Use of cationic surfactants in the cyanidation of refractory carbonaceous ores for recovery of metals

Abstract

A process for recovery of precious metals from ores or concentrates containing refractory carbonaceous material by cyanidation leaching. The process involves addition to the ores or concentrates at least one cationic surfactant before or during the addition of cyanide-containing solution. The agent enables the recovery of precious metals by cyanidation from high preg-robbing carbonaceous ores and improves the recovery of precious metals by cyanidation from medium to low preg-robbing carbonaceous ores. The agent also prevents froth and foaming formation during the cyanidation process.

Claims

1. A method for recovering a metal from ore or concentrate containing carbonaceous material by cyanidation leaching, the method comprising the following steps: a) treating the ore or concentrate containing carbonaceous material with at least one cationic surfactant in order to reduce or prevent retention of said metal or a cyanide complex of said metal by said ore or concentrate as a result of the presence of said carbonaceous material in said ore or concentrate, the ore or concentrate after said treating being designated “treated ore or concentrate”, and b) cyanidation leaching of the treated ore or concentrate, wherein the cationic surfactant is a saturated or unsaturated alkyl amine or derivative thereof, wherein the alkyl amine is selected from the group consisting of primary alkyl amines, secondary alkyl amines, tertiary alkyl amines and alkyl polyamines, and wherein the alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of 14 to 40.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising a step of adding a cyanide-containing solution to the ore or concentrate.

3. The method of claim 1, further comprising a step of roasting the ore or concentrate prior to the treating step.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein the ore or concentrate is in an aqueous ore slurry with particle size 80% passing 30 mesh or finer and a pulp density of 5% to 80%.

5. The method of claim 1, further comprising a step of oxidizing the ore or concentrate prior to the treating step.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein the alkyl amine is animal based or vegetable based fatty alkyl amine.

7. The method of claim 1, wherein the alkyl amine is alkoxylated.

8. The method of claim 1, wherein the cationic surfactant is selected from the group consisting of a salt of the alkyl amine, an alkyl amine derivative, and combinations thereof.

9. The method of claim 1, wherein the cationic surfactant is an alkyl quaternary ammonium salt.

10. The method of claim 1, wherein the cationic surfactant is an alkyl amine oxide.

11. The method of claim 1, wherein the cationic surfactant is selected from the group consisting of an alkyl amide, amidoamine, imidazoline, and combinations thereof.

12. The method of claim 1, wherein the ore or concentrate is treated with the cationic surfactant and at least one other surfactant selected from the group consisting of a cationic surfactant different from the cationic surfactant, an anionic surfactant, a non-ionic surfactant, an amphoteric surfactant, and combinations thereof.

13. The method of claim 1, further comprising a step of adding a defoamer to the ore or concentrate prior to the step of cyanidation leaching.

14. A method for recovering a metal from ore or concentrate containing carbonaceous material by cyanidation leaching, the method comprising the following steps: a) treating the ore or concentrate containing carbonaceous material with at least one cationic surfactant in order to reduce or prevent retention of said metal or a cyanide complex of said metal by said ore or concentrate as a result of the presence of said carbonaceous material in said ore or concentrate, the ore or concentrate after said treating being designated “treated ore or concentrate”, and b) cyanidation leaching of the treated ore or concentrate, wherein the cationic surfactant is a saturated or unsaturated alkyl amine or derivative thereof, wherein the alkyl amine is selected from the group consisting of primary alkyl amines, secondary alkyl amines, and tertiary alkyl amines, and wherein the alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of 14 to 40.

Description

DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

(1) The present invention is directed to a method for recovering a metal from ore or concentrate containing carbonaceous material by cyanidation leaching. The process comprises the step of treating the ore or concentrate with at least one cationic surfactant, and cyanidation leaching of the treated ore or concentrate. To initiate the leaching, a cyanide-containing solution may be added to the ore or concentrate. The addition of the cyanide-containing solution may be done simultaneously with or after the treating step. The treating step is initiated by adding the at least one cationic surfactant to the ore or concentrate. Additionally, the ore or concentrate may be roasted before being treated with the cationic surfactant.

