Methods and devices for placement of electrocardiogram leads
10863943 ยท 2020-12-15
Assignee
Inventors
Cpc classification
A61B5/684
HUMAN NECESSITIES
A61B5/1072
HUMAN NECESSITIES
International classification
Abstract
Methods and devices for identifying the 4.sup.th and the 5.sup.th intercostal spaces for the purpose of proper placement of ECG precordial leads, regardless of the patient's height and/or weight. By calculating the sternal length, the distance between the sternal notch and the xiphoid process, the locations of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal spaces can be determined. The present invention also features devices for measuring the length and to indicate to a user the location of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal spaces based on the measured sternal length. The methods and devices provide a more accurate identification of the 4.sup.th and the 5.sup.th intercostal spaces resulting in proper ECG lead placement, which then facilitates accurate ECG interpretation.
Claims
1. A sternal measurement device (100) comprising: a. a ruler base (110) having a first end (111), a second end (112) and a first set of sternal length measurements (118a) disposed along a surface (115) of the ruler base in ascending order from the first end (111) to the second end (112), said sternal length measurements (118a) corresponding to a length of the ruler base (110); b. a slide base (120) slidably connected to the ruler base (110), the slide base (120) having a first end (121), a second end (122), and a second set of sternal length measurements (118b) disposed along a surface (125) of the slide base, wherein a first sternal length measurement (118b) disposed at the second end (122) of the slide base is a unit of length greater than a last sternal length measurement (118a) disposed on the second end (112) of the ruler base, wherein the second set of sternal length measurements (118b) are in ascending order from the second end (122) to the first end (121) of the slide base; and c. a set of intercostal length measurements (128) disposed on the surface (125) of the slide base, each intercostal length measurement (128) positioned next to one of the sternal length measurements (118b) such that each sternal length measurement (118b) has a corresponding intercostal length measurement (128); wherein the sternal measurement device (100) measures a sternal length between a sternal notch and a xiphoid process, wherein the sternal length is the maximum sternal length measurement displayed by the device (100) when the first end (111) of the ruler base is placed at the sternal notch and the second end (122) of the slide base is placed at the xiphoid process, wherein the intercostal length measurement is determined by the maximum sternal length measurement.
2. The device (100) of claim 1, wherein the intercostal length measurements (128) correspond to a 4.sup.th intercostal placement length, the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length being a distance from the sternal notch to a 4.sup.th intercostal space, wherein the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length indicates the location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space for placement of an electrode.
3. The device (100) of claim 2, wherein the intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length is selected from the following table depending on the sternal length measurement. TABLE-US-00003 Sternal length 4.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 11.8 16 12.1 17 12.3 18 12.6 19 12.9 20 13.1 21 13.4 22 13.7 23 13.9 24 14.2 25 14.5 26 14.8.
4. The device (100) of claim 1, wherein the intercostal length measurements (128) correspond to a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length, the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length being a distance from the sternal notch to a 5.sup.th intercostal space, wherein the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length indicates the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space for placement of an electrode.
5. The device (100) of claim 4, wherein the intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length is selected from the following table depending on the sternal length measurement. TABLE-US-00004 Sternal length 5.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 13.8 16 14.2 17 14.6 18 14.9 19 15.4 20 15.7 21 16.1 22 16.5 23 16.9 24 17.3 25 17.2 26 18.
6. The device of claim 1 further comprising flanges (130) disposed on the first end (111) of the ruler base (110) and the second end (122) of the slide base (120).
7. The device of claim 1 further comprising one or more intercostal length measurements (128) disposed on the surface (115) of the ruler base and positioned adjacent to the sternal length measurements (118a).
8. The device of claim 1 further comprising a stopper mechanism (116) that stops the first end (121) of the slide base from sliding out of the ruler base, thereby preventing the slide base from completely separating from the ruler base.
9. The device of claim 1, wherein the ruler base (110) is a tube and the slide base (120) is disposed within the ruler base (110) such that the device is telescoping.
10. The device of claim 1, wherein the slide base (120) slides underneath the ruler base (110) such that the ruler base (110) overlaps the slide base (120).
11. The device of claim 1, wherein the sternal length measurements and intercostal length measurements are in centimeters.
12. A method of identifying a 4.sup.th intercostal space in a subject, comprising: a. providing a sternal measurement device (100) according to claim 1; b. placing the first end (111) of the ruler base at a sternal notch of the subject and the second end (122) of the slide base at a xiphoid process of the subject; c. viewing the maximum sternal length measurement displayed by the device (100), wherein the maximum sternal length measurement corresponds to a sternal length of the subject; d. viewing an intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the maximum length measurement, wherein the intercostal length measurement is a 4.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space; and e. measuring the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space in the subject.
