A STABLE PVC COMPOSITION COMPRISING AN ENVIRONMENT-FRIENDLY PLASTICIZER
20230044924 · 2023-02-09
Inventors
- Håkan BJÖRNBERG (Malmö, SE)
- Anders MAGNUSSON (Bjärnum, SE)
- Eva GUSTAVSSON (Lund, SE)
- Peter JOHANSSON (Vankiva, SE)
Cpc classification
C08K3/014
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C09D127/06
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C08L27/06
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C09D127/06
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C08K5/005
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C08K2201/014
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C08K5/005
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
International classification
C08K3/014
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Abstract
The present invention refers to a polyvinyl chloride composition with high stability, said composition comprising: a) 100 phr (parts per hundred resin) of a polyvinyl chloride resin, b) 10-150 phr of pentaerythritol tetravalerate as plasticizer, said pentaerythritol tetravalerate having an acid value of less than 0.05 mg KOH/g and being obtained through esterification of valeric acid and high purity pentaerythritol having a purity of at least 98%, an ash content of less than 200 ppm and a dipentaerythritol content of 0.1-2 wt%, c) 0.3-14 phr of at least one stabilizer, and optionally d) at least one additive, wherein and the amount of free acid in the polyvinyl chloride composition is less than 30 ppm, preferably less than 20 ppm. The invention further refers to a polyvinyl chloride article comprising said composition and having an amount of free acid less than 30 ppm, preferably less than 20 ppm. The present invention also refers to a method for analyzing the amount of free acid in a polyvinyl chloride sample.
Claims
1. A polyvinyl chloride composition with high stability comprising: (a) 100 phr (parts per hundred resin) of a polyvinyl chloride resin, (b) 10-150 phr of pentaerythritol tetravalerate as plasticizer, the pentaerythritol tetravalerate having an acid value of less than 0.05 mg KOH/g and obtained through esterification of valeric acid and high purity pentaerythritol having a purity of at least 98%, an ash content of less than 200 ppm, and a dipentaerythritol content of 0.1-2 wt%, (c) 0.3-14 phr of at least one stabilizer, and (d) optionally, at least one additive, wherein the high stability is defined as an amount of free acid in the polyvinyl chloride composition being less than 30 ppm of free acid.
2. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the amount of free acid in the polyvinyl chloride composition is less than 20 ppm.
3. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the high purity pentaerythritol has an ash content of less than 50 ppm.
4. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the stabilizer (c) is present in an amount of 1-6 phr.
5. The composition according to claim 1 having a high process stability, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from the liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS), and solid organic based (OBS) and the optional additive (d) is selected from the carbodiimide, epoxidized soybean oil (ESO), epoxidized linseed oil (ELO), amine, phosphite, overbased carboxylate, overbased sulfonate, overbased phosphonate, overbased salicylate, overbased phenate including Ca, Ba or Mg, oxazolidine, zeolite, hydrotalcite, calcium oxide, and calcium hydroxide, wherein the high process stability is defined as not more than 30 ppm of acid leaving the composition during processing.
6. The composition according to claim having a high storage stability, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from the liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS), solid organic based (OBS), and solid Mg/Zn and the optional additive (d) is selected from carbodiimide, overbased carboxylate, overbased sulfonate, overbased phosphonate, overbased salicylate. overbased phenate including Ca, Ba or Mg, zeolite, hydrotalcite, calcium oxide, and calcium hydroxide, wherein the high storage stability is defined as a concentration of free acid not increasing more than 15 ppm during 6 months of storage.
7. The composition according to claim 1 having a high hydrolytic stability, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, paste Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS), and solid organic based (OBS) and the optional additive (d) is a carbodiimide, polymeric primary epoxide and/or a zeolite, wherein the high hydrolytic stability is defined as a concentration of free acid not being more than 150 ppm after 3 weeks of exposure to near 100 % RH and 50° C.
8. The composition according to claim 1 having a combination of high process stability, high storage stability, and high hydrolytic stability, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, and liquid organic based and solid organic based stabilizers and the optional additive (d) is a carbodiimide, polymeric primary epoxide, and/or a zeolite.
9. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the polyvinyl chloride resin (a) is a polyvinyl chloride suspension resin (S-PVC).
10. The composition according to claim 9, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from liquid Ba/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, and liquid calcium organic based stabilizers.
11. (canceled)
12. (canceled)
13. (canceled)
14. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the polyvinyl chloride resin (a) is a polyvinyl chloride emulsion resin (E-PVC).
15. The composition according to claim 14, wherein the stabilizer (c) is selected from liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, and liquid calcium organic based stabilizers, and wherein the composition is a plastisol.
