer & CRM IEMs.
[1560] As described, a heterogenous |EM polymeric film comprising a blend of a PFSA monomer with a mechanical support polymer such as PTFE, PFMMD, PDD, styrenesulfonate, polyethylene, polystyrene, ketone nitrile, polyphenylene, poly-arylene, polyamide, poly-ketone (PEEK), and other carbon or hydrocarbon compounds. Such heterogenous films are referred to as a composite reinforced membranes or CRM in recognition that the backbone, generally hydrophobic, provides mechanical support. Compared to pure bulk conducting perfluorinated sulfonic-acid (PFSA), however, many composite reinforced membranes (CRMs) achieve stability only by sacrificing ionomeric density resulting in lower current densities and reduced conductivities.
[1561] In accordance with the Grotthuss mechanism of hopping conduction between protons and water molecules, high proton conductivities result mainly from protons, i.e. ionized hydrogen, released from sulfonic acid groups able to hop along the ionomers aided by local vehicular water molecules. Only by either increasing microporosity to enhance water membrane permeability or by increasing the densities of ionomeric pendants can proton transport be improved. Accordingly the greater the microporosity or the higher the density of sulfonic acid groups in the membrane, the higher the density of hydronium ions transporting ionic charge, and the greater the net proton conductivity. Because, however sulfonic acid is hydrophilic and TFE is not, forming a secure bond to a hydrophobic backbone like PTFE subsequent to PFSA polymerization requires a solvent or glue such as PVA for intermolecular bonding. As such, a heteropolymer IEM comprising a PVA-bonded coating of PFSA atop a hydrophobic TFE-PTFE mainchain is referred to in the above table as a PFSA-PVA-PTFE composite reinforced membrane. It should be understood that in a porous membrane filled with nooks and crannies like Swiss cheese, the term surface has two different meanings which in some discussion may be ambiguous.
[1562] In its macrostructural context, the surface of the membrane is the two dimensional atomic plane forming an interface with the catalyst layer comprising the CCM, i.e. the catalyst coated membrane. In a microstructural context, the inner walls of any chamber, pore, conduit, tube, or channel present within the polymer matrix represents a microscopic surface along which surface current can flow. So while the macrostructural surface of the IEM is perpendicular to the fuel cell's current flow, conduction within the membrane is parallel to the microporous surfaces and orthogonal to the macrostructural surface.
[1563] For this reason, hybrid PFSA-PTFE CRM membranes may be considered as surface conductors rather than bulk conductors because the hydrophobicity of PTFE limits internal hydration suppressing bulk vehicular transport of hydronium ions within the pores instead relegating cation conduction to charge hopping from ionomer-to-ionomer occurring along the exposed inner surfaces of the pores. To enhance the conductance of a CRM, the density of micropores must be increased to maximize the films internal surface area thereby exposing more sulfonic acid ionomeric groups to contribute in charge transport, analogous to enhancing the surface area of activated charcoal in a filter. Alternatively, additional protons can be added using membrane doping by ionic liquids.
[1564] By contrast, significantly increasing the size rather than the density of pores within an ionomer suffers from numerous drawbacks. Although larger pores enhance film hydration enhancing vehicular transport of hydronium ions, the larger pores increase the preponderance of fuel crossover and oxygen back streaming. When pores become too large the incoming hydrogen fuel source entering the anode comprising either hydrogen gas in a H.sub.2 fuel cell or methanol in a direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) is able to transit unimpeded from the anode into the cathode without first being ionized into protons. Significant fuel crossover in large pore membranes is problematic for a variety of reasons. This means porosity is a key factor is determining IEM performance and limiting fuel crossover.
[1565] Firstly, un-ionized hydrogen crossover wastes fuel. Hydrogen gas passing unimpeded from anode to cathode is released into the atmosphere unused as a gaseous effluent without enhancing fuel cell electrical conduction or generating electricity. Secondly, if the hydrogen gas content in the oxygen rich cathode exceeds a certain concentration, a flammable gaseous mix of H.sub.2 and O.sub.2 may result in the cathode. Thirdly, hydrogen reacting with oxygen in the cathode can produce hydrogen peroxide (H.sub.2O.sub.2) that diffuses into the ionomeric membrane. The hydrogen peroxide bonds to the sulfonic acid groups inhibiting their proton exchange ability and permanently degrading the ionomer and fuel cell operation. In this scenario ionomer damage is likely non-uniform with the greatest impairment of ionomer function located nearer the cathode. As such, transport through the damage zone relies exclusively on vehicular transport with greatly diminished charge hopping conduction. The net result is lower fuel cell current, higher voltage sag, lower film conductance, reduced energy efficiency, and greater heat dissipation.
[1566] The formation of overly large pores in the membrane can also encourage oxygen back streaming. the process whereby unreacted oxygen gas flows from the cathode across the membrane into the anode. Once there, the oxygen invariably reacts with the hydrogen rich atmosphere producing hydrogen peroxide (H.sub.2O.sub.2). The anodically generated H.sub.2O.sub.2 then diffuses into ion exchange membrane bonding to sulfonic acid ionomer groups degrading the fuel cell performance in a manner similar to the effect of cathodic hydrogen peroxide except that the damage zone, the region of greatest functional impairment, is closest to the anode rather than the cathode.
[1567] Another adverse effect of a membrane with excessive large pores is diminished mechanical strength. Like osteoporosis in living bone, an overly porous membrane becomes brittle and easily damaged from stresses incurred during manufacturing and handling. Moreover, large pores easily retain excess water causing the membrane to swell excessively during operation in humid ambient conditions, especially at high current densities. Conversely, during inactivity membrane stored water easily drains from large pores causing drying and film contraction. Humidity cycling during operation repeatedly causing swelling and drying stresses the film eventually precipitating microcracks in the membrane which grow in length and size until the membrane leaks gas and can no longer operate reliably or safely.
[1568] To avoid these various failure modes, a heterogenous ion exchange membrane made in accordance with this invention includes some combination of (i) micropores and nanopores fabricated with consistent dimensions and densities, (ii) strengthened endoskeletal support to limit film stresses from handling and humidity cycling, and (iii) a nanocoating to prevent carbon monoxide and other gaseous toxins from invading the cathode and damaging the catalyst coated membrane (CCM) core of the fuel cell. These preventative measures may include molecular blockers, metal scavengers, and antidotes to unwanted chemical toxins. These protective measures may be incorporated into the ionomeric membrane matrix, into the catalyst layers, and optionally into the gas diffusion layer. Protection against environmental contaminants need only be into the cathode side of an MEA5 as the cathode air exchange is exposed to the unfiltered ambient while the anode gasses are self-contained and thereby protected from contamination.
[1569] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1581] In an alternative embodiment of the invention the structural membrane is coated with a colloidal dispersion of solvent and PFSA, i.e. where nanoscopic particles of PFSA are suspended in the solvent forming small primary aggregates of three-to-four molecules as dictated by the polar solvent chemistry. During curing, these clusters then agglomerate into secondary aggregates on the order of hundreds of nanometers in size forming rodlike structures 1 nm in diameter depending on the ratio of water to alcohol in the solvent. The dispersion also naturally forms chemical bonds to the semi-rigid endoskeleton made in accordance with this invention as described previously for
[1582] In another embodiment made in accordance with this invention, membrane conductivity is improved by increasing porosity using a process involving the introduction and subsequent removal of a sacrificial filler as part of the membrane fabrication sequence resulting in vacancies in the polymeric matrix appearing as empty bubbles referred to herein as sacrificial pores 3005. Like the endoskeletal support frame, the sacrificial filler process is equally applicable to heterogenous CRM membranes formed using either a PFSA-PVA-PTFE process and structure, a dispersion of PFSA-PTFE nanoparticles, or a combination thereof.
[1583] As copolymers of PFSA and PTFE, these hybrid films including PFSA-PTFE and PFSA-PVA-PTFE ionomeric polymers comprise composite reinforced membrane or CRMs providing mechanical resilience and durability advantages over PFSA. Because however, PTFE is a dense semi-crystalline electrically insulating and hydrophobic polymer, its incorporation into a PFSA polymer invariably reduces membrane conductivity by suppressing vehicular transport of hydronium through bulk channels. Instead electrical conduction is limited to proton transport via charge hopping along the PFSA backbones, comprising the so-called Grotthuss mechanism. Since the conduction throughout the matrix occurs through ionomer termini of sulfonic acids arranged linearly along PFSA chains, the cross sectional area of charge transport channels is reduced by the presence of excess PTFE either as separate chains or as PFSA with extended portions of PTFE 21 in the mainchain, i.e. where m>>n. Mechanistically, the impact of the preponderance of PTFE groups in the matrix is charge transport behavior similar to surface conduction, consequentially resulting in a more resistive film.
[1584] To compensate for a decreased conductance, the hybrid film must be thinned to 20 m or less relying on the mechanical strength of PTFE to prevent film breakage during handling. Made in accordance with this invention, the introduction of a reinforcing endoskeleton into the membrane provides added mechanical support for handling of the film, thereby allowing the mole fraction of PTFE in the blend to be reduced. By reducing the fraction of PTFE in the polymer, conductance is enhanced by a higher density of PFSA chains and through greater porosity. The number of conductive pores is further enhanced by the introduction of a sacrificial filler such as sucrose into the polymer prior to casting and subsequently removing it to form micropores.
[1585] The micropores are able to transport protons, water and hydronium ions. Hydrogen atoms, oxygen atoms, hydronium ions, and water molecules have effective diameters of 0.08 nm, 0.13 nm, 0.2 nm, and 0.28 nm respectively, meaning all four masses should be able to pass through any pore 0.3 nm in diameter. In a hydrogen fuel cell oxygen back-streaming from the anode to the cathode to the anode is minimal, not because of pore size but because of a small yet perpetual positive pressure differential between the anode and cathode maintained by the hydrogen gas supply. accordingly hydrogen gas flow occurs primarily from anode to cathode attached to larger water molecules, forcing oxygen to swim upstream against a prevailing current. As such, a reasonable density of micropores can be introduced into the PEM membrane to enhance conductivity without significantly increasing oxygen back-streaming, i.e. crossover.
[1586] In the case of a DMFC, the maximum pore size is limited by the need to prevent fuel crossover, the unwanted flow of methanol across the membrane. Methanol is a relatively large molecule having an average diameter of 0.36 nm, nearly double that of an hydronium ion. Because of its larger molecular dimension, channels in the membrane with dimensions greater than 0.2 nm but less than 0.35 nm will transport protons but prevent methanol cross-over.
[1587] As such, the introduction of sacrificial fillers into the mold casting process forms conductive channels in the polymeric matrix facilitating the ability to adjust conductance of a membrane independent of its thickness. One such sacrificial filler made in accordance with this invention is sucrose or alternatively fructose or glucose. Sugars comprise rather large molecules compared to elemental atoms, but are diminutive contrasted to hydrocarbon fuels and large polypeptides such as proteins. Specifically, sucrose has an average cross sectional dimension of 0.7 nm to 0.9 nm. In the sacrificial filler process described herein, dissolved sucrose leaves empty regions called vacancies or sac pores in the polymer matrix. These vacancies appearing as holes or bubbles in the polymer roughly equal to the molecular dimensions of the sacrificial filler used to create them.
[1588] While these vacuous bubbles may appear overly large compared to oxygen and methanol, in reality sacrificial sucrose does not form contiguous pores of the same size as its vacancy bubbles. Instead, at low sucrose concentrations the bubbles do not overlap but connect through smaller channels in the polymer matrix, analogous to the small openings in a spider web. These narrow conduits serve as choke points limiting gas flow. Being a semi-amorphous semi-crystalline polymer, it is impossible to predict a-priori the actual size and density of gas channels created in a PFSA-PTFE CRM by a sacrificial filler process. Instead, an optimum degree of porosity can be determined empirically by adjusting the quantity of filler mixed with the polymer for casting and measuring the tradeoff between conductivity and undesirable back-streaming or adverse fuel crossover effects. Alternatively, if film porosity is too great, a smaller sacrificial sugar such as fructose or glucose may be used in place of sucrose.
[1589] Aside from the important role of sacrificial fillers in PEM fabrication as described in various embodiments made in accordance with this invention, permanent fillers and dopants added to the matrix can further enhance mechanical and electrical film properties. A permanent filler is a foreign material not a monomer of the chain which once introduced and molded into the polymer remains indefinitely as part of the polymeric matrix. Permanent fillers include (a) carbon fillers, (b) oxide fillers, (c) POSS fillers, (c) nanostructure fillers, (d) MOFs, and (e) solid acid fillers & PIL dopants.
[1590] Among these, carbon fillers include functionalized nanotubes (CNTs), functionalized graphene oxide (GO), and functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs). Oxide fillers include silica, zeolites, mordenite, nesosilicates, silica mesostructured cellular foam (Si-MCF), and hollow mesoporous silica (HMS). Metal oxides include molybdate, Al-grafted mesoporous silica (MCF-ionomers), zirconium-dopamine composites, intercalant zirconium. and phosphotungstic treated silica. Polyhedral and double decker oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS, DDSQ) include countless chemical and structural variants. Nanostructure fillers include metallic and ionic nanoparticles, nanospheres, nanoclusters, and nanofibers and may include ionic or metallic functional groups. MOFs include catalytic, ionomeric, and scavenger metals in various geometries, where homogeneous and heterogenous elemental metal atoms and metallic clusters are suspended in a matrix or organic ligands. Solid acids and PILs comprise additives used to control conductivity through film pH. The discussion of fillers and dopants, while mentioned here specifically in the context of a PFSA-PTFE film, the concept is general and applies equally for all membrane types.
[1591] The composition of PFSA-PTFE composite reinforced membranes including its ionomer type, heteropolymeric backbone structure, solvents used in its synthesis, composition of its inventive endoskeleton, and novel use of fillers and dopants is listed in the table below. Structurally, the attachment of a PFSA-PTFE film to a support endoskeleton is neither trivial nor obvious, particularly if the pillars forming the endoskeleton are also made of a hydrophobic PTFE matrix.
TABLE-US-00015 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 2. perfluorinated sulfonic PFSA CRM polymers: PTFE, solv: PVA, PFOA, sac filler, CNTs, acid poly tetrafluoro heteropolymers FEP, PE, PP HFC, ethanol, PE oxides, POSS, ethylene pillars; reinforced X-L: P(AA-AMPS), NPs, MOFs, PIL PFSA-PTFE fillers (C-fiber/NT) TFE, GA PFSA-PVA-PTFE
[1592] Solutions to this bonding problem include (a) co-molding the membrane and the pillars at the same time where separate mold chambers containing different mold materials cross link during polymerization possibly aided by a cross-linking agent like glutaraldehyde (GA) or tetrafluoroethylene (TFE), (b) damage the endoskeletal pillars with a chemical etch or radiation to create bonding sites for the membrane to attach to, (c) form bondable groups on the pillars so that the membrane can attach itself, (d) coat the pillars with an adhesive that can glue to the membrane, or (e) form a copolymer membrane where one of the polymer groups readily attaches to the pillar. This process and the resulting connection between the endoskeletal pillar and the membrane is referred to herein as a pillar link. Although the pillar link is most challenging when hydrophobic polymers such as PTFE are involved, the methods described are applicable to any combination of endoskeletal and ionomeric membrane material and will not be repeated again for each section.
3. Amorphous Glassy Matrix Homopolymer IEMs.
[1593] In an alternative embodiment, the inert molecular backbone of a composite reinforced membrane is modified using an alternative homopolymer chemistry having a lower atomic density than PTFE. An example of this approach is illustrated in
[1594] In an exemplary PFMMD 1020a structure as depicted. one of the CF.sub.2 bonds in the m-repeat group of PFSA is replaced by a fluorinated carbon-oxygen ring 1024 to form a perfluoro-(2-methylene-4-methyl-1,3-dioxolane) membrane having the acronym PFMMD. The structural change impacts both bulk and interfacial membrane permeabilities affecting oxygen solubility, diffusivity, interfacial permeation rate constants, and ionomer distribution in the catalyst layer. While the increased permeability may weaken CRM strength, when used in conjunction with the semi-rigid endoskeletal frame made in accordance with this invention, film porosity as determined by the m-to-n ratio of the polymeric repeated units for PFMMD can be optimized without concern for affecting membrane mechanical properties such as strength, durability, and swelling.
[1595] In an alternative implementation PDD 1020b one of the CF.sub.2 bonds in the m-repeat group of PFSA is replaced by a cross-linked oxygenated fluorocarbon attached to trifluoromethyl groups to form a ring-structured monomer 1023, perfluoro-(2,2-dimethyl-1,3-dioxole) also know as PDD. By enhancing membrane permeability, oxygen transport resistance is reduced enhancing PEM conductivity. Another benefit of the enhanced permeability is an increase in interfacial catalytic activity and suppression of layered backbone folding of the ionomer near the catalyst surface.
[1596] Fabrication of glassy amorphous films involves a two-step processpolymerization and hydrolysis.
[1597] Like PFSA-PTFE, polymerization of glassy matrices ensues by slowly stirring the components in an inert atmosphere with a polymerization initiator [CF.sub.3(CF.sub.2).sub.2 C(O)O].sub.2 for example available from Tokyo Chemical Industry Co., Ltd dissolved in Vertrel XF solvent available from DuPont-Mitsui Fluorochemicals Co., Ltd for three days. Vertrel XF is a proprietary hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) fluid designed to replace current hydrochlorofluorocarbon (HCFC) and perfluorocarbon (PFC) fluids and well suited for use in vapor degreasing equipment for cleaning, rinsing, and drying.
[1598] The polymer is then heated to 100 C. to remove fluid. Hydrolysis is performed by immersing the film in NaOH aqueous solution and heating to 130 C. for 12 hours, followed by rinsing in HCl and deionized water at 80 C., thereby converting fluorinated side group 1023f into a hydrolyzed terminus 1023h to realize sulfonic ionomer 1023. Through hydrolysis, the polymer perfluoro-(2,2-dimethyl-1,3-dioxole) (fPDD) 1020f is thereby converted into hydrolyzed perfluoro-(2,2-dimethyl-1,3-dioxole) (hPDD) 1020h.
[1599] Although these membranes hold promise in fuel cell, electrolysis, and filter applications they are inherently glassy and brittle requiring added mechanical support especially during manufacturing and MEA7 assembly. As such, membrane integrity can be greatly enhanced through integration with the endoskeletal and exoskeletal support and frame.
[1600] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1612] A summary of fabrication conditions for glassy IEMs is described in the table below.
TABLE-US-00016 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 3. glassy amorphous amorphous polymer: PFMMD, solv: DMF, HFB, sac filler, CNTs, matrix glassy CRMs & PMMA, PU, PVDF. DEC oxides, POSS, PDD homopolymers pillars: reinforcing X-L: FBzO, FDTBO, NPs, MOFs, PIL PFMMD fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) PFDMO
[1613] As described, a glassy amorphous IEM comprises a composite reinforced membrane comprising PDD, PFMMD, or any other homopolymer having large groups that interfere with polymer crystallinity. Although any number of endoskeletal materials may be used in pillar construction, molecules of similar composition to the membrane such as PFMMD, PMMA, PU, and PVDF offer better bonding strength then hydrophobic perfluorinated materials. Exemplary solvents include dimethylformamide (DMF), hexafluorobenzene (HFB, F.sub.6Bz), and diethyl carbonate (DEC). During synthesis, cross linking agents include perfluorodibenzoyl peroxide (FBzO).sub.2 or simply FBzO, perfluoro-di-tert-butyl peroxide (FDTBO), and perfluoro-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDMO). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
[1614] Applications of glassy amorphous membranes include gas separation membranes and proton exchange membranes for hydrogen fuel cells.
4. Functionalized Polyethylene (PE) Polymer IEMs.
[1615] As an alternative to a composite reinforced membrane comprising a fluorocarbon backbone such as PTFE, enhanced mechanical stability can also be achieved using a fluorine-free membrane comprised of hydrocarbon homopolymers known as a polyolefins. One example of a polyolefin is polyethylene (PE), functionalized into a catalyst or ionomer by sulphonic acid or other electronically active groups. By definition, polyolefins are polymerized versions of basic olefins, i.e. unsaturated hydrocarbons containing a double bond between two carbon atoms.
[1616] Olefins, or using a more modern term alkenes, as depicted schematically in
[1617] Specifically styrene comprises a modified benzene ring 1027 with the chemical formula C.sub.6H.sub.5CHCH.sub.2 where one of the hydrogen bonds has been substituted by a vinyl group 1026 having a chemical structure CHCH.sub.2. During polymerization, the vinyl double bond 1026 is split forming two single bonds with adjacent styrene monomers 1025. Post polymerization, the resulting backbone 1030 of the polyolefin binds the modified benzene rings 1027 together in a string. Structurally analogous to the fluorocarbon backbone in PTFE and PFSA, the polyolefin spine comprises only hydrocarbons. Commercial examples of polyolefin plastics include polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), polyisobutylene, and polymethylpentene (PMP). Shorthand notation often represents polyolefin spine only as the backbone 1030 absent the attached ring structures.
[1618] One structural form of a polyolefin suitable for forming an ion exchange membrane (IEM) is the class of polymers referred to as polyethylene aka PE.
[1619] Finally the trimethyl amine pendant 1034n terminus is modified by into an active bromated ionomer 1035i by bromomethane CH.sub.3Br. Alternatively sulfuric acid H.sub.2SO.sub.4 can be used to form a SO.sub.3H sulfonic acid ionomer. Numerous pragmatic issues challenging the functionalization of PE include managing film porosity, enhancing conductance, and controlling durability as required by real world applications of fuel cells and electrolyzers.
[1620] In particular, high density polyethylene (HDPE) sheet is susceptible to environmental stress cracking (ESC), a brittle failure that occurs when the HDPE sheet cracks while in tension. Unsupported, HDPE can fail at tensile stresses lower than normal levels. By combining it with the skeletal support described herein, the tensile strength of a PE membrane can be enhanced significantly.
[1621] By adopting the inventive features of the application, the performance of polyethylene (PE) membranes can be greatly enhanced. Improvements include (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1622] As previously mentioned, although PE membranes hold promise in fuel cell, electrolysis, and filter applications they can become brittle over time, especially when exposed to light and various chemical agents. They also suffer from high thermal expansion, stress cracking, and poor temperature performance. Some of these deficiencies can be overcome by providing added mechanical support especially during manufacturing, MEA7 assembly, and during operation. As such, membrane integrity can be greatly enhanced through integration with the endoskeletal and exoskeletal support and frame. Given its poor thermal performance, it is important to avoid excessive temperatures.
[1623] The method of limiting self heating by dividing a fuel cell into micro-stacks is especially valuable in realizing a reliable PE based IEM and fuel cell. In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1624] Made in accordance with this invention, inventive features include: [1625] an ion exchange membrane 3003 composed of one or more polymeric backbone chains 3009c including ionomers 3009i present along the backbone chains or connected to the mainchain via a pendant sidechain; and/or [1626] a semi-rigid network of pillars comprising a wide exoskeleton 3004x and a grid pattern of a thinner endoskeleton 3004e, where the exoskeleton shown in top view 3003 may be cut mechanically or cut by laser to singulate the membrane from other membranes fabricated in the same film sheet; [1627] where the pillars comprise a reinforced core 3007 containing carbon fiber or plastic shards optionally surrounded by adhesive or molecular glue 3008; [1628] where the polymer chain 3009c is chemically attached to pillar's core 3007 by pillar link 3006 which may include adhesive or molecular glue 3008 to facilitate attachment; [1629] where the pillars form a skeletal structure circumscribing multiple panes of membrane 3003 providing mechanical support and limiting membrane 3003 deformation due to water absorption or dehydration; [1630] where membrane 2003 may include sac-pores 3005 interrupting the lattice periodicity of membrane 3003 by the previous introduction of a sacrificial filler prior to molding and its subsequent removal post casting by a solvent leaving a hole in its place of the sac-filler; [1631] where an optional nanocoating (not shown) is formed atop membrane 3003 to either enhance membrane conductivity, increase the rate of oxygen reduction reactions (ORR) in the cathode, or provide protection against membrane poisoning including boron nitride or other materials that inhibit the diffusion of carbon monoxide (CO) into the catalyst layer; [1632] where ionomeric polymer 3002 may comprise the polyolefin polyethylene (PE) as mainchain 1030 optionally blended or cross linked to other homopolymers, heteropolymers, copolymers, thereby controlling varying degrees of film crystallinity and anisotropy; [1633] where ionomeric polymer 3002 may comprise sidechains serving as pendants and influencing crystalline regularity, porosity, conductivity, and fuel cross-over of the membrane; [1634] where ionomeric polymer 3002 may comprise an ionomer 3009i of reactive sulfonic acid groups SO.sub.3H, carboxylic acid groups COOH, phosphonic acid groups PO.sub.3H.sub.2, phosphoric acid groups comprising PO.sub.4H.sub.2, imide groups CONH, quaternary ammonium groups NR.sub.3.sup.+, pyridinium groups C.sub.5H.sub.5N.sup.+, imidazolium groups C.sub.3H.sub.3N.sub.2.sup.+; tetraalkylammonium groups NR.sub.4.sup.+; phenolic hydroxyl groups OH, or any other acidic group which easily ionizes to donate conducting cations of H.sup.+, Na.sup.+, or K.sup.+ into the solid electrolyte; and finally [1635] where the combination of the endoskeletal pillars and the membrane coating are used to seal in any ionic liquid doping to prevent seepage, leakage, or IL depletion.
[1636] A summary of fabrication conditions for polyethylene IEMs is described in the table below including descriptions of the ionomer, endoskeleton, solvents, and fillers.
TABLE-US-00017 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 4. functionalized homopolymer polymers: PE, EVA, solv: TCE, xylene, sac filler, CNTs, polyethylene PE membrane EPDM, PU, PP. toluene, TCB oxides, POSS, sPE pillars: reinforcing X-L: azo, H.sub.2O.sub.2, NPs, MOFs, PIL BrPE fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) silane
[1637] Made in accordance with this invention, a homopolymer membrane comprising a polyethylene (PE) backbone with a trimethyl amine pendant functionalized by an active bromated or sulfonated ionomer terminus is described for fabricating sPE and BrPE IEMs with endoskeletal support. Endoskeletons as disclosed may comprise a range of materials but offer superior bonding to a PE membrane for ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) copolymers because EVA contain PE compatible ethylene units; ethylene propylene diene monomers (EPDMs) pursuant to suitable surface treatments increase PE surface bonding energies; polyurethane (PU) as a commonly used post surface treatment PE adhesive; polypropylene (PP) through welding, i.e. localized concurrent melting of PP and PE polymers.
[1638] Suitable PE solvents include aromatic hydrocarbons such as trichloroethane (TCE), xylene, toluene, and trichlorobenzene (TCB). PE cross linking agents generate CC and CH links. Compounds include azo, i.e. chemicals with a diazinyl (HNNH) functional group; peroxide (H.sub.2O.sub.2), and silane (SiH.sub.4). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
[1639] In contrast to other polymers, the impermeability of polyethylene to water means its application in hydronium vehicular transport, thereby relegating all conduction mechanisms within the film to either charge hopping along ionomers grafted onto the PE mainchain, or by interaction with ionomeric fillers or ionic liquids. As such, ionomeric conduction in polyethylene films is similar to that of PFSA-PTFE in that charge transport exhibits a surface like behavior rather than bulk conduction.
5. Functionalized Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) Polymer IEMs.
[1640] Another fluorine-free category of ion exchange membranes is based on homopolymers, heteropolymers, and copolymers of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA).
[1641] By phosphorylating PVA and combining it with cellulose acetate PVA can be adapted for use in methanol fuel cell applications. Alternatively, insulating PVA can be functionalized into a conductive ionomer by grafting sulfonic domains at the hydroxyl side group of the polymer backbone or by doping the film with sulfonated graphene oxide.
[1642] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1654] Aside from grafting, poly vinyl alcohol can also be functionalized by attaching an aromatic organic compound such as a phenyl as a pendant bound to an ionomer such as sulfonic acid SO.sub.3H.
[1655] In addition to its use in PEM based hydrogen fuel cells, poly vinyl alcohol films can also be adapted for used in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs). Methods include doping with H.sub.3PO.sub.2 or H.sub.3PO.sub.4; doping with phosphotungstic acid (PWA) aided by the reagent dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO); blending with chitosan and sodium alginate; and synthesizing PVA-layered silica nanocomposite membranes. Another method involves forming a heterogenous PVA-silica sulfonated membrane employing a trimethoxysilylpropanethiol (TMSP) sol-gel process in the presence of PVA solution.
[1656] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1668] The below table summarizes various structures, ionomers, endoskeletons, solvents, cross-linkers, and fillers used to synthesize PVA membranes made in accordance with this invention comprising a heterogenous membrane of polyvinyl acid (PVA) homopolymers and heteropolymers with a variety of sidechains, grafts, and copolymers.
TABLE-US-00018 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 5A. sulfonated polyvinyl heterogenous polymer: PVA, PAA, solv: methanol sac filler, alcohol PVA polymers PEG, PVP, starch ethanol, DMSO, CNTs, NPs, sPVA & copolymers pillars; reinforcing DMF, maleic acid, oxides, PIL PVA-g-CA fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) glyoxal, STMP, CA POSS, MOFs, PVA-SSA X-L: GA, SHMP, DA, PVA-co-SSA SA, SSA 5B. phosphorylated polyvinyl alcohol PPVA (PO.sub.3H.sub.2, PO.sub.4H.sub.2) PWA-PVA TSMP PVA chitosan Na-alginate PVA
[1669] Membrane functionalization includes ionomers of sulfosuccinic acid C.sub.4H.sub.6O.sub.7S; sulfonic acid SO.sub.3H; cellulous acetate (CA); phosphorous acid (H.sub.2PO.sub.4,), phosphoric acid PO.sub.3H.sub.2, phosphotungstic acid (PWA, PTA), and trimethoxysilylpropanethiol groups aka TMSP. Endoskeletons compatible with PVA membranes include polyacrylic acid (PAA) and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), able to form hydrogen bonds with PVA; polyethylene glycol (PEG) able to form copolymers with PVA; starch, able to form biodegradable polymers with PVA, and cellulose such as carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) able to form composites. Suitable PVA solvents include water, dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), ethanol, methanol, and dimethylformamide (DMF).
[1670] Cross linking agents include glutaraldehyde (GA), glyoxal, maleic acid, citric acid, trisodium trimetaphosphate (STMP), sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP), dianhydride (DA), succinic acid (SA), and sulfosuccinic acid (SSA). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
6. Functionalized Polyvinyl Difluoride (PVDF) Polymer IEMs.
[1671] Another class of fluorocarbon free ion exchange membranes is based on functionalized homopolymers, heteropolymers, and copolymers of the hydrocarbon polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF).
[1672] In this matrix, the ionomer SO.sub.3H 1074 not only participates in ion exchange but also through hydrogen bonding provides added crosslinking among the chains. One example of PVDF polymerization is used to achieve high actuation response for a polymer metal composites actuator Although the used is in the fabrication of actuators and sensing, in accordance with this application such PVDF synthesis can be adapted and repurposed for ionomer applications such as fuel cells, electrolysis, and filtration by integrating the inventive features of (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1673]
[1674] In particular the monomer PFSA 24 includes hydrogen bond 22 to sulfonic acid group 23 and inert hydrophobic PTFE chain 21a, or combinations thereof. Various synthesis methods include PVDF/PMMA composite membranes for seawater desalination by gap membrane distillation antifouling for waste water treatment. Although PVDF polymers are used in desalinization and water filtration and the general literature does not discuss or imply their use in fuel cells and electrolysis, the function of PVDF copolymer membranes can be adapted for ionomeric applications by integrating the inventive features of (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1675]
[1676]
[1677]
[1678]
[1679] Although published papers discuss various PVDF applications including actuators, filter, and fuel cells, none address the fundamental problematic issues of PVDF membranes, namely excessive swelling, low mechanical strength, poor film durability, and low cathodic reaction rates. By integrating the inventive features of this application, the ionomeric performance of PVDF copolymers can be greatly enhanced. These elements include (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1680] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1692] Made in accordance with this invention, an ion exchange membrane comprising homopolymers, heteropolymers, and copolymers of a polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF) backbone with a variety of sidechains, grafts, and copolymers is disclosed. Examples include PVDF copolymerized with combinations of PVP, AIBN, SPA, HFP, PFH, PC and PFSA.
[1693] By controlling the mix of constituent moieties, the blend provides an added degree of structural support whereby the polymer's structure can be considered a heterogenous composite reinforced membrane or CRM. These various PVDF copolymers may be functionalized by sulfonating the copolymer backbones of polystyrene (PS), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polycarbonate (PC), perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA), polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP), or by sulfonating dehydrofluorinated portions of a PVDF mainchain.
TABLE-US-00019 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 6. sulfonated heterogenous polymers: PVDF, solv: DMF, NMP, sac filler, CNTs, polyvinylidene-fluoride PVDF CRM PMMA, PTFE, EVA, MEK, ace, TEP, oxides, POSS, PVDF-SA PE, PAm, PMP, ABS, ethanol, esters, NPs, MOFs, PIL PVDF-PVP-SA TPU, PEEK THF, chloroform. PVDF-AIBN-SPA pillars: reinforcing X-L: TAIC, MEP, PVDF-AIBN-SPA-PFH fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) PVP diamines, PVDF-co-sPVA BPO. PVDF-PVP-PSSA PVDF-co-sPC PVDF-co-PMMA PVDF-co-PFSA
[1694] Endoskeletal support compatible to bond with a PVDF membrane include poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA), polyethylene (PE), polymethylpentene (PMP), polyamides (PAm, nylon), acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU), polyether ether ketone (PEEK), and polyethylene-co-vinyl acetate (EVA). Other endoskeletal materials can be chosen to bond to the corresponding copolymers in the film.
[1695] Solvents potentially involved in forming PVDF include dimethylformamide (DMF), N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP), methyl ethyl ketone (MEK), acetone (ace), ethanol, tetrahydrofuran (THF), chloroform, triethylphosphate (TEP), and various esters. Cross linking agents involved in PVDF synthesis include triallyl isocyanurate (TAIC), and a macromonomer of ethylene oxidepropylene oxide (MEP), diamines such as hexamethylenediamine, benzoyl peroxide (BPO), and polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
7. Polypropylene (PP) CRM Copolymer IEMs.
[1696] The hydrocarbon polypropylene (PP) has the potential for use in composite reinforced ion exchange membranes, not as an ionomer but as a copolymer or composite to strengthen mechanical weaker polymers. Electrically, its low surface energy and non-polar hydrophobic nature makes it a poor candidate as a ionomeric conductor. Moreover, its low surface energy also renders it a poor candidate for grafting ionomeric pendants except by using radiation damage. Instead pristine PP is relegated to providing mechanical support in composite reinforced membranes constructed from other polymers better suited for supporting conduction.
[1697] Accordingly,
[1698] The monomers used to create PFSA polymers which typically include a vinyl ether with a sulfonyl fluoride precursor group can post polymerization, be hydrolyzed to form the sulfonic acid group. For example, in the case of Nafion production, the sulfonyl fluoride groups in the monomer can be hydrolyzed to sulfonic acid groups after polymerization. This step is usually done intentionally in a controlled manner to convert the precursor polymer to the functional PFSA polymer with its characteristic ion-exchange properties. The polymerization process itself must however be carefully controlled to ensure that the resulting polymer has the desired molecular weight and properties. Impurities, including water, can affect the polymerization process, but water does not chemically damage the PFSA monomers.
[1699] A less attractive alternative involves pre-mixing in solution by dissolving both monomers in a polar-nonpolar solvent mix for example comprising xylene or decalin to dissolve PP monomers and using highly fluorinated solvents, such as perfluorinated alkanes (e.g., perfluorohexane) or perfluorinated ethers to dissolve PFSA. Because however, perfluorosulfonic acid polymers have a unique structure with a hydrophobic fluorocarbon backbone and hydrophilic sulfonic acid groups, strictly speaking they do not dissolve. Instead their structure allows them to swell in polar solvents, particularly in water due to the ionic nature of the sulfonic acid groups, thereby forming a gel-like state rather than a clear solution. As such. blending of PFSA and PP in solution is less attractive than mixing the constituent monomers; Moreover, care must be taken to avoid adverse or exothermic reactions and managing the handling of extremely toxic chemicals.
[1700] A more pragmatic solution to synthesize PFSA-PP blended membrane 1090 involves two step process of extruding polypropylene nanofibers using electrospinning and to subsequently lightly crush them into a permanent membrane filler comprising shorter PP snippets or shards. The PP nanofibers are then loaded into a casting mold with PFSA monomers for polymerization. PFSA polymerization is then performed using conventional PFSA membrane synthesis irrespective of the presence of the PP nanofibers.
[1701] Note that because the polymerized PFSA does not chemically bond to polypropylene, the membrane is generally considered a blend and not a copolymer. As such, structural integrity is achieved by ensuring one of the two polymers stoichiometrically dominates the matrix and that the two backbones are intertwined to improve the composite mechanical strength. Since the purpose of the membrane is for ion exchange, it means PFSA should comprise a higher mole fraction of the film than PP, rather than the converse. The resulting structure is essentially a PFSA or PFSA-PTFE polymer including a permanent polypropylene nanofiber filler. This process however does not preclude the use of sacrificial fillers described previously to control ionomer porosity or to employ permanent fillers to enhance conductivity.
[1702] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1714] A summary of a PP block copolymer is shown reinforcing an exemplary PFSA ionomer.
TABLE-US-00020 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 7. polypropylene blend heterogenous polymer: PP, PE, solv: xylene, TCE, sac filler, CNTs, with ionomeric block PP CRM EPDM, TPO, TPE decalin, tetralin, oxides, POSS, copolymers pillars: reinforcing TCB. NPs, MOFs, PIL PFSA-b-PP fillers (C-fiber, X-L: FFA, BM, PFSA-PTFE-b-PP CNTs) pentane, heptane other polymers-b-PP
[1715] As described, the resulting PP block copolymer constitutes a heterogenous composite reinforced membrane (CRM) of the polyolefin polypropylene and an ionomer polymer of either PFSA or PFSA-PTFE. Although PFSA is provided as an example polymer blend, other polymers may substituted for PFSA in the polypropylene supported matrix. Endoskeletal support can be made for pillar links to the ionomeric backbone. Bonding an endoskeleton to the polypropylene, although more difficult, can be achieved using polyethylene (PE) especially if pretreated with a corona or plasma to increase surface energy; ethylene-propylene-diene monomers (EPDM) with suitable adhesives; direct bonding to thermoplastic olefin (TPO), or thermoplastic elastomers (TPE).
[1716] Polypropylene solvents include aromatic hydrocarbons such as toluene, decalin, or xylene, or with chlorinated solvents such as trichloroethane (TCE) or trichlorobenzene (TCB). Cross linking agents with starting material maleated polypropylene include furfurylamine (FFA), bismaleimide (BM), dichloromethane (DCM), pentane, and heptane. Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
8. Functionalized Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Polymer IEMs.
[1717] Motivated by demand for non-fluorinated membranes, the hydrocarbon polyvinyl chloride (PVC) can be functionalized as an ionomer or catalyst, and/or grafted onto a copolymer containing ionomeric or catalytic groups.
[1718] By integrating inventive features of this application, the ionomeric performance of sPVC polymers can be greatly enhanced. These elements include (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1719] Polyvinyl chloride can also be functioned by grafting to another ionomeric or catalytic polymer. For example, PVC can be grafted onto polyl-vinyl-3-butyilimidazolium (PVC-g-p(VBIm)) ionomers by reacting it with 1-bromobutane and 1-vinylimidazole via quaternization to yield the monomer I-vinyl-3-butyl-imidazolium bromide, subsequently polymerized into P(VBIm) prior to grafting onto PVC. Polyvinyl chloride copolymer membranes such as PVC-g-p(VBIm) are especially beneficial in performing chemical separation and purification, e.g. separating CO.sub.2 from CH.sub.4.
[1720] In summary membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1732] The following table summarizes construction of sulfonated poly vinyl chloride (PVC) membrane:
TABLE-US-00021 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 8A. sulfonated heterogenous polymer: PVC, ABS, PC, solv: DMSO, NMP, sac filler, CNTs, polyvinyl chloride PVC polymers PU, PE, PP, TPE, PMMA, THF, DMAc, CHN, oxides, POSS, sPVC & copolymers EPX, PVDF, SBR ace, CPN. NPs, MOFs, PIL 8B. grafted polyvinyl pillars: reinforcing X-L: GA, STMP, CA chloride fillers (C-fiber, CNT) SHMP. PVC-g-p(VBIm)
[1733] The sulfonated polyvinyl chloride polymer comprises a heterogenous membrane comprising a chlorinated segment and a methylated segment with a corresponding pendant and attached ionomer. PVC forms pillar links amendable to bonding to a spectrum of endoskeletal materials including PVC pillars using PVC adhesives; acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) using solvent cements or applicable adhesives; polycarbonate (PC) using PVC-PC adhesives, polyurethane (PU) using PU adhesives and sealants; polyethylene (PE) using specialized adhesives can create a bond to low-energy PE surfaces; polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) with appropriate surface treatment; or to polypropylene (PP) pillars using molecular glues able to bond polar and non-polar materials. Other endoskeletons bondable by adhesives such as epoxy resins (EPX) may comprise thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), and styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR).
[1734] Solvents used in preparing PVC may include dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO); 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone (NMP); N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc); tetrahydrofuran (THF); high concentration acetone (ace), cyclohexanone (CHN), and cyclopentanone (CPN). PVC cross linking agents include glutaraldehyde (GA), sodium trimetaphosphate (STMP), sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP), and citric acid (CA). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
9. Functionalized Polyimide (PI) Polymer IEMs.
[1735] Another membrane capable of ionomeric conduction is the homopolymer polyimide.
[1736] As an alternative implementation,
[1737] The combined mix of diamine, dianhydride, and aromatic sulfonamides is then treated by triethylamine TEA (Et.sub.3N chemically as (C.sub.2H.sub.5).sub.3N) followed by treatment in benzoic acid (C.sub.6H.sub.5COOH) and m-cresol aka 3-methylphenol (CH.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.4(OH)) to produce sulfonated polyimide sPI 1125. The resulting sulfonated polyimide comprises polymer segment 1124 of length y containing radicals R.sub.1 and R.sub.2 and aromatic sulfonamide portion 1123 of length x containing radical R.sub.2 plus multiple instances of attached sulfonic acid groups SO.sub.3H. This chain construction benefits from a high degree of sulfonation and associated high conductivity without compromising the polymer's structural integrity. Chemical reagents and polymerizing agents in this process include triethylamine (TEA), benzoic acid, and m-cresol aka 3-methylphenol.
[1738] Variants of the three constituent moieties shown in
[1739] Various processes exist for synthesizing sulfonated polyimide sPI with protic ionic liquid composite membranes. The published membrane synthesis as reported does not address or anticipate fundamental problematic issues plaquing IEMs and PEMs including IL leakage, membrane swelling, mechanical strength, film durability, and cathodic reaction rates. By integrating the inventive features of this application, the ionomeric performance of sulfonated PI polymers can be greatly enhanced.
[1740] These elements include (a) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability, reduce swelling and prevent ionic liquid leakage, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1741] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1753] Construction elements of a polyimide (PI) based membrane are listed in the table below including descriptions of the ionomer, endoskeleton, solvents, and fillers.
TABLE-US-00022 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 9. sulfonated polyimide heterogenous polymers: EPX, PI, solv: DMAc, NMP, sac filler, CNTs, ODADS, pBABTS sPI homo- PTFE, PEEK, PAm CH.sub.2Cl.sub.2, DMF, THF, oxides, POSS, BAPP, BAPN, 9FDA polymer pillars: reinforcing DMSO NPs, MOFs, PIL NTDA, ODPA, DSDA fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) X-L: see solvents
[1754] As detailed above, a sulfonated polyimide membrane comprises a heterogenous polymer composed of functional radicals including the sulfonamides 4,4-diamino diphenylether-2,2-disulfonic acid (ODADS) and sulfonated 1,4-bis(4-aminophenoxy)benzene (pBABTS); diamines (R.sub.1), of 1,4-bis(4-aminophenoxy-2-sulfonic acid) benzenesulfonic acid (BAPP), 2,7-bis(4-aminophenoxy) naphthalene (BAPN), and 4,4-(9-fluorenylidene) dianiline (9FDA); and dianhydrides (R.sub.2) of naphthalene-1,4,5,8-tetracarboxylic dianhydride (NTDA), 4,4-oxydiphthalic anhydride (ODPA), and 3,3,4,4-diphenylsulfone tetracarboxylic dianhydride (DSDA).
[1755] Endoskeletal materials able to bond to polyimide support pillars include epoxy resins EPX, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) subject to surface treatment, polyether ether ketone (PEEK) using select high-temperature adhesives, or polyamide (PAm, nylon) using suitable adhesives able to bond to both polymer types. The role of solvents in fabricating polyimide is to enable a reaction between a dianhydride and a diamine under ambient conditions using a dipolar aprotic solvent. Examples include such as N-methylpyrrolidinone (NMP), m-cresol, N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), dichloromethane (CH.sub.2Cl.sub.2), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), and to a lesser extent tetrahydrofuran (THF). Polymerization of PI involves reacting a dianhydride and a diamine at ambient conditions in a dipolar aprotic solvent, so that no specific polymerizing or cross linking agent is required other than the solvents present in synthesis. Membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
10. Functionalized Polystyrene (PS) Polymer IEMs.
[1756] Pure polystyrene, i.e. polystyrene (PS) homopolymers represent a class of polymers that is an amorphous thermoplastic that is rigid, brittle and relatively hard with poor chemical resilience. To improve its mechanical and temperature performance, PS is often cross linked to itself or used to form copolymers with other polymeric materials.
[1757] To better understand the need and benefit of cross linking and copolymerization, we must first consider what are the various constructions of homopolymers, cross linked homopolymers, and copolymers. In the lexicology of polymers, a homopolymer is a linear chain of homogenous monomers bound together during the process of polymerization. In contrast, a copolymer is a polymer that is made of two or more monomer species. The polymer is bound to its copolymer counterpart through chemical bonding which may involve another polymer serving as a bridge or through a organic ligand generally involving covalent bonds.
[1758] For long chains, copolymer bonding may also comprise hydrogen bonds which gain strength through a large number of interchain electrostatic attraction points. As a subtle point, the process of concurrently forming bonds between multiple polymeric chains during formation of a homopolymer is referred to as polymerization, whereas the process of forming bonds between multiple dissimilar polymeric chains during film formation is called copolymerization. By contrast, the bonding of a polymeric to another or to another portion of the same chain is referred to as cross-linking.
[1759] As such, cross linked chains may bond multiple chains of the same material, of dissimilar materials, or may form loops on its own chain. Although cross linking may occur during polymerization or be performed subsequent to synthesizing the polymer, as a matter of semantics reagents causing cross chain bonding during polymerization are referred to polymerizing agents while those used to cause cross linking after polymerization are commonly referred to a cross linking agents. For simplicities sake, herein we use terms of polymerizer and cross-linker (X-L) as interchangeable, to be understood in the context of the reaction being discussed.
[1760] To clarify
[1761] By contrast,
[1762]
[1763] Given the forgoing,
[1764] In an alternative process styrenesulfonate 1145, a styrene monomer is combined together with divinylbenzene 1141 then polymerized with poly(styrenesulfonate) 1142p, where the poly(styrenesulfonate) contains protected sulfone groups 1145p and on-chain bridging 1143. In the final step, the protected sulfone groups 1145p are functionalized, i.e. deprotected, forming sulfonic acid groups 1145a thereby transforming cross-linked poly(styrenesulfonate) 1142p into cross-linked poly(styrenesulfonic acid) 1142a.
[1765]
[1766] In the second stage shown in steps (b) n-butyl styrenesulfonate monomer (BuSS) 1150c is first treated with azobisisobutyronitrile (AIBN) and dodecyl-dimethyl-acetic-acid)-trithiocarbonate (DDMAT) to form the intermediary compound N-butyl 4-styrenesulfonate (NBuSS) 1150d then dissolved in sodium hydroxide (NaOH) and a blend of tetrahydrofuran (THF) and ethanol (EtOH) and after stirring in a solution of HCl in ethanol, subsequently precipitated. The precipitate, a homopolymer poly(styrenesulfonic acid) (PSSA) 11150e includes sulfonic acid homopolymer 1151s.
[1767] Alternatively, steps (c) in
[1768] Published works on polystyrene polymeric membrane synthesis do not however address or anticipate fundamental problematic issues plaquing IEMs and PEMs including membrane swelling, mechanical strength, film durability, and cathodic reaction rates. By integrating the inventive features of this application, the ionomeric performance of sulfonated PS polymers can be greatly enhanced. These elements include (i) sacrificial fillers to control film porosity and conductivity, (ii) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (iii) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (iv) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film.
[1769] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1781] The following table describes various components of a polystyrene ionomeric film:
TABLE-US-00023 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 10. sulfonated heterogenous polymers: PS, ABS, PC, solv: DVBz, DMSO, sac filler, CNTs, polystyrene PS polymer & PVC, PU, PE, PMMA, ace, toluene, ethyl oxides, POSS, SPS X-L copolymers PET, PAm, TPE EPX. acetate, THF, DCM NPs, MOFs, PIL PSSA pillars: reinforcing fillers X-L: DVBz, DBPO XL-PSSA (C-fiber, CNTs) HMeBnCl
[1782] A heterogenous sulfonated polystyrene (PS) membrane as described comprises a sulfonated polystyrene (SPS) polymer, poly(styrenesulfonic acid) PSSA; and crosslinked (X-L) styrenesulfonate acid (PSSA). Endoskeletal materials compatible for bonding with PS include polystyrene (PS); acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), a similar polymer easily bonded by cyanoacrylate or acrylic-based adhesives; polycarbonate (PC), easily bonded to polystyrene using adhesives such as polystyrene cement, epoxy, or solvent-based adhesives; polyvinyl chloride (PVC) bonded by adhesives like cyanoacrylates, epoxies, or solvent-based adhesives; polyurethane (PU) bonding to polystyrene via polyurethane-based adhesives or other compatible glues; poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA, acrylic) bonded to polystyrene using solvent-based adhesives that can slightly dissolve the surface of both polymers, creating a strong bond as the solvents evaporate.
[1783] Other endoskeletal materials include polyethylene terephthalate (PET), bondable to PS sing adhesives that are compatible with both materials, such as certain epoxies or UV-curable adhesives; polyamide (PAm, nylon) bondable using adhesives like epoxy or with the aid of a primer that can enhance the adhesion between the two polymers; thermoplastic elastomers (TPE) using glue compatible with both materials. More difficult skeletal material candidates to bond include polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene, both of which require prebonding treatments such as radiation or plasmas to induce damage sites for dangling bonds or defects on which PS can attach.
[1784] Solvents for polystyrene include most organic solvents including divinyl benzene (DVBz), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), acetone (ace), toluene, ethyl acetate, tetrahydrofuran (THF), and dichloromethane (DCM). Cross linking agents for PS synthesis include p-hydroxymethyl benzyl chloride (HMe-BnCl), divinyl benzene (DVBz), and dibenzoyl peroxide (DBPO). Membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
11. Functionalized Poly Fluorenyl Ether Ketone Nitrile (PFEKN) Polymer IEMs.
[1785] Another homopolymer, poly (fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile) P(FEKN) is a candidate for high temperature fuel cell applications, especially for operation over 80 C. Although sulfonated poly (fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile) polymers have been used to form low equivalent weight P(FEKN) membranes via one-step polycondensation from commercial raw materials, their measured electrical and mechanical properties were not competitive to other IEM polymers and limited to only high temperature operation.
[1786]
[1787] The second segment 1162s of length m represents the sulfonated group in the heterogenous polymer. Specifically it comprises another BPFL groups 1161s attached to an ether-ketone group 1165 to which two SO.sub.3H ionomers 1163a and 1163b attach. The total length (m+n) of a unit cell contains eleven aromatic hydrocarbon rings largely responsible for controlling the porosity of the cell. Conventional P(FEKN) membrane synthesis does not address or anticipate fundamental problematic issues plaguing their use in IEMs and PEMs including membrane swelling, mechanical strength, film durability, and cathodic reaction rates. By integrating the inventive features of this application, the ionomeric performance of sulfonated P(FEKN) polymers can be greatly enhanced. These elements include (a) sacrificial fillers to enhance film porosity and conductivity, (b) endoskeletal support to improve film strength and durability and to reduce swelling, (c) nanoparticle coating to improve interfacial reaction rates, especially on the cathode side where the slower oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurs, and (d) doping with fillers and PILs to enhance bulk conductivity in the film. None of these features are anticipated in any reported studies.
[1788] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1801] Features of sulfonated poly fluorenyl ether ketone polymers are described in the table below:
TABLE-US-00024 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 11. sulfonated poly heterogenous polymers: PEEK, solv: DMAC, sac filler, CNTs, fluorenyl ether ketone FEKN polymer PPS, PI, TPU. BHPF, DMSO oxides, POSS, nitrile pillars; reinforcing X-L: DHPhthal NPs, MOFs, PIL sPFEKN fillers (C-fiber, CNTs)
[1802] As described sPFEKN is a heteropolymer comprising a sulfonated chain of fluorenylidene diphenol groups bridged by alternating benzonitrile and ether-ketone groups. Endoskeletal compositions compatible with bonding to the membrane include polyether ether ketones (PEEK), polyphenylene sulfide (PPS), polyimide (PI), and thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU). Solvents include reagents similar to those used with PEEK and PEK films including N-dimethyl-acetamide (DMAC), bisphenol fluorene (BHPF), and dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO). Cross linking agents include 2-dihydro-4-(4-hydroxyphenyl)-1(2H)-phthalazone (DHPhthal). Membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
12. Functionalized Polyphenylene (PPh, PP) Polymer IEMs.
[1803] Another broad class of polymers amenable to synthesis of non-fluorinated ion exchange membrane membranes is polyphenylene. Polyphenylenes are macromolecules which comprise benzenoid aromatic nuclei directly joined to one another by CC bonds. As a hydrocarbon based polymer, polyphenylene exhibits a number of beneficial material and electrical qualities. For example, one member of the chemical family, poly (p-phenylene) (PPhP, PPP) can be transformed from an electrical insulator into an electrical conductor or ionomer by doping with electron acceptors or donors. Polyphenylene ether (PPhE, PPE) is noted for its ability to survive temperatures of 320 C. or higher without melting making it a good prospective candidate for high temperature fuel cells.
[1804] It should be noted while it is common practice to abbreviation polyphenylene by the acronym PP, this terminology is identical to the abbreviation for another polymer, polypropylene. As such, throughout this patent unless specifically identified as an exception or contained in an exhaustive list of terms, the acronym PP shall mean polypropylene and the acronym PPh shall mean polyphenylene. This nomenclature is consistent with the convention that phenyl is ofttimes denoted as Ph in chemical formulas to distinguish it from phosphorus P.
[1805]
[1806]
[1807] The process results in a precursor molecule poly(p-phenylene)-phenyloxide-R (PPPh-PhOR) where phenyloxide-R represents an attached sidechain (SC) of a phenol-oxide bound to the radical R. In case (a), treatment of PPPh-PhOR 1171 with sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) resulting in the sidechain polymer poly(benzoyl-1,4-phenylene)SC-sP(BnPh) 1172. Alternatively, PPPh-PhOR 1171 treated with sulfuric acid blended with trimethylsilyl chloride (TMSiCl, TMSCl) results in an extended sidechain polymer poly(p-phenoxybenzoyl-1,4-phenylene) (SC-sP(PhBnPh)) 1173.
[1808]
[1809] For radical R=H.sup.+(Ph) 1184a, the resulting linear polymer is sPhPPh-H.sup.+ or alternatively as sPPP-H.sup.+. For radical R=H.sup.+(NPh) 1184b, the resulting non-linear polymer is sPhPPh-NH.sup.+ or alternatively sPPP-NH.sup.+. For radical R=H.sup.+(BPh).sub.p=H.sup.+(BPh) 1184c, the resulting para-biphenyl polymer is sPhPPh-(B.sub.pPh)H.sup.+or alternatively sPPP-(B.sub.pPh)H.sup.+. Continuing in
[1810] Other radicals R 1182 shown in
[1811] In another variant,
[1812]
[1813] In an alternative method of case (b) the process involves halogenation of un-sulfonated reactant 4,4dibromobiphenyl (DiBr(BPh)) 1288 into 4,4dibromo-3,3biphenyldisulfonic acid (DiBr(BPh)S) 1189 during which sulfonic ionomer 1187 is attached to the polymer. In
[1814]
[1815] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1828] The following table describes the composition of various inventive polyphenylene IEMs:
TABLE-US-00025 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 12. functionalized heterogenous polymers: PPh, solv: CDM, PVDF, sac filler, CNTs, polyphenylene PPh polymer EPX, PUA, SIA, MAA DMF, PEG, NMP, oxides, POSS, PPhDSA, PBPhDSA pillars: reinforcing DMAc, ethanol, NPs, MOFs, PIL sPPh (linear, sidechain, fillers glycol, glycerol, kinked) aliphatic polyols, sPPh-benzoyl MI sPPh-phenoxybenzoyl X-L: heat, sulfur, SDAPP (Diels Alder) peroxide, metal un-sulfonated PPh-R oxides, S donors sPPh-BXPY sidechain SC-sP(BnPh) sidechain SC-sP(PhBnPh) sPPh-QPh/sPhPPh-R +radical R = H.sup.+(TPh) +radical R = H.sup.+(BPh).sub.p +radical R = H.sup.+(BPh).sub.m +radical R = H.sup.+(BPh).sub.o sPhPPh-(DB)H.sup.+ sDAPPh, sPhPPh-H.sup.+ sPhPPh-OH Di(BPh)S-R, DiBr(BPh)S-R sPPh-(X + Y)N sterically hindered SI-P(PhBnPh)
[1829] As listed, polyphenylene (PPh) membranes made in accordance with this invention comprise an expansive list of compounds comprising heterogenous ionomeric polymers. Aside from bonding with itself, PPh can bond with a variety of endoskeletal materials including epoxy resins (EPX), polyurethane adhesives (PUA) especially post surface preparation, silicone adhesives (SiA), and modified acrylic adhesives (MAA). PPh solvents include dichloromethane (CDM), polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF), dimethylformamide (DMF), polyethylene glycol (PEG, PEO), N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), ethanol, glycol, glycerol, aliphatic polyols, and diiodomethane (methylene iodide, MI). Cross linking occurs with heating, sulfur, peroxides, metal oxides, and with sulfur donors. Membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
13. Functionalized Polyarylene Ether (PAE) Polymer IEMs.
[1830] Another class of hydrocarbon based membranes comprise fluorine-free compounds made of the homopolymer polyarylene ether, a high performance thermoplastic with high glass transition temperatures noted for its robust mechanical properties, exceptional thermal stability, and superior chemical resistance. Conventional uses for PAEs include water purification, electrolysis, and ion exchange. PAEs comprise a mainchain featuring alternating rigid aromatic rings and flexible ether bonds, facilitating its high temperature performance and resilience to acid and alkali corrosion, solvent resistance, and oxidative stability. PAE membranes can also be further multi-functionalized to resist contamination from metal ions, microorganisms, bacteria, and other pollutants.
[1831] They may be subcategorized by their different functional groups, namely poly(arylene ether sulfone) (PAES, PAESf) containing sulfone segments in the mainchain; poly(arylene ether ketone) (PAEK) containing ketone segments in the mainchain; and poly(arylene ether nitrile) (PAEN) bonding cyano groups on its sidechain. PAEs are chemically related to polyether ether ketones (PEEK), polyethersulfones (PESf), and poly(arylene ether nitrile)s (PEN) considered elsewhere in this application.
[1832]
[1833] During subsequent functionalization with a radical R of hydrogen ions H.sup.+ or sulfonic acid SO.sub.3H, segment 1203 is transformed into equal length 1203r by converting BPFL 1200p into radical functionalized group 1200r by attaching the acidic groups onto the aromatic rings. All other groups remain unchanged. The functionalization may be performed in a number of ways, one of which involves sulfonation using a 12 h treatment at 15 C. in HSO.sub.3Cl and CH.sub.2Cl.sub.2 while incorporating phosphotungstic acid and graphene oxide to enhance conductivity.
[1834] Alternatively various monomers can be polymerized into a sulfonated polyarylene ether sulfone (SPAES) using processes composite membranes containing poly(2,5-benzimidazole)-grafted graphene oxide. Specifically,
[1835]
[1836] Alternatively
[1837]
[1838] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1852] The following table describes various structural elements of the SPAE class of membranes:
TABLE-US-00026 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 13. sulfonated poly heterogenous polymers: PAE, PS, HIPS, solv: NMP, DMAc, sac filler, CNTs, (arylene ether)s PAE polymers PAm, PEs, PU, ABS, DMSO, DMF, PEG, oxides, POSS, sPAE pillars; reinforcing fillers DGMME NPs, MOFs, PIL, sPFPE (C-fiber, CNTs) X-L: DT, SDT, PFPE PFPE-GO sPAESf
[1853] The various sulfonated polyarylene ethers comprise heterogenous polymers of non-fluorinated sPAE, fluorinated sPFPE, and sulphone based sPAES. Endoskeletal materials compatible with bonding to PAEs include polystyrene (PS) and high-impact polystyrene (HIPS) which share the styrene moiety in the backbone of poly(arylene ether)s; polyamides (PAm, nylon) using appropriate adhesives or surface treatments; polyesters (PEs) using compatibilizers or coupling agents containing carboxyl or anhydride groups to enhance interfacial adhesion; polyurethanes (PU) using adhesives or by interpenetrating polymer networks (IPNs) by synthesizing PU in the presence of PAE; and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS). Solvents for s(PAE)s include N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), dimethylformamide (DMF), polyethylene glycol (PEG, PEO), and diethylene glycol monomethyl ether (DGMME). Cross linkers include dithiol (DT), sulfonated dithiol (SDT), and bishydroxy perfluoropolyether (PFPE). Aside from PFPE-GO crystallites described in the section, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
14. Functionalized Poly Ether Ketone (PEK) Polymer IEMs.
[1854] A special category of polyarylene ether is a class of non-fluorinated thermoplastics heteropolymers referred to as polyether ketones. Collectively referred to as PEK or PEEK these polyether ketones contain any number of ether and ketone groups assembled on a polymer mainchain in varying stoichiometries and sequences. Polyether ketones (PEKs) including polyether ether ketone (PEEK) are formed by the dialkylation of bisphenolate salts, i.e. a process that adds two alkene groups onto the phenylated salt using step-growth polymerization.
[1855] Constructed by a linear polymeric chain of covalently bonded phenyl groups, the resulting semicrystalline matrix exhibits superior mechanical properties and chemical resistance even at elevated temperatures. Aside from mechanical applications of plastics, polyester ketones have chemical applications membrane such as solid polymer electrolysis (SPE) and as proton exchange membranes in fuel cells.
[1856] The basic process for forming a polyether ketone is illustrated in
[1857] Although nascent poly ether ketones are electrical insulators, the polymers area readily functionalized by sulfonic groups to become proton specific ionomeric conductors.
[1858]
[1859]
[1860]
[1861]
[1862]
[1863]
[1864]
[1865] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1879] The following table describes various structural elements of the PEK and PEEK class of membranes:
TABLE-US-00027 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 14. sulfonated poly heterogenous polymers: PEK, PEEK, solv. HNO.sub.3, HF sac filler, CNTs, (ether-ketone)s PEEK polymer PEI, PAI, PAm, PPhS, PU, H.sub.2SO.sub.4, ClPh, DCM, oxides, POSS, sPEK, sPEKK EPX, adhesives (silicone, C.sub.13H.sub.8O, THF, ace NPs, MOFs, PIL sPEEK cyanoacrylates), PTFE X-L: AlCl.sub.3-DCE sPEEK-PEEK pillars: reinforcing fillers K.sub.2CO.sub.3-DCE, HQu, sPEEEK, sPEEKK (C-fiber, CNTs) PhOBnCl-DMAc sPEKKK, sPEKEKK sPEK-PEK (s2PEK)
[1880] The prior table describes the construction of various polyether ether ketone IEMs made in accordance with this invention. Comprising various combinations of ether and ketone groups, the family of heterogenous polymers collectively referred to as PEK or PEEK, may include one-to-three ether groups and one-to-three ketone groups in varying numbers and sequences. Endoskeletal compositions compatible with bonding to polymeric blends of ethers and ketones may include polyetherimide (PEI), polyamide-imide (PAI), and polyphenylene sulfide (PPhS) using high temperature or interlocking adhesives; epoxy resins (EPX); polyurethanes (PU) and cyanoacrylates for lower temperature operation; and with proper pretreatment of the endoskeletal pillars with adhesives comprising silicone and modified acrylics.
[1881] Composite reinforced poly ether ketone membranes blended with polytetrafluoroethylene (PEEK-PTFE) may also bond to PTFE pillars. Alternatively, glues may be used to attach poly ether-ketone based membranes to poly ether-ketone pillars. such as PEK and PEEK. All PEK-PEEK family polymers can be functionalized by sulphonic acid, as denoted by a lowercase prefix s whereby sulfonated PEK is denoted as sPEK, sulfonated PEEK is denoted as sPEEK, etc.
[1882] Solvents may include nitric acid (HNO.sub.3), sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4), hydrofluoric acid (HF), 4-chlorophenol (C.sub.6H.sub.5ClO, ClPh), 9-fluorenone (C.sub.13H.sub.8O), methylene chloride (DCM), tetrahydrofuran (THF, oxolane), acetone (ace), and hexafluoroisopropyll (HFIP). Cross linking agents of poly ester ketone compounds include sodium borohydride (NaBH), bis(hydroxymethyl) (CH.sub.3O). Polymerization agents and catalysts include aluminum chloride in dichloroethane (AlCl.sub.3-DCE) and 4-phenoxybenzoyl chloride (PhOBnCl, C.sub.13H.sub.9ClO.sub.2) in N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc, C.sub.4H.sub.9NO), hydroquinone (HQu, C.sub.6H.sub.6O.sub.2). Membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
15. Functionalized Poly Ether-Sulfone/Ketone-Sulfone Polymer IEMs.
[1883] Another related class of heteropolymers is that of polyether sulfones and poly ketone sulfones. This group includes sulfones combined with ether such as polyether ether sulfone (PEES, PEESf); sulfones combined with ketones such as polyketone ketone sulfone (PKKS, PEESf), or sulfones combined with both ethers and ketones such as poly(arylene ketone ether ketone sulfone) (PAKEKS, PAKEKSf). All poly ether/ketone sulfone moieties including PEESf, PKKSf, and PAKEKSf contain aromatic hydrocarbon rings, i.e. benzene rings. Somewhat confusingly, these aromatic groups are explicitly named in some polymers while the name of other polymers neglects to mention their presence. Moreover, when explicitly identified in a polymer's common chemical name, these aromatic rings may be referred to as arylene, aryne, phenyl, or phenylene depending on its bonding and oxidation states.
[1884] In contrast to 14 describing various combinations of ethers and ketones, polymers described in this section all contain a sulfone group, which may be abbreviated as either S or Sf. The abbreviation S is ambiguous and must be taken in context of the polymer containing it. Other S can be mistakenly confused with the symbol for elemental sulfur. Accordingly, sulfone (S, Sf) is an organosulfur compound having the form RS(O).sub.2R where both oxygen atoms form double bonds to the central sulfur atom. As described, sulfone polymer radicals may comprise an ether group, a ketone, group, or an aromatic hydrocarbon ring. In polymers, sulfones confer numerous beneficial material properties including mechanical strength and resistance to oxidation, corrosion, high temperatures, and creep under stress. Direct comparison between ketone and sulfone groups shows no discernable difference or advantage of one over the other in proton exchange membranes.
[1885] In the case of polyether sulfones such as polyether ether sulfone (PEES, PEESf) 1253 described in section 15 A shown in
[1886]
[1887]
[1888] A PEESf mainchain can also form a copolymer with other polymer types such as poly(ether imide) (PEI) prospectively applicable in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs). As shown in
[1889] Various synthesis methods for forming poly(ether sulfone)s exist, some facile such as self-polycondensation of AB-type monomers. Other processes are more complex. For example,
[1890] More complex copolymerization sequences involve two-step functionalization and cross linking as shown in
[1891] Subsequent treatment in dimethylacetamide (DMAc) at 60 C. on un-fluorinated hydrocarbon 1261n shown in
[1892] The resulting heterogenous polymer 1261p has the chemical name sulfonated poly (1,4-phenylene ether-ether-sulfone)-poly (2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid) (sP(PhEESf)-PAMPS) where the abbreviation Ph refers to the phenylene group 1252s, Sf refers to the sulfone group 1251s, and S refers to sulfonic acid 1054. One prospective process to form such polymers involves the integration of intercalated poly (2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid) into sulfonated poly (1,4-phenylene ether-ether-sulfone). Other ether sulfone monomers combine different sulfone reactants to form a longer chain precursor.
[1893] For example in
[1894] Another process for creating sulfonated fluorinated polyethersulfone is described in
[1895] Subsequent treatment in chlorosulfuric acid-allylsilane (ClSO.sub.3SiMe.sub.3) and sodium methoxide (NaOMe) attaches sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) 1054 to one of the aromatic rings, converting polymer segment 1275 into an ionomeric polymer segment 1275s while leaving segment 1276 undisturbed. The resulting heterogenous polymer comprising ionomeric segment 1275s of length y and un-sulfonated segment 1276 of length x is referred to herein as sulfonated fluorinated polyethersulfone (sFPESf, sFPES). Such functionalized ionomers also referred to as partially-fluorinated polyethersulfone are in their present implementation applicable for high temperature membranes with minimal swelling, but limited in performance at room temperature.
[1896] An alternative membrane synthesis technique shown in
[1897] As shown segment 1304n contains one hydroxy-quaterphenyl (4Ph-OH) group 1301, two esters 1250n, and one sulfone group 1302. In contrast, segment 1305 contains two sulfone groups 1302 and two ethers 1250n. Functionalization by concentrated sulfuric acid (96% H.sub.2SO.sub.4) converts the phenyl groups Ph in hydroxy-quaterphenyl group 1301 to radicals R where is a phenyl group with a sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) ionomer. Since ionomeric radical R substitutes three phenyls, a significant change in the conductivity of segment 1304s is manifested. The resulting heterogenous polymer containing sulfonated segment 1304s and un-sulfonated segment 1305 is referred to herein as poly(phenyl ether sulfone) with the acronym sP(PhESf).
[1898] In the context of 15A on sulfonated polyester sulfones sPESf, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1911] Other related polymers described in section 15B including ketone sulfones and ether-ketone sulfones. As shown in
[1912]
[1913] Exemplary processes for forming ether-sulfone heteropolymers include forming poly(ether-ether sulfone)s and sulfonated poly(ether-ether sulfone)s derived from functionalized 1,1-diphenylethylene derivatives. The subsequent functionalization of PAKEKSf into an ionomeric polymer by sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) 1055, comprises sulfonated segment 1286s with ionomer SO.sub.3H and un-sulfonated segment 1285 is shown in
[1914]
[1915] In
[1916] Various functionalized ionomeric linear copolymers comprising arylene, ester, ketone, and sulfone groups may also be formed. As depicted in
[1917] The resulting sPAEKSf linear copolymer comprises four segmentsa methylated ester sulfone group 1287a, an ester sulfone group 1287b, a sulfonated methyl ester ketone group 1288s; and a sulfonated methyl ester group 1289s. Ionomeric functionalization is achieved through sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3Na) group 1055 attaching to both sulfonated segments 1288s and 1289s of equal length 0.5x. Un-sulfonated groups 1287a and 1287b each of length 0.5y where x and y need not be equal and where the total length n is thereby the sum of the four segments n=(x+y).
[1918] Dopants may also be introduced into sulfonated poly ether sulfone (sPESf, sPES) membranes to enhance conductivity as depicted in
[1919] As shown in
[1920] Bismuth compounds introduced into the polymer matrix can act as reinforcing agents, improving the mechanical strength and durability of the membrane, a feature particularly important for maintaining membrane integrity under operational stress and high-temperature conditions. The incorporation of bismuth permanent fillers can also enhance the flexibility and toughness of the membrane, reducing the likelihood of cracking or tearing. Bismuth compounds incorporated as nanoparticles also create a more uniform and finely structured membrane matrix, enhancing the dispersion of the fillers and improving the overall performance of the membrane. The incorporation of bismuth compounds into the matrix also invoke changes in the morphology of the membrane, such as pore size and distribution, beneficially influencing the membrane's transport properties and improving its overall efficiency. Bismuth enhances chemical stability, rendering making the film more resistant to degradation by chemical species such as free radicals, acids, or bases. Bismuth compounds can also be included in a nanoparticle coating or embedded into the catalyst layer. For example, made in accordance with this invention the addition of these bismuth compounds into the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) accelerate the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), the rate limiting reaction in a PEM fuel cell.
[1921] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1935] The following table describes various structural elements of the hybrid sulfone class of membranes including ether sulfones, ketone sulfones, and ether-ketone sulfone heteropolymers. Sulfone heterogeneous polymers and copolymers comprising combinations of arylene, ketone, esters, and bismuth and copolymers of ether imide and poly(2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid) (PAMPS) collectively comprise a subset of poly(arylene ketone sulfones) and poly(arylene ketone ester sulfones). Numerous ionomer moieties are listed in the table.
[1936] Endoskeletal pillar materials or coatings able to bond to heterogenous sulfone compounds include epoxy adhesives and resins (EPX), polyimides (PI), silicone adhesives, polyurethane (PU), acrylic adhesives, along with other poly arylene ester sulfone, poly arylene ketone sulfone, and poly arylene ester ketone sulfone polymers (PAEKS) and various cyanoacrylates (CAc) including methyl groups (MCA), ethyl groups (ECA), N-butyl (N-BCA), octyl groups). Commonly abbreviated as CA cyanoacrylates herein as referred to as CAc to avoid confusion with citric acid (CA).
TABLE-US-00028 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 15. ether sulfone, ketone heterogenous polymers: EPX, solv: DMSO, sac filler, CNTs, sulfone, ether-ketone sulfone polymers HF-IPS, PAEK, PU, NMP, Bz, xyl, oxides, POSS, sulfone heteropolymers +arylene PI, CAc tol NPs, MOFs, PIL sPESf +ketone pillars: X-L: Bz, BnOH, sPEESf +esters reinforcing fillers DMF, NMP sPEDSf +bismuth (C-fibers, CNTs) sPEESf-co-PEI sulfone sP(PhEESf)-co-PAMPS copolymers sFPESf +ether imide sPKKSf +PAMPS sPAKEKSf (s2PAKES) sPAEKSf SPES-BiTMA SPES-Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6
[1937] Solvents used in forming ether sulfone and ketone sulfone polymers include dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), benzene (Bz), xylene (xyl), toluene (tol), hexafluoroisopropyl alcohol (HF-IPA). Solvents and cross linkers used in polymerization include N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), N-methyl pyrrolidone (NMP), and biphenyl A (BPA), benzene (Bz), and benzyl alcohol (BnOH, cresol). Aside from the bismuth crystallites and nanoparticles BiTMA and Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6 described in the section, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
[1938] Although described separately in the previous sections, poly arylene ethers (PAEs) include poly arylene ketones, poly ether ketones, poly ether sulfones, poly ketone sulfones, and poly ether ketone sulfonesall of which include an arylene group. Arylene is a broad class of bivalent radicals (as phenylene) derived from an aromatic hydrocarbons by removal of a hydrogen atom from each of two carbon atoms of the nucleus.
16. Functionalized Hybrid Polymer IEMs with Carbon Fillers.
[1939] In common speech, the term hybrid means the mixing two or more different components in the composition of something. In the lexicon of chemistry and material science, the term hybrid is more definitive, applying both to the nature of chemical bonding and to materials formed therefrom. Specifically in localized valence theory, a hybrid chemical bond comprises atomic orbitals of different yet interacting elements or molecules sufficiently similar to accommodate persistent electrostatic attraction. If the attraction is sufficiently strong and the orbitals reasonably compatible, a chemical bond will result.
[1940] Although all chemical bonds are governed by physics, specifically the laws of electromagnetics defined by Maxwell and Gauss, the type of bond, namely Van der Waals, hydrogen, ionic, or covalent depends on the attractive force between atoms and other factors such as 3D-shape. Specifically if the outer atomic shell of an element is completely filled, the element is generally unreactive, e.g. in the case of group VIII (group 18) noble gasses like neon and xenon.
[1941] In the cases of elements having one fewer or one more electron than a fully filled electronic shell, chemical reactivity in such high electronegative or electropositive elements such as Li, Na, K, and F is significant, often leading to ionic bonds. Fluorine forms especially strong bonds to carbon, which explains the chemical resilience of PTFE. Other factors enabling or preventing hybrid bonds include quantum mechanical effects such as orbital splitting and the Pauli exclusion principle, polar vs nonpolar molecules, and hydrophobicity vs hydrophilicity.
[1942] Hybrid bonding is an especially important factor in forming manmade crystals such as GaAs, GaN, and InP; and in forming hybrid polymers. Specifically in polymer chemistry, a hybrid polymer is a material containing two or more different types of molecules. Hybrid polymers either comprise a copolymer comprising two different polymers bonding by a cross linking molecule such as glutaraldehyde, formaldehyde, etc. Copolymers generally involve independent synthesis of the separate monomers later polymerized into homopolymer strands and subsequently cross-linked to form the homopolymers.
[1943] The separate strands may be arranged linearly on a common mainchain, may form branches off of one another, or may comprise distinct backbones bridged together by cross-linking ligands. If the homopolymer segments are long, the copolymers are referred to as block polymers (discussed later in the application. A heteropolymer by contrast comprises dissimilar monomers polymerized into a heterogenous backbone concurrently, i.e. the monomers are contemporaneously polymerized and linked.
[1944] Another form of hybrid polymer is any homopolymer and heteropolymer doped by a permanent filler such as carbon, silicates, zeolites, tungsten crystals, POSS, MOFs or other additives. Herein, copolymeric and doped membranes are therefore referred to as hybrid polymers. In the context of this invention, a carbon filled membrane is a polymeric membrane containing permanent fillers containing carbon compounds, crystals, and matrices such as pristine graphene, graphene oxides, carbon nanotubes, carbon nanospheres, carbon nanofibers, and other carbon compounds. Other allotropes of carbon include diamond, graphite, ionsdaleite, buckminsterfullerene (C.sub.60), fullerene (C.sub.540 and C.sub.70), amorphous carbon, cyclocarbon, carbon nanobuds, schwarzites, glassy carbon, and linear acetylenic carbon (carbyne).
[1945] Among these, carbon nanotubes (CHTs) represent a highly useful allotrope of carbon comprising hollow tubes made of rolled up sheet of graphene, i.e. single atomic layers of carbon. Shown in
[1946] As a material, carbon nanotubes exhibit extraordinary tensile strength, high thermal conductivity, and high durability. Although pure carbon nanotubes is considered a moderate conductor, surface treatment with ionomeric groups and metals can dramatically influence its conductivity much like chemical doping of semiconductors such as silicon can change its conductivity by many orders-of-magnitude.
[1947] Using the classic electronic shell terminology for the periodic table of elements, carbon like silicon is a group 14 (or classically group IV) element, meaning both carbon and silicon contain four valance electrons in a shell requiring eight electrons to complete. Covalent bonding with itself or other group IV elements can result in complete elimination of ionized conduction electrons, making CNT behavior that of a semiconductor. As a semiconductor, minor changes in the concentration of surface dopants can dramatically influence conduction. As such, doping CNTs can greatly enhance conductivity by forming surface bonds easily ionized. For example any bond broken at energies less than the thermal energy kT/q, 0.026 eV at room temperature, releases a free electron into the conduction band contributing to conduction. In this sense, carbon nanotubes electrical conductivity ranges from that of a good conductor to that of a semiconductor. Interestingly, the bandgap of a CNT decreases with its diameter, meaning the larger the CNT, the more conductive it becomes.
[1948] A CNT can also be functionalized by attaching ionomeric or catalytic groups onto its surface. Conversely insulating CNTs can be made through oxidation of carbon surfaces. Functionalization of carbon nanotubes has many diverse uses including electromechanical actuation using ionic polymer metal composite actuators based on sulfonated poly(1,4-phenylene ether-ether-sulfone)-carbon nanotubes. Other processes attach functional groups to the CNT surface. For example, as shown in
[1949] Carbon nanotubes can be used to enhance Nafion membranes by introducing functionalized multiwalled carbon nanotubes into the polymer. As shown in
[1950] Exemplary ionomeric activation of functionalized carbon nanotubes is depicted in
[1951] As such, the inclusion of functionalized or un-functionalized carbon nanotubes into a polymer can affect its mechanical and electrical properties. Nanotubes can also influence film morphology. The diameters of CNTs is measured in nanometers with single walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) having diameters between 0.5 nm to 2 nm. With lengths up to several microns or longer, CNTs can have length-to-width aspect ratios of 4000. Comparable in dimension to long polymers, the presence of long CNTs in a membrane can affect crystallinity, porosity, and fuel crossover. One problem is that CNTs are so small they may be mobile under certain conditions, escaping from the membrane if they are not properly tethered or constrained. One such method is to employ an endoskeleton and membrane nanocoating to constrain their movement in a manner similar to the inventive embodiment herein used to prevent leakage of ionic liquids (ILs).
[1952] Made in accordance with this invention, carbon nanotubes may be used in a variety of beneficial ways in a ionomeric membrane, namely, [1953] as a permanent filler comprising unfunctionalized CNTs added to endoskeletal pillars providing enhance mechanical strength, improved film rigidity, and greater thermal conductivity, [1954] as a permanent filler added to a catalyst layer comprising a catalyst functionalized nanotubes to enhance reaction rates, particularly for cathode side oxygen reduction reactions (ORRs), [1955] as a permanent filler added to an ion exchange membrane comprising a metal or ionomer functionalized CNT to enhance conductivity. [1956] as a permanent filler added to an ion exchange membrane comprising CNTs which together with the application of sacrificial fillers, control the porosity of a ion exchange membrane.
[1957] Aside from the use of carbon nanotubes, graphene oxides (GO) comprise another category of carbon filler beneficial as a permanent filler in an ion membrane. Unlike CNTs which behave as metals or semiconductor depending on doping, graphene oxide function as two-dimensional semimetals. One prospective process for functionalizing GO involves sulfonating poly(arylene ether sulfone) to form a composite membrane with perfluorosulfonic acid containing perfluoropolyether grafted graphene oxide. Graphene oxide may be functionalized 1371 by Krytox-157-FS, a fluorinated surfactant 1370 to produce perfluoro-polyether grafted graphene oxide (PFPE-GO) 1372.
[1958] Another prospective process involves introducing a poly(2,5-benzimidazole)-grafted graphene oxide into proton exchange membrane to enhance conductance.
[1959] Another functionalized GO variant comprising poly (3,4-benzimidazole) graphene oxide (ABPI-GO) substrate shown in
[1960]
[1961] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[1975] The following table describes carbon filled ionomeric and catalytic polymers and membranes:
TABLE-US-00029 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 16. carbon filled heterogenous polymers: matched solv: matched to sac filler, CNTs, polymers carbon filled to IEM ionomer IEM polymer; oxides, POSS, PFSA-PTFE polymers pillars: reinforcing X-L: cross linkers NPs, MOFs, PIL PFSA-PVA-PTFE fillers (C-fibers, CNTs) matched to IEM including CNTs, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES polymer type GO sPVA PBI, CS
[1976] Unlike previously cited polymers, the addition of permanent carbon fillers is agnostic to the polymer used to form a membrane or to construct the endoskeletal. Instead in accordance with this invention, carbon compounds confer several unexpected benefits including (a) carbon fiber or un-functionalized nanotubes can be embedded into inert pillars to mechanically strengthen the membrane's endoskeletal support, (b) catalyst or scavenger functionalized nanoparticles or carbon functionalized nanotubes as a coating to improve catalytic activity and balance redox reaction rates and/or protect against catalyst poisoning, and (c) permanent fillers comprising functionalized carbon nanotubes and/or functionalized graphene oxides to enhance film conductivity, control film porosity, improve membrane strength, reduce polymer swelling, and manage fuel crossover in DMFCs.
17. Functionalized Hybrid Polymer IEMs with Silica Fillers.
[1977] Although intrinsically not as electrically or chemically active as carbon fillers, silicon based fillers can also be functionalized to improve conductivity while enhancing film strength. Silicon, the most carbon-like element in the periodic table is another group IV element with four filled valance electrons in an eight electron shell. As such, silicon can be processed to form insulators such as amorphous glass and oxides; to form semiconductors comprising a hyper-pure single-crystal ingots, wafers, chips, and nanoparticles; and to form conductors of metal crystallites and quasi-crystals.
[1978] A comparison of silicates, i.e. oxidized silicon is available online, e.g. on Britannica website, and through various papers discussing the formation and uses of large-pore mesostructured cellular foam (MCF) silica. The electrical behavior of oxidized silicon compounds is closely related to chemical morphology, structures which include amorphous structures 1401 such as silicon dioxide (SiO.sub.2) 1400; crystalline forms 1403 such as nesosilicates ((SiO.sub.4).sup.4) 1402; and silica MCF 1404 aka mesostructured cellular foam 1406. MCF 1404 particles are considered foam-like as they comprise semi-hollow silica spheroids 1405c with windows 1405w. These spheroids easily bond to hydroxide (OH) outside the spheroid boundary.
[1979]
[1980] A process to functionalize mesoporous silica nanospheres is illustrated in
[1981]
[1982] By contrast, MCF assisted vehicular transport of protons shown in
[1983] Because excess protons in the matrix form hydrogen bonds with water (H.sub.2O) molecules shown as dotted lines, the spider-web of hydrogen bonds provides additional structural support to the matrix of ionomers and polymers. For example through this tenuous fluid network, ionomer 1423b indirectly bonds polymer backbone 1421b to polymer backbone 1421a even there is no covalent bonding between the two polymer mainchains. The addition of mesostructured cellular foam 1430 further contributes to the hydrogen bonding network by forming additional hydrogen bonds between water droplets in the matrix and the O.sup. and OH groups present of the MCF's surface. In this manner, the introduction of mesostructured cellular foam 1430 a permanent filler in the membrane helps regulate water sorption and membrane swelling. This mechanism occurs even if the MCF is not functionalized by sulfonic acid, i.e. even if there are no SO.sub.3 groups present on the surface of MCF 1430.
[1984] Note that
[1985] The process of doping a membrane involves introducing the MCF into the mold during casting. The morphological and electrical changes to the otherwise undoped pristine ionomer depend on the species of MCF added during synthesis. For example as shown in
[1986] Silica based mesostructured cellular foam can given the right conditions and adequate time be processed to exhibit self-assembly of macrostructures. As shown in
[1987] Made in accordance with this invention include channel-embedded aluminum-substituted mesoporous silica may be used to enhance conductivity in high-temperature anhydrous proton-exchange membrane fuel cells. These self assembled silica crystallites form a mesostructured inorganic solid surfactant composite 1444 which can be further modified by calcination, i.e. heating solids at a high temperature to remove volatile substances or oxidizing a specific amount of mass, to form a honeycomb silicate structure referred to as mesoporous silica 1445. The mesoporous silica is then functionalized by grafting aluminum or other metals onto the substrate to form an isomeric MCF comprising Al-grafted mesoporous silica 1446 as illustrated in the transmission electron micrograph 1447. The aluminum MCF ionomer can then be introduced into a non-fluorinated membrane such as phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) for use in a direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC).
[1988] One such process for Al-MCF doping of PBI is shown in
[1989] Doping of PBI with permanent fillers of Al-MCF is important in high temperature fuel cells, i.e. operating above 100 C. to prevent acid leaching from the membranes while limiting fuel crossover. The introduction of an Al-substituted hexagonally ordered mesoporous silica (Al-MCM) channel into poly(2,2-m-(phenylene)-5,5-bibenzimidazole) (m-PBI) membrane markedly enhances the reliability of a PBI membrane. Moreover Al-MCM channels enables a mPBI composite membrane to absorb increased H.sub.3PO.sub.4, thereby improving proton conductivity and high temperature fuel cell performance.
[1990] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2004] The following table describes the use of silica fillers in a variety of polymeric membranes:
TABLE-US-00030 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 17. silica filled heterogenous polymer: matched solv: matched to HMS-PA, Si-MCF, polymers silica filled to IEM polymer; IEM polymer; MCF-SO.sub.3H, MCF-OH, PFSA-PTFE polymers pillars: reinforcing X-L: cross linkers MCF-NH.sub.2, Al-MCF PFSA-PVA-PTFE fillers (C-fiber, CNTs, matched to IEM sac filler, CNTs, SPAESs, sPEEK, silica, silicates) polymer type oxides, POSS, sPEESf NPs, MOFs, PIL sPVA, CS PBI, PBU-co-Al-MCF
[2005] Heterogenous membranes comprising a variety of polymers doped with hollow phosphoric acid doped mesoporous silica (HMS-PA), mesostructured cellular foam (silica MCF) including MCF-SO.sub.3H, hydroxy MCF, or MCF-NH.sub.2; and Al-grafted mesoporous silica 1446 especially when forming a hybrid membrane with poly (2,2-m-(phenylene)-5,5-bibenzimidazole) aka mPBI. The construction of the endoskeleton and membrane depend on the polymer itself, not on the high temperature capable silica filler. The permanent silica filler may however be combined with the sacrificial filler process described herein to further control conductivity and fuel crossover.
18. Functionalized Hybrid Perfluoro-Methyl-Dioxolane (PFMMD-Co-PFSA) Copolymer IEMs.
[2006] Compared to glassy amorphous membranes made of perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane (PFMMD) homopolymers described in 3, another approach to forming ionomeric membranes comprises forming a copolymer of PFMMD with perfluorinated sulfonic acid (PFSA). As described previously PFSA films are attached to polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) backbone providing mechanical rigidity but limiting gas perfusion by its semi-crystalline morphology. Although PFSA membranes with PTFE polymeric backbones offer good mechanical strength, the ionomer suffers significant mass-transport losses and excessive heating at high currents, thereby limiting its useful power density, especially at low Pt loadings. Replacing PTFE mainchains with PFMMD introduces amorphous areas improving charge transport and enhancing film conductivity.
