Shearable tubular system and method
11255132 · 2022-02-22
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
International classification
E21B33/06
FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
E21B17/00
FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
Abstract
A tubular string for a subterranean well comprises a first string that is located in the well and that can access or traverse horizons of interest, such as during drilling, completion, or workover. A second tubular string is assembled above this first tubular string and is selected so that only this second tubular string normally traverses a blow out preventer during periods when there is an elevated risk that the blow out preventer will be actuated. The second tubular string is made of a more easily shearable material than the first tubular string, such as a titanium alloy, an aluminum alloy, or a composite material. A third or further tubular strings may be assembled above the second tubular string, such as in subsea applications.
Claims
1. A method for accessing subterranean horizons, comprising: assembling a first tubular string comprising multiple sections of first tubular material to extend beneath a subterranean level to a horizon of interest; assembling a second tubular string comprising multiple sections of a second tubular material attached above the first tubular string, the second tubular string extending along a length that will traverse a blow out preventer during accessing of the horizon of interest; and assembling a third tubular string comprising multiple sections of the first tubular material attached above the second tubular string; wherein during accessing the horizon of interest, except during placement and removal of the first tubular string, only the second tubular string traverses the blowout preventer; and wherein the second tubular string comprises a single wall material, and the first tubular material has a first difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, and the second tubular material has a second difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, the second difference being less than the first difference, wherein the second tubular string is made of a titanium alloy or aluminum alloy, wherein the first and the third tubular strings are made of a steel alloy.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the first tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at most approximately 0.85 and the second tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at least approximately 0.90, whereby the second tubular material is more favorable to shear by action of the blow out preventer than the first tubular material.
3. The method of claim 2, comprising assembling the first, second, and third tubular strings in series as the tubular strings are deployed in a well.
4. The method of claim 2, wherein, except during placement and removal of the first tubular string, the first tubular string is deployed underground, and the third tubular string is deployed underwater between the sea surface and the second tubular string.
5. The method of claim 2, wherein the second tubular string is characterized by a yield strength to tensile strength ratio of at least approximately 0.9, a modulus of elasticity of at most approximately 17 Mpsi, and a fracture toughness of at most approximately 45 KSIin.sup.−2.
6. A method for accessing subterranean horizons, comprising: assembling a first tubular string comprising multiple sections of a first tubular material to extend only beneath a subterranean level to a horizon of interest except during placement and removal of the first tubular string; assembling a second tubular string comprising multiple sections of a second tubular material attached above the first tubular string, the second tubular string extending along a length that will traverse a blowout preventer during accessing of the horizon of interest; and assembling a third tubular string comprising multiple sections of the first tubular material attached above the second tubular string to extend only above the blow out preventer in a subsea environment; wherein the second tubular string comprises a single wall material, and the first tubular material has a first difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, and the second tubular material has a second difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, the second difference being less than the first difference, wherein the second tubular string is made of a titanium alloy or aluminum alloy, wherein the first and the third tubular strings are made of a steel alloy.
7. The method of claim 6, wherein the first tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at most approximately 0.85 and the second tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at least approximately 0.90, whereby the second tubular material is more favorable to shear by action of the blow out preventer than the first tubular material.
8. The method of claim 6, comprising assembling the first, second, and third tubular strings in series as the tubular strings are deployed in a well.
9. A tubular string comprising: a first tubular string comprising multiple sections of first tubular material extending only beneath a subterranean level to a horizon of interest except during placement and removal of the first tubular string; a second tubular string comprising multiple sections of second tubular material attached above the first tubular string, the second tubular string extending along a length that will traverse a blow out preventer during accessing of the horizon of interest; and a third tubular string comprising multiple sections of first tubular material attached above the second tubular string to extend only above the blow out preventer in a subsea environment; wherein the second tubular string comprises a single wall material, and the first tubular material has a first difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, and the second tubular material has a second difference between yield strength and tensile strength thereof, the second difference being less than the first difference, wherein the second tubular string is made of a titanium alloy or aluminum alloy, wherein the first and the third tubular strings are made of a steel alloy.
