LAMINATED GLAZING
20170291842 · 2017-10-12
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
B32B17/1055
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B17/10036
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B17/10889
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
Abstract
Methods of making a laminated glazing having reduced optical distortion when installed in a vehicle are described. The laminated glazing has first and second sheets of glazing material each separately shaped between a pair of shaping members that are then laminated together. The position for bending the first sheet of glazing material may be deliberately offset from the position for bending the second sheet of glazing material. During the lamination step, the first sheet of glazing material may be displaced relative to the second sheet of glazing material by a lateral and/or longitudinal positional displacement. The first and/or second sheet of glazing material may have been cut such that after lamination at least a portion of the peripheral edges thereof are aligned. Apparatus for shaping a sheet of glazing material for carrying out the aforementioned methods is also described, as is a resulting laminated glazing.
Claims
1. A method of making a laminated glazing comprising the steps: (i) transporting a first sheet of glazing material in a first direction between a pair of shaping members; (ii) positioning the first sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the first sheet of glazing material is at a first position for bending between the pair of shaping members; (iii) shaping the first sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (iv) transporting the first sheet of glazing material away from between the pair of shaping members; (v) transporting a second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (vi) positioning the second sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the second sheet of glazing material is at a second position for bending between the pair of shaping members, (vii) shaping the second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members, (viii) transporting the second sheet of glazing material away from between the pair of shaping members; and (ix) using suitable lamination conditions to laminate the first sheet of glazing material to the second sheet of glazing material via at least one adhesive sheet, wherein the first position for bending is deliberately offset from the second position for bending.
2. A method according to claim 1, wherein the first position for bending and the second position for bending are selected such that the first and second sheets of glazing material, when shaped in steps (iii) and (vii) respectively are able to be suitably paired to make the laminated glazing in step (ix).
3. A method according to claim 1, wherein the positioning means has a longitudinal tolerance in a direction parallel to the first direction such that a reference point on a reference sheet of glazing material is positionable at a target location in a direction parallel to the first direction to within the longitudinal tolerance.
4. A method according to claim 3, wherein the magnitude of the longitudinal tolerance is less than 2.0 mm, preferably less than 1.0 mm.
5. A method according to claim 3, wherein the positioning means has a lateral tolerance in a direction perpendicular to the first direction such that a reference point on a reference sheet of glazing material is positionable at a target location in a direction parallel to the first direction to within the lateral tolerance.
6. A method according to claim 5, wherein the magnitude of the lateral tolerance is less than 2.0 mm, preferably less than 1.0 mm.
7. A method according to claim 1, wherein the first position is offset from the second position by a lateral displacement being greater than the magnitude of the lateral tolerance and/or a longitudinal displacement being greater than the magnitude of the longitudinal tolerance.
8. A method according to claim 1, wherein when the first sheet of glazing material is at the first position the positioning means are in a first configuration and when the second sheet of glazing material is at the second position the positioning means are in a second configuration.
9. A method according to claim 8, wherein when the positioning means are in the first configuration, a reference point on a reference sheet of glazing material positioned by the positioning means between the pair of shaping members is at a first location, and when the positioning means are in the second configuration, the reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material positioned by the positioning means between the pair of shaping members is at a second location, further wherein the first location of the reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material is displaced relative to the second location of the reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material by a lateral displacement being greater than the magnitude of the lateral tolerance and/or a longitudinal displacement being greater than the magnitude of the longitudinal tolerance.
10. A method according to claim 9, wherein the lateral positional displacement is the same as the lateral displacement.
11. A method according to claim 9, wherein the longitudinal positional displacement is the same as the longitudinal displacement.