[2007] An exemplary process to synthesize the amorphous polymer poly(perfluoro-2-methylene-4-methyl-1,3-dioxolane) (PFMMD) made in accordance with a Dupont patent is illustrated in
[2008]
[2009]
[2010]
[2011]
[2012] Combining the PFMDD version of monomer 1504 where RfCF.sub.3 with PFMD monomer 1504f forms a structurally related copolymer poly(PFMDD-co-PFMD) 1513r except for the different radical Rf. In shorthand the tri-copolymer is referred to as P(PFMDD-co-PFMD) 1515r. Although the generic structure of the copolymer with radical R.sub.f is labelled as 1513r, the specific instance where R.sub.fCF.sub.3, i.e. P(PFMDD-co-PFMD) is referred to a 1513m.
[2013] Alternatively combining the aforementioned PFMMD version of monomer 1504 where R.sub.fF with chlorotrifluoroethylene (CTFE) 1514 forms the copolymer poly(PFMMD-co-CTFE) 1515r or in shorthand as P(PFMMD-co-CTFE). Combining the PFMDD version of monomer 1504 where RfCF.sub.3 with chlorotrifluoroethylene (CTFE) 1514 forms the copolymer poly(PFMDD-co-CTFE) 1515r or in shorthand as P(PFMDD-co-CTFE). Although the generic structure for both copolymers with radical R.sub.f is labelled as 1515r, the specific instance P(PFMMD-co-CTFE) where R.sub.fF is numbered as 1515p and where the copolymer P(PFMDD-co-CTFE) where RfCF.sub.3 is numbered as 1515m.
[2014] Unfortunately, perfluorodioxolane polymers forming amorphous glassy membranes while good for gas separation, are neither catalytic nor ionomeric and not useful for electrolysis, in dialysis, or in fuel cells. As such, process and structural modifications are necessary to adapt these polymers for electrochemical applications. As shown in
[2015]
[2016] These benefits of an amorphous are illustrated schematically in
[2017] Shown in
[2018] Made in accordance with this invention a new class of linear copolymer is described comprising a tri-copolymer of perfluoro (methylene-r) dioxolane copolymers with perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA). The benefits of the new membranes are numerous. Advantages of the new tri-copolymers include: [2019] compared to other perfluoro (methylene-r) dioxolane (PFMD) homopolymers and copolymers, the new tri-copolymer membranes are ionomeric where PFMDs are not because they contain a conductive sulfonic group 1566 [2020] the ionomeric group in the new tri-copolymer can optionally bond to various catalytic groups including metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and other permanent fillers rendering the membrane useful for catalysis and filtering, [2021] compared to pristine perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA), the new membrane is mechanically stronger and less susceptible to swelling and water logging, and [2022] compared to PFSA-PTFE heteropolymers, the amorphous portions of the film offer superior gas transport and higher conductivity than the semi-crystalline portions of a PTFE supported ionomer.
[2023] One variant of the PTFE-free tri-copolymer shown in
[2024] Another variant of the PTFE-free tri-copolymer shown in
[2025] A second category of the PTFE-free tri-copolymers shown in
[2026] Another PTFE-free tri-copolymer shown in
[2027] A third category of the PTFE-free tri-copolymers is shown in
[2028] Another PTFE-free tri-copolymer shown in
[2029] Made in accordance with this invention, the tri-copolymers of
[2030] In summary membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2045] The following table describes various structural elements of the perfluoro-2-methylene-4,5-dimethyl-1,3-dioxolane (PFMDD) and methylene-methyl-dioxolane copolymers (PMMD) backbone class of membranes including perfluorinated sulfonic acid (PFSA), PFMD, chlorotrifluoroethylene (CTFE), and pentafluorostyrene (PFSt) compounds:
TABLE-US-00031 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 18. methylene-methyl- hybrid polymers: PVDF, PU, solv: DMF, HFB, sac filler, CNTs, dioxolane copolymers PFMMD PS, PFMD, PFMMD, DEC, PVA. oxides, POSS, PFMMD-co-PFSA copolymers PMMA, PFMDD. X-L: FBzO, NPs, MOFs, PIL PFMDD-co-PFSA pillars: reinforcing FDTBO, PFDMO. PFMD-co-PFSA fillers (C-filler, CNTs). PFMMD-co-PFMD-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-PFMD-co-PFSA PFMD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA PFMMD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA PFMD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA PFMMD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA PFMDD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA
[2046] Section 3 describes pristine heteropolymer IEMs of PMMDD and PFSA, whereas the above table describes glassy amorphous hybrid IEMs of composite reinforced membranes comprising copolymers of PFMMD related polymers including PFMMD, PDMDD, PFMD, or any other polymer such as PFSt or CTFE having large groups that interfere with polymer crystallinity. Although any number of endoskeletal materials may be used in pillar construction, molecules of similar composition to the membrane such as PFMD, PFMMD, PFMDD, PMMA, PU, and PVDF offer better bonding strength then hydrophobic perfluorinated materials.
[2047] Exemplary solvents include dimethylformamide (DMF), hexafluorobenzene (HFB), and diethyl carbonate (DEC). During synthesis, cross linking agents include perfluorodibenzoyl peroxide (FBzO).sub.2 or simply FBzO, perfluoro-di-tert-butyl peroxide (FDTBO), and perfluoro-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDMO). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here. Applications of glassy amorphous membranes of copolymers include gas separation membranes and proton exchange membranes for hydrogen fuel cells.
19. Functionalized Hybrid Phenylenediamine (PDD) Copolymer IEMs.
[2048] Another category of glassy or amorphous copolymers are those related to poly(dioxo-dihydro) compounds. The synthesis of one such compound PDDP-CSFS is shown in
[2049] Subsequent treatment in stabilizer 1,4-dioxane and benzoyl peroxide (BPO) for 24 h at 80 C. produces the linear copolymer poly(2,5-dioxo-2,5-dihydro-1H-pyrrole-1-carbonyl) sulfonyl fluoride-co-styrene (PDDP-CSF-co-St, PDDP-CSFS) 1574 with sulfonic acid ionomer 1574. In a parallel process shown in
[2050]
[2051] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2065] Whereas section 3 describes pristine heteropolymer IEMs of PDD and PFSA, the characteristics of PDD and PDDP copolymer membranes are described in the below table:
TABLE-US-00032 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 19. phenylenediamine hybrid PDD polymers: PAm, PU, solv: DMF, HFB, sac filler, CNTs, PDD copolymers copolymers PI, aramid fiber, EPX DEC, PVA. oxides, POSS, PDDP-CSFS pillars: reinforcing X-L: FBzO, NPs, MOFs, PIL PDDP-CSFS-co-SPmax fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) FDTBO, PFDMO.
[2066] Copolymer ionomers comprise phenylenediamine linear chains copolymerized with carbonyl-sulfanoyl fluoride, and sulfonated phenylsulfonyl biphenyl monomers. Exemplary solvents include dimethylformamide (DMF), hexafluorobenzene (HFB), and diethyl carbonate (DEC). During synthesis, cross linking agents include perfluorodibenzoyl peroxide (FBzO).sub.2 or simply FBzO, perfluoro-di-tert-butyl peroxide (FDTBO), and perfluoro-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDMO). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here. Applications of glassy amorphous membranes of copolymers include gas separation membranes and proton exchange membranes for hydrogen fuel cells.
20. Functionalized Hybrid Phenyl Copolymer IEMs.
[2067] Linear chains of phenyl may also be used to form ionomeric copolymers, especially in the form of phenyl-co-alkanes and phenyl-co-aldehydes. An alkane is a molecule incorporating an acyclic, i.e. open chain saturated hydrocarbon, comprising hydrogen and carbon atoms arranged in a tree structure in which all the carbon-carbon bonds are single. In phenyl-co-alkanes linear chain polymers, alkanes form the linkage between various phenyl moieties. For example, in
[2068] As shown in step 3 of
[2069] Step 5 of
[2070] An exemplary process for formation of a phenol sulfonic acid membrane is depicted in
[2071] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2085] The following table describes characteristics of hybrid phenyl based ionomeric copolymers, which may be subdivided into two classes, namely alkane and aldehydes, describing the functional groups attached to the aromatic ring. Easily functionalized by sulfonic acid, hybrid phenyl copolymers comprise linear copolymers alternating phenyl or phenol groups with either alkane or aldehyde strands.
TABLE-US-00033 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 20. phenyl copolymers hybrid Ph polymers: EPX, PU, solv: EtOH, IPA, ace, sac filler, CNTs, sPh-alkane copolymers PI, PS, PVA, PAm, PAc MIBK, ETAC, TCM, tol oxides, POSS, sPh-aldehyde pillars: reinforcing X-L: Ziegler-Natta NPs, MOFs, PIL fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) catalyst, BF.sub.3, SnCl.sub.4, SbF.sub.3, TiCl.sub.4.
[2086] Endoskeletal polymers able to bond to phenyl aldehydes include epoxy resins (EPX) through covalent bonding between aldehyde groups; polyurethanes (PU) through hydroxyl to polyol bonds; polystyrene (PS, PSt) which is an alkylbenzene able to bond to alkanes; polyacrylates (PAc) made from acrylic acids able to form ester linkages with alcohol groups on a phenyl-alkane chain; polyvinyl (PVA) reacting with aldehyde groups of phenyl-aldehydes to form hemiacetals or acetals; polyimides (PI) synthesized from diamines and diacids able to form amide bonds to amino group or a carboxylic acid group on phenyl-alkane or phenyl-aldehyde chains.
[2087] Solvents of the phenyl group in phenol based polymers include ethanol (EtOH, CH.sub.3CH.sub.2OH); IPA (2-propanol, isopropyl alcohol); acetone (ace, 2-propanone, dimethyl ketone), MIBK (4-methylpentan-2-one, (CH.sub.3).sub.LCHCH.sub.2C(O)CH.sub.3)); ethyl acetate (ETAC, EtOAc, ethyl ethanoate, C.sub.4H.sub.8O.sub.2); chloroform (TCM, trichloromethane, CHCl.sub.3); and toluene (tol, toluol, C.sub.6H.sub.5CH.sub.3, PhCH.sub.3). Polymerization of alkanes can be performed using Ziegler-Natta catalysts prepared by reacting certain transition metal halides with organometallic reagents such as alkyl aluminum, lithium and zinc reagents. Aldehyde polymerization is catalyzed by boron trifluoride (BF.sub.3), tin tetrachloride (SnCl.sub.4), antimony trifluoride (SbF.sub.3), and titanium tetrachloride (TiCl.sub.4). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
21. Functionalized Hybrid Polystyrene (PS, PSt) Copolymer IEMs.
[2088] While section 10 describes pristine polyolefin sulfonated polystyrene membranes, this section describes copolymers of polystyrene (PS, PSt) used to form hybrid IEMs. As described, polystyrene can form copolymers with itself through multi-chain cross linking, linear copolymers with polystyrene sulfonates, grafted polymers with perfluoroalkoxy alkanes, copolymers with polyurethane thermoplastics, and linear mainchains comprising both rigid and flexible polystyrene segments.
[2089] Like many polyolefins, pure polystyrene is not a good electrical conduction, but can be functionalized by sulphonic acid or other acid groups to form ionomers, or functionalized by bonded metallic groups, fillers, or dopants to form catalytic groups. Made in accordance with this invention, both ionomeric and catalytic IEMs of polystyrene can be rendered useful for application of filtering, purification, electrolysis, and membrane fuel cells.
[2090]
[2091] Another way to improve gas transport while increasing film strength is achieved through cross linking between or among multiple sPTFS backbones as depicted by cross-linked sulfonated poly(trifluorostyrene) (sPTFS-X) 1619. Although cross linking may involve an organic ligand such as glutaraldehyde, in other instances a shared ionomer may perform the same function through electrostatic cross linking, even if the ionomer is covalently bonded to only one PSt mainchain. For example, sPTFS-X 1619 illustrates poly(trifluorostyrene) 1619p of chain length n is bonded to a second poly(trifluorostyrene) 1619m or chain length m through an acidic cross link 1620x comprising two phenyl groups sharing a common sulfonic acid 1054x.
[2092]
[2093] It should be noted that although nascent ethylene (H.sub.2CCH.sub.2) and butylene (H.sub.2CCHC.sub.2H.sub.x) contain carbon-to-carbon double bonds, in the polymeric forms secondary bonds to the polymer's mainchain eliminates the double bond by usurping the unused extra electron. As shown, polystyrene segment 1621a contains unfunctionalized polystyrene groups PS and sulfonated portions sPSS with sulphonic acid (SO.sub.3H) 1054 attached to the aromatic ring. As such, the hybrid copolymer is referred to as polystyrene-co-polystyrene-sulfonate (PS-co-sPSS). Given the linking role of the polyethylene (PE) 1621b and polybutylene (PBu) 1621c groups, a more complete name for the copolymer is polystyrene-co-polystyrene-sulfonate-co-polyethylene-co-polybutylene (PS-co-sPSS-co-PE-PBu). The fully descriptive moniker, however is not required as the PE and PBu groups do not influence conductivity and have minimal impact of porosity.
[2094] Another approach to manage strength and porosity of polystyrene ionomers is by grafting of sulfonated polystyrene to other polymer mainchains. In
[2095] Polystyrene (PSt) ionomers can also form copolymers with polyurethane (PU). As depicted in
[2096] The resulting copolymer as shown is thermoplastic polyurethane-co-polystyrene sulfonate-co-sulfonated divinyl benzene (PTPU-co-PSS-co-sDVB). The hydrogen bonding of thermoplastic urethane to sulfonated polystyrene divinyl benzene has applications in electrodialysis but using embodiments of this invention can be enhanced for use in fuel cell applications.
[2097] Another benefit of TPU is its ability to control rigidity, whereas soft and hard segments imparts rubber-like and glass-like characteristics to the backbone. While soft segments include polyether or polyurethane ester (PUE) having molecular weights of 1000-3000, the hard TPU segments include complexes of polyurethane diisocyanate with diols. The combination of hard and soft segments influences mechanical film properties affecting permeation rate and selectivity in gas separation, desalination and pervaporation membranes, and gas permeability in ion exchange membranes.
[2098] The topographical impact of blending flexible polyurethane-ester (PUE) 1630 with rigid scaffolding 1631 is depicted schematically in
[2099] The PSS ionomers 1627s further form hydrogen bonds 1628 to DVB ligands 16251 thereby facilitating cross linking between the polystyrene (PSt) 1627p mainchain and the PTU-co-PUE linear copolymer 1630 and 1631. The result is a quatre-copolymer comprising thermoplastic polyurethane-co-polyurethane-ester-co-sulfonated divinyl benzene-co-polystyrene-sulfonate or PTPU-co-PUE-co-DVB-co-PSS 1629. The membrane may also be doped with electroconductive polyaniline as a permanent filler. Polyaniline is a conducting polymer and organic semiconductor of the semi-flexible rod polymer family.
[2100] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2114] In order to form PSt conductive ionomers, copolymers of polystyrene are beneficial to control conductivity and porosity. Examples include linear and cross linked poly(trifluorostyrene) (PTFS and PTFS-X); poly(perfluoroalkoxy alkane) grafted copolymers with polystyrene sulfonic acid (P(PFA)-g-PSSA), and polystyrene-sulfonate copolymers (PS-co-sPSS). Styrene-urethane copolymers include poly(thermoplastic-polyurethane-divinylbenzene-co-polystyrene-sulfonate) aka P(TPU-co-DVB-co-PSS) optionally blended with other homopolymers such as polyurethane-ester P(TPU-co-PUE-DVB-co-PSS). The following table describes elements of polystyrene copolymers:
TABLE-US-00034 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 21A. styrene copolymers hybrid PSt polymers: PS-PU, solv. PVDF, NH.sub.4I, sac filler, CNTs, linear PTFS copolymers ABS, PC, PE, PP, Na.sub.2SO.sub.4, DMAc, oxides, POSS, cross linked PTFS-X PVC, PET, PMMA BzOH, EtOAc NPs, MOFs, PIL, P(PFA)-g-PSSA pillars; reinforcing X-L: heat, (BzO).sub.2, polyaniline PS-co-sPSS fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) (OHMe)-BnCl 21B. styrene-urethane copolymer PTPU-co-sDVB-co-PSS PTU-co-PTUE-co-sDVB-co- PSS
[2115] Endoskeletal polymers may include polystyrene-polyurethane (PS-PU) blends; acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) which bonds to polystyrene through solvent welding dissolving both polymers and welding their surfaces together; polycarbonates (PC) bonded to polystyrene using solvent bonding or with special adhesives that bond to both polymers; polyethylene and polyproline (PE, PP) bondable to polystyrene only following surface treatments such as corona, plasma, or flame treatment whereby PSt surface energy is increased, allowing for better adhesion with adhesives or by using specialized bonding agents; polyvinyl chloride (PVC) bonding to PSt using adhesives compatible with both materials or via solvent welding; polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bonded to polystyrene using suitable adhesives; polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) bonded to polystyrene using solvent bonding similar to ABS; or by thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs) through over-molding.
[2116] Solvents of polystyrene include polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF), ammonium iodide (NH.sub.4I), sodium sulfate (Na.sub.2SO.sub.4), dimethylacetamide (DMAc), benzaldehyde (BzOH), and ethyl acetate (EtOAc). Polymerization of polystyrene is prepared by free radical addition polymerization of styrene in the presence of benzoyl peroxide (BzO).sub.2 as a catalyst. Post polymerization cross linking include p-hydroxymethyl benzyl chloride (OHMe-BnCl). Polyaniline is a conductive filler and dopant compatible with polystyrene. Other membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
22. Functionalized Hybrid Polysulfone (PSU, PSf) Polymer IEMs.
[2117] A superior albeit more expensive alternative to polycarbonate, polysulfone is a high temperature thermoplastic with superior hydrolytic, thermal, and oxidative stability. Containing an aryle-SO.sub.2-aryle subunit, three forms of polysulfone comprise three moietiespolysulfone (PSU, PSf) described in this section, polyethersulfone (PES, PESU, PESf) discussed in sections 13, 15, 33, 37 and polyphenylene sulfone (PPSU).
[2118]
[2119] As shown in
[2120] The resulting sulfonated polysulfone (sPSU) 1639 as shown contains on average one sulfonic acid group (SO.sub.3H) for every four aromatic rings. The molecule is considered a hybrid polymer or heteropolymer because the repeating segments on the mainchain alternate between a sulfone group and a methylated group. Because the two segments are however formed concurrently, the backbone while a heteropolymer is not classified as a copolymer.
[2121] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2135] The following table describes the construction of polysulfone heteropolymer hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00035 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 22. polysulfone hybrid PSf polymers: PEEK, PEI, solv: NMP, DMAc, sac filler, CNTs, heteropolymers polymers PBI, PAm, PE, PP, DMF, CHCl.sub.3, CdCL.sub.2 oxides, POSS, sPSf-PSf PC, ABS, PU X-L: FeCl.sub.3, SbCl.sub.5, NPs, MOFs, PIL pillars; reinforcing BMP, TPO, TMPTA fillers (C-fiber, CNTs)
[2136] Linear heteropolymers of sulfonated polysulfone (sPSU, sPSf) and un-sulfonated polysulfone (PSU, PSf) represent the cost common instances of hybrid PSf copolymers. Endoskeletal pillar materials compatible with polysulfone membranes include: polyether ether ketone (PEEK) and polyetherimide (PEI) bonded to polysulfone using high-performance adhesives resistant to high temperatures; and polyamide (PAm) bondable to PSf using adhesives such as epoxy resins or polyurethane adhesives pursuant to surface preparation such as roughening.
[2137] Polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP) although difficult to bond may use epoxies or modified acrylic bonding subsequent to surface treatments such as corona and plasma treatments used to increase the surface energy and improve adhesion; polycarbonate (PC) bondable to polycarbonate using adhesives that are compatible with both materials such as certain epoxies or solvent-based adhesives; acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) bondable to polysulfone using adhesives like cyanoacrylates, epoxies, or solvent-based adhesives after suitable surface preparation; polyurethanes (PU) using adhesives that form strong bonds with both materials, including polyurethane adhesives and some epoxies; and polybenzimidazole (PBI) with suitable adhesives.
[2138] Solvents used in forming polysulfone polymers include N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), chloroform (CHCl.sub.3), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), or cadmium chloride (CdCL.sub.2). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing polysulfone membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include Friedel-Crafts catalysts such as ferric chloride (FeCl.sub.3, iron (III) chloride) or antimony pentachloride (SbCl.sub.5). Cross linking of polysulfone can be performed by 4,4-trimethylene bis(1-methylpiperidine) (BMP) or by photoinduced cross linking in 2,4,6-trimethylbenzoyl-diphenyl-phosphine oxide (TPO) and trimethylolpropane tri-acrylate (TMPTA). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
23. Functionalized Hybrid Polyamide Sulfonimide (PAm-Co-Sim) Copolymer IEMs.
[2139] Another category of ionomeric polymer is functionalized polyamides. Polyamides are polymers formed of repeating units linked by intervening amide bonds facilitating good thermal and chemical resistance as well as controlled crystallinity. A polymer of amide, not to be confused with polyimide, comprises a general structure a backbone of NCR where the nitrogen form a single H-N bond and the oxygen forms a CO double bond to the on-chain carbon, or more simply as the chemical formula (OC)(NH). Polyamides applicable for membranes comprise a subgroup called aramids or aromatic polyamidesamide polymers that contain phenyl rings in their repeating units. One motivation for forming ionomeric polyamides is the elimination of sulfonic acid groups (SO.sub.3H) found to be subject to degradation by hydrogen peroxide (H.sub.2O.sub.2) present in an IEM matrix.
[2140] An exemplary process for formation of functionalized polyamide is illustrated in
[2141]
[2142] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2156] The following table describes the construction of polyamide-sulfonimide copolymer hybrid membranes. Linear copolymers of sulfonated and un-sulfonated polyamide (PAm) represent the principal instance of hybrid PAm copolymers. Endoskeletal pillar materials compatible with polyamide membranes include cyanoacrylate adhesives (CA) able to bond to fine features especially when fast curing is desirable; epoxy adhesives (EPX) bond to PAm, especially two-component epoxies offering improved durability; polyurethane (PU) form strong flexible bonds with PU using polyurethane adhesives or solvent welding.
TABLE-US-00036 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 23. polyamide sulfonimide hybrid PAm polymers: CA, PU, solv: HF, PFD, sac filler, CNTs, copolymers copolymers EPX BTF, F-626 oxides, POSS, SPA-co-Slm pillars: reinforcing X-L: CPL, SAm NPs, MOFs, PIL fillers (C-fiber, CNTs)
[2157] Solvents used in forming polyamide-sulfonimide polymers include formic acid (FA), cresol (C.sub.7H.sub.8O), or fluoric solvents such as fluorane (HF), perfluorodecalin (PFD), benzotrifluoride (BTF), and perfluorooctyl-dimethylbutyl-ether (F-626). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing polyamide-sulfonimide membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include E-caprolactam (CPL, (CH.sub.2).sub.5CNH), sulfonamide (SAm). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
24. Functionalized Hybrid Phosphazene (Pz) Polymer IEMs.
[2158] Phosphazene comprises several classes of organophosphorus compounds comprising phosphorus (V) with a double-bond between phosphorus and nitrogen, i.e. N=P. Although phosphazene, also known as iminophosphoranes or phosphine imides may be used in filter membranes for water purification and gas separation, it can also be functionalized into an ionomeric membrane either for proton exchange membranes including direct methanol fuel cells or in anion exchange membranes. Material properties include resilience to chemical attack, thermal stability, and flexibility.
[2159] An exemplary process for formation of a phosphazene membrane is illustrated in
[2160] Subsequent oxidation in concentrated sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) sulfonates the phenol groups thereby synthesizing poly sulfonated phosphazene P(sPz) 1653s. Not all phosphazene groups become sulfonated. Some radical remain as unfunctionalized phenol groups. A linear copolymer comprising a mix or sulfonated phosphazene P(sPz) 1653s and un-sulfonated phosphazene P(Pz) 1653 is illustrated in
[2161] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2175] Linear copolymers of sulfonated and un-sulfonated phosphazene (Pz) represent the principal instance of hybrid PAm copolymers. Endoskeletal pillar materials compatible with phosphazene (Pz) membranes include: compatible phosphazene blends (Pz) formed to achieve specific chemical and structural properties present in the Pz membrane; polyurethanes (PU) using polyurethane adhesives offering versatile adhesion capabilities; silicone polymer (SiP) bonded to Pz using silicone-base polymer adhesives; and epoxy resins (EPX) offering strong adhesive properties bonding with a variety of materials including Pz. The table below describes the construction of phosphazene copolymer hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00037 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 24. phosphazene hybrid Pz polymers: Pz, PU, SiP, EPX solv: C.sub.6H.sub.14, tol, sac filler, CNTs, heteropolymer polymers pillars: reinforcing fillers THF oxides, POSS, P(sPz-Pz) (C-fiber, CNTs) X-L: AlCl.sub.3, TCB, NPs, MOFs, PIL CaSO.sub.4, HSO.sub.3(NH.sub.2)
[2176] Solvents of phosphazene (Pz) include tetrahydrofuran (THF, oxolane), hexane (C.sub.6H.sub.14), and toluene (tol, PhCH.sub.3). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing phosphazene (Pz) membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include Lewis acids such anhydrous aluminum chloride (AlCl.sub.3) or trichlorobenzene (TCB), hydrous calcium sulfate (CaSO.sub.4.Math.2H.sub.2O), and sulfamic acid (HSO.sub.3 (NH.sub.2)). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here. Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
25. Hybrid Siloxane (SiX) Polymer IEMs.
[2177] Siloxanes are polymers comprising a backbone of silicon and oxygen [-SiOSiOSi-] forming strong bonds resilient to attack. These silicon sites also bond to organic radical side groups R.sub.1, R.sub.2, and R.sub.3 producing a polymer [-R.sub.2SiOSiR.sub.2OSiR.sub.3-]. Each silica functional group [R.sub.xSiO], referred to siloxy, may be identical or may differ from one another.
[2178] These radicals, often comprising methyl, ethyl or phenyl groups define many of the polymer's material properties such as crystallinity, porosity, rigidity, durability, and temperature coefficient. Siloxane also known as silicone should not be confused with the element silicon which it containssilicon is an element, silicone is a polymer. As, such siloxane can be used in forming membranes for a variety of application including high selectivity separation of gasses and liquids, for proton and anion ion exchange membranes in fuel cells, for separators in lithium ion batteries, for hydrolysis, for electrodialysis, for antibacterial filtering, and more.
[2179] While pristine siloxane containing few ionized groups exhibits poor electrical conductance, any or all of these side groups can then be functionalized by catalytic or ionomeric termini. An exemplary heteropolymer for siloxane membrane is illustrated in
[2180] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2195] The table below describes the construction of siloxane heteropolymer hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00038 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 25. siloxane hybrid SiX polymers: SiA, PU, solv: C.sub.7H.sub.16, tol, sac filler, CNTs, heteropolymers polymers EPX, CA Bz, TCM oxides, POSS, P(sSiX-co-SiX) pillars: reinforcing X-L: C.sub.2Bz, Me.sub.2 NPs, MOFs, PIL fillers (C-fiber, CNTs)
[2196] Endoskeletal pillars bonding with siloxane membranes include silicone-based adhesives (SiA) and polyurethanes (PU) both well matched to bonding silicone membranes; and for epoxy resins (EPX) and cyanoacrylate adhesives (CA) as a general purpose adhesives. Solvents for siloxane (SiX) copolymers include heptane (C.sub.7H.sub.16), toluene (tol), benzene (Bz), and chloroform (trichloromethane, TCM). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing siloxane (SiX) hybrid membranes include dichlorobenzoyl catalysts such as 2,4-dichlorobenzoyl peroxide (C.sub.14HCl.sub.4O.sub.4), and dimethyl compounds such as 2,5-dimethyl (C.sub.32H.sub.66O.sub.2). Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
26. Functionalized Hybrid Triazine (Tz) Polymer IEMs.
[2197] Triazine is a class of nitrogen-containing heterocycles based on the general molecular formula is C.sub.3H.sub.3N.sub.3. Comprising a six-sided benzene-like ring with three nitrogen for carbon substitutions, triazine molecules are named by the location of the nitrogen substitutions on the aromatic ring, e.g. 1,2,4-triazine substitutes nitrogen on the first, second, and fourth positions. For the purpose of this invention, there is no distinction among these variation topological moieties as they only secondarily influence ionomeric membrane performance by influencing crystallinity.
[2198]
[2199]
[2200] The term sCTF-12 is a top level descriptor describing covalent triazine frameworks (CTF) 1684a comprises 12 aromatic rings (12) lining its interior surface and is sulfonated at least in part, hence the prefix of a small letter s. This name does not describe how many phenyls or triazine radiate outside the inner ring of the CTF. The nominative 6T6sPh provides a greater structural detail when 6T refers to six triazine rings 1679 while the term 6sPh means the CTF also includes six sulfonated phenyl rings. The two description can be used separately or preferably together to describe the superstructure of a covalent triazine framework. Mixing ammonium iodide (NH.sub.4I) 1680 with three benzene compound 1682 results in a different CTF framework 1684b. While this CTF has a more tile-like geometry than the first example. As shown it contains only nine aromatic rings on its inner periphery, hence its name sCTF-9. That said the CTF unit cell comprises a total of three triazines 1679 and twelve sulfonated phenyl groups. As such, its superstructure is 3T12sPh. In other words the CTF unit cell is composed of 15 rings, only nine of which reside on its inner periphery. If ammonium iodide (NH.sub.4I) 1680 is mixed with tetrafluoro-1,4-benzoquinone 1683 the resulting triazine framework CTF-12 is also circular shaped with twelve aromatic rings, none of them sulfonated hence its name CTF-12. The term 6T6Ph-F.sub.4 identifies the framework includes six triazines 1619, and six phenyls each with four fluorine atoms.
[2201] Although covalent triazine frameworks may manifest tile-like or ring-like geometries, some structures are topologically more linear or random.
[2202] For example in phosphorylated CTFtetrafluoride (pCTF-TF) 1687, two triazines 1679 bind a center tetrafluoride phenyl group. Phosphoric acid groups 1677 bond to nitrogen atoms of the triazine but also bond to fluorine atoms on the tetrafluoride group. No fluorine is present in this example, meaning ionomeric conduction is regulated by the phosphoric groups and not be sulfonic acid as in most ionomers.
[2203] By contrast, phosphorylated CTFsulfonated phenyl (pCTF-sPh) 1685 made in accordance with this invention combines both phosphoric acid 1677 and sulfonic acid 1054 into a common covalent triazine framework representing a new class of ionomer, described herein as a co-ionomer able to conduct through two different ionomeric moieties in the same group. Advantages of the newly invented co-ionomer is its ability to conduct over a wider range of ambient conditions such as hydration, pH, and temperature and to provide redundancy protecting against ionomer poisoning by H.sub.2O.sub.2 and other parasitic compounds. As shown pCTF-sPh 1685 includes phosphoric acid 1677 bonded to nitrogen atoms of triazine 1679 and sulfonic acid 1054 bonded to the phenyl group Ph held between the two triazine groups. As such, the moniker pCTF-sPh describes a phosphorylated covalent triazine framework with a sulfonated phenyl group.
[2204] Another example of phosphoric-sulfonic co-ionomer CTF is the molecule shown in the center illustration comprising phosphorylated CTFsulfonated tris(4-formylphenyl)amine aka pCTF-sTPA 1686. As its name indicates, the triazine framework comprises one phosphorylated triazine group 1679 with attached phosphoric acid 1677 molecules (pCTF) combines with sulfonated tris(4-formylphenyl)amine comprising a central nitrogen axle and three phenyl groups, each with attached sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) 1054 groups, hence its name sTPA as the acronym sulfonated tris-phenylamine. As shown, the central nitrogen may also bond to an additional phosphoric acid group.
[2205]
[2206]
[2207] Made in accordance with this invention, the CTF has been sulfonated into sCTF 1692 by the addition of sulfonic acid (SA, SO.sub.3H) 1054 onto the phenyl groups in the CTF superstructure as combined with triazine 1679. This step can be performed by modifying phenyl groups using an aromatic substitution reaction, wherein a hydrogen atom on an arene is replaced by a sulfonic acid group (SO.sub.2OH) in an electrophilic aromatic substitution reaction with fuming sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) where
##STR00008##
[2208] As indicated sulfur trioxide (SO.sub.3) or its protonated derivative is the electrophile substituted for hydrogen in the reaction. Since water is a byproduct of the reaction, dehydrating agents can accelerate reaction rates by reducing acid dilution during the reaction. For example, adding thyionl chloride (SOCl.sub.2) to the above reaction eliminates the production of excess water by instead forming (SO.sub.2+2HCl). An alternative to sulfuric acid is to sulphonate the aromatic ring using chlorosulfuric acid (HSO.sub.3Cl) in which case the substitution react becomes
##STR00009##
[2209] Other methods to sulphonate benzene or phenyl rings include the Tyrer sulfonation process developed in 1917 and the Piria reaction of 1851. Regardless of the method used to sulphonate the phenyl groups of the triazine framework, he resulting molecular structure 1693, once modified is suitable for use in membranes. Rather than attempting to form a whole new class of membranes and overcome all the challenges therein, an alternative is blend the sulfonated CTF as a filler and dopant into an existing membrane fabrication process. One such candidate is polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF). As shown polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) 1690 with a molecular structure (C.sub.2H.sub.2F.sub.2).sub.n 1691 when combined with the newly reported sulfonated covalent triazine framework sCTF 1682 can produce a sulfonated version of a copolymer of PVDF and CTF, i.e. sulfonated covalent triazine framework polyvinylidene fluoride copolymer (sCTF-co-PVDF). Since the ionomeric regions added to the CTF having the same morphology as the un-sulfonated copolymer pictured in SEM 1694.
[2210] Because covalent triazine frameworks were developed for antibacterial filters and for water purification, they are not ionomeric nor catalytic nor do they represent the same field of science or inventive art as ion exchange membranes. As described above, using methods made in accordance with this invention to functionalize covalent triazine frameworks (CTFs) into sulfonated covalent triazine frameworks (sCTFs), phosphorylated covalent triazine frameworks (pCTFs), or the combination of both into co-ionomeric sulfonated phosphorylated covalent triazine frameworks (spCTF).
[2211]
[2212] Alternatively a scavenger metal such as nickel, iron, cobalt, etc. could be inserted in place of catalyst metal 1695, the purpose of which is to bond to or impede the transport of carbon monoxide through the membrane especially to protect the anode catalyst from carbon monoxide poisoning. As a protective layer, sCTF-24-Pt 1688 should be coated on the cathode side of the membrane to disrupt CO diffusion before it can even enter the IEM. The protective function of scavenger metals is described in greater detail in section 34 on MOFs.
[2213] Although aforementioned processes involve co-synthesis of covalent triazine frameworks functionalized by sulfonic or phosphoric acid, an alternative process of doping a triazine substrate after it is fabricated is shown in
[2214] Another fabrication method for forming an ionomeric membrane with triazine does not involve covalent triazine networks but instead comprises triazine containing bisphenols (TBPh) formed by bonding sulfonated bisphenols to triazine 1679. As shown in
[2215] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2229] The table below describes the construction of triazine (Tz) polymer and copolymer hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00039 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 26. triazine copolymers hybrid Tz triazine polymers: solv: DMSO, EtOH, triazine fillers/coat: and heteropolymers polymers & EPX, Ph, PI, CE MeCN, MeOH, 6T6sPh, 3T12sPh, PCTF/sCTF copolymers copolymers: pillar H.sub.2O, TCM 6T6Ph-F.sub.4, pCTF-sPh, PCTF-sPh matched to IEM X-L: SA, HCl, KOH, PCTF-TF, sCTF-24, PCTF-sTPA polymer; NaOH, AlCl.sub.3, ZnCl.sub.2, PCTF-sTPhA, PCTF-TF pillars: reinforcing heat, UV light 6T18sPh-Pt 6TsPh, 3T6sPh fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) membrane fillers: 6T6Ph-F.sub.4 sac filler, CNTs, 6T12sPh6BPy oxides, POSS, NPs, sCTF-co-PVDF MOFs, PIL P(SPAES)-co-TBPh
[2230] Ionomers include sulfonated and phosphorylated covalent triazine frameworks (CTF) where a lowercase p prefix indicates phosphorylated CTFs, a lowercase s prefix indicates a sulfonated CTF, phenyl, or phenol group, and a upper case P denotes a polymer. Endoskeletal pillars able to bond to triazine membranes include epoxy resins (EPX) creating a cross-linked network between the epoxy matrix and the triazine framework; phenolic resins (Ph) linking the CTF via phenol ligands; polyimides (PI) which easily bond to triazine as PI often triazine rings in their structure to provide high thermal stability and enhance its mechanical strength; and cyanate esters (CE) which easily polymerize through and into triazine rings, forming a highly cross-linked thermoset polymer with excellent thermal stability and dielectric properties.
[2231] Solvents used in forming triazine (Tz) polymers include dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) comprising a highly polar organic solvent that can dissolve many organic and inorganic compounds including some triazines; acetonitrile (MeCN) a polar aprotic solvent able to dissolve a wide range of compounds including triazines; methanol (MeOH) and ethanol (EtOH), polar solvents that can dissolve many polar substances including some triazines; water (H.sub.2O) able to dissolve water soluble triazines especially those with hydrophilic groups; and chloroform (trichloromethane, TCM), another slightly polar solvent.
[2232] Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing siloxane-triazine (Tz-Sx) hybrid membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include strong acids such as sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4, SA) or hydrochloric acid (HCl); strong bases such as sodium hydroxide (NaOH) or potassium hydroxide (KOH); Lewis acids comprising metal salts such as aluminum chloride (AlC.sub.3) or zinc chloride (ZnCl.sub.2); heat and ultraviolet light. Triazine nanoparticles can also be used as fillers or coatings including the previously described molecules and frameworks 6T6sPh, 3T12sPh, 6T6Ph-F4, pCTF-sPh, pCTF-TF, sCTF-24, pCTF-sTPhA, and 6T18sPh-Pt. Other membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
27. Functionalized Poly Methyl Methacrylate (PMMA) Hybrid Polymer IEMs.
[2233] Methyl methacrylate (MMA) with the chemical composition CH.sub.2C(CH.sub.3)COOCH.sub.3. is a methyl ester of methacrylic acid (MAA). MMA is the monomer of poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA) used primarily in the production of acrylic plastics, one of the oldest plastic in use. It is also used as a economical alternative to alternative to polycarbonate (PC) when flexural and tensile strength, transparency, and UV tolerance are more important than impact strength, chemical resistance, and heat resistance. Compared to polystyrene and polyethylene, PMMA is more stable to environmental insults. Non electrochemical applications of PMMA include lenses for vehicular lighting and eye glasses, signs and displays, window coatings, and as a shatter proof substitute for glass. It is also used extensively for medical and dental fillers and implants including the hollow fiber kidney.
[2234] Applications of PMMA membranes have been primarily for kidney dialysis. Because of its small pore size, PMMA is also used for air separation. Conversely, the small pore size of pristine PMMA makes a poor candidate for ion exchange membranes limiting gas and ionic transport thereby diminishing conductance. Attempts to form ionomeric membranes with PMMA rely on copolymerization to enhance film porosity. For example
[2235] Using photochemical cross-linking to promote the reaction the copolymer sulfobutyl-vinylimidazolium trifluoro methanesulfonate-co-methyl methacrylate (sBVlm-TfO-co-MMA) 1708. The impinging light source comprises photons with energy E=h where =h/c is the frequency of the light used in photoexcitation, h is Planck's constant, and c is the speed of light.
[2236] This process comprises photoactivation od protic ionic liquid [HSO.sub.3BVIm][TfO] with MMA and hPFSVE to form aromatic rings with sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) mediated via cyclopropene radicals (C.sub.3H.sub.3). Photo processing is however not scalable to production volumes and suffers from poor uniformity and incomplete polymerization.
[2237] An alternative approach shown in
[2238] The next step involves introducing the SO.sub.3H group onto the halogenated group. This may be achieved through a sulfonation reaction using fuming sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) or chlorosulfonic acid (SO.sub.3Cl). During substitution, halogen on benzyl halide can then undergo a nucleophilic aromatic substitution if it is an activated aryl halide, or a nucleophilic aliphatic substitution if it is a primary halide. Should the sulfonation step results in a sulfonyl chloride (RSO.sub.2Cl) instead of a sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H), a hydrolysis step may be required to convert the sulfonyl chloride into the corresponding sulfonic acid by treatment by water or an aqueous base.
[2239] In the absence of this complex functionalization, the synthesized PMMA 1712 polymer is neither ionomeric or catalytic. Aside than MMA monomer 1705, other monomers shown in
[2240] PMMA can also be used to form nanospheres rather than membranes. PMMA nanospheres, properly functionalized and used as permanent fillers in polymers, offer numerous advantage over PMMA membranes. Most notably nanospheres exhibit significantly more surface area and ionomers densities than a two-dimensional membrane comprising sheets of ionomers. This surface area advantage confers greater ionomer density than that available limited to the porous channels and more conduits meandering through a polymeric membrane. These nanoparticles can be used as dopants or fillers in a range of polymers, either to enhance conductivity, control porosity, or catalytically promote faster reaction rates.
[2241] Unfortunately published processes for forming PMMA nanospheres focus on synthesizing nano-coatings for improving light emitting diode efficiency, totally unrelated to forming ionomers for ion exchange membranes. For example, forming PMMA using emulsion polymerization has been researched by the Univ of Wisconsin Madison and published online by its MRSEC group. Focused wholly on polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) nanospheres for photonics, the fabricated nanospheres enhance optical quantum efficiency but are not intended to enhance fuel cell efficiency.
[2242] The work does however illustrate methods to form PMMA nanospheres. As shown in
[2243] Depending on bridging within the cluster different configurations and reactivities may result as shown in
[2244]
[2245] Once a stable nanosphere or nanocluster is formed, functionalization with sulfonic or phosphoric acid is more straightforward. For example, as shown in
[2246]
[2247]
[2248] The direct formation of nanoclusters, i.e. aggregates of nanospheres illustrated in
[2249] Made in accordance with this invention, the Zn.sup.21 zinc PMMA nanosphere 1772 can be functionalized in a two-step process comprising treatment in sodium hydroxide (NaOH) producing poly methyl methacrylate zinc hydroxide nanospheres (PMMA ZnOH NS) 1773h. Subsequently a H.sub.2O rinse followed by drying and heat treatment 100 C. converts zinc hydroxide (ZnOH) into zinc oxide (ZnO). The resulting nanocluster comprises an aggregate of poly methyl methacrylate zinc oxide nanospheres 1773o.
[2250] The zinc nanoparticles can may be added as an ionic filler into membranes comprising PFSA or PVA as inorganic ion exchange sites within the matrix improving conductivity and film stability. Unlike organic compounds, inorganic ion exchange sites cannot be detected using detected using absorbance spectroscopy so their presence and electrical activity is determined indirectly by measuring the electrical behavior of IEMs with and without the ZnO nanoparticle or PMMA-ZnO doping. They may be used in hydrogen PEM furl cells and direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs).
[2251] PMMA polymers may form in various isometric arrangements of radical R groups. An isomer is a group of chemical having the same chemical formula and compositions but with different structural arrangements. Examples of PMMA isomers shown in
[2252] Made in accordance with this invention, poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA) polymers shown previously in
[2253] Another grafted polymer PMMA-g-PVDC 1789 is depicted in
[2254] In summary, top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2268] Hybrid poly(methyl methacrylate) structures include both PMMA membranes and PMMA fillers comprising copolymers and grafts. PMMA copolymer membranes include the tetra copolymer sulfobutyl-vinylimidazolium-trifluoro-methanesulfonate-co-methyl methacrylate (sBVlm-TfO-co-MMA).
[2269] Radical R functionalized PMMA membranes include grafts of poly(methyl methacrylate) with polyester (PMMA-g-PE) or with polyvinylidene fluoride (PMMA-g-PVDF), and copolymers with maleic anhydride P(MMA-co-MAH) and with maleic anhydride derivatives P(MMA-co-MAH-co-Mi). The radical* R may comprise hydrogen ions (H.sup.+), sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H, SA), phenylated sulfonic acid (Ph-SA, C.sub.6H.sub.6SO.sub.3), phosphoric acid (PA, H.sub.3PO.sub.4), boric acid (BA, H.sub.3BO.sub.3), citric acid (CA, C.sub.6H.sub.8O.sub.7), and benzenesulfonic acid (BzSA, BzSO.sub.3H, C.sub.6H.sub.6O.sub.3S), and others.
[2270] The table below describes the construction of methyl methacrylate (MMA) and poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA) copolymers and grafted hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00040 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 27. methyl methacrylate hybrid PMMA polymers: ABS, solv: Ac, tol, DCE, PMMA fillers: Pd copolymers and grafts copolymers SAN, ASA, EMA, MEK, DCM, NEth, PMMA NC, Pd sBVIm-TfO-co-MMA MBS, MABS, Anon, TCM, PhCl, P(MMA-PAA) NC, functionalized* PMMA MMA-VA Xylol, Anisole, sPMMA, PMMA- PE-g-PMMA pillars: DEP, PMA, EtOAc, SA, porous NS, PMMA-g-PVDC reinforcing fillers HCOOH PMMA NCs (ZnS, P(MMA-co-MAH) (C-fiber, CNTs) X-L: BPO, CTA, ZnO) P(MMA-co-MAH-co-Mi) tBPPiv other fillers: * R = H.sup.+, SA, Ph-SA, PA, sac filler, CNTs, BA, CA oxides, POSS, NPs, MOFs, PIL
[2271] Endoskeletal polymers able to form pillar links with PMMA membranes include acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) used for its toughness and impact resistance; styrene-acrylonitrile (SAN) a copolymer of styrene and MMA able to bond to PMMA because of shared constitutes; acrylonitrile-styrene-acrylate (ASA) a copolymer of acrylonitrile, styrene, and acrylate also derived from MMA; ethylene methyl acrylate (EMA) copolymerized from ethylene and MMA; methyl methacrylate-butadiene-styrene (MBS) combining MMA with butadiene and styrene; methyl methacrylate-acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene (MABS) and tetra copolymer of MMA with acrylonitrile, butadiene, and styrene; and methyl methacrylate-vinyl acetate (MMA-VA) a copolymer of MMA with vinyl acetate offering superior adhesion and flexibility.
[2272] Solvents used in forming methyl methacrylate (MMA) polymers include acetone (Ac, C.sub.3H.sub.6O) toluene (tol, PhCH.sub.3, C.sub.6H.sub.5CH); dichloroethane (DCE, C.sub.2H.sub.2Cl.sub.2); butanone aka methyl ethyl ketone (MEK); cyclohexanone (Anon, C.sub.6H.sub.10O); nitroethane (NEth, C.sub.2H.sub.5NO.sub.2), chloroform (TCM, trichloromethane, CHCl.sub.3); dichloromethane (DCM, CHCl.sub.2) (or methylene chloride); benzene (Bz, C.sub.6H.sub.6); chlorobenzene (PhCl, C.sub.6H.sub.5Cl); xylene (Xylol, dimethylbenzene, C.sub.8H.sub.10); methoxybenzene aka anisole or phenyl methyl ether (CH.sub.3OC.sub.6H.sub.5); diethyl phthalate (DEP); methoxypropyl acetate (PMA, C.sub.6H.sub.12O.sub.3); ethyl acetate (EtOAc, C.sub.4H.sub.8O.sub.2); ethyl lactate (Acytol, lactic acid, C.sub.5H.sub.10O.sub.3); and formic acid (methanoic acid, HCOOH). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing methyl methacrylate (MMA) hybrid membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include benzoyl peroxide (BPO, (BzO).sub.2), tert-butyl peroxypivalate (tBPPiv), thiol-containing chain transfer agents (CTAs).
[2273] PMMA based fillers as described include the palladium doped catalytic nanoclusters Pd PMMA and Pd P(MMA-PAA), sulfonated nanospheres sPMMA and PMMA-SA, zinc doped nanoclusters ZnS, ZnOH, and ZnO PMMA, and inert porous nanospheres. Other membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
28. Functionalized Hybrid Carboxy Methyl Cellulose (CMC) Polymer IEMs.
[2274] Given the propensity for ionomer fouling and fuel cross-over in direct methanol fuel cells (DFMCs) one alternative membrane to PFSA comprises a tri-copolymer of carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). Carboxy methyl cellulose is a polysaccharide comprising a flexible water soluble polymeric matrix containing hydroxyl and sodium carboxymethyl groups (CH.sub.2COONa) derived from fibrous plant tissue. CMC beneficial material properties include biodegradability, nontoxicity, high hydrophilicity, biocompatibility and excellent film forming ability. A variety of CMC applications include its use in textiles, drugs, detergents, purification and flocculation, food processing, and more.
[2275] As a cellulose molecule, CMC suffers from limited stability and poor miscibility. By blending it with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), CMC forms a copolymer offering increase its physicochemical properties such as miscibility, tensile strength, and higher ionic conductivity than CMC alone. Unfortunately the CMC-co-PVA copolymer is still electrically uncompetitive to other ionomeric membranes. To improve membrane conductivity, the copolymer can be mixed with acrylamide making it better suited for electrochemical applications.
[2276]
[2277] Film conductance may be further enhanced by ionomeric fillers 1798 comprising sulfonated activated carbon (SAC) or carboxylated carbon nanotubes (CCNT) or by doping with ionic liquids, all three of which may diffuse out of the membrane. In one embodiment of the invention the permanent fillers are constrained within the polymer matrix laterally by the endoskeletal pillar matric and perpendicular to the film by a nanocoatings. Alternatively CMC can be copolymerized with propylene carbonate (PC) and ammonium chloride. Proton conduction in CMC-co-PC is facilitated through dissociation of H.sup.+ from ammonium chloride (NH.sub.4Cl) or alternatively from ammonium bromide (NH.sub.4Br).
[2278] The table below describes the construction of carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) copolymer hybrid membranes:
TABLE-US-00041 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 28. carboxy methyl hybrid CMC polymers: PAM, PVA, solv: water, IPA, IBA, CMC fillers: cellulose copolymers copolymers PEO, PEG, PAA, PVP EtOH SAC, CCNT CMC-co-PVA pillars: reinforcing X-L: HCOOH, AcOH, other fillers: CMC-co-PVA-co-AA fillers (C-fiber, CNTs) H.sub.2CO.sub.3, pyr, glycolic, sac filler, CNTs, CMC-co-PCNH.sub.4Cl acid, butyric acid, oxides, POSS, CMC-co-PCNH.sub.4Br Acytol NPs, MOFs, PIL
[2279] Hybrid carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) membranes include copolymers of CMC with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), acrylamide (AA), and polycarbonate (PC) doped with NH.sub.4Cl or NH.sub.4Br. Endoskeletal polymers bondable to CMC polymers include polyacrylamide (PAM) able to form composites; polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) present in the copolymer; polyethylene oxide (PEO); polyethylene glycol (PEG) through hydrogen bonding forming hydrogels; and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP). Solvents used in forming carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) copolymers include water, isopropanol (IPA), isobutanol (IBA), and ethanol (EtOH).
[2280] Catalysts and reagents beneficial in carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) hybrid membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include citric acid (C.sub.6H.sub.5(O.sub.7).sup.3) and carboxylic acids, i.e. acids containing carboxyl (COOH) functional group. Carboxylic acids include formic acid (methanoic acid, HCOOH), carbonic acid (hydroxymethanoic acid, H.sub.2CO.sub.3), acetic acid (AcOH), glycolic acid (C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.3), ethyl lactate (Acytol, lactic acid, C.sub.5H.sub.10O.sub.3), pyruvic acid (Pyr, C.sub.3H.sub.4O.sub.3), butyric acid (C.sub.3H.sub.7COOH), and others. CMC specific filers include sulfonated activated carbon (SAC) or carboxylated carbon nanotubes (CCNT). Other membrane fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
29. Functionalized Hybrid Multi-Acid Sidechain (MASC) Polymer IEMs.
[2281] Rather than modifying the backbone of a polymer, an alternative approach to improve IEM performance over that offered by PFSA or Nafion is to modify the construction of the pendant attaching the ionomer terminus to its polymer mainchain. Potential benefits of substituting the fluorocarbon pendant of 3M, Nafion or Aquivion with an alternative sidechain containing fewer hydro-fluorine groups is to adjust the film morphology and crystallinity to control swelling, water update, and fuel crossover, especially in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs). Generally the modification comprises a substitution of one ore more
[2282] As shown in
[2283] The technical report by the US Dept. of Energy consider that by adjusting the length of the MASC sidechain the film's properties prospectively may be varied.
[2284] The relative position of the sulfonyl fluoride group within the sidechain remains unchanged in subsequent processing steps including (a) conversion of SO.sub.2F terminus 1820 into SO.sub.2H terminus 1821, (b) conversion of SO.sub.2H terminus 1821 into SO.sub.2NH.sub.2 terminus 1822, and (c) conversion of SO.sub.2NH.sub.2 terminus 1822 into (SO.sub.2NHSO.sub.2) terminus 1823. Notice this structure is identical to that of sulfonyl fluoride group (SO.sub.2NHSO.sub.2) 1812 except that the group is positioned farther along a longer the sidechain. These longer MASC structures mat be referred to as perfluoro-ionone chain extended (PFICE) ionomeric polymers.
[2285] Direct synthesis of PFIA from PFSA is illustrated in
[2286] Direct synthesis of a related MASC polymer is illustrated in
[2287] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2301] The table below describes the construction of multi acid sidechain (MASC) copolymer hybrid membranes based on a variety of ionomeric mainchains:
TABLE-US-00042 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 29. multi-acid sidechain MASC hybrid polymer: solv: catalysts, used sac filler, CNTs, modified polymers polymer matched to IEM in forming polymers oxides, POSS, PFIA-PFSA MASC polymer. match membrane, NPs, MOFs, PIL PFIA-PTFE MASC pillar: reinforcing not filler ortho-bis acid MASC fillers (C-fiber, X-L: reagents PFIA-co-PVA-co-PTFE CNTs) matching PFIA-co-SPAES, sPEEK, membrane sPEES polymer PFIA-co-sPVA, sPBI, sCS
[2302] Endoskeletal pillars should be chosen to bond to the mainchain polymer to which the PFIA or MASC attaches. Solvents used in forming multi-acid sidechains (MASC) modified copolymers are chosen to be compatible with the polymer mainchain. If for example the mainchain comprises a MASC modified PFSA homopolymer or a PFSA-PTFE, then solvents compatible with PFSA-PTFE are preferred. Similarly catalysts and reagents beneficial in multi-acid sidechains (MASC) hybrid membranes and cross linking them to other polymers are selected to match the polymer mainchain, not the pendant. Membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
30. Functionalized Hybrid Arylene Ether (PAE) Polymer IEMs.
[2303] Another class of thermoplastic polymers, poly(arylene ether)s (PAEs) have been developed for water filtration including oil/water separation, desalination, and wastewater treatment, which involve the removal of heavy metal ions, dyes, oils, and other organic pollutants. Beneficial characteristics of PAEs include corrosion resistance, high-temperature resistance, anti-fouling properties, and durability in challenging environments. Although limited, some effort has been made to adapt these compounds to form ionomeric membranes. While section 13 considered functionalization of pristine poly arylene ether, synthesis of hybrid PAE blends confers beneficial morphological and electrical properties to proton exchange membrane (PEM) chemistry than pure PAE films cannot offer.
[2304] Ionomer membranes produced from hexaarylbenzene-based partially fluorinated poly(arylene ether) blends involve combining sulfonated poly(arylene)s and highly rigid hexaarylbenzene (HAB, HABz) derivatives with cardo structured fluorenyl, i.e. where the pendent groups comprise chains of aromatic rings such as phenyl, benzene, etc. In three dimensions, these pendent groups are necessarily orthogonal to the plane of the mainchain irrespective as to whether the polymer backbone also comprises aromatic rings. To promote rapid growth a high-boiling-point solvent such as dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) is also required.
[2305]
[2306] Ionomer (7BDO) 1821 comprises polymerized diphenol monomer 2,3-diphenyl-[1,1:4,1:4,1:4,1-quinquephenyl]-4,4-diol. The resulting polymer (P12F97B) 1822 is then functionalized by chlorosulfonic acid (CIHO.sub.3S) and dichloromethane (DCM) to produce sulfonated PAE polymer s(P12F97B) 1823 including ionomer sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) 1054.
[2307]
[2308]
[2309] Using this somewhat confusing naming system, the sulfonated PAE polymer 1852 containing segments 12F and 7B is referred to as P12F9B7B which has been shortened to P12F97B. To remain consistent with this document the prefix of a lower case s is used to denote that segment 1851 is sulfonated, hence its name s7B as is the case for the resulting polymer, vis--vis sP12F97B. Similarly polymer 1837 containing segments s6F and sCB is named s6F9CB but for accuracy should be s6F9B2CB.
[2310] Membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2324] The table below describes the construction of arylene ether polymers (PAE) hybrid membranes. Poly arylene ether heteropolymers comprise linear sequences of hydrophobic and hydrophilic sequences which may or may not be sulfonated. These heteropolymers are described structurally by a molecular code. Endoskeletons able to bond the PAE heteropolymer membranes mirror those compatible with homopolymer PAE.
[2325] Pillar materials compatible with bonding to PAEs include polystyrene (PS) and high-impact polystyrene (HIPS) which share the styrene moiety in the backbone of poly(arylene ether)s; polyamides (PAm, nylon) using appropriate adhesives or surface treatments; polyesters (PE) using compatibilizers or coupling agents containing carboxyl or anhydride groups to enhance interfacial adhesion; polyurethanes (PU) using adhesives or by interpenetrating polymer networks (IPNs) by synthesizing PU in the presence of PAE; and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS).
TABLE-US-00043 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 30. arylene ether PAE arylene polymers: PAE, PS, HIPS, solv: NMP, DMAc, sac filler, CNTs, heteropolymers ether polymer PAm, PE, PU, ABS, PC, DMSO, DMF, PEG, oxides, POSS, sP12F9B7B PPO, PP, PMMA, PET DGMME NPs, MOFs, PIL, sP6F9B2CB pillars; reinforcing fillers X-L: DT, SDT, PFPE-GO (C-fiber, CNTs) PFPE
[2326] Solvents for s(PAE)s include N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), dimethylformamide (DMF), polyethylene glycol (PEG, PEO), and diethylene glycol monomethyl ether (DGMME). Cross linkers include dithiol (DT), sulfonated dithiol (SDT), and bishydroxy perfluoropolyether (PFPE). Aside from PFPE-GO crystallites, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
31. Functionalized Hybrid POSS-Doped Polymer IEMs.
[2327] Polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes or polyhedral oligosilsesquioxanes (POSS, SSQs) is a silicon based framework with SiOSi linkages and tetrahedral Si vertices producing cage-like structures. Cages may take on a variety of shapes ranging from closed or open cubic shapes to hexagonal to octagonal drum-like shapes. Some configurations spontaneously rearrange. Other shapes include double decker silsesquioxanes (DDS).
[2328] Generally described as nanoparticles, polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes are minute chemical molecules of 1-to-3 nm in dimension capable of modulating conductivity, catalytic, and material properties. As an membrane ionomeric additive, POSS fillers are useful in proton exchange membranes for hydrogen fuel or for direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs). They also may form cross linkers for copolymer synthesis. Regardless of the topological configurations, pristine POSS is neither catalytic or ionomeric. Moreover, POSS does not form planar sheets needed for forming membranes. Instead POSS is a precursor to various chemical structures used for dopants and permanent fillers in membranes of other compositions.
[2329]
[2330]
[2331] As a consequence of a substitution reaction, thiol group SH is replaced by a ligand and meta-phosphoric acid (HO.sub.3P). Specifically in the top plane of POSS-S-PA 1849a, thiol group SH is converted to sulfur (S) 1854t then bonded to meta-phosphoric acid (HO.sub.3P) 1853t via carbon-oxygen pendant 1855t. Similarly in the lower plane of POSS-S-PA 1849b, thiol group SH is converted to sulfur 1854b then bonded to meta-phosphoric acid (HO.sub.3P) 1853t via carbon-oxygen pendant 1853b.
[2332]
[2333] Made in accordance with this invention, polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane (POSS) polymers as shown can be functionalized by various ionomeric radicals including hydrogen ions H.sup.+, sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H), or sulphonated phenyl groups regardless of whether the POSS-R is in the form of a membrane, film, nanosphere, or nanocluster. Methods in substitution chemistry able to convert a non-ionomeric radical into an proton exchange group by attaching ionized hydrogen (H.sup.+) groups, sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H) 1054, sulfonated phenyl group (C.sub.6H.sub.6SO.sub.3), or other acids (not shown) such as boric acid (H.sub.3BO.sub.3), phosphoric acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.4), citric acid (CA), benzenesulfonic acid (BzSA, BzSO.sub.3H, C.sub.6H.sub.6O.sub.3S) and other acids (not shown) have been described previously and will not be repeated here.
[2334]
[2335] Processes for thiol to PEG conversion include self-assembly of amphiphilic polyether-octa-functionalized polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane via a thiol-ene click reaction whereby every radical R is converted from HS to PEG. PEG is however not useful as an ionomer meaning the process must be significantly modified to produce polyhedral silsesquioxanes useful for charge transport.
[2336] Made in accordance with this invention one or several functional groups may be converted to PEG to perform chemical functions such as bonding while the remainder of the remaining radicals in the polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane (POSS) polymers are functionalized by various ionomeric radicals including hydrogen ions H.sup.+, sulfonic acid (SA, SO.sub.3H), or sulphonated phenyl groups (Ph-SA) regardless of whether the POSS-R is in the form of a membrane, film, nanosphere, or nanocluster. In this method the POSS can be considered di-functional.
[2337] Many possible POSS configurations are based on a octahedral template of polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes 1870 containing a uniform distribution of butyl 1871 pendants as depicted in
[2338] Various monofunctional oligomeric silsesquioxane (POSS) molecules with radiating pendants comprising homo-substitute groups form functional additives for preparation of polyethylene-based composites. Without subsequent processing made in accordance with this invention to attach ionomeric functional groups comprising sulfonic acid, phosphoric acid, or other acids, these monofunctional POSS are not useful for ionomeric or catalytic purposes.
[2339]
[2340] Recalling the polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane-isobutyl (POSS-iBu) 1870 from
[2341] These three POSS variants are considered difunctional because they contain two different types of functional groups and are thereby able to bond to two different classes of molecules within a polymer. Because neither functional group is ionomeric or catalytic, the difunctional POSS moieties are not useful in ion exchange membranes. Made in accordance with this invention, however, some of the attachment points can be modified to include an electrically active functional group involving sulfonic acid (SA or Ph-SA), phosphoric acid (PA), boric acid (BA), or other acids.
[2342]
[2343] These three POSS variants are considered difunctional because they contain two different types of functional groups and are thereby able to bond to two different classes of molecules within a polymer. But because neither functional group is ionomeric or catalytic, the difunctional POSS moieties shown are not useful in ion exchange membranes. Made in accordance with this invention, however, some of the attachment points can be modified to include an electrically active functional group involving sulfonic acid (SA or Ph-SA), phosphoric acid (PA), boric acid (BA), or other acids.
[2344] Although butyl POSS 1879 can be functionalized by styryl 1885 and polystyrene 1885 groups, a more generic difunctional version shown in
[2345]
[2346]
[2347] Three other butyl-based difunctional POSS illustrated in
[2348] These three POSS variants are considered difunctional because they contain two different types of functional groups and are thereby able to bond to two different classes of molecules within a polymer. But because neither functional group is ionomeric or catalytic, the difunctional POSS moieties shown are not useful in ion exchange membranes. Made in accordance with this invention, however, some of the attachment points can be modified to include an electrically active functional group involving sulfonic acid (SA or Ph-SA), phosphoric acid (PA), boric acid (BA), or other acids.
[2349]
[2350] One dimensional POSS 1863m which may be considered as point-contact POSS containing a single bonding point. As such, they do not define or impact polymer geometry but only attach to a membrane as formed. Representative 1D topological configurations of POSS 1863m include pendant 1863p; endcaps 1863e and 1893ee; along with barbells 1893b and 1893bb.
[2351] Planar POSS 1863d aka 2D POSS have two or more connections in the same plane. As such, 2D POSS cab form linear strings such as bead chains 1894c, sheets and planar polymers 1784p. Embedded within a membrane planar POSS can enhance electrical conductivity and reduce fuel crossover but do not add significant structure support as no bonds exist orthogonal to the bonding plane. The 3D version of POSS 1863t comprise at least three bonds, one or more in each of three-axis. Examples include like dendritic webs 1895e and 3D matrix 1895t.
[2352] Another class of oligomeric silsesquioxane molecules is that of double-decker silsesquioxane (DDSQ). Less cage-like than POSS, DDSQs form bird-nest like structures able to capture and gold other molecules or large atoms called guests. As shown in
[2353] Although DDSQ 1900 is considered difunctional because they contain two different types of functional groups, namely phenyl (Ph) and methyl (Me) groups, because neither functional group is ionomeric or catalytic, pristine DDSQ 1900 is not useful in ion exchange membranes. Made in accordance with this invention, however, some of the attachment points can be modified to include an electrically active functional group involving sulfonic acid (SA or Ph-SA), phosphoric acid (PA), boric acid (BA), or other acids.
[2354] Other difunctional DDSQ variants shown in
[2355] In the illustration, the term FG refers to functional group, to be distinguished from an organic, ionomeric, or catalytic radical R. Various functional groups shown in
[2356] Other functional groups shown in
[2357] Cubic DDSQ illustrated in
[2358]
[2359] Thereafter tetrafluoride ethylene oxide (F.sub.4EtO) nucleophilic substitution reaction inverting the silicon corner bonds of cube DDSQ 1924 from endo-fluorine isomers into exo-fluorine bonds. In the final phase the exo-fluorine atoms are substituted by anilino groups through the substitution with lithiophenyl-N-1,1,4,4,-tetramethyldisilylazacyclopentane 1926 and deprotection by methyl alcohol (MeOH), tetrahydrofuran (THF), and pyridinium p-toluene sulfonate (PPTS) producing dianilino DDSQ 1927 macromers as shown in
[2360] Made in accordance with this invention, the cubic double decker silsesquioxane (DDSQ) polymers as shown can be functionalized by various ionomeric radicals including hydrogen ions H.sup.+, sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H), or sulphonated phenyl groups regardless of whether the DDSQ-R is in the form of a membrane, film, nanosphere, or nanocluster.
[2361]
[2362] Although the coating is intended to enhance solar adsorption in photovoltaic cells, when functionalized by various ionomeric radicals including hydrogen ions H.sup.+, sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H), or sulphonated phenyl groups made in accordance with this invention, the material can be repurposed for use in ionomeric membranes.
[2363] Similarly,
[2364] As depicted the presence of POSS can enhance conduction by providing added conduits for hopping conduction or alternate pathways to catalyze unionized fuel leaking into the membrane. For example incoming hydrogen gas 1944 is ionized into H.sup.+ protons 1945a which immediately is absorbed by the nearest ionomer 1942 releasing another proton that hops to the next ionomer changing to proton 1945c.
[2365] This electron changes in the next ionomer and again into proton 1945e when it encounters ionomeric POSS 1943. Since protons are indistinguishable, there is no way to identify protons 1943a formed by ionization from protons 1943c emitted by ionomers 1942 or those protons 1963e emitted from ionomer groups on POSS 1943.
[2366] Indirect evidence proving the POSS role in conduction can be confirmed by correlating increases in conductance to the doping density of inventive ionomeric POSS fillers within an IEM. The role of inventive catalytic POSS is best suited as a coating atop the polymer membrane. Increased catalytic POSS density in the coating causes an corresponding yet asymptotic increase in the free H.sup.+ ions entering the membrane also contributing to enhanced film conductance. This cooperative co-conduction mechanism occurs independently of the type of polymer used to form the membrane, so long that POSS nanoparticles are able to bond onto the membrane matrix.
[2367] In other words, the application of POSS and DDESQ as membrane fillers is agnostic to polymer chemistry. Examples of polymers treatable with POSS macromer doping, represent a wide spectrum including polyimide (PI), polyureas, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide, poly(N-vinylpyrrolidone), poly(hydroxyether of bisphenol A) (PPh), epoxy resin (EPX), poly(aryl ether sulfone) (PSf), vinylene-arylene copolymers (Vi-co-Ary), poly(azomethine)s (PAz), poly(cyclo-octadiene)s, polysiloxanes (PSiX), polybenzoxane (PBz), and phenol resins. Not all of the polymers form membranes but may still be used as nano-coatings atop other ionomeric polymers.
[2368] In summary membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2382] As a permanent filler and dopant, functionalized POSS and DSSQ can be introduced into any membrane polymer either fluorocarbon or hydrocarbon. Material selection of the endoskeleton, solvents, catalysts, and cross-linkers relate to the membrane polymer, not the POSS dopants.
[2383] Polyhedral oligomeric and double-decker silsesquioxane based permanent fillers and dopants (POSS and DDSQ) as described include POSS-PA, POSS-R, POSS-FG-R, POSS-iBu-FG-R, POSS-styryl-R, POSSPSR, POSS-FG1-FG2-R, DDSQ-R, and DDSQ-FG-R where R may comprise any ionomer such as sulfonic acid (SA), phenylated sulfonic acid (Ph-SA), phosphoric acid (PA), boric acid (BA), citric acid (CA) and other acids. Aside from POSS and DDSQ fillers, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
TABLE-US-00044 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 31. POSS/DSSQ POSS/DSSQ polymer: matched solv: catalysts, POSS fillers: POSS-PA, doped polymers doped hybrid to IEM polymer. used in forming POSS-R, POSS-FG-R, PFSA-PTFE polymer pillar: reinforcing polymers match POSS-iBu-FG-R, POSS- PFIA fillers (C-fiber, membrane, not styryl-R, POSS-PS-R, PFSA-PVA-PTFE CNTs) filler POSS-FG1-FG2-R, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES X-L: reagents DDSQ-R, DDSQ-FG-R SPVA, sPBI, sCS matching other fillers: sac filler, membrane CNTs, oxides, POSS, polymer NPs, MOFs, PIL
32. Functionalized Hybrid Nano-Treated Polymer IEMs.
[2384] Nanostructures can be used to impact the electrical and material properties of polymer membranes either as a filler and dopant or as a coating. Where catalysts, barrier materials, and protective scavengers are most effective as coatings, nanoparticle ionomeric dopants and permanent fillers are more effective when integrated into the polymer bulk itself.
[2385]
[2386] Rather than depositing nanostructures upon the surface of a IEM, the structures may be integrated within as permanent fillers introduced during molding and polymerization.
[2387] Aside from coating membranes or acting as a filler, nanocoatings can also coat individual polymer chains. As shown in
[2388] In cross section dopamine composite polymer 1971b comprises its uniform core 1972 of ePTFE encased by a dopamine coating 1973. A higher resolution cross sectional view reveals the ePTFE chain 1971x is coated by OH radicals 1973x. For clarity's sake the OH groups are shown on only one side of ePTFE chain 1971x but in reality concentrically encase the polymer chain. In the second step, a sol-gel process in zirconium oxide (ZrO.sub.2) coats dopamine composite polymer 1971b with a layer of zirconium 1974 shown in cross section 1974x thereby forming composite membrane (ZCM) 1970c comprising zirconium composite polymer 1971b.
[2389] The ZCM coating as describes provides beneficial characteristics to a membrane with antimicrobial and antioxidant attributes. One such process for sol-gel modification of a PTFE membrane is whereby expanded polytetrafluoroethylene skeletons are modified by a surface sol-gel process. While the sol-gel process can modify a polymer's backbone, it does not directly apply to ion exchange membranes but instead is more applicable to biomedical applications and is not in the same field of art as fuel cells and electrolyzers.
[2390] An alternative process shown on
[2391] In a second step platinum dioxide (PtO.sub.2, platinum(IV) oxide hydrate) reacts with the exposed dopamine hydroxide groups 1973n to form a layer of platinum 1975x, some of which are coated by OH groups formed by PtO groups bonding to free hydrogen during the reaction. In so doing outer platinum outer shell 1975 concentrically encases the shell of dopamine hydroxide groups 1973n and the polymer 1972m core. The result is platinum composite 1971o forming catalytic membrane or coating 1970o. In an alternative process palladium oxide (PdO) or titanium dioxide (TiO.sub.2) are used to form the catalyst layer.
[2392] The attachment to the intermediate bonding layer occurs through the oxygen groups of the metal, not by oxidizing the metal itself. As such, the process can be performed at relatively low temperatures. If the membrane comprises scavenger metals intended to protect the catalyst layer of the CCM from carbon monoxide poisoning, the catalyst may be replaced by nickel, cobalt, iron or other low cost metals using NiO, FeO, or CoO oxides as the reactants. Alternatively both catalyst and scavenger may be intermixed in an desired ratio.
[2393] Another form of nanostructure treatment involves carbon nanotubes. Although the carbon nanotubes are larger than nanoparticles, they can be functionalized by nanoparticles attached to their surfaces. The functionalized nanotube can then be used as a permanent filler in membranes to enhance catalytic and ionomeric activity. As illustrated in
[2394] By wrapping the nanotube with a negatively charged polyelectrolyte bonding layer 1981a, a positively charged monolayer 1981b can then be deposited onto the nanotube. Exemplary electrolytes include polybenzimidazole (PBI) 1982a and pyridine polybenzimidazole (PyPBI) 1982b. Once deposited positively charged monolayer 1981b serves as the real template for nanoparticle adsorption via electrostatic interactions, shown as the nanoparticle attaching step. The process results in a nanoparticle (NP) coated 1983 coated nanotube 1980.
[2395] One type of nanoparticles comprises Pt or Pd based alloys beneficial as catalysts in supporting electrochemical reactions. While free metal NPs are unstable and prone to losing their catalytic potential through irreversible aggregation during electrochemical processes, affixing catalytic nanoparticles to a framework such as a CNT greatly reduces these aging effects. For example, sonification and microwave irradiation of platinum NPs comprising hexachloroplatinate (PtCl.sub.6).sup.2 and ethylene glycol (EG).
[2396] Another method to functionalize carbon nanotubes is electrochemical functionalization of the CNT surface. As shown in
[2397] Another process for synthesizing platinum catalyst nanoparticle coated carbon nanotubes is depicted in
[2398] By protonating THF-pretreated CNTs, adsorption of (PtCl.sub.6).sup.2 and Sn.sup.4 ions onto sterically-accessible oxygen sites results electrostatic autonomous assembly of nanoparticles in hydrogen environments. The self-arranging PtSn nanoparticles 1992 naturally adhere multiwalled carbon nanotube (MWCNT) 1980 thereby forming platinum-tin functionalized nanoparticle coated CNTs 1989c.
[2399] Made in accordance with this invention,
[2400]
[2401] Aside from cation conduction via hydrogen and methanol, the structure of phosphorylated titanium nanotubes can be adapted to a AEM fuels including hydrogen borohydride fuel cells. Titanium oxide functionalized nanotubes can also be used in sulfonated PVA/PEO membranes. Nanotechnology can contribute to the ex post facto modification of polymers such as radiation induced grafted polymers.
[2402] Nanoengineering can also be used to form a nanograft to attach ionomers to polymeric mainchains. As shown in
[2403] Another nanotechnology potentially applicable for doping ion exchange membranes is electrospinning. In electrospinning shown in
[2404]
[2405] In one embodiment made in accordance with this invention, the extruded nanofibers are gently crushed in a mechanical press to shorten their length thereby increasing film density. Such methods are required if the nanofiber mesh results in an overly porous film suffering from fuel crossover in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) or excessive oxygen back streaming in hydrogen PEM fuel cells. By breaking the nanofibers into shorter snippets their impact on the intrinsic density of the polymer host material is reduced.
[2406] Other nanotechnology methods applicable to polymer ion exchange membranes include the integration of dopamine nanoparticles in PTFE matrix. Historically such technology have been used exclusively in filters for biomedical applications. Recent research on dopamine polymers has expanded into its repurposing as permanent fillers for ion exchange membranes and for hosting catalysts. Examples include Nafion composite membranes impregnated with polydopamine and poly(sulfonated dopamine). In manufacturing, Nafion composite membranes are doped with poly(sulfonated dopamine) (sPDA) by forcing the membrane to swelling, introducing the sPDA, then drying the film to return to its normal dimensions.
[2407] As shown in
[2408] As shown in
[2409] A schematic representation of a membrane comprising poly(sulfonated dopamine) P(DA-sDA) 2044 doped perfluorosulfonic acid-polytetrafluoroethylene 2047 is shown in
[2410] As humidity cycling is a known failure mechanism for PFSA films, the extreme humidification required to create the dopant pores and subsequent desiccation unavoidably induces defects and membrane stresses, damaging its innate ionomers. Moreover, as PFSA pore size increases made possible through humidification are limited, the concentration of dopamine able to fit within these pores is limited. A such the beneficial impact of adding dopamine ionomer sites is more than offset by damage to PFSA polymer's ionomers. Also the method for creating pores through swelling is limited to PFSA and is not applicable for hydrocarbon based polymers.
[2411] Made in accordance with invention, the formation of pores to trap and retain dopamine in an ion exchange membrane is achieved through the disclosed process using a sacrificial filler as shown in
[2412] The remnants of the removed sac filler in membrane polymer 2049b comprise vacancies 2039c persisting in regions where the sacrificial filler once occupied. Meanwhile in step 2048c, polydopamine (PDA) 2044 is synthesized as a permanent membrane filler. In step 2048d, the PDA 2044 dopant fills the vacancies 2039d in membrane 2049c thereby increasing the conductive ionomeric pathways in the matrix. Since no extreme hydration or swelling is used to modify the polymer matrix, the membrane's intrinsic electrical and material properties remain undisturbed. Moreover the PDA doped membrane can be formed in conjunction with a endoskeletal frame to provide added mechanical support.
[2413] Polydopamine can also be used to form catalytic coatings.
[2414] Made in accordance with this invention, a nanocoating applicable to fuel cells shown in
[2415] Coated atop an ion exchange membrane the film provides hydrogen catalysis through its platinum core, commences proton hopping conduction of ionized hydrogen (H.sup.+) by sulfonic ionomer groups located within the PFSA-PTFE nanoparticles 2054z, and inhibits carbon monoxide poisoning of the platinum catalysts by the surface layer of cobalt nanoparticles 2055s or other scavenger metal NPs. In this manner, the inventive coating increases fuel catalysis and improves membrane conductivity while simultaneously protecting the catalyst from CO poisoning.
[2416] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2432] Nano-treated hybrid polymer IEMs include nanolayers, nanofibers, nanocoatings, nanoparticles, nanoclusters, nanospheres, nanotubes, nanocomposites, and nanoparticle coated carbon nanotubes. Aside from nano treated membranes, novel nano polymers include dopamine membranes (PDA, P(sDA), P(DA-sDA)); hybrid nano-doped polymers such as {PFSA-PTFEP(DA-sDA)}; nano-coated membranes (DCM, ZCM, PtCM); phosphorylated titania-carbon-nanotube (PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 CNT) doped sulfonated polyvinyl alcohol-co-sulfophthalic acid-co-polyethylene oxide (s(PVA-co-SPA-co-PEO)); radiation-grafted polymers, and sulfonated polystyrene (P(sPS) NF) nanofiber infused membranes. The following table describes the construction of various nano-treated polymers:
TABLE-US-00045 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 32A. nano treated hybrid polymer polymer: solv: catalysts, nano fillers: nano polymers nano treated IEM matched to used in forming coatings, ZCM, PFSA-PTFE, PFIA nanolayers IEM polymer. polymers match PtCM, NP coated PFSA-PVA-PTFE, SPA-PVA nanofibers pillar: membrane, not CNTs (PtNH2, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES nanocoatings reinforcing filler TiNH2, PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 NP, sPVA, sPBI, sCS nanoparticles fillers (C-fiber, X-L: reagents PtSn, rad graft, 32B. novel nano polymer nanoclusters CNTs) matching nano fiber (sPS), PDA, P(sDA) nanospheres membrane SPDA NP, P(DA- P(DA-sDA) nanotubes polymer SDA) NP PFSA-PTFEP(DA-sDA) nanocomposite other fillers: DCM, ZCM, PtCM sac filler, oxides, s(PVA-co-SPA-co-PEO) POSS, MOFs, PIL radiation grafted IEM P(sPS) NF infused IEM
[2433] Endoskeletal support is matched to the membrane chemistry as is applicable solvents, polymerizing agents, catalysts, and cross linkers. Nano fillers described herein include nano coatings, composite coated membrane (DCM, ZCM, PtCM); nanoparticle coated CNTs (PtNH.sub.2, TiNH.sub.2, PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 NP, PtSn); radiation grafted polymers; nanofibers of sPS; dopamine nanoparticles (PDA, sPDA, P(DA-sDA)). Aside from nano fillers, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
33. Functionalized Hybrid Zirconium-Doped Polymer IEMs.
[2434] The element zirconium is a ductile metal highly resistant to corrosion and heat. Applications include its use in ceramics, lamp filaments, catalytic converters, nuclear reactors, furnace bricks, and other high temperature environments. Zirconium and its compounds such as zirconium phosphate can also function as an inorganic ion exchanger and solid state proton conductor making it attractive for use in batteries and in fuel cells.
[2435] As depicted in
[2436] By contrast type zirconium phosphate Zr(PO.sub.4)(O.sub.2P(OH).sub.2).Math.2H.sub.2O, zirconium atoms are arranged in parallel planes 2061a and 2061b bound to other planes by PO.sub.4.sup.3 tetrahedra 2063a, 2063b, and 2063c via unprotonated oxygen, but ultimately terminating with hydroxide atoms. In type zirconium, exposed phosphate groups are replaced by monovalent anions X 2964 and a neutral ligand Y 2076 represented by the general formula Zr(PO.sub.4)XY, where X={F.sup., Cl.sup., Br.sup., OH.sup., HSO.sub.4.sup.} and Y={DMSO, H.sub.2O}.
[2437] Although the tri-dentate phosphate groups 2062 in -type zirconium phosphate are better suited for proton conduction or ion separation filtering than its other configurations, ion exchange membranes comprising layered zirconium phosphate perform unremarkably compared to other ionomeric polymers. Instead composite membranes doped with nanosized zirconium phosphate, phosphonates or organophosphates offer a higher potential than bulk zirconium phosphate. The Zr nanoparticles can be used as ionomeric fillers in a variety of membrane types including PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, polyether sulfone (PESf), and others.
[2438] For example
[2439] For example, the in situ formation of ZrO.sub.2 nanoparticles within the pores of an ion exchange membrane can modulate water uptake, i.e. either increase or decrease hydration, as well as improve selectivity and conductivity. The bonding mechanisms for a Zr NP within a IEM pore and the resulting impact on ion concentrations and pH is depicted graphically
[2440] As shown, a conduction channel 2081 in membrane 2080 contains a number of free protons 2082 and electrons 2083 that varies with pH of the solute. The addition of a ZrO.sub.2 nanoparticle NP 2084 in the pore electrostatically bonds 2085 to the interior sidewall. The catalytic action of the NP buffers the acid base reactions facilitating neutralization of excess protons 2082 by electrons 2083 reducing the impact of pH variations on IEM conduction. Such electrochemical auto-regulatory mechanisms are especially valuable in ionomeric membranes used in electrodialysis, electro-deionization, and diffusion dialysis.
[2441] Although zirconium can beneficially affect the performance of a ion exchange membrane, it cannot control porosity or pore density nor improve film durability. When combined with other features made in accordance with this invention such as the use of a sacrificial filler to form vacancies to capture and hold the Zr nanoparticles or the addition of an endoskeleton to provide mechanical support to the membrane, the potential benefit of zirconium in IEM function is greatly enhanced.
[2442] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2456] Features of a zirconium doped polymer for filtration or as an ion exchange membrane are described in the following table including a description of various ionomers, as well as applicable endoskeleton constructions, solvents and reagents used in its fabrication, cross linking molecules used to induce polymerization as well as to promote bonding between the polymer the endoskeletal pillars. The table also lists a variety of fillers which can be added to improve performance and film durability.
TABLE-US-00046 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 33. Zr-doped polymers Zr doped polymer: solv: catalysts, Zr fillers: PFSA-PTFE, PFIA hybrid polymer matched to IEM used in forming (Zr(O.sub.3POH).sub.2 PFSA-PVA-PTFE, SPA-PVA polymer. polymers match Zr(PO.sub.4)XY, ZrO.sub.2 SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES pillar: reinforcing membrane, not NPs sPVA, sPBI, sCS fillers (C-fiber, filler other fillers: CNTs) X-L: reagents sac filler, CNTs, match oxides, POSS, membrane NPs, MOFs, PIL polymer
[2457] Zirconium doping made in accordance with this invention can be added to any type of membrane, wither by coating the membrane of by infusing the polymer with ZrO2 nanoparticles. In one embodiment, the Zr NPs residing within the membrane are contained within vacancies created in the matrix using the described sacrificial filler process. Endoskeletal support is matched to the membrane chemistry as is applicable solvents, polymerizing agents, catalysts, and cross linkers. Zirconium fillers described herein, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
34. Functionalized Hybrid Metal Oxide Framework (MOF) Doped Polymer IEMs.
[2458] Metal oxide frameworks represent a new class of membrane dopants combining organic and metallic components. In a MOF a matrix of metal atoms are interlinked into a framework by organic ligands. A MOF is the metallic version of a covalent organic framework (COF). COFs are a class of materials forming porous quasi crystalline structures connected by strong covalent bonds. Because they lack metal atoms however COFs cannot provide the same degree of catalytic activity or conductivity boosts that metal atom offer.
[2459] The behavior of a MOF depend not only on its composition but on its crystalline structure.
[2460] The ligands bond to the metal core and can therefore are referred to as metal-to-organic ligands labelled by the homophonic acronym M2O. Convex MOF topologies increase the ratio of functional groups to metal ions thereby reducing the relative electrochemical contribution of metal within the MOF in favor of more functional groups. For example one catalyst metal ion can break a molecule into multiple pieces, where the functional groups chemically process the resulting pieces.
[2461] The coordination number or CN defines the number of ligands bonded to a metal atom regardless if whether the terminus of the organic ligand is a functional group or another metal atom. In the example shown CN=6 means six organic ligands 2101o are bonded to central metal atom 2100. In this manner the CN represents the degree of connectivity of the metal atoms in the frame. By example a CN=8 metal atom has a greater number of attached organic ligands than a CN=6 MOF topology. While in the case of a convex MOF a higher CN means ratiometrically more functional groups than metal ions, in a concave MOF comprising closed geometric figures such as cubes and trapezoids, a larger CN number indicated a greater degree of metal-to-metal scaffolding and mechanical strength and/or rigidity. Note the term CN is an acronym for coordination number and should not be confused with the abbreviation for toxic chemical cyanide.
[2462] Another example is the cluster MOF comprising two or more atoms bonded to functional groups 2102 by metal-to-organic M2P ligands 2101o but where the metal atoms are bond by metal-to-metal, i.e. M2M, ligands 2101m. The metal to metal bonds add additional structure and strength to the MOF without sacrificing the density of functional termini. A concave MOF as shown primarily comprises immobile metal atoms arranged in a fixed geometric pattern by a special M2M ligand 2106 able to attach to functional groups 2104, where in most cases the functional groups do not bond to the metal ions through a dedicated M2O ligand. In such cases the metallic framework is strengthened but with reduced electrochemical activity of the functional groups. In some cases the purpose of the functional groups is to capture and sequester foreign molecules including toxins, salts, or gasses. Applications of MOFs thereby may possibly include water filtration, blood electrodialysis, hydrogen capture and storage, desalinization, and even capture of radioactive elements such as uranium or radioactive cesium.
[2463] As illustrated some of the functional groups may located inside the geometric structure, hence the term concave MOF, while other groups may exist outside the frame like a convex MOF. In many applications such as molecular sequestering the exterior functional groups are not strong enough to indefinitely hold guest atoms and ions. Conversely, for the concentric facing functional groups, the retention of MOF guests is supported by the added framework of the M2M ligands 2106 that act as prison bars preventing accidental escape of sequestered visitor molecules. Pressure and temperature affect equilibrium ratio of captured and free molecules as well as the size and electrostatic surface potential of captured ions.
[2464] The volumetric capacity of a regular geometrically shaped MOFs can be extended into three-dimensions as exemplified in
[2465]
[2466]
[2467]
[2468] As shown in the left side drawing of
[2469] Although the 2112a, 2112b, and 2112c bonds comprise Van der Waals or hydrogen bonds, secured by the expansive spiderweb like network of PFA-PTFE 2111 polymer fibers, the MOF quasi crystals are non-subject to dislocation within the matrix. It should be noted that bonding within the MOF is covalent bonding through organic ligands while crystal-to-crystal bonds are not as strong, being electrostatic in nature. Through its functional groups MOFs can enhance electrochemical activity, catalysis, ionic selectivity, or conductivity of a membrane.
[2470]
[2471] Metal complexes may be formed by any number of transition metals including basic zinc acetate 2135 with formula Zn.sub.4O(CH.sub.3CO.sub.2).sub.6 and with coordination number CN=4 shown in
[2472] A key component of any MOF is the organic ligand used for metal-to-metal bonding. Material selection and processing determines the relative ratio of proton sites (PS) to proton hopping sites (PHS). As depicted in
[2473] Although reactivity of an MOF can be enhanced, highly reactive metal atoms or metal clusters functioning as catalysts or ionomers become increasingly put at risk for poisoning from carbon monoxide and other toxins proportion to electrochemical activity. Aside from carbon monoxide, other compounds poison to metallic catalysts such as Pt and Pd include halides, cyanides, sulfides, sulfites, phosphates, phosphites, and organic molecules such as nitriles, nitro compounds, oximes, and nitrogen-containing heterocycles. Poisoning generally involves a toxin bonding to active sites of a catalyst, reducing the catalytic density and increasing the mean free path required for reactants to reach a catalyst.