10. The tubular string of claim 9, wherein the first tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at most approximately 0.85 and the second tubular material has a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of at least approximately 0.90, whereby the second tubular material is more favorable to shear by action of the blow out preventer than the first tubular material.
11. The tubular string of claim 9, wherein the second tubular string is characterized by a yield strength to tensile strength ratio of at least approximately 0.9, a modulus of elasticity of at most approximately 17 Mpsi, and a fracture toughness of at most approximately 45 KSIin.sup.−2.
Description
DRAWINGS
(1) These and other features, aspects, and advantages of the present invention will become better understood when the following detailed description is read with reference to the accompanying drawings in which like characters represent like parts throughout the drawings, wherein:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
(10) Turning now to the drawings, and referring first to
(11) In the simplified illustration of
(12) In accordance with the present disclosure, at least two different tubular stocks are provided and used by the operation, and these may be stored on a deck or other storage location. In
(13) In the illustration of
(14) To allow the string to be sheared in case of need, a blow out preventer 44 is located, typically at the earth's surface 20, and possibly in conjunction with other equipment, such as hydraulic systems, instrumentation, valving, and so forth. Control and monitoring components or systems 46 (including a BOP control system) will typically be associated with the blow out preventer (BOP) to allow for actuation when needed. Those skilled in the art will recognize that such equipment typically provides shear blades that are in generally opposed positions and can be urged towards one by strong hydraulic rams once the BOP is actuated. Actuation of the BOP is an unusual but critical event, and is typically performed only when well conditions absolutely necessitate it, such as when excessive pressures are detected from the well. For safety reasons it is important that the BOP reliably shear the string to seal the well.
(15) It has been found that certain tubular materials used in wells may not be effectively sheared by such BOPs, however. In particular conventional steel tubulars used in oil and gas wells are difficult or impossible to shear under the forces available from BOPs. This is particularly true of thick walled tubulars (e.g., 4 to 7 inches in outer diameter with thick walls, such as on the order of 1 inch or more in thickness). But it has been found that other materials may be much more favorable to shearing, and can be used in specific locations in the tubular string, particularly through the BOP, and particularly when horizons or regions are being accessed that have a higher likelihood of requiring actuation of the BOP. In the illustrated embodiment, the first tubular string 36 extends over a first length 48, the second tubular string 38 extends over a second length 50, and the upper or third tubular string 40 extends over a third length 52. It is contemplated that different tubular strings or sections will be used because the lower and upper strings may be less expensive (e.g., conventional steels), while the second string or section, while more expensive, will be selected to have material properties that render it much more likely to be sheared by the BOP. That is, there may not be a need for this material in the well or through the depth of water below the platform, but for at least that length of the string that is likely to be moved through the BOP during operation, and particularly during accessing those regions of higher risk of excessive pressure events, the more shearable material is used.
(16) It should be noted that the upper or third tubular string may be the same material as the second tubular string, but in many cases this will not be economical owing to the relatively higher cost of the second material, particularly in deep water and where the upper tubular string is not likely ever to traverse the BOP.