16. The composition according to claim 5, wherein the polyvinyl chloride resin (a) is a polyvinyl chloride emulsion resin (E-PVC) and the stabilizer (c) is a liquid Ba/Zn and/or a liquid Ca/Zn stabilizer, and wherein the composition is a coating.
17. (canceled)
18. A polyvinyl chloride article comprising the composition according to claim 1, wherein the amount of free acid in the article is less than 30 ppm.
19. A method for analyzing the amount of free acid in a polyvinyl chloride composition according to claim 1 comprising extracting the acid from the polyvinyl chloride composition, derivatizing the acid with a carbodiimide and an amine, and determining the amount of amide by liquid chromatography.
20. The method according to claim 19, wherein the acid is extracted from the polyvinyl chloride composition in an ultrasonic bath with acetonitrile.
21. The method according to claim 19, wherein the carbodiimide is 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide (EDC) and the amine is 2-nitrophenyl-hydrazine (2-NPH).
22. The method according to claim 19, wherein the acid is valeric acid.
23. The article of claim 18, wherein the article is selected from flooring, roof membranes or other outdoor applications, stationary, films, and/or automotive applications.
24. The article of claim 18, wherein the article is selected from artificial leather, floor coverings, wall coverings, coated fabrics, car underbody coatings and/or toys or other rotational moulded articles.
Description
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0017] The present invention refers to a polyvinyl chloride composition with high stability, said composition comprising: [0018] a) 100 phr (parts per hundred resin) of a polyvinyl chloride resin, [0019] b) 10-150 phr of pentaerythritol tetravalerate as plasticizer, said pentaerythritol tetravalerate having an acid value of less than 0.05 mg KOH/g and being obtained through esterification of valeric acid and high purity pentaerythritol having a purity of at least 98%, an ash content of less than 200 ppm and a dipentaerythritol content of 0.1-2 wt%, [0020] c) 0.3-14 phr of at least one stabilizer, and optionally [0021] d) at least one additive, wherein the amount of free acid in the polyvinyl chloride composition is less than 30 ppm, preferably less than 20 ppm and most preferably less than 10 ppm.
[0022] The plasticizer in the present invention could also be used together with other polymers which are processed with plasticizers, like vinyl chloride-based copolymers, polyvinylidene chloride, polyvinyl acetate, polyvinyl butyral, polyacrylates, polyamides, polylactides, polyurethane, cellulose and derivatives thereof and rubber polymers. The present invention is however focusing on polyvinyl chloride (PVC).
[0023] PVC is obtained by homopolymerization of vinyl chloride. The PVC used in accordance with the invention a) may be prepared, for example, by suspension polymerization, microsuspension polymerization, emulsion polymerization, or bulk polymerization. Preferably the PVC is prepared by suspension polymerization (S-PVC) or emulsion polymerization (E-PVC). The polyvinyl chloride used in the present invention is preferably a commercial polymer. S-PVC accounts for more than 80% of the PVC market and is used for all kinds soft plastic items, tubes and rigid plastic profiles. E-PVC has smaller grain size and is typically used to produce plastic flooring, faux leather or faux wallpaper etc.
[0024] The PVC composition according to the invention may be mixed as a dry blend, or liquid mixture or paste, and may be processed further after additional processing to granules. Examples of different processing operations are extruding, injection molding, spraying, calendaring, rotational molding, dipping, spreading, coating, sintering and casting.
[0025] The plasticizer in the composition of the present invention, pentaerythritol tetravalerate b) is preferably present in amounts of 20-50 phr. Said pentaerythritol tetravalerate is obtained through esterification of valeric acid and high purity pentaerythritol having a purity of at least 98%, an ash content of less than 200 ppm, preferably less than 100 ppm and most preferably less than 50 ppm. The pentaerythritol tetravalerate plasticizer in the composition of the present invention can be included in the range of products commercially known as Pevalen™.
[0026] The plasticizer of the present invention is a general purpose plasticizer, but is especially suitable for close contact PVC applications, such as coated textiles, contact/design films and automotive interiors. The pentaerythritol tetravalerate plasticizer in the composition of the present invention contributes to great properties in S-PVC, especially regarding hardness, volatility, blend time, UV-stability, extraction water solutions and good migration to rubber and extraction chemicals and oils. When used in a plastisol the pentaerythritol tetravalerate uniquely enables both low viscosity and fast gelation, and contributes to low fogging properties.
[0027] The plasticizer of the present invention, pentaerythritol tetravalerate, is a very stable compound on its own, but as a plasticizer in a PVC composition the stability of pentaerythritol tetravalerate can sometimes be a problem. Several factors are influencing the stability, for instance stabilizers, additives, pentaerythritol tetravalerate quality and concentration, PVC type and quality, processing parameters and humidity.