[2474] If the poisoning occurs slowly the catalyst layer coating a PEM membrane will become dysfunctional in a unform homogenous manner. Conversely, if the reaction occurs rapidly damage will concentrate near the gas inlet impeding gas flow by an inactive shell, a condition known as pore-mouth poisoning. To prevent poisoning three inventive solutions are proposed (a) remove toxins by a chemical scrubber at the gas ingress, (b) employ scavenger metals to capture and sequester toxic gasses from reaching the catalyst metal, or (c) restoring damaged catalysts by detoxifying the active site of the metal.
[2475] Although metal organic frameworks may play a role in all three solutions, an inventive MOF design can be especially beneficial in case (b), reducing the statistical probability of a toxin reaching the catalyst sites by chemical gettering. Specifically by imposing scavenger metals along the path of gas flow, i.e. metals not involved catalysis or conduction, the likelihood that a toxin can ever reach active metal sites is diminished. The scavenger metal laced MOFs can be present within the polymeric membrane, within the catalyst layer, or coated atop the catalyst layer.
[2476] In one embodiment of a scavenger MOF, a metal oxide framework contains two types of transition metals, one serving as the catalyst or ionomer, the other functioning as a scavenger. Made in accordance with this invention,
[2477] By contrast, the ligand scavenger shown in the center illustration comprises a homogenous MOF with catalyst metals 2170c and conventional M2M organic ligands 2171c. Instead, the functional groups bound to ligands 2171c are replaced with scavenger metals 2174 or organo-metallic complexes. In a third embodiment depicted on the right side of the drawing, a convention metal oxide framework with homogenous metal catalysts 2170c, conventional M2M organic ligands 2171c and organic functional groups 2173 contains guest molecule 2175 containing scavenger metals designed to lure toxins away from the corner catalyst metal atoms 2170c.
[2478] Scavenger-catalyst MOFs can be extended into multi-planar matrices. As shown in
[2479]
[2480] A key design consideration for the inventive catalyst-scavenger framework is the M2M organic ligands needed to bond the scavenger metals to the catalyst metal. To determine the organic ligands used for realizing such a heterogenous metal framework, the specific metals must be considered.
[2481] Each element on the table is identified by its atomic number, its chemical symbol, and its elemental name and highlighting dangerous, toxic, and radioactive elements consistent with RoHS government standards and symbols. The table is also arranged in rows representing the period of element. Transition metals are limited to the periods 4 through 7 of which all period 7 elements, i.e. from atomic numbers 103 to 113, along with the specific period 6 elements technetium Tc and ruthenium Ru having atomic numbers 43 and 44. Depending on its form osmium Os, atomic number 76, can be a severe respiratory irritant and in other cases a deadly toxin. It may however be used safely as in certain alloy forms.
[2482] Other transition metals excluded by RoHS standards for toxicity include vanadium V, cadmium Cd, and mercury Hg, atomic numbers 23, 48, and 80. Aside from these elements excluded for use in the their pure form, the remaining transition metals in block 2180 may be used in MOFs. Specifically the metals contained within subblock 2181, the PGM platinum group metals aka the noble precious metals, are especially useful as catalysts and ionomers in ion exchange membranes. They include rhodium Rh, palladium Pd, iridium Ir, platinum Pt and gold Au. Silver is often not considered a noble metal as it cab easily be oxidized.
[2483]
[2484] In methanol fuel cells, however, pure platinum is ineffective because of its inability to absorb water and oxidize away water. Instead in methanol fuel cells, a platinum-ruthenium allow is preferred as they bind the oxygen present in water where Rh is a period 5 metal. Other studies have considered an alloy of quaternary alloy containing platinum, ruthenium, osmium, and iridium, showing improved oxygen generation in direct methanol fuel cells. In accordance with this invention, good candidates for scavenger metals include the period 4 metals iron, cobalt, and nickel and possibly ruthenium in period 5.
[2485] The selection of bimetallic ligands able to bond dissimilar metals, i.e. a metal-ligand-hetero metal, is a key element of realizing the catalyst-scavenger MOF made in accordance with this invention. The previously unreported ligands are illustrated for protecting platinum and titanium catalysts using the low cost widely available period 4 metals 2184 comprising iron (Fe), cobalt (Co), and nickel (Ni) as scavenger metals. Accordingly, metal-ligand-hetero-metal (M-L-hM) MOFs 2200 required to covalently bond catalyst metals 2201c labelled C to scavenger metals 2201s labelled S require special organic ligands 2202. In this chemical nomenclature M refers to metal attached to one end of the organic ligand and hM refers to a hetero metal, meaning a metal attached to the other end of the organic ligand 2202 may be different than the metal M.
[2486] For example,
[2487]
[2488] Other Fe-L-Ti ligands shown in
[2489]
[2490] Other Co-L-Pt organic ligands shown in
[2491]
[2492]
[2493]
[2494] Although the MOFs described can be included in a polymer during molding, infusing MOFs into a polymer after polymerization is difficult because of the limited size and density of channels and pores present in most polymers. Made in accordance with this invention, one solution to this challenge is to employs the sacrificial filler process described previously herein. As illustrated in
[2495] For example if the polymer is PFSA and the filler in sucrose, water can remove the sugar from the polymer without damaging the PFSA material. The resulting membrane 4007b retains voids 4006b, i.e. chambers and holes where the sucrose previously resided. In step 4005c, MOF filler 4008 is synthesized and mixed into solution. In step 4005d the membrane is treated with the MOD laden solution, infusing the MOF particles into the polymeric matrix filling the voids with MOF nanoparticles 4006c resulting in functionalized membrane 4005e.
[2496]
[2497] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2517] Metal organic frameworks comprise fillers and dopants that may be incorporated into a polymer matrix or applied as a coating. They do not comprise the polymer matrix itself.
[2518] Examples of MOF doped membranes include fluorocarbons such as PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, PFIA, PFSA-PVA-PTFE; hydrocarbons such as SPA-PVA, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES, sPVA, and SPA-PVA; phenyl based polymers such as phenylene-benzimidazole (PBI) and poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) (PVBC); polysaccharides such as chitosan, as well as grafted polymers.
[2519] MOF fillers may comprise any number of geometries including convex coordinations (stars, clusters), and convex cage-like structures (cubes, trapezoids, mirrored trapezoids, rectangular arrays, hexagonal drums, octagonal drums). Metal atoms forming a MOF's geometric corners include any metal including transition metals, refractory metals, noble metals, or metal complexes such as Zr.sub.6O.sub.4(OH).sub.4, Zn.sub.4O(CH.sub.3CO.sub.2).sub.6. The metal framework may also form clusters such as sulfonic ferrous metal cluster (Fe-MIL-101-NH.sub.2PPOSO.sub.2Cl), chromium terephthalate metal cluster (MIL-101(Cr)), or zinc-oxide hexaphosphate ester (Zn.sub.6O.sub.24.Math.C.sub.6H.sub.18O.sub.24P.sub.6).
[2520] The following table describes characteristics of MOF fillers and the membranes they are used as fillers or dopants:
TABLE-US-00047 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 34A. MOF doped polymers MOF doped polymer: matched solv: catalysts, MOF fillers: cat PFSA-PTFE, PFIA and grafted to IEM polymer used in forming MOFs (Pt, Pd, Ti), PFSA-PVA-PTFE hybrid pillar: reinforcing polymers match scav MOFs (Co, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES polymers fillers (C-fiber, membrane, not Ni, Fe), cat-scav sPVA, SPA-PVA CNTs) filler MOFs, scav guest sPBI, sCS X-L: reagents MOFs, sMOFs, 34B. MOF graft polymers matching metal clusters PVBC-co-OPBI-TG membrane other fillers: polymer sac filler, CNTs, oxides, POSS, NPs, MOFs, PIL
[2521] Catalyst (cat) MOFs include Pt, Pd, and Ti metals. Scavenger (scav) metals bonding carbon monoxide (CO) to prevent poisoning include Fe, Ni, and Co configured on MOF corners or as cage guests. Sulfonated versions (sMOFs) include sulfonic acid groups bound to the organic ligands or to a guest molecule. Made in accordance with this invention a special category of MOF doped IEMs comprises vacancies in the polymer created by the previously described sacrificial filler process where the vacancies are subsequently filled by MOFs.
[2522] Endoskeletal support is matched to the membrane chemistry as is applicable solvents, polymerizing agents, catalysts, and cross linkers. Aside from MOFs described herein, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
35. Functionalized Hybrid Tungsten (W) Doped Polymer IEMs.
[2523] Transition-metal carbides (TMCs) exhibit catalytic properties similar to platinum group metals (PGMs) but at a fraction of the cost. Unfortunately present day TMC synthesis involves numerous unresolved problems preventing their commercial deployment. A more attractive option is to adopt nanofabrication methods to produce nano-TMCs, 1-to-4 microns in size. Benefits include controlled composition, adjustable crystallinity, and tunable sizes. Of the various candidate metals for producing nano-TMCs, the high-temperature refractory metal tungsten and its alloys, including tungsten carbide (WC) and molybdenum tungsten carbide (Mo.sub.cW.sub.1-xC).
[2524] Although not matching the performance of platinum catalysts, applications for lower cost tungsten carbide catalysts includes a diverse range of applications including hydrogenation, dehydrogenation, hydrogenolysis, isomerization, and electrochemistry.
[2525] Such sequences include non-sintered, metal-terminated tungsten carbide nanoparticles for catalysis and durable self-hydrating tungsten carbide-based composites as polymer electrolytes applicable in membrane fuel cells and batteries.
[2526] In an alternative approach shown in
[2527] Because of its high temperature capabilities, tungsten can be used to boost conductivity in hydrocarbon based ionomeric membranes. As an example,
[2528] As shown, sodium pentacyano-ammineferroate (SPCAF) 2271 is combined with 1,4,7,10,13-penta-oxacyclopentadecane (15-crown-5) 2272 dissolved in solution using water (H.sub.2O) as a solvent and by ammonia (NH.sub.2) and mixed with poly(4-vinylpyridine) (P4VP) 2270 dissolved in methanol (MeOH) to produce pentacyano-ammineferroate poly(4-vinylpyridine) 2273. Thereafter blending pentacyano-ammineferroate poly(4-vinylpyridine) 2273 with 15-crown-5 2272 as reactants produces the polymer ferrocyanide-coordinated poly(4-vinylpyridine) (CP4VP) 2274.
[2529]
[2530]
[2531] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2545] As described, membranes particularly well suited to tungsten doping include those comprising polymers poly(4-vinylpyridine) (P.sub.4VP) and quaternized polyethyleneimine (QPEI); copolymers PSf-co-P4VP and PVA-co-QPEI; and ionomers CP4VP and R.sub.4N.sup.+. The following table describes characteristics of tungsten doped membranes mad in accordance with this invention including tungsten doped polymers, copolymers, and the application of tungsten as a general conductive filler in polymers: Examples of tungsten doped membranes include fluorocarbons such as PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, PFIA, PFSA-PVA-PTFE; hydrocarbons such as SPA-PVA, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES, sPVA, and SPA-PVA; phenyl based polymers such as phenylene-benzimidazole (PBI) and poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) (PVBC); polysaccharides such as chitosan, as well as grafted polymers.
TABLE-US-00048 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 35A. W-doped copolymers tungsten (W) polymer: solv: catalysts, W fillers: PWA, polymers: PV4P, QPEI doped hybrid matched to IEM used in forming WC NPs, copolymer: PSf-co-P4VP polymers and polymer. polymers match other fillers: copolymer: PVA-co-QPEI copolymers pillar: reinforcing membrane, not sac filler, CNTs, ionomers: CP4VP, R.sub.4N.sup.+ fillers (C-fiber, filler oxides, POSS, 35B. W-doped polymers CNTs) X-L: reagents other NPs, PIL PFSA-PTFE, PFIA match MOFs PFSA-PVA-PTFE, SPA-PVA membrane SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES polymer sPVA, sPBI, sCS
[2546] Endoskeletal support is matched to the membrane chemistry as is applicable solvents, polymerizing agents, catalysts, and cross linkers. Tungsten dopants and fillers include tungsten carbide (WC) and phosphotungstic acid (PWA). Aside from W-doping, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
36. Functionalized Hybrid Zeolite-Doped Polymer IEMs.
[2547] Zeolite (ZI) is a microporous crystalline aluminosilicate useful either as a catalyst or as a filler affecting porosity of a polymer matrix. Primarily comprising a crystalline compound of silicon, aluminum, and oxygen, zeolite is a solid with the chemical constituency M.sup.+(AlO.sub.2).sup.(SiO.sub.2).sub.x.Math.(H.sub.2O).sub.y where M is a metal ion, or may comprise H.sup.+, Na.sup.+ and other cations. Structurally, the
[2548] Structural descriptions of zeolite have been categorized in a 2016 PhD study at Univ of Manchester entitled Membrane electrode assembly modification by zeolite and graphene oxide to reduce methanol permeation in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell, Other description for zeolite structure includes the Wikipedia reference entitled Zeolite.
[2549] As described formulaically for every aluminate (AlO.sub.2) molecule zeolite contains x silicate (SiO.sub.2) molecules, meaning the variable x represents the silicon-to-aluminum ratio Si/AI. While zeolites with high Si/Al ratios, e.g. for x >3, zeolites are more hydrophobic. At lower x ratios a correspondingly greater preponderance of negatively charged AlO.sup.Al bonds increases electrostatic attraction of cations, labelled here as M+. The charges attract hydronium ions filling the microporous cavities of zeolite with water. Zeolite crystalline microporous structures having typical diameters of 0.3-0.8 nm, however are not structurally supported by absorbed water, but by rigid covalent bonding.
[2550] Accordingly the loss of water does not result in collapse of zeolite cavities and channels the way it does in PFSA membranes. The ability to structurally maintain voids within the solid material explains zeolites ability to function as a catalyst over a wide range of relative humidities without loss of structural integrity. The catalytic capability of zeolite makes it applicable, as a bulk membrane dopant, as a membrane surface coating, and as an interfacial layer between membranes and catalysts or gas diffusion layers. It also can be used to functionalize filtration membranes with antibacterial, antioxidative, and anticorrosion properties.
[2551]
[2552] Another process for functionalizing a zeolite template is described in a paper Sulfonic acid functionalization of different zeolites and their use as catalysts in the microwave-assisted etherification of glycerol with tert-butyl alcohol, in Molecules 12 Dec. 2017. Although the specific reaction is not applicable to forming ionomeric membranes, it does confirm that a zeolite surface can be functionalized by ionomeric groups.
[2553] A more simplistic process for functionalizing molecular zeolite with sulfonic acid represented schematically in
[2554] In yet another process shown in
[2555] Like the myriad of silicon-oxide crystals on display in a museum's minerology exhibit, zeolite geometric shapes rely on the reaction conditions when the crystal is formed. Depending on reactants, temperature, pH, concentrations, catalysts, and cooling rates the geometries of zeolite can take on numerous configurations. For example
[2556]
[2557]
[2558] Functionalized zeolite nanoparticles can also be complexed into nanoclusters as shown in
[2559] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2572] The following table describes zeolite doped polymers and copolymers:
TABLE-US-00049 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 36A. zeolite frameworks zeolite doped polymer: solv: catalysts, zeolite fillers: PhSA-Zl polymers and matched to used in forming Zl NP, Zl NC, 36B. zeolite doped polymers copolymers IEM polymer. polymers match s-mordenite PFSA-PTFE, PFIA pillar: membrane, not other filers: PFSA-PVA-PTFE, SPA-PVA reinforcing filler sac filler, CNTs, SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES fillers (C-fiber, X-L: reagents oxides, POSS, sPVA, sPBI, sCS CNTs) match membrane NPs, MOFs, PIL polymer
[2573] Examples include phenyl sulfonic acid zeolite based membranes and various zeolite fillers including zeolite nanoparticles, zeolite nanoclusters, and sulfonated mordenite. Endoskeletal support is matched to the membrane chemistry as is applicable solvents, polymerizing agents, catalysts, and cross linkers. Aside from zeolites described herein, membrane fillers and dopants described previously have been omitted for the sake of brevity, and will not be repeated here.
37. Functionalized Acid-Base Polysulfone (PSf) Polymer IEMs.
[2574] Some membrane may be considered acid-base ion exchange membranes. An acid-base ion exchange membrane is a type of membrane that facilitates the selective passage of ions between two solutions while preventing the passage of other particles, such as larger molecules or ions of a different charge. These membranes are typically used in processes like electrodialysis, fuel cells, and other electrochemical applications.
[2575] The acid-base part of the name refers to the functional groups attached to the polymer matrix of the membrane. An acidic ion exchange membrane has sulfonic acid groups (SO.sub.3H), which can release protons (H.sup.+) and exchange them with other positively charged ions, i.e. cations in the solution. Conversely, a basic ion exchange membrane has amine groups (NH.sub.2), which can release hydroxide ions (OH) and exchange them with other anions (negatively charged ions) in the solution.
[2576] The main purpose of these membranes is to allow for the selective transport of ions based on their charge and size, balanced reactions required for maintaining charge neutrality across the membrane while allowing for the separation of different substances or the generation of electricity in the case of fuel cells. The acid-base nature of the membrane determines which type of ions it will preferentially transport. An example of a polymer used in acid-base ion exchange membranes is polysulfone. Although a polysulfone heteropolymer IEM is discussed in section 22, this section describes various polysulfone moieties in terms of acid-base chemistry and features thereof.
[2577]
[2578] To functionalize a polysulfone polymer into an ionomer, sulfonic acid molecules are attached as pendants on the polymeric backbone using grafting or substitution reactions. One such process shown in
[2579] One method for synthesis of Udel polysulfone 2341 shown in
[2580] Once exemplary process shown in
[2581]
[2582] Another element of fabricating polysulfone based ion exchange membranes is the inclusion of permanent fillers comprising nanospheres, graphene, carbon nanotubes, and polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes aka POSS, described previously and separately in this application. Their use to enhance the mechanical and electrical properties of polysulfones is therefore exemplary but not limiting or exclusive, and is therefore the description. in this section is not an exhaustive treatment of the molecular or nanostructure additives. One such additive is platinum-titanium nanoparticles or nanospheres such as Pt-Ti NPs of varying chemical compositions.
[2583] One such nanoparticle shown in
[2584] As shown, polysulfone membrane 3002 comprises a network of polymeric sulfone chains and sulfonated polysulfone chains 2341s forming backbones of the lattice to which pendants with ionomer terminus 2341i attach. During fabrication, shards of functionalized graphene oxide FPGO-sPSf 2354z and nanoparticles PtTiO.sub.2 NPs 2357 also bond onto the polysulfone chains 2341 to limit their migration during conduction, generally through hydrogen or Van der Waal bonds. Free floating molecules of water H.sub.2O 2348 and proton ionized water referred to as hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+ are naturally present within the lattice affecting film conduction and hydration. Charge conduction within the doped polysulfone film can occur by two mechanisms either by proton hopping aka as the Grotthuss mechanism or by vehicular transport.
[2585] In charge hopping shown by the arrows protons can jump among the various ionomeric elements, namely from HSO.sub.3 ionomer 2341, PtTiO.sub.2 NPs 2357, and functionalized graphene oxide FPGO-sPSf 2354z. In vehicular transport, various forms of water serve as the molecular transport carrier. Although water can chemically bond to nearly any polar molecule to conduct electricity, proton conduction occurs primary by hydronium ions. When water (H.sub.2O) reacts to form a hydronium ion (H.sub.3O), it gains a proton (H.sup.+) from an acid. This process is known as protonation, which is neither oxidation or reduction. More specifically in redox reactions, oxidation is defined as the loss of electrons, and reduction is defined as the gain of electrons.
[2586] Since the formation of a hydronium ion involves the gain of a proton rather than the gain or loss of electrons, it does not fit the definition of oxidation or reduction. Because the hydronium ion has a net positive charge it acts as a cation in a fuel cell flowing from anode to cathode under influence of an electric field, a conduction process referred to as drift. If however the concentration of hydronium ions N in the anode exceeds that of the cathode the concentration gradient also drives a second charge conduction mechanism known as diffusion having a current magnitude per area I/A proportional to the concentration gradient (dN/dx). Total fuel cell current is the sum of its drift and diffusion components offset by losses from charged oxygen molecules flowing from the cathode to anode and counter opposing proton conduction, but still producing heat as an unwanted byproduct.
[2587] Both proton hopping and vehicular charge transport mechanisms are illustrated in an alternative version of a polysulfone membrane 3002 shown in
[2588] Despite the filler substitution, conduction mechanisms are similar when proton hopping conduction 2336 occurs primarily through HSO.sub.3 ionomers 2341i and occasionally through ion exchange involving POSS fillers 2358. Unlike nanoparticles, however, POSS fillers 2358 can also enhance vehicular charge transport 2337 by maintaining a higher concentration of hydronium carriers available for charge transport, and to reduce gas permeability to reduce drag from fuel crossover. For clarification purposes, protonation of water involving the process H.sub.2O+H.sup.+.fwdarw.H.sub.3O is shown in region 2338 where incoming hydrogen ionized by MEA3 catalyst combines with water to form positively charged hydronium ions.
[2589] In summary membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2602] Endoskeletal pillar materials compatible with polysulfone membranes include: polyether ether ketone (PEEK) and polyetherimide (PEI) bonded to polysulfones using high-performance adhesives resistant to high temperatures; polyamide (PAm) bondable to PSf using adhesives such as epoxy resins or polyurethane adhesives pursuant to surface preparation such as roughening; polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP) although difficult to bond may use epoxies or modified acrylic bonding subsequent to surface treatments such as corona and plasma treatments used to increase the surface energy and improve adhesion; polycarbonate (PC) bondable to polycarbonate using adhesives that are compatible with both materials such as certain epoxies or solvent-based adhesives; acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) bondable to polysulfones using adhesives like cyanoacrylates, epoxies, or solvent-based adhesives after suitable surface preparation; polyurethanes (PU) using adhesives that form strong bonds with both materials, including polyurethane adhesives and some epoxies; and polybenzimidazole (PBI) with suitable adhesives.
[2603] The following table describes characteristics of polysulfone acid-base membranes. As articulated, acid-base polymers of sulfonated polysulfone (sPSU, sPSf), bromated polysulfone (BrPSU, BrPSf), and para-linked bromated polysulfone (BrPSU.sub.x, BrPSf.sub.x), exemplify polymers involved in acid base membrane chemistry:
TABLE-US-00050 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 37A. polysulfone polymers PSf acid- polymer (PSf): PEI other solv: sulfone fillers: sPSf base PEEK, PBI, PAm, PE, reagents used in POSS, PtTiO.sub.2 BrPSf fillers & PP, PC, ABS, PU forming polymer NPs, FPGO-sPSf para-linked (BrPSf).sub.x polymers polymer (other): match membrane, other fillers: 37B. polysulfone filler matched to IEM not filler sac filler, CNTs, doped polymer. X-L: reagents oxides, POSS, PFSA-PTFE, PFIA pillar: reinforcing match membrane NPs, MOFs, PIL PFSA-PVA-PTFE fillers (C-fiber, polymer SPA-PVA CNTs) SPAES, sPEEK, sPEES sPVA, sPBI, sCS
[2604] Solvents used in forming polysulfone polymers include N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), chloroform (CHCl.sub.3), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), or cadmium chloride (CdCL.sub.2). Catalysts and reagents beneficial in polymerizing polysulfone membranes and cross linking them to other polymers include Friedel-Crafts catalysts such as ferric chloride (FeCl.sub.3, iron (III) chloride) or antimony pentachloride (SbCl.sub.5). Cross linking of polysulfone can be performed by 4,4-trimethylene bis(1-methylpiperidine) (BMP) or by photoinduced cross linking in 2,4,6-trimethylbenzoyl-diphenyl-phosphine oxide (TPO) and trimethylolpropane tri-acrylate (TMPTA).
[2605] Acid base polymer specific fillers include polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes (POSS), platinum titanium dioxide nanoparticles (PtTiO2 NPs), and functionalized poly graphene oxide sulfonated polysulfone (FPGO-sPSf). Other membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
38. Functionalized Anhydrous Poly-Bibenzimidazole (PBI) Polymer IEMs.
[2606] Another class of high performance acid-base polymers comprising robust polymeric mainchains and strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding is polybenzimidazoles (PBIs). PBIs are noteworthy for their superior material properties of durability, heat resistance, mechanical strength, chemical stability, radiation resistance, and stable dielectric constants. Non electrical applications of PBI polymers include clothing for harsh environments like firefighters, astronauts, protective work gloves, and welders apparel. PBI has also been adapted for use in proton exchange membranes. Since the pristine polymer is not conductive, PBI must first be functionalized by chemically attaching ionomeric groups onto the polymer to support hopping conduction. Other means to enhance conductivity involve the application of permanent fillers to introduce additional ionomeric groups into the matrix.
[2607] Polybenzimidazoles do not however make good aqueous ion exchange membranes as PBI tends to dry out, especially at temperatures of 80 C. or higher. Instead acid-base PBIs are used in anhydrous reactions where acids rather than water are involved in carrier transport and supplying protons. Because of the basic characteristic of the polymer, charge carriers require acids. Unlike. liquid acid fuel cell, these acids remain mostly sequestered in the ion exchange membrane behaving as dopants, i.e. proton sources, analogous to the way boron introduced into silicon crystal creates positive charges called holes to transport charge. These acid carriers may comprise phosphoric or sulfuric acid. Alternative acids include phytic acid and phosphotungstic acid. The acids however are unable to damage the PBI polymeric matrix even at temperatures as high as 200 C.
[2608] One method to introduce immobile or quasi-mobile acidic proton sources into the polymer matrix is through the use of protic ionic liquids (PIL). A protic ionic liquid is an ionic liquid that is formed via proton transfer from a Brnsted acid to a Brnsted base. As described by the Brnsted-Lowry theory, an acid base reaction involves the transfer betwixt the two thereby conjugating them into a linked pair. By exchanging a proton (H.sup.+) the acid forms its conjugate base and the base forms its conjugate acid thereby creating a stable link with reversible reactions. In recognition of the discovery a conjugated acid is referred to as a Brnsted acid and its base pair is called a Brnsted base as summarized by the equation
HA+BA.sup.+HB.sup.+
where acid HA is a proton donor which becomes a conjugate base A.sup. after surrendering its proton, and where base B is a proton acceptor becoming a conjugate acid HB.sup.+ after accepting a proton.
[2609]
[2610] Unlike many water based ion exchange membranes using fluorinated polymers, PBI is composed entirely of aromatic hydrocarbons, i.e. pentagonal and hexagonal carbon ring like structures. Fabrication methods for PBI vary.
[2611]
[2612] A process for forming a PBI variantpoly(arylene ether benzimidazole) is described in 5.17Aromatic polyethers, polyetherketones, polysulfides, and polysulfones, in Chapter 17 of the book Polymer Science: A Comprehensive Reference, 2012 Elsevier BV. The process show in
[2613] Although PBI is able to conduct protons in the presence of unbound phosphoric acid, embodiments of this invention the acid may comprise a membrane bound ionomer of an acid of phosphorus or of sulfur. Creating a polymer mainchain attached ionomer generally involves a substitution reaction of a membrane side group. For example in
[2614] PBI can also form bonds with sulfonic acid groups.
[2615] The main polymer of polybenzimidazole varies with the number of aromatic rings in the mainchain. As shown in
[2616]
[2617] Another modification to PBI polymers is shown in
[2618]
[2619]
[2620]
[2621] Alternatively, crosslinking ImCCP 2411z with PBI/OPBI nanofibers 2381x produces a related but distinct copolymer imidazolechloro cyclotriphosphazene-co-polybenzimidazole (ImCCP-co-PBI) 2413. In both cases, the starfish shaped HCCP 2410z and ImCCP 2411z crosslinkers produce similarly strong PBI copolymers.
[2622] As shown in
[2623] The structural cross linking of oxydiphthalic polybenzimidazole (OPBI) to poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) aka PVBC using quaternary ammonia to form a OPBI-co-PVBC copolymer membrane is illustrated in
[2624] Another PBI copolymer illustrated in
[2625]
[2626] As depicted in
[2627] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2640] Polybenzimidazole used in anhydrous IEMs comprise a diverse spectrum of polymers and copolymers. The two most common classes of PBIs comprise the five aromatic ring moiety named poly 2,2-(phenylene)-5,5-bibenzimidazole commonly referred to as p-PBI, m-PBI, or simply PBI and a five aromatic ring variant containing a single oxygen on its mainchain referred to as oxy-polybenzimidazole with the acronyms O-PBI or OPBI. Other variants include the two-ring ABPBI, the dihydroxy 20H-PBI, dioxy 2O-PBI, hexafluorinated F.sub.6-PBI, and sulfur dioxide SO.sub.2PBI.
[2641] PBI may also form heteropolymers such as poly(arylene ether benzimidazole) PAEBI or PBI-ZIF, and sidechain sulfur dioxide SCSO.sub.2PBI. PBI copolymers include a terephthaloyl chloride, aminodiphenyl sulfone, dihydrogen phosphate TCI-co-PhDP-TDS; hexachlorocyclotriphosphazene HCCP-co-PBI, imidazolechlorocyclotriphosphazene ImCCP-co-PBI; poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) OPBI-co-PVB; and polyaniline OPBI-co-PANI.
[2642] PBI may also form cross links to other PBI mainchains. Ionomeric groups include bound and free floating phosphoric acid, phosphoric protic ion liquids (PILs), sulfonic acid, and quaternary ammonia compounds. The following table describes characteristics of PBI membranes and fillers: Endoskeletal pillars able to bond to polybenzimidazole are limited as PBI comprises a chemical stable high temperature polymer. The only polymeric resins which can bond to PBI comprise are epoxy (EPX) and polyimide (PI). So although these polymers can be used to form carbon filled pillars of the endoskeleton, PI and EPX can also act as an adhesive bridge between PBI and a variety of polymers PB to which cannot bond.
TABLE-US-00051 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 38. polybenzimidazole anhydrous polymers: solv: CSA, pPA, PBI fillers: PIL (PBI/OPBI) anhydrous IEM PBI or OPBI EPX, PI NMP, MeSO.sub.3H, P[HVIm], H.sub.2PO.sub.4, p-PBI, m-PBI proton via EPX: GRP, DMAc PBI nanofibers, OPBI conductors CFRP, AFRP, PE, X-L: ZIF PHVIM-H.sub.2PO.sub.4 PIL PC, ABS, PAm, DBpX, PhC.sub.l2, other fillers: 2OH-PBI PE, PVC, TPE (CH.sub.2CH).sub.2SO, B.sub.3Br, sac filler, CNTs, F.sub.6-PBI via PI: EPX, PU, Be.sub.3Br, C.sub.14H.sub.13NO, PA, oxides, POSS, SO.sub.2-PBI SIL, PTFE, PE, HCCP, ImCCP, QAs, NPs, MOFs, PIL 2O-PBI PP, PVDF, DABCO, quinuclidine PAEBI PEEK, TCl-co-PhDP-TDS copolymer pillar: HCCP-co-PBI copolymer reinforcing ImCCP-co-PBI copolymer fillers (C-fiber, ABPBI CNTs) OBPI-co-PVBC quaternary ammonia link + DABCO + quinuclidine + quinuclidinol PA doped OPBI-co-PANI copolymer
[2643] Bonding PBI to polymer pillars via epoxy (EPX) adhesives include polymers such as glass-reinforced plastic (GRP, fiberglass); carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP), aramid fiber reinforced polymer (AFRP); polyurethane (PU); polycarbonate (PC); acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS); polyamide (PAm); polyester (PE); polyvinyl chloride (PVC); and various thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs). Bonding PBI to polymer pillars via polyimide (PI) adhesives include polymers such as epoxy (EPX); polyurethane (PU); silicone (SIL); polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE); polyethylene (PE); polypropylene (PP); polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF); polyether ether ketone (PEEK); and itself (PI).
[2644] Solvents of PBI include concentrated sulfuric acid (CSA, H.sub.2SO.sub.4); polyphosphoric acid (pPA); N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP); dimethylacetamide (DMAc); and methane-sulfonic acid (MeSO.sub.3H). PBI is able to respond to a wide spectrum of cross linkers including ,-dibromo-p-xylene (DBpX or PhBr.sub.2), 1,3,5-tris(bromomethyl)-2,4,6-triethylbenzene (BeBr.sub.3), p-xylylene dichloride (PhCl.sub.2, C.sub.8H.sub.8Cl.sub.2), divinyl sulphone ((CH.sub.2CH).sub.2SO), 1,3,5-tris-(bromomethyl)benzene (B.sub.3Br), benzoxazine (C.sub.14H.sub.13NO), hexachlorocyclotriphosphazene HCCP, imidazolechlorocyclotriphosphazene (ImCCP), along with quaternary ammonia compounds including 1,4-diazabicyclo-[2.2.2]-octane (DABCO), quinuclidine, quinuclidinol. In some instances phosphoric acid may also provide cross chain bonding through diphosphate QA pairs. PBI specific fillers include protic ion liquids such as P[HVIm], phosphoric acid (H.sub.2PO.sub.4), electrospun and crushed PBI nanofibers, and zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF) fillers. Other membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
39. Biopolymer IEMs.
[2645] Biopolymers are polymers derived from living organisms such as plants, sea creatures, and microbes. Attractive for their promising advantages of biodegradability, biocompatibility, and environmentally friendliness, biopolymers offer a natural alternative to synthetic polymers derived from fluorocarbon forever chemicals and petroleum based plastics. Many biopolymers occur abundantly in nature, offering the prospect for a commercially viable material source with minimal environmental impact. Although these ecofriendly polymetric materials potentially support a wide range of applications, one exceptionally important area of interest is the use of biopolymers in energy technology, including the prospect for fabricating biopolymer-based ion exchange membranes for fuel cells and water electrolyzers.
[2646] Three most promising biopolymers are depicted in
[2647] In its two-ring moiety, each ring of chitosan 2490 contains bonds to two oxygens (O), two hydroxides (OH), and one amine (NH.sub.2) group. As shown, the two rings comprise stereo isomers of one another around a horizontal line of symmetry, i.e. where the NH.sub.2 group is located above the molecular main plane in the left sided ring, and below the plane in the right side ring. The chemical formula for the two ring chitosan moiety is C.sub.8H.sub.13NO.sub.5 where five carbons occupy each ring and two more bond to the OH groups. Other chitosan moieties such as C.sub.12H.sub.24N.sub.2O.sub.9 and C.sub.18H.sub.35N.sub.3O.sub.13 include three cyclic rings while C.sub.56H.sub.103N.sub.9O.sub.39 comprise nine cyclic rings.
[2648] Like chitosan, cellulose (CE) 2491 also comprises a stereo isomer construction symmetric around a horizontal line of symmetry, except that the cyclic rings bond only to oxygen (O) and hydroxide (OH) but with no nitrogen groups. The molecular formula for cellulose is therefore more simply (C.sub.6H.sub.10O.sub.5).sub.n. Another related molecule alginic acid (AA) 2492 is similar to cellulose except one on chain carbon per ring bonds to a carboxylic acid groups comprising (C(O)OH). The chemical formula for alginic acid is (C.sub.6H.sub.8O.sub.6).sub.n.
[2649] Although chitosan occurs in nature in some fungi such as Mucoraceae, in most general chitosan is synthesized from chitin. Chitin is an abundant naturally occurring polymer coming from the skin of shellfish such as shrimp, lobster, and crab, along with shelled insects and certain fungi. Chitosan can be produced by treating chitin in alkali chemicals or various reagents in order to deacetylate the compound, i.e. by removing some or all of the acetyl groups from chitin. Cellulose, by contrast is pervasive in biosphere forming the cells wall of plants. Commercial sources include the husks of rice, wheat and corn straw, and sugarcane bagasse. On the other hand alginic acid is derived from brown seaweed. Although these biopolymers hold promise as sustainable green-tech polymer sources, they still in their infancy. Among them, chitosan has the most progress to date.
[2650] One process to convert chitin into chitosan shown in
[2651] The attractiveness of chitosan as a biologic, enzymatic, or ionomeric material is in part motivated by the numerous bonding points on the molecule capable of being functionalized post polymerization. For example cyclic bound OH groups can be modified by sulfonylation and alkenylation; while the aldehyde group (CHO) can be functionalized through esterification such as sulfation and sulfonation; carboxymethylation; and alkylation.
[2652] The aldehyde group (CHO) along with the amine group (NH.sub.2) can also function as graft points for copolymerization; for chemical coupling or crosslinking; or for metal coordination with metal elements, complexes, and MOFs. Alternatively, the oxygen linker is subject to glycosidic bond cleavage but also adversely subject to degradation. The generalized production of chitosan with DCA is described by Wikipedia on their page Chitosan and will not be considered further here.
[2653] Because of its numerous accessible bonding sites, chitosan forms numerous functionalized moieties including N-succinyl chitosan, chitosan-4-mercaptobenzoic acid, chitosan-g-poly(acrylic acid), carboxymethyl chitosan, trimethyl chitosan, N-palmitoyl c chitosan, N-octanoyl chitosan, N-myristoyl chitosan, N-caproyl chitosan, and chitosan-g-beta-cyclodextrin. The vast majority of these polymers are used in medical and pharmaceutical applications, and are insightful inasmuch that they highlight the versatility of chitosan bonding.
[2654] In its nascent form, chitosan is not an ionomer or an electrical conductor. Instead it must be functionalized by a acidic group to participate in ion exchange, either with protons in PEMs or anions in AEMs. For proton conduction two of the most significant acids are sulfonic acid and phosphoric acid. One process for sulfonating chitosan moiety 2502b is illustrated with acetic sulfate 2505 is shown in
[2655] As an alternative to sulfuric acid, acetyl sulfate (AcSO.sub.4, C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.5S) is a reagent able to sulfonate a variety of polymers at moderate temperatures with minimal reaction byproducts. Acetic anhydride (Ac.sub.2O, (CH.sub.3CO).sub.2O) 2503 is an isolable anhydride of a nonpolar carboxylic acid widely used in organic synthesis as a reagent. By combining it with the D-glucosamine moiety of chitosan (CS) 2502b, the chitosan becomes functionalized into an ionomer forming sulfonated chitosan (sCS) 2502s, aka D-glucosamine SA where sulfonic acid (SA) 1054 functions as an ionomer for proton conduction.
[2656] The reaction uses and also produces acetic acid (AcA, CH.sub.3COOH) 2506 as both a reactant and a byproduct. Acetic acid, a weak monoprotic acid with the chemical formula CH.sub.3COOH is a chemical reagent used in synthesis of vinyl acetate which can be polymerized into polyvinyl acetate or other polymers. Like ethanol and water, liquid acetic acid is a hydrophilic (polar) protic solvent able to dissolve polar compounds, inorganic salts, and sugars including chitosan. In one exemplary embodiment the sulfonation of chitosan employs acetyl sulfate as a sulfonating agent.
[2657] An alternative method to sulfonate chitosan involves cross linking using sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4). As shown in
[2658] Chitosan can also be functionalized by phosphorylation. The chemical structure of phosphorylated chitosan or pCS is depicted in
[2659] In a second variant shown in
[2660] In a third variant shown in
[2661] Although functionalized chitosan and related polymers hold promise in future ionomeric membranes, they lack structural integrity and suffer from substandard conductivities. Aside from fragility, reliability, and low conductivity concerns, membranes constructed of chitosan can be improved significantly using inventive matter in this application. Remedies include (a) enhancing the film's mechanical strength by forming copolymers made in accordance with this invention, (b) enhancing the film's mechanical strength using the endoskeletal matrix and pillars made in accordance with this invention, (c) enhancing the porosity and electrical conductivity using the sacrificial filler made in accordance with this invention, and (d) increasing the ionomeric density by including protic ionic liquids or conductive dopants to enhance film conductivity.
[2662] In regards to improving conductivity,
[2663] Chitosan forms copolymers with a variety of polymer types including polyacrylonitrile (PAN), polystyrene (PS), and polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). For example in
[2664] In
[2665]
[2666] Another copolymer of chitosan shown in
[2667] For this reason the film is not considered a copolymer but a blended polymer as denoted by the nomenclature CS-b-PFSA 2517. Its should be noted by only changing the atomic composition of sidechain SC, the pendant PFSA 1515a can be converted into a multi acid sidechain (MASC) such as perfluoro imide acid (PFIA). In such cases, the blended polymer is described as CS-b-PFIA.
[2668] Conduction mechanisms within the CS-b-PFSA 2517 are depicted schematically in
[2669] An exemplary process to form a grafted polymer of chitosan is shown in
[2670] By combining chitosan-g-vinylpyridine (CS-g-PVP) 2531 with carboxylic carbon nanotube (carboxy CNT) 1355 produces chitosan-g-vinylpyridine CNT 1332 as shown in
[2671] As an alternative made in accordance with this invention, a grafted polymer of chitosan shown in
[2672]
[2673]
[2674] Chitosan can also be modified to suppress fuel crossover in direct methanol fuel cells using acid-base amphoteric nanoparticles, for example comprising zwitterionic molecules of modified polydopamine. By participating in cross linking of chitosan, additional mechanical strength and durability can be conferred to a film. One possibility is to bond polydopamine (PDA) to a surfactant used in nanomaterial synthesis thereby bridging the polydopamine via a linear nanochain to a ionomeric terminus.
[2675] For example, as shown in
[2676]
[2677] As shown in
[2678] Chitosan can also be functionalized through introduction of covalently bonded permanent fillers into the polymer matrix. As shown in
[2679] Made in accordance with this invention, depending on the choice of radical R the molecule can be modified to contain a single species of ionomer such as sulfonic acid or co-ionomers comprising two acids such as sulfonic and phosphoric acid. For example
[2680] By contrast in the co-ionomer moiety 2498c of sulfonated-phosphorylated cellulose acetate grafted copolymer (spCA-g-P(MMA-co-AMPS)), radical R comprises phosphoric acid (PA, H.sub.2PO.sub.4) 2497. Including the sulfonic acid 1054 associated with the AMPS side group, the segment includes two ionomers of the differing chemical composition and reactivityone involving sulfonic acid, the other comprising phosphoric acid.
[2681] The combination of two different ionomers, both capable of proton conduction offers redundancy in conduction mechanisms not available from IEMs with homo-ionomeric groups. By incorporating both sulfonic and phosphoric acid groups into a proton exchange membrane (PEM) as ionomers, numerous unexpected benefits are manifest. These benefits include improved conductivity, enhanced operating range of temperature range over varying conditions of humidity, temperature, and pH; greater film durability; and longer use life. The benefit of the dual-acid co-ionomer membrane is not limited to biopolymers but applies to all polymers and copolymers, details which will be enumerated later in this application.
[2682]
[2683] In summary, membrane top view 3000 and membrane side view 3001 in
[2695] The below table summarizes various structures, ionomers, endoskeletons, solvents, cross-linkers, and fillers used to synthesize biopolymer membranes made in accordance with this invention comprising a heterogenous membrane of biopolymers such as chitosan homopolymers and heteropolymers with a variety of sidechains, grafts, and copolymers.
[2696] As listed below, biopolymers of chitosan (CS), cellulose (CE), cellulose acetate (CA), and alginic acid (AA), and variants thereof include sulfonated ionomers such as sCS, sCE, sCA, and sAA; along with phosphorylated ionomers such as pCS, pCE, pCA, and pAA. Functionalized chitosan copolymers and grafts include polyacrylonitrile (sCS-co-PAN-R), polystyrene (sCS-co-PSR), polyvinyl alcohol (sCS-co-PVA-R), perfluorinated sulfonic acid (CS-co-PFSA, sCS-co-PFSA), vinylpyridine (sCS-g-PVP), sulfosuccinic acid (CS-g-SSA), polydopamine (CS-co-fPDA), and polydopamine-co-(3-(3-aminopropyl) dimethyl-ammonio) propane-1-sulfonate (PDA-co-AMPS). Cross-linked chitosan-to-chitosan chains include POSS, sulfonic acid (SA), phosphoric acid (PA), glutaraldehyde (GA), and sulfonated glutaraldehyde (sGA).
[2697] Exemplary cellulose grafts include cellulose acetate-g-methyl methacrylate-co-2-acrylamido-2-methyl propane sulfonic acid (CA-g-P(MMA-co-AMPS). Permanent fillers and dopants include sulfonated or phosphorylated graphene oxide (sGO, pGO), chitosan grafted styrenesulfonic acid coated carbon nanotubes (CS-g-SSA-CNT), protic ionic liquids (PIL), polydopamine-co-ADPS-sulfonic acid nanochains (PDA-co-ADPS-SA NCs) and polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes (POSS).
TABLE-US-00052 ionomer structure endoskeleton solvents, X-L fillers 39. chitosan biopolymers chitosan polymers: solv: HCl, AcOH, biopolymer filler: sulfonated (sCS) chitosan alginate, PAA, PEG, L-AA, HCOOH, L- sCS-GO, pCS-GO, phosphorylated (pCS) cellulose syn polypeptides Gu, lacOH, SuA, CS-g-SSA CNT, sCS-co-PAN-R cellulose cellulose polymers: malOH, MA, PA CS-PEO nanofiber, sCS-co-PS-R acetate PVA, PEG-PEO, X-L: PA, SA, GA, P[HVIm] H.sub.2PO.sub.4 PIL, sCS-co-PVA-R alginic acid PEG, PLA sGA, POSS, SO.sub.4.sup., POSS X-L, PDA-co- CS-co-PFSA pillar: ECH AMPS nano-chain sCS-b-PFSA reinforcing fillers other fillers: sCS-g-PVP (C-fiber, CNTs) sac filler, CNTs, CS-g-SSA oxides, POSS, SA XL-CS NPs, MOFs, PIL POSS XL-sCS CS-co-fPDA 39. other biopolymers cellulose (sCE) cellulose acetate (sCA, pCA, spCA) CA-g-P(MMA-co-AMPS) alginic acid (AA)
[2698] Made in accordance with this invention, a variety of endoskeletal support able to bond to biopolymer membranes include chitosan and cellulose compatible pillars. Chitosan compatible pillars include alginate able to form ionic bonds between its carboxylate groups and chitosan's amino groups; polyacrylic acid (PAA) able to form hydrogen bonds with chitosan within a proper range of pH; polyethylene glycol (PEG) able to form hydrogen bond between both hydroxyl and amino groups of chitosan; as well as various synthetic polypeptides containing carboxylic acid groups forming ionic bonds with the amino groups of chitosan.
[2699] A number of polymeric pillars can also bond to cellulose membranes. They include polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and polyethylene oxide (PEO) able to form strong hydrogen bonds with the hydroxyl groups of cellulose; poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) which when properly modified can form hydrogen bonds to CE; polyethylene glycol (PEG) and to a lesser extent polylactic acid (PLA) both of which can form hydrogen bonds to cellulose.
[2700] Solvents able to dissolve or modify the surface of chitosan include hydrochloric acid (HCl), acetic acid (AcOH, HAc), L-ascorbic acid (L-AA), formic acid (HCOOH), L-glutamic acid (L-Gu), lactic acid (LacOH), maleic acid (malOH), malic acid (MA), phosphorous acid (PA), and succinic acid (SuA). Solvents for cellulose include polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polyethylene glycol (PEG), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), and polylactic acid (PLA). Cross linkers include phosphoric acid (PA), sulfonic acid (SA), glutaraldehyde (GA), sulfonated glutaraldehyde (sGA), cross linking polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes (X-L) POSS), sulfate anion group (SO.sub.4.sup.), and epichlorohydrin (ECH).
[2701] Biopolymer fillers include sulfonated and phosphorylated graphene oxides (sCS-GO, pCS-GO), sulfosalicylic acid carbon nanotubes (CS-g-SSA CNTs), chitosan polyethylene oxide (CS-PEO) nanofibers, protic ionic liquids such as P[HVIm]H.sub.2PO.sub.4 PIL, cross linking POSS X-L, and nanochain PDA-co-AMPS. Other membranes fillers and dopants were described previously and for brevity's sake, will not be repeated here.
40. Ionic Liquid (IL) IEMs.
[2702] An ionic liquid is liquid phase organic salt comprising an organic cation or proton paired with an organic or inorganic anion. Unlike ordinary liquids which such as water and fossil fuels which comprise mostly of electrically neutral molecules, an ionic liquid is derived from positively and negatively charged radicals which remain ionically bonded below a certain melting temperature and dissociate from one another above its melting point. To be considered a ionic liquid the ionic molecule's dissociation temperature generally occurs below 100 C.
[2703] For clarity's sake, below its decomposition temperature T.sub.d of an ionic liquid shall be referred as an ionic salt IS comprising its bonded constituent cations IS.sub.c and anions IS.sub.a together forming the net neutral molecular structure IS.sub.cIS.sub.a. Above its dissociation temperature T.sub.d, the charged radicals separate forming free-floating radicals comprising the ionic liquid's cation [IL.sub.c].sup.+ and the ionic liquid's anion [IL.sub.a].sup.. As such, dissociation of an ionic salt to form an ionic liquid [IL] is governed by the dissociation reaction above the dissociation temperature T.sub.d given by
where the bracketed components indicate the ionic molecule has been ionized from its ionic salt IS.sub.cIS.sub.a into its constituent ionic components [IL.sub.c].sup.+ and [IL.sub.a].sup.. Once dissociated, the charged radicals float in solution and do not recombine. In the case of ionic liquids, the term dissociation temperature T.sub.d can generally be construed as synonymous with melting temperature T.sub.m, meaning the solid salt goes into solution.
[2704] Unlike conventional fluids an ionic liquid behaves as a viscous solution similar to compressed fluids even when not under pressure. In general, ionic liquids exhibit solubility in both polar and non-polar liquids, depending on the nature of the ionic liquid and the solvent. Due to strong ionic interactions between an IL and a polar solvent's molecules, ionic liquids are quite soluble in a wide range of polar solvents such as water, methanol, and ethanol. Ionic liquids also may dissolve in non-polar solvents like hexane, toluene, or chloroform where the bonding occurs via non-polar or weakly polar groups within the solution. The solubility of ionic liquids in various solvents strongly depends on the specific cation and anion comprising the ionic liquid. For example, ionic liquids with long alkyl chains may have increased solubility in non-polar solvents, while those with more hydrophilic groups are more soluble in polar solvents.
[2705] The influence of an ionic liquid on conduction in an ion exchange membrane depends on the carrier type of the film. Although and IL contribute both cations and anions to an electrolyte, only one of the two species significantly affects membrane conductivity. Specifically an ionic liquid affects the conductivity of a proton exchange layer by action of its cationic radicals [IL.sub.c].sup.+. Conversely, the presence of the ionic liquid anion [IL.sub.a].sup. has little or no influence on conductance of a proton exchange membrane.
Types of Ionic Liquids.
[2706] Ionic liquids comprise a broad spectrum of chemical compounds addressing diverse applications. Examples include chiral ionic liquids (CILs) used as solvents and catalysts; switchable polarity solvent ionic liquids (SPS-ILs) used in solvent recovery and solute separation; bio-ionic liquids (Bio-ILs) used in biodiesel, renewable fuel, and chemical compound production; and energetic ionic liquids used in propellants and explosives. Other ionic liquids include neutral ionic liquid (N-ILs) as solvent; metallic ionic liquids (M-ILs) for catalysts, solvents, organometallic hydration, and waste recycling; basic ionic liquids (B-ILs) providing eco-friendly catalysts, solvents, and chemical base substitutes; and supported ionic liquids (S-ILs) for solvent, catalyst, and separation processes.
[2707] Ionic liquids commonly used in electrochemical applications such as batteries, fuel cells, hydrolysis, and super capacitors are primarily categorized into three classes, namely: [2708] Protic ionic liquids (PILs)ionic liquids comprising cations having NH bonds able to easily ionize at room temperature donating free protons to a membrane or electrolyte. Examples of PILs include imidazolium [C.sub.3H.sub.5NH.sub.2].sup.+, pyridinium [C.sub.5H.sub.5NH].sup.+, ammonium [NH.sub.4].sup.+, ethanolammonium ([C.sub.2H.sub.5NH.sub.3].sup.+, diethanolammonium [C.sub.4H.sub.11NO.sub.2].sup.+, triethanolammonium [C.sub.6H.sub.15NO.sub.3].sup.+, tetramethylammonium [C.sub.4H.sub.12N].sup.+, diethylmethylammonium [DEMA].sup.+, piperidinium [C.sub.5H.sub.12N].sup.+, morpholinium [C.sub.4H.sub.10NO].sup.+, and quinuclidinium [C.sub.7H.sub.14N].sup.+ cations; [2709] Aprotic ionic liquids (AILs)ionic liquids comprising cations lacking NH bonds. Examples of AILs include cations comprising 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium [BuMeIm].sup.+, 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium [EMeIm].sup.+, 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium [HMeIm].sup.+, 1-octyl-3-methyl imidazolium [OMeIm].sup.+, 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium ([BuMePyrr].sup.+, 1-ethyl-1-methyl pyrrolidinium [EtMePy].sup.+, 1-butyl-1-methylpiperidinium [BuMePip].sup.+, 1-ethyl-1-methyl piperidinium [EtMePip].sup.+, tetraethylammonium [TEtA].sup.+, and tetrapropylammonium [TPA].sup.+, and quaternary ammonium [NR.sub.4].sup.+; and, [2710] Polymerized ionic liquids (PolyILs)ionic liquids comprising a polyelectrolyte where ionic groups are connected through a polymeric backbone. Examples of poly ILs include vinyl copolymers of imidazolium such as poly(1-butyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(BuVIm)].sup.+, poly(1-ethyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(EtVIm)].sup.+, poly(1-hexyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(HVIm)].sup.+, and poly(1-octyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(OVIm)].sup.+. Other PolyILs include vinyl copolymers of pyrrolidinium such as poly(1-butyl-1-vinylpyrrolidinium) [Poly(BuVPyrr)].sup.+ and poly(1-ethyl-1-vinylpyrrolidinium) [Poly[EtVPyrr].sup.+. Other vinyl copolymers comprise poly(1-butyl-1-vinylpiperidinium) [Poly(BuVPip)].sup.+ and poly(1-ethyl-1-vinylpiperidinium) [Poly(EtVPip)].sup.+.
[2711] Although protic, aprotic, and polymerized ionic liquids are considered as preferred ILs for improving ion exchange membrane performance, the other types of membranes listed may also used.
Ionic Liquid Synthesis.
[2712] Synthesis of an ionic liquid generally involves substituting a positively charged group onto a neutral organic molecule then complexing it with a negatively charged molecule to form a weakly bonded ionic pair. To minimize bond strength, one charged radical generally the cation is generally significantly larger and having a higher molecular weight than its oppositive charged counterpart. The first reported synthesis of a ionic liquid occurred in 1914 by Von P Walden in the journal Bulletin de l'Acadmie Imperiale des Sciences de St Ptersburg describing a process neutralizing ethylamine with concentrated nitric acid to form ethylammonium nitrate [EtNH.sub.3].sup.+[NO.sub.3].sup. exhibiting a ion dissociation temperature, i.e. melting point (mp) of 13 C. The author discusses a number of unique characteristics of low temperature ammonium salts described as molten salts stating Anhydrous salts were chosen, which melt at relatively low temperatures, approximately up to 100 C. These low melting points limited the degree of thermolysis of both the solvent and the dissolved salts in the molten salt. Therefore, they allowed for the reproducibility of the observation of melts of anhydrous mineral salts at low temperatures previously only feasible at high temperatures.
[2713] Processes used to form ionic liquids can be divided into two categoriesprimary IL synthesis and secondary IL synthesis. In primary synthesis, non-ionic organic and inorganic reactants, i.e. reactants that are not especially electropositive or electronegative are combined to form a new compounds or molecules that behave as radicals with monovalent, divalent, and sometimes trivalent charge. In secondary IL synthesis, a primary ionic liquid is further modified into a different ionic liquid either by modifying the IL cation, IL anion, or both in order to modify the chemical, electrical, thermal, or material properties of the original primary IL.
[2714]
[2715] Above its dissociation temperature T>T.sub.d the ionic salt 2600a can be depicted as a primary ionic liquid 2600i by removing the hydrogen bond shown previously as a dotted line from the molecule as depicted in
[2716] It should be noted that in some publications simpler abbreviations for constituent organic molecules are used thereby shortening the compound's acronym but adding ambiguity into its meaning. Except when referring to a specific reference in this application the organic radical butyl is abbreviated as Bu rather than B since the single letter abbreviation can be misconstrued to mean elemental boron. Similarly, a methyl group is abbreviated herein as Me to avoid confusion with the capitalized letter M which may refer to a metal atom, ion, crystal, or cluster. Especially problematic is abbreviating radicals capitalized letter E as it can be easily misinterpreted among several candidate meanings. Instead herein Et is used for ethyl, Eth is used for ethanol, and PE for polyester. A solitary capitalized letter E is thereby preserved to mean energy.
[2717] Some acronyms are less ambiguous when considered in context to the topic being discussed primarily because they do not appear together in the same discussion. For example, a capitalized letter V has three meaningsthe element vanadium, the electrical parameter voltage, and to represent spatial volume of an object or container. Similarly the letter R may refer to a chemical radical R or to electrical resistance.
[2718] Organic liquids can also be converted from one to another affecting material properties without affecting an IEM's electrochemistry. For IL doping of a proton exchange membrane, the electrochemically inactive anion can be substituted without substantially affecting conduction so long that the IL cation remains the unchanged. As shown by combining organic salt 2600 or organic liquid 2600i with potassium hexafluorophosphate (KPF.sub.6) 2601 the chlorine anion [Cl].sup. is displaced from the organic liquid [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. 2600i while concurrently the potassium cation [K].sup.+ is displaced from potassium hexafluorophosphate 2601.
[2719] Above its melting point at 8 C., the resulting ionic salt dissolves into an ionic liquid comprising positively-charged cation [1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium].sup.+ 2602 abbreviated as [BuMIm].sup.+ with molecular structure 1602m and negatively-charged anion [hexafluorophosphate].sup. 2603 or [PF.sub.6].sup. with molecular structure 1603m. Despite both being monovalent, the size of the positively charged cation 2602m having an appearance of a sprig of grapes is significantly larger than anion 2603m. These molecular images are subsequently used to illustrate the role of IL dopants in membrane conduction mechanisms.
[2720] Referring again to
[2721] In a related process variant, the chloride radical in the ionic liquid [BuMIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. 2600i is replaced with a nitrate group [NO.sub.3].sup. without changing its imidazole cation. Specifically the ionic salt 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride (BuMeIm.sup.+Cl.sup.) is treated at room temperature for 24 h by silver nitrate (AgNO.sub.3) thereby converting the salt into the ionic liquid 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium nitrate [BuMeIm].sup.+[NO.sub.3].sup. (not shown).
[2722] As represented in
[2723] In another secondary IL synthesis process baaed on metal metathesis reaction (b) as identified, an ionic liquid 2590 comprising organic cation 2590c and anion 2590a are reacted with a metallic salt 2593 containing metal cation 2593c and anion 2593a dissolved in a compatible solvent. Metal cation 2593c may comprise a transition metal, typically of silver (Ag), or alternatively comprising am an element from Group-I of the periodic table. Depending on thermodynamics, the cation and anions of the reactants are swapped resulting in a secondary ionic liquid 2595 comprising organic cation 2590c and anion 2591a. A waste salt of metallic cation 2593c and anion 2590a is subsequently removed as a solute by filtering. As described the metallic cation is a waste product which can be reclaimed and used again improving the environmental sustainability of the secondary IL synthesis process. As in the prior acid-base IL reaction, the species of anions 2590a and 2591a must differ, i.e. [X].sup.+[Y].sup.+.
Conduction in Ionic Liquids.
[2724] The effect of an ionic liquid on conduction must be considered in the context of the conduction mechanisms and polymer type the IL is doping. The cross sectional schematic shown in
[2725] Some of the freed protons 2614 are able to hop from one ionomer to another via Grotthuss charge transport 2614t as depicted in
[2726] Note that although the conduction path between ionomer to ionomer jump 2617c does not complete an electrical circuit with the conduction path 2617f from ionomer 2612 to CCL 2610c, charge neutrality is maintained within the membrane as the charges entering via conduction 2617a from the anode precisely counterbalance those exiting via conduction 2617f into the cathode. Since protons like electrons are indistinguishable from one another, the only charge accounting require is the net change in charge in accordance with charge conservation, aka Kirkoff's current law.
[2727]
[2728] As shown in
[2729] Within the membrane, protons may transfer from ionomer-to-ionomer 2617c, from IL-cation-to-cation 2617d, and betwixt IL-cations-and-ionomers 2617e. Protons also exit the membrane into the cathode catalyst layer 2610c from ionomer 2612 via conduction path 2617f or from IL cation 2618 via conduction path 2517g. Note IL anions 2619 do not conduct current in a PEM membrane as they are surrounded by ionized ionomers having affixed net negative charge holding the anions in place.
[2730] In this manner, ionic liquid doping enhances protonic conduction in a PEM membrane without affecting the membrane's structure or durability. The anionic component of the ionic liquid does not significantly enhance negative charge conduction of ionic anions, e.g. OH- and electrons, in the polymer matrix. This means the addition of ionic liquid doping does not adversely impact charge selectivity in a proton exchange membrane, i.e. the conductivity of protons is selectively enhanced while negative charge transport remains negligible. Curiously, because of IL's bipolar nature the addition of the same ionic liquid into an anionic membrane enhances negative ion conduction but does not enhance proton conduction. In other words, the mechanism of conduction of an ionic liquid depends on its surroundings, not only on its own chemical composition.
Ionic Liquid Cations.
[2731] For IL doping of proton exchange layers, the magnitude of conductivity modulation depends on the concentration of IL doping and on the chemical species of the IL cation compound but not on the anion composition. A sample of possible IL cations able to be complexed in ionic salt precursors of various ILs include a variety of species: [2732] imidazoliumshown in
[2744] Many but not all cations of ionic liquids comprise onium ions representing a broad class of cations derived from neutral molecules through the addition of a proton (H.sup.+) or other cations. Onium ions contain a central atom, often of nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, or oxygen, carrying a positive charge. Of the foregoing, some cationic superbases are onium ions, but not all superbases are onium ions.
[2745] Simple onium cations comprise hydrides with no substitutions. They include Group-13 cations such as boronium, i.e. pronated boron [BH.sub.4].sup.+ and pronated boranes [B.sub.xH.sub.y].sup.+ a Group-14 cations comprising carbonium ions aka hydrocarbons [C.sub.nH.sub.2n+3].sup.+, silanium [SiH.sub.5].sup.+, germonium [GeH.sub.5].sup.+, stannonium [SnH.sub.3].sup.+, plumbonium [PbH.sub.3].sup.+, and flerovonium [FIH.sub.3].sup.+. They also include Group-15 onium cations referred to as pnictogen ions comprising ammonium [NH.sub.4].sup.+, phosphonium [PH.sub.4].sup.+, arsonium [AsH.sub.4].sup.+, stibonium [SbH.sub.4].sup.+, bismuthonium [BiH.sub.4].sup.+, and moscovonium [McH.sub.4].sup.+.
[2746] Non-radiative Group-16 onium cations, i.e. chalcogens include sulfonium [H.sub.3S].sup.+, selenonium [H.sub.3Se].sup.+, and telluronium [H.sub.3Te].sup.+. Group-17 halogen-based onium cations, also known as halonium ions [H.sub.2].sup.+ include fluoronium [H.sub.2F].sup.+, chloronium [H.sub.2Cl].sup.+, bromonium [H.sub.2Br].sup.+, and iodonium [H.sub.2I].sup.+. Pseudo-halogen onium cations include protonated hydrogen azide aka aminodiazonium, and protonated hydrogen cyanide and its isomers referred to as hydrocyanonium or methylidyneammonium. Other simple onium cations comprise Group-18 noble gasses of helium, neon, argon, krypton, and xenon.
[2747] Onium cations with monovalent substitutions include primary ammonium cations [RH.sub.3N].sup.+ of hydroxylammonium, methylammonium, ethylammonium, hydrazinium, and anilinium; secondary ammonium cations [R.sub.2HN.sub.2].sup.+ comprising dimethylammonium, diethylammonium, ethylmethylammonium, and diethanolammonium; tertiary ammonium cations [R.sub.3NH].sup.+, and quaternary ammonium cations [NR.sub.4].sup.+ including tetrafluoroammonium, tetramethylammonium, tetraethylammonium, tetrapropylammonium, tetrabutylammonium, trimethyl ammonium compounds, didecyldimethylammonium, and pentamethylhydrazinium. Similarly monovalent substitutions include quaternary phosphonium cations [PR.sub.4].sup.+ such as tetraphenylphosphonium; quaternary arsonium cations [AsR.sub.4].sup.+ such as tetraphenylarsonium; and quaternary stibonium cations [SbR.sub.4].sup.+ such as tetraphenylstibonium.
[2748] Other onium cations with monovalent substitutions include primary cations' of sulfonium [RSH.sub.2].sup.+ comprising protonated thiols; primary cations of fluoronium [RFH] comprising protonated fluorides; and primary cations of oxonium [ROH.sub.2].sup.+ comprising protonated alcohols [(ROH)H].sup.+ and protonated hydrogen peroxide [(H.sub.2O.sub.2)H].sup.+ including methyloxonium, ethyloxonium, and dioxidanonium. Secondary cations' include secondary sulfonium cations [R.sub.2SH].sup.+; secondary fluoronium cations [R.sub.2F].sup.+ such as dichlorofluoronium; secondary iodonium cations [R.sub.2I].sup.+ such as diphenyliodonium; and secondary oxonium cations [R.sub.2OH].sup.+ comprising protonated ethers such as dimethyloxonium. Tertiary cations include tertiary sulfonium cations [R.sub.3S].sup.+ comprising trimethylsulfonium; tertiary selenonium cations [R.sub.3Se].sup.+ comprising triphenylselenonium; tertiary telluronium cations [R.sub.3Te].sup.+ comprising triphenyltelluronium; and oxonium cations [R.sub.3O].sup.+ including trifluorooxonium, trimethyloxonium, triethyloxonium, oxatriquinacene, and oxatriquinane.
[2749] Onium cations with polyvalent substitutions include secondary ammonium cations comprising diazenium, guanidinium; tertiary ammonium cations comprising nitrilium and diazonium; cyclic tertiary ammonium cations containing nitrogen [RNHR].sup.+ such as pyridinium; and various quaternary ammonium cations. Quaternary ammonium cations with a one double-bond of the form [RNR.sub.2].sup.+ include iminium, diazenium, and thiazolium. Quaternary ammonium cations with two double-bond substitutions having the form [RN=R].sup.+ include bis(triphenylphosphine)iminium and nitronium. Quaternary ammonium cations having a triple bond in the form [RNR].sup.+ include diazonium and nitrilium. Other onium cations with polyvalent substitutions include tertiary oxonium cations with a triple-bonded substitution having a form [RO].sup.+ comprising acylium ions and nitrosonium; and cyclic tertiary oxonium cations of the form [ROR].sup.+ comprising pyrylium. Tertiary sulfonium cations with triple bonds of the form [N-S].sup.+ include thionitrosyl.
[2750] Pronated nitric acid and sulfuric acid cations with polyvalent substitutions include dihydroxyoxoammonium [H.sub.2NO.sub.3].sup.+ and trihydroxyoxosulfonium [H.sub.3SO.sub.4].sup.+ respectively. Doubly pronated cations include hydrazinediium, diazenediium, and diazynediium. Hydride-based enium cations include protonated borylenes; carbenes, alkenes including methylene and ethene; benzene; tropylidene; silylenes; nitrenes; phosphinidene; and organomercury compounds.
Ionic Liquid Anions.
[2751] The IL anion comprises the complementary component to the cation of an ionic liquid. Because the attraction between cation and anion is ionic, there is no requirement for covalent bonding between the ionic radicals. As such, a potentially unlimited number of combinations of ionic liquids are possible. The design of organic liquids for use in a proton exchange membrane commonly involves an organic cation combined with either inorganic or organic anions.
[2752] Rather than controlling conductivity of a PEM membrane the way the IL cation does, the main influence of the IL anion radical on proton ionomers is its impact of the dissociation temperature of the ionic salt forming the ionic liquid. Although today the temperature where the cation and anion of an ionic salt is now commonly referred to as its dissociation temperature T.sub.d older publications refer to this condition as the melting temperature T.sub.m of the ionic salt.
[2753]
[2754] Line 2651 represents the 50% condition where the two ionic concentration are equal, i.e. conc(IS.sub.a)=conc(IS.sub.c). In such a case, above its melting temperature the ionic liquid is neutral, being neither acidic or basic. As labelled on the second x-axis, this neutral condition is described as pH=7. The parameter pH is defined by the negative logarithm of the hydrogen ion concentration conc(H). For higher anion molar concentrations where conc(IS.sub.a) >conc(IS.sub.c), the proton absorbing ability of the solution dominates its available protons and the IL becomes basic with a corresponding pH>7. For lower anion molar concentrations, i.e. where conc(IS.sub.a)<conc(IS.sub.c) the proton donating cations dominate ionic chemistry and the IL becomes acidic with pH<7.
[2755] The ordinate axis represent the melting temperature of the ionic salt in degrees Centigrade. For reference, line 2652 represents the temperature T=0 C., the melting point of water at one atmosphere pressure. While this reference is meaningful experientially, its relevance in a proton exchange membrane is uncertain as ionomers and dopants in the membrane may alter water's freezing point. For an exemplary ionic salt curve 2650 represents the solid-liquid phase transition of the ionic dopantbelow the line the ionic dopant comprises a solid ionic salt, above the line the ionic salt melts into an ionic liquid. The following table illustrates the influence of anion species on IL melting point by comparing compounds based on the same cation 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium:
TABLE-US-00053 IL Anion Anion Melting IL Cation Name Equation Temp T.sub.m [EtMeIm].sup.+ carborane [CB.sub.11H.sub.12].sup. 122 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ chlorinated carborane [CB.sub.11H.sub.6Cl.sub.6].sup. 114 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ chloride [CI].sup. 87 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ boride [Br].sup. 81 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ iodide [I].sup. 80 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ sulfate [SO.sub.4].sup.H.sub.2O.sub.2 70 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ ethylated carborane [C.sub.2H.sub.5CB.sub.11H.sub.11].sup. 64 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ hexafluorophosphate [PF.sub.6].sup. 62 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ methylated carborane [CH.sub.3CB.sub.11H.sub.11].sup. 59 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ gold trichloride [AuCl.sub.3].sup. 58 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ nitrogen dioxide [NO.sub.2].sup. 55 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ arsenic hexafluoride [AsF.sub.6].sup. 53 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ gallium (III) chloride [GaCl4].sup. 47 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ nitrate [NO.sub.3].sup. 38 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ tetrafluoroborate [BF.sub.4].sup. 15 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ tetrachloroaluminate [AlCl.sub.4].sup. 7 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ bis(trifluoromethyl- [Tf.sub.2N].sup. 3 C. sulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+ triflate [TfO].sup. 9 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ trifluoromethane- [TFSA].sup. 14 C. sulfonic anhydride [EtMeIm].sup.+ dicyanamide [N(CN).sub.2].sup. 21 C. [EtMeIm].sup.+ acetate anion [C.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.2].sup. 45 C.
[2756] Notice the melting point of the ionic salt varies nonlinearly and non-monotonically with the anion mole fraction exhibiting two meting point minima at 38% and 66% and high melting points at concentration extremes. At neutral pH, the ionic liquid behaves like undoped water with a zero degree melting point. Line 2653 represents room temperature, i.e. where T=25 C. As shown, the ionic salt is in its liquid form at room temperature for any anion molar fractions between 31% and 77%. At 80 C., the temperature at which PFSA ionomers and many other proton exchange membranes operate, the usable range of the ionomer expands greatly.
[2757] A small sampling of exemplary anions [IL.sub.a].sup. used in ionic liquids are shown in
[2758] These negatively charge ionic species include the following inorganic compounds: [2759] bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide [FSO.sub.2NSO.sub.2F].sup. [2760] borate [BO.sub.3].sub.3.sup. [2761] borohydride [BH.sub.4].sup. [2762] bromide [Br].sup. [2763] bromate [BrO.sub.3].sup. [2764] chlorate [ClO.sub.3].sup. [2765] chloride [Cl].sup. [2766] chlorochromate [CrO.sub.3Cl].sup. [2767] chromate [CrO.sub.4].sub.2.sup. [2768] copper chloride [CuCl.sub.2].sup. [2769] dihydrogen phosphate [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup. [2770] dichromate [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2 [2771] fluoride [F].sup. [2772] fluorohydrogenate anion [(FH).sub.nF].sup. [2773] hexafluorophosphate [PF.sub.6].sup. anion 2601 [2774] hydrogen phosphate [HPO.sub.4].sup.2 [2775] hydrogen sulfate [HSO.sub.4].sup. [2776] hydrogen sulfite (bisulfite) [HSO.sub.3].sup. [2777] hydroxide [OH].sup. [2778] hypochlorite [ClO].sup. [2779] iodate [IO.sub.3].sup. [2780] iodide [I].sup. [2781] metasilicate [SiO.sub.3].sup.2 [2782] molybdate [MoO.sub.4].sup.2 [2783] nitrate [NO.sub.3].sup. anion 2656 [2784] perchlorate [ClO.sub.4].sup. [2785] periodate [IO.sub.4].sup. [2786] permanganate [MnO.sub.4].sup. [2787] phosphate [PO.sub.4].sup.3 [2788] silicate [SiO.sub.4].sup.4 [2789] sulfate [SO.sub.4].sup.2 [2790] sulfite [SO.sub.3].sup.2 [2791] superoxide [O.sub.2].sup. [2792] tetraborate [B.sub.4O.sub.7].sup.2 [2793] tetrafluoroborate [BF.sub.4].sup. anion 2657 [2794] thiosulfate [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2 [2795] tribromide [Br.sub.3].sup. [2796] tungstate [WO.sub.4].sup.2 [2797] zinc chloride [Zn.sub.6Cl.sub.3].sup.
[2798] Exemplary organic anions employed in ionic liquids, i.e. organic [IL.sub.a].sup., include: [2799] acrylate [ACR].sup. [2800] acetate [OAc].sup. or [CH.sub.3COO].sup. or [C.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.2].sup. [2801] benzenesulfonate [C.sub.6H.sub.5SO.sub.3].sup. [2802] benzoate [C.sub.6H.sub.5COO].sup. [2803] bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [NTf.sub.2].sup. or [Tf.sub.2N].sup. [2804] bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate [AOT].sup. [2805] bis(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate [DEHP].sup. [2806] bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide [FSO.sub.2N.sup.SO.sub.2F].sup. or [FSI].sup. [2807] bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide or bistriflimide [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup. or [TfSi].sup. [2808] butyrate [C.sub.3H.sub.7COO].sup. [2809] carbonate [CO.sub.3).sup.2 [2810] citrate [C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7].sup.3 [2811] cyanate [OCN].sup. [2812] dicyanamide [DCA].sup. or [N(CN).sub.2].sup. [2813] diethylphosphate [(C.sub.2H.sub.5O).sub.2PO.sub.2].sup. or [DEP].sup. [2814] dodecanesulfate [DS].sup. [2815] ethoxide [C.sub.2H.sub.5O].sup. [2816] ethylsulfate [EtSO.sub.4].sup. [2817] ethylsulfonate [C.sub.2H.sub.5SO.sub.3].sup. [2818] ferricyanide [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.3 [2819] ferrocyanide [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.4 [2820] formate [HCOO].sup. or [OFm].sup. [2821] hydrogen carbonate (bicarbonate) [HCO.sub.3].sup. [2822] L-lysinate [Lys].sup. [2823] malonate dianion [Mal].sup.2 [2824] mesylate [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup. [2825] methoxide [CH.sub.3O].sup. [2826] methanesulfonate [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup. [2827] methylphosphate dianion [MeP].sup.2 [2828] dimethylphosphate [(CH.sub.3O).sub.2PO.sub.2].sup. or [DMeP].sup. [2829] methanesulfonate [MeSO.sub.3].sup. [2830] octanoate [C.sub.7H.sub.15COO].sup. or [C.sub.8H.sub.15O.sub.2].sup. [2831] oxalate [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2 [2832] phthalate [C.sub.8H.sub.4O.sub.4].sup.2 [2833] propionate [C.sub.2H.sub.5COO).sup. or [OPr].sup. [2834] sulfonate [RSO.sub.3].sup. [2835] tartrate [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2 [2836] trifluoroacetate [CF.sub.3COO].sup. or [C.sub.2F.sub.3O.sub.2].sup. [2837] tetracyanoborate [B(CN).sub.4].sup. [2838] thiocyanate [SCN].sup. [2839] thiosulfate [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2 [2840] tosylate [p-CH.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.4SO.sub.3].sup. [2841] tricyanomethanide [C(CN).sub.3].sup. [2842] triflate [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup. [2843] trifluoromethanesulfonate (triflate) [-OTf], [TfO].sup. or [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup. anion 2655, and [2844] trifluoromethylacetate [F.sub.3MeAc].sup. or [-TFA] anion 2658
[2845] Broadly speaking, the impact of the anion on the melting point and physical properties of an ionic salt and ionic liquid depends on its size and molecular charge density. Specifically smaller and less polarizable anions (like [Cl].sup., [B]r.sup., and [NO].sub.3.sup.) tend to pair well with cations that have a lower charge density and larger size, such as ammonium and imidazolium cations. These combinations typically result in lower melting points and higher ionic conductivity. ILs with monovalent anions are generally more stable and soluble in a variety of solvents. This makes them easier to synthesize and more suitable for use in batteries, fuel cells, and as green solvents.
[2846] Larger and more polarizable anions (like [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3, and organic anions) are better paired with cations that have a higher charge density and smaller size, such as carbonium cations. Multivalent anion often result in ILs with higher melting points and unique solvation properties, exhibiting lower solubility in common solvents and higher thermal stability. These properties can be advantageous in specific applications such as high-temperature processes and specialized separations possibly adaptable for use in high temperature fuel cells.
[2847] While examples of various ionic liquids applicable for use in ion exchange membranes and electrochemical devices such as fuel cells, hydrolyzers, batteries, and supercapacitors are nearly unlimited, it is convenient to consider ILs arranged in groups according to the category of cation used in its synthesis. In such analysis to categorize the ILs by the cation family on which the IL is based.
Imidazolium ILs.
[2848] One such category shown in
[2849] In its disubstituted form .sub.2[Im].sup.+ 2702, a second substitution reaction strips hydrogen from the other nitrogen attaching a neutrally charged radical to the ring. Similarly in trisubstituted imidazolium.sub.3[Im].sup.+ 2703, a second neutral radical is attached to one of the carbon atoms. Yet another variant involves merging the imidazolium ring with a benzene ring (Bz) to form the disubstituted monovalent cation benzimidazolium [BzIm].sup.+ 2704.
[2850] Because an attached radical can also comprise one of a large family of organic molecules containing varying counts of constituent linearly arranged carbon atoms called alkyls, imidazolium [Im].sup.+ cations represent an impressive array of IL cation options. The principle of facile designer-cations for ionic liquids is depicted schematically as N-alkyl-N-methylimidazolium [C.sub.nMeIm].sup.+ radical 2710 in
TABLE-US-00054 n alkyl prefix linear formula Im cation abbreviation 1 N-methyl CH.sub.3 1,3-methylimidazolium [DMeIm].sup.+ 2 N-ethyl (CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium [EtMeIm].sup.+ 3 N-propyl (CH.sub.2).sub.2CH.sub.3 1-propyl-3-methylimidazolium [PrMeIm].sup.+ 3 iso-propyl CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isopropyl-3-methylimidazolium [i-PrMeIm].sup.+ 4 N-butyl (CH.sub.2).sub.3CH.sub.3 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium [BuMeIm].sup.+ 4 iso-butyl (CH.sub.2)CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isobutyl-3-methylimidazolium [i-BuMeIm].sup.+ 4 sec-butyl CH(CH.sub.3)(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-secbutyl-3-methylimidazolium [s-BuMeIm].sup.+ 4 tert-butyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.3 1-tertbutyl-3-methylimidazolium [t-BuMeIm].sup.+ 5 N-pentyl (CH.sub.2).sub.4CH.sub.3 1-pentyl-3-methylimidazolium [C.sub.5MeIm].sup.+ 5 tert-pentyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.2(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-tertpentyl-3-methylimidazolium [t-C.sub.5MeIm].sup.+ 6 N-hexyl (CH.sub.2).sub.5CH.sub.3 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium [C.sub.6MeIm].sup.+ 7 N-heptyl (CH.sub.2).sub.6CH.sub.3 1-heptyl-3-methylimidazolium [C.sub.7MeIm].sup.+ 8 N-octyl (CH.sub.2).sub.7CH.sub.3 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium [C.sub.8MeIm].sup.+ 10 N-decyl (CH.sub.2).sub.9CH.sub.3 1-decyl-3-methylimidazolium [C.sub.10MeIm].sup.+
[2851] The number of carbon atoms in the linear chain determines the name of the prefix to the imidazolium root word. For example, an imidazolium cyclic ring with two attached methyl groups and no intervening carbon atoms shown in
[2852]
[2853] Imidazolium may also comprise n=4 four-carbon alkyl side groups called butyl groups forming linear or Y-branched structures attached to the imidazolium cyclic ring. As a disubstituted imidazolium cation, the molecule 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium [BuMeIm] 2714a comprises methyl (CH.sub.3) and linear butyl side groups.
[2854] In the trisubstituted IL cation 1-butyl-2,3-dimethylimidazolium 2714b, the imidazolium aromatic ring comprises three appendages, namely two methyl groups (CH.sub.3) with no intervening carbon between the carbon termini and its cyclic ring; and a third side comprising the butyl group including a methyl terminus. Accordingly 1-butyl-2,3-dimethylimidazolium 2714b is abbreviated as [BuDMeIm].sup.+ where Bu denotes the linear butyl group and the DMe term refers to the two methyl groups one of which bonds to nitrogen the other to carbon. Another disubstituted [Im].sup.+ cation 1-butyl-3-ethoxycarbonylimidazolium shown in
[2855] In this sense, the prefix iso is employed when all carbon side groups attached to the cyclic form a continuous chain except for one. Also applicable in four carbon butyl chains, the terms sec-butyl or s-butyl refer to a isomer where a functional group is bonded on the second atom, and the term tert-butyl or t-butyl where a functional group is bonded onto the tertiary atom.
[2856] In 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium [CsMeIm].sup.+ 2716 the hexyl group comprises an organic chain where n=6. Although the abbreviation for hexyl can be the letter H, there is an ambiguity with the prefix hepta meaning n=7 carbons. As such, in this work the numeric based prefix C.sub.6 is preferred. Likewise where n=8, the cation referred to as 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium 2718 has the abbreviation [CsMeIm].sup.+. The following table lists a variety of imidazolium based IL cations and exemplary anions:
TABLE-US-00055 IL Cation Chemical Cation Exemplary Category Compound Symbol Anions Imidazolium imidazolium [Im].sup.+ [AOT].sup., [ACR].sup., N-alkyl-N- [C.sub.nMeIm].sup.+ [Oac].sup., methylimidazolium [BF.sub.4].sup., [FSI].sup., 1,3-dimethyl- [DMeIm].sup.+ [Cl].sup., imidazolium [DEP].sup., [DS].sup., 1-ethyl-3- [EtMeIm].sup.+ [I].sup., methylimidazolium [MeSO.sub.3].sup., 1-propyl-3- [PrMeIm].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., methylimidazolium [O.sub.2.sup.].sup., [Opr].sup., 1-butyl-3- [BuMeIm].sup.+ [PF.sub.6].sup., methylimidazolium [RSO.sub.3].sup., 1-butyl-2,3- [BuDMeIm].sup.+ [SCN].sup., dimethylimidazolium [TfO].sup., 1-butyl-3-ethoxy- [Bu(COOEt)Im].sup.+ [TfSI].sup., carbonylimidazolium [C(CN).sub.3].sup., 1-pentyl-3- [C.sub.5MeIm].sup.+ [Tf.sub.2N].sup. methylimidazolium 1-hexyl-3- [C.sub.6MeIm].sup.+ methylimidazolium 1-methyl-3- [MeOctIm].sup.+ octylimidazolium 1-octyl-3- [C.sub.8MeIm].sup.+ methylimidazolium 1-decyl-3- [C.sub.10MeIm].sup.+ methylimidazolium 3-methyl-(ethoxy- [Me(COOEtMe)Im].sup.+ carbonylmethyl)- imidazolium
[2857] In a related isomer 1-methyl-3-octylimidazolium [MeOctIm].sup.+ the constituent functional groups are identical but the positions of the methyl and octyl groups attached to the imidazolium ring are swapped. Specifically in 1-methyl-3-octylimidazolium, the methyl group is attached to the nitrogen atom at position 1 of the imidazolium ring while the octyl group is attached to the nitrogen atom at position 3. Conversely for 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium, the n=8 alkyl group is attached to position 1 and the methyl group is bound to position 3.
[2858] The list is by no means complete or even exhaustive, but intended simply to represent some exemplary molecular forms. Similarly the anions listed may be considered independently from the cations used to form the ionic liquid. Together the various permutations and combinations of I.sub.L cations and IL anions listed produce an extensive array of ionic liquids available for doping proton exchange membranes. The selection of cation and anion for an ionic liquid depends involves numerous factors including conductivity, durability, stability, operating temperature range, humidity, toxicity and RoHS, and compatibility with the ionomeric polymer used to form the film.
[2859] In particular, although imidazolium cations can be paired with either monovalent or multivalent anions, due to preferable physical properties such as low melting point and stability they are generally formed using ionic salts with monovalent anions. As such, only monovalent anions are listed in the above table.
[2860] As described previously, the anion radical has a direct effect on the phase transition temperature from ionic salt to ionic liquid and less impact on proton conductivity. That said, the cation can also influence the dissociation temperature of an ionic liquid. For example, in
Pyrrolidinium ILs.
[2861] As shown in
[2862] As depicted in the same illustration, a monovalent pyrrolidinium cation [Pyrr].sup.+ 2751 forms a solid ionic salt (IS) or and ionic liquid IL with anion X or more accurately [X].sup. which may comprise any number of possible combinations, the only difference being whether the ambient temperature is higher or lower than the dissociation temperature (T.sub.d) of the ionic salt, also often referred to as the salt's melting temperature (T.sub.m). It should be noted that although the synthesis of pyrrolidinium involves a monosubstitution of the on-ring NH, the attachment actually comprises two side-groups, not one, where both groups are attached to the same nitrogen atom.
[2863] In a monovalent substitution, only one of the side groups is electrically charged. The second group is neutral. By contrast in the divalent pyrrolidinium cation 2752, both side groups are electrically charged. The divalent pyrrolidinium cation [Pyrr].sup.2+ is expressed chemically as [C.sub.4H.sub.11N].sup.2+ recognizing the cyclic ring attaches to two hydrogen ions not present in neutral pyrrolidine. To maintain charge neutrality, the divalent pyrrolidinium cation [Pyrr].sup.2+ must be balanced by two single charged anions [X].sup. or optionally a one doubly-ionized anion [X].sup.2.
[2864] Both the monovalent and divalent pyrrolidinium cations 2751 and 2752 are represented as bonded to a radical R. The most common substituted radicals R comprise a methyl or alkyl groups. Strictly speaking, a methyl group is a degenerate case of an alkyl group comprising only the terminus carbon and lacking any intervening carbon atoms, i.e. where n=1. The genericized form of a monovalent pyrrolidinium cation is N-alkyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium 2755 where the alkyl group may vary in length n in accordance with the following table:
TABLE-US-00056 n alkyl prefix linear formula Pyrr cation abbreviation 1 N-methyl CH.sub.3 1,1-methylpyrrolidinium [DMePyrr].sup.+ 2 N-ethyl (CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-ethyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [EtMePyrr].sup.+ 3 N-propyl (CH.sub.2).sub.2CH.sub.3 1-propyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [PrMePyrr].sup.+ 3 iso-propyl CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isopropyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [iPrMePyrr].sup.+ 4 N-butyl (CH.sub.2).sub.3CH.sub.3 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [BuMePyrr].sup.+ 4 iso-butyl (CH.sub.2)CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isobutyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [i-BuMePyrr].sup.+ 4 sec-butyl CH(CH.sub.3)(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-secbutyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [s-BuMePyrr].sup.+ 4 tert-butyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.3 1-tertbutyl1-methylpyrrolidinium [t-BuMePyrr].sup.+ 5 N-pentyl (CH.sub.2).sub.4CH.sub.3 1-pentyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.5MePyrr].sup.+ 5 tert-pentyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.2(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-tertpentyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [t-C.sub.5MePyrr].sup.+ 6 N-hexyl (CH.sub.2).sub.5CH.sub.3 1-hexyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.6MePyrr].sup.+ 7 N-heptyl (CH.sub.2).sub.6CH.sub.3 1-heptyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.7MePyrr].sup.+ 8 N-octyl (CH.sub.2).sub.7CH.sub.3 1-octyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.8MePyrr].sup.+ 10 N-decyl (CH.sub.2).sub.9CH.sub.3 1-decyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.10MePyrr].sup.+
[2865] In accordance with alkyl sequential naming standard methyl-ethyl-propyl-isopropyl-butyl or MEPIB or denoting the carbon number sequence, a myriad of combinations of pyrrolidinium molecules are possible. Recognizing the on-ring nitrogen atom in pyrrolidinium form bonds with not one but two side groups, the number of possible permutations and combinations is almost inconceivable. To simplify this matrix, it is convenient to consider one chain is the degenerate n=1 alkyl group methyl while the other sidechain is varied in length.
[2866] Accordingly when the second sidechain comprises a methyl group, i.e. an alkyl group where n=1, the pyrrolidinium molecule 2761 shown in shown in
[2867] The molecule's isomer, 1-isopropyl-3-methylpyrrolidinium 2763b comprising the cation [iPr(MePyrr)].sup.+ is shown in
TABLE-US-00057 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Pyrrolidinium pyrrolidinium [Pyrr].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3, N-alkyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.nMePyrr].sup.+ [CO.sub.3].sup.2, [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2 N,N-dimethylpyrrolidinium [DMePyrr].sup.+ [CrO.sub.4].sup.2, [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, N-ethyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [EtMePyrr].sup.+ [MoO.sub.4].sup.2, [WO.sub.4].sup.2, N-propyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [PMePyrr].sup.+ [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, [SiO.sub.4].sup.4, N-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [BuMePyrr].sup.+ [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., [OAc].sup., N-isobutyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [iBuMePyrr].sup.+ [OFm].sup., [Mal].sup.2, N-octyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.6MePyrr].sup.+ [(FH).sub.n[F].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup., N-decyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [C.sub.10MePyrr].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [HSO.sub.4].sup. N,N-dimethylpyrrolidinium [DMePyrr].sup.+ [HCOO].sup., [CH.sub.3COO].sup., N-diethyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium [(DEt]MePyrr].sup.+ [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [C.sub.7H.sub.15COO].sup.