13. The method of claim 12, wherein the maximum sternal length measurement is either the last sternal length measurement (118a) at the second end (112) of the ruler base or the sternal length measurement (118b) on the slide base (120) that is closest to the second end (112) of the ruler base.
14. A method of identifying a 5.sup.th intercostal space in a subject, comprising: a. providing a sternal measurement device (100) according to claim 1; b. placing the first end (111) of the ruler base at a sternal notch of the subject and the second end (122) of the slide base at a xiphoid process of the subject; c. viewing the maximum sternal length measurement displayed by the device (100), wherein the maximum sternal length measurement corresponds to a sternal length of the subject; d. viewing an intercostal length measurement (128) adjacent to the corresponding maximum length measurement, wherein the intercostal length measurement is a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from the sternal notch to the 5.sup.th intercostal space; and e. measuring the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space in the subject.
15. The method of claim 14, wherein the maximum sternal length measurement is either the last sternal length measurement (118a) at the second end (112) of the ruler base or the sternal length measurement (118b) on the slide base (120) that is closest to the second end (112) of the ruler base.
16. A method of correctly placing ECG leads on a subject, said method comprising: a. providing a sternal measurement device (100) according to claim 1; b. measuring a length of a sternum of the subject using the sternal measurement device (100) by placing the first end (111) of the ruler base at a sternal notch of the subject and the second end (122) of the slide base at a xiphoid process of the subject; c. determining an intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the sternal length measurement, wherein the intercostal length measurement (128) is a 4.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from a sternal notch to a 4.sup.th intercostal space of the subject; d. measuring the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space in the subject; and e. placing a V1 lead at the 4.sup.th intercostal space right of the sternum, and placing a V2 lead at the 4.sup.th intercostal space left of the sternum.
17. The method of claim 16 further comprising: a. determining a second intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the sternal length measurement, wherein the second intercostal length measurement (128) is a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from a sternal notch to a 5.sup.th intercostal space of the subject; b. measuring the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space in the subject; and c. placing a V4 lead at the 5.sup.th intercostal space at a left midclavicular line.
18. The method of claim 17 further comprising: a. placing a V3 lead midway between the V2 and V4 leads; b. placing a V5 lead at a left mid axillary line horizontal with the V4 lead; and c. placing a V6 lead at a left anterior axillary line horizontal with the V4 lead.
19. The method of claim 17, wherein the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length is selected from the following table depending on the sternal length measurement: TABLE-US-00005 Sternal length 4.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 11.8 16 12.1 17 12.3 18 12.6 19 12.9 20 13.1 21 13.4 22 13.7 23 13.9 24 14.2 25 14.5 26 14.8.
20. The method of claim 17, wherein the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length is selected from the following table depending on the sternal length measurement: TABLE-US-00006 Sternal length 5.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 13.8 16 14.2 17 14.6 18 14.9 19 15.4 20 15.7 21 16.1 22 16.5 23 16.9 24 17.3 25 17.2 26 18.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) The features and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from a consideration of the following detailed description presented in connection with the accompanying drawings:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(14) Following is a list of elements corresponding to a particular element referred to herein:
(15) 100 device
(16) 110 ruler base
(17) 111 first end of ruler base
(18) 112 second end of ruler base
(19) 115 surface of ruler base
(20) 116 stopper mechanism
(21) 118a first set of sternal length measurements
(22) 118b second set of sternal length measurements
(23) 120 slide base
(24) 121 first end of slide base
(25) 122 second end of slide base
(26) 125 surface of slide base
(27) 128 intercostal length measurements
(28) 130 flange
(29) Because the 4.sup.th intercostal space can be difficult to locate by traditional palpation in obese, and even non-obese, patients for electrocardiogram (ECG) lead placement, the present invention provides a method and device capable of locating the 4.sup.th intercostal space using other easily identifiable landmarks on the chest. The invention facilitates this process by measuring the sternal notch to xiphoid process distance and providing the sternal notch to 4.sup.th intercostal space distance. This should decrease the percentage of lead misplacement leading to misdiagnoses. Furthermore, the present invention does not require specific ECG systems to use or read unique data like other flexible ECG systems.
(30) The present disclosure provides data that the precordial locations of the ECG leads can be determined based on the sternal length measured from the sternal notch to the tip of the xiphoid process. As used herein, the term sternal length refers to the distance between the sternal notch and the xiphoid process. As used herein, the term 4.sup.th intercostal placement length refers to the distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space. As used herein, the term 5.sup.th intercostal placement length refers to the distance from the sternal notch to the 5.sup.th intercostal space.