[0028] Already at the low amount of 0.003 mg/m.sup.3 the smell of valeric acid is detected. When compared to 2-ethylhexanol, released upon hydrolysis of diethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) and isodecanol, released upon hydrolysis of diisodecyl phthalate (DIDP), they start to smell at amounts of 0.4 mg/m.sup.3 and 0.1 mg/m.sup.3, respectively and their odours are not unpleasant.
[0029] It is a challenge to analyze such small amounts of valeric acid. For this purpose a new analysis method to monitor the hydrolytic stability of the plasticizer of the present invention has been developed. This method includes a reliable method based on Liquid Chromatography (LC) where the amount of valeric acid in a PVC film is quantified by LC after derivatization of the acid to an amide, through reaction with a carbodiimide and an amine. The valeric acid analysis method is further described in Example 7.
[0030] It is not easy to foresee what PVC stabilizers are suitable to use together with pentaerythritol tetravalerate. Some PVC stabilizers have shown to have a tendency to decompose/hydrolyse pentaerythritol tetravalerate. After some extensive testing certain stabilizers have been found to work well in PVC formulations with the plasticizer of the present invention. It has also been found that the use of certain additives can increase the stability of pentaerythritol tetravalerate in PVC compositions.
[0031] In some embodiments of the present invention the addition of an additive d) has the effect of reducing the degradation of the plasticizer, pentaerythritol tetravalerate b), a degradation induced by the presence of a stabilizer c). For instance has the addition of an overbased additive shown to generally have a very positive effect on the performance of both liquid and solid Ca/Zn stabilizers, as well as for Ba/Zn stabilizers, regarding the stability of pentaerythritol tetravalerate in a PVC composition. Especially the process stability and the storage stability are increased with the presence of an overbased additive. A suitable amount of additive is in the range of 0-2 phr, preferably 0.25-1 phr, depending on the amount of valeric acid released in the corresponding PVC composition with only stabilizer.
[0032] The chemistry involved in the interaction between the different components in a PVC composition is rather complex and sometimes unpredictable. Although liquid Ca/Zn stabilizers have shown to contribute to a high process stability, solid Ca/Zn stabilizers does not work at all, at least not alone. The addition of a certain additive has shown to play an essential part in situations where the stabilizer has an hydrolysing effect on the plasticizer of the present invention. A combination of stabilizer and additive can work miracles in terms of stabilizing the plasticizer of the present invention in a PVC composition. The combination of a Ca overbased additive and a solid Ca/Zn stabilizer has for instance shown to counteract the hydrolysing effect of the solid Ca/Zn stabilizer on the plasticizer of the present invention and increase the process stability. Solid Ca/Zn stabilizers are suitable in low amounts in PVC formulations for food contact applications. Stabilizers comprising tin (Sn) have shown to have a very low compatibility with pentaerythritol tetravalerate. Through extensive testing and analyzing it has been realized which stabilizers works well with the plasticizer of the present invention and which does not. The amount of stabilizer in the composition of the present invention is preferably 1-6 phr.
[0033] In order to reach a PVC composition of the present invention, having a high process stability, suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS) and solid organic based (OBS). A composition according to the present invention is classified as having a high process stability when not more than 30 ppm of acid is leaving the composition during processing. Suitable additives d) that contribute to high process stability are selected from the group consisting of carbodiimide, epoxidized soybean oil (ESO), epoxidized linseed oil (ELO), amine, preferably a tertiary amine, phosphite, overbased carboxylate, overbased sulfonate, overbased phosphonate, overbased salicylate or overbased phenate including Ca, Ba or Mg, preferably overbased calcium carboxylate, overbased barium carboxylate, overbased magnesium alkyl salicylate and overbased calcium sulfonate, oxazolidine, zeolite, hydrotalcite, calcium oxide and calcium hydroxide.
[0034] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention and that contribute to a PVC composition with high process stability are listed in the table below. Over hundreds of different stabilizers have been screened in order to arrive at this preferred list of stabilizers.