Pyridinium ILs.
[2868] Pyridinium is the conjugate acid of pyridine (Pyr) and the cation [Pyr].sup.+ of pyridinium ionic liquids. Its basis, pyridine or Pyr 2770 shown in
[2869] The most common side groups of monovalent pyridinium 2771 comprise alkyl groups of varying lengths n, generically called N-alkylpyridinium. N-alkylpyridinium 2775 chemically denoted as H(H.sub.2C).sub.n or [H(H.sub.2C).sub.n(Pyr)].sup.+ describes a monovalent hydrocarbon chain (H.sub.2C).sub.n of length n attached to the pyridinium cyclic core. N-alkylpyridinium therefore represents a generic class of molecules following the methyl-ethyl-propyl-isopropyl-butyl naming convention (MEPIB) for increasing n lengths as described in the following table:
TABLE-US-00058 n alkyl prefix linear formula Pyrr cation abbreviation 1 N-methyl CH.sub.3 1-methylpyridinium [MePyr].sup.+ 2 N-ethyl (CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-ethylpyridinium [EtPyr].sup.+ 3 N-propyl (CH.sub.2).sub.2CH.sub.3 1-propylpyridinium [PrPyr].sup.+ 3 iso-propyl CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isopropylpyridinium [i-PrPyr].sup.+ 4 N-butyl (CH.sub.2).sub.3CH.sub.3 1-butylpyridinium [BuPyr].sup.+ 4 iso-butyl (CH.sub.2)CH(CH.sub.3).sub.2 1-isobutylpyridinium [i-BuPyr].sup.+ 4 sec-butyl CH(CH.sub.3)(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-secbutylpyridinium [s-BuPyr].sup.+ 4 tert-butyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.3 1-tertbutylpyridinium [t-BuPyr].sup.+ 5 N-pentyl (CH.sub.2).sub.4CH.sub.3 1-pentyllpyridinium [C.sub.5Pyr].sup.+ 5 tert-pentyl C(CH.sub.3).sub.2(CH.sub.2)CH.sub.3 1-tertpentyllpyridinium [t-C.sub.5Pyr].sup.+ 6 N-hexyl (CH.sub.2).sub.5CH.sub.3 1-hexylpyridinium [C.sub.6Pyr].sup.+ 7 N-heptyl (CH.sub.2).sub.6CH.sub.3 1-heptylpyridinium [C.sub.7Pyr].sup.+ 8 N-octyl (CH.sub.2).sub.7CH.sub.3 1-octylpyridinium [C.sub.8Pyr].sup.+ 10 N-decyl (CH.sub.2).sub.9CH.sub.3 1-decylpyridinium [C.sub.10Pyr].sup.+
[2870] Several examples of varying length alkyl groups are depicted in
[2871] In
[2872] An exemplary list of common pyridinium based ionic liquids are described in the following table including the aforementioned alkyl groups. The following table describes a variety of pyridinium ionic liquid combinations.
TABLE-US-00059 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Pyridinium pyridinium [Pyr].sup.+ [Br].sup. [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., 1-alkylpyridinium [C.sub.nPyr].sup.+ [OAc].sup., [OFm].sup., 1-methylpyridinium [MePyr].sup.+ [Mal].sup.2, [(FH).sub.nF].sup., 1-ethylpyridinium [EtPyr].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., 1-propylpyridinium [PrPyr].sup.+ [HSO.sub.4].sup. [HCOO].sup., 1-butylpyridinium [BuPyr].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., 1-isobutylpyridinium [i-BuPyr].sup.+ [CF.sub.3COO].sup., 1-pentyllpyridinium [C.sub.6Pyr].sup.+ [C.sub.7H.sub.15COO].sup. 1-hexylpyridinium [C.sub.6Pyr].sup.+ 1-octylpyridinium [C.sub.8Pyr].sup.+ 1-butyl-3,5-dimethylpyridinium [Bu(DMe)Pyr].sup.+
[2873] It should be noted however that other pyridinium cations may also be synthesized by attaching sidechains onto carbon atoms of the cyclic ring. One example is 1-butyl-3,5-dimethylpyridinium which in addition to a n=4 butyl group attached to the nitrogen in the 1-position, it also include two additional methyl groups, i.e. dimethyl, attached to carbon in the 3- and 5-positions. As pyridinium more readily form salts with low melting temperatures comprising monovalent anions, for clarity's sake examples of multivalent anions are excluded from the table.
Ammonium ILs.
[2874] A far more diverse spectrum of ionic liquids is facilitated using the ammonium cation. Ammonium represents protonated variants of the ammonia molecule NH.sub.3 2790 shown in
[2875] As shown in
[2876] In a quaternary ammonium ionic liquid 2794, all four hydrogens atoms are replaced by radicals R resulting in the ubiquitous monovalent cation quaternary ammonium [NR.sub.4].sup.+ also designated as [QA].sup.+. Although all the four radicals R may comprise identical carbon chains, the radicals may also differ resulting in a cation formula [NR.sub.aR.sub.bR.sub.cR.sub.d].sup.+. Note that the degenerate case of quaternary ammonium [NR.sub.4].sup.+ where [R].sup.+=[H].sup.+ reverts to the standard ammonium cation [NH.sub.4].sup.+. Aside from cases where the side groups compete with one another ionically, in general any combination of radicals may occur.
[2877] For example, three groups may be identical with one different, or two groups of identical radicals may occur. These variants are illustrated by example in
[2878] As shown in
[2879] Specifically when n=1, each side group comprises a single carbon and three hydrogens, i.e. methyl groups. The resulting cation tetramethylammonium 2801 may be abbreviated as [(Me.sub.4)N].sup.+ or [(TMe)Am].sup.+. When n=2, each of four ethyl side groups comprising a CH.sub.3 terminus with a single intervening CH.sub.2 attach to a central nitrogen to form tetraethylammonium 2802 abbreviated as [(Et.sub.4)N].sup.+ or [(TEt)Am].sup.+.
[2880] As shown in
[2881] Rather than side groups of alkyl, or more side groups may comprise phenyl or benzene rings. For example, in
[2882] As depicted in
[2883] A mix of short chain and long chain side groups are also possible. As depicted in
[2884] Other longer chain examples shown in
[2885] Other ammonium variants depicted in
[2886] These various cations combined with an expansive list of anions produce an inexhaustible list of ionic liquid candidates, each with differing physical and electrical properties. The table below list some of these possible combinations: As ammonium cations are versatile in the bonds with which they form ionic salts, ammonium anions include both monovalent and multivalent anions.
TABLE-US-00060 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Ammonium ammonium [NH.sub.4].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., primary ammonium [NH.sub.3R].sup.+ [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [MeSO.sub.3].sup., secondary ammonium [NH.sub.2R.sub.2].sup.+ [I].sup., [Br.sub.3].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., tertiary ammonium [NHR.sub.3].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., quaternary ammonium [NR.sub.4].sup.+, [QA].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, methylammonium [MeNH.sub.3].sup.+, [MeAm].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HCOO].sup. dimethylammonium [Me.sub.2NH.sub.2].sup.+, [Me.sub.2Am].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup. trimethylammonium [Me.sub.3NH].sup.+, [Me.sub.3Am].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., tetraalkylammonium [TAA].sup.+, [(H.sub.2Cn).sub.4N].sup.+ [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [SCN].sup., tetramethylammonium [Me.sub.4N].sup.+, [TMeAm].sup.+ [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., tetraethylammonium [Et.sub.4N].sup.+, [TEtAm].sup.+ [(FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [CrO.sub.4].sup.2 tetrapropylammonium [Pr.sub.4N].sup.+, [TPrAm].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3, tetrabutylammonium [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+, [TBuAm].sup.+ [CO.sub.3].sup.2, [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, tetrahexylammonium [H(H.sub.2C.sub.6).sub.4N].sup.+, [THexAm].sup.+ [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, [MoO.sub.4].sup.2, tetraoctylammonium [H(H.sub.2C.sub.8).sub.4N].sup.+, [TOctAm].sup.+ [WO.sub.4].sup.2, [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, tetradecylammonium [H(H.sub.2C.sub.10).sub.4N].sup.+, [TDecAm].sup.+ [SiO.sub.4].sup.4, [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2, tetraphenylammonium [Ph.sub.4N].sup.+, [TPhAm].sup.+ [SeO.sub.4].sup.2, [S.sub.2O.sub.8].sup.2, phenyltrimethylammonium [PhMe.sub.3N].sup.+, [PhMe.sub.3Am].sup.+ [VO.sub.4].sup.3, [AsO.sub.4].sup.3, benzyltriethylammonium [BzEt.sub.3N].sup.+, [BzEt.sub.3Am].sup.+ [BO.sub.3].sup.3, [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.3, benzyltributylammonium [BzBu.sub.3N].sup.+, [BzBu.sub.3Am].sup.+ [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.4, [P.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.4, benzyltripropylammonium [BzPr.sub.3N].sup.+, [BzPr.sub.3Am].sup.+ [MnO.sub.4].sup.2 triethylmethylammonium [Et.sub.3MeN].sup.+, [Et.sub.3MeAm].sup.+ dioctyldimethylammonium [((H(H.sub.2C).sub.8).sub.2MezN].sup.+, [DOctDMeAm].sup.+ dodecylethyldimethylammonium [(H(H.sub.2C).sub.12)EtMe.sub.2N].sup.+, [DodecEtDMeAm].sup.+ benzyldimethylstearylammonium [BzMe.sub.2(H(H.sub.2C).sub.17)N].sup.+, [Bz(DMe)SteAm].sup.+ trimethylstearylammonium [Me.sub.3(H(H.sub.2C).sub.21)N].sup.+, [Me.sub.3SteAm].sup.+ tetra(4-thiaalkyl)ammonium [Th.sub.4N].sup.+, [TThAm].sup.+ O-(2-carboxypropan-2-yl) Cpr(OH)NH.sub.3].sup.+, hydroxylammonium [Cpr(OH)Am].sup.+ hydroxylammonium [NH.sub.3OH].sup.+ ethanolammonium [EthAm].sup.+ diethanolammonium [DEthAm].sup.+ triethanolammonium [Eth.sub.3Am].sup.+ triethylammonium [Et.sub.3N] or [Et.sub.3Am].sup.+ tributylammonium [Bu.sub.3Am].sup.+ tributylmethylammonium [Bu.sub.3MeA].sup.+ trimethylphenylammonium [Me.sub.3PhA].sup.+ methyl trioctylammonium [MeTOctA].sup.+ N,N-diethyl-N-methyl-N- [DEtMe(MeOEt)Am].sup.+ (2methoxyethyl)ammonium N-oxoammonium [R.sub.aR.sub.bNO].sup.+ aminoxl oxoammonium [RMe.sub.4NO]+
Phosphonium ILs.
[2887] Structurally similar to the aforementioned ammonium cation, phosphonium derived from phosphine comprises a central phosphorus (rather than nitrogen) core having the chemical formula PR.sub.4.sup.+ where R is hydrogen or an alkyl, aryl, or halide group. As depicted in
[2888] As shown in
[2889] In the event that all four hydrogen functional groups are substituted by methyl groups the quaternary cation is referred to as tetramethylphosphorium [Me.sub.4P].sup.+ 2846. The genericized version for alkyl groups of length n is described as (alkyl)phosphonium 2847 chemically represented as [(H(H.sub.2C).sub.n).sub.4P].sup.+.
[2890] Like the ammonium cations described previously, the functional sidechains of phosphonium can be substituted by one-to-four phenyl or methyl groups. As shown in
[2891] Similar heterogenicity is evident in butylldiethylmethylphosphonium 2851 shown in
[2892] The table below describes possible ionic liquids comprising phosphonium cations and a variety of anions which may be combined in a mix-and-match fashion. Like ammonium, phosphonium forms ionic salts and ionic liquids with both monovalent and multivalent anions, a sample of which are included in the below table. Except for the pristine radical itself abbreviated [Phosm].sup.+, cation symbols for all the phosphonium ions are represented by the letter P which should be understood contextually to mean phosphonium and not elemental phosphorus.
TABLE-US-00061 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Phosphonium phosphonium [Phosm].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Br].sup., [FSI].sup., triethylhexylphosphonium [Et.sub.3HexP].sup.+ [TfSI].sup., [F].sup.[NO.sub.3].sup., triethylbenzylphosphonium [3EtBzP].sup.+ [MeSO.sub.3].sup., [I].sup., [Br.sub.3].sup., tributylmethylphosphonium [3BuMeP].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., triisobutylmethylphosphonium [3iBuMeP].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, trioctylmethylphosphonium [3OctMeP].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HCOO].sup. trihexyltetradecylphosphonium [3HTDP].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup. trihexylmethylphosphonium [3HMeP].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., triisopropylmethylphosphonium [3(iPr)MeP].sup.+ [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [SCN].sup., tetraethylphosphonium [TEtP].sup.+ [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., tetrabutylphosphonium [TBuP].sup.+ [(FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [NTf.sub.2], tetraphenylphosphonium [TPhP].sup.+ [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CrO.sub.4].sup.2 [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [CO.sub.3].sup.2, [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, [MoO.sub.4].sup.2, [WO.sub.4].sup.2, [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, [SiO.sub.4].sup.4, [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2, [SeO.sub.4].sup.2, [S.sub.2O.sub.8].sup.2, [VO.sub.4].sup.3, [AsO.sub.4].sup.3, [BO.sub.3].sup.3, [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.3, [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.4, [P.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.4, [MnO.sub.4].sup.2
Sulfonium ILs.
[2893] Sulfonium is a monovalent cation of sulfur, a molecular structural variant of sulfide. As shown in
[2894] As an organosulfur compound with the general structural form [SH.sub.3].sup.+, the cation sulfonium 2861 comprises a protonated sulfide. Despite its structural similarity to the sulfide molecule, synthesis of sulfonium generally involves a reaction of thioethers with alkyl halides, the reaction proceeds by a nucleophilic substitution mechanism. In a single substitution reaction, one hydrogen is replaced by a radical R to form the primary sulfonium cation [SR.sub.1H.sub.2].sup.+ 2862. A more common reaction forms a secondary sulfonium cation [SR.sub.2H].sup.+ 2863, one comprising a single sulfur central core attached to one hydrogen and two radicals. In tertiary sulfonium 2864, all three hydrogens are substituted with radical R to form the cation [SR.sub.3].sup.+.
[2895] Examples of primary, secondary, and tertiary methyl substitutions of sulfonium are shown in
[2896] Other variants shown in
[2897] A list of sulfonium cations and anions for sulfonium ionic liquids is described in the table below including both monovalent and multivalent anions: As in the case described previously with sulfonium, except for the pristine radical itself abbreviated [Sulfm].sup.+, cation symbols for all the sulfonium ions are represented by the letter S which should be understood contextually to mean the compound sulfonium and not elemental sulfur.
TABLE-US-00062 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Sulfonium sulfonium [Sulfm].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Br].sup., trimethylsulfonium [3MeS].sup.+ [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., [F].sup. triethylsulfonium [3EtS].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [MeSO.sub.3].sup., tripropylsulfonium [3PrS].sup.+ [I].sup., [Br.sub.3].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., tributylsulfonium [3BuS].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., trioctylsulfonium [3OctS].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, dimethylsulfonium methylide [DMeS-Me].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HCOO].sup. methylethylsulfonium [MeES].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup. methylpropylsulfonium [MePrS].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., methylphenylsulfonium [MePhS].sup.+ [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [SCN].sup., benzylsulfonium [BzS].sup.+ [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CrO.sub.4].sup.2 [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3 [CO.sub.3].sup.2, [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, [MoO.sub.4].sup.2, [WO.sub.4].sup.2, [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, [SiO.sub.4].sup.4, [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2, [SeO.sub.4].sup.2, [S.sub.2O.sub.8].sup.2, [VO.sub.4].sup.3, [AsO.sub.4].sup.3, [BO.sub.3].sup.3, [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.3, [Fe(CN).sub.6].sup.4, [P.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.4, [MnO.sub.4].sup.2
Thiaizolium ILs.
[2898] As shown in
[2899] Alkyl-thiazolium cation examples shown in
[2900] Other two-ring thiazolium cations shown in
[2901] Examples of ionic liquids based on thiazolium cations are described in the following table: The selection of anions depends on the desired materials properties. Specifically monovalent anions such as chloride, bromide, or nitrate form ionic liquids with lower melting points and better fluidity, while multivalent anions offer greater high temperature stability and lower viscosities making them easier to retain within a membrane.
TABLE-US-00063 IL Cation Chemical Cation Category Compound Symbol Exemplary Anions Thiazolium thiazolium [Tz].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Br].sup., methylthiazolium [MeTz].sup.+ [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., [F].sup. ethylthiazolium [EtTz].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [MeSO.sub.3].sup., benzylthiazolium [BzTz].sup.+ [I].sup., [Br.sub.3].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., phenylthiazolium [PhTz].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., allylthiazolium [AlylTz].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, butylthiazolium [BuTz].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HCOO].sup. hexylthiazolium [HTz].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup. octylthiazolium [OctTz].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [SCN].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [(FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup.
Piperidinium ILs.
[2902] As shown in
[2903] Examples of alkyl variants shown in
[2904] The following table summarizes piperidinium cations used in ionic liquids: Piperidinium cations are more often found in ILs with multivalent anions due to their ability to stabilize higher charge densities, properties similar to pyrrolidinium. Pyrrolidinium cations include the full MEPIB+ spectrum of linear and branching alkyl carbon chains including methyl, ethyl, propyl, isopropyl, and butyl isomers, along with longer chains. In the abbreviated cation symbol names the ion piperidinium is abbreviated as (Pip) or (PipH) depending on bonds to its cyclic ring.
TABLE-US-00064 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Piperidinium piperidinium [PipH].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., N-methylpiperidinium [Me(PipH)].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, N,N-dimethylpiperidinium [DMe(Pip)].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [CO.sub.3].sup.2, N-ethylpiperidinium [Et(PipH)].sup.+ [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, [CrO.sub.4].sup.2, N-ethyl-N-methylpiperidinium [EtMe(Pip)].sup.+ [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2 N-propylpiperidinium [Pr(PipH)].sup.+ [C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7].sup.3, [BO.sub.3].sup.3 N-propyl-N-methylpiperidinium [PrMe(Pip)].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Br].sup., N-butylpiperidinium [Bu(PipH)].sup.+ [FSI].sup., [TfSI].sup., [F].sup. N-butyl-N-methylpiperidinium BuMe(Pip)].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [MeSO.sub.3].sup., N-pentylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.5(PipH)].sup.+ [I].sup., [Br.sub.3].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., N-pentyl-N-methylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.5Me(Pip)].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup., N-hexylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.6(PipH)].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, N-hexyl-N-methylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.8Me(Pip)].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HCOO].sup. N-octypiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.8(PipH)].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup. N-octyl-N-methylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.8Me(Pip)].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., N-decylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.10(PipH)].sup.+ [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [SCN].sup., N-decyl-N-methylpiperidinium [H(H.sub.2C).sub.10Me(Pip)].sup.+ [ClO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [(FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [P.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.4
Protonated Hydrocarbons.
[2905] Aside from the forgoing cations, a variety of hydrocarbon compounds may form cations in ionic liquids. Hydrocarbon fuel and hydrocarbon solvent based cations are imprecisely referred to a carbonium.
[2906] Examples shown in
[2907]
[2908] The following table of carbonium cations along with a diverse spectrum of monovalent and divalent anions are able to make a long list of hydrocarbon based ionic liquids:
TABLE-US-00065 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Protonated methanium, protonated methane [CH.sub.5].sup.+ [Cl].sup., [Br].sup., [I].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup., hydrocarbons protonated methanol [CH.sub.3OH.sub.2].sup.+ [PF.sub.6].sup., [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [F].sup. (carbonium) ethanium, protonated ethane [C.sub.2H.sub.7].sup.+ N(CN).sub.2].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup., [OH].sup. protonated ethanol [C.sub.2H.sub.5OH.sub.2].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., propanium, protonated propane [C.sub.3H.sub.9].sup.+ [C.sub.2H.sub.5SO.sub.3].sup., [HCOO].sup. protonated propanol [C.sub.3H.sub.9O].sup.+ [(C.sub.2H.sub.5O).sub.2PO.sub.2].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., butanium, protonated butane [C.sub.4H.sub.11].sup.+ [(CH.sub.3O).sub.2PO.sub.2].sup., [FSI].sup., protonated butanol [C.sub.4H.sub.11O].sup.+ [C.sub.2H.sub.5COO].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup. octonium, protonated octane [C.sub.8H.sub.19].sup.+ [C.sub.3H.sub.7COO].sup., [ClO.sub.3].sup. protonated acetone [CH.sub.3COH.sup.+CH.sub.3].sup.+ [FSO.sub.2NSO.sub.2F].sup., [BrO.sub.3].sup., pronated acetic acid [CH.sub.3COOH.sub.2].sup.+ [IO.sub.3].sup., [ClO].sup., [OCN].sup., protonated acetonitrile [CH.sub.3CNH].sup.+ [SCN].sup., [C.sub.2O.sub.4).sup.2, [SiO.sub.4].sup., protonated dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) [C.sub.2H.sub.6OSH].sup.+ [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, [C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7].sup.3, protonated toluene [C.sub.7H.sub.9].sup.+ [C.sub.8H.sub.4O.sub.4].sup.2, [HCO.sub.3].sup., protonated aniline [C.sub.6H.sub.5NH.sub.3].sup.+ [SiO.sub.3].sup.2, [BO.sub.3].sup.3, [TfSI].sup., [B.sub.4O.sub.7].sup.2, [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [Br.sub.3].sup., [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., [MeSO.sub.3].sup., [WO.sub.4].sup.2, [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [ClO.sub.4].sup., [HSO.sub.4].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup. [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [MnO.sub.4].sup. [(FSO.sub.2).sub.2N].sup., [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2
Biochemical ILs.
[2909] Aside from carbonium cations described previously, cations forming ionic liquids may also be derived from biochemical sources. Biochemical ionic liquids offer the prospect of exceptional biocompatibility, sustainable sourcing, low toxicity, and biodegradability while displaying beneficial physio-chemical properties including solvation capabilities, ionic conductivity, low vapor pressure, and high thermal stability.
[2910] For example, in cholinium-amino acid ionic liquid, a deprotonated amino is reacted with the choline hydroxide base to form a protic ionic liquid (PIL) having cholinium as its cation. PILs represent a subclass of ionic liquids arising from an acid-base reaction or proton transfer. As shown in
[2911] Creatininium 2911 comprises a protonated version of creatine having the formula [C.sub.4H.sub.8N.sub.3O]abbreviated [CreH].sup.+ where the extra hydrogen is nitrogen bound. A protonated version of lysine, lysinium 2912 abbreviated [LysH].sup.+ has the chemical composition [C.sub.6H.sub.15N.sub.2O.sub.2].sup.+. The following table lists exemplary biochemical ionic liquids.
TABLE-US-00066 IL Cation Chemical Category Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Biochemical carbonium see prior table carbonium: see prior table. cations cholinium [Chol].sup.+ cholinium: [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., creatininium [CreH].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup. argininium [ArgH].sup.+ creatininium: [Cl].sup., [Br].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., histidinium [HisH].sup.+ [SO.sub.4].sup.2, [HSO.sub.4].sup. lysinium [LysH].sup.+ argininium: [BF.sub.4].sup.+, [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., guanidinium [GuaH].sup.+ [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [CF.sub.3COO].sup., [C.sub.6H.sub.5SO.sub.3].sup. [SO.sub.3].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [OTf].sup. histidinium: [TFA].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., [SCN].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [I].sup. lysinium: [HCOO], [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, [PFBuS].sup., [NTf.sub.2].sup., [ClO.sub.3].sup. guanidinium: [TsO].sup., [MetSO).sup., (ClO.sub.4).sup., (PF.sub.6).sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Cl].sup., [I].sup.
Superbase ILs.
[2912] A superbase is a chemical compound with extremely high basicity, i.e. with a strong ability to accept protons (H.sub.+)much stronger typical bases such as sodium hydroxide (NaOH) or potassium hydroxide (KOH). Once absorbing a ionized hydrogen, the protonated superbase is referred to as a superbase cation. Ionic liquids containing superbase cations are referred to as superbase ILs. Unlike the previously described ion liquids defined by the chemical structure of their constituent cation, superbase cations are characterized by their basicity, not their molecular structure or atomic composition. As such, superbase ILs are not specific to any one chemical family but cross structural forms.
[2913] One broad category of superbase ILs comprise quaternary ammonium cations with alkyl sidechains of varying carbons lengths including tetramethylammonium (n=1), tetraethylammonium (n=2), tetrapropylammonium (n=3), tetrabutylammonium (n=4) and longer chain moieties (not listed). Another superbase cation is the tetraphenyl variant of phosphonium, referred to as tetraphenylphosphonium.
[2914] Less commonly known superbase variants shown in
TABLE-US-00067 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Superbase tetramethylammonium [TMeA].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [OAc].sup., [I].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., cations tetraethylammonium [TEtA].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., tetrapropylammonium [TPrA].sup.+ [NO.sub.3].sup., [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., tetrabutylammonium [TBuA].sup.+ [C.sub.2H.sub.5SO.sub.4].sup., [HSO.sub.4].sup., [Br].sup., tetraphenylphosphonium [TPhP].sup.+ [Cl].sup. [ClO.sub.4].sup., [SCN].sup., [HCOO].sup., 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-enium [DBUH].sup.+ [CO.sub.3].sup.2, [p-CH.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.4SO.sub.3].sup., 1,5,-diazabicyclo[4,3,0]non-5-enium [DBNH].sup.+ [PO.sub.4].sup.3, [RSO.sub.3].sup.. 1,1,3,3-tetramethylgyuanidrium [TMGH].sup.+ For ammonium and sulfonium phosphazene bases [PzH].sup.+ see previous tables. tris(dimethylamino)sulfonium [3DMAmSulfH].sup.+ cyclopropenium [Cp].sup.+
Poly ILs.
[2915] A polyionic liquid or polymeric ionic liquid (PIL), is a type of ionic liquid where the ionic liquid moieties are incorporated into a polymer backbone. This results in a material that combines the unique properties of ionic liquids (such as high ionic conductivity, low volatility, and thermal stability) with the mechanical properties of polymers (such as flexibility, processability, and structural integrity). In a PIL the cation attaches to a backbone by containing a functional group compatible with or identical to functional groups and monomers present in the polymeric backbone. These polymers may comprise longer chains or smaller snippets providing mechanical rigidity to the ionic liquid cation without interfering with its ability to exchange charge and enhance film conductivity.
[2916] Examples of polymers used to form Poly ILs include the following: [2917] poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) [2918] poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) [2919] poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) [2920] polystyrene (PS) [2921] poly(acrylonitrile) (PAN) [2922] poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) [2923] poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) [2924] Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA)
[2925] For example, IL cations containing a vinyl group will more easily bond with poly vinyl groups because of a shared chemical radicals and compatible charge structure. As a case in point,
TABLE-US-00068 Category IL Cation Chemical Compound Cation Symbol Exemplary Anions Poly(IL)s poly(1-butyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(BuVlm)].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., [PF.sub.6].sup., poly(1-ethyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(EtVlm)].sup.+ [CF.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [Tf.sub.2N].sup., poly(1-hexyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(H(CH.sub.2).sub.6Vlm)].sup.+ [N(CN).sub.2].sup., [Br].sup., poly(1-octyl-3-vinylimidazolium) [Poly(H(CH.sub.2).sub.8Vlm)].sup.+ [CH.sub.3COO].sup., [I].sup., poly(1-butyl-1-vinylpyrrolidinium) [Poly(BuVPyrr)].sup.+ [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [IO.sub.4].sup., poly(1-ethyl-1-vinylpyrrolidinium) [Poly[EtVPyrr].sup.+ [EtSO.sub.4].sup., [NO.sub.3].sup., poly(1-butyl-1-vinylpiperidinium) [Poly[BuVPip].sup.+ [p-CH.sub.3C.sub.6H.sub.4SO.sub.3].sup., poly(1-ethyl-1-vinylpiperidinium) [Poly(EtVPip)].sup.+ [CH.sub.3SO.sub.3].sup., [H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [HPO.sub.4].sup.2, [HCOO].sup., [C.sub.6H.sub.5COO].sup., [ClO.sub.4].sup., [FSO.sub.2NSO.sub.2F].sup., [C.sub.2O.sub.4].sup.2, [C.sub.4H.sub.4O.sub.6].sup.2, [C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7].sup.3, [BO.sub.3].sup.3, [CrO.sub.4].sup.2, [Cr.sub.2O.sub.7].sup.2, [MnO.sub.4].sup.,[SCN].sup., [S.sub.2O.sub.3].sup.2, [IO.sub.3].sup., [Cl].sup., [BF.sub.4].sup., [BH.sub.4].sup.
Problems with ILs.
[2926] Despite their potential to improve the conductance properties of a ion exchange membrane ionic liquids suffer from a variety of issues. Among these the biggest issues are leakage and leaching of the IL escaping from the membrane, i.e. poor containment. The impact of IL leakage cause a number of significant issues.
[2927] For example, if the level of conductivity of an ion exchange membrane depends on charge transport enhancement from IL cations, any leakage or dispersion of the IL concentration over time will produce a marked decline in ionomer current and corresponding increase in membrane resistance and power loss. Higher power losses will also cause increased heating which may further accelerate the IL dispersion and leaching. In applications involving ionic filtering, any decline in IL content may compromise a separation membrane's ability to selectively remove impurities and contaminants.
[2928] Changes in IL concentration impacting the stoichiometry and charge balance in an ionomeric film can also adversely impact film stability, causing physical and chemical degradation of the membrane material, thereby reducing its lifespan and effectiveness. Changes in the membrane's internal environment due to IL loss can also cause IEM swelling or shrinkage, which can further compromise film integrity and performance.
[2929] Other considerations involve environmental impact including toxicity and persistence. Specifically many ILs are toxic to aquatic and terrestrial life where a release into the environment could cause significant ecological damage. ILs are often designed to be stable and non-volatile, persisting in the environment for long periods leading to long-term contamination with unknown toxic and mutagenic risks. Leakage could impact the health of both users and workers involved in fuel cell fabrication, requiring special handling, safety measures, and recycling protocols.
[2930] Another issue for ionic doping is membrane porosity. In polymeric ionomers, the crystallinity and atomic density of the film can range from dense matrices with limited sized pores and few channels to extremely porous films with extensive leakage aggravated by fuel crossover.
Improved IL Doping.
[2931] To resolve problematic issues with ionic liquids, the methods used to form ionomeric polymers made in accordance with this invention stabilize the presence of ionic liquids within the ionomer. Once fabricated, the improved membrane thereby prevents leakage and seepage of ionic liquid thereby overcoming the deficiencies of conventional membranes.
[2932] The improved IL doping of an ion exchange membrane is achieved using fabrication of the inventive membrane described previously except that after molding the membrane is doped by ionic liquid doping then sealed by a coating. The features include: [2933] a grid-like inert skeletal support for the membrane comprising an endoskeleton and exoskeleton; [2934] micropores fabricated in the ionomer using a sacrificial filler during molding subsequently removed prior to ionic liquid doping; [2935] sealing the ionic liquid into the membrane with the anode and cathode catalyst layers comprising a composition able to conducting electricity and transport gasses but relatively impervious to ionic liquids.
[2936] The fabrication sequence is illustrated in
[2937] In step (d) shown in
[2938] Made in accordance with this invention, the sealant additives included in modified catalyst layer 2937 may comprise any of the following: [2939] carbon nanotubes (CNTs)Carbon nanotubes can enhance electrical membrane conductivity and provide a barrier to ionic liquid leakage due to their high aspect ratio and surface area; [2940] graphene oxide (GO)GO can improve mechanical strength and provide a barrier to prevent ionic liquid leakage while maintaining good electrical conductivity; [2941] silica (SiO.sub.2) nanoparticlesSilica nanoparticles can be used to create a more tortuous path for the ionic liquid, reducing leakage while still allowing gas diffusion and maintaining conductivity; [2942] zirconium phosphate (ZrP)ZrP has been shown to improve proton conductivity and can help in creating a barrier to ionic liquid leakage; [2943] metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)MOFs can be tailored to have high surface area and porosity, which can help in gas diffusion and ionic liquid retention; [2944] polymer binders: Polymers like Nafion or other perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) ionomers can be used to enhance proton conductivity and provide a matrix that can help retain the ionic liquid within the membrane; [2945] ceramic particlesIncorporating ceramic particles such as titania (TiO.sub.2) or alumina (Al.sub.2O.sub.3) can improve the mechanical stability of the membrane and reduce ionic liquid leakage; [2946] ionic liquid-immobilized (ILI NP) nanoparticlesNanoparticles that are functionalized to immobilize ionic liquids can be used to retain the ionic liquid within the membrane while allowing gas and proton transport; [2947] layered double hydroxides (LDHs)LDHs can be used to enhance proton conductivity and provide a barrier to ionic liquid leakage due to their layered structure; [2948] conductive polymersPolymers such as polyaniline (PANI) or polypyrrole (PPy) can be used to enhance electrical conductivity and provide a barrier to ionic liquid leakage' [2949] hybrid materialsCombining different materials, such as mixing carbon-based materials with inorganic nanoparticles, can create composite membranes with enhanced properties tailored for specific applications. [2950] zeolites metal-organic framework (ZL-MOFs) CompositesThese porous materials can be incorporated into the membrane to enhance gas permeability and selectively allow certain molecules to pass through while retaining ionic liquids. [2951] cross-linked networks (XLN)Creating a cross-linked polymer network as a catalyst coating can help in retaining the ionic liquid within the membrane, providing mechanical stability and reducing leakage. [2952] nanofibers (NF) and electrospun membranesElectrospinning techniques can produce nanofiber membranes with high surface area and porosity, which can be beneficial for retaining ionic liquids and enhancing gas transport. [2953] functionalized silica nanoparticles (fSi-NP)Silica nanoparticles functionalized with ionic liquid-compatible groups can improve the interaction between the ionic liquid and the membrane matrix, reducing leakage. [2954] boron nitride (BN) NanoparticlesBN nanoparticles can suppress IL leakage while also forming a barrier to carbon monoxide contamination causing catalyst poisoning; [2955] self-healing materialsIncorporating self-healing polymers can help in maintaining membrane integrity and preventing ionic liquid leakage overtime. [2956] layer-by-layer (LbL) AssemblyThis technique allows for the precise control over the composition and thickness of each layer, which can be used to create a membrane with tailored properties for specific applications. LbL assembly may include sequenced deposition using sputtering, co-sputtering, multi-target sputtering, or molecular beam epitaxy.
[2957] The aforementioned processes of forming micropores using a sacrificial filler and then filling the pores with an ionic liquid may be used without employing a inert skeletal matrix of may be used in conjunction with the matrix. Similarly, the inert skeleton may be used to constrain the seepage and leakage of ionic liquids laterally throughout the film and along its periphery without employing the sacrificial filler method of pore formation.
[2958] Another possibility is to combine the forgoing IL doping method with permanent fillers used to further enhance membrane conductivity. Unlike ILs which may be somewhat mobile within the membrane, permanent fillers made in accordance with this invention are bound to the matrix in fixed location. In fabrication, the permanent filler is added to the mold compound prior to polymerization. As shown in step (a) of
[2959] Permanent fillers as described herein include graphene oxides (GOs) including perfluoropolyether grafted graphene oxide (PFPE-GO) or poly (2,5-benzimidazole) grafted graphene oxide (ABPBI-GO); phosphotungstic acid (PWA) crystallites; bismuth trimesic acid (BiTMA); bismuth molybdate (Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6); bismuth metal oxide frameworks (BiMOF); sulfonated poly ether sulfone conjugates (SPESf) with BiTMA, Bi.sub.2MoO.sub.6 or BiMOF; neutral carbon walled nanotubes (CNTs); single or multiwalled carbon nanotubes functionalized by SO.sub.3H, COOH, POH, NH.sub.2, SiO.sub.2, chitosan (CS), or TiO.sub.2; carbon nanoflakes; mesostructured cellular foam (silica MCF); nesosilicates ((SiO.sub.4).sup.4). Another chitosan carbon nanotube is comprises the graft chitosan-g-styrenesulfonic acid (CS-g-SSA CNT). Chitosan also may bond to sulfonated graphene oxide (CS-sGO).
[2960] Other permanent dopants include phosphorylated hollow mesoporous silica with phosphoric acid (HMS-PA); nascent mesostructured cellular foam (MCF); sulfonated mesostructured cellular foam (MCF-SO.sub.3H); hydroxy mesostructured cellular foam (MCF-OH); amino mesostructured cellular foam (MCF-NH.sub.2); aluminum-grafted mesoporous silica (AI-MCF); aluminum-grafted hybrid mesoporous silica (mPBI-AI-MCF); covalent triazine framework (C.sub.3H.sub.3N.sub.3); poly(methyl methacrylate) nanospheres (PMMA-NS); Pd-poly(methyl methacrylate) nanoclusters (Pd-PMMA NCs); sulfonated poly(methyl methacrylate) nanospheres (sPMMA NS); nascent porous poly(methyl methacrylate) nanospheres (PMMA NS); poly methyl methacrylate sulfonated zinc nanospheres and nanoclusters (PMMA ZnS NS/NC); and poly methyl methacrylate zinc oxide nanospheres (PMMA ZnO NS/NC).
[2961] Another class of permanent dopants include polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS) including thiol (POSS-SH), phosphoric (POSS-PA), isobutyl (POSS-iBu), vinyl (POSS-Vi), 1-chlorobutane (POSS-BCl), octakis(dimethylsilyloxy) (Ot-POSS), octavinyl (OV-POSS), octaphenyl (OPh-POSS), isobutyl-vinyl (POSS-iBu-Vi), isobutyl-butylamine (POSS-iBu-NH.sub.2), butyl chloride (POSS-BuCl), isobutyl hydroxide (POSS-iBu-OH), isobutyl-styryl (POSS-iBu-styryl), isobutyl-polystyrene (POSS-iBu-PS), cyclopentyl-polystyrene (POSS-Cp-PS), cyclohexyl-polystyrene (POSS-Cy-PS), aminopropylisobutyl (POSS-AM-iBu), mercaptopropyl-isobutyl (POSS-SJ-iBu), and other generic variants such as mono(acryloisobutyl) (POSS-A). Sulfonated polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (sPOSS) include cyclopentyl-polystyrene (sPOSS-Cp-PS) and cyclohexyl-polystyrene (POSS-Cy-PS). Related moieties and isomers include double decker silsesquioxane (DDSQ) including methylated and non-methylated functionalized variants (Me DDSQ-R) and (NMe DDSQ-R) where R may comprise vinyl, methylpropyl, methyltrichlorosilane, dichloromethylvinylsilane, stereo-vinyl, allyloxytrimethylsilane, amino-butyloxycarbonyl, propyl glycidyl ether radicals, 4-bromostyrene, 4-acetoxystyrene, or trioxy-indole radicals.
[2962] Other permanent dopants include various nanocomposites including zirconium composite membrane (ZVM, ZrCM) and platinum composite membranes (PtCM), nanoparticle coated carbon nanotubes (NP CNT) functionalized by amino (NH.sub.2), platinum-amino (PtNH.sub.2), titanium-amino groups (TiNH.sub.2), and platinum-tin (PtSn) adsorbed surface groups. Platinum titanium dioxide nanoparticles (PtTiO.sub.2 NP) together with graphene oxide sulfone (FPGO-sPSf) also can enhance film conductivity and stability.
[2963] Other nanostructure permanent dopants include electrospun nanofibers (NF) such as poly sulfonated polystyrene nanofibers (P(sPS)NF). Other dopants include poly dopamine and poly sulfonated dopamine P(DA-sDA), silver nanoparticles (Ag-NP), cobalt nanoparticles (Co-NP) and ionomeric nanoparticles (PFSA-PTFE NP). Zirconium dopants include intercalant Zr of types , , and ; and zirconium nanospheres.
[2964] A large class of permanent dopants that may be mixed with ionic liquids include metal oxide frameworks (MOFs) including zirconium, tungsten, iron, zinc, zinc-oxide, chromium, along with catalyst and scavenger metals. MOF dopants may also include triazole or phosphoric acid guests and grafts. A specialized category of MOFs comprises structural forms of tungsten including tungsten-carbon nanoparticles (WC NP) and phosphotungstic acid (PWA). Other fillers include the aluminum silicon composite zeolite which may be functionalized by acids such as phenylsulfuric acid (PhSA-ZI) or sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3S) in sulfonated mordenite. Zeolite may be formed into nanocrystals functionalized by acids or metals.
[2965] For higher temperature applications, p-oxydiphenylene-benzimidazole (OPBI) may form stable nanostructure copolymer dopants with hexachlorocyclotriphosphazene (HCCP-co-PBI); with imidazolechlorocyclotriphosphazene (ImCCP-co-PBI); and with zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (PBI-co-ZIF).
[2966] The corresponding flow chart for including ionic liquids into the aforementioned membranes made in accordance with this invention is illustrated in
[2967] In step 2942 Mold IEM the ionomer monomer is mixed with solvent and cross linkers together with sacrificial filler and any permanent fillers, then polymerized at the applicable temperature. In step 2943 Remove Sac Filler, a solvent such as water is used to dissolve and remove the sacrificial filler from the membrane. The solvent has no significant effect on the membrane polymer, the skeletal pillars, or any permanent fillers and dopants. In step IL Dope Membrane the membrane is coated or immersed in ionic liquid and soaked until the IL penetrates into the pores in the ionomer's polymer matrix including accumulating in the previously formed sac pores.
[2968] The membrane is then thermally annealed in step 2945 Anneal Membrane to remove any excess solvent or water. Finally the exterior surface of the IEM is coated on both the anode and cathode sides in step 2946 Coat Membrane. The coating may be combined with the catalyst layer slurry including catalyst metal, carbon, and any other barrier materials like boron nitride. In addition to functioning as the catalyst layer of the CCM the coating also serves as the sealant to prevent ionic liquid leakage from the membrane's surfaces. Alternatively the sealant may be deposited in a separate step from the catalyst layer after or more likely before the CL formation. The sealant layer maybe formed using immersion is a solution, by spray coating, printing, or by sputtering.
[2969] While this coating prevents IL leakage from the planar surfaces of the membrane is doesn't stop leakage of the ionic liquid laterally out of the sides of the membrane. The chemically inert skeletal structure is however impervious to IL diffusion. Together with the sealant the IL is confined into a cube or rectangular enclosure bounded on all side. An AI generated depiction of endoskeletal confinement of ionic liquid in and atop a membrane is depicted metaphorically as syrup and pancakes and waffles as shown in
IL Membrane Compatibility.
[2970] The compatibility of a specific ionic liquid and particular composition of IEM depends on the ability of the ionomer to cooperatively conduct ions through a Grotthuss hopping conduction mechanism and through vehicular transport, generally involving the drift and diffusion of hydronium cations. Other considerations involve the mutual compatibility of the IL and IEM operating together over a specific temperature range, the pH of the ionic liquid, and any damage the IL might cause the ionomer or its polymeric backbone.
[2971] In general, ionic liquids containing halides, high viscosity, poor thermal stability, and long alkyl chains are generally not suitable for use in proton exchange membranes due to their potential to cause phase separation, reduce ionic conductivity, and degrade membrane material. Factors include poor membrane stability in the presence of strong acids aggravated by the IL; poor thermal stability over expected operating temperature ranges possibly causing the IL to decompose; high reactivity causing IL conductivity to degrade through unwanted chemical reactions thereby impeding its ability to absorb and donate protons into solution; and the inability of an IL to form a uniform, stable phase with the membrane material.
[2972] In ionomers relying on high levels of hydration and water-borne charge transport, ion liquids with excessive hydrophobicity may be unable to engage in charge transfer with membrane attached ionomer groups. For optimal benefit in cation conduction, it is therefore important to pair ionic liquids with a ion exchange membrane material to ensure compatible and durability, offer efficient ion transport, and deliver stable operation. For operation below 100 C., this criteria also means the ionic liquid should exhibit low viscosity at its nominal operating temperature.
[2973] The following table describes the best and worst combinations of PEM membranes with various ionic liquids:
TABLE-US-00069 PEM Structure Beneficial(Best)ILs Unsuitable(Worst)ILs 1 PFSA [EtMelm].sup.+ [OTf].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+ [Tf.sub.2N].sup., [EtMelm]].sup.+[Cl].sup., homopolymer [EtMelm].sup.+[TFSIm].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+ [MeSO.sub.3].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PFSA) [BuMelm].sup.+ [OTf].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtPyr].sup.+ [OTf].sup., [BuPyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [P6,6,6,14].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup. [EtMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup. [BuMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[SCN].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[SCN].sup. 2 PFSA CRM [BuMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; heteropolymer [OctMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [OctMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; (PFSA-PTFE) [DecMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Br].sup.; [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [BuMePyrr] .sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[HSO.sub.4].sup.; [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. [BuMelm].sup.+[SCN].sup.; [BuMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup.; [EtMelm].sup.+[EtSO.sub.4].sup. 3 amorphous glassy [EtMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., BuMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., matrices [EtMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., (PDD, PFMMD) [BuMelm].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[NO.sub.3].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [BuMePyrr].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[SCN].sup., [EtMePyrr].sup.+[FSI].sup., [BuMePip].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup., [EtMePip].sup.+[FSI].sup., [P6,6,6,14].sup.+[TFSI.sup.], [EtMelm].sup.+[HSO.sub.4].sup., [P6,6,6,14].sup.+[DCA].sup., [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. [BuMelm].sup.+[HCOO].sup., [(DEt)(MeOEt)Am].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [TEtS].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [TMeS].sup.+[FSI].sup., [BuPyr].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Br].sup. 4 polyethylene [EtMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PE) [EtMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup. [OctMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup. 5 polyvinyl alcohol [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PVA) [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [BuMePyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., EtMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[Br].sup., [TBuP].sup.+[Cl].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [DEt(MeEt)Am].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [TEtS].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMePyrr].sup.+[DCA].sup., [Choline].sup.+[DHP].sup. [BuMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. 6 polyvinyl difluoride [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PVDF) [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [TEtS].sup.+[TFSI].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[TFSI].sup. [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [TBuP].sup.+[Cl].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Cl].sup. 8 polyvinyl chloride [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PVC) [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [Cho].sup.+[DHP].sup. [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup. 9 polyimide [BuMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PI) [HexMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Bu.sub.4P].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup. [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc] 10 polystyrene [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PS) [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [Cho].sup.+[DHP].sup. [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup. 11 poly fluorenyl ether [EtMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [BuEtlm].sup.+[Cl].sup., ketone nitrile [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PFEKN) [Et.sub.3S].sup.+[TfO].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup. [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[I] 12 polyphenylene [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PPh) [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n).sub.4N].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n)Pyr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Ac].sup., [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n).sub.4P].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup. [BuMelm].sup.+[OH].sup., [N2222].sup.+[Cl].sup., [MePyr].sup.+[Cl].sup. 13 polyarylene ether [EtMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [BuEtlm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PAE) [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [Et.sub.3S].sup.+[TfO].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2] [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[I] 14 poly ether ketones [EtMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [BuEtlm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PEK, PEEK, PE.sub.xK.sub.y) [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [Et.sub.3S].sup.+[TfO].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup. [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[I] 15 poly ether sulfones + [EtMelm].sup.+[TfO].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+ [BF.sub.4].sup., [BuEtlm].sup.+[Cl].sup., ketones [HexMelm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [TEtAm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PESf, PEKSf) [Et.sub.3S].sup.+[TfO].sup., [MePrPyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup. [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[I] 37 polysulfone acid-base [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., polymer [HexMelm][PF.sub.6].sup., [Et.sub.4N].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [MeOctlm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PSf) [Ch].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [EtPyr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup. [Et.sub.3NH].sup.+[OAc].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Br].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup. 38 anhydrous phenylene- [EtMelm].sup.+[OTf].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., bibenzimidazole [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., BuMePyrr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N.sup.], [EtMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., (PBI) [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [NBu.sub.4].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[Br].sup., [BuMePip].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup. [HexMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [OctMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., 39 chitosan & cellulose [BuMelm].sup.+[Cl].sup., [EtMelm].sup.+[OAc].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., biopolymer [HexMelm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., [TBuAm].sup.+[Br].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., (CS, CL) [Ch].sup.+[DHP].sup., [Pyr].sup.+[Cl].sup. [EtMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2].sup., [BuMelm].sup.+[DCA].sup., [HexMelm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.
IL-Doped PFSA Homopolymer IEM:
[2974] The performance of proton exchange membranes (PEMs) in fuel cells described in 1 is highly dependent on the properties of the ionic liquids (ILs) used. For a PEM comprising a perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) homopolymer, the IL stoichiometry of both the cation and anion significantly influences IEM conductivity, stability, and overall efficiency. Ionic liquids offering good compatibility with bulk PFSA ionomers include imidazolium, pyridinium, phosphonium, sulfonate, and protic ionic liquid (PIL) based cations. Imidazolium-based ionic liquids provide high thermal stability and good proton conductivity.
[2975] Examples include the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[TFSIm].sup.. Other PFSA compatible [Im].sup.+ based ionic liquids include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium methanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[MeSO.sub.3].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoro-methanesulfonate [BuMetIm].sup.+[OTf].sup., and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl) imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup..
[2976] Pyridinium based ionic liquids compatible with bulk PFSA films include N-ethylpyridinium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtPyr].sup.+[OTf].sup. and N-butylpyridinium tetrafluoroborate [BuPyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.. Applicable phosphonium-based ILs include trihexyl(tetradecyl)phosphonium bis(trifluoromethyl sulfonyl)imide with the chemical formulation [(H(H.sub.2C).sub.6).sub.3(H(H.sub.2C).sub.14)P].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup. abbreviated as [P6, 6, 6,14].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup..
[2977] Ionic liquids unsuitable for use in bulk PFSA homopolymer films include the [Im].sup.+ based moieties 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [EtMeIm]].sup.+[Cl].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. where the chlorine radical can damage the ionomer and degrade conductance. Some ILs may result in chemical instability in bulk PFSA. They include ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [EtMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetra-fluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.. Both the [Im].sup.+ based ionic liquids 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [EtMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BuMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup. may cause membrane degradation through hydrolysis. Other chemically aggressive ILs include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide ([EtMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup., 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup., 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium thiocyanate [EtMeIm].sup.+[SCN].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium thiocyanate [BuMeIm].sup.+[SCN].sup. can also irrevocably deregulate a PFSA membrane.
IL-Doped PFSA-PTFE CRM Heteropolymer IEMs.
[2978] Although a composite reinforced membrane (CRM) comprising perfluorinated sulfonic acid (PFSA) supported by a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) backbone described in 2 still contains perfluorinated sulfonic acid, the best suited ionic liquids for a PFSA-PTFE heteropolymer membrane differs from its homopolymer sibling primarily due to distinct structural and chemical properties of both membrane types. In a PFSA homopolymer is hydrophilic while CRM moieties contain both hydrophobic and hydrophilic groups. Specifically ILs must be compatible with both PFSA and PTFE and not degrade or adversely affect the mechanical properties of the PTFE support framework.
[2979] Moreover, to enhance the mechanical properties of PTFE in a CRM, an ionic liquid must contain at least in part hydrophobic functional groups. While IL hydrophobicity does not impede Grotthuss hopping conduction of sulfonic acid ionomers, such ILs offer no substantive benefit to pure PFSA homopolymers which contain minimal segments of hydrophobic blocks along its spine. Ionic liquids better suited for PFSA-PTFE CRMs comprise imidazolium cations with anions that do not degrade the membrane's hydrophobic polymeric backbone such as butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BuMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., offering good chemical stability and hydrophobic properties, which can interact favorably with PTFE. However, its hydrophobic nature is not beneficial for pure PFSA membranes, which require high proton conductivity.
[2980] Another CRM compatible ionic liquid includes 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium [HexMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., whose hydrophobicity enhances the mechanical stability of PFSA-PTFE composites, but cannot enhance proton conductivity in pure PFSA membranes. The IL 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [OctMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. is hydrophobic and can improve the mechanical properties of PFSA-PTFE composites. Its lower affinity for water however renders it less suitable for pure PFSA membranes relying on water for proton conductivity.
[2981] Similarly, 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., provides good thermal and chemical stability, which complements the PTFE structure. Its low water uptake is however nor advantageous for PFSA homopolymer membranes. Another ionic liquid 1-decyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [DecMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. the molecule's long alkyl chain increases hydrophobicity benefiting PFSA-PTFE composites. However, it does not support the high proton conductivity required in pure PFSA membranes. Likewise 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [BuMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup. offers a balance between hydrophilicity and hydrophobicity, enhancing the mechanical and thermal stability of PFSA-PTFE composites. However, only moderate water uptake is not ideal for PFSA membranes that depend membrane hydration.
[2982] The ionic liquid 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup. and similarly 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. are hydrophobic in nature with good thermal stability, and therefore better suited for PFSA-PTFE composites. Their hydrophobicity, however, limits the ILs' utility in homopolymer PFSA membranes. Another IL, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup., enhance the mechanical properties of PFSA-PTFE composites but is also beneficial in maintaining a balance in proton conductivity for PFSA membranes. Aside from imidazolium cation, pyrrolidinium based ionic liquids such as 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoro methylsulfonyl)imide [BuMePyrr].sup.+Tf.sub.2N].sup. are also useful in enhancing film property.
[2983] Specifically ionic liquids that are not suitable for use in PFSA-PTFE heterogeneous membranes are those that comprise (a) excessively hydrophobic causing phase separation and loss of mechanical integrity in the membrane; (b) excessively viscous hindering ion transport and reducing membrane efficiency; (c) contain reactive groups such as halides (e.g., chloride, bromide) or strong acids/bases that can chemically degrade the PFSA or PTFE components; (d) aprotic ionic liquids can lead to dehydration of the membrane, reducing proton conductivity; (e) Ionic Liquids with high electronegativity which can extract water from the membrane, leading to dehydration and reducing performance; and (f) ILs with poor thermal stability.
[2984] Ionic liquids hostile to PFSA-PTFE CRMs include a variety of anions. For example, chloride [Cl].sup. and bromine [Br].sup. anions can be reactive and lead to chemical degradation of the membrane such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [OctMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Br].sup.. Highly acidic ionic liquids or compounds that hydrolyze to form highly corrosive HF acid. Examples include 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hydrogen sulfate [BuMeIm].sup.+[HSO.sub.4].sup.; and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium thiocyanate [BuMeIm].sup.+ [SCN].sup.. Other ionic liquids which may become unstable and degrade the membrane's polymeric matrix include acetate [OAc].sup., tetrafluoroborate [BF.sub.4].sup., dicyanamide [DCA].sup., and ethylsulfate [EtSO.sub.4].sup. anions, with exemplary ILs comprising 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [BuMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium ethylsulfate [EtMeIm].sup.+[EtSO.sub.4].sup..
IL-Doped Glassy Matrix IEMs.
[2985] The compatibility of ionic liquids with proton exchange membranes (PEMs) comprising amorphous glassy matrices such as perfluorodioxole (PDD) and perfluoromethyl dioxole (PFMMD) described in 3 can be influenced by various factors, including the ionic liquid's chemical structure, size, and interaction with the polymer matrix. Examples of ionic liquids compatible with glassy matrix membranes include those containing imidazolium cations such as 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[TfO].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BuMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoro methylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethane sulfonate [BuMeIm].sup.+[TfO]-offering good thermal stability and ionic conductivity. Other ILs include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; along with 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup. offering good compatibility with fluorinated matrices.
[2986] Aside from ILs with imidazolium cations, other glassy matrix compatible ionic liquids include those containing pyrrolidinium, phosphonium, ammonium, sulfonium, and pyridinium cations. Examples of pyrrolidinium cation [Pyrr].sup.+ based ILs include N-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethane sulfonyl)imide [BuMePyrr].sup.+[TFSI].sup.; N-ethyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium bis(fluoro sulfonyl)imide [EtMePyrr].sup.+[FSI].sup.; and N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide [MePrPyrr].sup.+[FSI].sup.. The pyrrolidinium cation along with piperidinium-based [Pyr].sup.+ ILs are less likely to disrupt the glassy polymer matrix. Similarly fluorine-based FSI anions are intrinsically compatible with fluorinated systems. Piperidinium [Pip].sup.+ cation ILs include N-butyl-N-methylpiperidinium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide [BuMePip].sup.+[TFSI].sup. and N-ethyl-N-methylpiperidinium bis(fluoro sulfonyl)imide [EtMePip].sup.+[FSI].sup..
[2987] High thermal stability phosphonium-based ionic liquids compatible with glassy matrix IEMs include trihexyl(tetradecyl)phosphonium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide [P6,6,6,14].sup.+[TFSI].sup. and trihexyl(tetradecyl)phosphonium dicyanamide [P6,6,6,14].sup.+[DCA].sup.. Ammonium [Am].sup.+ cation ILs characterized by superior conductivity in electrochemical applications such as proton exchange membranes and battery separators and high temperature operation include N,N-diethyl-N-methyl-N-(2-methoxyethyl)ammonium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide [(DEt)(MeOEt)Am].sup.+[TFSI].sup. and tetraethylammonium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide [TEtAm].sup.+[TFSI].sup..
[2988] Sulfonium-based ILs compatible with glassy matrix IEMs include triethylsulfonium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide [TEtS].sup.+[TFSI].sup. and trimethylsulfonium bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide [TMeS].sup.+[FSI].sup.. Pyridinium-based ionic liquids include N-butylpyridinium bis(trifluoromethane sulfonyl)imide [BuPyr].sup.+[TFSI].sup. and N-methylpyridinium tetrafluoroborate [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup..
[2989] A number of ionic liquids are similarly incompatible with specific composition ion exchange membranes. For example, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. exhibits poor compatibility due to strong ionic interactions that can disrupt the polymer matrix. 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup. exhibits strong hydrogen bonding interactions leading to phase separation in fluorinated polymers. For a 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium nitrate [BuMeIm].sup.+[NO.sub.3]-ionic liquid the presence of nitrate ions can cause instability and poor compatibility with fluorinated matrices. In the case of 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium thiocyanate [BuMeIm].sup.+[SCN].sup. the thiocyanate [SCN].sup. anion can interact unfavorably with the polymer, leading to poor compatibility.
[2990] Ionic liquids containing phosphate anions such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium phosphate [BuMeIm].sup.+[H.sub.2PO.sub.4].sup. can cause phase separation and instability in the polymer matrix. In the case of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium hydrogen sulfate [EtMeIm].sup.+[HSO.sub.4].sup., the hydrogen sulfate anion can lead to strong ionic interactions that are not favorable for fluorinated polymers. For butyl-3-methylimidazolium formate [BuMeIm].sup.+[HCOO].sup., the formate anion [HCOO]-can lead to unfavorable interactions with fluorinated polymers, causing phase separation and instability. Despite having a fluorinated anion, ionic interactions of ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup. may still suffer poor compatibility with certain fluorinated polymers.
[2991] Depending on composition, even imidazolium based ILs can suffer phase separation and incompatibility with glassy matrix IEMs. Especially in cases of chlorine [Cl].sup. and bromine [Br].sup. present within butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide [BuMeIm].sup.+[Br].sup., highly electronegative anions may actually damage the ionomeric membrane.
IL-Doped Polyethylene (PE) IEMs.
[2992] Proton exchange membranes (PEMs) comprising polyethylene (PE) described in 4 typically require ionic liquids (ILs) that are chemically compatible and do not cause significant degradation or swelling. the IL should not degrade or react with the polymer. Desirable properties of the IL include (a) thermal stability, i.e. maintaining its properties at the operating temperatures of the PEM, (b) ionic conductivity i.e. where IL should enhance ionic conductivity to facilitate the desired electrochemical processes, (c) low viscosity where the IL is sufficiently fluid to enhance ionic mobility for efficient charge transport, and (d) compatibility with the IEM to avoid damage to the membrane or its ionomers.
[2993] Here are some ionic liquids that in accordance with the foregoing are generally considered more compatible with PE-based PEMs, they include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [EtMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., a relatively stable IL unlikely to interact aggressively with polyethylene; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. which similarly comprises a stable anion unreactive with PE; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.. The [NTf.sub.2].sup. anion is known for its chemical stability and low reactivity, making it a good candidate for use with polyethylene membranes. Another ionic liquid is 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [BuMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.. Like [EtMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup., this IL has a low reactivity and high chemical stability, making it suitable for use with PE-based PEMs along with 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [EtMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup. offering good compatibility with various polymers, including polyethylene.
[2994] Similarly, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup., 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BuMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup. and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoro-borate [EtMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup. offer characteristics compatible with PE membranes in electrochemical applications. Some ILs may comprise more chemically aggressive acetate and chloride anions but can still be paired with imidazolium based cations when doping PE membranes. These ILs include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup. and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup..
[2995] Certain ionic liquids are unsuitable for use in polyethylene ion exchange membranes causing chemical reactions or physical interactions detrimental to the integrity and performance of polyethylene (PE) ion exchange membranes. Primarily through adverse reactions with chemically aggressive anions, ILs may degrade the polymeric support structure or damage the electrochemically active ionomer, especially those including certain chloride, bromide, phosphate, acetate, and dicyanamide. Examples include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup., 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup., butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoro borate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup., 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup., 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [OctMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup., and 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup..
IL-Doped Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) IEMs.
[2996] Ionic liquids compatible with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) based ion exchange membranes in 5 include both imidazolium and non-imidazolium cation types. These include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoro methane sulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.. Non-imidazolium ILs compatible with PVA membranes include 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [BuMePyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; tetrabutyl-ammonium bromide [TBuAm].sup.+[Br].sup.; tetrabutylphosphonium chloride [TBuP].sup.+[Cl].sup.; N,N-diethyl-N-methyl-N-(2-methoxyethyl)ammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [DEt(MeEt)Am].sup.+ [NTf.sub.2].sup.; triethylsulfonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [TEtS].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; 1-butyl-1-methyl pyrrolidinium dicyanamide [BuMePyrr].sup.+[DCA].sup.; and choline dihydrogen phosphate [Cho].sup.+[DHP].sup..
[2997] Some ionic liquids incompatible with or potentially damaging to PVA-based PEMs include chemical degradation, excessive swelling, or plasticization of the PVA matrix. Specifically, anions containing chloride [Cl].sup. and sulfonate [OTf].sup. which can cause chemical instability and degradation in polyvinyl acetate include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethane-sulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.; and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [BuMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.. ILs containing acetate and tetrafluoroborate anions react aggressively with the PVA polymer causing hydrolysis, significant swelling, membrane degradation, and damage to the chemical integrity of the PVA matrix. These include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [BuMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup..
IL-Doped Polyvinyl Difluoride (PVDF) IEMs.
[2998] Ionic liquids compatible with polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF) described in 6 based proton exchange membranes include both imidazolium and non-imidazolium cation ionic liquids. Ionic liquids with [Im].sup.+ cations include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluoro phosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with PVDF proton exchange membranes include ammonium, sulfonium, and pyrrolidinium cations such as tetrabutylammonium tetrafluoroborate [TBuAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; triethyl sulfonium bis(trifluoromethyl sulfonyl)imide [TEtS].sup.+[TFSI].sup.; N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoro methylsulfonyl)imide [MePrPyrr].sup.+[TFSI].sup..
[2999] Ionic liquids which can degrade or damage the PVDF proton exchange membrane due to chemical reactivity or incompatibility with the polymer structure include those containing chemically aggressive anions such as chlorides or acetates exemplified by 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; tetrabutylphosphonium chloride [TBuP].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium chloride [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Cl].sup..
IL-Doped Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) IEMs.
[3000] Using ionic liquid doping of poly vinyl chloride membranes described in 8 made in accordance with this invention can benefit from enhanced conductivity and improved mechanical stability. IL dopants may comprise imidazolium and non-imidazolium moieties.
[3001] Exemplary PVC compatible imidazolium ionic liquids include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; Non-imidazolium-based ILs compatible with poly vinyl chloride ionomers include tetraethylammonium tetrafluoroborate [TEtAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; methylpyridinium tetrafluoroborate [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; and choline dihydrogen phosphate [Cho].sup.+[DHP].sup..
[3002] Ionic liquids incompatible with or potentially harmful to PVC PEMs include those containing reactive chloride and acetate anions such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; N-methyl-N-propyl-piperidinium chloride [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.. Through a different reaction also adverse to the PEM's structure, highly basic hydroxide anions such as tetrabutylammonium hydroxide [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+[OH].sup. can cause hydrolytic degradation of the polyimide.
IL-Doped Polyimide (PI) IEMs.
[3003] Made in accordance with this invention, polyimide (PI) ion exchange membranes described in 9 may also be doped with ionic liquids comprising either imidazolium or non-Imidazolium cations. IL-doped polyimide membranes with [Im].sup.+ cations include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [BuMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methyl-imidazolium tetrafluoroborate [EtMeIm].sup.+[BF4].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoro-methylsulfonyl)imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with polyimide proton exchange membrane include tetrabutylphosphonium bis(trifluoromethyl-sulfonyl)imide [Bu.sub.4P].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoro methylsulfonyl)imide [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and tetrabutylammonium bis(trifluoromethyl sulfonyl)imide [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup..
[3004] Ionic liquids incompatible with or potentially harmful to polyimide PEMs include those containing reactive chloride and acetate anions such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; N-methyl-N-propyl-piperidinium chloride [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.. Through a different reaction also adverse to the PEM's structure, highly basic hydroxide anions such as tetrabutylammonium hydroxide [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+[OH].sup. can cause hydrolytic degradation of the polyimide.
IL-Doped Polystyrene (PS) IEMs.
[3005] Using ionic liquid doping of polystyrene (PS) of 10 membranes made in accordance with this invention can benefit from enhanced conductivity and improved mechanical stability. IL dopants may comprise imidazolium and non-imidazolium moieties.
[3006] Exemplary PS compatible imidazolium ionic liquids include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; Non-imidazolium-based ILs compatible with polystyrene ionomers include tetraethylammonium tetrafluoroborate [TEtAm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; methylpyridinium tetrafluoroborate [MePyr].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; and choline dihydrogen phosphate [Cho].sup.+[DHP].sup..
[3007] Ionic liquids incompatible with or potentially harmful to PS PEMs include those containing reactive chloride and acetate anions such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; N-methyl-N-propyl-piperidinium chloride [MePrPip].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.. Through a different reaction also adverse to the PEM's structure, highly basic hydroxide anions such as tetrabutylammonium hydroxide [Bu.sub.4N].sup.+[OH].sup. can cause hydrolytic degradation of the polyimide.
IL-Doped Polyphenylene (PPh) IEMs.
[3008] IL doping of polyphenylene (PPh) described in 12 may comprise either imidazolium and non-imidazolium cations. Imidazolium [Im].sup.+ based ILs compatible with PPh membranes include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methyl-imidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with polyphenylene proton exchange membranes ammonium, pyridinium, and phosphonium moieties including tetraalkylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n).sub.4N].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; alkylpyridinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n)Pyr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; and alkyl-phosphonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [(H(CH.sub.2).sub.n).sub.4P].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup. comprising alkyl chains of length n.
[3009] For example when n=2 (ethyl) for tetraalkylammonium, the cation may be referred to as tetraethylammonium denoted as [TEtAm].sup.+ or by the numeric code [N2222].sup.+ where each number denotes the length of each of the four functional groups. For alkyl-phosphonium where n=4 (butyl) for all four functional groups, the cation may be called tetrabutylphosphonium denoted by [TEtAm].sup.+ or by the numeric code [P2222].sup.+. The functional groups of a IL cation need not contain identical length carbon chains. For example, in the tripropyl dodecyl phosphonium cation [(H(H.sub.2C).sub.12)(Pr).sub.3P].sup.+ or [(Dodec)(Pr).sub.3P].sup.+ three chains comprise n=3 (propyl) groups and one chain comprises a n=12 (dodecyl) group. For shorthand, the IL cation can be identified as [P33312].sup.+.
[3010] Ionic liquids incompatible or harmful to polyphenylene proton exchange membranes include those contain chloride, acetate, or hydroxide anions such as 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[Ac].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hydroxide [BuMeIm].sup.+[OH].sup.; tetraalkylammonium chloride such as [N2222].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and methyl-pyridinium chloride [MePyr].sup.+[Cl].sup..
IL-Doped Poly Ether Heteropolymer IEMs.
[3011] A variety of ion exchange membranes involve poly ether heteropolymers described in sections 11, 13, 14, and 15 including poly ether ketones, poly ether sulfones, poly ether ketone sulfones, polyarylene ethers, and poly fluorenyl ether ketone nitriles. Common to these various classes of ionomeric membranes is ether Et.sub.2O, an linear organic compound comprising an oxygen center surrounded by two ethyl groups. It can also be expressed as (C.sub.2H.sub.5).sub.2O or as the n=2 carbon chain (H(CH.sub.2).sub.2).sub.2O. Unlike the ethyl functional groups in alkyl sidechains, in poly ether membranes and related moieties such PEKN, PEK, PEEK, PAE, etc. the ether group forms the backbone of the polymer. The addition of ionic liquid doping into a poly ether based IEM must not degrade this relatively volatile component.
[3012] IL doping of poly ether based membranes made in accordance with this invention comprise both imidazolium and non-imidazolium cations including 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoro-methanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[TfO].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with poly ether PEM moieties include tetraethyl ammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [TEtAm].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup.; triethylsulfonium trifluoromethane sulfonate [Et.sub.3S].sup.+[TfO].sup.; and N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide** [MePrPyrr].sup.+[NTf.sub.2].sup..
[3013] IL dopants that impair IEM function or damage the polymeric matrix of poly ether related IEMs include the electronegative chloride, bromide, and iodide anions along with acetate and dicyanamide compounds. Examples of poly ether antagonists include 1-butyl-3-ethylimidazolium chloride [BuEtIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methyl imidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup.; and tetrabutylammonium iodide [TBuAm].sup.+[I].sup..
IL-Doped Polysulfone (PSf) IEMs.
[3014] Polysulfone acid-base membranes can also by enhanced using the ionic liquids made in accordance with this invention. IL dopants compatible with polysulfone IEMs comprising imidazolium cations include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm][PF.sub.6].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with polysulfone acid-base polymer proton exchange membranes include tetraethylammonium tetrafluoroborate [Et.sub.4N].sup.+[BF4].sup.; choline bis(trifluoro methylsulfonyl)imide [Ch].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and ethylpyridinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtPyr].sup.+ [Tf.sub.2N].sup..
[3015] ILs which can be corrosive and damage or degrade the polysulfone polymer structure include chloride, bromide, and dicyanamide anions. Acetate anions can be reactive causing hydrolysis of the polymer backbone. Exemplary ionic liquids incompatible with polysulfone include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-methyl-3-octyl imidazolium chloride [MeOctIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; triethylammonium acetate [Et.sub.3NH].sup.+[OAc].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide [HexMeIm].sup.+[Br].sup.; and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup..
IL-Doped Phenylene-Bibenzimidazole (PBI) IEMs.
[3016] The doping of phenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) ion exchange membranes with ionic liquids include both imidazolium and non-imidazolium cations. These include 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OTf].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [BuMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based IL doping of PBI membranes including 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [BuMePyrr].sup.+ [Tf.sub.2N].sup.; N-methyl-N-propylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [MePrPyrr].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; tetrabutylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide; tetrabutylammonium bis(trifluoromethyl-sulfonyl)imide [NBu.sub.4].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; and 1-butyl-1-methylpiperidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [BuMePip].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup..
[3017] Ionic liquids incompatible with PBI ion exchange membranes primarily comprise reactive chloride and bromide anions which can damage the polymeric backbone and its ionomeric groups. They include 1-methyl-3-butylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [EtMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide [BuMeIm].sup.+[Br].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methyl imidazolium chloride [HexMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; and 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [OctMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.;
IL-Doped Biopolymer IEMs.
[3018] The doping of biopolymer based ion exchange membranes such as chitosan and cellulose with ionic liquids can be used to enhance conductivity but must not degrade the structural matrix of the biopolymer, especially at elevated temperatures. Biopolymer compatible doping comprising imidazolium-based ionic liquids include 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride [BuMeIm].sup.+[Cl].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate [EtMeIm].sup.+[OAc].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [HexMeIm].sup.+[BF.sub.4].sup.. Non-imidazolium-based ionic liquids compatible with biopolymer IEMs include tetrabutylammonium bromide [TBuAm].sup.+[Br].sup.; choline dihydrogen phosphate [Ch].sup.+[DHP].sup.; and methylpyridinium chloride [Pyr].sup.+[Cl].sup..
[3019] Conversely ionic liquids potentially harmful to biopolymers comprise those that attacked the fibrous backbone of the biopolymer such as hexafluorophosphate, trifluoromethylsulfonyl, and dicyanamide radicals. These include the exemplary ionic liquids 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BuMeIm][PF.sub.6].sup.; 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [HexMeIm].sup.+[PF.sub.6].sup.; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EtMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup.; 1-butyl-3-methyl-imidazolium dicyanamide [BuMeIm].sup.+[DCA].sup.; and 1-hexyl-3-methyl imidazolium bis(trifluoromethyl sulfonyl)imide [HexMeIm].sup.+[Tf.sub.2N].sup..
IL-Doped Copolymers and Hybrid IEMs.
[3020] Copolymers and hybrid ion exchange membranes contain an amalgamate or blend of more than one polymer forming the ionomeric membrane. Like homopolymers, the chemistry of an ionic liquid dopant must not damage of disturb the structural integrity of the constituent polymeric backbones of the IEM. Since many of these copolymers use polymers described previously, the suitability of an ionic liquid cation and anion in a hybrid membrane is governed by the same rules as its constituent homopolymers.
[3021] Made in accordance with this invention, the PFSA polypropylene copolymer (PFSA-co-PP) described in 7 follows the same recommendation for suitable and unsuitable ILs described in 1 and 2 for PFSA homopolymers and PFSA-PTFE CRMs. Similarly the hybrid glassy copolymers such as (PFMMD-co-X) of 18 and (PDD-co-X) of 19 adhere to the same guidelines as the glassy membranes of 3.
[3022] Comprising aromatic cyclic rings, the hybrid phenyl copolymer (phenyl-co-X) of 20 and hybrid styrene copolymers (styrene-co/g-X) in 21 structurally resemble that of polystyrene described in 10. As such, the recommended choice for applicable and hostile ILs used in hybrid phenyl copolymer are substantially equivalent.
[3023] Similarly hybrid polysulfone P(Sf-sSf) described in 22 follows the same guidelines as that of polysulfone acid-base polymer (PSf) described in 37. Hybrid polyamide membranes P(Am-co-SAm) discussed in 23 are compatible with polyimides described in 9.
[3024] Hybrid poly phosphazene P(Pz-co-sPz) in 24 and hybrid poly siloxane P(SiX-co-sSiX) in 25 are often combined with a mutually compatible with thermoplastics such as polyethylene described in 4. Hybrid triazine (CTP) polymers in 26 shares aromatic structural similarities and I.sub.L compatibility with polysulfone membranes described in 15. Phosphazene is also mutually compatible with PVDF discussed in 6.
[3025] Ionic liquids compatible with hybrid methacrylate copolymer P(MMA-co-X) in 27 are similar to those applicable to amorphous glassy matrices such as PFMMD in described in 6. Based on a cellulose backbone, hybrid poly carboxy methyl cellulose (CMC) described in 28 is similarly compatible with ion liquid used with biopolymers described in 39. Hybrid poly multi-acid sidechain (MASC, PFIA) membranes described in 29 are compatible with the same ILs used with PFSA homopolymers and PFSA-PTFE CRMs described in 1 and 2. Unsurprisingly hybrid poly arylene-ether (PAE) is 30 similar to polyarylene ether (PAE) described in 13.
41. Block Copolymers.
[3026] A block polymer represents a copolymer comprising two different polymers chemically bound together to form one or more heterogenous polymer backbones. The topological relationships of the blocks are represented graphically in
[3027] By contrast, the alternating heteropolymer 2951 comprises two segments A and B arranged in alternating fashion. A backbone of alternating short polymer snippets is not considered a block polymer because its chain components are too short to determine the physical or electrical properties of the chain. For example, a PFSA-PTFE composite reinforced membrane is not classified as a block polymer because the polymer PTFE is the same as PFSA except it lacks the attached sidechain.
[3028] A true block polymer 2953 is a polymeric chain where one or both segments are distinct and sufficiently lengthy to influence the physical and electrochemical properties of the polymer. By contrast linked hybrid heteropolymers 1954a and 2954b are simply cross-linked chains of dissimilar polymers but do not constitute block polymers. Cross linked polymers are discussed throughout this application and will not be repeated here except to mention the cross linking requires an intermediate cross linking molecule not unlike those required to bond the IEM film to the inert pillar of the endoskeleton structure described herein.
[3029] Similarly, cross linked polymers require a cross linker, a molecule that has a functional group or two termini one that bonds to polymer A the other to polymer B. In the fabrication process of linked hybrid heteropolymer 2954a and 2954b, polymer A and B can be formed first then cross linked or more commonly formed concurrently in the presence of the cross-linking molecule. The grafting of one polymer onto another such as graft hybrid heteropolymer comprising mainchain 2955a and graft chain 2955b is normally performed sequentially. In essence the only true block structure is block heteropolymer 2953.
[3030] Cross linkers include glutaraldehyde (GA); sulfonated glutaraldehyde (sGA); glyceraldehyde; formaldehyde; divinyl benzene (DVB); epichlorohydrin (ECH), p-hydroxymethyl benzyl chloride (HMe-BnCl), divinyl benzene (DVBz); and dibenzoyl peroxide (DBPO); 2-dihydro-4-(4-hydroxyphenyl)-1 (2H)-phthalazone (DHPhthal); peroxide (H.sub.2O.sub.2); dithiol (DT), dithiol (DT), bishydroxy perfluoropolyether (PFPE); sodium borohydride (NaBH); bis(hydroxymethyl) (CH.sub.3O); N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF); N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc); N-methyl pyrrolidone (NMP); and biphenyl A (BPA), benzene (Bz); benzyl alcohol (BnOH, cresol); perfluorodibenzoyl peroxide ((FBzO).sub.2, FBzO), perfluoro-di-tert-butyl peroxide (FDTBO); perfluoro-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDMO); p-hydroxymethyl benzyl chloride (OHMe-BnCl); 4,4-trimethylene bis(1-methylpiperidine) (BMP); photo-induced 2,4,6-trimethylbenzoyl-diphenyl-phosphine oxide (photo TPO); trimethylolpropane tri-acrylate (TMPTA); E-caprolactam (CPL, (CH.sub.2).sub.5CNH); sulfonamide (SAm); anhydrous aluminum chloride (AlCl.sub.3); trichlorobenzene (TCB); hydrous calcium sulfate (CaSO.sub.4.Math.2H.sub.2O); sulfamic acid (HSO.sub.3 (NH.sub.2)); benzoyl peroxide (BPO, (BzO).sub.2); tert-butyl peroxypivalate (tBPPiv); thiol-containing chain transfer agents (CTAs); dithiol (DT), sulfonated dithiol (SDT); 4,4-trimethylene bis(1-methylpiperidine) (BMP); trimethylolpropane tri-acrylate (TMPTA); phenyl (Ph); methylated phenyl (MePh); ,-dibromo-p-xylene (DBpX or PhBr.sub.2); 1,3,5-tris(bromomethyl)-2,4,6-triethylbenzene (BeBr.sub.3); p-xylylene dichloride (PhCl.sub.2, C.sub.8H.sub.8Cl.sub.2); divinyl sulphone ((CH.sub.2CH).sub.2SO), 1,3,5-tris-(bromomethyl)benzene (B.sub.3Br); benzoxazine (C.sub.14H.sub.13NO), hexachlorocyclotriphosphazene HCCP; imidazolechlorocyclotriphosphazene (ImCCP); polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes (X-L) POSS); and sulfate anion groups (SO.sub.4-).
[3031] Depending on polymer chemistry acid and bases may also form cross links. Examples include citric acid (C.sub.6H.sub.5(O.sub.7).sup.3); acetic acid (AcOH), glycolic acid (C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.3), ethyl lactate (Acytol, lactic acid, C.sub.5H.sub.10O.sub.3), pyruvic acid (Pyr, C.sub.3H.sub.4O.sub.3), butyric acid (C.sub.3H.sub.7COOH); sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4, SA); hydrochloric acid (HCl); strong bases such as sodium hydroxide (NaOH) or potassium hydroxide (KOH); Lewis acids comprising metal salts such as aluminum chloride (AlCl.sub.3) or zinc chloride (ZnCl.sub.2); and carboxylic acids; i.e. acids containing carboxyl (COOH) functional groups such as formic acid (methanoic acid, HCOOH), and carbonic acid (hydroxymethanoic acid, H.sub.2CO.sub.3); along with quaternary ammonia compounds including 1,4-diazabicyclo-[2.2.2]-octane (DABCO), quinuclidine, and quinuclidinol. Heat and ultraviolet light can also promote cross linking between and among homopolymer and heteropolymer chains.
[3032] The challenge in forming a block copolymer is how to define the length of the dissimilar segments of the block polymer. One method to form a block copolymer IEM made in accordance with this invention is to employ an excision-insertion reaction. As shown in
[3033] Polymer {B} 2962 with functional group radical R.sub.b 1961b is then bonded onto the freshly cleaved polymer {A} segments and subsequently annealed to form the block copolymer containing the sequenced blocks 2960x, 2962x, 2960y resulting in a heteropolymer {A|B|A} containing two distinct radicals R.sub.a 2691a and R.sub.b 2691b. Although radicals R.sub.a and R.sub.b may comprise the same functional group, for example a medium length pendant with a sulfonic acid terminus, the sidechains and ionomers may also differ. For example, radical R.sub.a may comprise a short pendant with a phosphoric acid group while radical Rb may be constituted of a long sidechain or PFIA pendant with a sulfonic acid ionomeric terminus. The assembly of block polymers containing differing sidechains and ionomer termini represents a new class of membrane suitable for numerous applications including filtration, chemical separation, battery separators, as well as fuel cell ion exchange membranes.
[3034] Another method to form a heterogenous block copolymer made in accordance with this invention involves bonding a cyclic ring to a linear copolymer through a process referred to as a modified ring opening polymerization (MROP). As depicted in
[3035] An alternative method, a nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction while more easily executed, produces polymer segments of varying lengths. As depicted in
[3036] Another method to form a block copolymer made in accordance with this invention is to adapt a nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction as shown in
[3037] The X-M-L 2983 complex is then recycled by removing the halogen to recover a nascent metal-ligand molecule M-L 2981 for the next monomer bonding. The result of repeated cycles of attaching new monomers mono {A} onto the polymer chain {A}.sub.n is to grow the length of chain A-A-A-A- comprising A-block 2984 one addition at a time, the process of which is referred to as block-A synthesis 2985a. It should be noted when n=0, i.e. the first time through the loop, there is no starting polymer poly {A}.sub.n whereby poly {A}.sub.0=mono {A}.
[3038] After a desired length of the A-block 2984 is achieved, the sequential synthesis process transitions to block-B synthesis 2985b following the same basic algorithm except that the monomer changes to mono{B}. With each loop, another B polymer group is appended onto the polymer chain. As shown, polymeric chain poly{B|A}.sub.n 2986 is combined with metal-ligand 2987 and monomer mono{B}.sub.m to form longer polymer poly {B IA}.sub.n 2988 with byproduct X-N-L 2989 recycled back into metal-ligand 2987. As such, the chain A-A-A-A- comprising A-block 2984 is converted into a block polymer 2984z comprising the sequence A-A-A-A-B-B-. The process may be repeated by returning to block A process 2986a to form alternating blocks of {A} and {B} monomers.
[3039] A more tractable approach made in accordance with this invention called cross link polymerization is to form distinct polymer blocks defined by terminating linking molecules on one of the two polymers and then to merge them together into block copolymers in a subsequent annealing process. Such a process is shown in
[3040] In a parallel process, monomer mono{B} 2995 is catalyzed at a controlled rate for a specified time to form polymer poly{B} 2996 with an exemplary sequence (BBB) in snippet 2996X. In this process, the cross linker XL 2992 is selected to bond to both polymers poly{A} 2991 and poly{B}2996 but is initially attached only to poly{A} 2991. The duration of each polymerization reaction, each monomers' polymerization reaction rate, the catalyst type, and the catalyst concentration together determine the statistical distribution of polymers poly {A} 2991 and polymer poly {B}2996. In general the lengths of the two polymers, herein referred to as snippets, are generally not the same. In this example the length of the {A} and {B} snippets 2991X and 2996X are not the same.
[3041] The two dissimilar snippets are then combined in a catalytic cross linking process 2997 to form the block polymer poly {A|B|A} 2998 with an exemplary sequence 2998x of (-A-A-A-A-XL-B-B-B-XL-A-A-). In this manner, and two polymers disclosed in this application that share the ability to bond to a common cross linker XL 2992 can be bonded to form a block polymer.
[3042] In the event that the two polymers have no affinity to any common cross linker, the two separate cross linker can be attached as the termini of poly{A} 2991 and poly{B} 2996 separately. This process referred to as click polymerization requires the two cross linkers to a include complementary structures for bonding the respectively cross linkers XL.sub.a to XL.sub.b to each other, clicking together like toy Legos. The resulting sequence is (-A-A-A-A-XL.sub.a-XL.sub.b-BBB-XL-A-A-). The click polymerization process is therefore more flexible in bonding dissimilar polymers into a block copolymer than the aforementioned cross-linker polymerization (XLP) technique, but is also more complex and expensive.
Cross Linking Agents.
[3043] The term crosslinker and its designation XL is not intended to be limited to multichain polymers but also includes bonding multiple snippets into a single chain of alternating or random block copolymers. Another name for these linking molecules is chain extenders. For example as shown previously in
[3044] Other PVA cross linkers include dianhydrides such as 3,3,4,4-benzophenone tetracarboxylic dianhydride (BTDA), 4,4-oxydiphthalic anhydride (ODPA), and pyromellitic dianhydride (PMDA) and on pH sensitive XLs comprising trisodium trimetaphosphate (STMP) and sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP). Photo-cross-linking agent 4,4-diazostilbene-2,2-disulfonic acid disodium salt (DAS) can be used to cross link poly (vinyl pyrrolidone) (PVP) to PFSA. As illustrated in
[3045] Crosslinking of polyethylene (PE) is used to enhance properties not achievable by polyethylene homopolymers. Crosslinking occurs when the polymer adjacent chains become linked covalently. This bond can be formed directly through carbon-carbon bonds, or indirectly through a bridge-forming group, which creates interchain bridges. Chemical crosslinking of varying densities of PE can be achieved using cross linking agents such as azo, silane or peroxide such as dialkyl peroxide. Dialkyl peroxides such as 2,5-dimethyl-2,5-di(t-butylperoxy)hexane) involves breaking of OO bonds to form the alkoxyl radical.
[3046] In polyimides (PI), cross liking agents shown previously in
[3047] As shown previously in
[3048] As shown previously in
Exemplary Block Polymers.
[3049] Given the aforementioned processes and heterogeneities in film stoichiometry, a nearly infinite number of polymeric membranes are possible. An exhaustive compendia of possible outcomes is neither insightful nor illustrative. And although a specific membrane may be synthesized by a numerous methods as disclosed herein, the mechanical, physical, and electrical properties of such materials are not purely deterministic but vary statistically based on small inhomogeneities in the chemical mix, temperature distribution, solvent concentration, and catalytic reaction rates. Many of these processes are non-linear, reactions where pursuant to thermodynamic constraints a small perturbation in an initial condition or dynamic variations of process parameters produce a significant impact on the chemical reaction product (the butterfly effect). Prescribing the formation of block copolymers is even more complex as the synthesis of each block contained within the chain occurs at its own reaction rate independent of the other blocks.
[3050] As such, the exemplary block copolymers as shown herein are included not only to support enablement of the methods disclosed herein but to illustrate the diversity in reaction products when synthesizing copolymer ion exchange membranes. Each copolymer block is identified in a block map as either hydrophilic, hydrophobic, or cross linking with brackets identifying the repeating sequence as applicable.
[3051]
[3052]
[3053]
[3054]
[3055] Another alternating di-block copolymer 6019 shown in the lower chemical representation of
[3056]
[3057] In the top graphic illustrating block copolymer SPAESf-HFB-PAESf-HFB, hydrophilic block A 6021 comprises sulfonated arylene ether sulfone (SPAESf) forming a block copolymer with hydrophobic block B 6022 comprising un-sulfonated arylene ether sulfone (PAESf). The two blocks are bound through cross linkers XL 6023a and 6023b comprising hexafluorobenzene (HFB).
[3058] In the lower graphic illustrating block copolymer SPAESf-DFBP-PAESf-DFBP, hydrophilic block A 6025 comprises sulfonated arylene ether sulfone (SPAESf) forming a block copolymer with hydrophobic block B 6026 comprising un-sulfonated arylene ether sulfone (PAESf). The two blocks are bound through cross linkers XL 6027a and 6027b comprising hexafluorobenzene decafluorobiphenyl (DFBP).
[3059]
[3060]
[3061]
[3062]
[3063] Other densely sulfonated block copolymers include sulfonic acid groups locally concentrated in specific regions of the molecular moieties with well-defined phase-separated structures inducing comparable or better proton conductivity than PFSA-based ionomers.
[3064] In
[3065]
[3066]
[3067] Any of the aforementioned block copolymers can be combined with the previously described endoskeletal support, the sacrificial filler micropores, or a combination thereof.
Summary of Ion Exchange Membranes.
