Woven thermal protection system
10604872 ยท 2020-03-31
Assignee
Inventors
- Margaret M. Stackpoole (Santa Clara, CA, US)
- Jay D. Feldman (Sunnyvale, CA, US)
- Donald T. Ellerby (Santa Clara, CA, US)
- Ethiraj Venkatapathy (Los Altos, CA, US)
- Curt G. Wilkinson (Fleetwood, PA, US)
Cpc classification
B32B7/09
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2307/30
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B5/26
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B5/08
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2255/02
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2262/14
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
D03D11/00
TEXTILES; PAPER
B32B2250/20
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B7/02
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2262/106
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2260/021
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B32B2262/02
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
B32B5/02
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
Abstract
A thermal protection system (TPS) for a space vehicle that undergoes partial or full ablation when the TPS is exposed to severe heating during entry into a planetary atmosphere. A first layer includes at least one of carbon, phenolic, silica, alumina and another oxide, low thermal conductivity fibers and yarns connecting two or more first layer sub-layers, is recession-resistant and has reduced porosity. A second layer has a smaller fiber fraction, reduced thermal conductivity and reduced density, and serves as a thermal insulator. The first layer may have partial or full insertion of a resin, or may have a surface densified, recession-resistant sub-layer. Values of a first subset of as many as eight environmental parameters can be used to characterize the space vehicle mission. A second subset of TPS parameters for the system is evaluated to identify whether an ablator system with these TPS values can survive the conditions associated with the first subset of environmental parameters.
Claims
1. A thermal protection system (TPS) for installation onto a surface of a heat-exposed vehicle, the TPS having at least two layers, the at least two layers comprising: a first layer of material comprising a plurality sub-layers, each sub-layer of the plurality of sub-layers of the first layer comprising a two-dimensional woven structure having a plain weave architecture in a tight weave pattern of yarns, each sub-layer in the first layer comprising a same architecture and density as other sub-layers in the first layer, the first layer of material having an external surface for interfacing with high temperatures; and a second layer of material comprising a plurality of sub-layers, each sub-layer comprising yarns configured in an x- or a y-direction or yarns woven together in an x- and y-direction, each sub-layer in the second sub-layer comprising a same architecture and density as the other sub-layers of the same direction in the second layer, wherein the architecture of the sub-layers of the first layer is different than the architecture of the sub-layers of the second layer, wherein the first layer is adjacently connected to the second layer by a single yarn that is inserted in a z-direction at a point through at least a last sub-layer of the first layer and at an adjacent point in a first sub-layer of the second layer, the first sub-layer of the second layer adjacent to the last sub-layer of the first layer, wherein each sub-layer of the first and second layers receives the single yarn inserted through each layer at least once, wherein the first layer is configured to be positioned superficial to the second layer on the TPS, and the second layer is configured to be positioned deeper than the first layer and closer to the vehicle's surface, and wherein the first layer comprises a higher density compared to one or more subsequent layers.
2. The TPS of claim 1, wherein the 3D orthogonal weave connects the plurality of sub-layers in a third or z-direction using one or more fibers to limit or control thermal conduction.
3. The TPS of claim 1, wherein each of the at least two layers further comprises a plurality of sub-layers connected to each other using the 3D layer-to-layer weave or the 3D orthogonal weave such that the plurality of sub-layers are contiguous to each other.
4. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein one or more of the at least two layers comprise the organic fiber or a blend of the carbon fiber and organic fiber with a fiber volume fraction of 45 to 60 percent.
5. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the first layer comprises a diffusion depth to allow resin to diffuse into the first layer, wherein the diffusion depth is no greater than a thickness of the first layer.
6. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the one or more subsequent layers are configured to serve as thermal insulators.
7. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the first layer of material comprises a heat transformation layer covering majority of, or all of, the external surface of the first layer, the heat transformation layer is an exposed surface of the TPS system configured to reduce charring or heat transformation of the first layer during entry into an atmosphere of a planetary body.
8. The TPS of claim 1, wherein the plurality of sub-layers are adjacently connected, non-adjacently connected, or adjacently and non-adjacently connected.
9. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the sub-layers of the first layer are composed of a non-blended yarn, and the sub-layers of the second layer composed of a blended yarn.
10. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the first layer of material has a higher volume fraction of fibers than the second layer of material.
11. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the TPS has a thermal conductivity range of 0.1 to 0.4 W/m-K.
12. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the thermal conductivity of the second layer is lower than the first layer.
13. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the sub-layers of the first layer are composed of carbon yarn, and the sub-layers of the second layer composed of blended carbon phenolic yarn.
14. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the first layer is recession-resistant.
15. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein each of the sub-layers of the first layer and in the sub-layers of the second layer are connected by the single yarn in a layer-to-layer weaving pattern in the z-direction.
16. The TPS system of claim 1, the TPS comprising a third layer of material of a plurality of deeper layers of material, the third layer composed of oxide-based yarns, wherein the third layer of material has a lower thermal conductivity than the second layer of material, the third layer of material adjacently connected to the second layer.
17. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the external surface of the first layer of material is subject to a resin film infusion process.
18. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein the resin film infusion process includes forcing a high-viscosity B-staged resin into at least the first layer from the external surface, and creating a surface-densified material.
19. The TPS system of claim 1, wherein each of the sub-layers of the first layer and in the sub-layers of the second layer are connected by the single yarn in a 3D orthogonal weaving pattern in the z-direction.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
(10)
(11) In one embodiment (high fiber volume fraction), the fibers 14 comprise about 50-65 percent of the volume of the first layer 12, with the remainder of the volume in the first layer 12 being either void or a resin matrix. In this embodiment, a second layer 15, adjacent to the first layer 12, contains a lower volume fraction of fibers 16, with a range of about 40-65 percent of the volume being fiber content and the remainder 17 being non-fiber content. A resin (not explicitly shown) is optionally added to the first layer 12 and is optionally added to the second layer 15. The resin may comprise one or more of phenolic, polyimide, cyanate ester, phthalonitride. PBO and PBI. The final materials may be (i) dry (no resin), (ii) moderately infused with resin (resin fraction70 percent of the maximum achievable), or (iii) fully infused with resin (resin fraction>70 percent of the maximum achievable). The first layer 12 will withstand relatively high heat flux and is a recession-resistant layer. The second layer 15 serves as a thermally insulating layer, preferably with lower thermal conductivity and relatively high thermal heat capacity, than the first layer 12. For example, the layer 12 may consist of carbon yarn, and the layer 15 may consist of the blended carbon phenolic yarn. Additional layers of material, for example, oxides, such as silica, alumina, zirconia and/or organic polymer yarns, are preferably positioned so that the second layer 15 lies between the first layer 12 and an additional (third or more) layer. Oxide-based yarns have lower thermal conductivity than do carbon-based yarns so that a functionally graded carbon-to-oxide weave can also be used to locally control thermal conductivity.
(12) The fibers 14 in
(13) The patterns illustrated in
(14) In another embodiment 21, illustrated in
(15) A surface densified ablator material may be prepared by spraying or by B-stage resin film infusion (described in the following) or by otherwise exposing one or more exposed surfaces of an open cell material, a woven carbon preform or similar material. The woven preform material preferably has a porosity in the range of 40-65 percent, with representative density about 0.7 to 1.1 g/cm.sup.3 if it were a carbon layer, before infusion with a phenolic or other resin, including polyimide, cyanate ester, phthalonitrile, PBO. PBI and/or similar resin. This resin is allowed to diffuse into the first layer 22 to a representative diffusion depth h, and this first layer is subsequently cured. The diffusion depth h (1-20 mm) is preferably chosen to be greater than an estimated recession distance d(rec) of the first layer 22, when subjected to the temperature range and pressure range that are anticipated for the chosen mission. The diffusion depth h is preferably no greater than a thickness of the first layer 22, but may be greater. A portion of Layer 1 that is not surface densified normally contains little or no resin. When the depth h of the surface densified portion is chosen to be less than the estimated surface recession distance d(rec) experienced during a mission, the first layer material may fail, through development of a tunnel or other unacceptable ablation behavior that allows a portion of the first layer of the material to be removed or ablated beyond what is acceptable to maintain bondline integrity at the TPS to substructure interface.