(2) The method of the present invention is suitable for the recovery of a metal from its ore or concentrate; examples of such metal include, but are not limited to, gold, silver, and platinum group metals. Platinum group metals include, but not limited to, platinum, palladium, rhodium, iridium, ruthenium, and osmium.

(3) In one embodiment, the ore or concentrate may be in the form of an aqueous ore slurry with particle size 80% passing 30 mesh and a pulp density of 5% to 80%. In another embodiment, the aqueous ore slurry has a particle size 80% passing 100 mesh; in yet another embodiment, 80% passing 200 mesh. Also, in one embodiment, the aqueous ore slurry has a pulp density of 20% to 50%; in another embodiment, 15% to 65%.

(4) The method of the present invention may include the step of oxidizing the ore or concentrate prior to the treating step. This oxidizing step may be particularly useful when the ore or concentrate is in the form of an aqueous ore slurry. The oxidizing step may be done by pressure oxidation, chlorine oxidation, peroxide oxidation or bacteria biodegradation.

(5) The ore or concentrate may be treated with the cationic surfactant with agitation for a period of 1 minute to 10 hours; such agitation is done after the addition of the cationic surfactant to the ore or concentrate. In one embodiment, the ore or concentrate is treated with the cationic surfactant for a period of 10 minutes to 2 hours; in another embodiment, 20 minutes to 1 hour. The ore or concentrate may also be treated with the cationic surfactant at a temperature of 10° C. to 100° C. Heating may be needed to bring up the temperature of the ore or concentrate (slurry) to the desired temperature. In one embodiment, the ore or concentrate is treated with the cationic surfactant at a temperature of 10° C. to 50° C.; in another embodiment, 15° C. to 30° C.; in yet another embodiment, 50° C. to 95° C.; and in one other embodiment, 60° C. to 90° C. The treatment of the ore or concentrate may be carried out in an acidic or basic condition. In one embodiment, the ore or concentrate is treated in a condition of pH 0-7; in another embodiment pH 1-5; in yet another embodiment pH 1-4.

(6) The amount of the at least one cationic surfactant used to treat the ore or concentrate is in the range of 0.01 kg/ton (0.01 kg of surfactant to a ton of ore or concentrate) to 20 kg/ton basis of the ore or concentrate. In one embodiment, the amount is in the range of 0.1 kg/ton to 5 kg/ton; in another embodiment, 0.2 kg/ton to 2 kg/ton.

(7) The cyanidation leaching suitable for the present method includes carbon-in-leach (CIL) cyanidation, carbon-in-pulp (CIP) cyanidation, resin-in-leach (RIL) cyanidation and direct cyanidation. Preferably, the cyanidation is performed at a basic condition, e.g., pH 8-13, 9-12, or 10-11; this may be done by adjusting the pH prior to the addition of the cyanide-containing solution.

(8) A large number of ore bodies and large amount of carbonaceous ores are suitable to be treated in accordance with the present invention. The carbonaceous ore may be very high preg-robbing by itself, the carbonaceous ore may show low to medium preg-robbing nature. The carbonaceous ore may contain oxidized ore material, such as copper oxide or iron oxide. Also, the carbonaceous ore may contain metal sulfide, such as iron sulfide (pyrite, arsenopyrite, realgar, etc.) or copper sulfide (chalcopyrite, chalcocite, enargite, etc.). These sulfides, if present, may be removed by pressure oxidation, bio-oxidation or roasting.

(9) Preg-robbing is understood to be the phenomenon where the gold cyanide complex is removed from leaching solution by the constituents of the ores. In other words, gold is leached out by cyanide from ores and simultaneously the formed gold cyanide complex is adsorbed back to the ores by its native components, and this will make the gold unavailable for recovery at later steps.

(10) The cationic surfactant suitable for use in the present invention includes alkyl amine and derivatives thereof, alkyl amide, amidoamine, and imidazoline. The alkyl amine may be a primary, secondary, or tertiary alkyl amine or alkyl polyamine. The alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of about 4 to about 40. In one embodiment, the alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of about 6 to about 32; in another embodiment, about 8 to about 28; and in yet another embodiment, about 10 to about 24. In a preferred embodiment, the alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of about 14 to about 40, in another embodiment, about 16 to about 32, in yet another embodiment, about 16 to about 22. The alkyl amine may be animal based or vegetable based fatty alkyl amine. In one embodiment, the alkyl amine is derived from animal based fat or vegetable oil. In another embodiment, the alkyl amine is derived from coconut, castor, tallow, tall oil, soyabean, palm, corn, or rapeseed. The alkyl amine may be alkoxylated (e.g., ethoxylated or propoxylated or both ethoxylated and propoxylated).