[3068] The ion exchange membranes described herein comprise a variety of novel fabrication sequences resulting in unique structural matrices of polymers and ionomers overcoming the inherent deficiencies of fragility, inconsistency, poor conductivity, and limited longevity plaguing present day ion exchange membranes. Structural features unique to ionomeric membranes and solid electrolytes made in accordance with this invention include an combination of: [3069] endoskeletal support pillars or grid providing mechanical support to an ionomeric or polymeric matrix or ion exchange membrane including necessary bonding between the thin polymer matrix and the skeletal support grid; [3070] a homopolymer comprising two-or-more hetero-ionomers forming a proton exchange membrane (PEM) or an anion exchange membrane (AEM) providing superior conductance over a wide range of operating conditions; [3071] various combinations of two-or-more copolymers integrating a homo-ionomer into an electrolyte film with controlled pore size and pore density offering good conductivity with limited fuel crossover in a proton exchange membrane (PEM) or an anion exchange membrane (AEM); [3072] an ionomeric membrane or film comprising two-or-more hetero-ionomers integrated into a homopolymer or into two-or-more copolymers forming a proton exchange membrane (PEM) or an anion exchange membrane (AEM) providing superior conductance over a wide range of operating conditions; [3073] an ionomeric membrane containing sac pores' comprising voids of controlled size and density created using a sacrificial filler process described herein; [3074] an ionomeric membrane containing the aforementioned sac pores doped with permanent fillers affecting conductivity and material properties; [3075] an ionomeric membrane containing the aforementioned sac pores doped with an ionic liquid [3076] an ionomeric membrane doped with an ionic liquid who leakage is limited by the presence of an inert nonporous endoskeletal matrix. [3077] a nanocoating applied to the planar surfaces of an ion exchange membrane controlling catalytic activity, limiting leakage of ion liquids, and/or preventing environmental contamination of the membrane with carbon monoxide and other chemicals toxic to the membrane, its ionomers, or its catalysts.
[3078] The foregoing inventive polymer and ionomer features may be used separately or in combination, for example (i) endoskeleton only, (ii) sacrificial filler only, (iii) endoskeleton and sacrificial filler, (iv) permanent fillers and dopants, (v) endoskeleton with permanent fillers and dopants, (vi) sacrificial filler combined with permanent fillers and dopants, (vii) endoskeleton with sacrificial filler combined with permanent fillers and dopants, and (viii) any of the foregoing with nanocoatings applied to the membrane surfaces.
Ionomeric Polymers.
[3079] These features are illustrated in summary form in the illustrations comprising
[3080] In another embodiment of this invention, an ion exchange membrane may contain one or more types of ionomers.
[3081] If the ionomer concentration comprises too high of mole fraction of the polymeric membrane excessive water retention, membrane swelling, humidity dependence, and humidity cycling induced reliability failures can result. The ionomer concentration can be limited either by either employing longer monomers or by dividing the polymer into two segments, those with ionomeric pendants and those without. By controlling their respective lengths, the mole fraction of the ionomer is determined. A di-monomer chain therefore comprises a homogenous polymer backbone having alternating segments of repeated two monomers distinguishable only by those segments with attached pendants and ionomeric termini, the ratio of which determines the compromise between strength and conductance.
[3082] Since the two monomers differ only by being inert or functionalized, the polymer can be considered as a heteropolymer. Alternatively because the backbone itself is essentially the same in every segment, the polymer can also be considered as a homopolymer, or more precisely as a hybrid homopolymer. Regardless, the ion exchange film comprises a homo-ionomer as it contains only a single species of ionomer as a functional group. Such di-monomer membranes may include both fluorocarbons, hydrocarbons, or a blend of both.
[3083] The di-monomer comprising the composite reinforced membrane (CRM) of PFSA-PTFE is exemplary as the non-pendant segments of the TFE backbone of PFSA differs from inert PTFE only in length, not in composition. As such, the longer the hydrophobic portion of the chain is extended, the stronger the membrane becomes and the lower its conductivity. Furthermore because of its hydrophobicity, expanded lengths of PTFE chains also form quasi-crystalline domains within the membrane reducing film porosity thereby inhibiting vehicular transport of hydronium and further degrading membrane conductance.
[3084] Another broad class of ion exchange membranes comprise heteropolymer and copolymer films. As shown in the center graphic of
[3085] To compensate for degraded conductivity in heteropolymers and copolymers, ion exchange membranes made in accordance with this invention involve methods to (i) control the porosity of the film to enhance proton transport, (ii) enhance the carrier density through the addition of permanent fillers and dopants, (iii) enhancing proton generation and oxygen reduction rates at the catalyst-layer-to-membrane interface, and (iv) enhancing gas flow to the CCM through graded or multilayer gas diffusion layers.
[3086] To control the film porosity as per item (i), the membrane composition is adjusted to reduce crystallinity to prevent dense compaction of the polymer strands by the application of a sacrificial filler to form sac pores in the polymer matrix. To enhance proton transport vis-h-vis item (ii) within the ionomer, a variety of permanent fillers made in accordance with this invention such as functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs), graphene oxides (GOs), and metal organic frameworks (MOFs) are introduced into the mold compound prior to polymerization. Some larger permanent fillers described herein also can enhance film porosity. Alternatively or in combination, ionic liquids can be introduced into the membrane post polymerization.
[3087] For item (iii), improved ion transport at the catalyst-membrane interface is achieved by either etching the interface using sputter etching prior to CL deposition, or by applying a nanoparticle coating after polymerization but prior to CL formation. A heterogenous slurry of carbon and catalyst metal optionally combined with catalytic PMMA nanoparticles or MOFs can also be used to enhance ionization rates, especially in the cathode interface controlling the oxygen reduction rate (ORR). In one embodiment, the catalyst layer composition on the anode and cathode are dissimilar, with the cathode containing alternative metals such as tungsten, palladium, and titanium dioxide along with barriers against carbon monoxide such as boron-nitride nanoparticles. For item (iv), the gas diffusion layer is deposited or printed atop a denser carbon substrate with monotonically declining density either layered or continuously varying porosity.
[3088] In the rightmost graphic of
Polymer Porosity.
[3089] As described above, the porosity of an ionomeric membrane made in accordance with this invention is a function of the packing density of the polymer strands constituting the membrane. For example, as depicted in the graphic of
[3090] That said, the atomic packing density and inversely, the membrane's porosity are both measures of a polymer's degree of crystallinity or lack thereof. The impact of atomic structural property affecting porosity is depicted phenomenologically in the schematic representation of a skeletally reinforced polymeric membrane shown in
[3091] Interstitially located with and among the random distribution of polymer strands, are naturally-occurring pores 6105 the size and shape of which is determined by the density of the polymer strands polymer A 6101a and polymer B 6101b. The closer and more tightly-packed these polymeric strands are, the smaller the average size of pore 6105 is. The more loosely the polymer backbones are packed, the larger the pores become.
[3092]
[3093] For contrast,
[3094] Another means by which to modulate the conductivity of an ionomeric membrane is shown in
[3095]
Polymer Chemistries.
[3096] Various constructions of IEMs along with exemplary polymers are listed in
[3097] Abbreviations used in
[3098] Examples of hydrocarbon homopolymers shown in
[3099] Other homopolymers as shown in
[3100]
[3101] As depicted, the ionomer may constitute a sulfonic acid group of SO.sub.3.sup. or may be substituted by other acids such as phosphonic or phosphotungstic acid. The ionomeric membranes as fabricated herein may contain a combination of hetero-ionomers, copolymers, micropores, permanent fillers, ionic liquids, and/or ionomeric dopants.
[3102] Di-monomer ion exchange membranes made in accordance with this invention comprise two classes of polymersfluorocarbons and hydrocarbons. Because the polymer backbone is essentially identical for the two segments except that one attaches to a pendant and the other doesn't then such polymers may be referred to as a hybrid polymer but generally not as a copolymer. Whether they are referred to as heteropolymers is a matter of opinion as the spine of the polymer is essentially unaltered but the segment is in fact different because of its attached sidechain and ionomer terminus.
[3103] Several fluorocarbon di-monomer membranes are illustrated in
[3104] Other di-monomer fluorocarbon membranes with sulfonic acid ionomers include glassy matrices of poly(perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane) (PFMMD) 6221 and perfluoro-dimethyl-dioxole (PDD) 6222. A related polymer with the same TFE-PTFE polymer backbone is perfluoro imide acid (PFIA) 6223, where the fluorocarbon sidechain is replaced by an MASC, a multi-acid side chain of length y. The ionomeric membranes as fabricated herein may contain a combination of hetero-ionomers, copolymers, micropores, permanent fillers, ionic liquids, and/or ionomeric dopants.
[3105] As shown in
[3106] In the segment of length n the ionomer is attached to the mainchain as an ionone, while in the other segment the ionomer is attached to a sidechain. As depicted, the ionomers may constitute a sulfonic acid group of SO.sub.3 or may be substituted by other acids such as phosphonic acid. The ionomeric membranes as fabricated herein may contain a combination of hetero-ionomers, copolymers, micropores, permanent fillers, ionic liquids, and/or ionomeric dopants.
[3107] Made in accordance with this invention, hydrocarbon di-monomer copolymers shown in
[3108] Other highly asymmetric di-monomer copolymers include sulfonated polyimide (sPI) 6240 and sulfonated poly(fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile) (sPFEKN) 6241 in
[3109]
[3110] Another ionomer 6255 shown in
[3111]
[3112]
[3113]
[3114]
[3115]
[3116]
[3117] Other PVDF copolymers are represented in
[3118] Fluorocarbon compounds may also form copolymers and grafted copolymers made in accordance with this invention as depicted in
[3119] Other ionomeric polymers made in accordance with this invention as depicted in
Ionomer Electrochemistry.
[3120] The ionic group functioning as an electrically active site or electrochemically functional group in a polymer is commonly referred to an ionomer. Ionomers perform numerous tasks in polymer chemistry, especially in polymer membranes. Made in accordance with this invention, various roles of ionomers include performing and optimizing catalysis of chemical reactions, selectively filtering impurities and contaminants passing through ionomeric membranes, or engaging in ionic conduction. All of these functions are important in hydrogen-based energy production systems and operation.
[3121] Catalytic applications of ionomers include product manufacturing of fibers and materials, e.g. in membrane fabrication, or in a fuel cell by accelerating electrochemical activity otherwise too slow or thermodynamically unfavorable to be useful. For example, catalytic functions of an ionomer are valuable in efficiently promoting the formation or breaking of hydrogen bonds in hydronium ions, a key component of vehicular charge transport in the aqueous electrochemistry of fuel cells and water-to-hydrogen electrolysis. Other ionomeric functions described herein include the process of accelerating the rate of oxygen reduction reactions (ORR) at the interface between a cathode catalyst layer in a hydrogen or direct methanol fuel cell and to help prevent catalyst poisoning.
[3122] In high selectivity filtering applications needed as water pretreatment for water-to-hydrogen electrolysis, ionomers made in accordance with this invention can be used to enhance water desalination, wastewater treatment and recycling, water purification, and deionization. Using smaller pore sizes, the fabricated ionomeric membranes can also be used in scrubbers and air filters to protect fuel cell catalysts and membranes against air impurities and toxins able to damage catalyst metals and ionomeric groups. In comparison to conventional filters, the presence of the ionomers in a membrane electrochemically enhances attraction of charged impurities and polar molecules to the filter and enhances their retention after capture. The same purification technology is also adaptable to kidney electrodialysis.
[3123] In electrochemical device applications such as fuel cells and electrolyzers, the ionomer is the primary component of electrical conduction within an ion exchange membrane, the conductivity of which is determined by an ionomer's chemical composition, hydrophilicity, concentration, and attachment onto the membrane's polymeric matrix. An ionomer is by definition a ionized functional group fixed onto a polymer spine or lattice able to bond to and release ions.
[3124] In the case of a proton exchange membrane (PEM), the ionomer comprises a neutral acid bonded onto the polymer. In the presence of an aqueous solution, the acid loses a proton into solution leaving a negatively changed ion behind. As such, the ionomer in a PEM membrane comprises an immobile anion, a negatively charged ion able to attract, bond to, and release positively charged protons. The role of an immobile anion in a PEM is somewhat confusing because mobile anions act as negative charge carriers in IL doped AEM membranes. In a PEM however, the anion functions in charge transport of mobile cations, typically protons comprising ionized hydrogen (H.sup.+) or other positively charged ionized molecules.
[3125] In the case of a anion exchange membrane (AEM), the ionomer comprises a neutral base bonded onto the polymer. In the presence of an aqueous solution, the base gains a proton from solution creating a positively charge protonated immobile ion. As such, the ionomer in a AEM membrane comprises an immobile cation, a positively charged ion able to attract, bond to, and release negatively charged radicals such hydroxide ions (OH). The role of an immobile cation in an AEM is somewhat confusing because mobile cations act as positive charge carriers in IL doped PEM membranes. In a AEM however, the anion functions in charge transport of mobile cations, typically protons comprising ionized hydrogen (H.sup.+).
[3126] So while a mobile cation in a PEM transports positive charge an immobile cation forms the ionomer in a AEM fuel cell. Conversely, while a mobile anion in an AEM transports negative charge an immobile anion forms the ionomer in a PEM fuel cell. In other words, an inventive PEM membrane made in accordance with this invention comprises an inert polymer with an immobile anion ionomer optionally enhanced by cations from ionic liquid doping. Likewise, inventive AEM membrane made in accordance with this invention comprises an inert polymer with an attached immobile cation ionomer optionally enhanced by anions supplied by ionic liquid doping.
[3127] Ionomers can be attached onto a polymer backbone by two meanseither as an ionone, a functional group bonded on-chain, i.e. within the polymer's spine; or as part of a pendant where the ionomer is attached at the terminus of a side chain bonded onto the polymer spine. In ionones where the ionomer is embedded within the polymeric backbone or with a cyclic ring such as a phenyl group, the challenge is that hydrophobic molecules in the polymer backbone can repel both water and hydronium needed to transport protons to and from the ionomer.
[3128] Accordingly, the polymeric chain's proximity to the ionomer impedes ion exchange thereby limiting conduction. This consideration is particularly an important factor when an ionomer's primary charge transport involves hopping conduction, i.e. the Grotthuss mechanism and when the main polymer is hydrophobic such as PTFE.
[3129] In such instances, performance of the film can be enhanced by instead attaching the ionomer to the terminus of a sidechain, the length of which may vary depending on how hydrophobic the main polymer is. Pendant attached ionomers thereby provide a greater degree of freedom in membrane design and ionomer performance but may reduce the structural durability of a film, especially for very long sidechains.
[3130] In proton exchange membranes, acidic groups attach themselves to the polymeric membrane during molding forming immobile functional groups, i.e. ionomers. These ionomers enable ion conduction in the film, remaining permanently affixed onto the polymer matrix throughout the use life of the membrane. The ionomers attach either as ionones onto the main chain or cyclic rings, or alternatively as termini of sidechain pendants. Without the presence of these ionomers, the undoped pristine membrane is non-conductive, essentially comprising an insulating or semi-insulating dielectric film.
[3131] The function of these immobile acids in a PEM membrane is to (i) attach to the spine of the membrane polymer either through a covalent bond, grafted sidechain, or in some cases via a hydrogen bond; (ii) participate in charge transport in the membrane by bonding to and releasing protons or other mobile cations traversing the conducting polymeric matrix; (iii) contribute to membrane conduction through a combination of hopping conduction of protons and vehicular transport of mobile hydronium cations; (iv) facilitate conduction via a combination of diffusion current and drift currents depending respectively on proton concentration gradients and electric fields present within and across the membrane; and (v) control hydration and membrane water concentrations consistent with membrane current densities for varying temperatures and relative humidity levels.
[3132] Together with the base polymer, sidechains and their ionomers may also influence certain material IEM film properties such as porosity, fuel crossover, hydrostatic swelling, film flexibility, mechanical strength, durability, coefficient of temperature expansion (CTE), temperature cycle life, humidity cycle life, resilience to corrosive chemicals, and immunity against environmental toxins such as carbon monoxide.
[3133] As described previously, these membrane-attached acids function as ionomers participating in PEM conduction by first releasing a hydrogen ion turning the neutral acid into an immobile anion then subsequently capturing free hydrogen (H.sup.+) ions or proton from hydronium ions before repeating the process. Numerous conduction paths exist in an ionomeric proton exchange membrane including proton capture (deprotonation) and release (protonation, ionization). Proton capture includes transfer from the anode catalyst layer to an ionomer, ionomer capture of free protons from solution, ionomer extraction of protons from hydronium ions, transfer of protons from other ionomers, and as applicable transfer of protons from ionic liquid mobile cations [IL.sub.c].sup.+.
[3134] The release of protons from an ionomer includes release of a free hydrogen ions into solution, proton transfer to another ionomer, proton transfer into water forming hydronium, proton transfer to an ionic liquid, or proton transfer to the cathode catalyst layer finalizing in an oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) combining protons and oxygen into water. The rate of these various processes depends on the concentration of ionomers, hydration levels, solution pH, ambient conditions, and the fraction of ionomers comprising protonated acids and deprotonated immobile anions.
[3135] In anion exchange membranes the isomeric groups act as bases rather than acids, releasing anions such as hydroxide radicals (OH) into solution thereby converting basic ionomers into immobile cations before capturing another hydroxide radical (OH) returning the ionomer back into a neutral base. As the dual process of a proton exchange membrane, the release of hydroxide from an ionomer in a AEM may be considered as gaining a positive charge, i.e. protonation. Conversely recapturing a hydroxide radical (OH) may be considered as eliminating positive charge, vis-h-vis deprotonation.
[3136] Ironically, water also participates in the vehicular transport of hydroxide in solution. In accordance with the principal of charge neutrality, In the autoionization of water, a proton is transferred from one water molecule to another thereby splitting water into a protonated hydronium cation [H.sub.3O].sup.+ and a hydroxide [OH].sup. anion, i.e. where 2H.sub.2O[H.sub.3O].sup.+ [OH].sup.. Although proton ion exchange membranes generally outperform AEMs because hydrogen is more mobile than hydroxide, anion exchange membrane offer cost advantages by avoiding a heavy reliance on expensive noble metals like platinum and palladium as catalysts.
[3137] The inventions described herein including micropores using sacrificial fillers, the inclusion of permanent fillers into a membrane, hetero-ionomers, and endoskeletal support are all equally compatible with anion exchange membranes as they are with proton exchange membranes.
Ionomer Ionization.
[3138] As described, IEM fuel cells may either be cationic or anionic depending on whether the ionomers are able to transport positive or negatively charged ions. Necessarily the ionomers in an IEM must be opposite in polarity of the charges they conduct. For an anion exchange membrane (AEM), the charge carriers transported through the matrix are mobile negatively-charged anions such as OH radicals. Accordingly, the ionomeric groups in the AEM necessarily comprise positively-charged cations in order to contribute to conduction, vis-h-vis an anionic IEM contains mobile anions as charge carriers and immobile cation ionomers supporting charge hopping conduction therein.
[3139] Conversely in proton exchange membrane (PEM), the charge carriers transported through the matrix are mobile positively-charged cations such as ionized hydrogen H.sup.+ and H.sub.3O.sup.+ hydronium ions, both of which manifest a net positive charge by an excess of protons. In order to participate in charge hopping conduction of cations, the ionomeric groups forming a PEM must contain immobile anion ionomers. In other words, a PEM membrane contains mobile charges of H.sup.+ ionized hydrogen and H.sub.3O.sup.+ hydronium ions combined with deprotonated acids comprising immobile anion ionomers.
[3140] The construction of cationic fuel cell comprises a proton exchange membrane (PEM) separating an anode and cathode regions. In PEMFC operation (i) hydrogen gas or methanol is supplied to the anode as fuel where the excess unspent hydrogen is recirculated; (ii) catalysts rip electrons from protons of the incoming fuel; (iii) the released protons travel across the ionomeric polymer electrolyte able to conduct cations but preventing electron conduction; and (iv) upon entering the cathode, the protons recombine with electrons and oxygen supplied to the cathode to form water. The water is mostly removed from the cathode as effluent along with any unused oxygen or air. In a hydrogen fuel cell the only reaction byproduct is water. In a direct methanol fuel cell, however the process of ionizing methanol releases a small amount of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO.sub.2) which appears as waste gas in the hydrogen regress.
[3141] Some of the generated water formed in the cathode back diffuses into the membrane forming an aqueous solution of mobile hydrogen ions and hydronium ions. The polymeric matrix includes un-ionized electrically neutral acids and immobile anionic ionomers, both attached to the polymeric backbone or sidechains. During steady state operation with a constant supply of fuel and a constant electrical load, fuel cell operation is governed by an electrochemical reaction where the relative concentrations of free and immobile ions within the PEM electrolyte are in equilibrium governed by fundamental physical laws of conservation of charge and conservation of mass.
[3142] Specifically the mass of the fuel and oxygen influxes must equal the mass of the water effluent less the water remaining in the membrane film. Conservation of mass may be considered as a special case of the general law what goes in must come out except for what stays there. Conservation of charge, the principle that the total electric charge in an isolated system never changes. In the context of a fuel cell, charge conservation means charge entering the fuel cell must balance charges contained within the cell less those removed.
[3143] Consider a polymeric matrix containing membrane-bound acids having the generic chemical composition (A.sup.)H.sup.+ where H.sup.+ represents a hydrogen ion and (A.sup.) represents an immobile anion or in alternate notation [AH].sup.0 referring to a neutral acid. The superscript is included to highlight the fact that the un-ionized acid has zero net charge, Mechanistically, in an aqueous solution, i.e. when the polymeric membrane is hydrated, some fraction of the immobile acids become ionized by losing a proton into solution, a mechanism referred to as deprotonation. When the acid groups are deprotonated they assume a net negative charge state forming an anion. Because of their ability to attract, attach to, and subsequently release protons from solution, the deprotonated acid groups form ionomers.
[3144] The population of ionized and deionized acids in an IEM membrane are not static but vary with current conduction, temperature, and humidity as well as by the composition of the membrane. In steady state operation, at any given moment some ionomers are losing protons while other ionomers are gaining protons. Starting with a charge neutral membrane comprising m some portion n of the acids will spontaneously ionize into ionomers, whereby the quality of un-ionized acids is given as (mn). In terms of charge balancing, this mechanism can be written by the bidirectional reaction
##STR00010##
where n represents the number of acid groups ionized into ionomers and (mn) describes the portion of functional groups remaining as charge neutral acids. The ratio =[n/m] can be interpreted as the ionization constant of acid molecules converting from neutral acids into electrically active immobile anionic ionomers and mobile cations of hydrogen. Another term for this constant is DPP, an acronym for the degree of deprotonation. Substituting the ionization constant (mn)=(mm)=m(1) in which case the equation becomes
##STR00011##
[3145] Defining the concentrations [AH.sup.0]m(AH) and [A.sup.]m(A.sup.) having units of either mol/L, mol/cm.sup.3, or charge/cm.sup.3, then the reaction equation simplifies into concentration-based formula
##STR00012##
[3146] The degree of deprotonation is a function of the type of acid and hydration of the membrane. At room temperature [AH].sup.0 will spontaneously split into ionized anion [A.sup.] and hydrogen [H.sup.+] components, in accordance with the equilibrium reaction [AH.sup.0][A.sup.]+[H.sup.+]. In the presence of water, however, ionized hydrogen [H.sup.+] combines with water [H.sub.2O] to form hydronium ions [H.sub.3O+] by the reaction [H.sup.+].sup.+[H.sub.2O].fwdarw.[H.sub.3O.sup.+] with virtually no hydrogen existing as free protons. In such case, the acid dissociation equation can be expressed as [AH.sup.0]+[H.sub.2O][A.sup.]+[H.sub.3O.sup.+] where all three solutes are mobile in a solvent of water.
[3147] It should be mentioned in the lexicography of ionic liquids, it is common to write the ionic valency for mobile cations and anions outside the brackets such as [AH].sup.0 and [A].sup. while for ionomeric membranes, inclusion of the charge state inside the bracket is more common. Although there is no fundamental difference in meaning, this application adopts the same conventions to be more easily cross-checked against published literature in the art.
[3148] The measure of ionization of an acid in solution, i.e. a liquid acid, is thereby determined by its K.sub.a valuethe multiplicative product of the ionized anion [A.sup.] and hydrogen [H.sup.+] concentrations divided the concentration of the un-ionized neutral acid [AH].sup.+, as given by the relation
For convenience the value can be re-expressed logarithmically as the constant pK.sub.a whereby
Solving for Ka as a function of pK.sub.a gives yield the insightful relation
This relation means shows the more negative a pK.sub.a value is, the greater the Ka value is meaning the number of anions and cations are significantly greater than remaining neutral acid groups. For example in the case of sulfonic acid pK.sub.a varies from 2 to +1, with corresponding Ka values of 100 to 14 0.1 times that of the unionized acids respectively, or as fraction of total solutes 99% to 9% ionized. At pK.sub.a=0, the numerator and denominator are equal meaning only 50% of the acid groups are ionized.
[3149] Typically Nafion and related PFSA ionomers reportedly K.sub.a=0.176 meaning roughly =15% of the acid groups ionize into anions, whereby 85% of the acid groups remain un-ionized outnumbering the ions by a factor of 5.6-to-1. This pK.sub.a corresponds to a pK.sub.a=0.754. By contrast, phosphonic is a weaker acid than sulfonium where pK.sub.a=1.3 for the first dissociation and therefore K.sub.a=0.05 meaning the neutral acid groups outnumber the ionized groups 20-to-1, meaning only 4.8% of the acid groups are ionized. A list of acids used in accordance with this invention to form ionomeric membranes are described here below. The list is exemplary but not intended to be limiting or exhaustive.
[3150] In accordance with this invention, acids with pK.sub.a values below 1.5 and ionization constants >95% as denoted by a single asterisk (*) are considered very strong acids and should not be used in ion exchange membranes except in very dilute concentrations as they can degrade the structural integrity of the polymer. Chlorinated acids such as perchloric acid, chlorosulfonic acid, and hydrochloric acid are altogether avoided as they are very corrosive, degrading the catalyst metal atoms and damaging the fuel cell assembly. Despite its relatively high pK.sub.a value of 3.17, hydrofluoric acid denoted by ** is extremely corrosive and biologically dangerous as it disintegrates skeletal bone.
[3151] As such, HF is altogether avoided in the inventive membranes at any concentration. Referring to the table again, aqueous sulfonic acid and amide conjugate acid vary widely in pK.sub.a values from 2-to-0 depending on the specific acid moiety. The more useful range for ionomeric applications includes pK.sub.a values from 0.5 to +1.5 include trifluoroethyl (TFE) bound sulfonic acid ionomers referred to PFSA-SO.sub.3H such as those in Nafion and related fluorocarbon films with its pK.sub.a=+0.754 corresponding to a 15% ionization level. As shown, other IEMs made in accordance with this invention include membrane-bound acids with between 15% and 3% ionization constants including sulfamic acid (H.sub.3NSO.sub.3), the first dissociation of phosphonic acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.3), the first dissociation of sulfosuccinic acid (C.sub.4H.sub.6O.sub.7S), and diethylphosphate DEP (C.sub.4H.sub.10O.sub.4P). It also includes various weaker moieties of aqueous sulfonic acid and amide conjugate acids.
TABLE-US-00070 Acid pK.sub.a Acid dissoc K.sub.a Ionized trifluoromethanesulfonic acid 14 10.sup.14.sup. 100% (triflate, CF.sub.3SO.sub.3H)* perchloric acid (HClO.sub.4)* 10 10.sup.10.sup. 100% hydroiodic acid (HI)* 10 10.sup.10.sup. 100% hydrobromic acid (HBr)* 9 10.sup.9.sup. 100% chlorosulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3Cl) 6 10.sup.6.sup. 100% hydrochloric acid (HCl)* 6 10.sup.6.sup. 100% sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4), 1.sup.st dissoc * 3 10.sup.3.sup. 99.9% nitric acid (HNO.sub.3)* 1.4 25.1 96.2% sulfonic acid, solute (RSO.sub.3H) 2 to 0 100-1 99%-50% amide conjugate acid (CONH) 1 to 0.5 10-3.2 91%-76% sulfonic acid ionomer (PFSA-SO.sub.3H) +0.754 0.176 15% sulfamic acid (H.sub.3NSO.sub.3) +1 0.10 9.1% phosphonic acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.3), 1.sup.st dissoc +1.3 0.050 4.8% sulfosuccinic acid (C.sub.4H.sub.6O.sub.7S), 1.sup.st dissoc +1.5 0.032 3.1% diethylphosphate (DEP) +1.5 0.032 3.1% phosphoric acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.4), 1.sup.st dissoc +2.15 0.0071 0.70% pyruvic acid (C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.3) +2.49 0.0032 0.32% phosphotungstic acid (H.sub.3[P(W.sub.3O.sub.10).sub.4]) +3.1 0.00079 0.079% citric acid (C.sub.6H.sub.8O.sub.7), 1.sup.st dissoc +3.1 0.00079 0.079% hydrofluoric acid (HF) ** +3.17 0.00068 0.068% glycolic acid (C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.3) +3.83 0.00015 0.015% carboxylic acid (R-COOH) +4 to +5 0.0001-10 ppm 0.01%-10 ppm acetic acid (AA) +4.76 17.3 ppm 17.3 ppm butyric acid (C.sub.3H.sub.7COOH) +4.82 15.1 ppm 15.1 ppm phenol, phenyl hydroxide (C.sub.6H.sub.5OH) +10 0.1 ppb 0/1 ppb ethyl lactate (C.sub.5H.sub.10O.sub.3) +14.2 6.3 10.sup.15 6.3 10.sup.15
[3152] Acids ionized between 1% and 0.1% still can function individually as ionomers or in hetero-ionomer proton exchange membranes described herein. They include the first dissociation of phosphoric acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.4) or pyruvic acid (C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.3). Acids with ionization fractions between 0.1% and 0.05%. i.e. with pK.sub.a values of around +3.1 such as phosphotungstic acid (H.sub.3[P(W.sub.3O.sub.10).sub.4]) and the first dissociation of citric acid (C.sub.6H.sub.8O.sub.7) while not effective as membrane-bound ionomers, can be used to form crystalline structures of PWA or CA. As described previously in this application, these ionomeric crystals when added into a membrane as a permanent filler enhance film conductivity without affecting pH, ionomer ionization constants, or membrane integrity.
[3153] Finally, any acid or conjugate base with pK.sub.a>+3.5 and ionization constants <0.02% are not effective in providing meaningful charge transport but can be used as a chemical buffer to regulate pH and swelling in the PEM despite changing levels of ambient humidity and conducted current impact film hydration. A blend of a conjugate acid and a weak base (or conversely a mix of a weak acid and its conjugate base forms a buffer solution, resisting pH change in response to limited additions of a strong acid or a strong base.
[3154] Made in accordance with this invention, an ion exchange membrane may comprise a polymer containing moderately ionized acid species with pK.sub.a values between 0 and +3.5 including sulfonic acid, sulfamic acid, phosphonic acid, sulfosuccinic acid, diethylphosphate, phosphoric acid, pyruvic acid, phosphotungstic acid, citric acid, and dilute forms of amide conjugate acids. These acids may be used singularly or in combination to form [3155] membrane-bound acids as homo-ionomers; [3156] two-or-more membrane as hetero-ionomers; [3157] membrane-bound acids combined with dilute free acid radicals functioning as buffers against pH variation; [3158] membrane-bound acids combined with dilute free acid radicals, i.e. ionic liquid dopants; and [3159] membrane-bound acids as homo-ionomers, combined with crystalized acids or fillers such as PMMA, MOFs, DSSQs, etc. containing ionomeric acid groups as permanent membrane fillers.
[3160] As described previously, extremely strong acids having very negative pK.sub.a values, i.e. below pK.sub.a2, are not recommended except when used in extremely dilute concentrations as they can degrade polymer integrity and shorten film lifetime. Chlorinated acids are to be avoided altogether for corrosion complications. Hydrofluoric acid are not be used for health concerns to humans and to the biosphere.
[3161] In accordance with this invention, the distinction among ionomers, ionomeric fillers, and ionic liquids, and buffers as applied in the ion exchange membranes described herein is essentially defined by carrier mobility. In an IEM, an ionomer is an acid bound to the polymeric backbone which becomes ionized to form an immobile cation or anion able to support hopping conduction. Specifically in a PEM, the acid donates a mobile proton into solution through an ionization process of deprotonation leaving behind an immobile anion. Conversely in a IEM, the acid absorbs a mobile proton from solution or releases a hydroxide group as a solute through an ionization process of protonation forming an immobile cation.
[3162] An ionomeric filler is nearly the same except the acid is a functional group attached to a crystal or atomic structure, e.g. a phosphotungstic crystal or functionalize metal organic framework (MOF), whose structure is sufficiently large to lock the host molecule in place with the polymer's molecular matrix even though it is not necessarily chemically-bound or grafted onto the polymer itself. The resulting ionomeric groups introduced during casting or molding thereby represent permanent ionomeric fillers within the membrane.
[3163] Ionic liquids and buffers by contrast are diffuse fluids within the polymer's atomic matrix introduced during the membrane's manufacturing process. Specifically, ionic liquid doping comprises a permanent filler of an organic salt that melts into mobile cations and anions at room temperature to provide additional charge carriers not associated with immobile ionomers. Buffers include either a mixture of a weak acid and its conjugate base or conversely a weak base and its conjugate acid designed to regulate pH and impede chemical degradation and structural damage to the membrane polymer and its endoskeletal support.
[3164] Made in accordance with this invention these liquid fillers are constrained by the endoskeleton from leaking out the sides of the membrane by the inert insoluble composition of the pillars such as plastic or PTFE forming the skeleton. An added feature to prevent lateral leakage is the wider exoskeletal frame that circumscribes the outer edge of every singulated membrane, providing added structural support impervious to acids and ions. In this invention, ionic liquid or buffer leakage in a direction perpendicular to the membrane is prevented through containment provided by the CCM's heterogenous catalyst layer comprising a combination of catalyst metals, carbon, PTFE nanoparticles, and other fillers such as boron nitride, MOFs, zeolites, crystals, and organic fillers.
Film Hydration and Conductivity.
[3165] The electrochemical reaction to synthesize a proton exchange membrane (PEM) comprises forming a polymeric backbone attached to sidechains and acid termini spontaneously ionizing to form anionic ionomers. To determine the molecular concentration N.sub.PFSA for an ionomeric polymer such as Nafion, we can use the definition:
where N.sub.PFSA is the PFSA molecular concentration in moles per liter (mol/L) or moles per cubic centimeter (mol/cm.sup.3), is material density in g/cm.sup.3, and EW is the ionomer's equivalent weightthe mass of the polymer in grams that contains one mole of ionomeric acid groups. Using Avogadro's number, N.sub.A=6.02210.sup.23 molecules/mol, moles can be converted into the number of molecules. The chemical and atomic compositions for three different PFSA ionomeric films are described and compared in the following table, namely Nafion 1100, 3M (729), and Aquivion 720.
[3166] As listed, for Nafion 1100 or similar long sidechain PFSA ionomers the dry molecular gravimetric density is =1.95 g/cm.sup.3 and the EW=1100 g/mol producing a molar concentration N.sub.PFS A=(1.95 g/cm.sup.3)/(1100 g/mol)=0.001772 mol/cm.sup.3=1.178 mol/L. Using Avogadro's number, N.sub.A=6.02210.sup.23 molecules/mol, the molecular concentration of PFSA is (N.sub.PFSA)(N.sub.A)=(0.00178 mol/cm.sup.3)(6.02210.sup.23 molecules/mol)=1.07110.sup.21 PFSA groups/cm.sup.3. Since each Nafion multi-segment string contains one sulfonic acid group, the number of sulfonic acid groups per cm.sup.3 volume is the same as the number of Nafion molecules per cm.sup.3. In m=6.6 backbones, one TFE segment with an attached pendant is accompanied by 6.6 inert PTFE segments, making the film 13% hydrophilic.
[3167] For Aquivion 720 or similar short sidechain PFSA ionomers, the dry molecular density is =1.93 g/cm.sup.3 and the EW=720 g/mol. Calculating M.sub.PFSA=(1.93 g/cm.sup.3)/(720 g/mol)=0.002681 mol/cm.sup.3=2.681 mol/L. Using Avogadro's number, N.sub.A=6.02210.sup.23 molecules/mol, the molecular density of PFSA is M(N.sub.A)=(0.002681 mol/cm.sup.3)(6.02210.sup.23 molecules/mol)=1.61410.sup.21 PFSA groups/cm.sup.3.
[3168] In contrast to its molecular concentration, the actual atomic composition of long sidechain Nafion 1100 with m=6.6 comprises 20 atoms of carbon (C), 39 atoms of fluorine (F), 5 atoms of oxygen (O), 1 atom of sulfur (S) totaling 65 atoms of varying mass not counting the sulfonic acid ionomer's hydrogen ion. Given the molecular density of 1.07110.sup.21 PFSA groups/cm.sup.3, this means the atomic concentration of PFSA such as Nafion 1100 can be found by multiplying the 65 atoms/PFSA molecule by the molecular density of PFSA at 1.07110.sup.21 molecules/cm.sup.3 resulting in an atomic density of 6.9610.sup.22 atoms/cm.sup.3.
[3169] Short sidechain PFSA molecules such as 3M (729) and Aquivion 720 have lower equivalent weights than Nafion 1100, roughly EW7255 resulting in molar ionic densities of 2.7 mol/L or molecular concentrations of approximately 1.610.sup.21 PFSA/cm.sup.3, roughly 50% greater than the ionic density long-sidechain Nafion. This higher ionomer concentration means short sidechain PFSA molecules offer higher conductivity but at the expense of greater water absorption and swelling, with adverse consequences for use life. With 3.5m4.4 roughly one TFE spinal segment out of five include an attached hydrophilic sidechain. The remaining segments comprise hydrophobic PTFE.
[3170] Given the molecular density of 1.07110.sup.21 PFSA groups/cm.sup.3, this means the atomic concentration of short sidechain PFSA can be found by multiplying the 43 atoms/PFSA molecule by the molecular density of PFSA resulting in an atomic density of 6.910.sup.22 atoms/cm.sup.3, almost identical long sidechain PFSA. Despite having similar atomic densities by weight or by atomic number, short sidechain PFSA contains 50% more ionomers resulting in enhanced conductivity.
[3171] Somewhat surprisingly however, at 6.910.sup.22 cm.sup.3, PFSA has a higher atomic density than single crystal silicon at 5.010.sup.22 cm.sup.3. Moreover, at 1-to-1.510.sup.21 ionomers/cm.sup.3 PFSA contains 100 more conducting ionomers than dopant atoms in heavily doped P-type silicon at 410.sup.19 B/cm.sup.3. Although silicon comprises a regularly patterned ultra-pure matrix of atoms arranged in a diamond crustal lattice and interrupted infrequently by boron dopant atoms, by contrast, PFSA comprises a quasi-amorphous quasi-crystalline structure.
TABLE-US-00071 PFSA Nafion 3M Aquivion Membrane 1100 (729) 720 Units sidechain type long (LSC) short (SSC) short (SSC) equivalent 1100 729 720 g/eq weight EW total acid 0.91 1.37 1.39 meq/g capacity TAC atomic density 1.98 1.93 1.93 g/cm.sup.3 molar ionic 1.178 2.65 2.681 mol/L density N.sub.ion molecular 1.071 10.sup.21 1.594 10.sup.21 1.614 10.sup.21 PFSA/cm ionic density N.sub.ion atomic density 6.96 10.sup.22 6.85 10.sup.22 6.85 10.sup.22 atoms/cm.sup.3 N.sub.PFSA repeats m 6.6 3.5 4.4 groups carbon C 7 + 13 = 20 6 + 7 = 13 4 + 9 = 13 atoms fluorine F 13 + 26 = 39 11 + 14 = 25 7 + 18 = 25 atoms oxygen O 5 4 4 atoms sulfur S 1 1 1 atoms total atomic 65 43 43 atoms number
[3172] Comparing PFSA to silicon also provides some useful insight explaining film conductivity, the major difference being the influence of hydration and ambient humidity of conductivity. Because of the closed structure of semiconductor crystals, water is unable to penetrate the atomic matrix and therefore uninfluential in the material conductive properties. By contrast, the porosity of many ionomeric polymers, especially PFSA, easily accommodate the absorption of water into its atomic matrix either from ambient humidity or from the cathodic catalyst-membrane interface. To include the role of water in ionomeric conduction, the electrochemical reaction equation is modified to
##STR00013##
where the hydration factor also known as water uptake is defined as the ratio of water concentration [H.sub.2O] where
Verified experimentally for a wide spectrum of aqueous ion exchange membranes, interstitial water content directly affects the quantity [A.sup.] of ionized acid groups. The role of water is especially significant at low levels of hydration but then diminishes asymptotically at higher hydration levels as modelled using the empirical form
where the hydration fitting parameter .sub.H2O=14.
[3173] The following table exemplifies the profound influence of hydration of PFSA ionomer conduction properties. Specifically, the hydration factor describes the ratio of interstitial membrane water molecules to sulfonic acid groups. The ionization constant =f() describes the fraction of acid groups ionized. The ion concentration [A.sup.] thereby describes the concentration of ionized acid groups per unit volume deprotonated into immobile anions.
TABLE-US-00072 Relative Relative Ion Hydration Ionization Humidity Humidity Concentration (%) (%) RH.sub.25 C. (%) RH.sub.80 C. (%) [A.sup.] (q/cm.sup.3) 1.55 10 38 51 1.0685 10.sup.20 2.47 15 50 62 1.8075 10.sup.20 3.50 20 58 70 2.1438 10.sup.20 6.00 30 71 80 3.2157 10.sup.20 9.33 40 79 86 4.2877 10.sup.20 14.0 50 85 90 5.3596 10.sup.20 21 60 89 93 6.4315 10.sup.20 33 70 93 96 7.5262 10.sup.20 56 80 96 97 8.5753 10.sup.20 126 90 98 99 9.6472 10.sup.20 100 100 100 1.0719 10.sup.21
[3174] 1 As modelled, the ionization constant and the concentration of deprotonated ionomers [A.sup.] do not exhibit a linear dependence on hydration factor For example, at =6, roughly 30% of the acid groups are ionized and at =14 over half are. Estimates of the relative humidity at 25 C. and 80 C. as listed are based on the relation =(TC.Math.RH)/(1RH) where TC is a temperature coefficient and RH is the relative humidity. From the aforementioned analysis, the activation of sulfonic acid groups in PFSA at %=15% means the carrier concentration is roughly (N.sub.PFSA(N.sub.A))=0.15(1.071910.sup.21 PFSA groups/cm.sup.3)=1.8110.sup.20 active ionomers/cm.sup.3. At this activation, this deprotonated ionomer concentration represents approximately (1.8110.sup.20 cm.sup.3)/(6.9610.sup.22 cm.sup.3)=1.81/696=0.0026=0.26% of the atomic density, or roughly one part per 385 atoms. Some debate however remains as to what is the maximum percentage of ionomers that can be ionized.
[3175] For comparison's sake, the maximum boron acceptor concentration in degeneratively doped P-type silicon is approximately 410.sup.19 cm.sup.3, 0.08% of its atomic density despite nearly 100% the dopant atoms being ionized. This limitation in the maximum dopant concentration is due to the solid solubility of boron in silicon.
TABLE-US-00073 Density Atomic conc Humidity Hydration Ionization Conductivity variable: N.sub.atomic RH, 25 C. [A.sup.] (25 C.) units: Material g/cm.sup.3 atoms/cm.sup.3 % % % q/cm.sup.3 S/cm PFSA 1.98 6.96 10.sup.22 38 1.55 10 1.0685 10.sup.20 5 10.sup.3 Nafion 58 3.50 20 2.1438 10.sup.20 8 10.sup.3 1100 79 9.33 40 4.2877 10.sup.20 1.2 10.sup.2 89 21 60 6.4315 10.sup.20 1.3 10.sup.2 96 56 80 8.5753 10.sup.20 1.4 10.sup.2 100 100 1.0719 10.sup.21 1.45 10.sup.2 PFSA 1.93 6.85 10.sup.22 49 2.38 10 1.6139 10.sup.20 2 10.sup.2 Aquivion 68 5.35 20 3.2778 10.sup.20 5 10.sup.2 720 85 14 40 6.4556 10.sup.20 1 10.sup.1 93 32 60 9.6834 10.sup.20 1.3 10.sup.1 97 86 80 1.2911 10.sup.21 1.4 10.sup.1 100 100 1.6139 10.sup.21 1.5 10.sup.1 P-type Si 2.3 5.00 10.sup.22 NA NA 100 4.0 10.sup.19 350
[3176] Comparing PFSA to silicon, with only 15% to 20% of its acid groups ionized PFSA film contains a minimum of 1.8110.sup.20 cm.sup.3 conducting sites compared to that of silicon's 410.sup.19 cm.sup.3. Despite its lower carrier concentration, silicon is substantially more conductive than any ionomer.
[3177] One common measure of electrical conduction for any material is the conductivity parameter =J/E defining the relationship between current density JI/A and electric field E. As shown in the table, the conductivity of ionomeric polymers is generally less than 0.2 S/cm while heavily doped P-type silicon has a conductivity of 350 S/cm. Care should be taken not to confuse the SI standard MKS unit system of 20 S/m with the cgs system value 0.2 S/cm commonly employed in microelectronics and material science.
[3178] For example, the peak conductivity of long sidechain Nafion 1100 membranes is approximately =0.015 S/cm while short sidechain PFSA membranes such as Aquivion 720 exhibit values of =0.15 S/cm, an order-of-magnitude more conductive. This means P-type silicon has conductance advantages of over long and short sidechain PFSA of 17,500 and 1,750 respectively. The higher conductivity of the short sidechain PFSA over LSC PFSA cannot be explained by ionomer density, accounting for at most roughly 1100/720=1.53 or only 53% better conduction. Instead, the role of water must be considered in charge transport. Again, further insight can be obtained by comparing PFSA to P-type silicon.
[3179] Using the definition of hole drift current J.sub.h=Q.sub.hv.sub.h where is the average drift velocity v.sub.h of a hole and where Q.sub.h is the total hole charge Q.sub.h=qN.sub.A where q is an elemental charge of a hole and Na is the number of acceptor dopant atoms. In classical electromagnetics, the electrostatic force F imposed on charge by an electric field E is given by F=QE. Equating the electrostatic force with Newton's law F=m*a where m* is the effective mass of the charge and the variable a is its acceleration, then Q.sub.hE=m*a or solving for acceleration =Q.sub.hE/m*. Carrier velocity, the average speed of positive charges Qn in an electric field is given by v.sub.h=a.sub.tt where .sub.tt is referred to by any number of names such as relaxation time, transit time, or collision time describing the average time a carrier requires to pass its energy on to another atom or molecule. Combining acceleration and velocity according to Newton's laws of motion, the resulting equality known as the drift transport equation becomes v.sub.h=a.sub.tt=(Q.sub.h.sub.tt/m*)E where the quantity .sub.h(Q.sub.h.sub.tt/m*) is defined as hole mobility. .sub.h.
[3180] Substituting mobility into the drift transport equation simplifies the relation for the average drift velocity of a hole to v.sub.h=.sub.hE. Combining the drift velocity v.sub.h expression with the drift current equation J.sub.h=Q.sub.hv.sub.h to eliminate carrier velocity yields the expression J.sub.h=Q.sub.h(.sub.hE). Given the aforementioned definition of hole charge Q.sub.h=qN.sub.A the expression becomes J.sub.h=Q.sub.hv.sub.h=(qN.sub.A)(.sub.hE)=(qN.sub.A.sub.h)E.
[3181] The parenthetical term is herein defined as conductivity =(qN.sub.A.sub.h) whereby J.sub.h=I/A=E. Given the definition of hole conductivity as =q.sub.hN.sub.A, conductance is proportional to the multiplicative product of hole mobility .sub.h, acceptor doping concentration N.sub.A, and the elemental charge of a hole q which is identical to the charge on an electron. Using empirical data for hole mobility for degeneratively doped silicon at .sub.h=55 cm.sup.2/Vs. Accordingly, conductivity a for degeneratively boron-doped P-type silicon is given by =q.sub.hN.sub.A=(1.610.sup.19 coul)(55 cm.sup.2/Vs)(410.sup.19 atoms/cm.sup.3)350 S/cm.
[3182] The transport and drift equations are not limited to hole conduction in P-type semiconductors but may be applied ionized molecules including hydrogen, where Q.sub.H+ denotes the quantity of ionized protons in a solid Q.sub.H+=(qN.sub.H+). In a PEM ionomeric membrane, the concentration N.sub.H+ is equivalent to the ionized acid groups resulting in immobile anions, whereby N.sub.H+=[A.sup.]. In such cases J.sub.H+=(Q.sub.H+)(.sub.H+E)=(qN.sub.H+)(.sub.H+E)=(qN.sub.H+.sub.H+)E. Defining hole conductivity as the parenthetical term =(qN.sub.H+.sub.H+) then J.sub.H+=I/A=E. Rearranging the conductivity equation as .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+), can be applied to empirically derive carrier mobility .sub.H+ of a proton exchange membrane from measured conductivity and calculated ionized acid concentration N.sub.H+=[A.sup.]. The only uncertainty is the ionization constant which is subject to empirical error.
[3183] Evaluated at a condition where =20%, i.e. where one-fifth of the sulfonic acid groups are ionized, then allowing for their different total acid capacity TAC and corresponding molar ionic concentration N.sub.ion, at =3.5 Nafion 1100 exhibits an ion density of [A.sup.]=2.143810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 with a conductivity =810.sup.3 S/cm. Applying the equation for effective mobility .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+) then Nafion has an effective mobility .sub.H+=(810.sup.3 S/cm)/((1.610.sup.19 coul)(2.143810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3))=0.000233 cm.sup.2/Vs or in scientific notation as .sub.H+=2.3310.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs.
[3184] Although hydration is required for fuel cell operation, excessive initial water can impair conduction. At =9.3, Nafion 1100 is at 40% ionization with [A.sup.]=4.287710.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 and =1.210.sup.2 S/cm corresponding to .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+)=1.7410.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs. At even greater membrane hydration where =56 Nafion, =1.410.sup.2 S/cm, and .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+)=1.0210.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs. The decline in mobility is largely due water logging impeding charge transport.
[3185] Similar calculations can be made using short sidechain PFSA membranes. Referring again to the table, at =5.35 and =20%, Aquivion 720 has an ion density [A.sup.]=3.277810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 with conductivity =510.sup.2 S/cm with corresponding mobility given by .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+)=(510.sup.2 S/cm)/((1.610.sup.19 coul)(3.277810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3))=0.000954 cm.sup.2/Vs or in scientific notation as .sub.H+=9.5410.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs. At =14, ion density and conductivity increase to [A.sup.]=6.455610.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 and =0.1 S/cm, whereby .sub.H+=/(qN.sub.H+)=0.000968 cm.sup.2/Vs=9.6810.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs. In this SSC PFSA, the higher level of hydration increases carrier concentrations by 6.46/3.28=1.97 without degrading mobility. At higher hydration levels however, even short-sidechain low-EW PFSA membranes show degraded mobilities.
[3186] In this direct comparison, carrier mobility, not carrier concentration, is largely responsible for conductance differences among silicon, SSC PFSA, and LSC PFSA films with mobilities in the magnitudes 10.sup.+1, 10.sup.1, and 10.sup.2 respectively. This large discrepancy cannot be explained by the mass difference between electrons and protons, but instead must be considered a consequence of effective mass. As derived previously, the effective mass of a charge is related to its mobility , charge q, and carrier transit time by the relation =Q.sub.tt/m* where m*, the effective mass of the transiting charge is inversely proportional to carrier mobility. Carrier mobility is the solid-state analog to mobility K for gasses defining a measure of friction linked the time .sub.tt ions take to traverse a defined cell length.
[3187] While distance is difficult to define in gaseous systems, in solid material the transit time .sub.h is more well defined by the average distance between ionomers. In particular the effective mass of a proton in a proton exchange membrane behaves as a larger mass to account for the stickiness of the ionomers such as sulfonic acid which during conduction must first capture the proton then subsequently release it again as a hydrogen ion. This process invariable loses energy making the effective mass of the proton in a the exchange process appear more massive than its rest mass.
[3188] That said, studies suggest that the effective mass of a hydrogen ion (m.sub.H+)* is generally considered to be within the same order-of-magnitude of the mass of free hydrogen ions m.sub.H+, i.e. within a factor-of-ten, but these are only guesstimates. If we consider the rest mass of a hydrogen atom to be m.sub.H+=1.672610.sup.24 grams, then a rough estimate for the effective proton mass (m.sub.H+)*110.sup.23 grams. Unfortunately, direct measurement of the effective mass of hydrogen in transit in a heterogenous ionomeric polymer is difficult and subject to numerous experimental errors. A more accurate and self consistent calculation, employed in this application for the first time, employs a ratiometric comparison of proton mobility .sub.H+ to hole mobility .sub.h.
[3189] Because silicon hole mobility and the effective mass of heavy holes, i.e. holes in heavily doped material, are precisely known experimental errors can be eliminated. Specifically the effective mass m.sub.h* of a heavy hole is approximately m.sub.h*=0.49m.sub.0 where m.sub.0=9.10910.sup.28 g is the mass of a free electron. The effective mass of a heavy hole measured in grams is therefore m.sub.h*=0.49m.sub.0=(0.49)(9.10910.sup.28 g)=4.46310.sup.28 g. The mobility of a hole in heavily doped material is approximately 55 cm.sup.2/Vs.
[3190] The mobility of long sidechain PFSA is 2.3310.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs, a factor 2.3610 s times less mobile than hole mobility of 55 cm.sup.2/Vs. As such, the effective mass of a proton in Nafion is m.sub.H+*=(2.3610.sup.5)m.sub.h*=(2.3610.sup.5)(4.46310.sup.28 g)=1.0510.sup.22 g. Compared to the rest mass of free hydrogen m.sub.H+=1.672610.sup.24 g, the effective mass of the LSC proton is given by m.sub.H+*=(1.0510.sup.22 g)/(1.672610.sup.24 g)=63(m.sub.H+), sixty-three times more massive than a free hydrogen ion.
[3191] By contrast mobility of short sidechain PFSA is 9.6810.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs, a factor of (55 cm.sup.2/Vs)/(9.6810.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs)=5.6810.sup.4 heavier than a heavy hole. As such, the effective mass of a proton in Aquivion is m.sub.H+*=(5.6810.sup.4)m.sub.h*=(5.6810.sup.4)(4.46310.sup.28 g)=2.5310.sup.23 g. Compared to the rest mass of free hydrogen atoms m.sub.H+=1.672610.sup.24 g, the effective mass of the LSC proton is given by m.sub.H+*=(2.5310.sup.23 g)/(1.672610.sup.24 g)=15(m.sub.H+), fifteen times heavier than a hole.
[3192] As the dominant mechanism of charge conduction in an ionomeric polymer is that of diffusion and not of drift, the diffusion constant for ion transport is a key factor in describing current flow. According to Einstein, the diffusivity of a charge carrier is inextricably linked to its mobility by the thermodynamic mechanism of Brownian motion and thermal vibration as quantified by the thermal voltage k.sub.BT/q according to the Einstein relation
where D is diffusivity, is carrier mobility, k.sub.B is Boltzmann's constant, T is temperature, q is the elemental charge of an proton or electron, and V.sub. is the thermal voltage equal to 25.69 mV at 25 C. and 82.21 mV at 80 C. Given proton mobility from above, proton diffusivity is found by evaluating the expression D.sub.H+=(.sub.H+)(V.sub.). For LSC at 25 C., D.sub.H+=(2.3310.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs)(0.02560 V)=6.010.sup.6 cm.sup.2/s while at 80 C., proton diffusivity is increased because of a higher thermal voltage having a value D.sub.H+=1.910.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s. For SSC at 25 C., D.sub.H+=(9.6810.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs)(0.02560 V)=2.510.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s while at 80 C. diffusivity is D.sub.H+=7.910.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s.
[3193] Unlike P-type silicon whose hole diffusivity depends on semiconductor bandgap and boron's acceptor energy level above the valence band, proton diffusivity in a PEM depends primarily on the polymer membrane's chemistry, stoichiometry, and film hydration. A wide range of diffusivities have been reported for Nafion and other PFSA membranes using NMR diffusion studies of proton-exchange membranes summarized in the table below. The table includes various reported IEMs and equivalent weights at differing hydration levels. The diffusivity values are directly measure using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The mobility values are calculated from the Einstein relation .sub.H+=D/V.sub. where V.sub.(25 C.)=25.69 mV and V.sub.(80 C.)=82.21 mV.
TABLE-US-00074 Equiv weight Hydration Energy 25 C. Diffusivity Mobility (cm.sup.2/Vs) symbol (units) Material EW (g/eq) E.sub.a (eV) D.sub.0 (cm.sup.2/s) .sub.H+ (25 C.) .sub.H+ (80 C.) F 950 950 1.5 0.32 7.7 10.sup.6 3.00 10.sup.4 9.60 10.sup.4 FS 930 RFS 930 1.4 0.31 8.1 10.sup.6 3.15 10.sup.4 3.00 10.sup.4 Nafion 117 1100 2.6 0.25 1.1 10.sup.2 4.28 10.sup.1 4.28 10.sup.1 Nafion 212 1100 6.4 0.23 8.0 10.sup.3 3.11 10.sup.1 3.11 10.sup.1 Nafion 211 1100 6.6 0.24 1.2 10.sup.2 4.67 10.sup.1 4.67 10.sup.1 Nafion 117 1100 6.7 0.22 7.8 10.sup.3 3.04 10.sup.1 3.04 10.sup.1 F 950 950 8.3 0.20 4.7 10.sup.3 1.82 10.sup.1 1.82 10.sup.1 FS 930 RFS 930 8.6 0.22 1.4 10.sup.2 5.45 10.sup.1 5.45 10.sup.1
[3194] During charge transport through an ionomeric membrane, both drift and diffusion current are present. Unlike drift current which relies on electric field force to propel a charge by electrostatic force, diffusion current depends only on a concentration gradient dN/dx and charge diffusivity D to produce electric current, as described by Fick's First Law for diffusion stating
where for an ion exchange membrane dN.sub.H+/dx is the concentration gradient of hydrogen present across the polymeric membrane. The differential dN is defined as dN=N.sub.ACLN.sub.CCL where N.sub.ACL is the generated proton concentration in the anode catalyst layer (ACL) and N.sub.CCL is the proton concentration in the cathode catalyst layer (CCL), the difference dN/dx comprising the carrier gradient across the membrane of effective thickness dx.
[3195] While the injected charge is in fact added to the resident charge from the ionized acids, the immobile anions and ionized protons are charge neutral and in the absence of charge injection or electric fields do not conduct electricity or generate energy.
[3196] Assuming the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) at in the CCL converts 100% of the incoming hydrogen ions into water, the proton concentration at the membrane-to-CCL interface is zero, i.e. [H+].sub.CCL=0. As such, dN=N.sub.ACL the carrier concentration [H+].sub.ACL generated by catalysis of incoming hydrogen fuel. Assuming a 20-m thick membrane, dx=2010.sup.4 cm then at 25 C., N.sub.ACL=dN=Jdx/qD=(0.25 A/cm.sup.2)(2010.sup.4 cm)/((1.610.sup.19 coul)(6.010.sup.6 cm.sup.2/s))=5.210.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 for LSC PFSA.
[3197] The corresponding LSC ion gradient is dN/dx=(5.210.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3)/(2010.sup.4 cm)=2.610.sup.23 ions/cm.sup.4. The added charge defined as Q.sup.+=5.210.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 is approximately 2.5 times the ionized ionomer concentration of N.sub.H+2.143810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3.
[3198] In the case of a SSC PFSA where D=2.510.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s, then N.sub.ACL=dN=Jdx/qD=(0.25 A/cm.sup.2)(2010.sup.4 cm)/((1.610-19 coul)(2.510.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s))=1.2510.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3. At Q.sup.+=1.2510.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3 this injected charge is roughly half the ionized ionomer concentration of N.sub.H+N.sub.H+3.277810.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3. The corresponding SSC ion gradient is dN/dx=(1.2510.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3)/(2010.sup.4 cm)=6.2510.sup.22 ions/cm.sup.4. Compared to long sidechain PFSA, SSC is able to conduct more current with less extra charge because of its higher conductivity, higher mobility, and lower effective mass.
[3199] A summary of material properties for ionomeric conduction in PFSA is contrasted to that of P-type silicon, an apropos comparison as both involve conduction through the successive binding and release of positive charges. Using the diffusion equation, the described membrane conducts current densities of J=0.25 A/cm.sup.2. To convert current density (A/cm.sup.2) into current (A) as per the relation I=JA it is necessary to determine the appropriate estimate of conducting area A. As detailed previously, charge hopping conduction involves the transfer of protons (or other charge carriers) from one fixed site to another. This is facilitated by the presence of immobile anions such as sulfonic acid groups in PFSA membranes or other acids in hydrocarbon based IEMs. This type of conduction is primarily driven by a concentration gradient of mobile hydrogen ions.
TABLE-US-00075 P-type Property Silicon PFSA Units structural silicon PTFE PTFE support crystal charge ionized LSC sulfonic SSC sulfonic source boron anion anion density 2.3 2.0 2.0 g/cm.sup.3 charge N.sub.A N.sub.H+ N.sub.H+ cm.sup.3 density 4 10.sup.19 2.1438 10.sup.20 3.2778 10.sup.20 effective 0.49m.sub.0 63m.sub.H+ 15m.sub.H+ mass m* conductivity 360 8 10.sup.3 5 10.sup.2 S/cm mobility .sub.h = 55 .sub.H+ = 2.33 10.sup.4 .sub.H+ = 9.68 10.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs diffusivity D.sub.h = 1.4 D.sub.H+ = 6.0 10.sup.6 D.sub.H+ = 2.5 10.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s D (25 C.) diffusivity D.sub.h = 4.5 D.sub.H+ = 1.9 10.sup.5 D.sub.H+ = 7.9 10.sup.5 cm.sup.2/s D (80 C.) tortuosity 1 3 3 factor peak ion p = Q.sup.+ = 5.2 10.sup.20 Q.sup.+ = cm.sup.3 concentration 4 10.sup.19 1.25 10.sup.20
[3200] Since ionomers such as sulfonic acid groups comprise immobile anions spread throughout the membrane, charge hopping (Grotthuss) conduction occurs from one acid releasing a proton which diffuses to the nearest unoccupied immobile anion only to be captured and re-released into the matrix. The residence time of the proton staying attached to an un-ionized acid varies from durations of picoseconds (10.sup.12 seconds) to nanoseconds (10.sup.9 seconds) depending on membrane hydration, temperature, and the polymer's molecular structure and crystallinity. Because of its small atomic size, hydrogen ions can penetrate in all directions throughout the polymeric matrix flowing from high concentration areas to lower. So long that a slight pressure and convective flow delivers a steady supply of hydrogen to the anode catalyst layer (ACL) then the interfacial proton concentration Q.sup.+ is maintained at a concentration higher than the ionized anion concentration. Excess charge ranges from 15% to 1000%, i.e. 100. This means the dominant driving force for charge hopping conduction in a ionomeric membrane is diffusion.
[3201] Given that immobile anions are uniformly distributed and hydrogen ions can diffuse through the entire cross-sectional area, diffusion based charge hopping results is uniform current conduction across the IEM. As such, describing diffusion current by the current density parameter J accurately represents conduction current in any size membrane. In other words, the applicable area for calculating diffusion current in an IEM is the full active area of a fuel cell A.sub.FC.
[3202] For example, if the diffusion current density in a PFSA membrane is J=250 mA/cm.sup.2 then the calculated current for a membrane of area A.sub.FC=1 cm.sup.2, the resulting current I=JA.sub.FC=(250 mA/cm.sup.2)(1 cm.sup.2)=250 mA. If the area is 200 times greater, i.e. A.sub.FC=200 cm.sup.2 then the current is also 200 greater, where I=JA.sub.FC=(250 mA/cm.sup.2)(200 cm.sup.2)=50 A, a very realistic magnitude of current useful in power and energy applications.
[3203] Comparing diffusive charge hopping to vehicular transport reveals a dramatic difference. Vehicular transport involves the movement of ions or molecules that carry the charge, such as hydrated protons (H.sub.3O.sup.+) or other ion clusters to move through the membrane by physically migrating along pathways or channels. For vehicular transport, a matrix of micropores and nanopores must form a contiguous interconnected patchwork of interconnected tunnels to carry water and conduct hydronium ions. In the absence of these channels, vehicular transport cannot provide interstitial conduction. To determine the relative contributions of diffusion and drift mechanisms in vehicular transport several parameters must be determined namely (i) the length dx of the conduction path; (ii) the concentration gradient dN/dx over that path; (iii) the average cross sectional area of the conducting channels; and (iv) the average electric field dV/dx along the path, and (iv) the physical constants of mobility .sub.H+ and diffusivity D.sub.H+ for proton conduction in specific ionomeric films.
[3204] Three of these calculations depend on the length of the vehicular conduction path. This length dx is not the membrane thickness X.sub.IEM but is significantly longer accounting for the tortuous path length of the conductive channels weaving their way through the polymer matrix. A longer path length dx lowers dN/dx reducing vehicular diffusion current, and also lowers the electric field dV/dx reducing vehicular drift current. A tortuous multiplicative factor of =2.5 to =3.0 times the membrane thickness is a reasonable estimate based on various studies. Accordingly, the path length for vehicular transport is dx=X.sub.IEM. For example, a X.sub.IEM=20 m film with =3.0, dx=X.sub.IEM=3(20 m)=60 m. For a LSC membrane concentration gradient of 2.610.sup.23 ions/cm.sup.4 and a diffusivity of 6.010.sup.6 cm.sup.2/s, the corresponding LSC diffusion current density is J.sub.diff=qD(dN/dx)=250 A/cm.sup.2.
[3205] Although the diffusion component of vehicular transport depends on the concentration gradient dN/dx, the drift component of vehicular transport relies on electrostatic force as a function of the electric field E=dV/dx. Given the cell voltage developed across a single CCM later is approximately dV=700 mV and assuming a membrane thickness of X.sub.IEM=20 m film with a tortuosity factor =3.0, then dx=X.sub.IEM=3(20 m)=60 m. Given E=dV/dx then the electric field E=0.7V/(6010.sup.4 cm)=116 V/cm.
[3206] From the drift current equation J.sub.dr=q.sub.H+N.sub.H+E=(1.610.sup.19 coul)(2.3310.sup.4 cm.sup.2/Vs)(2.143810.sup.20 coul/cm.sup.2)(116 V/cm)=(810.sup.3 S/cm)(116 V/cm)=928 mA/cm.sup.2. Given a conductivity of =810.sup.3 S/cm from the foregoing, the drift current density J.sub.dr in conducting micropore channels is given by J.sub.dr=E=(810.sup.3 S/cm)(116 V/cm)=0.928 A/cm.sup.2=928 mA/cm.sup.2, a current 3.7 greater than the vehicular diffusion current of 250 mA/cm.sup.2.
[3207] Together, total vehicular current J.sub.v comprising both drift and diffusion components sum to J.sub.v=J.sub.diff+J.sub.dr=(250 A/cm.sup.2)+(928 mA/cm.sup.2)=1178 mA/cm.sup.2 of which 21% is diffusion and 79% is drift. Although the current density is high, the total current contribution of vehicular transport is a relatively small fraction of total IEM current. The reason for diminutive contribution is because of the small cross sectional area of the conducting channels and their relatively low density. Assuming a cross sectional area of a micropore (p) to be A.sub.up=100 nm.sup.2 per pore, the total vehicular current carried by any one channel is approximately J.sub.v A.sub.p=(0.1178 A/cm.sup.2)(1 cm.sup.2/10.sup.14 nm.sup.2)(100 nm.sup.2)=0.117810.sup.12 A or 12 pA/channel. Removing dead end channels, the total density of conducting micropores in a reference fuel cell of area A.sub.FC=1 cm.sup.2 area of pristine PFSA is estimated to be approximately .sub.p=A.sub.p/A.sub.FC=5%. The total current contribution of vehicular conduction current is therefore J.sub.v.sub.p A.sub.FC=(0.1178 A/cm.sup.2)(5%)(1 cm.sup.2)=5.9 mA/cm.sup.2, only 2.4% of the total membrane current.
[3208] In summary, charge hopping current in a conventional ionomeric membrane is dominated by diffusion current with virtually no drift current contribution. Vehicular transport in pristine membranes contributes less than 5% of total current due to the limitation of tortuous conduction further constrained by low microporous channel densities and small cross sectional areas of conducting polymeric conduits. Further limitations of conventional ionomeric membranes includes a propensity of short sidechain (SSC) membrane to swell excessively with hydration and suffer water logging further adversely impacting conduction and IEM performance.
[3209] To offset the inherent deficiencies as identified here, an improved ionomeric membranes made in accordance with this invention includes [3210] physically constraining the ionomeric membrane with an endoskeletal matrix designed to reduce physical deformation of ionomeric membranes during manufacturing and in operation, especially for higher conductivity polymers with a propensity for water logging like short sidechain PFSA; [3211] enhancing the density of contiguous microporous channels through the use of sacrificial fillers to enhance vehicular conduction improving current density and conductivity while reducing conduction losses; [3212] expanding the cross sectional area of micropores through the use of sacrificial fillers to enhance vehicular conduction improving current density and conductivity while reducing conduction losses; [3213] reducing tortuosity of microporous channels by eliminating dead end channels through the use of sacrificial fillers enhancing vehicular conduction, improving current density, and boosting conductivity while reducing conduction losses; [3214] reducing the mean free path, transit time, and effective mass of protons traversing the molecular matrix through the introduction of permanent fillers comprising ionomeric crystals, organic, metal organic, and other charge transfer compounds not bound to the polymeric matrix; and [3215] enhancing the mobile charge concentration in the membrane through membrane doping with ionic liquids, where the ionic liquids are contained by endoskeletal support and membrane nano-coatings to prevent seepage and IL leakage.
[3216] These innovations improve overall membrane conductivity by enhancing vehicular transport without damaging membrane integrity or disrupting the efficiency of charge hopping conduction.
Charge & Mass Conservation.
[3217] Referring again to the equation
##STR00014##
where the hydration factor also known as water uptake is defined as the ratio of water concentration [H.sub.2O] and
the term on the left side of the equation [(1)[AH.sup.0] describes the quantity of ionomeric groups comprising unionized acids and where [AH.sup.0]m(AH.sup.0). The term on the right [A.sup.]+Q.sup.+ describes the quantity of immobile and mobile charges present in the film where the concentration [A.sup.] is equal to m[A.sup.]. In the absence of current flow through the membrane, any net change of charge present in the film must sum to zero, i.e. q=0.
[3218] Accordingly, charge balance requires that the total positive charge Q.sup.+ created by deprotonation of the polymeric acid forming anions [A.sup.] must precisely balance the number of mobile protons Q*=[H.sup.+] released. As such, the magnitude of charges |q| must balance whereby |Q.sup.+|=|[H.sup.+]|=|m(A.sup.)| meaning every liberated proton (H.sup.+) leaves an immobile anionic ionomer (A.sup.) behind. The number of free protons released, however, does not remain constant. In aqueous solutions when the membrane is hydrated, hydrogen atoms coming in contact with water molecules spontaneously and rapidly convert into hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+, meaning the total mobile charge quantity Q.sup.+ is necessarily split between hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+ and free hydrogen ions H.sup.+.
[3219] Assuming a resulting charge ratio between hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+ and unconverted hydrogen ions (1)H.sup.+ then the total mobile charge Q.sup.+ can be expressed by in terms of electrostatic charge neutrality as
or chemically in terms of an equilibrium reaction as
##STR00015##
[3220] The value of depends, not only the conversion of aqueous hydrogen into hydronium as measured by pH but also by the hydration of the ionomeric polymer. In cases of high hydration, the value of .fwdarw.1 meaning all the hydrogen is converted into hydronium ions. Because nearly 100% of free hydrogen coming in contact with water spontaneously and instantaneously forms hydronium, the value of is not a measure of hydronium conversion rates but of the fraction of ionized hydrogen in proximity to water.
[3221] While in solution, the dissociation of water into hydrogen and hydroxide and the subsequent nearly total conversion into hydronium means for all practical purposes in aqueous solutions, the concentrations [H.sup.+]=[H.sub.3O.sup.+] and the terms hydrogen can be used interchangeably in the calculation of acidity and in calculating the power of hydrogen commonly referred to as pH. In a ionomeric membrane at low hydration levels however, hydrogen ions [H.sup.+] can exist and persist without ever coming in contact with water molecules.
[3222] As such, in the foregoing equation Q.sup.+=(1)[H.sup.+]+[H.sub.3O.sup.+] the term (1)[H.sup.+] represents anhydrous hydrogen while [H.sub.3O.sup.+] represents hydrated hydrogen (H.sup.+.Math.H.sub.2O). Since the term pH has no meaning for gaseous hydrogen atoms or ions, then only water complexed hydrogen [H.sub.3O.sup.+] determines the pH of the solution present inside the channels of aqueous ion exchange membranes. Defining aqueous pH by the relation [H.sub.3O.sup.+]=10.sup.(pH)
then as a function of hydronium concentration in water, pH is given by the equation
Adapting the concept of pH for an ionomeric membrane, the membrane pH is equal to
where is the ionization constant for the acid, is the fraction of hydrogen ions converted into hydronium, and k is the hydration factor. For example, assuming a Nafion 1100 film with =20% and N.sub.H+2.143810.sup.20 then the effective pH of the membrane depends on the hydronium fraction as follows: As shown the effective pH of a PFSA membrane is quite low attributable to the small pK.sub.a+0.754 and high dissociation constant for sulfonic acid.
[3223] Continuing with reaction stoichiometry, substituting the value of [Q.sup.+] into the reaction equation yields the mass-charge conserved expression
##STR00016##
where the multiplicative term (1) is used to adjust the un-ionized water concentration (1)[H.sub.2O] and the unconverted free hydrogen concentration (1)[H.sup.+]. Made in accordance with conservation principles the equilibrium reaction [H.sub.3O.sup.+](1)[H.sup.+]+(1)[H.sub.2O] describes that for every hydronium ions formed the free hydrogen ion and unreacted water concentration are reduced by a factor of (1). The hydronium term may also be expressed in pH as [H.sub.3O.sup.+]=10.sup.(pH)
TABLE-US-00076 Ion [H.sub.3O.sup.+] Material Ionization Density N.sub.H+ Conversion Effective pH Nafion 20% 0.2356 1% 2.63 1100 moles/cm.sup.3 2% 2.33 2.142 10.sup.20 5% 1.82 ions/cm.sup.3 10% 1.63 20% 1.32 30% 1.15 40% 1.03 50% 0.93 60% 0.85 70% 0.78 80% 0.73 90% 0.67 100% 0.63
[3224] Since the foregoing reactions are bidirectional as indicated by the mirrored arrows symbol , then in equilibrium neutral acids convert to mobile charge of protons [H.sup.+] and hydronium ions [H.sub.3O.sup.+] while at an equal opposite rate the mobile charges de-ionize back into charge neutral acids [AH.sup.0]. Concurrently in equilibrium a portion of newly released protons [H.sup.+] spontaneously convert into hydronium ions [H.sub.3O.sup.+] while concurrently an equal number of hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+ revert into mobile proton H.sup.+ cations. The relative ratios of the three components are determined by statistical mechanics and thermodynamics as embodied in the acid ionization constant and the hydronium autoionization ratio . The values of and remain constant for a given membrane chemistry maintained at a fixed temperature, pressure, and humidity.
Ionomeric Conduction.
[3225] In fuel cell operation, the reaction equation for the membrane electrochemistry is perturbed by the continuous supply of new charge in the form of ionized hydrogen fuel entering the membrane from the anode terminal and eventually departing the cathode. Including the influx in charge Q.sup.+ the steady state equation during fuel cell operation and electric power generation is then
##STR00017##
[3226] The incremental charge Q.sup.+ comprises the hydrogen ion fuel ingress at the anode and egress at the cathode feeding an oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurring in the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) and is the energy conversion efficiency of the ORR consuming hydrogen ions and oxygen to produce electricity and water as a waste product. Specifically, cations Q.sup.+ transported across the membrane reaching the cathode, are converted into water according to the ORR reaction equation
##STR00018##
[3227] Defining the term Q.sup.+ as the net change in charge and mass during operation then Q*=.sub.H++dq+Q.sub.diff.sub.O2+.sub.H2O where D denotes material flux including hydrogen fuel in .sub.H+=dN.sub.H+, oxygen reducing agent in .sub.O2=dN.sub.O2, and net water .sub.H2O comprising generated water G[H.sub.2O] less water R[H.sub.2O] removed by draining. Substituting the foregoing yields the relation
##STR00019##
Applying the ORR water reaction .sub.H2O=G[H.sub.2O]R[H.sub.2O] and combining water terms yields the closed loop equation
##STR00020##
[3228] A key element of this expression is that generated water G[H.sub.2O] offset by any water removed from drainage R[H.sub.2O] is the source of water (1)[H.sub.2O] used to form hydronium [H.sub.3O.sup.+] and is also the source of water used to facilitate ionization of the acid groups into immobile anions [A.sup.]. In other words, once the fuel cell commences operation it generates its own water needed to support the reaction. Taking the time derivative of the foregoing equation in steady state operation yields the simplified expression
##STR00021##
where I.sub.FC=(dq/dt)+C.sub.FC(dV/dt). This equation means so long that hydrogen and oxygen are supplied, the fuel cell will produce electric current and waste water. It should be noted that in steady state Q.sup.+ is equal to zero, meaning whilst the fuel cell is operating, the hydrogen fuel and oxygen ingress balance the water and electrical outputs in both mass and charge. To sustain steady state conduction, a constant supply of charge dq must be maintained by corresponding continuous supply of hydrogen fuel labelled here as incoming flux .sub.H+=dN.sub.H+.
[3229] Before the steady state condition is reached, however, the concentration gradient must be established, a process akin to charging diffusion capacitance, named here as C.sub.FC where C.sub.FC=Q.sub.diffdV. Diffusion charge Q.sub.diff is the concentration gradient times membrane thickness as given by Q.sub.diff=(dN.sub.H+/dx)X.sub.IEM, which in the case of a 20 m thick Nafion 1100 is given by Q.sub.diff=(2.610.sup.23 ions/cm.sup.4)(2010.sup.4 cm)=5.210.sup.20 ions/cm.sup.3=83.2 coulombs=23 mAh. This energy is equal to 83 A-see or 1.4 A-min, meaning it takes nearly a minute and a half to clear the stored charge in the membrane. Assuming V.sub.FC=0.7V, the diffusion capacitance is 58 farads.
[3230] Once the capacitor is charged and the fuel cell voltage stabilizes then dV/dt=0 and the displacement current component disappears until operation is terminated. Upon cessation of operation, the stored charge in the membrane must dissipate before conduction ceases. Since no significant recombination mechanisms exist, charge depletion requires excess charge to diffuse out of the ionomeric matrix.
Immobile Anionic Homo-Ionomers for PEMs.
[3231] A number of acids compatible with ionomers made in accordance with this invention are described herein as illustrated in
Sulfuric Acid:
[3232] Applicable acids as shown by example in
(H.sub.2SO.sub.4)(SO.sub.4).sup.2+H.sup.++H.sub.3O.sup.+
[3233] In operation, the concentration of protonated and deprotonated ionomer termini reach an equilibrium condition between the neutral acids (H.sub.2SO.sub.4); immobile sulfate anions (SO.sub.4).sup.2; and mobile cations H.sup.+ and H.sub.3O.sup.+ (not shown). A more complete description as discussed previously includes hydration resulting from the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) providing a transport medium from ions in aqueous fuel cells. For brevity's sake the role of water is excluded from the equation as shown. As such, the equations are illustrative and not intended to conserve charge or mass. For example, in the divalent ionization shown, two hydrogen ions 2H.sup.+ are released into solution, not one as indicated. But since water is excluded from the equation and hydronium ions include excess protons in varying concentrations and quantities no insight by detailed accounting of hydrogen and water molecules.
[3234] To further complicate matters sulfuric acid (H.sub.2SO.sub.4) may also be converted into a monovalent anionic ionomer hydrogen sulfate (HSO.sub.4).sup. (not shown) by the simplified reaction (H.sub.2SO.sub.4)(HSO.sub.4).sup.+H.sup.++H.sub.3O.sup.+. And since the reaction kinetics for monovalent and divalent deprotonation are similar, it is more likely in fuel cell operation both monovalent and divalent immobile anions are present concurrently in which case, the simplified reaction equation becomes
##STR00022##
again where the equation is neither mass or charge balanced. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with sulfuric acid and immobile anion derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion; polybenzimidazole (PBI); sulfonated poly(ether-ether ketone) (SPEEK); sulfonated poly(phenylene oxide) (SPPO); sulfonated polyimides (SPI); sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone) (SPAES); and poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) blended with sulfonated polymers; and others without limitation. These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Sulfonic Acid:
[3235] In a similar manner, sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3) is converted into the monovalent anionic ionomer (SO.sub.3).sup. 6301 called sulfonate by the reaction
##STR00023##
Although the pK.sub.a of sulfonic acid ranges from 2 to 0 or possibly to +0.5 in solution, sulfonic acid groups attached to polymers typically exhibit reduced acidity at pK.sub.a=+0.754, likely because of electrostatic and hydrophobic influence of adjacent polymer backbones.
[3236] Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with sulfonic acid and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion; sulfonated poly(ether-ether ketone) (SPEEK); sulfonated poly(phenylene oxide) (SPPO); sulfonated polyimides (SPI); sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone) (SPAES); poly(styrene sulfonic acid) (PSSA); poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) blended with sulfonated polymers; and others without limitation. These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Sulfamic Acid:
[3237] Another sulfur-based compound, sulfamic acid (H.sub.3NSO.sub.3), pK.sub.a=+1, is converted into the monovalent anionic ionomer (H.sub.2NSO.sub.3).sup. 6302 as per the equilibrium reaction
##STR00024##
where ionization of the sulfamic acid produces a monovalent immobile anion (H.sub.2NSO.sub.3).sup. called sulfamate. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with sulfamic acid and immobile anion derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion; sulfonated poly(ether-ether ketone) (SPEEK); sulfonated poly(phenylene oxide) (SPPO); sulfonated polyimides (SPI); sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone) (SPAES); sulfonated poly(arylene ether ketone) (SPAEK); poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) blended with sulfonated polymers; and others without limitation.
[3238] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Sulfosuccinic Acid:
[3239] In the equilibrium reaction of sulfosuccinic acid: (SSA), pK.sub.a=+1.5, having the chemical composition (C.sub.4H.sub.6O.sub.7S) given by
##STR00025##
sulfosuccinic acid is converted into monovalent anionic ionomer (SSA).sup. 6303 called sulfosuccinate having the formula (C.sub.4H.sub.5O.sub.7S).sup. by deprotonation of an OH group. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with sulfosuccinic acid and immobile anion derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion; sulfonated poly(ether-ether ketone) (SPEEK); sulfonated poly(phenylene oxide) (SPPO); sulfonated polyimides (SPI); sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone) (SPAES); sulfonated poly(arylene ether ketone) (SPAEK); poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) blended with sulfonated polymers; and others without limitation.
[3240] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Phenol Hydroxide:
[3241] Phenyl comprising a aromatic benzene ring (C.sub.6H.sub.6) in which a hydrogen atom has been replaced with am atom or functional group has the general form (C.sub.6H.sub.5R). In the special case where the hydrogen is replaced with a hydroxyl group (ROH) the resulting cyclic compound (C.sub.6H.sub.5OH) is referred to as phenol, i.e. oxygenated phenyl. Since phenyl has the pseudoatomic abbreviation Ph, then the hydroxide variant is commonly referred to by the nomenclature (PhOH) as phenol hydroxide.
[3242] Deprotonating the hydroxide group results in the anion (PhO).sup. having a chemical formula (C.sub.6H.sub.5O).sup. called phenolate. With a pK.sub.a=+10, phenol hydroxide comprises a relatively weak acid. In the case of a ionomeric membrane, phenol hydroxide is converted into phenolate, a monovalent anionic ionomer (PhO).sup. 6304 through a process of ionization of the hydroxide group made in accordance with the equilibrium reaction
##STR00026##
[3243] Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with phenol hydroxide acid and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: polybenzimidazole (PBI); functionalized poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with crosslinking agents; functionalized poly(phenylene oxide) (PPO); functionalized poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK); functionalized poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO); functionalized polyimides (PI); functionalized polysulfone (PSU); and others without limitation.
[3244] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Phosphonic Acid.
[3245] Another acid capable of forming ionomers in PEM membranes includes phosphonic acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.3), pK.sub.a=+1.3, converted into monovalent anionic ionomer dihydrogenphosphite (H.sub.2PO.sub.3).sup. 6305 by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00027##
[3246] Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with phosphonic acid and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion; polybenzimidazole (PBI); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with phosphonic acid groups; poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK) with phosphonic acid groups; poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) with phosphonic acid groups; polyimides with phosphonic acid groups; polysulfone (PSU) with phosphonic acid groups; and others without limitation.
[3247] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Phosphoric Acid.
[3248] Phosphoric acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.4) is a medium strength triprotic acid capable of ionizing into multiple valence states. Single proton ionization results in the monovalent anion (H.sub.2PO.sub.4).sup. referred to dihydrogen phosphate. The ionization of two hydrogens into solution produces the divalent anion hydrogen phosphate (HPO.sub.4).sup.2. Complete deprotonation of all hydrogen atoms produces the trivalent phosphate anion (PO.sub.4).sup.3. The respective pK.sub.a values for the single, double, and triple ionized variants are pK.sub.a values of 2.15, 7.2, and 12.4.
[3249] As such, only the singularly ionized moiety dihydrogen phosphate (H.sub.2PO.sub.4).sup. is relevant to phosphoric acid based ionomers whereby the equilibrium reaction
##STR00028##
produces the immobile anion dihydrogen phosphate (H.sub.2PO.sub.4).sup. 6306. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with phosphoric acid and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: polybenzimidazole (PBI); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with phosphoric acid groups; poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK) with phosphoric acid groups; poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) with phosphoric acid groups polyimides with phosphoric acid groups; polysulfone (PSU) with phosphoric acid groups; and others without limitation, including polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE).
[3250] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Amide Conjugate Acids.
[3251] In some instances an acid auto ionizes into a charged radical by removal of a proton during formation. One example includes the amide conjugate acid (RCONH).sup. 6307, pK.sub.a=1 to 0.5. Amides are derived from carboxylic acids, i.e. acids containing a (COOH), where the molecule's OH terminus is substituted with an NH.sub.2 group resulting in the structure (RCONH.sub.2) which immediately deprotonates to form (RCONH).sup. 6307 in accordance with the equilibrium reaction
##STR00029##
[3252] In solution the opposing side of the molecule labelled R bonds to a radical such as CH.sub.3 to form ethanamide (CH.sub.3CONH.sub.2) or the (CH.sub.3CONH).sup. anion. In an ionomer, exposed carbon ion bonds to the polymeric backbone rather than a radical R. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with amide conjugate acids and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: polybenzimidazole (PBI); polyamide-imide (PAI), polyimides; poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO); and others without limitation.
[3253] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Carboxylic Acid:
[3254] Similarly, carboxylic acid (RCOOH), pKa=+4 to +5, forms the immobile anion (RCOO).sup. 6308 through deprotonation of its terminus hydrogen in accordance with the equilibrium reaction
##STR00030##
where the exposed hydrogen is ionized producing the monovalent anion (RCOO).sup. 6308 referred to as carboxylate. Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with carboxylic acids and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: polybenzimidazole (PBI); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with carboxylic acid groups; poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK) with carboxylic acid groups; poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) with carboxylic acid groups; polyimides with carboxylic acid groups; polysulfone (PSU) with carboxylic acid groups; and others without limitation.
[3255] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
Phosphotungstic Acid:
[3256] Likewise, phosphotungstic acid (PWA), pKa=+3.1, is converted into the monovalent anionic ionomer phosphotungstate (PWA).sup. 6309 through equilibrium reaction
##STR00031##
[3257] Made in accordance with this invention, homo-ionomeric ion exchange membranes compatible with phosphotungstic acid and immobile derivatives therefrom include the following polymers: polybenzimidazole (PBI); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with phosphotungstic acid groups; poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK) with phosphotungstic acid groups; poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) with phosphotungstic acid groups; polyimides with phosphotungstic acid groups; polysulfone (PSU) with phosphotungstic acid groups; and others without limitation.
[3258] These polymers may by used in any combination with other inventive features of this application including endoskeletal support, micropores fabricated via sacrificial fillers, permanent fillers and dopants including ionic liquids, and membrane coatings including catalysts, scavengers, MOFs, and barriers against gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide.
[3259] Other hydrocarbons and acids shown in
[3260] These various ionomers are especially advantageous in IEMs of specific polymers. For example, because of its inert reactivity and chemical stability perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) polymer such as Nafion is well suited for a range of ionomers including ethyl lactate, citric acid, glycolic acid, diethylphosphate, butyric acid, pyruvic acid, acetic acid, and triflate. For its superior thermal stability polybenzimidazole (PBI) enhances the performance of citric acid, glycolic acid, pyruvic acid, and acetic acid. Sulfonated polyether ether ketone (SPEEK) with is good chemical resistance and excellent proton conductivity is well matched to Citric acid, glycolic acid, pyruvic acid, acetic acid, and triflate.
[3261] With superior mechanical properties and resilience to chemical attack, polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) and polyetherimide (PEI) are both compatible with ethyl lactate, citric acid, glycolic acid, pyruvic acid, and acetic acid. For cost sensitive applications polypropylene (PP) and polyethylene (PE) can be used with ethyl lactate, citric acid, glycolic acid, butyric acid, pyruvic acid, and acetic acid. Other polymers compatible with citric acid, glycolic acid, pyruvic acid, acetic acid include polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), poly(ether-ether ketone) (PEEK), and polysulfone (PSU).
Hetero-Ionomers IEMs.
[3262] Another class of ion exchange membrane made in accordance with this invention is a hetero-ionomer or dual-ionomer IEM. In such membranes, two different ionomers are included in the polymer matrix. By combining two different ionomers into the same film, the operating range of an ion exchange membrane can be expanded beyond that of single ionomer electrochemistry.