(16) In resin film infusion, a relatively high viscosity B-staged resin is forced into the target layer material (e.g., carbon yarn) at an exposed surface of the target layer at a specified temperature and pressure, depending upon the resin used. With this procedure followed, the resin density develops a front with a greater slope than a normal diffusion front as the resin diffuses through the target layer material. The shape of the resin front is not as sharp as a step function. Use of B-stage resin film infusion produces a steep transition from a relatively high resin density region (adjacent to the exposed surface) to a lower resin density region, or inversely, as illustrated in
(17) Optionally, a third layer 19 in
(18) Optionally, the system 11 or the system 21 has a heat transformation layer covering most or all of what would otherwise be an exposed surface of the system. Where the thickness h of the heat transformation layer is sufficiently large, this layer acts as a sacrificial layer that is mostly or fully transformed to char. The first layer material is heated to extreme temperatures but undergoes reduced charring or to other heat transformation processes. The TPS ablator system, 11 or 21, overlies and fully protects an assembly of carrier structure (e.g., composite or metal structural tiles, not shown here) that are expected to experience a severe heating environment upon entry into an atmosphere associated with a planetary body. A portion of the ablator is expected to become charred or volatilized during entry. In determining a design and material composition of a TPS ablator system, the following environmental and mission parameters, among others, are considered: estimated atmospheric pressure at the body's surface, vehicle entry flight path angel (EFPA), estimated terminal velocity at surface heating time interval, maximum heating rate, estimated heat load, estimated heat load gradient, estimated surface recession depth.
Estimates of suitable material and design parameters are developed from the preceding seven entry environmental conditions, including the following: layer 1 thickness and material composition and constituent properties, layer 2 (or subsequent) thickness, material composition and constituent properties, fiber connectivity (e.g., adjacent or non-adjacent, layer-to-layer or orthogonal), resin insertion, as a fraction of maximum resin insertion, presence or absence of surface densification, extent of resin insertion (fraction of full density), and placement (depth from surface) of resin densification.
Example 1
(19) Entry into a Saturn-like atmosphere of a 1-meter, conical nose entry vehicle. Saturn has an estimated maximum atmospheric pressure p(Saturn), at or near the planet's surface, of about 104 kPa, which is about 1 percent of p(Earth), and has an estimated planetary mass m(Saturn) of about 95 times m(Earth). This results in an estimated terminal velocity (at Saturn's surface of 20-28 km/sec, an estimated peak pressure of 0.8-12 atm, a relatively high maximum heat flux of 1,900-14,000 W/cm.sup.2, an estimated maximum heat load of 120-630 J/cm.sup.2. A suitable TPS heat shield for an approach to the Saturn surface may have the following shield characteristics: layer 1 carbon thickness 1.6 cm. layer 2 blend thickness 4.4 cm, total thickness of combined layers 6.0 cm,
Example 2
(20) Entry into a Venus-like atmosphere of a 3.5-meter diameter, conical nose entry vehicle. Venus has an estimated maximum atmospheric pressure p(Venus), at or near the planet's surface, of about 9.3 MPa, which is about 9 times that of p(Earth), and has an estimated planetary mass m(Venus) of about 0.8 times m(Earth). This results in an estimated terminal velocity (at Venus's surface) of 10-12 km/s, an estimated peak pressure of 0.9-10 atm, a relatively high maximum heat flux of 760-5400 W/cm.sup.2 and an estimated maximum heat load of 12-34 J/cm.sup.2. A suitable TPS heat shield for an approach to the Venus surface may have the following shield characteristics: layer 1 thickness 0.2 cm. layer 2 blend thickness 2.5 cm, total thickness of combined layers 2.7 cm.
(21) For each approach, the vehicle entry flight path angle is assumed to be in a range 5-10, initial heating time interval 1 is 5-90 s, heating rate (variable with time) is 760-14000 W/cm.sup.2, and heat load is 12-5400 J/cm.sup.2 The infrastructures for Examples 1 and 2 are obtained using a thermal response tool. FIAT, and known material properties of each layer, including density and thermal conductivity. Note that each of the Examples 1 and 2 includes heat fluxes in a sub-range 1500-4000 W/cm.sup.2, where the conventional approaches, including use of fully dense carbon phenolic material, are not efficient. Use of other materials and of innovative fiber configurations extends the range of heat fluxes, with no substantial loss in efficiency.