(11) The cationic surfactant may also be a salt of the alkyl amine or the alkyl amine derivative. Suitable salts include acetate, sulfate, phosphate, chloride, bromide, and nitrate. The cationic surfactant may also be an alkyl quaternary ammonium salt; examples thereof include, but are not limited to tallowalkyl trimethyl ammonium chloride and N,N,N′,N′,N′-pentamethyl-N-tallow-1,3-propane diammonium dichloride. The cationic surfactant may also be an alkoxylated (e.g., ethoxylated or propoxylated or both ethoxylated and propoxylated) alkyl quaternary ammonium salt; examples thereof include, but are not limited to, tris(2-hydroxyethyl) tallowalkyl ammonium acetate, cocoalkylmethyl ethoxylated (2) ammonium chloride. The cationic surfactant may also be an alkyl amine oxide (alkoxylated or unalkoxylated); examples thereof include, but are not limited to bis(2-hydroxyethyl)-cocoalkylamine oxide, dimethylhydrogenated tallowalkylamine oxide.

(12) In one particular embodiment, the cationic surfactant is an ethoxylated alkylamine derived from tallow. In another particular embodiment, the cationic surfactant is a propoxylated alkylamine derived from tallow.

(13) The amidoamine may be a primary, secondary, or tertiary amidoamine or amidopolyamine. The alkyl amide, amidoamide or imidazoline suitable for use as the cationic surfactant in the method of the present invention has an alkyl chain length of about 4 to about 40. In one embodiment, the alkyl amide, amidoamide or imidazoline has an alkyl chain length of about 6 to about 32; in another embodiment, about 8 to about 28; and in yet another embodiment, about 10 to about 24. In a preferred embodiment, the alkyl amine has an alkyl chain length of about 14 to about 40, in another embodiment, about 16 to about 32, in yet another embodiment, about 16 to about 22. The alkyl amide, amidoamide or imidazoline may be animal based or vegetable based fatty alkyl amine. In one embodiment, the alkyl amide, amidoamide or imidazoline is derived from animal based fat or vegetable oil. In another embodiment, the alkyl amide, amidoamide or imidazoline is derived from coconut, castor, tallow, tall oil, soyabean, palm, corn, or rapeseed.

(14) It is understood that the cationic surfactant may be a combination of a cationic surfactant with at least one other surfactant, such as a different cationic surfactant, an anionic surfactant (e.g., sodium lauryl ether sulfate), a non-ionic surfactant (e.g., C10-12 alcohol ethoxylate), and amphoteric surfactant (e.g., N-tallowalkyl betaine). If the cationic surfactant is a mixture of surfactants, the amount of the surfactant mixture used to treat the ore or concentrate is in the range of 0.01 kg/ton (0.01 kg of surfactant to a ton of ore or concentrate) to 20 kg/ton basis of the ore or concentrate. In one embodiment, the amount is in the range of 0.1 kg/ton to 5 kg/ton; in another embodiment, 0.2 kg/ton to 2 kg/ton.

(15) Depending on the cationic surfactant used in the treatment of the ore or concentrate, formation of large amount of foaming or froth during the leaching process may occur. As such, the method according to the present invention may further comprise the step of adding a defoamer to the ore or concentrate prior to the step of cyanidation leaching. Examples of a suitable defoamer include, but are not limited to, oils (or dispersion thereof), waxes (or dispersions thereof), ethyleneoxide (EO) or propyleneoxide (PO) polymers, and silicone-based dispersions or emulsions.

(16) The present inventors have also unexpectedly discovered that while some of the surfactants used to treat the ore or concentrate may result in the formation of large amount of foaming or froth during the leaching process caused by the movement of the ores and/or the intentional introduction or in-situ generation of air/oxygen during the leaching (particularly when the carbonaceous ores are in the form of aqueous slurry with fine particle size of less than 300 microns), others do not. Particularly, it has been unexpectedly discovered that while the treatment of the ore or concentrate with an ethoxylated alkylamine derived from tallow may cause a large amount of foaming or froth, the same treatment with a propoxylated alkylamine derived from tallow does not. This discovery may lead to a more efficient recovery method in which no defoamer is necessary.