Sulfuric-Sulfamic-Acid Co-Ionomer:
[3263] Representative examples of hetero-ionomer IEMs made in accordance with this invention as shown in
##STR00032##
including the presence of water (H.sub.2O).sub.x as a reaction solvent for the forward reaction ionizing neutral acids. Water identified as (H.sub.2O).sub.y also plays a role dynamically managing proton and hydronium concentrations during charge transport. Aside from its solvent and transport abilities, water does not actively participate in deprotonation of the electrolyte's acids. Instead, membrane water is the product of the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) converting transported protons reaching the anode catalyst layer (ACL) into water according to the reaction 4H.sup.++4e.sup..fwdarw.O.sub.2.fwdarw.2H.sub.2O. Because however, water is neither a reactant nor product of the acid-ionomer equilibrium reaction, the ionomer's overall electrochemistry is more simply expressed as
##STR00033##
with the understanding described in a previous section of this application that the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) occurring at the membrane-cathode catalyst-layer interface supplies the water necessary to hydrate the membrane and facilitate charge transport. Since the chemical activity of the two acids and their equilibrium constants differ, the combination of the two acids support ionomeric function over an extended range of pH and hydration levels. Other ions possibly added into the membrane such as functionalized permanent fillers and ionic liquids are not shown.
[3264] The sulfuric-sulfamic acid co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including perfluorosulfonic acidpolytetrafluoroethylene copolymer (PFSA-PTFE); polybenzimidazole (PBI); sulfonated polyether ether ketone (SPEEK); polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF); and the homopolymer polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE).
Sulfonic-Phosphonic-Acid Co-Ionomer:
[3265] As represented, a heterogenous mixed-acid dual-ionomer membrane 6361 made in accordance with this invention combines sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3) 6301, pK.sub.a=+0.754 and phosphonic acid (H.sub.3PO.sub.3), pK.sub.a=+1.3, by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00034##
to form two immobile anionic ionomers (SO.sub.3).sup. 6301 and (H.sub.2PO.sub.3).sup. 6305. Although renowned for its high proton conductivity, sulfonic acid can suffer from dehydration at higher temperatures. By combining sulfonic acid with phosphonic acid, the resulting hetero-ionomer membrane exhibits better thermal stability and mechanical properties than its homo-ionomer constituents. The combination also provides more uniform conductivity over a range of humidity levels and temperatures.
[3266] A sulfonic-phosphonic-acid co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including perfluorosulfonic acidpolytetrafluoroethylene copolymer (PFSA-PTFE); poly(arylene ether sulfone) (PAES); polybenzimidazole (PBI); polyphosphazenes (Pz); and polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF).
Sulfonic-Acid Phenol-Hydroxide Co-ionomer:
[3267] Another hetero-ionomer membrane 6362 made in accordance with this invention combines sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3), pK.sub.a=+0.754 and phenol hydroxide (Ph-OH), pK.sub.a=+10 together by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00035##
forming two immobile anionic ionomers (SO.sub.3).sup. 6301 and phenol hydroxide (PhO).sup. 6304 along with mobile charge carriers of hydrogen ions H.sup.+ 6358 and hydronium ions H.sub.3O.sup.+ 6359. The unique combination of the two acids provides a synergistic effect in conductivity by combining the strong acidic properties of sulfonic acid with an acid less sensitive to pH and ambient conditions.
[3268] And since phenol hydroxide groups offer improved thermal stability, the hetero-ionomeric membrane is well suited for high-temperature applications where maintaining membrane integrity is crucial. Moreover combining sulfonic acid and phenyl hydroxide groups can help manage hydration within the membrane. This is especially important for maintaining proton conductivity and preventing dehydration, especially under low-humidity conditions.
[3269] Another feature of the inventive sulfonic acidphenol hydroxide co-ionomer IEM is enhanced chemical stability. Specifically, the hetero-ionomer is inherently resistant to oxidative and hydrolytic degradation, extending the membrane's lifespan and improving its performance and tolerance to harsh environments, e.g. when exposed to environmental toxins and poisons. A unique benefit of this hetero-ionomer membrane is its ability to reduce fuel crossover of either hydrogen or methanol.
[3270] A sulfonic-acid-phenol-hydroxide co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including polysulfone (PSU); polyether ether ketone (PEEK); polybenzimidazole (PBI); poly(arylene ether sulfone) (PAES); and polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF).
Sulfosuccinic-Sulfonic-Acid Co-Ionomer:
[3271] Another hetero-ionomer membrane 6363 made in accordance with this invention combines sulfosuccinic acid (SSA, C.sub.4H.sub.6O.sub.7S), pK.sub.a=+1.5, and sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3), pK.sub.a=+0.754 together by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00036##
forming two immobile anionic ionomers (SSA).sup. 6303, chemically as (C.sub.4H.sub.5O.sub.7S).sup. and sulfonic acid (HSO.sub.3).sup. 6301 along with mobile charge carriers of hydrogen ions (H).sup.+ 6358 and hydronium ions (H.sub.3O).sup.+ 6359. The unique combination of the two acids provides two chemical variants of sulfonated ionomers together offering superior conductivity over a wide range of hydration levels with superior water retention in low humidity conditions. Sulfosuccinic acid offers the characteristic of improved thermal stability of the membrane, making it suitable for high-temperature applications. Together combination of the two sulfonated co-ionomers offers good resistance to chemical degradation, extending a membrane's lifespan and enhanced mechanical strength exhibiting flexible mechanical properties ensuring durability under operational stresses.
[3272] The sulfosuccinic-sulfonic-acid co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including poly(arylene ether sulfone) (PAES); polybenzimidazole (PBI); polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF); polysulfone (PSU); polyether ether ketone (PEEK); and polystyrene sulfonate (PSS).
Pyruvic-Butyric-Acid Co-Ionomer:
[3273] Other representative examples of hetero-ionomer IEMs made in accordance with this invention as shown in
##STR00037##
forming two immobile anionic ionomers, the pyruvate anion (C.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.3).sup. 6315, and butyrate anion (C.sub.4H.sub.7O.sub.2).sup. 6314 along with mobile charge carriers of hydrogen ions H.sup.+ 6358 and hydronium ions H.sub.3O 6359. The pyruvate anion (C.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.3).sup. is a 2-oxo monocarboxylic acid anion that is the conjugate base of pyruvic acid. Butyrate is the conjugate base of butyric acid, formed by deprotonation of the carboxy group in butyric acid.
[3274] Benefits of combining pyruvate and butyrate anions into an hetero-ionomeric film include higher conductivity and enhanced flexibility. Pyruvic acid also improves the thermal stability of the membrane. Both acids are biodegradable, making the membrane more environmentally friendly. As a disadvantage, bio-membranes can be more susceptible to chemical degradation, especially in harsh operating conditions.
[3275] The pyruvic-butyric-acid co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including polyethylene (PE); polypropylene (PP); poly(ethylene-co-methacrylic acid) (PEMAA); poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA); and poly(acrylic acid) (PAA).
DEP-Triflate Co-Ionomer:
[3276] The hetero-ionomer membrane 6365 made in accordance with this invention combines diethylphosphate (DEP, C.sub.4H.sub.10O.sub.4P), pK.sub.a=+1.5, and dilute trifluoromethane-sulphonic acid (triflate, OTf, CF.sub.3SO.sub.3H), pK.sub.a=+14, together by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00038##
forming two immobile anionic ionomers, the diethylphosphate anion (C.sub.4H.sub.9O.sub.4P) 6313, and triflate anion (CF.sub.3SO.sub.3).sup. 6317 along with mobile charge carriers of hydrogen ions (H)+6358 and hydronium ions (H.sub.3O).sup.+ 6359. The triflate anion (CF.sub.3SO.sub.3).sup. 6317 is an extremely stable polyatomic ion derived from the superacid triflic acid (CF.sub.3SO.sub.3H). Triflate may be synthesized in any number of variants comprising the formula ROSO.sub.2CF.sub.3 and the general structure ROS(O).sub.2CF.sub.3 often simplified to the notation OTf. With a pK.sub.a=14, triflate is one of the strongest acids known and therefore must be used in extremely weak concentrations to avoid damaging the membrane's polymeric structure.
[3277] By contrast DEP is a dialkyl phosphate having ethyl as the alkyl group and a conjugate acid of diethylphosphate, i.e. DEP.sup.. With a pK.sub.a=+1.95, although still considered a strong acid, DEP is a significantly weaker acid than triflate. The unique combination of dilute triflate with DEP confers numerous advantages to a membrane including excellent proton conductivity enhancing PEM efficiency, superior resistance to chemical attack thereby extending its operational life, and uniquely low swelling maintaining structural integrity over a wide range of environmental and operational conditions. Moreover, diethylphosphate improves the membrane's thermal stability.
[3278] The DEP-triflate co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is compatible with a variety of polymers including polyethylene oxide (PEO); poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA); polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF); poly(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate) (EVA); and poly(acrylonitrile) (PAN).
Citric-Acetic-Acid Co-Ionomer:
[3279] The hetero-ionomer membrane 6366 made in accordance with this invention combines citric acid (CA, C.sub.6H.sub.8O.sub.7) 6311, pK.sub.a=+3.1, with acetic acid (AA, CH.sub.3COOH), pK.sub.a=+4.76, together by the equilibrium reaction
##STR00039##
forming two immobile anionic ionomers, the citrate anion (C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7).sup.3 6311, and acetate anion (C.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.2).sup. 6316 along with mobile charge carriers of hydrogen ions H.sup.+ 6358 and hydronium ions H.sub.3O 6359. With a skeletal structure HOC(CO.sub.2H)(CH.sub.2CO.sub.2H).sub.2 citric acid is a weak organic acid occurring naturally in fruits and vegetables which may be concentrated for industrial purposes. Citric acid is a weak tribasic acid with pKa values of 3.128, 4.761, and 6.396. The citrate anion (C.sub.6H.sub.5O.sub.7).sup.3 is trivalent comprising tricarboxylic acid trianion, obtained by deprotonation of the three carboxy groups of citric acid. Acetic acid 6311 is a moderately weak hydrocarbon based acid with pK.sub.a=4.76 having a structure CH.sub.3COOH where the only the last oxygen-attached hydrogen is an acidic proton. Acetic acid, the main component of vinegar from which its name was derived, may also be written formulaically as CH.sub.3CO.sub.2H, C.sub.2H.sub.4O.sub.2, HC.sub.2H.sub.3O.sub.2, or by the pseudo-element symbol AcOH.
[3280] The benefit of combining citric and acetic acids together to form an a ionomeric membrane is primarily one of biocompatibility and safety. Although weak acids result in lower conductivities than using strong acids, they are safer for the environment, users, and manufacturers. That said, since both acids are efficient proton donors, their combination can exhibit enhanced conductivities over their homo-ionomer constituents. Because citric acid has multiple carboxyl groups, its use can improve the hydration properties of the membrane in in maintaining high proton conductivity even at lower humidity levels. Furthermore, since citric acid has a higher boiling point compared to acetic acid, it contributes to the thermal stability of the membrane allowing the hetero-ionomeric membrane to operate efficiently at a broader range of temperatures.
[3281] The combination of citric and acetic acids offers good chemical stability via a balanced chemical environment, enhancing the chemical stability of the membrane and resisting degradation over time, thereby extending the operational life of the membrane. In terms of mechanical stability, citric acid readily cross-links with other polymer chains, potentially enhancing the mechanical strength and durability of the PEM membrane rendering it more resilient to mechanical stress and deformation. The use of this inventive citric-acetic co-ionomer also confers beneficial advantages in limiting fuel crossover in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) through reduced methanol permeability, thereby improving the overall efficiency of the fuel cell. And since both citric acid and acetic acid are relatively inexpensive and readily available, PEM membranes fabricated with them offer a cost-effective option compared to using extremely caustic chemicals.
[3282] Aside from biocompatibility in use, fuel cells based on a citric-acetic acid membrane offer benefits in biocompatible recycling. Both citric acid and acetic acid are biodegradable and environmentally friendly. Using them in PEM membranes can contribute to the development of more sustainable and eco-friendly fuel cell technologies especially when combined with natural polymers such as chitosan and cellulose acetate.
[3283] The citric-acid acetic-acid co-ionomer made in accordance with this invention is also compatible with a variety of polymers including poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA); poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG); poly(acrylic acid) (PAA); poly(ethylene-co-methacrylic acid) (PEMAA); and poly(vinyl acetate) (PVAc).
[3284] The benefit of blending ionomers made in accordance with the invention is to combine dissimilar features to enhance structural or electrical properties of the membrane. As described in the prior examples, this benefit may involve combining an ionomer with enhanced durability or strength with another providing enhanced conductivity. Another example is to combine an ionomer which works well under low hydration conditions but is inefficient in high humidity with another ionomer that functions best in humid conditions without suffering water logging. Another advantageous combination blends an ionomer with good conductivity at low temperatures with another that works best at elevated temperatures.
[3285] The key design principle in engineering a hetero-ionomeric membrane in accordance with this invention is that at least one characteristic parameter between the two ionomers exhibits different optimum operating conditions. The benefit of a hetero-ionomer membrane is to expand the operational range of the film, synergistically enhance its performance, or both. This principle is illustrated graphically in
[3286] For example, if the x-axis is operating temperature and the y-axis represents conductivity, ionomer-B 6361 exhibits greater performance and at higher temperatures than ionomer-B 6361. At lower temperatures however, ionomer A 6360 outperforms ionomer-B in the lower temperature range. Although the performance criteria shown is exemplary of a fuel cell, the same co-ionomer membrane can for example be used for air and water filtration, chemical processing and catalysis, kidney dialysis, and deionization except the performance parameters are different. For example, filter performance may be measured by egress selectivity, catalytic rates, solid removal, fluid turbidity, particulate density, fluid pH, etc. while operating conditions may include temperature, ingress viscosity, pH, turbidity, flow rate, etc.
Permanent Fillers.
[3287] During membrane fabrication, permanent fillers may be added to the mold compound of any ionomeric polymer to enhance performance. Permanent fillers made in accordance with invention include bismuth compounds, graphene oxides; carbon nanotubes; silicates and zeolites; zirconium, tungsten and transition metals; metal-organic-frameworks (MOFs); nanostructures including PMMA, POSS, nanofibers and nanoparticles; polyoctahedral and double-decker silsesquioxanes (POSS, DDSQ); and functionalized triazines frameworks.
Bismuth Compounds:
[3288] One category of permanent filler depicted in
[3289] Made in accordance with this invention, bismuth compounds introduced into the polymer matrix act as reinforcing agents, improving the mechanical strength and durability of the membrane, a feature particularly important for maintaining membrane integrity under operational stress and high-temperature conditions. The incorporation of bismuth permanent fillers also enhances the flexibility and toughness of the membrane, reducing the likelihood of cracking or tearing. Bismuth compounds incorporated as nanoparticles also create a more uniform and finely structured membrane matrix, enhancing the dispersion of the fillers and improving the overall performance of the membrane.
[3290] In another embodiment, the incorporation of bismuth compounds into the matrix also invoke changes in the morphology of the membrane, such as pore size and distribution, beneficially influencing the membrane's transport properties and improving its overall efficiency. In one class of embodiments made in accordance with this invention, the membrane is formed with permanent fillers added prior to molding or casting the film into its final morphology and stoichiometry.
[3291] Made in accordance with this invention, bismuth compounds introduced into the polymer matrix act as reinforcing agents, improving the mechanical strength and durability of the membrane, a feature particularly important for maintaining membrane integrity under operational stress and high-temperature conditions. In one embodiment, the incorporation of bismuth permanent fillers also enhances the flexibility and toughness of the membrane, reducing the likelihood of cracking or tearing. Bismuth compounds incorporated as nanoparticles also create a more uniform and finely structured membrane matrix, enhancing the dispersion of the fillers and improving the overall performance of the membrane.
[3292] In another embodiment, the incorporation of bismuth compounds into the matrix also invoke changes in the morphology of the membrane, such as pore size and distribution, beneficially influencing the membrane's transport properties and improving its overall efficiency. Bismuth enhances chemical stability, rendering making the film more resistant to degradation by chemical species such as free radicals, acids, or bases. Bismuth compounds can also be included in a nanoparticle coating or embedded into the catalyst layer. For example, made in accordance with this invention the addition of these bismuth compounds into the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) accelerate the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), the rate limiting reaction in a PEM fuel cell.
[3293] Bismuth enhances chemical stability, rendering making the film more resistant to degradation by chemical species such as free radicals, acids, or bases. Bismuth compounds can also be included in a nanoparticle coating or embedded into the catalyst layer. For example, made in accordance with this invention the addition of these bismuth compounds into the cathode catalyst layer (CCL) accelerate the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), the rate limiting reaction of a PEM fuel cell. Applications of bismuth compounds in ionomeric membranes include enhancing proton exchange membranes (PEMs) in fuel cells to improve their efficiency, durability, and performance; enhancing the efficiency of water splitting by improving ion conductivity and catalytic activity in water electrolyzers; improve ion transport and overall battery performance in batteries, and in enhance sensitivity and selectivity for chemical sensors.
Graphene Oxides:
[3294] In another set of embodiments made in accordance with invention, graphene oxides (GO) are introduced into the membrane's polymeric matrix. The graphene oxides shown in
[3295] Specifically acid groups 6410 such as sulphonic acid (GO-SO.sub.3H) are highly proton-conductive. When GOs are functionalized with sulphonic acid, the proton conductivity of the membrane increases, which is crucial for the efficient operation of proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs). Similarly, other acid groups 6410 comprising phosphonic acid (GO-PO.sub.3H.sub.2) also contribute to proton conductivity, and their incorporation can enhance the membrane's ability to conduct protons, improving overall fuel cell performance.
[3296] Acidic functional groups facilitate proton hopping mechanisms, where protons are transferred from one functional group to another. This can significantly boost the overall proton conductivity of the membrane. Furthermore the presence of functional groups form continuous pathways for proton transport reducing membrane resistance, leading to higher efficiency and reduced self heating.
[3297] Acid functionalization of graphene oxides made in accordance with this invention also enhances the chemical stability of a ion exchange membrane. Specifically, the presence of strong acidic groups like sulphonic and phosphonic acids resist oxidative degradation, thereby maintaining membrane integrity over prolonged use in aggressive fuel cell environments. In particular, functionalizing GOs can improve the chemical stability of the membrane, making it more resistant to degradation from reactive species such as radicals and extending the operational lifetime of the membrane.
[3298] Furthermore, functionalizing GOs with hydrophilic groups such as sulphonic, phosphonic, or phosphoric acids enhances the water retention capability of the membrane. Adequate water content is essential for maintaining high proton conductivity and preventing membrane dehydration, which can lead to reduced performance and durability. Functional groups such as carboxyl, hydroxyl, and sulphonic acids are hydrophilic, meaning they can attract and retain water molecules. This is beneficial for maintaining the hydration levels necessary for efficient proton conduction.
[3299] Membrane swelling in the presence of water made in accordance with this invention is controlled by the type and density of functional groups. Properly balanced swelling can enhance proton conductivity without compromising mechanical strength. Moreover, as a unique embodiment enhanced water retention is counterbalanced by the mechanical rigidity and structural support of the inert skeletal structure disclosed herein, whereby the tendency for membrane swelling, water logging, and film deformation are suppressed.
[3300] Acidic functional groups bonded to graphene oxide increase the ion exchange capacity of the IEM film. This is particularly beneficial in applications where selective ion transport is crucial, such as in electrodialysis or redox flow batteries. Functionalized GOs also reduce the fuel crossover. e.g. hydrogen or methanol through the membrane, enhancing fuel cell efficiency, preventing performance losses, and suppressing ionomer and catalyst degradation.
[3301] Another aspect of membranes integrating graphene oxides made in accordance with this invention is tailored morphology. Specifically, the integration of functionalized GOs forms well-defined nanostructures within the membrane facilitating enhanced proton transport while maintaining mechanical integrity. Polysulfone is known for its excellent mechanical properties and thermal stability. Integrating GOs with polysulfone in accordance with this invention produces mechanically robust membranes able to withstand the harsh operational conditions of fuel cells.
[3302] The introduction of functionalized graphene oxides can also promote the formation of layered structures, further enhancing proton conductivity through contiguous porous channels while maintaining mechanical strength. Functionalized GOs also function as molecular reinforcing agents within the polymer matrix, enhancing the mechanical strength and durability of the membrane. This is particularly important for maintaining structural integrity under operational stress.
[3303] Functional groups like sulphonic and phosphonic acids attached to a graphene oxide substrate improve the thermal stability of an ionomeric membrane, especially beneficial in applications where an IEM is subjected to high temperatures, thereby ensuring consistent performance and longevity. Enhanced thermal stability also means that the membrane is less likely to decompose at high temperatures, ensuring long-term durability and reliability.
[3304] Lastly, the introduction of functionalized graphene oxides into the membrane in accordance with this invention can be tailored to selectively allow the transport of protons while blocking other ions. This selectivity is crucial for maintaining the efficiency of the fuel cell by preventing the crossover of unwanted ions. By enhancing ion selectivity, functional groups can also suppress fuel crossover and counter adverse effects therefrom.
Carbon Nanotubes:
[3305] As an embodiment of this invention carbon nanotubes (CNTs), whether a pristine CNT 6420, a nanocoated CNT 6421, or a functionalized CNT 6422, offer unique properties that can significantly alter and improve the performance of ion exchange membranes (IEMs) in fuel cells and other applications. By introducing permanent fillers containing CNTs into an ion exchange membrane in accordance with this invention, numerous benefits include enhanced proton efficiency; enhanced thermal stability; reduced fuel crossover; improved water management; and enhanced electrocatalytic activity.
[3306] Without functionalization, pristine CNTs 6420 create pathways in a polymeric matrix that improve proton transport due to high surface area and excellent thermal and electrical conductivity. Depending on the polymer, pristine CNTs interstitial to a membrane may enhance mechanical properties by acting as reinforcing agents within the membrane matrix similar to the action of carbon fibers, providing structural support and increasing tensile strength. Because of their inability to bond directly onto a polymer's lattice, enhancement in a film's tensile strength is minimal. Pristine CNTs have inherently high thermal stability, which helps maintain the integrity of the membrane under thermal stress. Pristine CNTs can also contribute to reducing methanol crossover by enhancing the barrier properties of the membrane and in maintaining an optimal water balance within the membrane, crucial for consistent performance in fuel cells. CNTs also enhance electrocatalytic activity, aiding in the overall reaction kinetics within the fuel cell.
[3307] Although pristine CNTs 6420 can improve electrical, mechanical, chemical, and thermal properties of an ionomeric polymer, in their native form, the poor wettability, weak interfacial boding, and hydrophobicity of carbon nanotubes are unable to strengthen a material matrix. In accordance with this invention, one means to enhance the surface reactivity of CNT is by coating its surface with nanocoatings of metals, metal alloys, and metal polymers. The resulting nanocoated CNTs 6421 are able to enhance the electrical, thermal, catalytic, and ionomeric properties of pristine nanotubes by facile coating processes. The nanocoating process may involve electroplating, electroless plating, and ultrasonic spray atomization processes, primarily of silver (Ag), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), cobalt (Co), gold (Au), and various metallic alloys such as nickel-phosphorus (NiP), nickel-cobalt (NiCo), and nickel-cobalt-phosphorus (NiCoP). By improving the surface reactivity nanocoated CNTs are better suited as a permanent filler in membranes featuring magnetic and ferromagnetic, electrically and thermally conductive properties, and catalytic capabilities.
[3308] The high catalytic activity and thermal conductance of metal nanocoated CNTs is similar to fillers of metal-organic-frameworks (MOFs). In one embodiment the addition of nanocoated CNTs into a membrane's ionomeric polymeric matrix equilibrates temperature gradients within the polymer. By introducing scavenger metal coated CNTs such as nickel and cobalt into the membrane, its membrane nanocoating, or into the catalyst layer, toxic carbon monoxide can be captured before doing damage to ionomers and catalysts. Made in accordance with this invention, the inclusion of a low density of platinum, palladium, or titanium coated CNTs can also suppress fuel cross over converting stray hydrogen into protons within the film's atomic matrix enhancing fuel cell conversion efficiency and further suppressing the formation of damaging peroxides (H.sub.2O.sub.2).
[3309] A variant of a nanocoated CNT also shown in
[3310] Structurally, the CNT bound functional groups interact with the polymeric matrix of the membrane, leading to better dispersion, stronger interfacial bonding, and improved mechanical properties of the membrane, thereby making it more durable and resistant to degradation. The introduction of functional groups also improve the thermal stability of the CNTs, in turn enhancing the thermal stability of the ion exchange membrane, a characteristic crucial for applications operating at elevated temperatures. Furthermore, in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs), functionalized CNTs reduce methanol crossover creating a more tortuous path for methanol molecules, thereby improving fuel efficiency.
[3311] In another embodiment, the hydrophilicity of functionalized carbon nanotubes attract water molecules, improving the hydration of the membrane and thus enhancing its ionic conductivity. Certain functional groups can impart electrocatalytic properties to CNTs, which can be beneficial for reactions occurring at the membrane interface. CNTs can also be used in ion exchange membranes for water purification systems, enhancing ion selectivity and increasing the efficiency of contaminant removal.
[3312] As various embodiments of this invention, both functionalized and pristine carbon nanotubes offer unique benefits that can significantly improve the performance of ion exchange membranes in fuel cells and other applications. Functionalized CNTs provide additional chemical functionality that can be tailored for specific needs, while both pristine and functionalize CNTs offer inherent properties that enhance conductivity, mechanical strength, and stability. The benefit of CNT functionalization depends on the functional group itself. These groups include amino, silica, titania, hydroxy-phosphorus, and carboxyl group, along with various exemplary acids including sulfonic acid, phosphonic acid, and phosphoric acids. The role of functionalized of CNTs in an ion exchange membrane depends not only on the functional group but on the application of the membrane.
[3313] For example CNTs functionalized by amino groups (CNT-NH.sub.2) 6423a exhibit a variety of changes involving increased hydrophilicity, enhanced chemical reactivity, and improved membrane selectivity, characteristics important in ion exchange membrane based filters such as water desalinization, deionization, aqueous turbidity and solid particulate separation, protein removal, and other cases. Amine-functionalized CNTs can also be used in photocatalytic applications for environmental remediation, such as the degradation of organic pollutants under light irradiation.
[3314] An amino group is an organic compound containing nitrogen and hydrogen called amine. Since nitrogen, like oxygen is more electronegative than either carbon and hydrogen, amino groups exhibit some polar character similar to water. The presence of amino groups on the surface of a carbon nanotube modifies the normally hydrophobic character of carbon nanotubes into a hydrophilic CNT, improving their dispersion in aqueous solutions and enhancing its aqueous chemical reactivity. The introduction of amine groups can enhance the gas adsorption and separation capabilities of CNTs, which is useful in applications like hydrogen storage and carbon dioxide capture.
[3315] In another embodiment of this invention involving ion exchange reactions (not shown), the combination of both amino and ionomeric functionalized coatings on a carbon nanotube assist in luring water into the vicinity of the ionomer thereby enhancing charge transport and proton exchange. Amino-functionalized CNTs also can form strong interactions with other molecules or materials, enhancing the mechanical properties and selectivity of the membrane, including improving the attachment of CNTs to the polymer's backbone.
[3316] Silica functionalized CNTs 6423s exhibit significantly enhanced mechanical strength and durability, improved thermal stability and better resistance to chemical degradation, together rendering membranes containing silica functionalized CNT more robust with longer cycle life. Titania functionalized CNTs 6423t impart antibacterial properties to a membrane, thereby preventing biofouling. Titania can enhance the UV resistance of CNTs, making the membranes more suitable for UV microbe sterilization applications. Titania-functionalized CNTs also exhibit photocatalytic properties, also beneficial for applications like water purification and pollutant degradation. In ion exchange membranes, the antimicrobial and antifouling behavior of titania functionalized CNTs confers enhanced filter performance especially in applications involving effluent filtration or in electrodialysis
[3317] Made in accordance with this invention, carbon nanotubes can also be decorated with hydroxy-carbon groups 6423h (CNT-P(OH).sub.2). These functional groups impart flame-retardant properties to CNTs, enhancing the fire safety of membranes, and improve compatibility of CNTs with other materials, such as polymers, enhancing the overall performance of composite membrane containing CNTs as permanent filers. Unlike the inert carbon surface of a pristine CNT, hydroxy-phosphorus groups can participate in numerous chemical and electrochemical reactions useful in tailoring membrane properties.
[3318] In another class of embodiments the CNTs are functionalized only by hydroxide (CNT-OH) groups without the added phosphorus. By themselves, hydroxyl groups enhance the biocompatibility of CNTs, making them more suitable for biomedical applications and also improve the mechanical properties of CNT composites by promoting bonding between the CNTs and the polymer matrix. Hydroxyl-functionalized CNTs also exhibit improved thermal stability, making them suitable for applications that require high-temperature resistance. By acting as catalytic sites, hydroxyl groups enhance the catalytic activity of CNTs in various chemical reactions. Hydroxyl-functionalized CNTs can be used in environmental applications such as pollutant adsorption and water purification due to their enhanced reactivity and adsorption capabilities. Both amine (CNT-NH.sub.2) and hydroxyl (CNT-OH) functional groups play valuable roles in enhancing the properties and functionalities of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) for a wide range of applications.
[3319] In another embodiment carboxyl functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNT-C(O)OH) 6423c are used as permanent fillers in ion exchange membranes. Like amino groups, carboxyl groups significantly increase the hydrophilicity of CNTs, improving water permeability in filtration applications and preventing drying out of IEMs in electrochemical applications such as fuel cells. Carboxyl groups also serve as reactive sites for numerous chemical modifications, allowing for the attachment of various functional molecules to tailor the membrane properties. Carboxyl groups can also enhance the dispersibility of CNTs in aqueous and organic solvents, leading to more uniform membrane structures. In one embodiment carbon nanotubes functionalized by a combination of carboxyl groups together with one or more ionomeric acids such as sulfonic acid, phosphonic acid, or others are introduced as permanent fillers during synthesis of an ion exchange membrane. In this scenario the carboxyl group assists in the uniform dispersion of the CNTs throughout the membrane while the acid groups enhance the films conductivity and carrier mobility. Carboxyl-functionalized CNTs can exhibit ion exchange properties, beneficial in water softening and desalination processes and in enhancing IEM efficiency in fuel cells.
[3320] In one class of embodiments, the introduction of acid functionalized carbon nanotubes as permanent fillers in an ion exchange membrane offers a number of advantages to film properties including improved conduction and charge transport in a proton exchange membrane (PEM), enhanced hydrophilicity, accelerated catalysis, flame retardancy, corrosion resistance, biocompatibility, improved metal ion coordination, better ion exchange, and improved electrochemical performance.
[3321] Examples of acid functionalized CNTs include sulfonic acid (CNT-SO.sub.3H) 6423s, phosphonic acid (CNTPO.sub.3H.sub.2), and phosphoric acid (CNTPO.sub.4H.sub.2). The presence of sulfur and phosphor acid groups enhances the proton conductivity of CNTs, making them suitable for use in proton exchange membranes for fuel cells. These acid groups significantly increase the hydrophilicity of CNTs, making them more dispersible in aqueous solutions, beneficial for various applications requiring homogeneous dispersion in water and in polar solvents during fabrication. Acid-functionalized CNTs can act as strong acid catalysts in various chemical reactions, including esterification, alkylation, polymerization, and hydrolysis. They are particularly useful in heterogeneous catalysis.
[3322] In other embodiments, acid groups are added as permanent fillers in membranes to better facilitate ion exchange processes useful in water purification, deionization, and softening applications. Acid groups also can enhance the biocompatibility of CNTs, making them more suitable for biomedical applications, and can better coordinate with metal ions, useful in applications like water purification, heavy metal ion removal, and catalysis. Made in accordance with this invention, the incorporation of acid groups can improve the corrosion resistance of CNT-based materials, making them suitable for extended membrane life or used as protective coatings.
[3323] The incorporation of acid functionalized CNTs also improve the flame retardant properties membranes and coatings, making them useful to improve membrane safety and in composite materials for fire-resistant applications. Finally acid functionalized CNT materials and membranes enhance electrochemical properties, making them beneficial for use in energy storage devices such as supercapacitors and lithium-ion batteries.
[3324]
Silicates and Zeolites:
[3325] A silicate is a large family of molecules having the general tetrahedral structure (SiO.sub.4).sup.4 comprising a central silicon atom surrounded by four oxygen atoms. Silicates are derived from a family of charge-neutral molecules called silica, also known as silicon dioxide (SiO.sub.2), comprising a variety of covalently bound molecules such as quartz, cristobalite, and tridymite, which can interconvert at certain temperatures.
[3326] Given the high enthalpy of the silicon-oxygen bond (SiO), silicates are resistant to attack by most acids unless if the presence of HF or NaOH. In the case of HF etching, SiO.sub.2 is oxidized to form silicon tetrafluoride (SiF.sub.4). Silicon dioxide can also be etched with basic hydroxide salts such as NaOH forming sodium silicate Na.sub.2SiO.sub.3 but only at extremely high temperatures. Since HF is not normally present in an fuel cell and operating temperatures are limited, then silicon based molecules are well suited as permanent fillers in the acidic environment of proton exchange membrane (PEM).
[3327] Silica can also form ionized molecules known as silicates. As the quadrivalent anion of silica, silicates invariably form a wide variety of larger molecules, often structurally in the form of crystals, clusters, rings, and chains, containing strong high temperature bonds. These atomically bound quasi-crystals may in turn, maintain a net charge, typically negative, able to participate in ion exchange reactions with protons and cations.
[3328] Replacing some silicon atoms in the three-dimensional superstructure of silicon dioxide by aluminum atoms, forms aluminosilicate known as zeolite. As a subclass of silicates, zeolite combining quadrivalent silicate anion [SiO].sup.4 and the pentavalent aluminate anion [AlO4].sup.5 together forming the silicate superstructure zeolite ([M].sup.+)(AlO.sub.2.sup.)(SiO.sub.2).sub.x(yH.sub.2O) where the metallic-ion [M].sup.+ may comprise monovalent cations such as H.sup.+, Na.sup.+, and K.sup.+; or divalent cations including Mg.sup.2+ and Ca.sup.2+. Examples of zeolite compounds include Na.sub.2 Al.sub.2Si.sub.2O.sub.8.Math.yH.sub.2O, and the naturally occurring minerals gemelinite Na.sub.2Ca(AlO.sub.2).sub.2(SiO.sub.2).sub.4.Math.6H.sub.2O and erionite Na.sub.2K.sub.2CaMg(AlO.sub.2).sub.2(SiO.sub.2).sub.2.Math.6H.sub.2O.
[3329] Because of the presence covalently bound aluminum, zeolite is mechanically strong yet having an electrochemical behavior more metal-like than silicates. It is thereby are used in numerous industrial applications involving ion exchange or as a reaction catalyst, particularly in the processes of cracking, isomerization and hydrocarbon synthesis common in the fossil fuel and petrochemical industries. Because of structural integrity, zeolite makes a good candidate as a permanent filler in a proton or anion exchange membrane, a relatively benign environment compared to its usual applications.
[3330] As depicted previously in
[3331] Formation of silica base nanoparticles may include a number of processes, the most widely of which include spherical colloidal silica systems using the seeded growth of nanoparticles as developed by Stber; using amino acid-catalyzed (AAC) methods; or by employing water-in-oil reverse microemulsion (WORM). Since silica and silicate nanoparticle synthesis are well established, the processes for their formation will not be further elaborated herein.
[3332] As one embodiment of this invention the combination of a stable covalently-bonded silica molecule matrix with high surface density contain immobile reactants such as acids or metals enables the silicate mesostructure to contribute to conduction and catalytic activity without compromising the structural integrity of the silicate permanent filler.
[3333] Similarly zeolite made in accordance with this invention include the zeolite nanocluster 6480 and self-forming zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF) 6481, in the example shown bonded to a polybenzimidazole (PBI) skeleton. Like the aforementioned silicate mesostructures the zeolites offer a stable exoskeletal structure with large surface area and the opportunity to host reactive species within the structure such as a metal catalyst atom shown previously in zeolite nanocluster 2334 in
[3334] Beneficial uses of IEM permanent fillers comprising silicates and zeolites made in accordance with this invention include enhanced ionic conductivity achieved by through the additional pathways for ion transport provided by the permanent filler and by the release of additional charge carriers such as protons donated into solution by ionization of silicate-bound or zeolite-bound immobile acids. In this sense, the nanoparticles act as extra ionomers but do not interfere with the structural integrity of the inert hydrophobic polymer forming the backbone of the membrane. Like carbon nanotubes, silicates and zeolites are able to enhance IEM conduction by creating a denser concentration of immobile anions and mobile cations, but without the added challenge of pretreating its surface to facilitate bonding to the polymeric matrix the way the inert surfaces of CNTs require.
[3335] Other benefits of silicates and zeolites include reinforcing the membrane structure, enhancing its tensile strength and flexibility by creating cross linking bonds to adjacent polymer backbones otherwise not secured to one another. In this manner the fillers improve the microstructure of the membrane by creating a more uniform and interconnected network. Moreover since silicon and oxygen form high energy covalent bonds 6.7 eV (640 kJ/mol), the dissociation temperature is very high, in the range of 600 to 800 C. As this temperature is an order-of-magnitude hotter than the operating temperature of the membrane, the inclusion of silicate and zeolite permanent fillers into a membrane cast or mold prior to polymerization improves the temperature stability of the film, i.e. enabling the membrane to withstand higher temperatures without degradation or leakage. Similarly because of these high energy bonds, silicate and zeolite fillers are impervious to acids, bases, and solvents, thereby improving the chemical resistance of the membrane.
[3336] Overall, the addition of silicates and zeolites into an ion exchange membrane made in accordance with this invention improve the magnitude and selectivity of ion transport, reducing crossover, enhancing efficiency, and reducing waste heat. When added into the CCM catalyst layer or an optional membrane nanocoating, the presence of the silicates and zeolites can improved interfacial charge transfer, enhance catalysis, and provide added protection against the diffusion of gaseous environmental toxins such as nitric oxide (NO) otherwise able to damage or disable catalytic metals.
Zirconium, Tungsten & Transition Metals (TMs):
[3337] As depicted in the abridged periodic table of the elements shown in
d.sub.xy,d.sub.yz,d.sub.zx, d.sub.x.sub.
enabling it to form bonds with various ligands, whereby the zirconium d-orbitals split into multi-levels forming complex bonds with ligands in a manner similar to the mechanisms described previously for a metal-organic-frameworks (MOFs). The d-orbitals also can split enabling the formation of metallic crystals and quasi-crystals, as well as forming various bonds chemical bonds with other compounds and with the polymeric matrix. Because of an ability for electrons in its an unfilled 4.sup.th shell to change orbitals, zirconium that can participate in bonding, electronic transitions, and catalytic reactions. Examples of zirconium forming various electronic configurations as shown include intercalated zirconium 6450, zirconium nanospheres 6451, and zirconium oxide (ZrO.sub.2) 6452.
[3338] Specifically, tungsten (W) with an atomic structure {(Xe)4f.sup.145d.sup.46s.sup.2} contains a filled penultimate shell of 14 electrons, along with four valance electrons in its d-shell, and two more valance electrons in its outer s orbital. The four electrons in the fifth shell can occupy and two of the five possible d-orbitals described previously. This versatile electronic configuration enables tungsten to engage in conduction, catalysis, bonding, and crystallization like zirconium but with a higher density of free electrons. As such, tungsten compounds properly constructed in accordance with this invention exhibit higher conductivity, better ionomeric charge exchange efficiencies, and enhanced charge transport over that of zirconium.
[3339] Exemplary molecules demonstrating the versatility of tungsten made in accordance with this invention include tungsten carbide (WC), tungsten nanoparticles 6471, and phosphotungstic acid 6470. Tungsten has a high density of free electrons, which contributes to its excellent electrical conductivity. Additionally, tungsten has a high melting point and is often used in applications requiring stable and efficient electrical conduction at high temperatures. As such, tungsten molecules made in accordance with this invention when included within a polymeric membrane improves conductivity and mechanical strength of the film.
[3340] Aside from enhancing conductivity and providing structural support molecules, metals, metal-oxides and metallic quasi-crystals comprising transition metals also function as catalysts useful in the synthesis of ion exchange membranes and as electrochemical components in the CCM in the operation of a fuel cell or an ionic filter membrane. For example, as a catalyst zirconium is used for polymerizing alkenes to produce polyethylene and polypropylene, a part of membrane synthesis. Tungsten is also well known for its catalytic properties, especially in reactions involving hydrogenation, dehydrogenation, and other chemical processes. Tungsten's catalytic activity is often enhanced when it is in the form of tungsten carbide (WC). This form is particularly useful in industrial applications such as hydrocracking but may also be applied to ionic membrane filtering.
[3341] In the context of this application, the catalytic properties of tungsten, zirconium, and other catalytic metals can be used in a variety of ways, either in the catalyst layers of a CCM, in nanocoatings of the ionomeric membrane, or within the ionomeric membrane itself. For example, in one set of embodiments a zirconium nanocluster or tungsten quasi-crystal such as tungsten carbide (WC) is introduced into an ion exchange membrane as a permanent filler during synthesis. The role of these membrane permanent fillers within the polymeric matrix is not only to enhance conductivity by increasing the density and number of charge transport pathways to reduce tortuosity, but to secondarily function as a safeguard for reducing fuel crossover. In this function, stray hydrogen escaping the catalyst in the anode and diffusing into the membrane encounters the catalytic permanent filler which converts the hydrogen into protons and electrons thereby increasing the conversion efficiency and reducing risk of hydrogen peroxide formation in the cathode.
[3342] In yet another embodiment, permanent fillers of zirconium and tungsten compounds are added into a nanocoating deposited on the cathode side of the membrane. In this case the catalysts are used to sequester or dissociate environmental gaseous toxins such as carbon monoxide (NO) present in the oxygen supply, generally contained within atmospheric air used as the oxygen source in open cathode fuel cells.
[3343] In other embodiments of this invention, zirconium, tungsten or other transition metal (TM) compounds are used in the catalyst coated membrane (CCM), also known as the membrane electrode assembly MEA3. The addition of the transition metal catalyst into the catalyst layer (CL) promotes more efficient proton generation from hydrogen or methanol in the anode catalyst layer (ACL), a reaction referred to as the hydrogen oxidation reaction (HOR) or hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). For HOR reactions, catalytic efficacy depends on a catalysts metal's ability to adsorb and dissociate hydrogen molecules and facilitate the transfer of protons and electrons. As tungsten in the form of tungsten carbide (WC) exhibits hydrogen catalytic properties similar to platinum, WC is particularly effective in HER due to its ability to adsorb hydrogen and facilitate proton generation.
[3344] The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) at the cathode of a proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) is a key reaction determining the overall efficiency and performance of the fuel cell. Catalysts are crucial for enhancing the efficiency of this reaction. Since the HOR reaction and ORR are complementary reactions in a REDOX reaction pair, the optimum catalyst metal is not necessarily the same. Traditionally, platinum (Pt) has been the most effective catalyst for both HER and especially for ORR due to its high activity and stability. However, due to the high cost and scarcity of platinum, alternative catalysts or enhancing the performance of platinum by combining it with other metals are now needed.
[3345] More generally any non-radioactive non-corrosive transition metal may be used in the catalyst layer of a fuel cell. As described for zirconium and tungsten above and previously in the section on metal organic frameworks (MOFs), transition metals also known as d-block elements are good candidates as catalysts for a variety of reasons including their (i) availability of vacant d-orbitals in an unfilled shell; (ii) ability to manifest various oxidation states; (iii) ability to form transition states in the chemical reaction; and (iv) ability to form complex compounds with the ligands.
[3346] Alternative transition metals described herein include nickel, copper, chromium, cobalt, tungsten, and the abundant elements of iron along with titanium, manganese, zirconium, vanadium, and chromium. Like platinum, the precious metals of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium are rare and therefore more costly.
[3347] In one embodiment of the invention, platinum catalysts in the ACL and/or the CCL are replaced with platinum alloys of platinum-cobalt (PtCo); platinum-nickel (PtNi); and platinum-iron (PtFe). Non-platinum catalysts made in accordance with this invention comprise transition metal-nitrogen-carbon (TM-NC) catalysts coordinated with nitrogen and embedded in a carbon matrix including exemplary metal compounds such as iron (FeNC) or cobalt (CoNC). In another embodiment the catalysts comprise metal oxides such as manganese oxide (MnO.sub.2), cobalt oxide (Co.sub.3O.sub.4), iron oxide (Fe.sub.3O.sub.4), and titanium dioxide (TiO.sub.2).
[3348] As an embodiment of this invention to enhance catalytic activity, especially for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in the cathode catalyst layer (CCL), tungsten carbide (WC) is included either as a primary catalyst or as a co-catalyst used in conjunction with platinum or metal-nitride, or metal-oxide compounds intermixed within in a carbon matrix. WC is advantageous as it emulates many platinum like characteristics including conductance, structural integrity, thermal and chemical stability, but at substantially lower cost.
[3349] In another set of embodiments zirconium is included in the catalyst layer, not as a primary catalyst but as a co-catalyst. Doping pure zirconium into transition metal (TM) catalysts can improve the overall mechanical stability and electronic properties of the catalyst layer while enhancing dispersion and uniformity of the active sites. Zirconium doping of WC stabilizes the carbide phase, preventing the formation of undesirable oxide layers that could deactivate the catalyst. Zirconium also enhances resistance to corrosion and oxidation, extending the catalyst's operational lifespan. Together, Zr-WC exhibits modified surface properties such as increased surface area, increased active site density, and better adsorption and activation of oxygen molecules, important for efficient oxygen reduction reactions.
[3350] In another embodiment zirconium oxide (ZrO.sub.2) is added to support for platinum or other transition metals, providing stability and enhancing the dispersion of the catalytic particles. Alternatively, incorporation of ZrO.sub.2 into tungsten carbide provides a high surface area support structure for WC nanoparticles, enhancing the surface area and maximizing the number of active sites available for ORR. The strong interactions between ZrO.sub.2 and WC also enhance the stability of the catalyst, preventing aggregation and sintering of tungsten carbide nanoparticles under operational conditions while enhancing catalysis. ZrO.sub.2, known for its excellent chemical stability and resistance to acidic and basic environments, thereby protects the active WC catalyst sites from harsh conditions often encountered in fuel cells and other electrochemical systems, prolonging the catalyst's life. Moreover, ZrO.sub.2 has a high oxygen storage capacity facilitating a steady supply of oxygen to the active catalytic sites during the ORR.
Metal-Organic-Frameworks:
[3351] Made in accordance with this invention metal organic frameworks (MOFs) such as exemplary MOF quasi crystals 6460, zirconium metal clusters 6461, metal clusters 6462, and MOF prisms and lattices 6463 shown in
[3352] In accordance with this invention the elements controlling conduction, chemical bonding, and catalytic activity can be independently selected or even combined within the same MOF. For example a MOF used as a permanent filler in an IEM or PEM can include ionomeric groups or acids to enhance conductivity, but can also include catalyst used to suppress fuel crossover. Alternatively a nanocoating may include MOFs containing both scavenger metals preventing nitric oxide (NO) poisoning and active catalyst metals such as platinum to enhance reaction rates and conversion efficiency.
Nanostructures:
[3353] Made in accordance with this invention, various nanostructures are employed to modify the structure, stoichiometry, porosity, chemical reactivity, mechanical strength, durability, thermal resistance, electrical conductivity, and other material properties. Various embodiments of nanostructures used as permanent fillers made in accordance with this invention as depicted in
[3354] All the nanostructures described herein may be added into the polymer matrix during molding as permanent fillers; may be used as a component of membrane nanocoatings; or may be an additive to CCM catalyst layers. These nanostructures may be applied separately or combined with skeletal membrane support, the sacrificial pore process, with any other permanent filler. They may included in homo-ionomer and hetero-ionomer films comprising any described polymer, hybrid polymer, copolymer, or block polymer.
[3355] Nanofibers (NF)Made in accordance with this invention, one class of nanostructure is a nanofibers may be used to directly form a membrane or may be used to as a permanent filler within a membrane comprising a copolymer The nanofibers may form a entangled web with a copolymer whereby material strength is increased even if the two polymers do not chemically bond to one another. In another embodiment the nanofibers 2401 are fabricated using electrospinning and subsequently gently crushed 2402 to reduce the average length of the nanofibers 2401m before loading them into the mold for casting as depicted in
[3356] This sequence controls the average length of the fibers to prevent their protrusion from the molded film without crushing them so finely they change into a powder. Made in accordance with this invention polymers able to form reasonably strong extruded or electrospun fibers including polyurethane (PU); polypropylene (PP); polyimide (PI); and poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET). Other polymers such as polystyrene (PS); polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC); poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA); and polycarbonate (PC); while able to be functionalized by ionomeric groups do not form strong flexible nanofibers and are less adaptable for extrusion or electrospinning processes.
[3357] Polyurethanes (PU) offer excellent mechanical properties able to form strong extruded or electrospun fibers in textiles and gauze, medical devices, and elastomers. As described previously polyurethanes can be functionalized by incorporating ionomeric groups by modifying the polymer backbone or by adding functional groups during the polymerization process.
[3358] Polypropylene (PP) comprises strong nonwoven fibers with good tensile strength and chemical resistance. Polypropylene however is relatively inert and nonpolar, making it challenging to functionalize with ionomeric groups after synthesis except by grafting techniques. Other PP as described previously must be functionalized by blending with co polymers that contain ionomeric groups.
[3359] Polyimides (PI) offer excellent thermal stability and mechanical properties able to form strong nanofibers applicable for high-performance applications such as aerospace and electronics. Polyimides as described herein can be functionalized by incorporating ionomeric groups during the polymerization process using monomers that contain functional groups or in subsequent processing by post-polymerization modification.
[3360] Poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) is a thermoplastic polymer offering excellent mechanical properties and chemical resistance able to produce fibers for textiles, such as polyester fabrics, and for industrial applications like tire cords. Made in accordance with this invention PET can be adapted for nanofiber based membranes and permanent fillers via functionalizing it during copolymerizing with monomers that contain ionomeric groups or alternatively by surface modification techniques, enhancing its conductivity, adhesion properties, and compatibility with other materials.
[3361] While many polymers can be polymerized by a casting process into a thin membrane and functionalized by ionomeric groups, far fewer polymers are well suited for extrusion or electrospinning to form nanofibers. For example, polycarbonate (PC) offers high impact resistance and optical clarity. While not well suited to form fibers, it is still well suited for applications such as eyewear lenses, automotive components, and electronic devices including quasi rigid membranes in high temperature fuel cells. Polycarbonate can be functionalized by incorporating ionomeric groups during its molding process. Poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), also known as acrylic, is a transparent thermoplastic often used as a lightweight and shatter-resistant alternative to glass. Although it can form fibers it is better suited for applications such as optical devices, lenses, and displays. Nonetheless PMMA can be functionalized by copolymerizing with monomers that contain ionomeric groups or by surface modification techniques, enhancing its material properties such as improving its adhesion to other materials or increasing its hydrophilicity.
[3362] Polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC) is beneficial for its barrier properties and not as useful to form strong flexible fibers but is still applicable in rigid filter membranes. PVDC can be functionalized by copolymerizing with other monomers that contain ionomeric groups thereby improving its compatibility with other materials and enhance its properties for specific applications. Another polymer, polystyrene (PS) is generally brittle and does not form strong fibers. It is more commonly used in applications where rigidity is required, such as packaging and insulation. Although polystyrene can be functionalized it requires steps involving sulfonation or by copolymerizing it with other monomers that contain ionomeric groups. For example as shown in poly sulfonated polystyrene nanofiber (P(sPS) NF) matrix 2035 in
[3363] Coated CompositesIn another class embodiments involving nanostructuring, polymer nanofibers (NF) 6461 shown in
[3364] After synthesis, the fibers are coated by various beneficial materials including a nanoparticle slurry of PTFE and PFSA molecules, by alloys or oxides of transition metals and catalysts such as platinum, by cross linkers and molecular glues such as glutaraldehyde, by polymer bonding agents such as polydopamine and reduced graphene oxide (rGO), or by various ligands. Coating may be performed by soaking the fibers in a liquid suspension; by deposition using sputtering or chemical vapor deposition (CVD); or by ultrasonic spray coating. Subsequent annealing depends on the materials employed where molding and cross linking of the nanofibers may precede the coating process or be performed after coating.
[3365] For example if the coating includes a suspension of PFSA and PTFE nanoparticles, subsequent thermal processing may be performed at a higher temperature used in polymerization and cross linking reactions, e.g. between 125 C. and 250 C. In other applications, the coating is only dried generally at temperatures between 25 C. and 60 C. While the nanocoating may comprise catalytic or ionomeric functional groups, in biofilters it may also include polydopamine (PDA) to improve biocompatibility of graphene nanofibers (GNs) or include antibacterial coatings such as tetracycline hydrochloride.
[3366] In one embodiment chitin nanofiber modified by surface modification with polydopamine produces nanofiber-polydopamine composite able to remove dyes such as methyl blue and various metals such as Fe.sup.3+, Mn.sup.2+, Cu.sup.2+, and Ni.sup.2+ from wastewater. In one embodiment the filter membrane is reinforced by the endoskeleton described herein to provide added mechanical support. Other nanocomposites 1964 in
[3367] Metal & Metal-Oxide Nanoparticles (NPs)In another set of embodiments made in accordance with this invention metal or metal oxide nanoparticles 6442 are included either discretely as permanent fillers loaded in the membrane prior to molding or attached to carbon nanotubes. Examples shown previously in
[3368] PMMA NanospheresAside from its role as a polymer, poly(methyl methacrylate) is also able to form nanospheres (PMMA NS) 1723 described in
[3369] The addition of PMMA nanospheres made in accordance with this invention also enhances the mechanical strength and durability of PEMs. This is particularly important for the longevity and reliability of fuel cells often subjected to harsh operating conditions. PMMA nanospheres as described increase the thermal stability of PEMs rendering membranes more resistant to degradation at higher temperatures which is beneficial for fuel cell performance and lifespan. In direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs), PMMA nanospheres help reduce methanol crossover from the anode to the cathode, crucial for maintaining the efficiency and performance of the fuel cell.
[3370] PMMA nanospheres made in accordance with this invention also enhance the water retention capabilities of PEMs. Proper hydration is essential for maintaining high proton conductivity. PMMA nanospheres help retain water within the membrane, especially under low-humidity conditions. PMMA nanospheres can be easily functionalized with various chemical groups. This allows for the tailoring of the membrane properties to meet specific requirements, such as enhancing compatibility with other membrane components or improving specific performance metrics. PMMA nanospheres can be uniformly dispersed within the polymer matrix of the PEM. This uniform distribution helps in achieving consistent performance across the entire membrane, preventing localized weaknesses or failures. Moreover, PMMA nanospheres are chemically stable and resistant to various chemical environments. This stability ensures that the PEM maintains its integrity and performance over time, even in the presence of reactive species. And because PMMA is relatively inexpensive compared to other nanomaterials incorporating PMMA nanospheres into PEMs offers a cost-effective way to enhance ionomeric properties without significantly increasing the overall cost of the fuel cell.
[3371] Examples of PPMA nanosphere used as permanent fillers include sulfonated poly(methyl methacrylate) (sPMMA) 1745 in
[3372] Nano-barrierIn one embodiment of this invention shown in
Polyhedral Silsesquioxanes:
[3373] Another category permanent filler made in accordance with this invention comprises polyoctahedral and double decker silsesquioxanes POSS 6490 and DDSQ 6491 shown in
[3374] For one thing, POSS and DDSQ are hydrophilic improving hydration and correspondingly enhancing conductivity. The presence of hydrophilic groups also create more pathways for proton transport and reduce the tortuosity of conduction pathways. The nanoscale dispersion of POSS within the polymer matrix also forms well-defined proton-conducting channels, further improving the overall conductivity of the membrane. Proper water management is essential to prevent membrane dehydration and ensure stable operation.
[3375] In another embodiment of this invention, the addition of POSS and DDSQ and permanent fillers enhance the film's mechanical properties including durability, strength, thermal, and chemical stability. The incorporation of POSS into PEMs significantly enhances a membrane's mechanical strength and durability due to the rigid cage-like structure of POSS, which reinforces the polymer matrix. POSS molecules also improves the thermal stability of PEMs, making them more resistant to high temperatures important for efficient operation of fuel cells. POSS also improves the chemical stability of PEMs by providing resistance to oxidative and hydrolytic degradation important in the harsh operating environments of fuel cells, where the membrane is constantly exposed to reactive species. By enhancing the chemical stability, POSS-modified PEMs achieve longer operational lifespans, improving reliability in mission critical applications, reducing the frequency of membrane replacement, and lowering overall maintenance costs.
[3376] In general, POSS molecules can be functionalized with various organic groups, allowing for the customization of the PEMs' properties to suit specific applications. This functionalization can be used to optimize proton conductivity, mechanical properties, and compatibility with other components of the fuel cell. The ability to tailor the properties of POSS-modified PEMs makes them versatile for different types of fuel cells, including those operating at different temperatures and humidity levels.
Ionic Liquids.
[3377] If a cation or anion is mobile, it modulates the conductivity of any material in which it is introduced. Rather than relying on ionization of membrane acids, mobile ionic charges are introduced into membranes by infusing the material with ionic liquid. Ionic liquids are ionic salts, typically with an organic compound forming a cation and a halogen as anion. Since ionic liquids include both a positively charged cation [IL.sub.c].sup.+ and a negatively charged anion [IL.sub.a].sup., the introduction of an ionic liquid into a ion exchange membrane improves the conductivity of both PEM and AEM types, a topic discussed in the following section
[3378] Specifically to enhance proton conduction in a proton exchange membrane (PEM) also known as a cation exchange membrane, the cations [IL.sub.c].sup.+ present in an ionic liquid used to dope a PEM film increases the concentration of positively charge ions in the matrix thereby enhancing conductivity. The added charge density reduces the film's resistivity across the spectrum of usable current densities, improving conductance and conversion efficiency without provoking a commensurately proportional increase in hydration and membrane swelling. Ionomeric polymer membranes doped with ionic liquids enhance proton density and improve conductivity. For IL doping of proton exchange layers, the magnitude of conductivity modulation depends on the concentration of IL doping and on the chemical species of the IL cation compound but not on the anion composition. A sample of possible IL cations able to be complexed in ionic salt precursors of various ILs include a variety of species depicted in
[3379] Ionic liquid cation include cyclic rings with single radical extensions pyridinium 2632 and thiazolium 2636. Pyridinium 2532 comprises an aromatic conjugate acid of pyridine and ionic liquid cation having the chemical formulation [C.sub.5H.sub.5NH].sup.+ abbreviated as [Pyr].sup.+. Thiazolium 2636 comprises a protonated form of thiazole, a 5-membered heterocyclic sulfur-nitrogen compound and ionic liquid cation having the chemical formula [C.sub.3H.sub.4NS].sup.+ and abbreviation [Tz].sup.+.
[3380] ILs comprising diradical extensions from a cyclic ring include imidazolium 2630, pyrrolidinium 2631, and piperidinium 2637. Imidazolium 2630 comprises a protonated form of an organic aromatic heterocycle imidazole and ionic liquid cation with a chemical composition [C.sub.3N.sub.2H.sub.3].sup.+ abbreviated as [Im].sup.+. Pyrrolidinium 2631 comprises a protonated form of organic amine heterocycle pyrrolidine and ionic liquid cation having a chemical formulation [(CH.sub.2).sub.4NH.sub.2].sup.+ and the abbreviation [Pyrr].sup.+. Piperidinium 2637 comprises a protonated form of the heterocyclic methylated amine piperidine and ionic liquid cation having the chemical formulation [C.sub.5H.sub.12N].sup.+ abbreviated as [PipH].sup.+.
[3381] A triradical IL with a central core is sulfonium 2635. Sulfonium comprises a positively charged organosulfur compound and ionic liquid cation with a chemical formula [SR.sub.3].sup.+ comprising three organic substituents R attached to a central sulfur core.
[3382] Tetrahedral ILs include ammonium 2663a, quaternary ammonium 2663b, and phosphonium 2634. The subclass ammonium comprises a positively charged polyatomic ion of ammonia and ionic liquid cation 2663a having the chemical formulas [NH.sub.4].sup.+ or as a quaternary ammonium cation 2663b with the form [NR.sub.4].sup.+ where R represents one or more hydrogen atoms replaced by organic groups or other compounds. Phosphonium comprises a positively-charged tetrahedral polyatomic ion and ionic liquid cation having the chemical formula [NR.sub.4].sup.+ where R represents a hydrogen atone or an alkyl, aryl, or halide group.
[3383] Protonated hydrocarbons (carbonium cations) comprise a broad class of positively charged protonated hydrocarbon solvents and ionic liquid cations referred to collectively as alkali carbonium aka alkanium 2638 including methanium, protonated methanol, ethanium, protonated ethanol, propanium, protonated propanol, butanium, protonated butanol, octonium, protonated acetone, protonated acetonitrile, protonated dimethyl sulfoxide [(DMSO)H].sup.+, protonated toluene, protonated aniline, and others.
[3384] Biochemical cations comprise a diverse class of positively-charged and protonated organic compounds formed by or participating in biochemical reactions including carbonium (described above) and protonated choline, aka cholinium 2639 along with protonated creatine, protonated arginine, protonated lysine, protonated histidine, etc.
[3385] Other ionic liquids include superbase cations result from superbase reactions where a strong base such as ammonium, phosphonium, sulfonium, phosphazene, amidine, guanidine, and other onium ions becomes protonated forming IL pairs or releasing the sequestered protons thereby influencing ionic conductivity.; and,
[3386] Poly ionic liquids comprising copolymers of ionic salts exemplified by vinyl functionalized imidazolium and by vinyl pyrrolidinium 2640 including numerous variants mirroring those of their fundamental cation radical offer added control over ionomeric conductivity, thermal stability, and changing hydration.
[3387] Many but not all cations of ionic liquids comprise onium ions representing a broad class of cations derived from neutral molecules through the addition of a proton (H.sup.+) or other cations. Onium ions contain a central atom, often of nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, or oxygen, carrying a positive charge. Of the foregoing, some cationic superbases are onium ions, but not all superbases are onium ions.
[3388] In one embodiment shown in
IEM Applications.
[3389] The applications of the foregoing inventions are nearly unlimited including primary power generation for fixed infrastructure such the power grid; for locally generated power for residences, offices, factories and hospitals; and in mobile power solutions for vehicular power in transportation including electric powered cars, trucks, trains, airplanes, and drones. Other mobile applications include portable generators, remote location power, and ad hoc emergency power networks.
[3390] Embodiments made in accordance with this invention include the individual elements of a fuel cell or electrolysis system, the processes used to fabricate the elements, the inventive benefits of combining these elements into a energy conversion device such as a fuel cell or electrolysis system, and the augmentation of an energy conversion device to store electrical charge as part of the energy conversion process. Examples of buffer augmented energy conversion devices made in accordance with this application include for example, intelligent buffered fuel cells and buffered electrolysis systems.
[3391] Applications of the IEMs made in accordance with this invention include: [3392] Fuel cells that convert a fuel source into electricity by the transport of positive charges such as hydrogen across an IEM membrane, and storing the generated electric charge in an electrical buffer comprising an array of super capacitors or electrochemical cells such as lithium ion or sodium ion batteries. IEMs that conduct positive ions across the membrane are referred to as proton exchange membranes having the acronym PEM or alternatively as cation exchange membranes. [3393] Fuel cells that convert a fuel source into electricity by the transport of negative charge ionized molecules such as hydroxyl across an IEM membrane, and storing the generated electric charge in an electrical buffer comprising an array of super capacitors or electrochemical cells such as lithium ion or sodium ion batteries. IEMs that conduct negative ions across the membrane are referred to as anion exchange membranes having the acronym AEMs. [3394] Electrolysis using electricity to convert a reactant such as water, methane, or glucose into a fuel source such as hydrogen by the transport of positive charges across an IEM membrane, where the electrolytic process is powered by a source of electrical power such as grid power, solar PV generated power, or from electric charge stored in an electrical buffer comprising an array of super capacitors or electrochemical cells such as lithium ion or sodium ion batteries. IEMs that conduct positive ions across the membrane are referred to as proton exchange membranes having the acronym PEM or alternatively called cation exchange membranes. [3395] Electrolysis using electricity to convert a reactant such as alkaline solutions or potassium hydroxide into a fuel source such as hydrogen by the transport of negative charges such as hydroxyl ions across an IEM membrane, where the electrolytic process is powered by a source of electrical power such as grid power, solar PV generated power, or from electric charge stored in an electrical buffer comprising an array of super capacitors or electrochemical cells such as lithium ion or sodium ion batteries. IEMs that conduct negative ions across the membrane are referred to as anion exchange membranes having the acronym AEMs. [3396] Electrodialysis, the process of electrochemical separation of ions in aqueous solutions using IEMs driven by the application of an electrical potential. Dialysis methods relying on IEM separation include Donnan dialysis, reverse electrodialysis, and electro-electrodialysis. Dialysis may used PEM proton exchange membranes or AEM anion exchange membranes (AEM) depending on the compounds being separated. [3397] Electrochemical filtering, the process where an ionomeric filter membrane containing polymeric bound immobile anion or cation groups along with various catalysts is used to remove pollutants including particulates, solvents, metals, heavy metals, salts, and other contaminants from water or from wastewater. Electrochemical filtering is an important process in wastewater management and water recycling. [3398] Desalination, the process where an ionomeric filter membrane is used to attract, capture and ultimately remove salts from seawater in order to produce fresh water. [3399] Deionization, the process where ionized salts and organics are removed from water using an ionomeric filter membrane containing polymeric bound immobile anion or cation groups along with various catalysts. Deionized water is the reactant used for hydrolysis of water into hydrogen.
Buffered Fuel Cell.
[3400] In contrast to a conventional fuel cell, inventive benefits of the buffered fuel cell made in according with this invention is its ability to decouple, i.e. isolate the electrical performance of a fuel cell from electrical loads it powers. Instead, the electrical load 5015 draws its power from the electrical energy storage buffer 5104, and the fuel cell shown here as a fixed array 5001 supplies power to charge and refresh the buffer by converting fuel 5005 into electricity. The load does not however directly draw power from the fuel cell. Represented in a simplified schematic shown in
[3401] Electrical load 5015 in turn draws its power from energy storage buffer 5014. In this manner energy is passed through the buffer, allowing the charging current and charging rate of the buffer to be lower than the load current and slower than the buffer's discharge rate. During rapid load transients the lower impedance electrical storage is nearly able to supply current to the load while the recharging of the depleted charge is slower because of the higher impedance of the fuel cell. This phase delay means the majority of the electricity formed in the fuel cell is not supplied directly to the electrical load but instead flows through the electrochemical cell. For example a PEM may exhibit 1.2 of electrical resistance per cm.sup.2 of active membrane area, i.e. having a specific resistance of [R.sub.FC A.sub.FC]=1200 mcm.sup.2. Current densities of PFSA membrane based hydrogen fuel cells range from [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=200 mA/cm.sup.2 to 1000 mA/cm.sup.2 not counting for thermal limitations.
[3402] In contrast, a lithium ion battery in an 18650 form factor comprises a cylindrical cell with a radii of 0.9 cm and a circular cross sectional area of 2.5 cm.sup.2 with a typical resistance of R.sub.bat50 m for a specific resistance of [R.sub.bat A.sub.xs]=120 mcm.sup.2, having specific resistances roughly one order-of-magnitude lower than fuel cells. Operating at a nominal current of I.sub.bat3000 mA, the current density of the electrochemical cell is approximately [I.sub.bat/A.sub.xs]=(3000 mA)/(2.5 cm.sup.2)=1200 mA/cm.sup.2, 20% higher than the highest fuel cell current density running hot, i.e. generating significant heat, and roughly 6 the current density of a fuel cell running in cool mode, i.e. at current densities of 200 mA/cm.sup.2. From an application perspective this comparison is meaningful volumetrically as the cross section area A.sub.xs of a battery is analogous to the surface area of the fuel cell A.sub.FC. Electrochemically however, the comparison is not accurate as the true surface area of the separator is not 2.5 cm.sup.2 but approximately 2000 cm.sup.2 comprising a 20 m thick film rolled up into a tubular shape over one hundred times to fit within the battery's cylindrical can.
[3403] So long that the buffer doesn't become fully depleted during a high-current load condition, then on-average the buffer will recover during intervals where the load current is lower allowing replacement of the lost charge. In this sense the buffered fuel cell comprises two half circuits with different impedancesthe high impedance loop formed by the fuel cell array 5001, QXR charge transfer regulator 5013, and energy storage buffer 5014; and a second low impedance loop formed between energy storage buffer 5014 and electrical load 5015.
[3404] To prevent damage to the fuel cell and energy buffer cells, certain protective functions are required. QXR charge transfer regulator 5013 performs necessary functions of (i) preventing excessive current draw from fixed fuel cell array 5001, (ii) preventing excessive charging currents into energy storage buffer 5014, and (iii) and preventing overcharging of the buffer resulting in an overvoltage condition on the buffer cells. The functions of QXR charge transfer regulator 5013 can be realized using discrete components, by combining current limiters with a voltage regulator, by employing current limited voltage regulators, or by adapting a battery charger. In essence, the QXR performs two dutiesto ensure the fuel cell doesn't overdrive or overcharge the buffer and that the buffer doesn't draw more current than the fuel cell can reliably supply.
[3405] Overcharging a lithium battery by charging at too fast of a rate or charging to too high a voltage can result in excess heating, venting or leakage of its electrolyte, fire, or explosion. By contrast, drawing too much current from a fuel cell while capable of causing excess heating, is more limited by voltage sag, specifically where the fuel cell voltage drops dramatically above a certain current density. Although the physical mechanisms are many, the precipitous decline in a fuel cell's voltage is in part due to water logging in high-humidity environments and drying out under arid conditions
[3406] Aside from current limiting provided by QXR 5013, another method to reduce excess power dissipation in a fuel cell stack is to dynamically vary the electrical topology of the fuel cell stack. This advanced feature of a buffered fuel cell is to replace a fixed topology of fuel cell array 5001 with an electrically reconfigurable dynamic array 5001d as shown in
[3407] Electrically the number of series connected cells n determines the voltage of the fuel cell stack nV.sub.FC where the voltage of a single fuel cell V.sub.FC is a function of humidity, temperature, and current density. For example, if the voltage of the fuel cell stack in a dry climate drops too low to adequately charge a lithium ion battery, i.e. with a voltage nV.sub.FC3.5V then additional cells can be connected in series to increase the stack voltage, e.g. by increasing from n=8 cells to n=10 cells.
[3408] Conversely, if the voltage of the fuel cell in a humid environment exceeds the maximum safe buffer overcharge voltage V.sub.OC4.2V to a voltage higher than the ability of QXR charge transfer regulator 5013 to prevent overcharging the buffer cells, then the number of series connected fuel cells can be dynamically be reduced to a shorter stack, e.g. reducing the stack from n=8 to n=6. The FCC fuel cell control 5026 unit can perform this function simply by monitoring the fuel cell stack voltage either with a circuit comprising discrete comparators and ratioed voltage references, or using an A/D converter.
[3409] Operation of the FCC fuel cell control 5016 unit is described in greater detail in a related patent application Intelligent Buffered Fuel Cell with Low Impedance incorporated by reference herein. Rather than dynamically varying the number of individual active layers in a fuel cell, a more pragmatic method involves organizing the fuel cell stacks into groups called stacks containing fewer layers, for example between 12 and 22 series connected membranes, and then to include or bypass some of the stacks in the array depending on operating conditions.
[3410] In a similar manner the number of fuel cells m connected in parallel can be adjusted to regulate the current output of the fuel cell stack. For example if the load 5015 is rapidly discharging energy buffer 5014 at a rate where the fuel cell cannot replenish, e.g. during operation in dry cold conditions then the current output capability can be increased by increasing the total width of operating fuel cells. If a fuel cell contains two stacks one with width m.sub.1 and the other with m.sub.2 then in the case of insufficient current both fuel cells can be dynamically activated charging the array topology from nsm.sub.1p to ns(m.sub.1+m.sub.2)p and increasing the current from m.sub.1l.sub.FC to (m.sub.1+m.sub.2) I.sub.FC where the fuel cell current per unit area I.sub.FC=[I.sub.FC/A].Math.mA.sub.FC where [I.sub.FC/A] is a design parameter for the fuel cells such as 200 mA/cm.sup.2 and AFC is the area of a unit-cell fuel cell, e.g. 1 cm.sup.2.
[3411] The sensory and decision making operations of FCC fuel cell control 1016 mean the buffered fuel cell is performing intelligent functions, and is therefore referred to as an intelligent buffered fuel cell or iBFC. The intelligence functions may be realized using dedicated electronic circuitry or reconfigurable logic including programmable logic array, microcontrollers, general processor units, or microprocessor based systems. The control algorithms may be stored as autonomous firmware without. dedicated operating system, or using software executed atop an operating system and kernel.
[3412] Another feature of the buffered fuel cell is its ability to electrically protect its buffer array from the outside environment, specifically from electrical load 5015
including conducting excessive load currents, from shorted loads, from reverse conduction, or from over-discharging the buffer. Referring again to
[3413] Instead, if energy storage buffer is to be charged from an electrical source other than its fuel cell, in one embodiment shown in
[3414] Moreover, energy recovery 5018 module conditions various forms of incoming power to make them compatible with the noise free DC power requirements to properly charge the buffer cells. As shown in iBFC block diagram of
[3415] Various embodiment of an intelligent buffered fuel cell made in accordance with this invention, the iBFC offers functionality and performance advantage neither a conventional fuel cell can. Referring to the following comparative table, a conventional fuel cell can generate electricity offering unlimited driving range without the need for charging, has a low weight and has no thermal runaway self heating safety risks while the Li-ion battery is precisely opposite. Conversely a lithium battery is able to store electric charge when a fuel cell cannot, is able to be refreshed from a charger station without the need for fuel, is able to recover waste electrical energy from the environment like from regenerative braking while a fuel cell cannot.
[3416] Even more significantly a Li-ion battery pack is capable of delivery high on-demand power at high currents, albeit for limited durations, and represents a low-impedance stiff voltage source with milliohm series resistances. By contract the fuel cell cannot deliver high currents without experiencing significant voltage drops, i.e. droop, sag, and dropouts. Lithium ion battery packs can and often do exhibit overheating representing a fire hazard and safety risk.
[3417] In contrast, the iBFC offers the best features of both the lithium ion battery and a fuel cell able to deliver high currents into a low impedance load such as motor or a high current DC/DC converter or DC/AC inverter without issue. Moreover, as an omnipower device the iBFC can convert fuel into electricity and store the generated charge or accept electrical power from external electrical power sources including renewable sources such as PV solar or wind; store power from the grid; and capture regenerative energy from motor braking.
TABLE-US-00077 Li-ion Fuel Feature Battery Cell iBFC Generates electricity + + Stores electric charge + + Requires charging + + Fuel resupply increases kWh + + Pluggable, charge station refresh + + Energy recovery (regen braking) + + Unlimited driving range (refueling) + + High current + + Stiff voltage source during transients + + Able to drive high-I DC/DC converter + + Able to drive high-P DC/AC inverter + + Low resistance, low impedance + + Lightweight + + No thermal runaway + + Omnipower input capable +
[3418] Because the buffer in the iBFC uses a small fraction of the cells in a battery powered EV or power wall, the iBFC weighs a small fraction of Li-ion batter packs of comparable energy capacities, and greatly reduces the risk of thermal runaway and battery pack fires. One key feature of this invention is the buffered fuel cell's ability to utilize power from multiple inputseither from fuel such as hydrogen or methanol, electrical energy from the power grid or a backup generator, renewable energy from solar photovoltaic panels or from wind, and energy recovery from regenerative braking, i.e. using a slowing motor to function as a generator recovering its inertial kinetic energy back into electricity.
[3419] One exemplary schematic of an intelligent buffered fuel cell is shown in
[3420] Buffer 5030 contained within iBFC 1025 comprises electrochemical cells 5031a and 5031b, buffer load access BLA controller 5032, and disconnect switch 5035 including bidirectionally blocking diodes 5036. BLA controller 5032 has two electrical inputsa voltage input measuring the potential of electrochemical cells 5031a and 5031b, and a current monitor depicted symbolically by a current sensor signal 5033.
[3421] In operation, electrochemical cells 5031a and 5031b within buffer 5030 are discharged by load 5021 through a loop comprising currents 5027 and 5028. Concurrently fuel cell current 5023 provides charging current 5026 via CI/CV charger 5025 to replenish charge lost during operation. Any voltage or current outside the cell's safe operating area either exceeding the maximum safe current I.sub.max, exceeding the maximum cell voltage V.sub.OC, or discharging below the minimum allowable cell voltage V.sub.ODC results in the automatic disconnection of the cell. In stacked module applications whenever a cell is disconnected from load 5021, bypass MOSFET 5037 is activated to provide a shunt current path 5029 allowing the stacked modules to continue operation despite disconnecting buffer 5030 from the external circuit.
[3422] Like disconnect MOSFET 5035, bypass MOSFET 5037 in its off state is bidirectionally blocking 5038 represented symbolically by back-to-back diodes. The need for bidirectional blocking in the off state is to prevent both normal polarity conduction and to prevent anomalous reverse current conduction, i.e. prohibit electrical load 5021 from acting as a charger to electrochemical cells 5031a and 5031b in buffer 5030.
[3423] One realization of a bidirectionally blocking MOSFET 5060 is shown in
[3424] The function of body bias generator BGG 5065 is to dynamically bias the body potential on terminal B of MOSFET 5060 to prevent diode conduction of source-to-body diode 5061a and drain-to-body diode 5061b. Note that the nomenclature drain is arbitrary in a bidirectional switch as the polarities may reverse based on operating conditions. As such, the terminals are more appropriately referred to S1 and S2. BBG 5065 includes two cross-coupled BBG MOSFETs 5066a and 5066b connecting S1 and S2 to the B body terminal. The gate of BBG MOSFET 5066b is tied to source S1 while the gate of BBG MOSFET 5066a is tied to source S2.
[3425] In operation, when the potential of source S1 is more positive than that of S2, i.e. V.sub.S1>V.sub.S2, then N-channel BBG MOSFET 5066b is biased into an on-state while BBG MOSFET 5066a remains off thereby shorting the body B of power MOSFET 5060 to S2 shorting out intrinsic diode 5061b and reverse biasing diode 5061a. Conversely, when the potential of source S2 is more positive than that of S1, i.e. V.sub.S2>V.sub.S1, then N-channel BBG MOSFET 5066a is biased into an on-state while BBG MOSFET 5066b remains off thereby shorting the body B of power MOSFET 5060 to S1 shorting out intrinsic diode 1061a and reverse biasing diode 5061b. In the manner only which ever body diode 5061a and 5062 are reversed bias remain in the circuit.
[3426] Auxiliary MOSFETs 5067a and 5067b having their gate, source, and body terminals hardwired to the B terminal of power MOSFET 5060 do not switch but function as lower forward dop diodes referred to herein a pseudo-Schottky diodes to prevent the body potential from floating at low bias potentials. Specifically whenever source S1 is more positive than that of S2, i.e. V.sub.S1>V.sub.S2, but at a voltage below the threshold N-channel BBG MOSFET 5066b, the transistor remains off and the potential at the B terminal floats to an intermediate value when V.sub.B>V.sub.S2. By forward biasing the body voltage, the source-to-body barrier potential is reduced thereby lowering the threshold connected MOSFET and reducing its turn on voltage limiting the range in which the body voltage can float and preventing leakage current. In other words auxiliary MOSFETs 5067a and 5067b function analogous to Schottky diodes conducting at a lower voltage than enhancement mode MOSFETs 5066a and 5066b.
[3427] In an alternative implementation shown in
[3428] The gate electrodes 5076 are embedded in a vertically etched trench lined with a gate oxide 5075. The gate oxide may or may not be uniform along the trench at the bottom of the trench or along its sidewall between the trench bottom and the P.sub.body-to-N.sub.epi junction. The device is referred to a DMOSFET because of its double diffused structure, i.e. first diffusing the body P.sub.body 5072 into the epitaxial N.sub.epi layer 5071, then implanting and diffusing the source N+ 5074 within P.sub.body 5072. Because of concentration gradient between body P.sub.body 5072 and epitaxial N.sub.epi layer 5071, most depletion spreading in the off-state extends into the lightly doped N.sub.epi layer 5071 and not into the more highly doped body region P.sub.body 5072. In this manner the device can achieve submicron channel lengths with no short channel effects. Breakdown voltages can range from 15V to hundreds-of-volts with most devices rated at 30V and 60V. Bothe P-channel and N-channel devices are available.
[3429] Using two identical trench DMOSFET devices, a bidirectionally blocking bidirectionally conducting switch with low on-state resistance and superior blocking characteristics can be realized. In one configuration two trench DMOSFET devices 5081a and 5081b are connected in a common source arrangement where the body-to-drain antiparallel diodes 5082a and 5082b are biased in opposing directions to prevent diode conduction between drain terminals D1 and D2. As such, BDS conduction occurs only via the MOS channel under gate control regardless of the connection polarity.
[3430] In another configuration two trench DMOSFET devices 5083a and 5083b are connected in a common drain arrangement. Similarly, in the common drain connection the body-to-drain antiparallel diodes 5084a and 5084b face opposing directions thereby preventing diode conduction between drain terminals D1 and D2.
[3431] In realizing the BLA 1032 buffer load access functions of bidirectional disconnect 5028 and bypass 5029, both MOSFETs 5035 and 5037 shown in
[3432] Because negative terminal is shared, one of the devices can be eliminated simply altering the logic gate truth table. In this compact circuit DMOSFETs 5090b and 5092a are eliminated and replace by DMOSFET 5095. Because the intrinsic antiparallel diode 5096 in DMOSFET 5095 is diametrically opposed to diodes 5091a in the disconnect switch and 5092b in the bypass switch, bidirectional blocking is not compromised. By combining the disconnect and bypass functions two of the four discrete DMOSFETs can be eliminated to realize the BLA function resulting in reduced power loss within the power DMOSFET semiconductor switches.
[3433] The described functions are part of the buffered load access module 5120h in the iBFC intelligent buffered fuel cell 5121 shown in
[3443] Collectively, the various functional modules or blocks comprising energy storage buffer 5120a, intelligent buffer system controller 5120b, fuel cell control module 5120c, temperature control module 5120d, fuel management interface FMI 5120e, humidity control module 5120f, and energy recovery module 5120g comprise intelligent buffer (iB) 5120. As such, the intelligent buffered fuel cell iBFC 5121 can be represented in a simplified form comprising a dynamic fuel cell array 5119, intelligent buffer (iB) 5120, and communication comprising control bus 5122.
Power Dissipation.
[3444] Although the concept of the intelligent buffered fuel cell is adaptable to wide range of electrical applications, it is more efficient to deliver power at higher voltages than at lower potentials. The principle that power delivery is more efficient at higher voltages is universally applicable to all electrical energy sources including the power grid, batteries in BEV battery electric vehicles, and even for the buffered fuel cell as disclosed herein.
[3445] The value of operating at higher voltages can be best understood by using simple electrical network analysis. By representing a real power source using a lumped element model as an ideal voltage source having voltage V.sub.s in series with a lumped element resistor having resistance R.sub.s power transfer and power losses can be analyzed. Assuming a lossless power source, i.e. where =100%, power generated by the idealized voltage source is given by the network branch constraint P.sub.s=I.sub.sV.sub.s=I.sub.sV.sub.s. Similarly power P.sub.L delivered to the electric load is given by P.sub.L=I.sub.LV.sub.L. Power loss in the resistor is likewise given by P.sub.R=I.sub.RV.sub.R.
[3446] If we consider a single-loop circuit containing the three identified components, namely a power source, load, and resistor, then in accordance with KVL Kirchhoff's voltage law the loop voltage must sum to zero, i.e. V.sub.L+V.sub.RV.sub.S=0. By convention the source voltage Vs has minus sign to denote it is a power source rather than an electrical load. Rearranging the equation for the output voltage gives the result V.sub.L=V.sub.SV.sub.R. With lonely one loop, the current in every element in identical meaning I=I.sub.L=I.sub.S=I.sub.R. Given the general equal P=IV, the KVL voltage equation can be rewritten in terms of power as IV.sub.L=(IV.sub.SIV.sub.R) or simply P.sub.L=P.sub.SP.sub.R where power is lost in the resistance in transit to the load. Although many sources of resistance may arise in a power electrical circuit, in most cases the power losses occur in power semiconductor device such as the aforementioned power MOSFETs used in power supplies, disconnect switches, and in power multiplexers.
[3447] Aside from causing unwanted energy losses and lower energy efficiency, power dissipation in the power devices causes unwanted heating. The power MOSFET must survive the elevated temperature from its own self heating or in may burn up. Unfortunately, in the vast majority of power applications, there is never a good source of heat sinking to remove waste heat, especially in surface mounted power MOSFETs which can only remove heat convectively via copper cladding of the PCB printed circuit board, typically deposited to thickness of 70 m corresponding a copper weight of 610 g/m.sup.2, commonly referred to as a 2-ounce copper PCB.
[3448] In low-frequency power switching applications, the power MOSFET is modelled as a constant resistance carrying an average current I=l.sub.ave=I.sub.peakD where D is the duty cycle representing the conduction on-time divided by the total clock period. To determine the temperature rise, parameters include the dissipated power in watts; the resistance in ohms; the maximum allowable junction temperature T.sub.j(max) in C.; the ambient temperature T.sub.a in C., and the ability of the PCB copper to dissipate heat measured by the thermal resistance in C./W.
[3449] Since power loss in the series resistance P.sub.R is given by the relation P.sub.R=IV.sub.R by using Ohm's law V.sub.R=IR we can modify the power loss equation into P.sub.R=I(IR)=I.sup.2R. This relation reveals the important consideration that power loss depend on the square of the current, meaning delivering power from a source to an electrical load at a high current dissipates more power losses and creates more heat than using a lower current and a higher voltage. This factor is the reason the power grid uses a high voltage transmission network, and only drops the voltage locally for residential power.
[3450] As described previously since the power delivered by a power source is given by the relation P.sub.s=I.sub.sV.sub.s=IV.sub.s where =100%, then I=P.sub.s/V.sub.s. Substituting this current into the resistive power loss equation results in the power transfer function describing power loss P.sub.R as a function of source power input power P.sub.s and series resistance Rs, as given by
[3451] This relation is plotted in
[3452] Extending the concept to a 48V supply produces a counterintuitive result. As shown by curve 5143c, a 48V source delivers less power to a load than the 24V supply of curve 5141. As shown by point 5143c, thermal losses of 2 W occurs at 9.4 A. Ideally doubling the voltage should halve the current, maintain the same input power, and improve output power by lower conduction losses I the power MOSFET resistance. Unfortunately the 4-m 30V trench DMOSFET used in a 24V system is not applicable for use in 48V systems. Instead a 60V device must be used.
[3453] The higher blocking voltage requires use of a thicker-more resistive epitaxial layer. In voltage scaling of power MOSFETs the resistance increase by the breakdown voltage ratio raised to the power of 2.5V. Algebraically voltage scaling can be expressed as [R.sub.DSA].sub.2=(V.sub.B2/V.sub.B1).sup.2.5[R.sub.DS1 A].sub.15.3 [R.sub.DS1 A].sub.1. So even though the current is halved and the power loss reduced by .sup.th, the resistance increased by 5.3 resulting in a net loss in performance.
[3454] So limiting the thermal dissipation in a PCB mounted power MOSFET lacking heat sinking is a key design consideration in designing the maximum conducted current in a system. The maximum power dissipation is given by the temperature rise T=T.sub.j(max)Ta and the convective thermal resistance according to the equation
The specific value of thermal resistance depends on the PCB and the semiconductor package design. A sample of various surface mount packages used by power MOSFET is described in the table below. The power levels shown in the table are illustrated on the graph for a A.sub.PCB=(2.5 cm).sup.2 with 610 g/m.sup.2 copper cladding.
[3455] As explained in the prior paragraph, 24V is an especially beneficial voltage for delivering significant power levels. Applications include residential, commercial, transportation, and mobility energy. By delivering power at 24V, currents are reduced six-fold from that of 4V lithium ion battery based systems when delivering the same rated power at a higher voltage. Moreover, at 24V a 4 m power MOSFET can conduct up to 23 A without exceeding the 2 W package power limit, thereby delivering up to 530 W to a load.
TABLE-US-00078 Package T.sub.j(max) Ta T P(max) (W) D2PAK 18.0 C./W 90 C. 25 C. 65 C. 3.6 W DPAK 22.2 C./W 2.9 W SOT-223 27.2 C./W 2.4 W SOP-8 33.0 C./W 2.0 W TSOP-6 47.3 C./W 1.4 W TSSOP-8 60.9 C./W 1.1 W https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/103166/how-does-power-dissipation-for-surface-mount-components-work
[3456] An exemplary circuit,
[3457] Fuel cell stacks 5200a and 5200b are hardwired in series to produce a fixed cell configuration comprising n=42 as shown by curve 5221b. In operation whenever voltage monitor 5205 detects the fuel stack voltage nV.sub.FC falls below V.sub.ref reference voltage 5208, pass transistor 5206b is turned off and pass transistor 5206c is turned on increasing the fuel cell stack by 21 cells so that n=63. By increasing the stack to n=63, the voltage transfer function transitions from n=42 curve 5221b to n=63 curve 5221c.
[3458] As shown in
[3459] The series battery array is connected to load 5204 through a protection circuit referred to as BLA buffer load access 5203. Each cell is contained in battery holder 5258 with contacts applying pressure to eliminate contact resistance without the need to solder wires to the battery terminals which risks battery damage. In the embodiment of
[3460] An exemplary schematic representation of a 24V iBFC module is shown in the top view of
[3461] The entire module is enclosed in encasement 5260 forming wind tunnels 5261 to convectively cool fuel cell stacks 5253t, 5253m, and 5253b. In the example shown, each of the three stacks comprise an rectangular geometry m.sub.FC=200 arranged in an aspect ratio oof 15.513. The active area of the each stack in the fuel cell is m.sub.FC(A.sub.FC)=200(1 cm.sup.2)=200 cm.sup.2. The number of layers per stack as shown varies. In one case the fuel cell comprises three 12-layer stacks with n=36 total PEM+ membranes. In a second case, the fuel cell comprises three 16-layer stacks for n=48 total PEM+ membranes. In a third case, the fuel cell comprises three 21-layer stacks for n=63 total PEM+ membranes.
