METHOD FOR DETERMINING WIND SPEED COMPONENTS BY MEANS OF A LASER REMOTE SENSOR
20230204786 · 2023-06-29
Inventors
- Jonathan CHAUVIN (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Benoit BAYON (US)
- Fabrice GUILLEMIN (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Romain GOUSSAULT (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
- Guillaume SABIRON (RUEIL-MALMAISON CEDEX, FR)
Cpc classification
G01S17/58
PHYSICS
Y02A90/10
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
Y02E10/72
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
Abstract
The invention is a method for determining wind speed components by using a placed LiDAR sensor (1). For this method, the wind speed components are first approximated by using the signals from the LiDAR sensor (1). These approximations are used in a wind signal model, and then used in a non-stationary Kalman filter (KAL), to construct filtered measurement signals. The filtered measurement signals are then used to reconstruct (REC) the wind speed components.
Claims
1-10. (canceled)
11. A method for determining wind speed components with a LiDAR sensor, the LiDAR sensor being oriented vertically for carrying out measurements in at least one horizontal measurement plane, comprising steps of: a) acquiring measurement signals from the LiDAR sensor in the at least one horizontal measurement plane; b) determining an approximation of the wind speed components in the at least one horizontal measurement plane by using a geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the acquired measurement signals; c) determining an average speed and a standard deviation of wind in the at least one measurement horizontal plane by using the approximation of wind speed components; d) constructing a wind signal model using a sum of two first-order filters, the wind signal model being dependent on parameters; e) determining the parameters of the wind signal model by using the determined standard deviation and the determined average of the wind speed components; f) filtering the acquired measurement signals by using a non-stationary Kalman filter, the wind signal model and the determined parameters of the wind signal model; and g) determining the wind speed components in the at least one measurement plane by using a geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the filtered measurement signals.
12. The method as claimed in claim 11, comprising filtering the measurement signals using a first-order low-pass filter for approximating the wind speed components.
13. The method as claimed in claim 11, wherein the wind signal model is a Kaimal model of a wind spectrum of the wind.
14. The method as claimed in claim 12, wherein the wind signal model is a Kaimal model of the wind spectrum of the wind.
15. The method as claimed in claim 11, wherein a transfer function H of the wind signal model (MOD) is written:
16. The method as claimed in claim 12, wherein a transfer function H of a wind signal model (MOD) is written:
17. The method as claimed in claim 13, wherein a transfer function H of the wind signal model (MOD) is written:
18. The method as claimed in claim 14, wherein a transfer function H of the wind signal model (MOD) is written:
19. The method as claimed in claim 15, wherein a transfer function H of the wind signal model (MOD) is written:
20. The method as claimed in claim 15, wherein the parameters a and b are obtained using the equation:
21. The method as claimed in claim 12, wherein the parameters a and b are obtained using the equation:
22. The method as claimed in claim 13, wherein the parameters a and b are obtained using the equation:
23. The method as claimed in claim 15, wherein the parameters a and b are obtained using the equation:
24. The method as claimed in claim 11, wherein a covariance matrix of the non-stationary Kalman filter is determined by minimizing a cost function accounting for dispersion and an average deviation of the acquired measurement signals.
25. The method as claimed claim 11, wherein a reconstruction of the wind speed components using measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter is implemented by the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
26. The method as claimed claim 12, wherein a reconstruction of the wind speed components using measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter is implemented by the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
27. The method as claimed claim 13, wherein a reconstruction of the wind speed components using measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter is implemented by the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
28. The method as claimed claim 15, wherein a reconstruction of the wind speed components using measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter is implemented by the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
29. The method as claimed in claim 11, comprising steps of: a) segmenting the determined wind speed components by a predetermined time interval; and b) determining at least one characteristic of the wind speed for the predetermined time interval.
30. The method as claimed in claim 29, wherein the predetermined time interval is between 1 min and 1 h.
31. The method as claimed in claim 26, wherein the at least one wind characteristic is chosen from average wind speed, standard deviation of wind speed, maximum wind speed, average wind direction, wind turbulence intensity, average of a vertical component of wind speed, and a standard deviation of this vertical component of the wind speed.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0029] The present invention is a method for determining wind speed components by using a LiDAR sensor. Wind speed components is the name given to the projections of the wind speed in a reference frame, in particular in an orthonormal reference frame.