12. A method according to claim 9, wherein the lateral displacement and/or longitudinal displacement is less than
13. A method according to claim 9, wherein the lateral displacement and/or longitudinal displacement is less than
14. A method according to claim 9, wherein the lateral displacement and/or longitudinal positional displacement is between
15. A method according to claim 12, wherein d is between 2 mm and 10 mm.
16. A method according to claim 12, wherein n is between 1.5 and 1.8, preferably 1.52.
17. A method according to claim 12, wherein θ is between 20° and 80°, preferably between 50° and 70°.
18. A method of manufacturing a laminated glazing comprising: (i) transporting a first sheet of glazing material in a first direction between a pair of shaping members; (ii) positioning the first sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the first sheet of glazing material is at a first position for bending between the pair of shaping members; (iii) shaping the first sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (iv) transporting the first sheet of glazing material away from between the first pair of shaping members; (v) transporting a second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (vi) positioning the second sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the second sheet of glazing material is at a second position for bending between the pair of shaping members; (vii) shaping the second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (viii) transporting the second sheet of glazing material away from between the first pair of shaping members; and (vii) laminating the first sheet of glazing material to the second sheet of glazing material via at least one adhesive sheet, and when the first sheet of glazing material is positioned relative to the second sheet of glazing material during the laminating, the first sheet of glazing material is displaced relative to the second sheet of glazing material by a lateral positional displacement and/or a longitudinal position displacement.
19. A method according to claim 18, wherein the positioning means has a longitudinal tolerance in a direction parallel to the first direction such that a reference point on a reference sheet of glazing material is positionable at a target location in a direction parallel to the first direction to within the longitudinal tolerance.
20. A method according to claim 19, wherein the positioning means has a lateral tolerance in a direction perpendicular to the first direction such that the reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material is positionable at the target location in a direction parallel to the first direction to within the lateral tolerance.
21. A method according to claim 19, wherein the first position is the same as the second position to within the lateral tolerance and/or the longitudinal tolerance.
22. A method of manufacturing a laminated glazing comprising: (i) transporting a first sheet of glazing material between a pair of shaping members; (ii) positioning the first sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the first sheet of glazing material is at a first position for bending between the pair of shaping members; (iii) shaping the first sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (iv) transporting the first sheet of glazing material away from between the pair of shaping members; (v) transporting a second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (vi) positioning the second sheet of glazing material with positioning means such that the second sheet of glazing material is in a second position between the pair of shaping members; (vii) shaping the second sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members; (viii) transporting the second sheet of glazing material away from between the pair of shaping members; and (ix) laminating the first sheet of glazing material to the second sheet of glazing material via at least one adhesive sheet, and when the first sheet of glazing material is positioned relative to the second sheet of glazing material during the laminating, the first sheet of glazing material is displaced relative to the second sheet of glazing material and wherein the first sheet of glazing material and/or the second sheet of glazing material have been cut such that after lamination at least a portion of the peripheral edges of the first and/or second sheets of glazing material are aligned.
23. A method according to claim 22, wherein the first and/or second sheet of glazing material has been cut prior to being shaped, such that if the first and second sheets of glazing material were shaped in a conventional manner they would not form a congruent pair.
24. A method according to claim 1, wherein the first and/or second sheet of glazing material is a glass sheet, in particular a soda-lime-silica glass sheet.
25. Apparatus for shaping a sheet of glazing material, in particular a glass sheet, the apparatus comprising: (i) a pair of shaping members, (II) means for transporting the sheet of glazing material between the pair of shaping members and (iii) positioning means for positioning the sheet of glazing material at a position for bending between the pair of shaping members, wherein the positioning means has a lateral tolerance and a longitudinal tolerance; and (iv) control means for controlling the configuration of the positioning means, wherein the control means is able to place the positioning means in a first configuration, such that with the positioning means in the first configuration, a reference sheet of glazing material is positionable between the pair of shaping members and a reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material is at a first lateral position and/or a first longitudinal position, and wherein the control means is able to place the positioning means in a second configuration, such that with the positioning means in the second configuration, the reference sheet of glazing material is positionable between the pair of shaping members and the reference point on the reference sheet of glazing material is at a second lateral position and/or a second longitudinal position, the first lateral position being displaced relative to the second lateral position by more than the lateral tolerance and/or the first longitudinal position being displaced relative to the second longitudinal position by more than the longitudinal tolerance.