[3462] The forced-air powered by fan 5251i, transiting the length of the module, and exiting through grating 5251 located at opposite ends of 24V iBFC module enclosure 5260, delivers convective surface cooling along the exposed surfaces of the three fuel cell stacks 5253t, 5253m, and 5253b. The forced-air convective surface cooling of the stacks occurs in addition to internal fuel cell cooling provided by cathode air flow for oxygen delivery or by any dedicated fluid cooling channel carried in tripolar plates internal to each fuel cell stack. Additional cooling may also be achieved by thermal conduction from the bottom surface of each fuel cell stacks in thermal contact with the metallic frame forming support shelves within the module. The metal plate may be actively cooled or temperature regulated.
[3463] In one embodiment the combination of thermal conduction into its backplate, convection across its surface, and forced airflow through its cathode provide three cooperative forms of heat removal from the active fuel cells. By limiting the height of the stacks, the temperature gradient across the stack is limited and heat conduction into the backplane is maximized. In another embodiment the backplane to which the stacks are attached includes embedded cooling such as liquid heat or refrigerant transfer.
[3464] In another embodiment, one-or-more series arrays of electrochemical buffer cells such as lithium ion batteries are connected in series, positioned perpendicular to the baseplate or printed circuit board. The electrochemical buffer cells comprising Li-ion, Na-ion, or other chemistries located along cutline CL identified in
[3465] The buffer array can be expanded to form a battery buffer comprising two series parallel strings 6s2p, three parallel strings 6s3p, four parallel strings 6s4p or more. With a nominal voltage of 3.88V per cell during discharge an a 1 C discharge rate of I.sub.1C=3.2 A, each 6s1p string contains P.sub.bat=6(I.sub.bat)(V.sub.bat)=6(3.2 A)(3.8V)=6(12 W)=72 W per buffer string containing E=72 Wh of energy.
[3466] In the case of parallel connected cells, it is beneficial to metallically strap the cathodes and anodes of parallel cells to ensure they maintain the same voltages. Referring to
[3467] As shown, the array includes bottom metallic straps 5263v, 5263x, top metallic straps 5264w and 5264y connecting an array of electrochemical cells in alternating antiparallel orientations. For example, parallel cells 5525q, 5525r, and 5525s are oriented with anode-up cathode-down while parallel cells 5255t, 5255u, and 5255v are positioned cathode-up anode-down.
[3468]
[3469] Operating at 80% efficiency, each stack consumes 416 W releasing 83 W of heat. By actively maintaining a back plate at 25 C. and limiting the maximum fuel cell temperature to 90 C. means the maximum temperature differential T between the peak allowable PEM+ membrane temperature T.sub.s and the backplate T.sub.bp is T=(T.sub.sT.sub.bp)=(90 C.25 C.)=65 C. The thermal impedance .sub.cond required for maintaining this temperature differential exclusively by conductive cooling while dissipating P.sub.s=83 W is then equal to .sub.condT/P.sub.s=68 C./83 W=0.8 C./W not accounting for any convective surface cooling, cathode air flow convection, or refrigerant cooling. The specifications of an iBFC module therefore may comprise two ratingsone for liquid cooling, the other for air cooling, both for which include thermal conduction into a cooled backplate. Generally. using liquid cooling the ratings are determined by electrical limitations while air cooled operation is primarily determined by thermal considerations. Electrical specifications are calculated as follows [3470] VoltageFully charged iBFC voltage maintains a 24V constant voltage so long that the discharge rate. i.e. load current, is less than the fuel cell 42 A output capability. Although a lithium ion cell is operate down to 0.7V some capacity loss occurs deeply discharging a battery. As such, the minimum rated output voltage V.sub.min of the disclosed module is 22.8V, i.e. V.sub.buf3.8V with the majority of stored electrical energy at or above 23.3V. [3471] Continuous Output CurrentAs specified in the following table, the continuous current output of the a 36s200p fuel cell is 43 amps with real-time refreshing of the buffer. In continuous conduction, the buffer array is in equilibrium with no net energy flow or change in its state-of-charge. As such, the continuous current of the buffered fuel cell is 43 A running at a current density of [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=215 mA/cm.sup.2. In an alternative embodiment the fuel cell can be run at a higher current density by monitoring the internal temperature of the fuel cell and increasing the current appropriately. [3472] PoD Output CurrentPower-on-demand comprises the sum of continuous fuel cell current plus the current supplied when a battery is being discharged at a 1 C-to-2 C rate per buffer string without recharging. At 1 C the buffer can support the current for 1 hour, while at 2 C the buffer can only maintain a discharge current for 30 minutes. The PoD heavy load iBFC current is thereby is specified by the range (I.sub.FC+m.sub.buf(I.sub.1C))I.sub.PoD(I.sub.FC+m.sub.buf(I.sub.2C)). Given a fixed continuous fuel cell current of I.sub.FC=43 and a nominal Li-ion discharge rate of I.sub.1C=3.2 A, the PoD current range for m.sub.buf=1 is 46 A-to-49 A for a 6s1p buffer. The PoD current range for m.sub.buf=3 is 53 A-to-62 A for a 6s3p buffer. The PoD current range for m.sub.buf=.sup.6 is 62 A-to-81 A for a 6s6p buffer. [3473] Transient Output CurrentThe 10 s-transient power current comprises two elements (i) running the fuel cell at a higher current density, e.g. at [I.sub.FC(10 s)/A.sub.FC]=420 mA/cm.sup.2; and (ii) conducting a discharge current in each string of buffer cells at 10 C, ten times the nominal discharge rate for a electrochemical cell like Li-ion, i.e. where I.sub.10C=32 A per string. As such, the ten-second transient current is I.sub.10s=[I.sub.FC(10 s)/A.sub.FC](A.sub.FC)+m.sub.buf(I.sub.10C)=[420 mA/cm.sup.2](200 cm.sup.2)+m.sub.buf(30 A)=84 A+m.sub.buf(I.sub.10c). For m.sub.buf=1, I.sub.10s=84 A+32 A=116 A; or m.sub.buf=3, I.sub.10s=84 A+96=180 A; and for m.sub.buf=6, I.sub.10s=84 A+182 A=276 A. [3474] Continuous Output PowerThe iBFC continuous output power is given by P.sub.out=(I.sub.out)(V.sub.out)=(43 A)(23.3V)=1 kW regardless of the number of series buffer strings m.sub.buf. By the same definition, a competitive lithium ion battery pack's continuous output power is zero. [3475] PoD Output PowerThe power-on-demand output power for the iBFC is P.sub.PoD=(I.sub.PoD)(V.sub.out) where for m.sub.buf=1 (23.3V)(45 A)=1072 WP.sub.PoD(23.3V)(40 A)=1142 W only slightly higher than the continuous power output. PoD deviates from continuous power as the number of series strings m.sub.buf increases. For m.sub.buf=3, then (23.3V)(53 A)=1235 WP.sub.PoD(23.3V)(62 A)=1445 W. For m.sub.buf=6, then (23.3V)(62 A)=1445 W P.sub.PoD(23.3V)(81 A)=1888 W. [3476] Transient Output PowerThe 10 s-transient output power P.sub.10s=(I.sub.10s)(V.sub.out) where for m.sub.buf=1 the pulse power is P.sub.10s=(116 A)(23.3V)=2703 W. For m.sub.buf=3 the pulse power is P.sub.10s=(180 A)(23.3V)=4194 W. For m.sub.buf=6 the pulse power is P.sub.10s=(276 A)(23.3V)=6431 W.
[3477] The table to follow summarizes features on three buffered fuel says comprising three 12-layer stacks of area A.sub.FC=200 cm.sup.2 buffered by electrochemical arrays comprising 6s1p, 6s3p, and 6s6p topologies.
[3478] As described, a buffered fuel cell provides power-on-demand (PoD) at any humidity, but loses its ability to fully refresh itself below a specified humidity depending on the design of the dynamic fuel cell array. For example, for a fuel cell array comprising a total of 36-layers the minimum humidity level is around 75% while for 48-layers the minimum RH is 34%. By contrast, a 60-layer system works down to 27% humidity. Operation of this minimum humidity level, the output is able to maintain 24V or greater and charge the buffer stack to a voltage of at least 23.3V, i.e. 3.88V per cell. As such, a s200p iBFC is able to maintain a continuous output voltage of 23.3V.
[3479] Unlike conventional fuel cells that push power output to its thermal limit and attempt to control power output by regulating gas flows, the iBFC avoids overheating by maintaining a more efficient operating current maintained electronically by the charge transfer regulator and through its fuel cell control circuit. Fundamentally controlling current output through gas flow control is a bad idea as a significant time delay necessarily occurs between sensing a change in electrical loading and adjusting gas flow to react.
TABLE-US-00079 Specification Typical Value Condition Output Voltage, 23.3 V 25 V nV.sub.FC 40 V, Nominal dyn, V.sub.buf = 3.88 V Output Voltage, Range 22.8 V to 25.2 V n.sub.buf = 6, 3.8 V V.sub.buf 4.2 V Output Current, 43 A [I.sub.FC/A] = 215 mA/cm.sup.2, Continuous m = 200, I.sub.buf = 0 Output Current, 46 A to 49 A 6s1p, 1 C-to-2 C PoD (1 h to 30 m) discharge, I.sub.1C = 3.2 A Power-on-Demand 53 A to 62 A 6s3p, 1 C-to-2 C discharge, 3I.sub.1C = 9.6 A 62 A to 81 A 6s6p, 1 C-to-2 C discharge, 6I.sub.1C = 19.2 A Output Current, 116 A 6s1p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, Transient (10 s) I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 180 A 6s3p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 276 A 6s6p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 Output Power, 1000 W buffer equilibrium, Continuous net I.sub.buf = 0 Output Power 1072 W to 1142 W 6s1p, 1 C-to-2 C PoD (1 h to 30 m) discharge. I.sub.1C = 3.2 A Power-on-Demand 1235 W to 1445 W 6s3p, 1 C-to-2 C discharge, 3I.sub.1C = 9.6 A 1445 W to 1888 W 6s6p, 1 C-to-2 C discharge, 6I.sub.1C = 19.2 A Output Power, 2703 W 6s1p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, Transient (10 s) I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 4194 W 6s3p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 6431 W 6s6p, I.sub.10C = 32 A, I.sub.FC/A = 430 mA/cm.sup.2 Power Output/stack, 333 W Surface air flow rate 3 stacks FR > 200 cm/s Conversion Efficiency 80% Cathode flow rate Power Consumption/ 416 W 60 SLPM, 0.08 cm/s stack Conduction into Power Loss, Heat/stack 83 W cooled plate Thermal Impedance .sub.s 0.8 C./W Maximum stack 90 C. Temp T.sub.s Backplate Temp T.sub.bp 25 C. Input Current, 3.2 A 6s1p, 1 C charge Charging (1 h) 9.6 A 6s3p, 1 C charge 19.2 A 6s6p, 1 C charge
[3480] Firstly, adjusting gas flow rates is inaccurate and nonlinear, relying on temperature sensing or other indirect means difficult to calibrate. Secondly, gas flow control using mass flow controllers is imprecise leading large current fluctuations including overshoots and undershoots. Lastly a significant time lag occurs from when a flow is adjusted until when the gas concentration within the fuel cell anode changes and the reaction kinetics change.
[3481] By contrast, so long that a minimum required gas flow is maintained current regulation in the iBFC is entirely electronic. Excess hydrogen flowing into the anode unused in conduction reverts from protons back into gas thereby naturally limiting the proton concentration to precisely match the current demanded by the QXR circuit. The reaction time and current regulation occurs in nanoseconds, orders of magnitude faster than gas regulation. In this way, the iBFC is vastly superior to conventional prior art fuel cells.
24V Stack Design.
[3482] Thermal design considerations play an important if not critical role in architecting and fabricating a reliable fuel cell. As described previously, one way to reduce internal heating in a fuel cell is to control overdrive, i.e. matching the unregulated output voltage of a fuel cell stack to the buffer it is intended to charge. Rather than employing a voltage regulator to control a fuel cell's output voltage, the inventive method disclosed herein uses a dynamically reconfigurable fuel cell stack to produce a quasi-constant voltage, importantly without regulation. By eliminating the need for a large high-current voltage regulator, an additional source of power dissipation and heat generation is eliminated.
[3483] In principle, a dynamic fuel cell changes the number of membranes electrically connected in series within a fuel cell stack to adjust for changing conditions of temperature, humidity, and current and their influence on output voltage. While using switches to include or remove individual membranes from a fuel cell's series circuit may benefit a six-volt array, in a 24V buffered fuel cell each individual membrane represents less than 3% of the output voltage. In a 400V stack, each layer contributes as little as 0.1% to the stack voltage.
[3484] So although dynamically reconfiguring individual ionomeric membranes may reduce waste heat, such an solution is costly and unwieldy to implement on a layer-by-layer basis, especially in higher voltage containing dozens or hundreds of connected layers. Moreover producing a spectrum of custom fuel cells of varying layer counts is inefficient and costly manufacturing. Instead it is advantageous to assemble a fixed-height fuel cell stack reusable in a wide spectrum of fuel cell designs as a standard. In operation, one or more stacks are dynamically switched in and out of the fuel cell series circuit to adjust the fuel cells output voltage.
[3485] Selection of the number of membranes in the stack represents a compromise between too few layers having insignificant impact in controlling losses and requiring too many stack assemblies and too many layers concentrating heat and not limiting the voltage range. As shown previously in
[3486] One solution to reduce heating is to divide the fuel cell into more stacks each with fewer layers. For example by reducing the number of layers from 21 membranes down to 12 layers the heat within the stack is reduced by 43%. Compared to a single 63 layer stack the electrochemically heat generated within a 12-layer fuel cell stack is reduced by 80%.
[3487]
[3488] Concurrently inverter 5207 turns on pass-through MOSFET 5206z connecting stack 5200p in series with stacks 5200q to 5200s resulting in a fuel cell stack 48s120p. In the case where V.sub.FC>V.sub.ref the comparator output of the voltage monitor 5205 is in its high state, representing a digital 1 such as +5V turning on bypass 5206y and disabling pass-through MOSFET 5206z. The resulting network is a series connection of stacks 5200q to 5200s excluding stack 5200p resulting in a fuel cell stack 36s120p.
[3489]
[3490] For all voltages V.sub.FC<0.67V the fuel cell follows the curve 5231w. At V.sub.FC=0.5V/layer, the stack voltage drops to minimum voltage 5220l of V.sub.min=24V corresponding to a lower humidity level of RH=34%. As such, a two-state dynamic fuel cell comprising four 12s120p stacks is able to operate from 34%-to-100% relative humidity over a membrane voltage range from 0.5V-to-0.9V while maintaining a fuel cell stack output voltage bounded between 24V-to-32V.
[3491] This performance is contrasted to a fixed n=48 fuel cell following the dotted line extension of curve 5221w which is limited by a 40V maximum to 24V minimum by humidity within the range of 34% to 98.4%. At 100% humidity the fixed array voltage will rise to 43V exceeding the specific maximum value. Exceeding 40V has several disadvantages including (i) it requires UL safety certification as a high voltage system, (ii) it requires the use of more costly less efficient power MOSFETs, (iii) it generates more heat in the fuel cell, and (iv) it reduces the efficiency of the charge transfer regulator QXR controlling the energy transfer from the fuel cell to the buffer stack.
[3492] For example because the maximum voltage exceeds 40V, charging a buffer stack to 24V using linear charging is only =24V/40V=60% efficient, meaning forty percent of the power transferred is burned in the charger as heat. While excessive power loss can be ameliorated by using a switching charger, the transient current capability of a fuel cell is limited by its high internal impedance. By minimizing the maximum voltage differential V=(V.sub.maxV.sub.nom) between the fuel cell stack and the buffer, charger inrush currents are also minimized, reducing the required current rating of the charger devices.
[3493] As stated previously aside from better managing transient currents, another unique benefit of the stack architecture made in accordance with this invention is heat dissipation. By spreading the membrane generated heat losses across four stacks, the concentration of heat losses is reduced by 75%.
Wide Humidity 24V Fuel Cells.
[3494] To electrically expand the operational range of a fuel cell to function at lower humidity levels, a dynamic buffered fuel cell made in accordance with this invention comprises additional series stacks connected into the series stack only under extremely dry conditions. These extra stacks are disconnected at higher humidity conditions to avoid producing over-voltages. To tailor a dynamic fuel cell to cover the widest humidity range, a number of stacks can be connected in series in varying numbers or combinations.
[3495] As shown in
[3496] Similarly all curves shown drop below the minimum voltage 5220l of 24V within the specified range. Specifically the five curves 5221u, 5221v, 5221w, 5221y, and 5221z reach minimum voltage 5220l at per layer voltages of 0.67V, 0.57V, 0.5V, 0.44V, and 0.4V respectively, roughly corresponding to relative humidity values of 78%, 50%, 34%, 30%, and 27%. Clearly the higher membrane counts of n 48 layers work at lower membrane voltages and humidity levels but exhibit too much voltage at normal humidity ranges. Conversely fuel cells where n 42 avoid the overvoltage problem but can't function in dry air when RH50%. To overcome this conflict, the dynamic buffered fuel cell made in accordance with this invention employs a switched array of fuel cell stacks. This method is much more flexible and less costly than adjusting the number of active layers within one fuel cell stack.
[3497] As shown in
[3498] As depicted for the dynamic FC labelled n={36,60} shown on the left, the corresponding truth table contains three allowed states. In the case (En.sub.u, En.sub.w)=(0, 0) both transistors are in their open off state and the fuel cell stack is cutoff. When signals (En.sub.u, En.sub.w)=(0, 1) pass-transistor MOSFET 5206u is cutoff disconnecting stacks 5200o and 5200p from the stack but bypass transistor 5206w is activated. The resulting fuel cell comprises a fuel cell stack where n=36. When signals (En.sub.u, En.sub.w)=(1, 0) bypass transistor 5206w is disabled but pass MOSFET switch 5206u is active inserting stacks 5200o and 5200p into the network whereby n=60. As such, the fuel cell stack may comprise an array where the number of membranes n may comprise 60, 36 or zero (off).
[3499] The output characteristics of this two state fuel cell stack is illustrated in
[3500] In order to minimize the maximum voltage of the five stack array, an additional state must be added. Returning to
[3501] In the combination where input (En.sub.u, En.sub.v, En.sub.w)=(0, 0, 1), only bypass MOSFET switch 5206w is active whereby the fuel cell comprises stacks 5200q, 5200r, and 5200s and the aggregate fuel cell stack comprises n=36 layers. In the combination where input (En.sub.u, En.sub.v, En.sub.w)=(0, 1, 0), only bypass MOSFET switch 5206w is active whereby the fuel cell comprises four stacks, namely 5200p, 5200q, 5200r, and 5200s, and n=48. Lastly, In the combination where input (En.sub.u, En.sub.v, En.sub.w)=(1, 0, 0), only pass-through MOSFET switch 5206wu is active comprising all five stacks for a net fuel cell stack comprises n=60. The resulting characteristics are shown in the curves of
[3506] The following table compares 24V fuel cell modules comprised of dynamically controlled series-connected stacks to that of a single fuel cell:
TABLE-US-00080 Parameter Fixed Array Dynamic Array FC topology fixed, n = 48 n = 36, 48 n = 36, 48, 60 Number of stacks 1 3, 4 3, 4, 5 Target 24 V 24 V 24 V voltage V.sub.nom Voltage range 19 V to 43 V 24 V to 32 V 24 V to 32 V (over RH range) Humidity range 34% to 98.4% 34% to 100% 27% to 100% Self heating concentrated (+6X) reduced (75%) reduced (85%) Regulator Buck converter none required none required for V V.sub.nom
[3507] Advantages of the dynamic fuel cell using a switched array of FC stacks made in accordance with invention include the following: [3508] maintains a minimum output voltage of 24V over a wide range of operating conditions [3509] limits the maximum voltage of a fuel cell stack to a defined voltage such as 40V or 32V [3510] operates over a wide range of humidity levels from 100% down to 34% extendable down to 27% with a minor increase in component count [3511] eliminates the need for a Buck or Buck-boost converter to charge a battery stack or buffer [3512] reduces heating within a fuel cell by up to 80%
[3513] The enumerated advantages of a dynamic fuel cell comprising a switched array of FC stacks over conventional fuel stack designs are significant in reducing heat, expanding the operating range, and improving reliability. No similar dynamic fuel cell design exists in the literature or in the market.
Heavy Duty Buffered Fuel Cell.
[3514] Another consideration of a fuel cell is instantaneous power output, referred to herein as on-demand power. The ability of a buffered fuel cell to deliver high currents to a load depends on a number of factors namely: [3515] the voltage differential between the fuel stack voltage and the voltage of the electrical load being powered which is a function of the number of membranes per stack, the number of stacks connected in series, and ambient conditions such as temperature and humidity; [3516] the transient and steady-state current demand of the load; [3517] the thickness and composition of the ionomeric membrane; [3518] the active area of the ionomeric membranes A.sub.FC; [3519] the membrane current density I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC e.g. 215 mA/cm.sup.2; [3520] current limiting imposed by the charge transfer regulator (QXR); [3521] the number of parallel strings of battery buffer cells; and [3522] parasitic resistances such as pass-through MOSFETs in the fuel cell array and access MOSFETs in the buffer load access circuit.
[3523] To analyze the relative contributions of these electrical elements in determining the on demand power capability of a given design buffered fuel cell made in accordance with this invention, the power-switch-load topology must be carefully considered. As shown in
[3524] In operation, charge transfer regulator QXR 5301 employs both voltage and current feedback to control the current flowing between the fuel cell stack 5300 and buffer 5302. The current feedback performs two tasks (i) to prevent excessive current from being drawn from the fuel cell stack 5300 causing the stack voltage nV.sub.FC to sag or collapse, and (ii) preventing excessive charging current to flow into buffer 5302 potentially damaging or overheating the electrochemical cells. The value of current transferred may comprise (i) a prefixed value matched to the specific fuel cell stack; (ii) a programmable current adjusted in response to instructions from a iBFC microcontroller, e.g. according to environmental, system, or load requirements; (iii) a two-step response corresponding to different current densities required during steady-state and transient operation; (iv) a feedback controlled current limit adjusted by monitor the temperature in one or more fuel cell stacks using temperature sensor 5330; or (v) combinations thereof.
[3525] While QXR 5301 controls energy transfer between the fuel cell stack 5300 and buffer 5302 the, buffer load access circuit 5303 protects the buffer 5302 from an electrical load 5304 by limiting the peak current output during discharging and preventing the buffer from over-discharge, i.e. when its voltage drops so low that damage can occur to the battery's internal separator film. As shown the current I.sub.FC flowing out of fuel cell 5300 and through QXR 5301 is summed with the current I.sub.buf from buffer array 5302 and delivered to the electrical load through the buffer load access circuit 5303 as load current IL to electrical load 5304 whereby
[3526] In this circuit particular iBFC topology, the QXR fuel cell current I.sub.FC, buffer current I.sub.buf, and load current all connect to summing node 5506, and always balance to a net zero node current. While the fuel cell output current I.sub.FC and the iBFC's load current IL are both positive numbers, the polarity of the buffer current I.sub.buf may be positive or negativepositive during discharging, negative during recharging. From the above equation it follows that during discharge when the buffer current is positive, the load current can exceed the fuel cell's output, i.e. I.sub.L>I.sub.FC. Conversely when the buffer is charging and fuel cell current I.sub.buf<0 is negative, a portion of the fuel cell's current is diverted from the load to the buffer reducing the power available to an electrical load.
[3527] One role of the buffer cell is to smooth out the current fluctuations by supplying extra current to a load when needed and recharging itself when the energy supply exceeds demand. Since periods of high demand are limited in duration, e.g. less than 10 seconds, the transient current rating of a heavy-duty buffered fuel cell (HD iBFC) can greatly exceed its continuous current rating. The expanded operating range however requires a change in the topological circuit for the HD iBFC compared to the standard buffered fuel cell described herein.
[3528] It should be noted unlike in conventional battery packs where a battery disconnect switch (BDS) prevents its batteries both overcharging and over-discharging, in the buffered fuel cell made in accordance with this invention the responsibility for protecting the buffer cells is split between the charge transfer regulator and the buffer load access circuit. As shown, charge transfer regulator QXR 5301 controls the charging rate and prevents overcharging of the buffer 5302, while the role of the buffer load access (BLA) 5303 is to prevent over-discharging of the buffer and over-discharging the battery cells. The BLA also protects against reverse charging where the electrical load acts as a power source and attempts to charge the buffer by having its load current flow into rather than out of the output of the buffered fuel cell.
[3529] The necessity of the split protective functions is obvious topologically. The charge transfer regulator 5201 can only control energy flowing from the fuel cell stack 5300 into battery buffer 5302 because it is interposed between the two. It has no ability to protect the buffer 5302 from electrical load 5304 because it is not located between them. Protecting buffer 5302 from the load is entirely the purview of the buffer load access circuit. Conversely, because the buffer load access circuit 5303 is interposed between load 5304 and buffer 5302, it has no control over charging of the buffer from fuel cell 5300. This distinction is completely different from the battery disconnect switch in a lithium ion battery pack which integrates all cell protection functions aside from charging and cell balancing.
[3530] Reiterating, the conventional buffered fuel cell contains a summing node 5306 where the inbound and outbound currents of the fuel cell stack, the buffer, and the load converge. Ostensibly, in the absence of any interference from charge transfer regulator QXR 5301 or buffer load access BLA 5303 circuitry, under normal operation the three blocks of the standard iBFC shown in
[3531] The net function of the disclosed iBFC s therefore is that of a self recharging battery where the load is completely disconnected from and unaware of the presence of the fuel cell. Likewise the fuel cell never sees the current demand of the load or even aware of its power demands except that it detects when the buffer voltage decays with a lower state-of-charge (SoC). While this architecture of self recharging battery is essentially fool proof from a user perspective, it suffers one major drawbackit cannot invoke extra current capacity of the fuel cell to help supply high current load transients because the charge transfer regulator prevents it from doing so.
[3532] This limitation is better understood by considering the standard buffered fuel cell disclosed herein in the schematic form of
[3533] In this manner the fuel cell stack comprises five 12s120p stacks selectable in combinations of n={0, 236, 48, 60} layers.
[3534] If all three switches are open, no complete circuit path exists in the fuel cell and the device is off. If bypass switch 5310x is conducting and the other switches are off then all the power is generated in 36s120p stack 5310x and n=36. If bypass switch 5310v is conducting and the other switches are off then all the power is generated in the series connected 36s120p stack 5310 and 12s120p stack 5310y and n=48. If both bypass switches are open and pass-through switch 5310u is closed then the all three stacks 5310x, 5310y, and 5310z are conducting whereby n=60.
[3535] Regardless of the voltage nV.sub.FC of the dynamic stack the entirety of the stack's current is fed into charge transfer regulator QXR 5311a comprising two competing dependent current regulatorscurrent source 5312a designed to protect the fuel cell from excessive current and voltage sag, and current source 5313a designed to properly charge the buffer cells 5314. The current source 5313a terminates into the aforementioned summing node 5316 along with buffer 5314 and load 5204.
[3536] To reiterate the role of charge transfer regulator 5311a is threefold, (i) to prevent excessive current from being drawn from the fuel cell stack 5310, (ii) to prevent excessive charging current to flow into buffer 5314, and (iii) to prevent charging the buffer to an unsafe voltage, all while meeting the minimum current requirement for the load. Since the maximum load current I.sub.L(max) can be limited by BLA 5303, the maximum fuel cell demand is known and the fuel cell be designed accordingly.
[3537] In
[3538] The first criteria, preventing excessive currents from flowing from fuel cell stack 5310 depends on the active area A.sub.FC of the fuel cell membranes and the design criteria of a safe current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]. Selection of a target current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC] is an iterative process because fuel cell voltage is a function of current density, i.e. V.sub.FC=f([I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]). Specifically higher current densities reduce a fuel cell's voltage. Despite the voltage sag phenomena, higher current densities also beneficially result in a higher output power but adversely impact self heating, temperature, and reliability. While current densities may run between 200 mA/cm.sup.2 and 1000 mA/cm.sup.2, reliability and overheating concerns favor lower current densities, e.g. where [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=215 mA/cm.sup.2. As one option, higher current values for current source 5312 can be programmed either by limiting their duration, e.g. conducting [I.sub.FC(10 s)/A.sub.FC]=430 mA/cm.sup.2 for up to 10 seconds during a load transient, or by limiting the current in accordance with the fuel cell temperature detected by sensor 5330.
[3539] In order to calculate the fuel cell voltage V.sub.FC at a specific current, the precise relationship between fuel cell voltage and current density must be known in advance. To define the V.sub.FC versus I.sub.FC response surface over variations in temperature and relatively humidity requires an ionomeric polymer must first be fabricated and characterized. Such a curve is often referred to as a polarization curve, a technical misnomer as polarization phenomena is only one of several energy loss mechanisms determining the V.sub.FCI.sub.FC relation. In fact because the depends on the chemistry of the polymer and the fabrication process used to synthesize it, there is no practical means available today to accurately simulate or predict this voltage-current behavior a priori. Once the current density and membrane size is decided, the maximum current of the fuel cell I.sub.FC(max) and the instantaneous power output capability of the fuel cell stack is set.
[3540] In QXR 5311a operation, any current demand exceeding the specified maximum current value will be electronically limited by current source 5310a. Accordingly the current capability of the fuel cell has a maximum value of I.sub.FC(max)=A.sub.FC [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC] with a corresponding maximum power output of P.sub.FC(max)=V.sub.FC I.sub.FC(max)=V.sub.FCA.sub.FC[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC] where V.sub.FC is a function of current. For example, if [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC] is selected to be 215 mA/cm.sup.2 at V.sub.FC=0.7V per layer, for a fuel cell with A.sub.FC=200 cm.sup.2 then the maximum fuel cell current is
As such, the current limit value for current source 5312a can be present to 43 A.
[3541] With a nominal stack voltage of n.sub.sV.sub.FC=(12)(0.7V)=8.3V for a fuel cell stack having n.sub.s=12 layers, the corresponding peak power output P.sub.s(max) is
For a three stack array this corresponds to an output voltage n.sub.FCV.sub.FC=3n.sub.sV.sub.FC=3(8.3V)=25V, a voltage slightly below the Li-ion safe operating area (SOA) limit of 25.2V total or 4.2V per cell. At a voltage of 25V, the fuel cell output includes voltage headroom (V.sub.FCV.sub.buf) needed for charging the buffer array to a nominal voltage of n.sub.FCV.sub.FC=23.3V via current limiter 5313a. During charging, as the buffer approaches its terminal value the voltage differential (V.sub.FCV.sub.buf) declines and the charging current approaches zero.
[3542] In constant voltage (CV) mode charging, a comparator monitoring the buffer voltage by feedback 5331 may be programmed to discontinue charging at a lower voltage, e.g. at n.sub.FCV.sub.FC=23.3V thereby avoiding any safety risks associated with exceeding a Li-ion overcharge voltage V.sub.OC safety limit. Another benefit for discontinuing charge below 4.2V per cell is that battery life studies show that not charging a Li-ion cell to its capacity, i.e. for SoC<100%, has been found to improve the cycle life and use life of the electrochemical cells. In such as case, the output of buffer current limiter 5313a limits the voltage to the nominal fuel cell stack voltage of m.sub.FC(V.sub.FC)=23.3V or V.sub.FC=3.88V per cell in which case the power output of each stack is limited to
and the fuel cell delivers a total power of
[3543] The second criteria for the QXR, to avoid excessive charging currents in the battery is determined by the manufacturer-specified maximum charging C-rate of the cells and the number of parallel strings m.sub.buf in the battery buffer but not by the number of buffer cells n.sub.buf in series in each string. If we define the max charge rate as [I.sub.chg(max)] then the maximum current safely delivered by the current limit for current source 5313
If we assume a maximum charge rate for a Li-ion cell to be 1 C, then for a 3200 mA Li-ion cell the current limit for a single string of six 18650 lithium ion batteries is
and is 6.4 A for a two-string pack where m.sub.buf=2, 9.6 A for a three-string pack where m.sub.buf=3, 19.2 A for a six-string pack where m.sub.buf=6, and so on.
[3544] Since in an iBFC with a single summing node the net current is always governed by KCL to be I.sub.FCI.sub.bufI.sub.L=0, then when I.sub.L=0 the charging current is equal to the fuel cell current, i.e. I.sub.FC=I.sub.buf. This condition means in a QXR comprising a single charge transfer regulator, the maximum fuel cell current cannot exceed the maximum safe charging current so I.sub.FCI.sub.buf(max). Made in accordance with this invention, when the rated charging current of a buffer I.sub.chg(max) greatly exceeds the current handling ability of a fuel cell, i.e. when I.sub.chg(max) >>I.sub.FC(max) or more precisely when
then the fuel cell current I.sub.FC(max) needs to be limited to prevent voltage collapse by selecting a value well below the maximum charging C-rate of the cell. In such cases, buffer current source 5313a can be eliminated and the current limiting of current source 5312a may suffice to protect both fuel cell and buffer, in essence because the fuel cell is too small to harm the buffer. As the equation suggests, this condition occurs only for extremely small fuel cells or those incapable of operating at higher current densities or when driving extremely large buffers from a small fuel cell, a condition referred to as trickle charging. Such cases may however occur in mobility solutions especially those in avionics and space such as drones, aircraft, spacecraft, and satellites.
[3545] The disadvantage of this approach is that the majority of the load current I.sub.L must be supplied by the buffer, not the fuel cell. In other words, during a load condition when I.sub.L>I.sub.FC(max) the buffer must make up the difference as the fuel cell is limited in its current capability. In such case, the load current can be expressed as
so long that buffer cell array doesn't run out of stored charge Q.sub.buf. Rearranging the charge-rate equation C-rate=(I.sub.buf/Q.sub.buf) where C-rate has units of inverse hours, i.e. h.sup.1 and Q.sub.buf has units of coulombs or ampere-hours (Ah or mAh), results in two polarities of buffer current: positive current I.sub.FC>0 flowing from the fuel cell into the buffer during charging, and negative current I.sub.FC<0 flowing from the fuel cell to the load during discharging.
For lithium ion cells, a C-charging rate of CCR=1 is nominal as faster charging can irrevocably damage cells. For discharging C-discharging rates of CDR=1 to CDR=2 are not uncommon. During discharging, the load current as a function of charge storage can be expressed as
One major disadvantage of a fixed-current-limit design implementation is the performance of the iBFC when the usable buffer charge is depleted, i.e. Q.sub.buf=0 and I.sub.buf=0 in which case
In other words, when the buffer current capability greatly exceeds that of fuel cell currents, in a fixed current limit design the only available current when the buffer is depleted is the current-limited fuel cell output I.sub.FC(max). During design, care must be maintained to ensure this current is adequate for the load's continuous power consumption plus some surplus power needed to recharge the buffer in a reasonable time. The minimum fuel cell output current must thereby exceed
Assuming a 10 A load and a Q.sub.buf=20 Ah buffer, a 3-hour recharge rate (CCR=0.33) requires a fuel cell capable of currents I.sub.FC(max)>I.sub.L+(CCR)(Q.sub.buf)=10 A+(0.33/h)(20 Ah)=16.5 A. If however the load current IL exceeds I.sub.FC(max)I.sub.buf(chg), the buffer will not ever find time to recharge. As such, the iBFC will suffer a net energy deficit ultimately where the only power available from the iBFC is limited to the fuel cell's output. In alternative design, a higher current fuel cell is used to drive a much smaller buffer array, whereby
In such a design the fuel cell current I.sub.FC greatly exceeds the ability of the buffer array from conducting, absorbing, and storing the fuel cell generated charge without risking overheating and damage, i.e. I.sub.FC>I.sub.chg(max). Given the KCL condition at the summing node 5316
then in a light load or no load condition where I.sub.L0,
meaning in a single current limiter architecture, the maximum fuel cell current is limited by the buffer 5313a. Applying this condition to the load current equation has a peak power-on-demand current output
For example, a m=200 fuel cell capable of 42 A combined with a 9 A buffer is only capable of 18 A while discharging the buffer. After buffer discharge, the current output drops to 9 A meaning the 42 A fuel cell capacity is totally wasted.
[3546] In one embodiment the buffer array 5314 can be electrically disconnected from the summing node 5316 by a power switch such as a power DMOSFET once it is charged and reconnected only when I.sub.L>I.sub.FC. Although this method allows the iBFC current to exceed the buffer charging current I.sub.buf(max), it can lead to voltage discontinuities and instabilities.
[3547] In more reasonable cases where the two fuel cell and buffer currents are comparable both current limiters 5312a and 5313a may be required whereby the circuit must sense, detect, and adjust the current to the applicable limit dynamically as operating condition or circuit topologies change, e.g. in high load or sleep mode conditions. Current limiter 5312a sets the current I.sub.FC(max) from the fuel cell stack. As a dependent source the current limit value can be programmed at multiple values for example at [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=200 mAcm.sup.2 during steady-state mode and [I.sub.FC(PoD)/A.sub.FC]=400 mAcm.sup.2 during power-on-demand mode. Output current limiter 5316a controls the summing node current. In order to deliver the requisite output current IL to load 5204 and not overcharge buffer array 5314, it is necessary for the dependent current source 5313a to monitor the output current 5332 and to simultaneously to monitor the buffer array current 5333.
[3548] A summary of the dynamic QXR function is shown in the following table illustrating five different operating mode for the iBFC. [3549] Fully ChargedIn the fully charged condition, the net buffer current is zero, I.sub.buf=0 so there is no charge in the charge state, Q.sub.buf=0 meaning Q.sub.buf=Q.sub.max or SoC=100%. During the condition as long a the fuel cell matched the load current I.sub.FC=I.sub.L the buffer charge state will remain constant. [3550] ChargingDuring charging the state of charge SoC of the buffer is increasing Q.sub.buf>0 by an amount Q.sub.buf=I.sub.buft or more accurately Q.sub.buf=I.sub.buf(t) dt, a condition that only occurs when the fuel cell current I.sub.FC is greater than the load current I.sub.L so that I.sub.FC>I.sub.L. The charging mode can be subdivided into two cases, I.sub.FC
[3554] These operating modes are summarized in the following table describing the operating mode (buffer charged, charging, discharged), net change in the buffer charge, fuel cell current, buffer current, and load (output) current of the iBFC.
TABLE-US-00081 Operating Buffer Charge Fuel Cell Buffer Load Mode State Q (Ah) Current I.sub.FC Current I.sub.buf Current I.sub.L fully Q.sub.buf = Q.sub.max, I.sub.FC 0 I.sub.FC = I.sub.L charged Q.sub.buf = 0 charging Q.sub.buf > 0 I.sub.FC (I.sub.FC I.sub.L) = I.sub.FC > I.sub.L +(CCR)(Q.sub.buf) I.sub.FC(max) (I.sub.FC(max) I.sub.L) = +(CCR)(Q.sub.buf) equilibrium Q.sub.buf = 0 I.sub.FC(max) 0 I.sub.FC = I.sub.L discharging Q.sub.buf < 0 I.sub.FC (I.sub.FC I.sub.L) = I.sub.L > I.sub.FC (CDR)(Q.sub.buf) I.sub.FC(max) (I.sub.FC(max) I.sub.L) = (CDR)(Q.sub.buf) fully Q.sub.buf = Q.sub.min, I.sub.FC 0 I.sub.L = I.sub.FC discharged Q.sub.buf = 0 I.sub.FC(max)
[3555] It should be understood by those skilled in the art that the dual function current limit function represented by series current sources 5312a and 5313a shown in
[3556] Another protective function of charge transfer regulator 5311a is its voltage clamping ability. In operation voltage feedback from the output of QXR 5201 monitoring the buffer string voltage prevents the overcharging buffer cells to an overvoltage condition V.sub.buf>V.sub.buf(max)/n.sub.buf. Charging of an electrochemical cell or battery beyond its maximum specified voltage can cause electrolyte leakage, fire, or possibly explosion depending on the cell's chemistry. For lithium ion this voltage is approximately 4.2V per cell. Other cell balancing circuitry is required to make sure all series connected cells maintain the same voltage irrespective of the state-of-charge. These functions are described in an associated application entitled Intelligent Buffered Fuel Cell with Low Impedance and will not be elaborated upon here.
[3557] While the charge transfer regulator design of
and is 64 A for a two-string pack where m.sub.buf=2, and 96 A for a three-string pack where m.sub.buf=3, and so on. To facilitate conduction at such as high rate two possible implementations may be employed to realize the high current dynamic QXR function, either (i) detect the current spike and increase the CDR limit from 2 C to 10 C for a duration of 10 seconds after which the current limit is returned to 2 C; or program the default value of the current limiter to be CDR=10 C and upon detecting a transient start a 10 second timer after which the CDR value is reduced to 2 C. Alternatively the buffer load access circuit can disconnect the load as a short circuit detection for any current exceeding the 10 C limit. As one embodiment of the iBFC, by combining the fuel cell, QXR, and buffer array into the iBFC three possible operating conditions can be realized, namely (i) continuous power; (ii) power-on-demand; and (iii) 10 s transient power.
[3558] In the iBFC's continuous power mode, there is no net change in the state-of-charge (SoC) in the buffer meaning I.sub.buf=0 and the charge transfer regulator's output relies solely on the fuel cell, i.e. I.sub.QXR=I.sub.FC where in one embodiment a m.sub.buf=200 fuel cell is operated at a single current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=200 mA/cm.sup.2. In another embodiment, the QXR current limiter operates at two different current levels, [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=200 mA/cm.sup.2 in continuous mode and PoD mode, and double the current density [I.sub.FC(10 s)/A.sub.FC]=400 mA/cm.sup.2 in 10 s transient mode.
[3559] It should be mentioned that when lithium-ion battery packs including the Tesla Powerwall refer to continuous current they mean the current other than short duration transient current. A battery's continuous current mode is only temporary so long that the batteries are charged. Once the battery is drain the pack is dead. By contrast, by converting hydrogen fuel into energy the buffered fuel cell described herein can truly operate continuously, i.e. perpetually, so long that fuel is available with no need for down time to recharge like a BEV or battery pack requires.
[3560] In power-on-demand (PoD) mode, the iBFC combines continuous power from the fuel cell stack and stored power from the buffer array. Like a battery pack. the iBFC buffer array contains a finite amount of charge Q.sub.buf only able to supply current I.sub.buf<0 to an electrical load for a limited amount of time until is completely discharged. In terms of the C-discharge rate, the maximum PoD interval is given by t.sub.buf=1/CDR during which the current is I.sub.buf=CDR(Q.sub.buf). If however during a defined interval the buffer is alternatively charged and discharged, the available charge stored in the buffer is partially restored whereby Q.sub.buf=(I.sub.buf/CCRI.sub.buf/CDR).
[3561] The charge stored in the buffer depends on the size of the buffer. In one string of Li-ion cells the charge per cell is Q.sub.bufI.sub.buf dt or in discrete form as Q.sub.buf=I.sub.buft.sub.buf. Similarly in m.sub.buf parallel strings of Li-ion cells the total charge capacity of the buffer array is Q.sub.bufm.sub.bufI.sub.buf dt or in discrete form as Q.sub.buf=m.sub.bufI.sub.buft.sub.buf which means capacity in mAh scales with the number of parallel strings in the buffer array but not with the number of cells n.sub.buf within a string. For example, a 6s1p array has a capacity of 3.2 Ah the same as a 2s1p array. A 6s3p array however holds 9.6 Ah, triple that of a 6s1p array.
[3562] In PoD mode the buffer array current adds to the fuel cell output based on the size of the buffer. As exemplified in the table below, in an iBFC comprising a 6s1p buffer array in a power-on-demand condition the buffer supplies 43 A while the buffer provide only 3 A for a total output to the load of 46 A. For a 6s3p buffer array in a power-on-demand condition the buffer supplies 43 A while the buffer provide 9.6 A for a total output to the load of approximately 53 A. In a 6s13p array, the fuel cell current and the buffer currents are roughly equal, with a total PoD output current of 85 A. Although the function of current source 5313a need to detect the load current I.sub.L to calculate the current output I.sub.FC from the fuel cell stack it cannot control the current flow from the buffer array 5314 to load 5204only the BLA circuit 5303 can control the load current.
[3563] As another embodiment of this invention, during a 10 s transient QXR 5311a allows the current density of the fuel cell stack to double while BLA 5303 allows currents to flow in an aggregate amount equal to I.sub.FC at A.sub.FC(400 mA/cm.sup.2) plus a 10CDR buffer current I.sub.buf=m.sub.buf(I.sub.10C). Referring again to the table, an iBFC with a 6s1p buffer array will conduct 86 A from the fuel cell array and 30 A from the buffer delivering a total output current of 116 A, roughly 2.7 its continuous output rating. An iBFC with a 6s3p buffer array will conduct 86 A from the fuel cell array and 96 A from the buffer delivering a total output current of 182 A, 4.2 its continuous output. An iBFC with a 6s13p buffer array will conduct 86 A from the fuel cell array and 416 A from the buffer delivering a total output current of 502 A, nearly 12 times its continuous output.
TABLE-US-00082 iBFC Cont Q.sub.buf PoD 10 s Transient Topology Condition (A) (Ah) Current (A) Current (A) FC Only I.sub.FC = I.sub.FC(max), 43 A 0 43 A 86 A m.sub.FC = 200 6s1p I.sub.1C = 3.2 A, 3.2 43 A + 86 A + iBFC I.sub.10s = 32 A 3 A = 46 A 32 A = 118 A 6s3p 3I.sub.1C = 9.6 A, 10 43 A + 86 A + iBFC 3I.sub.10s = 96 A 10 = 53 A 96 A = 182 A 6s7p 7I.sub.1C = 22.4 A, 22 43 A + 86 A + 224 iBFC 7I.sub.10s = 224 A 22 A = 65 A A = 310 A 6s13p 13I.sub.1C = 41.6 A, 42 43 A + 86 A + 416 iBFC 13I.sub.10s = 416 A 42 A = 85 A A = 502 A 6s31p 31I.sub.1C = 100 A, 92 43 A + 86 A + 1.0 iBFC 31I.sub.10s = 1000 A 100 A = 143 A kA = 1.09 A 6s54p 54I.sub.1C = 173 A, 173 43 A + 86 A + 1.6 iBFC 50I.sub.10s = 1730 A 173 A = 216 A kA = 1.69 kA
[3564] Another method to allow the fuel cell to deliver high load currents, i.e. heavy duty HD operation, without damaging the buffer array involves a different charge transfer regulator circuit topology QXR 5311b as shown in
[3565] For example if the fuel cell stack is modified to contain stacks with 12s250p membranes either by doubling the active area or by placing two 12s125p stacks in parallel the current out from the fuel cell jumps to 54 A.
[3566] In its new location, buffer current limiter 5313b still protects buffer 5314 to a maximum charging current of 1 C. Its insertion between the output node and the buffer array however is problematic. In particular, the function of buffer current source 5313b is to unidirectionally charge the buffer array 5314 from the fuel cell and to protect the buffer from overcurrent conditions, whereby. current flowing from fuel cell 5310 into buffer 5314 is limited to 1 C per buffer string m.sub.buf. As such, the size of the power DMOSFET used in charger current source is smaller than power MOSFETs used to power loads. As such, the current source 5313b is too resistive and too low in its current rating for supplying load transients at meaningful discharge rates of 2 C to 10 C. Moreover, its control circuit is not designed to accommodate or regulate reverse current flow.
[3567] In one embodiment, this problem is circumvented by introducing an antiparallel path around current regulator 5313b comprising power bypass circuit 5315 forming a new discharge path antiparallel to buffer current limiter. Unlike the current source 5313b, current limiter bypass circuit 5315 acts like a low-voltage-drop diode allowing current to flow from buffer 5314 to load 5317 but not in the opposite direction. For this reason, the device which is actually a power circuit is represented schematically as controlled Schottky rectifier.
[3568] The bidirectional transfer characteristics between the output node 5317 and buffer 5314 are shown in the I-V graph of
[3569] In the converse direction shown in quadrant I where positive discharge current flows out of buffer 5314 to the buffer load access protection and ultimately to load 5314, current limiter bypass ILB circuit 5315 according to diode curve 5325 then jumps to linear curve 5326 as soon as diode current is detected. The low drop is achieved by gate drive 5323 in bypass circuit 5320 turning on low resistance power MOSFET 5322 and shunting current around diode 5321. Bypass circuit 5320 circuit only allows current to flow unidirectionally from buffer 5314 to the output 5317 but not in the opposite polarity. As the current rises too high bypass circuit 5320 may current limit the discharge current to +10 C shown by curve 5327.
[3570] In this manner current flowing out of the fuel cell is limited only by its specified maximum current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC], the buffer can participate in supplying current to a load from 2 C continuously and up to +10 C during transients all while the maximum charging current of buffer 5314 is limited to 1 C. Assuming a single buffer string of lithium ion batteries rated at 3500 mA, the maximum charging rate of the buffer is limited to 1 C or 3.2 A while the stacks of fuel cells source 43 A of current, 3 A of which is used for recharging the buffer with 40 A remaining for powering the load. Once the buffer recharges the entire fuel cell output is available to the load as a steady state power limited only by cooling requirements. The steady state current capability of the iBFC without discharging the buffer is then 43 A at a nominal voltage V.sub.out=23.3V or 1000 W per stack, again limited only by heat management.
[3571] In a high current transient a 6s1p buffer string comprising 3200 mA Li-ion cells, the transient discharge current limit for a single string of six 18650 lithium ion batteries is 32 A for up to 10 seconds. Adding that to 43 A from the fuel cell delivers a current of I.sub.load=32 A+43 A=75 A. At a nominal voltage of 7.8V per stack, each stack delivers a continuous power of 333 W per stack. For a fuel cell comprising only three stack the total iBFC transient power out is 1000 W, i.e. 1 kW. If more power is required the circuitry can sense the high currents and increase the stack height by connecting more stacks in series while limiting the voltage to under 40V.
Measured PEM Membrane Losses.
[3572] The power output and power losses in every membrane is in order of priority a function of current density, relative humidity, and temperature. Aside from the fuel cell assembly and control circuitry described herein, process dependent membrane material properties, the subject of a significant portion of this application, have a profound influence on fuel cell operating efficiency. In order to build accurate electrical models of a fuel cell, the IEM voltage-current characteristics must first be verified. The primary source of characterization data is a membrane's polarization curves, a graph of the fuel cell voltage versus current or current density. When measure current is normalized to an active area A.sub.FC=1 cm.sup.2 then current in mA and current density in mA/cm are identical numerically.
[3573] As shown in the polarization curves of
[3574] A second region, known as the ohmic loss' region at moderate current densities between points A2 and A4, As a straight line on an V-I curve the region can be characterized as a small signal series linear resistance RV.sub.FC/I.sub.FC over the region spanning the range from I.sub.2=50 mA/cm.sup.2 and I.sub.4=180 mA/cm.sup.2. Due to its linearity, the phenomena is primarily attributed to resistance to the flow of ions through the membrane and to a lesser extent to electronic conduction losses through the electrodes and external circuit. As described previously in the section on charge transport, the ohmic region includes Joule heating and kinetic losses due to the imperfect processes of proton capture and release affecting diffusivity, and by inelastic collisions of protons affecting carrier mobility. Although there is a slight change in slope in Nafion polarization curve 580p at point A3 it is relatively minor. Beyond current density I.sub.4>180 cm.sup.2 identified the span from point A4 to A5, voltage losses sharply increase identifying the onset of the concentration loss region. Conduction losses in this region are generally attributed to voltage drop due to mass transport limitations, where the reactants are not supplied to the electrodes quickly enough and to parasitic effects such as water logging, swelling, and fluid retentions interfering with charge transport.
[3575] By contrast the experimentally fabricated film comprising a 20 m thick PFSA composite reinforced membrane shown by curve 581p demonstrates significantly lower voltage sag at point B2 and lower series resistance between B2, B3, and B4. These beneficial characteristics in the ohmic region are attributable to reduced scattering from enhanced crystallinity from the PTFE polymeric backbones offset by a lower effective ionomeric cross section where inert PTFE polymers displace conducting PFSA segments. Above current Is shown by point B5. high current effects begin to dominate losses leading to significant voltage sag and large thermal losses.
[3576] Significant improvements in fuel cell efficiency are demonstrated by the 20 m microporous membrane made in accordance with this invention. As shown by curve 582p, the enhanced transport in the film all but eliminates activation losses between points 0 and C2 retaining an efficiency of =0.92V/0.94V=98% which declines to =0.89V/0.94V=95% remaining relatively flat with a small constant differential resistance of V.sub.FC/I.sub.FC=(0.94V0.89V)/(110 mA)=0.5 until point C3. Beyond current I.sub.3=110 mA/cm.sup.2 differential ohmic losses increase, but the membrane retains an overall efficiency of =0.77V/0.94V=82%. At point C5 corresponding to I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC=200 mA/cm.sup.2, the efficiency further declines to =0.70V/0.94V=75%.
[3577] At this current the average resistance of the fuel cell is approximately given by R=(0.94V0.70V)/(200 mA)=240 mV/200 mA=1.2. As shown, an equivalent electrical model of the fuel cell operating at point C5 at 200 mA is a voltage source 5240 with an effective voltage V.sub.eff=0.94V and a 1.2 series resistance 5341. With a voltage drop of V.sub.r=0.24V across resistor 5341, the measured fuel cell voltage V.sub.FC=V.sub.effV.sub.r=0.94V0.24V=0.70V present at the fuel cell output and across electrical load 5204a. Comparing the =75% efficiency of the porous membrane at point C5 to the other measured curves illustrates the substantial benefits of the disclosed PEM membrane mad in accordance with this invention. Specifically point B5 for the PFSA CRM membrane has an efficiency of =0.60V/0.94V=64%, a full 11% less efficient than the porous PEM membrane. The effective resistance of the composite PFSA film is R=(0.94V0.60V)/200 mA=340 mV/200 mA=1.70, a 42% higher series resistance. The performance of commercial Nafion at point A5 is even worse with an efficiency of =0.46V/0.94V=49% with a resistance R=(0.94V0.46V)/200 mA=480 mV/200 mA=2.4, double the resistance of the porous membrane of point C5.
[3578] The single-layer unit-area (1s1p) PEM electrical model derived from measured data can be linearly scaled from n.sub.FC=1 and m.sub.FC=1 to other dimensions to confirm the electrical performance of a wide variety of fuel cell voltages, currents, power levels, and applications. Moreover, further studies have shown that by thinning the gas diffusion layers only slightly lowering parasitic resistances in the MEA5, the ohmic resistance of the 1s1p model can be further reduced by 20% or more with no impact on the electrochemical effective voltage V.sub.eff of the cell. As such, the reference model is adjusted by changing the ohmic resistance to R.sub.FC=1.0.
[3579] As shown in
[3580] Given an area of A.sub.FC=200 cm.sup.2 and a current density of [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=200 mA/cm.sup.2 consistent with measured values, the 12s200p stack fuel cell 5350a has a current of I.sub.FC=40 A and by Ohm's law, a voltage drop V.sub.r=(40 A)(60 m)=2.9V across resistor 5341a. The terminal voltage of the stack fuel cell is then V.sub.FC=V.sub.effI.sub.FCR.sub.FC which at I.sub.FC=40 A becomes V.sub.FC=11.3V2.9V=8.4V with a corresponding efficiency =8.4V/11.3V75% and per layer voltage V.sub.FC/n.sub.FC=8.4V/12=0.7V per layer. In other words a standard reference model for a 12s200p stack array based on measured data and a linearly scalable MEA7 model comprises a 0.94V voltage source and a 1 series resistance producing a terminal voltage of 8.V at 40 A load current for a net generated power output of 336 W at an efficiency of 75%. By stacking the models in series, higher voltages and power levels can be produced without reengineering the stack.
[3581] The waste heat generated in each 12-layer stack module is therefore P.sub.loss=(25%)(336 W)=84 W thermally cooled over two 200 cm.sup.2 surfaces at a wort-case power density of 0.4 W/cm.sup.2 comprising thermal conduction into conductive backplane and forced air convection off its surface. Assuming a worst case temperature rise to T.sub.FC=85 C., the temperature differential to a backplane at T.sub.bp=25 C. is T=T.sub.FCT.sub.bp=60 C. with a corresponding thermal impedance of .sub.s=T/P=60 C./85 C.=0.70 C./W. Such thermal impedance can be achieved convectively by air cooling at a flow rate of 0.02 cm.sup.3/s not including conductive cooling into the backplane. Because each stack maintains its own thermal equilibrium to the PCB and to the air, combining stacks to achieve higher power levels is not thermally limited. In this way, the stacks can be series connected to achieve higher power output levels using the reference model to predict their performance.
[3582] In one embodiment a 36s200p fuel cell array 5350b comprises three series stacks with a V.sub.eff=33.8V effective voltage, a 180 m resistance, an output voltage of 25.2V, a 40 A output current delivering a power output of 1006 W at 75%. In essence every three 12-layer stacks deliver 1 kW of output power. In a second embodiment a 48s200p fuel cell array 5350c comprises four series stacks with a V.sub.eff=45.1V effective voltage, a 240 m resistance, an output voltage of 33.6V at 40 A delivering a power output of 1344 W at 75%. In a third embodiment a 60s200p fuel cell array 5350d comprises five series stacks with a V.sub.eff=56.4V effective voltage, a 300 m resistance, an output voltage of 42V at 40 A output current delivering a power output of 1680 W at 75%. These stacks performance specifications are summarized in the following table for ease of comparison:
TABLE-US-00083 Parameter Calculation stack Configuration Topology (n.sub.FC)s(m.sub.FC)p 12s200p 24s200p 36s200p 48s200p 60s200p # of stacks (n.sub.FC)(m.sub.FC)/2400 1 2 3 4 5 Current I.sub.FC m.sub.FC(200 mA/cm.sup.2) 40 A 40 A 40 A 40 A 40 A Effective V.sub.eff n.sub.FC(0.94 V) 11.3 V 22.6 V 25.2 V 45.1 V 56.4 V Resistance R.sub.FC n.sub.FC(5 m) 60 m 120 m 180 m 240 m 300 m Output V.sub.FC V.sub.eff I.sub.FCR.sub.FC 8.4 V 17.8 V 25.2 V 33.6 V 42.0 V Power P.sub.FC I.sub.FCV.sub.FC 336 W 712 W 1008 W 1344 W 1680 W Efficiency P.sub.FC/(V.sub.eff I.sub.FC) 75% 75% 75% 75% 75% Heat P.sub.loss (1 )P.sub.FC 83 W
[3583]
[3584] Looking at the maximum voltage of the stack, the 36-layer stack voltage 5221u does not exceed a 32V maximum voltage 5220w over the entire range of fuel cell voltages and humidity levels. The 36-layer design does however drop below the 24V minimum allowed voltage 5220l at V.sub.FC=0.67V per layer corresponding to a RH=74%. For n.sub.FC=48 curve 5221w, the voltage exceeds a 40V maximum stack voltage criteria 5220u around a humidity 98.5% when V.sub.FC=0.83V per layer. It also drops below the 24V minimum allowed voltage 5220l at V.sub.FC=0.5V per layer corresponding to a RH=34%. The voltage curve 5221z for the n.sub.FC=60 layer design exceeds a 40V maximum stack voltage criteria 5220u when V.sub.FC=0.67V per layer at a humidity of 74 and drops below the 24V minimum allowed voltage 5220l at V.sub.FC=0.4V per layer corresponding to a RH=27%.
[3585] So in essence the high layer count stacks function to lower humidity levels at cell voltages but easily exceed the maximum voltage within a normal humidity range of 85%. Conversely stacks of fewer cells do not exceed the maximum target voltage but fail to produce adequate voltage below RH=74%. In essence, no one curve satisfies the target stack voltage range over a nominal humidity range. All three fuel cell stack designs are able to satisfy the need for producing a 1 kW output at 25V, well above the 24V minimum voltage 5220l.
[3586] These three cases are shown by point 5432b for a n.sub.FC=36 for V.sub.FC=0.7V and RH=85%; by point 5432c for a n.sub.FC=48 for V.sub.FC=0.52V and RH=36%; and by point 5432d for a n.sub.FC=60 for V.sub.FC=0.42V and RH=29%. As shown in
[3587] As shown by 60s200p fuel cell stack 5350r, the fuel cell voltage is able to function down to V.sub.eff=0.66V by increasing the number of layers from n.sub.FC=48 to n.sub.FC=60 and correspondingly increasing the effective stack voltage 5340r to n.sub.FCV.sub.eff=39.6V. This higher voltage offsets the losses in resistance 5341r which increases from 240 m to 300 m. The resulting output voltage remains unchanged at n.sub.FCV.sub.FC=25.2V but corresponds to a lower V.sub.FC=0.66V per layer. In this manner switching among various numbers of stacks enables a guaranteed 1 kW output despite declining cells voltages in low humidity conditions.
[3588] Once adverse effect of including more fuel cells into a stack, is the added ohmic losses which decrease the overall efficiency when the cells are running at lower voltages. For example while the three stack design operates at 75% efficiency, four stacks drop to =25.2V/36.7V=68%. This is still significantly better than conventional fuel cells that cant operate at all without humidification which consumes power and lowers the overall system efficiency even more.
Effective Power Output.
[3589] The iBFC output current described previously for continuous, PoD, and transient modes can be translated into output power by the formula P.sub.out=(I.sub.out)(V.sub.out). In continuous conduction mode, with V.sub.BFC=23.3V and I.sub.BFC=43 A, the power output of the buffered fuel cell is 1 kW.
[3590] In power-on-demand conditions, iBFC designs with buffers ranging from 6 Li-ion (6s1p) cells to 318 (6s53p) cells, the PoD outputs range from 1.1 kW to 5.0 kW. Of particular interest is the 6s31p iBFC where combining with three 200 cm.sup.2 fuel cells with 186 Li-ion cells results in 3.3 kW of generated output, 1 kW of which is generated from fuel, the other two-thirds from buffer-stored charge. The series or parallel connection of six 6s31p iBFC produces a 10 kW power-on-demand system comprising 3 kW of continuous power and 7 kW of buffer power.
[3591] Alternatively, series or parallel connection of two 6s53p iBFC produces a 10 kW power-on-demand system comprising 2 kW of continuous power and 8 kW of buffer power. Because of the different ratio of buffer stored power to fuel cell generated power the two 5 kW modules require 106 Li-ion cells while three 3333 W modules require only 93 Li-ion cells.
TABLE-US-00084 Buffer Voltage Cont Cont PoD PoD 10 s Trans 10 s Trans Topology V.sub.BFC (V) I.sub.BFC (A) P.sub.BFC (W) I.sub.BFC (A) P.sub.BFC (W) I.sub.BFC (A) P.sub.BFC (W) 0s0p FC only 23.3 V 43 A 1.0 kW 43 A 1.0 kW 80 A 1.8 kW 6s1p iBFC n.sub.FC = 36 215 mA/cm.sup.2 3 stacks 46 A 1.1 kW 120 A 2.8 kW 6s3p iBFC m.sub.FC = 200 53 A 1.2 kW 180 A 4.1 kW 6s7p iBFC 65 A 1.5 kW 300 A 6.9 kW 6s13p iBFC 85 A 2.0 kW 500 A 12 kW 6s31p iBFC 143 A 3.333 kW 1 kA 23 kW 6s53p iBFC 216 A 5.0 kW 1.7 kA 38 kW
[3592] The calculation of the 10-second transient power assumes a doubling of fuel cell generated current at [I.sub.FC(PoD)/A.sub.FC]=2(215 mA/cm.sup.2)=(430 mA/cm.sup.2) along with a discharge rate of CDR=10 C for the buffer cells where I.sub.10C=10(3.2 A)=32 A. Transient power is only an approximation as variations in current densities, self heating in conduction, stray inductance, PCB capacitance, and parasitic resistance collectively affect the peak current and transient waveforms.
[3593] As such, excess precision in the calculations are unnecessary. For example for the 6s31p iBFC design, the I.sub.FC(10 s)=(200 cm.sup.2)[430 mA/cm.sup.2]2(43 A)86 A. The transient buffer current I.sub.buf(10 s)=m.sub.buf(I.sub.10C)31(32 A)992 A which combined with the 86 A fuel cell current equals the summation I.sub.BFC(10 s)=I.sub.FC(10 s)+I.sub.buf(10 s)=86 A+992 A=1078 A1 kA with a corresponding transient power of P.sub.BFC(10 s)=V.sub.buf(I.sub.FC(10 s)+I.sub.buf(10 s))(23.3V)(1 kA)23 kW. Transient power is only meaningful to ensure there is sufficient momentary power needed to supply capacitive inrush power and motor cold cranking current needed to overcome stiction.
[3594] The below table is an exemplary comparison of iBFCs capable of 5 kW power-on-demand comprising 12-layer stacks, each with an area of A.sub.FC=200 cm.sup.2. The topology of the fuel cell there for is given as (n.sub.FC)s(m.sub.FC)p where n.sub.FC equals the total number of fuel cell layers in integer multiples of twelve, i.e. 12, 24, 36, 48, 60, 72, and 84; and where m.sub.FC is the dimensionless ratio of the total area of all fuel cell layers connected in parallel divided by a unit area of 1 cm.sup.2. In this example m.sub.FC is limited to integer multiples of 200, i.e. m.sub.FC=200, 400, 600 for one, two, or three parallel cells of 200 cm.sup.2 each. Calculations to complete the following table involve the following steps: [3595] FC #The total number of stack fuel cells FC # in an array (n.sub.FC)s(m.sub.FC)p comprises the integer multiple of fuel cell stacks irrespective of their topological arrangement FC #=int{(n.sub.FC/12)(m.sub.FC/200)}=int{(n.sub.FC)(m.sub.FC)/2400}. For example for a 48s200p the FC #=int{(48/12)(200/200)}=4 stacks. For a 36s400p the FC #=int{(36/12)(400/200)}=int{(3)(2)}=6 stacks. [3596] V.sub.BFCThe output voltage V.sub.BFC of the buffered fuel cell in this example is given by the total number of series connected fuel cell layers n.sub.FC multiplied by the minimum per-layer fuel cell voltage V.sub.FC=0.65V when I.sub.buf=0, i.e. when the buffer is charged to the same voltage as the fuel cell stack, mathematically as V.sub.BFC=n.sub.FCV.sub.FC=n.sub.FC(0.65V). [3597] I.sub.FCThe total fuel cell output current during normal operation, i.e. not in 10 s transient mode, is given by number of parallel-connected fuel cell layers expressed by the dimensionless factor m.sub.FC multiplied by the nominal current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=215 mA/cm.sup.2, or algebraically as I.sub.FC=(A.sub.FC)[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=(m.sub.FC.Math.1 cm.sup.2)[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=(m.sub.FC)(215 mA). [3598] Buf #The total number of buffer cells in a buffer array (n.sub.buf)s(m.sub.buf)p irrespective of the topological configuration is given by the multiplicative product of its number of buffer cells in each string n.sub.buf multiplied by the number of parallel strings m.sub.FC whereby Buf #=(n.sub.buf)(m.sub.buf). [3599] I.sub.bufThe buffer current I.sub.buf during power-on-demand (PoD) mode is equal to the C-discharge rate CDR times the buffer charge Q.sub.buf whereby I.sub.buf=(m.sub.buf)(CDR)(Q.sub.buf) and where for a Li-ion 18650 cell Q.sub.buf=3.2 Ah. For a CDR=1 C, the I.sub.buf=m.sub.buf(3.2 A). In one examples a 8s37p buffer array comprising 297 cells discharging at 1 C carries I.sub.buf=m.sub.buf(3.2 A)=(37)(3.2 A)=118 A while a 12s20p array of 240 cell array has a 1 C discharge rate of I.sub.buf=m.sub.buf(3.2 A)=(20)(3.2 A)=64 A in PoD mode and a I.sub.10s=m.sub.buf(I.sub.10C)=(20)(32 A)=640 A in 10 s transient mode. In steady-state, aka continuous mode where the buffer does not change its state-of-charge, I.sub.buf=0. [3600] I.sub.ssThe steady state or continuous current output from the iBFC to the load is entirely supplied by the fuel cell, i.e. I.sub.SS=I.sub.FC. As illustrated in the table when I.sub.FC=43 A, them I.sub.SS=43 A, when I.sub.FC=86 A, them I.sub.SS=86 A. [3601] P.sub.ssThe steady state power is given by the buffer fuel cell output voltage VBFC times the steady state current, whereby P.sub.SS=(V.sub.BFC)(I.sub.SS). Examples include 48s200p fuel cell delivering 43 A for 1.3 kW continuous power; 36s400p delivering 86 A for 2 kW; and 60s400p delivering 86 A for 3.3 kW of continuous power [3602] Power-on-DemandFor power-on-demand conditions where I.sub.PoD=I.sub.FC+I.sub.buf current is supplied by both the fuel cell and the buffer so long that Q.sub.buf>0. For example, in the fuel cell topology 36s200p, the iBFC delivers 215 A at 23.3V for a power output of 5 kW, where 80% of the PoD power comes from the buffer, and only 20% from 3 fuel cell stacks. In the fuel cell 36s400p, the iBFC delivers 215 A at 23.3V for a power output also comprising 5 kW, where 60% of the PoD power comes from the buffer, and 40% its 6 fuel cell stacks. In another iBFC design with a 5 kW power output, increasing the fuel cell contribution to 9 stacks with a 36s600p topology delivers 215 A at 23.3V where 40% of the PoD power comes from the buffer and 60% from the fuel cell electrical generation.
[3603] The following table illustrates the flexibility of the iBFC is reconfiguring the overall charge generation and storage capability of the iBFC for varying designs. For convenience, the fuel cell topologies shown are multiples of 12-layers to match without limitation the aforementioned exemplary stacks.
TABLE-US-00085 # FC Voltage FC Buffer Buffer Cont PoD PoD FC Topology V.sub.BFC (V) I.sub.FC (A) Topology (#) I.sub.buf (A) Cont P.sub.ss (W) I.sub.PoD (A) P.sub.PoD (W) =int{(n.sub.FC) =(n.sub.FC) =(m.sub.FC) #buf = int =(m.sub.buf) I.sub.ss (A) =(I.sub.FC) =I.sub.FC + =(I.sub.PoD) (m.sub.FC)/2400} (0.65 V) (0.215 A) {(n.sub.buf)(m.sub.buf)} (3.2 A) =I.sub.FC (V.sub.BFC) I.sub.buf (V.sub.BFC) 3 36s200p 23.3 V 43 A 6s54p (324) 172 A 43 A 1.0 kW 215 A 5.0 kW 4 48s200p 31.2 V 43 A 8s37p (296) 118 A 43 A 1.3 kW 161 A 5 60s200p 39.0 V 43 A 10s27p (270) 85 A 43 A 1.7 kW 128 A 6 36s400p 23.3 V 86 A 6s40p (240) 129 A 86 A 2.0 kW 215 A 6 72s200p 46.6 V 43 A 12s20p (240) 64 A 43 A 2.0 kW 107 A 7 84s200p 54.6 V 43 A 14s15p (210) 49 A 43 A 2.4 kW 92 A 9 36s600p 23.3 V 129 A 6s27p (162) 86 A 129 A 3.0 kW 215 A 10 60s400p 39.0 V 86 A 10s13p (130) 42 A 86 A 3.3 kW 128 A
[3604] As an embodiment of this invention, the iBFC facilitates a spectrum of designs to deliver power-on-demand whereby the share of deliverable power can be allocated by design in any ratio between the continuous steady-state generating capability of stack fuel cells and the rapid low impedance deliver of the electrochemical buffer array.
[3605] Unlike in a battery buffer where increasing the energy capacity of the battery pack necessarily results in an equivalent increase in output power, i.e. where (E.sub.bat)/(P.sub.bat)=constant, in the buffered fuel cell the power-on-demand output capability in kW can be adjusted independently from the stored energy kWh. For example, a high-capacity iBFC doesn't require a large buffer for storing charge, hydrogen fuel provides that benefit. Similarly a high power output can be achieved with a high capacity high Q.sub.buf buffer array, a large fuel array high current fuel cell, or some combination thereof even if the stored fuel capacity is minimal.
[3606] The iBFC architecture made in accordance with this invention is also scalable to different power levels either by modifying the buffer-to-fuel-cell current ratios or by paralleling or stacking modules. For example, the parallel combination of two 24V 5 kW iBFC modules results in a 10 kW 24V module with twice the current delivery capability of the individual modules, increasing the current output from 210 A to 420 A. The series stacking of two 24V 5 kW iBFC modules results in a 10 kW module capable of delivering 210 A at 48V.
[3607] Both current and voltage output specifications are independent of the kWh energy capability of the system which depends only on its hydrogen fuel. Regardless of the size of the fuel cell, each kilogram is capable delivers 33 kWh of energy. Considering a head-to-head comparison of battery packs to the buffered fuel cell, and 11 kW rated battery module can deliver roughly 11 kWh of energy, meaning to match the capability of the iBFC with 1 k of hydrogen requires three battery pack modules, just to handle one day's home use. Even a diminutive 1.4 kW fuel cell can convert and deliver one days worth of energy, i.e. 33 kWh to a home without exceeding its energy delivery capacity.
[3608] Scaling a 5 kW iBFC to a higher power such as 10 kW made in accordance with this invention involves three possible solutions (i) increasing the percentage of power delivered from the fuel cell; (ii) connecting two 5 kW modules in which case the ratable power contributions remain unaltered, or (iii) increasing the fractional contribution of buffer power.
TABLE-US-00086 # FC Voltage FC Buffer Cont PoD PoD FC Topology V.sub.BFC (V) I.sub.FC (A) Topology (#) Buffer Cont P.sub.ss (W) I.sub.PoD (A) P.sub.PoD (W) =int{(n.sub.FC) =(n.sub.FC) =(m.sub.FC) #buf = int I.sub.buf (A) I.sub.ss (A) =(I.sub.FC) =I.sub.FC + =(I.sub.PoD) (m.sub.FC)/2400} (0.65 V) (0.215 A) {(n.sub.buf)(m.sub.buf)} =(m.sub.buf)(3.2 A) =I.sub.FC (V.sub.BFC) I.sub.buf (V.sub.BFC) 4 48s200p 31.2 V 43 A 8s87p (696) 277 A 43 A 1.3 kW 320 A 10 kW 5 60s200p 39.0 V 43 A 10s67p (670) 213 A 43 A 1.7 kW 256 A 6 36s400p 23.3 V 86 A 6s108p (648) 344 A 86 A 2.0 kW 430 A 6 72s200p 46.6 V 43 A 12s54p (648) 172 A 43 A 2.0 kW 215 A 7 84s200p 54.6 V 43 A 14s44p (616) 140 A 43 A 2.4 kW 183 A 8 96s200p 62.4 V 43 A 16s37p (592) 117 A 43 A 2.7 kW 160 A 8 48s400p 31.2 V 86 A 8s73p (584) 235 A 86 A 2.7 kW 321 A 10 60s400p 39.0 V 86 A 10s53p (530) 170 A 86 A 3.4 kW 256 A
[3609] The above table reveals the a 10 kW iBFC as shown comprising four-to-ten 20 cm.sup.2 twelve-layer stacks may deliver between 1.3 kW (13%) to 3.4 kW (34%) of its output power from electric generation within the fuel cell. To reach 50% generated power, i.e. 5 kW of 10 kW out requires 15 stacks where every three stacks produce 1 kW.
[3610] iBFC Power Blade. Although the iBFC can be arrayed to form 2 kW, 5 kW, 10 kW and even 20 kW energy modules using the methods detailed herein, in an alternative embodiment the iBFC can be configured as 5 kW power blades.
[3611] In a computer blade server, pluggable printed circuit boards (PCBs) called server blades contain arrays of processors and highs peed memory used for high speed computing, artificial intelligence, cloud services, bitcoin and crypto mining, communication networking, and other scalable computing functions. The PCBs are plugged into an enclosure called a rack, frame, or cage, where the connectors, aka backplane, provide the electrical connections into and out of the PCB to the outside world including power to drive the processors and high speed memory, power to any onboard cooling. The connectors also include high speed data busses, control busses, Ethernet, or standardized computer bus interfaces. Collectively, these cages power server blades while facilitating external connectivity. The cage also provides local cooling to a server farm's all important HVAC cooling system, without which the servers would burn up.
[3612] While in a server farm each card represents an electrical load, in an set of inventive embodiments of the intelligent buffered fuel cell described herein a new class of rack-mounted modules contains power generating circuitry and energy storage capacity. Referred to herein as iBFC power blades, these power generating modules form a modular scalable power source for residential and commercial buildings and offices, as well as backup power for hospitals and mission critical use cases.
[3613] As depicted in
[3619] Power generated by fuel cell stacks 7009 and stored in arrays of buffer cells 7008 contained in each power blade is summed together in DC power bus 7006 then delivered to DC-to-AC inverter 7007, the power output of which is distributed to users and electrical loads via an AC microgrid. In this manner, any group of persons, businesses, or neighborhoods can operate their own private electrical utility grid, converting hydrogen into electricity and distributing the generated power to its owners and users by way of a shared microgrid.
[3620] In the example shown, backplates 7002x have dimensions matched to the card slots, specifically a width of 76 cm (30 in) and a depth of 48.3 cm (19 in). Because of the height of lithium ion buffer cells used in the IBFC, comprising for example 18650 canisters, the power blade height is rated as 2 U, i.e. having a maximum dimension of 8.89 cm (3.5 cm).
[3621] As shown in
[3622] Returning to the FC anode, hydrogen flowing into the fuel cell and being distributed by the hydrogen ingress manifold 7016i then flows across the face of the IEM membrane stack 2019 through BPP channels 7017. Excess unconverted hydrogen not transported through the membranes is collected by the hydrogen egress manifold 7016e for recycling, whereby unused gas exits stack assembly 7009 through pipe nipple 7018e and into H.sub.2 recycle conduit 7021e within backplate 7025. The returned hydrogen gas then flows back to a central system where optionally the moisture is adjusted, i.e. regulated within a target range of relative humidity. Once processed the recycled hydrogen is returned to the hydrogen input network thereby forming a closed-loop hydrogen circuit where no unionized hydrogen gas is wasted or vented into the air.
[3623] In another embodiment of the invention, gas is delivered into the fuel cell stack module without the use of flexible tubing, but instead by directly attaching fuel cell stack assembly 7009 onto the backplate 7025 as shown in
[3624] Within the core of backplate 7025, a number of gas and coolant channels, 7021g and 7021c respectively are embedded to transport gases and vapor through the backplate to the various stack fuel cells 7009. By distributing gasses within backplate 7025 the need for flexible tubes and hoses which invariable age and suffer leakage over time can be eliminated. The inventive embodiments herein distinguishes the power blade design over conventional fuel cell modules which are subject to high failure rates from stress failures, overheating, and leaky tubing.
[3625] As shown backplate substrate 7025 is capped with an insulating layer 7042 forming the base of a printed circuit board (PCB) facilitating electrical connections among the iBFC components forming the power blade. The PCB substrate itself may comprise a non-conductive material such as fiberglass, fiberglass-reinforced epoxy resin (FR4), epoxies, or polyimide. Conductors may include copper foil laminates such as copper traces 7030. Some portions of the insulating PCB substrate 7042 are removed prior to assembly onto backplate substrate in order to facilitate gas transport such as via window 7022 where gas flows from the backplate's internal gas conduits such as 7021i through the opening 7022 and into stack pipe nipple 7018 located on the underside of stack assembly 7009. To prevent gas leakage at the PCB to stack interface a gasket or grommet 7032 provides an airtight seal between the two.
[3626] In one embodiment of this invention, fabrication of backplate 7025 starts with thermal conductor 7040 comprising metal, carbon, or composite material as shown in
[3627] As a unique embodiment of this invention, backplate 7025w comprise a temperature regulated thermally conductive core supporting a printed circuit board substrate of insulator 7042 with copper conductive traces 7030. Because the conductive traces must be thick to carry high currents, e.g. using 4 oz copper, there is naturally a gap 7031 laterally located between traces. Although the gap may be filled with air or an insulator, the connection between backplate gas port and pipe nipple 7018 on the stack assembly do not sit flush against one another on the bond plane. As described to prevent gas loss in the connection between the two, the design includes a grommet or gasket 7032 to seal the volume against gas leakage. A more detailed description shown in
[3628] A modification to the backplate, shown in
[3629] As shown in
[3630] As shown in
[3631] A variety of designs may be used to form power blades with a minimum power output of 5 kW. Nine different designs are compared in the following table comprising between three and twelve fuel cell stacks, between 96 and 480 buffer cells, and outputs between 23.3 V and 54.6 V. The designs all utilize a standardized backplate 7025 of area A.sub.bp=(48.3 cm)(76 cm)=3671 cm.sup.20.36 m.sup.2. With a 2 U maximum height of 8.89 cm, the unit volume of the power blade is Vol=(8.89 cm)(3671 cm.sup.2)=32,635 cm.sup.3.
[3632] As depicted in
[3633] By contrast, the buffer fuel cell disclosed herein has two sources of energy stored in its buffer and energy generated in its fuel from a hydrogen fuel supply. The current output of a buffered fuel cell is thereby I.sub.BFC=I.sub.buf+I.sub.FC where I.sub.buf=f(Q.sub.buf) depends on the state-of-charge (SoC) in the buffer and I.sub.FC does not. Using the same definition of continuous power, the power delivered while Q=0, then there to be no net change in the state-of-charge in a battery in continuous mode. As such the net current flowing in the iBFC buffer must also be zero, whereby I.sub.bat=0. In such cases, I.sub.BFC=(I.sub.buf+I.sub.FC)=I.sub.FC. Since I.sub.SSI.sub.FC=[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](A.sub.FC) depends on the design current density [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC] and the active area A.sub.FC of the fuel cell membranes in the stack, then for a at 215 mA/cm.sup.2 a 200 cm.sup.2 buffered fuel cell delivers I.sub.SS=43 A of continuous steady-state current 7070c while a 400 cm.sup.2 cell delivers I.sub.SS=86 A.
[3634] The second mode to deliver energy to a load is referred to herein as power-on-demand or PoD. In the case of a battery pack, the only source of power is to deplete charge stored in the battery whereby Q<0. Given that a single string of batteries can deliver a current I.sub.bat=(CDR)(Q.sub.bat) where Q.sub.bat=(Q.sub.batQ.sub.min) then the stored charge Q.sub.bat declines linearly with time at a constant battery current I.sub.bat until Q=0. At a industry standard safe discharge rate of 1 C, the battery current equation simplifies to I.sub.bat=(Q.sub.bat)/(1 h) meaning at a 1 C rate the battery will discharge for one hour as shown by curve 7071b to Q.sub.min after which I.sub.batt=0 to avoid battery damage.
[3635] By contrast, power on demand discharge for the buffered fuel cell includes bother buffer discharge current I.sub.buf=(CDR)(Q.sub.buf) and continuously generated fuel cell current I.sub.FC whereby I.sub.PoD=I.sub.FC+I.sub.buf=I.sub.FC+(CDR)(Q.sub.buf) per string. Assuming a 1 C discharge rate the equation simplifies to I.sub.FC+I.sub.buf=I.sub.FC+(Q.sub.buf)/(1h). Comparing iBFC PoD curve 7070b to 1 C battery curve 7071b two major differences are obvious. Firstly, given the same buffer capacity as battery capacity, Q.sub.buf=Q.sub.bat, the on-demand current I.sub.bat of the battery is less than the buffered fuel cell, the difference being the current I.sub.SS generated by the fuel cell.
[3636] Secondly when the buffer discharges to Q=0 after one hour, the iBFC current still conducts the steady state current I.sub.SS 7070c, e.g. 43 A or 86 A where the battery current drops to zero 7071c. As such the buffered fuel cell delivers more average power during power-on-demand and continues to operate even after the buffer is depleted. A battery only storage system is only good until it is discharged, then is useless until it can be recharged typically over a period of several hours.
[3637] Lastly during transient power surges for intervals less than 10 seconds, both the iBFC current and the buffer can conduct current 10 C, an order of magnitude higher normal discharge currents. Given that I.sub.bat=I.sub.buf=(CDR)(Q.sub.b)=10C(Q.sub.b) either solution can handle high current spike 7072. Academically speaking, the buffered fuel cell offer slightly higher current as during a transient the fuel cell can deliver a transient current double its steady state value without significant losses, namely P.sub.10s2P.sub.SS+10(P.sub.buf)=V.sub.buf(2I.sub.ss+10I.sub.buf) where 2P.sub.SS=2[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](A.sub.FC)=(430 mA/cm.sup.2)(200 cm.sup.2)==86 A. But since this 86 A difference is small compared to a C buffer current, there is no significant difference between curve 7070a and 7071a except that the iBFC can continue to supply current without reducing its transient current capability. If however, a battery state-of-charge is already reduced by previous discharging, its ability to source transient current may also be jeopardized.
[3638] With these definitions, a meaningful comparison can be made between various designs.
TABLE-US-00087 # FC Voltage FC Buffer Buffer Cont PoD PoD FC Topology V.sub.BFC (V) I.sub.FC (A) Topology (#) I.sub.buf (A) Cont P.sub.ss (W) I.sub.PoD (A) P.sub.PoD (W) =int{(n.sub.FC) =(n.sub.FC) =(m.sub.FC) #buf = int =(m.sub.buf) I.sub.ss (A) =(I.sub.FC) =I.sub.FC + =(I.sub.PoD) (m.sub.FC)/2400} (0.65 V) (0.215 A) {(n.sub.buf)(m.sub.buf)} (3.2 A) =I.sub.FC (V.sub.BFC) I.sub.buf (V.sub.BFC) 3 36s200p 23.3 V 43 A 6s56p (336) 179 A 43 A 1.0 kW 222 A 5.2 kW 3 36s200p 23.3 V 43 A 6s80p (480) 256 A 43 A 1.0 kW 299 A 7.0 kW 4 48s200p 31.2 V 43 A 8s37p (296) 118 A 43 A 1.3 kW 161 A 5.0 kW 5 60s200p 39.0 V 43 A 10s28p (280) 90 A 43 A 1.7 kW 133 A 5.2 kW 6 36s400p 23.3 V 86 A 6s40p (240) 129 A 86 A 2.0 kW 215 A 5.0 kW 6 72s200p 46.6 V 43 A 12s20p (240) 64 A 43 A 2.0 kW 107 A 5.0 kW 6 72s200p 46.6 V 43 A 12s25p (300) 80 A 43 A 2.0 kW 123 A 5.7 kW 7 84s200p 54.6 V 43 A 14s15p (210) 49 A 43 A 2.4 kW 92 A 5.0 kW 7 84s200p 54.6 V 43 A 14s21p (294) 67 A 43 A 2.4 kW 110 A 6.0 kW 12 72s400p 46.6 V 86 A 12s8p (96) 26 A 86 A 4.0 kW 112 A 5.2 kW
[3639] In an exemplary twelve fuel cell design as shown in
[3640] In another embodiment of this invention, an exemplary seven fuel cell design shown in
[3641] In another embodiment of this invention, an alternate seven fuel cell design shown in
[3642] In another embodiment of this invention, a six fuel cell design shown in
[3643] In alternate embodiment of this invention, another six fuel cell design shown in
[3644] In a different six fuel cell design also exemplified by previously shown
[3645] In another embodiment of this invention, an five fuel cell design shown in
[3646] In yet another embodiment of this invention, an four fuel cell design shown in
[3647] In a lower voltage embodiment of this invention, an three fuel cell design shown in
[3648] Lastly in yet another low voltage embodiment of this invention, an three fuel cell design shown in
Comparing 5 kW Power Blade Designs.
[3649] To compare various 5 kW power designs an areal power density model of both buffer and fuel cell performance is required. Although, in practice both components come in only discrete quantized areas, for example 200 cm.sup.2 for a fuel cell, when creating a model we can assume a granularity of 4 cm.sup.2 minimal required PCB area for an 18650 lithium ion cell and 1 cm.sup.2 increments for fuel cell active areas to fill in the remaining unused area. The standard PCB area for a rack mounted cage is 76 cm48.3 cm equaling 3671 cm.sup.2. Assuming on 82% areal utilization, the resulting usable active area of the PCB is A.sub.pcb=3000 cm.sup.2.
[3650] To determine power density, the fabricated fuel cell membranes characterized herein exhibited minimal voltage sag at a current density of [I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC]=215 mA/cm.sup.2. This current density is consistent with the previous analysis for the continuous steady state power of a fuel cell where I.sub.FC=[I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](A.sub.FC)=(215 mA/cm.sup.2)(200 cm.sup.2)=43 A. Assuming a n.sub.FC=12 layer stack with a minimum voltage of V.sub.FC=0.65V per layer under low humidity condition, then the minimum stack voltage is given by V s(min)=(n.sub.FC)(V.sub.FC)=12(0.65V)=7.8V and the maximum voltage in high humidity is by V.sub.s (max)=(n.sub.FC)(V.sub.FC)=12(0.9V)=10.8V, 38% higher than the minimum stack voltage.
[3651] The power density is then given by [P.sub.FC(min)/A.sub.FC][I.sub.FC/A.sub.FC](V.sub.FC)=(215 mA/cm.sup.2)(7.8V)=1.7 W/cm.sup.2 increasing by 38% to 2.4 W/cm.sup.2 in humid conditions. This means for a reference area of m.sub.FC=200, the output power is P.sub.FC(min)=[P.sub.FC(min)/A.sub.FC](A.sub.FC)=[1.7 W/cm.sup.2](200 cm.sup.2)=340 W which is the approximately the same as P.sub.FC(min)=(I.sub.FC)(V.sub.FC)=(43 A)(7.8V)335 W accounting for rounding errors. In essence at low humidity three 200 cm.sup.2 stacks produce 1 kW minimum and 1.4 kW maximum.