(17) The present invention will now be illustrated by the following non-limiting examples.

EXAMPLES

Example 1

(18) A sample of carbonaceous gold ore with approximately 0.10 oz/ton of gold was used for cyanidation leaching. The ore was a double refractory ore containing approximately 0.6% organic carbon and showed medium preg-robbing, it was obtained as acidic discharge slurry from autoclave after pressurized oxidation (POX) with a particle size of 80% passing 150 microns and pulp density up to 50%. Additional water was used to reduce pulp density to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach (CIL) cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 90° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 1 hour at 90° C. and at the pH as-is. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 1 shows the leaching results after ore was conditioned with different surfactants used at various dosages.

(19) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 Surfactant Surfactant dosage Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) (%) none 0 51.7 Armac HT (hydrogenated tallow 0.5 72.7 alkylamine acetate) Armac HT 1.0 77.7 Armac HT 2.0 78.3 Armac HT 5.0 80.0 Ethomeen T/12 (ethoxylated 0.5 75.0 alkylamine derived from tallow) Ethomeen T/12 1.0 76.0 Ethomeen T/12 2.0 77.3 Ethomeen T/12 5.0 74.3 Armeen HT (hydrogenated tallow 0.5 75.0 alkylamine) Armeen HT 1.0 75.7 Armeen HT 2.0 76.7 Armeen HT 5.0 79.0

Example 2

(20) A sample of the same ore and its acidic POX autoclave discharge slurry as in example 1 was used for cyanidation leaching. Additional water was used to reduce the pulp density of the slurry to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 90° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned at 90° C. and at the pH as-is for a period of 20 to 60 minutes. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 2 shows the leaching results after ore was conditioned with surfactant for different period of time.

(21) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Surfactant Surfactant dosage conditioning Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) time (min) (%) none 0 60 51.7 Armac HT 2 60 78.3 Armac HT 2 50 79.0 Armac HT 2 40 80.0 Armac HT 2 30 79.0 Armac HT 2 20 79.0 Ethomeen T/12 0.5 60 75.0 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 60 76.0 Ethomeen T/12 0.5 30 79.3 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 30 77.7

Example 3

(22) A sample of the same ore and its acidic POX autoclave discharge slurry as in example 1 was used for cyanidation leaching. Additional water was used to reduce the pulp density of the slurry to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 30 minutes at the pH as-is and at different temperatures from 20° C. to 90° C. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 3 shows the leaching results after ore was conditioned with surfactant at different condition temperatures.

(23) TABLE-US-00003 TABLE 3 Surfactant Surfactant dosage conditioning Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) temperature (° C.) (%) none 0 90 51.7 Ethomeen T/12 1 20 70.0 Ethomeen T/12 1 40 72.3 Ethomeen T/12 1 65 76.0 Ethomeen T/12 1 80 76.0 Ethomeen T/12 1 90 77.7

Example 4

(24) A sample of carbonaceous gold ore with approximately 0.23 oz/ton of gold was used for cyanidation leaching. The ore was a double refractory ore containing approximately 4.4% total carbon with 0.7% organic carbon and showed very high preg-robbing, it was obtained as alkaline discharge slurry after pressurized oxidation with a particle size of 80% passing 100 microns and pulp density up to 50%. Additional water was used to reduce pulp density to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 90° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 1 hour at 90° C. and at the pH as-is. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 4 shows the leaching results after the ore was conditioned with surfactant.

(25) TABLE-US-00004 TABLE 4 Surfactant Surfactant dosage conditioning Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) temperature (° C.) (%) none 0 90 7.6 Ethomeen T/12 1 90 46.5

Example 5

(26) A sample of carbonaceous gold ore with approximately 0.11 oz/ton of gold was used for cyanidation leaching. The ore was a double refractory ore containing approximately 1.45% organic carbon and showed very high preg-robbing, it was obtained as acidic discharge slurry from autoclave after pressurized oxidation with a particle size of 80% passing 100 microns and pulp density up to 50%. Additional water was used to reduce pulp density to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 80˜90° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 30 minutes at 80˜90° C. and at the pH as-is. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 5 shows the leaching results after the ore was conditioned with surfactant at various dosages.