TABLE-US-00001 Trademark Type Form Supplier Lankromark™ LZB985 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Reagens SL/326 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lastab™ DE565 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX/782 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX 791 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab UBZ 780 RF Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Mark® BZ 961 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Baerostab UBZ 711-1 X RF Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Baerostab UBZ 751 RF Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Mark® BZ 855 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Baerostab UBZ 711-3 X RF Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Reagens SLX/981/2 PF Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SL/338 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab MC 8763-3 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens TS 389 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens CL/355 Ca/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens CL/358 Ca/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/768 Ca/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab UBZ 729-1 SRF Ca/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Mark® 2181 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB578 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1106 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Interlite™ ZX9127 Ca/Zn Paste Valtris Specialty Chemicals Interlite™ ZP9623 Ca/Zn Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Baeropan R 8703 KA/20 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Baeropan R 8703 KA/5 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Naftosafe® C CP 85111 Ca/Zn Solid Chemson Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Baerostab MOE 11062 Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Mark® OBS 1200 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Baerostab NT MZ 5S OBS Liquid Baerlocher TS 587 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® PXX 30152-01 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Reapak B-NT/7056/3 X OBS Solid Reagens Mark® OBS 705 OBS Solid Galata Chemicals Naftosafe® 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Baerostab MC 90163-1 CP OBS Solid Baerlocher Baerostab UBZ 711-1 X RF Ba/Zn Liquid Baerlocher Ackrostab™LZB 6148 OBS Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB996 OBS Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Baerostab UBZ 751 OBS Solid Baerlocher TS 587 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers
[0035] In order to reach a PVC composition of the present invention, having a high storage stability, suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS), solid organic based (OBS) and solid Mg/Zn. A composition according to the present invention is classified as having a high storage stability when the concentration of free acid is not increasing more than 15 ppm during 6 months of storage.
[0036] Suitable additives d) that contribute to high storage stability are selected from the group consisting of carbodiimide, polymeric primary epoxide, overbased carboxylate, overbased sulfonate, overbased phosphonate, overbased salicylate or overbased phenate including Ca, Ba or Mg, preferably overbased calcium carboxylate, overbased barium carboxylate, overbased magnesium alkyl salicylate and overbased calcium sulfonate, zeolite, hydrotalcite, calcium oxide and calcium hydroxide.
[0037] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention and that contribute to a PVC composition with high storage stability are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00002 Trademark Type Form Supplier Naftosafe® PXX 30152-01 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe®HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Reapak B-NT/7056/3 X OBS Solid Reagens TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Mark® OBS 705 OBS Solid Galata Chemicals Baerostab NT580 A Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Reapak B-NT/8083/2 M Ca/Zn Solid Reagens Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB985 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX 782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab NT170 PS Ca/Zn Paste Baerlocher Reapak B-NT/8083/2 M Ca/Zn Solid Reagens Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Interlite™ ZP9623 Ca/Zn Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Naftosafe® 4774-07 Ca/Zn Solid Chemson Reagens SL/326 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Interlite™ ZP9600 Ca/Zn Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Mark® CZ 2053 Ca/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Lastab™ DE565 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Mark® CZ 2053 Ca/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Mark® CZ 2051 Ca/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Baeropan R 8703 KA/20 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Baeropan R 8703 KA/5 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Reagens SLX/782 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens TS 389 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Reagens SLX/791 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab NT MZ 55 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Lastab™ DC2040S Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lastab™ CE706PF Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Baerostab MC 9308 EP Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Naftosafe® CZP 4774-07 Ca/Zn Solid Chemson Naftosafe® CZP 97801 Ca/Zn Solid Chemson Reapak B-NT/8104M Ca/Zn Solid Reagens
[0038] In order to reach a PVC composition of the present invention, having a high hydrolytic stability, suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, paste Ca/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS) and solid organic based (OBS). A composition according to the present invention is classified as having a high hydrolytic stability when the concentration of free acid is not more than 150 ppm after 3 weeks of exposure to near 100% RH and 50° C. Suitable additives d) that contribute to high hydrolytic stability are carbodiimides, polymeric primary epoxides and/or zeolites.
[0039] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention and that contribute to a PVC composition with high hydrolytic stability are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00003 Trademark Type Form Supplier Naftosafe® PXX 30152-01 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Reapak B-NT/7056/3 X OBS Solid Reagens TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Mark® OBS 705 OBS Solid Galata Chemicals Interlite™ ZX9127 Ca/Zn Paste Valtris Specialty Chemicals Baerostab NT580 A Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Reapak B-NT/8083/2 M Ca/Zn Solid Reagens Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB985 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Interlite™ ZX9004 Ca/Zn Paste Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 587 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Baerostab NT170 PS Ca/Zn Paste Baerlocher Reapak B-NT/8083/2 M Ca/Zn Solid Reagens Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0040] In order to reach a PVC composition of the present invention, having a combination of high process stability and high storage stability, suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, solid Ca/Zn, solid Mg/Zn, liquid organic based (OBS) and solid organic based (OBS). Suitable additives d) that contribute to a combination of high process stability and high storage stability are selected from the group consisting of carbodiimide, overbased carboxylate, overbased sulfonate, overbased phosphonate, overbased salicylate or overbased phenate including Ca, Ba or Mg, preferably overbased calcium carboxylate, overbased barium carboxylate, overbased magnesium alkyl salicylate and overbased calcium sulfonate and zeolite.