[0030] For the invention, the LiDAR sensor is directed substantially vertically. In other words, the measurement is directed along a substantially vertical axis. For example, the LiDAR sensor may be placed on the ground and oriented vertically. According to the invention, the LiDAR sensor makes it possible to measure the wind speed on at least one measurement plane. In view of the orientation of the LiDAR sensor, the measurement plane is substantially horizontal. There are multiple types of LiDAR sensor, for example scanned LiDAR sensors, continuous LiDAR sensors or pulsed LiDAR sensors. Within the scope of the invention, a pulsed LiDAR is preferably used. However, other LiDAR technologies may be used while remaining within the scope of the invention.
[0031] The LiDAR sensor allows a continuous measurement. The use of such a sensor therefore allows continuous determination of measurement signals. In addition, the LiDAR sensor is easily able to be moved from one site to another. For example, the sampling rate of the LiDAR sensor may be between 0.1 and 5 Hz (or even more in the future), and may be 1 Hz. In addition, the LiDAR sensor makes it possible to obtain relative information in multiple measurement planes at multiple heights. The LiDAR sensor may therefore be used to determine wind speed components at multiple heights, which may be used in particular to determine the variation in wind speed as a function of height.
[0032]
[0033] As may be seen in
[0034] This figure also shows, only at the point b1, the wind speed vector W, and these three components Wx, Wy, Wz, respectively on the x, y and z axes.
[0035] The method according to the invention comprises the following steps:
1—acquiring measurement signals;
2—approximating the wind speed components;
3—determining the average speed and the standard deviation;
4—constructing the wind signal frequency model;
5—determining the parameters of the model;
6—non-stationary Kalman filter; and
7—determining the wind speed components.
[0036] These steps will be described in detail in the remainder of the description. Steps 2 to 7 may be implemented by a computing system, in particular a computer. Steps 2 to 7 may be implemented offline after step 1.
[0037]
[0038] According to a second embodiment of the invention, the method may comprise an additional step of filtering the acquired measurement signals before approximating the wind speed components, in order to remove aberrant values. This makes possible increasing the robustness and the reliability of the method.
[0039] The method according to the second embodiment of the invention may thus comprise the following steps:
1—acquiring measurement signals;
1.2—filtering the measurement signals;
2—approximating the wind speed components;
3—determining the average speed and the standard deviation;
4—constructing the wind signal frequency model;
5—determining the parameters of the model;
6—non-stationary Kalman filter; and
7—determining the wind speed components.
[0040] These steps will be described in detail in the remainder of the description. Steps 1.2 to 7 may be implemented by a computation system, in particular a computer.
[0041]
[0042] According to a third embodiment of the invention, the method may comprise additional steps in order to determine a characteristic of the wind speed. For this third embodiment, the method may comprise the following steps:
1—acquiring measurement signals;
2—approximating the wind speed components;
3—determining the average speed and the standard deviation;
4—constructing the wind signal model;
5—determining the parameters of the model;
6—non-stationary Kalman filter;
7—determining the wind speed components;
8—segmenting the wind speed components; and
9—determining a characteristic of the wind speed.
[0043] These steps will be described in detail in the remainder of the description. Steps 2 to 9 may be implemented by a computing system, in particular a computer.
[0044]
[0045] The second and third embodiments may be combined.
1—Acquiring Measurement Signals
[0046] This step comprises acquiring the measurement signals from the LiDAR sensor for at least one measurement plane. In other words, the measurement signal from the sensor is acquired for each measurement point of at least one measurement plane. Advantageously, these measurement signals may be recorded, in particular in a computer memory, in order to be able to be processed by a computing system in the following steps.
[0047] In order to determine the wind speed components in multiple measurement planes, this step may be carried out for multiple measurement planes.
[0048] Advantageously, the measurement signals may be acquired over a long period of time, for example for a duration that may vary from several days and range up to a year, or even more.