(22) Table 1 represents some results of a TPS sizing study performed on the environmental configurations set forth in Examples 1 and 2, with a goal of estimating the minimum layer 1 thickness required for survival of the space vehicle. A survival thickness for layer 1 is taken to be a thickness equal to (1+f) times an estimated recession depth d(rec) of the layer 1 material, where f is a selected non-negative fraction (e.g., f=0.51) that may be taken to be 0 in some situations. The differences for different headings (30 versus 90 relative to a North pole for the Saturn probe arise from accounting for presence of the substantially planar rings located at an equator (=90) of Saturn (non-isotropic).
(23) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE 1 TPS Sizing Study Ranges. Saturn probe Venus probe Nose configuration 45 45 Vehicle max. diameter 1.0 m 1.0 m Vehicle entry mass 250 kg 2750 kg Atmos. entry velocity 26, 28 km/sec 10.8, 11.6 km/sec Entry flight path angle (EFPA) 6.5 8.5 Vehicle heading 30, 90 isotropic Peak heat flux (W/cm.sup.2) 1900-14,000 760-5400 Integrated heat load (kJ/cm.sup.2) 120-630 12-34 Equivalent heating time 45-63.2 s 6.3-15.8 s Peak pressure 0.8-12 atm. 0.9-10 atm. Peak G-load 14-200 18-190 Minimum layer 1 thickness 1.6 cm 4.4 cm Layer 2 thickness 0.8 cm 2.5 cm
(24)
(25)
(26) In determining a design and material composition of a TPS ablator system, the following environmental and mission parameters, among others, are considered in a multiple layer configuration: maximum atmospheric pressure at the body's surface, terminal velocity of space vehicle, vehicle entry flight path angle vehicle estimated terminal velocity, heating time interval, maximum heating rate, estimated heat load, estimated surface recession depth.
(27) Estimates of suitable material and design parameters are developed from the preceding nine conditions, including the following: layer 1 thickness, material composition and constituent properties, layer 2 thickness and yarn blend, if any, and constituent properties, fiber connectivity. resin insertion, as a fraction of maximum resin insertion, presence or absence of surface densification.
(28) One appropriate procedure here begins with a specification of M of the nine conditions set forth in the preceding paragraph (1M9). Specification of each of the M parameters will introduce one or more limitations on choice(s) of one or more of the material parameters set forth in the preceding paragraph. In some instances, specification of the combination of M conditions may require that one or more of the parameters values lie(s) outside the parameter range(s) available. For example, for a particular maximum heating rate and an estimated heat load, the estimated surface recession depth may be equal to or larger than the available layer 1 thickness for the layer 1 material composition(s) available. This situation will require a reformulation of the conditions available for the particular mission, in order to avoid recession that consumes the entire layer 1 thickness.
(29) Assuming that specification of the M conditions is consistent with the available conditions, application of the M conditions will limit the choice(s) of the available parameter values. Preferably, the M conditions are specified in a fixed order, chosen so that the least restrictive conditions are specified first. This may prevent, or minimize, the possibility that initial choice of a condition will act as a spoiler that removes all combinations of the other conditions from consideration.
(30)
(31) For the systems prepared according to the invention, the measured tensile strengths are about 4.1 MPa (CP-B1; blended yarn weave; light phenolic infusion) and about 5.7 MPa (CP-B4; blended yarn weave; full phenolic infusion) for system densities of 0.9 g/cm.sup.3 and 0.6 g/cm.sup.3, respectively. The CP-B4 system provides an increase in tensile strength of approximately 180 percent, relative to the heritage MX4926 material, with a system density that is about 42 percent of the density of the MX4926 material.
(32)
(33)
(34)
(35)
(36) The Resin module 124 analyzes and provides relevant information for an Infusion module 141, which estimates resin density, surface densification, if any, and any secondary processing (e.g., partial or full infusion) that may be appropriate. Where non-zero resin infusion is called for, relevant information from the Infusion module 141 is received and analyzed by three modules, 152, 153 and 154, that address single (uniform) layer, graded layer and multi-layer woven TPS. Information from the modules 151, 152, 153 and 154 is received by a Final Product module 161, with feedback to the Performance Requirements module 111 to adjust parameters in an iterative approach.