[0041] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention and that contribute to a PVC composition with a combination of high process stability and high storage stability are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00004 Trademark Type Form Supplier Lankromark™ LZB985 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX 782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Reagens SL/326 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lastab™ DE565 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX 782 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/791 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens TS 389 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Interlite™ ZP9623 Ca/Zn Solid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Baeropan R 8703 KA/20 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Baeropan R 8703 KA/5 Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Naftosafe® PXX 30152-01 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Reapak B-NT/7056/3 X OBS Solid Reagens Mark® OBS 705 OBS Solid Galata Chemicals TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® 30152 OBS Solid Chemson
[0042] In order to reach a PVC composition of the present invention, having a combination of high process stability, high storage stability and high hydrolytic stability, suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn, liquid organic based and solid organic based stabilizer. Suitable additives d) that contribute to a combination of high process stability, high storage stability and high hydrolytic stability are carbodiimides, polymeric primary epoxides and/or zeolites.
[0043] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention and that contribute to a PVC composition with a combination of high process stability, high storage stability and high hydrolytic stability are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00005 Trademark Type Form Supplier Lankromark™ LZB985 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Reagens SLX 782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Naftosafe® PXX 30152-01 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Reapak B-NT/7056/3 X OBS Solid Reagens
[0044] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is a polyvinyl chloride suspension resin (S-PVC) and suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, solid Ca/Zn and liquid calcium organic based stabilizer.
[0045] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a S-PVC are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00006 Trademark Type Form Supplier Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 510 with TS 511 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Baerostab NT MZ 5S Ca/Zn Solid Baerlocher Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Reapak B-NT/7056 3X OBS Solid Reagens TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers Reagens SL/326 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0046] In an embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is a S-PVC and in order to reach a PVC composition having a high process stability in calendaring, suitable stabilizers c) are then selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, solid Mg/Zn and liquid calcium organic based stabilizer.
[0047] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a S-PVC for use in calendaring are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00007 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SL/326 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0048] In an embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is a S-PVC and in order to reach a PVC composition having a high process stability in extrusion, suitable stabilizers c) are liquid Ba/Zn, and/or liquid calcium organic based stabilizer.
[0049] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a S-PVC for use in extrusion are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00008 Trademark Type Form Supplier Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0050] In an embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is a S-PVC and in order to reach a PVC composition having a high process stability in injection molding, suitable stabilizers c) are liquid Ba/Zn, and/or liquid calcium organic based stabilizer.
[0051] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a S-PVC for use in injection molding are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00009 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0052] In another preferred embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is a polyvinyl chloride emulsion resin (E-PVC) and suitable stabilizers c) are selected from the group consisting of liquid Ba/Zn, liquid Ca/Zn and liquid calcium organic based stabilizer.
[0053] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a plastisol made from E-PVC are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00010 Trademark Type Form Supplier Mark® 4825 Ba/Zn Liquid Galata Chemicals Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Lastab™ CF 419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 510 with TS 511 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals TS 588 OBS Solid AM Stabilizers
[0054] In an embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is an E-PVC and in order to reach a PVC composition having a high process stability in coating, suitable stabilizers c) are then liquid Ba/Zn and/or liquid Ca /Zn stabilizers.
[0055] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a E-PVC for use in coating are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00011 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0056] In another embodiment of the present invention the polyvinyl chloride resin a) is an E-PVC and in order to reach a PVC composition having a high process stability in molding, suitable stabilizers c) are then liquid Ba/Zn stabilizers.
[0057] Particularly preferred stabilizers that have shown good compatibility with the plasticizer of the present invention in a E-PVC for use in molding are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00012 Trademark Type Form Supplier Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0058] The present invention also refers to a polyvinyl chloride article comprising a composition according to the invention and where the amount of free acid in said article is less than 30 ppm, preferably less than 20 ppm and most preferably less than 10 ppm.
[0059] The present invention further refers to the use of a S-PVC composition according to the invention, for making flooring, roof membranes or other outdoor applications, stationary, films and/or automotive applications.
[0060] For the use of a S-PVC composition of the present invention for making flooring, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00013 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0061] For the use of a S-PVC composition of the present invention for making roof membranes or other outdoor applications, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00014 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 510 with TS 511 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson
[0062] For the use of a S-PVC composition of the present invention for making stationary, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00015 Trademark Type Form Supplier Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals
[0063] For the use of a S-PVC composition of the present invention for making films, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00016 Trademark Type Form Supplier Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0064] For the use of a S-PVC composition of the present invention for making automotive applications, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00017 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® 6092 ACM Mg/Zn Solid Galata Chemicals Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0065] The use of an E-PVC composition according to the invention, for making artificial leather, floor coverings, wall coverings, coated fabrics, car underbody coatings and/or toys or other rotational moulded articles is also included in the present invention.