[3652] To determine the areal power density of a lithium ion cell, the required printed circuit board of 18650 cells with diameters of 1.8 cm are positioned in a rectangular grid indexed by 2 cm in both planar axis. The resulting area is A.sub.bat=A.sub.buf=(2 cm).sup.2=4 cm.sup.2 per cell. Note the area A.sub.buf is the PCB area used by each perpendicularly mounted Li-ion cell, not the active area of the separator rolled up inside the battery. Using nominal characteristics for 18650 Li-ion cells each cell exhibits an average current at 1 C discharge rate of I.sub.bat=l.sub.buf=3200 mA with a corresponding area current density of [I.sub.buf/A.sub.buf]=(3200 mA)/(4 cm.sup.2)=800 mA/cm.sup.2. The nominal voltage for each cell V.sub.bat=V.sub.buf=3.9V at a 1 C discharge rate. The corresponding power density of the cell is [P.sub.buf/A.sub.buf]=[I.sub.buf/A.sub.buf](V.sub.buf)=(800 mA/cm.sup.2)(3.9V)=3.1 W/cm.sup.2. By comparison the areal power of the fuel cell ranges from 1.7 4 W/cm.sup.2 to 2.4 W/cm.sup.2, roughly 45% to 23% lower than a battery, depending on relative humidity. Of course, the fuel cell is able to perpetually deliver power while a battery can only deliver power at a 1 C discharge rate for one hour. Given each Li-ion cell occupies 4 cm.sup.2 of PCB board space, the power delivered at 1 C rate from a single Li-ion cell is P.sub.buf=[P.sub.buf/A.sub.buf](A.sub.buf)=[3.1 W/cm.sup.2](4 cm.sup.2)=12.4 W per cell.
[3653] Normalizing the buffer cell to a 200-cm.sup.2 area means one standard 335 W stack fuel cell occupies the same area as 50 buffer cells capable of delivering P.sub.buf(1 C)=(#buf)(P.sub.bf/cell)=(50)(12.4 W/cell)=620 W for one hour where #buf=n.sub.FCm.sub.FC. This areal power output compares to a fuel cell supplying 335 W at low humidity and 460 W in humid conditions. It should be noted that although this comparison is areal, i.e. normalized to the same area, it is also relatively accurately volumetrically since the height of the fuel cell stack and the height an 18650 cell including mounting hardware are roughly equal and under 2 U height in instrument rack vernacular. Weight is calculated by 45 g/cell for Li-ion and for fuel cells by bipolar plates (49%), end caps (28%), and GDLs (20%).
TABLE-US-00088 Com- ponent 1 cell Li-ion 12-layer stack FC Dis- 1 C rate nominal double charge density density Duration 1 hour* perpetual thermal (steady state) limit Current 800 mA/ 215 mA/cm.sup.2 430 mA/ density cm.sup.2 cm.sup.2 Current/ 3.20 A 0.86 A 1.72 A 4 cm.sup.2 unit Current/ 160 A 43 A 86 A 200 cm.sup.2 cell Humidity low high low Voltage 3.9 V 7.8 V 10.8 V 7.8 V Power 3.1 W/cm.sup.2 1.7 W/cm.sup.2 2.4 W/cm.sup.2 3.4 W/cm.sup.2 density Power/ 12.4 W* 6.8 W 9.6 W 13.6 W 4 cm.sup.2 unit Power/ 620 W* 340 W 480 W 680 W 200 cm.sup.2 cell Weight/ 2.25 kg 0.4 kg 200 cm.sup.2 cell
[3654] Specifically the 2.25 kg weight of fifty Li-ion buffer cells is nearly six times greater than a 12 layer stack occupying the same 200 cm.sup.2 of PCB space weighing only 400 g. Scaling the occupied PCB area by fifteen times to 3000 cm.sup.2, the active area of a power blade's printed circuit board, allows a direct estimate of the weight and gravimetric energy density of various iBFC designs.
TABLE-US-00089 #FC #buf % A.sub.FC % A.sub.buf P.sub.SS P.sub.PoD Wt FC Wt buf Wt total P Density n.sub.FCm.sub.FC n.sub.bufm.sub.buf A.sub.FC/A.sub.pcb A.sub.buf/A.sub.pcb I.sub.FCV.sub.FC P.sub.FC + P.sub.buf 400 g/FC 45 g/cell Wt P.sub.PoD/Wt 0 750 0% 100% 0 kW 9.3 kW 0 kg 33.8 kg 33.8 kg 275 W/kg 3 480 20% 64% 1.0 kW 7.0 kW 1.2 kg 21.6 kg 22.8 kg 307 W/kg 3 336 20% 45% 1.0 kW 5.2 kW 1.2 kg 15.1 kg 16.3 kg 319 W/kg 4 296 27% 39% 1.3 kW 5.0 kW 1.6 kg 13.2 kg 14.8 kg 338 W/kg 5 280 33% 37% 1.7 kW 5.2 kW 2.0 kg 12.6 kg 14.6 kg 356 W/kg 6 300 40% 40% 2.1 kW 5.7 kW 2.4 kg 13.5 kg 15.9 kg 358 W/kg 7 294 47% 39% 2.4 kW 6.0 kW 2.8 kg 13.2 kg 16.0 kg 375 W/kg 12 96 80% 13% 4.0 kW 5.2 kW 4.8 kg 4.3 kg 9.1 kg 570 W/kg 15 0 100% 0% 5.1 kW 5.1 kW 6.0 kg 0 kg 6.0 kg 850 W/kg
[3655] From the foregoing summary, varying the number of fuel cell stacks from 3 to 12 and simultaneously varying the number of buffer cells from 480 to 96 in inverse proportion results in a the fuel cell varying from 20% to 80% of the available power blade's PCB area, while the buffers occupy between 64% and 13% of the available area. The overall PCB utilization, i.e. the fractional sum of (% FC+% buf) vary non-monotonically between 65% and 93%. All designs deliver a power-on-demand minimum output power of 5 kW. Net weight also varies non-monotonically between 22.8 kg and 9.1 kg with a nominal weight of 15 kg per power blade.
[3656] These practical designs are bounded by two extreme cases not classified as buffered fuel cells, namely a 100% fuel cell version delivering 5.2 kW of PoD weighing only 9 kg, contrasted against a 100% buffer version with a PoD output of 7 kW weighing nearly 34 kg. The net result is the spectrum of designs exhibit a monotonic variation in power density between 275 W/kg for a pure battery system and 850 W/kg for a fuel cell only implementation. All iBFCs varied from 307 to 375 W/kg except for the twelve fuel cell version having a gravimetric power density of 570 W/kg.
[3657] These power densities should not be confused with energy densities. Although the relationship between energy density and power density for a lithium ion cell is essentially one for one, i.e. x kWh=x kW#buf, that relation is not true for a fuel cell. For a fuel cell, its power output is based on its number of layers and its membrane area PFC(n.sub.FC)(A.sub.FC) but its continuous power is limited only by its available fuel E.sub.FC=[33 kWh/kg H.sub.2](Wt H.sub.2) so long that the fuel cell is sufficiently large to deliver the total energy over the required period of time, vis--vis where P.sub.FCE.sub.FC/t. For example, so long that a fuel cell has a power output capability of 1.4 kW, it is able to deliver 33 kWh of energy indefinitely as long as it has fuel. Once the minimum power condition is met, the fuel cell total available energy has nothing to do with its power rating.
[3658] As shown in
[3659] As shown by curve 7101, any increase in the area allocated to buffer cells linearly decreases the fuel cell area and generated power P.sub.FC but correspondingly increases the buffer power P.sub.buf shown by curve 7100. The sum of the two power components, referred to as power-on-demand P.sub.PoD=P.sub.buf+P.sub.SS shown by curve 7102 increases in proportion to buffer area A.sub.FC. The total power increases to when #buf=750 where A.sub.buf=3000 cm.sup.2, where the power is equal to P.sub.buf=P.sub.PoD=[P.sub.buf/A.sub.buf](A.sub.buf)=[3.1 W/cm.sup.2](3000 cm.sup.2)=9.3 kW. As shown, the ratio of continuous power P.sub.ss to power-on-demand P.sub.PoD, where =P.sub.SS/P.sub.PoD is shown by curve 7103.
[3660]
[3661]
[3662]
[3663]
[3664]
Energy Bank Autonomous Power System.
[3665] An autonomous hydrogen power system made in accordance with this invention comprises a power generation and storage system referred to herein as an energy bank capable of supplying electrical power to a home, business, or microgrid supplying multiple users. When operating off grid, i.e. without relying on public utilities for electrical energy, the system is able to operate fully autonomously where the self generated power is equal to the electrical load demand which it powers. Alternatively the system may operate quasi-autonomously where the generated power is used to supplement or cost-reduce other sources of power.
[3666] In fully autonomous mode, the energy bank is able to produce and supply energy indefinitely so long that a fuel supply is made available. Operating in a manner analogous to a gas-powered water heater, so long that fuel is available the operation of the energy bank will supply electricity without even being noticed. As such, the energy bank is not a battery backup system with limited energy consumed after a few hours of use. Instead it can be considered as a primary source of power converting fuel into electricity perpetually. Moreover the iBFC based energy bank integrates its own secondary power storage to handle periods of high peak demand.
[3667] As disclosed herein, the intelligent buffered fuel cell (iBFC) is the core component of the energy bank used to realize an efficient environmentally-friendly alternative to grid power and public utilities. Depending on user requirements the energy bank may be configured with one or more iBFCs connected in series, parallel, or series-parallel circuits. Each iBFC includes a combination of fuel cells, electrochemical buffers, and a charge transfer regulator used to control energy flow. In one set of embodiments, the fuel cells employ a proton exchange membrane (PEM) to generate electricity from a cationic fuel source such as hydrogen or methanol. In another embodiment the system utilizes anionic fuel cells (AEMs) able to convert hydroxide or other alkali fuels into electricity.
[3668] Regardless of whether the ion exchange membrane (IEM) is cationic or anionic, the generated electricity is stored in an electrochemical buffer coulombically, generally comprising an array of lithium ion cells or other emerging charge storage chemistries. In operation, a charge transfer regulator (QXR) controls energy flow between the fuel cell and buffer, both limiting the current demand drawn from the fuel cell to mitigate voltage sag while properly charging the battery at a prudent level of current and within a prescribed safe voltage range. The charging algorithms may include constant voltage mode, constant current mode, or sequencing thereof, including protection against overcharge, over-discharge, over-temperature, and cell voltage imbalances. The buffer may be charged from fuel generated electricity or from an external electrical source, directly charging the buffer array. The operational details of the iBFC are described in greater detail in a related application Intelligent Buffered Fuel Cell with Low Impedance and will not be described further here.
[3669] In one embodiment shown in
[3670] Made in accordance with this invention, the power output rating of an energy bank able to generate this amount of power in one 24-hr day is thereby given by P.sub.SSE/t=33 kWh/24 hr1.3 kW. In other words, any energy bank with a power output rated at 1.3 kW or greater is able to supply a full day's power without drawing down stored charge in its buffer. To handle periods of high demand the fuel cell and the buffer work together to deliver a power-on-demand output of 5 kW to 7 kW depending on the design, after which the fuel cell replenishes the buffer's lost charge.
[3671] Referring the 5 kW power blade design table and graphs, only those designs with three fuel cells and P.sub.SS=1 kW fall short of the 1.3 kW output necessitated by fully-autonomous operation at daily energy breakeven. That said, the 1 kW rating is rated at low humidity. In high humidity environs, the steady-state output of even the three fuel cell iBFC energy bank increases to 1.4 kW, meaning any of the 5 kW power blades described herein are able to autonomously meet all daily energy production needs by hydrogen conversion.
[3672] Another consideration in autonomous power generation is the source of hydrogen used in the energy bank which may be (i) purchased from a hydrogen supplier, or (ii) made autonomously on location. As illustrated in the previously cited
[3673] One of the lower cost solutions involves conversion of natural gas into hydrogen with or without carbon sequester, referred to as gray or blue hydrogen respectfully. Costs vary by region but in 2024 gray hydrogen can be acquired wholesale in bulk at $1 US per kilogram, equivalent to $0.03 per kWh, significantly lower than electric grid power today. Commercially generated hydrogen 7304a may be supplied 7307 as via tanks or canisters transported 7304b from central production facilities 7304a to commercial outlets such as gas stations or convenience stores, or supplied in bulk to high volume consumers such as smart grid facilities, energy storage facilities. Bulk liquid hydrogen shipments may also be supplied heavy users like cloud computing, server farms, A1 central hosts, supercomputers, crypto miners, and cloud network providers. In high volume or mission critical applications, hydrogen gas can also be delivered using subterranean pipes 7304c.
[3674] Another hydrogen production method suitable for autonomous energy involves hydrolysisthe electrolytic splitting of water into hydrogen and oxygen. In hydrolysis, water is catalytically broken into its constituent H.sub.2 and O.sub.2 gasses, where the hydrogen is ionized by a catalyst into protons and transported across an ion exchange membrane under the influence of an electric field. Once arriving in the cathode the proton and electrons recombine to produce elemental hydrogen and hydrogen gas molecules ready for storage.
[3675] As such, hydrolyzer 7302 converts power from an electric source such as PV solar panel 7301 into hydrogen 7307a to be stored in hydrogen bank 7303 for later use. Alternatively, a portion of the solar electric current can be diverted to energy bank 7309 and stored coulombically. If the source of power driving the electrolyzer comprises renewable energy from wind or solar PV, the hydrogen produced 7307a is considered green hydrogen. Commercial green hydrogen is available for $5 to $7 US per kilogram. Self made hydrogen, by contrast costs $0 per kWh after the capital expense is recovered or written off.
[3676] One limitation of the architecture of autonomous hydrogen power system 7300 is the delicate balance required between the electrical energy source illustrated as PV solar panel 7301 and the hydrogen output rate of the water to-hydrogen electrolyzer depicted as iBWHC 7302. Should the source of electrical power be less than the optimum power required to maximize the rate of hydrogen evolution 7307a, then less hydrogen will be produced for lack of energy. In other words, the hydrolyzer will be operating below its capacity and the potential to generate and store energy will underperform expectations.
[3677] Conversely if the source of electrical power 7301 exceeds the maximum conversion rate of hydrolyzer 7302, then excess electricity will be generated that the hydrolysis can't use. Electrical energy will be wasted as heat without ever being converted into storable hydrogen fuel. This problem can be averted by routing excess power to buffer for direct charging 7308 within energy bank 7305, a least temporarily.
[3678] Once the buffer is fully charged however, excess PV power will be lost if water-to-hydrogen conversion of electrolyzer 7302 cannot keep up. Complicating matters further, for most sources of renewable power, be it PV solar or wind generation, the electrical output is not steady nor perpetual. PV solar only produces power when the sun is shining in the daylight hours. Wind power is only generated when the wind is blowing. Even a non-renewable power source such as an emergency diesel or gasoline generator is problematic as it cannot be used at night without violating city anti-noise ordinances. This means the electrical power used to power the hydrolyzer is only available part of the day and at inconsistent power levels.
[3679] One embodiment of this invention is to replace the conventional water-to-hydrogen converter (WHC) comprising electrolyzer 7302 with a more advanced system, an intelligent buffered water to hydrogen converter or iBWHC. In the iBWHC, the electrical input to the electrolyzer includes a battery array used to store excess electricity generated by the primary electrical power source 7301 such as a PV solar or wind system until the hydrolysis processor can catch up with the energy surplus. While as a stand alone unit, inclusion of a buffer improves the throughput of electrolyzer 7302 avoiding the need for a more-expensive higher capacity electrolytic converter, it does add cost to include the electrical buffer cells.
[3680] An alternative more cost effective approach shown in
Improved Water-to-Hydrogen Electrolysis.
[3681] The inverse function of a membrane fuel cell which converts hydrogen and oxygen into water and electricity is the electrochemical process of water hydrolysis, an electrolytic reaction converting water and electricity into hydrogen and oxygen. In electrolysis at the anode, water oxidation results in the release of oxygen gas (O.sub.2), mobile protons (H.sup.+), and hydronium ions (H.sub.3O) by the oxygen evolution reaction (OER), not mass balanced
H.sub.2O(I).fwdarw.O.sub.2(g)+(H.sup.+(aq)+H.sub.3O.sup.+(aq))+e.sup.
where the parenthetical lowercase letter (1) indicates liquid, (aq) indicates aqueous meaning in solution, and (g) refers to the gaseous state of matter. Hydrogen ions liberated in the anode catalyst layer ACL 7404a migrate through the IEM 7405 electrolyte to the cathode catalyst layer 7404c either as protons (H.sup.+) or as hydronium ions (H.sub.3O.sup.+). At the cathode, reduction of protons occurs leading to the production of hydrogen gas (H.sup.2) conducted through the cathode gas diffusion layer (KGDL) 7403c via the corresponding reaction represented by the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER):
##STR00040##
Overall, PEM hydrogen electrolysis comprises a net REDOX reaction
##STR00041##
where the anode and cathode catalysts are ideally dissimilar.
[3682] Because a hydrolyzer's hydrogen generation rate cannot be matched to its electrical input, it is important to temporarily store electric charge to continuously power the electrolysis process. As shown in
[3683] In the conversion process, the charge transfer regulator QXR performs two functions. First it ensures that the current delivered from the buffer array does not exceed a specified discharge rate to avoid damage to the electrochemical cell, for example 1 C. The programmability of the QXR 7409 also enables the maximum rate to be adjusted based on temperature or urgent demand. The second function is to control the current flow through the ion exchange membrane to prevent excessive current, over heating, or membrane damage.
[3684] In one embodiment the PEM+ membrane 7405z is adapted for use as the ion exchange membrane 7405 in the electrolyzer. Beneficial features of the PEM+ membrane in electrolysis includes [3685] high conductivity bipolar plates 7401a and 7401c for reduced resistance, improved reaction uniformity, and higher conversion efficiencies; [3686] graded gas diffusion layers AGDL 7403a and KGDL 7403c to improve water transport in the anode and hydrogen transport in the cathode leading to higher generation rates; [3687] asymmetric catalyst layers comprising ACL 7304a cathode catalyst layers 7304c optimizing the reaction rates for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) using the metallic oxides RuO.sub.2 or IrO.sub.2 and accelerating the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) with transition metals Pt or Pd; [3688] ion exchange membrane 7405 including an endoskeleton providing structural support allowing the membrane to be made thinner than conventional electrolysis membranes; [3689] ion exchange membrane 7405 including sac pores generated using a sacrificial filler process improving membrane porosity; and [3690] ion exchange membrane 7405 including permanent fillers and ionic liquids optionally contained by endoskeletal support and nanocoating layers.
[3691] Of particular significance is the role of the endoskeletal support grid enabling the IEM to be reduced from 100 m to 20 m, thereby profoundly affecting conductivity as was similarly demonstrated by the PEM+ membrane in fuel cell measurements.
[3692] Using conventional ion exchange membranes, each kilogram of hydrogen requires 55 kWh to generate 1 kg of hydrogen, and each kilogram of hydrogen can only generate 33 kWh of electrical energy, a n efficiency loss of 40% i.e. where WHHC=(33 kHh)/(55 kWh)=60%. As an embodiment of this invention, an improved ionomeric polymer is used to form the ion exchange membrane in a water to hydrogen electrolyzer to improve the overall conversion efficiency and hydrogen yield increasing conversion efficiency from 60% to 75%, reducing the power input required from 55 kWh to 44 kWh.
[3693] In an alternate system topology shown in
[3694] In the system shown, charge transfer regulator QXR 7411 controls the energy transfer rate from dynamic fuel cell array 7410 to energy storage buffer 7400 to prevent fuel cell voltage sag and overcharging or excessive charging currents in energy storage buffer 7400. A second charge transfer regulator QXR 7409 controls the flow of electric current from shared energy storage buffer 7400 into WHC electrolyzer 7410 to prevent excessive buffer currents and to protect the membrane in the hydrolyzer. Both dynamic fuel cell array 7410 comprising PEM+ membrane 7405f and WHC electrolyzer 7410 comprising PEM+ membrane 7405e benefit from the improved membrane features disclosed herein except that they include different catalyst layers. Together they improved the overall system efficiency in autonomous hydrogen energy systems, especially for powering multi user microgrids.
Advanced IEM Features.
[3695] Features of the advanced membrane beneficial for both iBFC fuel cell conversion of hydrogen to electricity and as an electrolyte in electrolytic water-to-hydrogen conversion (W2HC) hydrolysis include a variety of creative embodiments which may be combined in various ways in inventive IEM 7400 as shown in
Inventive Embodiments
[3700] Inventive elements of an improved ion exchange membrane (IEM) and its applications in energy conversion and electrochemistry include devices comprising enhanced ionomeric membranes and structures along with synthesis and fabrication processes therefore. Exemplary applications of the improved IEMs include their use in stack fuel cells, intelligent buffered fuel cells (iBFCs), energy banks for individual residences and businesses; power blades for scalable autonomous power generation and microgrid distribution; water hydrolysis for hydrogen generation; and ionic filtering of fluids. Topics as disclosed, cover both apparatus and method subject matter.
Electrochemical Membrane Innovations.
[3701] Improved ion exchange membranes (IEM) described herein include new and innovative ionomeric polymers [
[3702] Improved IEM fabrication using facile process methods include (i) controlling the relative ratio of hydrophobic-to-hydrophilic mainchain polymer segments; (ii) controlling the crystalline and amorphous structure of the polymer matrix through blending of monomers during polymerization; (iii) stoichiometrically adjusting the polymeric pore size and density of the polymer; (iv) controlling the length of sidechains with ionomeric termini including short sidechain (SSC), long sidechain (LSC), and multi-acid sidechain (MASC) pendants; and (v) enhancing conductivity over a wider ranges of temperature, humidity, and pH by integrating two-or-more acids into a hetero-ionomer. In another set of embodiments specific acids or acid-pairs are matched to the membrane polymer composition for compatibility, enhancing performance while preventing film degradation and fuel cell corrosion.
[3703] Alternative fabrication methods employ grafting sidechains with ionomer termini onto chemical or radiation-induced damage sites onto a polymer's mainchain, coating polymers with nanoparticles to form nano-entangled sidechain attachments to the polymer matrix, or embedding pristine or crushed electrospun nanofibers into the mold prior to polymerization.
[3704] In one set of embodiments, proton exchange membranes containing membrane bound acids that readily deprotonate into immobile anions, are paired to specific polymers with which they are most compatible. Membrane bound acids [
[3705] In another set of embodiments, mutually compatible acid pairs [
[3706] Aside from controlling the structure of ionomeric membranes during polymerization, other inventive embodiments include the addition of fillers [
[3707] In conventional membrane synthesis, quasi-crystalline and amorphous polymer regions may spontaneously form during crosslinking adversely impacting pore formation and suppressing charge transport [
[3708] In another broad class of inventive embodiments, monomers used to form the improved ion exchange membranes are blended with permanent fillers [
[3709] Exemplary permanent fillers [
[3710] In one embodiment, after membrane polymerization, the polymer is soaked in an ionic liquid allowing mobile ions to seep into the natural interstitial pores and channels within polymeric matrix thereby enhancing electrical conductivity. The improvement however is mitigated by limitation if the naturally occurring density of membrane pockets and conduits not blocked by intervening atomic structure and choke points impeding vehicular transport.
[3711] In an alternative embodiment, the polymer matrix is first fabricated using the sacrificial filler process where after polymerization the sacrificial filler is removed opening sac pores and channels. Thereafter the microporous membrane is soaked in ionic liquid whereby IL cations and anions pool within the pores [
[3712] As ionic liquids comprise organic ionic salts with low melting points, at fuel cell operating temperatures and even at room temperature the salts readily dissociate into liquids comprising mobile anions and cations. When introduced into an ionomeric membrane, these mobile charges aid in charge transport within the matrix via the film's dominant conduction mechanism. For example, mobile IL cations participate in conduction in a proton exchange membrane (PEM) while mobile IL anions contribute to charge transport in anion exchange membrane (AEM).
[3713] For example, embodiments of this invention include PEM dopants comprising the following IL cations [
[3714] Although performance improvements offered by innovative IEMs with micropores, skeletal support, and hetero-ionomers augmented by permanent fillers and dopants described herein represent generalized device concepts, their implementation is process dependent involving non-obvious combinations of monomers, reagents, cross-linkers, acids, dopants, and fillers varying with each class of polymer.
[3715] While detailed discussions are contained throughout this application as arranged by section representative samples of ionomeric polymer membranes are summarized here for convenience's sake. The table contains two classes of inventive embodimentsmembranes and fillers. Membranes include PFSA homopolymer, composite reinforced PTFE-PFSA, amorphous glassy matrices, functionalized polyethylene (PE), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), polypropylene (PP), functionalized polyvinyl chloride (PVC), functionalized polyimide (PI), functionalized polystyrene (PS), poly(fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile (sPFEKN), polyphenylene (PPh), functionalized polyarylene ether (SPAE), polyarylene ether sulfone (SPAESf), functionalized poly ether ketones (PEK), functionalized poly ether sulfones (PESf), functionalized ketone sulfones (PKSf), functionalized arylene ether ketone sulfones (PAEKSf), perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane (PFMMD) or perfluoro-methylene-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDD), poly-dioxo-dihydro-pyrrole copolymers (PDDP-co-X), phenyl copolymers (Ph-co-X) of alkane and aldehyde, polystyrene (PSt) and/or polyurethane (PTU), polysulfone (PSu, PSf), polyamide sulfonimide (SPA-co-Slm), phosphazene (Pz), siloxane (SiX), triazine (Tz), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), multi-acid sidechain (MASC), arylene ether polymer (PAE), acid-base polysulfone (PSf), anhydrous p-oxydiphenylene-bibenzimidazole](PBI), biopolymers including chitosan (CS), cellulose acetate (CA), alginic acid (AA), and polydopamine (PDA).
[3716] Permanent fillers and dopants include carbon fillers (GO, CNT), silicates, PMMA NS, polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes compounds POSS and DDSQ, nanostructures including NSs, NCs, NFs, CNTs, and nanocoatings, zirconium (Zr) NS, MOFs, tungsten (W) NCs, zeolite (ZI), ionic liquids, and block copolymers.
TABLE-US-00090 Independent Claims Dependent Claim Support 1. A proton exchange membrane comprises a the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 4B, 18B, PFSA homopolymer where the skeleton comprises PTFE co- 19A, 23, 24, the membrane contains micropores formed molded with or glued to the PFSA film 77A, 77B, 81, by a sacrificial filler process optionally reinforced by rigid filler 104 the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM is coated with PTFE NPs the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids 2. A proton exchange membrane comprises a the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 23, 24, composite PTFE-PFSA polymer where the skeleton comprises PTFE co- 77B, 81, 104, the membrane contains micropores formed molded with or glued to the PFSA film 105, 106, 107 by a sacrificial filler process optionally reinforced by rigid filler the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM is coated with PTFE NPs the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids the polymer mainchain is grafted or entangled to a sidechain and ionomer 3. A proton exchange membrane comprises an the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, amorphous glassy matrix such as PFMMD, PDD, the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 110 or sulfonated fluorocarbon glass where polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains micropores formed one of the membrane bound acids by a sacrificial filler process comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains skeletal support the IEM includes permanent fillers the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes ionic liquids membrane bound acidic ionomers mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 4. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polyethylene (PE) where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 113 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 5A. Proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) grafted onto the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 115 functionalized cellulose acetate (CA) where polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains micropores formed one of the membrane bound acids by a sacrificial filler process comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains skeletal support the IEM includes permanent fillers the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes ionic liquids membrane bound acidic ionomers mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 5B. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 117 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic, sulfonic, or the membrane contains at least two different sulfosuccinic acid (SSA) membrane bound acidic ionomers SSA forms a cross link between at least two PVA mainchains the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 6. A proton exchange membrane comprises the copolymer is PVP-PSSA FIGS. 24, 77B, copolymers or blends of polyvinylidene fluoride the copolymer is PMMA 104, 118-123, (PVDF) with other polymers where the copolymer is PC 124 the membrane contains micropores formed the copolymer is PFSA by a sacrificial filler process the copolymer is PVP-SA the membrane contains skeletal support the copolymer is AIBN-SPA the membrane contains at least two different the copolymer is AIBN-SPA-PFH membrane bound acidic ionomers the copolymer is HFP the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 7. A proton exchange membrane comprising the copolymer is PFSA FIGS. 24, 77B, polypropylene (PP) blended with other the micropores are formed by sugar 104, 118-123, polymers where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 126 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 8. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polyvinyl chloride (PVC) where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 128 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises sulfuric or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 9. A proton exchange membrane comprises the PI chain includes sulfonamides FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polyimide (PI) where such as ODADS and PBABTS 104, 129-131, the membrane contains micropores formed the PI chain includes diamines such 132 by a sacrificial filler process as BAPP, 9FDA, BAPN the membrane contains skeletal support the PI chain includes dianhydrides the membrane contains at least two different such as BPADA, NTDA, ODPA, DSDA membrane bound acidic ionomers the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA one of the membrane bound acids comprises sulfuric or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 10. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polystyrene (PS) where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 136 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 11. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, poly(fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile (sPFEKN) the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 138 where polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains micropores formed one of the membrane bound acids by a sacrificial filler process comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains skeletal support the IEM includes permanent fillers the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes ionic liquids membrane bound acidic ionomers mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 12. A proton exchange membrane comprises PPh variants include sPP, sPP-QA, FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polyphenylene (PPh) where sPPP-H.sup.+, sPPN-H.sup.+, sPPB-H.sup.+, sPPT-H.sup.+, 104, 153 the membrane contains micropores formed sPPBm-H.sup.+, sPPBo-H.sup.+, sPPP-OH, sPPP by a sacrificial filler process N-free, sPPP(X + 0)N, sPPP(X + 1)N the membrane contains skeletal support PP also comprise PPDSA, PBPDSA, the membrane contains at least two different BXPY, DiBPS, DiiPS, DiBtBS, Si-PPBP membrane bound acidic ionomers the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 13. A proton exchange membrane comprises the micropores are formed by sugar FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized polyarylene ether (SPAE) and the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 104, 154-158, polyarylene ether sulfone (SPAESf) where polymer coated with PVA or adhesive 159 the membrane contains micropores formed one of the membrane bound acids by a sacrificial filler process comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains skeletal support the IEM includes permanent fillers the membrane contains at least two different including Krytox-157 FSL GO, PFPE- membrane bound acidic ionomers GO, and PWA crystallites the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 14. A proton exchange membrane comprises poly ether ketones include sPEEK, FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized poly ether ketones (PEK) where sPEK, sPEKK, sPEEEK, sPEEKK, 104, 160-169, the membrane contains micropores formed sPEKKK, sPEKEKK, 2PEK 170 by a sacrificial filler process the micropores are formed by sugar the membrane contains skeletal support the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains at least two different polymer coated with PVA or adhesive membrane bound acidic ionomers one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 15A. A proton exchange membrane comprises poly ether sulfones include R-PEESf, FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized poly ether sulfones (PESf) sPEESf, sPESfESf, sPESf 104, 171-179, polymers and copolymers where poly ether sulfones copolymers 180 the membrane contains micropores formed include sPEESf-co-PEI, sP(PhEESf)- by a sacrificial filler process PAMPS the membrane contains skeletal support poly ether sulfone variants include the membrane contains at least two different sPEDSf, sFPESf, sP(PhESf) membrane bound acidic ionomers radicals R may be H+, SO.sub.3H, SO.sub.3Na . . . the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 15B. A proton exchange membrane comprises ketone sulfones include sPKKSf FIGS. 24, 77B, functionalized ketone sulfones (PKSf), arylene arylene ether ketone sulfones 104, 181A- ether ketone sulfones (PAEKSf), and variants include sPAKEKSf, sPAKEKSf, sPAEKSf 185, 186 therefrom where the micropores are formed by sugar the membrane contains micropores formed the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid by a sacrificial filler process polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes permanent fillers fillers include bismuth compounds of BiTMA and B.sub.i2MoO.sub.6 the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 16. A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of carbon PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 187-195, compounds and nanostructures applicable for a PBI, PI, and CS 196 range of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon pristine carbon nanotubes including polymer chemistries SW-CNT, MW-CNT CNTs functionalized by COOH, SO3H, POH, NH.sub.2, SiO.sub.2, and TiO.sub.2 graphene oxides (GO) functionalized by Krytox-157 FS, PFPE, and ABPBI GO variants include Hohman, Scholz- Boehn, Ruess, and Lerf-Klinowski 17. A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, contains permanent fillers of silica PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 197-204, PBI, PI, and CS 205 inert silicates controlling density silica mesostructured cellular foam functionalized hollow MCF PA,SA,OH Al-MCF mPBI hybrid membrane 18. A hybrid proton exchange membrane copolymers include P(PFMMD-co- FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises functionalized perfluoro-methylene- PFMD), P(PFMDD-co-PFMD), 104, 206A- methyl-dioxolane (PFMMD) or perfluoro- P(PFMMD-co-CTFE), P(PFMDD-co- 211F, 212 methylene-dimethyl-dioxolane (PFDD) CTFE), P(PFMMD-co-PFSt), and polymers and copolymers where PFMMD-co-PFSA the membrane contains micropores formed tri-copolymers include P(PFMMD-co- by a sacrificial filler process PFMD-co-PFSA), P(PFMDD-co-PFMD- the membrane contains skeletal support co-PFSA), P(PFMMD-co-CTFE-co- the membrane contains at least two different PFSA), P(PFMMD-co-CTFE-co-PFSA), membrane bound acidic ionomers P(PFMMD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA), and P(PFMMD-co-PFSt-co-PFSA) the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 19. A hybrid proton exchange membrane PDDP copolymers include PDDP- FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises poly-dioxo-dihydro-pyrrole CSFS, SPmax-1200, PDDP-CSFSt-co- 104, 213- copolymers (PDDP-co-X) where SPmax, PDDP-CSFSt-co-SPmax, 215B, 216 the membrane contains micropores formed the micropores are formed by sugar by a sacrificial filler process the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains skeletal support polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains at least two different one of the membrane bound acids membrane bound acidic ionomers comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 20. A hybrid proton exchange membrane phenyl copolymers comprise FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises phenyl copolymers (Ph-co-X) of sulfonated phenyl-co-alkane (SP3) and 104, 217-221, alkane and aldehyde where phenyl-co-alkane (sPhCH = O) 222 the membrane contains micropores formed the micropores are formed by sugar by a sacrificial filler process the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains skeletal support polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains at least two different one of the membrane bound acids membrane bound acidic ionomers comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 21. A hybrid proton exchange membrane styrene polymers include FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises polystyrene (PSt) and/or poly(trifluorostyrene) (sPTFS) 104, 223-227, polyurethane (PTU) polymers and copolymers styrene cross links and grafts include 228 including grafts and cross-links where sPTFS-XL-sPTFS and P(PFA)-g-PSSA the membrane contains micropores formed styrene and urethane copolymers by a sacrificial filler process include PS-co-sPSS, PTPU-co-sDVB the membrane contains skeletal support styrene-urethane copolymers the membrane contains at least two different include PTPU-co-PSS-co-sDVB, PTPU- membrane bound acidic ionomers co-PUE-co-DVB-co-PSS the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 22. A hybrid proton exchange membrane polysulfone includes (sPSf, sPSU) FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises polysulfone (PSu, PSf) polymer the micropores are formed by sugar 104, 229-230, where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 231 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 23. A hybrid proton exchange membrane sulfonimide includes SPA-co-SIm and FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a polyamide sulfonimide (SPA-co- sSPA-co-SIm 104, 232- Slm) polymer where the micropores are formed by sugar 233B, 234 the membrane contains micropores formed the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid by a sacrificial filler process polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 24. A hybrid proton exchange membrane phosphazene include P(sPz), P(sPz- FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a phosphazene (Pz) polymer where co-Pz), or P(pPz-co-Pz) 104, 235A- the membrane contains micropores formed the micropores are formed by sugar 235B, 236 by a sacrificial filler process the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains skeletal support polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains at least two different one of the membrane bound acids membrane bound acidic ionomers comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 25. A hybrid proton exchange membrane siloxane includes P(sSiX-co-SiX) FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a siloxane (SiX) polymer where the micropores are formed by sugar 104, 237, 238 the membrane contains micropores formed the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid by a sacrificial filler process polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 26. A hybrid proton exchange membrane triazine polymers include pCTF, FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a triazine (Tz) polymer or copolymer sCTP, pCTF-sPh, pCTF-pTPA, pCTF- 104, 240-245, where sTPhA, pCTF-TF 246 the membrane contains micropores formed copolymers include sCTF-co-PVDF, by a sacrificial filler process P(SPAESf-co-TBPh) the membrane contains skeletal support functionalized triazine frameworks the membrane contains at least two different include 6T6sPh, 3T6sPh, 6T12sPh6bPy, membrane bound acidic ionomers and 6T6Ph-F.sub.4 the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers SA or PA functionalized triazine substrate as a permanent filler the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 27. A hybrid proton exchange membrane of PMMA copolymers include sP(MMA- FIGS. 24, 77B, nanospheres comprise a poly(methyl co-MAH), sP(MMA-co-MAH-co-Mi) 104, 247A- methacrylate) (PMMA) polymer where PMMA grafted IEMs including PE-g- 261, 262 the membrane contains micropores formed PMMA, PMMA-g-PVDC by a sacrificial filler process the micropores are formed by sugar the membrane contains skeletal support the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains at least two different polymer coated with PVA or adhesive membrane bound acidic ionomers one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers SPMMA and porous PMMA nanospheres PMMA-nanoclusters including Pd PMMA NCs, Pd MMA-MAA NCs, ZnS NS doped NCs, ZnO NS doped NCs, the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 28. A hybrid proton exchange membrane copolymers include CMC-co-PVA-co- FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) AA 104, 263 copolymers where the micropores are formed by sugar the membrane contains micropores formed the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid by a sacrificial filler process polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains skeletal support one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains at least two different comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 29. A hybrid proton exchange membrane multi acid sidechains include PFIA FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a multi-acid sidechain (MASC) the micropores are formed by sugar 104, 264- polymer where the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid 265C, 266 the membrane contains micropores formed polymer coated with PVA or adhesive by a sacrificial filler process one of the membrane bound acids the membrane contains skeletal support comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the membrane contains at least two different the IEM includes permanent fillers membrane bound acidic ionomers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 30. A hybrid proton exchange membrane poly arylene ether moieties include FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises arylene ether polymer (PAE) where P12F9-7B, sP6F9-CB 104, 267-269, the membrane contains micropores formed the micropores are formed by sugar 270 by a sacrificial filler process the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains skeletal support polymer coated with PVA or adhesive the membrane contains at least two different one of the membrane bound acids membrane bound acidic ionomers comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 31 A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of polyhedral PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 271- oligomeric silsesquioxanes compounds POSS PBI, PI, and CS and DDSQ and nanostructures thereof polyoctahedral SQ compounds applicable for a wide range of fluorocarbon include POSS-SH, POSS-S-PA, POSS-R, and hydrocarbon polymer chemistries POSS-PEG-R, POSS-iBu, POSS-Vi, POSS- 8CI, Ot-POSS, OV-POSS, OPh-POSS, POSS-iBu-Vi, POSS-iBu-NH.sub.2, POSS-Bu- CI, POSS-iBu-3OH, POSS-iBu-styryl, POSS-iBu-PS, POSS-PS-R, sPOSS-Cp-PS, sPOSS-Cy-PS, POSS-AM-iBu, POSS-SH- iBu, POSS-A, POSS resin-cage polyoctahedral SQ compounds include unreactive POSS, 1D POSS, planar POSS, and 3D POSS double-decker SQ compounds include DDSQ, NMe DDSQ-R, and Me DDSQ-R 32 A hybrid proton exchange membrane hybrid membranes include s(PVA-co- FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of nanostructures SPA-co-PEO) with PO.sub.4TiO.sub.2 CNT fillers 104, 293- applicable for a range of fluorocarbon and hybrid membranes of PFSA-PTFE 296B, 307 hydrocarbon polymer chemistries with P(DA-sDA) hybrid membrane comprising sol-gel matrix with scavenger NP and catalyst ionomeric membranes may include PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, PBI, PI, and CS nanocoatings include polyimide (PI) atop PTFE-PFSA membrane nanocomposites include PTFE-PFSA nanofiber pristine extended PTFE nanofibers include dopamine and zirconium nanocoated ePTFE, DPA and Pt nanocoated polyimide carbon nanotubes include CNTs coated by PBI, functionalized by (PtCl.sub.6).sup.2, NH.sub.2, Pt-NH.sub.2 NPs, Ti-NH.sub.2 NPs, Pt-Sn NPs electrospun nanofibers (NFs) of poly sulfonated polystyrene 33 A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of zirconium (Zr) PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 308-311, compounds and nanostructures applicable for a PBI, PI, and CS 312 range of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon polyether sulfone membrane polymer chemistries includes intercalant zirconium (-type, -type, and -type) zirconium nanospheres 34 A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of metal organic PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 313- frameworks (MOFs) and nanostructures PBI, PI, and CS 333B, 334 applicable for a range of fluorocarbon and MOFs comprise convex, concave, hydrocarbon polymer chemistries cluster, rectangular prism, cube, trapezoid, double trapezoid, hexagonal drum, octagonal drum geometries with or without guests MOFs include 3D quasi crystals, acid pendants, with acid-to-acid and quasi- crystal bonding MOFs include metal clusters of zinc acetate, zirconium hydroxide, sulfonic ferrite, chromium terephthalate, and zinc oxide scavenger MOFs include MOF vertex, ligand, guest, or interleaved scavengers metal-ligand-heterometals include Fe-Pt, Fe-Ti, Co-Pt, and Ni-Pt systems M-L-M bonds include M-dithiolene, M-EDT, M-PLTSC, M-ambidentate, M- DPPE, M-BIPY, M-salicylaldehyde, and M-Schiff base 35 A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of tungsten (W) PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 335-339, compounds and nanostructures applicable for a PBI, PI, and CS 340 wide range of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon PSf membrane includes PWA, P4VP, polymer chemistries CP4VP PVA membranes includes PWA, QPEI, and R.sub.4N.sup.+ IEM dopants include WC NPs, PWA phosphotungstic acid 36 A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of zeolite (ZI) PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 341-349, compounds and nanostructures applicable for a PBI, PI, and CS 350 range of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon functionalized zeolites (Al.sub.2O.sub.3).sup. polymer chemistries (SiO.sub.2).sub.x includes phenylsulfuric acid zeolite (PhSA-Zl) zeolite geometries include L, LTA/A, X&Y, ZSM-5, pentasil MOR, pentasil FOR, pentasil BEA, and s-mordenite zeolite NC includes metal catalyst 37. A hybrid proton exchange membrane functionalized polysulfone includes FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises an acid-base polysulfone (PSf) sPSf, BrPSf, (BrPSf)x 104, 351-361, polymers where functionalized graphene oxide 362 the membrane contains micropores formed doped polysulfone (FPGO-sPSf) by a sacrificial filler process the micropores are formed by sugar the membrane contains skeletal support the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid the membrane contains at least two different polymer coated with PVA or adhesive membrane bound acidic ionomers one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers Pt-TiO.sub.2 nanoparticle filler polyoctahedral silsesquioxanes (POSS) filler the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 38. A hybrid proton exchange membrane PBI variants include O-PBI, 2O-PBI FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises anhydrous p-oxydiphenylene- PAEBI, ABPBI, 20H-PBI, F.sub.6-PBI, SO.sub.2- 104, 363-378, bibenzimidazole] (PBI) polymer where PBI, SC-SO.sub.2-PBI 379 the membrane contains micropores formed copolymers include HCCP-co-PBI, by a sacrificial filler process ImCCP-co-PBI, OPBI-co-PVBC, DABCO- the membrane contains skeletal support co-OPBI-co-PVBC-co-quinuclidine, the membrane contains at least two different OPBI-co-QA, PBI-co-ZIF membrane bound acidic ionomers includes crushed electrospun fibers the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA or adhesive one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 39. A hybrid proton exchange membrane biopolymers comprise functionalized FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a biopolymers where chitosan (CS), cellulose (CE), alginic 104, 380- the membrane contains micropores formed acid (AA), phosphorylated chitosan 401D, 402 by a sacrificial filler process (pCS), chitosan sulfonate (sCS), XL the membrane contains skeletal support sulfonated chitosan (sCS), cellulose the membrane contains at least two different acetate (CA), polydopamine (PDA), membrane bound acidic ionomers CS-co-PEO, fCS-co-PEO bio-copolymers (CS-co-PAN)-R, (CS- co-PS)-R, (CS-co-PVA)-R, CS-co-PFSA, grafted biopolymers CS-g-PVP, CS-g- SSA, sCA-g-P(MMA-co-AMPS), spCA-g- P(MMA-co-AMPS) carbon functionalized chitosan CS-g- PVP-CNT, CS-g-sGO polyhedral oligomeric SQ doped chitosan (POSS XL-CS) polydopamine copolymer PDA-co- ADPS-SA, sCS-co-PDA-co-ADPS-SA, CS- co-PDA, CS-co-fPDA the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton 40. A hybrid proton exchange membrane ionomeric membranes may include FIGS. 24, 77B, containing permanent fillers of ionic liquid PFSA, PFSA-PTFE, SPAESf, SPEEK, PVA, 104, 403A- compounds and nanostructures applicable for a PBI, PI, and CS 421422A-423, diverse range of fluorocarbon and hydrocarbon mobile cations include imidazolium 424 polymer chemistries [Im].sup.+, pyrrolidinium [Pyrr].sup.+, pyridinium [Pyr].sup.+, ammonium [NH.sub.4].sup.+, quaternary ammonium [NR.sub.4].sup.+, sulfonium [SR.sub.3].sup.+, thiazolium [Thia].sup.+, piperidinium [Pipr].sup.+; phosphonium [PR.sub.4].sup.+, protonated HC alkanium [C.sub.nH.sub.2n+3].sup.+; biochemical cations e.g. cholinium [CholH].sup.+ mobile anions hexafluorophosphate [PF.sub.6].sup.; nitrate [NO.sub.3].sup. ; triflate [OTf].sup.; tetrafluoroborate [BF.sub.4] ; trifluoromethylacetate [TFA].sup. forming ILs via metal metathesis reaction or acid-base neutralization reaction, sequestering IL by endoskeletons and nanocoating pooling IL ions in sac pores 41. A hybrid proton exchange membrane polymer blocks sequenced by FIGS. 24, 77B, comprises a block copolymers including where excision-insertion reactions (EIR), 104, 426-428L the membrane contains micropores formed modified ring opening polymerization by a sacrificial filler process (MROP), nucleophilic aromatic the membrane contains skeletal support substitution reaction, atomic transfer the membrane contains at least two different radical polymerization (ATRP), or cross membrane bound acidic ionomers linker polymerization (XLP) sidechain block polymers e.g. PSf-R A/B alternating block polymers e.g. PESf-b-(Ph.sub.2SO.sub.2)(PhO.sub.6)(PhSA).sub.10 comb multi-block copolymer e.g. PSf-b-(PSf-co-STz) alternating di-block copolymers, e.g. (SPAESf).sub.x-b-(PAESf).sub.y, (SPAESf).sub.x-b-Pl.sub.y tri-block polymer e.g. P((S.sup.2)(R-co- R))-b-((PhSO.sub.3H).sub.6).sub.2 quad-block copolymer, e.g. PSS-b-Et- b-(Eth-ran-Prp)-b-PSS penta-block copolymer, e.g. (t-BuS)- b-(Eth-co-Prp)-b-(PSS-co-PS)-b-(Eth-co- Prp)-(t-BuS) mirrored quad-block copolymer, e.g. SPh30-b-PAESf-b-PAESf-b-SPh30 branched multi-block copolymer e.g. PASf(CF.sub.3).sub.2-b-(PESf-g-SPPhO), (PA(CF.sub.3).sub.2 (F.sub.3Ph).sub.2-b-(PAE-g-SPS) random multi-block copolymer e.g. SPAESf-b-TFPh-b-PAESf-b-TFPh the micropores are formed by sugar the skeleton comprises a quasi-rigid polymer coated with PVA one of the membrane bound acids comprises phosphonic or sulfonic acid the IEM includes permanent fillers the IEM includes ionic liquids mobile IL cations are sequestered by a nanocoating and endoskeleton
Structural Membrane Innovations.
[3717] Another embodiment of this invention is the integration of skeletal support within an ion exchange membrane [
[3718] In one embodiment the inert pillar is hydrophobic and the active membrane panes are hydrophilic where an ampipathic linking molecule such as a solvent, cross-linker, or molecule glue containing both polar and non-polar bonding sites chemically binds the two dissimilar polymers into a unitary membrane having the benefit of both superior mechanical strength and good conductivity. This is in direct contradiction to a composite reinforce membranes (CRM) where increasing the mole fraction of the inert hydrophobic polymer improves film strength by sacrificing conductivity and vice versa.
[3719] In various embodiments, the skeletal pillars comprise hydrocarbon or fluorocarbon compounds such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polyimide (PI), or hexafluoropropylene oxide (HFPO), optionally fortified by rigid fillers of carbon fibers, pristine carbon nanotubes, electrospun polymer fibers, plastic shards, graphene, or other strengtheners. In related embodiments, conductive ionomeric membranes comprise any of the polymers or copolymers described in this application including PFSA homopolymer; PFSA-PTFE composite reinforced membranes (CRMs); polyphenylene; polysulfone; poly phosphazene; poly fluorocarbon glasses like PFMMD; polyimide; covalent triazine; heteropolymers of arylene, ketone, ether, sulfone and nitrile groups such a SPEEK or PAESf; anhydrous membranes such as phenylene bibenzimidazole (PBI); and biopolymers including polydopamine (PDA), chitosan, and cellulose acetate (CA).
[3720] Fabrication of skeletally supported IEMs include first polymerizing the skeletal pillar matrix in accordance with a pattern defined by a mold chaise inserted into a casting mold, then removing the mold insert and treating the skeleton to improve bonding such as chemically roughening its surface then applying a pillar link bonding agent or molecular glue. The empty spaces in the mold are then filled with the ionomeric monomer along with reagents and solvents for cross linking and polymerization. After curing, the skeletal membrane is removed from the mold.
[3721] In an alternative sequence the skeletal monomer is loaded into the mold along with the mold chase insert, then treated with a weak bonding agent or glue such as hexafluoropropylene oxide (HFPO) and baked to loosely bind the pillar monomers together into a unitary structure. The mold chaise insert is then removed and the empty spaces filled with ionomeric monomer along with reagents and solvents for cross linking and copolymerization. During copolymerization the pillar monomers are polymerized into he skeletal matrix, the ionomeric monomers are polymerized into the conductive ionomeric membrane, and if compatible the pillar monomers and the ionomer monomers bond to one another forming a seamless unitary ion exchange membrane with embedded skeletal support. After curing, the skeletal membrane is removed from the mold.
[3722] In one set of embodiments the skeletal matrix includes two different width pillarsnarrow endoskeletal pillars crossing throughout the membrane and a wider exoskeleton circumscribing the membrane. In another embodiment, multiple IEMs are concurrent fabricated on a single sheet with exoskeletal pillars delineating one IEM from another. In yet another embodiment, the exoskeletal pillars are cut by lasers to singulate the IEMs from one another without disturbing the endoskeletal matrix internal to each IEM. In yet another embodiment, the entire sheet of multiple skeletal IEMs is attached to a thicker frame circumscribing the IEM sheet's periphery and used during by automated manufacturing or robotic handlers to grab ahold of the membrane.
Gas Transport Innovations.
[3723] Gas delivery to the catalyst coated membrane occurs in the gas diffusion layer, a porous carbon material surrounding the CCM. In one embodiment sheets of comparably sized gas diffusion layers (GDLs) are attached to the both anode and cathode sides of IEM sheet prior to laser singulation [
[3724] In yet another embodiment the endoskeleton is combined with a membrane nanocoating to prevent leakage of permanent fillers or ionic liquids present in the molecular matrix of the polymeric membrane. The combination of endoskeletal support and ionic liquid uniquely solves the major issue plaguing ionic liquidsthat overtime the IL fluid leaks out of the membrane. With the inclusion of inventive endoskeletal and exoskeletal pillars through the membrane and circumscribing its perimeter, the IL cannot leak lateral out of the polymer. In another embodiment [
[3725] The invention further comprises an heterogenous catalyst layer (CL) deposited or laminated onto the improved IEM forming an improved catalyst coated membrane (CCM) also known as a three-layer membrane electrode assembly (MEA3). The heterogenous catalyst layer may include additives comprising various blends of carbon, transition metal catalysts; metal oxides and nanoclusters; and CL fillers of bismuth, polyhedral silsesquioxanes (POSS, DDSQ), metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), graphene oxide (GO), functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs), boron nitride (BN), PTFE nanospheres, and dopamine (DPA). These additives may be blended into the catalyst layer, or can be deposited as a nanocoating onto the IEM prior to catalyst layer formation creating an interstitial layer between the membrane and the CL. Alternatively the additives may be coated onto the catalyst layer forming an interstitial layer between the gas diffusion layer and the catalyst layer.
[3726] Functions of the additives include sequestering and/or degrading atmospheric toxins such as carbon monoxide (CO) or other harmful compounds such as H.sub.2O.sub.2 preventing them from reaching and damaging the catalyst coated membrane (CCM) or ionomers within the IEM. Other benefits include improving electrical conductivity within the catalyst layer; reducing interfacial resistance and contact potentials lowering activation losses; and enhancing catalysis to increase the efficiency of hydrogen oxidation reactions (HOR) or oxygen evolution reactions (OER) in the MEA anode or to increase the turnover rates for oxygen reduction reactions (ORR) or hydrogen evolution reactions (HER) in the MEA cathode.
[3727] The invention further includes the device and processing of a inventive heterogeneous gas diffusion layer (hGDL) in one embodiment comprising a dense microporous film coated with a stepped or graded carbon diffusion layer of decreasing density and increasing porosity with the top of the GDL having the greatest porosity. Compared to existing uniform density films, the graded carbon GDL improves gas diffusivity and reduces the average electrical resistance of the GDL.
[3728] In one embodiment the gradation in density is achieved by increasing the length of carbon fibers to decrease density. In one embodiment the GDL graded carbon is printed using three print heads each applying carbon ink of different carbon fiber lengths. In an alternative embodiment a single print head dispenses ink of varying composition to create the graded density.
[3729] In other embodiments the hGDL may include boron nitride or MOFs within the carbon layer to suppress NO and environmental toxins. Alternatively, the bottom of the GDL may be coated with a nanocoating comprising a blend of carbon and catalyst to minimize interfacial resistance.
[3730] In another embodiment the top of the GDL can be coated with a nanocoating of non-catalytic metal to reduce interfacial resistance between the GDL and the bipolar plate. In yet another embodiment the bottom of the bipolar plate is coated with the same metal as deposited on the top of the GDL. During assembly the contact of two identical materials does not cause any differential contact potential, which is beneficially manifested as a reduced voltage drop and a lower effective resistance for the membrane.
[3731] The combination of the inventive hGDL with various innovative elements of the aforementioned MEA3 results in an improved five-layer membrane electrode assembly (MEA5) referred to herein as a PEM+ (pronounced PEM plus) or AEM+ membrane. Measurement data of fabricated MEA5 fuel cells confirm the PEM+ embodiment of this invention achieves 40% higher conversion efficiencies than existing Nafion membranes, and doubles the delivered power output of the fuel cell for the same amount of waste heat generation.
BPP & stack FC Innovations.
[3732] Attaching a high-conductivity bipolar plate (BPP) or tripolar plate (TPP) to the aforementioned improved MEA5 assembly results in a seven-layer membrane electrode assembly (MEA7) with improved performance. As an embodiment of this invention, the bipolar plate typically 2 mm thick in conventional fuel cells, is to a thickness of under 0.5 mm, e.g. to 0.45 mm, reducing the BPP electrical resistance by between 50% and 75%.
[3733] Aside from lowering its electrical resistance, thinning the carbon or composite bipolar plate significantly reduces its thermal resistance of heat conduction. In one embodiment, assembling a twelve layer stack fuel cell results in a substantial reduction in thermal resistance. In operation heat flow conducted from the topmost membrane through the entire stack and into a temperature controlled baseplate exhibits an order-of-magnitude lower thermal resistance than possible using forced air convection, thereby eliminating the need for expensive liquid cooling of the fuel cell stack. By eliminating the need for liquid cooling, the tripolar plate and its cooling channel can be replaced by a thinner lower resistance bipolar plate, thereby further reducing internal heating within the cell.
[3734] The improved ion exchange membrane made in accordance with this invention has many applications including stack fuel cells, intelligent buffered fuel cells (iBFC), electrolytic water-to-hydrogen conversion (WHC), and well as deionization, water filtration, and dialysis. In a intelligent buffered fuel cell [
[3735] In another embodiment of the invention, the number of stacks in the fuel cell array is dynamically varied to maintain the closest match between the fuel cell output voltage and the minimum buffer input voltage needed to reliably charge the string of buffer cells to full charge. The number of fuel cells is adjusted by a power multiplexer switch array. Examples including switching between two-or-three 21-layer stacks [
[3736] Exemplary intelligent buffered fuel cell (iBFC) designs with 24V minimum output voltage includes a dynamic fuel cell design comprising three-to-five stacks with approximately 60 total layer maintaining a voltage range of 24V to 40V able to function down to a 0.4V per layer FC voltage corresponding to 27% relative humidity [
Power Circuit & System Innovations.
[3737] Various circuit topologies [
[3738] In one embodiment, the iBFC delivers power to an electrical load in one of three conditions [
[3739] In a second higher current mode referred to as power-on-demand, the iBFC delivers power to the electrical load from both its fuel cell and simultaneously from charge stored in its buffer but only as long as the buffer retains stored charge. Depending on its design, the iBFC output power can range 2 to 5 its steady state continuous current mode. After discharging for one hour at a 1 C rate, the iBFC is still able to maintain its continuous output current while a battery is completely dead. As such, a battery has only a power-on-demand operating mode where the iBFC supplies both power-on-demand and continuous current. Moreover in the steady state mode, whenever the load demand drops below the peak power output limit of the fuel cell stack, the excess available power is diverted to recharge the buffer array of its spent charge. In this manner the iBFC functions as self recharging battery appearing to a user as a perpetually charged power source.
[3740] In a third state, a 10-second current transient both the iBFC and a conventional battery pack behave similarly, delivering up to 10 its power-on-demand current rating. The ability to deliver high transient current necessary for supplying capacitive inrush current spikes and motor startup, means the effective output impedance of the iBFC is comparable to lithium ion batteries and an order of magnitude less resistive than conventional fuel cells.
[3741] In claim language the iBFC comprises a fuel cell based power generator with integrated charge storage cable of delivering high power-on-demand currents to an electrical load for a limited interval and continuous power perpetually from a fuel source, whereby excess generated power not consumed by the electrical load replenishes charge lost by the energy buffer during higher power demand periods. Such beneficial electrical performance cannot matched by any power source available today, either a battery or fuel cell.
[3742] In another embodiment the iBFC includes protective disconnect circuitry [
[3743] In another set of embodiments, the iBFC is configured as a 5 kW power-on-demand iBFC power blade an inventive temperature regulated printed circuit board inserted into a rack mounted system called an energy bank capable of connecting up to 100 kW of iBFC generated power to a power microgrid [
[3744] In another embodiment, a fuel cell stack includes gas ports and electrical connections on its underside [
[3745] In exemplary power blade designs multiple fuel cells are mounted flat on the power blade backplate while lithium ion battery cells such as 18650 cylindrical type cells are mounted perpendicular to the PCB [
[3746] In general, the greater the fractional area of the power blade dedicated to buffer cells the greater the transient current and higher the power-on-demand ratings are, but at the expense of a lower continuous power output capability [
Glossary
[3747] Acid-base polymersAcid-base polymers, also known as polyelectrolytes, are polymers that contain acidic or basic functional groups which can dissociate in water to form charged species, enabling ion exchange. Example include poly(acrylic acid) (PAA), poly(methacrylic acid) (PMAA), sulfonated polystyrene (SPS), poly(ethyleneimine) (PEI), poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA borate or PVA phosphate), poly(4-vinylpyridine) (P4VP), poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP), poly(styrene sulfonic acid) (PSSA), poly(vinylpyrrolidone) (PVP), and poly(allylamine) (PAAm). Acid-base copolymersThe use of blended copolymers having different material, chemical, and electrical properties where at least one of the copolymers comprises an acid-base polymers.
[3748] Examples include SPEEK-PVA-PBI, SPEEK-PEI, SPSU-PBI, PA-PBI, PANI-PBI, PBI-ZIF, PBI-PVBC, PAEBI, PSU-P4VP, OPBI-OPBI-TG, SPA-PVA, CMC-PVA-AA, PTPU-PSS-DVB, PFA-PSSA, PS-co-sPSS, sPh-C.sub.nH.sub.2n+2, and sPTFS-X. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to acid-base copolymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3749] AnionAn anion is any negatively charged ion attracted to a positively charged electrode, i.e. anode, of a electrochemical cell. Anions comprise atoms or molecules formed by the addition of extra electrons through the process of reduction. Examples include the hydroxyl radical OH; ions of halogens such as chlorine Cl.sup., bromine Br.sup., and iodine I.sup.; dichromate anion (Cr.sub.2O.sub.7).sup.2; and sulfate anion (SO4).sup.2. An anion may comprise a mobile negatively charged molecule such as OH- or a negative radical of an ionic liquid used to conduct current in an anion exchange membrane. Alternatively, an immobile anion is a membrane-bound ionized acid in a proton exchange membrane after losing a H.sup.+ to solution.
[3750] Anion exchange membraneA anion exchange membrane or AEM, also referred to as an alkaline or hydroxide membrane is a type of membrane used in anion fuel cells which conducts negatively charged alkaline ions, usually OH hydroxide ions through an IEM exclusively containing positively-charged immobile ionomers. In operation oxygen and water combine in the cathode to form OH transiting the membrane to the anode where the hydroxide reacts with the fuel, typically hydrogen to form H.sub.2O waste water, or methanol (CH.sub.3OH) to form waste water and CO.sub.2.
[3751] AnodeIn the context of fuel cells, the electrode of an electrochemical cell where oxidation occurs. In a PEM, the anode supplies cations transported across the membrane and supplies free electrons via its terminal to an external circuit as electricity. In the context of IEM water hydrolysis the anode is the electrode where an oxygen evolution reaction (OER) occurs. In acronym such as ACL for anode catalyst layer, the term cathode is generally abbreviated by the uppercase letter A.
[3752] Bipolar plateA bipolar plate or BPP is an electrically conductive plate used to carry gas to the MEA5 fuel cell assembly transporting fuel to the anode, and oxygen or air to the cathode. The BPP also carried electric current between stacked fuel cells from the anode of one fuel cell to the cathode of the next.
[3753] Catalyst layerA thin interfacial layer located between an ion exchange membrane and its gas diffusion layer comprising a combination of carbon, transition metals such as platinum acting as catalysts and optionally metal-oxides such as TiO.sub.2, various additives such as MOFs and POSS, and boron nitride to inhibit NO diffusion. The catalyst layer on the cathode side of a membrane called the CCL may differ chemically and stoichiometrically from the anode catalyst layer, the ACL.
[3754] CathodeIn the context of fuel cells and batteries, a cathode is the electrode of an electrochemical cell where reduction occurs. In a PEM, the cathode receives protons transiting the membrane, then combines them with oxygen to form water as a byproduct. Hydrogen PEM fuel cells therefore do not produce CO.sub.2 or other greenhouse gasses. In the context of IEM water hydrolysis the cathode is the electrode where a hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) occurs. In acronyms, the term cathode may be abbreviated by the uppercase letter C or by the letter K, nomenclature evolved from power semiconductors used to eliminate ambiguity caused by the widespread use of capital C to symbolize catalyst, collector, carbon, charge, coulombs, capacitance, charge-rate, or degrees centigrade.
[3755] CationA cation is any positively charged ion attracted to negative charged electrode, i.e. cathode, of a electrochemical cell. Cations comprise atoms or molecules formed by removal of electrons through the process of oxidation. Examples of cations include ionized hydrogen H.sup.+, hydronium ions H.sub.3O, ammonium ions NH.sub.4+, calcium ions Ca.sub.2.sup.+, and ions of various transition metals such as silver ions Ag.sup.+, ionized aluminum Al.sub.3.sup.+, mercurous ions (Hg.sub.2).sub.2.sup.+, ferrous ions Fe.sup.2+, and ferric ions Fe.sub.3.sup.+. In a proton exchange membrane, a mobile cation may comprise a unbound proton, i.e. a hydrogen ion H.sup.+; a mobile positively charged molecule such as the hydronium ion H.sub.3O.sup.+; or the positive radical of an ionic liquid. Alternatively, an immobile cation is a membrane-bound ionized functional group in a anion exchange membrane after losing OH.sup. or gaining H.sup.+ from solution.
[3756] Cation exchange membraneA cation ion exchange membrane is an alternative name for a proton exchange membrane or PEM.
[3757] CCMThe term CCM is an acronym for a catalyst coated membrane comprising a sandwich of a central ion exchange membrane covered on both sides by a coating comprising a catalyst such as Pt and other materials such as carbon or nanoparticles. The term CCM is synonymous with a three layer membrane electrode assembly MEA3.
[3758] Closed cathode fuel cellA closed cathode fuel cell is a fuel cell where the gas channels for hydrogen supply to the anode, oxygen or air supply to the cathode, and coolant air or fluid are separated offering superior control of fuel cell hydration and maintaining performance in harsh environments. Using a dedicated oxygen supply, a closed cathode fuel cell can operate in a vacuum such as in space applications.
[3759] Direct methanol fuel cellsA direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) is proton exchange membrane (PEM) based fuel cell where methanol fuel is consumed to produce electricity. In operation the methanol is first converted to hydrogen which is transported across the PEM membrane. As the byproduct of a hydrogen fuel cell is water and CO.sub.2, DMFC is not considered a green energy source. DMFC emits 35% less greenhouse gasses than gasoline internal combustion engines.
[3760] ElectronAn electron (e.sup.) is a stable subatomic particle having a negative electric charge present in atoms and ions. Electrons electrostatically facilitate chemical bonding between atoms. They are also the dominant charge carrier of electrical conduction in metals and in many solids, but not exclusively in ionic liquids or semiconductors where anions or holes may be significant. Ionized free electrons are not considered anions. Electrons are not conducted by proton exchange membranes.
[3761] EndoskeletonPillars of inert polymer transecting an ionomeric membrane into panes and providing mechanical support to conductive polymer. The endoskeletal matrix merges with the wider exoskeleton circumscribing the periphery of each IEM.
[3762] ExoskeletonPillars of inert polymers and strengthening pillars circumscribing the inventive skeletal IEM. The exoskeleton forms a continuous grid-like pattern with the endoskeletal pillars it contains and connects by tie bars to a frame supporting multiple IEMs in a singular sheet. The exoskeleton is cut by laser to separate individual membranes from one another and from the membrane frame, a process referred to as singulation.
[3763] FunctionalizationThe process of functionalization involves the conversion of an insulating non-conductive polymer into a conductive ionomeric polymer by the introduction of ionomer molecular groups or other charge conducting materials into the polymeric matrix. Modifications to the matrix may include sulfurization, copolymerization, grafting, or inducing radiation damage onto the polymeric chain. Another method to functionalize a polymer is through doping, the introduction of conductive or ionomeric fillers into the matrix. Dopants including metal oxides, metal oxide frameworks (MOFs), polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS), nanoparticles and nanocomposites, electrospun nanofibers, carbon nanotubes, and proton ionic liquids (PIL). Made in accordance with this invention MOFs may contain a mix of ionomers and protective scavenger metals.
[3764] Gas diffusion layerA gas diffusion layer or GDL is a porous materials comprising carbon fiber or carbon compounds used in fuel cells and electrolyzers to transport gasses between a bipolar plate and a catalyst layer of a CCM and to carry electric currents through its fibrous matrix. The GDL may comprise a uniform homogenous material, a two-step construction with a smaller pore MPL microporous layer and less dense carbon coating; or as disclosed herein comprise a heterogenous gas diffusion layer (hGDL) comprising a MPL coated multiple layers or a continuous gradation of carbon of varying density to enhance conductivity and improve gas diffusion. In membrane based fuel cells, electrolyzers, and electrodialysis systems, an important role of the GDL is to spread gasses emerging from narrow channels of a bipolar plate uniformly across a membrane's surface through lateral diffusion.
[3765] Glassy amorphous polymersPerfluorinated polymers containing large subgroups along the polymer's backbone such as perfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane sulfonic acid (PFMMD-SD), and perfluorodimethyldioxole (PDD) are categorized as glassy amorphous polymers. By impeding the periodicity of the polymer, crystallinity of the matrix is randomly disrupted resulting in amorphous regions comingled with semi-crystalline regions. Sulfonic acid or grafts of PFSA are included within the matrix to control film conductivity. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements topartially perfluorinated polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3766] Heterogenous gas diffusion layerA heterogenous gas diffusion layer or hGDL a described herein is a gas diffusion layer used in membrane devices comprising a non-unform carbon density in the carbon coated layer positioned atop a denser microporous layer. The hGDL may be formed using multizone printing from a multi-head printer or by blending multiple solutes in single head printing.
[3767] Hopping conductionIn an ion exchange membrane, hopping conduction aka Grotthuss transport involves an anion or cation hopping from one ionomer to another in succession. The ionomers may comprise sulfonic acid in PEMs and quaternary ammonium or N-containing cations, for example based on pyrrolidinium (PY), piperidinium (PRD), and imidazolium (IM) moieties in AEMs.
[3768] Hydrogen fuel cellA proton exchange membrane (PEM) based fuel cell where hydrogen is the fuel consumed to produce electricity. The byproduct of a hydrogen fuel cell is water. With no CO.sub.2 effluent hydrogen fuel cell based electricity is considered as a green energy source.
[3769] Hydrogen ionsHydrogen ions comprise any cation comprising ionized hydrogen charges including ionized elemental hydrogen or molecules containing ionized hydrogen such as hydronium ions.
[3770] Hydronium ionsA hydronium ion is a molecule combining water (H.sub.2O) and a proton (H.sup.+) resulting in the hydrophilic cation H.sub.3O.sup.+ capable of vehicular charge transport.
[3771] IonAn ion is any elemental atom or molecule that has lost an electron through the process of oxidation resulting in net positive charge or gained an electron through the process of reduction resulting in a net negative charge.
[3772] Ion exchange membraneAn ion exchange membrane in a semi permeable membrane able to selectively control the conduction of ions by their charge state. Proton exchange membranes (PEM) conduct positively charged cations and inhibit transport of negatively charged anions. Conversely, anion exchange membranes (AEMs) conduct negatively charged cations but suppress transport of positively charged cations. All IEMs suppress electron conduction through the membrane.
[3773] MEA3The three layer catalyst coated membrane (CCM(comprising a sandwich of a central ion exchange membrane covered on both sides by a coating comprising a catalyst such as Pt and other materials such as carbon or nanoparticles.
[3774] MEA5The five-layer membrane assembly comprising a MEA3 sandwiched between two gas diffusion layers (GDLs).
[3775] MEA7The seven-layer membrane assembly comprising a MEA6 sandwiched between two bipolar or tripolar plates.
[3776] Membrane electrode assemblyThe term membrane electrode assembly (MEA) describes the layers of material constructing a fuel cell comprising the catalyst coated membrane or three layer MEA3, which sandwiched by two gas diffusion layers (GDLs) define a five layer MEA5. The addition of two bipolar or tripolar plates surrounding the MEA5 forms a seven-layer assembly referred to as MEA7.
[3777] Membrane frameThe outer edge of a sheet of IEMs used for automated or robotic handling on the matrix prior to singulation. The membrane frame connects to the exoskeleton of the individual IEMs through narrow tie bars which are removed during singulation of the sheet into individual IEMs.
[3778] Micro-stack Fuel CellThe innovative micro-stack (stack) fuel cell as disclosed herein comprises the series connection of between 10-to-24 individual MEA7 fuel cell layers housed in a single fuel cell assembly and capped between two opposing endplates. Compared to high power fuel cell stacks, the voltage, power and heat generated from a stack is substantially less, e.g. under 40V and less the 1 kW. Advantages of the stack is its low profile for improved industrial design, significantly reduced thermal resistance, better conductive cooling, and the ability to function in multiplexed dynamic fuel cell arrays.
[3779] Modified perfluorinated polymersModifications of perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) to enhance a polymer's material and electrical performance comprise dopants and fillers including PTFE; silica and silicates; titanium oxides; zirconium; imidazole; triazine; zeolite nanoparticles; platinum-titanium nanoparticles; functionalized carbon nanotubes (CNTs); metal oxide frameworks (MOFs); poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) nanoclusters; polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS); double decker silsesquioxane (DDSQ); ferrous, zinc, and chromium nanoclusters; tungsten nanoparticles; nanofibers; graphene oxide; and proton ionic liquids. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to modified perfluorinated polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3780] Non-fluorinated polymersComprising aliphatic or aromatic polymers with benzene ring structures in the backbone or in the pendant groups, hydrocarbon based polymers lacking fluorine are cheaper, exhibit reduced oxygen leakage and fuel crossover, and suffer less temperature degradation to PFSA films. Examples include sulfonated polyarylene ether sulphone (SPAES), sulfonated poly ether-ether ketone (SPEEK), sulfonated poly ether-ether sulfone (SPEES), polysulfone (PSf, PSU), chitosan (CS), sulfonimide branched poly(phenylenebenzophenone)s (SI-PPBP), and anhydrous poly(phenylene-bibenzimidazole) (PBI). Unlike perfluorinated polymers containing environmentally persistent and toxic pollutants known as forever chemicals, hydrocarbon based membranes are chemically inert. As a disadvantage, non-fluorinated polymers exhibit lower conductance than PFSA. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to modified perfluorinated polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3781] Open cathode fuel cellIn a hydrogen PEM fuel cell, open cathode fuel cell comprises a fuel cell membrane electrode assembly where the cathode is open to an ambient air supply an does not require a dedicated oxygen supply. In an open cathode fuel cell the air supply also provides cooling of the assembly.
[3782] PAEPolyarylene ether (PAE) polymers comprise thermoplastics featuring a mainchain of alternating rigid aromatic rings and flexible ether bonds, conferring numerous beneficial material properties including high-temperature resilience; oxidative stability; and resistance to solvents, alkali, and acids. Variations of polyarylene ethers depend on which functional groups are attached to the polymer's backbone. Specifically, polyarylene ethers having ketone segments on the mainchain are referred to as poly(arylene ether ketone) (PAEK), while those with sulfone segments on the mainchain are referred to as poly(arylene ether sulfone) (PAES). Polyarylene ethers with cyano (CN) functional groups on sidechains are referred to as poly(arylene ether nitrile) (PAEN). PAE can also form sulfonated copolymers P(SPAES)-co-TBPh.
[3783] PAmPolyamide (PAm, PA) is a thermoplastic polymer of repeating units linked by amide bonds formed by step-growth polymerization or solid-phase synthesis. Monomers may comprise amides themselves resulting in a homopolymer but polyamides may also easily be copolymerized. Functionalization of polyamide can be involve sulfonization by fuming sulfuric acid or by aqueous treatment in solutions of SO.sub.3 of CCl.sub.4 or by forming copolymers such as sSPA-co-Sim.
[3784] PBIPhenylene-bibenzimidazole (PBI) and its variant pyridine polybenzimidazole (PyPBI) comprise an acid-base hydrocarbon polymer offering exceptional thermal and chemical stability. Preparation of PBI can be achieved by condensation reaction of diphenyl isophthalate with tetraaminodiphenyl. PBI membranes are dense and rigid with strong hydrogen bonding and low gas permeability. Because of its basic structure, Polybenzimidazole can be functionalized by strong acids to form ionomers for proton conduction. PBI doped with phosphoric acid can be used as high temperature electrolyte in direct methanol fuel cells. The also can be functionalized with sulfonic acid in a variety of configurations and cross linked with other functionalized PBI chains, with poly(vinylbenzyl chloride) (PVBC), polyaniline (PANI), or zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF).
[3785] Partially perfluorinated polymersPartially perfluorinated polymers such as grafted PFSA and PFSA copolymers including perfluoro-hydro-dimethyl-dioxolane-co-perfluorosulfonic acid (PFMMD-co-PFSA), fluorinated ethylene propylene (FEP), polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), and sulfonated fluorinated polyethersulfone (sFPESf) contain reduced levels of fluorine on the polymer's mainchain, generally substituted by hydrocarbon groups providing an added degree of control over crystallinity, fuel crossover, conductivity, permeability, and temperature dependence. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to partially perfluorinated polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3786] PDDPerfluorodimethyldioxole (PDD) comprises a perfluorinated glassy amorphous polymer functionalized by sulfone ionomers to modulate film conductance. PEPolyethylene (PE) is polyolefin thermoplastic offering good mechanical strength. Polyethylene can be converted into an ionomer by introducing sulfonic acid (sPE) or bromine (BrPE) to modulate film conductivity.
[3787] PEK/PEEKPoly ether ketone (PEK) and polyether ether ketone (PEEK) are semicrystalline thermoplastic polymers in the polyaryletherketone (PAEK) family formed by step-growth polymerization via the dialkylation of bisphenolate salts. PEEK is highly resistant to thermal degradation and to attack in both organic and aqueous environments. The polymers can be functionalized into ionomers using sulfuric acid to produce a wide range of options by varying the number of ether and ketone groups on the chains, including sPEK, sPEEK, sPEKK, sPEEEK, sPEEKK, sPEKKK, sPEKEKK, and copolymers sPEK-co-PEK (2PEK).
[3788] Permanent fillerAn permanent filler (PF) is an additive mixed with IEM monomers and molded permanently into polymeric matrix, affecting conductivity, crystallinity, atomic density, hydrophilicity, catalytic turnover, hydration, swelling, durability, strength, and reliability. Examples include pristine and functionalized bismuth compounds, graphene oxides, carbon nanotubes, silicates, zirconia, tungsten, metal organs frameworks, zeolite, nanostructures, and polyhedral silsesquioxanes. While permanent fillers are normally additives included in the ionomeric membrane, they may also be integrated into nanocoating, catalyst layers, or within a gas diffusion layer. In contrast to sacrificial fillers which are dissolved and removed subsequent to molding, permanent fillers remain within the polymer matrix indefinitely. Added to the mold compound before polymerization, permanent fillers are distinct from ionic liquids that are soaked into the membrane after polymerization and prior to attachment of gas diffusion layers.
[3789] PFEKNPoly(fluorenyl ether ketone nitrile) (PFEKN) is a perfluorinated polymer containing nitrile groups synthesized by nucleophilic substitution polycondensation of dihydroxy-naphthalene-disulfonic acid disodium salt resulting in a sulfonated polymer sPFEKN, the degree of sulfonation and conductivity of which depends on the molar fraction of its reactants.
[3790] PFMMDDPerfluoro-methylene-methyl-dioxolane sulfonic-acid (PFMMD-SA) comprises a perfluorinated glassy amorphous polymer functionalized by sulfone ionomers to modulate film conductance.
[3791] PFSAPerfluorosulfonic acid, a perfluorinated ionomeric polymer used is a wide range of applications including ion exchange membranes for fuel cells, filters, electrolysis, electrodialysis and more. PFSA contains three components (a) polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) backbone; (b) a pendant comprising a sidechain of vinyl ethers such as (for example OCF.sub.2CFOCF.sub.2CF.sub.2), and (c) an electrically conductive ionomer comprising sulfonic acid (SO.sub.3H). The length of the sidechain controls, crystallinity, conductivity, durability, fuel crossover, permeability, and the film's temperature operating range. Commercial trade names for PFSA ionomers include long-sidechain Nafion and short-sidechain Aquivion. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to modified perfluorosulfonic acid polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3792] PIPolyimide (PI) is a thermoplastic characterized by its thermal stability, good chemical resistance, and excellent mechanical properties. The general structure of polyimide is (RONR.sub.2O) which should not be confused with polyamide characterized by amino acid groups (NH.sub.2). Like other polymers nascent PI is a poor conductor. Functionalization of polyimide into an ionomer is accomplished through sulfonization via aromatic sulfonamides such as pBABTS resulting in the conductive ionomer sulfonated polyimide (sPI). The ionomer can also be copolymerized with PVDF for potential use in direct methanol fuel cells (DMFC).
[3793] PMMAPolymethyl methacrylate (PMMA or acrylic glass), a thermoplastic polymer produced from the polymerization of methyl methacrylate (MMA), generally through PMMA is routinely produced by emulsion polymerization, solution polymerization, or bulk polymerization. Functionalization of PMMA may involve attaching a sulfonated phenol group to PMMA through a silicon intermediary or forming a copolymer or graft. Copolymers of PMMA-co-MAH, PMMA-g-PVDC, P(MMA-co-MAH-co-Mi), PE-g-PMMA, sBVlm-TfO-co-MMA.
[3794] PolyolefinA class of thermoplastics, polyolefins use repeated monomeric units called olefins (alkenes) to form the polymeric mainchain. Ionomers such as sulfonic acid may be introduced within the polymer backbone, as side groups, or as the terminus of pendants grafted onto to the mainchain. Polyolefins have the general form (CH.sub.2CHR)n where R is an alkyl group. Commercial examples pf polyolefin plastics include polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), polyisobutylene, and polymethylpentene (PMP).
[3795] PPPolypropylene (PP) is a low-density partially crystalline polyolefin thermoplastic derived from chain growth polymerization of its monomer propylene. Once polymerized, PP is resistant to most organic solvents. Although pristine polypropylene is non-conductive, its can be grafted or copolymerized with ionomeric polymers such as PFSA or PFSA-PTFE for use in ion exchange membranes.
[3796] PPhPolyphenylene (PPh or PP) and para-phenylene (PPPh, PPP) are semicrystalline thermoplastic polymers comprising a linear polymer of the phenylene. Phenylene, a divalent radical C.sub.6H.sub.4 derived from benzene by displacement of two hydrogen atoms, is characterized by mechanical strength, stiffness, toughness, and chemical inertness. Sulfonated polyphenylenes include poly(benzoyl-phenylene) (sPPh), sulfonated polyphenylene quaterphenol (sPPh-QP), branched, sulfo-phenylated polyphenylene (sPPhB-H.sup.+), sulfonated Diels-Alder polyphenylene (sDAPPh), sulfonated hydrated phenylated polyphenylene (sPPPh-H.sup.+), hydroxylated sulfonated phenylated polyphenylene (sPPPh-OH), diiodo-biphenyldisulfonic acid (DilPhS). Bromated polyphenylene includes dibromo-biphenyldisulfonic acid (DiBrBPhS).
[3797] PSUPolysulfone (PSU, PSf) is a thermoplastic polymer composed of aromatic groups, ether groups and sulfonyl groups characterized high strength, stiffness, with an extremely high melting temperature. To enhance conduction for fuel cell applications, polysulfone is functionalized through sulfonization of the benzene rings to produce sulfonated polysulfone (sPSf, sPSU)
[3798] ProtonThe positive nuclei of ionized elemental hydrogen and a stable subatomic particle present in the nucleus of all atoms. Ionized hydrogen H.sup.+ is a cation electrostatically attracted to negatively biased electrodes.
[3799] Proton exchange membraneA proton exchange membrane or PEM is a type of membrane used in cation fuel cells where positively-charged protons or cations transit an IEM exclusively containing negative charged immobile ionomers. The most common use of PEM membranes is in hydrogen fuel cells, where hydrogen fuel is ionized to form protons which subsequently transit the polymer membrane as H.sup.+ or H.sub.3O ions.
[3800] PSPolystyrene (PS) is a solid thermoplastic polymer made from monomers of the aromatic hydrocarbon styrene. Often used in protective packaging, polystyrene has good thermal stability. With ionomeric applications in fuel cells, polystyrene can be functionalized by sulfonating a block copolymer of polystyrene and poly(ethyl-ran-propylene) (sPSEP-PS). Another method is a block copolymer combining sulfonated polystyrene with polyisobutylene and with un-sulfonated polystyrene P(SSIBS). Alternatively, the monomer precursor to polystyrene can first be sulfonated to produce styrenesulfonate sSA. Thereafter the sulfonated monomer is then cross-linked to produce sulfonated polystyrene sPS. Because however polystyrene is not biodegradable, its use is restricted and its future uncertain.
[3801] PTFEPolytetrafluoroethylene, a chemically-inert non-conductive fluoropolymer commonly known as Teflon with beneficial material properties of nonreactivity, hydrophobicity, a low coefficient of friction, and good insulating properties. PTFE forms a portion of the polymeric backbone of perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA).
[3802] PVAPoly vinyl alcohol (PVA), a water soluble polymer with glue like cross-linking capabilities. Unlike vinyl polymers, PVA is not prepared by polymerization of the corresponding monomer, since the monomer, vinyl alcohol, is thermodynamically unstable. Instead it is prepared by hydrolysis of polyvinyl acetate. PVA can be made conductive by incorporating solutions of salt ions, conductive polymers, carbon compounds, or metal materials; by treatment from sulfosuccinic acid, or by cross-linking PVA to ionomeric polymers such as PFSA using glutaraldehyde (GA) or other aldehydes.
[3803] PVCPolyvinylchloride (PVC, vinyl) is a thermoplastic insoluble in most solvents except for chlorinated hydrocarbon solvents. The rigidity of PVC depends on weight fraction of phthalate plasticizer added with under 25% considered rigid or semi-rigid and over 50% categorized at vert flexible. For use in ion exchange membranes, PVC is functionalized by the process of sulfonization, using ethylenediamine and sulfuric acid to cleave and attach SO.sub.3H ionomeric groups onto the mainchain resulting in sulfonated polyvinylchloride (sPVC).
[3804] PVDFPolyvinylidene fluoride, a semi-crystalline thermoplastic partially perfluorinated polymer, offering enhanced thermal stability and lower cost. PVDF can be made conductive through treatment by silver nanoparticles or by blending with poly (methyl methacrylate)-co-poly (sodium-4-styrene sulfonate) (PMMA-co-PSSNa) using a solvent evaporation method. Made in accordance with this invention, further improvements to PVDF polymers include a reenforced endoskeletal support matrix, sacrificial and permanent fillers to control film porosity, and scavenger MOFs to protect against CO poisoning.
[3805] Sacrificial fillerA sacrificial filler is a compound introduced into the mold compound prior to IEM polymerization that by occupying some molar volume within the membrane reduces the atomic density of the polymer's atomic matrix. Subsequent removal of the sacrificial filler by dissolving in a solvent results in a vacancy in the membrane's atomic matrix called a sac pore in spaces once occupied by the sacrificial filler. In one embodiment of this invention the sacrificial filler is sugar and the solvent used to remover it, is water. At sufficiently high sacrificial filler concentrations, the resulting sac pores merge together forming a network of channels enhancing vehicular charge transport of hydronium ions yet impeding crossover of larger fuel molecules like methanol. Described in the lexicon of apparatus claims, a membrane containing sacrificial filler molecules at time t.sub.1 immediately after polymerization comprises an atomic matrix of polymer mainchains with a lower density than the same matrix had the sacrificial filler not been present. The same membrane at time t.sub.2 after the filler is removed comprises an identical atomic density of polymer chains but now includes sac pores in every location previously occupied by the sacrificial filler. In alternative description, a membrane containing a sacrificial filler weighs more than a membrane once the sacrificial filler has been removed.
[3806] ScavengerA compound or transition metal or MOF used to sequester and potentially degrade environmental toxins such as NO and unwanted reaction byproducts such as H.sub.2O.sub.2 from reaching and degrading the catalyst layer and the membrane's ionomers.
[3807] SingulationThe process of laser cutting an exoskeletal pillars to separate a membrane matrix into multiple IEMs, detaching them from one another and from the membrane frame holding the sheet together during processing.
[3808] SkeletonAn inventive feature for mechanically reinforcing an ion exchange membrane with a grid-like pattern of inert pillars having greater strength and rigidity than the ionomeric polymer comprising the conductive portions of the membrane. The skeletal structure may comprise stronger or more hydrophobic polymers than the membrane's conductive regions and may include strengthening fillers of carbon fibers, carbon nanotubes, plastic shards, or graphene. The skeletal matrix may include three components, an endoskeleton located throughout the membrane, an exoskeleton, comprising a wider skeletal pillar circumscribing the membrane, and a frame comprising a thicker or stronger support for mechanical handling holding one-or-more exoskeletal pillars in place during manufacturing. The frame attaches to the exoskeleton through tie bars removed during singulation.
[3809] ThermoplasticA thermoplastic is any high molecular weight plastic polymer which is pliable or moldable at elevated temperatures and solidifies upon cooling. Thermoplastics include acrylics (PAA, PMMA), polystyrene (PS, ABS), polyamide (PAm), polybenzimidazole (PBI), polycarbonate (PC), polyether sulfone (PES), polysulfone (PSU, PSf), polyoxymethylene (POM), polyether ether ketone (PEEK) and other members of the polyaryletherketone (PAEK) family, polyetherimide (PEI), polyethylene (polyethene, polythene, PE), various polyphenylenes (PPh or PP), polypropylene (PP), polystyrene (PS), polyvinyl chloride (PVC), polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, Teflon). Unlike polyolefins which represent a class of polymers defined by the molecular structure, thermoplastics are categorized by the material properties, specifically melting point, irrespective of its chemical structure or composition. Thermoplastic can be converted into ionomeric polymers by functionalization, the process of introducing mobile charge through sulfonation, grafting, copolymerization, radiation damage, or by doping the film with ionomeric nanoparticles, metal organic frameworks, proton ionic liquids, and other fillers.
[3810] Tripolar plateA tripolar plate or TPP is an electrically conductive plate used to carry gas to the MEA5 fuel cell assembly transporting fuel to the anode, oxygen or air to the cathode, and carrying liquid coolant or forced air through the fuel cell.
[3811] Vehicular ion transportThe conduction of mobile ionic charges not involving membrane bound ionomers. In PEM conduction, vehicular transport may involve free protons H.sup.+, protons in solution (H.sup.+.Math.H.sub.2O), or hydronium ions (H.sub.3O.sup.+). In AEM conduction, vehicular transport may involve hydroxyl ions OH or hydrated hydroxide (OH.sup..Math.H.sub.2O).