(31) According to some embodiments, the present invention features devices for identifying the 4.sup.th intercostal space and/or 5.sup.th intercostal space for the purpose of placing ECG leads, related to the patient's height and/or weight. For example, the present invention provides sternal measurement devices for measuring the sternal notch to xiphoid process length and for indicating to a user the location of the 4.sup.th and/or the 5.sup.th intercostal space based on the measured sternal lengths.
(32) Referring to now to
(33) The ruler base (110) may be constructed in a variety of configurations. For example, the device (100) shown in
(34) In some embodiments, the sternal measurement device (100) may include a slide base (120) having a first end (121), a second end (122), and a second set of sternal length measurements (118b) disposed along a surface (125) of the slide base. In some embodiments, the slide base (120), e.g., the first end, is slidably housed within the inner cavity of the ruler base (110) and the second end (122) extends from the ruler base (110), e.g., in the case of the tube-shaped ruler base shown in
(35) In other embodiments, the slide base (120) may also be marked with a second set of sternal length measurements (118b) disposed along a surface (125) of the slide base for the purpose of measuring sternal length. The first sternal length measurement on the slide base (120) may be located at the second end (122), and the first sternal length measurement corresponds to the next unit of length greater than the last unit of length on the ruler base (110), e.g. the last sternal length measurement (118a) disposed on the second end (112) of the ruler base. For example, if the last unit of length on the ruler base (110) is 15 cm, then the first unit of length at the second end (122) of the slide base is 16 cm. In preferred embodiments, the second set of sternal length measurements (118b) are in ascending order from the second end (122) to the first end (121) of the slide base.
(36) When using the device (100) for measuring sternal length, a user places the first end (110) of the ruler base (110) at the sternal notch or xiphoid process and the second end (122) of the slide base (120) at the xiphoid process or sternal notch, respectively. For example, the sternal length is the maximum sternal length measurement displayed by the device (100) when the first end (111) of the ruler base is placed at the sternal notch and the second end (122) of the slide base is placed at the xiphoid process. If the sternal length is less than or equal to the last (greatest) unit of length on the ruler base, then the ruler base is used to determine the sternal length. For example, as shown in
(37) In preferred embodiments, the device (100) may further comprise intercostal length measurements (128) disposed on the ruler base (110) and/or slide base (120). In some embodiments, each intercostal length measurement (128) may be positioned next to one of the sternal length measurements (118b) such that each sternal length measurement (118b) has a corresponding intercostal length measurement (128). For example, as shown in
(38) Without wishing to limit the present invention, the intercostal length measurement may be determined by the maximum sternal length measurement. In one embodiment, the intercostal length measurements (128) may correspond to the appropriate 4.sup.th intercostal placement length (distance between sternal notch and 4.sup.th intercostal space). The 4th intercostal placement length indicates the location of the 4th intercostal space for placement of an electrode. For example, the length measurement (sternal length) of 23 cm shown in
(39) In another embodiment, the intercostal length measurements (128) may correspond to a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length (distance from the sternal notch to a 5.sup.th intercostal space). The 5.sup.th intercostal placement length indicates the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space for placement of an electrode. For example, the length measurement (sternal length) of 25 cm shown in
(40) In preferred embodiments, a user can look at the sternal length measurement (118) to determine the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal length measurements. Although the sternal length measurements and intercostal length measurements may be in centimeters, it is not limited to this unit or measurement. Alternatively, the measurements may be in inches. In some embodiments, the intercostal length measurements may be calculated based on the data in
(41) TABLE-US-00001 Sternal length 4.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 11.8 16 12.1 17 12.3 18 12.6 19 12.9 20 13.1 21 13.4 22 13.7 23 13.9 24 14.2 25 14.5 26 14.8
(42) As another example, the intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length may be selected from the following table depending on the sternal length measurement.
(43) TABLE-US-00002 Sternal length 5.sup.th Intercostal length measurement (cm) measurement (cm) 15 13.8 16 14.2 17 14.6 18 14.9 19 15.4 20 15.7 21 16.1 22 16.5 23 16.9 24 17.3 25 17.2 26 18
(44) In some embodiments, the device (100) of the present invention may further comprise flanges (130), tabs, or other components disposed at the ends (e.g., first end of the ruler base and second end of the slide base) to anchor the device (110) at the sternal notch or xiphoid process. In other embodiments, the device (100) may further comprise a stopper mechanism (116) that stops the first end (121) of the slide base from sliding out of the ruler base, thereby preventing the slide base from completely separating from the ruler base. In
(45) In some embodiments, the device (100) may be constructed from any appropriate material, e.g., PVC or other polymer, etc. Alternatively, the device may be 3D printed instead of being made out of PVC pipe. In other embodiments, the device (100) may be rigid, flexible, or comprise portions that are rigid and portions that are flexible. The present invention is not limited to the materials or configurations disclosed herein.