[0066] For the use of an E-PVC composition of the present invention for making artificial leather, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00018 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/781 Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0067] For the use of an E-PVC composition of the present invention for making floor coverings, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00019 Trademark Type Form Supplier TS 221 Ca/Zn Liquid 100 Mark® OBS 2405 OBS Liquid Galata Chemicals
[0068] For the use of an E-PVC composition of the present invention for making coated fabrics, particularly preferred stabilizers are listed in the table below.
TABLE-US-00020 Trademark Type Form Supplier Reagens SLX/782 F Ba/Zn Liquid Reagens Lankromark™ LZB1150 Ba/Zn Liquid Valtris Specialty Chemicals TS 510 with TS 511 Ba/Zn Liquid AM Stabilizers Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS Solid Chemson Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS Solid Chemson
[0069] The composition of the present invention may also comprise other suitable additives, in addition to the ingredients above. For example lubricants, fillers, pigments, flame retardants, light stabilizers, blowing agents, polymeric processing aids and/or impact modifiers.
[0070] The composition according to the invention may be used for producing foams using blowing agents. For this purpose, chemical or physical blowing agents are preferably added to the composition. In plastisol foams, the stabilizer is often called a kicker and is added in order to regulate the decomposition temperature of the blowing agents.
[0071] The present invention is further explained with reference to enclosed embodiment Examples, which are to be construed as illustrative and not limiting in any way.
EXAMPLES
[0072] Example 1 illustrates the synthesis of the plasticizer of the present invention: pentaerythritol tetravalerate, [0073] Example 2 illustrates the preparation of a PVC composition of the present invention with S-PVC, processing and preparation of test samples, [0074] Example 3 illustrates the preparation of a PVC composition of the present invention with E-PVC, processing and preparation of test samples, [0075] Example 4 illustrates PVC compositions only comprising a stabilizer, [0076] Example 5 illustrates PVC compositions comprising the combination of a stabilizer and an additive, [0077] Example 6 illustrates the evaluation of obtained PVC test samples, [0078] Example 7 illustrates the valeric acid analysis method.
Example 1
Synthesis of Pentaerythritol Tetravalerate
[0079] 2 mole of pentaerythritol (having a purity of at least 98%, an ash content of less than 200 ppm and a dipentaerythritol content of 0.1-2 wt%), and 8 mole (+25% surplus) of valeric acid were charged into a glass reactor equipped with stirrer, condenser, nitrogen inlet and thermometer. 4% by weight of xylene was added as an azeotropic solvent. The mixture was heated under stirring to 220° C. Esterification water began to evaporate and when approximately 80% of a theoretical water amount had been collected the reaction mixture was cooled to 150° C. and 0.1% by weight of titanium(IV)isopropoxid (Tyzor TPT) was added as a catalyst. The mixture was subsequently heated to 220° C. and maintained until a desired acid number was reached and a theoretical water amount was collected, where after the reaction mixture was cooled and the solvent and unreacted valeric acid was removed under vacuum while slowly increasing the temperature to 180° C. After cooling, the solution was neutralised by addition of calcium hydroxide and a small amount of water, followed by vacuum distillation at 140° C. and filtration at room temperature. Pentaerythritol valerate with 97% tetra esterification and an acid value of less than 0.05 mg KOH/g was obtained.
Example 2
Preparation of a PVC Composition of the Present Invention with S-PVC
[0080] 100 phr of a PVC homopolymer suspension resin powder (S-PVC) (Norvinyl S-7060, commercially available from Inovyn) was blended with 50 phr pentaerythritol tetravalerate obtained in Example 1, 2 phr of a selected stabilizer (as found in Table 1) and optionally a defined amount of an additive. The components were mixed at a temperature of about 80-90° C. for about 10 min, until the plasticizer was completely absorbed by the S-PVC polymer.
Processing and Preparation of Test Samples
[0081] The S-PVC powder composition to be tested was then homogenized and gelated on a dual roller mill at a temperature of 165° C. for 5 minutes. Some rolls were stored in aluminium foil to be tested for storage stability 6 months later. The rest of the rolls were conditioned in a climate room (at 23° C. and 50% RH) and subsequently pressed at a temperature of 190° C. for 3 minutes to form smooth test films with a thickness of 1.3-1.4 mm. The hot samples were then placed between cooling plates and pressed at 20 bar until a temperature of 130° C. was reached. The samples were then cut into pieces of no less than 2 g each and sent to valeric acid analysis. The amount of valeric acid leaving the PVC composition during pressing was determined as a measure of process stability. The samples were then placed in a climate room ((at 23° C. and 50 % RH) for storage until the samples were subjected to a hydrolysis test were the concentration of valeric acid was measured. A long-term stability test was also performed, where the valeric acid concentration was measured after 6 months.