26. A laminated glazing comprising at least two sheets of glazing material (a first sheet of glazing material and a second sheet of glazing material), joined by an interlayer structure comprising at least one (a first) sheet of adhesive interlayer material, the first sheet of glazing material, the second sheet of glazing material and the first sheet of adhesive interlayer material each having a first major surface and a second opposing major surface, the laminated glazing being configured such that the second major surface of the first sheet of glazing material faces the first major surface of the first sheet of adhesive interlayer material, and the first major surface of the second sheet of glazing material faces the second major surface of the first sheet of interlayer material, there being an Imprint on at least a portion of the first major surface of the first sheet of glazing material and substantially the same imprint on at least a portion of the first major surface of the second sheet of glazing material, wherein when viewed at zero angle of incidence to the radius of curvature of the first sheet of glazing material, the imprint on the first major surface of the first sheet of glazing material is offset from the imprint on the first major surface of the second sheet of glazing material.
27. A laminated glazing according to claim 26, wherein the amount of offset between the imprints is greater than 0.5 mm, or greater than 1 mm, or greater than 1.5 mm, or greater than 2 mm, or greater than 2.5 mm, or greater than 3 mm, or greater than 3.5 mm, or greater than 4 mm, or greater than 4.5 mm, or greater than 5 mm.
Description
[0119] Embodiments of the present invention will now be described by way of example only with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0120]
[0121]
[0122]
[0123]
[0124]
[0125]
[0126]
[0127]
[0128]
[0129]
[0130]
[0131]
[0132]
[0133]
[0134]
[0135] The geometric centre C is shown in the major surface of the glass ply 1, 3. When bending, the intention is to position the point C on each ply 1, 3 at the same position between press bending members. The axis A-A′ is suitably positioned and is parallel to the parallel edges of the glass ply 1, 3. The axis B-B′ is perpendicular to the axis A-A′ and is positioned mid-way between the upper and lower edges of the glass ply 1, 3.
[0136]
[0137] The edges of the individual glass sheets 1, 3 of the laminated glazing 10 shown in
[0138] The point C′ lies at the geometric centre of each of the glass plies 11, 13. When bending, the intention is to position the point C′ on each ply 11, 13 at the same position between press bending members. The axis A-A′ is suitably positioned and is parallel to the parallel edges of the glass ply 1, 3. The axis B-B′ is perpendicular to the axis A-A′ and is positioned mid-way between the upper and lower edges of the glass ply 11, 13.
[0139]
[0140] The curved glass sheet has a desired curvature as specified in a CAD drawing of the glazing. On the curvature measurement map 21, the deviation of actual curvature of the curved glass sheet at a given point from the desired curvature at that point (as specified by the CAD drawing) is specified by a pixel having a particular grey level i.e. a certain level of reference RGB values to indicate no deviation. That is, if there is no deviation from the desired curvature there would be a grey point having a particular shade (a reference shade) on the curvature measurement map 21. The greater the deviation of actual curvature of the curved glass sheet at a given point from the desired curvature at that point (as specified by the CAD drawing), the greater is the variation in the shade of grey for the pixel away from the shade of grey representing no deviation. Positive and negative deviations may be represented on the curvature measurement map. The area of the curvature measurement map 21 near the upper edge, as indicated by arrow 22, is almost entirely black indicating that part of the curved glass sheet has the greatest deviation from the desired curvature. In the region 22 the deviation is of the order of a few tenths of a micron.
[0141] The curvature measurement map 21 shows that instead of being smooth i.e. the curvature map is all one shade of grey, the surface of the curved glass sheet is covered with an imprint. This imprint is from the stainless steel woven cloth that covers the surface of the male die. The imprint on the glass surface may be enhanced if the male die is configured to use negative pressure reducing means capable of drawing the heat softened sheet towards the shaping surface of the male die. This type of male die is described in WO2005/033026A1. Given that the imprint is of the order of a few hundredths to a few tenths of a micron, to the human eye the surface of the curved glass sheet appears smooth.
[0142] The points a, b, c and d lie at the corners of a rectangle e. At the centre of the rectangle e is the point C. The rectangle abcd may be particularly relevant since this is an important vision area for a vehicle windscreen.
[0143] A heat softened glass sheet that is pressed between a male die covered with a stainless steel woven cloth and the female support ring will have the imprint on the concave surface.
[0144] If the female shaping member is a full surface complementary shaping member instead of a support ring, there may be an imprint on both opposed major surfaces of the press bent glass sheet.