1.2—Filtering the Measurement Signals
[0049] It will be recalled that this is an optional step. This step comprises filtering the measurement signals, in particular in order to limit aberrant values for the purpose of making the method more reliable and robust.
[0050] According to one embodiment, this filtering may be implemented by way of a first-order low-pass filter in order to reproduce a continuous and realistic representation of the measured wind state. This may be a filter with a variable time constant. The older the last valid value passed to the first-order filter, the more the time constant of the filter decreases (in other words, the weight of the state stored in the filter is increasingly low compared to the weight of the next valid value t). This embodiment makes it possible to derive an instantaneous, low-frequency, denoised and realistic value of the wind state contained in the radial measurements.
2—Approximating the Wind Speed Components
[0051] This step comprises approximating the wind speed components based on the measurement signals from the LiDAR sensor, or where applicable based on the filtered measurement signals from the LiDAR sensor. This approximation is used to adapt the measurement signal model. This is merely an approximation for an intermediate step, and the values of the wind speed components determined in step 7 of the method are more accurate, reliable and robust.
[0052] For this step, the wind speed components are reconstructed by way of a geometric reconstruction.
[0053] According to one embodiment of the invention, the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components may implement a pseudo-inverse “Moore-Penrose” operation applied to the measurement signals (or where applicable to the filtered measurement signals).
[0054]
[0055] Using geometric projections, it is possible to write the following equations:
[0056] Where 1, . . . , i, . . . , n are the measurement points of a measurement plane, and ml, . . . , mi, . . . , mn are the measurement signals of the measurement plane.
[0057] Using the pseudo-inverse “Moore-Penrose” operation, it is therefore possible to obtain the estimated wind speed components in the measurement plane by way of the measurement signals:
[0058] According to one implementation of the invention, this step may comprise a step of filtering the estimated speed, in particular in order to limit aberrant values for the purpose of making the method more reliable and robust.
[0059] According to one embodiment, this filtering may be implemented by way of a first-order low-pass filter in order to reproduce a continuous and realistic representation of the measured wind state. This may be a filter with a variable time constant. The older the last valid value passed to the first-order filter, the more the time constant of the filter decreases (in other words, the weight of the state stored in the filter is increasingly low compared to the weight of the next valid value). This embodiment makes it possible to derive an instantaneous, low-frequency, denoised and realistic value of the wind state contained in the radial measurements.
3—Determining the Average Speed and the Standard Deviation
[0060] This step comprises determining the average speed and its standard deviation based on the approximation of the wind speed components determined in step 2 (possibly filtered). For this step, it is possible to implement the conventional average and standard deviation calculations.
[0061] According to one embodiment of the invention, the average speed and its standard deviation may be determined over a rolling time horizon. For example, the rolling time horizon for this embodiment may be between 10 minutes and several days.
4—Constructing the Wind Signal Model
[0062] This step comprises constructing a wind signal model using the sum of two first-order filters, the wind signal model being dependent on two parameters. The two parameters make it possible to adjust the contributions of each filter to the measurement provided by the LiDAR sensor.
[0063] According to one embodiment of the invention, the wind signal model may comprise an integrator and a low-pass filter. The integrator makes it possible to illustrate the average speed of and the slow variation in the wind speed. The low-pass filter makes it possible to model instantaneous turbulence, with a time constant approximating the frequency response of the wind turbulence spectrum, as defined in the IEC61400-1 standard. The sum of the two filters makes it possible to model a power spectral density PSD signal consistent with the Kaimal model defined in the standard. The transfer function H corresponding to the PSD model may be given by (the function H is also called in the remainder of the wind signal model description):
[0064] Where a and b are the parameters of the wind signal model, s is the Laplace variable, and τ is the time constant.
[0065] Thus, according to one embodiment of the invention, the wind signal model may correspond to the Kaimal model, which is written as:
[0066] Where k is the index corresponding to the component under consideration (k varies between 1 and 3 and represents the z, y and x axes), f is the frequency, Vhub is the average wind speed obtained in step 3, σ is the standard deviation component, Sk is the spectrum of the speed component in the direction k, and Lk is an integral scale parameter of the speed component.