Example 3
Preparation of a PVC Composition of the Present Invention with E-PVC
[0082] 100 phr of a PVC homopolymer emulsion resin (E-PVC) (Pevikon 2170, commercially available from Inovyn) was blended with 50 phr pentaerythritol tetravalerate obtained in Example 1, 2 phr of a selected stabilizer (as found in Table 1) and optionally a defined amount of an additive. The components were mixed at a temperature of about 80-90° C. until the plasticizer was completely absorbed by the E-PVC polymer, producing a plastisol paste.
Processing and Preparation of Test Samples
[0083] A paper substrate was mounted in a frame and the frame was attached to the oven. A coating device (roll + doctors knife) on the Mathis equipment is used to coat the substrate with the plastisol. The wet thickness was 1-1.2 mm and the dry thickness was appr. 0.8-1 mm. The paste was coated on a paper to produce a film or a fabric to produce coated fabrics. The PVC paste was then fused in an oven with a curing time of 1,5 minutes at 190° C. and 1900 rpm fan speed.
[0084] The cured plastisol films were then analyzed for valeric acid concentration, tested for hydrolytic stability and long-term storage stability after 6 months. In order to measure the process stability the plastisol films were pressed at 100 bar and at a temperature of 190° C. for 2 minutes to form smooth test films with a thickness of 1.3-1.4 mm. The hot samples were then placed between cooling plates and pressed at 20 bar until a temperature of 130° C. was reached. The samples were then cut into pieces of no less than 2 g each and sent to valeric acid analysis. The amount of valeric acid leaving the PVC composition during pressing was determined as a measure of process stability. The samples were then placed in a climate room ((at 23° C. and 50 % RH) for storage until the samples were subjected to a hydrolysis test were the concentration of valeric acid was measured. A long-term stability test was also performed, where the valeric acid concentration was measured after 6 months.
Example 4
PVC Compositions Only Comprising a Stabilizer
[0085] PVC compositions A-L and Q-U in Table 1 are compositions only comprising a stabilizer and no additive. The ingredients of these compositions were mixed in amounts according to Table 1 and processed according to the procedure in Example 2 and 3. The amount of valeric acid was analyzed for the different samples at formation, during pressing and after long-term storage in order to measure the stability of the compositions. For compositions A-K the valeric acid concentration was also measured after hydrolysis testing. The stability criteria was evaluated in Example 6 and the result is reported in Table 2. Compositions A-K are compositions according to the invention and P-T are comparative compositions having a too high amount of valeric acid.
Example 5
PVC Compositions Comprising the Combination of a Stabilizer and an Additive
[0086] PVC compositions P-T comprising S-PVC, pentaerythritol tetravalerate from Example 1 and a stabilizer in amounts according to Table 1 were mixed, roll milled and pressed according to the procedure in Example 2. The amount of valeric acid in the samples after pressing was analyzed in order to assess the process stability of the compositions. The amount of valeric acid in the samples was also analyzed after 6 months in order to assess the storage stability. As can be seen from the results, reported in Table 2, the amount of valeric acid is too high for all of the compositions, except for compositions S and T that have storage stability.
[0087] In the compositions (P-R) comprising a liquid Ca/Zn stabilizer and the composition S comprising a solid Ca/Zn stabilizer, a liquid calcium overbased additive (PlastiStab 2266 from AM Stabilizers) was added in amounts according to Table 1 (composition L-O). The new compositions (L-O) comprising a stabilizer and an overbased additive were mixed, roll milled and pressed according to the procedure in Example 2 and the amount of valeric acid after pressing was analyzed. As can be seen from the results, reported in Table 2, the amount of valeric acid is considerably lowered by the presence of the overbased additive. The amount of valeric acid in composition L-O are low enough to reach the process stability criteria of less than 30 ppm.
[0088] By the addition of the calcium overbased additive, the degradation of pentaerythritol tetravalerate induced by the presence of the Ca/Zn stabilizer is reduced in comparison to the compositions without said additive. The result shows an increased process stability and storage stability by the addition of the calcium overbased additive.