[0145]
[0146] The shaping surface of the male die 5 is covered with a stainless steel woven cloth. The male die 35 may be of the type described in WO2005/033026A1. The direction indicated by arrow 34 is perpendicular to the rollers 32 and parallel to the longitudinal axis of the bending furnace.
[0147] A pair of locators 38, 39 are raised when the glass sheet 31 is in the desired position between the shaping members for bending. The locators (often known as stops) are configured to act on the leading edge of the flat glass sheet 31.
[0148] Each locator 38, 39 is in electrical communication with a controller 40. The controller is used to actuate the locators at the correct time and may take inputs from suitable sensors such as photodiodes upstream thereof. Such sensors provide positional input of the glass sheet, or a portion thereof, such as an edge portion of the glass sheet, to the controller so that the controller actuates the locators to correctly position the glass sheet 31 in between the shaping members 35, 37.
[0149] Once the glass sheet 31 is supported on the female support ring 37 (by movement of the female support ring 37 relative to the rollers), the male die 35 moves relative to the female support ring 37 to press bend the glass sheet therebetween. For example, the male die 35 is moveable vertically relative to the female support ring 37 in the direction of arrow 35′. As is conventional in the art, the female support ring 37 may be segmented to permit displacement of the female support ring 37 above the level of the conveyor rolls 32, for example as described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,015,968.
[0150] After the glass sheet is bent, the glass sheet is suitably transported to a cooling furnace. For example the glass sheet may be transported by means known in the art, such as on rollers, by air flotation, or carried on a shuttle ring. In
[0151] The locators 38, 39 have a positional accuracy which determines how consistent the bending operation is. When the control means actuates the locators ideally each locator 38, 39 should stop subsequent glass sheets 31 at the same position each time for bending between the male die 35 and the support ring 37. For example the imaginary reference point C on the glass sheet 31 should coincide with the imaginary reference point M located at the centre of the male die. The reference point C may be located at the geometric centre of the flat glass sheet 31. In practice each locator 38, 39 is able to be position to within a lateral tolerance and a longitudinal tolerance.
[0152] This is illustrated in
[0153] The target longitudinal position for the locator 38 is X and the target lateral position for the locator 38 is Y. The target position X lies along lateral axis X′-X″ and the target position Y lies along longitudinal axis Y′-Y″. The position X, Y lies at the intersection of axis X′-X′ with the axis Y′-Y″. The axis X′-X″ is parallel to the lateral axis (or direction) of the furnace and the axis Y′-Y″ is parallel to the longitudinal axis (or direction) of the furnace. Typically the rollers 32, 42 are parallel to the lateral axis of the furnace.
[0154] The positions X, Y may be measured relative to a fixed point on the furnace, for example the position of the first conveyor roller, the entrance to the furnace, etc. The lateral tolerance is ±δx and the longitudinal tolerance is ±δy. Therefore the locator 38 may be positioned at the point X, Y to within ±δr and ±δy. Shown in phantom is the locator 38′ at position X+δx, Y+δy.
[0155] Note that in this example the centre point of the locator 38 is desired to be at the point X, Y but it may be some other fixed point on the locator. The dimensions of the locator may be taken into account when positioning the locator at a given point X, Y such that the reference point C on the flat glass sheet is correctly positioned between the shaping members.
[0156] In prior art systems for separately shaping two glass sheets for use as inner and outer plies in a laminated glazing such as a vehicle windscreen, the locators 38, 39 target for the same position for each ply, taking into account any dimensional change of the inner ply, as described in relation to
[0157]
[0158] The locator 38 is shown at a first position 38(1). This position of the locator is X1, Y1 and is at the intersection of axis X1′-X1″ and Y1′-Y1″. The axis X1′-X1″ is parallel to the lateral axis of the furnace and the axis Y1′-Y1″ is parallel to the longitudinal axis of the furnace. The outer ply of a vehicle windscreen is positioned by the locator at position X1, Y1 such that the reference point C on the outer ply is in the correct position for bending between the shaping members.