(46) The ruler base and/or slide base may be constructed in a variety of sizes. For example, in some embodiments, the ruler base is 10 cm in length. In other embodiments, the ruler base is from 10 to 15 cm in length, or from 12 to 18 cm in length, or from 15 to 20 cm in length. In some other embodiments, the slide base may be from 5 to 10 cm in length, or from 7 to 12 cm in length, or from 10 to 15 cm in length.
(47) In alternative embodiments, the sternal length measurements (118), or the intercostal length measurements (128), or both may be displayed on a digital screen instead of on the surface of the bases. For example, the device may have the sternal length measurements disposed on the surface of the bases while the intercostal length measurements may be displayed on a digital screen. As another example, both the sternal length measurements and the intercostal length measurements may be displayed on a digital screen. In yet another embodiment, the slide base and/or ruler base may have a plurality of light indicators. The light indicators may be disposed at 4.sup.th and/or 5.sup.th intercostal space locations along the device. For example, the light indicators may be disposed at 11.8 cm, 12.1 cm, 12.3 cm, 12.6 cm, 12.9 cm, 13.1 cm, 13.4 cm, 13.7 cm, 13.9 cm, 14.2 cm, 14.5 cm, and 14.8 cm for the possible 4.sup.th intercostal spaces. Light indicators may be disposed at 13.8 cm, 14.2 cm, 14.6 cm, 14.9 cm, 15.4 cm, 15.7 cm, 16.1 cm, 16.5 cm, 16.9 cm, 17.3 cm, 17.2 cm, and 18 cm for the possible 5.sup.th intercostal spaces. When the device is used to obtain a sternal length measurement, the light indicator at the intercostal space location corresponding to the sternal length measurement is activated, thereby indicating the position of the intercostal space. For instance, if the sternal length measurement is 26 cm, then the light at the 14.8 cm for the 4.sup.th intercostal space, or the light at the 18 cm for the 5.sup.th intercostal space, or both are activated.
(48) According to other embodiments, the present invention the present invention features methods of identifying the location of the 4.sup.th and/or 5.sup.th intercostal space based on a sternal length, measured as the distance between the sternal notch and the xiphoid process. In one embodiment, a method of identifying a 4.sup.th intercostal space in a subject may comprise providing any of the sternal measurement devices (100) described herein, placing the first end (111) of the ruler base at a sternal notch of the subject and the second end (122) of the slide base at a xiphoid process of the subject, viewing the maximum sternal length measurement displayed by the device (100), and viewing an intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the maximum length measurement. The maximum sternal length measurement corresponds to a sternal length of the subject. In some embodiments, the maximum sternal length measurement is either the last sternal length measurement (118a) at the second end (112) of the ruler base or the sternal length measurement (118b) on the slide base (120) that is closest to the second end (112) of the ruler base. In other embodiments, the intercostal length measurement is a 4.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space. The method further comprises measuring the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space in the subject.
(49) According to yet other embodiments, the present invention provides a method of identifying a 5.sup.th intercostal space in a subject. The method is similar to the method described for identifying the 4.sup.th intercostal space, with the difference being that the intercostal length measurement corresponds to a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from the sternal notch to the 5.sup.th intercostal space. The 5.sup.th intercostal placement length is measured from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space in the subject.
(50) According to some embodiments, the present invention further provides for a method of correctly placing ECG leads on a subject. The method may comprise providing any of the sternal measurement devices (100) described herein, measuring a length of a sternum of the subject using the sternal measurement device (100) by placing the first end (111) of the ruler base at a sternal notch of the subject and the second end (122) of the slide base at a xiphoid process of the subject, determining an intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the sternal length measurement, the intercostal length measurement (128) is a 4.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from a sternal notch to a 4.sup.th intercostal space of the subject, measuring the 4.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space in the subject, and placing a V1 lead at the 4.sup.th intercostal space right of the sternum, and placing a V2 lead at the 4.sup.th intercostal space left of the sternum. In other embodiments, the method may further comprise determining a second intercostal length measurement (128) corresponding to the sternal length measurement, the second intercostal length measurement (128) is a 5.sup.th intercostal placement length, which is a distance from a sternal notch to a 5.sup.th intercostal space of the subject, measuring the 5.sup.th intercostal placement length from the sternal notch to identify the location of the 5.sup.th intercostal space in the subject, and placing a V4 lead at the 5.sup.th intercostal space at a left midclavicular line. In yet other embodiments, the method may further comprise placing a V3 lead midway between the V2 and V4 leads, placing a V5 lead at a left mid axillary line horizontal with the V4 lead, and placing a V6 lead at a left anterior axillary line horizontal with the V4 lead.