[0089] For compositions comprising a solid Ca/Zn stabilizer a calcium overbased additive could increase the process stability. For compositions comprising a liquid Ca/Zn stabilizer both the process stability and the storage stability can be increased by the addition of a calcium overbased additive. As can be seen from
Example 6
Evaluation of Obtained PVC Test Samples
[0090] The stability of the compositions A-T was evaluated in terms of valeric acid concentration, determined in the produced PVC film by a new method developed to be able to analyze low amounts of valeric acid in PVC films with Liquid Chromatography (LC) after derivatization of the acid to an amide, see Example 7.
[0091] The process stability was evaluated by measuring the amount of valeric acid leaving the PVC compositions during pressing. In order for a composition to be considered as process stable, the amount of valeric acid must not be more than 30 ppm, preferably not more than 20 ppm and most preferably not more than 10 ppm.
[0092] The storage stability was evaluated by measuring the amount of valeric acid in the formed PVC samples and then after 6 months of storage in a climate room (at 23° C. and 50 % RH). The difference in valeric acid concentration must not have increased more than 15 ppm in order for a composition to have storage stability. In some cases the compositions have a negative value for storage stability, indicating a decline in the amount of valeric acid. The reason for this could be that free valeric acid is absorbed by the stabilizer or the additive. For instance zeolites seem to have the ability to absorb valeric acid.
[0093] Hydrolytic stability was evaluated by exposing the PVC samples to near 100 % RH and 50° C. for 3 weeks and then measuring the amount of valeric acid. The valeric acid concentration must not be more than 150 ppm in order for a composition to be considered as hydrolytic stable.
[0094] Process stability, storage stability and hydrolytic stability were evaluated for compositions A-K and the results are presented in Table 2. All of these compositions did meet the stability criteria. Compositions L-T were evaluated for process stability and storage stability. Compositions P-T did not have enough process stability only comprising a stabilizer. With effective amounts of an additive present the compositions L-O did reach an acceptable process stability. Regarding storage stability, compositions P-R comprising a liquid Ca/Zn stabilizer were not stable enough, but obtained storage stability with the addition of a liquid calcium overbased additive. Composition S comprising a solid Ca/Zn stabilizer is storage stable, but the storage stability is further increased with the addition of a liquid calcium overbased additive (composition O).
Example 7
Valeric Acid Analysis Method
[0095] Valeric acid was extracted from 0.5 mg PVC cut into small pieces in 1 ml acetonitrile during 30 min on ultrasonic bath. The amount of valeric acid was then determined with liquid chromatography after derivatization of the acid with a carbodiimide and an amine.
[0096] The carbodiimide used was 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide (EDC) and the amine was 2-nitrophenylhydrazine (2-NPH). EDC first reacted with valeric acid to form an O-acylisourea intermediate and the intermediate then reacted with 2-NPH to form an amide derivative of the acid and an urea, according to the reaction scheme below:
##STR00001##
[0097] The amide derivative of the acid was then analyzed with liquid chromatography in order to determine the amount of valeric acid in the PVC sample. The result of the different valeric acid measurements is reported in table 2. The detection limit of this method is 0.2 ppm.
TABLE-US-00021 Compositions Campositions of the invention Comparative compositions A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T PVC Norvinyl S-7060 S-PVC 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 Pevikon 2170 E-PVC 100 100 100 100 100 Plasticizer Pentaerythritol tetravalerate 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 Stabilizer LankroMark™ LZB985 Ba/ZN L 2 LankroMark™ LZ81150 Ba/Zn L 2 Reagens SLX 782 F Ba/Zn L 2 Mark* 4825 Ba/Zn L 2 TS 221 Ca/Zn L 2 Lastab™ CF419 Ca/Zn L 2 Lastab™ CF375T Ca/Zn L 2 Mark* OBS 2405 OBS L 2 Naftosafe® PXX 30152 OBS S 2 Naftosafe® HFP 86871 OBS OBS S 2 Reapak 8-NT/7056 3X OBS S 2 Reagens CLX 743 Ca/Zn L 2 2 T5 468 Ca/Zn L 2 2 LankroMark™ L2C 803 Ca/Zn L 2 2 Mark* CZ 180 Ca/Zn S 2 2 Lastab™CE 706PF Ca/Zn L 2 Additive Plastistab 2265 Ca O8.sup.® L 1 0.5 0.5 0.5 *OB= overbased
TABLE-US-00022 Stabilities Limit value Compositions of the invention Comparative compositions A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T Process stability Veleric acid (ppm) 30 29 15 12 21 12 6 7 0.9 7 9.5 7.7 22 18 20 8 77 45 38 51 93 Storage stability Change in Valeric acid after 6 months (ppm) <15 0 15 1.0 0.5 0 0.8 0.3 0.2 1.0 1.6 3.5 0 6 0 0 57 18 20 4 0 Hydrolytic stability Valeric acid (ppm) 150 76 100 93 96 38 66 96 28 19 26 29