[0159] In order to consistently achieve improved optical quality in transmission for laminated windscreens installed in a vehicle at a typical installation angle off-normal, the position for bending of the inner ply for the vehicle windscreen is deliberately offset with respect to the position for bending the outer ply. The locator 38 is moved from position 38(1) to position 38(2) such that the desired position is at X2, Y2, which lies at the intersection of axis X2′-X2″ and Y2′-Y2″. The axis X2′-X2″ is parallel to the lateral axis of the furnace and the axis Y2′-Y2″ is parallel to the longitudinal axis of the furnace. The outer ply of a vehicle windscreen is positioned by the locator at position X2, Y2, shown as 38(2). The position of the locator 38 is changed using the controller 40.
[0160] As described with reference to
[0161] The magnitude of the lateral separation between axis Y1′-Y1″ and axis Y2′-Y2″ is greater than the twice the magnitude of the lateral tolerance of the locator 38, that is |X1−X2|>2×|δx|.
[0162] The magnitude of the longitudinal separation between axis X1′-X1″ and axis X2′-X2″ is greater than the twice the magnitude of the longitudinal tolerance of the locator 38, that is |Y2−Y1>2×|δy|.
[0163] In this example, δx is 0.5 mm, so the longitudinal tolerance is +0.5 mm i.e. x=±0.5 mm. Also, δy is 0.5 mm, so the lateral tolerance is ±0.5 mm i.e. δ=±0.5 mm. The lateral separation between axis Y1′-Y1″ and axis Y2′-Y2″ was 2.5 mm and the longitudinal separation between axis X1′-X1″ and axis X2′-X2″ was 2.5 mm.
[0164] The first glass sheet positioned by locator 38 at position X1, Y1 is shaped between the male die 35 and female support ring 37. A second glass sheet positioned by locator 38 at position X2, Y2 is shaped between the male die 35 and female support ring 37.
[0165] Once cooled, the first and second glass sheets are laminated together with a sheet of PVB.
[0166] The optical quality of the laminated glazing was found to have a higher quality when inclined at an angle of 60° to the vertical compared to when measured at normal incidence i.e. the laminated glazing is inclined at 0° to the vertical.
[0167] Since the locator 38 is at a first position to bend the outer ply and at a deliberately offset second position to bend the inner ply, the imprints on the major surfaces of the outer and inner plies are offset relative to each other when viewed at normal incidence.
[0168] In an alternative embodiment to that shown in
[0169] In another alternative embodiment to that shown in
[0170] In another alternative embodiment to that shown in
[0171] Another way to achieve the offset between the outer and inner plies is described with reference to
[0172]
[0173] As is conventional in the art, the inner glass ply 53 is also positioned between the male die 35 and female support ring 37 by the locator 38 at position X, Y. The inner glass ply 53 is also shaped and cooled and transported away on rollers 42.
[0174] In accordance with the second aspect of the present invention, and with particular reference to
[0175] The imaginary reference point M1 lies on the major surface of the outer ply 51 and is that point that was in contact with the male die 35 at imaginary point M on the surface of the male die. The imaginary reference point M2 lies on the surface of the inner ply and is that point that was in contact with the male die 35 at imaginary point M on the surface of the male die. The reference points M1, M2 are located at the geometric centre of the major surface of the inner and outer plies 51, 53.
[0176] In a conventional lamination process when the inner and outer plies are laid up for lamination the imaginary references points M1 and M2 are aligned. In this way, the resulting laminated glazing would have the edges aligned. However in accordance with the present invention the imaginary reference points M1 and M2 are deliberately offset by more than twice the magnitude of the lateral tolerance and/or longitudinal tolerance of the locators. In this way, the imprint on the major surface of the outer ply that was in contact with the male die 35 and the imprint on the major surface of the inner ply that was in contact with the male die 35 are offset relative to one another when viewed at normal incidence to the surface of the laminated glazing.
[0177] A consequence of this is that the edges of the laminated glazing 57 are not aligned, as shown in
[0178] To avoid the overlap 54 the overlapping edges prior to laminating the two plies 51, 53 may be removed by cutting for example. Alternatively, the flat glass sheets prior to being shaped may be suitably cut such that when they are misaligned the edges are aligned in the resulting laminated glazing. It will be apparent that the shapes may be cut to have an outline defined by the degree of overlap between the outer and inner plies as shown in
[0179] The laminated glazing may be encapsulated such that the peripheral edge of the laminate is covered with a gasket of suitable material such as polyurethane. Using encapsulation in this way hides the misaligned edges.