[0067] The following relationship is also present:
σ.sub.k.sup.2=∫.sub.0.sup.∞S.sub.k(f)df
[0068] And the parameter σk is linked to the standard deviation determined in the previous step, depending on the component under consideration. For example, for the z axis, σ1 may have the value of the standard deviation, for the y axis, σ2 may be 0.8 times the standard deviation, and for the x axis, σ3 may be 0.5 times the standard deviation.
[0069] The parameter L may be linked to a scale parameter.
[0070] As a variant, the method according to the invention is adapted to other wind models, such as the “Von Karman” model.
5—Determining the Parameters of the Model
[0071] This step comprises determining the parameters of the wind signal model by way of the standard deviation and the average wind speed both determined in step 3. Thus, at the end of this step, the wind signal model is adapted to the measurements carried out by the LiDAR sensor, thereby making it possible to make the determination of the wind speed components accurate.
[0072] According to the embodiment of the transfer function H described above, the parameters a and b of the transfer function are determined. It is possible to determine the parameters a, and b, by way of the following equation:
[0073] In which the vector L is the vector of the components of the direction of the measurement beam in question, and S is the vector of the spectral components of the Kaimal model, which depend on known parameters, in particular the average wind speed and the standard deviation both determined in step 3.
[0074] It is thus possible to estimate the parameters a and b using the equation:
6—Non-Stationary Kalman Filter
[0075] This step comprises filtering the measurement signals obtained in step 1 by way of a non-stationary Kalman filter, the wind signal model constructed in step 4 and the parameters of the wind signal model determined in step 5. This thus gives filtered measurement signals suitable for accurately determining the wind speed components, in a robust manner. It will be recalled that a Kalman filter is an infinite impulse response filter that estimates the states of a dynamic system based on a series of incomplete or noisy measurements. The filter is described as being a non-stationary because the model embedded in the Kalman filter, explained in particular in steps 4 and 5, describes a signal with a priori variable variance and average, depending on the measurement conditions and the characteristics of the measured wind.
[0076] For this purpose, it is possible to formulate the transfer function H in the continuous state space as follows:
[0077] X contains the states of the transfer function H and
[0078] Y contains the estimate of the contribution of the wind to the raw and noisy radial measurement.
[0079] Y is therefore the filtered radial measurement, in other words the measurement signal filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
[0080] By discretizing this transfer function, it is possible to write:
[0081] Where Ts is the sampling time of the discretization.
[0082] For this step, it is also possible to implement the following recurrence equations:
[0083] At the time k, the prediction of the state at the time k+1 is denoted x.sub.k+1|k, and the predicted output is denoted .sub.k+1|k where x.sub.k+1|k=A.sub.k|k
.sub.k+1|k=CAx.sub.k|k.
[0084] The confidence in this prediction, corresponding to the covariance of the error on the state, is as follows: P.sub.k+1|k=AP.sub.k|kA.sup.T+BQ.sub.kB.sup.T where Q is the covariance matrix.
[0085] This prediction thus gives the most probable value of the state and the output.
[0086] At the time k+1, the prediction is updated with the measurement:
x.sub.k+1|k+1=x.sub.k+1|k+K.sub.k+1(y.sub.k+1−y.sub.k+1|k)
[0087] The gain K may be given by:
K=P.sub.k+1|k*C.sup.T*(Ck+1|kC.sup.T+DQ.sub.k+1D.sup.T+V.sub.k+1)
[0088] It is then possible to update the prediction matrix:
P.sub.k+1|k+1=(I−K.sub.k+1P.sub.k+1|kC)P.sub.k+1|k
[0089] According to one embodiment of the invention, the covariance matrix of the non-stationary Kalman filter may be determined by minimizing a cost function that takes into account the dispersion and the average deviation of the measurement signals. The philosophy of adjusting the covariance matrix may be summarized as follows: The more complex the site, the more uncertain the model, and the higher the “method noise” (corresponding to the covariance matrix).
[0090] For example, the following operations may be implemented:
[0091] The prerequisite: having measurement data from the LiDAR sensor and what are known as reference data, for example originating from an anemometric measurement mast. The placed LiDAR sensor may be positioned close enough to the measurement mast for the respective measurements to be correlated.