(37) Summary of Surface Densification Process.
(38) Surface densification can be accomplished by two approaches: resin film infusion or applying the resin directly to the woven outer surface by a spraying or painting application taking care to apply a known mass of resin to a known area of material to control the resin loading. Suitable resins include phenolic, cyanate ester, polyimide, phthalonitrile, PBO, PBI and combinations thereof.
(39) In resin film infusion, a relatively high viscosity B-staged resin is forced into the target layer material (e.g., woven preform) at an exposed surface of the target layer at a specified temperature and pressure, depending upon the resin used. With this procedure followed, the resin density develops a front with a greater slope than a normal diffusion front as the resin diffuses through the target layer material. The shape of the resin front is not as sharp as a step function. Use of B-stage resin film infusion produces a steep transition from a relatively high resin density region (adjacent to the exposed surface) to a lower resin density region, or inversely, as illustrated in
(40) In a spray or paint application of a selected resin, such as an undiluted resin or a mixture of the resin, with a suitable solvent such as ethanol (Eth), methanol (Meth), isopropyl alcohol (IPA), another alcohol, an ether, an aldehyde, a ketone, a carboxylic acid, and/or an ester as solvent, is applied to substantially uniformly cover a surface of the woven material. Depending on the processing conditions and viscosity of the resin the diffusion into the perform may be controlled. The spray/paint/diffusion procedure may be repeated, if desired, to modify the resulting density profile of the surface region and/or to vary the thickness of the modified surface region.
CONCLUSION
(41) The invention disclosed here uses a woven material, prepared by any of at least three processes, as a basis for a thermal protection system material: (1) a dry woven TPS material that is produced in a single weaving process using a blended yarn or set of yarns that may consist of various compositions such as carbon, ceramic oxide, polymer or a blend thereof, containing both carbon and an ablative polymer constituent, produced in a single step with a single density or as a low-to mid-density graded material, without requiring infusion of a resin; (2) a woven TPS material, moderately infused with a resin (matrix phase) to yield a mid-density material; and (3) a high density TPS material, fully infused with a resin matrix phase. The fraction of resin infusion can be varied according to the mission.
(42) Use of a dual layer or multi-layer woven TPS material allows the weave to comprise an outer, higher density layer that is recession resistant and an inner insulator layer, with reduced areal mass, as compared with a monolithic layer. The multiple layer woven TPS material can be balanced between relatively low thermal conductivity and relatively high mechanical strength, relying on different fiber properties and weaving architectures. A weave with layer-to-layer connectivity appears to be most suitable for control of thermal conductivity between the layers, while a three dimensional orthogonal weave (all, or nearly all, layers connected by a vertically oriented fiber) provides the most robust structural performance. A dual multi-layer woven TPS material has no discrete interface between layers.
(43) Use of continuous fibers appears to be best suited to provide a recession-resistant outer layer. The thickness of each layer can be chosen to correspond to a specific mission entry environment. Performance of a dual layer or multiple layer can be further enhanced or modified by use of localized surface densification of a recession-proof layer, for example, by supplemental resin infusion. Spun yarns are preferred for an insulating layer, with relatively low density. A higher bulk in a spun yarn is important in achieving efficient thermal insulation.
(44) Many resins and fibers have been evaluated for suitability, including organic and various continuous and spun carbon fibers, organic polymer fibers (e.g., phenolic, PBI, PBO and polyimide) and oxide fibers (e.g. quartz), and resin matrix polymers (e.g., phenolic, cyanate ester, polyimide, phthalonitrile, PBO, PBI and combinations thereof). The woven TPS approach to manufacturing heat shield materials offers a possibility to maintain a capability or to quickly restart this process, if the process becomes temporarily dormant. The approaches disclosed here allow one to balance a thermal load and a mechanical load, by choice of a proper fiber and/or resin and a proper weave, according to the anticipated atmosphere entry conditions.