(17) By way of example, it is presently contemplated that the first or lower tubular string may be made of conventional steel tubular material. The third tubular string may be made of the same or material, but in some cases of a lower wall thickness. The second tubular string may be made of materials that are more easily sheared, such as titanium alloys, aluminum alloys, or composite materials. The strings are assembled as illustrated generally in
(18) The materials of each string may be designed or selected to provide required tensile strengths, internal pressure ratings, and end thread connections to allow for ready assembly and servicing of the well in the particular conditions then present, and to withstand tensile and compressive loading on the string (e.g., the weight of a completion workover riser). The materials may, of course, be prepared, heat treated, and so forth, to enhance their strength and material properties (e.g., tensile and hoop strengths). Moreover, any suitable length of the second string may be used, such as lengths as short as 10 or 20 feet to extended lengths of hundreds or thousands of feet. It may be noted, too, that in certain applications the more easily shearable second tubular string disclosed here may be considered a “shear joint” that may supplement or replace a conventional shear joint, such as in subsea test tree applications for well completion and re-working. Particular applications may include, for example, not only for direct inclusion into strings used in drilling, completion and re-working, but also use with wireline or slickline tools for well intervention, running logging tools, installing plugs (e.g., completion or subsea wellheads). Further, versions of the proposed second, more easily shearable strings may be incorporated into these tool strings, such as within heavy-walled section components such as “sinker bars” or similar devices that have thick metallic cross-sections and are difficult to shear by shear rams when needed to create a well-barrier against release of fluids (e.g., hydrocarbons).
(19) As noted above, it has been found that conventional tubular materials used in wells may not be effectively sheared by BOPs under the forces available.
(20)
(21) The process of shearing the tubulars is illustrated again in
(22) The material properties believed to be of particular interest in allowing for reliable shearing of the second tubular string include yield and tensile strengths and their relative relationships to one another, modulus of elasticity, fracture toughness, and tendancy, based upon these properties, of cracks to propagate quickly. Regarding, first, the strength of the materials, for steel alloys a typical strength yield strength may be on the order of approximately 150 KSI, although this may range, for example between 135 to 165 KSI yield strength range. Tensile strengths for such steel materials may range typically between 20 to 30 KSI higher than the yield strength. A ratio of yield strength to tensile strength may be, therefore, on the order of 0.8 to 0.85. Titanium alloys suitable for the present techniques, on the other hand, have yield strengths typically on the order of 150 KSI, with typical ranges of 120 to over 170 KSI. The tensile strengths of these materials, however, is only approximately 10 KSI above the yield strength, resulting in a substantially higher ratio of on the order of above 0.90. Similarly, aluminum alloys suitable for use in the present techniques will typically have a yield strength on the order of approximately 58 KSI with ranges of 40 to 75 KSI. Typical tensile strengths would be on the order of approximately 63 KSI with ranges of 46 to 81 KSI, resulting in a difference between the yield strength and the tensile strength of only approximately 6 KSI, and a ratio of yield strength to tensile strength of higher than 0.90. Composites are unique in that they can be manufactured to meet any of the requirements for optimum shearability, with very narrow ranges and differences between the yield strength and the tensile strength.
(23) Regarding the modulus of elasticity, conventional steels used for well tubulars have a modulus typically on the order of 29.5 Mpsi, with typical ranges of 27 to 31 Mpsi. Titanium tubulars contemplated for the present techniques, on the other hand, have a modulus typically on the order of 16.5 million psi, with typical ranges of 13.5 to 17 Mpsi. That is, significantly lower than that of steel tubulars. Aluminum alloy tubulars suitable for the present techniques have a modulus typically on the order of 10 Mpsi. Ranges 9 to 11.5 Mpsi. Suitable composites can be made to have a very low modulus, such as on the order of 5 Mpsi if required.
(24) Regarding the fracture toughness, this property may be defined the ability of a material containing a crack to resist fracture. The value indicates the stress level that would be required for a fracture to occur rapidly. Typical steels used for well tubulars may have a fracture toughness on the order of 100 KSIin.sup.−2, with ranges of approximately 65 to 150 KSIin.sup.−2. Titanium tubulars contemplated for the present techniques, on the other hand have fracture toughness valued on the order of approximately 45 KSIin.sup.−2, with ranges of approximately 35 to 70 KSIin.sup.−2. Suitable aluminum tubulars have a fracture toughness typically on the order of approximately 35 KSIin.sup.−2. Here again, composite tubulars may be made to have very low fracture toughness valued, similar to those mentioned for titanium and aluminum alloys.