[0092] The principle:
[0093] Developing a relevant cost function, taking into account the dispersion and the deviation of the reconstructed turbulence intensity TI compared to the TI resulting from the “mast” measurements.
[0094] The cost function is minimized using suitable optimization algorithms, by adjusting the “multiplicative gain of the covariance matrix Q” parameter.
Preferably, it is possible to add optimization constraints as a function of an acceptable error constraint. For example, this acceptable error constraint may be defined according to a range of average wind speeds.
7—Determining the Wind Speed Components
[0095] This step comprises determining the wind speed components in at least one measurement plane, by way of the measurement signals filtered by way of the non-stationary Kalman filter obtained in step 6. For this step, a reconstruction of the wind speed components is implemented based on the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter. This step thus makes it possible to determine wind speed components in a robust and accurate manner.
[0096] Multiple reconstruction techniques, based on stronger or weaker wind homogeneity, spatial coherence and/or fixed turbulence propagation hypotheses may be used for this step.
[0097] According to one embodiment, the reconstruction of the wind speed components by way of the filtered measurement signals may be implemented by way of a geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components based on the filtered measurement signals. In other words, for this embodiment, it is possible to implement the method for reconstructing wind speed components that is implemented in step 2, that is to say the geometric reconstruction of the wind speed components implementing a pseudo-inverse “Moore-Penrose” operation applied to the measurement signals filtered by the non-stationary Kalman filter.
8—Segmenting the Wind Speed Components
[0098] It should be noted that this step is optional. This step may be implemented in order to determine at least one characteristic of the wind speed based on the wind speed components. This step comprises temporally segmenting the wind speed components obtained in the previous step by a predetermined time interval. In other words, datasets of wind speed components are generated for the predetermined time interval. The predetermined time interval is the one over which it is desired to determine the characteristic of the wind speed.
[0099] According to one embodiment of the invention, the predetermined time interval may be between 1 min and 1 h, preferably between 5 min and 30 min, and may for example be 10 min. These time intervals make it possible to have a significant characteristic of the wind speed, in order to determine the possibility of installing a wind turbine at the measurement location.
9—Determining a Characteristic of the Wind Speed
[0100] It should be noted that this step is optional, and follows step 8. This step comprises determining at least one characteristic of the wind speed over the predetermined time interval, for at least one measurement plane.
[0101] According to one embodiment of the invention, a wind characteristic is chosen from among: an average wind speed, a standard deviation of the wind speed, a maximum wind speed, an average wind direction, wind turbulence intensity, an average of the vertical component of the wind speed, and a standard deviation of the vertical component of the wind speed.
[0102] Preferably, in this step, it is possible to determine at least the wind turbulence intensity over the predetermined time interval, which corresponds to the ratio of the standard deviation of the wind speed to the wind speed. Indeed, this characteristic makes it possible to determine the class of the wind turbine.
[0103] Preferably, it is possible to determine at least wind turbulence intensity over the predetermined time interval, an average wind speed and an average wind direction. Indeed, these characteristics make it possible to determine the class of the wind turbine, its position and its dimensions.
[0104] The present invention furthermore relates to a method for installing a wind turbine, in which method the following steps are implemented: [0105] At least one of determining the wind speed components, and at least one characteristic of the wind speed, by way of the method according to any one of the variants or combinations of variants described above, pertaining to at least one site, [0106] At least one of installing a wind turbine on the site as a function of the wind speed components and as a function of the at least one characteristic of the wind speed.
[0107] In the installation step, it is possible to determine the wind turbine that is installed in terms of dimensions, class and its structure, and it is also possible to determine its orientation and its control by at least one of a function of the wind speed components and as a function of the at least one characteristic of the wind speed.
[0108] According to one implementation of the invention, the first step may be repeated on multiple sites. Next, the site most suitable for the installation of a wind turbine is determined by the at least one of a function of the wind speed components and as a function of the at least one characteristic of the wind speed. This may be in particular the site at which the wind speed is within an operating range suitable for the recovery of energy by a wind turbine.