(27) TABLE-US-00005 TABLE 5 Surfactant Surfactant dosage conditioning Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) temperature (° C.) (%) none 0 90 9.3 Ethomeen T/12 0.1 90 32.6 Ethomeen T/12 0.25 90 50.2 Ethomeen T/12 0.5 90 55.0 Ethomeen T/12 1 80 62.3 Ethomeen T/12 2 80 59.7 Ethomeen T/12 5 80 60.7

Example 6

(28) A sample of carbonaceous gold ore with approximately 0.21 oz/ton of gold was used for cyanidation leaching. It was obtained from the 1st stage of roaster with a particle size of 80% passing 100 microns. The ore contains 0.88% organic carbon and showed medium preg-robbing after roasting at a much higher throughput. Water was used to adjust pulp density to 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 80° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 30 minutes at 80° C. and at the pH as-is. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 6 shows the leaching results after the ore was conditioned with surfactant.

(29) TABLE-US-00006 TABLE 6 Activated carbon Surfactant dosage used in CIL Gold Recovery Surfactant used added (kg/t) leaching (%) none 0 carbon 1 71.9 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 1 82.7 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 2 81.6 Propomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 1 80.6 (propoxylated alkylamine derived from tallow) Propomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 2 78.9

Example 7

(30) A sample of carbonaceous gold ore with approximately 0.10 oz/ton of gold was used for cyanidation leaching. The ore was crushed and ground to powder form with a particle size of 80% passing 75 microns. Water was added into powder to give a pulp density of 30˜40% wt solids, and the resulting slurry was used for further treatments by surfactant and corresponding carbon-in-leach cyanidation leaching. A stainless steel tank with this ore slurry was heated to 80° C. in a water bath. Surfactant was added to the heated slurry and the slurry was conditioned for 30 minutes at 80° C. and at the pH as-is. Then, the conditioned slurry was transferred to a bottle, and the pH of the slurry was adjusted, if needed, to pH 10˜11.5 using lime. Sodium cyanide of approximately 1 g/L and activated carbon of approximately 20 g/L were added, and the bottle was rotated on a roller for 20 hrs. The pulp was then filtered and washed for gold analysis. The percentage gold recovery is calculated from assayed head gold and residue gold. An example where the slurry was not treated by any agent was carried out the same way, and the gold recovery was measured through same CIL cyanidation leaching process. Table 7 shows the leaching results after the ore was conditioned with surfactant.

(31) TABLE-US-00007 TABLE 7 Activated carbon Surfactant Surfactant dosage used in CIL Gold Recovery used added (kg/t) leaching (%) none 0 carbon 1 33.6 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 1 45.3 Ethomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 2 53.6 Propomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 1 49.8 Propomeen T/12 1.0 carbon 2 53.6

Example 8

(32) A sample of the same ore and its powder as in Example 7 was used for foaming tests. The foaming tests were done in a 500 mL erlenmeyer flask under constant agitation by a magnetic stirring bar, with air flow of 1 L/min through micro pipette. Water and ore powder were added into the erlenmeyer flask, and gave a slurry with pulp density of 35˜40% wt solids. Surfactant or surfactant mixture was added into slurry and the slurry was heated to 70˜90° C. Foam would generate from the slurry under constant agitation and air sparging, and bubble out of the flask. The out of the flask foam was collected in a pre-graduated catch tray for a period of 60 minutes from the start of agitation and air sparging, the amount of the foam generated during the test was measured there.

(33) TABLE-US-00008 Surfactant Surfactant dosage Amount of foam used added (kg/t) observation generated Ethomeen T/12 1.0 Foam was More than quickly formed 1.0 liter and stable Mixture of 75% 1.0 small amount <100 mL Ethomeen T/12 + of foaming 25% Prppomeen T/12 Mixtures of 50% 1.0 almost no <1 mL Ethomeen T/12 + foaming 50% Propomeen T/12 Propomeen T/12 1.0 almost no <1 mL foaming