EXAMPLE
(51) The following is a non-limiting example of the present invention. It is to be understood that said example is not intended to limit the present invention in any way. Equivalents or substitutes are within the scope of the present invention.
(52) In a recent report (Day et al., 2015, J Electrocardiology 48:1058-1061), CT x-rays measured the location of the 4.sup.th interspace in 55 adults. The distance from the sternal notch to the fourth interspace was found to be a mean of 67% of the sternal length, with an overall correlation of r=0.600 (p=<0.001). The present invention has discovered that the location of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal space is related to the length of the sternum and there is a trend to a higher percent of the distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th and the 5.sup.th intercostal spaces when there is a shorter sternal length, as shown in
(53) Methods
(54) The population included patients and healthy volunteers. The study was approved by the Human Subjects Committee. All patients signed an informed consent. A trained ECG technician and a cardiologist blindly performed the measurements on 13 adult volunteers, as well as on 18 patients. The proposed method compared palpation of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal spaces to a percentile of the sternal length. Location of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th intercostal space using a simple device was evaluated to assist in proper placement of the precordial leads to obtain accurate diagnosis.
(55) The first measurement was obtained by the technician determining the distance from the sternal notch to the xiphoid process. Without wishing to be bound to a particular theory or mechanism, the length of the sternum can be readily measured even in obese individuals. If there is a concern of the precise location of the end of the xiphoid process, a flat pillow can be placed below the patient's back at the level of the xiphoid process to raise the sternum to assist in locating this point. The location of the 4.sup.th intercostal space was determined by palpation. When this was located a removable marker was placed on the sternum. The distance from the sternal notch to this point was measured and the percentage of the distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space relative to the length of sternum was calculated. The physician then independently repeated this process without knowledge of the technicians' data. If the measurement of the sternal length or the distance of the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space was different by 2 cm between the investigators, the measurement was made jointly and the final values were determined by consensus.
(56) All statistical calculations were done using SPSS11. Reliability was assessed using intraclass correlation. This statistic quantifies the agreement between the technician and the cardiologist. The intraclass correlation was 0.90 initially and 0.94 when significant disparities were identified and those patients re-measured. External validity was assessed by calculating the relationship clinically between distance of the 4.sup.th intercostal space distance to the sternal notch and the length of the sternum measured as distance from the xiphoid process to the sternal notch. These data were compared to the same relationship obtained in the previous study in which measurements were made by CT scan.
(57) Results
(58) Data from the CT study in Day et al. were modified by adding half the width of the 4.sup.th intercostal space to the distance from the sternal notch to the 4.sup.th intercostal space (4.sup.th intercostal placement length) to correspond to the procedure used in the clinical setting. The locations of the 4.sup.th and 5.sup.th interspaces were calculated as a linear function of the sternal length (plotted in
(59) The linear function depicted in
(60) Discussion
(61) The proposed method of the present invention can accurately locate the precordial ECG positions as a function of the sternal length. Facilitation of the location of the V1 and V2 electrode placement using a device, such as those shown in
(62) Various modifications of the invention, in addition to those described herein, will be apparent to those skilled in the art from the foregoing description. Such modifications are also intended to fall within the scope of the appended claims. Each reference cited in the present application is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
(63) Although the preferred embodiment of the present invention has been shown and described, it will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art that modifications may be made thereto which do not exceed the scope of the appended claims. Therefore, the scope of the invention is limited only by the following claims. Reference numbers recited in the claims are exemplary and for ease of review by the patent office and are not limiting in any way. In some embodiments, the figures presented in this patent application are drawn to scale, including the angles, ratios of dimensions, etc. In some embodiments, the figures are only representative and the claims are not limited by the dimensions of the figures. In some embodiments, descriptions of the inventions described herein using the phrase comprising includes embodiments that could be described as consisting of, and as such the written description requirement for claiming one or more embodiments of the present invention using the phrase consisting of is met.
(64) The reference numbers recited in the below claims are solely for ease of examination of this patent application, and are exemplary, and are not intended in any way to limit the scope of the claims to the particular features having the corresponding reference numbers in the drawings.