[0180] To illustrate the effect of misaligning the outer ply relative to the inner ply a number of laminated vehicle windscreens were made. Each windscreen has an inner ply of 2.1 mm float glass joined to an outer ply of 2.1 mm float glass via an adhesive sheet of PVB.
[0181] Each inner ply and a corresponding outer ply were made by press bending each individual glass ply between the same press bending members using substantially the same bending conditions. In particular the position of the inner ply and the outer ply between the press bending members was such that the surface imprint would align if laid up in a conventional manner during the lamination process. A suitable press bending furnace is described in WO02004/085324A1, in particular the figures and related description thereof. Other suitable press bending furnaces are known, for example as described in EP0398759A2.
[0182] Five windscreens were made where the inner ply was misaligned horizontally with respect to the outer ply. In this context, “horizontal” means the direction with respect to the windscreen in the installed position.
[0183] A test was designed to simulate the situation, where a driver looks “cross-car” through a vehicle windscreen, i.e. whilst sat in the driver's seat, the driver looks through the portion of the vehicle windscreen on the passenger side of the vehicle, as for example when observing traffic lights. When the driver looks through the glass in this way, the optical path of light has a horizontal angel of inclination to the normal of the glass surface of the order of 450.
[0184] Each sample was tilted to 61° from the vertical to simulate an installation angle and then rotated about the vertical axis in a clockwise and anti-clockwise direction of 45°.
[0185] In order to assess the optical affects, the optical power in a region in the centre of the windscreen under test was measured, see for example the region abcd on
[0186] For each measurement angle +45° and −45°, the optical power characterised in terms of the parameter ROC in the test region of each respective windscreen was measured and an average calculated. For each angle of rotation the measured optical power characterised in terms of the parameter ROC was divided by the average optical power.
[0187] This test was carried out on each of the five windscreens. The five windscreens were made with a different degree of misalignment between the inner ply and the outer ply when the plies were laid up for lamination:
TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 SAMPLE MISALIGNMENT (mm) A −2 B −1 C 0 D +1 E +2
[0188] The results are shown in
[0189] It would therefore be expected that as the vertical misalignment increases the optical power will reduce in a similar way.
[0190] To determine the effect of vertical misalignment, ten windscreens were made where the inner 2.1 mm glass ply was moved upwards relative to the outer 2.1 mm glass ply prior to being laminated. A positive displacement represents an upwards misalignment. In this context, upwards means the upper portion of the windscreen in the installed position at an angle of about 61° from the vertical i.e. the portion of the windscreen nearest the vehicle roof is the upper part of the windscreen.
[0191]
[0192] The line through the data points on
[0193] To determine the effect of rake angle on optical quality a number of windscreens were made where the vertical misalignment between the inner and outer plies was changed. Four samples were made where the misalignment was −0.25 mm (line 85), +0.7 mm (line 86), +2.4 mm (line 87) and +2.6 mm (line 88) and the results are shown in
[0194] In
[0195] As the rake angle increases, the +2.4 mm (line 87) and +2.6 mm (line 88) samples exhibit a minimum in ROC at around 300 rake angle. At a rake angle of 700 the samples +2.4 mm (line 87) and +2.6 mm (line 88) have significantly lower ROC compared to the samples with little misalignment (80-100 millidioptres compared to >120 millidioptres).
[0196] Without being bound by theory, one explanation for the optical power not having a minimum at zero millidioptres is that there is still some optical distortion caused by the PVB adhesive sheet, in particular thickness variations of the PVB sheet.
[0197] The examples above demonstrate that when the inner and outer plies are bent using a conventional press bending furnace, by deliberately offsetting the bent plies when they are laid up for lamination can result in a laminated glazing having a better optical quality when measured at an installation angle (i.e. around 60° from the vertical) compared to when measured at normal incidence (i.e. at 00 from vertical).
[0198] It would be expected that similar behaviour would be observed if the inner and outer glass plies were offset with respect to each other when each ply was press bent between the shaping members. Consequently the inner and outer plies would be deliberately press bent at different position between the shaping members.
[0199] The present invention provides particular application for the production of vehicle windscreens, especially windows for cars. Such windows typically comply with the requirements of ECE R43.