(25) Finally, regarding tendancy for rapid crack propagation, this may be considered to result from stored energy in the material during deformation, and from the other characteristics discussed above. As noted, the tubulars contemplated for the second tubular string, to be positioned in the BOP, will typically be deformed, but with cracks initiating in multiple locations, such as adjacent to locations that contact the BOP jaws, and in locations approximately 90 degrees from these locations, such as where the material is bent or crushed at opposite sides. Essentially then, owing to the strength values (particularly the relatively smaller difference between the yield strength and the tensile strength), the lower modulus of elasticity, and the lower fracture toughness, the proposed tubulars tend to store significant energy during deformation, that is released to cause very rapid propagation of the initiated cracks. In tests, it has been shown that a titanium tubular tends to virtually shatter under forces significantly lower than those that only resulted in deformation of comparably sized steel tubulars (without actual shearing of the latter).
(26) Regarding the specific materials that may be used, it is believed that typical conventional steel tubulars may be made of an alloy composition corresponding to AISI 4100 and 4300 series alloys. Presently contemplated titanium tubulars may be selected from the so-called Alpha Beta and Beta families. Suitable aluminum tubulars may be selected, for example, from 2000, 6000, and 7000 series. Suitable composites may include carbon fiber compositions.
(27) Based upon these materials, it has been demonstrated in full scale tests that such titanium tubulars are significantly easier to shear. It is believed, for example, that a 6.625 in OD steel tubular in thick wall sections can not be sheared by a BOP with available shear forces. A titanium tubular with similar dimensions was sheared fully with application of much lower forces than those that are not successful in shearing the steel tubular.
(28) As noted above, in many applications the present technique will be used to select a first tubular string that will lie below the BOP during working of the well, particularly in a horizon considered at risk. The second tubular string, comprising the more readily shearable material will be located above the first string, and will normally traverse the BOP, while a third string will be positioned above this second string. Variants on this approach are envisioned, however, as illustrate in
(29) In the case of the string illustrated in
(30)
(31) Based upon these parameters, the first tubular string is assembled at step 148. This may be done in a conventional manner during working of the site. During drilling, for example, tools and instrumentation will be used with the tubular string that are suitable for such phases of operation. During later operations, such as completion and workover, other tools will be associated with the tubular string, and many other components may be called upon, depending upon the phase of operation and the tasks being performed. Once the desired length of the first tubular string is assembled and deployed, then, the second tubular string, made of the more easily shearable material, is assembled above the first tubular string, at step 150. Again, the length of this string is selected so that when horizons more at risk are being worked or traversed, only the second tubular string will be located in the BOP. Of course, there are periods during which the first tubular string may be inserted into the well, and withdrawn from the well, but the present focus is on those periods most at risk, and in ensuring that the second tubular string is in the BOP during most or all high risk periods. Thereafter, the third tubular string may be assembled above the second tubular string, as indicated at step 152.
(32) Once assembled and deployed, the tubular string is used to work the well, as indicated at step 154. In particular, the string may be raised and lowered as indicated at step 156, but with the second tubular string always in the BOP during periods of risk of actuation of the BOP. Operations during these steps may be conventional insomuch as the well is drilled, completed, instrumented, reworked, and so forth, while monitoring well parameters, particularly pressures. When the BOP is to be actuated, then, as indicated at block 158, the second tubular string should be in place traversing the BOP, rather than the first or third strings. When actuated, the BOP acts to shear the second tubular string, as indicated by reference numeral 160.
(33) It should be noted that the foregoing discussion has focused on subsea wells, and these are considered to be of particular interest in the present technique because an extended length of relatively lower cost, but less easily shearable material may be used in that portion of the tubular string that simply accesses the well though the depth of the sea (that is, the upper tubular string). However, the techniques may also be used for land-based applications.
(34) While only certain features of the invention have been illustrated and described herein, many modifications and changes will occur to those skilled in the art. It is, therefore, to be understood that the appended claims are intended to cover all such modifications and changes as fall within the true spirit of the invention.